An Amish Sin - Cast

Name	Known for
Dylan Ratzlaff Rachel Rachel See fewer	Cruel Summer (2021)
Kellie Martin Sara Sara See fewer	ER (1994)
Rukiya Bernard Grace Grace See fewer	Yellowjackets (2021)
Troy Mundle Levi Levi See fewer	Prey (I) (2022)
Jaden Oehr Lucas Lucas See fewer	Team Zenko Go (2022)
Alexander Brophy Amon Amon See fewer	Van Helsing (2016)
Rubi Tupper Bevin Bevin See fewer	Fire Country (2022)
Khobe Clarke Nate Nate See fewer	Firefly Lane (2021)
Micah Steinke Iddo Iddo See fewer	iZombie (2015)
Eugene Lipinski Bishop Bishop See fewer	The Recruit (2003)
Lesley Mirza Bishop's Wife Bishop's Wife See fewer	Watson (2024)
David Nykl Malachi Malachi See fewer	Stargate: Atlantis (2004)
Annette Reilly Malachi's Wife Malachi's Wife See fewer	Chilling Adventures of Sabrina (2018)
Dax Belanger Eli Eli See fewer	Dial S for Santa (2023)
Ian Gregson Amish Villager Amish Villager See fewer	Wrongfully Accused (1998)
Camryn Macdonald Anna Anna See fewer	Time Helmet
Ryan Mah Cleve Cleve See fewer	Golden Delicious (2022)
Izzie Okane Phoebe (as Izzie O'Kane) Phoebe (as Izzie O'Kane) See fewer	Girl in the Shed: The Kidnapping of Abby Hernandez (2022)
Mairav Robens-Paradise Ruth Ruth See fewer	The Twilight Zone (2019)
Astrid Trueman Isabel Isabel See fewer	Doomsday Mom (2021)