Chapter Text
You run out ahead of the two boys who just wouldn’t leave you alone. Turning back to look at them you giggle, as they try to reach out for you, “Missed me again, Carter!” You continue running, until Bryce is able to catch up, jumping in front of you, and Carter comes from behind.
“Caught you, Starlight,” Bryce says, placing an open mouth kiss to your neck. Carter’s hands start to roam around your hips, dipping lower when you push them away.
“No, no sharing yet.”
“Why?” Bryce whines. He sticks his lower lip out, while Carter rests his chin on your shoulder. “We’ve been taking turns and watching for awhile. Can’t we just try and share?”
“Yeah, Starlight, we will be so good for you.”
With Carter’s arms around your hips, and you grow wetter by the second, you look at Bryce. Would it be so bad, and terrible if you just let them share you like they had wanted. Taking turns with them had been fun. You loved having Carter taunt Bryce, while he slowly stroked his cock. Or when Bryce had you in the floor fucking into you, while Carter pretended to be watching a movie. The strain in his pants proved just how much he had enjoyed the show.
“Have you ever heard of men sharing women?”
“You have no idea,” Carter responds, nibbling on your ear. “Come on, let’s go back to the house,” your body stiffens up. There was something off about that house. The boys wanted to act that you were being silly, but there were secrets within those walls.
“Why don’t you tell me who else lives there?” You cock up your eyebrow, pulling Bryce closer to you and Carter. Letting them get a tiny taste of sandwiching you.
“Why is it any of your business? It’s just an old frat house. Some of the alums visit with their wives, or girlfriends, and they like things to stay quiet. I think they’re all there tonight. Maybe after we’ve got you loosened up, you can meet them,” Bryce’s slots his lips against yours, while Carter kisses along your neck. His body rocks into the back of your ass, and it just felt so damn good.
“But, won’t people hear?” You pant out. Carter smiles on your neck, starting to nip at the sensitive area. “I mean won’t — people care?”
“A couple of the members are in a poly relationship. This isn’t just sex,” Bryce’s hand kneads on your tit, and you start to melt on him. “It’s nothing, and even if there weren't others, who cares? Don’t me and Carter make you feel good?”
Carter’s hands start drifting up your dress, and your body folds, pushing your ass into him, whimpering out both of their names, “Wouldn’t you like to know what we both feel like in you? We would treat you so good, it would open up so many more opportunities. They’ll love you.”
“I want both of you,” your voice was already wrecked, and they hadn’t done anything. Feeling over your body out in the open, and you really just wanted them inside of you.
“Of course you do,” Carter says as a car pulls up. He opens the door letting Bryce and yourself crawl in, and gives a nod to the man in the front. You were letting their hands continue to tease you, not caring that there was a girl leaned over in the front seat. Her head bobbing on the driver’s dick. You didn’t pay any attention to her gagging as she sucked the life out of him through his cock. Or notice how that car was randomly right where Carter and Bryce needed them to be. No, you didn’t care.
You had a leg draped on either side of them as they took turns palming you over your covered core. The three of you in the oddest make out ring. Taking turns with each other, or you watching the two of them. Biting on your lip, when Carter dips below your panties. “Fuck,” the woman in the front seat grunts.
“Shh, you only got to go because Muffin and Justin couldn’t handle anymore. Back to work,” he says, pushing her back down. He pulls into the clubhouse, and gives a nod to the two boys, “We’ll be seeing you later. Fuck, right there.”
Picking you up, Bryce lets your legs wrap tight around him. His hands lifting you up, rubbing your sex over him, “She’s so hot, Carter. She won’t need any prep. Are you excited about finally taking both of us? How do you want us? Your cunt, ass, or mouth?”
You mewl as he takes you into a new room. A gigantic mirror on the wall, to better watch them tear you apart. With a look at your reflection, you knew it was going to be a long night. “Not my mouth,” you sigh as Carter starts to take your clothes off. Making sure to give you plenty of kisses over your heated skin. Bryce walks to the side, hitting a button to start recording the session, but also grabbing up some lube.
Walking back to you, he stumbles trying to get out of his clothes, “I want her ass,” he says with a grunt. Carter didn’t care, he just wanted the three of you connected finally.
He squirts some lube on his cock, while you start to crawl over Carter. Not waiting for Bryce as you start to ride Carter. You look over at the mirror watching as you work yourself over him. Able to see Bryce smirking at you, before walking behind the two of you. Pouring some of the lube out on your tight hole. He watches you fuck Carter a moment, before grabbing at your hips.
“Stop moving, Starlight,” he runs his tip over your puckered hole, massaging over the tight entrance before he pushes through. You gasp at the intrusion. Sure they had each had your ass, but your cunt had been empty. Now here Carter was petting over your face, while Bryce took his time sliding into your ass. Stopping only when he bottoms out, and you release a deep moan. The both of them kiss over your sticky skin. “You took us both so well.”
“It was like you were made for us.
“I always knew you had it in you.”
“I bet you feel us in your stomach, huh?”
Non stop praises over and over again, while you try and focus on the torturous pleasure. Out of your mind and out of your body, just pure euphoria. You had taken them both at the same time, and there was a beauty in it. A fullness you couldn’t explain, nor would you want to. It was just Carter, Bryce, and you.
Both of them stare at you like the goddess you are. Their hands soothingly touch over your body, such a juxtaposition to the way that they rut into you. Carter was more smooth, while Bryce was grabbing you. Neither could get enough of you, or this moment. You were clenching around them in minutes, and a pleasure that makes everything go white rushes over your body.
“Did you come already?” Bryce asks, taking a nibble of your shoulder. His pelvis barely pushes into you, while he watches you come back down from your high.
“Oh, Bryce, she’s in for a treat then. Go on and finish, she’s got a long night ahead of her. You’re finally going to become one of us. You want that don’t you?”
“Yes. I want to always be a part of you.”
“Good. To the brotherhood,” Bryce grabs tightly to your hips, and stabs into your ass. Utterly destroying you, while Carter tries to keep you relaxed.
“What’s mine is theirs,” he smiles at you, but you were too busy, laying your body on his chest. Letting the two of them make a mess of you, while you enjoy taking them both. Your body accommodated them both so well, and that was a good thing.
You squeeze onto Carter’s arms as Bryce pounds into you. Both of their cocks twitch inside your body, and you wonder if this was always what it was going to be like. Would you always feel this good with them? But when their spunk fills you to the brim simultaneously with the three of you coming, you know it’s true.
“Move aside, boys,” that was a new voice. You peek around you and Bryce and see your professor standing at the door. “It’s time to start your new life. Thirty-two more times. You know the rules. Don’t cum in her. If she passes out, keep going. When we’re finished, Carter and Bryce will stay with her. Feed her, give her water, massage her aching body, and then she’ll be fitted with her own bracelet.”
“What’s happening?” You ask as Bryce gets off of you. Carter pushes you to the side as more men come into the room. “What’s going on?”
“Starlight, you wanna be with us, right?”
“Y-y-yeah,” your legs get jerked down the bed, as a large man starts to take himself out.
“This is Ari,” Bryce lets you know. Ari’s hand runs up your slit, watching your boyfriends cum ooze out of both of your holes. “There are more. We protect our own. So we need to be a part of one another. Just take it like a good girl.”
Ari’s length slams into you, and you chirp looking at them. “It’s the only way we can be together,” Carter lets you know. Sitting on the bed beside you as he pets your hair gently. “We take care of our own. They have to know that you’re worth taking of.”
“They?”
You watch confused as men upon men walk into your room. All staring at where Ari connects to you. His pace was brutal. His hands tight on your body. Counting thirty-two more men. “They don’t have to touch you after this. But they will protect all of us. We’ll have a good life. You understand don’t you?”
Ari’s thumb presses on your clit, and he gives your little bean hard tight circles. “You won’t remember most of us,” Ari grunts, shooting his load up your chest. “But we’ll all remember you,” he taps on another man’s shoulder while he moves to you. Flipping you around on your knees.
“It’s a business deal, Starlight. Welcome to your new life. Just relax. We’ll take care of the rest,” Bryce lets you know that his name was Frank that was commanding you.
“Okay,” you whine, and both the boys move to pet your skin.
“We’ll be with you the whole time.”
“And, should they hurt you, we kill them,” a man with long hair leans down beside you, brushing your hair out of your face. “Just ask Rumlow’s girl. She now belongs to Steve and Bucky. We don’t hurt our Omegas. We protect them.”
Pleasure courses through your veins as Frank lets his spend spurt on your ass. His absence was quickly replaced by another. And then another. And another, losing count and consciousness, but you were welcoming it. Protection. Love. A built in family. And above all else…TO THE BROTHERHOOD.