Shivika Agrawal - Dissertation Final
Shivika Agrawal - Dissertation Final
Shivika Agrawal - Dissertation Final
Year: 2021-22
Batch No. 19
Undertaken by:
Shivika Agrawal
The study titled “Contemplative Spaces in Architecture ” is hereby approved as an original work of
Shivika Agrawal enrolment no. 17E1AAARM40P021 on the approved subject carried out and
presented in manner satisfactory to warrant its acceptance as per the standard laid down by the
university. This report has been submitted in the partial fulfillment for the award of Bachelor of
Architecture degree from Rajasthan Technical University, Kota.
It is to be understood that the undersigned does not necessarily endorse or approve any statement
made, any opinion expressed or conclusion drawn therein, but approves the study only for the purpose
it has been submitted.
12.12.2021
Jaipur
i
DECLARATION
I, Shivika Agrawal, here by solemnly declare that the research work undertaken by
me, titled ‘ Contemplative Spaces in Architecture ’ is my original work and wherever I have
incorporated any information in the form of photographs, text, data, maps, drawings, etc. from
different sources, has been duly acknowledged in my report.
This dissertation has been completed under the supervision of the guide allotted to
me by the school. Further, whenever and wherever my work shall be presented or
published it will be jointly authored with my guide.
Shivika Agrawal
V Year B.Arch (C)
Aayojan School of Architecture, Jaipur
CERTIFICATE
This is to certify that the research titled, Contemplative Spaces in Architecture is a bonafide work by
Shivika Agrawal of Aayojan School of Architecture, Jaipur. This research work has been completed
under my guidance and supervision in a satisfactory manner. This report has been submitted in partial
fulfillment of award of BACHELOR OF ARCHITECTURE degree from Rajasthan Technical University,
Kota.This research work fulfills the requirements relating to the nature and standard laid down by the
Rajasthan Technical University.
ii
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
I would also like to thank the Dean of Academics, Prof. N.S. Rathore for his able advice and valuable
time throughout the research process.
I would like to express gratitude to Dissertation and Thesis Coordinator, Prof. Archana S. Rathore, for
giving me a chance to take up this research and constant motivation throughout.
My sincere thanks to my dissertation guide, Prof. Naveen Sharma for his valuable advices and
criticisms throughout my research journey, which helped me learn better and produce better results.
Lastly, I would like to express my heartfelt gratitude to my friends and family who have constantly
motivated me throughout my journey, without whom this would not have been successful.
Shivika Agrawal
V Year B.Arch. C
Aayojan School of Architecture, Jaipur
iii
ABSTRACT
Space for contemplation helps architecture reach more spiritual realms. By allowing users to have a space
where they can think, pray, meditate, or simply just be in the present moment. Contemplative spaces
create an environment for user where one can achieve mindfulness. One needs a certain time for
ourselves to realize and analyze the inner most consciousness, Humans have now got a tendency to get
attracted to what is outside them and not what lies within. Though peace can be found anywhere and
everywhere but, because of the hush and bush around, people are getting away from the real spirituality
Le. 'connection with your inner self. Therefore, because of the imbalance that is being created, has to
change in terms of human well-being giving an opportunity to the vast study of architecture to put
forward its intelligence in creating spaces that will attract humans for their own benefits and that it will
keep them at a distance from the commercial world.
This research studies the qualitative parameters of contemplative spaces such as philosophy and various
elements which helps in creating the experience soul stirring for the user. The cases which were required
to direct this research are: Widhover Contemplative Center, Shreyas Retreat Centre, Jawahar Kala Kendra
and Osho Dham. The research also focuses on the experience of human beings in such spaces.
The method used in this research is based on literature review for collecting data and observation to
identity and analyze the qualities of various spiritual spaces. By comparing the result of identified cases
the final result would be obtained.
The study would conclude that the Fundamental elements of contemplative center enhances the user
experience. Various design elements would be recommended that helps in enhancing the user experience.
iv
CONTENTS
Approval
Declaration
Certificate
Acknowledgement
Abstract
Contents
List of illustrations
List of fables
v
CHAPTER 3 : IDENTIFIED CASES OF BUILT ENVIRONMENT 12-24
5.1 Conclusion
5.2 Recommendations
Bibliography
vi
List of Illustrations
9 https://www.architecturalrecord.com
Fig 2.13 Light role
10 https://www.architecturalrecord.com
Fig 2.14 Widhover view
Fig 2.15 shaded spiral pathway 10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?
v=BUYeQa_-ojk
Fig 2.17 Light and shadow 10 Book : Psychological impact of light and
colour
Chapter 3 :
15 https://www.architecturalrecord.com
Fig 3.6 View
18 https://www.archdaily.com/795356/
Fig 3.23 shreyas-retreat-the-purple-ink-studio
Chapter 5 :
According to Pallasma, an impressive architectural experience sensitises our whole physical and
mental receptivity. After decades of abstract scientific theory, it is urgent that we return to a
qualitative, phenomenological understanding of architecture Aravet, who stresses the importance of
phenomenology in contemporary architectural discourse, describes phenomenology as "a core field of
philosophy that is rooted in the first person.
1
1.2 CRITERIA OF SELECTION
Therefore a detailed study of spaces that is helpful in making an atmosphere for contemplation is
important. The quality of built environment will have a major role in this research.
2
HYPOTHESIS
AIM -
Analysing the qualities of Architecture that contributes in making the environment helpful in
achieving mindfulness.
SCOPE :
Research would include the study of the qualitative parameters of a Contemplative Spaces . The study
will also focus on the comparitive analysis of the case-studies.
LIMITATION :
The study will be limited to qualitative parameters of contemplative spaces, it will not include
phenomological aspect of the contemplative spaces.
OBJECTIVE:
4) To conclude the physical paramters of the contemplative space help users in achieving the state of
contemplation
3
1.7 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY
Selection of Topic
Contemplative Spaces in Architecture
Hypothesis Statement:
Fundamental elements of contemplative space enhances user ecperience
Analysis
4
CHAPTER 2
CONTEMPLATIVE SPACES
AND ITS
CHARACTERISTICS
1.1 Contemplation
con·tem·pla·tion
Contemplation
1. The act or state of contemplating.
2. Thoughtful observation or study.
The word contemplate is derived from the Latin word, meaning Mental Health
Architecture
"to observe, especially in a space marked off for observation".
With the word space integrated into the actual origin of the
word, inherently a concern for the relation between the designed
Mindfulness Neuroscience
space and the act of contemplating arises.
Figure 2.1
The dictionary explains contemplation equals meditation on spiritual matters, but contemplation can’t be
considered to be an equivalent of meditation. Meditation is focussed on something or someone specific; a
subject. In modern society, the definition of contemplation is often used in a non-religious context. It is
referred to as a mode of profound self-reflection, the devotion is not necessarily addressed , but rather
towards the essence of the subject’s own spirit. In this research, only non-religious manifestations are
considered.
Contemplative spaces are the spaces designed that create an environment where the act of contemplation
can be achieved very easily. These are not to be considered as isolated building typologies, just like
churches or sanctuaries, but as integrated accessories for different building uses. The physical design
responsible for such movement can be a range of contexts, from sacred spaces such as religious buildings,
to calming gardens, to spaces of refuge in vibrant urban centres.
6
2.2
2.3 Types
Types of
of Contemplative
Contemplative Spaces
Spaces
1. Sanctuary mode
This type entails architectural forms that simply provide boundaries between the wider, presumably
more prosaic, environment.
Example :
2. Theatric mode
The theatric mode involves architectural forms creating a stage-setting or backdrop for theatrical
spiritual activities. This can be seen in most churches which feature raised pulpits or stages where
sermons can be performed.
Example :
Traditional protestant cathedral is a clear example of this mode, with its
clear focus point on the altar and the spectacle of the mass, the building has
a clear facilitating theatrical function, giving meaning through its scale and
impressive but modest architecture.
Figure 2.6
Figure 2.7
7
3. Contemplation mode
This involves built configurations that serve as the actual object of direct and purposeful, meditative
attention. This is when architecture not only facilitates a contemplative experience, but is also crucial
in instigating it.
Examples :
Figure 2.8
Figure 2.9
8
2.3 Qualitative Parameters of Contemplative Spaces -
Color Theory -
Sound Vibrations -
The sound vibrations emitted in a space have a profound effect on the atmosphere and on the users. The
sounds that are emitted in a space consequently create a particular atmosphere that is conducive to
particular activities.
In the end, the sounds that reverberate inside a space indeed impart the place’s sacredness or otherwise.
Complete
Figure 2.11silence can also be very spiritual. By2.12
Figure removing all the sound of a space,
Figure a2.13
mysterious quality
could emerge, one
that differentiates from normative human interactions.
9
Connection with Nature -
The physical manifestation of architecture. When a person occupies an architectural space that is
connected to the natural world, he or she experiences being part of a logical and harmonious place.
Nature also has a mystical, underlying logic to its design, and many architects, past and present, have
attempted to reproduce this harmonious logic in their built work.
10
Threshold -
A threshold into a sacred space also varies according to context. For example, in a quite, peaceful village
in the foothill of the Swiss Alps, a sacred space may contrast its context and be filled with noise.
11
CHAPTER 3
IDENTIFIED
CASES
3.1 Widhover Contemplative Centre
Year : 2014
The Windhover Contemplative Center is a retreat on the Stanford campus, US with the aim of
supporting self-renewal. During observation, contemplative elements are also present in the
architecture to form contemplative property.
Figure 3.2
Role of Light -
12
MATERIAL -
The space is composed primarily of three materials: stained oak, rammed earth, and glass.
Glass is used to connect the spaces Rammed earth walls use a mix The stained oak brings the
visually but separate them of various materials to create interior light down to create a
processionally. elegant striations. grotto condition.
From the gravel at the entry to the trees in the courtyard, each object is carefully chosen to create a
continuous color palette to reinforce a calming atmosphere, enhancing the main refuge pattern.
13
Based on the site’s contextual condition, it is shown that how the elements of contemplative space are
used here in the design to create a better environment for the users.
COLOR THEORY -
Strawberry Creek running along the site’s edge gives the student a visual and audible connection
throughout. Inside the space the will also be a tree on a different level than the main space.
Figure 3.9
Figure 3.10 Creek running throught the edge of site
The connection with the natural surrounding lanscape is an important focal point of the project. Most
of the contemplation spaces have a visual, audial, tactile and factory connection to the creek, the
flora, and fauna.
14
LIGHT ROLE -
Little light will enter the threshold, placing the individual in a polar
opposite from the daylight outside the sacred space. As one exits the
threshold, he or she enters the main space and again meets the sunlight.
THRESHOLD -
The threshold will serve as a transitional space that removes the students from their day-to-day living
routine and places them into a sacred space.
When a person experiences a new space whose characteristics are similar to a memorable sacred space
they were once in, they begin to recollect feelings and emotions of the previous sacred space they were in.
In this way, memory, sacredness, and architecture all link together.
15
When a person experiences a new space whose characteristics are similar to a memorable sacred space
they were once in, they begin to recollect feelings and emotions of the previous sacred space they were
in. In this way, memory, sacredness, and architecture all link together.
SOUND VIBRATION -
Figure 3.16
Figure 3.15 Creek running along side’s edge Figure 3.17 Sketch showing Stawerry Creek
For the majority of the time the only sound that enters the space is that of flowing water in the
creek. It produces the calming and soothing feel for the users. Sound vibration can be used as an
important design element to make spaces that will help the users in artist residency.
16
3.2 SHREYAS RETREAT CENTER, BANGALORE
Figure 3.19
17
Based on the site’s contextual condition, it is shown that how the elements of contemplative space are
used here in the design to create a better environment for the users.
LIGHT ROLE :
The design makes clever use of natural light, which renders the exposed
walls and ceilings with a serene glow and a magnificent play of light and
shadows. Various design elements such as handcrafted jaali screens and
solid wood doors and creating connection between the spaces. The bond is
further strengthened by the different openings that help merge the interiors
and exteriors seamlessly.
Figure 3.20 Figure 3.21 brick jaali Figure 3.21 Transitional space
MATERIALS :
The Materials used are concrete, wood, stone and glass ; providing a serene, beautiful and serene
environment, where light plays a fundamental role. The materials are balanced with each other, since wood
gives warmth, concrete solidity, stone connection with the earth and glass reflection of light.
Glass Wood :
It provides
warmth to
the users
Concrete :
Concrete as a material
provides solidity
18
CONNECTION WITH NATURE :
The landscape merges the geometry of network of the surrounding paths to form break-away spaces for
the guests to lounge. These buffer zones create smooth transitions from the exterior, to semi covered
spaces, and also offer a beautiful play of light.
The designed spaces growing from the sunken ground The landscape integrates flawlessly with
towards the sky, are an epitome of tranquility. the built pathways, creating break-away
spaces for the users to relax
THRESHOLD :
19
3.3 OSHO DHAM , NEW DELHI.
Delhi, Delhi
Project Facts -
Mukharjee
Year - 1996
Introduction -
Osho center is designed by Ar. Snehsanu Mukharjee, a delhi based architect. Oshodham offers a very
green, aesthetic, and peaceful environment for those on inner journey . OshoDham has a meditation
supported by residential facilities for long term-sterm stays.
Design Concept -
The design concept of the centre is based on enlightenment, mental peace and physical satisfaction. Once
one enters the centre, one is abushed with the immmense amount of mental peace and satisfaction.
20
Features :
Sound Vibration -
The meditation hall is incorporated with a The cherubic sound of gurging water bodies and
humidification system which helps to bring fountains with the chirping of birds belp the
down the ambient air temperature during the meditators to go deep on the path of awareness
warm summer months. through meditation.
Pathways -
Connection with Nature -
The provision of spiral path throughout the The outdoor landscape forms part of the functions
centre seems quite interesting. This has helped of the centre for spiritual practices to take place in
to achieve a compact organisation of spaces nature Landscaping elements.
which leaves the rest of the land free for natural
farming
Role of Light -
21
Jawahar Kala Kendra
Architect-Charles Correa
Construction-1992
Department
Ground coverage-15%
CONNECTIVITY :
Jaipur Airport-7 km
Jaipur Gandhinagar Riway Station-1.5 km
High Court Circh Bus Stop-100 m
SMS Stadium Metro Station-1,7 km
ACCESS:
The site is well connected with roads and streets touching the site on three sides.
CLIMATE :
Jaipur has a hot semi-arid climate it receives over 63 cm of rainfall annually, butmost rains occur in
the monsoon months between June and Septem ber Temperatures remain relatively high during
summer & can go upto 450 Temperatures in winter days.
Figure 3.36
22
Zoning And Circulation
Museum / Gallery
Learning Spaces
Recreational Spaces
Administration area
Figure 3.37
The centre is made in 8 blocks incorporating Art gallery, theatres, libraries, museums, studios,
administrative spaces, workshops and cafeteria. Two of the most active areas are Cafeteria and
Amphitheatre.
Internal Circulation
External Circulation
Main Features:
Entry 2 • Grid-Iron Planning
• Central Courtyard
• Two major Axes
• In this, entry 1 is pedestrian entry
while entry 2 is vehicular entry.
Entry 1
Figure 3.38
23
Response to Climate :
Softscape
Hardscape
Figure 3.39
Features :
24
CHAPTER 4
ANALYSIS
CHAPTER 5
CONCLUSION AND
RECOMMENDATIONS
5.1 CONCLUSIONS :
The study concludes that qualities of architecture contributes in making of the contemplative environment and
enhances the experience of contemplation for the users. These qualities of architecture can be used to design
and enhance the environment of a meditation center where people can experience spirituality.
In the end, we can prove that the fundamental elements enhances the experience of the users.
5.2 RECOMMENDATIONS :
Threshold :
1. The clever use of natural light should be made in the spaces as light can affect the mood of a user.
2. For light and shadow play, jaalis or pergolas can be provided in the transition spaces which also
maintains the thermal comfort of a soace.
27
Sound Vibrations :
The sound vibrations emitted in a space consequently create a particular atmosphere that is conducive to
particular activities.
Water bodies as a part of landscape should be provided as it has profound effect and user and also helps in
maintaining the temperature around a space,
Material:
Material and color should be used in the spaces according to their significance.
Color :
Color can have pyschological effect on a users mind:
Green can have calming effect on a users.
White color makes a space look larger and depicts purity
Figure 5.5
28
Glossary of terms :
2. Contemplative Space - Contemplative spaces are the spaces designed that create an environment
where the act of contemplation can be achieved very easily
6. Perceptual - Relating to the ability to interpret or become aware of something through the senses
9. Sacredness - Something that is dedicated or set apart for the service or worship of a deity
14. Phenomenology - Phenomenology is the philosophical study of the structures of experience and
consciousness
Bibliography :
BOOKS
RESEARCH PAPERS
WEB-REFERENCES
1. oshoworld.com
2. rereeti.org
3. The art of contemplation: mindfulness in galleries | Blog | Royal Academy of Arts
4. Art and Contemplation: How Artists are Creating Mindful Spaces with their Work -
BeautyHarmonyLife
5. Contemplative Spaces: towards a new design approach (neuroarchitectura.com)
6. The Effects Of Contemplative Architecture (architecturecompetitions.com)
7. The art of contemplation: mindfulness in galleries | Blog | Royal Academy of Arts
8. Art and Contemplation: How Artists are Creating Mindful Spaces with their Work -
BeautyHarmonyLife
9. --Contemplative Spaces: towards a new design approach (neuroarchitectura.com)
10. The Effects Of Contemplative Architecture (architecturecompetitions.com)
11. Making use of that contemplative space that’s essential for creating art that lives - The Sunday
Guardian Live
12. rereeti.org
13. Contemplative Art – The Center for Contemplative Mind in Society