Boiler Rbi
Boiler Rbi
Boiler Rbi
Roger Bartlett
Integrity & Reliability Manager
Risk management
Risk Based Inspection
RBI applied to boilers
Experience with statutory inspection of boilers
at ARC
Standard methodology
Semi-quantitative assessment of
RISK based on CRITICALITY
Determines pro-active inspection
activities/condition monitoring for
static equipment
Gives indications where re-
design needed
LOW Criticality:
Reduced or NO activity
Safeguarding of integrity
PROBABILITY of FAILURE
CONSEQUENCES
- HSE
- Production losses and damage
X = Intolerable
E = Extreme
H = High
M = Medium
L = Low
ALLIANCE REFINING COMPANY LIMITED
N = Negligible
Differentiation: Age-Related vs Non-Age-
Related Degradation Mechanisms
Stability/Predictability of Degradation
Number and Quality of previous
inspections
Process stability and control
INSPECTION INTERVALS
Criticality, Confidence and Remnant
Life
QUALIFIED PERSONNEL
ALLIANCE REFINING COMPANY LIMITED
ALLIANCE REFINING COMPANY LIMITED
Process Monitoring for Non-Age Related
Mechanisms
Parameters to be monitored, as
described in Operating Window
Frequency, as described in
Operating Window
Parameters Locations
SPRC RRC
Waste heat boilers 2 3
Design Steam Flow (ton/hr) 65 100
Design Pressure (kg/cm2) 55 148
Design Temperature (C) 399 545
Operating Pressure (kg/cm2) 42.5 135
Operating Temperature (C) 395 334
Fuel supply Natural gas Natural gas
ALLIANCE REFINING COMPANY LIMITED
Fired-Tube Waste Heat Boilers
Parameters Locations
SPRC RRC
Waste heat boilers 2 2
Design Steam Flow (ton/hr) 12.9 12
Design Pressure (kg/cm2) 49 50
Design Temperature (C) 371 280
Operating Pressure (kg/cm2) 42 46
Operating Temperature (C) 343 260
Fuel supply Natural gas Natural gas
ALLIANCE REFINING COMPANY LIMITED
Statutory Inspection Frequency
Fire box region - Internal inspection (refractory and adjacent steam drum, roof
tubes and top burner)
- Inspection of all refractory and tips of burners.
- Inspection of all insulation within air register.
- Check tube for any sign of deformation, check membrane weld
for signs of cracking.
raw water
or fire pond water 42S115 42D117 42D102
Clarifier Clearwell Clarified
Tank Water
42G102A/B/C
42S112 42G116A/B/C
42S116A/B/C/D
Sludge Blowdown Sump Gravity Filters 43D101
Portable
water
LGC Boiler
HGC Blowdown
UT Distribution
CoolingTower Salt
To users
regen.
RO Reject
42D108
Surge Tank
42G110A/B/C
42S121A/B/C
41G111A/B 42S123A/B/C Softener
42S124A/B/C/D Catridge Filters
RO Membrane Unit Sodium Zeolite Resin
HGC
41D101
BFW HP BFW
41D102 HP Boiler
41G109A/B Deaerator
LGC
41G101A/B
MP BFW
External Corrosion:
- Fuel Gas Firing (clean)
- Low Temperature vs Design
Creep:
- Operating Window carefully controlled
- No flame impingement
- Low Temperature/Pressure vs Design
ALLIANCE REFINING COMPANY LIMITED
RBI Assessment - Example
Steam Drum:
Superheater Tubes:
NOTES:
40
2.0 mm
22.8
18.8
31.75
16.8
25
E -1112 T i C ond/ Feed P r eheater M P / HP / HHP s team 1 H N 1.05 0.1 10. 55 0.7 7.35 6Y V I & HT SD/ I 5/ 1/ 07
C ombined P i pi ng C L-021-212 Demi n Water P i pi ng Demi ner al i s ed Water 1 M N 0.25 0.01 25 0.6 15 6Y UT T M OS/ NI 1/ 1/ 04
F-4101 T o GT Gener ati ng tubes Fl ue Gas 1 VH H 0.25 0.01 25 0.5 12.5 3Y V I , UT T M & HT SD/ I 12/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4101 T o ST Super heater tubes Fl ue Gas 1 VH H 0.25 0.01 25 0.5 12.5 3Y V I & HT SD/ I 12/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4102 T o GT Gener ati ng T ubes Fl ue Gas 1 VH H 0.25 0.01 25 0.5 12.5 3Y V I , UT T M & HT SD/ I 11/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4102 T o ST Super heater tubes Fl ue Gas 1 VH H 0.25 0.01 25 0.5 12.5 3Y V I & HT SD/ I 11/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4103 T o GT Gener ati ng T ubes Fl ue Gas 1 VH H 0.25 0.01 25 0.5 12.5 3Y V I , UT T M & HT SD/ I 1/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4103 T o ST Super heater tubes Fl ue Gas 1 VH H 0.25 0.01 25 0.5 12.5 3Y V I & HT SD/ I 1/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
V -4102 Fuel Gas K .O Dr um Fuel Gas 1 M M 3 0.1 30 0.4 12 6Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 7/ 1/ 08
V -4102 Fuel Gas K .O Dr um Fuel Gas 1 M M 3 0.1 30 0.4 12 3Y UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 05
V -4901A Fuel Gas K O Dr um Fuel Gas 1 H M 3 0.1 30 0.5 15 6Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 7/ 1/ 08
V -4901B Fuel Gas K O Dr um Fuel Gas 1 H H 2.35 0.16 14. 69 0.4 5.88 3Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 7/ 1/ 05
C ombined P i pi ng C L-021-(241-249) C ombi ned P i pi ng For Demi n Water Demi n Water 1 M N 0.25 0.01 25 0.6 15 6Y UT T M OS/ NI 1/ 1/ 04
C ombined P i pi ng C L-022-(241-249) Uti l i ty Water P i pi ng Uti l i ty Water 1 M N 1 0.1 10 0.6 6 I NV UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 03
V -4103 C onti nous B l owdown Dr um M P ,HP ,HHP Steam 1 VH L 3 0.1 30 0.7 21 12Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
V -4103 C onti nous B l owdown Dr um M P ,HP ,HHP Steam 1 VH L 3 0.1 30 0.7 21 6Y UT T M SD/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
V -4201 M P C ondens ate Fl as h Dr um M P ,HP ,HHP Steam 1 VH L 3 0.1 30 0.7 21 12Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
V -4201 M P C ondens ate Fl as h Dr um M P ,HP ,HHP Steam 1 VH L 3 0.1 30 0.7 21 6Y UT T M SD/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
V -4202 LP Condens ate Fl as h Dr um M P ,HP ,HHP Steam 1 VH L 3 0.1 30 0.7 21 12Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
V -4202 LP Condens ate Fl as h Dr um M P ,HP ,HHP Steam 1 VH L 3 0.1 30 0.7 21 6Y UT T M SD/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
E -4101 T f B l owdown C ool er Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 M N 1.2 0.1 12. 05 0.6 7.26 6Y V I & HT SD/ I 5/ 1/ 07
E -4101 T f Hd B l owdown C ool er Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 12Y V I , UT T M & HT SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
E -4101 T f Hd B l owdown C ool er Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y UT T M SD/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
E -4202 T f C ondens ate T r i m C ool er Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 M N 1.2 0.1 12. 05 0.6 7.26 6Y V I & HT SD/ I 2/ 1/ 09
E -4202 T f Hd C ondens ate T r i m C ool er Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 12Y V I , UT T M & HT SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
E -4202 T f Hd C ondens ate T r i m C ool er Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y UT T M SD/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
E -4203 T f SteamC ondens er Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 M N 1.2 0.1 12. 05 0.6 7.26 6Y V I & HT SD/ I 5/ 1/ 07
E -4203 T f Hd SteamC ondens er Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 12Y V I , UT T M & HT SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
E -4203 T f Hd SteamC ondens er Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y UT T M SD/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
V -4103 C onti nous B l owdown Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 12Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
V -4103 C onti nous B l owdown Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
V -4104 I nter mi ttent Bl owdown Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 7/ 1/ 08
V -4104 I nter mi ttent Bl owdown Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
V -4201 M P C ondens ate Fl as h Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
V -4201 M P C ondens ate Fl as h Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 12Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
V -4202 LP Condens ate Fl as h Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
V -4202 LP Condens ate Fl as h Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 12Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
V -4203 SteamC ondens ate Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
V -4203 SteamC ondens ate Dr um Steam C ondens ate B ef or e Deoi l er 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 12Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
C ombined P i pi ng C L-030-(241-249) I H C ombi ned P i pi ng For B oi l er Feed Water B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 1 M H 1 0.1 10 0.3 3 I NV UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 03
C ombined P i pi ng C L-030-(241-249) I H C ombi ned P i pi ng For B oi l er Feed Water B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 2 M H 1 0.1 I NV UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 03
C ombined P i pi ng C L-030-(241-249) I H C ombi ned P i pi ng For B oi l er Feed Water B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 5 VL H 1 0.1 6Y V I & WFM P T SD/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
C ombined P i pi ng C L-030-(241-249) I H C ombi ned P i pi ng For B oi l er Feed Water B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 5 VL H 1 0.1 1Y VI OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 03
V -4101A Dear ator s B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 12Y V I & UT T M SD/ I 8/ 1/ 14
V -4101A Dear ator s B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 2 H N 3 0.1 24Y Sel ecti ve del aggi ng SD/ NI 5/ 1/ 26
V -4101A Dear ator s B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 2 H N 3 0.1 12Y V I &I R OS/ NI 8/ 1/ 14
V -4101A Dear ator s B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 5 VL N 3 0.1 6Y V I & WFM P T SD/ I 7/ 1/ 08
V -4101B Dear ator s B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 12Y V I & UT T M SD/ NI 8/ 1/ 14
V -4101B Dear ator s B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 1 VH N 3 0.1 30 0.8 24 6Y UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 08
V -4101B Dear ator s B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 2 H N 3 0.1 12Y V I &I R OS/ NI 8/ 1/ 14
V -4101B Dear ator s B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 2 H N 3 0.1 24Y Sel ecti ve del aggi ng SD/ NI 5/ 1/ 26
V -4101B Dear ator s B oi l er Feed Water (B FW) 5 VL N 3 0.1 6Y V I & WFM P T SD/ I 7/ 1/ 08
C ombined P i pi ng C L-046-(241-249) C ombi ned P i pi ng For Steam C ondens ate Steam C ondens ate to Stor age
1 M H 1 0.1 10 0.3 3 I NV UT T M OS/ NI 7/ 1/ 03
T o Stor age
F-4101 T i GT Gener ati ng T ubes B oi l er T ube 1 VH L 0.25 0.01 25 0.7 17.5 3Y V I , UT T M & HT SD/ I 12/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4101 T i ST Super heater tubes B oi l er T ube 1 VH L 0.25 0.01 25 0.7 17.5 3Y V I & HT SD/ I 12/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4102 T i GT Gener ati ng T ubes B oi l er T ube 1 VH L 0.25 0.01 25 0.7 17.5 3Y V I , UT T M & HT SD/ I 11/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4102 T i ST Super heater tubes B oi l er T ube 1 VH L 0.25 0.01 25 0.7 17.5 3Y V I & HT SD/ I 11/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4103 T i GT Gener ati ng T ubes B oi l er T ube 1 H L 0.25 0.01 25 0.6 15 3Y V I , UT T M & HT SD/ I 1/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
F-4103 T i ST Super heater tubes B oi l er T ube 1 H L 0.25 0.01 25 0.6 15 3Y V I & HT SD/ I 1/ 1/ 06 Legal r equi r ement
Se l e c t e d
C or r os i on F a i l ur e c al c A c tC or A l l o I ns pe c t i o n os i / N e x t I ns pe c t i o n
T a g numbe r A s s e t D e s c r i pt i o n c a l c c o nf C or r os i on R e mna nt L i f e c a l c i nt e r v f a c t c a l c i ns p i nt e r v F r e q c o de c o mme nt s
l oo p na me M o de I D C r i tA s s es w M e t ho d I nt r u s i v e D ate
R ate
P 200018 / P 205018 Sour f eed gas f r om A DIP 1 & 2 1 L H 3 0.05 60 0.3 6 UT M 2008
P 210001 Sour f eed gas f r om A DIP 1 & 2 1 L H 3 0.05 60 0,3 6 UT M 2008
V 2106 Feed gas K O dr um 1 L H 3 0.05 60 0.3 6 VI 2008
P 210002 Sour gas to E 2107 1 L H 3 0.05 60 0.3 6 UT M 2008
E 2107 Feed gas heater 1 L H 3 0.05 60 0.3 6 VI 2008
P 210003 / 006 / 210101 Sour gas l i ne to F2101 / F2201 1 L H 1 0.05 20 0.3 6
P 240043 Sour f eed gas f r om SWS 1 L H 4 0.05 80 0.3 6 UT M 2008
V 2107 Feed gas K O dr um 1 L H 3 0.05 60 0.3 6 VI 2008
P 210005 Sour gas to P 210006 1 L H 4 0.05 80 0.3 6
F2101 C l aus bur ner 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2003 R ef r actor y
M 2101 C ombus ti on chamber 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2003 R ef r actor y
E 2101 (tube s ide) Waste heat boi l er 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2003 R ef r actor y
P 210102 P r ocess gas to E 2102 1 L M 3 0.02 150 0.4 8
E 2102 1 st Sul phur condens er 1 L M 1.5 0.05 30 0.4 8 VI 2004
P 210103 P r ocess gas to M 2102 1 L M 1.5 0.05 30 0.4 8
F2102 1s t Li ne bur ner 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2003 R ef r actor y
M 2102 1s t M i xi ng chamber 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2003 R ef r actor y
P 210104 P r ocess gas to R 2101 1 L M 3 0.05 60 0.4 8
R 2101 1s t C l aus r eactor 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2003 R ef r actor y
P 210105 P r ocess gas to E 2103 1 L M 3 0.05 60 0.4 8
E 2103 2nd Sul phur condens er 1 L M 1 0.05 20 0.4 8 VI 2004
P 210106 P r ocess gas to M 2103 1 L M 1 0.05 20 0.4 8
F2103 2nd Li ne bur ner 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2003 R ef r actor y
M 2103 2nd M i xi ng chamber 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2003 R ef r actor y
P 210107 P r ocess gas to R 2102 1 L M 3 0.05 60 0.4 8
R 2102 2nd C l aus r eactor 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2003 R ef r actor y
P 210108 P r ocess gas to E 2104 1 L M 3 0.05 60 0.4 8
E 2104 3r d Sul phur condens er 1 L M 1 0.05 20 0.4 8 VI 2004
P 210109 P r ocess gas to V 2105 1 L M 1 0.05 20 0.4 8
V 2105 Sul phur coal es cer 1 L M 3 0.05 60 0.4 8 V I / UT M 2004
P 210110 T ai l gas to i nci ner ator s 1 L M 1 0.05 20 0.4 8
P 210111/ P 220111 T ai l gas to M 2150 / M 2250 1 L M 1 0.05 20 0.4 8
F2150 I nci ner ator bur ner 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2004 R ef r actor y
M 2150 I nci ner ator mi xi ng chamber 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2004 R ef r actor y
P i pi ng 48" T ai l gas 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 R ef r actor y
R 2150 I nci ner ator r eactor 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 VI 2004 R ef r actor y
Fl ue gas duct T ai l gas to stack 1 L M 0 0 na 0.4 8 R ef r actor y
P 210121 Li qui d s ul phur to V 2101 1 L M 4 0 na 0.4 8 R ef r actor y
P 210122 Li qui d s ul phur to V 2102 1 L M 4 0.05 80 0.4 8
P 210123 Li qui d s ul phur to V 2103 1 L M 4 0.05 80 0.4 8
P 210124 Li qui d s ul phur to V 2104 1 L M 4 0.05 80 0.4 8
V 2111 / 12 / 13 / 14 Sul phur f unnel s 1 L M 4 0.05 80 0.4 8 VI 2004
V 2101 / 02 / 03 / 04 Sul phur l ocks 1 L M 4 0.05 80 0.4 8 VI 2004
P 210125 Li qui d s ul phur to stor age 1 L H 4 0.05 80 0.3 6
V 2108 Sul phur degass i ng vessel 1 L H 3 0.05 80 0.3 6 VI 2008
W210003 B FW to V 2110 1 H M 1 0.05 100 0.7 14
V 2110 Steam dr um 1 H M 3 0.01 300 0.7 14 VI 2003 T hai Lei gi sl ati on
S210001 I P s teamoutl et 1 H M 1 0.01 100 0.7 14
W210018 B FW to E 2102 1 H M 1 0.01 100 0.6 12
E 2101 (shel l si de) WHB 1 H M 1.5 0.01 150 0.7 14 VI 2003 T hai Legi s l ati on
E 2102 (shel l si de) Sul phur condens er 1 H M 1.5 0.01 150 0.7 14
S210021 LP steam outl et 1 H M 1 0.01 100 0.7 14