Carnival in Flanders (musical)

Harold Arlen was approached to write the score, but the task ultimately fell to Van Heusen and Burke. Bing Crosby was providing much of the financing for the production and had great faith in the songwriting team,^[2] who had written several of his hits, despite the fact that their previous theatrical collaboration, Nellie Bly (1946),^[3] had been a critical and commercial flop.

George Oppenheimer, one of the book's original co-writers, withdrew from the project during pre-Broadway tryouts in Philadelphia, and Dorothy Fields joined her brother Herbert to help with rewrites. Eventually all their work was discarded by Sturges, who replaced Bretaigne Windust as director and completely reworked the book before the show reached California for a series of stagings by light opera companies prior to the New York City opening. Choreographer Jack Cole was replaced by Helen Tamiris, and several cast changes were made before the troubled production finally opened on Broadway.

Carnival in Flanders opened on September 8, 1953 at the New Century Theatre, where it ran for only six performances. The cast included John Raitt, Dolores Gray, and Roy Roberts. Critics were enchanted by Oliver Smith's sets and Lucinda Ballard's costumes, inspired by Brueghel paintings, and Gray's lively performance,^[2] but universally panned every other aspect of the production. In his review for The New York Times, Brooks Atkinson wrote "As an actress [Dolores Gray] is authoritative enough to bring down the house with some of the maudlin songs...In the version prepared for the stage by Preston Sturges it is laborious and banal... As usual, the theatre has lavished a lot of wealth and talent on this hokum. Lucinda Ballard has dressed everybody to the nines... Although Oliver Smith's scenery is cluttered and rather desperate, there is certainly a lot of it."^[4]

According to Sturges, the available rehearsal time prior to the Broadway opening was not sufficient for the actors to be comfortable with the changes, and he attributes this as the reason for the play's commercial and critical failure.^[5] If remembered at all, it is primarily as the source of the Van Heusen-Burke standard "Here's That Rainy Day."^[6]

• Jan Breugel
• The Butcher
• The Inkeeper
• The Barber-Surgeon
• The Fishermonger
• Lisa, the Inkeepers wife
• Else, The Barber-Surgeon wife
• Marie, The Fishermonger's wife
• The Burgomaster
• Cornelia
• Siska
• The Duke D'olivares
• The Courier

Dolores Gray won the Tony Award for Best Actress in a Musical.^[6] It remains the shortest-lived Tony-honored performance ever.^[2]

Notes

Bibliography

• Mandelbaum, Ken, Not Since Carrie: Forty Years of Broadway Musical Flops. New York, St. Martin's Press, 1991. pages 169-71

• ​Carnival in Flanders​ at the Internet Broadway Database  
• Carnival in Flanders on Floormic.com at archive.today (archived January 23, 2013)