some advice? Please dont laugh when I say this. I'm transgender, ftm, but I dont like being called transgender, I just want to be called male. But at the same time,I'm african american, and dont want to be an african american male. The very thought scares me to no end and makes me want to not bother with transitioning. My therapist says that my dysmorphia and dysphoria are too conflicting to do anything with, but I dont want to stay as I am. So I'm at an stalemate. Idk what to do next. Advice?
(Disclaimer: Iâm not a therapist or any sort of medical professional, so I can only offer my opinions + advice, but if anything feels off to you at all, then totally feel free to ignore it!)
Of course Iâm not gonna laugh, Anon, and I donât get why anyone would -- youâre in a very, very difficult, painful position, and a LOT of therapists arenât great at figuring out the tentative balance of understanding who a patient is, what a patient needs, what a patient wants, and which steps they need to take with said patient in order to not harm that person... it can definitely take time. If theyâre a good fit for you, theyâll become better at understanding that balance (and also doing their proper research) as they get to know you more, and will offer more helpful options if theyâre open-minded about trying a variety of angles instead of just sticking to their little therapy scripts, esp when those scripts donât always apply neatly to every individual.
Iâm not trans (and Iâm white), so I could be totally off on a bunch of what Iâm about to say (plus everyoneâs experiences are different regardless), but I have met a few different people who donât want to refer to themselves -- or be referred to as -- transgender. Though their birth assignment doesnât align with who they are, which fits the definition of âtransâ, the term itself just... doesnât work for them, specifically, and I think I can understand that.  I was born intersex (a person with mixed physical sex characteristics -- many that I didnât even find out about until much later in life), but I wouldnât consider that to be a huge part of me, or a defining way to describe my own relationship with gender. For example, I wouldnât want to be referred to as âthat intersex personâ, by other people, unless it was genuinely medically relevant in that moment.
So what Iâm personally interpreting from what youâve written here is that you donât want the bodily aspect of things to be this constant focus of what your experience in life is, regarding gender. Since cisgender (and also many intersex men, tbh) get to be referred to as just men, then you should be able to have that same thing, if it feels right for you, imo.  You being what other people would define as âtransâ doesnât make you less of a man regardless, so, ultimately, itâs fair to just want to be referred to as a man, same as all other men.
Wrt to you not wanting to be an African American male due to the terror you feel associated with that specific combo of identities -- well, that sounds incredibly tough for you to be going through, and to try to reconcile! And itâs something I canât personally imagine (I wish I could help more, so Iâll just offer what I can, but again, if anything sounds off to you, feel free to disregard what Iâm saying!)Â
I can think of a lot of reasons off the top of my head as to why a person would be terrified to be a black man, but the ones that come to mind for me are things like: having to face an increased risk of police brutality, racism, other stereotypes, other pplâs expectations as to who you should be -- all those types of wide-reaching social reasons. But I also donât know if those reasons are your specific reasons for being terrified of being an African American male, you know? Like on a personal level. I can take a guess at more specific, internal reasons you might have, but that would be me kinda doing armchair therapy, so I wonât deep-dive there -- however, itâs always a good idea, and appropriate, for you to do some of that intense self-examination, you know? And Iâm sure you and your therapist have done a lot of that already, but if you havenât yet written down your exact reasons for this particular terror, maybe try that out! Itâs one of the skills we learn in DBT (and other forms of therapy that Iâve been through).
Iâd write out separate pages for each specific thought. For example, one page listing the reasons/thoughts/emotions as to why you donât feel comfortable with being labelled as trans (the ways in which it doesnât apply to you, how you feel when someone does apply it, etc). And another sheet listing the reasons/thoughts/emotions as to why being an African American man would terrify you, VS just being African American in general.  Again, your reasons for not wanting to be referred to a certain way are totally valid, Anon! These sorts of sheets/journaling exercises are just to help you feel like you have a more solid grasp on where your own emotions are coming from, and to give you something physical to hold onto when you want to explain it in more detail to yourself and your therapist!Â
A really, really, really helpful sort of worksheet/mindfulness activity to help us figure out what weâre feeling is this one I also learned in DBT (a form of therapy that is just ridiculously helpful for everyone, imo), and may help with writing out the things I mentioned above. These are called behaviour chain analysis worksheets, and are usually used to prevent a behaviour that you want to stop engaging in, but what they also ultimately do is help ppl unravel thoughts, emotions -- your primary emotion is especially important to know, because thatâs something you can then target with your therapist. Hereâs some info on how to do one: https://www.verywellmind.com/how-to-do-a-chain-analysis-for-problem-behaviors-2797587
And a basic worksheet version (it can rly help to have on-hand, so it can be written down and you can check it out whenever you need to). https://www.dbtselfhelp.com/html/behavior_chain_analysis.html
Like, for example, say you do one of these sheets to figure out the primary emotion behind bodily dysmorphia. Say the behaviour was that you snapped at a friend for making a comment about your body, and you want to know why exactly you snapped at them (what about their comment hurt enough to elicit the reaction), and prevent it in the future. The behaviour chain analysis is a space where you can write down what the behaviour was.  In this example itâd be; âBehaviour: Snapped At Friendâ, and then you write down the initial feelings you had associated with it, and the thoughts that went with those feelings. Â
Eventually, for example, say that you thought the reason you snapped at them was anger (which is by definition, a secondary emotion -- secondary emotions arenât less important than primary emotions, but theyâre the emotions that happen after primary emotions, sometimes mere seconds after), but when you look at the thoughts you wrote down that you experienced in the moment you snapped at the friend, and dig a little deeper, say it turned out that the primary emotion (the one that happened before the thoughts, and before the secondary emotions) wasnât anger, but actually shame.
(Iâm not saying yours will be shame btw, I just like using shame as an example, because a lot of my own thoughts and feelings and behaviours and inner conflicts are rooted in shame).
So then that gives you something solid to show yourself, but also to bring to your therapist. Instead of the therapist focusing on only the thoughts and feelings that theyâre visibly seeing in you in a session, they now know that youâre struggling with underlying shame, or sorrow, or grief, or disgust, or fear, or whatever the primary emotions end up being for you. Then the therapist can more easily help you through tackling the dysmorphia, and any unwanted behaviours and thoughts + emotions associated with it. And being able to tackle one of the things youâre struggling with in the ask you sent me above means that the dysphoria may start to make more sense for you in the same context as the dysmorphia -- and, hopefully, there will eventually be less of a conflict between the two, or at least theyâll be more understandable, even if theyâre entirely separate from each other.
Since youâre not yet sure you want to transition due to these very genuine inner conflicts, then, like, I get why your therapist isnât going ahead with it, but I also donât want you to have to stagnate with therapy, or be denied the sense of progress, or with generally getting to know yourself either -- I want you to have the opportunity to live a life that feels right for you, but without the various intense fears associated with that! And I know that itâs fully possible, and will likely just take time, and support, and a willingness to unravel some things that... are probably gonna hurt a lot to unravel. So you should definitely make sure youâre ready to unpack those things and are doing it with a professional you trust; and that you have outside support networks as well (friends, family, whoever is close to you that you can talk to).
Remember that thereâs absolutely no time limit on when you can and canât transition, if you choose to in the future! Plus, there are ways of transitioning that arenât All The Way, you know? Reversible things you can do (which may have been what you were asking for from the start, ahahaha! My apologies for my wordiness in this response :â)
There are obvs options like binding, packing, etc., that you probably already know about (and know more about than me, tbh). But you can also try other things out too -- there are certain types of makeup techniques/contouring for a more masculine look, more natural forms of altering hormones (if you feel safe doing so, and your doctor suggests any safe options -- definitely research this one thoroughly ahead of time). Â
A legal change of name can also switch up how you feel a whole lot, if youâre ready/able to do so, (and if not, even just asking ppl to refer to you by a name that you choose, or a variety of different names, depending on whether youâre not sure which one fits yet; itâs always okay to change your mind wrt these things). Â
Changing your wardrobe drastically can also rly alter how other ppl view and treat you, and I know there are resources online, and many on this site (mainly written by ppl who use the term trans for themselves, but that will hopefully be helpful to you as well), that have clothing swap links, and other suggestions as to more transition-related things you can do to move forward, while also not making any decisions that feel too permanent! Here are some of the links/resources along that vein that I could find:
https://transclothesexchange.tumblr.com/ (clothing exchanges)
https://transguys.com/style/trans-clothing-exchanges (clothing exchanges)
https://thebodyisnotanapology.tumblr.com/post/97564996149/transgender-resources (resources in general, including general body positivity, which could be incredibly helpful during especially dysmorphic and/or dysphoric times!)Â
https://advicefromabro.tumblr.com/gi (I think this is an older post, but it mentions an app that will allow you to find a gender-neutral or safe bathroom, if thatâs currently a concern for you!)
https://transstudiesarchive.tumblr.com/post/168139537672/transgender-resources-masterpost (looks like this one has some resources for African American people as well, among a variety of races)
https://nonbinary-support.tumblr.com/resources (this one has some links regarding name changes and tips for choosing a name, if thatâs something that youâre interested in!)
https://transgenderteensurvivalguide.tumblr.com/post/147789231360/makeup-tips-for-ftm-people (some makeup and skincare tips for men!)
(I hope some of these are helpful for you, Anon! Iâm sorry that they use language that doesnât apply to you, itâs just what came up when I researched these tips -- but I think these are resources that could be helpful for anyone in a similar boat, not strictly trans ppl!)
In any case, whatever you do and donât do, you can always choose who you are and how you represent yourself. There are some physical aspects to a body that cannot be changed, or can only be changed with medical intervention, and some aspects of appearance that will always be there (skin colour, etc), but these things donât define who you are. I dunno how helpful this will be, but I wanted to also leave you with this; you may have certain body parts, but they arenât your gender, or the sum of you. People might assign labels like âtransâ to you, but that doesnât make them right, or you wrong.  Youâre African American, but thatâs not the sum of you either. Your race, your gender, these are important aspects of our lives in the sense that they inform our experiences in a lot of ways, but they arenât Who You Are. âAfrican American maleâ may be something a doctor writes on a sheet for you someday, or maybe not, but regardless, it says nothing about you as a person: Â
It doesnât tell anyone what you love, what you dislike, what makes you happy, your hobbies and interests, what youâre good at, what you want to become good at, your dreams, your goals, your personal achievements, those little things in life that make you smile sometimes, your complexities, your favourite colour, a place youâd love to go, a place you already like to go when you want to be alone, or somewhere or something you want to share with a loved one someday, a movie scene that made you cry, whether or not youâre an animal person/want pets (or already have them), your lifelong habits, embarrassing things you did when you were younger, how deeply and wonderfully you affect the people in your life, stories you may have created, your sense of beauty and style, a song or a poem that speaks to you, your sense of humour... all these things are yours. No matter where you are in life right now, and no matter where you want to be in the future! No one has the right to define you but you -- and no one can take that from you.Â
Happy New Year, Anon! And best of wishes~!!! : D