Doctor Who, but Chronologically: 57
IT WAS A FOUR-PARTER!!! Sort of. No Slitheen this time, but we return to 2006 for Christmas, to discover that:
- The Doctor is mid-regeneration, with a shiny new David Tennant-shaped face and a coma
- Mickey and Jackie don't know when Rose will come back, but they're clearly listening out for the TARDIS at all times, and
- Harriet Jones is now Prime Minister!
This last point is what makes it a very neat quadrilogy when watched this way, because the Themes mean you could bundle this as a single story and call it the Rise and Fall of Harriet Jones. It's interesting, too, because by the end of this story, Harriet has disgraced herself by shooting an alien ship out of the sky and the Doctor brings down her government in retaliation, a plot point that I hated 20 years ago when this episode first aired; funnily enough, though, I find that I now think it's the right choice from a story perspective. I still wish it didn't happen, like, because I like the character. But, in terms of plot and story and Themes... yes, correct ending. BUT I DON'T HAVE TO LIKE IT. I contain multitudes.
I'm getting ahead of myself. Okay, so, the TARDIS crashes into Rose's housing estate, nearly flattening Mickey and Jackie, and the Doctor staggers out, beams "Merry Christmas!" at them both, and then promptly falls into a coma. He is still wearing Christopher Eccleston's leather jacket, which is really wearing him. Rose follows, looking shell-shocked and traumatised, and tells her family that this is the Doctor now.
And so, a major Theme of the episode is the central question: if he can change like this so radically, Doctor Who? Who is he now? Has he changed too much? Is this the same man?
This would be shocking and compelling! Except we've seen about six different Doctors. Old news. Fuck, we've even seen Clara reacting to Peter Capaldi. It was harder for her; neither she nor Rose know what the fuck is going on, because no one has deigned to tell either, but at least Rose is surrounded by people who validate her feelings and try to support her through it rather than emotionally abusing her and trying to tell her she's a shallow cunt who just wants to fuck him because she reacts with any emotion other than blinding happiness while he calls her a freak and chooses to abandon her in a different century three times.
Anyway: new Tennant! I wonder how we lost Eccleston? Let's see how soon we get that answer :)
Meanwhile, a nice Welshman with a beautiful accent called Mr Llywelyn (not that anyone else pronounces it right) has sent a probe to Mars, containing samples of Earth things in case of aliens. This includes rocks and seeds and a sample of human blood, for baffling reasons. Unfortunately, it is intercepted by a bunch of skull-faced aliens doing a Queen Bohemian Rhapsody impression. They arrive and use the blood to do a sort of mass hypnosis on anyone who is A+ blood type (not me lol. Uh, my husband though) and make them stand on roofs, ready to jump. They then beam Harriet Jones and the beautiful Welshman and also an assistant and an army man aboard, and tell Harriet that if she surrenders the planet, half of humanity will be enslaved; if not, a third will jump to their deaths.
They also immediately kill the nice Welshman, because Welsh people are not allowed to survive. Never forgive, never forget. Oh, and the army man, but shrug.
Anyway, after being menaced by four Santas and a Christmas tree for a bit, Rose and Mickey wrestle the unconscious Doctor back into the TARDIS, and then the Sycorax beam them aboard. Rose takes a brave stand, and tries to imitate the Doctor by telling the Sycorax to get fucked. She does this by citing a bunch of aliens and monsters she's heard of/encountered! This includes:
- The Shadow Proclamation (we've seen this! The Doctor says this to the Nestene Consciousness)
- The Gelth Confederacy (we've seen this! the ghosts in Dickensian London!)
- The Slitheen (we've seen this! FOUR PARTER)
- The Mighty Jagrafess (the what?)
- The Daleks (we've seen this! Churchill had some, with Matt Smith and Amy. And there were some in Manhattan with Martha and some pig men. But when has Rose seen them?)
It doesn't work and she is laughed at. Mean.
But Mickey accidentally pours tea into the TARDIS and that finally wakes the Doctor up, who manages to save the day by means of an extraordinarily camp sword fight for possession of the planet, during which two different things are dropped off the spaceship and onto London below: (a) the Doctor's severed hand (it grows back using regeneration energy); (b) AN ENTIRE SYCORAX WARRIOR, COMPLETE WITH SWORD
No one seems bothered by the idea that those might have landed on someone. ALSO, it was only a few episodes back that River told us the Doctor's corpse needs to be burned, because a single cell could bring down entire intergalactic empires in the wrong hands - are we okay?? With an entire hand??? Just falling on South Wimbledon?? Unclear. No one seems to give a shit. Hope that doesn't crop up again :)
The Sycorax promise to leave, on pain of satsuma. The gang go back to London. And then, in a truly bewildering move, the Doctor tells Harriet about all the hundreds if not thousands of alien species wanting to conquer Earth and then wanders off for crisps. This is not Reassuring, and makes her decide that Earth needs to be able to defend itself for when it doesn't have the Doctor around to win improbable swordfights. And so, she orders "Torchwood" to fire on the spaceship.
WHICH IS FUN BECAUSE we have, in fact, already heard of Torchwood! We saw it founded by Queen Victoria, to kill alien threats and that. This is not mysterious to us. More confirmation that they're still about. But the upshot is, the big Torchwood gun obliterates the fleeing spaceship, and so the Doctor is furious at, you know, all the deaths, and so he says to the assistant man, "Don't you think she looks tired?"
The following day Harriet is embroiled in a health scandal and a vote of no confidence is called.
Speaking as someone who lived and blogged through the fall of the Tory party in the last five years, LOL would that happen the next day. This is less believable to me than the Sycorax. But okay.
(I still mourn the fall of Harriet Jones. But, I do now think that's a good narrative choice. People in positions of power may have wonderful personalities - Harriet knows everyone's names, and makes people coffee, and is a general delight in spite of being PM - but when they are responsible for that many lives and then live through the trauma of seeing people murdered in front of them, they may choose to wield their power negatively, for very human and understandable reasons. Her empathy becomes her weakness. She doesn't want anyone else to die; she feels scared; she feels guilty and responsible. And so she chooses to kill a fleeing enemy to send a message. That's good character work, and good for establishing to the audience that the Doctor is a character who nonetheless will never make that choice, and nor should you. I think this is right and good, but I reserve the right to be grumpy about it because I like Harriet Jones T_T)
Anyway, ultimately, Rose decides he's still the Doctor, and chooses to keep travelling with him. Jesus, though, but this is a softer Doctor. Episode 2 of this four-parter ended with Eccleston insisting that he will not ever do dinner with family, and bullying Rose into leaving with him; this one ends with Tennant sitting at Christmas dinner in a paper crown, and shyly asking Rose if she still wants to come with him, while they both gaze with naked adoration at one another. Fuck Mickey - the entire audience feels like a third wheel. I felt like I needed to pull a curtain across the TV.
Oddly, we are nonetheless told that this Doctor is a "no second chances sort of man". I wonder how consistent that will prove to be :)
ANYWAY. Let's update the board!