Management of oxidative stress and other pathologies in Alzheimer’s disease

Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is one of the most common neurodegenerative disorders and is characterized by a variety of symptoms such as loss of memory, decline of cognitive functions, abnormal behavior and psychiatric problems. AD is multifactorial in nature with an unknown etiology that is characterized by several pathological manifestations, including abnormal beta-amyloid (Aβ) accumulation, death of cholinergic neurons, microtubule τ protein aggregation, metal dyshomeostasis of copper, iron and zinc, metal-induced oxidative stress and other aspects (Jalili-Baleh et al. 2018).

Particular regions of the brain in AD patients display an abundance of two abnormal protein structures, amyloid plaques and neurofibrillary tangles (NFTs) and a loss of the connections between cells. Both amyloid plaques and neurofibrillary tangles (NFTs) occur as an accompanying phenomenon of normal aging; however in patients suffering from AD, these two neuropathological markers are present in abnormally large quantities (Kumar et al. 2018). The main component of neurofibrillary tangles is tau protein.

Amyloid precursor protein (APP) is the initial source of the amyloid plaques. The enzymes responsible for cleavage of APP are called alpha-, beta- and gamma secretase. The benign pathway involves cleavage of the APP by α-secretase at a critical stage where there is the potential to form amyloid-β (Aβ), which thus prevents the latter from being formed (Schedin-Weiss et al. 2014). The pathological pathway involves the participation of β-secretase (BACE-1), which first cleaves the APP molecule at one end of the Aβ. BACE-1 is a transmembrane-bound aspartyl protease and is the major β-secretase involved in APP metabolism. γ-Secretase then cuts the remaining fragment of APP which is anchored in the membrane of neuronal cells (MacLeod et al. 2015). Further cleavages result in the release of Aβ into the extracellular space, which then forms aggregates (oligomers) of various sizes.

The amyloid hypothesis (“null hypothesis”) was formulated more than 25 years ago and since then, Aβ has been considered to be the main factor in Alzheimer’s disease (Selkoe 2001; Bush 2003; Sayre et al. 2001; Varadarajan et al. 2000). However, a complementary hypothesis has been formulated, termed the “alternate hypothesis”, which claims that Aβ is in fact a secondary event (consequence) of the disease, rather than being the initiating factor (Pimplikar 2009). Nonetheless, both hypotheses are in agreement that the Aβ peptide is linked with the formation of reactive oxygen species (ROS). Indeed, various markers of oxidative stress found in the brains of patients with Alzheimer’s provide evidence that ROS-induced oxidative stress occurs in AD (Devi and Anandatheerthavarada 2010; Tillement et al. 2010; Block and Calderon-Garciduenas 2009).

The pathogenesis of AD is also associated with the cholinergic system (Kuca et al. 2006), which uses an enzyme acetylcholinesterase (AChE) to catalyze the hydrolysis of the neurotransmitter acetylcholine, into choline and the acetate anion. AChE contains a peripheral anionic binding site (PAS) and a catalytic site (CAS). It has been proposed that acetylcholine firstly binds to the PAS and then rapidly diffuses to the CAS. As the condition of AD progresses, the activity of AChE decreases, while that of the non-specific cholinesterase enzyme, butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE), increases. Increased activity of BuChE is linked with the aggregation of the Aβ peptide (Geula and Darvesh 2004). Current pharmacotherapy for patients suffering from AD is based on the enhanced cholinergic neurotransmission which is attained by application of cholinesterase inhibitors (ChEI).

Evidence for another critical pathology associated with AD, which is termed metal-induced oxidative stress, has been obtained from the precise quantification of redox-active transition metals such as iron (Fe) and copper (Cu), and the redox-inactive metal, zinc (Zn), in the brain tissues (Rajendran et al. 2009; Valko et al. 2016). The detailed application of specific physical techniques, which include scanning transmission ion microscopy, Rutherford back scattering spectrometry and particle-induced X-ray emission, revealed an enhanced concentration of Cu, Fe and Zn in the amyloid plaques (Rajendran et al. 2009): thus, the levels of copper and zinc were found to be nearly treble and iron nearly double those in the surrounding tissues. Irrespective of the precise multifactorial origin of AD, these data support the hypothesis that metal-induced oxidative stress plays an important role in the pathology of the disease (Butterfield and Halliwell 2019).

Currently approved drugs for the clinical treatment of Alzheimer’s disease are inhibitors of AChE, such as donepezil (recommended dose 5–10 mg/day), rivastigmine (recommended dose 1.5–6 mg/day), and glutamate (recommended dose 16–24 mg/day), and, less commonly used, the uncompetitive antagonist of the N-methyl-d-aspartate receptor, memantine (recommended dose 5–20 mg/day), which blocks the flow of the charged species. In addition to various side effects of these drugs, which include diarrhea, nausea, bradycardia and hepatotoxicity, their serious limitation is that the symptoms are improved only temporarily, and that it is not possible to inhibit or reverse the progression of the disease. Even though Aβ is one of the key biomarkers of AD, administration of the antiamyloidβ monoclonal antibodies, bapineuzumab and solanezumab (phase III trials) failed to improve cognitive functions in patients suffering from AD (Wang et al. 2016).

As discussed above, proteolytic formation of neurotoxic Aβ from APP is the critical event in the development of Alzheimer’s disease. During this process, both β-secretase and γ-secretase play important roles, and accordingly, the secretase inhibitors, semagacestat and avagacestat, have been developed and tested with the aim of suppressing the formation of Aβ. However, the results were not fully convincing and serious side effects arose (Doody et al. 2013; Coric et al. 2015). Tau is a multifunctional protein involved in the stabilization of microtubules, and because it plays a critical role in AD, attention has been targeted both on the protein itself and its phosphorylation, but yet again with limited success (Kumar et al. 2015).

It has been suggested that dysfunction of the dopaminergic system in the mesolimbic pathway is related to the ‘positive symptoms’ of schizophrenia. Different levels of dopamine dysfunction can also occur in the course of all phases of AD (Martorana and Koch 2014). The most frequent symptoms typical for dysfunction of dopamine systems are the extrapyramidal signs and apathy. Dopamine-related symptoms involve cognitive decline and neuronal degeneration linked with the presence of oxidative stress. Clinical application of dopaminergic drugs, involving mainly DA-D2 agonists such as rotigotine, exhibit improved cognitive functions in Alzheimer’s patients (Koch et al. 2014). Further research and clinical trials are needed to clarify the potential therapeutic outcomes of dopaminergic therapy in patients with AD. In addition, attention should be focused on the role of dopaminergic dysfunction in cognitive decline of patients with AD.

The complex pathophysiological mechanisms of Alzheimer’s disease require a targeted selection of drugs that can suppress early pathogenic alterations and prevent and/or alter the natural course of the disease’s progression. As outlined above, disturbed metal homeostasis results in metal-induced oxidative stress, which is documented by a number of oxidative stress markers in the brains of AD patients. Oxidative stress is an integral pathology in a range of age-dependent diseases such as cancer, cardiovascular disease and various neurological disorders, including Alzheimer’s disease. Despite the contradictory and insufficiently convincing reports on the possible beneficial effects of supplements to suppress oxidative stress, it appears that naturally occurring antioxidants in vegetables and fruits, when supplemented with multiple antioxidants, may be very effective in combating some of the harmful effects linked with oxidative stress, especially in the early stages of the development and progression of the disease. The aim of this review is to discuss the role of (metal-induced) oxidative stress and other pathologies in AD and prospective therapeutic approaches, which employ synthetic and/or natural antioxidants either as individual supplements or as an integral component of bifunctional/multifunctional drugs to adjust any oxidant/antioxidant imbalance in AD.

Redox-active (Fe, Cu) and redox-inactive (Zn) metals are required for the function of enzymes, which play key roles in various physiological processes. Oxidative stress is a common denominator in various metal-overload diseases such as Wilson’s disease (copper) and hemochromatosis (iron), or diseases with perturbed metal homeostasis such as AD, which disturbs the compartmentalization of metal ions (Poprac et al. 2017).

Copper- and iron-induced formation of ROS

The concentration of copper and iron varies between different regions of the brain (Roberts et al. 2012), and thus while healthy neuropils contain approximately 79 μM of copper, in AD, due to the association of copper with senile plaques, its level is substantially decreased (Deibel et al. 1996). Hence, in the brains of Alzheimer’s patients, copper is pathologically transferred to the senile plaques, which causes a copper deficiency to arise in the brain cells. Applying a combination of three physical techniques, namely scanning transition microscopy, scattering spectrometry and proton-induced X-ray emission, significantly increased concentrations of metals in the amyloid plaques were identified: thus, while the concentration of iron was found to be doubled, the concentration of copper was trebled and that of zinc almost trebled, as compared with the surrounding tissue (Rajendran et al. 2009).

While the precise quantification of total Fe or Cu (and also non-redox Zn) levels remains a matter of debate, it may be less important to know the exact total amounts of iron or copper, than to know the ratio of Fe³⁺ to Fe²⁺ or Cu²⁺ to Cu⁺ species.

Free, or non-chelated, iron or copper are the main components of the “labile metal pools” which can catalyze the formation of damaging ROS via the Fenton reaction (Valko et al. 2005) (Eq. 1):

The formation of hydroxyl radicals via the Fenton reaction requires hydrogen peroxide, which is produced by the removal of the superoxide radical anion (O ^·−₂ ), the latter being generated under physiological conditions by the activated enzyme NADPH oxidase, to kill oxygen-dependent pathogens. Physiologically balanced levels of superoxide radical anion are maintained via the dismutation reaction (Eq. 2) (Halliwell and Gutteridge 2007):

which is catalyzed by the superoxide dismutase (SOD) enzymes that function in conjunction with hydrogen peroxide-removing enzymes, such as catalase (Matés et al. 1999) (Eq. 3):

and glutathione peroxidases (GPx) (Halliwell and Gutteridge 2007; Matés et al. 1999) (Eq. 4):

where glutathione (GSH) is oxidized to glutathione disulfide (GSSG).

The superoxide radical anion may reduce ferric ions to ferrous species, yielding molecular dioxygen in the process:

By combining the equations for the Fenton reaction (1) and reaction (5), an overall reaction known as the Haber–Weiss reaction is obtained (Valko et al. 2004) (Eq. 6):

The shielding of redox-active metals such as copper and iron plays an important role in preventing metal-induced oxidative stress. The binding of natural substances via coordinating atoms such as oxygen, nitrogen or sulfur to redox metals blocks their catalytic activity to form ROS via Fenton chemistry. Since the maximal coordination number of iron and copper is six, the hexadentate chelators can provide catalytically more inert complexes than free metal ions due to their ability to completely saturate the coordination sphere around redox ions. Thus, a suitable proposed biologically active molecule that binds to all six sites of redox ions catalytically deactivates the free (unbound) metal ions. There are many examples of chelators that inhibit the catalytic reactions with the participation of redox metals (Lovejoy and Richardson 2003). Flavonoids or some alkaloids have a strong affinity for redox-active metal ions such as Cu(II) and Fe(II) and thus may affect metal-induced DNA damage. Generally, the more favorable the interaction between the redox metals and the flavonoids, the more profound is the antioxidant activity observed. While interactions of ferrous ions and flavonoids result in a very effective mechanism of DNA damage prevention, interactions of flavonoids with cuprous ions is much weaker and do not give rise to effective antioxidant activity and, in fact, may even promote DNA damage via excessive ROS formation (Perron et al. 2011).

The pathways for the formation of ROS and their elimination by antioxidants and antioxidant enzymes are depicted in Fig. 1.

Various pathways of ROS formation and their elimination by antioxidant defense mechanisms

Full size image

Redox-active copper and iron in AD

The “null hypothesis” in Alzheimer’s disease has been focused predominantly on Aβ (Braak and Braak 1991) and thus the increased formation of Aβ as a preventive antioxidant for brain lipoproteins under the conditions of oxidative stress is proposed to be a key phenomenon in the incidence of AD (Hardy and Selkoe 2002).

The neurotoxicity of Aβ is closely connected with the length and conformation of the peptide chain (Atwood et al. 1998). Aβ(1–42) is the most abundant species in amyloid plaques and is more toxic than Aβ(1–40); Aβ(1–42) also has the greatest aggregation ability and affinity toward cupric ions and is furthermore a major source of hydrogen peroxide and ROS. Aβ aggregates into two conformational states: the cytotoxic ordered fibrillary β-sheet and the benign amorphous non-fibrillar non-β-sheet (Chafekar et al. 2007). The neurotoxicity of Aβ is associated with its aggregation properties. The process of aggregation is strongly influenced by the peptide concentration, the pH of its local environment and by the relative concentrations of iron, copper and zinc there.

The general view that Aβ is toxic of itself has recently been challenged and it has been demonstrated that it is not toxic in the absence of redox metal ions (Huang et al. 1999). Hence, it may be concluded that the signs of oxidative damage detected in Aβ are a direct consequence of the presence of the redox-active metals, copper and iron (Valko et al. 2005; Bush and Curtain 2008). Indeed, Aβ has a high affinity toward copper and iron and has been shown that it can reduce both these metals, with the subsequent formation of hydrogen peroxide and oxidized amyloid (Cuajungco et al. 2000; Huang et al. 1999; Hung et al. 2010). Since the toxicity of Aβ is associated with its ability to form hydrogen peroxide (Valko et al. 2005) and other ROS, this may be suppressed by the administration of antioxidants and free radical scavengers (Halliwell 2001).

Oxidative stress/damage in AD is characterized by the upregulation of antioxidant enzymes, and most sensitively by the elevation of levels of heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) (Premkumar et al. 1995). A recent study has identified RNA as a major target for oxidative damage in patients with AD, for which mitochondrial dysfunction and elevated levels of 8-hydroxy-guanine—a sensitive marker of oxidative damage—are collectively responsible (Valko et al. 2006).

Aβ participates in the oxidation of membrane lipids, which results in the formation of 4-hydroxynoenal (Ciccotosto et al. 2004; Smith et al. 2006), a compound that has been shown to modify histidine units in Aβ via covalent bonding. A cellular deficiency of copper results in the localization of amyloid on cholesterol rich lipid rafts, thus forming a favorable environment for the formation of Cu–Aβ complexes (Hung et al. 2009).

The catalytic action of copper ions results in the oxidation of several amino acids on the side chains of Aβ, as has been demonstrated by the formation of methionine sulfoxide and methionine sulfone at position 35 (Ciccotosto et al. 2004; Ali et al. 2005) and by the modification of lysines at positions 16 and 28 (Chen et al. 2007). Various oxidation products of histidine and N3-pyroglutamate have been detected in amyloid plaques, while in addition, tyrosine at position 10 is another target for redox metal-induced redox reactions (Barnham et al. 2004; Haeffner et al. 2005) and a variety of tyrosine modifications (Reynolds et al. 2005).

As discussed above, it has been documented that the N-terminal residues of histidine (His13, His14, His6) and tyrosine (Tyr10) participate in the complexation of copper ions with Aβ (Cerpa et al. 2004). It has been suggested that the N-terminal end of Aβ is complexed with cupric ions which results in the formation of the

sulfide radical of Met35 (Met-S^·+), accompanied by the reduction of cupric ions to cuprous species (Eq. 7). As is clear from the reaction (7), the process of metal reduction requires the one-electron oxidation of methionine which results in the formation of radical cation (Met-S^·+), and which has been proposed to play a role in the neurotoxicity of Aβ with the subsequent formation of more ROS.

In spite of the fact that thermodynamic calculations, based on the half-cell reduction potentials of the cupric/cuprous and Met/Met-S^·+ couples, show that the reaction (7) is rather unfavorable, electron transfer from Met-S to Aβ–Cu(II) may be assisted by the exergonic deprotonation reaction of MetS^·+, thus making the reaction (7) feasible under in vivo conditions (Pogocki 2003; Valko et al. 2005).

The Met-S^·+ radical cation may be stabilized via the formation of a three-electron sulfur–sulfur bond (Cerpa et al. 2004), since theoretical calculations have predicted the formation of an S.:O bond in Aβ, where the notation “.:” indicates a three-electron bond, in which two electrons occupy a bonding σ-orbital, while the third electron is located in a the σ^* antibonding orbital. The Met-S^·+ radical cation may also react very rapidly with ROS, for example with superoxide radical anions, to form Met-sulfoxide (MetSO) as a product, which has been detected in AD senile plagues (Cerpa et al. 2004; Pogocki 2003):

In conclusion, amyloid plaques are rich in a variety of oxidized Aβ species, and since methionine is highly prone to oxidative damage under in vivo conditions, this residue is closely linked with the pathogenesis of AD. Oxidation of Met35 to Met-sulfoxide has a consequence of reducing toxic and pro-apoptotic effects of the Aβ protein fragment on isolated mitochondria.

ROS are involved in the process of lipid peroxidation and are responsible for the formation of a variety of reactive carbonyl compounds. The latter can react further with very important biological molecules such as proteins, lipids and DNA, to cause such phenomena as protein cross-linking and DNA damage. During the course of these reactions, a variety of advanced glycation (AGE) and advanced lipid (ALE) peroxidation end products are formed (Sayre et al. 2001; Chafekar et al. 2007), which may further trigger activation of signaling pathways such as those involving proinflammatory cytokines (interleukin-6) (Valko et al. 2005). ROS-mediated lipid peroxidation of polyunsaturated fatty acids results in the formation of various reactive aldehydes, among which 4-hydroxy-trans-2-nonenal (HNE), 4-oxo-trans-2-nonenal (4-ONE), acrolein and 4-oxo-trans-2-hexenal are well-known neurotoxic agents.

An interesting correlation between cholesterol levels and AD has been proposed. High levels of cholesterol in the blood can increase both the aggregation of Aβ and the brain iron load, which may catalyze oxidative damage. Thus, hypercholesterolemia has been proposed to be a potential risk factor for AD (Ong and Halliwell 2004).

Redox-inert zinc in AD

In micromolar concentrations, zinc is able to inhibit Aβ-induced toxicity (Cuajungco et al. 2000; Maret 2019; Dong et al. 2006; Deshpande et al. 2009; Garai et al. 2007). While the protective mechanism of zinc against the Aβ toxicity is not fully known, it has nonetheless been proposed that the cytoprotection is assisted by blocking the membrane calcium channel pore formed by Aβ(1–40).

Further roles of zinc in AD are closely associated with copper (Cuajungco et al. 2000). Zinc is able to compete with copper (and partly with iron) and bind tightly to Aβ, so changing its conformational state to such an extent that copper ions are unable to access its binding sites. The inability of copper ions to reach the binding sites (copper and zinc share binding sites), due to their saturation by zinc, results in the prevention of copper–Aβ-induced formation of ROS.

Various exogenous and endogenous factors that result in the induction of both oxidative and nitrosative stress may in turn trigger the pathological metabolism of Aβ, which is accompanied by uncontrolled flooding of the vesicular zinc pool (Cuajungco and Lees 1998). Taken together, while low levels of zinc may protect against Aβ toxicity, excess of zinc induced by oxidative stress could be responsible for neuronal death. In support of this, it has been confirmed that the interaction of Aβ with high concentrations of zinc is responsible for the precipitation of the Aβ (Cuajungco and Faget 2003).

From the above, discussion it follows that a delicate balance between the metabolism of Aβ and copper and zinc is maintained exclusively under normal physiological conditions. However, under conditions of oxidative and nitrosative stress, this balance is disturbed and is followed by the deposition of amyloids and elevated zinc pools.

As discussed above, AD is multifactorial in origin and involves three main pathologies: (1) a deficiency of acetylcholine, caused by the aberrant activity of an enzyme AChE, (2) the formation of extracellular amyloid plaques and neurofibrillary tangles and (3) (metal-induced) oxidative stress. Here, we discuss predominantly those drugs which suppress the oxidative stress component of AD, either by acting as individual molecules or as an active part of a multifunctional drug.

Multifunctional drugs containing metal-chelating and oxidative stress-suppressing moiety

The key therapy against AD is based on the application of centrally acting AChE inhibitors to compensate for the cholinergic deficit in the brain. AChE is found primarily in the blood and in the neural synapses, and has been shown to be the most viable therapeutic target to improve the symptoms of AD. In addition to AChE, the liver contains butyrylcholinesterase (BuChE) (Mehta et al. 2012). Most of the available drugs for the treatment of AD target both AChE and BuChE; however, some of them are more selective than others. Historically, the first ChEI was the alkaloid, physostigmine, isolated from the seeds of Physostigma venenosum, but the drug exhibited many side effects and was accordingly abandoned for the treatment of AD (Orhan et al. 2009). Tacrine was the first drug approved for the treatment of AD, and was introduced in 1993 (Tumiatti et al. 2010); however, due to its various side effects, its widespread application was limited and a series of new drugs were approved after 1995, including donepezil, rivastigmine and galantamine.

To address the multifactorial nature of AD, a new approach, based on the application of “one molecule—multiple targets”, has recently attracted the wide interest of scientists. A variety of drugs, called multitarget-directed ligands (MTDLs), which are capable of acting at the various neuropathological levels of AD, have been prepared and studied. Such a hybrid usually consists of two chemically and pharmacologically different molecules that are connected by a linker unit of varying size and chemical type (Girek and Szymanski 2019). Multifunctional drugs combine BBB permeability with the ability to target multiple receptors, as a means to combat those key pathologies that are typical for AD.

Since tacrine has demonstrated very mild improvements in the cognitive functions of AD patients, medicinal chemists were prompted to undertake the design and testing of hybrid molecules containing tacrine and an antioxidant moiety. Such a multipotent approach toward targeting the oxidative stress component in AD included the introduction of novel tacrine–melatonin (Spuch et al. 2010), tacrine–coumarin (Hamulakova et al. 2014), tacrine–gallamine (Elsinghorst et al. 2007), tacrine–resveratrol (Jerabek et al. 2017), tacrine–scutellarin (Spilovska et al. 2017), tacrine–anisidine (Korabecny et al. 2015), tacrine–trolox (Nepovimova et al. 2015) and related hybrid molecules (Fig. 2).

Structures of ligands used for the synthesis and studies of tacrine hybrids

Full size image

Melatonin is a hormone, produced by the pineal gland that is involved in the synchronization of the circadian rhythms. It has additionally been shown to act as a highly effective scavenger of hydroxyl radicals, superoxide radicals and nitric oxide and is also one of the most efficient lipophilic antioxidants known. From a study which evaluated the influence of tacrine–melatonin hybrids on the behavior and neuropathologic changes in APP transgenic mice (Spuch et al. 2010), it was shown that administration of such drugs caused a significant reduction in Aβ deposits. On the basis of an object recognition test, it was revealed that the application of the hybrids also alleviated several behavioral deficits, including short-term memory loss, which indicates that a remarkable neuroprotective effect is in operation and thus a potential therapeutic strategy for the treatment of AD is identified. Using the same tacrine–melatonin hybrids, in another study (Rodríguez-Franco et al. 2006) some very promising antioxidant activity against oxygen radicals was reported, as determined by the ROS-absorbance capacity assay, which used fluorescein. One additional result from this study was that a dichloro-derivative of tacrine linked with melatonin is a more powerful inhibitor of AChE than tacrine by a factor of 40,000.

Coumarin is found in many plants and since it inhibits the synthesis of vitamin K, it is used therapeutically as an anticoagulant. A variety of tacrine–coumarin hybrids were prepared and characterized as potential drugs for the treatment of AD (Xie et al. 2013; Xie et al. 2015). Different derivatives of coumarin with different types and lengths of the tacrine–coumarin linkers have been used. The coumarin moiety is active against aggregation of Aβ, the tacrine moiety is active against inhibition of AChE and BuChE and the linker, which contains oxygen and nitrogen donors, is involved in the chelation of redox-active metal ions. In our own group, we studied tacrine–7-hydroxycoumarin hybrids linked by polyamine tethers of different lengths via an amide functionality (Hamulakova et al. 2016). It was found that the compounds exhibited a significant activity toward the inhibition of hAChE (IC₅₀ = 38 nM) and hBuChE (IC₅₀ = 63 nM), and a greater than 50% inhibitory effect against Aβ was observed for several compounds with different lengths of the linker. With respect to the oxidative stress component of AD, interaction of the hybrid compounds with Cu(II) ions and the formation of free radicals were studied using EPR spectroscopy. The results confirmed that reduction of cupric to cuprous species occurred upon interaction with the hybrids, while EPR spin trapping experiments (with DMPO as the spin trap), using the model Fenton reaction, confirmed that the formation of hydroxyl radicals was significantly suppressed, in comparison with a system containing free copper ions. Hence, a potential protective effect of the hybrid molecules against free metal (copper)-catalyzed formation free radicals, which results in oxidative stress in AD brain, is indicated. The protective activity of tacrine–coumarin hybrids against DNA damage in a model Fenton system was in accordance with the conclusions drawn from the EPR spectroscopic measurements (Hamulakova et al. 2016).

There have been very few investigations made of such hybrid drugs which interact simultaneously with a cholinergic system and muscarinic acetylcholine receptor M₂, which use G proteins in their signaling pathway, even though many types of neurons respond sensitively to stimulation of muscarinic receptors. In one such study (Elsinghorst et al. 2007; Romero et al. 2013), it was found that while gallamine itself did not exhibit significant antioxidant properties, in the form of a hybrid, where it interacted with a cholinergic system and a muscarinic choline receptor, it was a very effective inhibitor of AChE, with IC₅₀ = 500 pm.

Resveratrol is a natural phenolic compound occurring in red wine, blueberries, grapes and other fruits, which has been documented to exhibit protective effects against metal-induced oxidative stress in cerebro-cardio-vascular systems (Carrizzo et al. 2013). Thus, resveratrol has been found to suppress cognitive and motor impairment, neuroinflammation, apoptosis, DNA damage, and oxidative and nitrosative damage (Singh et al. 2013). In tacrine–resveratrol hybrids, tacrine functions as a cholinesterase-inhibiting moiety, while the resveratrol moiety acts as an antioxidant and neuroinflammatory suppressor; it is also an effective antiaggregation modulator of Aβ and a ChEI at micromolar concentrations.

Scutellarin is a herbal flavonoid which occurs in the Chinese traditional herb Erigeron breviscapus Hand-Mazz and has several beneficial effects on human health, based on antioxidant, antiinflammatory and cardioprotective properties along with other positive features. New derivatives and improved formulations have been developed to improve the bioavailability and effectiveness of scutellarin, and thus a series of 6-Cl-tacrine–scutellarin hybrids was prepared and studied as potential therapeutic agents for the treatment of AD. On the basis of a DPPH assay it was determined that the hybrids exhibit weaker radical-scavenging (antioxidant) activities than the Trolox standard. The scutellarin molecule contains –OH groups which are assumed to be responsible for its radical-scavenging activity; however, the phenolic –OH groups of the scutellarin molecule are hindered by –OCH₃ groups in the hybrids, which thus prevents them from manifesting their antioxidant effects under the conditions of the DPPH assay.

Docking calculations revealed that the scutellarin functionality protrudes out of the cavity gorge, while the tacrine functionality interacts with the CAS of AChE. A similar stereochemical orientation has also been reported for tacrine–tianeptine or 7-methoxytacrine–adamantylamine hybrids (Ceschi et al. 2016; Spilovska et al. 2013; Korabecny et al. 2015). An opposite arrangement, in which tacrine interacts with PAS has been reported for 7-methoxytacrine–p-anisidine (Korabecny et al. 2015), 7-methoxytacrine–donepezil (Misik et al. 2015) and tacrine–trolox heterodimers (Nepovimova et al. 2015).

p-Anisidine is known to suppress intracellular accumulation of the precursor to the neurotoxic Aβ, APP. p-Anisidine has been used to synthesize 7-methoxytacrine–p-anisidine hybrids as potential dual-binding site AChE inhibitors for the treatment of Alzheimer’s disease (Korabecny et al. 2015). Both functionalities were linked with an alkyl tether containing urea/thiourea molecules. With respect to inhibitory activity against AChE, the hybrids were slightly more active than 7-methoxytacrine and less active than tacrine. Interestingly, those hybrids with longer linkers displayed a greater inhibitory activity toward AChE.

Trolox is a synthetic water-soluble analog of vitamin E that exhibits very efficient radical-scavenging activity and the Trolox Equivalent Antioxidant Capacity (TEAC) assay is used to determine the antioxidant/radical scavenging of a given compound (or extract) with respect to trolox as a standard. Thus, trolox has been used to prepare tacrine–trolox hybrids with the aim of alleviating metal-induced oxidative stress in AD. While some of the resulting compounds were found to have slightly better cholinesterase activity than the reference molecule tacrine, more importantly, it was noted that these hybrids could block the PAS of the AChE which is connected to the neurotoxic pathways of AD via AChE-induced aggregation of Aβ. Docking calculations revealed that while the trolox moiety interacts with CAS, the tacrine functionality binds to the PAS of the AChE. On the basis of a DPPH assay, it was determined that due to the excellent radical-scavenging ability of the trolox functionality, these compounds were able to alleviate ROS-induced oxidative stress.

Benzimidazoles are compounds that can exert various biological effects. With the aim of addressing several pathologies in AD, the hydroxyphenylbenzimidazole functionality was incorporated into the series of tacrine–hydroxyphenylbenzimidazole hybrids (Hiremathad et al. 2018). The latter compounds were found to exhibit excellent AChE inhibitory activity at nanomolar concentrations and are more strongly active in this regard than is the parent tacrine. They also inhibited copper-induced and self-induced aggregation of Aβ and showed mild radical-scavenging/antioxidant activity and metal-chelating efficiency; furthermore, the hybrids were able to inhibit Aβ and iron/ascorbate-induced neurotoxicity in neuronal cells.

Ferulic acid is a hydroxycinnamic acid present in plant cell walls. The presence of two hydroxyl groups in the molecular structure predetermines the ferulic acid to be an effective antioxidant. In line with this, several tacrine–ferulic acid hybrids have been prepared and studied as potential drugs for the treatment of AD (Zhu et al. 2018). Hybrids have been shown to be active inhibitors of both AChE and BuChE in the nanomolar range. In addition, the compounds significantly inhibited the self-induced aggregation of Aβ and showed antioxidant activity. In vivo evaluation of hybrids using Morris water navigation task confirmed that some of the hybrids significantly improved memory in the scopolamine-induced cognitive impairment. Taken together, ferulic acid appears to be a promising agent for further investigation.

The aim is to develop multitarget agents that meet the criteria for clinical testing for AD. However, clinical application of MTDL therapy faces several problems, such as too high molecular mass of hybrids and their problematic penetration through the CNS barrier. In addition, the concentration of inhibitor in in vitro assay may be significantly different from the optimal concentration for use under in vivo conditions. For example, inhibitor 7-methoxytacrine (7-MEOTA), which shows cellular toxicity under in vitro assays, surprisingly, does not exhibit hepatotoxicity in the in vivo assays (Girek and Szymanski 2019; Nepovimova et al. 2015). In the course of in vivo tests, it is important to evaluate the value of the median lethal dose of hybrid molecules. Critical toxicity concentrations of novel hybrids should also be determined within the in vivo tests. To achieve all these goals, attention should be focused on deeper understanding of the mechanism of action of multitarget drugs (Prati et al. 2016). This will require robust pharmacokinetic and pharmacodynamic data confirming whether the drug crosses effectively BBB and simultaneously modulates multiple targets. In a recent paper, it has been suggested that the Aβ hypothesis, which has been formulated more than 20 years ago, should have been rejected because of the limited progress that has been made (Herrup 2015). In fact, potentially more promising targets, such as tau protein, have been studied relatively scarcely.

In conclusion, most of these hybrid compounds are potent inhibitors of AChE and BChE and also of Aβ aggregation. In addition, the antioxidant functionality, represented by coumarins, melatonin and other antioxidant molecules, reduces the level of oxidative stress via ROS-scavenging mechanisms as well as via chelation of redox-active Cu and Fe. Chelated metal ions exhibit a suppressed catalytic activity in various reactions, including the Fenton reaction (1) which is the origin of hydroxyl radical formation that causes damage to neurons.

Herbal drugs

The therapeutic potency of the herbal drugs is manifested predominantly by (1) their inhibitory activity against AChE, (2) antioxidant or radical-scavenging and redox metal-chelating activities, (3) inhibition of Aβ aggregation, τ protein hyperphosphorylation and (4) antiinflammatory activity. The entry of drugs to the CNS from the circulatory system is governed by the blood–brain barrier (BBB) (Wang et al. 2016), and crossing the BBB is a critical issue for AD drugs, although many single compounds extracted from herbs have been found to do this and thus manifest their therapeutic potency in the brain (Fig. 3).

Structures of herbal drugs with therapeutic potency against Alzheimer’s disease

Full size image

Huperzine A is an alkaloid, which occurs naturally in the plant, Huperzia serrata, and is a selective and reversible inhibitor of AChE. It has been shown that of two bifunctional hybrids, donepezil–huperzine A was less effective, while tacrine–huperzine A was more effective as an inhibitor of AChE, under in vitro conditions, than the parent tacrine. Huperzine A has better oral bioavailability than donepezil or tacrine and engenders more beneficial effects on short-term memory than on long-term memory. Huperzine A improves both the cognitive functions and the memory of patients with AD, without causing side effects, and is marketed in the USA as a nutraceutical cognitive enhancer.

Huperzine A exhibits antioxidant properties and decreases the levels of BACE1 and APP695 proteins; accordingly, it is also able to reduce the incidence of Aβ hyperphosphorylation of τ protein in the hippocampus and cerebral cortex in transgenic mice with AD (Huang et al. 2014).

Natural huperzine B is an alkaloid isolated from the same Chinese medicinal herb as huperzine A. While huperzine B is less active than huperzine A (Shi et al. 2009), several derivatives of huperzine B have been found to show a greater potency, and are more active than huperzine A, galantamine or rivastigmine.

One of the most active inhibitors of AChE is serpentine, a terpene alkaloid isolated from the Apocynaceae family of flowering plants. This alkaloid has a high anticholinergic potency (IC₅₀ = 0.77 µM) which is related to the binding of its quaternary nitrogen functionality to the aspartate residue of PAS (Pereira et al. 2010).

Ginseng (genus Panax) is the root of plants that grow in Korea (Korean ginseng) and China (Chinese ginseng), and its main active components are ginsenosides and gintonin, which is a glycolipoprotein fraction. There are more than 30 ginsenosides (e.g., Rg1, Rg2) extracted from ginseng, which exert various different biological effects. Many studies have demonstrated that ginsenosides can prevent and improve the symptoms of AD, by regulating antiinflammatory effects, synaptic plasticity, the formation of Aβ and the activity of β secretase (Kim et al. 2013). Ginsenoside Rg1 has been documented to suppress the level of Aβ in the hippocampus of the brains of mice with AD, which resulted in the protection of cholinergic neurons and synapses, along with improved cognitive functions (Fang et al. 2012) The neuroprotective effect of Rg1 is linked to a suppressed apoptosis of neuronal cells and increased levels of Bcl-2 over Bax, and inhibition of the expression of cytochrome C. (Gong et al. 2011). Ginsenoside Rg3 inhibits the hyperphosphorylation of τ protein and the neuroinflammatory response via suppression of inflammatory factors, such as tumor necrosis factor (TNF-α), interleukin 1 beta (IL-1β) and cyclooxygenase (COX), which in turn improves both memory and cognitive performance in rats (Lee et al. 2013).

The positive effects of Salvia miltiorrhiza (Danshen) on neurological disorders, including AD, are due to the presence of two types of active components: hydrophilic components, such as danshensu and lipophilic components, such as tanshinone IIA (Lu et al. 2015). Tanshinone IIa significantly protects neurons against metal-induced oxidative stress by several mechanisms: an increase in the concentration of glutathione peroxidase (GPX), direct ROS and RNS scavenging activity, an increase in the level of the membrane potential, a reduction in the toxic effects of malondialdehyde (MDA), a suppression of the activity of superoxide dismutase, an increase in the level of glutathione peroxidase (GSH-PX), and an increase in the amount of the Bcl-2 over Bax with regard to Aβ-induced toxicity in the cortical neurons of rats (Liu et al. 2010).

Extracts from danshen (Radix S. miltiorrhiza) are characterized by lipophilic components such as tanshinone IIA and hydrophilic components such as salvianolic acid B (Lu et al. 2015; Wang et al. 2016; Weng et al. 2015). Since most of these components protect neurons, they have the potential to be used to combat some of the pathologies that are features of AD. Lipophilic tanshinone IIA has been found to decrease the number of apoptotic PC12 cells via activation of PI3K/AKt and phosphorylation of GSK3β (Xiuli et al. 2015). However, the most significant effect of tanshinone IIA is against oxidative stress, which is one of the key pathologies in AD and thus it reduces the formation of ROS, malondialdehyde and the activity of caspase 3. Conversely, tanshinone IIA is found to increase the mitochondrial membrane potential and the ratio of Bcl-2/Bax in cortical neurons (Liu et al. 2010). Danshensu, which is a hydrophilic component of danshen, also has the ability to alleviate some of the symptoms of AD as a result of reducing oxidative stress: thus, oxidative damage achieved by hydroxydopamine-induced overexpression of PI3K/Akt/Nrf2 has been found to be suppressed through danshen-induced expression of the enzyme, heme oxygenase-1 (Chong et al. 2013). Other active components, such as tanshinone I and its derivatives, as extracted from danshen, show neuroprotective effects (Wong et al. 2010) which involve a reduction both in the uptake of calcium and in the release of lactate dehydrogenase.

Corilagin (gallotannin) was isolated in the early 1950s from Libidibia coriaria, which is a tree that is native to Central America (Li et al. 2018) and in addition to its anticancer and hepatoprotective properties, neuroprotective activities have been demonstrated for this compound. Thus, Aβ has been found to induce extensive formation of ROS and cell cycle arrest in PC 12 cells (Youn et al. 2016), but it was shown that corilagin provided protection of the cells against these damaging effects. Furthermore, the compound resulted in an activation of the transcription factor NF-kappaB, a suppressed formation of inflammatory mediators involving TNF-α, and NO^· and a downregulation of the inducible enzyme nitric oxide synthase (NOS). Overall, these results indicate a variety of neuroprotective effects for corilagin, which is therefore a promising agent for the prevention and treatment of AD.

Ginkgo biloba is one of the oldest trees on our planet and has been continually cultivated for use in traditional medicine. Representative extracts from the Ginkgo leaf contain 25% flavonoid glycosides, up to 10% of organic acids and 3–7% of terpenoids. Although the exact mechanism of the action of gingko is not fully understood, it is known that protection of cells from oxidative damage is provided by an optimization of blood flow and the scavenging of ROS. Gingko is able to function as a neuroprotective agent as a result of the preservation of mitochondrial function, antiinflammatory activity and the suppression both of neuronal apoptosis and Aβ aggregation (Shi et al. 2010). The antioxidant action of gingko results from increased levels of antioxidants such as glutathione and/or antioxidant enzymes such as superoxide dismutase. However, clinical trials involving gingko gave inconsistent results and from one study, involving more than 2800 participants, no reduction in the progression of AD was found (Vellas et al. 2012). In contrast, improvements both to cognitive functions and the neuropsychiatric symptoms of patients with AD, who were treated with gingko EGB761, were reported. Positive clinical results and a satisfactory tolerance were also observed for patients with dementia, when administered with gingko EGB761. On the basis of experiments using animal models it was determined that the positive effect of gingko EGB761 is achieved via reduced apoptosis of the cells and a suppression of inflammation that is linked with cytokines such as tumor necrosis factor α and chemokine CCL-2 (Liu et al. 2015).

Uncaria rhynchophylla (Chotoko) is a Chinese plant used in traditional medicine (Xian et al. 2011) and a study was made of its protective effect against cognitive decline in mice, as induced by d-galactose (d-gal). The results demonstrated improvements in goal-orientated (for example, in searching for food) behavior, as assessed by an open-field test. Mice treated with U. rhynchophylla (200, 400 mg/kg weight) showed inhibition of AChE which resulted in increased levels of acetylcholine and additionally, the levels of glutathione, one of the most effective intracellular antioxidants known, were found to be raised, which resulted in an elevated overall brain antioxidant status.

Lemon balm (Melissa officinalis) is a plant growing in Europe, Iran and Central Asia and contains compounds that belong to the terpene family. Melissa has been used throughout history to treat neurological disorders, including problems with memory and mood (Wightman 2017) and its relevant effect on the CNS is achieved via the action of monoterpenes and sesquiterpenes. In addition to their antioxidant effects, this group of compounds has a positive effect on neurons and toward the activation of the cholinergic system and upregulation of γ-aminobutyric acid-(GABA)-ergic neurons (Awad et al. 2009). From a clinical trial in which patients with mild to moderate AD were treated with lemon balm for 4 months, positive effects of M. officinalis on agitation were reported (Akhondzadeh et al. 2003). However, two alternative studies failed to find statistically significant positive results from the application of Melissa to AD patients, although it should be noted that in these investigations, the Melissa was administrated in the form of aromatherapy spray, so the exact dose received by patients was not known.

Curcumin is produced by Curcuma longa plants and it was demonstrated that its application could prevent deposition of Aβ in the brains of murine models for AD (Wang et al. 2009). In addition, it was found that an alleviated hyperphosphorylation of tau resulted from application of curcumin and that the substance also reduces the degree of oxidative stress by binding redox-active metals such as copper(II). Although a positive activity of curcumin has also been found toward the cholinergic system and on the overall antioxidant status of neurons (Tang and Taghibiglou 2017), the major barrier to the therapeutic use of curcumin is its low bioavailability and solubility. Thus, an intake of several grams of curcumin resulted in only nanomolar serum concentrations which are very low for a therapeutic effect to be achieved (Lao et al. 2006). Several formulations, such as curcumin-cyclodextrin have been tested and these were found to increase the solubility/bioavailability of curcumin by a factor of ten thousand. Another potential strategy that might improve the bioavailability of the material is based on the application of curcumin encapsulated in nanoparticles (nanocurcumin) (Bisht et al. 2007).

Panchagavya is an Ayurvedic medicine mixture consisting of five cow products and has been reported to improve cognitive performance, to attenuate seizures and suppress metal-induced oxidative stress in pentylenetetrazole-induced seizures in rats (Joshi et al. 2015).

Overall, it appears that herbs may provide an important source of new prospective drugs for the treatment of AD with a further advantage that the active components contained in herbs have relatively very mild side effects and may exhibit multitarget modes of action, to alleviate those pathological manifestations as are characteristic for AD.

Flavonoids

Flavonoids are polyphenolic compounds that occur in plants and have significant antioxidant (radical-scavenging) and metal-chelating properties. There are six main subgroups of flavonoids: (1) flavanols, (2) flavones, (3) isoflavones, (4) flavanones, (5) flavanols and (6) anthocyanins (Williams et al. 2004). Although there is presently no direct association between neurological status and consumption of flavonoids, the beneficial effects of these materials appear to be related to their ROS scavenging properties, redox metal-chelating capacity and their interaction with intracellular neuronal and glial signaling pathways.

The antioxidant and metal-chelating properties of flavonoids along with their ability to interact with signaling pathways may render their therapeutic potential to prevent the onset and progression of AD. However, the prospective usefulness of flavonoids is mainly restricted to the prevention period or to the early stages of the development of the disease, although supplementation with flavonoids may result in improvements to cognitive performance, since metal-induced oxidative stress in AD affects mainly cognition and/or short-/long-term memory (Airoldi et al. 2018; Sureda et al. 2017; de Andrade Teles et al. 2018) Some biological roles for flavonoids are outlined in Fig. 4.

Biological roles of flavonoids

Full size image

The biological activity of flavonoids is related to their molecular structural features of which the most important determinants of biological activity are the hydroxyl groups on the B ring and a C2–C3 double bond in the C ring (Fig. 5). These particular structural characteristics are all important determinants of the radical-scavenging (antioxidant) activity of flavonoids and due to their distinct structural characteristics, different flavonoids act differently in living cells according to their varying interactions with kinases or receptors.

Flavonoids with potential activity against Alzheimer’s disease

Full size image

Flavonoids are molecules that interact with various neuronal signaling pathways which may involve such protein kinase and lipid kinase signaling pathways as PI3K/Akt, mitogen-activated protein kinase (MAPK), NF-kappaB, tyrosine kinase, protein kinase C and other pathways (Spencer 2010). Upregulation or downregulation of signaling pathways significantly influences the functions of neurons by influencing the phosphorylation of target molecules.

Structurally similar flavonoids may activate different pathways. For example, while the flavonoid quercetin has been shown to inhibit Akt/PKB signaling pathways via inhibition of PI3-kinase activity, the structurally similar hesperetin has been found to activate Akt/PKB signaling and trigger prosurvival activity in neurons (Vauzour et al. 2007). In addition to its antioxidant activity, (−)epicatechin is able to modulate protein kinase signaling pathways and was demonstrated to stimulate a rapid, extracellular signal-regulated kinase (ERK)- and PI3-kinase-dependent increase in CREB phosphorylation, in addition to Akt phosphorylation, which showed bell-shaped concentration response characteristics (Schroeter et al. 2007). Some flavonoids are capable of disrupting fibrillization and can act as BACE-1 inhibitors, consequently resulting in suppression of Aβ formation, but further studies are necessary to select the most potent flavonoids in this regard (Baptista et al. 2014).

Luteolin commonly occurs in parsley and celery and belongs to the group of flavone compounds. The neuroprotection of luteolin against cognitive decline and the accompanying mechanisms induced by Aβ peptide were studied in rats (Yu et al. 2015). On the basis of the results of animal behavior tests, it was revealed that luteolin was able to ameliorate Aβ-induced cognitive/memory impairments. Supplementation of rats with luteolin improved their antioxidant status by increasing the levels of acetylcholine, superoxide dismutase (SOD), glutathione peroxidase (GPX) and by simultaneously decreasing the levels of the oxidant malondialdehyde. Luteolin has been shown to support cell survival via increasing the Bcl-2/Bax ratio and thus this compound offers potential as a therapeutical agent to target both cholinergic and oxidative stress systems in AD.

Inhibition of glycogen synthase kinase 3 (GSK-3) may suppress pathological cleavage of APP. Luteolin has been shown to induce inhibition of GSK-3, which in turn decreased cleavage of APP by amyloidogenic γ-secretase (Rezai-Zadeh et al. 2009). Luteolin was also able to decrease the levels of soluble Aβ. A structurally similar flavonoid to luteolin, diosmin, has been found to suppress the pathological manifestations associated with Aβ in animal experiments.

Green, white and black teas contain the catechin, epigallocatechin-3-gallate (EGCG), which is frequently used in dietary supplements, due to its many health benefits. That EGCG has significant neuroprotective effects documented from a number of studies of cell lines and animal models (Mandel et al. 2008). EGCG has been shown to reduce Aβ levels in the brain via the modulation of APP processing (Rezai-Zadeh et al. 2008; Gaudreault and Mousseau 2019) and it inhibits Aβ aggregation in animal models via activation of α-secretase and by disrupting unfolded peptide (Awasthi et al. 2016). On the basis of theoretical studies it was proposed that, in addition to electrostatic effects, van der Waals interactions between EGCG and Aβ are important, and these appear to be responsible for the inhibitory activity of EGCG. EGCG not only reduces levels of Aβ, but can also lower levels of damaging ROS and ameliorate Aβ-induced mitochondrial dysfunction. It was found that ATP levels were increased by 75% in mitochondria isolated from various brain regions, such as cortex, striatum and hippocampus, due to the presence of EGCG (Dragicevic et al. 2011).

Among the most promising flavonoids that might be used for the protection of neurons against AD are myricetin, morin, rutin, quercetin, fisetin, kaempferol, apigenin and glycitein, since they have shown antiamyloidogenic and destabilizating effects toward Aβ fibrils (Ono et al. 2003). The antiamyloidogenic and fibril-destabilization activities of some flavonoids, as studied in vitro, were found to be in the following order: myricetin ~ morine ~ quercetin > kaempferol > catechin, which can be rationalized on the basis of structural similarities/differences of these molecules. The molecules of myricetin, morine, quercetin and kaempferol lack chirality, and both catechol and γ-benzopyrone moieties are located in a single plane. In contrast, the catechin molecule possesses two chiral centers, so the two rings occupy different planes. The anti-AD properties of flavonoids are also markedly influenced by their substitution by hydroxyl groups and, thus, as the number of hydroxyl groups increases in the series of flavonoids (myricetin 6, morin 5, quercetin 4 and kaempferol 4), their anti-AD activity also increases. From all of the above, it may be concluded that the antiamyloidogenic and fibril-destabilization properties of flavonoids are significantly influenced by the overall stereochemistry and number of hydroxyl groups in their molecules.

The optimal concentration of myricetin, morin, rutin and quercetin required for effective destabilization of Aβ fibrils has been found to be in the range of 0.1–1 μM (Ono et al. 2003). Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations revealed that destabilization of Aβ fibrils by morin is achieved via its binding at the end groups of the fibrils, which thereby creates a barrier against the attachment of another peptide (Lemkul and Bevan 2010). In addition, morin interacts with the hydrophobic core of the Aβ and breaks the interaction between oppositely charged residues of the Asp23–Lys28 fragment, in addition to destabilizing the hydrogen bonding network of the backbone.

From clinical studies it was discovered that quercetin exerts potent neuroprotective effects in patients suffering from AD according to an improvement in learning and spatial memory tasks, as determined by the elevated plus maze test (Bhullar and Rupasinghe 2013). Accordingly, in our own research group, we have investigated the antioxidant effect of free quercetin and quercetin coordinated to copper ions with regard to the formation of ROS in the Cu-catalyzed Fenton reaction and DNA damage (Jomova et al. 2017). Since the Cu(II)–quercetin (1:2) complex intercalates into DNA, a protective effect for quercetin via a ROS-scavenging mechanism has been confirmed only at higher stoichiometric ratios of quercetin relative to copper.

Some flavonoids are structurally homologous to the pharmacological modulators of ERK signaling and therefore their effect on the ERK pathways, via interactions with MAPK kinases MEK1 and MEK2 has been studied. It was found that activation of ERK can result in downstream activation of the cAMP response element-binding protein (CREB) which may upregulate neuroprotective pathways and synaptic plasticity and memory (Impey et al. 1998).

Catechins (e.g., EGCG) are the main components of green tea extract, and when senescence-accelerated mice were administered with green tea extracts for 6 months, it was shown that memory impairments were prevented by a suppressed formation of Aβ increased activity of the cAMP–PKA/CREB pathway, and the upregulation of proteins related to synaptic plasticity. (Li et al. 2009).

Resveratrol is a naturally occurring phenol which is produced by several plants as a protective substance against injury (Gomes et al. 2018). Although resveratrol exists in two isomers, the pharmacological activity of the cis-isomer has not as yet been elucidated. Resveratrol is present both as a free substance and as 3β-glucoside resveratrol in grapes and wine. The solubility of resveratrol in water is rather low, as too is its bioavailability, since the substance rapidly degrades (Rege et al. 2014). To overcome the biological obstacles associated with resveratrol administration, various strategies have been proposed and tested, including encapsulation of resveratrol in liposomal formulations, the application of protein (carrier)–resveratrol complexes, the use of solid lipid nanoparticles and the formation of resveratrol–cyclodextrin complexes (Augustin et al. 2013).

The protective antioxidant/radical-scavenging properties of resveratrol against neuronal damage have been the subject of various studies (Wang et al. 2018). It was found that long-term supplementation with resveratrol in rats with streptozotocin-induced diabetes suppressed the formation of malondialdehyde and restored glutathione levels to normal (Sadi and Konat 2016). Resveratrol scavenges ROS either directly or indirectly via inhibition of pro-oxidative genes such as NAD(P)H and activation of antioxidant enzymes including SOD, catalase, GPX and thioredoxin (Carrizzo et al. 2013). On the basis of animal studies it was shown that in addition to its direct ROS scavenging activity, resveratrol suppresses the activity of enzymes involved in formation of ROS, such as iNOS, which is associated with the Aβ-induced peroxidation of lipids and downregulation of heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1) (Huang et al. 2011). Since resveratrol is able to interact with redox-active metal ions, such an interaction may prevent accumulation of iron or copper which might otherwise lead to copper and/or iron-induced formation of ROS and neuroinflammation. As discussed above, dysregulation of zinc is also linked with AD, since accumulated zinc can indirectly promote ROS formation, mainly via displacing isostructural copper ions from copper-containing antioxidant enzymes. Resveratrol has not been shown to modulate zinc levels directly; however, the indirect and positive influence of resveratrol on zinc-related pathologies has been proven (Rege et al. 2014).

Resveratrol prevents the proinflammatory impact of Aβ on macrophages by inhibiting the activation of signal transducer and transcription (STAT) family proteins and of nuclear factor-kappaB, by interfering with IKK and IκB phosphorylation (Capiralla et al. 2012). An antiamyloidogenic effect of resveratrol is achieved by suppression of Aβ formation/aggregation and by the destabilization of Aβ fibrils (Rege et al. 2014). The long-term administration of resveratrol has been shown to be effective in protecting animals against Aβ-induced neuronal damage, increased expression of HO-1, cell death and lipid peroxidation.

Tannic acid is a plant polyphenol tannin containing a number of hydroxyl groups, which is found in green, black and white teas, bananas, beans, raspberries and other sources. Due to the number of hydroxyl groups present in its molecules, tannic acid can exert significant radical-scavenging/antioxidant, antiinflammatory and antibacterial effects and several in vivo and in vitro studies have demonstrated the neuroprotective effects of tannic acid against AD (Braidy et al. 2017). In addition to its redox metal-chelating and antioxidant properties, tannic acid is able to inhibit β-secretase (BACE1), which is responsible for the formation and deposition of the Aβ peptide, and it can also suppress aggregation of the principal component of intracellular neurobifrillary tangles (NFT), the τ-peptide.

Investigations were made of the potential therapeutic activity of flavonoids against cognitive impairments using rodent models, which demonstrated that anthocyanin-fortified bilberry extracts could modulate the APP processing that was directly linked with Aβ production and ameliorate cognitive impairments (Vepsalainen et al. 2013).

From the above information, it can be concluded that supplementation of elderly people with polyphenols may provide protection against the incidence and progression of AD. While positive potential therapeutic effects are clearly documented from a number of different studies, it is likely to take some considerable time before this knowledge can be transferred to clinical applications for the prevention/treatment of neurodegenerative diseases such as AD. By extrapolating the doses used in animal studies to humans (with an average weight of ca 75 kg), it appears that supplementation of about 3000 mg to 15,000 mg of a flavonoid per day is required; however, due to the fact that flavonoids undergo rapid metabolism and elimination or transformation, their bioavailability would appear to be a serious limitation. Hence, various formulations, for example, using nanocarriers, encapsulation matrixes and other means to increase the bioavailability of flavonoids for clinical applications, are necessary and it is hoped to prove successful in the near future.

Recently, it has been reported that corn silk contains many biologically active substances such as flavonoids, alkaloids, phytosterols, vitamins and other components (Li and Lapcik 2018; Ma et al. 2014; Hu and Deng 2011). Thus corn silk may be a valuable nutritional supplement to alleviate the symptoms of AD.

Metal complexes containing coordinated phenolic compounds (e.g., flavonoids) have been shown to be active against various cancer cells, such as leukemia cells, hepatocellular cells, cells of colon and rectum, cervical cells and other human cancer cells. Zn(II) and Mn(II) complexes with quercetin, Ni(II) complexes with rutin, Cd(II) complexes with morin and other metal–flavonoid complexes caused caspase activation and induction of apoptosis (Perron et al. 2011). Cytotoxicity of metal complexes was attributed predominantly to DNA intercalation mechanism of action. Intercalation mechanism has been substantiated by the insertion of a planar aromatic system of flavonoids between DNA base pairs. From the above follows that when selecting a suitable flavonoid for the treatment of AD, possible prooxidant properties of the flavonoid must be taken into account.

Antioxidants

Melatonin (Fig. 6) was discovered in 1958 and is a hormone that regulates circadian rhythms. Melatonin’s antioxidant properties were first described in 1993 by the group of Reiter (Tan et al. 1993). Although melatonin levels in the body decrease naturally, with age, AD patients have just half the level of melatonin as people without the disease. It has been found that supplementation of AD patients with melatonin alleviates both their sleep disorders and behavioral disturbances (sundowning) (Rosales-Corral et al.2012). It has been proposed that melatonin may inhibit the enzyme β-secretase and simultaneously enhance the α-secretase processing of βAPP. Since melatonin is a more efficient antioxidant than ascorbic acid and provides protection against metal-induced oxidative stress and also shows remarkable anti-neuroinflammatory properties, it is a promising potential therapeutic agent for the treatment of AD (Shukla et al. 2017). However, attention should be focused on optimizing both the required dose and the stage before the onset of the disease when melatonin should be administered.

Structures of melatonin and α-lipoc acid

Full size image

An interesting link between ascorbic acid and Aβ has been reported (Dikalov et al. 2004). While neurotoxic forms of Aβ were found to stimulate Cu-mediated oxidation of ascorbate anion (AscH⁻) to ascorbyl radical anion (Asc^·−) (Eq. 9), the nontoxic form of Aβ did not (Ryglewicz et al. 2002).

Oxidation of ascorbate anions by cupric ions reduces the latter to cuprous species (Eq. 10), which may catalyze the decomposition of hydrogen peroxide (Eq. 11) resulting in the formation of hydroxyl radicals. Reaction of cuprous species with molecular oxygen may regenerate cupric species and superoxide radical anions (Eq. 12). These reactions can be described as follows (see also Fig. 7):

Amyloid-β-copper(II) complex and oxidation of ascorbate

Full size image

A study has been made of the role of vitamin E in the prevention of neurodegenerative disorders (Azzi et al. 2003), the results of which indicated that vitamin E supplementation may be of the greatest benefit if it is commenced well before the onset of the various diseases and applied for a prolonged period. In addition, the most effective strategy seems to be to consume vitamin E together with ascorbate (vitamin C), which has a capacity to regenerate vitamin E from its radical form (the tocopherol radical) (Fig. 1).

α-Lipoic acid (Fig. 6) is a natural compound which is readily absorbed from the diet and reduced to its dithiol form, dihydrolipoic acid. Lipoic acid is soluble in both water and fat (Packer et al. 1995; Smith et al. 2004) and has been shown to confer physiological benefits to patients with AD. The beneficial properties of lipoic acid have been related to its antioxidant/radical-scavenging abilities and a stimulated formation of acetylcholine via activation of choline acetyltransferase. Lipoic acid is further able to chelate redox-active metals and thus prevent the formation of ROS via the Fenton reaction and it also contributes to the formation of the reduced form of glutathione (GSH) (Packer et al. 1997).

From a study in which nine patients (age: 67 ± 9 years) with AD and dementias were supplemented daily with 600 mg lipoic acid for a period of 337 ± 80 days (Maczurek et al. 2008), it was found that a stabilization of the decline of cognitive functions occurred, as demonstrated by the scores from two neuropsychological tests conducted over a period of almost 1 year. However, it has been pointed out that since lipoic acid is an effective chelator of redox-active metals, which may in turn lead to a depletion of metal-containing enzymes, its long-term use in the treatment of neurological diseases should be undertaken with caution (Suh et al. 2004).

AD is a multifactorial disease characterized by accumulation of the neurotoxic forms of Aβ peptide, which are capable of forming amyloid plaques. AD is also linked to a deficiency in the neurotransmitter acetylcholine in brains that have been associated with altered activity of the enzyme AChE, which converts acetylcholine into choline and acetate. An imbalance in redox metal homeostasis, resulting in ROS-induced oxidative stress, appears to be an important factor in the pathogenesis of AD. The observed oxidative stress markers in the AD brain involve DNA oxidation products, hydroxyl radical adducts with DNA bases, lipid peroxides, RNS, advanced glycation end products and other markers (Hatanaka et al. 2015).

The current strategy of medicinal chemists for battling AD is based on the design and studies of multifunctional drugs that combine Aβ antiaggregation activity, AChE inhibitory activity, and antioxidant and metal-chelating activity. In addition, the application of herbal drugs, flavonoids and antioxidants has a great therapeutic potential.

The main focus of research in this field is on modifications of existing drugs that have specific biological activity, of which tacrine is probably the most frequently used due to its cholinesterase inhibitory activity and is applied for the design of multitarget-directed ligands. A number of hybrid compounds containing structural moieties derived from natural sources, such as flavonoids, alkaloids, coumarin and other molecules, have also been investigated for the treatment of AD, the majority of which displayed improved antioxidant, metal-chelating and inhibitory activities toward AChE. Effective hybrid molecules include resveratrol, trolox and coumarin, in which the antioxidant moieties chelate redox metals and thus suppress metal-catalyzed formation of ROS (chelated metals have a lower catalytic activity than free metals) and/or directly scavenge ROS.

Many herbal drugs, such as huperzine A and B, ginseng, corilagen, curcumin and others are able to cross the BBB and exhibit therapeutic potential via the inhibition of AChE, chelation of redox-active metals, inhibition of the aggregation of Aβ and reduction of neuroinflammation.

Flavonoids not only act as antioxidants, but are also signaling molecules, and are able to slow down the progression of the disease and improve cognitive performance in patients suffering from AD. An important property is their ability to chelate redox metals and cause disruption of Aβ aggregation (Baptista et al. 2014). Several flavonoids have been reported with promising neuroprotective properties against cognitive dysfunction in AD. The flavonoid, quercetin, protects neurons against severe oxidative stress and attack by ROS via mild intercalation of its molecules into DNA, thus creating a protective barrier against stronger intercalators and/or attack by ROS.

Among the critical challenges that must be met in regard to the clinical use of antioxidants or flavonoids against AD are: to establish the ideal dose, to devise effective formulations to preserve bioavailability, and the most effective stage at which to administer the drug, so as to optimize the overall effectiveness of the antioxidant therapy. The key aim is to determine and optimize the age of the patient at which it is most effective to start the antioxidant therapy, to delay the onset of AD by at least 5 years. This would reduce the number of current sufferers of AD by one-half in less than 25 years. If the onset could be delayed by a decade, the current number of AD patients would be reduced by 80%. Delaying the onset of the disease and/or alleviating the symptoms using multifunctional hybrid or single molecules is a critical goal in the battle against AD.