Revision Notes
Revision Notes
Revision Notes
BASANT K. PURI
MA, PhD, MB, BChir, BSc (Hons) MathSci, MRCPsych, DipStat, MMath
Senior Lecturer/Consultant in Psychiatry and Imaging, MRC CSC, Imperial College London;
Honorary Consultant in Imaging, Department of Imaging, Hammersmith Hospital, London
ANNE D. HALL
BA, MB, BCh, MRCPsych
Consultant Psychiatrist, South Kensington and Chelsea Mental Health Centre, Chelsea and
Westminster Hospital, London
http://www.arnoldpublishers.com
Whilst the advice and information in this book are believed to be true and
accurate at the date of going to press, neither the author[s] nor the publisher
can accept any legal responsibility or liability for any errors or omissions
that may be made. In particular, (but without limiting the generality of the
preceding disclaimer) every effort has been made to check drug dosages;
however it is still possible that errors have been missed. Furthermore,
dosage schedules are constantly being revised and new side-effects
recognized. For these reasons the reader is strongly urged to consult the
drug companies’ printed instructions before administering any of the drugs
recommended in this book.
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
What do you think about this book? Or any other Arnold title?
Please send your comments to feedback.arnold@hodder.co.uk
Contents
In preparing the second edition of this book, we have taken the opportunity to update much of the
information contained therein. As is evident from the increased size of this edition, we have also
greatly expanded many chapters; this has happened partly to furnish the reader with more
background material that puts the key facts in their proper context, and partly in line with the latest
syllabi for the examinations for Parts I and II of the Membership of the Royal College of
Psychiatrists. These Revision Notes should also prove useful in preparing for similar postgraduate
examinations in psychiatry in other parts of the English-speaking world.
BKP
ADH
This page intentionally left blank
Preface to the First Edition
This book aims to provide detailed revision notes covering all the important basic sciences and
clinical topics required for postgraduate psychiatry examinations. To this end, the current syllabus
for both parts of the examinations for the Membership of the Royal College of Psychiatrists has been
followed closely. It should be emphasized, however, that this book is not meant to be a replacement
for either wider reading, or, more importantly, clerking and following-up patients.
BKP
ADH
This page intentionally left blank
1
Basic psychology
Definition of learning
Learning is a change in behaviour as a result of prior experience. It does not include behaviour
change caused by maturation or temporary conditions (e.g. drug effects or fatigue).
Learning may occur through associations being made between two or more phenomena. Two
forms of such associative learning are recognized: classical conditioning and operant conditioning.
Cognitive learning is a more complex process in which current perceptions are interpreted in the
context of previous information in order to solve unfamiliar problems. Evidence that learning can
also take place through the observation and imitation of others has led to the development of the
observational learning theory.
Classical conditioning
DEFINITION AND INTRODUCTION
Classical conditioning (respondent learning) was first described by the Russian physiologist Ivan
Petrovich Pavlov (1849–1936) in 1927. (Although Pavlov was awarded a Nobel prize, that was in
1904 for his work on digestion.) Following several repetitions of pairing of light (or a bell sounding)
followed by the presentation of food to a dog, it was found that just switching on the light led to
salivation. The dog had been conditioned to associate the light with food. Food was acting as the
unconditioned stimulus (US), eliciting the reflex response of salivation without new learning being
involved. The response to the unconditioned stimulus is known as the unconditioned response (UR).
The light would not normally have elicited the response of salivation, but was now a conditioned
stimulus (CS) that had elicited the response through its association with an unconditioned stimulus.
The conditioned response (CR) is the learned or acquired response to a conditioned stimulus. This is
shown diagrammatically in Figure 1.1. Thus, in Pavlov’s experiments, salivation was both an
unconditioned response before conditioning, and a conditioned response after conditioning.
2 Basic psychology
US UR
CS CR
Figure 1.1 Diagram showing the processes associated with classical conditioning. US = unconditioned stimulus;
UR = unconditioned response; CS = conditioned stimulus; CR = conditioned response.
CONCEPTS
Acquisition stage
The acquisition stage of conditioning is the period during which the association is being acquired
between the conditioned stimulus and the unconditioned stimulus with which it is being paired.
Timing
∑ Delayed conditioning. In delayed conditioning the onset of the conditioned stimulus precedes
that of the unconditioned stimulus and the conditioned stimulus continues until the response
occurs. Delayed conditioning is optimal when the delay between the onsets of the two stimuli is
around half a second.
∑ Simultaneous conditioning. In simultaneous conditioning the onset of both stimuli is
simultaneous and the conditioned stimulus continues until the response occurs. It is less
successful than delayed conditioning.
∑ Trace conditioning. In trace conditioning the conditioned stimulus ends before the onset of the
unconditioned stimulus and the conditioning becomes less effective as the delay between the
two increases.
∑ Backward conditioning. In backward conditioning the presentation of the conditioned stimulus
occurs after that of the unconditioned stimulus.
Higher-order conditioning
In higher-order conditioning the conditioned stimulus is paired with a second (or third, etc.)
conditioned stimulus, which on presentation by itself elicits the original conditioned response. In
other words, the original conditioned stimulus now acts as the unconditioned stimulus in the new
pairing. If there is just a second conditioned stimulus, then this gives rise to second-order
conditioning. A third conditioned stimulus gives rise to third-order conditioning, and so on.
Higher-order (that is, second-order or above) conditioning is weaker than first-order conditioning;
in general, the higher the order, the weaker the conditioning.
Extinction
Extinction is the gradual disappearance of a conditioned response and occurs when the conditioned
stimulus is repeatedly presented without the unconditioned stimulus. It does not entail the
complete loss of the conditioned stimulus. Following extinction, if an experimental animal is
allowed to rest, a weaker conditioned response re-emerges; this is known as partial recovery.
Generalization
Generalization is the process whereby, once a conditioned response has been established to a given
stimulus, that response can also be evoked by other stimuli that are similar to the original
conditioned stimulus.
Principles of learning theory 3
Discrimination
Discrimination is the differential recognition of, and response to, two or more similar stimuli.
Incubation
Incubation is the increase in strength of conditioned responses resulting from repeated brief
exposure to the conditioned stimulus.
Stimulus preparedness
Stimulus preparedness refers to the fact that some stimuli are more likely to become conditioned
stimuli than are others.
CONCEPTS
Trial-and-error learning/behaviour
Thorndike described experiments in which hungry cats were placed in puzzle boxes. By chance, in
time a cat would effect an escape, for example by pressing on a lever, and reach some visible food
outside the box. Less time would be needed to carry out the same behaviour in later trials. This is
trial-and-error learning or behaviour.
Law of effect
Thorndike’s law of effect holds that voluntary behaviour that is paired with subsequent reward is
strengthened.
Skinner box
Skinner developed the experimental procedures of Thorndike, creating the Skinner box. Operant
conditioning can be demonstrated using a Skinner box in which, for example, every time the animal
presses a lever a pellet of food is released. If hungry rats are placed in it, random trial-and-error
learning leads to the lever being pressed, the conditioned response, to obtain the reinforcing
stimulus of the reward of food pellets. If, after many repetitions of this pairing, the conditioned
4 Basic psychology
response is no longer reinforced, then the conditioned response abates; that is, extinction occurs.
Following extinction, if the animal is allowed to rest, a weaker conditioned response can re-emerge;
this is partial recovery. Discrimination (see above) can also occur.
CONCEPTS
The bobo doll experiments
Albert Bandura (1925–present), a Canadian psychologist working at Stanford, USA, carried out the
bobo doll experiments. (Bobo dolls are inflatable, balloon-like objects, shaped like eggs, which bob
back up after being knocked down, owing to the presence of extra weighting in the dolls’ ‘bottoms’.)
Bandura made a film of one of his female students verbally and physically attacking a bobo doll,
including hitting it with a hammer. This film was then shown to groups of kindergartners. The
children liked the film and when let out to play in an area containing a new bobo doll and some toy
hammers, they proceeded verbally and physically to imitate the actions of the young woman in
Bandura’s film.
Bandura pointed out that a change in behaviour in the children had occurred without rewards
being received for approximations to the new behaviour. He termed this phenomenon, which
clearly differed from classical and operant learning, observational learning or modelling; his theory
is referred to as social learning theory.
To deal with the criticism that a bobo doll is made to be hit, Bandura repeated the bobo doll
experiments, this time substituting a live clown for the doll. Again, the children imitated the actions
of the young woman, to the extent of kicking and punching a live clown, and hitting him with (toy)
hammers.
In contrast, unsuccessful observational learning is more likely to occur in association with the
following factors:
∑ low arousal (e.g. sleepiness)
∑ over-arousal
∑ the presence of distracting stimuli.
2 Retention.
3 Reproduction. The translation of what has been remembered into behaviour.
4 Motivation. See the section below on concepts of extinction and reinforcement in explaining
behaviour.
Cognitive learning
DEFINITION
The notion of a mental model of reality is central to the cognitive approach to psychology.
Cognition involves the reception, organization and utilization of information. Cognitive learning is
an active form of learning in which mental cognitive structures (cognitive maps) are formed. These
allow mental images to be formed which allow meaning and structure to be given to the internal and
external environment.
MECHANISMS
Cognitive learning can occur in the following ways:
∑ Insight learning. The learning occurs apparently out of the blue, because of an understanding of
the relationship between various elements relevant to a problem.
∑ Latent learning. Cognitive learning takes place but is not manifested except in certain
circumstances such as the need to satisfy a basic drive.
ASSIMILATION THEORY
The assimilation theory of cognitive learning is based on the following concepts:
∑ Learning in humans is influenced by prior knowledge.
∑ Human learning is manifested by a change in the meaning of experience rather than a purely
behavioural change.
∑ Those involved in teaching should help their students reflect on their experiences.
∑ Those involved in teaching should construct new meanings.
REINFORCEMENT
A positive reinforcer is a reinforcing reward stimulus (e.g. food and water, money in humans) which
increases the probability of occurrence of the operant behaviour. A negative reinforcer is an aversive
6 Basic psychology
stimulus (e.g. an electric shock, fear) whose removal increases the probability of occurrence of the
operant behaviour. For example, a Skinner box may be arranged so that, in order to avoid an
aversive stimulus, the animal must press a lever. Learning this response is called avoidance
conditioning. Escape conditioning is a variety of negative reinforcement in which the response learnt
provides complete escape from the aversive stimulus (very resistant to extinction).
Primary reinforcement occurs through reduction of needs deriving from basic drives (e.g. food
and drink). Secondary reinforcement derives from association with primary reinforcers (e.g. money,
tokens).
SCHEDULES OF REINFORCEMENT
In continuous reinforcement, reinforcement takes place following every conditioned response. This
leads to the maximum response rate.
In partial reinforcement, only some of the conditioned responses are reinforced.
∑ In a fixed interval schedule, reinforcement occurs after a fixed interval of time. It is poor at
maintaining the conditioned response; the maximum response rate typically occurs only when
the reinforcement is expected.
∑ In a variable interval schedule, reinforcement occurs after variable intervals. It is very good at
maintaining the conditioned response.
∑ In a fixed ratio schedule, reinforcement occurs after a fixed number of responses. It is good at
maintaining a high response rate.
∑ In a variable ratio schedule, reinforcement occurs after a variable number of responses. It is very
good at maintaining a high response rate.
PUNISHMENT
Punishment is the situation that occurs if an aversive stimulus is presented whenever a given
behaviour occurs, thereby reducing the probability of occurrence of this response. The removal of
the aversive stimulus then allows it to act as a negative reinforcer rather than a punisher.
MOTIVATION
In observational learning theory, Bandura has put forward the following motives that encourage
observational learning:
∑ Past reinforcement. This is similar to the types of reinforcement that are recognized in classical
and operant learning theory.
∑ Promised reinforcements. These are incentives which can be imagined.
∑ Vicarious reinforcement. This refers to the sight and recollection of the model that is being
reinforced.
Negative motivations that inhibit observational learning include:
∑ past punishment
∑ promised punishment – that is, threats
∑ vicarious punishment.
Bandura contends that punishment is less effective than reinforcement.
Principles of learning theory 7
HABITUATION
Habituation is an important component of the behavioural treatment of obsessive–compulsive
disorder using exposure and response prevention. The ultimate aim of exposure techniques is to
reduce the discomfort associated with the eliciting stimuli through habituation.
For example, Vaughan and Tarrier (1992) have described the use of image habituation training in
the therapy of patients suffering from post-traumatic stress disorder. Image habituation training
involved the generation by the patient of verbal descriptions of the traumatic event, which were
recorded onto audiotape. After the initial training session with the therapist, homework sessions of
self-directed exposure in which the person visualized the described event in response to listening to
the audiotape recordings were carried out. There were significant decreases in anxiety between and
within homework sessions, suggesting that habituation did occur and was responsible for
improvement. Treatment gains were maintained at six-month follow-up.
CHAINING
In (response) chaining, the components of a more complex desired behaviour are first taught and
then connected in order to teach the latter. Chaining may be conceptualized in the following two
different ways.
1 Responses function as discriminative stimuli for subsequent responses.
2 Responses produce stimuli that function as discriminative stimuli for subsequent responses.
Chaining can be used in, for example, people with learning difficulties. Thvedt et al. (1984)
studied stimulus functions in chaining. Twenty-four adults with learning difficulties learned a chain
of circuit board assembly responses consisting of placing resistors in the board and pressing
switches. Lights came on after switch responses. After learning the chain, each subject was exposed
to three experimental conditions (counterbalanced):
∑ altered stimulus location
∑ altered stimulus sequence
∑ missing stimulus.
This study lent some support for the second conceptual position given above (i.e. that responses
produce stimuli that function as discriminative stimuli for subsequent responses).
SHAPING
In shaping, successively closer approximations to the desired behaviour are reinforced in order to
achieve the latter. It finds application clinically in the management of behavioural disturbances in
8 Basic psychology
people with learning difficulties and in the therapy of patients suffering from psychoactive
substance use disorder.
For example, Preston et al. (2001) have used shaping to attempt to bring about cocaine
abstinence by successive approximation. Cocaine-using methadone-maintenance patients were
randomized to standard contingency management (abstinence group of size 49) or to a contingency
designed to increase contact with reinforcers (shaping group of size 46). For eight weeks, both
groups earned escalating-value vouchers based on thrice-weekly urinalyses: the abstinence group
earned vouchers for cocaine-negative urines only; the shaping group earned vouchers for each urine
specimen with a 25% or greater decrease in cocaine metabolite (during the first three weeks) and
then for negative urines only (during the final five weeks). Cocaine use was found to be lower in the
shaping group, but only in the last five weeks, when the response requirement was identical. Thus,
the shaping contingency appeared to prepare patients better for abstinence. (A second phase of the
study showed that abstinence induced by escalating-value vouchers can be maintained by a non-
escalating schedule, suggesting that contingency management can be practical as a maintenance
treatment.)
CUEING
Cueing is the process of helping the learner to focus attention on the important or relevant stimuli
to render the essential learning characteristics distinct from the other stimuli; it consists of any
action which separates figure from ground (see below). The use of cueing can decrease learning
times. For example, in reading matter and pictorial presentations, visual cues can be given using any
of the following strategies:
highlighting implosions
underlining bordering
arrows texture
contrasting colours novelty
animation size
explosions labelling.
A famous example is that of Clever Hans. Hans was a horse, belonging to Mr Von Osten, which
appeared capable of carrying out a range of intellectual tasks normally associated with humans,
such as the arithmetical operations of addition, subtraction, multiplication and division of natural
numbers and fractions, reading and spelling. Answers were communicated by means of tapping out
the answer with one of his feet. For example, if asked to calculate ‘2 + 3’, Clever Hans would tap his
foot five times and then stop. Pfungst (1907/1911), in conjunction with the Berlin psychologist Carl
Stumpf, designed a set of experiments which showed that Clever Hans was, in fact, being cued to
give the correct answer by the questioner. The questioner, consciously or unconsciously, would
provide Clever Hans with visual cues, such as subtle changes in facial expression and posture. For
example, in the above example, as Clever Hans reached five foot taps, he could pick up visual cues
showing how the tension in the questioner was rising. As soon as the fifth tap was executed, the sense
of relief in the questioner was also apparent in visual cues, and the horse knew this was when to stop
tapping.
A clinical example of the therapeutic use of cueing is in unilateral neglect, following a cerebral
lesion. Robertson et al. (1992) based their therapeutic intervention on the experimental finding that
limb activation contralateral to a cerebral lesion appears to reduce visual neglect. (There is
controversy as to whether this is the result of perceptual cueing or of hemispheric activation.) In the
treatment of unilateral left neglect, Robertson et al. found that treatment focused on cueing for left
arm activation, without explicit instructions for perceptual anchoring, gave positive results.
Principles of learning theory 9
ESCAPE CONDITIONING
As mentioned above, in escape conditioning the animal learns to escape from an unpleasant or
punishing stimulus by making a new response. For example, rodents can be trained to escape from
electric shocks by pressing a button.
This is a form of negative reinforcement, in which the reinforcement is getting away from an
aversive stimulus. It is a special form of operant conditioning, consisting of a conditioning
procedure in which successive occurrences of a response repeatedly terminate a negative reinforcing
stimulus.
Escape conditioning may be used in the treatment of alcoholism. For example, Glover and
McCue (1977) found that a group of patients with alcoholism, when treated with partially
reinforced electrical escape conditioning, had a significantly better outcome on follow-up than a
control group which showed a parallel level of motivation and were treated by conventional
methods. No sex differences in outcome were found for either group. In the experimental group
treated with escape conditioning, better prognosis was associated with higher social class and older
age, and poorer prognosis with single marital status. There were no variations in outcome for age in
the control group. In the age range 20 to 40 years, escape conditioning did not show better results
than conventional therapies, but with subjects above this age range it was significantly superior.
AVOIDANCE CONDITIONING
As mentioned above, in avoidance conditioning the animal learns to avoid an unpleasant or
punishing stimulus by making a new response. For example, rodents can be trained to avoid electric
shocks by pressing a button.
Like escape conditioning, avoidance conditioning is a form of negative reinforcement, in which
the reinforcement is getting away from an aversive stimulus. Avoidance conditioning may be
considered to be a special case of operant conditioning under intermittent reinforcement.
Avoidance conditioning, and indeed also escape conditioning, may be used in the treatment of
enuresis. For example, Hansen (1979) described a twin-signal device that provided both escape and
avoidance conditioning in enuresis control.
SELF-CONTROL THERAPY
Bandura helped to develop the therapeutic technique of self-control therapy, based on concepts of
self-regulation. It may be used as part of a treatment package for the cessation of smoking, in
countering over-eating, and in helping students to improve their ability to study. The components
are as follows.
∑ Behavioural charts. This involves keeping a record of one’s behaviour based on self-observation.
For example, in attempting to improve study habits prior to an examination, a student may
make a record of how much time is spent studying each day, how many books are (re-)read, and
how many past or sample examination papers are fully attempted. Such a record could be
graphical or in the form of a behavioural diary. In the case of the latter, further relevant details
should be noted, which may offer insight into cues associated with the desired (or undesired)
behaviour. For example, the student may find that he or she accomplishes more when in a
library compared with being at home, and accomplishes least when in a room with a television
switched on.
∑ Environmental planning. Based on the behavioural chart and diary, changes to one’s
environment can be planned. For example, to continue with the example of the student, he or
10 Basic psychology
she may plan to spend more time in a library and in study groups with others also sitting the
same examination, and less time at home with the television switched on.
∑ Self-contracts. A contract can be written down (perhaps witnessed by the therapist), stipulating
the reward to oneself for accomplishing certain tasks, and the punishment for not doing so. For
example, in the case of the student, the contract might state ‘If I fully revise chapters 1 to 4 from
my revision book next week, then I shall reward myself by buying my favourite recording of
Beethoven’s Fifth Piano Concerto; if I fail to achieve this goal, then I shall … [state some
unpleasant but necessary task or chore].’
MODELLING THERAPY
Bandura also developed modelling therapy. Here, a person suffering from a difficulty coping with a
certain situation watches somebody else cope perfectly easily with the same situation, and then in
turn is able to cope by means of observational learning. An example of the use of modelling therapy
is in the treatment of phobias.
Perception
Definition
Perception is an active process involving the awareness and interpretation of sensations received
through sensory organs.
Thresholds
∑ Absolute threshold is the minimum energy required to activate the sensory organ.
∑ Difference threshold of two sources of a sensory modality is the minimum difference that has to
exist between the intensities of the two sources to allow them to be perceived separately.
Weber’s law
The increase in stimulus intensity needed to allow two sources of intensity to be perceived as being
different is directly proportional to the value of the baseline intensity.
Fechner’s law
Weber’s law is an approximation which fails to hold over a large range of stimulus intensities. A
better, though again not perfect, approximation is provided by Fechner’s law which holds that
sensory perception is a logarithmic function of stimulus intensity.
Perceptual organization
Perception is an active process in which there is a search for meaning. A number of perceptual
phenomena are described in Gestalt psychology:
Phenomena of visual and auditory perception 11
FIGURE–GROUND DIFFERENTIATION
Patterns are perceived as figures differentiated from their background with contours and
boundaries, thus simulating objects. Thus the relevant perceptual system needs to make a ‘decision’
as to how to differentiate correctly between the figure that is being perceived and its background. In
doing so, the following features characterize figure and ground, particularly in respect of visual
stimuli:
∑ The figure is more conspicuous than the ground.
∑ The figure appears more like an object in its own right.
∑ The ground does not appear to be an object, but rather generally formless.
∑ The ground extends past the figure.
∑ The perception is of the figure being ‘in front of ’ the ground.
∑ The contour or outline that differentiates figure from ground is perceived as belonging to the
figure rather than the ground.
An example of a visual figure–ground relationship is shown in Figure 1.2. It may not be obvious,
the first time this is looked at, what information it conveys. In fact, the figure consists of the spaces
between the objects (the ground). Armed with this knowledge, it is immediately clear that a word of
importance to examination candidates is depicted.
OBJECT CONSTANCY
This is the tendency to perceive objects as unchanged under different conditions:
∑ Shape constancy. The perception of an object’s shape is constant regardless of the viewing angle.
∑ Size constancy. The perception of an object’s size is constant regardless of the viewing distance.
12 Basic psychology
Figure 1.3 Visual example of a reversible figure/ground relationship – the Rubin vase.
DEPTH PERCEPTION
A three-dimensional visual perception is formed from two-dimensional retinal images as a result of
multiple cues such as binocular vision and convergence, relative size and brightness, motion
parallax, object interposition, and linear perspective.
PERCEPTUAL SET
Perceptual set is a motivational state of mind in which certain aspects of stimuli are perceived
according to expectation. This can be associated with a change in the perception threshold. The way
in which stimuli are perceived is influenced by personality and individual values, and past
experiences. Perceptual set was described in his book Becoming in 1955 by the American
psychologist Gordon Willard Allport (1897–1967).
∑ Difficulties in depth perception. This can occur, for example, owing to ocular problems.
Abnormal ocular lens accommodation can give rise to abnormalities in monocular cueing,
while defects in the ability of the eyes properly to converge can cause abnormalities in binocular
cueing.
HALLUCINATIONS
Hallucinations are false sensory perceptions occurring in the absence of real external stimuli. They
are perceived as being located in objective space and as having the same realistic qualities as normal
perceptions.
According to visual perceptual theory, the majority of the processing that comprises perception
takes place within the brain rather than in the sense organs themselves. Therefore, any factors that
adversely affect neuronal processing within the brain may cause the subject to experience
hallucinations. Such factors (described in later chapters) include cerebral lesions, psychoactive
substances, and toxic states.
Furthermore, on the basis of visual perceptual theory it would also be predicted that
abnormalities in the sense organs themselves or in primary perceptual functioning could also give
rise to hallucinations. Evidence exists to support this contention. For instance, visual hallucinations,
in the absence of other psychopathology, have been reported in association with ocular disease with
visual loss in Charles Bonnet syndrome (‘visual hallucinations of the blind’). An auditory analogue
to visual perceptual theory also exists; an example of auditory impairment being associated with
auditory hallucinations is the report of the association of musical hallucinations with hearing
impairment.
OTHER PSYCHOPATHOLOGY
An agnosia is an inability to interpret and recognize the significance of sensory information, which
does not result from impairment of the sensory pathways, mental deterioration, disorders of
consciousness and attention or, in the case of an object, a lack of familiarity with the object.
Abnormalities in the way in which visual perceptual systems (functioning according to visual
perceptual theory) interact with systems of the brain associated with functions such as learning and
memory can give rise to agnosias.
In schizophrenia, depersonalization, derealization, temporal lobe epilepsy and acute brain
syndromes, there is disturbance of perception, particularly depth perception and perceptual
constancy.
MU-GHAYEB
Mu-Ghayeb is a traditional bereavement reaction that occurs in Oman following a sudden
unexpected death. The deceased relative or friend may be seen as an unearthly figure at night.
During the daytime, the deceased may be seen, normally clothed, in circumstances that are difficult
to authenticate; for instance, sitting in a motor vehicle that passes by at speed. These visual
phenomena are consistent with the belief in traditional Omani society that after such a sudden
untimely ‘death’ the ‘deceased’ continue to be alive; they are expected to be resurrected to a strange,
ghostly existence, with nocturnal wanderings interleaving episodes of sleeping naked in caves
during the day. This belief in the return of the dead persists even after an elaborate ritual of burial
and a prescribed period of mourning. The deceased are expected to leave the grave after burial and
join their families when the spell placed on them by a sorcerer is broken or counteracted. Although
the Mu-Ghayeb belief is inconsistent with their Islamic religion, this culture-specific response to
bereavement may be explained in terms of sudden and untimely death which used to be rife in the
seafaring Omani society (Al-Adawi et al., 1997).
Information processing
Information processing is concerned with the way in which external signals arriving at the sense
organs are converted into meaningful perceptual experiences.
Data-driven processing
The processing is initiated by the arrival of data. The simplest scheme for classifying and recognizing
patterns is template matching, in which recognition is achieved by matching the external signal
against the internal template.
Attention
Attention is an intensive process in which information selection takes place. Types include:
∑ Selective/focused attention. One type of information is attended to while additional distracting
information is ignored; e.g. the cocktail party effect. In dichotic listening studies in which
subjects attend to one channel evidence indicates that the unattended channel is still being
processed and the listener can switch rapidly if appropriate.
∑ Divided attention. At least two sources of information are attended to simultaneously.
Performance is inefficient. Loss of performance is called ‘dual-task interference’.
∑ Sustained attention. The environment is monitored over a long period of time. Performance
deteriorates with time.
∑ Controlled attention. Effort is required. It has been suggested that a defect of controlled attention
might underlie symptoms of schizophrenia.
∑ Automatic attention. The subject becomes skilled at a task and therefore little conscious effort is
required.
∑ Stroop effect. An automatic process is so ingrained that it interferes with controlled processing.
Memory
Memory comprises encoding/registration, storage and retrieval of information.
∑ Encoding/registration. This is the transformation of physical information into a code that
memory can accept.
∑ Storage. This is the retention of encoded information. According to the multi-store model of
Atkinson and Shriffrin (1968), which has now been superseded, memory storage can be
Factors affecting memory 17
Iconic Rehearsal/
Environmental Echoic transfer
input . . Recoding Short-term Long-term
. . process memory memory
. . Retrieval/
Haptic response
control
Sensory
registers
Figure 1.4 The multi-store modal model of memory. (After Atkinson & Shriffrin, 1968).
ENCODING/REGISTRATION
Conrad (1964) showed that confusion occurs between acoustically similar letters presented against
background noise. For example, the letter P is more likely to be incorrectly recalled as V (which is
acoustically similar) than as the letter R (which is visually similar). Baddeley (1966a) then went on
to demonstrate that acoustically similar words are also more difficult to recall immediately (a test of
short-term memory) than are semantically similar words. For example, the sequence
rat–mat–cat–cap (which are acoustically similar words) is more difficult to recall immediately than
the sequence large–big–huge–grand (which is semantically similar). However, in a test of long-term
memory, Baddeley (1966b) found a semantic similarity effect rather than a phonological similarity
effect. So, in terms of the parameters studied, it appeared that encoding or registration for short-
term memory is better for semantically similar word sequences than for phonologically
(acoustically) similar words, while encoding or registration for long-term memory is better for
phonologically (acoustically) similar word sequences than for semantically similar words.
Semantic encoding has been shown to aid short-term memory in respect of trigrams (three-
letter sequences). Increased memory span has been demonstrated for meaningful trigrams, such as
CNN–CIA–NBC, than for meaningless trigrams, such as AUM–GLB–CDX (Bower & Springston,
1970).
With respect to iconic memory encoding, a preceding or subsequent visual sensory presentation
of data at a similar energy level (that is, brightness) to that of the index presentation leads to a
masking of the index presentation so that it is not registered. The term for this phenomenon is
energy masking and it occurs at the level of the retina. Another form of masking that has been
described is pattern masking, in which the preceding or subsequent visual presentation is of data
visually similar to that of the index presentation. Pattern masking occurs at a deeper level of visual
information processing than the retinal level. The deduction of the relative depth of level of visual
processing at which energy masking and pattern masking occur followed from the finding that,
whereas the former can take place only when the index presentation and the masking presentation
are both to the same eye, the latter can take place even when the index presentation is to one eye and
the corresponding masking presentation is to the other eye (Turvey, 1973). With respect to rapidly
changing picture presentations, it appears to take about 100 ms for a scene to be understood and no
longer be susceptible to ordinary visual masking, and a further 300 ms or so to be no longer
susceptible to conceptual masking (from a succeeding picture representation, for example) (Potter,
1976).
So far as the registration of two auditory stimuli is concerned, experiments in which two sounds
are presented to subjects and in which the just noticeable interval between noise pulses is compared
with the level of the second noise pulse demonstrate that confusion occurs between the echoic
image of the first auditory presentation and the onset of the second auditory presentation, unless
either a sufficient time interval is allowed for the echoic image of the first presentation to fade before
presenting the second stimulus, or the volume of the second stimulus is increased (Plomp, 1964).
As with visual masking (see above), so binaural masking has also been demonstrated. A masking
sound presented soon after an index sound interferes with detection; this interference is greater
when both stimuli are presented to the same ear than when the masking sound is presented to the
contralateral ear following the presentation of the index auditory stimulus (Deatherage & Evans,
1969).
In studies of auditory encoding of stimuli and their serial position, a suffix effect occurs. This
refers to the auditory encoding error that occurs when there is a categorical similarity between the
penultimate and ultimate speech-like sounds heard (Crowder, 1971; Ayres et al., 1979).
Factors affecting memory 19
Elaborating meaning appears to improve encoding of the written word. For instance, your
encoding of the text of each of the remaining chapters of this book is likely to be better if you look
at some questions specifically related to these chapters before reading each of them. (Suitable
questions may be found in the companion books of multiple choice questions (MCQs) and
extended matching items (EMIs).) When you read the actual chapters after being primed with the
need to search for the answers, you are more likely to elaborate parts of each of these chapters, and
encode the information better (Frase, 1975; Anderson, 1980).
STORAGE
One of many examples of findings that are not consistent with the multi-store modal model of
memory is that of the finding of positive recency effects in delayed free recall. According to the
model, a continuous distraction procedure, such as counting backwards between the presentation of
items such as unrelated words, should prevent the subject from rehearsing the items and should
replace these items in short-term memory. However, in practice the serial position curve shows both
a primacy effect and a recency effect under such circumstances (Tzeng, 1973). There also does not
appear to be a positive (or negative) relationship between the amount of rehearsal of presented
items and how well they are recalled from short-term memory (Craik & Watkins, 1973; Glenberg et
al., 1977).
Gillund and Shiffrin (1981) found that the free recall of complex pictures was better than that of
words. Many further studies have confirmed a picture superiority effect. In general, pictures are
remembered and recalled better than words, and non-verbal information storage of pictures and
designs is found to be more stable over a period of hours and days than is the storage of words (e.g
Hart & O’Shanick, 1993). Simple pictures appear to be better remembered than complex pictures;
the asymmetric confusability effect is manifested in the finding that there is a greater accuracy in
recognition testing of same versus changed stimulus in simple rather than complex pictures (Pezdek
& Chen, 1982).
RETRIEVAL
Retrieval of information from the long-term memory is error prone but is improved if the
information being stored is organized. Hierarchical organization is particularly useful in this regard,
perhaps because it improves the search process within long-term memory (Bower et al., 1969).
Another optimal condition for retrieval of information is to arrange that the context within
which the information is to be retrieved is similar to that within which it was encoded (Estes, 1972).
modal model of memory, and in particular on the assumption implicit in this model that holding
information in short-term memory (or the short-term store) necessarily leads to information
transfer into long-term memory (or the long-term store). Furthermore, since in this modal model
the short-term memory (store) acts as the working memory that is essential for learning, it would
be expected that patients with short-term memory (store) impairment should manifest impaired
long-term learning. However, Shallice and Warrington (1970) described the case of a patient with a
severely affected short-term memory (store) who nonetheless had a normal long-term learning
capacity; this person had a memory span of just two digits and almost no recency effect in the free-
recall task (in which the subject is asked to recall as many of a previously presented list of unrelated
words as he/she can, in any order). Moreover, when a short-term memory (store) deficit is
experimentally induced in normal subjects by giving them digits to rehearse concurrently with a
grammatical reasoning task, even with eight digits the reasoning time increases by only around 50%
and the error rate remains around 5% (the same as with fewer digits to rehearse) (Baddeley & Hitch,
1974), and this in spite of the fact that a digit load of eight should have totally filled the short-term
memory (store) according to the multi-store modal model. Tasks using a similar digit load
concurrent with comprehension and free-recall learning also show that the long-term memory
(store) can be impaired but that the recency effect still occurs, again contrary to the modal model
prediction.
In response to these difficulties, Baddeley and Hitch formulated the working memory model
shown diagrammatically in Figure 1.5. The central executive is an attentional controller which is
supported by two active slave systems, the articulatory or phonological loop, responsible for the
maintenance of speech-based information, and the visuospatial scratch-pad or sketch-pad, which can
hold and manipulate information in the visuospatial domain. This model was compatible with the
findings mentioned in the previous paragraph. For example, concurrent verbal (articulatory)
activity and visual or spatial activity appear to interfere with two different systems. Subjects using a
mnemonic based on spatial location to remember word lists have better recall of the lists than those
who use a simple rote rehearsal procedure, but this advantage disappears if the former subjects are
required to carry out a visuospatial task concurrently (Baddeley & Lieberman, 1980). Again, a
patient with gross impairment of digit span would be hypothesized to have a defect of their
phonological loop functioning; if there were no co-existent impairment of the functioning of the
central executive or visuospatial sketch-pad, then normal learning should still be possible.
Central
executive
Visuospatial Articulatory or
scratch-pad phonological
or sketch-pad loop
Figure 1.5 The working memory model of Baddeley and Hitch. (After Baddeley & Hitch, 1974).
Working memory capacity can be measured using a task in which, after reading a series of
sentences, the subject is required to recall the last word of each of these sentences (Daneman &
Carpenter, 1980). This task therefore requires both comprehension and recall (as opposed to just
recall in the simple word-span task).
Factors affecting memory 21
There is a strong positive correlation between working memory tests and intelligence quotient
(IQ) tests. Furthermore, standard intelligence quotient tests appear to be more susceptible to the
subject’s previous knowledge, whereas working memory tests appear to have a greater relationship
to the speed of processing (Kyllonen & Christal, 1990).
In terms of the model of working memory of Baddeley and Hitch (1974), the central executive is
a limited-capacity system which provides the link between the two slave systems (see Figure 1.5) and
long-term memory; it is responsible for planning and selecting strategies (Baddeley, 1986). The
visuospatial scratch-pad or sketch-pad appears to have a visual component, which is concerned with
such factors as shape and colour, and a spatial component, which is concerned with location
(Baddeley & Lieberman, 1980; Baddeley, 1986). The articulatory or phonological loop also appears
to be made up of two components: a memory store which can hold phonological information for
one to two seconds; and an articulatory control process (or processor) (Baddeley, 1986; Paulesu et
al., 1993). Memory traces in the phonological loop can be refreshed by means of subvocal
articulation. (Subvocal or vocal articulation may also be used to provide an input into this slave
system upon the visual presentation of objects by the subject articulating the names of those
objects.) The phonological loop is held to provide the basis for digit span. In particular, the number
of items retained in the digit span is believed to be a function of both the rate of fading of the
memory trace in the phonological loop and the rate of refreshing of memory traces by means of
subvocal articulation. The size of the storage capacity can be reduced in the following ways:
∑ The phonological similarity effect. This involves trying to remember items with similar sounding
names.
∑ Presenting irrelevant spoken material. This gains access to the store and corrupts the memory
trace.
∑ The word length effect. As the length of the words increases, the memory span decreases,
presumably because of the longer time required for longer words to be rehearsed, leading to a
greater probability of memory trace decay.
∑ Articulatory suppression. This requires a subject repeatedly to articulate an irrelevant speech
sound which interferes with subvocal rehearsal.
SEMANTIC MEMORY
Semantic memory refers to the subject’s knowledge of facts, language, concepts, and the like, and is
an aspect of long-term/secondary memory that is consistent with the finding that verbal
information is stored in terms of meaning rather than exact words (Tulving, 1972). It is easier to
remember words paired with meanings (Bower, 1972), and to recall words synonymous to those in
a given list (Sachs, 1967). Therefore semantic encoding is a more efficient way than simple rehearsal
of transferring information from the ‘short-term memory’ to the long-term/secondary one.
22 Basic psychology
EPISODIC MEMORY
Episodic memory is an aspect of long-term/secondary memory that refers to the memory for
events. It provides a continually changing and updated record of autobiographical material
(Tulving, 1972).
SKILLS MEMORY
Skills memory, or procedural memory, is an aspect of long-term/secondary memory that supports
skilled performance.
THEORIES OF FORGETTING
Under the multi-modal model of memory, forgetting from long-term memory could be caused by
interference or trace decay.
According to the interference theory, forgetting by interference is item-dependent. There are
two main types. In proactive interference/inhibition, previous learning is likely to impair subse-
quent learning. In retroactive interference/inhibition, new learning is likely to impair previous
learning.
According to the decay theory, memories fade with time. The longer the item remains in the
memory system, the weaker its strength. New material has a high trace strength while older has a low
trace strength. Forgetting by decay is time-dependent.
SCHEMATA
A schema (plural schemata) may be defined as a mental model or representation, built up through
experience, about a person, an object, a situation, or an event (Searleman & Herrmann, 1994). The
roles of schemata include (Morton & Bekerian, 1986):
∑ interpretation of sensory data
∑ retrieval of information from memory
∑ organization of actions
∑ determination of goals
∑ determination of behaviour
∑ allocation of processing resources
∑ directing overall processing in attentional, perceptual and memory systems.
They help to integrate information that is currently being experienced with the subject’s long-term
past in a single representation (Groeger, 1997).
It has been suggested that lack of the schemata needed to help organize episodic memory may
help explain the origin of infantile amnesia, which is the inability of humans to access their early
childhood memories (Schachtel, 1947). In contrast, the organization of retrieval cues into stable
retrieval schemata has been put forward as being part of the explanation of the occurrence of
exceptional memory performance, in the skilled memory theory (Ericsson & Kintsch, 1995).
ELABORATION
As mentioned earlier in this chapter, elaboration appears to improve encoding of new information.
Methods of elaboration include:
∑ semantic processing
∑ forming complex images
∑ attempting to answer questions based on the material to be learned.
There is much evidence that stands in opposition to this early theory. To give just two examples:
∑ Many infrahuman animals appear to be able to think but do not appear to possess language.
∑ Temporary paralysis of all voluntary muscles with D-tubocurarine is not associated with an
inability to think (Smith et al., 1947).
CONCEPTS
Concepts are the properties or relationships that given object classes or ideas have in common. They
constitute a means of grouping what otherwise would form too wide a variety of disparate items or
ideas for efficient thought and communication.
∑ Concrete concepts refer to objects. For example, the concept ‘book’ refers to objects having
properties shared by most books, such as having pages, containing information, having a title,
having authors, and so on.
∑ Abstract concepts refer to abstract ideas, such as honesty, integrity and justice. Concepts of
activities include drinking, walking, cycling, and so on.
PROTOTYPES
Prototypes are idealized forms. For instance, the prototypical book might be considered to have the
shape of this book with: a front cover having a title; a back cover; multiple pages in between the
covers mostly containing printed words arranged into sentences, paragraphs, subsections, sections
and chapters; some diagrams interspersed amongst the words; a title page and list of contents at the
beginning; an index at the end. According to the prototype theory, the acquisition of prototypes
occurs through repeated exposure.
Reasoning
DEDUCTIVE REASONING
This is reasoning based on deduction, the domains of which include:
∑ relational inferences
∑ propositional inferences
∑ syllogisms
∑ multiply quantified inferences.
Relational inferences are based on relations such as:
Is equal to, denoted by =
Is greater than, denoted by >
Is less than, denoted by <
Is greater than or equal to, denoted by ≥
Is less than or equal to, denoted by £
After
Before
To the right of
To the left of.
Factors affecting thought 25
INDUCTIVE REASONING
In inductive reasoning, a general statement is derived by inductive arguments from many instances.
An elementary example is given from number theory in mathematics. Consider the following
(correct) equations:
1=1
1+2=3
1 + 2 + 22 = 7
1 + 2 + 22 + 23 = 15
1 + 2 + 22 + 23 + 24 = 31
1 + 2 + 22 + 23 + 24 + 25 = 63.
Consider the values of the positive integers (whole numbers) on the right-hand side of each
equation. We have:
1 = 2 - 1 = 21 - 1
3 = 22 - 1
7 = 23 - 1
15 = 24 - 1
31 = 25 - 1
63 = 26 - 1.
So here we have the following pattern that appears to be emerging:
1 + 2 + 22 + 23 + … + 2n - 1 = 2n - 1 (1.1)
(This may also be written as 20 + 21 + 22 + 23 + … + 2n - 1 = 2n - 1.)
We have six instances in which equation (1.1) is true. What we shall now do is use inductive
reasoning to prove that the general statement, equation (1.1), is itself true.
Let S represent the set of positive integers (positive whole numbers, such as 1, 2, 3, etc.) for which
the formula given in equation (1.1) is correct. Now, when n = 1, the left-hand side of this formula is
Factors affecting thought 27
Problem-solving strategies
ALTERNATIVE REPRESENTATIONS
One method of problem-solving is to represent the given data in a different way. For example, we
have seen two different representations in the last two examples. In the first of these, in which a
problem relating to the relative order of chapters of this book was set, a diagrammatic
representation was used, in which the data were, as it were, visualized. In the most recent example,
on the other hand, in which inductive reasoning was being used, it was more convenient to use
symbolic representation. In a similar fashion, in elementary mathematics, problem-solving can also
sometimes be carried out using a more geometric approach or a more algebraic approach.
EXPERTISE
The way in which problems are represented by experts tends to differ from the representations used
by inexperienced people. For instance, the way in which the reader (assumed to be clinically
competent and qualified) might diagnose a central nervous system lesion in a patient would likely
be different and more efficient (and more likely to be correct) than the methods employed by
relatively inexperienced third-year medical students; the recall of the person’s symptoms and signs
would also tend to be better for the reader. In particular, compared with a beginner, an expert’s
memory would tend to have more potential representations of the problem that he or she can draw
upon to solve it. Experts are also more likely to be able to invoke heuristics (see below) that are not
available to novices.
COMPUTER SIMULATIONS
Computer simulations may be used to study the way in which representations and heuristics are
employed in problem-solving.
28 Basic psychology
Algorithms
In a general sort of way, an algorithm consists of a specific sequence of steps that need to be carried
out according to precise instructions in order to solve a given problem. For example, suppose you
were to stop reading right now and take a pencil and paper and calculate the value of 22 divided by
7 to three decimal places, using long division. The correct answer is 3.143. The method you used to
carry out this calculation involved a mechanical use of the rules of long division; no deep thought is
required but, rather, a simple adherence to the simple rules of this method of problem-solving. This
is a characteristic feature of algorithms.
More precisely, an algorithm is any process that can be carried out by a Turing machine. A Turing
machine is a simple, mechanical calculating device invented by the British mathematician Alan
Turing (1912–54). At its most basic, a Turing machine can be imagined to be an infinitely long tape
segmented into squares. Starting at any one square, the Turing machine can do the following:
1 Stop the computation.
2 Move one square to the right.
3 Move one square to the left.
4 Write S0 to replace whatever is in the square being scanned.
5 Write S1 to replace whatever is in the square being scanned.
.
.
.
n+4 Write Sn to replace whatever is in the square being scanned.
This may seem, at first sight, to be a rather primitive machine that can only handle addition and
subtraction, say. In fact, however, it can carry out multiplication, division, and the calculation of
square roots and other power functions. Indeed, it may be the case that, in principle, a Turing
machine can carry out any calculation that a powerful modern supercomputer can.
Heuristics
As mentioned above, heuristics are strategies that can be applied to problems and that often give the
correct answer (or ‘goal state’) more quickly than simple algorithms; they are not guaranteed to
work, however. Such heuristic techniques are not usually available to novices, whereas experts can
access these during problem-solving. As an example, at one stage of his career the author of this
chapter had cause to devise a method of accurately quantifying cerebral ventricular volumes in
serial magnetic resonance scans that had been accurately matched using subvoxel registration, a feat
that had not hitherto been accomplished. A heuristic of the type ‘consider an analogous problem
that you know you can solve’ was used first, and then this solution was generalized to allow the
required equations to be arrived at.
Kantianism. He distinguished between the study of whole populations (the nomothetic approach)
and the study of individuals (the idiographic approach).
The nomothetic approach to personality considers that personality theory should be at least
partly based on the study of the common features and differences between people. For instance,
personality has been defined by Wiggins (1979) as being:
. . . that branch of psychology which is concerned with providing a systematic account of the ways in
which individuals differ from one another.
In contrast, the idiographic approach attempts to gain an understanding of personality in the
context of each individual’s unique existence. According to Tyrer and Ferguson (2000):
The idiographic approach focuses on the uniqueness of the individual and as such can provide a rich,
multifaceted description of subtle areas of personal attributes and behaviour. Numerous strands are
brought together to build up a portrait which cannot be confused with any other. The case history is
the most obvious example and has been used with effect to describe processes, which can then be
generalized to explain similar psychological mechanisms in others.
An influential early proponent of the idiographic approach was Gordon Allport (1937), but the
nomothetic approach has prevailed.
Anxious
Depressed
Emotional
Guilt feelings
Irrational
Low self-esteem
Moody
Shy
Tense.
Psychoticism, which is orthogonal to (and therefore independent of) extraversion and neuroticism
in the revised Eysenck factor analysis-based model of personality, is associated with traits such as:
Aggressive
Antisocial
Cold
Creative
Egocentric
Impersonal
Impulsive
Tough-minded
Unempathetic.
In contrast to traits, which refer to stable phenomena related to behaviour and ideas relating to
enduring dispositions, states are unstable short-term features of the individual. An example of a
state variable is a temporary short-term feeling of anxiety in someone who normally scores highly
on the extraversion dimension.
Trait and state approaches can be combined. For example, Figure 1.6 shows a model (based on
Michael Eysenck, 1982) of the adverse effects of anxiety on information processing and
performance; this model in turn is based on the more complex model of Spielberger (1966).
Trait anxiety
External
State anxiety Processing Performance
stressors
• Subjective feelings of
apprehension
• Autonomic nervous system
arousal
Figure 1.6 Eysenck’s state-trait model showing the effects of anxiety on performance. (After Eysenck, 1982).
Construct theory
The personal construct theory of George Kelly (an American engineer who went on to become a
clinical psychologist) is based on the proposition that behaviour in humans is anticipatory rather
than reactive (Kelly, 1955). Kelly considered every man to be a scientist, interpreting the world on
the basis of past experience. Constructs are created and predictions made accordingly. A system of
32 Basic psychology
constructs results, unique in each individual, existing at various levels of consciousness, those
formed at earlier developmental stages being unconscious. Each construct has a range of
convenience, some are specific (e.g. chewy versus tender), whereas others have a wider range of
convenience. Constructs are arranged into hierarchies. Superordinate constructs are central to the
individual’s sense of identity, subordinate constructs less so.
According to this theory, anxiety results when the individual is presented with events outside
his or her range of personal constructs. Hostility comprises imposition of constructs upon
another.
The main points relating to construct systems are as follows:
∑ Individuals’ construct systems make the world more predictable and thereby make it easier to
negotiate one’s way around.
∑ Individuals’ construct systems are not static but may grow and be modified in response to
circumstances. For example, suppose you were under the impression that professors of
psychiatry are honest, intelligent people of integrity who care deeply about the need to help
discover the aetiology of various types of mental illness and who wish to help find the best
treatments for such illnesses. If you were then to discover that a couple of such professors were
in fact utterly dishonest, cruel, selfish and psychopathic, with little or no real commitment to
academic excellence but ready to steal the fruits of the work of others, then your construct
system in this regard would be challenged. In these circumstances, you could alter your
construct system in one of these ways:
∑ Adaptation. Your construct system could be changed to reflect your new experience.
∑ Immunization. You could try to maintain your belief system by having thoughts such as
‘There must be some important reason that I am not privy to which explains why they
seemed to act in such an evil way.’
∑ The construct system of an individual represents the truth as uniquely understood and
experienced by that person.
∑ A construct system is not necessarily internally consistent.
∑ Since construct systems are partly a function of prior experience, they affect expectations and
behaviour.
∑ Constructs representing core values and the most important relationships of a person are more
firmly held and of greater importance that those related to less important matters.
∑ The degree to which one individual can relate to and understand the construct system of
another person is a function to his/her empathy with the latter.
Humanist approaches
Humanistic approaches pay particular attention to those qualities that differentiate humans from
non-human animal species. The Association for Humanistic Psychology lists the following five basic
postulates:
Man, as man, supersedes the sum of his parts.
Man has his being in a human context.
Man is aware.
Man has choice.
Man is intentional.
Self-actualization is held to be a core individual motivational force.
Factors affecting personality 33
MASLOW
Abraham Maslow is considered to be another leading founder of the humanist approach. Maslow’s
hierarchy of needs is considered in the next section of this chapter. Transient episodes of self-
actualization have been termed ‘peak experiences’ by Maslow (1970); they are described in terms
such as:
Aliveness
Beauty
Effortlessness
Goodness
Perfection
Self-sufficiency
Truth
Uniquenss
Wholeness.
∑ They accept themselves and other people for what they are.
∑ They are highly creative.
∑ They have a good sense of humour.
∑ They tend to be problem-centred rather than self-centred.
∑ They are able to tolerate uncertainty.
∑ They exhibit spontaneous thought.
∑ They exhibit spontaneous behaviour.
∑ Even though they do not make an effort to be unconventional, nevertheless they are resistant to
enculturation.
∑ They have the capacity to consider life objectively.
∑ They form deep and satisfying relationships with relatively few others.
Being honest
Assuming responsibility
Working hard at the tasks decided upon
Becoming fully absorbed and concentrating fully, experiencing life as a child does
Identifying one’s defences and giving them up
Being prepared to try new things
Evaluating experiences personally without being swayed by the opinions of others
Being willing to be unpopular.
34 Basic psychology
Psychoanalytic approaches
Behaviour and feelings are explained by unconscious drives and conflicts. The id is held to be
derived from the libido. Irrational, impulsive instincts are unable to postpone gratification, and are
present at birth. The ego develops as the child grows. A conscious mind balances the demands of the
id with the realities of the outside world. Anxiety results if the ego is unable to control the energies
of the id. The superego comprises the internalization of the views of parents and society, like a
conscience. The id, ego and superego are in balance with each other.
Situationist approach
The external situation is considered the most powerful determinant of behaviour. Situationists
maintain that traits result from differences in learning experiences. Behaviour changes according to
the situation an individual finds himself (or herself) in. Proponents dismiss the trait theory. Mischel
(1983) argues against the existence of any stable personality dimension because of poor correlation
between behaviour or attitudes in one situation compared with another.
Factors affecting personality 35
Interactionist approach
Interactionism holds that behaviour depends upon both the situation and the person (or
personality traits) as well as their mutual interaction. Endler (1983) was a prominent advocate of
the interactionist approach, arguing that behaviour is:
. . . a function of a continuous multidirectional process of person-by-situation interactions; cognitive,
motivational and emotional factors have important determining roles on behaviour, regarding the
person side; and the perception or psychological meaning that the situation has for the person is an
essential determining factor of behaviour.
Inventories
Personality inventories are questionnaires in which the same questions are put to each person.
16PF
As mentioned above, Cattell and colleagues (1970) developed the 16PF (16 Personality Factor
questionnaire) which measures 16 primary factors along 16 dimensions. It was based on the use of
factor analysis to identify these 16 basic personality traits, which are listed above, from an initial list
of over 3000 personality trait names of Allport and Odbert (1936). Over 100 questions (with yes/no
answers) were then selected to allow these traits to be measured. For example, the following
question helps to assess trait E (assertive/dominant versus humble/cooperative):
Do you tend to keep in the background on social occasions?
An affirmative reply would give the subject a point on the humble/cooperative end of the trait E
scale, while a negative reply would give a point on the assertive/domain end.
The 16PF gives scores on various personality characteristics such as:
Dominance
Emotional stability
Self-control.
MMPI
The opinions of experts (usually working in psychiatry) were garnered in generating the categories
for subjects on whom the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory or MMPI was developed.
The final version of the MMPI contains over 550 (567 in one recent version) statements (or
questions), relating to:
Attitudes
Emotional reactions
Physical symptoms
Psychological symptoms.
The person being tested is asked to answer true, false, or cannot say to each statement. An example
of such a statement is:
At times my thoughts have raced ahead faster that I could speak them.
36 Basic psychology
An affirmative response to this statement would yield a higher score on the hypomania (Ma) scale.
Scores are obtained for several scales from the MMPI as follows (with their abbreviations):
Lie/social desirability (L)
Frequency/distress (F)
Correction/defensiveness (K)
Hypochondriasis (Hs)
Depression (D)
Hysteria (Hy)
Psychopathic deviancy (Pd)
Paranoia (Pa)
Psychasthenia (Pt)
Schizophrenia (Sc)
Hypomania (Ma)
Social introversion–extraversion (Si)
Masculinity–femininity (Mf).
The first three of these scales are used for validity purposes. They include the following statements:
∑ L scale:
∑ Once in a while I think of things too bad to talk about.
∑ At times I feel like swearing.
∑ I do not always tell the truth.
∑ Once in a while I put off until tomorrow what I ought to do today.
∑ I would rather win than lose in a game.
∑ I do not like everyone I know.
∑ F scale:
∑ Evil spirits possess me at times.
∑ When I am with people I am bothered by hearing very queer things.
∑ My soul sometimes leaves my body.
∑ Someone has been trying to poison me.
∑ Someone has been trying to rob me.
∑ Everything tastes the same.
∑ My neck spots with red often.
∑ Someone has been trying to influence my mind.
∑ K scale:
∑ Often I can’t understand why I have been so cross and grouchy.
∑ At times my thoughts have raced ahead faster than I could speak them.
∑ Criticism or scolding hurts me terribly.
∑ I certainly feel useless at times.
∑ I have never felt better in my life than I do now.
∑ What others think of me does not bother me.
∑ I find it hard to make talk when I meet new people.
∑ I frequently find myself worrying about something.
Tyrer and Ferguson (2000) have made the following comment:
. . . the individual scales . . . show a considerable degree of intercorrelation. The scales themselves have
unfortunately been labelled using standard psychiatric nosology (e.g. paranoia, schizophrenia and
hypomania) which can lead to confusion with Axis I diagnosis. They should more properly be regarded
as indicative of the presence of specific personality attributes. Although the MMPI is currently used in
Factors affecting personality 37
candidate-selection procedures, its principal value would appear to be in the study of clinically
abnormal personalities where interpretation by an experienced psychologist is required.
In addition to the problem of the intercorrelation of many scales, another problem with the
MMPI is that responses may change over time. (This is a problem relating to reliability.) The same
person taking the MMPI at baseline and then a few days later may score differently overall and on
different scales.
CPI
The California Psychological Inventory or CPI employs some of the same statements as the MMPI.
In the development of the CPI, the opinions of non-experts, such as the peers of the test subjects,
were used. The CPI is constructed to measure less ‘abnormal’ personality traits than the MMPI (in
‘normal’ people), such as:
Dominance
Independence
Responsibility
Self-acceptance
Socialization
Flexibility
Masculinity–femininity.
In total, the CPI has over 450 (480 in one recent version) true/false items, of which many (178 in the
same recent version) are from the MMPI, and yields 15 scales that measure personality and three
scales that are used to eliminate response bias. Overall, the CPI yields the following three broad
vector scales:
Internality/externality
Norm-favoring/norm-questioning
Self-fulfilled/dispirited.
The CPI was given to 13 000 individuals and separate scores were obtained for males and
females. The mean scores for each scale were obtained. The scores of subjects now taking the CPI
can be compared with the mean scores for these original 13 000 individuals.
OTHER INVENTORIES
Other personality inventories include:
∑ Children’s Personality Questionnaire
∑ Differential Personality Inventory
∑ Edwards Personality Inventory
∑ Eysenck Personality Inventory
∑ Eysenck Personality Questionnaire
∑ Maudsley Personality Inventory
∑ Neo Personality Inventory
∑ Omnibus Personality Inventory.
The Maudsley Personality Inventory (MPI) was superseded by the Eysenck Personality Inventory
(EPI), which in turn was superseded by the Eysenck Personality Questionnaire (EPQ) which
measures psychoticism and contains a lie scale.
38 Basic psychology
LIMITATIONS OF INVENTORIES
There are several limitations on the use of personality inventories.
∑ There are limitations imposed by the cultural origins of the questionnaires. For example, in
assessing the answers to the MMPI and the CPI, it needs to be borne in mind that these
questionnaires were created for American subjects. One of the statements on the F scale of the
MMPI is that ‘Evil spirits possess me at times’; in some cultures it is accepted as perfectly normal
that ‘evil spirits’ should ‘possess’ a person, while in other cultures such terminology might be
normal but not to be taken literally.
∑ Deliberate faking. Subjects may deliberately try to come across as possessing (or not possessing)
a particular personality trait. Lie scales are often included to try to detect for this.
∑ Questionnaires are susceptible to response sets – subjects may exhibit a systematic tendency to
respond to test questions.
∑ The inventories tend to have a low validity, particularly in respect of predictive validity.
∑ A social desirability bias may occur, in which subjects may have an unconscious tendency to give
socially desirable responses that make them look good.
∑ The inventories only rarely allow an assessment of the underlying reasons for the responses to
questions.
∑ The responses depend on an accurate knowledge, on the part of the subjects, of their beliefs,
behaviour, abilities and feelings.
∑ The responses depend on a willingness, on the part of the subjects, to make known their beliefs,
behaviour, abilities and feelings.
∑ Questionnaires are susceptible to contamination by relatively minor changes in the mental state
of the subject.
∑ The dimensions chosen by psychologists in creating questionnaires may be difficult to relate to
personality disorder categories used by psychiatrists.
Rating scales
There are several rating scales that may be used for the assessment of personality disorder. The
following are all structured interview schedules.
SAP
The Standardized Assessment of Personality or SAP is carried out by a trained clinical interviewer.
A personality profile is obtained from an informant. An ICD-10 diagnosis is obtained.
SCID II
The Structured Clinical Interview for DSM-III-R Personality Disorders or SCID II is carried out by
a clinician and yields DSM diagnoses.
SIDP
The Structured Interview for DSM-III Personality Disorders or SIDP is carried out by a psychologist
or psychiatrist and yields DSM-III-R diagnoses.
Factors affecting personality 39
PAS
The Personality Assessment Schedule or PAS yields five diagnostic categories:
Sociopathic
Schizoid
Passive dependent
Anankastic
Normal.
It assesses 24 dimensions of personality and should be carried out by a trained clinical interviewer.
PDE
The Personality Disorder Examination or PDE yields DSM diagnoses.
IPDE
The International Personality Disorder Examination for DSM-IV and ICD-10 personality disorders
or IPDE is carried out by trained interviewers and covers DSM-IV(-TR) and ICD-10 operational
criteria.
Repertory grid
George Kelly devised the repertory grid or role construct repertory (REP) test. This grid assesses
personality based on an individual’s personal constructs. A typical grid might consist of ten rows
(excluding rows containing headings), which need to be filled in by the subject. The subject begins
by naming specific people who fit into given categories, such as a happy person, and a successful
person. These form columns that cross the rows. Other columns correspond to other people, such
as the subject’s father, mother, the subject himself or herself, children, spouse or partner, etc. There
is now a grid of, say, ten rows and around ten columns. On each row, three cells are circled; no two
rows contain the same three circles. These correspond to three different individuals. Row by row, the
subject must now decide for the three individuals concerned what description shows how two of
these three individuals are similar and how they differ from the third individual. The former
description is placed in a column (column 1) on the left-hand side of the grid, while the latter
description is similarly placed in a column (column 2) on the right-hand side of the grid. A code is
used to fill in the circles (e.g. 1 for similarity, as in the column 1 description, 2 for difference, as in
column 2, and 0 if neither column 1 nor column 2 applies). Then the rest of the grid is filled in.
There are many scoring systems available, although the grid itself overall gives an indication of how
the subject views others.
Q-sort schedule
This is an ipsative method, that is, one which compares alternatives within an individual, in which
the rater (or coder) sorts statements into a standard distribution. Jack Block (1961, 1971) used it in
his research on childhood development. A deck of cards was produced in which each card contained
a word or phrase. An individual was described by sorting this deck into piles corresponding to how
closely the card descriptions were deemed to apply to the subject. The Q-sort schedule is designed
to apply across different individuals and over time, over different ages.
40 Basic psychology
Intrinsic theories
Whereas extrinsic theories require reduction of drive externally, intrinsic theories propose that the
activity engaged in has its own intrinsic reward.
Optimal arousal
An example is offered by optimal arousal, in which the subject attains an optimal level of arousal to
achieve optimal performance. In general a moderate level of arousal leads to an optimum degree of
alertness and interest, and therefore to a comparatively high efficiency of performance. High and
low arousal lead to reduced performance and are described in the inverted-U shape of the
Yerkes–Dodson curve.
Cognitive dissonance
According to this theory, first formulated by Festinger, discomfort occurs when two or more
cognitions are held but are inconsistent with each other. The individual is motivated to achieve
cognitive consistency and may change one or more of the cognitions.
Attitude-discrepant behaviour
When attitude and behaviour are inconsistent (attitude-discrepant behaviour), alteration of
attitude helps bring about cognitive consistency.
Curiosity drive
Whereas the homeostatic model predicts that once physiological needs such as thirst and hunger
have been satisfied, or aversive stimuli such as pain have successfully been avoided, and the body
Factors affecting emotion 41
returned to its normal state, the organism should no longer be motivated and should be quiescent,
in practice this is not the case. Humans and other mammals, for example, have been noted to seek
stimulation actively. A curiosity drive has been proposed to help explain this phenomenon, in which
the organism has drives to:
∑ explore new environments
∑ investigate objects
∑ manipulate objects (if appropriate)
∑ seek changing sensory stimulation (and avoid sensory deprivation)
∑ seek sensation.
Types of emotion
An emotion is a mental feeling or affection having cognitive, physiological and social concomitants.
Plutchik has classified them into eight primary emotions:
Disgust
Anger
Anticipation
Joy
Acceptance
Fear
Surprise
Sadness.
Any two adjacent emotions can give rise to a secondary emotion. For example, the secondary
emotion of love is derived from the primary emotions of joy and acceptance. Similarly, submission
results from acceptance and fear, disappointment from surprise and sadness, contempt from disgust
and anger, and so on.
42 Basic psychology
James–Lange theory
According to this theory, the experience of emotion is secondary to the somatic responses (e.g.
sweating, increased cardiac rate, increased arousal) to the perception of given emotionally
important events. For example, if an arachnophobe becomes aroused, experiences increased activity
of the sympathetic nervous system and runs away after seeing a spider, the feelings of anxiety and
fear are the result of the increased sympathetic activity and running away, and not primarily because
of the emotion-evoking stimulus.
Cannon criticized this theory. It was argued that similar physiological changes can accompany
different emotions. Also, pharmacologically induced simulation of such physiological changes is
usually not accompanied by these emotions. The experience of emotions can be shown to be
independent of somatic responses, sometimes occurring before the somatic responses.
Cannon–Bard theory
This holds that, following the perception of an emotionally important event, both the somatic
responses and the experience of emotion occur together. In neurophysiological terms, the perceived
stimulus undergoes thalamic processing, and signals are then relayed both to the cerebral cortex,
leading to the experience of emotion, and to other parts of the body, such as the autonomic nervous
system, leading to somatic responses.
This theory can be criticized on the basis of the observation that there are stimuli (e.g. sudden
danger) which can lead to increased sympathetic activity before the emotion is experienced.
Conversely, the experience of emotions sometimes occurs before the somatic response.
STRESS
Stress results when demand exceeds resources. An individual’s response to a stressful situation is
affected by biological susceptibility and personality characteristics.
Stress 43
Situational factors
These include life events, daily hassles/uplifts, conflict and trauma (see Chapter 29).
Life events
These are changes in a person’s life that require readjustment. They are ranked in order from most
to least stressful. The most stressful include: death of spouse; divorce; marital separation; gaol term;
death of close family member; personal illness; and marriage. The scale has been found to be
universally applicable to people in both underdeveloped and Western countries. Many conditions,
both physical and mental, show an excess of life events in the months preceding onset.
Coping mechanisms
Although the following mechanisms, used to cope with stress, are conscious, they relate to
unconscious defence mechanisms too (given in parentheses):
∑ concentration only on the current task (denial)
∑ empathy (projection)
∑ logical analysis (rationalisation)
∑ objectivity (isolation)
∑ playfulness (regression)
∑ substitution of other thoughts for disturbing ones (reaction formation)
∑ suppression of inappropriate feelings (repression).
Learned helplessness
Seligman found that dogs given unavoidable electric shocks suffered a number of phenomena
which he considered were similar to depression, such as reduced appetite, disturbed sleep and
reduced sex drive. He called this learned helplessness.
44 Basic psychology
The cognitive theory of depression is based largely on this concept. Further work has found that
individuals who believe that they have no personal control over events are much more likely to
develop learned helplessness, whereas those believing that nobody could have controlled the
outcome are unlikely to do so. Thus a person’s attribution of what is occurring influences the
likelihood of developing major depression in cognitive terms.
Locus of control
Rotter differentiated those who see their lives as being under their own control (internal locus of
control) from those who see their lives as being controlled externally (external locus of control).
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Al-Adawi, S., Burjorjee, R. & Al-Issa, I. 1997: Mu-Ghayeb: a culture-specific response to bereavement in Oman.
International Journal of Social Psychiatry 43:144–151.
Al-Issa, I. 1977: Social and cultural aspects of hallucinations. Psychological Bulletin 84:570–587.
Allport, G.W. 1937: Personality: A psychological interpretation. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston.
Allport, G.W. 1955: Becoming: Basic Considerations for a Psychology of Personality. New Haven, CT: Yale
University Press.
Allport, G.W. & Odbert H.S. 1936: Trait names: a psycholexical study. Psychological Monographs 47, no. 211.
Anderson, J.R. 1980: Cognitive Psychology and its Implications. San Francisco: Freeman.
Atkinson, R.C. & Shriffrin, R.M. 1968: Human memory: a proposed system and its control processes. In Spence,
K.W. & Spence, J.T. (eds) The Psychology of Learning and Memory, vol. 2. New York: Academic Press.
Atkinson, R.L., Atkinson, R.C. & Smith, E.E 1990: Introduction to Psychology, 10th edn. San Diego: Harcourt Brace
Jovanovich.
Ayres, T.J., Jonides, J., Reitman, J.S., Egan, J.C. & Howard, D.A. 1979: Differing suffix effects for the same physical
suffix. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory 5:315–321.
Baddeley, A.D. 1966a: Short-term memory for word sequences as a function of acoustic, semantic and formal
similarity. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 18:362–365.
Baddeley, A.D. 1966b: The influence of acoustic and semantic similarity on long-term memory for word
sequences. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 18:302–309.
Baddeley, A.D. 1986: Working Memory. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Baddeley, A.D. & Hitch, G. 1974: Working memory. In: Bower, G.A. (ed.) The Psychology of Learning and
Motivation, vol. 8. New York: Academic Press.
Baddeley, A.D. & Lieberman, K. 1980: Spatial working memory. In: Nickerson, R.S. (ed.) Attention and Performance,
vol. 8. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Bandura, A. & Walters, R.H. 1963: Social Learning and Personality Development. New York: Holt, Rinehart &
Winston.
Block, J. 1961: The Q-sort Method in Personality Assessment and Psychiatric Research. Springfield, IL: Charles C.
Thomas.
Block, J. 1971: Lives Through Time. Berkeley, CA: Bancroft Books.
Boran, M. & Viswanathan, R. 2000: Separating subculture from psychopathology. Psychiatric Services 51:678.
Bower, G.H. 1972: Mental imagery and associative learning. In: Gregg, L.W. (ed.) Cognition in Learning and
Memory. New York: John Wiley.
Bower, G.H. & Springston, F. 1970: Pauses as recoding points in letter series. Journal of Experimental Psychology
83:421–430.
Bibliography 45
Bower, G.H., Clark, M., Winzenz, D. & Lesgold, A. 1969: Hierarchical retrieval schemes in recall of categorical word
lists. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior 8:323–343.
Braine, M.D.S, Reiser, B.J. & Rumain, B. 1984: Some empirical justification for a theory of natural propositional
logic. In The Psychology of Learning and Motivation, vol. 18. New York: Academic Press.
Byrne, R.M.J. & Johnson-Laird, P.N. 1989: Spatial reasoning. Journal of Memory and Language 28:564–575.
Cattell, R.B., Eber, H.W. & Tatsuoka, M.M. 1970: Handbook for the Sixteen Personality Factor Questionnaire.
Champaign, IL: Institute for Personality and Ability Testing.
Conrad, R. 1964: Acoustic confusion in immediate memory. British Journal of Psychology 55:75–84.
Craik, F.I.M. & Watkins, M.J. 1973: The role of rehearsal in short-term memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and
Verbal Behavior 12:599–607.
Crowder, R.G. 1971: The sound of vowels and consonants in immediate memory. Journal of Verbal Learning and
Verbal Behavior 10:587–596.
Daneman, M. & Carpenter, P.A. 1980: Individual differences in working memory and reading. Journal of Verbal
Learning and Verbal Behavior 19:450–466.
Deatherage, B.H. & Evans, T.R. 1969: Binaural masking: backward, forward and simultaneous effects. Journal of
the Acoustical Society of America 46:362–371.
Endler, N.S. 1983: Interactionism: a personality model but not yet a theory. In Page, M.M. (ed.) Nebraska
Symposium on Motivation 1982: Personality – current theory and research. Lincoln, NE: University of Nebraska
Press.
Ericsson, K.A. & Kintsch, W. 1995: Long-term working memory. Psychological Review 102:211–245.
Estes, W.K. 1972: An associative basis for coding and organization in memory. In: Melton, A.W. & Martin, E. (eds)
Coding Processes in Human Memory. Washington, DC: Winston.
Eysenck, H.J. 1944: Types of personality: a factorial study of 700 neurotic soldiers. Journal of Mental Science
90:851–961.
Eysenck, H.J. & Eysenck, S.B.G. 1991: The Eysenck Personality Questionnaire-Revised. Sevenoaks: Hodder &
Stoughton.
Eysenck, M.W. 1982: Attention and Arousal: Cognition and Performance. New York: Springer.
Frase, L.T. 1975: Prose processing. In: Bower, G.H. (ed.) The Psychology of Learning and Motivation, vol. 9. New
York: Academic Press.
Garety, P., Kuipers, E., Fowler, D. et al. 2001: A cognitive model of the positive symptoms of psychosis.
Psychological Medicine 31:189–195.
Gillund, G. & Shiffrin, R.M. 1981: Free recall of complex pictures and abstract words. Journal of Verbal Learning
and Verbal Behavior 20:575–592.
Glenberg, A.M., Smith, S.M. & Green, C. 1977: Type I rehearsal: maintenance and more. Journal of Verbal Learning
and Verbal Behavior 16:339–352.
Glover, J.H. & McCue, P.A. 1977: Electrical aversion therapy with alcoholics: a comparative follow-up study.
British Journal of Psychiatry 130:279–286.
Greenberg, D. & Brom, D. 2001: Nocturnal hallucinations in ultra-orthodox Jewish Israeli men. Psychiatry
64:81–90.
Groeger, J.A. 1997: Memory and Remembering: Everyday Memory in Context. Edinburgh: Longman.
Hansen, G.D. 1979: Enuresis control through fading, escape, and avoidance training. Journal of Applied
Behavioural Analysis 12:303–307.
Hart, R.P. & O’Shanick, G.J. 1993: Forgetting rates for verbal, pictorial, and figural stimuli. Journal of Clinical and
Experimental Neuropsychology 15:245–265.
Hirschberg, N. 1978: A correct treatment of traits. In London, H. (ed.) Personality: A New Look at Metatheories.
New York: Macmillan.
Jacobsen, E. 1932: The electrophysiology of mental activities. American Journal of Psychology 44:677–694.
Johns, L.C., Nazroo, J.Y., Bebbington, P. & Kuipers, E. 2002: Occurrence of hallucinatory experiences in a
community sample and ethnic variations. British Journal of Psychiatry 180:174–178.
46 Basic psychology
Johnson-Laird, P.N. 1993: Human and Machine Thinking. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Kelly, G.A. 1955: The Psychology of Personal Constructs. New York: Norton.
Kyllonen, P.C. & Christal, R.E. 1990: Reasoning ability is (little more than) working-memory capacity. Intelligence
14:389–433.
Maslow, A.H. 1967: Self-actualization and beyond. In Bugental J.F.T (ed.) Challenges of Humanistic Psychology.
New York: McGraw-Hill.
Maslow, A.H. 1970: Motivation and Personality, 2nd edn. Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders.
Mischel, W. 1983: Alterations in the pursuit of predictability and consistency of persons: stable data that yield
unstable interpretations. Journal of Personality 51:578–604.
Morton, J. & Bekerian, D.A. 1986: Three ways of looking at memory. In Sharkey N.E. (ed.) Advances in Cognitive
Science vol. 1. Chichester: Ellis Horwood.
Mu-Ghayeb 1997: A culture-specific response to bereavement in Oman. International Journal of Social Psychiatry
43:144–151.
Newell, A. & Rosenbloom, P.S. 1981: Mechanisms of skill acquisition and the law of practice. In Anderson, J.R.
(ed.) Cognitive Skills and their Acquisition. Hillsdale, NJ: Erlbaum.
Ohaeri, J.U., Adelekan, M.F., Odejide, A.O. & Ikuesan, B.A. 1992: The pattern of isolated sleep paralysis among
Nigerian nursing students. Journal of the National Medical Association 84:67–70.
Paulesu, E., Frith, C.D. & Frackowiak, R.S.J. 1993: The neural correlates of the verbal component of working
memory. Nature 362:342–345.
Pezdek, K. & Chen, H.C. 1982: Developmental differences in the role of detail in picture recognition memory.
Journal of Experimental Child Psychology 33:207–215.
Pfungst, O. 1907. Das Pferd des Herrn von Osten (Der Kluge Hans). Ein Beitrag zur experimentellen Tier- und
Menschen-Psychologie. Leipzig: Johann Ambrosius Barth. [Translated into English by C.L. Rahn, with a
prefatory note by J.R. Angell, as Pfungst, O. 1911: Clever Hans (The Horse of Mr Von Osten): A Contribution to
Experimental Animal and Human Psychology. New York: Henry Holt.]
Plomp, R. 1964: Rate of decay of auditory sensation. Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 36:277–282.
Potter, M.C. 1976: Short-term conceptual memory for pictures. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human
Learning and Memory 2:509–522.
Preston, K.L., Umbricht, A., Wong, C.J. & Epstein, D.H. 2001: Shaping cocaine abstinence by successive
approximation. Journal of Consulting Clinical Psychology 69:643–654.
Robertson, I.H., North, N.T. & Geggie, C. 1992: Spatiomotor cueing in unilateral left neglect: three case studies of
its therapeutic effects. Journal of Neurological and Neurosurgical Psychiatry 55:799–805.
Ryle, G. 1949: The Concept of Mind. London: Hutchinson.
Sachs, J.D.S. 1967: Recognition memory for syntactic and semantic aspects of connected discourse. Perception
and Psychophysics 2:437.
Schachtel, E.G. 1947: On memory and childhood amnesia. Psychiatry 10:1–26.
Schachter, S. & Singer, J.E. 1962: Cognitive, social and physiological determinants of emotional state.
Psychological Review 69:379–399.
Schwab, M.E. 1977: A study of reported hallucinations in a southeastern county. Mental Health and Society
4:344–354.
Searleman, A. & Herrmann, D. 1994: Memory from a Broader Perspective. New York: McGraw-Hill.
Shallice, T. & Warrington, E.K. 1970: Independent functioning of verbal memory stores: a neuropsychological
study. Quarterly Journal of Experimental Psychology 22:261–273.
Skinner, B.F. 1953: Science and Human Behavior. New York: Macmillan.
Skinner, B.F. 1969: Contingencies of Reinforcement. New York: Appleton–Century–Crofts.
Slamecka, N.J. 1960: Retroactive inhibition of connected discourse as a function of practice level. Journal of
Experimental Psychology 59:104–108.
Smith, S.M., Brown, H.O., Thomas, J.E.P & Goodman, L.S. 1947: The lack of cerebral effects of D-tubocurarine.
Anesthesiology 8:1–14.
Bibliography 47
Spear, P.D., Penrod, S.D. & Baker, T.B. 1988: Psychology: Perspectives on Behaviour. New York: John Wiley.
Spielberger, C.D. 1966: The effects of anxiety on complex learning and academic achievement. In Spielberger, C.D.
(ed.) Anxiety: Current Trends in Theory and Research, vol. 1. London: Academic Press.
Thvedt, J.E., Zane, T. & Walls, R.T. 1984: Stimulus functions in response chaining. American Journal of Mental
Deficiency 88:661–667.
Thorndike, E.L. 1911: Animal Intelligence. New York: Macmillan.
Tulving, E. 1972: Episodic and semantic memory. In: Tulving, E. & Donaldson, W. (eds) The Organization of
Memory. New York: Academic Press.
Tulving, E. 1985: Memory and consciousness. Canadian Psychology 26:1–12.
Turvey, M.T. 1973: On peripheral and central processes in vision: inferences from an information-processing
analysis of masking with patterned stimuli. Psychological Review 80:1–52.
Tyrer, P. & Ferguson, B. 2000: Classification of personality disorder. In: Tyrer, P. (ed.) Personality Disorders:
Diagnosis, Management and Course. Oxford: Butterworth–Heinemann.
Tzeng, O.J.L. 1973: Positive recency effects in delayed free recall. Journal of Verbal Learning and Verbal Behavior
12:436–439.
Vaughan, K. & Tarrier, N. 1992: The use of image habituation training with post-traumatic stress disorders. British
Journal of Psychiatry 161:658–664.
Watson, J.B. 1913: Psychology as the behaviorist views it. Psychological Review 20:158–177.
Wiggins, J.S. 1979: A psychological taxonomy of trait-descriptive terms: the interpersonal domain. Journal of
Personality and Social Psychology 37:395–412.
Wolpe, J. 1958: Psychotherapy by Reciprocal Inhibition. Palo Alto: Stanford University Press.
This page intentionally left blank
2
Social psychology
DEFINITION
The definition of an attitude has been given variously as: ‘a mental and neural state of readiness,
organized through experience, exerting a directive or dynamic influence upon the individual’s
response to all objects and situations with which it is related’ (Allport); and ‘an enduring
organization of motivational, emotional, perceptual, and cognitive processes with respect to some
aspect of the individual’s world’ (Krech & Crutchfield). They are mutually consistent and internally
consistent.
COMPONENTS
Attitudes are based on beliefs, a tendency to behave in an observable way, and also have affective
components which are the most resistant to change. A change in one of these three components
leads to changes in the other two.
When predicting behaviour, situational variables must be taken into account. Otherwise
measured attitudes are poor predictors of behaviour.
Measurement of attitude
Thurstone scale
This is a dichotomous scale indicating agreement/disagreement with presented and previously
ranked statements. Disadvantages of this scale include:
∑ Different response patterns may result in the same mean score.
∑ The set-up is unwieldy.
∑ The ranking may be biased.
50 Social psychology
Likert scale
This is a five-point scale indicating level of agreement with presented statements. Its advantages
include the fact that it has increased sensitivity compared with the dichotomous Thurstone scale;
and that it is more easily administered. A disadvantage is that different response patterns may result
in the same mean score.
Attitude change
A change in one of the three components of attitude leads to changes in the other two.
The origin of attitudes can be by means of the processes of learning: classical conditioning,
operant conditioning, and observational learning. Superimposed on these are cognitive processes
such as appraisal and modification in the light of new information.
Attitudes can be modified by either central pathways, entailing the consideration of new
information, or by peripheral pathways involving the presentation of cues. Advertising uses both
pathways.
The balance theory of Heider holds that each individual attempts to organize his or her attitudes,
perceptions and beliefs so that they are in harmony or balance with each other.
Persuasive communication
The factors to consider are those concerned with the communicator, the recipient and the message
being communicated.
Communicator
Characteristics of persuasive communicators include:
∑ attractiveness
∑ audience identification with the communicator
∑ credibility
∑ expertise
∑ genuine motivation
∑ being an opinion leader
∑ non-verbal communication
∑ views of reference groups.
Recipient
High self-esteem and intelligence of the recipient increase the likelihood that complex
communications will be persuasive.
Self-psychology 51
Message
Key aspects relating to the message and attitude change include:
∑ Message repetition can be a persuasive influence leading to attitude change.
∑ Explicit messages are more persuasive for the less intelligent and implicit messages for the more
intelligent recipient.
∑ Interactive personal discussions are more persuasive than mass media communication.
∑ One-sided communications are more persuasive for those who are less intelligent and/or already
favourably disposed to the message.
∑ Two-sided presentations are more effective with intelligent and neutral recipients.
∑ A low-anxiety recipient is more influenced by a high-fear message, and vice versa.
SELF-PSYCHOLOGY
Self-concept
This is a set of attitudes that the individual holds about himself/herself. It does not necessarily
correspond to reality. Self-theory was developed by Rogers.
Self-esteem
This is one’s own evaluation of self-worth and feeling accepted by others. Those lacking in self-
esteem have feelings of worthlessness, alienation and lack of acceptance by others, whereas those
with high self-esteem are more socially active, less prejudiced, more risk-taking and warmer in
social relationships. It is learned and so may change with experience.
Self-esteem may be raised by identification with a group. For example, deaf individuals who
identify with other deaf people have a higher self-esteem, on average, than those who do not. In
turn, the raised self-esteem can help to compensate for problems relating to personal identity.
Self-image
Self-image is a set of beliefs held about oneself, based on achievements and social interactions,
which influences personal meaning and behaviour.
Self-perception theory
An individual infers what his or her attitude must be by observation of his or her own behaviour, in
a similar way to how other people infer the individual’s behaviour.
52 Social psychology
Self-perception theory provides a better explanation than cognitive dissonance theory for
behaviour that lies within the general range of behaviours acceptable to the individual.
INTERPERSONAL ISSUES
Interpersonal attraction
In general, humans seek the company of others to whom they are attracted. In difficult situations
this may allow assessment by social comparisons, taking note of the opinions of others (social
comparison theory – Festinger). An alternative theory is that seeking the company of others leads to
arousal reduction (Epley).
Theories of interpersonal attraction include:
∑ Reinforcement theory. Reciprocal reinforcement of the attractions occurs with rewards in both
directions (Newcomb). Conversely, punishments diminish the probability of interpersonal
attraction.
∑ Social exchange theory. People prefer relationships that appear to offer an optimum cost–benefit
ratio (Homans).
∑ Equity theory. The preferred relationships are those in which each feels that the cost–benefit
ratio of the relationship for each person is approximately equal (Hatfield & Traupmann).
∑ Proxemics. This relates to interpersonal space/body buffer zone.
Factors predisposing to interpersonal attraction include proximity, familiarity, similarity of
interests and values, exposure, perceived competence, reciprocal liking and self-disclosure, and
physical attractiveness. Similarity is more important than complementarity, although the latter
increases in importance with time.
According to the matching hypothesis, pairing occurs such that individuals seek others who have
a similar level of physical attractiveness.
Attribution theory
Attribution theory (Heider) deals with the rules people use to infer the causes of observed
behaviour.
∑ Internal or dispositional attribution. This is the inference that the person is primarily responsible
for his or her behaviour.
∑ External or situational attribution. This is the inference that the cause of a behaviour is external
to the person.
∑ Primary (fundamental) attribution error. When inferring the cause of other people’s behaviour
there is a bias towards dispositional rather than situational attribution.
Theory of mind
In primate research, theory of mind refers to the ability of primates to mentalize their fellows. In
humans, the (‘cold’) theory of mind refers to the ability of most normal people to comprehend the
thought processes of others (such as their attention, feelings, beliefs, false beliefs and knowledge).
Leadership, social influence, power and obedience 53
Research into children tends to suggest that, at the age of 3 years, normal human children do not
acknowledge false belief as they have difficulty in differentiating belief from world. Formulating a
theory of mind appears not to be inevitable, but relies on cognitive changes that occur at around the
age of 4 years. It has been suggested that a failure to acquire a theory of mind is associated with
disorders such as autism.
A ‘hot’ theory of mind entails constructing the meaningful intentions and evaluative attitudes
(such as fear, surprise and pleasure) of others. The latter can be inferred from facial expressions.
Leadership
Lewin et al. distinguished between the following leadership styles:
∑ autocratic: abandon task in leader’s absence; good for situations of urgency
∑ democratic: yields greater productivity unless a highly original product is required
∑ laissez-faire: appropriate for creative, open-ended, person-oriented tasks.
Social facilitation
This refers to the way in which tasks and responses are facilitated when carried out in the presence
of others (Allport; Harlow). For it to occur, the others do not necessarily have to be engaging in the
same task. Facilitation also occurs if the others are simply observing; this has been called the
audience effect (Dashiell).
Social power
French and Raven described the following five types of social power:
∑ authority: power derived from role
∑ reward: power derived from ability to allocate resources
∑ coercive: power to punish
∑ referent: charismatic and liked by others
∑ expert: power derives from skill, knowledge and experience.
Conformity
Two types of conformity to the actions and opinions of others have been identified (Duetsch &
Gerard):
∑ Informational social influence. An individual conforms to the consensual opinion and behaviour
of the group both publicly and in his/her own thoughts (evident with ambiguous stimuli).
∑ Normative social influence. An individual publicly conforms to the consensual opinion and
behaviour of the group but has a different view in his/her own mind. The individual conforms
to the group under social pressure to avoid social rejection.
54 Social psychology
Self-reliant, intelligent, expressive, socially effective individuals are least vulnerable to group
pressure.
Obedience to authority
Milgram found that most subjects would obey an experimenter’s orders to administer what they
believed to be increasingly powerful electrical shocks to others, right up to the maximum voltage
available. Factors that increased the rate of obedience included:
∑ the presence of the experimenter
∑ the belief that the prior agreement was binding on the subject
∑ increasing distance from the apparently suffering person.
INTER-GROUP BEHAVIOUR
Stereotypes
A stereotype is an over-generalized inference about a person or group of people in which they are all
assumed to possess particular traits or characteristics.
The use of schemata (working stereotypes) is inevitable until further experience either refines or
discredits them. Many stereotypes are benign but may be resistant to change. However, stereotypes
can become self-perpetuating and self-fulfilling.
Stigma
Definition and example
Stigma is an attribute of an individual which marks him or her as being unacceptable, inferior or
dangerous and ‘spoils’ identity. For example, psychiatric disorders are highly stigmatized in societies
which value rationality.
∑ Enacted stigma is the experience of discrimination of an individual who bears a stigma.
∑ Felt stigma is the fear of discrimination of an individual who bears a stigma.
Development
Stigma first appears during the psychoanalytic stage of latency, approximately corresponding with
Erikson’s stage of industry versus inferiority, during which children develop a strong awareness of
the ways in which they are similar to and differ from others.
Prejudice
Definition and example
Prejudice is a preconceived set of beliefs held about others who are ‘pre-judged’ on this basis; the
negative meaning of the term is the one usually used. It is not amenable to discussion and is resistant
to change. Prejudiced individuals may behave in ways that create stereotyped behaviour which
sustains their prejudice.
The phenomenon of aggression 55
For example, racism or racial prejudice is the dogmatic belief that one ‘race’ is superior to
another one, and that there exist identifiable ‘racial characteristics’ that influence cognition,
achievement, behaviour, etc.
Discrimination is the enactment of prejudice. (In the case of racism, the enactment is also termed
‘racialism’.)
Reducing prejudice
Cook showed that the following conditions need to be satisfied in order to reduce prejudice:
∑ equal status
∑ the potential for personal acquaintance
∑ exposure to non-stereotypical individuals
∑ a social environment favouring equality
∑ co-operative effort.
Explanations of aggression
Psychoanalytic
Aggression is viewed as a basic instinct.
Operant conditioning
Positive reinforcers can include victim suffering and material gains. The consequences of aggression
play an important role in shaping future behaviour.
Ethology
Some ethologists believe that humans and animals are innately aggressive. Animal studies show that
certain behaviours inhibit aggression:
∑ maintaining a distance
∑ evoking a social response incompatible with aggression
∑ familiarity.
56 Social psychology
Frustration–aggression hypothesis
This proposes that preventing a person reaching his or her goal induces an aggressive drive resulting
in behaviour intended to harm the one causing the frustration. Expressing this aggression reduces
the aggressive drive.
Arousal
Emotional arousal can increase aggression.
Influence of television
It is known that children imitate observed aggression. Some studies suggest a relationship between
exposure to violence on television and aggressive behaviour in boys, but not in girls. It may be that
this is because aggressive behaviour in boys, but not in girls, is socially reinforced.
Ways in which filmed violence may increase aggressive behaviour include:
∑ teaching aggressive styles of conduct
∑ increasing arousal
∑ desensitizing people to violence
∑ reducing restraint on aggressive behaviour
∑ distorting views about conflict resolution.
The concept of the type of interpersonal co-operation known as altruism refers to an act (or acts)
which are motivated by the desire to benefit another person (or persons) rather than oneself.
Altruism may be considered to be a higher defence mechanism is which the individual deals with
emotional conflict or internal or external stressors by dedication to meeting the needs of others.
Unlike the self-sacrifice sometimes characteristic of reaction formation, the individual receives
gratification either vicariously or from the response of others (DSM-IV-TR).
Altruism can also be explained on the basis of social exchange theory (see above).
It has been suggested that failure to exclude an ulterior motive means that, strictly speaking,
altruism cannot be said to have occurred under these circumstances. Indeed, there may be personal
rewards of a private nature that occur as a result of acting in this way; for instance, a person may feel
virtuous.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Atkinson, R.L., Atkinson, R.C. & Smith, E.E. 1990: Introduction to Psychology, 10th edn. San Diego: Harcourt Brace
Jovanovich.
Bandura, A. & Walters, R.H. 1963: Social Learning and Personality Development. New York: Holt, Rinehart &
Winston.
Spear, P.D., Penrod, S.D. & Baker, T.B. 1988: Psychology: Perspectives on Behaviour. New York: John Wiley.
3
Neuropsychological processes
MEMORY
SENSORY MEMORY
The anatomical correlate of iconic memory is probably visual association cortex, while that of
echoic memory is probably auditory association cortex.
SHORT-TERM MEMORY
The anatomical correlate of auditory verbal short-term memory is the left (dominant) parietal lobe,
while that of visual verbal short-term memory is possibly the left temporo-occipital area. That of
non-verbal short-term memory is possibly the right (non-dominant) temporal lobe.
EXPLICIT MEMORY
This requires a deliberate act of recollection and can be reported verbally. It includes declarative
memory and episodic memory, which are probably stored separately, since it is possible to lose one
type of memory while retaining the other. Declarative memory involves knowledge of facts whereas
episodic memory involves memory of autobiographical events. Explicit memory involves the medial
temporal lobes, particularly the hippocampus, entorhinal cortex, subiculum and parahippocampal
cortex. Damage to these structures results in an inability to store new memory; they have been
termed bottleneck structures. Memory probably passes from medial temporal lobe structures after a
few weeks/months to longer-term storage in the cortex.
The amygdala may be involved in the emotional charging of information. It may also be a
bottleneck structure.
IMPLICIT MEMORY
This is recalled automatically without effort and is learned slowly through repetition. It is not
readily amenable to verbal reporting. It comprises procedural knowledge, that is, knowing how. Its
storage requires functioning of the cerebellum, amygdala and specific sensory and motor systems
58 Neuropsychological processes
used in the learned task. For example, the basal ganglia are involved in learning motor skills.
Classical and operant learning involve implicit memory.
LANGUAGE
Cerebal dominance
Cerebral dominance for language is as follows:
∑ In 99% of right-handers the left cerebral hemisphere is dominant.
∑ In 60% of left-handers the left cerebral hemisphere is dominant.
In early life there is plasticity for cerebral dominance for language before the functions are
established.
Wernicke’s area
This is the sensory speech and language area, occupying the posterior part of the auditory
association cortex (BA 42 and 22) of the superior temporal gyrus. It is usually larger in the left
hemisphere. It is involved in making sense of speech and language.
Angular gyrus
This part of the brain (BA 39) has abundant connections with the somatosensory, visual, and
auditory association cortices. Lesions here produce inability to read or write.
Pathways
∑ Understanding spoken language (hearing): spoken word Æauditory cortex Æ auditory
association cortex Æ Wernicke’s area Æ hear and comprehend speech.
∑ Understanding written language (reading): written word Æ visual cortex Æ visual association
cortex Æ angular gyrus Æ Wernicke’s area Æ read and comprehend.
∑ Speaking: thought/cognition Æ Wernicke’s area Æ Broca’s area Æ motor speech areas Æ
speech.
∑ Writing: thought/cognition Æ Wernicke’s area Æ angular gyrus Æ motor areas Æ write.
Dysphasias
Damage to brain areas involved with speech and language results in dysphasia; the type of dysphasia
is determined by the areas of the brain involved.
Perception 59
Receptive dysphasia
Damage to Wernicke’s area disrupts the ability to comprehend language, either written or spoken.
In addition to loss of comprehension, the person also is unaware that his or her dysphasic speech is
difficult for others to follow. Speech is normal in rhythm and intonation (because Broca’s area is
intact), but the content is abnormal. Words used have lost their meaning; empty words (e.g. ‘thing’,
‘it’) and paraphrasias are used liberally. Thus damage to Wernicke’s area results in a fluent receptive
dysphasia.
Expressive dysphasia
Damage to Broca’s area results in loss of rhythm, intonation and grammatical aspects of speech.
Comprehension is normal (because Wernicke’s area is intact) and the person is aware that his or her
speech is difficult for others to follow, resulting in distress and frustration. Speech is slow and
hesitant, often lacking connecting words. Speech sounds agrammatical and articulation may be
crude, probably because of the close proximity of Broca’s area to motor areas. Thus damage to
Broca’s area results in dysfluent expressive dysphasia.
Conduction dysphasia
Damage to the arcuate fasciculus results in a conduction dysphasia in which the person cannot
repeat what is said by another. Comprehension and verbal fluency remain intact.
Global dysphasia
This results from global left hemispheric dysfunction, and shows a combination of all the above.
PERCEPTION
Perception relates to the means by which the brain makes representations of the external
environment.
Agnosia is the inability to interpret and recognize the significance of sensory information, which
does not result from impairment of the sensory pathways, mental deterioration, disorders of
consciousness and attention, or, in the case of an object, a lack of familiarity with the object.
Visual perception
∑ Shape, colour and spatial orientation are recognized in the occipital lobes. A lesion at this level
results in pseudoagnosia.
∑ Visuospatial elements are drawn together into complete percepts (objects seen as a whole) in the
right parietal lobe. Meaning is not yet attributed to the objects. A lesion at this level results in
apperceptive agnosia.
∑ The meaning of objects is then accessed from the left parietal lobe (which itself accesses meaning
from semantic memory) and processed in parieto-occipital areas. A lesion at this level results in
associative agnosia.
OTHER AGNOSIAS
∑ Prosopagnosia is an inability to recognize faces. In advanced Alzheimer’s disease a person may
misidentify his or her own mirrored reflection – the mirror sign.
60 Neuropsychological processes
∑ In agnosia for colours, the person is unable correctly to name colours, although colour sense is
still present.
∑ In simultanagnosia, the person is unable to recognize the overall meaning of a picture whereas its
individual details are understood.
∑ Agraphognosia or agraphaesthesia is tested by asking the person to identify, with closed eyes,
numbers or letters traced on his or her palm; this disorder is present if the person is unable to
identify such writing.
∑ In anosognosia, there is a lack of awareness of disease, particularly of hemiplegia (most often
following a right parietal lesion).
∑ Autotopagnosia is the inability to name, recognize or point on command to parts of the body.
∑ In astereognosia, objects cannot be recognized by palpation.
∑ In finger agnosia, the person is unable to recognize individual fingers.
∑ Topographical disorientation can be tested using a locomotor map-reading task in which the
person is asked to trace out a given route by foot.
∑ In hemisomatognosis or hemidepersonalization, the person feels that a limb (which in fact is
present) is missing.
Apraxias
Apraxia is an inability to perform purposive volitional acts, which does not result from paresis,
incoordination, sensory loss or involuntary movements.
∑ Constructional apraxia is closely associated with visuospatial agnosia. There is an inability to
construct a figure.
∑ In dressing apraxia, there is an inability to dress.
∑ In ideomotor apraxia, there is an inability to carry out progressively more difficult tasks.
∑ In ideational apraxia, there is an inability to carry out a coordinated sequence of actions.
PREFRONTAL CORTEX
This is probably involved in the following functions:
∑ problem-solving
∑ perceptual judgement
∑ memory
∑ programming and planning of sequences of behaviour
∑ verbal regulation
∑ level of response emission
∑ adaptability of response pattern
∑ tertiary level of motor control.
BROCA’S AREA
This is involved in expressive speech.
ORBITAL CORTEX
This is probably involved in the following functions:
∑ personality
∑ social behaviour.
GERSTMANN’S SYNDROME
This is caused by dominant parietal lobe lesions and consists of:
∑ dyscalculia
∑ agraphia
∑ finger agnosia
∑ right–disorientation.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Smith, E.E., Nolen-Hoeksema, S., Fredrickson, B.L. et al. (eds) 2003: Atkinson and Hilgard’s Introduction to
Psychology (with Lecture Notes and InfoTrac), 14th edn. Florence, KT: Wadsworth.
This page intentionally left blank
4
Human growth and development
CONCEPTUALIZING DEVELOPMENT
BASIC CONCEPTS
Human development involves an interaction between nature and nurture.
Stage theories propose that development occurs in a progressive sequence reflecting maturation.
Examples include: Piaget’s cognitive stages; Freud’s psychosexual stages; and Kohlberg’s stage
theory. Maturation refers to the orderly changes in behaviour that result from biological
development and whose timing and form are relatively independent of external experience.
Maturational tasks are influenced by: biological growth; the drive for independence; and other
people’s general expectations.
GENE–ENVIRONMENT INTERACTIONS
These interactions determine all psychological characteristics, such as intelligence. Genetic factors
determine the inherited potential, while environmental factors determine the degree to which this
potential is fulfilled.
With respect to intelligence, while it is generally agreed that there is a genetic component to
intelligence, there is disagreement about the degree of environmental influence on it. The
correlation coefficient for intelligence quotient (IQ) between monozygotic twins is 0.86 compared
with 0.60 for dizygotic twins. Using factor analysis, Spearman identified a general factor, g, and a
specific factor, s, of intelligence; it was proposed that the level of g was associated with how
intelligent the individual was.
HISTORICAL MODELS
The historical developmental models of Freud and Erikson are described in Chapter 33. Social-
learning models lay emphasis on the way in which environmental influences affect subsequent
behaviour. The most influential theory of cognitive development is that of Piaget (see below).
64 Human growth and development
Attachment theory
This comes from the work of Bowlby. Attachment refers to the tendency of infants to remain close
to certain people (attachment figures) with whom they share strong positive emotional ties.
Monotropic attachment is when the attachment is to one individual, usually the mother. Polytropic
attachment is less common. Attachment usually takes place from infant to mother. In contrast,
neonatal–maternal bonding takes place in the opposite direction. Both processes can start
immediately after birth.
Some behaviourists consider attachment to result from the mother acting as a conditioned rein-
forcer. This theory was challenged by Harlow who, using cuddly and wire artificial surrogate mothers
and infant rhesus monkeys, found that attachment is a function of the requirement to be in contact
with a soft object (contact comfort), which provides security. Other studies have found that warm
or rocking artificial surrogate mothers are preferred to colder or still surrogates, respectively.
Lorenz considered attachment to result from imprinting whereby geese, during a critical period
soon after hatching, persistently follow the first nearby moving object encountered. There is no
evidence that imprinting occurs in primates.
Bowlby considered infant attachment to take place in the context of a warm, intimate and
continuous relationship with the care-giver in which there is reciprocal satisfaction. The attachment
process takes an average of 6 months to become fully established. Bonding is stronger if there is
tactile contact as soon as possible after birth. The mother’s attachment behaviour is reinforced by
infant smiling, movement and crying. Attachment behaviours are the signs of distress shown by the
child when separated from his or her attachment figure, and include:
∑ crying when the care-giver (usually mother) leaves the room
∑ attempting to follow her
∑ clinging hard when distressed
∑ hugging her
∑ being more playful and talkative in her company
∑ using her as a secure base from which exploration can take place.
These start to occur at about the age of 6 months and decrease visibly by 3 years. Prior to this age
separation is tolerated without distress.
Attachment abnormalities
INSECURE ATTACHMENT
There is chronic clinginess and ambivalence towards the mother. Clinically this may be relevant, as
it may be a precursor to:
∑ childhood emotional disorders (including school refusal)
∑ disorders (such as agoraphobia) starting in adolescence and adulthood.
AVOIDANT ATTACHMENT
A distance is kept from the mother, who may sometimes be ignored. Clinically, avoidant attachment
caused by rejection by the mother may be relevant as it may be a precursor to:
∑ poor social functioning in later life (including aggression).
Family relationships and parenting practice 65
SEPARATION ANXIETY
This is the fear an infant shows of being separated from his or her care-giver. Holding a comfort
object or transitional object (Winnicott) may help with separation.
The rate of disappearance of separation anxiety varies with the child’s:
∑ experiences of previous separations (real or threatened)
∑ handling by mother
∑ perception of whether mother will die or depart
∑ temperament.
Stranger anxiety
This refers to a fear of strangers shown by infants usually between the ages of 8 months and 1 year.
It is not necessarily part of attachment behaviour and may occur independently of separation
anxiety.
Maternal deprivation
Following a failure to form adequate attachments, for example because of prolonged maternal
separation or rejecting parents, the effects of maternal deprivation may include:
∑ developmental language delay
∑ indiscriminate affection-seeking
∑ shallow relationships
∑ enuresis
∑ aggression
∑ lack of empathy
∑ social disinhibition
∑ attention-seeking and overactivity in school
∑ poor growth – deprivation dwarfism.
Child-rearing practice
Table 4.1 (after Baumrind, 1967) shows how the parents of three groups of children have been found
to score on the four dimensions of:
66 Human growth and development
Table 4.1 The way in which parents of three groups of children score on the dimensions of control, maturity
demands, communication and nurturance
Family structure
In the UK and US, around 25% of children are not living with both biological parents by the age of
16 years. If orthodox families are defined as those nuclear families in which there are two parents
with a small number of children, then non-orthodox family structures may or may not be relevant
so far as healthy psychosocial development of the child is concerned (see Table 4.2).
Single parent
≠ Behavioural and emotional problems (particularly if no other support)
Extended family
Not harmful
Two lesbian parents
Not harmful
Large family size
≠ Behavioural and educational problems
Ø Intelligence
∑ discord
∑ overprotection of children by parents
∑ rejection of the child(ren)
∑ enmeshment, whereby parents may be over-involved in their children’s feelings and lives
∑ disengagement, whereby parents may be under-involved in their children’s feelings and lives
∑ triangulation, in which exclusive alliances are formed within the family; e.g. father/daughter
(although this may for example be helpful in preventing father from leaving home)
∑ communication difficulties owing to ambiguous or incongruous communications
∑ myths created within the family.
Marital conflicts may cause the parents to need to have a child with a problem who can act as a
scapegoat (until he or she leaves home).
Impact of bereavement
The death of a parent leads to initial bereavement reactions, which may include prolonged sadness,
crying and irritability during childhood. In addition:
∑ Young children may exhibit functional enuresis and/or temper tantrums.
∑ Older children (especially girls) my have sleep disturbance and/or clear-cut depressive reactions.
∑ School performance may be impaired (possibly temporarily).
All of these girls had experienced prolonged sexual abuse (>2 years) involving physical force which
was perpetrated by a parent.
Recognized sequelae of sexual abuse include:
∑ anxiety states and anxiety-related symptoms (e.g. sleep disturbance, nightmares, psychosomatic
complaints, and hypervigilance), re-enactments of the victimization, and post-traumatic stress
disorder (Goodwin, 1985; Green, 1985)
∑ depression (Gaensbauer & Sands, 1979; Sgroi, 1982)
∑ dissociation (Kluft, 1985; Putnam, 1985)
∑ paranoid reactions and mistrust (Green, 1978; Herman, 1981)
∑ excessive reliance on primitive defence mechanisms (e.g. denial, projection, dissociation, and
splitting) (Green, 1978)
∑ borderline personality disorder (especially in females) (Herman et al., 1989)
∑ inability to control sexual impulses (precocious sexual play with high sexual arousal)
(Cosentino et al., 1995; Friedrich & Reams, 1987; Yates, 1982)
∑ weakened gender identity (a tendency to reject their maleness or femaleness) (Aiosa-Karpas et
al., 1991)
∑ increased incidence of homosexuality (Finkelhor, 1984)
∑ increased incidence of molesting children (the cycle of abuse may continue – there is a high
incidence of sexual abuse in the backgrounds of male and female child molesters) (McCarty,
1986; Seghorn et al., 1987)
∑ drug and alcohol abuse (Herman, 1981)
∑ eating disorders (Oppenheimer et al., 1985).
TEMPERAMENT
∑ Environmental influences affect how the biological bases of temperament are expressed. For
example, Gunnar (1994) showed how sensitive, responsive care-givers could enhance otherwise
highly inhibited preschoolers’ likelihood of approaching novel stimuli.
∑ Concepts of temperament can be useful in helping people solve problems. When the processes
of linkage between temperament and the evolution of character and personality are understood
better, this should assist prevention and treatment.
The stability of temperament and its relationship to the evolution of character and personality
have been demonstrated in a number of studies. Characteristics of temperament in infants and
preschool-age children predict adjustment in middle childhood and adolescence. For example,
Caspi and Silva (1995) showed how temperamental qualities at the of age 3 years predict personality
traits in young adulthood. In an unselected sample of over 800 subjects, the following five
temperament groups were identified when the children were aged 3 years:
Under-controlled
Inhibited
Confident
Reserved
Well-adjusted.
These groups were reassessed at the age of 18 years. The findings in the young adults were as follows:
∑ Under-controlled children scored high on measures of impulsivity, danger seeking, aggression,
and interpersonal alienation (as young adults).
∑ Inhibited children scored low on measures of impulsivity, danger seeking, aggression, and social
potency.
∑ Confident children scored high on impulsivity.
∑ Reserved children scored low on social potency.
∑ Well-adjusted children continued to exhibit normative behaviours.
Piaget believed that infantile and childhood intellectual development involve interactions with the
outside world (for example through play). These lead to certain outcomes:
∑ New cognitive structures (schemes) are constructed incorporating new information.
∑ In the presence of suitable existing schemes:
∑ assimilation: new information is incorporated into appropriate existing schemes
∑ accommodation: there is modification of existing scheme(s).
Piaget identified the following four stages of cognitive development:
Sensorimotor
Preoperational
Concrete operational
Formal operational.
SENSORIMOTOR STAGE
This is the first stage and occurs from birth to 2 years of age. Circular reactions are repeated
voluntary motor activities, for example shaking a toy, occurring from around 2 months. They are
classified as follows:
Language development 71
∑ primary circular reactions – from 2 to 5 months (approximately), when they have no apparent
purpose
∑ secondary circular reactions – from 5 to 9 months (approximately), when experimentation and
purposeful behaviour are gradually manifested
∑ tertiary circular reactions – from 1 year to 18 months (approximately), which include the
creation of original behaviour patterns and the purposeful quest for novel experiences.
During this stage the infant comes to distinguish himself/herself from the environment. Thought
processes exhibit egocentrism, in which the infant believes that everything happens in relation to
him/her. Until around 6 months the infant believes that an object hidden from view no longer exists.
Object permanence is fully developed after around the age of 18 months.
PREOPERATIONAL STAGE
This is the second stage and occurs from age 2 to 7 years. During this stage the child learns to use the
symbols of language. Certain thought processes are exhibited during this stage.
∑ Animism. Life, thoughts and feelings are attributed to all objects, including inanimate ones.
∑ Artificialism. Natural events are attributed to the actions of people.
∑ Authoritarian morality. It is believed that wrongdoing, including breaking the rules of a game,
should be punished according to the degree of the damage caused, whether accidental or not,
rather than according to motive; negative events are perceived as punishments.
∑ Creationism. A teleological approach is taken in which, for example, stars and the moon exist in
order to provide light at night.
∑ Egocentrism. This is as in the sensorimotor stage.
∑ Finalism. All things have a purpose.
∑ Precausal reasoning. This is based on internal schemes rather than the results of observation; so
that, for example, the same volume of liquid poured from one container to another with a
different height and diameter may be considered to have changed volume.
∑ Syncretism. Everything is believed to be connected with everything else.
LANGUAGE DEVELOPMENT
Language can be defined as the sum of the skills required to communicate verbally (Graham,
1991).
72 Human growth and development
∑ In the first hours postnatally, the baby learns to distinguish his/her mother’s voice.
∑ By 3 to 4 months babbling occurs.
∑ By 8 months repetitive babbling occurs.
∑ By 12 months the baby has usually acquired the equivalent designations ‘mama’, ‘dada’ (no
matter what language the parent speaks) and one additional word.
∑ By 18 months a 20- to 50-word vocabulary is expressed in single-word utterances.
∑ By 2 years, two- or three-word utterances can be strung together with some understanding of
grammar. These are telegraphic utterances omitting grammatical morphemes (small units of
meaning signifying the plural, for example).
∑ At an average age of 3 years, the child can usually understand a request containing three parts.
∑ Bilingual home. Being brought up in a home in which two languages are spoken is not a
disadvantage unless there is another cause of slowed language development.
∑ Family size. Larger family size is associated with slower speech development.
∑ Pregnancy. Intrauterine growth retardation is associated with slower language development.
Prolonged second-stage labour is associated with slower language development.
∑ Sex. Early language development in girls is slightly greater than in boys.
∑ Social class. Being middle-class is associated with relatively faster language development.
∑ Stimulation. Although the capacity for language and grammar may be built-in, speech and
language are not achieved in the usual manner if children are deaf or are not spoken to.
∑ Twins. Being a twin is associated with slower speech development.
MORAL DEVELOPMENT
∑ Stage 4: Authority orientation. Laws and social rules are upheld in order to avoid the censure of
authorities and because of guilt about not doing one’s duty.
Learned response
Fear/anxiety may become associated with particular situations by means of learning.
Lack of control
Fear/anxiety may occur when an individual feels helpless in a situation beyond his or her control.
SEXUAL DEVELOPMENT
Sex determination
Sex determination is primarily as a result of the sex chromosomes (XX female and XY male). Gonad
formation is first indicated in the embryo by the appearance of an area of thickened epithelium on
the medial aspect of the mesonephric ridge during week five. Various factors affect subsequent
differentiation of the genital organs into male ones (epididymis, ductus (vas) deferens, ejaculatory
ducts, penis, and scrotum) or female ones (fallopian tubes, uterus, clitoris, and vagina) during
ontogeny.
Y chromosome
In mammals, testis determination is under the control of the testis-determining factor borne by the
Y chromosome. SRY, a gene cloned from the sex-determining region of the human Y chromosome,
has been equated with the testis-determining factor in humans.
Endocrine actions
Androgens and oestrogens can modify the process of sexual differentiation, while in twin pregnancy
with fetuses of opposite sex and anastomosed placental circulations, the genetically male fetus may
have a masculinizing effect on the genetically female fetus. A genetically female fetus may also be
masculinized (and be born with either ambiguous or male genitalia) by fetal androgen from another
source (e.g. in congenital adrenal (suprarenal) hyperplasia). Similarly, a genetically male fetus with
a Y chromosome and testes may develop female genitalia in the absence of fetal androgen (e.g. in
enzyme deficiency) or if androgen receptors are defective (e.g. in testicular feminization).
Sexual development 75
Changes at puberty
Puberty consists of a series of physical and physiological changes which convert a child into an adult
who is capable of sexual reproduction.
Physical changes
These include:
∑ growth spurt
∑ change in body proportions
∑ development of sexual organs
∑ development of secondary sexual characteristics.
Tanner described a standardized system for recording breast, pubic hair and genital maturation:
∑ Onset in girls. In 95%, onset occurs at between 9 and 13 years. The first sign is:
∑ breast formation – in 80%
∑ pubic hair growth – in 20%
∑ In Western countries menarche occurs at a mean age of 13.5 years.
∑ Onset in boys. In 95%, onset occurs at between 9.5 and 13.5 years. The first sign is usually
testicular and scrotal enlargement, followed by growth of the penis and pubic hair. On average,
the first ejaculation occurs at around 13 years.
Physiological changes
A raising of the threshold for gonadohypothalamic negative feedback precedes the onset of puberty.
An increase in suprarenal androgen release (adrenarche) usually begins between the ages of 6 and 8
years; these hormones lead to the growth of sexual hair and skeletal maturation.
GENDER IDENTITY
This is an individual’s perception and self-awareness with respect to gender. It is usually established
by the age of 3 or 4 years and usually remains firmly established thereafter.
GENDER/SEX TYPING
This is the process by which individuals acquire a sense of gender and gender-related cultural traits
appropriate to the society and age into which they are born. It usually begins at an early age with
male and female infants being treated differently, for example with respect to the choice of their
clothing.
GENDER ROLE
This is the type of behaviour that an individual engages in that identifies him or her as being male
or female, for example with respect to the type of clothes worn and the use of cosmetics.
SEXUAL BEHAVIOUR
Sexual drive
This is the need to achieve sexual pleasure through genital stimulation. It exists from birth to middle
childhood and increases again during adolescence as a result of increased androgen secretion.
76 Human growth and development
Childhood sexuality
This may manifest itself in normal children as:
∑ sex play in infancy
∑ erections in boys
∑ vaginal lubrication in girls
∑ masturbation – which may involve orgasm
∑ exploratory encounters with other children.
Masturbation
This is the predominant mode of sexual expression for most adolescent males and probably fewer
adolescent females.
Sexual orientation
This is the erotic attraction that an individual feels. Its shaping is a developmental process associated
with certain patterns of childhood experience and activity. Superimposed on this, there are
arguments for and against the theory that human sexual orientation is biologically determined.
The term ‘homosexuality’ is associated with the following behavioural dimensions:
∑ sexual fantasy
∑ sexual activity
∑ sense of identity
∑ social role.
The first of these is the most important dimension in assessing homosexual orientation. If present,
it does not necessarily imply sexual activity with others, as in individuals who are homosexual in
orientation and celibate.
It should be noted that there is no non-human mammalian species in which predominant or
exclusive homosexuality occurs in the way it does in humans.
Neuroanatomical
LeVay (1991) reported histological differences in the interstitial nuclei of the anterior hypothalamus
between homosexual and heterosexual men, suggesting that sexual orientation may be mediated by
Sexual development 77
the central nervous system. The anterior hypothalamus of the brain is known to participate in the
regulation of male-typical sexual behaviour. The volumes of four cell groups in this region
(interstitial nuclei of the anterior hypothalamus (INAH) 1, 2, 3, and 4) were measured in
postmortem tissue from three subject groups: women, men who were presumed to be heterosexual,
and homosexual men. No differences were found between the groups in the volumes of INAH 1, 2,
or 4. As had been previously reported, INAH 3 was found to be more than twice as large in the
heterosexual men as in the women. It was also, however, more than twice as large in the heterosexual
men as in the homosexual men. This finding indicates that INAH is dimorphic with sexual
orientation, at least in men.
A second neuroanatomical difference was reported by Allen and Gorski (1992). On the basis of
the examination of 90 postmortem brains, it was found that the midsagittal plane of the anterior
commissure in homosexual men was 18% larger than in heterosexual women and 34% larger than
in heterosexual men. This finding of a difference in a structure not known to be related to
reproductive functions supports the hypothesis that factors operating early in development
differentiate sexually dimorphic structures and functions of the brain in a global fashion.
Genetic
Bailey and Pillard (1991) found evidence of heritability of homosexuality in a study of monozygotic
(MZ) and dizygotic (DZ) twins. Homosexual male probands with MZ cotwins, DZ cotwins, or
adoptive brothers were recruited. Of the relatives whose sexual orientation could be rated, 52%
(29/56) of MZ cotwins, 22% (12/54) of DZ cotwins, and 11% (6/57) of adoptive brothers were
homosexual. Childhood gender non-conformity did not appear to be an indicator of genetic
loading for homosexuality.
In a second genetic study, Hamer et al. (1993) reported a linkage between DNA markers on the
X chromosome and male sexual orientation. Pedigree and linkage analyses on 114 families of
homosexual men were carried out. Increased rates of homosexual orientation were found in the
maternal uncles and male cousins of these subjects, but not in their fathers or paternal relatives,
suggesting the possibility of sex-linked transmission in a portion of the population. DNA linkage
analysis of a selected group of 40 families in which there were two gay brothers and no indication of
non-maternal transmission revealed a correlation between homosexual orientation and the
inheritance of polymorphic markers on the X chromosome in approximately 64 percent of the
sib-pairs tested. The linkage to markers on Xq28 had a multipoint lod score of 4.0.
Neuroanatomical
LeVay (1991) pointed out that his sample contained no homosexual women and that AIDS patients
may constitute an unrepresentative sample of homosexual men. Moreover, some presumed
78 Human growth and development
heterosexual men had relatively small INAH 3 nuclei (within the homosexual range) and some
presumed homosexual men had relatively large INAH 3 nuclei (within the heterosexual range). The
effect might have resulted from AIDS (although there was no effect of AIDS on the volume of the
three other INAH nuclei examined and the size difference in INAH 3 was present when the
homosexual men were compared with heterosexual AIDS patients).
Genetic
King (1993) has pointed out that the result of Hamer et al. (1993) is preliminary. Their evidence is
based on a small, highly selected group of homosexual men. The result is purely statistical. The gene
is hypothetical and has not been cloned, and the linkage has been observed in only one series of
families.
ADOLESCENCE
Equity theory
According to equity theory the preferred relationships, particularly those of an intimate nature,
between any two given people are those in which each feels that the cost–benefit ratio of the
relationship for each person is approximately equal. It has been argued that the amount of
emotional investment of both the adolescent and the parent(s) in their relationship means they
both wish to preserve it. As the adolescent pursues autonomy, this can lead to occasional conflicts,
but these are usually not fervent enough to destroy the relationship.
Separation–individuation
It has been argued that adolescence can be considered to represent a second separation–
individuation phase, in which continued biological, motor and social development now allow the
adolescent to move away from a dependent relationship with the parent(s) to take his or her own
place in society. However, social and psychological pulls towards dependency mean that the
separation–individuation may entail ambivalence and conflict.
Anna Freud
A rapid oscillation between excess and asceticism during adolescence was described by Anna Freud
(1936/1946). Affective instability and behaviour swings were considered to be caused by:
∑ the drives stimulated by sexual maturity
∑ pubertal endocrine changes
∑ instability of the newly stressed defences of the ego against these drives.
Erikson
Erikson (1959) characterized adolescence as manifesting ‘adolescent turmoil’ and a maladaptive,
temporary state of ‘identity diffusion’, which he implied all adolescents passed through.
Pairing
Even in Western countries, it appears that there are a number of constraints which govern the choice
of mate in much the same way as elders or parents do in arranged marriages.
Reinforcement theory
People are attracted to those who reinforce the attraction with rewards. This process is a reciprocal
one with rewards also passing in the opposite direction and further reinforcing the interpersonal
attraction (Newcomb, 1956).
Equity theory
As mentioned above, this is a modification of the social exchange theory in which the preferred
relationships, particularly of an intimate nature, between two people are those in which each feels
that the cost–benefit ratio of the relationship for each person is approximately equal (Hatfield &
Traupmann, 1981).
Matching hypothesis
According to this hypothesis, heterosexual pairing tends to occur in such a way that, although ideally
a person would prefer to pair with the most attractive people (Huston, 1973), in practice individuals
seek to pair with others who have a similar level of physical attractiveness rather than the most
attractive (Berscheid & Walster, 1974). This is felt by the individual to lead to a greater probability of
acceptance by the other person, a lower probability of rejection, and a lower probability of losing the
partner to another person in the future.
Cultural differences
People in Asian and African countries tend to value home-keeping potential and a desire for home
and children in mate selection, while people in Western countries tend to value love, character and
emotional maturity. Chastity is rated very highly in some countries (such as India and China) and
cultures (such as orthodox/traditional Jewish, Christian and Islamic communities) and very low in
others (such as Australia, New Zealand, North America, South America, and Scandinavia –
excluding their traditional observant religious groups) (Buss et al., 1990).
Cross-cultural constancies
Across cultures, men prefer mates who are physically attractive, while women prefer mates who
show ambition, industriousness and other signs of earning power potential (Buss et al., 1990).
Parenting
Parenting is a complex, dyadic process that is influenced by a range of factors, including:
∑ cultural beliefs of the parent about child-rearing (Maccoby & Martin, 1983)
∑ genetic – temperamental characteristics of the parent (i.e. genetic factors influencing the
provision of parenting) (Perusse et al., 1994)
∑ genetic – temperamental characteristics of the child (i.e. genetic factors influencing the
elicitation of parenting) (Bell, 1968).
Furthermore, reporting bias is likely, with parents stressing the similarity with which they treat their
children, and children emphasizing the differences in parental treatment that they perceive (Plomin
et al., 1994).
82 Human growth and development
Abusive parenting is a strong predictor of later psychopathology. On the other hand, parental
warmth and support buffers children against externalizing and antisocial behaviour (Hetherington
& Clingempeel, 1992) and is positively associated with a child’s self-esteem (Bell & Bell, 1983).
BEREAVEMENT
Parkes described the following five stages of bereavement:
∑ alarm
∑ numbness
∑ pining for the deceased – illusions or hallucinations of the deceased may occur
∑ depression
∑ recovery and reorganization.
Normal ageing 83
NORMAL AGEING
Physical aspects
Health
In general, most elderly people in Western countries enjoy good health, in spite of the changes that
occur in body systems with increasing age.
Cerebral changes
Blessed et al. (1968) found no histological evidence of dementia in the brains of 28 non-
demented individuals. Evidence of cerebral atrophy was absent or slight in the majority, and
84 Human growth and development
brain mass and ventricular size did not differ significantly from those of younger adults
(Tomlinson et al., 1968).
Social aspects
Stereotyping
Old age is generally a stigmatized period. For instance, people are complimented for looking
younger than their chronological age.
Empty-nest syndrome
Prior to the onset of old age, parents usually witness their children leaving home, particularly in
Western countries. The difficulties some parents encounter on being left on their own have been
described as the empty-nest syndrome.
Ego integrity
Successful resolution of the psychosocial crisis of this age leads to an integrated view of one’s life, its
meaning, its achievements (both for the self and others, including future generations), and the ways
in which difficulties were coped with. There is an acceptance of one’s mortality, a feeling that one’s
life has been lived in a satisfactory way, and a readiness to face death.
Despair
The alternative is despair, both on reflection of how life has been lived and the way in which others
have been treated, and also on looking to the future and the sense of transience that is felt on facing
the end of life. Rather than having a sense of contentment and completion, there is despair at the
prospect of death.
Cognitive aspects
Prior to the late 1960s, it was generally believed that the normal ageing brain degenerates and that
this is accompanied by intellectual deterioration. By the 1970s this view had been challenged on the
basis of new research. Thus Schaie (1974) wrote:
The presumed universal decline in adult intelligence is at best a methodological artifact and at
worst a popular misunderstanding of the relation between individual development and socio-
cultural change … the major finding … in the area of intellectual functioning is the demolishing
of [the belief in] serious intellectual decrement in the aged.
Although the elderly do not generally perform as well as younger subjects on cognitive tasks
dependent on processing speed, old age is not necessarily associated with a large decline in
intellectual ability (Durkin, 1995). Reasons for this include:
∑ Different abilities contribute to intellectual behaviour, so that a reduction in one (e.g. processing
speed) may be compensated for by an increase in another (such as experience-based
judgement).
Bibliography 85
∑ Cross-sectional comparisons of different age groups may confound age differences with cohort
effects.
∑ Changes in performance with age may be offset by practice.
∑ Crystallized intelligence (the ability to store and manipulate learned information) increases
through adulthood and often remains high into old age.
Definitions
∑ Timely death. This refers to the situation in which the expected life expectancy is approximately
equal to the actual length of time lived.
∑ Untimely death. This refers to the situation in which the actual length of time lived is
significantly less than the expected life expectancy, as a result of one of the following:
∑ premature death at a young age
∑ sudden unexpected death
∑ violent/accidental death.
∑ Unintended death. This refers to the situation in which death is unintended, usually occurring as
a result of pathological processes or trauma.
∑ Intended death. This refers to the situation in which death is intended by the deceased, who
played a part in his or her suicide.
∑ Subintended death. This refers to the situation in which the deceased may have manifested an
unconscious desire to bring about his or her death, for example by facilitating the onset of death
through psychoactive substance abuse.
Impending death
If it is believed that one’s death is near, an individual may pass through the following five stages that
are similar to those recognized as occurring in the terminally ill (Kübler-Ross, 1969):
∑ Shock and denial. The diagnosis may be disbelieved and another opinion sought. This first stage
may never be passed.
∑ Anger. The person may be angry and wonder why this has happened to him/her.
∑ Bargaining. The person may, for example, try to negotiate with God.
∑ Depression. The symptomatology of a depressive episode is manifested.
∑ Acceptance. The person may finally come to terms with his or her mortality and understand the
inevitability of death.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Aiosa-Karpas, C.J., Karpas, R., Pelcovitz, D. et al. 1991: Gender identification and sex role attribution in sexually
abused adolescent females. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 30:266–271.
Allen LS, Gorski RA 1992: Sexual orientation and the size of the anterior commisure in the human brain.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 85:7199–7202.
86 Human growth and development
Bailey, J.M. & Pillard, R.C. 1991: A genetic study of male sexual orientation. Archives of General Psychiatry
48:1089–1096.
Bates, J.E. 1989: Concepts and measures of temperament. In Kohnstamm, G.A., Bates, J.E. & Rothbart, M.K. (eds)
Temperament in Childhood. New York: John Wiley.
Bates, J.E., Wachs, T.D. & Van den Bos, G.R. 1995: Trends in research on temperament. Psychiatric Services
46:661–663.
Baumrind, D. 1967: Child care practices anteceding three patterns of pre-school behavior. Genetic Psychology
Monographs 75:43–88.
Bell, D.C. & Bell, L.G. 1983: Parental validation and support in the development of adolescent daughters. In
Grotevant, H.D. (ed.) Adolescent Development in the Family. San Francisco: Jossey Bass.
Bell, R.Q. 1968: A reinterpretation of the direction of effects in studies of socialization. Psychological Review
75:81–95.
Berscheid, E. & Walster, E. 1974: Physical attractiveness. In Berkowitz, L. (ed.) Advances in Experimental Social
Psychology. New York: Academic Press.
Blessed, G., Tomlinson, B.E. & Roth, M. 1968: The association between quantitative measures of dementia
and of senile change in the cerebral grey matter of elderly subjects. British Journal of Psychiatry
114:797–811.
Block, J. & Haan, N. 1971: Lives Through Time. Berkeley, CA: Bancroft Books.
Buss, D.M. et al. 1990: International preferences in selecting mates: a study of 37 cultures. Journal of Cross-
Cultural Psychology 21:5–47.
Caspi, A. & Silva, P.A. 1995: Temperamental qualities at age three predict personality traits in young adulthood:
longitudinal evidence from a birth cohort. Child Development 66:486–498.
Chess, S. & Thomas, A. 1984: Origins and Evolution of Behavior Disorders: From Infancy to Early Adult Life. New
York: Brunner/Mazel.
Cosentino, C.E., Meyer-Bahlburg, H.F.I., Nat, D.R. et al. 1995: Sexual behavior problems and psychopathology
symptoms in sexually abused girls. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
34:1033–1042.
Dorner, G. 1986: Hormone-dependent brain development and preventative medicine. Monographs in Neural
Sciences 12:17–27.
Dorner, G. 1989: Hormone-dependent brain development and neuroendocrine prophylaxis. Experimental and
Clinical Endocrinology 94:4–22.
Durkin, K. 1995: Developmental Social Psychology. Cambridge, MA: Blackwell.
Elmer, E. & Gregg, C.S. 1967: Developmental characteristics of abused children. Pediatrics 40:596–602.
Erikson, E. 1959: Growth and Crises of the Healthy Personality. New York: International Universities Press.
Eshelman, J.R. 1985: One should marry a person of the same religion, race, ethnicity, and social class. In Feldman,
H. & Feldman, M. (eds) Current Controversies in Marriage and the Family. Newbury Park, CA: Sage.
Finkelhor, D. 1984: Child Sexual Abuse: New Theory and Research. New York: Free Press.
Freud, A. 1936/1946: The Ego and the Mechanisms of Defence (trans. Baines, C). New York: International
Universities Press.
Freud, S. 1917/1957: Mourning and melancholia. In Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of
Sigmund Freud, vol 14 (trans./ed. Strachey, J.). London: Hogarth.
Freud, S. 1926/1959: Inhibitions, symptoms and anxiety. In Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works
of Sigmund Freud, vol. 20 (trans./ed. Strachey, J.). London: Hogarth.
Friedrich, W. & Reams, R. 1987: Course of psychological symptoms in sexually abused young children.
Psychotherapy 24:160–171.
Gaensbauer, T. & Sands, K. 1979: Regulation of emotional expression in infants from two contrasting
environments. Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry 21:167–171.
George, C. & Main, M. 1979: Social interactions and young abused children: approach, avoidance, and aggression.
Child Development 50:306–319.
Bibliography 87
Goodwin, J. 1985: Post-traumatic symptoms in incest victims. In Eth, S. & Pynoos, R.S. (eds) Post-Traumatic Stress
Disorder in Children. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.
Gooren, L., Fliers, E. & Courtney, K. 1990: Biological determinants of sexual orientation. Annual Review of Sex
Research 1:175–196.
Gowers, S.G. (ed.) 2001: Adolescent Psychiatry in Clinical Practice. London: Arnold.
Graham, P. 1991: Child Psychiatry: A Developmental Approach, 2nd edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Green, A.H. 1978: Psychiatric treatment of abused children. Journal of the American Academy of Child Psychiatry
17:356–371.
Green, A.H. 1985: Children traumatized by physical abuse. In Eth, S. & Pynoos, R.S. (eds) Post-Traumatic Stress
Disorder in Children. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.
Green, A.H., Voeller, K., Gaines, R. et al. 1981: Neurological impairment in battered children. Child Abuse and
Neglect 5:129–134.
Gunnar, M.R. 1994: Psychoendocrine studies of temperament and stress in early childhood: expanding current
models. In Bates, J.E. & Wachs, T.D. (eds) Temperament: Individual Differences at the Interface of Biology and
Behavior. Washington, DC: American Psychological Association.
Hamer, D.H., Hu, S., Magnuson, V.L., Hu, N. & Pattatucci, A.M. 1993: A linkage between DNA markers on the X
chromosome and male sexual orientation. Science 261:321–327.
Hatfield, E. & Traupmann, J. 1981: Intimate relationships: a perspective from equity theory. In Duck, S. & Gilmour,
R. (eds) Personal Relationships, vol. 1. New York: Academic Press.
Herman, J. 1981: Father–Daughter Incest. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
Herman, J., Perry, J.C. & van der Kolk, B. 1989: Childhood trauma in borderline personality disorder. American
Journal of Psychiatry 146:490–495.
Hetherington, E.M. & Clingempeel, W.G. 1992: Coping with marital transitions: a family systems perspective.
Monographs of the Society of Research into Child Development 57 (serial no. 227).
Homans, G.C. 1961: Social Behavior: Its Elementary Forms. New York: Harcourt Brace.
Huston, T.L. 1973: Ambiguity of acceptance, social desirability and dating choice. Journal of Experimental Social
Psychology 9:32.
King, M-C 1993: Human genetics: sexual orientation and the X [news and views]. Nature 364:288–289.
Kluft, R. 1985: Childhood Antecedents of Multiple Personality. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.
Kübler-Ross, E. 1969: On Death and Dying. New York: Macmillan.
LeVay, S. 1991: A difference in hypothalamic structure between heterosexual and homosexual men. Science
253:1034–1037.
McCarty, L. 1986: Mother–child incest: characteristics of the offender. Child Welfare 65:447–458.
Maccoby, E.E. & Martin, J.A. 1983: Socialization in the context of the family: parent–child interaction. In Mussen,
P.H. (ed.) Handbook of Child Psychology. Vol. IV: Socialization, Personality, and Social Development. New York:
John Wiley.
Marks, I. 1987: The development of normal fear: a review. Journal of Child Psychology and Psychiatry
28:667–698.
Martin, H.P. 1972: The child and his development. In Kempe, C.H. & Helfer, R.E. (eds) Helping the Battered Child
and His Family. Philadelphia: Lippincott.
Newcomb, T. 1956: The prediction of interpersonal attraction. American Psychologist 11:575.
Oates, K. 1986: Child Abuse and Neglect: What Happens Eventually? New York: Brunner/Mazel.
Offer, B. & Offer, J.B. 1975: From Teenage to Young Manhood: A Psychological Study. New York: Basic Books.
Oppenheimer, R., Howells, K., Palmer, L. et al. 1985: Adverse sexual experiences in childhood and clinical eating
disorders: a preliminary description. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 19:157–161.
Perusse, D., Neale, M.C., Heath, A.C. & Eaves, L.J. 1994: Human parental behavior: evidence for genetic influence
and potential implication for gene–culture transmission. Behavioral Genetics 24:327–335.
Plomin, R., Reiss, D., Hetherington, E.M. & Howe, G.W. 1994: Nature and nurture: genetic contributions to
measures of the family environment. Developmental Psychology 30:32–43.
88 Human growth and development
Putnam, F. 1985: Dissociation as a response to extreme trauma. In Kluft, R. (ed) Childhood Antecedents of
Multiple Personality Disorder. Washington, DC: American Psychiatric Press.
Schaie, K.W. 1974: Translations in gerontology – from lab to life. Intellectual functioning. American Psychologist
29:802–807.
Schechter, M.D. & Roberge, L. 1976: Sexual exploitation. In Helfer, R.E. & Kempe, C.H. (eds) Child Abuse and
Neglect: The Family and the Community. Cambridge, MA: Ballinger.
Seghorn, T.K., Prentky, R.A. & Boucher, R.J. 1987: Child sexual abuse in the lives of sexually aggressive offenders.
Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry 26:262–267.
Sgroi, S. 1982: Handbook of Clinical Intervention in Child Sexual Abuse. Lexington, MA: Lexington Books.
Steele, B.F. 1983: The effect of abuse and neglect on psychological development. In Call, J.D., Galenson, E. &
Tyson, R.L. (eds) Frontiers of Infant Psychiatry. New York: Basic Books.
Thomas, A. & Chess, S. 1977: Temperament and Development. New York: Brunner/Mazel.
Tomlinson, B.E., Blessed, G. & Roth, M. 1968: Observations on the brains of non-demented old people. Journal of
the Neurological Sciences 7:331–356.
Yates, A. 1982: Children eroticized by incest. American Journal of Psychiatry 139:482–485.
Zuckerman, M. 1991: Psychobiology of Personality. New York: Cambridge University Press.
5
Psychological assessment
PRINCIPLES OF MEASUREMENT
INTERVIEWS
Sources of error include:
∑ Response set. This is a tendency always to agree or to disagree with the questions asked.
∑ Bias towards the centre. This is a tendency always to avoid extreme responses. As a result, there is
an excess choice of middle responses.
∑ Extreme responding. This is the opposite tendency of selecting extreme responses.
∑ Social desirability. This is the choice of responses that the subject believes the interviewer desires.
It may be reduced through the inclusion of lie scales or the forced-choice technique.
∑ Defensiveness. The subject avoids giving too much self-related information.
∑ Halo effect. The observer allows his/her preconception to influence the responses.
∑ Hawthorne effect. The interviewer alters the situation by his or her presence.
SELF-PREDICTIONS
This is a direct method of measuring behaviour in which the subject is asked to give his or her own
prediction concerning the behaviour under question. It can be combined with self-recording.
PSYCHOPHYSIOLOGICAL TECHNIQUES
These involve the direct use of physiological measurements in assessing behaviour.
NATURALISTIC OBSERVATIONS
These involve the assessment of behaviour as it occurs with minimum interference by the observer.
In time-sampling techniques, the subject is observed during given time intervals at given times of
the day or night.
90 Psychological assessment
Naturalistic observations are used in the functional analysis of problem behaviours. This method
is sometimes referred to as ABC (Antecedents, Behaviours, Consequences).
SCALING
This refers to the conversion of raw data into types of scores more readily understood, for example
ranks, (per)centiles and standardized scores.
NORM-REFERENCING
A norm is an average, common or standard performance under specified conditions. A test may be
standardized to this norm.
CRITERION-REFERENCING
A criterion is a set of scores against which the success of a predictive test can be compared.
INTELLIGENCE
Components of intelligence
Charles Spearman, who discovered factor analysis, put forward the notion that all individuals
possess, to varying extents, general abilities; this general intelligence factor is known as g. The main
determinant of intelligence test scores was held to be g by Spearman.
A separate component of intelligence comprised specific abilities, known as s. Different
intelligence subtests were held to index different s factors.
Overall, a person would be considered bright (high g factor) or not-so-bright (low g factor), but
the person’s actual overall intelligence would be calculated as follows:
Intelligence = g + (sum of the magnitudes of the various s factors)
For example, arithmetic performance would be a function of g plus the individual’s aptitude for
arithmetic (specific s).
Louis Thurstone (1938) criticized Spearman’s g, and instead suggested that intelligence consisted
of several primary abilities. On the basis of the factor analysis of a large database of intelligence test
scores, he found the following seven primary abilities (Thurstone & Thurstone, 1963):
Verbal comprehension
Word fluency
Number
Space
Memory
Perceptual speed
Reasoning.
Intelligence 91
Verbal subtests
The only one of these six subtests which is timed is the arithmetic subtest.
Information: 29 questions
Comprehension: 16 items including the interpretation of proverbs
Arithmetic: 14 mental arithmetic problems
Similarities: 14 pairs of items for which the subject is asked to state in what way each pair is alike
Digit span: lists of three to nine digits which must be remembered in the forward direction and
lists of two to eight digits which must be remembered backwards
Vocabulary: the subject is asked to give the meaning of 35 words.
Performance subtests
All five of these subtests are timed.
Picture completion: 20 incomplete pictures are presented to the subject who is asked to state the
important part missing from each one
Block design: the subject is asked to reproduce designs with red and white blocks
Picture arrangement: the subject is asked to arrange 10 sets of cartoon pictures so that their
sequence makes sense
92 Psychological assessment
Nature–nurture
Potential intelligence (aptitude) is inherited, but environmental factors influence the fulfilment of
potential (attainment).
Cultural influences
Tests of attainment can give rise to discrepant results when applied to people from different cultures.
It is thought that tests measuring aptitude are less prone to such influences.
Language tests
Boston Naming Test
In this language test, the subject is asked to name 60 line drawings (Kaplan et al., 1983).
Token Test
A number of tokens, such as differently coloured rectangles and circular discs, are used in this test.
The subject is asked to carry out progressively more complicated verbal instructions using these
tokens (De Renzi & Vignolo, 1962). The Token Test is sensitive to minor impairment in language
comprehension, and performance tends to be more impaired in aphasia than in people who are
non-asphasic.
Perception tests
Bender–Gestalt Test/Bender Visual Motor Gestalt Test
The subject is asked to copy nine designs (Bender, 1938, 1946).
Memory tests
Benton Visual Retention Test
In this visual recall test, designs on cards are each presented to the subject for 10 seconds, after each
of which the subject attempts to recall and draw each design (Benton, 1955, 1963). In order to
Techniques used in neuropsychological assessment 95
exclude visuoperceptual problems, the subject can also be asked separately to copy the designs with
the cards on display. It may be used to test for brain damage and early cognitive decline.
Rey–Osterrieth Test
In this visual memory test, the subject is presented with a complex design. The subject is asked to
copy this design and then, 40 minutes later, without previous notification that this will occur, the
subject is asked to draw the same design again from memory (Rey, 1941; Osterrieth, 1944). Non-
dominant temporal lobe damage can lead to impaired performance on this test, whereas domain
temporal lobe damage tends not to (but is associated with verbal memory difficulties).
WMS-R
The Wechsler Memory Scale (revised) or WMS-R is a memory test battery that contains the
following subtests (Wechsler, 1987):
96 Psychological assessment
Intelligence tests
WAIS and similar tests
The intelligence tests based on the WAIS are considered in the previous section of this chapter.
Techniques used in neuropsychological assessment 97
NART
The National Adult Reading Test or NART (Nelson & McKenna, 1975; Nelson, 1982) is a reading test
consisting of phonetically irregular words which have to be read aloud by the subject. If a person
suffers deterioration in intellectual abilities, the person’s premorbid vocabulary may remain less
affected (or unaffected). The NART can therefore be used to estimate the premorbid IQ.
Verbal fluency
A typical verbal fluency test involves asking the subject to articulate as many words as possible,
during two-minute intervals, starting with the letters F, A and S, in turn. Proper nouns (such as the
name Forsythe) and derivatives such as plurals and different verb endings are not allowed to count
together with the root words. For instance, one cannot count both ‘font’ and ‘fonts’, or ‘float’ and
‘floated’ and ‘floating’. The score is the total number of allowable words achieved. Verbal fluency is
impaired in left (dominant) frontal lobe lesions.
Personality tests
Personality inventories have been considered in Chapter 1. Here, psychometric methods of assessing
personality are summarized.
Objective tests
The items presented have limited responses. Objective tests include:
∑ 16PF (Sixteen Personality Factor Questionnaire) – see Chapter 1.
∑ MMPI (Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory) – see Chapter 1.
∑ CPI (California Psychological Inventory) – see Chapter 1.
∑ EPQ (Eysenck Personality Questionnaire) – This contains 90 items in true/false format. Subjects
are rated on the following dimensions: extraversion, introversion, and neuroticism.
∑ HDHQ (Hostility and Direction of Hostility Questionnaire) – This is used to measure
relationships that could be affected by personality status.
In general, because of evidence that mental state markedly affects scoring of questionnaires, they
have been replaced by interview schedules and other observer ratings.
Projective tests
The presented items have no one correct answer, instead taking the form of ambiguous stimuli,
upon which the subject projects his or her personality. Their reliability and validity have not been
established. Examples include the:
100 Psychological assessment
CANTAB
The Cambridge Neuropsychological Test Automated Battery or CANTAB is an automated
computerized battery that offers sensitive and specific cognitive assessment, preferably using a
touch screen. The standard CANTAB consists of the following 13 computerized tasks:
∑ Motor screening. This screening task is administered before the other tasks and introduces the
subject to the touch screen and checks that the subject can touch this properly and that he or she
can hear, comprehend and follow instructions appropriately.
∑ Big/little circle. This tests that a subject can follow an explicit instructional rule and that he or she
can then reverse this rule.
∑ Delayed matching to sample.
∑ ID/ED shift. This tests the ability to attend to specific attributes of compound stimuli and then to
shift that attention as required.
∑ Matching to sample visual search. This is a speed/accuracy trade-off visual search task.
∑ Paired associates learning. This delayed response procedure tests list memory and then list
learning (or visuospatial conditional learning).
∑ Pattern recognition memory.
∑ Rapid visual information processing. This tests vigilance (sustained attention) and working
memory.
∑ Reaction time.
Techniques used in neuropsychological assessment 101
Information–Memory–Concentration Test
This is a relatively straightforward set of questions that may be tried even by those with medium to
severe levels of dementia.
GMS
The Geriatric Mental State Schedule or GMS is a semi-structured interview that assesses the
subject’s mental state.
CAMDEX
The Cambridge Examination for Mental Disorders of the Elderly or CAMDEX is an interview
schedule consisting of three sections (Roth et al., 1986, 1988):
102 Psychological assessment
∑ A structured clinical interview with the person is conducted to obtain systematic information
about the present state, past history and family history.
∑ A range of objective cognitive tests are administered which constitute a mini-
neuropsychological battery, known as the CAMCOG.
∑ A structured interview with a relative or other informant is conducted to obtain independent
information about the respondent’s present state, past history and family history.
The assessment also includes a brief physical and neurological examination, and recording the
results of investigations.
Nurse-rated scales
∑ Crichton Geriatric Behaviour Rating Scale is a retrospective nursing-rated assessment.
∑ Clifton Assessment Schedule is another nursing-rated assessment.
∑ Stockton Geriatric Rating Scale is also a nursing-rated assessment.
PBE
The Present Behavioural Examination or PBE involves interviewing carers and rates psycho-
pathological and behavioural changes in dementia.
MOUSEPAD
The Manchester and Oxford Universities Scale for the Psychopathological Assessment of Dementia
or MOUSEPAD also involves interviewing carers and rates psychopathological and behavioural
changes in dementia.
SCAG
The Sandoz Clinical Assessment: Geriatric or SCAG consists of 18 symptom areas and an overall
global assessment, each being rated on an eight-point scale (from 0 = not present, to 7 = severe)
(Shader et al., 1974):
Mood depression Emotional lability
Confusion Fatigue
Mental alertness Self-care
Motivation initiative Appetite
Irritability Dizziness
Hostility Anxiety
Bothersome Impairment of recent memory
Indifference to surroundings Disorientation
Unsociability Overall impression of the person.
Uncooperativeness
PADL
The Performance Test of Activities of Daily Living or PADL is a simple performance test that assesses
the self-care capacity of the subject by asking him or her to carry out certain essential activities of
daily living.
Bibliography 103
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Anthony, J.C., Le Resche, L., Niaz, U., Von Korf, M.R. & Folstein, M.F. 1982: Limits of the ‘Mini-Mental State’ as a
screening test for dementia and delirium among hospital patients. Psychological Medicine 12:397–408.
Baddeley, A., Emslie, H. & Nimmo-Smith, I. 1992 The Speed and Capacity of Language Processing Test. Bury St
Edmunds: Thames Valley Test Co.
Bender, L. 1938: A Visual Motor Gestalt Test and its Clinical Uses. New York: American Orthopsychiatric
Association.
Bender, L. 1946: Instructions for the Use of Visual Motor Gestalt Test. New York: American Orthopsychiatric
Association.
Benton, A.L. 1955: The Revised Visual Retention Test: Clinical and Experimental Applications. New York: The
Psychological Corp.
Benton, A.L. 1963: The Revised Visual Retention Test: Clinical and Experimental Applications. New York: The
Psychological Corp.
Blessed, G., Tomlinson, B.E. & Roth, M. 1968: The association between quantitative measures of dementia and of
senile change in the cerebral grey matter of elderly subjects. British Journal of Psychiatry 114:797–811.
Coughlan, A.K. & Hollows, S.E. 1985: The Adult Memory and Information Processing Battery. Leeds: A.K. Coughlan,
Psychology Department, St James University Hospital.
De Renzi, E. & Vignolo, L.A. 1962: The token test: a sensitive test to detect receptive disturbances in aphasics.
Brain 85:665–678.
Folstein, M.F., Folstein, S.E. & McHugh, P.R. 1975: ‘Mini-mental state’: a practical method for grading the
cognitive state of patients for the clinician. Journal of Psychiatric Research 12:189–198.
Graham, F.K. & Kendall, B.S. 1960: Memory-for-designs test: revised general manual. Perceptual and Motor Skills
11:147–188.
Inglis, J. 1959: A paired-associate learning test for use with elderly psychiatric patients. Journal of Mental
Science 105:440–443.
Isaacs, B. & Walkey, F.A. 1964: A simplified paired-associate test for elderly hospital patients. British Journal of
Psychiatry 110:80–83.
Kaplan, E., Goodglass, H. & Weintraub, S. 1983: Boston Naming Test. Philadelphia: Lea & Febiger.
Kendrick, D.C., Parboosingh, R.-C. & Post, F. 1965: A synonym learning test for use with elderly psychiatric
subjects: a validation study. British Journal of Social and Clinical Psychology 4:63–71.
Kendrick, D.C., Gibson, A.J. & Moyes, I.C.A. 1979: The revised Kendrick battery: clinical studies. British Journal of
Social and Clinical Psychology 18:329–340.
Knafelc, R., Lo Giudice, D., Harrigan, S. et al. 2003: The combination of cognitive testing and an informant
questionnaire in screening for dementia. Age and Ageing 32:541–547.
Lezak, M.D. 1995: Neuropsychological Assessment, 3rd edn. New York: Oxford University Press.
McKenna, P. & Warrington, E.K. 1983: Graded Naming Test. Windsor: NFER–Nelson.
Mead, L.A., Mayer, A.R., Bobholz, J.A. et al. 2002: Neural basis of the Stroop interference task: response
competition or selective attention? Journal of International Neuropsychological Society 8:735–742.
Nelson, H.E. 1982: The National Adult Reading Test Manual. Windsor: NFER–Nelson.
Nelson, H.E. & McKenna, P. 1975: The use of current reading ability in the assessment of dementia. British Journal
of Social and Clinical Psychology 14:259–267.
Osterrieth, P.-A. 1944: Le test depression copie d’une figure complexe: contribution à l’étude de la perception et
de la mémoire. Archives de Psychologie 30:206–353.
Pardo, J.V., Pardo, P.J., Janer, K.W. & Raichle, M.E. 1990: The anterior cingulate cortex mediates processing
selection in the Stroop attention of conflict paradigm. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciencesof the
USA 87:256–259.
Post, F. 1965: The Clinical Psychiatry of Late Life. Oxford: Pergamon.
104 Psychological assessment
Raven, J.C. 1958: Guide to using the Mill Hill Vocabulary Scale and the Progressive Matrices Scales. London: H.K.
Lewis.
Raven, J.C. 1982: Revised Manual for Raven’s Progressive Matrices and Vocabulary Scale. Windsor: NFER–Nelson.
Rey, A. 1941: L’examen psychologique dans les cas d’encéphalopathie traumatique. Archives de Pathologie
28:286–340.
Roth, M., Huppert, F.A., Tym, E. & Mountjoy, C.Q. 1988: CAMDEX. The Cambridge Examination for Mental Disorders
of the Elderly. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Roth, M., Tym, E., Mountjoy, C.Q. et al. 1986: CAMDEX: a standardised instrument for the diagnosis of mental
disorder in the elderly with special reference to the early detection of dementia. British Journal of Psychiatry
149:698–709.
Shader, R.I., Harmatz, J.S. & Salzman, C. 1974: A new scale for clinical assessment in geriatric populations:
Sandoz Clinical Assessment – Geriatric (SCAG). Journal of the American Geriatrics Society 22:107–113.
Shallice, T. 1982: Specific impairments of planning. In Broadbent, D.E. & Weiskrantz, L. (eds) The Neuropsychology
of Cognitive Function. London: Royal Society.
Stroop, J.R. 1935: Studies of interference in serial verbal reactions. Journal of Experimental Psychology
18:643–662.
Thurstone, L.L. 1938: Primary Mental Abilities. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
Thurstone, L.L. & Thurstone, T.G. 1963: SRA Primary Abilities. Chicago: Science Research Associates.
Trenerry, M.R., Crossan, B., Deboe, J. & Leber, W.R. 1989: Stroop Neuropsychological Screening Test Manual.
Florida: Psychological Assessment Resources Inc.
Warrington, E.K. & James, M. 1991: The Visual Object and Space Perception Battery. Bury St Edmunds: Thames
Valley Test Co.
Wechsler, D. 1987: Wechsler Memory Scale – Revised Manual. San Antonio, TX: The Psychological Corp.
Wilson, B.A. 1987: Rehabilitation of Memory. New York: Guildford Press.
Wilson, B.A., Cockburn, J. & Baddeley, A. 1991: The Rivermead Behavioural Memory Test, 2nd edn. Bury St
Edmunds: Thames Valley Test Co.
Wilson, B.A., Cockburn, J. & Halligan, P. 1987: Behavioural Inattention Test. Fareham: Thames Valley Test Co.
6
Principles of evaluation and psychometrics
BASIC CONCEPTS
Qualitative data
Qualitative variables refer to attributes that can be categorized such that the categories do not have
a numerical relationship with each other; e.g. eye colour.
Quantitative data
Quantitative variables refer to numerically represented data. These can be of the following types:
∑ discrete quantitative variables which can take on only known fixed values; e.g. the number of
new patients seen each week in a psychiatric outpatient department
∑ continuous quantitative variables which can take on any value in a defined range; e.g. the height
of psychiatric inpatients.
Scales of measurement
Table 6.1 summarizes the properties of different types of measurement scale.
Sampling methods
Simple random sampling
A simple random sample is one chosen from a given population such that every possible sample of
the same size has the same probability of being chosen.
106 Principles of evaluation and psychometrics
Systematic sampling
This type of sampling saves time and effort. Common examples include:
∑ Periodic sampling. Every nth member of the population is chosen. This may not always lead to a
random choice because of an unforeseen underlying pattern.
∑ Using random numbers. Using random numbers can be a better method than periodic sampling
for ensuring random choice. Random numbers, obtained, for example, from a computer
program, a scientific calculator with a (pseudo)random number generator, or a table of random
numbers, can be used to choose every nth member of the population.
∑ Stratified random sampling. A given population is stratified before random samples are chosen
from each stratum. This can be useful when studying a disease that varies with respect to sex and
age, for example.
Frequency distributions
Frequency distribution
This is a systematic way of arranging data, with frequencies being given for categories of a
qualitative or quantitative variable. For continuous quantitative variables the categories should be
contiguous and mutually exclusive, and are known as class intervals.
Frequency table
This is a frequency distribution arranged in the form of a table, with the first column giving
contiguous mutually exclusive values (which may be class intervals) of a variable and the adjoining
column giving the corresponding frequencies.
Relative frequency
The relative frequency of a category/class interval/variable is the proportion of the total frequency
corresponding to that category/class interval/variable:
Relative frequency = (frequency of category)/(total frequency)
Cumulative frequency
The cumulative frequency of a given value of a variable is the total frequency up to that value.
Bernoulli distribution
This is the probability distribution for a discrete binary variable (range = 0, 1), which is a special case
of the binomial distribution B(1, p), where p is the probability of ‘success’:
Mean = p
Variance = p(1 - p)
Binomial distribution
The binomial distribution, B(n, p), is the probability distribution for a discrete finite variable (range
= 0, 1, 2, …, n):
Mean = np
Variance = np(1 - p)
Poisson distribution
The Poisson distribution, Poisson (m), is the probability distribution for a discrete infinite variable
(range = 0, 1, 2, …), where m = np:
Mean = m
Variance = m
The Poisson distribution can be used in situations in which the following criteria are fulfilled:
∑ Events occur randomly in time or space (length, area or volume).
∑ The events are independent (i.e. the outcome of any given event does not affect the outcome of
any other).
∑ Two or more events cannot take place simultaneously.
∑ The mean number of events per given unit of time or space is constant.
The interval one standard deviation either side of the mean of the p.d.f. of a normal distribution
encloses 68.27% of the total area under the curve.
The interval two standard deviations either side of the mean of the p.d.f. of a normal distribution
encloses 95.45% of the total area under the curve.
The interval three standard deviations either side of the mean of the p.d.f. of a normal
distribution encloses 99.73% of the total area under the curve.
If X ~ N(m, s2), then the standard normal variate Z is given by:
Z = (X - m)/s
For Z ~ N(0, 1):
Mean = 0
Variance = 1
The cumulative distribution function, P(Z < z), is given by (z).
For N(m, s2), the two-tailed 5% points are given by:
m - 1.96s and m + 1.96s
t distribution
When n < 30, the t distribution, t(n) or tn, is used in making inferences about the mean of a normal
population when its variance is unknown. The t distribution is symmetrical about the mean but has
longer tails than the normal distribution.
n is the number of degrees of freedom, and is given by:
n=n-1
For n ≥ 30, t(n) ª N(0, 1).
c2 distribution
The chi-squared distribution with n degrees of freedom, c2(n), is obtained from the sum of the
squares of n independent variables, Z1 to Zn, where each Z ~ N(0, 1):
If W = SZi2 ,where i = 1 to n , and Zi ~ N(0, 1),
then W ~ c2(n)
The chi-squared distribution is asymmetrical.
F distribution
The F distribution is related to the c2 distribution and is asymmetrical. A given F distribution is
described in terms of n1 and n2, each of which gives a number of degrees of freedom. This is usually
abbreviated to F(n1, n2).
The arithmetic mean is suitable for use with data measured on at least an interval scale. A major
disadvantage is that it can be unduly influenced by an extreme value.
The median is the middle value of a set of observations ranked in order. If the number of
observations is odd:
Median = middle value
If the number of observations is even:
Median = arithmetic mean of the two middle values
The median is suitable for use with data measured on at least an ordinal scale. It gives a better
measure of central tendency than the mean for skewed (asymmetrical) distributions.
The mode of a distribution is the value of the observation occurring most frequently. The
category/interval occurring most frequently is the modal category. It can be used with all
measurement scales.
Quantiles
Quantiles are cut-off points that split a continuous distribution into equal groups.
∑ The median splits a distribution into two equal parts.
∑ The two tertiles split the distribution into three equal parts.
∑ The three quartiles split the distribution into four equal parts.
∑ The four quintiles split the distribution into five equal parts.
∑ The nine deciles split the distribution into 10 equal parts.
∑ The 99 percentiles split the distribution into 100 equal parts.
The kth quantile of n observations ranked in increasing order from the first to the nth is
calculated by interpolating between the two observations adjacent to the qth, where q is given by:
q = k(n + 1)/Q
where Q is the number of groups into which the quantiles divide the distribution.
The median and interquartile or 10 to 90 percentile range can be more useful summary statistics
than the mean and standard deviation for skewed distributions.
Standard deviation
The standard deviation of a distribution is based on deviations from the mean and has the same
units as the original observations.
For a population of size N and mean m, the population standard deviation, s, is given by:
Population standard deviation, s = ÷{[S(x - m)2]/N}
For a sample of size n and mean x̄, the sample standard deviation, s, is given by:
Sample standard deviation, s = ÷{[S(x - x̄)2]/(n - 1)}
The standard deviation can be used for data measured on at least an interval scale.
Variance
The variance is the square of the standard deviation and has units that are the square of those of the
observations.
For a population of size N and mean m, the population variance, s2, is given by:
Population variance, s2 = [S(x - m)2]/N
For a sample of size n and mean x̄, the sample variance, s2, is given by:
Sample variance, s2 = [S(x - x̄)2]/(n - 1)
The variance can be used for data measured on at least an interval scale.
Graphs
The graph of a function f is the set of points (x, f(x)).
DRAWING GRAPHS
A properly drawn graph should have the following properties:
∑ clearly labelled axes
∑ the independent variable represented (usually) on the horizontal axis
∑ a clear heading/caption or reference in the accompanying text
∑ the units for both axes clearly stated
∑ the scales given for both axes.
The scales may be, for example:
∑ linear
∑ logarithmic
∑ broken (which can be represented by a break in the axis).
LINEAR RELATIONSHIPS
If the graph of variable y against variable x is a straight line, these variables are related by the
equation:
y = mx + c
Basic concepts 111
in which m and c are constants: m is the gradient of the line, and c is the intercept of the line on the
vertical axis (y-axis).
EXPONENTIAL RELATIONSHIPS
If the graph of y against x is a straight line, where y = ln Y and x = X (ln Y is the logarithm of Y to
base e, that is, loge Y), then variables X and Y are related by the equation:
Y = Cemx
in which m and C are constants such that m is the gradient of the line, and ln C is the intercept of
the line on the vertical axis (y-axis).
This exponential relationship also holds if:
∑ e is replaced by 10
∑ ln Y is replaced by log10 Y
∑ ln C is replaced by log10 C.
Outliers
Outliers are extreme values.
Measures of dispersion
Outliers exert an extreme effect on the range. Measures relating to quantiles are less affected in such
a case and may therefore be preferred. Since it takes into account all the values in a distribution, the
standard deviation (or variance) may be affected by outliers, although less so than the range.
112 Principles of evaluation and psychometrics
Stem-and-leaf plots
Stem-and-leaf plots can be used to represent a continuous variable. Their advantage over
histograms is that they allow the representation of all the individual data. The stems consist of a
vertical column of numbers on the left-hand side of the plot. The leaves are numbers to the right of
the stems, which may, for example, represent tenths. All the individual data can then be derived by
combining the individual leaves with their corresponding stems, while the shape of the overall plot
indicates the shape of the distribution. They are particularly easy to represent in computer
printouts. For instance, the distribution 13.5, 13.7, 14.5, 14.6, 14.6, 14.7, 15.2, 15.9 and 16.4
(arbitrary units) may be represented as the following stem-and-leaf plot:
13 57
14 5667
15 29
16 4
DESCRIPTIVE STATISTICS
Descriptive statistics are ways of organizing and describing data. Examples include:
∑ diagrams
∑ graphical representations
∑ numerical representations
∑ tables.
INFERENTIAL STATISTICS
Inferential statistics allow conclusions to be inferred from data. An example is inferring a likely
range of values for the population mean from the sample mean.
Null hypothesis
The initial hypothesis is the null hypothesis, H0, usually representing no change:
H0: q = q0
where t is the unknown parameter and q0 is its hypothesized value.
Alternative hypothesis
The alternative hypothesis, H1, may, for example, be one of the following types:
H1: q π q0
H1: q > q0
H1: q < q0
H1: q = q1
Significance level
The significance level, a, is the size of the critical region and represents the following probability:
a = P(type I error)
where a type I error is the error of wrongly rejecting H0 when it is true.
The two-sided central confidence interval for the unknown parameter q of a distribution with
confidence level (1 - a) can be derived from the random interval of the type:
(q-(X), q+(X))
By substituting the observation x for X, the realization of the random interval, (q-(x), q+(x)), is the
two-sided central confidence interval for q, in which:
∑ q-(x) is the lower confidence limit (confidence bound) for theta;
∑ q+(x) is the upper confidence limit (confidence bound) for theta.
SPECIFIC TESTS
t -test
The t-test is used for testing the null hypothesis that two population means are equal when the
variable being investigated has a normal distribution in each population and the population
variances are equal; that is, the t-test is a parametric test.
116 Principles of evaluation and psychometrics
Independent-samples t -test
This procedure tests the null hypothesis that the data are a sample from a population in which the
mean of a test variable is equal in two independent (unrelated) groups of cases.
Assuming equal population variances (which can be checked using Levene’s test), the standard
error of the difference between two means, x̄1 and x̄ 2, of two independent samples (taken from the
same parent population) of respective sizes n1 and n2, and respective standard deviations s1 and s2, (s1
ª s2) is given by:
Standard error of difference = s÷[1/n1 + 1/n2]
where the pooled standard deviation s is given by:
s = ÷{[(n1 - 1)s12 + (n2 - 1)s22]/(n1 + n2 - 2)}
If the population variances cannot be assumed to be equal, then the standard error is given by:
Standard error of difference = ÷[s12/n1 + s22/n2]
Paired-samples t -test
This procedure tests the null hypothesis that two population means are equal when the observations
for the two groups can be paired in some way. Pairing (a repeated-measures or within-subjects
design) is used to make the two groups as similar as possible, allowing differences observed between
the two groups to be attributed more readily to the variable of interest.
For n pairs, the appropriate standard error is given by:
Standard error of differences of paried observations = sd/÷n
where sd is the standard deviation of the differences of the paired observations.
Chi-squared test
The chi-squared (c2) test is a non-parametric test that can be used to compare independent
qualitative and discrete quantitative variables presented in the form of contingency tables
containing the data frequencies.
Null hypothesis
For a given contingency table, under H0:
Expected value of a cell = (row total)(column total)/(sum of cells).
Calculation of chi-squared
The value of c2 for a contingency table is calculated from:
c2 = S[(O - E)2/E]
where O is the observed value and E is the expected value.
In order to use the c2 distribution, the number of degrees of freedom of a contingency table, n, is
given by:
n = (r - 1)(k - 1)
where r is the number of rows and k is the number of columns.
Specific tests 117
2 ¥ 2 contingency table
A 2 ¥ 2 contingency table has one degree of freedom (see Table 6.2).
– – Total
– a y a+y
– b z b+z
Total a+b y+z a+b+y+z
Reproduced with permission from Puri, B.K. 1996: Statistics for the
Health Sciences. London: W.B. Saunders.
For a 2 ¥ 2 contingency table, the following formula can be used to calculate y2:
c2 = (az - by)2(a + b + y + z)/[(a + b)(y + z)(a + y)(b + z)]
Goodness-of-fit
The c2 test can be used to test how well an observed distribution fits a given distribution, such as the
normal distribution. This can be applied to both discrete and continuous data and tests the
hypothesis that a sample derives from a particular model.
Mann–Whitney U test
This is a non-parametric alternative to the independent-samples t-test. The test statistic, U, is the
smaller of U1 and U2:
118 Principles of evaluation and psychometrics
U1 = n1n2 + 1⁄2n1(n1 + 1) - R1
U2 = n1n2 + 1⁄2n2(n2 + 1) - R2
where
n1 = number of observations in the first group
n2 = number of observations in the second group
R1 = sum of the ranks assigned to the first group
R2 = sum of the ranks assigned to the second group.
For n1 ≥ 8 and n2 ≥ 8, U ª N(m, s2), where:
m = n1n2/2
s2 = n1n2(n1 + n2 + 1)/12
Confidence intervals
CONFIDENCE INTERVAL FOR THE DIFFERENCE BETWEEN TWO MEANS
The 100(1 - a)% confidence interval for the difference between two means is given by:
difference - t1 - a/2 (standard error of difference)
to difference + t1 - a/2 (standard error of difference).
where n1 and n2 are the sample sizes (both greater than 25), and K is rounded up to the nearest
integer. The total number of possible differences is equal to n1n2.
The 100(1 - a)% confidence interval for the median of these differences is from the Kth smallest
to the Kth largest of the n1n2 differences (K Œ ⌮+).
If n1 and/or n2 is less than or equal to 25, then tables based on the value of the corresponding
Mann–Whitney test statistic can be used.
CLINICAL TRIALS
Clinical trials are planned experiments carried out on humans to assess the effectiveness of different
forms of treatment.
CLASSIFICATION
The following classification of clinical trials is used by the pharmaceutical industry:
Phase I trial: clinical pharmacology and toxicity
Phase II trial: initial clinical investigation
Phase III trial: full-scale treatment evaluation
Phase IV trial: postmarketing surveillance.
∑ each subject does not know which treatment has been received by him/her
∑ the investigator(s) do not know the treatment allocation before the end of the trial.
Concurrent controls
It is not usually possible to confirm that the different treatment groups are comparable. Volunteer
bias may also occur, with volunteers faring better than those who refuse to participate in a trial.
Historical controls
Here the control group consists of a group previously given an older/alternative treatment. This
group is compared with suitable subjects receiving a new treatment being tested. Disadvantages of
using historical controls include:
∑ It cannot be assumed that everything apart from the new treatment being tested has remained
unchanged over time.
∑ The monitoring and care of current subjects receiving the new treatment are likely to be greater
than those of the historical controls.
∑ The efficacy of the new treatment is likely to be over-estimated.
∑ The findings of such a trial may be not be widely accepted because of the lack of randomization.
FACTOR ANALYSIS
Factor analysis is an attempt to express a set of multivariate data as a linear function of unobserved,
underlying dimensions, or (common) factors together with error terms (specific factors). The
common factors associated with each observed variable have individual loadings.
PRINCIPAL-COMPONENTS ANALYSIS
Principal-components analysis is used to produce uncorrelated linear combinations of the observed
variables of a multivariate dataset. The first component has maximum variance. Successive
components account for progressively smaller parts of the total variance. Each component is
uncorrelated with preceding components. A plot of the variance of each principal component
against the principal-component number is known as a scree plot.
CORRESPONDENCE ANALYSIS
A correspondence analysis is similar to a principal-components analysis but is applied to
contingency tables. It allows a two-dimensional contingency table to be presented as a two-
dimensional graph in which one set of coordinates represents the rows of the table and the other set
represents the columns. Rather than partitioning the total variance, as in principal-components
analysis, there is a partition of the value of c2 for the contingency table.
Problems of measurement in psychiatry 121
DISCRIMINANT ANALYSIS
This is a method of classification applied to a multivariate dataset. Independent variables used to
discriminate among the groups are known as discriminating variables. The discriminant function is
a linear function of discriminating variables which maximizes the distance (or separation) between
groups.
CLUSTER ANALYSIS
This is also a method of classification applied to a multivariate dataset which derives homogeneous
groups or clusters of cases based on their values for the variable set. Hierarchical methods can be
applied to the clusters.
PATH ANALYSIS
A series of multiple-regression analyses are used to allow hypotheses of causality between variables
to be modelled and tested. A path diagram allows these variables and their hypothetical
relationships to be represented graphically. It shows arrows between the variables, with regression
coefficients (known as path coefficients) associated with these arrows. Chi-squared tests are used to
test the model.
AIMS OF MEASUREMENT
The main aims of measurement in psychiatry are:
∑ to help in the diagnostic process or in other forms of categorization
∑ to measure symptomatology ± its change.
PROBLEMS OF MEASUREMENT
Problems in measurement in psychiatry include:
∑ defining caseness
∑ assessment of behaviour
122 Principles of evaluation and psychometrics
Measurement methods
A range of measurement methods can be employed in psychiatric/psychological assessments.
Examples include:
∑ observer rated scales: structured and semistructured standardized psychiatric interview
schedules
∑ screening instruments
∑ behavioural observation studies
∑ self-predictions
∑ self-recording (e.g. diaries)
∑ self-rating scales for the assessment of mood
∑ self-rating scales for the assessment of personality
∑ psychophysiological techniques
∑ naturalistic observations
∑ psychometric measurements (e.g. of intelligence and personality).
Reliability
The reliability of a test or measuring instrument describes the level of agreement between repeated
measurements. It can be expressed as the ratio of the variance of the true scores to the variance of
the observed scores:
Reliability = st2/(st2 + se2)
where st2 is the true score variance, and se2 is the measurement error variance.
With this definition, the range of values that the reliability can take is given by:
0 £ reliability £ 1.
A low value, close to zero, implies low reliability, while a high value, close to one, implies high
reliability.
Problems of measurement in psychiatry 123
TYPES OF RELIABILITY
∑ Inter-rater reliability. This describes the level of agreement between assessments of the same
material made by two or more assessors at roughly the same time.
∑ Intra-rater reliability. This describes the level of agreement between assessments made by two or
more assessors of the same material presented at two or more times.
∑ Test–retest reliability. This describes the level of agreement between assessments of the same
material made under similar circumstances but at two different times.
∑ Alternative-forms reliability. This describes the level of agreement between assessments of the
same material by two supposedly similar forms of the test or measuring instrument made either
at the same time or immediately consecutively.
∑ Split-half reliability. This describes the level of agreement between assessments by two halves of a
split test or measuring instrument of the same material made under similar circumstances.
Since some tests or measuring instruments contain different sections measuring different
aspects, in such cases it may be appropriate to create the halves by using alternative questions,
thereby maintaining the balance of each half.
KAPPA STATISTIC
The kappa statistic (or coefficient), k, is a measure of agreement in which allowance is made for
chance agreement. It is most appropriate when different categories of measurement are being
recorded and is calculated from the following formula:
k = (Po - Pc)/(1 - Pc)
where Pc is the chance agreement, and Po is the observed proportion of agreement.
The range of values that k can take is:
∑ k = 1: complete agreement
∑ 0 < k < 1: observed agreement > chance agreement
∑ k = 0: observed agreement = chance agreement
∑ k < 0: observed agreement < chance agreement.
The weighted kappa, kw, is a version of k that takes into account differences in the seriousness of
disagreements (represented by the weightings).
124 Principles of evaluation and psychometrics
CRONBACH’S ALPHA
Cronbach’s alpha, a, gives a measure of the average correlation between all the items when assessing
split-half reliability. It thereby indicates the internal consistency of the test or measuring
instrument.
Validity
The validity of a test or measuring instrument is the term used to describe whether it measures what
it purports to measure.
TYPES OF VALIDITY
∑ Face validity. This is the subjective judgement as to whether a test or measuring instrument
appears on the surface to measure the feature in question. In spite of its name it is not strictly a
type of validity.
∑ Content validity. This examines whether the specific measurements aimed for by the test or
measuring instrument are assessing the content of the measurement in question.
Problems of measurement in psychiatry 125
∑ Predictive validity. This determines the extent of agreement between a present measurement and
one in the future.
∑ Concurrent validity. This compares the measure being assessed with an external valid yardstick
at the same time.
∑ Criterion validity. This refers to predictive and concurrent validity together.
∑ Incremental validity. This indicates whether the measurement being assessed is superior to other
measurements in approaching true validity.
∑ Cross-validity. Cross-validation of a test or measuring instrument is used to determine whether,
after having its criterion validity established for one sample, it maintains criterion validity when
applied to another sample.
∑ Convergent validity. Convergent validity is established when measures expected to be correlated,
since they measure the same phenomena, are indeed found to be associated.
∑ Divergent validity. Divergent validity is established when measures discriminate successfully
between other measures of unrelated constructs.
∑ Construct validity. Construct validity is determined by establishing both convergent and
divergent validity, and is closely connected with the theoretical rationale underpinning the test
or measuring instrument. It involves showing the power of the hypothetical construct(s) or
latent traits both to explain observations and to make predictions.
Type I error
A type I error is the error of wrongly rejecting hypothesis H0 when it is true. As mentioned above,
the probability of making a type I error is denoted by a, the significance level:
a = P(type I error)
Type II error
A type II error is the error of wrongly accepting hypothesis H0 when it is false. The probability of
making a type II error is denoted by b:
b = P(type II error)
Power
The power of a test is the probability that hypothesis H0 is rejected when it is indeed false. It is related
to b, the probability of making a type II error, in the following way:
Power = 1 - b
Sensitivity
The sensitivity of a test or measuring instrument is the proportion of positive results/cases correctly
identified:
Sensitivity = (true positive)/(true positive plus false negative).
This ratio needs to be multiplied by 100 if the sensitivity is to be given as a percentage.
126 Principles of evaluation and psychometrics
Specificity
The specificity of a test or measuring instrument is the proportion of negative results/cases correctly
identified:
Specificity = (true negative)/(true negative plus false positive).
This ratio needs to be multiplied by 100 if the sensitivity is to be given as a percentage.
Predictive values
The predictive value of a positive result from a research measure is the proportion of the positive
results that is true positive:
Predictive value of a positive result = (true positive)/(true positive plus false positive).
The predictive value of a negative result from a research measure is the proportion of the negative
results that is true negative:
Predictive value of a negative result = (true negative)/(true negative plus false negative).
Biases
∑ Selection bias. This occurs when a characteristic associated with the variable(s) of interest leads
to higher or lower participation in the research study, such as an epidemiological cross-sectional
survey.
∑ Observer bias. In epidemiological studies, observer bias occurs when the researcher has clues
about whether the subject is in the case or comparison group, leading to a biased assessment.
This is particularly likely in studies involving retrospective assessments.
∑ Recall bias. In epidemiological studies, recall bias occurs when there is a difference in knowledge
between the subjects in the case and in the comparison groups, leading to a biased recall. For
example, in case–control studies the knowledge on the part of subjects (or, in the case of
childhood disorders, their parents) as to whether or not they have a given disorder may bias their
recall of exposure to putative risk factors.
∑ Information bias. Information bias includes both observer bias and recall bias.
∑ Confounding bias. In epidemiological studies, confounding bias occurs when the actual, but
unexamined, underlying cause of the disorder being researched is associated with both the
suspected risk factor and the disorder.
Meta-analysis
The term ‘meta-analysis’ is used to describe the process of evaluating and statistically combining
results from two or more existing independent randomized clinical trials addressing similar
questions in order to give an overall assessment.
Meta-analysis, survival analysis and logistic regression 127
DIFFICULTIES
The following are some difficulties associated with meta-analysis:
∑ There may be publication bias – trials showing a statistically significant difference are more
likely to be published than those not finding a statistically significant result.
∑ Researchers finding ‘non-significant’ results may be less likely formally to write up their results
for publication.
∑ One must arrive at selection criteria to determine which studies to include and which not to
include in the meta-analysis.
∑ The different centres in which the different clinical trials have taken place may differ with
respect to important variables in such a way as seriously to question the validity of combining
their data.
∑ If the meta-analysis is of clinical trials carried out on widely differing population groups, to
whom can the results of the meta-analysis properly be applied?
Survival analysis
This is a collection of statistical analysis techniques that can be applied to situations in which the
time to a given event, such as death, illness onset or recovery, is measured, but not all individuals
necessarily have to have reached this event during the overall time interval studied.
Survival function
The survival function, S(t), is given by:
S(t) = P(ts > t)
where t is time and ts is the survival time. The survival function is also given by:
S(t) = 1 minus cumulative distribution function of ts.
Survival curve
This is a plot of S(t) (on the ordinate) versus t (on the abscissa). Instead of being drawn as
continuous curves, sometimes survival curves are drawn in a stepwise fashion, with the steps
occurring between estimated cumulative survival probabilities.
Hazard function
This measures the likelihood of an individual experiencing a given event, such as death, illness onset
or recovery, as a function of time.
Logistic regression
This is a regression model used to predict the probability of a dichotomous variable, such as
better/not better at the end of the treatment period, on the basis of a set of independent variables,
x1 to xn:
P(event) = 1/{1 + exp[-(a0 + a1x1 + … + anxn)]}
where the coefficients a0 to an are estimated using a maximum-likelihood method.
128 Principles of evaluation and psychometrics
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Altman, D.G. 1991: Practical Statistics for Medical Research. London: Chapman & Hall.
Bryman, A. & Cramer, D. 1994: Quantitative Data Analysis for Social Scientists, revised edn. London: Routledge.
Cochran, W.G. 1954: Some methods for strengthening the common c2-test. Biometrics 10:417–451.
Coolican, H. 1994: Research Methods and Statistics in Psychology, 2nd edn. London: Hodder & Stoughton.
Dunn, G. & Everitt, B. 1995: Clinical Biostatistics: An Introduction to Evidence-based Medicine. London: Arnold.
Everitt, B. & Hay, D. 1992: Talking About Statistics: A Psychologist’s Guide to Design and Analysis. London: Arnold.
Puri, B.K. 1996: Statistics for the Health Sciences. London: W.B. Saunders.
Puri, B.K. 2002: SPSS in Practice: An Illustrated Guide, 2nd edn. London: Arnold.
7
Social sciences
DESCRIPTIVE TERMS
Social class
A social class is a segment of the population sharing a broadly similar type and level of resources,
with a broadly similar style of living and some shared perception of its common condition.
Determinants
The determinants of social class include:
∑ education
∑ financial status
∑ occupation
∑ type of residence
∑ geographical area of residence
∑ leisure activities.
Occupational classification
In British psychiatry, the following occupationally based classification given by the Office of
Population Censuses and Surveys has traditionally been used:
Social class I: professional, higher managerial, landowners
Social class II: intermediate
Social class III: skilled, manual, clerical
Social class IV: semi-skilled
Social class V: unskilled
Social class 0: unemployed, students.
Members of the same household are assigned to the social class of the head of the household.
130 Social sciences
Socioeconomic status
The socioeconomic status of an individual is his or her position in the social hierarchy. It is related
to social class and may increase, for example through educational achievement, or decrease, for
example through unemployment or mental illness.
Explanations
The following explanations for the relationship between social class and illness found in the Black
Report on socioeconomic inequalities in health have been suggested:
∑ Artefactual. The health inequalities found are artificial.
∑ Natural and social selection. Good health is associated with an improvement in social class while
poor health is associated with social drift downwards.
∑ Materialist/structural. Poor health is primarily a function of material deprivation. Inequalities in
wealth and income distribution are associated with inequalities in health.
∑ Cultural/behavioural. Certain unhealthy behaviour patterns are more common in lower social
classes (e.g. smoking, unhealthy diets), leading to health inequalities.
Max Weber
Max Weber was born in Erfurt in Prussia in 1864, and died in Munich, Germany, in 1920.
Bureaucracy
Weber studied bureaucracy, starting with his 1908 studies on Economies of Antiquity. He started by
outlining the development of modern forms of administration, and put forward the notion that
states in which the political machinery was centred around officialdom formed the basis of modern
bureaucratic structures. (He considered that ancient societies were not bureaucratic in the same
way.) He suggested that there existed the following types of bureaucracy:
∑ religious communities
∑ states
∑ economies
∑ the judiciary
∑ the modern agency
∑ the military.
Rationalization
Rationalization was the term used to denote the way in which nature, society and the actions of
individuals were oriented towards planning, technical procedures and rational actions.
Religion
According to Weber, social change can be caused by religious belief. He suggested that change can
both cause and be caused by ideas. His thesis of The Protestant Ethic and the Spirit of Capitalism
related capitalism to Protestantism. He had noted that, in his native Germany, there was a positive
association between success in capitalist ventures and being of the Protestant faith or background.
This association was caused, according to Weber, by the consequences of Puritan theology (as a
reaction to the severity of Calvinism). For example, the combination of the work ethic (based on the
Fourth Commandment), the belief that gain of wealth was a sign of being blessed, and an ascetic
unwillingness of Puritans to enjoy the fruits of such labour themselves, would lead overall to yet
further accumulation of capital.
Karl Marx
Karl Heinrich Marx was born in Trier in Prussia in 1818, and died in London, England, in 1883.
Communism
After he and his wife (newly wed) moved to Paris in 1843, Marx became a communist, authoring
Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844 (which was not published for about a century). In
collaboration with Engels, he co-authored The German Ideology in 1845/6 (published in 1932), in
which it was argued that historically nation states and societies generally had developed in such a
way that the interests of the economically dominant class were favoured. (Such arguments might
account for the difficulty that Marx and Engels encountered in trying to find a publisher for this
work.) Some of the unpublished ideas contained in this work were summarized by Marx and Engels
Historical sociological theories 133
in their 1848 pamphlet The Communist Manifesto. Here, they also argued that all history had
fundamentally been a history of class struggle.
Crime
Marx argued that powerful entities, such as corporations, could influence the definition of crime.
Thus, while white collar crime was deemed punishable, acts by more privileged members of society,
such as fraud and tax evasion, might go unpunished. Furthermore, corporate crimes might be
carried out in order to increase company profits, even if they involved engaging in activities that
may harm people (for instance, not paying heed to laws on health and safety, or disposing of toxic
waste inappropriately).
Religion
Arguing that religion was ‘an opiate of the masses’, Marx held that religion came from the oppressed
but benefited those at the top in society. He thought that organized religion:
∑ helped to anaesthetize the pain caused by oppression
∑ promised a reward in heaven or the after-life for those who endured oppression in their current
lives
∑ provided justification for the current social order, including the position in this that a believer
found themselves in
∑ promised that good behaviour would be rewarded
∑ suggested to the population that the current problems on the planet would be solved through
divine intervention.
Emile Durkheim
Emile Durkheim was born in Epinal in France in 1858, and died in Paris, France, in 1917.
Anomie
Durkheim introduced the term ‘anomie’ to refer to social disconnectedness or a lack of social
norms, which may be caused by a change in an individual’s relationship with his or her social group,
in which norms for conduct are absent, weak or conflicting. Two types of anomie may be
distinguished (Boulton, 1998):
∑ Acute anomie. This is caused by a sudden change or crisis that leaves the individual in an
unfamiliar situation.
∑ Chronic anomie. This refers to circumstances in which the rules of a social group have become
unclear to the individual or do not provide the means of meeting his or her aspirations.
Causes of acute anomie include:
∑ migration
∑ bereavement
∑ work redundancy.
Causes of chronic anomie include:
∑ homelessness
∑ long-term unemployment.
Widespread anomie may lead to a breakdown in social order. Durkheim considered that science
(in particular, social science), educational reform, and religion were ways of avoiding this.
134 Social sciences
Suicide
In his 1897 work Suicide, Durkheim suggested that there appeared to be an inverse relationship
between, on the one hand, how integrated individuals were in their society and culture, and, on the
other hand, the rate of suicide. A major cause of suicide, then, could be seen in terms of social forces.
According to Durkheim there were, in fact, three types of suicide:
∑ Altruistic suicide. This results from social integration in a culture that accepts suicide as a way of
expiating shame or blame.
∑ Egoistic suicide. This results in the context of the individual being socially further distanced from
social norms and restraints, such that meaning is questioned.
∑ Anomic suicide. This also results in the context of the individual being socially further distanced
from social norms and restraints, in which anomie exists.
Michel Foucault
Michel Foucault was born in Poitiers in France in 1926, and died in Paris, France, in 1984.
Principles of exclusion
In books such as his 1975 work Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison, Foucault put forward
his thesis that society uses institutions to carry out social exclusion. Such institutions included, he
argued, the following:
∑ asylums
∑ hospitals
∑ prisons.
With regard to mental illness, Foucault argued that one of the principles of exclusion that society
uses to define itself is the distinction between sanity and insanity.
Sexuality
Foucault made a study of the history of sexuality from ancient times. This was published in his 1976
to 1984 three-volume work History of Sexuality.
Talcott Parsons
Talcott Parsons was born in Colorado Springs in the USA in 1902, and died in Munich, Germany, in
1979. Aspects of his contribution to sociological theories are given elsewhere in this chapter.
Erving Goffman
Erving Goffman was born in Canada in 1922, and died in Philadelphia, USA, in 1982. Aspects of his
contribution to sociological theories are given elsewhere in this chapter.
Jürgen Habermas
Jürgen Habermas was born in 1929 in Düsseldorf, Germany. In his two-volume magnus opus, The
Theory of Communicative Action, Habermas built on the sociological theories of Max Weber, George
Social roles of doctors and illness 135
Herbert Mead, Emile Durkheim and Talcott Parsons to suggest reasoning capacities, besides
traditional cognitive–instrumental reasoning, which carry out subjective and inter-subjective
functions within the framework of societal interactions. He has gone on to defend modern society
and civil society.
SOCIAL ROLE
The social role of an individual in society is the pattern of behaviour in given social situations
expected of that person in relation to his or her social status. It consists of:
∑ obligations – behaviours towards others expected of the individual
∑ rights – behaviours from others expected in return for obligations.
Rights (privileges)
According to Parsons, the sick role carries the following two rights for the sick individual:
∑ exemption from blame for the illness
∑ exemption from normal responsibilities while sick, such as the need to go to work.
Obligations
The sick individual has the following obligations:
∑ the wish to recover as soon as possible, including seeking appropriate help from the doctor
∑ cooperation with medical investigations and acceptance of medical advice and treatment.
Illness behaviour
Illness behaviour is a set of stages describing the behaviour adopted by sick individuals (Mechanic,
1978). It describes the way in which individuals respond to somatic symptoms and signs and the
136 Social sciences
conditions under which they come to view them as abnormal. Illness behaviour therefore involves
the manner in which individuals:
∑ monitor their bodies
∑ define and interpret their symptoms and signs
∑ take remedial action
∑ utilize sources of help.
Family life is guided by the explicit and implicit relationship rules that prescribe and limit the
behaviour of members of the family and provide expectations within the family with respect to the
roles, actions and consequences of individuals.
Schizophrenia
Historically, the following types of family dysfunction were at various times believed to be a cause
of schizophrenia:
∑ schizophrenogenic mother
∑ double-bind
∑ marital skew and marital schism
∑ abnormal family communications.
These theories are now out of favour, but there is evidence for the more recent theory relating to the
effects of expressed emotion with respect to relapse in schizophrenia.
Schizophrenogenic mother
This concept was put forward by Fromm-Reichman in 1948. Schizophrenia was said to be a
consequence of an inadequate relationship between the future sufferer from schizophrenia, as a
child, and his or her mother. Characteristics of the schizophrenogenic mother were said to include
her being:
∑ rejecting
∑ aloof
∑ overly protective
∑ overtly hostile.
Double-bind
This concept was put forward by Bateson and colleagues in 1956. The parents communicated with
the child (the future sufferer from schizophrenia) in abnormal ways leading to feelings of
ambivalence and ambiguity, with messages that were typically:
∑ vague
∑ ambiguous
∑ confusing.
Schizophrenia developed as a result of exposure to such double-bind situations.
Expressed emotion
In an outcome study of 200 patients, mainly with schizophrenia, Brown et al. (1958) found that
those discharged to their families had a poor outcome, with the highest relapse rate occurring in
those families having close and frequent contact with the patients.
Subsequent follow-up studies have confirmed the association of high expressed emotion in
families, characterized by the frequent, intense expression of emotion and a pushy and critical
attitude by relatives to the patient, with an increased relapse rate in family members with
schizophrenia.
In assessing expressed emotion, the five relevant scales of the Camberwell Family Interview (CFI)
are:
∑ critical comments: indicating unambiguous dislike or disapproval
∑ hostility: expressed towards the person rather than his or her behaviour
∑ emotional over-involvement: exaggerated self-sacrificing or over-protective concern
∑ warmth: based on sympathy, affection and empathy
∑ positive remarks: expressing praise or approval of the patient.
The first three of these are associated with high expressed emotion and predict relapse (Vaughn &
Leff, 1976), as shown in Table 7.1.
Table 7.1 Effects of expressed emotion on the relapse rates of treated and untreated patients
with schizophrenia in the 9 months following discharge
Mood disorders
Expressed emotion
As with schizophrenia, high expressed emotion at home is associated with an increased risk of
relapse of depression.
Vulnerability factors
Two of the four vulnerability factors found by Brown and Harris to make women more susceptible
to suffer from depression following life events (see below) were:
∑ lack of a confiding relationship
∑ having three or more children under the age of 15 years at home.
Life events 139
LIFE EVENTS
Definition
Life events are sudden changes, which may be positive or negative, in an individual’s social life which
disrupt its normal course.
Life-change scale
Table 7.2 gives some life-change values for life events in the Holmes and Rahe Social Readjustment
Rating Scale (after Holmes & Rahe, 1967).
The full Holmes and Rahe Social Readjustment Rating Scale introduced in 1967 consists of a self-
report questionnaire containing 43 classes of life event.
∑ The occurrence of life events should correlate with onset of the disorder.
∑ The life events should precede the onset of the disorder and not the other way round.
∑ A hypothetical construct should exist with confounded variables excluded.
∑ The relationship between life events and the psychiatric disorder should be found to occur in
different populations and at different times.
∑ high reliability
∑ high validity.
Clinical significance
Depression
Many studies have found a relationship between life events and the onset of depression. In the 6–12
months prior to the onset, compared with normal controls, patients have a three- to five-fold greater
chance of having suffered at least one life event with major negative long-term implications
(involving threat or loss). However, most people who experience adverse life events do not develop
depression; as mentioned above, Brown and Harris (1978) identified four vulnerability factors that
make women more susceptible to suffer from depression following life events:
∑ loss of mother before the age of 11 years
∑ not working outside the home
∑ a lack of a confiding relationship
∑ having three or more children under the age of 15 years at home.
Schizophrenia
The evidence tends to suggest that independent life events are more likely to occur prior to relapse
rather than prior to first onset of schizophrenia (Brown & Birley, 1968; Tennant, 1985).
Anxiety
There is some evidence that life events are more likely to occur prior to anxiety (Finlay-Jones &
Brown, 1981; Miller & Ingham, 1985). From their study of life events occurring in the year before
the onset of three types of cases of psychiatric disorder of recent onset (depression, anxiety, and
mixed depression/anxiety) in young women, and normal controls, Finlay-Jones and Brown (1981)
argued that a life event involving severe loss was a causal agent in the onset of depression, and life
events involving severe danger were a causal agent in the onset of anxiety states. Cases of mixed
depression/anxiety were more likely to report both a severe loss and a severe danger before onset.
Mania
In general, the results of life-event studies of mania are conflicting.
Parasuicide/deliberate self-harm
There is strong evidence that threatening life events are more common prior to self-poisoning
attempts (e.g. Morgan et al., 1975; Farmer & Creed, 1989).
Functional disorders
Threatening life events have been found to be more likely to precede functional disorders presenting
physically such as abdominal pain without an organic cause (Creed, 1981; Craig & Brown, 1984)
and menorrhagia (Harris, 1989).
RESIDENTIAL INSTITUTIONS
∑ the family
∑ political parties
∑ religious groups.
GOFFMAN
From his study of the large St Elizabeth’s Hospital in Washington, DC, Goffman (1961) was one of
the first to suggest that institutions may be harmful. Concepts introduced by Goffman include:
∑ The total institution.
∑ Binary management. The daily lives of patients were highly regulated by staff who appeared to
live in a different world to the patients.
∑ Binary living.
∑ Batch living. Whereas normally life consists of a balance between work, home life and leisure
time, these three distinct entities did not exist in the total institution studied.
∑ Institutional perspective. The existence of an institutional perspective leads to the assumption
that there exists an overall rational plan.
∑ Mortification process. This is the process whereby an individual becomes an inhabitant of a total
institution.
∑ Betrayal funnel. This is the start of the mortification process through which relatives, via
doctors, send the individual into a psychiatric hospital.
∑ Role-stripping. The patient is processed through the admissions procedure, which would also
usually include being physically stripped naked for the purposes of a physical examination.
∑ Patient/inmate role. Patients or inmates could be considered to be metaphorically baptized into
this role through the admissions procedure, which would usually include bathing before being
given institutional clothing.
∑ Moral career. There are gradual changes in perception of patients about themselves and others,
occurring as a result of institutionalization.
INSTITUTIONAL NEUROSIS
Barton (1959) used the term ‘institutional neurosis’ to describe a syndrome he considered to be
caused by institutions in which the individual shows:
∑ apathy
∑ inability to plan for the future
∑ submissiveness
∑ withdrawal
∑ low self-esteem.
PREVALENCE OF SCHIZOPHRENIA
In Britain, there is a higher rate of diagnosis of schizophrenia in Afro-Caribbean and Irish
populations, compared with the indigenous population, and a lower rate in those of South Asian
origin.
∑ Those who migrate from their countries of origin have a greater likelihood of having
schizophrenia or a predisposition for schizophrenia (social selection). However, there is a
reduced rate in Asians and an increased rate in second-generation Afro-Caribbeans.
∑ Migration is associated with increased stress leading to an increased precipitation of
schizophrenia in those with an underlying predisposition. However, there is a reduced rate in
Asians and an increased rate in second-generation Afro-Caribbeans.
∑ Discrimination and deprivation lead to an increased rate of schizophrenia, or an increased
precipitation of schizophrenia in those with an underlying predisposition (social causation).
However, there is a reduced rate in Asians.
∑ Schizophrenia is over-diagnosed in Afro-Caribbeans.
PROFESSIONS
CHARACTERISTICS OF PROFESSIONS
The characteristics of professional status include:
∑ the possession of practical skills based on theoretical knowledge aquired over an extended
period of formal training/education
∑ assessments of competence carried out by the profession
∑ belonging to an organization
∑ recognition by the state of the professional organization
∑ adherence to a code of conduct
∑ providing altruistic service
∑ the possession of a monopoly of practice in a particular field.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Wing, J.K. 1978: Schizophrenia: Towards A New Synthesis. London: Academic Press.
Wing, J.K. & Brown, G.W. 1961: Social treatment of chronic schizophrenia: a comparative survey of three mental
hospitals. Journal of Mental Science 107:847–861.
Wing, J.K. & Brown, G.W. 1970: Institutionalism and Schizophrenia: A Comparative Study of Three Mental
Hospitals 1960–1968. London: Cambridge University Press.
8
Descriptive psychopathology
UNDER-ACTIVITY
Stupor
The key features of stupor, when the term is used in its psychiatric sense, include:
∑ mutism
∑ immobility
∑ occasional periods of excitement and over-activity.
Stupor is seen in:
∑ catatonic stupor
∑ depressive stupor
∑ manic stupor
∑ epilepsy
∑ hysteria.
In neurology the term ‘stupor’ refers to a person who responds to pain and loud sounds, and may
exhibit brief monosyllabic utterances and some spontaneous motor activity takes place.
Depressive retardation
This is a lesser form of psychomotor retardation occurring in depression which, in its extreme form,
merges with depressive stupor.
Obsessional slowness
This may occur secondary to repeated doubts and compulsive rituals.
OVER-ACTIVITY
Psychomotor agitation
A person with psychomotor agitation manifests:
148 Descriptive psychopathology
Hyperkinesis
In hyperkinesis, which may be seen in children and adolescents, the following features occur:
∑ over-activity
∑ distractibility
∑ impulsivity
∑ excitability.
∑ Tics. These are repeated irregular movements involving a muscle group and may be seen
following encephalitis, in Huntington’s disease and in Gilles de la Tourette’s syndrome, for
example.
∑ Parkinsonism. The features of parkinsonism include:
∑ a resting tremor
∑ cogwheel rigidity
∑ postural abnormalities
∑ a festinant gait.
DISORDERS OF SPEECH
∑ Thought blocking. There is a sudden interruption in the train of thought, before it is completed,
leaving a ‘blank’. After a period of silence, the person cannot recall what he or she had been
saying or had been thinking of saying.
DISORDERS OF EMOTION
DISORDERS OF AFFECT
Affect is a pattern of observable behaviours which is the expression of a subjectively experienced
feeling state (emotion), and is variable over time, in response to changing emotional states (DSM-
IV-TR).
∑ Blunted affect. In a person with a blunted affect the externalized feeling tone is severely reduced.
∑ Flat affect. This consists of a total or almost total absence of signs of expression of affect.
∑ Inappropriate affect. This is an affect that is inappropriate to the thought or speech it
accompanies.
∑ Labile affect. A person with a labile affect has a labile externalized feeling tone which is not
related to environmental stimuli.
DISORDERS OF MOOD
Mood is a pervasive and sustained emotion which, in the extreme, markedly colours the person’s
perception of the world (DSM-IV-TR).
∑ Dysphoria. This is an unpleasant mood.
∑ Depression. This is a low or depressed mood. It may be accompanied by anhedonia, in which the
ability to enjoy pleasurable activities is lost. In normal grief or mourning, the sadness is
appropriate to the loss.
∑ Elation. This is an elevated mood or exaggerated feeling of well-being that is pathological. It is
seen in mania.
∑ Euphoria. This is a personal and subjective feeling of unconcern and contentment, usually seen
after taking opiates or as a late sequel to head injury.
∑ Irritability. This is a liability to outbursts or a state of reduced control over aggressive impulses
towards others. It may be a personality trait or may accompany anxiety. It also occurs in
premenstrual syndrome.
Disorders of thought content 151
∑ Apathy. There is a loss of emotional tone and the ability to feel pleasure, associated with
detachment or indifference.
∑ Alexithymia. This is difficulty in the awareness of or description of one’s emotions.
PREOCCUPATIONS
∑ Hypochondriasis. This is a preoccupation with a fear of having a serious illness which is not
based on real organic pathology but instead on an unrealistic interpretation of physical signs or
sensations as being abnormal.
∑ Monomania. This is a pathological preoccupation with a single object.
∑ Egomania. This is a pathological preoccupation with oneself.
OBSESSIONS
Obsessions are repetitive senseless thoughts which are recognized as irrational by the person and
which are unsuccessfully resisted. Themes include:
∑ aggression
∑ dirt and contamination
∑ fear of causing harm
∑ religious
∑ sexual.
PHOBIAS
A phobia is a persistent irrational fear of an activity, object or situation leading to avoidance. The
fear is out of proportion to the real danger and cannot be reasoned away, being out of voluntary
control. Some types of phobia are:
∑ Acrophobia is a fear of heights.
∑ Agoraphobia literally means a fear of the market place. It is a syndrome with a generalized high
anxiety level anxiety about, or avoidance of, places or situations from which escape might be
difficult, or embarrassing, or in which help may not be available in the event of having a panic
152 Descriptive psychopathology
attack or panic-like symptoms. Objects of fear may include crowds, open and closed spaces,
shopping, social situations, and travelling by public transport.
∑ Algophobia is a fear of pain.
∑ Claustrophobia is a fear of closed spaces.
∑ Social phobia is a fear of personal interactions in a public setting, such as public speaking, eating
in public, and meeting people.
∑ Specific (simple) phobia is a fear of discrete objects (e.g. snakes) or situations.
∑ Xenophobia is a fear of strangers.
∑ Zoophobia is a fear of animals.
∑ Phobias of internal stimuli. These include obsessive phobias and illness phobias, which overlap
with hypochondriasis.
OVER-VALUED IDEAS
An overvalued idea is an unreasonable and sustained intense preoccupation maintained with less
than delusional intensity; that is, the person is able to acknowledge the possibility that the belief may
not be true. The idea or belief held is demonstrably false and is not one that is normally held by
others of the person’s subculture. There is a marked associated emotional investment.
DELUSIONS
A delusion is a false belief based on incorrect inference about external reality that is firmly sustained
despite what almost everyone else believes and despite what constitutes incontrovertible and
obvious proof or evidence to the contrary. The belief is not one ordinarily accepted by other
members of the person’s culture or subculture (e.g. it is not an article of religious faith). When a false
belief involves a value judgement, it is regarded as a delusion only when the judgement is so extreme
as to defy credibility (DSM-IV-TR).
∑ Mood-congruent delusion. The content of the delusion is appropriate to the mood of the
person.
∑ Mood-incongruent delusion. The content of the delusion is not appropriate to the mood of the
person.
∑ Primary delusion. A delusion that arises fully formed without any discernible connection with
previous events. It may be preceded by a delusional mood in which the person is aware of
something strange and threatening happening.
∑ Bizarre delusion. A delusion involving a phenomenon that the person’s culture would regard as
totally implausible.
∑ Delusional jealousy (pathological jealousy; Othello syndrome; delusion of infidelity). A delusion
that one’s sexual partner is unfaithful.
∑ Delusion of being controlled. Feelings, impulses, thoughts, or actions of the person are
experienced as being under the control of some external force rather than under his or her own
control.
∑ Delusion of doubles (l’illusion de sosies). A delusion that a person known to the person has been
replaced by a double. It is seen in Capgras’ syndrome.
∑ Delusion of poverty. A delusion that one is in poverty.
∑ Delusion of reference. The theme is that events, objects or other people in one’s immediate
Abnormal experiences 153
environment have a particular and unusual significance. These delusions are usually of a
negative or pejorative nature, but also may be grandiose in content (DSM-IV). When similar
thoughts are held with less than delusional intensity they are ideas of reference.
∑ Delusion of self-accusation. A delusion of one’s own guilt.
∑ Erotomania (de Clérambault’s syndrome). A delusion that another person, usually of higher
status, is deeply in love with the individual.
∑ Grandiose delusion. A delusion of inflated worth, power, knowledge, identity, or special
relationship to a deity or famous person.
∑ Persecutory (querulant) delusion. The central theme is that one (or someone to whom one is
close) is being attacked, harassed, cheated, persecuted, or conspired against (DSM-IV-TR).
∑ Somatic delusion. A delusion whose main content pertains to the appearance or functioning of
one’s body (DSM-IV-TR).
PASSIVITY PHENOMENON
This is a delusional belief that an external agency is controlling aspects of the self which are
normally entirely under one’s own control. Passivity phenomena include the following:
∑ Thought alienation. The person believes that his or her thoughts are under the control of an
outside agency or that others are participating in his or her thinking; it includes:
∑ thought insertion: the delusion that certain of one’s thoughts are not one’s own, but rather
are inserted into one’s mind by an external agency
∑ thought withdrawal: the delusion that one’s thoughts are being removed from one’s mind by
an external agency
∑ thought broadcasting: the delusion that one’s thoughts are being broadcast out loud so that
they can be perceived by others.
∑ Made feelings. This is the delusional belief that one’s own free will has been removed and that an
external agency is controlling one’s feelings.
∑ Made impulses. This is the delusional belief that one’s own free will has been removed and that
an external agency is controlling one’s impulses.
∑ Made actions. This is the delusional belief that one’s own free will has been removed and that an
external agency is controlling one’s actions.
∑ Somatic passivity. This is the delusional belief that one is a passive recipient of somatic or bodily
sensations from an external agency.
DELUSIONAL PERCEPTION
In a delusional perception the person attaches a new and delusional significance to a familiar real
perception without any logical reason.
ABNORMAL EXPERIENCES
SENSORY DISTORTIONS
∑ Hyperaesthesias. These are changes in sensory perception in which there is an increased intensity
of sensation. Hyperacusis is an increased sensitivity to sounds.
∑ Hypoaesthesias. These are changes in sensory perception in which there is an decreased intensity
of sensation. Hypoacusis is a decreased sensitivity to sounds.
154 Descriptive psychopathology
∑ Changes in quality. Changes in quality of sensations occur particularly with visual stimuli, giving
rise to visual distortions. Colourings of visual perceptions include:
∑ chloropsia – green
∑ erythropsia – red
∑ xanthopsia – yellow.
∑ Dysmegalopsia. Changes in spatial form include:
∑ macropsia: objects are seen larger or nearer than is actually the case
∑ micropsia: objects are seen smaller or farther away than is actually the case.
SENSORY DECEPTIONS
Illusions
An illusion is a false perception of a real external stimulus.
Hallucinations
A hallucination is a false sensory perception in the absence of a real external stimulus. A
hallucination is perceived as being located in objective space and as having the same realistic
qualities as normal perceptions. It is not subject to conscious manipulation and only indicates a
psychotic disturbance when there is also impaired reality testing. Hallucinations can be mood
congruent or mood incongruent. Types of hallucination include:
∑ auditory
∑ autoscopy (phantom mirror image): the person sees himself or herself and knows that it is he or
she
∑ extracampine: the hallucination occurs outside the person’s sensory field
∑ functional: the stimulus causing the hallucination is experienced in addition to the hallucination
itself
∑ gustatory
∑ hallucinosis: hallucinations (usually auditory) occur in clear consciousness
∑ hypnagogic: the hallucination (usually visual or auditory) occurs while falling asleep
∑ hypnopompic: the hallucination (usually visual or auditory) occurs while waking from sleep
∑ olfactory
∑ reflex: a stimulus in one sensory field leads to a hallucination in another sensory field
∑ somatic: somatic hallucinations include:
∑ tactile (haptic) hallucinations: superficial and usually involving sensations on or just under
the skin in the absence of a real stimulus; these include the sensation of insects crawling
under the skin (formication)
∑ visceral hallucinations of deep sensations
∑ trailing phenomenon: moving objects are seen as a series of discrete discontinuous images
∑ visual.
Pseudo-hallucinations
A pseudo-hallucination is a form of imagery arising in the subjective inner space of the mind. It
lacks the substantiality of normal perceptions and occupies subjective space rather than objective
space. It is not subject to conscious manipulation. An eidetic image is a vivid and detailed
reproduction of a previous perception. In pareidolia, vivid imagery occurs without conscious effort
while looking at a poorly structured background.
Cognitive disorders 155
COGNITIVE DISORDERS
DISORIENTATION
This is a disturbance of orientation in time, place or person.
DISORDERS OF ATTENTION
∑ Distractibility. A distractible subject’s attention is drawn too frequently to unimportant or
irrelevant external stimuli.
∑ Selective inattention. In selective inattention, anxiety-provoking stimuli are blocked out.
DISORDERS OF MEMORY
∑ Amnesia. This is the inability to recall past experiences.
∑ Hypermnesia. In hypermnesia the degree of retention and recall is exaggerated.
∑ Paramnesia. A paramnesia is a distorted recall leading to falsification of memory. Paramnesias
include:
∑ confabulation: gaps in memory are unconsciously filled with false memories
∑ déjà vu: the subject feels that the current situation has been seen or experienced before
∑ déjà entendu: the illusion of auditory recognition
∑ déjà pensé: the illusion of recognition of a new thought
∑ jamais vu: the illusion of failure to recognize a familiar situation
∑ retrospective falsification: false details are added to the recollection of an otherwise real
memory.
DISORDERS OF INTELLIGENCE
∑ Learning disability (mental retardation). Learning difficulty or mental retardation is classified by
DSM-IV-TR and ICD-10 according to the intelligence quotient (IQ) of the subject:
∑ 50 £ IQ £ 70 (50 £ IQ £ 69 in ICD-10): mild mental retardation
∑ 35 £ IQ £ 49: moderate mental retardation
∑ 20 £ IQ £ 34: severe mental retardation
∑ IQ < 20: profound mental retardation.
∑ Dementia. This is a global organic impairment of intellectual functioning without impairment
of consciousness.
∑ Pseudo-dementia. This resembles dementia clinically, but is not organic in origin.
156 Descriptive psychopathology
DISORDERS OF CONSCIOUSNESS
Levels of consciousness
The neurological terms used to describe progressively more unconscious levels are as follows:
∑ Somnolence (drowsiness). A subject who is drowsy or somnolent can be awoken by mild stimuli
and will be able to speak comprehensibly, albeit perhaps for only a little while before falling
asleep again.
∑ Stupor. A stuporose person responds to pain and loud sounds. Brief monosyllabic utterances
and some spontaneous motor activity may occur.
∑ Semi-coma. A semi-comatose person will withdraw from the source of pain but spontaneous
motor activity does not take place.
∑ Deep coma. No response can be elicited and there is no response to deep pain nor is there any
spontaneous movement. Tendon, pupillary and corneal reflexes are usually absent.
∑ Death.
Clouding of consciousness
The person is drowsy and does not react completely to stimuli. There is disturbance of attention,
concentration, memory, orientation and thinking.
Delirium
The person is bewildered, disoriented and restless. There may be associated fear and hallucinations.
Variations include:
∑ oneiroid state: a dream-like state in a person who is not asleep
∑ torpor: the person is drowsy and easily falls asleep
∑ twilight state: a prolonged oneiroid state of disturbed consciousness with hallucinations.
Fugue
This is a state of wandering from the usual surroundings in which there is also loss of memory.
APHASIAS
∑ Receptive (sensory) aphasia (Wernicke’s fluent aphasia). Difficulty is experienced in
comprehending the meaning of words. Types include:
∑ agnosic alexia: words can be seen but cannot be read
∑ pure word deafness: words that are heard cannot be comprehended
∑ visual asymbolia: words can be transcribed but cannot be read.
∑ Intermediate aphasia. Types of intermediate aphasia include:
∑ central (syntactical) aphasia: there is difficulty in arranging words in their proper sequence
∑ nominal aphasia: there is difficulty in naming objects.
∑ Expressive (motor) aphasia (Broca’s nonfluent aphasia). This refers to difficulty in expressing
thoughts in words while comprehension remains.
∑ Global aphasia. Both receptive aphasia and expressive aphasia are present at the same time.
∑ Jargon aphasia: The person utters incoherent meaningless neologistic speech.
Apraxias and agnosias 157
APRAXIAS
Apraxia is an inability to perform purposive volitional acts, which does not result from paresis,
incoordination, sensory loss or involuntary movements. It may be considered to be the motor
equivalent of agnosia.
∑ Constructional apraxia. There is difficulty in constructing objects or copying drawings. This is
closely associated with visuospatial agnosia, with some authorities treating the two as being
essentially the same.
∑ Dressing apraxia. There is difficulty in putting on one’s clothes correctly.
∑ Ideomotor apraxia. There is difficulty in carrying out progressively more difficult tasks, for
example involving touching parts of the face with specified fingers.
∑ Ideational apraxia. There is difficulty in carrying out a coordinated sequence of actions.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Hamilton, M. (ed.) 1985: Fish’s Clinical Psychopathology, 2nd edn. Bristol: Wright.
Institute of Psychiatry 1973: Notes on Eliciting and Recording Clinical Information. Oxford: Oxford University
Press.
Leff, J.P. & Isaacs, A.D. 1990: Psychiatric Examination in Clinical Practice, 3rd edn. Oxford: Blackwell Scientific.
Sims, A.C.P. 1985: Symptoms in the Mind. London: Baillière Tindall.
9
Psychoanalytic theories
EARLY INFLUENCES
Those who had an important early influence on Freud, and his pre-psychoanalytic theories,
included:
∑ Helmholz and Brücke – the physicochemical basis of brain function; concepts of energy and
conservation; the Helmholtz School of Medicine
∑ Meynert – neuroanatomy and behaviour
∑ Charcot – hysteria and hypnosis.
Freud also gained important ideas from the writings of:
∑ Darwin – the theory of evolution by natural selection
∑ Hughlings Jackson – the relationship of brain structure and function.
6 Bringing the event(s) to consciousness leads to a discharge or release of the associated affects
(‘psychic pus’) and resolution of the hysterical symptomatology (abreaction).
Technical development
The techniques employed by Freud progressed gradually through the following major phases:
∑ The use of hypnosis.
∑ The concentration method. The patient, lying on a couch with eyes closed, was asked leading
questions, and Freud would press his hands on the patient’s forehead.
∑ Free association. The patient, with open eyes but lying on a couch, was encouraged to articulate,
without censorship, all thoughts that came to mind.
The unconscious
This contains memories, ideas and affects that are repressed. Characteristic features include:
∑ outside awareness
∑ operating system – primary process thinking
∑ motivating principle – the pleasure principle
∑ access – access to its repressed contents is difficult, occurring when the censor gives way, for
instance by becoming:
∑ relaxed (e.g. in dreaming)
∑ fooled (e.g. in jokes)
∑ overpowered (e.g. in neurotic symptomatology)
∑ system position:
∑ no negation
∑ timelessness (reference to time is bound up in unconsciousness)
∑ image-oriented
∑ connotative
∑ symbolic
∑ non-linear.
The preconscious
This part of the mind develops during childhood and serves to maintain repression and censorship.
Characteristic features include:
∑ outside awareness
∑ operating system – secondary process thinking
∑ motivating principle – the reality principle
∑ access – access can occur through focused attention
∑ system position:
Sigmund Freud (1856–1939) 161
∑ bound by time
∑ word-oriented
∑ denotative
∑ linear.
The conscious
The conscious can be considered to be an attention sensory organ. Characteristic features include:
∑ within awareness
∑ operating system – secondary process thinking
∑ motivating principle – the reality principle
∑ access – easy
∑ system position:
∑ bound by time
∑ word-oriented
∑ declarative
∑ linear.
Censorship
Freud described the censorship process in the following way:
Let us compare the system of the unconscious to a large entrance hall, in which the mental impulses
jostle one another like separate individuals. Adjoining this entrance hall there is a second narrow room,
a kind of drawing room, in which consciousness also resides but on the threshold between these two
rooms a watchman performs his function; he examines the different mental impulses, acts as a censor,
and will not admit them into the drawing room if they displease him. It does not make much difference
if the watchman turns away from a particular impulse at the threshold itself or if he pushes it back
across the threshold after it has entered the drawing room. If they have already pushed their way
forward to the threshold and have been turned back by the watchman then they are inadmissible to
the consciousness; we speak of them as repressed but even the impulses which the watchman has
allowed to cross the threshold are not on that account necessarily conscious as well; they can only
become so if they succeed in catching the eye of consciousness. They are therefore justified in calling
the second room the system of the preconscious.
Primary process
This is the operating system of the unconscious. Its attributes include:
∑ displacement: an apparently insignificant idea is invested with all the psychical depth of meaning
and intensity originally attributed to another idea
∑ condensation: all the meanings and several chains of association converge on to a single idea
standing at their point of intersection
∑ symbolization: symbols are used rather than words.
Characteristics of primary process thinking include (Sklar, 1989):
∑ timelessness: the concept of time only develops after a period in the mind of a child in
connection to conscious reality (e.g. periodicity or chaos of feeding)
∑ disregard of reality of the conscious world
∑ psychical reality: memories of a real event and of imagined experience are not distinguished;
abstract symbols are treated concretely
∑ absence of contradiction: opposites have a psychic equivalence
∑ absence of negation.
162 Psychoanalytic theories
Secondary process
This is the operating system of the preconscious and the conscious.
∑ Time flows forward linearly.
∑ Reality is regarded – the content and logical basis of ideas is important.
∑ Verbal word-presentations are used.
∑ Contradictions are recognized and should not exist.
Pleasure principle
This is the motivating principle of primary process. It is mainly inborn. Pain/‘unpleasure’ is avoided
and pleasure is sought through tension discharge. This leads to:
∑ wish fulfilment
∑ the discharge of instinctual drives.
Reality principle
This is the motivating principle of secondary process. It is the result of external reality. It leads to:
∑ delayed gratification.
DREAMING
In his The Interpretation of Dreams (1900), Freud referred to dreams as ‘the Royal Road to the
Unconscious’.
Dream composition
Dreams were considered to be composed of:
∑ day residue: memories of the waking hours before the dream that are particularly emotionally
charged
∑ nocturnal stimuli: external stimuli (e.g. noise, moisture, touch), and internal stimuli (e.g. pain,
urinary bladder distension)
∑ unconscious wishes
∑ latent dream: the day residue, nocturnal stimuli and unconscious wishes.
Dream work
This refers to the process whereby the latent dream is converted into the manifest dream.
Operations that contribute to dream work can include:
∑ displacement
∑ condensation
∑ symbolization
∑ secondary elaboration (secondary revision) – the process of revising and/or elaborating the
dream after awakening in order to make it more consistent with the rules of secondary process.
The id
Most of the id is unconscious. It contains primordial energy reserves derived from instinctual
drives. Its aim is to maximize pleasure by fulfilling these drives.
The ego
According to Freud, the principal characteristics of the ego are as follows:
In consequence of the preestablished connection between sense and perception and muscular action,
the ego has voluntary movement at its command. It has the task of self-preservation. As regards
external events, it performs that task by becoming aware of stimuli by storing up experiences about
them (in the memory), by avoiding excessively strong stimuli (through adaptation), and finally by
learning to bring about expedient changes in the external world to its own advantage (through
activity). As regards internal events in relation to the id, it performs that task by gaining control over
the demands of the instinct, by deciding whether they are to be allowed satisfaction, by postponing
that satisfaction to times and circumstances favourable in the external world, or by suppressing their
excitations entirely. It is guided in its activity by consideration of the tension produced by stimuli,
whether these tensions are present in it or introduced into it.
Although much of the ego is conscious, most of its activity occurs without consciousness. Owing
to its direct access to perception, reality testing takes place in the ego. However, the ego can be said
to serve the following ‘three harsh masters’:
∑ the superego
∑ reality
∑ the id.
The superego
The superego is concerned with issues of morality. It develops initially as a result of the imposition
of parental restraint. Although more of the superego is conscious than is the case for the id, most of
its activity occurs without consciousness.
RESISTANCE
This is everything, in words and actions of the analysand, that obstructs him or her gaining access
to the unconscious. It can be used in psychoanalysis as a means to reach the repressed; indeed the
forces at work in resistance and repression are the same.
TRANSFERENCE
Sklar (1989) described the important features of the transference:
164 Psychoanalytic theories
The transference is an unconscious process in which the patient transfers to the therapist feelings,
emotions and attitudes that were experienced and/or desired in the patient’s childhood, usually in
relation to parents and siblings. It can be a passionate demand for love and hate in past relationships
between the child and the adult. This is a complex field that includes the unconscious splitting of the
therapist into masculine and feminine and locating unconscious affect and thinking of the ‘child’ part
of the patient in relation to the maternal and paternal aspects of the therapist (i.e. oedipal
transference). Furthermore, the direction of such a transference can be both positive and negative.
Thus, Freud encountered transference in many variations and certainly also in its hidden form,
transformed by resistance. The therapist’s transference represents on the one hand the most powerful
ally but, on the other, in terms of transference’s resistance, a therapeutic difficulty.
COUNTERTRANSFERENCE
Sklar (1989) described the important features of the countertransference:
The countertransference is the therapist’s own feelings, emotions and attitudes to his patient. In the
treatment mode, the therapist needs to screen out those that are mediated only by the therapist, and
take note of those generated in the therapist from emotional contact with the patient. The latter can
be an interesting aspect of the patient, e.g. the therapist may have the feelings of the patient as child
in relation to the patient enacting the parent. Thus, in the reverse transference, an aspect of the
patient is located in the therapist as a communication.
INSTINCTUAL DRIVES
Freud used the German word Trieb to refer to an instinctual drive. Unfortunately, this has often been
translated into the word ‘instinct’, a concept different from a ‘drive’. Important instinctual drives
identified by Freud were:
∑ libido: sexual ‘instinct’ and energy of the eros
∑ eros: life preservation ‘instinct’
∑ thanatos: death ‘instinct’.
PSYCHOSEXUAL DEVELOPMENT
The stages of psychosexual development identified by Freud were the oral, anal, phallic, latency and
genital phases.
∑ Oral phase – from birth to around 15–18 months of age. Erotogenic pleasure is derived from
sucking. In addition to the mother’s breast, the infant has a desire to place other objects in his or
her mouth.
∑ Anal phase – from around 15–18 months to 30–36 months of age. Erotogenic pleasure is derived
from stimulation of the anal mucosa, initially through faecal excretion, and later also through
faecal retention.
∑ Phallic phase – from around 3 years of age to around the end of the fifth year. Boys pass through
the Oedipal complex. Girls develop penis envy and pass through the Electra complex.
∑ Latency stage – from around 5–6 years to the onset of puberty. The sexual drive remains
relatively latent during this period.
∑ Genital stage – from the onset of puberty to young adulthood. A strong resurgence in the sexual
drive takes place. Successful resolution of conflicts from this and previous psychosexual stages
leads to a mature, well-integrated adult identity.
Carl Jung (1875–1961) 165
Jung founded the psychoanalytic school of analytic psychology. Jung was originally an important
member of Sigmund Freud’s inner circle and indeed at one time his designated successor.
ARCHETYPES
The archetypes of the objective psyche are energy-field configurations manifesting themselves as
representational images having universal symbolic meaning and typical emotional and behavioural
patterns. Five important types of archetype are identified in Jungian theory:
∑ Anima. This is the feminine prototype within each person.
∑ Animus. This is the masculine prototype within each person.
∑ Persona. This is the outward mask covering the individual’s personality and allowing social
demands to be balanced with internal needs. Both a public and a private persona may be
possessed by a person. The persona may be represented in terms of clothing in dreams.
∑ Shadow. This represents repressed animal instincts arising from phylogenetic development and
in dreams manifests itself as another person of the same sex.
∑ Self. This is a central archetype holding together conscious and unconscious aspects, including
future potential, archetypes and complexes.
COMPLEXES
Complexes surround archetypes and can be defined as feeling-toned ideas. They develop from an
interaction of personal experiences and archetypal models.
MENTAL OPERATIONS
Jungian theory postulates four operations of the mind: feeling, intuition, sensation and thinking.
∑ Feeling. This allows feelings:
∑ anger and joy
∑ love and loss
166 Psychoanalytic theories
INDIVIDUATION
This is the process of personality growth leading to the development of a unique realization of what
one intrinsically is.
Klein, who lacked any formal higher education and never developed a full theory of development,
was a controversial figure in the British Psycho-Analytical Society. When she began developing her
theories, Sigmund Freud viewed her as potentially challenging the work in child analysis of his
daughter, Anna Freud.
It is now known that Klein analysed her three children and wrote them up as disguised clinical
cases. She proposed that the aim of child psychoanalysis was to ‘cure’ all children of their ‘psychoses’.
Object relations
Klein believed that the infant was capable of object relations.
Paranoid–schizoid position
Rejecting the critical importance of autoeroticism for the infant, Klein believed instead that the
paranoid position – later, under the influence of Fairburn, renamed the paranoid–schizoid position –
developed as a result of frustration during the first year of life with pleasurable contact with objects
such as the good breast. The paranoid–schizoid position, characterized by isolation and persecutory
fears, developed as a result of the infant viewing the world as part objects, using the following
defence mechanisms:
∑ introjection (internalization)
∑ projective identification
∑ splitting.
Objects viewed by the infant as good are believed to be introjected, while those viewed as bad are
split or projected.
Donald Winnicott (1897–1971) 167
Aggression
A strong emphasis was placed on aggression, occurring particularly during the paranoid–schizoid
position.
Depressive position
This is said to develop by the age of 6 months when the child no longer views the world in terms of
part objects but realizes that objects are whole, and the world is not perfect.
EARLY DEVELOPMENT
The stages of development during the first year were considered to include, in chronological order:
∑ oral frustration
∑ oral envy (of parental ‘oral’ sex) and oral sadism, leading to Oedipal impulses
∑ a longing for the oral incorporation of father’s penis, by aggressive desires to bring about the
destruction of mother’s body (which contains father’s penis)
∑ castration anxiety in boys and fear of destruction of her own body in girls
∑ emergence of the primitive superego
∑ introjection of pain-causing objects
∑ development of a cruel superego
∑ ejection of the superego.
Winnicott was a British paediatrician who became a psychoanalyst. He was a contemporary of Anna
Freud and Melanie Klein, between whom he at one time tried to mediate. He made important
contributions to object relations theory and his reputation has grown steadily since his death.
COUNTERTRANSFERANCE
Objective countertransference
Winnicott broadened the understanding of the countertransference from that of Freud, speaking of
the objective countertransference. The objectivity derived from his belief that the counter-
transference was an understandable and normal reaction to the personality and behaviour of the
analysand.
168 Psychoanalytic theories
Countertransference hate
Winnicott normalized the existence of countertransference hate. He gave reasons why a mother
hates her infant (male or female) even from the start of their relationship. He then drew an analogy
from this mother–infant dyad to the therapist–patient relationship. Winnicott suggested that the
countertransference hate should be articulated to the analysand at the end of therapy, but most
analysts would tend not to go this far.
MOTHERHOOD
∑ Good-enough mother. The good-enough mother is a mother who responds to her baby’s
communications and meets his or her needs within an optimal zone of frustration and
gratification.
∑ Pathological mother. This is a mother who imposes her own needs over those of her baby, causing
her baby to create a false self in order to protect his or her true self.
∑ Capacity to be alone. Good parenting by the mother, allowing her child to become increasingly
autonomous while at the same time being dependent on her, results in the child being able to be
himself or herself in the presence of his/her mother, and vice versa. This was termed the ‘capacity
to be alone’ in the presence of another.
TRANSITIONAL OBJECT
This is an object, which is neither oneself nor another person (including mother), which is selected
by an infant at between 4 and 18 months of age for self-soothing and anxiety-reduction. Examples
include a blanket or toy that helps the infant go to sleep. It helps during the process of
separation–individuation. In adults, transitional phenomena that may allow us to cope with
loneliness and separation can include music, religion and scientific creativity.
OTHER CONCEPTS
Other important concepts associated with Winnicott include:
∑ the holding environment: a therapeutic ambiance or setting allowing the patient to experience
safety, and so facilitating psychotherapy
∑ the potential space: an area of experiencing identified as existing between the baby and the
object; it subsequently underlies all play, imagination, dreams and the interdependence of
transference and countertransference
∑ the squiggle game: a play therapy technique
∑ at-one-ment
∑ primary maternal preoccupation
∑ regression to dependence
∑ going on being
∑ impingement
∑ object usage.
∑ Repression. The basic defence, repression is the pushing away (Verdrangung) of unacceptable
ideas, affects, emotions, memories and drives, relegating them to the unconscious. When it is
successful, no trace remains in consciousness but some affective excitation does remain.
Bibliography 169
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Freud, A. 1936: The Ego and the Mechanisms of Defence. London: Hogarth.
Freud, S. 1953/1966: The Standard Edition of the Complete Psychological Works of Sigmund Freud, vols 1–24.
London: Hogarth.
Hall, C.S. 1956: A Primer of Freudian Psychology. London: George Allen & Unwin.
170 Psychoanalytic theories
Jung, C.G. 1961: Memories, Dreams, Reflections. New York: Random House.
Jung, C.G. 1964: Man and His Symbols. New York: Doubleday.
Klein, M. 1948: Contributions to Psycho-Analysis, 1921–1945. London: Hogarth.
Klein, M. 1949: The Psycho-Analysis of Children, 3rd edn. London: Hogarth.
Ogden, T.H. 1992: The dialectically constituted/decentred subject of psychoanalysis: II. The contributions of Klein
and Winnicott. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 73:613–626.
Segal, H. 1980: Melanie Klein. New York: Viking.
Sklar, J. 1989: Dynamic psychopathology. In Puri, B.K. & Sklar, J.: Examination Notes for the MRCPsych Part I.
London: Butterworth–Heinemann.
Winnicott, D.W. 1949: Hate in the Counter-Transference. International Journal of Psycho-Analysis 30:69–74.
Winnicott, D.W. 1958: Collected Papers: Through Paediatrics to Psycho-Analysis. New York: Basic Books.
Winnicott, D.W. 1965: The Maturational Processes and the Facilitating Environment. New York: International
Universities Press.
Winnicott, D.W. 1971: Playing and Reality. New York: International Universities Press.
10
Neuroanatomy
STRUCTURAL ORGANIZATION
The nervous system can be divided structurally into:
∑ the central nervous system (CNS)
∑ the peripheral nervous system (PNS).
The CNS consists of:
∑ the brain
∑ the spinal cord.
It is well protected by the skull and vertebral column and the meninges (layers of connective tissue
membrane):
∑ the dura mater – outermost layer
∑ the arachnoid mater – middle layer
∑ the pia mater – inner layer.
Cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) in the subarachnoid space offers further protection of the CNS.
The PNS consists of:
∑ the cranial nerves
∑ the spinal nerves
∑ other neuronal processes and cell bodies lying outside the CNS.
The PNS is not as well protected as the CNS.
FUNCTIONAL ORGANIZATION
The nervous system can be divided functionally into:
∑ the somatic nervous system, concerned primarily with the innervation of voluntary structures
172 Neuroanatomy
∑ the autonomic nervous system, concerned primarily with the innervation of involuntary
structures.
The autonomic nervous system is subdivided into two parts:
∑ the sympathetic
∑ the parasympathetic.
DEVELOPMENTAL ORGANIZATION
During ontogeny, the midline neural tube differentiates into the following vesicles:
∑ Prosencephalon. This differentiates into the telencephalon.
∑ Telencephalon. This gives rise to the cerebral hemispheres and contains the:
∑ pallium
∑ rhinencephalon
∑ corpus striatum
∑ medullary centre.
∑ Diencephalon. This consists of the:
∑ thalamus
∑ subthalamus
∑ hypothalamus
∑ epithalamus – consisting of the habenular nucleus and pineal gland.
∑ Mesencephalon. This consists of the:
∑ tectum – consisting of the corpora quadrigemina, made up of the
superior colliculi
inferior colliculi
∑ basis pedunculi
∑ tegmentum – containing
the red nucleus
fibre tracts
grey matter surrounding the cerebral aqueduct.
∑ Rhombencephalon. This differentiates into the:
∑ metencephalon – consisting of the
pons
oral part of the medulla oblongata
cerebellum
∑ myelencephalon – the caudal part of the medulla oblongata.
Figure 10.1 shows the main ontological divisions at an early stage and at a later stage of
neurodevelopment.
Neurones
Classification by morphology
On a morphological basis, neurones can be classified as:
Types of nervous system cell 173
A B
Prosencephalon
Prosencephalon
Telencephalon
Mesencephalon
Diencephalon
Rhombencephalon Mesencephalon
Rhombencephalon
Metencephalon
Myelencephalon
Figure 10.1 Ontological development of the cerebral vesicles. A: At an early stage. B: At a later stage.
Classification by size
An alternative classification is on the basis of size:
∑ Golgi type I – long axon
∑ Golgi type II – short axon terminating near the parent cell
∑ amacrine – no axon.
Neuroglia
Neuroglia, or interstitial cells, outnumber neurones five- to ten-fold.
∑ Central nervous system. The main types of neuroglia in the CNS are:
∑ astrocytes
∑ oligodendrocytes
∑ microglia
∑ ependyma.
∑ Peripheral nervous system. The main types of neuroglia in the PNS are:
∑ Schwann cells
∑ satellite cells.
∑ Astrocytes. There are two types of astrocytes or astroglia:
∑ fibrous astrocytes
∑ protoplasmic astrocytes.
∑ They are multipolar and their functions include:
structural support of neurones
phagocytosis
forming CNS neuroglial scar tissue
contributing to the blood–brain barrier.
174 Neuroanatomy
FRONTAL LOBES
FRONTAL OPERCULUM
This consists of areas 44, 45 and 47.
∑ Broca’s area. This is the core of the frontal operculum on the dominant (usually left) side, and
consists of areas 44 and 45. A lesion in this region can lead to expressive (motor) aphasia (Broca’s
nonfluent aphasia).
∑ Right side. Lesions in the non-dominant frontal operculum can lead to dysprosody.
∑ septal nuclei
∑ substantia innominata.
Lesions of the basal forebrain (either side) can lead to amnesia (retrograde and anterograde) and
confabulation.
TEMPORAL LOBES
∑ amygdala
∑ entorhinal cortex
∑ hippocampus.
Left-sided lesions can lead to anterograde amnesia affecting verbal information, while right-sided
lesions can lead to anterograde amnesia affecting non-verbal information. Bilateral lesions can lead
to verbal and non-verbal anterograde amnesia.
PARIETAL LOBES
TEMPOROPARIETAL JUNCTION
The posterior part of the inferior parietal lobule together with the posterior part of the superior
temporal gyrus (Wernicke’s area) form the greater Wernicke’s area. Left-sided lesions can lead to a
receptive (sensory) aphasia (Wernicke’s fluent aphasia), while right-sided lesions can lead to
phonagnosia (impairment in the ability to recognize familiar voices) and amusia (impaired ability
to recognize and process music).
OCCIPITAL LOBES
BASAL GANGLIA
COMPONENTS
Authorities differ on the components of the basal ganglia. According to Snell (1987) the basal
ganglia consist of the:
∑ corpus striatum
∑ caudate nucleus
∑ lentiform nucleus
∑ amygdala (amygdaloid nucleus or amygdaloid body)
∑ claustrum.
The lentiform nucleus consists of the:
∑ globus pallidus
∑ putamen.
Some of these structures are shown in the diagrammatic sketch of Figure 10.2.
Head of
Putamen
caudate nucleus
Amygdala (amygdaloid
nucleus or amygdaloid body) Tail of caudate nucleus
Figure 10.2 Sketch of the basal ganglia of the left adult cerebral hemisphere.
Efferents
∑ Efferents from the putamen pass to the globus pallidus.
∑ Efferents from the globus pallidus pass to the:
∑ hypothalamus
178 Neuroanatomy
∑ reticular formation
∑ substantia nigra
∑ subthalamus
∑ ventroanterior nucleus of the thalamus
∑ ventrolateral nucleus of the thalamus.
FRONTAL–SUBCORTICAL CIRCUITS
Alexander et al. (1986) have identified five parallel frontal–subcortical circuits which together form
one of the main organizational networks of the brain and are central to brain–behaviour
relationships. They connect specific regions of the frontal cortex with the basal ganglia and the
thalamus in circuits that mediate:
∑ motor activity
∑ eye movements
∑ behaviour.
The overall structure of each circuit is as follows:
frontal lobe cortex Æ caudate nucleus Æ globus pallidus/substantia nigra Æ thalamus Æ
frontal lobe cortex
Circuits
∑ Motor circuit. This originates in the SMA and subserves motor function.
∑ Oculomotor circuit. This originates in the frontal eye fields and subserves eye movements.
∑ Dorsolateral prefrontal circuit. This originates in the DLPFC and subserves executive cognitive
functions.
∑ Lateral orbitofrontal circuit. This originates in the lateral orbital cortex and subserves
personality.
∑ Anterior cingulate circuit. This originates in the anterior cingulate cortex and subserves
motivation.
LIMBIC SYSTEM
LIMBIC LOBE
This was described by Broca in 1878 as an arrangement of cortical structures around the
diencephalon, forming a border on the medial side of each cerebral hemisphere between the
neocortex and the remainder of the brain.
∑ Cortical areas. Cortical areas of the limbic lobe form the limbic cortex and include the:
∑ cingulate gyrus
∑ parahippocampal gyrus
∑ subcallosal gyrus.
∑ Nuclei. Subcortical nuclei that are part of the limbic lobe include the:
∑ amygdaloid nucleus
∑ septal nucleus.
Limbic system 179
COMPONENTS
There is disagreement as to precisely which structures form part of the modern definition of the
limbic system. A good guide is provided by both Snell (1987) and Trimble (1981).
Cortical areas
Cortical areas that are generally considered to be part of the limbic system nowadays include the:
∑ cingulate gyrus
∑ gyrus fasciolaris
∑ hippocampal formation:
∑ dendate gyrus
∑ hippocampus
∑ parahippocampal gyrus
∑ indusium griseum
∑ olfactory tubercle
∑ paraterminal gyrus (precommissural septum)
∑ prepiriform cortex
∑ secondary olfactory area (entorhinal area)
∑ subcollosal gyrus
∑ subiculum.
Nuclei
Subcortical nuclear groups that are generally considered to be part of the limbic system nowadays
include the:
∑ amygdala (amygdaloid nucleus)
∑ anterior thalamic nucleus
∑ dorsal tegmental nucleus
∑ epithalamic nucleus
∑ habenula
∑ hypothalamic nuclei
∑ mammillary bodies
∑ raphe nucleus
∑ septal nucleus (septal area)
∑ superior central nucleus
∑ ventral tegmental area.
Connecting pathways
Connecting pathways of the limbic system include the:
∑ anterior commissure
∑ cingulum
∑ dorsal longitudinal fasciculus
∑ fornix
∑ lateral longitudinal striae
∑ mammillotegmental tract
∑ mammillothalamic tract
∑ medial forebrain bundle
∑ medial longitudinal striae
∑ stria terminalis
∑ stria medullaris thalami.
180 Neuroanatomy
HIPPOCAMPAL FORMATION
The hippocampal formation consists of the:
∑ dendate gyrus
∑ hippocampus
∑ parahippocampal gyrus.
DENDATE GYRUS
This gyrus lies between the hippocampal fimbria and the parahippocampal gyrus. Anteriorly, it is
continuous with the uncus. Posteriorly, it is continuous with the indusium griseum. Histologically,
it is made up of the following three layers:
∑ molecular layer (outer)
∑ granular layer
∑ polymorphic layer (inner).
HIPPOCAMPUS
This grey matter structure lies mainly in the floor of the inferior horn of the lateral ventricle.
Anteriorly, it forms the pes hippocampus. Posteriorly, it ends inferior to the splenium of the corpus
callosum. Axons from each alveus converge medially to form the fimbria and crus of the fornix.
Histologically, the hippocampus is made up of the following three layers:
∑ molecular layer (outer)
∑ pyramidal layer
∑ polymorphic layer (inner).
Afferent connections of the hippocampus include fibres that originate from the:
∑ cingulate gyrus
∑ dendate gyrus
∑ hippocampus (the opposite one)
∑ indusium griseum
∑ parahippocampal gyrus
∑ secondary olfactory area (entorhinal area)
∑ septal nucleus (septal area).
PARAHIPPOCAMPAL GYRUS
This gyrus is separated from the remaining cerebral cortex by the collateral sulcus. Anteriorly, it is
continuous with the uncus. The subiculum of the parahippocampal gyrus allows the passage of
nerve fibres from the secondary olfactory cortex (entorhinal area) to the dendate gyrus.
AMYGDALA
The amygdala is also known as the amygdaloid nucleus, body or complex. It is continuous with the
tail of the caudate nucleus, lying anterior and superior to the tip of the inferior horn of the lateral
ventricle.
Major white matter pathways 181
Afferent connections
Afferent connections received by the amygdala include the:
∑ amygdala (the opposite one, via the anterior commissure)
∑ dopaminergic brain stem nuclei
∑ frontal association area
∑ lateral olfactory stria
∑ noradrenergic brainstem nuclei
∑ septal nucleus (septal area)
∑ serotonergic brainstem nuclei
∑ temporal association area
∑ uncus.
Efferent connections
Parts of the brain to which efferent connections pass from the amygdala include the:
∑ hypothalamus (via the stria terminalis)
∑ septal nucleus (septal area) (via the stria terminalis)
∑ corpus striatum
∑ frontal association area
∑ lateral olfactory stria
∑ temporal association area
∑ thalamus.
CORPUS CALLOSUM
This is the largest set of inter-hemispheric connecting fibres. It lies inferior to the longitudinal
fissure and superior to the diencephalon. It connects homologous neocortical areas.
The main divisions of the corpus callosum (rostral first) are the:
∑ rostrum
∑ genu
∑ body
∑ splenium.
These are shown in the diagrammatic sketch of the corpus callosum of Figure 10.3, which also
shows some adjacent structures.
FORNIX
This is the major efferent subcortical white matter tract of the hippocampus. The two crura of the
fornix, each formed from axons from the alveus of the hippocampus, converge inferior to the corpus
callosum and form the body of the fornix. The body of the fornix is connected anteriorly with the
inferior surface of the corpus callosum via the septum pellucidum. The body of the fornix then
divides into the two columns of the fornix.
182 Neuroanatomy
Choroid plexus
Septum pellucidum (of third ventricle)
Genu of corpus callosum Thalamus
Interthalamic connection
Rostrum of corpus callosum
Splenium of
Anterior commissure corpus callosum
Mammillary body
Cranial nerve III Fourth ventricle
Pons
Figure 10.3 Sketch of the corpus callosum in a midsagittal section of the adult human brain. The adjacent
cingulate cortex and septum pellucidum are also indicated. Note that the rostral direction is towards the left.
PAPEZ CIRCUIT
This is the concept introduced by Papez, in 1937, of a supposed limbic-system reverberating circuit
constituting the neuronal mechanism of emotion. It consisted of the:
∑ hippocampus
∑ hypothalamus
∑ anterior nucleus of the thalamus
∑ cingulate gyrus.
The postulated circuit was as follows:
hippocampus Æ (via the fornix)
Æ mammillary bodies of the hypothalamus Æ (via a synaptic connection)
Æ anterior nucleus of the thalamus Æ (the neuroimpulse then radiates up)
Æ cingulate gyrus Æ (via the cingulum)
Æ hippocampus.
ARCUATE BUNDLE
This is a specific group of association fibres arranged in a curved shape running parallel to the
cortical surface which, on the dominant (usually left) side, connects the more rostral Broca’s area
with Wernicke’s area.
Cranial nerves 183
ANTERIOR COMMISSURE
This small nerve fibre bundle crosses the midline in the lamina terminalis and connects
homologous areas of the neocortex and paleocortex. Parts of the limbic system in the two cerebral
hemispheres that are connected via the anterior commissure include the:
∑ amygdala
∑ hippocampus
∑ parahippocampal gyrus.
CRANIAL NERVES
I: OLFACTORY NERVE
This contains the central processes of the olfactory receptors, which pass from the olfactory mucosa,
through the cribriform plate of the ethmoid, to synapse with the olfactory bulb mitral cells. Axons
then pass in the olfactory tract to the primary olfactory cortex (also known as the periamygdaloid
and prepiriform areas) via the lateral olfactory striae.
V: TRIGEMINAL NERVE
This is the largest cranial nerve.
184 Neuroanatomy
Parasympathetic nuclei
These include:
∑ lacrimal nucleus: supplies the
∑ lacrimal gland
∑ superior salivary nucleus: supplies the
∑ nasal gland
∑ palatine gland
∑ sublingual gland
∑ submandibular gland.
Sensory nucleus
This receives taste fibres, via the geniculate ganglion, from the:
186 Neuroanatomy
Chorda tympani
This is a branch of the facial nerve given off before it passes through the stylomastoid foramen. The
chorda tympani joins the lingual branch of the mandibular division of the trigeminal nerve.
Parasympathetic nucleus
This receives inputs from the:
∑ hypothalamus
∑ olfactory system
∑ tractus solitarius nucleus
∑ trigeminal sensory nucleus.
Preganglionic fibres reach the otic ganglion via the tympanic plexus and the lesser petrosal nerve.
Postganglionic fibres supply the parotid gland by means of the auriculotemporal branch of the
mandibular nerve.
Sensory nucleus
This receives taste information from the posterior of the tongue.
X: VAGUS NERVE
The vagus nerve has three nuclei:
∑ main motor nucleus
∑ parasympathetic nucleus (the dorsal nucleus)
∑ sensory nucleus (the inferior part of the tractus solitarius nucleus).
Spinal cord 187
Parasympathetic nucleus
This receives inputs from the:
∑ hypothalamus
∑ glossopharyngeal nerve
∑ heart
∑ lower respiratory tract
∑ gastrointestinal tract, as far as the transverse colon.
It supplies the:
∑ involuntary muscle of the heart
∑ lower respiratory tract
∑ gastrointestinal tract, as far as the distal one-third of the transverse colon.
Sensory nucleus
This receives taste information from the inferior ganglion of the vagus nerve.
SPINAL CORD
DIVISIONS
From rostral to caudal, the spinal cord is divided into the following five parts:
188 Neuroanatomy
∑ amygdala.
This pathway is concerned with sensorimotor coordination.
GLUTAMATE SYSTEM
Neurones using glutamate, an excitatory neurotransmitter, include:
∑ cerebral cortical pyramidal cells
∑ hippocampal pyramidal cells
∑ primary sensory afferents
∑ cerebellar granule cells
∑ cerebellar climbing fibres.
The cerebral cortex contains abundant NMDA (N-methyl-D-aspartate) receptors, which serve an
integral role in corticocortical and corticofugal glutamatergic neurotransmission.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Alexander, G.E., DeLong, M.R. & Strick, P.L. 1986: Parallel organisation of functionally segregated circuits linking
basal ganglia and cortex. Annual Review of Neuroscience 9:357–381.
Heimer, L. 1995: The Human Brain and Spinal Cord. Berlin: Springer.
Puri, B.K. & Tyrer, P.J. 2004: Sciences Basic to Psychiatry, 3rd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Snell, R.S. 1987: Clinical Neuroanatomy for Medical Students, 2nd edn. Boston: Little, Brown.
Trimble, M.R. 1996: Neuropsychiatry, 2nd edn. Chichester: John Wiley.
This page intentionally left blank
11
Neuropathology
DEMENTIAS
Alzheimer’s disease
Macroscopic neuropathology
Macroscopic changes in Alzheimer’s disease include:
∑ global brain atrophy
∑ ventricular enlargement
∑ sulcal widening.
The atrophy is usually most marked in the frontal and temporal lobes.
Histopathology
Histological changes in the cerebral cortex in Alzheimer’s disease include:
∑ neuronal loss
∑ shrinking of dendritic branching
∑ reactive astrocytosis
∑ neurofibrillary tangles
∑ neuritic plaques (senile plaques).
There is a positive correlation between the number of neurofibrillary tangles and neuritic
plaques, on the one hand, and, on the other, the degree of cognitive impairment.
Histological changes seen commonly in the hippocampus include:
∑ granulovacuolar degeneration
∑ Hirano bodies
∑ neurofibrillary tangles
∑ neuritic plaques (senile plaques).
194 Neuropathology
Ultrastructural pathology
Neuritic plaques contain a core made of amyloid. This consists of 8-nm extracellular filaments made
up mainly of the b-peptide, Ab or b/A4. Scattered deposits of amyloid b protein in the brain in
Alzheimer’s disease have been found to localize to activated microglia.
Ab or b/A4 is derived from the b-amyloid precursor protein (APP).
Neurochemical pathology
Neurochemical changes that have been reported in Alzheimer’s disease include:
∑ Øacetylcholinesterase
∑ Øcholine acetyltransferase
∑ ØGABA
∑ Ønoradrenaline.
Pick’s disease
Pick’s disease is one histological type of frontotemporal dementia.
Macroscopic neuropathology
Macroscopic changes in Pick’s disease include:
∑ selective asymmetrical atrophy of the anterior temporal lobes and frontal lobes
∑ knife-blade gyri
∑ ventricular enlargement.
Histopathology
Histological changes in Pick’s disease include:
∑ Pick’s bodies
∑ neuronal loss
∑ reactive astrocytosis.
These changes may be seen in the:
∑ cerebral cortex
∑ basal ganglia
∑ locus coeruleus
∑ substantia nigra.
Ultrastructural pathology
Pick’s bodies consist of:
∑ straight neurofilaments
∑ paired helical filaments
∑ endoplasmic reticulum.
Multi-infarct dementia
ICD-10 classes multi-infarct dementia under vascular dementia.
Dementias 195
Macroscopic neuropathology
Macroscopic changes in multi-infarct dementia include:
∑ multiple cerebral infarcts
∑ local or general brain atrophy
∑ ventricular enlargement
∑ arteriosclerotic changes in major arteries.
Clinically, the following relationships have been found usually to hold approximately for the total
volume of the infarcts:
∑ 50 mL < volume £ 100 mL: cognitive impairment
∑ volume > 100 mL: dementia.
Histopathology
Histological changes include those of infarction and ischaemia.
Histopathology
Histological changes in the brain in dementia caused by Lewy body disease include:
∑ Lewy bodies
∑ neuronal loss
∑ neurofibrillary tangles
∑ neuritic plaques (senile plaques).
Compared with Parkinson’s disease, in which Lewy bodies are also found, in dementia caused by
Lewy body disease the density of Lewy bodies is much higher in the:
∑ cingulate gyrus
∑ parahippocampal gyrus
∑ temporal cortex.
Ultrastructural pathology
Lewy bodies contain:
∑ protein neurofilaments
∑ granular material
∑ dense core vesicles
∑ microtubule assembly protein
∑ ubiquitin
∑ tau protein.
196 Neuropathology
Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease
Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease (CJD) is transmitted by infection with a prion. In addition to the brain
changes mentioned below, CJD disease is also associated with degeneration in spinal cord long
descending tracts. It has an incubation period of many years. Infection may be transmitted from
surgical specimens, from postmortem preparations (such as corneal grafts) and from human
pituitary glands; the latter have been used to produce human somatotropin for clinical use. In 1995
in Britain a new variant of Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease (nvCJD) was reported which, it has been
suggested, may be linked to transmission, possibly via the food chain, from the neuropathologically
related disorder bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE).
Macroscopic neuropathology
There may be little or no gross atrophy of the cerebral cortex evident in rapidly developing cases. In
those surviving the longest, changes seen may include:
∑ selective cerebellar atrophy
∑ generalized cerebral atrophy
∑ ventricular enlargement.
Histopathology
Histological changes in the brain in dementia caused by Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease include:
∑ status spongiosus
∑ neuronal degeneration without inflammation
∑ astrocytic proliferation.
Punch-drunk syndrome
This is also known as post-traumatic dementia or boxing encephalopathy.
Macroscopic neuropathology
Typical macroscopic changes include:
∑ cerebral atrophy
∑ ventricular enlargement
∑ perforation of the septum pellucidum
∑ thinning of the corpus callosum.
Histopathology
Histological changes in the brain in punch-drunk syndrome include:
∑ neuronal loss
∑ neurofibrillary tangles.
CEREBRAL TUMOURS
The main types of cerebral tumours, listed in order of relative frequency, are:
∑ gliomas
Cerebral tumours 197
∑ metastases
∑ meningeal tumours
∑ pituitary adenomas
∑ neurilemmomas
∑ haemangioblastomas
∑ medulloblastomas.
Gliomas
These are tumours derived from glial cells and their precursors, and include:
∑ astrocytomas – derived from astrocytes
∑ oligodendrocytomas – derived from oligodendrocytes
∑ ependymomas – derived from ependymal cells.
Metastases
Cerebral metastases derive particularly from primary neoplasia in the lung, breast, kidney, colon,
ovary, prostate and thyroid.
Meningeal tumours
These include:
∑ meningiomas
∑ meningeal sarcomas (very rare)
∑ primary malignant melanomas derived from pia-arachnoid melanocytes (very rare).
Pituitary adenomas
These include, in approximate order of relative frequency (commonest first):
∑ sparsely granulated PRL (prolactin/lactotrophin/mamotrophin) cell adenomas
∑ oncocytomas
∑ null cell adenomas
∑ gonadotroph cell adenomas
∑ corticotroph cell adenomas
∑ densely granulated GH (growth hormone/somatotrophin) cell adenomas
∑ sparsely granulated GH cell adenomas
∑ mixed (GH cell–PRL cell) adenomas
∑ silent ‘corticotroph’adenomas, subtype 2
∑ unclassified adenomas
∑ acidophil stem cell adenomas
∑ silent ‘corticotroph’adenomas, subtype 1
∑ silent ‘corticotroph’adenomas, subtype 3
∑ mammosomatotroph cell adenomas
∑ thyrotroph cell adenomas
∑ densely granulated GH cell adenomas.
Neurilemmomas
These are also known as schwannomas. They are derived from Schwann cells and include acoustic
neuromas.
Haemangioblastomas
These are derived from blood vessels.
198 Neuropathology
Medulloblastomas
These cerebellar tumours are embryonal tumours.
SCHIZOPHRENIA
Gross neuropathology
∑ Brain mass. There is a slight but significant reduction in brain mass in schizophrenia, compared
with controls and allowing for differences in height, body mass, sex and year of birth (Brown et
al., 1986; Pakkenburg, 1987; Bruton et al., 1990).
∑ Brain length. Bruton et al. (1990) found a significant reduction in the maximum anteroposterior
length of formalin-fixed cerebral hemispheres in schizophrenia, compared with age- and sex-
matched normal controls. Both hemispheres were shorter in schizophrenia compared with the
controls.
∑ Cerebral volumes. In the postmortem brains of patients with schizophrenia, compared with age-
and sex-matched controls, Pakkenburg (1987) found a significant reduction in the volumes of
the:
∑ cerebral hemispheres
∑ cerebral cortex
∑ central grey matter.
∑ The volumes of the white matter did not differ significantly.
∑ Hippocampus and parahippocampal gyrus. Altshuler et al. (1990) studied the area and shape of
the anterior hippocampus and parahippocampal gyrus in postmortem brains from
schizophrenic, non-schizophrenic suicide, and non-psychiatric controls. No significant
differences were found in hippocampal area, but the parahippocampal gyrus was significantly
smaller in the schizophrenic group compared with the control group.
Bogerts et al. (1990) also studied postmortem brains of schizophrenic patients and control
subjects. Compared with the controls, in the schizophrenic group the hippocampal formation
was significantly smaller in the right and left hemispheres. The reduction in hippocampal
volume in the male schizophrenics was greater than in the female schizophrenics.
∑ Ventricular volume. Ventricular enlargement has been found in a number of postmortem studies
of schizophrenic brains (e.g. Brown et al., 1986; Pakkenburg, 1987; Bruton et al., 1990). The
ventricular enlargement particularly affects the temporal horn (Crow et al., 1989), indicating
temporal lobe neuropathology.
∑ Temporal lobe. The majority of postmortem studies have found a reduction in temporal lobe
volume in schizophrenia. While the grey matter is reduced in volume, particularly at the level of
the amygdala and anterior hippocampus, the volume of the white matter tends not to be
reduced.
Morphometric studies
Temporal lobe
Pyramidal cell disorientation in the hippocampus has been reported by Kovelman and Scheibel
(1984) and by Conrad et al. (1991), although this failed to be found by Altshuler et al. (1987).
Jeste and Lohr (1989) found that schizophrenic patients had a significantly lower pyramidal cell
density than normal controls in the left CA4 hippocampal region.
Schizophrenia 199
Synaptic pathology
Synaptic vesicles
Soustek (1989) found clusters of large numbers of synaptic vesicles in presynaptic knobs in the
cerebral cortex of schizophrenic postmortem brains but not in brains from control subjects.
Synaptophysin
Synaptophysin is a presynaptic vesicle protein the distribution and abundance of which provides a
synaptic marker which can be reliably measured in postmortem brains.
Eastwood et al. (1995) found that in schizophrenic brains, compared with controls,
synaptophysin mRNA was reduced bilaterally in:
∑ CA4
∑ CA3
∑ the subiculum
∑ the parahippocampal gyrus.
(The effect of antipsychotic medication was discounted as a separate rat study showed no effect of
haloperidol treatment on hippocampal synaptophysin mRNA.) Furthermore, Eastwood and
Harrison (1995) found decreased synaptophysin in the medial temporal lobe in schizophrenia,
compared with controls, using immunoautoradiography. Significant reductions were found in the:
∑ dentate gyrus
∑ subiculum
∑ parahippocampal gyrus.
Gliosis
Almost all recent quantitative studies investigating the regions of greatest structural differences in
schizophrenic patients have not shown significant gliosis (e.g. Jellinger, 1985; Roberts et al., 1987;
Bruton et al., 1990). This negative finding is consistent with either of the following possibilities:
1 The structural change in schizophrenic brains results from an embryonic insult prior to the
third trimester (since the developing brain does not show reactive gliosis until approximately
the third trimester).
2 A neuropathological process occurs at or after the third trimester but does not usually initiate a
glial reaction.
AUTISM
Histological changes
Bauman and Kemper (1985) studied the brain of a 29-year-old autistic man and found, compared
with the brain of an age- and sex-matched normal control, abnormalities in the:
∑ hippocampus
∑ subiculum
∑ entorhinal cortex
∑ septal nuclei
Movement disorders 201
∑ mammillary body
∑ amygdala (selected nuclei)
∑ neocerebellar cortex
∑ roof nuclei of the cerebellum
∑ inferior olivary nucleus.
Neuropathological studies suggest that the microscropic neuroanatomical abnormalities in
autism begin early in gestation, probably in the second trimester (Bauman, 1991).
Cerebellar pathology
Both neuropathological and structural neuroimaging studies have indicated that hypoplastia of the
cerebellar vermis as well as hypoplasia of the cerebellar hemispheres occurs in some subjects with
autism.
Neocerebellar abnormality
In their study of subjects with autism, Courchesne et al. (1988) measured the size of the cerebellar
vermis using magnetic resonance imaging and compared these with its size in controls. The
neocerebellar vermal lobules VI and VII were found to be significantly smaller in autism. This
appeared to be a result of developmental hypoplasia rather than shrinkage or deterioration after full
development had been achieved. In contrast, the adjacent vermal lobules I to V, which are
ontogenetically, developmentally and anatomically distinct from lobules VI and VII, were found to
be of normal size. Maldevelopment of the vermal neocerebellum had occurred in both retarded and
nonretarded patients with autism. The authors suggested that this localized maldevelopment might
serve as a temporal marker to identify the events that damage the brain in autism, as well as other
neural structures that might be concomitantly damaged. They concluded that the neocerebellar
abnormality may:
∑ directly impair cognitive functions that may be attributable to the neocerebellum
∑ indirectly affect – through its connections to the brain stem, hypothalamus and thalamus – the
development and functioning of one or more systems involved in cognitive, sensory, autonomic
and motor activities
∑ occur concomitantly with damage to other neural sites the dysfunction of which directly
underlies the cognitive deficits in autism.
MOVEMENT DISORDERS
Parkinson’s disease
Idiopathic Parkinson’s disease is characterized by a loss of dopaminergic neurones in the substantia
nigra.
202 Neuropathology
Macroscopic neuropathology
Macroscopic changes in idiopathic Parkinson’s disease include:
∑ depigmentation of the substantia nigra, particularly the zona compacta
∑ depigmentation of the locus coeruleus.
Diffuse cortical atrophy may take place.
Histopathology
Histological changes in idiopathic Parkinson’s disease include:
∑ neuronal loss
∑ reactive astrocytosis
∑ the presence of Lewy bodies in the:
∑ substantia nigra
∑ dorsal motor nucleus of the vagus
∑ hypothalamus
∑ nucleus basalis of Meynert
∑ locus coeruleus
∑ Edinger–Westphal nucleus
∑ raphe nuclei
∑ cerebral cortex
∑ olfactory bulb
∑ the presence of melanin-containing macrophages.
Neurochemical pathology
Neurochemical changes in idiopathic Parkinson’s disease include reduced inhibitory dopaminergic
action of the nigrostriatal pathway on striatal cholinergic neurones.
Macroscopic neuropathology
Macroscopic changes in Huntington’s disease include:
∑ small brain with reduced mass
∑ marked atrophy of the corpus striatum, particularly the caudate nucleus
∑ marked atrophy of the cerebral cortex, particularly the frontal lobe gyri (the parietal lobe is less
often affected)
∑ dilatation of the lateral and third ventricles.
Histopathology
Histological changes in Huntington’s disease include:
∑ neuronal loss in the cerebral cortex, particularly the frontal cortex
∑ neuronal loss in the corpus striatum, particularly neurones using as neurotransmitters
Movement disorders 203
Neurochemical pathology
Neurochemical changes that have been reported in Huntington’s disease include:
∑ ØGABA
∑ Øglutamic acid decarboxylase
∑ Øacetylcholine
∑ Øsubstance P
∑ ≠somatostatin
∑ Øcorticotrophin-releasing factor (CRF)
∑ dopamine hypersensitivity.
Evidence has recently been put forward suggesting that phospholipid-related signal transduction
in advanced Huntington’s disease is impaired (Puri, 2001).
Tardive dyskinesia
Tardive dyskinesia is a syndrome of potentially irreversible involuntary hyperkinetic dyskinesias
that may occur during long-term treatment with antipsychotic (neuroleptic) medication. The most
important hypotheses concerning the neurochemical pathology of tardive dyskinesia are:
∑ dopamine hypersensitivity
∑ free-radical induced neurotoxicity
∑ GABA insufficiency
∑ noradrenergic dysfunction.
∑ There is only limited support for dopamine hypersensitivity from postantipsychotic dopamine
turnover experiments in monkeys.
∑ Postmortem human brain tissue studies have not shown significant differences in D2 receptor
binding between schizophrenic patients with tardive dyskinesia and schizophrenic patients
without tardive dyskinesia.
∑ Blood biochemical assays have not shown consistent significant differences between patients
with tardive dyskinesia and patients without tardive dyskinesia with respect to:
∑ prolactin
∑ somatotrophin.
∑ No consistent significant differences have been shown between patients with tardive dyskinesia
and patients without tardive dyskinesia with respect to:
∑ plasma homovanillic acid
∑ urinary homovanillic acid
∑ CSF homovanillic acid.
∑ Dopamine agonists do not strikingly exacerbate tardive dyskinesia.
∑ Dopamine antagonist antipsychotics may sometimes worsen tardive dyskinesia.
A modification of this hypothesis includes a role for dopamine D1 receptors, but many of the
above problems also apply again. Moreover, postmortem human brain tissue studies have not
shown significant differences in D1 receptor binding between schizophrenic patients with tardive
dyskinesia and schizophrenic patients without tardive dyskinesia.
Free-radical induced neurotoxicity
According to this hypothesis the following sequence of events takes place:
long-term treatment with antipsychotic (neuroleptic) medication
Æincreased catecholamine turnover
Æfree-radical byproducts
Æmembrane lipid peroxidation in the basal ganglia (the basal ganglia have a high oxidative
metabolism)
Ætardive dyskinesia.
Evidence in favour of this hypothesis includes:
∑ a-tocopherol (vitamin E) being of benefit in rodent models of antipsychotic induced dyskinesia
∑ some studies showing increased blood or CSF levels of lipid peroxidation byproducts in patients
with tardive dyskinesia compared with those without tardive dyskinesia.
One problem with this hypothesis is that vitamin E treatment of tardive dyskinesia in general does
not lead to major clinical improvement.
GABA insufficiency
According to one version of this hypothesis, the following sequence of events takes place:
long-term treatment with antipsychotic (neuroleptic) medication
Ædestruction of GABAergic neurones in the striatum
Ædecreased feedback inhibition
Ætardive dyskinesia.
According to another version, the sequence of events is:
long-term treatment with antipsychotic (neuroleptic) medication
Ædecreased GABAergic neuronal activity in the pars reticulata of the substantia nigra
Ædecreased inhibition of involuntary movements
Ætardive dyskinesia.
Bibliography 205
Noradrenergic dysfunction
According to this hypothesis, noradrenergic over-activity contributes to the pathophysiology of
tardive dyskinesia. Evidence in favour of this hypotheses includes:
∑ Patients with tardive dyskinesia have been found to have significantly greater dopamine
b-hydroxylase activity than those without tardive dyskinesia.
∑ platelet 3H-dihydroergocryptine-a2 adrenergic receptor binding and CSF noradrenaline have
been found to be significantly correlated with the severity of tardive dyskinesia.
One problem with the hypothesis is that it has not so far proved possible effectively to treat
tardive dyskinesia with noradrenergic drugs.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Akbarian, S., Vinuela, A., Kim, J.J. et al. 1993a: Distorted distribution of nicotinamide–adenine dinucleotide
phosphate–diaphorase neurons in temporal lobe of schizophrenics implies anomalous cortical development.
Archives of General Psychiatry 50:178–187.
Akbarian, S., Bunney, W.E., Potkin, S.G. et al. 1993b: Altered distribution of nicotinamide–adenine dinucleotide
phosphate–diaphorase cells in frontal lobe of schizophrenics implies disturbances of cortical development.
Archives of General Psychiatry 50:169–177.
Akbarian, S., Kim, J.J., Potkin, S.G. et al. 1995: Gene expression for glutamic acid decarboxylase is reduced without
loss of neurons in prefrontal cortex of schizophrenics. Archives of General Psychiatry 52:258–266.
Altshuler, L.L., Conrad, A., Kovelman, J.A. & Scheibel, A. 1987: Hippocampal pyramidal cell orientation in
schizophrenia: a controlled neurohistologic study of the Yakovlev collection. Archives of General Psychiatry
44:1094–1098.
Altshuler, L.L., Casanova, M.F., Goldberg, T.E. & Kleinman, J.E. 1990: The hippocampus and parahippocampus in
schizophrenia, suicide, and control brains. Archives of General Psychiatry 47:1029–1034.
206 Neuropathology
Arnold, S.E., Hyman, B.T., Van Hoesen, G.W. & Damasio, A.R. 1991: Some cytoarchitectural abnormalities of the
entorhinal cortex in schizophrenia. Archives of General Psychiatry 48:625–632.
Arnold, S.E., Franz, B.R., Gur, R.C. et al. 1995: Smaller neuron size in schizophrenia in hippocampal subfields that
mediate cortical–hippocampal interactions. American Journal of Psychiatry 152:738–748.
Bauman, M.L. 1991: Microscopic neuroanatomic abnormalities in autism. Pediatrics 87:791–796.
Bauman, M. & Kemper, T.L. 1985: Histoanatomic observations of brain in early infantile autism. Neurology
35:866–874.
Benes, F.M., Davidson, J. & Bird, E.D. 1986: Quantitative cytoarchitectural studies of the cerebral cortex of
schizophrenics. Archives of General Psychiatry 43:31–35.
Benes, F.M., Majocha, R., Bird, E.D. & Marotta, C.A. 1987: Increased vertical axon numbers in cingulate cortex of
schizophrenics. Archives of General Psychiatry 44:1017–1021.
Bogerts, B., Falkai, P., Haupts, M. et al. 1990: Postmortem volume measurements of limbic system and basal
ganglia structures in chronic schizophrenics: initial results from a new brain collection. Schizophrenia
Research 3:295–301.
Brown, R., Colter, N., Corsellis, J.A. et al. 1986: Postmortem evidence of structural brain changes in schizophrenia:
differences in brain weight, temporal horn area, and parahippocampal gyrus compared with affective disorder.
Archives of General Psychiatry 43:36–42.
Bruton, C.J., Crow, T.J., Frith, C.D. et al. 1990: Schizophrenia and the brain: a prospective clinico-
neuropathological study. Psychological Medicine 20: 285–304.
Conrad, A.J., Abebe, T., Austin, R., Forsythe, S. & Scheibel, A.B. 1991: Hippocampal pyramidal cell disarray in
schizophrenia as a bilateral phenomenon. Archives of General Psychiatry 48:413–417.
Courchesne, E., Yeung Courchesne, R., Press, G.A., Hesselink, J.R. & Jerningan, T.L. 1988: Hypoplasia of cerebellar
vermal lobules VI and VII in autism. New England Journal of Medicine 318:1349–1354.
Crow, T.J., Ball, J., Bloom, S.R. et al. 1989: Schizophrenia as an anomaly of development of cerebral asymmetry: a
postmortem study and a proposal concerning the genetic basis of the disease. Archives of General Psychiatry
46:1145–1150.
Eastwood, S.L. & Harrison, P.J. 1995: Decreased synaptophysin in the medial temporal lobe in schizophrenia
demonstrated using immunoautoradiography. Neuroscience 69:339–343.
Eastwood, S.L., Burnet, P.W. & Harrison, P.J. 1995: Altered synaptophysin expression as a marker of synaptic
pathology in schizophrenia. Neuroscience 66:309–319.
Goldsmith, S.K. & Joyce, J.N. 1995: Alterations in hippocampal mossy fiber pathway in schizophrenia and
Alzheimer’s disease. Biological Psychiatry 37:122–126.
Jellinger, K. 1985: Neuromorphological background of pathochemical studies in major psychoses. In Beckman, H.
(ed.) Pathochemical Markers in Major Psychoses. Heidelberg: Springer Verlag, 1–23.
Jeste, D.V. & Lohr, J.B. 1989: Hippocampal pathologic findings in schizophrenia: a morphometric study. Archives
of General Psychiatry 46:1019–1024.
Kovelman, J.A. & Scheibel, A.B. 1984: A neurohistological correlate of schizophrenia. Biological Psychiatry
19:1601–1621.
Pakkenberg, B. 1987: Postmortem study of chronic schizophrenic brains. British Journal of Psychiatry
151:744–752.
Puri, B.K. 2001: Impaired phospholipid-related signal transduction in advanced Huntington’s disease.
Experimental Physiology 86:683–685.
Ritvo, E.R., Freeman, B.J., Scheibel, A.B. et al. 1986: Lower Purkinje cell counts in the cerebella of four autistic
subjects: initial findings of the UCLA/NSAC autopsy research report. American Journal of Psychiatry
143:862–866.
Roberts, G.W., Colter, N., Lofthouse, R., Johnstone, E.C. & Crow, T.J. 1987: Is there gliosis in schizophrenia?
Investigation of the temporal lobe. Biological Psychiatry 22:1459–1468.
Soustek, Z. 1989: Ultrastructure of cortical synapses in the brain of schizophrenics. Zentralblatt für Allgemeine
Patholic und Pathologische Anatomie 135:25–32.
12
Neuroimaging techniques
X-RAY
NEUROPSYCHIATRIC APPLICATIONS
The main use nowadays of skull radiography is in the assessment of trauma. It may also be useful in
the detection of intracranial expanding lesions.
CT
NEUROPSYCHIATRIC APPLICATIONS
Where available, CT and MRI (see below) have largely replaced skull radiography. Clinical uses of
CT include the detection of:
208 Neuroimaging techniques
PET
PET is positron emission tomography. It is a form of functional imaging. The basis of PET
neuroimaging is as follows:
1 A positron-emitting radioisotope or radiolabelled ligand is introduced into the cerebral
circulation. Routes commonly used are:
∑ intravenous administration (the radioactive substance is in solution)
∑ by inhalation (the radioactive substance is in gaseous form).
2 Then:
∑ Æ blood flow ± cerebral tissue binding in the brain
∑ Æ emission of positrons
∑ Æ positron–electron interactions
∑ Æ dual g photon emissions
∑ Æ detection of g photons
∑ Æ computer reconstruction of emerging g photon data.
3 Slice images are produced of the distribution of the radioisotopes in the brain.
The positron-emitting radioisotopes used can be produced in small cyclotrons.
NEUROPSYCHIATRIC APPLICATIONS
PET neuroimaging can give information about:
∑ metabolic changes
∑ regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF)
∑ ligand binding.
Clinical applications of PET include:
∑ cerebrovascular disease
∑ Alzheimer’s disease
∑ epilepsy, prior to neurosurgery
∑ head injury.
Some measurements made by PET, for example the study of regional cerebral blood flow, are
likely to be increasingly replaced by functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), since the latter
does not require the use of radioactive isotopes. On the other hand, fMRI is not a suitable
replacement for PET for ligand binding studies.
MRI 209
SPECT
NEUROPSYCHIATRIC APPLICATIONS
SPECT neuroimaging can give information about:
∑ regional cerebral blood flow (rCBF)
∑ ligand binding.
It is also of use in conditions in which the onset of the symptomatology being studied (e.g. epileptic
seizures, auditory hallucinations) may occur at a time when the patient is not in or near a scanner;
a suitable radioligand (e.g. 99m-technetium hexamethylpropylene amine oxime – HMPAO) can be
administered at the material time and the patient scanned afterwards.
Clinical applications of SPECT include Alzheimer’s disease.
The resolution of SPECT is generally poorer than that of PET, and both are likely to be
increasingly replaced by fMRI. However, fMRI is not a suitable replacement for SPECT for ligand
studies or for the type of study mentioned above in which the onset of the symptomatology being
studied may occur at a time when the subject is not in or near a scanner.
MRI
MRI is magnetic resonance imaging. It was previously referred to as nuclear magnetic resonance
(NMR). In vivo NMR is now taken to include MRI, MRA (magnetic resonance angiography), MRS
(magnetic resonance spectroscopy), and fMRI. In addition, it is possible to carry out in vitro NMR
studies of tissues at higher magnetic field strengths (say, over 11 teslas) than are currently allowed
for human subjects.
MRI and MRA are forms of structural imaging. MRS and fMRI are types of functional imaging.
The basis of MRI is as follows:
1 The patient is placed in a strong static magnetic field.
2 Then:
∑ Æ alignment of proton spin axes
∑ Æ pulses of radio-frequency waves at specified frequencies are administered
210 Neuroimaging techniques
NEUROPSYCHIATRIC APPLICATIONS
MRI is useful in most clinical and research studies requiring high-resolution neuroanatomical
imaging.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bydder, G.M. 1983: Clinical aspects of NMR imaging. In Steiner, R. (ed.) Recent Advances in Radiology and Medical
Imaging. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone, 15–33.
Costa, D.C. & Ell, P.J. 1991: Brain Blood Flow in Neurology and Psychiatry. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Costa, D.C., Morgan, G.F. & Lassen, N.A. 1993: New Trends in Nuclear Neurology and Psychiatry. London: John
Libbey.
Gadian, D.G. 1995: NMR and its Applications to Living Systems, 2nd edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Ketonen, L.M. & Berg, M.J. 1996: Clinical Neuroradiology. London: Arnold.
Puri, B.K. 2000: MRI and MRS in neuropsychiatry. In Young, I.R., Grant, D.M. & Harris, R.K. (eds) Methods in
Biomedical Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Spectroscopy. New York: John Wiley.
13
Neurophysiology
Neurones
Resting membrane ion permeabilities
The comparative permeabilities to different ions of the resting neuronal membrane are as follows:
∑ K+ (potassium ions) – relatively permeable
∑ Na+ (sodium ions) – relatively impermeable
∑ Cl- (chloride ions) – freely permeable
∑ organic anions – relatively impermeable.
Action potential
Neuronal stimulation leads to local depolarization.
If degree of depolarization > (a critical threshold) Æ nerve impulse or action potential.
During an action potential, the membrane potential rapidly becomes positive, before returning to
become negative. This is caused by an increase first in Na+ permeability, allowing the inflow of Na+,
212 Neurophysiology
and then in K+ permeability (with a rapid reduction in Na+ permeability at the same time), causing
an outflow of K+ and thereby restoring the negative membrane potential. The sodium pump then
restores the original ionic concentrations.
∑ Propagation of action potential. An action potential is propagated by the depolarization
spreading laterally to adjacent parts of the neurone.
∑ All-or-none phenomenon. The passage of an action potential along a neurone is an all-or-none
phenomenon.
∑ Absolute refractory period. This is the period during which the active part of the neuronal
membrane has a reversed polarity so that conduction or initiation of another action potential is
not possible in it.
∑ Relative refractory period. This is the period of repolarization after an action potential, during
which hyperpolarization occurs, making it more difficult for stimulation to allow the membrane
potential to reach the critical threshold.
∑ Conduction in unmyelinated fibres. The greater the diameter of the fibre the faster is the rate of
transmission.
∑ Conduction in myelinated fibres. The action potential appears to jump from one node of Ranvier
to the next, skipping the intervening myelinated parts. This rapid form of conduction is known
as saltatory conduction.
Synapses
Synapses may be found between:
∑ two neurones
∑ motoneurones and muscle cells
∑ sensory neurones and sensory receptors.
A synaptic cleft is the gap at a synapse between the membrane of a presynaptic fibre and that of
the postsynaptic fibre.
There are two types of synapse:
∑ Chemical. This is the more common type, in which a chemical neurotransmitter is stored in
presynaptic vesicles.
∑ Electrical. These are faster than chemical synapses, with direct membrane-to-membrane
connection via gap junctions.
Synaptic transmission
At chemical synapses the following events take place during synaptic transmission:
1 An action potential arrives at the presynaptic membrane.
2 There is influx of Ca2+ (calcium ions).
3 Presynaptic vesicles fuse to the presynaptic membrane.
4 Neurotransmitter is released into the synaptic cleft.
5 There is passage of neurotransmitter across the synaptic cleft.
6 Neurotransmitter binds to postsynaptic receptors.
7 There are ion permeability changes in the postsynaptic membrane.
8 There is postsynaptic depolarization or hyperpolarization (depending on the type of
neurotransmitter).
Pituitary hormones 213
Summation
One EPSP on its own is not usually sufficient to initiate an action potential. However, temporal
and/or spatial summation may allow the degree of depolarization to reach the critical threshold.
IPSPs, on summating with EPSPs, counter the effect of the latter.
Sensory receptors
The main types of sensory receptor in humans are:
∑ mechanoreceptors
∑ thermoreceptors
∑ light receptors
∑ nociceptors
∑ chemoreceptors.
Adaptation
In response to a continuous prolonged appropriate stimulus, most sensory receptors exhibit
adaptation:
∑ phasic receptors – the receptor firing stops
∑ tonic receptors – the receptor firing frequency falls to a low maintained level.
PITUITARY HORMONES
ACTH
This is a single-chain peptide which stimulates the production of the steroid hormone cortisol by
the adrenal glands.
FSH
Follicle-stimulating hormone consists of two peptide chains, a and b. FSH stimulates the gonads
(ovaries and testes).
214 Neurophysiology
Table 13.1 The anterior piuitary hormones and their corresponding hypothalamic releasing factors (hormones)
and release-inhibiting factors (hormones)
∑ In males, FSH stimulates seminiferous tubule Sertoli cells to promote the growth of spermatozoa
and also stimulates the release of inhibin A (the a subunit) and inhibin B (the b subunit). (In
turn, inhibin causes a negative feedback on the secretion of FSH by the anterior pituitary gland.)
∑ In females, FSH stimulates the development of follicles. It also stimulates the activity of
aromatose, which in turn stimulates the conversion of ovarian androgens into oestrogens. As in
males, FSH stimulates the release of inhibin (from stromal cells of the ovary), which in turn
causes a negative feedback on the secretion of FSH by the anterior pituitary gland.
LH
Luteinizing hormone consists of two peptide chains, a and b; the a chain of LH is the same as that
of FSH. LH stimulates the gonads (ovaries and testes).
∑ In males, LH stimulates the testicular Leydig cells to produce testosterone.
∑ In females, LH stimulates the ovaries to produce androgens. In menstruating females, a surge of
LH mid-cycle induces ovulation.
MSH
Melanocyte-stimulating hormone does not appear to be found in the human anterior pituitary. Its
functions in relation to pigmentation appear to have been taken over by ACTH and b-lipotrophin.
Prolactin
Prolactin is a single-chain peptide hormone that acts on the mammary glands to stimulate the
secretion of milk (normally during lactation). It also inhibits activity of the testes and ovaries.
GH
Growth hormone is a peptide hormone that stimulates the hepatic secretion of IGF-1 (insulin-like
growth factor-1; previously termed somatomedin C). In turn, binding of IGF-1 to widespread IGF-
BP (IGF-binding proteins) leads to the stimulation of anabolism (by stimulating the retention of
calcium, phosphorus and nitrogen, thereby promoting growth in bones, for example) and
stimulating the widespread biosynthesis of protein and collagen. Another important action of IGF-
1 is in terms of opposing the action of insulin.
Integrated behaviours 215
TSH
Thyroid-stimulating hormone consists of two peptide chains, a and b; the a chain of TSH is the
same as that of LH (and of FSH). TSH stimulates the synthesis by the thyroid gland of the thyroid
hormones T4 and T3. TSH also stimulates the release of T4 and T3 from the thyroid gland. (In turn,
T3 exerts a negative feedback control on the secretion of TRH and TSH.)
AVP or ADH
Arginine vasopressin or antidiuretic hormone is a nonapeptide that acts on the distal convoluted
tubule and collecting ducts of the renal nephron to exert an antidiuretic effect.
Oxytocin
Oxytocin is a nonapeptide that stimulates contraction of the uterine myometrium during
parturition (and perhaps during sexual intercourse), and, postpartum, stimulates the ejection of
milk from the mammary glands during lactation. In rats, it has been found that centrally
administered oxytocin has a satiety action (in both males and females). Oxytocin also has a
natriuretic action in both males and females.
INTEGRATED BEHAVIOURS
Regulatory behaviour
A regulatory behaviour is one that is controlled by a homeostatic mechanism. Examples include
behaviours related to hunger (feeding) and thirst (drinking).
In contrast, a non-regulatory behaviour is one that is not controlled by a homeostatic
mechanism. Examples include sexual behaviour and parenting behaviour.
Pain
The neural pathway for pain is as follows.
Pain detection by receptors (for example, nociceptors in the skin)
Æ dorsal-root ganglion neurones to spinal cord
Æ ventral spinothalamic tract
Æ medial lemniscus
Æ ventrolateral thalamus
Æ primary somatosensory cortex.
According to the gate theory of pain, gates in the spinal cord, involving activity in spinal cord
interneurones, can modify the perception of pain. These gates may also exist in the brainstem and
216 Neurophysiology
even the cerebral cortex. This theory may explain why shifting attention away from the source of
pain to something else may help reduce the severity of the pain that the subject is conscious of.
Hormonal substances, such as endorphins, may also influence the perception of pain. For
example, during times of war, a soldier at the front may hardly feel any pain initially following a
traumatic bodily injury such as the loss of part of a limb. In contrast, the same injury incurred in
civilian life during peacetime may cause the same person to scream out in agony.
Motor function
At its simplest, motor activity involves the following pathway:
Activity in the motor cortex (primary motor cortex – precentral gyrus, Brodmann area 4)
Æ ipsilateral corticospinal tract
Æ pyramidal decussation
Æ ipsilateral (mainly) ventral corticospinal tract (moves midline muscles) and contralateral
(mainly) lateral corticospinal tract (moves limb muscles).
Arousal
Further details regarding sleep and arousal are given later in this chapter. Here, we consider the
changes in thalamocortical systems that occur in sleep and arousal. Basically, the hypothalamus
appears to contain neuronal circuits that mediate homeostatic sleep mechanisms.
One important subcortical circuit involved is as follows. Output from the ventrolateral preoptic
area, suprachiasmatic nucleus, and tuberomammillary nucleus of the hypothalamus synchronizes
the non-rapid-eye-movement/rapid-eye-movement (NREM–REM) sleep cycle mechanisms of the
pontine brainstem. The parts of the latter that appear to be particularly involved are the:
∑ locus coeruleus
∑ raphe nuclei
∑ dorsolateral tegmental nucleus
∑ pedunculo pontine tegmental nucleus.
A second subcortical system of importance involves output from the ventrolateral preoptic area,
suprachiasmatic nucleus, and tuberomammillary nucleus of the hypothalamus to the thalamus, and
thence to the cerebral cortex.
Sexual behaviour
This is a non-regulatory form of behaviour with complex control mechanisms.
Sex hormones have an important effect on the brain. In male fetuses, during development
testosterone masculinizes the brain. This is the organizing effect of the hormone. This effect is
particularly noteworthy in the hypothalamic preoptic area; this area is much larger in males
following exposure to testosterone.
In the adult brain, sex hormones have an activating effect. In male adults, testosterone acts on the
amygdala to stimulate the motivation to carry out sexual activity. Testosterone also acts on the
hypothalamus to stimulate copulatory behaviour. In particular, stimulation of the medial preoptic
area, in the presence of circulating testosterone, induces copulatory behaviour in primates.
Integrated behaviours 217
(Destruction of the medial preoptic area in male monkeys, in which testosterone is circulating, is
associated with an abolition of mating; but masturbation in the presence of out-of-reach females
has been noted.) In female adults, ovarian hormones also appear to act on the amygdala to stimulate
the motivation to carry out sexual activity. In infrahuman quadrapedal mammals, the action of
ovarian hormones on the ventromedial hypothalamus stimulates lordosis (arching of the back,
staying still with the back side elevated – a position that is receptive for copulatory behaviour).
Humans are aware of the importance of cognitive influences on sexual behaviour. The influence
of the cerebral cortex in this context is clearly important but complex. For instance, while frontal
lobe lesions are often associated with a loss of sexual inhibition, loss of libido may also occur in
some cases.
Hunger
Feeding is a regulatory behaviour that particularly involves inputs from the following systems:
∑ digestive system (including insulin) and satiety signals
∑ hypothalamus
∑ cognition.
Insulin
The most important hormone which affects caloric homeostasis is insulin. When hungry, first the
smell and then the taste of a meal causes signals to be sent in the following way:
Smell of food ± taste of food
Æ aroma and taste signals
Æ cerebral cortex
Æ hypothalamus
Æ dorsal motor nucleus of the vagus nerve (cranial nerve X)
Æ vagal cholinergic fibres
Æ pancreas
Æ insulin secretion from pancreatic B cells.
This is known as the cephalic phase of insulin secretion.
Entry of food into the stomach and duodenum leads to a further secretion of insulin; this is the
gastrointestinal phase of insulin secretion.
Breakdown products from digested food enter the bloodstream and directly act on the pancreas,
further stimulating the secretion of insulin. This is known as the substrate phase of insulin secretion.
Satiety signals
Gastric distension, for example following the ingestion of food, gives rise to satiety signals along the
following pathway:
Food ingestion
Æ gastric distension
Æ stimulation of gastric wall stretch receptors
Æ vagal nerve transmission
Æ nucleus of tractus solitarius and area postrema (in the brainstem)
Æ hypothalamus
Æ cerebral cortex
Æ perception of gastric distension.
218 Neurophysiology
There exist other systems that also provide feedback to the brain from the alimentary canal.
For example, as the ingested (and partially digested) food reaches the intestines, many different
peptides are released. Just one of these, CCK (cholecystokinin), can stimulate vagal afferents
carrying pyloric gastric stretch receptor signals to the brainstem, thereby providing synergy with
the satiety signal system outlined above. Moreover, infrahuman mammalian experiments have
demonstrated the satiety action of CCK directly infused into the hypothalamus. Another neuro-
peptide that may affect hunger is oxytocin, intracerebroventricular injection of which decreases
food intake in rats.
Caloric intake also has a direct satiety effect, although the precise mechanism by which this
occurs is not clear at the time of writing.
Satiety signals are also given rise to by postgastric actions of ingested food. One mechanism
involved is undoubtedly related to the liver.
The hormone leptin (or Ob protein), biosynthesized in adipose tissue, has a circulating plasma
concentration that is positively correlated with overall adiposity. Leptin has a satiety action when
experimentally directly infused into cerebral ventricles, and hypothalamic leptin receptors have
been identified.
Hypothalamus
Rodent experiments from the 1950s onwards have suggested these facts:
∑ The ventrolateral hypothalamus (VLH) contains a hunger centre; bilateral damage to this area
causes aphagia in rats.
∑ The ventromedial hypothalamus (VMH) contains a satiety centre; damage to this area may
cause hyperphagia in rats.
This is known as the dual-centre hypothesis. More recent evidence has suggested that this simple
hypothesis is, in fact, incorrect. The true reason why bilateral ventromedial hypothalamic damage
leads to hyperphagia is related to:
∑ an increase in parasympathetic tone
∑ an increase in vagal reflexes (and therefore an increased rate of gastric emptying)
∑ a reduction in sympathetic tone
∑ a resetting of a hypothetical homeostatic set point
∑ an increase in the accumulation of stored fat
∑ a reduction in satiety duration following feeding.
Opposite effects occur following bilateral ventrolateral hypothalamus damage.
The neuropeptide NPY (neuropeptide Y) appears to act on the paraventricular nucleus to
increase food intake.
Cognitive factors
As with sexual behaviour, cognitive factors are clearly of importance in the integrated behaviour of
hunger and feeding. The ability of people to fast, for example, shows that cognitive activity can
override satiety signalling and any putative hypothalamic factors.
The amygdala is thought to play some role in hunger and feeding. It is known, for example, that
damage to the amygdala is associated with the abolition of taste-aversion learning and also with a
change in the types of food that are preferred.
Damage to the inferior prefrontal cortex often appears to be associated with reduced food intake.
This may, however, be at least partly related to the fact that this part of the cerebral cortex receives
olfactory signals, so that damage to the cortex may reduce the ability to respond to the aroma and
taste of food.
Integrated behaviours 219
Thirst
Drinking is a regulatory behaviour. There are two types of homeostatic mechanisms that are of
relevance, and that give rise to two different types of thirst. They are:
∑ osmotic homeostasis (related to osmotic thirst)
∑ volume homeostasis (related to hypovolaemic thirst).
Osmotic thirst
Osmotic thirst occurs when the concentrations of solutes in body fluids such as the plasma become
too high. This may occur as a result of a rise in concentration of one or more solutes (for example,
following sodium loading after eating a meal rich in sodium salts such as sodium chloride and
monosodium glutamate). It may also occur as a result of water deprivation (dehydration) or the
copious loss of dilute fluids such as sweat. Under any of these circumstances, the osmotic
homeostatic mechanism requires that water be drunk.
Before the behaviour associated with osmotic thirst kicks in, the body relies on its large poste-
rior pituitary stores of AVP (arginine vasopressin) to try to rectify the osmolality of the extracel-
lular and intracellular fluid compartments. The mechanism appears to involve the following
pathway.
Increase in solutes/water deprivation/dehydration/loss of dilute fluid
Æ raised extracellular fluid osmolality (and therefore also raised intracellular fluid osmolality
via osmosis)
Æ stimulation of osmoreceptor cells in the organ of the lamina terminalis, subfornical organ,
median preoptic nucleus, and magnocellular neurones in the supraoptic nucleus and
paraventricular nucleus
Æ projections from the organ of the lamina terminalis to the median preoptic nucleus, and to
the magnocellular AVP-secreting cells of the supraoptic nucleus and paraventricular nucleus
further stimulate these other brain regions
Æ secretion of AVP from the posterior pituitary
Æ stimulation of AVP V2 renal receptors
Æ increased water permeability of distal convoluted tubules and collecting ducts of nephrons
Æ increased water retention, increased urinary osmolality, and reduced urinary volume
Æ restoration of extracellular fluid osmolality.
At the time of writing, the neural pathways in the forebrain that are related to thirst have not
been clearly identified.
Another mechanism involved in osmotic homeostasis and osmotic thirst is the increased urinary
excretion of sodium ions as a result of the actions of ANP (atrial natriuretic peptide) and oxytocin.
ANP is released from the cardiac atria in response to increased atrial distension, in turn caused by
hyperosmolality of the extracellular fluid. The release of oxytocin from the posterior pituitary has
been mentioned earlier in this chapter.
Hypovolaemic thirst
Hypovolaemic thirst occurs when the total volume of body fluids such as the plasma becomes too
low. This may occur as a result of blood loss, for example. The hypovolaemic homeostatic
mechanism requires that fluids that contain solutes be drunk; if only pure water were drunk, then
hypo-osmolality would result. In experiments, hypovolaemic rats that are given a choice of pure
water or concentrated sodium chloride solution have been observed to drink enough of each in
order to be imbibing isotonic levels overall.
220 Neurophysiology
Sleep architecture
Sleep is divided into the following two phases:
∑ rapid-eye-movement (REM) sleep, during which the eyes undergo rapid movements and there is
a high level of brain activity
Arousal and sleep 221
Stages of sleep
The following stages normally occur during normal non-REM sleep:
stage 0 – quiet wakefulness and shut eyes; EEG: alpha activity
stage 1 – falling asleep; EEG: low amplitude, Ø alpha activity, low-voltage theta activity
stage 2 – light sleep; EEG: 2–7 Hz, occasional sleep spindles and K complexes
stage 3 – deep sleep; ≠ delta activity (20–50%)
stage 4 – deep sleep; ≠≠ delta activity (>50%).
Stage 3 + stage 4 = slow-wave sleep (SWS).
Non-REM sleep
Features of non-REM sleep include:
∑ Ø recall of dreaming if awoken during REM sleep
∑ Ø complexity of dreams
∑ ≠ parasympathetic activity
∑ upward ocular deviation with few or no movements
∑ abolition of tendon reflexes
∑ Ø heart rate
∑ Ø systolic blood pressure
∑ Ø respiratory rate
∑ Ø cerebral blood flow
∑ penis not usually erect.
Monoaminergic model
In this model:
∑ non-REM sleep is associated with serotonergic neuronal activity – raphe complex
∑ REM sleep is associated with noradrenergic neuronal activity – locus coeruleus.
Cellular model
In this model three groups of central neurones are of importance. These groups, and their
corresponding neurotransmitters, are the:
∑ pontine gigantocellular tegmental fields (nucleus reticularis pontis caudalis) – acetylcholine
∑ dorsal raphe nuclei – serotonin
∑ locus coeruleus – noradrenaline.
Lambda activity
Lambda activity occurs over the occipital region in subjects with their eyes open. It is related to
ocular movements during visual attention.
Mu activity
Mu activity occurs over the motor cortex. It is related to motor activity and is abolished by
movement of the contralateral limb.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
TRANSMITTER SYNTHESIS
The synthesis of the neurotransmitters noradrenaline, serotonin, dopamine, GABA and
acetylcholine is considered later in this chapter.
TRANSMITTER STORAGE
The transmitter at a synaptic cleft is stored in presynaptic vesicles. Each vesicle contains one
quantum, usually corresponding to several thousand molecules, of transmitter.
TRANSMITTER RELEASE
Transmitter release from synaptic vesicles takes place by exocytosis in a process controlled by Ca2+
influx. Because the number of vesicles released is an integer, transmitter release is essentially quantal
in nature. The Ca2+ enters via voltage-dependent ion channels. Importantly, Na+ influx and/or K+
efflux are not needed for transmitter release. Ca2+ influences or regulates:
∑ the probability of vesicular transmitter release
∑ vesicular fusion
∑ the transport of synaptic vesicles to the presynaptic active zone of exocytosis
∑ post-tetanic potentiation
∑ tonic depolarization of the presynaptic neurone.
ION CHANNELS
Ion channels are now classified into families on the basis of genetic sequence homology and, usually,
pore-lining a subunit topology. The main families are as follows:
226 Neurochemistry
∑ 6-TM
∑ 2-TM
∑ 4-TM or 8-TM
∑ ionotropic glutamate receptors
∑ nicotinic ACh and related receptors
∑ intracellular calcium ion channels
∑ chloride ion channels.
RECEPTORS
STRUCTURE
In general, the receptors to which neurotransmitters bind are proteins located on the external
surface of cell membranes. Until the 1980s receptors were classified and identified
pharmacologically but not according to their structures. Since 1983, however, when the primary
amino acid sequence of a receptor subunit of the nicotinic acetylcholine receptor was discovered,
the DNA of an increasing number of receptor proteins have been sequenced, and hence their amino
acid sequences discovered. This has led to a further clarification of receptor classification. It has also
become evident that, as expected, for receptors of classical neurotransmitters the amino acids
forming the binding site are on or close to the extracellular side of the receptor.
FUNCTION
The main function of a receptor is the molecular recognition of a signalling molecule, which in the
case of neurotransmission is a neurotransmitter, leading in turn to signal transduction. A receptor
generally responds to neurotransmitter binding in one of two ways:
∑ neurotransmitter binding Æ opening of transmembrane ion channel
∑ receptor–neurotransmitter Æ second-messenger system activation/inhibition.
G proteins
G proteins (named after their ability to bind guanosine triphosphate (GTP) and guanosine
diphosphate (GDP)) are often involved in transmembrane signalling, linking receptors to
intracellular effector systems. For neurotransmitter binding, the following types of G protein may
be involved:
∑ Gs
∑ Gi
∑ Go
∑ Gq.
Second messengers
Two of the most important second messenger systems are:
∑ receptor-neurotransmitter complex Æ G protein binding to receptor–neurotransmitter
complex Æ adenylate cyclase activation (or inhibition) Æ cyclic AMP (cAMP)
∑ neurotransmitter binding Æ hydrolysis of phosphatidylinositol biphosphate (a membrane
228 Neurochemistry
ADRENOCEPTORS
The adrenergic receptors are coupled to G proteins, via which they produce their physiological
effects. At the time of writing, the main adrenergic receptors and their main effectors (via G protein
a subunits) are believed to be:
∑ a1A Æ≠ Ca2+ (via Gi/Go)
∑ a1B Æ≠ IP3 (via Gq)
∑ a1C Æ≠ IP3 (via Gq)
∑ a1D Æ≠ IP3 (via Gq)
∑ a2A (human)/a2D (probably rat homologue) ÆØ adenylyl cyclase, ≠ K+, Ø Ca2+ (via Gi)
∑ a2B ÆØ adenylate cyclase (via Gi)
∑ a2C ÆØ adenylate cyclase (via Go)
∑ b1 Æ≠ adenylate cyclase (via Gs)
∑ b2 Æ≠ adenylate cyclase (via Gs).
The excitatory a1 adrenoceptors are postsynaptic, while the inhibitory a2 adrenoceptors are
found as both presynaptic and postsynaptic receptors.
SEROTONERGIC RECEPTORS
The main serotonergic receptors, grouped according to their relative homologies, and their
signalling systems, believed to exist at the time of writing, are as follows:
∑ 5-HT1A ÆØ adenylate cyclase
∑ 5-HT1B ÆØ adenylate cyclase
∑ 5-HT1Da ÆØ adenylate cyclase
∑ 5-HT1Db ÆØ adenylate cyclase
∑ 5-HT1E ÆØ adenylate cyclase
∑ 5-HT2A Æ≠ IP3
∑ 5-HT2B Æ≠ IP3
∑ 5-HT2C Æ≠ IP3
∑ 5-HT3 – ion channel
∑ 5-HT5A – signalling system not known at the time of writing
∑ 5-HT5B – signalling system not known at the time of writing
∑ 5-HT6 Æ≠ adenylate cyclase
∑ 5-HT7 Æ≠ adenylate cyclase.
DOPAMINERGIC RECEPTORS
The dopaminergic receptors are coupled to G proteins, via which they produce their physiological
effects. At the time of writing, the main dopaminergic receptors and their main effectors (via G
protein a subunits) are believed to be:
∑ D1 Æ≠ adenylate cyclase (via Gs)
∑ D2 ÆØ adenylate cyclase, ≠ K+, ØCa2+ (via Gi/Go)
∑ D3 ÆØ adenylate cyclase, ≠ K+, Ø Ca2+ (via Gi/Go)
Receptors 229
GABA RECEPTORS
The GABA receptor superfamilies may be large, with multiple types of GABA subunits having been
cloned. In general, there are two main types of receptor, the main effects of which are:
∑ GABAA Æ≠ Cl- (via a receptor-gated ion channel)
∑ GABAB Æ≠ K+ ± Ca2+ effects (via G protein coupling).
CHOLINERGIC RECEPTORS
Cholinergic receptors transduce signals via coupling with G proteins. At the time of writing, the
following types are recognized:
∑ nicotinic
∑ M1 (muscarinic)
∑ M2 (muscarinic)
∑ M3 (muscarinic)
∑ M4 (muscarinic)
∑ M5 (muscarinic).
GLUTAMATE RECEPTORS
The types of glutamate receptor recognized are:
∑ NMDA (N-methyl-D-aspartate) receptors
∑ AMPA (a-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazole propionic acid) receptors
∑ KA (kainic acid) receptors
∑ mGluRs (metabotropic glutamate receptors) (= trans-ACPD receptors).
The first three classes are ionotropic glutamate receptors that are coupled directly to cation-specific
ion channels.
NMDA receptors
At the time of writing, the NMDA receptor subtype is believed to include two families of subunits:
∑ NMDAR1 (= NR1)
∑ NMDAR2 (= NR2).
In turn, the following splice variants of NMDAR1 have been recognized:
∑ NMDAR1A (= NR1a)
∑ NMDAR1B (= NR1b)
∑ NMDAR1C (= NR1c)
∑ NMDAR1D (= NR1d)
∑ NMDAR1E (= NR1e)
∑ NMDAR1F (= NR1f)
∑ NMDAR1G (= NR1g).
Variants of NMDAR2 are modulatory subunits that form heteromeric channels but not homomeric
channels.
230 Neurochemistry
AMPA receptors
AMPA receptors can be formed from one or any two of:
∑ GluR1
∑ GluR2
∑ GluR3
∑ GluR4.
KA receptors
KA receptors include:
∑ GluR5
∑ GluR6
∑ GluR7
∑ KA1
∑ KA2.
mGluRs
The mGluRs are coupled to G proteins, unlike the other classes of glutamate receptor. At the time of
writing, the following subtypes have been cloned:
∑ mGluR1
∑ mGluR2
∑ mGluR3
∑ mGluR4
∑ mGluR5
∑ mGluR6.
These have been categorized into the following subgroups:
∑ subgroup I = mGluR1 and mGluR5
∑ subgroup II = mGluR2 and mGluR3
∑ subgroup III = mGluR4 and mGluR6.
The effector system for subgroup I involves stimulation of phospholipase C, while that for both
subgroup II and subgroup III involves inhibition of adenylate cyclase.
CLASSICAL NEUROTRANSMITTERS
Noradrenaline
Biosynthesis
The primary biosynthetic pathway is:
tyrosine
Æ DOPA (3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine)
Æ dopamine
Æ noradrenaline.
Classical neurotransmitters 231
Metabolism
The metabolic degradation of noradrenaline may begin with the action of either catechol-O-
methyltransferase (COMT) or monoamine oxidase (MAO). The catabolic pathway starting with the
action of COMT is as follows:
noradrenaline
Æ normetanephrine
Æ 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycolaldehyde
Æ VMA (vanillyl mandelic acid) = 3-methoxy-4-hydroxymandelic acid.
The corresponding enzymes are:
∑ COMT (acts on noradrenaline)
∑ MAO (acts on normetanephrine)
∑ aldehyde dehydrogenase (acts on 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycolaldehyde).
The catabolic pathway starting with the action of MAO has two major branches. The first branch
is as follows:
noradrenaline
Æ 3,4-dihydroxyphenylglycolaldehyde
Æ 3,4-dihydroxymandelic acid
Æ VMA (vanillyl mandelic acid) = 3-methoxy-4-hydroxymandelic acid.
The corresponding enzymes are:
∑ MAO (acts on noradrenaline)
∑ aldehyde dehydrogenase (acts on 3,4-dihydroxyphenylglycolaldehyde)
∑ COMT (acts on 3,4-dihydroxymandelic acid).
The second branch is as follows:
noradrenaline
Æ 3,4-dihydroxyphenylglycolaldehyde
Æ 3,4-dihydroxyphenylglycol
Æ MHPG (3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycol).
The corresponding enzymes are:
∑ MAO (acts on noradrenaline)
∑ aldehyde reductase (acts on 3,4-dihydroxyphenylglycolaldehyde)
∑ COMT (acts on 3,4-dihydroxyphenylglycol).
Re-uptake
Following its release into the synaptic cleft, the main method of inactivation of noradrenaline is by
means of re-uptake by presynaptic neurones.
232 Neurochemistry
Serotonin
Biosynthesis
The primary biosynthetic pathway is:
tryptophan
Æ 5-hydroxytryptophan
Æ serotonin.
The corresponding enzymes are:
∑ tryptophan hydroxylase (acts on tryptophan)
∑ 5-hydroxytryptophan decarboxylase = amino acid decarboxylase) (acts on 5-
hydroxytryptophan).
Metabolism
The metabolic degradation of serotonin is as follows:
serotonin
Æ 5-HIAA (5-hydroxyindoleacetic acid).
The enzyme catalyzing this is MAOA (MAO type A).
Dopamine
Biosynthesis
The primary biosynthetic pathway is:
tyrosine
Æ DOPA (3,4-dihydroxyphenylalanine)
Æ dopamine.
The corresponding enzymes are:
∑ tyrosine hydroxylase (acts on tyrosine)
∑ aromatic amino acid decarboxylase = DOPA decarboxylase (acts on DOPA).
Metabolism
The metabolic degradation of dopamine may begin with the action of either COMT or MAO. The
catabolic pathway starting with the action of COMT is as follows:
dopamine
Æ 3-methoxytyramine
Æ 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylacetaldehyde
Æ HVA (homovanillic acid).
The corresponding enzymes are:
∑ COMT (acts on dopamine)
∑ MAO (acts on 3-methoxytyramine)
∑ aldehyde dehydrogenase (acts on 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylacetaldehyde).
(A less important pathway allows 3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylacetaldehyde to be metabolized to 3-
methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylethanol via the action of aldehyde reductase.)
Neuropeptides 233
Re-uptake
Following its release into the synaptic cleft, the main method of inactivation of dopamine is by
means of re-uptake by presynaptic neurones.
GABA
Biosynthesis
GABA is derived from glutamic acid via the action of GAD (glutamic acid decarboxylase).
Metabolism
The metabolic breakdown of GABA to glutamic acid and succinic semialdehyde involves the action
of GABA transaminase (GABA-T).
Acetylcholine
Biosynthesis
Acetylcholine is derived from acetyl CoA and choline, in a reaction catalyzed by choline
acetyltransferase.
Metabolism
After release into the synaptic cleft, acetylcholine is hydrolyzed by cholinesterase into choline and
ethanoic (acetic) acid.
NEUROPEPTIDES
Some neurotransmitters consist of small proteins, or peptides. In this section, the following
neuropeptide transmitters are considered: CRH, CCK and the endogenous opioid peptides.
CORTICOTROPHIN-RELEASING HORMONE
The cell bodies responsible for secreting corticotrophin-releasing factor or hormone (CRF or CRH)
are located in the hypothalamic paraventricular nucleus. CRH is secreted from the hypothalamus
into the hypothalamopituitary portal system and in turn regulates the release of POMC (pro-
opiomelanocortin)-derived peptides, including corticotropin, from the adenohypophysis.
234 Neurochemistry
CHOLECYSTOKININ
Cholecystokinin (CCK), first located as gastrointestinal and pancreatic hormone, occurs in high
concentrations in the central nervous system, particularly in the cerebral cortex, hypothalamus and
limbic system. From a neuropsychiatric viewpoint, important cholecystokinin-like peptide
fragments in the brain include CCK-tetrapeptide (CCK-4) and octapeptide (CCK-8).
ENDOGENOUS OPIOIDS
Endogenous opioids isolated from the central nervous system are derived from peptide precursor
molecules:
∑ POMC Æ corticotropin, b-lipotropin
∑ proenkephalin Æ met-enkephalin, leu-enkephalin
∑ prodynorphin Æ dynorphin A, dynorphin B, a-neoendorphin.
The enkephalins met-enkephalin and leu-enkephalin are each pentapeptides.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
HISTORICAL OVERVIEW
Antidepressants
Tricyclic antidepressants and MAOIs
Tricyclic antidepressants and monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) were introduced between
1955 and 1958:
∑ MAOIs. These arose from the observation of elevated mood in patients with tuberculosis being
treated with the MAOI iproniazid, and less toxic MAOIs were subsequently developed. Kline
was one of the first to report the value of MAOI treatment in depression.
∑ Tricyclic antidepressants. Kuhn observed the antidepressant action of imipramine, while
studying chlorpromazine-like agents.
SSRIs
The selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs) were introduced in the late 1980s.
Lithium
In 1886, Lange proposed the use of lithium for treating excited states. Lithium was introduced by
Cade in 1949. Following his finding from animal experiments that lithium caused lethargy, Cade
observed (in 1948) that it led to clinical improvement in a patient with mania.
236 General principles of psychopharmacology
Antipsychotics
Reserpine
Reserpine was introduced by Sen and Bose in 1931, and in 1953 Kline confirmed that it was a
treatment for schizophrenia.
Typical antipsychotics
Important dates in the introduction of typical antipsychotics in psychiatric treatment in the
twentieth century include:
∑ In 1950, chlorpromazine was synthesized by Charpentier, who was attempting to synthesize an
antihistaminergic agent for anaesthetic use. Laborit then reported that chlorpromazine could
induce an artificial hibernation.
∑ The efficacy of chlorpromazine in the treatment of psychosis was reported by Paraire and
Sigwald in 1951, and by Delay and Deniker in 1952.
∑ In 1958, haloperidol was synthesized by Janssen.
Clozapine
Important dates in the introduction and, after 1988, the reintroduction of the atypical antipsychotic
clozapine include:
∑ In 1958, clozapine was synthesized as an imipramine analogue. Its actions appeared to be closer
to chlorpromazine than to imipramine.
∑ In 1961/2, the first clinical trial in schizophrenia (University Psychiatric Clinic, Bern) gave
disappointing results. Low doses of clozapine were used.
∑ In 1966, Gross and Langner reported good results in chronic schizophrenia.
∑ From 1975, clozapine was withdrawn from general clinical use in some countries owing to cases
of fatal agranulocytosis (including eight such deaths in Finland in 1975).
∑ In 1988, Kane and colleagues reported positive results from their multicentre double-blind
study of clozapine versus chlorpromazine in treatment-resistant schizophrenia. Subsequent
studies showed that social functioning also improved in response to clozapine.
Anxiolytics
Barbiturates
The first barbiturate, barbituric acid (malonylurea), was synthesized in 1864. The barbiturates were
introduced in 1903.
Benzodiazepines
The benzodiazepine chlordiazepoxide was synthesized in the late 1950s by Sternbach (working for
Roche) and introduced in 1960.
CLASSIFICATION
The examples given in each class of drug are not meant to be exhaustive.
Classification 237
Antipsychotics (neuroleptics)
TYPICAL ANTIPSYCHOTICS
In the following classification, note that the piperidine group of phenothiazines includes
thioridazine, which is classed here as an atypical antipsychotic.
∑ phenothiazines – aliphatic
∑ chlorpromazine
∑ levomepromazine (methotrimeprazine)
∑ promazine
∑ phenothiazines – piperazines
∑ fluphenazine
∑ trifluoperazine
∑ perphenazine
∑ prochlorperazine
∑ phenothiazines – piperidines
∑ pipothiazine palmitate
∑ pericyazine
∑ butyrophenones
∑ haloperidol
∑ droperidol
∑ benperidol
∑ trifluperidol
∑ thioxanthenes
∑ flupentixol
∑ zuclopenthixol
∑ diphenylbutylpiperidines
∑ pimozide
∑ fluspirilene.
ATYPICAL ANTIPSYCHOTICS
The atypical antipsychotics include:
∑ clozapine
∑ quetiapine
∑ risperidone
∑ sulpiride (a substituted benzamide; may also be categorized as a typical antipsychotic)
∑ amisulpride
∑ thioridazine (which may also be categorized as a typical antipsychotic)
∑ olanzapine
∑ sertindole (available only on a named-patient basis in the UK at the time of writing)
∑ zotepine
∑ aripiprazole (partial agonist at dopamine receptors).
Antimuscarinics (anticholinergics)
Antimuscarinic (anticholinergic) drugs used in the treatment of parkinsonism resulting from
pharmacotherapy with antipsychotics include:
238 General principles of psychopharmacology
∑ procyclidine
∑ trihexyphenidyl/benzhexol
∑ benzatropine (benztropine)
∑ orphenadrine
∑ biperiden.
Antidepressants
TRICYCLIC ANTIDEPRESSANTS
Tricyclic antidepressants include:
∑ dibenzocycloheptanes
∑ amitriptyline
∑ nortriptyline
∑ iminodibenzyls
∑ clomipramine
∑ imipramine
∑ trimipramine
∑ others
∑ amoxapine
∑ dosulepin/dothiepin
∑ doxepin
∑ lofepramine.
TRICYCLIC-RELATED ANTIDEPRESSANTS
Tricyclic-related antidepressants include:
∑ trazodone.
TETRACYCLIC ANTIDEPRESSANTS
Tetracyclic antidepressants include:
∑ maprotiline
∑ mianserin.
MAOIS
Monoamine oxidase inhibitors include:
∑ hydrazine compounds
∑ phenelzine
Classification 239
∑ isocarboxazid
∑ non-hydrazine compounds
∑ tranylcypromine.
SSRIS
Selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors include:
∑ fluvoxamine
∑ fluoxetine
∑ sertraline
∑ paroxetine
∑ citalopram
∑ escitalopram.
RIMA
There is currently one reversible inhibitors of monoamine oxidase-A (RIMA) in clinical use:
∑ moclobemide.
SNRI
At the time of writing there is one serotonin noradrenaline re-uptake inhibitor (SNRI) in clinical
use:
∑ venlafaxine.
NARI
The selective noradrenaline re-uptake inhibitor (NARI) in clinical use is:
∑ reboxetine.
NASSA
The noradrenergic and specific serotonergic antidepressant (NaSSA) in clinical use is:
∑ mirtazapine.
Benzodiazepines
Long-acting benzodiazepines include:
∑ diazepam
∑ alprazolam
∑ chlordiazepoxide
∑ clorazepate
∑ flunitrazepam
∑ flurazepam
∑ nitrazepam.
240 General principles of psychopharmacology
Other anxiolytics
Non-benzodiazepine anxiolytics in clinical use include:
∑ azaspirodecanediones – buspirone
∑ b-adrenoceptor blocking drugs – e.g. propranolol.
Antiandrogens
At the time of writing, there is one antiandrogen used for psychiatric reasons:
∑ cyproterone acetate.
PLACEBO EFFECT
DEFINITION
A placebo refers to any therapy or component of therapy that is deliberately used for its non-
specific, psychological or psychophysiological effect, or its presumed specific effect, but that is
without specific activity for the condition being treated.
Pill factors
The strength of the placebo effect varies with the physical form of the medication, including the size,
type, colour and number of pills (Buckalew & Coffield, 1982; Blakwell et al., 1972). For example, the
relative placebo effect for the following physical forms has been found to be stronger:
∑ multiple pills > single pills
∑ larger pills > smaller pills
∑ capsules > tablets.
242 General principles of psychopharmacology
Examples of the relative potency of medication varying with pill colour include (Schapira, 1970):
∑ Anxiety symptoms responded better to green tablets.
∑ Depressive symptoms responded better to yellow tablets.
Prescribing for psychiatric patients includes taking into consideration the following factors
(Cookson et al., 1993):
∑ the symptoms to be targeted in the short and long term
∑ age
∑ physical health
∑ circumstances
∑ drugs already being taken, including home remedies
∑ the effectiveness, or otherwise, of previous drug treatments
∑ personality
∑ lifestyle
∑ social setting
∑ the choice of actual drugs
∑ dose size
∑ dose schedule
∑ when to review outcome and who should help report it
∑ the role of the community psychiatry nurse and the GP in providing medication and
monitoring progress.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Blackwell, B., Bloomfield, S.S. & Buncher, C.R. 1972: Demonstration to medical students of placebo responses and
nondrug factors. Lancet i:1279–1282.
Buckalew, L.W. & Coffield, K.E. 1982: An investigation of drug expectancy as a function of capsule color and size
and preparation form. Journal of Clinical Psychopharmacology 2:245–248.
Cookson, J., Crammer, J. & Heine, B. 1993: The Use of Drugs in Psychiatry, 4th edn. London: Gaskell.
Healy, D. 2002: Psychiatric Drugs Explained, 3rd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Puri, B.K. 2005: Drugs in Psychiatry. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Schapira, K., McClelland, H.A., Griffiths, N.R. et al. 1970: Study of the effects of tablet colour in the treatment of
anxiety states. British Medical Journal 2:446–449.
Silverstone, T. & Turner, P. 1995: Drug Treatment in Psychiatry, 5th edn. London: Routledge.
White, L., Tursky, B. & Schwartz, G. (eds) 1985: Placebo: Theory, Research, and Mechanisms. New York: Guilford
Press, 431–447.
16
Pharmacokinetics
ABSORPTION
Routes of administration
Enteral administration
Enteral administration routes employ the gastrointestinal tract, from which the drug is absorbed
into the circulation. They include administration via the following routes:
∑ oral
∑ buccal
∑ sublingual
∑ rectal.
Parenteral administration
This includes administration via the following routes:
∑ intramuscular
∑ intravenous
∑ subcutaneous
∑ inhalational
∑ topical.
Rate of absorption
The rate of absorption of a drug from its site of administration depends on the following factors:
∑ the form of the drug
∑ the solubility of the drug, which is influenced by factors such as:
∑ the pKa of the drug
∑ particle size
244 Pharmacokinetics
∑ the ambient pH
∑ the rate of blood flow through the tissue in which the drug is sited.
Oral administration
Mechanisms of absorption
The main mechanisms of absorption of drugs from the gastrointestinal tract are:
∑ passive diffusion
∑ pore filtration
∑ active transport.
Site of absorption
The main site of absorption of most psychotropic drugs (which tend to be lipophilic at a
physiological pH) from the gastrointestinal tract is the small intestine.
Rectal administration
Advantages
Advantages of rectal administration over the oral route include:
∑ It can be used if the patient cannot swallow (e.g. because of vomiting).
∑ Gastric factors are bypassed.
∑ It can be used for drugs that are irritant to the stomach.
∑ There is reduced first-pass metabolism.
∑ It can be useful in uncooperative patients.
∑ It can be used to administer diazepam during an epileptic seizure, for example in a patient with a
learning difficulty.
Disadvantages
Disadvantages of rectal administration include:
∑ embarrassment
∑ presence of a variable amount of faecal matter, leading to an unpredictable rate of absorption
∑ local inflammation following frequent use of this route.
Absorption 245
Intramuscular administration
Factors influencing absorption
The rate of absorption of drugs administered intramuscularly is increased in the following
circumstances:
∑ lipid-soluble drugs
∑ drugs with a low relative molecular mass
∑ increased muscle blood flow (e.g. after physical exercise or during emotional excitement).
Disadvantages
Disadvantages of intramuscular administration include:
∑ pain
∑ usually unacceptable for self-administration
∑ risk of damage to structures such as nerves
∑ some drugs (e.g. paraldehyde) may cause sterile abscess formation
∑ reduced muscle blood flow (e.g. in cardiac failure), leading to reduced absorption
∑ tissue binding or precipitation from solution after intramuscular administration (e.g. for
chlordiazepoxide, diazepam, phenytoin), leading to reduced absorption
∑ increased creatine phosphokinase occurs, which may interfere with diagnostic cardiac enzyme
assays.
This route should not be used if the patient is receiving anticoagulant therapy.
Intravenous administration
Advantages
Advantages of intravenous administration include:
∑ rapid intravenous administration leading to rapid action – useful in emergency situations
∑ drug dose can be titrated against patient response
∑ large volumes can be administered slowly
∑ this route can be used for drugs that cannot be absorbed by other routes
∑ first-pass metabolism is by-passed.
Disadvantages
Disadvantages of intravenous administration include:
∑ adverse effects may occur rapidly
∑ dangerously high blood levels may be achieved
∑ it is difficult to recall the drug once administered
∑ risk of sepsis
∑ risk of thrombosis
∑ risk of air embolism
∑ risk of injection into tissues surrounding the vein, which may lead to necrosis
∑ risk of injection into an artery, which may lead to spasm
∑ cannot be used with insoluble drugs.
246 Pharmacokinetics
DISTRIBUTION
The rate and degree of distribution of psychotropic drugs between the lipid, protein and water
components of the body are influenced by the:
∑ lipid solubility of the drug
∑ plasma protein binding
∑ volume of distribution
∑ blood–brain barrier
∑ placenta.
Lipid solubility
Increased lipid solubility is associated with increased volume of distribution. This is the case for
most psychotropic drugs at physiological pH.
Volume of distribution
This is a theoretical concept relating the mass of a drug in the body to the blood or plasma
concentration:
Volume of distribution = (mass of a drug in the body at a given time)/(concentration of the
drug at that time in the blood or the plasma).
Distribution 247
A higher volume of distribution in general corresponds to a shorter duration of drug action. Factors
that may influence the volume of distribution include:
∑ drug lipid solubility: increased lipid solubility (e.g. most psychotropic drugs) is associated with
an increased volume of distribution
∑ adipose tissue: weight gain (e.g. some psychotropic drugs) leads to increased adipose tissue
which leads to an increased volume of distribution
∑ increasing age: reduced proportion of lean tissue leads to increased volume of distribution
∑ sex
∑ physical disease.
Infection
Infection may alter the normal functioning of the blood–brain barrier.
Receptors
The existence of specific brain receptors for many psychotropic drugs leads to psychotropic drug
protein binding in the brain, thereby forming a central nervous system reservoir. This does not
occur in the CSF, with its very low protein concentration.
Active transport
Active transport mechanisms are used to cross the blood–brain barrier by some physiological
substances and drugs (e.g. levodopa).
Diffusion
Some small molecules diffuse readily into the brain and CSF from the cerebral circulation (e.g.
lithium ions).
Placenta
Drugs may transfer into the fetal circulation from the maternal circulation across the placenta by
means of:
∑ passive diffusion
∑ active transport
∑ pinocytosis.
248 Pharmacokinetics
Since drugs may cause teratogenesis during the first trimester, they should be avoided during this
time if at all possible.
METABOLISM
While some highly water-soluble drugs (e.g. lithium) are excreted unchanged by the kidneys,
others, such as most highly lipid-soluble psychotropic drugs, first undergo metabolism
(biotransformation) to reduce their lipid solubility and make them more water-soluble, prior to
renal excretion. Metabolism sometimes results in the production of pharmacologically active
metabolites (e.g. amitriptyline Æ nortriptyline). Sites of metabolism include the:
∑ liver (the most important site of metabolism)
∑ kidney
∑ adrenal (suprarenal) cortex
∑ gastrointestinal tract
∑ lung
∑ placenta
∑ skin
∑ lymphocytes.
FIRST-PASS EFFECT
The first-pass effect (first-pass metabolism or presystemic elimination) is the metabolism
undergone by an orally absorbed drug during its passage from the hepatic portal system through the
Bibliography 249
liver before entering the systemic circulation. It varies between individuals and may be reduced by,
for example, hepatic disease, food or drugs that increase hepatic blood flow.
ELIMINATION
Elimination (excretion) of drugs and drug metabolites can take place by means of the:
∑ kidney – the most important organ for such elimination
∑ bile and faeces
∑ lung
∑ saliva
∑ sweat
∑ sebum
∑ milk.
With the exception of pulmonary excretion, in general water-soluble polar drugs and drug
metabolites are eliminated more readily by excretory organs than are highly lipid-soluble non-polar
ones.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Cookson, J., Crammer, J. & Heine, B. 1993: The Use of Drugs in Psychiatry, 4th edn. London: Gaskell.
King, D.J. 1995: Seminars in Clinical Psychopharmacology. London: Gaskell.
Puri, B.K. 2005: Drugs in Psychiatry. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Silverstone, T. & Turner, P. 1995: Drug Treatment in Psychiatry, 5th edn. London: Routledge.
This page intentionally left blank
17
Pharmacodynamics
ANTIPSYCHOTICS
Typical antipsychotics
Many of the actions of chlorpromazine, the archetypal antipsychotic, are believed to result from
antagonist action to the following neurotransmitters:
∑ dopamine
∑ acetylcholine – muscarinic receptors
∑ adrenaline/noradrenaline
∑ histamine.
Many of these actions also occur, to varying extents, with other typical antipsychotics.
ANTIDOPAMINERGIC ACTION
In general, typical antipsychotics are postulated to act clinically by causing postsynaptic blockade of
dopamine D2 receptors; their antagonism at these receptors is related to their clinical antipsychotic
potencies. It is the antidopaminergic action on the mesolimbic–mesocortical pathway which is
believed to be the effect required for this clinical action.
The antidopaminergic action on the tuberoinfundibular pathway causes hormonal side-effects.
Hyperprolactinaemia, resulting from the fact that dopamine is a prolactin-inhibitory factor, causes:
∑ galactorrhoea
∑ gynaecomastia
∑ menstrual disturbances
∑ reduced sperm count
∑ reduced libido.
The antidopaminergic action on the nigrostriatal pathway causes extrapyramidal symptoms:
∑ parkinsonism
∑ dystonias
252 Pharmacodynamics
∑ akathisia
∑ tardive dyskinesia.
ANTIMUSCARINIC ACTION
The central antimuscarinic (anticholinergic) actions may cause:
∑ convulsions
∑ pyrexia.
Peripheral antimuscarinic symptoms include:
∑ dry mouth
∑ blurred vision
∑ urinary retention
∑ constipation
∑ nasal congestion.
ANTIADRENERGIC ACTION
Antiadrenergic actions may cause:
∑ postural hypotension
∑ ejaculatory failure.
ANTIHISTAMINIC ACTION
Antihistaminic effects include drowsiness.
Atypical antipsychotics
The atypical antipsychotics have a greater action than do typical antipsychotics on receptors other
than dopamine D2 receptors. For example, clozapine, the archetypal atypical antipsychotic, has a
higher potency of action than do typical antipsychotics on the following receptors:
∑ 5-HT2
∑ D4
∑ D1
∑ muscarinic
∑ a-adrenergic.
LITHIUM
Lithium ions, Li+, are monovalent cations that cause a number of effects, some of which may
account for its therapeutic actions, including:
∑ ≠ intracellular Na+
∑ Ø Na,K-ATPase pump activity
Drugs used in the treatment of affective disorders 253
TRICYCLIC ANTIDEPRESSANTS
The most important postulated modes of action in the brain of tricyclic antidepressants in
achieving therapeutic effects are:
∑ inhibition of re-uptake of noradrenaline
∑ inhibition of re-uptake of serotonin.
For this reason, tricyclic antidepressants are also known as monoamine re-uptake inhibitors, or
MARIs. Peripherally, most tricyclic antidepressants also have an antimuscarinic action, which gives
rise to peripheral antimuscarinic side-effects such as:
∑ dry mouth
∑ blurred vision
∑ drowsiness
∑ urinary retention
∑ constipation.
Postural hypotension occurs as a result of the antiadrenergic action.
SSRIS
The most important postulated mode of action in the brain of SSRIs (selective serotonin re-uptake
inhibitors) in achieving therapeutic effects is:
∑ inhibition of re-uptake of serotonin.
Their relatively selective action on serotonin reuptake means that SSRIs are less likely than tricyclic
antidepressants to cause antimuscarinic side-effects. They are, however, more likely to cause
gastrointestinal side-effects such as nausea and vomiting.
MAOIS
The most important postulated mode of action in the brain of MAOIs (monoamine oxidase
inhibitors) in achieving therapeutic effects is:
∑ irreversible inhibition of MAO-A and MAO-B.
254 Pharmacodynamics
In the central nervous system, MAO-A (monoamine oxidase type A) acts on:
∑ noradrenaline
∑ serotonin
∑ dopamine
∑ tyramine.
In the central nervous system, MAO-B (monoamine oxidase type B) acts on:
∑ dopamine
∑ tyramine
∑ phenylethylamine
∑ benzylamine.
The inhibition of peripheral pressor amines, particularly dietary tryramine, by MAOIs can lead
to a hypertensive crisis when foodstuffs rich in tyramine are eaten (see Chapter 18).
RIMA
The most important postulated mode of action in the brain of the RIMA (reversible inhibitor of
monoamine oxidase-A) in achieving therapeutic effects is:
∑ reversible inhibition of MAO-A.
SNRI
The most important postulated modes of action in the brain of the SNRI (serotonin noradrenaline
re-uptake inhibitor) in achieving therapeutic effects are:
∑ inhibition of re-uptake of noradrenaline
∑ inhibition of re-uptake of serotonin.
NARI
The most important postulated mode of action in the brain of the NARI (selective noradrenaline re-
uptake inhibitor) in achieving therapeutic effects is:
∑ selective inhibition of the re-uptake of noradrenaline.
NASSA
The most important postulated modes of action in the brain of the NaSSA (noradrenergic and
specific serotonergic antidepressant) in achieving therapeutic effects are:
∑ increased release of noradrenaline by antagonism of inhibitory presynaptic a2-adrenoceptors
∑ increased release of serotonin by enhancement of a facilitatory noradrenergic input to
serotonergic cell bodies
∑ increased release of serotonin by antagonism of inhibitory presynatpic a2-adrenoceptors on
serotonergic neuronal terminals.
Anti-epileptic agents 255
BENZODIAZEPINES
The most important postulated mode of action in the brain of benzodiazepines in achieving central
therapeutic effects is:
∑ binding to GABAA receptors.
BUSPIRONE
The most important postulated mode of action in the brain of the azaspirodecanedione buspirone
in achieving central therapeutic effects is:
∑ partial agonism at 5-HT1A receptors.
ZOPICLONE
The cyclopyrrolone zopiclone is believed to achieve a central hypnotic effect by acting on the same
receptors as do benzodiazepines.
ZOLPIDEM
The imidazopyridine zolpidem in believed to achieve a central hypnotic effect by acting on the same
receptors as do benzodiazepines.
ANTI-EPILEPTIC AGENTS
CARBAMAZEPINE
Carbamazepine, which has a tricyclic antidepressant-like structure, may achieve its anticonvulsant
effect on the basis of the following actions:
∑ binding to and inactivation of voltage-dependent Na+ channels
∑ increased K+ conductance
∑ partial agonism at the adenosine A1 subclass of P1 purinoceptors.
SODIUM VALPROATE
Sodium valproate may achieve its anticonvulsant effect on the basis of the following actions:
∑ increased GABA
∑ Ø GABA breakdown
∑ ≠ GABA release
256 Pharmacodynamics
∑ Ø GABA turnover
∑ ≠ GABA-B receptor density
∑ ≠ neuronal responsiveness to GABA
∑ reduced Na+ influx
∑ increased K+ conductance.
PHENYTOIN
The mechanism of anticonvulsant action of phenytoin is unknown, but may involve:
∑ membrane stabilization
∑ Na+ channel binding
∑ Ca2+ channel binding
∑ benzodiazepine receptor binding
∑ GABA receptor function modulation.
PHENOBARBITONE
The actions of phenobarbitone may be similar to those given above for phenytoin.
GABAPENTIN
Gabapentin is believed to achieve its anticonvulsant effect by means of the following action:
∑ binding to a unique cerebral receptor site.
VIGABATRIN
Vigabatrin is believed to achieve its anticonvulsant effect by means of the following action:
∑ inhibition of GABA transaminase, leading to increased GABA release.
LAMOTRIGINE
Lamotrigine is believed to achieve its anticonvulsant effect by means of the following action:
∑ inhibition of glutamate release.
NORADRENALINE
ECT probably leads to increased noradrenergic function. In particular, ECT acutely causes:
∑ increased cerebral noradrenaline activity
∑ increased cerebral tyrosine hydroxylase activity
∑ increased plasma catecholamines, particularly adrenaline.
Chronic ECS (electroconvulsive shock) leads to:
∑ reduced b-adrenergic receptor density.
Neurochemical effects of ECT 257
SEROTONIN
ECT probably leads to increased serotonergic function. In particular, ECT acutely causes:
∑ increased cerebral serotonin concentration.
Chronic ECS leads to:
∑ increased 5-HT2 receptor density.
DOPAMINE
ECT probably leads to increased dopaminergic function. In particular, ECT acutely causes:
∑ increased cerebral dopamine concentration
∑ increased cerebral concentration of dopamine metabolites
∑ increased behavioural responsiveness to dopamine agonists.
In rat substantia nigra, repeated electroconvulsive shocks lead to:
∑ increased dopamine D1 receptor density
∑ increased second-messenger potentiation at dopamine D1 receptors.
GABA
ECT may cause a functional increase in GABAergic activity.
ACETYLCHOLINE
ECT probably leads to decreased central cholinergic function. In particular, ECT acutely causes:
∑ reduced cerebral acetylcholine concentration
∑ increased cerebral acetyltransferase activity
∑ increased cerebral acetylcholinesterase activity
∑ increased CSF acetylcholine concentration.
Chronic ECS leads to:
∑ reduced muscarinic cholinergic receptor density in the cerebral cortex
∑ reduced muscarinic cholinergic receptor density in the hippocampus
∑ reduced second-messenger response in the hippocampus.
ENDOGENOUS OPIOIDS
Chronic ECS leads to:
∑ increased cerebral met-enkephalin concentration and synthesis
∑ increased cerebral b-endorphin concentration and synthesis
∑ changes in opioid ligand binding.
ADENOSINE
Chronic ECS leads to:
∑ increased cerebral adenosine A1 purinoceptor density.
258 Pharmacodynamics
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bloom, F.E. & Kupfer, D.J. (eds) 1995: Psychopharmacology: The Fourth Generation of Progress. New York: Raven
Press.
Cookson, J., Crammer, J. & Heine, B. 1993: The Use of Drugs in Psychiatry, 4th edn. London: Gaskell.
Healy, D. 2002: Psychiatric Drugs Explained, 3rd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
King, D.J. 1995: Seminars in Clinical Psychopharmacology. London: Gaskell.
Puri, B.K. 2005: Drugs in Psychiatry. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Silverstone. T. & Turner, P. 1995: Drug Treatment in Psychiatry, 5th edn. London: Routledge.
18
Adverse drug reactions
CLASSIFICATION
Adverse drug reactions may be classified as:
∑ intolerance
∑ idiosyncratic reactions
∑ allergic reactions
∑ drug interactions.
CAUSAL RELATIONSHIP
The following criteria have been suggested as making it more likely that a causal connection exists
between a drug and an alleged effect (Edwards, 1995):
∑ There is a close temporal relationship between the effect and the taking of the drug, or toxic
levels of the drug or its active metabolites in body fluids have been demonstrated.
∑ The effect differs from manifestations of the disorder being treated.
∑ No other substances are being taken or withdrawn when the effect occurs.
∑ The reaction disappears when treatment is stopped.
∑ The effect reappears with a rechallenge test.
INTOLERANCE
In drug intolerance the adverse reactions are consistent with the known pharmacological actions of
the drug. These adverse drug reactions may be dose-related.
IDIOSYNCRATIC REACTIONS
Idiosyncratic adverse drug reactions are reactions which are not characteristic or predictable and
which are associated with an individual human difference not present in members of the general
population.
260 Adverse drug reactions
ALLERGIC REACTIONS
Allergic reactions to drugs involve the body’s immune system, with the drug interacting with a
protein to form an immunogen which causes sensitization and the induction of an immune
response. Criteria suggesting an allergic reaction include:
∑ There is a different time-course from that of the pharmacodynamic action; e.g:
∑ there is delayed onset of the adverse drug reaction
∑ the adverse drug reaction manifests only following repeated drug exposure.
∑ There may be no dose-related effect, with subtherapeutically small doses leading to sensitization
or allergic reactions.
∑ There is a hypersensitivity reaction, unrelated to the pharmacological actions of the drug.
Types of allergic reaction to drugs include:
∑ anaphylactic shock – type I hypersensitivity reaction
∑ haematological reactions – type II, III or IV hypersensitivity reaction; e.g.:
∑ haemolytic anaemia
∑ agranulocytosis
∑ thrombocytopenia
∑ allergic liver damage – type II ± III hypersensitivity reaction
∑ skin rashes – type IV hypersensitivity reaction
∑ generalized autoimmune (systemic lupus erythamtosus-like) disease – type IV hypersensitivity
reaction.
DRUG INTERACTIONS
Adverse drug reactions may result from interactions between different drugs. These may result
from:
∑ pharmacokinetic interactions
∑ pharmacodynamic interactions.
Pharmacokinetic interactions
Pharmacokinetic interactions between drugs include:
∑ precipitation or inactivation following the mixing of drugs
∑ chelation
∑ changes in gastrointestinal tract motility
∑ changes in gastrointestinal tract pH
∑ drug displacement from binding sites
∑ enzyme induction
∑ enzyme inhibition
∑ competition for renal tubular transport
∑ changes in urinary pH, leading to changes in drug excretion.
Pharmacodynamic interactions
Pharmacodynamic interactions between drugs include:
∑ inhibition of drug uptake
∑ inhibition of drug transport
∑ interaction at receptors
Psychotropic medication 261
∑ synergism
∑ changes in fluid and electrolyte balance.
PSYCHOTROPIC MEDICATION
Typical antipsychotics
In the previous chapter, the major categories of adverse drug reactions are given that are believed to
be caused by antagonist action to the following neurotransmitters:
∑ dopamine
∑ acetylcholine – muscarinic receptors
∑ adrenaline/noradrenaline
∑ histamine.
Other important adverse drug reactions include:
∑ photosensitization
∑ hypothermia or pyrexia
∑ allergic (sensitivity) reactions
∑ neuroleptic malignant syndrome
∑ effects of chronic pharmacotherapy.
Photosensitization
Photosensitization is more common with chlorpromazine than with other typical antipsychotics.
Hypothermia or pyrexia
Interference with temperature regulation is a dose-related side-effect.
Chronic pharmacotherapy
Long-term high-dose pharmacotherapy may cause ocular and skin changes, such as:
∑ opacity of the lens and/or cornea
∑ purplish pigmentation of the skin, conjunctiva, cornea and/or retina.
Atypical antipsychotics
CLOZAPINE
Clozapine may cause neutropenia and potentially fatal agranulocytosis, because of which regular
haematological monitoring is required. Other side-effects of clozapine include hypersalivation,
reduced convulsive threshold, impaired glucose tolerance, diabetes mellitus, constipation which
may be severe, paralytic ileus, tachycardia (1:10), myocarditis, cardiomyopathy and side-effects
common to chlorpromazine, including extrapyramidal symptoms.
OLANZAPINE
Olanzapine may cause:
∑ mild, transient antimuscarinic side-effects
∑ drowsiness
∑ speech difficulty
∑ exacerbation of Parkinson’s disease
∑ akathisia
∑ asthenia
∑ increased appetite
∑ weight gain
∑ raised triglyceride levels
∑ oedema
∑ diabetes mellitus
∑ hyperprolactinaemia.
The last of these side-effects only rarely manifests clinically. Less commonly, olanzapine may also
cause:
∑ blood dyscrasias
∑ bradycardia
∑ rash
∑ photosensitivity
∑ priapism
∑ hepatitis
∑ pancreatitis.
It may also cause an elevation in the level of creatine kinase.
Psychotropic medication 263
RISPERIDONE
Risperidone may cause:
∑ insomnia
∑ agitation
∑ anxiety
∑ headache
∑ drowsiness
∑ impairment of concentration
∑ fatigue
∑ blurred vision
∑ constipation
∑ nausea and vomiting
∑ dyspepsia
∑ abdominal pain
∑ hyperprolactinaemia
∑ sexual dysfunction
∑ priapism
∑ urinary incontinence
∑ tachycardia
∑ hypertension
∑ rash
∑ rhinitis.
The hyperprolactinaemia caused by risperidone may manifest as:
∑ galactorrhoea
∑ menstrual disturbances
∑ amenorrhoea
∑ gynaecomastia.
The following side-effects have also been reported in connection with risperidone:
∑ cerebrovascular accidents
∑ neutropenia
∑ thrombocytopenia.
Rare side-effects of risperidone include:
∑ seizures
∑ hyponatraemia
∑ abnormal regulation of temperature
∑ oedema.
SERTINDOLE
This atypical antipsychotic was suspended in the UK following a number of cases of sudden deaths
in patients that appeared to be related to the prolongation of the QT interval caused by sertindole.
At the time of writing, sertindole has been reintroduced into the UK, but its use is restricted to a
named-patient basis for use in patients who are enrolled in clinical studies and who are not tolerant
of at least one other antipsychotic drug.
264 Adverse drug reactions
Antimuscarinic drugs
Antimuscarinic drugs used in parkinsonism may give rise to the following side-effects:
∑ antimuscarinic side-effects (see Chapter 17)
∑ worsening of tardive dyskinesia
∑ gastrointestinal tract disturbances
∑ hypersensitivity.
Lithium
Renal function
Since lithium ions are excreted mainly by the kidneys, renal function must be checked prior to
commencing pharmacotherapy with lithium.
Plasma levels
The therapeutic index of lithium is low and therefore regular plasma lithium level monitoring is
required.
Therapeutic index = (toxic dose)/(therapeutic dose).
The dose is adjusted to achieve a lithium level of 0.4–1.0 mmol/L for prophylactic purposes, with
lower levels being used in the elderly.
Side-effects
Side-effects of lithium therapy include:
∑ fatigue
∑ drowsiness
∑ dry mouth
∑ a metallic taste
∑ polydipsia
∑ polyuria
∑ nausea
∑ vomiting
∑ weight gain
∑ diarrhoea
∑ fine tremor
∑ muscle weakness
∑ oedema.
Oedema should not be treated with diuretics since thiazide and loop diuretics reduce lithium
excretion and can thereby cause lithium intoxication.
Intoxication
Signs of lithium intoxication include:
∑ mild drowsiness and sluggishness, leading to giddiness and ataxia
∑ lack of coordination
∑ blurred vision
Psychotropic medication 265
∑ tinnitus
∑ anorexia
∑ dysarthria
∑ vomiting
∑ diarrhoea
∑ coarse tremor
∑ muscle weakness.
Concomitant use of NSAIDs, and any condition causing sodium depletion can lead to raised
lithium levels and risk of lithium intoxication.
Severe overdosage
At lithium plasma levels of greater than 2 mmol/L, the following effects can occur:
∑ hyperreflexia and hyperextension of the limbs
∑ toxic psychoses
∑ convulsions
∑ syncope
∑ oliguria
∑ circulatory failure
∑ coma
∑ death.
Chronic therapy
Long-term treatment with lithium may give rise to:
∑ thyroid function disturbances:
∑ goitre
∑ hypothyroidism
∑ memory impairment
∑ nephrotoxicity
∑ cardiovascular changes:
∑ T-wave flattening on the ECG
∑ arrhythmias
∑ hyperparathyroidism, hypercalcemia.
Thyroid function tests are usually carried out routinely every 6 months in order to check for
lithium-induced disturbances.
Withdrawal
Too rapid a withdrawal leads to an excess of manic relapses.
Carbamazepine
Since carbamazepine may lower the white blood count, regular monitoring of plasma
carbamazepine levels should be carried out.
266 Adverse drug reactions
Tricyclic antidepressants
The psychopharmacological basis of important side-effects of tricyclic antidepressants is as follows:
∑ blockade of ACh muscarinic receptors
∑ blockade of histamine H1 receptors
∑ blockade of a1-adrenoceptors
∑ blockade of 5-HT2/1c serotonergic receptors
∑ membrane stabilization.
Blockade of a1-adrenoceptors
This can lead to:
∑ drowsiness
∑ postural hypotension
∑ sexual dysfunction
∑ cognitive impairment.
Membrane stabilization
Membrane stabilization can lead to:
∑ cardiotoxicity
∑ reduced seizure threshold.
Cardiovascular side-effects
These include:
∑ ECG changes
∑ arrhythmias
∑ postural hypotension
∑ tachycardia
∑ syncope.
∑ photosensitization
∑ facial oedema
∑ allergic cholestatic jaundice.
Endocrine side-effects
These include:
∑ testicular enlargement
∑ gynaecomastia
∑ galactorrhoea.
Others
Other side-effects include:
∑ tremor
∑ black tongue
∑ paralytic ileus
∑ sweating
∑ hyponatraemia (particularly in the elderly)
∑ neuroleptic malignant syndrome (very rare with tricyclic antidepressants)
∑ abnormal liver function tests
∑ movement disorders
∑ pyrexia
∑ (hypo)mania
∑ blood glucose changes.
SSRIs
Important side-effects that may occur with SSRIs include:
∑ dose-related gastrointestinal side-effects:
∑ nausea
∑ vomiting
∑ diarrhoea
∑ headache
∑ restlessness
∑ sleep disturbance
∑ anxiety
∑ delayed orgasm.
MAOIs
DANGEROUS FOOD INTERACTIONS
As mentioned in Chapter 17, the inhibition of peripheral pressor amines, particularly dietary
tryramine, by MAOIs can lead to a hypertensive crisis when foodstuffs rich in tyramine are eaten.
Foods that should therefore be avoided when on treatment with MAOIs include:
∑ cheese (except cottage cheese and cream cheese)
∑ meat extracts and yeast extracts
268 Adverse drug reactions
Other side-effects
Other side-effects of MAOIs include:
∑ antimuscarinic actions
∑ hepatotoxicity
∑ appetite stimulation
∑ weight gain.
Tranylcypromine may cause dependency.
Benzodiazepines
An important side-effect of benzodiazepines is psychomotor impairment. If benzodiazepines are
taken regularly for four weeks or more, dependence may develop, so that sudden cessation of intake
may then lead to a withdrawal syndrome whose main features include:
∑ anxiety symptoms:
∑ palpitations
∑ tremor
∑ panic
∑ dizziness
∑ nausea
∑ sweating
∑ other somatic symptoms
∑ low mood
Psychotropic medication 269
∑ abnormal experiences:
∑ depersonalization
∑ derealization
∑ hypersensitivity to sensations in all modalities
∑ distorted perception of space
∑ tinnitus
∑ formication
∑ a strange taste
∑ influenza-like symptoms
∑ psychiatric/neurological symptoms:
∑ epileptic seizures
∑ confusional states
∑ psychotic episodes
∑ insomnia
∑ loss of appetite
∑ weight loss.
Buspirone
The main side-effects of buspirone are:
∑ dizziness
∑ headache
∑ excitement
∑ nausea.
Disulfiram
If alcohol is drunk while disulfiram is being taken regularly, acetaldehyde accumulates. Thus,
ingesting even small amounts of alcohol then causes unpleasant systemic reactions, including:
∑ facial flushing
∑ headache
∑ palpitations
∑ tachycardia
∑ nausea
∑ vomiting.
Ingestion of large amounts of alcohol while being treated with disulfiram can lead to:
∑ air hunger
∑ arrhythmias
∑ severe hypotension.
Cyproterone acetate
Side-effects of this antiandrogen agent in males include:
270 Adverse drug reactions
∑ inhibition of spermatogenesis
∑ tiredness
∑ gynaecomastia
∑ weight gain
∑ improvement of existing acne vulgaris
∑ increased scalp hair growth
∑ female pattern of pubic hair growth.
Liver function tests should be carried out regularly owing to a theoretical risk to the liver.
Dyspnoea may result from high-dose treatment.
OFFICIAL GUIDANCE
The official guidance in Britain on the use of antipsychotic drugs and benzodiazepines is given in
this section. BNF is the abbreviation for the latest British National Formulary, a six-monthly
publication of the British Medical Association and the Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great
Britain.
Important note
When prescribing an antipsychotic for administration on an emergency basis, it must be borne in
mind that the intramuscular dose should be lower than the corresponding oral dose (owing to
absence of the first-pass effect), particularly if the patient is very active (increased blood flow to
muscle considerably increases the rate of absorption). The prescription should specify the dose in
the context of each route and should not imply that the same dose can be given by mouth or by
intramuscular injection. The dose should be reviewed daily.
Bibliography 271
Benzodiazepines
In Britain, the Committee on Safety of Medicines (CSM) has issued the following advice with
respect to the presciption of benzodiazepines:
1 Benzodiazepines are indicated for the short-term relief (2–4 weeks only) of anxiety that is
severe, disabling or subjecting the individual to unacceptable distress, occurring alone or in
association with insomnia or short-term psychosomatic, organic or psychotic illness.
2 The use of benzodiazepines to treat short-term ‘mild’ anxiety is inappropriate and unsuitable.
3 Benzodiazepines should be used to treat insomnia only when it is severe, disabling or subjecting
the individual to extreme distress.
REPORTING
In Britain, the CSM holds an information database for adverse drug reactions. Doctors practising in
Britain are asked to report adverse drug reactions to: Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory
Agency, CSM, Freepost, London SW8 5BR (Tel: 0800 731 6789).
Yellow prepaid lettercards for reporting are available from the above address, by dialling a
24-hour Freefone service (Tel: 0800 731 6789), and from the back of the BNF book. Adverse drug
reactions can also be reported via the Internet on the following website: www.mca.gov.uk/
yellowcard.
ADROIT
ADROIT (Adverse Drug Reactions On-line Information Tracking) is an on-line service used in
Britain to monitor adverse drug reactions.
272 Adverse drug reactions
Newer drugs
In the BNF these are indicated by the symbol ▼. The BNF advises that doctors are asked to report
all suspected reactions.
Established drugs
The BNF advises that doctors are asked to report all serious suspected reactions. These include those
that are fatal, life-threatening, disabling, incapacitating, or which result in or prolong
hospitalization.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bloom, F.E. & Kupfer, D.J. (eds) 1995: Psychopharmacology: The Fourth Generation of Progress. New York: Raven
Press.
British Medical Association & Royal Pharmaceutical Society of Great Britain. British National Formulary. London:
BMA/RPSGB.
Cookson, J., Crammer, J. & Heine, B. 1993: The Use of Drugs in Psychiatry, 4th edn. London: Gaskell.
Edwards, J.G. 1995: Adverse reactions to and interactions with psychotropic drugs: mechanisms, methods of
assessment, and medicolegal considerations. In Healy, D. 2002: Psychiatric Drugs Explained, 3rd edn.
Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
King, D.J. (ed.) Seminars in Clinical Psychopharmacology. London: Gaskell, 480–513.
Puri, B.K. 2005: Drugs in Psychiatry. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
19
Genetics
BASIC CONCEPTS
CHROMOSOMES
Number
In normal humans the genome is distributed on 46 chromosomes in each somatic cell nucleus:
∑ one pair of sex chromosomes
∑ 44 autosomes = 22 pairs of chromosomes.
Sex chromosomes
The sex chromosomes are the X and Y chromosomes:
∑ normal females: XX
∑ normal males: XY.
Karyotype
This is an arrangement of the chromosomal make-up of somatic cells that can be produced by
carrying out the following procedures in turn:
∑ Arrest cell division at an appropriate stage.
∑ Disperse the chromosomes.
∑ Fix the chromosomes.
∑ Stain the chromosomes.
∑ Photograph the chromosomes.
∑ Identify the chromosomes.
∑ Arrange the chromosomes.
Centromere
This is the somewhat constricted region of each chromosome that is particularly evident during
mitosis and meiosis.
274 Genetics
Metacentric chromosomes
These are chromosomes with a centrally or almost centrally positioned centromere.
Acrocentric chromosomes
These are chromosomes in which the centromere is very near to one end.
Chromosomal map
The system agreed at the International Paris Conference in 1971 is as follows:
First position – a number (1 to 22) or letter (X or Y) that identifies the chromosome.
Second position – p (short arm of chromosome) or q (long arm of chromosome)
Third position (region) – a digit corresponding to a stretch of the chromosome lying between
two relatively distinct morphological landmarks
Fourth position (band) – a digit corresponding to a band derived from the staining properties of
the chromosome.
CELL DIVISION
Mitosis
This is the process of nuclear division allowing many somatic cells to undergo cell division via the
following stages:
∑ interphase
∑ prophase
∑ metaphase
∑ anaphase
∑ telophase.
Meiosis
This process involves two stages of cell division and occurs in gametogenesis via the following
stages:
∑ interphase
∑ prophase I
∑ metaphase I
∑ anaphase I
∑ telophase I
∑ prophase II
∑ metaphase II
∑ anaphase II
∑ telophase II.
Chromosomal division takes place once during meiosis, so that the resulting gametes are
haploid. Recombination takes place duing prophase I.
GENE STRUCTURE
Genes, the biological units of heredity, consist of codons grouped into exons with intervening
nucleotide sequences known as introns. The introns do not code for amino acids. Genes also contain
nucleotide sequences at their beginning and end that allow transcription to take place accurately.
Thus, starting from the 5¢ end (upstream), a typical eukaryotic gene contains the following:
Basic concepts 275
TRANSCRIPTION
This is the step in gene expression in which information from the DNA molecule is transcribed on
to a primary RNA transcript. This is followed by splicing and nuclear transport, so that the
information (minus that from introns) then exists in the cytoplasm of the cell on mRNA
(messenger RNA).
TRANSLATION
Following transcription, splicing and nuclear transport, translation is the process in gene expression
whereby mRNA acts as a template allowing the genetic code to be deciphered to allow the formation
of a peptide chain. This process involves tRNA molecules.
PATTERNS OF INHERITANCE
In this section, R and S are dominant alleles, and r and s the corresponding recessive alleles.
Law of uniformity
Consider two homozygous parents with genotypes RR and rr, respectively. Mating (¥) results in the
next (F1) generation having the genotype shown:
Parents: RR ¥ rr
F1: Rr
∑ The phenotypic trait is present in all individuals carrying the dominant allele.
∑ The phenotypic trait does not skip generations – vertical transmission takes place.
∑ Males and females are affected.
∑ Male to male transmission can take place.
∑ Transmission is not solely dependent on parental consanguineous matings.
∑ If one parent is homozgyous for the abnormal dominant allele, all the members of F1 will
manifest the abnormal phenotypic trait.
Variable expressivity can cause clinical features of autosomal dominant disorders to vary
between affected individuals. This, together with reduced penetrance, may give the appearance that
the disorder has skipped a generation. The sudden appearance of an autosomal dominant disorder
may occur as a result of a new dominant mutation.
Anticipation
This refers to the occurrence of an autonomic dominant disorder at earlier ages of onset or with
greater severity in the succeeding generations. In Huntington’s disease it has been shown to be
caused by expansions of unstable triplet repeat sequences.
Mosaicism
Abnormalities in mitosis can give rise to an abnormal cell line. Such mosaicism may affect somatic
cells (somatic mosaicism) or germ cells (gonadal mosaicism).
Uniparental disomy
This refers to the phenomenon in which an individual inherits both homologues of a chromosome
pair from the same parent.
Traditional techniques 277
Genomic imprinting
This refers to the phenomenon in which an allele is differentially expressed depending on whether
it is maternally or paternally derived.
Mitochondrial inheritance
Since mtDNA (mitochondrial DNA) is essentially maternally inherited, mitochondrial inheritance
may explain some cases of disorders that affect both males and females but that are transmitted
through females only and not through males.
TRADITIONAL TECHNIQUES
Family studies
Methodology
The rates of illness in the first- and second-degree relatives of probands are compared with the
corresponding rates in the general population. First-degree relatives have, on average, 50% of the
genome in common with the proband, and include the biological:
∑ father
∑ mother
∑ brothers
∑ sisters
∑ children.
Second-degree relatives have, on average, 25% of the genome in common with the proband, and
include the biological:
∑ grandfathers
∑ grandmothers
∑ uncles
∑ aunts
∑ nephews
∑ nieces
∑ grandsons
∑ granddaughters.
Difficulties
Difficulties (and possible solutions) with family studies applied to psychiatric disorders include:
∑ Psychiatric disorders need to be considered longitudinally. Lifetime expectancy rates or morbid
risks can be used.
∑ At the time of the study some relatives may not have reached an age range during which the
disorder manifests itself. Weinberg’s age-correction method can be used.
∑ Genetic factors are not separated well from environmental factors. Twin and adoption studies
can be used.
278 Genetics
Twin studies
Methodology
The rates of illness in co-twins of monozygotic (MZ) and dizygotic (DZ) probands are compared.
MZ twins share 100% of the genome, whereas DZ twins share, on average, 50% of their genome.
The rate of concurrence of a disorder in the co-twin of a proband is the concordance rate:
Pairwise rate (as a percentage) = (number of concordant pairs of twins)/(total number of twin
pairs) ¥ 100%.
Probandwise rate (as a percentage) = (number of co-twins of probands in whom the disorder is
concurrent)/(total number of co-twins) ¥ 100%.
Difficulties
Difficulties (and possible solutions) with twin studies applied to psychiatric disorders include:
∑ Pairwise and probandwise concordance rates usually give different results. Take care to note the
method used to determine the concordance rate.
∑ Zygosity was determined less accurately in older twin studies. Use modern, more accurate
methods.
∑ Diagnostic variability occurred in older twin studies. Use more detailed modern diagnostic
criteria.
∑ Sampling bias may occur. Use twin registers.
∑ Twins are at greater risk of central nervous system abnormalities resulting from birth injury or
congenital abnormalities (risk to MZ twins > risk to DZ twins), which may introduce errors if
central nervous system abnormalities contribute to the disorder being studied.
∑ Assortative mating may lead to a relative increase in the rate of illness in DZ twins compared
with MZ twins.
∑ Age-correction techniques may introduce errors, so do not use them.
∑ The environment does not necessarily affect twins equally. Use adoption studies.
Adoption studies
Methodology
Individuals are studied who have been brought up by unrelated adoptive parents from an early age,
instead of by their biological parents. Types of adoption studies include:
∑ adoptee studies
∑ adoptee family studies
∑ cross-fostering studies
∑ adoption studies involving monozygotic twins.
Difficulties
Difficulties with adoption studies applied to psychiatric disorders include:
∑ Few cases fulfil the criteria for adoption studies.
∑ Adoption studies take a long time to carry out.
∑ Information about the biological father may not be available.
∑ Adoption may cause indeterminate psychological sequelae for the adoptees.
∑ The process of adoption is unlikely to be random.
∑ In MZ twin studies it cannot be assumed that the environmental influences on each twin are
more or less equivalent following adoption.
Linkage analysis 279
Restriction enzymes
Restriction enzymes, also known as restriction endonucleases, cleave DNA only at locations
containing specific nucleotide sequences. Different restriction enzymes target different nucleotide
sequences, but a given restriction enzyme targets the same sequence.
Gene library
This is a set of cloned DNA fragments representing all the genes of an organism or of a given
chromosome.
Molecular cloning
This technique can be used to create a gene library. It can be carried out by splicing a given stretch
of (human) DNA, cleaved using a restriction enzyme, into a bacterial plasmid having at least one
antibiotic resistance gene. After reintroduction of the resulting recombinant plasmid into bacteria,
antibiotic selective pressure causes these bacteria to reproduce. Multiple recoverable copies of the
original (human) DNA are contained in the resulting bacterial colonies.
Gene probes
These are lengths of DNA that are constructed so that they have a nucleotide sequence
complementary, or almost complementary, to that of a given part of the genome, with which,
therefore, they can hybridize under suitable conditions.
Oligonucleotide probes
These are small gene probes that can be used to detect single-base mutations.
Southern blotting
This is a technique that allows the transfer of DNA fragments from gel, where electrophoresis and
DNA denaturation have taken place, to a nylon or nitrocellular filter. It involves overlaying the gel
with the filter and in turn overlaying the filter with paper towels. A solution is then blotted through
the gel to the paper towels. Autoradiography can then be used to identify the fragments of interest
on the filter. The technique is named after its inventor, Edwin Southern.
Recombination
As mentioned above, recombination takes place during prophase I of meiosis. There is alignment
and contact of homologous chromosome pairs during prophase I, allowing genetic information to
cross over between adjacent chromatids. This process of crossover or recombination causes a change
in the alleles carried by the chromatids at the end of the first meiotic division.
LINKAGE ANALYSIS
Genetic markers
A DNA polymorphism, such as a restriction fragment-length polymorphism, if linked to a given
disease locus, can be used as a genetic marker in linkage analysis without its precise chromosomal
280 Genetics
location being known. Genetic markers can also be used in presymptomatic diagnosis and prenatal
diagnosis.
Linkage
This is the phenomenon whereby two genes close to each other on the same chromosome are likely
to be inherited together.
Linkage phases
For two alleles occurring at two linked loci in a double heterozygote, the following linkage phases
can occur:
∑ coupling: the two alleles are on the same chromosome
∑ repulsion: the two alleles are on opposite chromosomes of a pair.
Recombinant fraction
This is a measure of how often the alleles at two loci are separated during meiotic recombination. Its
value can vary from zero to 0.5.
Lod scores
The lod score for a given recombinant fraction is the logarithm to base 10 of the odds P1:P2, where
P1 is the probability of there being linkage for a given recombinant fraction, and P2 is the probability
of there being no measurable linkage. Thus the lod score gives a measure of the probability of two
loci being linked. The lod score method was devised by Morton.
Maximum-likelihood score
This is the value of the recombinant fraction that gives the highest value for the lod score. It
represents the best estimate that can be made for the recombinant fraction from the given available
data.
Autosomal abnormalities
Down’s syndrome
The causes of Down’s syndrome are:
∑ Approximately 95% of cases result from trisomy 21 (47, +21) following non-disjunction during
meiosis.
∑ Approximately 4% result from translocation involving chromosome 21; exchange of
chromosomal substance may occur between chromosome 21 and:
∑ chromosome 13
∑ chromosome 14
∑ chromosome 15
∑ chromosome 21
∑ chromosome 22.
∑ The remaining cases are mosaics.
Note that almost all subjects with Down’s syndrome who live beyond the age of 40 years show
evidence of Alzheimer’s disease.
Principal inherited conditions encountered in psychiatric practice 281
Edward’s syndrome
This is caused by trisomy 18 (47, +18).
Patau syndrome
This is caused by trisomy 13 (47, +13).
Cri-du-chat syndrome
This partial aneusomy results from the partial deletion of the short arm of chromosome 5. Its
characteristic kitten-like high-pitched cry has been localized to 5p15.3. Its other clinical features
have been localized to 5p15.2, known as the cri-du-chat critical region of CDCCR.
XYY syndrome
In this syndrome, phenotypic males have the genotype 47,XYY.
Triple X syndrome
In this syndrome, phenotypic males have the genotype 47,XYY.
Tetra-X syndrome
In this syndrome, also known as super-female syndrome, phenotypic females have the genotype
48,XXXX.
Turner syndrome
In this syndrome, phenotypic females have the genotype 45,X (= 45,XO).
Alzheimer’s disease
The gene for APP (amyloid precursor protein) is located on the long arm of human chromosome 21
and is a member of a gene family which includes the amyloid precursor-like proteins (APLP) 1 and
2. This may explain the link between Alzheimer’s disease and Down’s syndrome (see above). The
apolipoprotein E e4 allele is common in Alzheimer’s disease, while the e2 allele is less common than
would be expected by chance. It may be that the e4 allele is associated with increased accumulation
of b-amyloid protein, while the reverse is true for the e2 allele.
282 Genetics
PHACOMATOSES
The phacomatoses (or phakomatoses), which exhibit neurocutaneous signs, include:
∑ tuberous sclerosis
∑ neurofibromatosis
∑ von Hippel–Lindau syndrome
∑ Sturge–Weber syndrome.
There are three main forms of tuberous sclerosis:
∑ TSC1 (tuberous sclerosis type 1), caused by a gene on chromosome 9
∑ TSC2 (tuberous sclerosis type 2), caused by a gene on chromosome 16
∑ TSC3 (tuberous sclerosis type 3), caused by a translocation that involves chromosome 12.
Neurofibromatosis is caused by an abnormality in the NF-1 gene (in the region 17q11.2).
OTHER DISORDERS
Other disorders that can be inherited in an autosomal dominant manner include:
∑ acrocephalosyndactyly type I
∑ acrocallosal syndrome
∑ acrodysostosis
∑ De Barsey syndrome
∑ periodic paralyses.
OTHER DISORDERS
There are many other disorders inherited in an autosomal recessive manner. Many are rare or very
rare. They include:
∑ Alexander disease
∑ cerebelloparenchymal disorders
∑ Coat disease
∑ Cockayne syndrome
∑ Cohen syndrome
∑ Friedrich’s ataxia
∑ Laurence–Moon syndrome
∑ macrocephaly
∑ oculocerebral syndrome
∑ oculorenocerebellar syndrome
∑ Refsum disease
∑ Rubinstein syndrome
∑ Turcot syndrome
∑ Wilson disease (hepatolenticular degeneration).
BIBLIOGRAPHY
McGuffin, P., Owen, M.J., O’Donovan, M.C., Thapar, A. & Gottesman, I.I. 1994: Seminars in Psychiatric Genetics.
London: Gaskell.
Puri, B.K. & Tyrer, P.J. 2004: Sciences Basic to Psychiatry, 3rd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
This page intentionally left blank
20
Epidemiology
NOTE
This chapter may usefully be read in conjunction with Chapter 6, which deals with the principles of
evaluation and psychometrics. In addition to topics that are epidemiological in nature, this chapter
also includes a few related subjects that are of value in the analysis of trial data.
DISEASE FREQUENCY
INCIDENCE
The incidence of a disease is the rate of occurrence of new cases of the disease in a defined
population over a given period of time. It is equal to the number of new cases over the given period
of time divided by the total population at risk (see below) during the same period of time.
Units
The unit of incidence is T-1; that is, (time) -1. For instance, Dunham (1965) gave the incidence of
schizophrenia as:
= 0.00022 year-1
= 0.00022 per year
= 0.22 per 1000 per year
= 22 per 100 000 per year, etc.
PREVALENCE
The prevalence of a disease is the proportion of a defined population that has the disease at a given
time.
∑ Point prevalence. This is the proportion of a defined population that has a given disease at a given
point in time.
∑ Period prevalence. This is the proportion of a defined population that has a given disease during
a given interval of time.
288 Epidemiology
∑ Lifetime prevalence. This is the proportion of a defined population that has or has had a given
disease (at any time during each individual’s lifetime thus far) at a given point in time.
∑ Birth defect rate. This is the proportion of live births that has a given disease.
∑ Disease rate at post mortem. This is the proportion of bodies, on which post mortems are carried
out, that has a given disease.
Units
Prevalence, being a proportion or ratio of two numbers, does not have units. A given prevalence
value may, however, be multiplied by 100 to express it as a percentage. For example, according to
Jablensky and Sartorius (1975), the annual prevalence of schizophrenia is:
= 0.002 to 0.004
= 2 to 4 per 1000
= 0.2–0.4%.
(Note that the annual prevalence is a type of period prevalence.)
POPULATION AT RISK
This is the population of individuals free of a given disease, who have not already had the disease by
the time of the commencement of a given period of time, who are at risk of becoming new cases of
the disease.
CHRONICITY
The chronicity of a disease is its average duration. It has the units of time.
CASE IDENTIFICATION
Caseness
An overall threshold is ideally defined in order to establish caseness: that is, to differentiate cases of
a given psychiatric disorder from non-cases. Classification systems and screening can be used to
help identify cases.
Classification
Classification systems that are useful in case identification are those that provide specific
operational diagnostic criteria as guides for making each psychiatric diagnosis. A widely used
example in psychiatry is that of DSM-IV-TR.
Case identification, case registers, mortality and morbidity statistics 289
Screening
Screening, by means of psychiatric assessment instruments, can be used to identify cases. The
instruments used should have good sensitivity and specificity:
Sensitivity = (true +ve)/[(true +ve) + (false -ve)]
Specificity = (true -ve)/[(true -ve) + (false +ve)]
In terms of the generalized diagnostic and test results shown in Table 20.1, the sensitivity and
specificity are given by:
Sensitivity = a/(a + c)
Specificity = d/(b + d).
The predictive value of a positive test result (or positive predictive value) is the proportion of the
positive results that is truly positive, while the predictive value of a negative test result (negative
predictive value) is the proportion of the negative results that is truly negative. The efficiency of the
test is the proportion of all the results that is true. In terms of the notation of Table 20.1, these are
given by the following expressions:
Positive predictive value = a/(a + b)
Negative predictive value = d/(c + d)
Efficiency = (a + d)/(a + b + c + d).
The sensitivity, specificity, predictive values and efficiency of a test are often expressed in terms of
percentages, simply by multiplying the above formulae by 100.
Three further measures (which may also be expressed as percentages by multiplication by 100)
that may be derived from Table 20.1 are:
Screen prevalence = (a + b)/(a + b + c + d)
Disease prevalence = (a + c)/(a + b + c + d)
Test accuracy = (a + d)/(a + b + c + d).
Likelihood ratio
This is a function of both the sensitivity and the specificity of a test, and indexes how much the test
result will change the odds of having a disease/disorder.
∑ The likelihood ratio for a positive result, LR+, is given by:
LR+ = sensitivity/(1 - specificity)
∑ It indexes the increase in the odds of having a disease when the test result is positive.
290 Epidemiology
LR- = (1 - sensitivity)/specificity
∑ It indexes the decrease in the odds of having a disease when the test result is negative.
Pre-test odds
The pre-test odds are a function of the prevalence of the disease and may be calculated as follows:
Pre-test odds = prevalence/(1 - prevalence)
(Prevalence, in this context, is also sometimes known as the pre-test probability.)
Post-test odds
The post-test odds of a disease are the odds that a patient has a disease, and incorporate information
relating to:
∑ disease prevalence
∑ the patient pool
∑ the likelihood ratio
∑ pre-test odds (that is, risk factors for the patient).
The post-test odds are calculated as follows:
Post-test odds = (pre-test odds) ¥ (likelihood ratio)
CASE REGISTERS
Examples of case registers that have proved useful in epidemiological studies and psychiatric
research generally include:
∑ Swedish and Danish twin registers
∑ psychiatric case registers, containing records of those who have been treated for psychiatric
disorders in certain hospitals or catchment areas.
Limitations of case registers include:
∑ The registered individuals may move out of the defined geographical area.
∑ The registers may not be kept up to date for other reasons.
MORTALITY STATISTICS
Mortality rate
This is the number of deaths in a defined population during a given period of time divided by the
population size during that time period. This measure is also sometimes referred to as the ‘crude
mortality ratio’ or CMR. It may be expressed as a percentage by multiplying the ratio by 100.
∑ Standardized mortality rate. This is the mortality rate adjusted to compensate for a confounder.
∑ Age-standardized mortality rate. This is the mortality rate adjusted to compensate for the
confounding effect of age.
∑ Standardized mortality ratio. The standardized mortality ratio, or SMR, is the ratio of the
observed standardized mortality rate, derived from the population being studied, to the
expected standardized mortality rate, derived from a comparable standard population. It may be
expressed as a percentage by multiplying the ratio by 100.
Measurements of risk 291
Life expectancy
This is a measure of the mean length of time that an individual can be expected to live based on the
assumption that the mortality rates used remain constant. It is calculated from the ratio of the total
time a hypothetical group of people is expected to live to the size of that group.
MORBIDITY RATE
This is the rate of occurrence of new non-fatal cases of a given disease in a defined population at risk
during a given period of time.
∑ Standardized morbidity rate. This is the morbidity rate adjusted to compensate for a confounder.
∑ Age-standardized morbidity rate. This is the morbidity rate adjusted to compensate for the
confounding effect of age.
∑ Standardized morbidity ratio. The standardized morbidity ratio is the ratio of the observed
standardized morbidity rate, derived from the population being studied, to the expected
standardized morbidity rate, derived from a comparable standard population. It may be
expressed as a percentage by multiplying the ratio by 100.
MEASUREMENTS OF RISK
The terms described in this section can usefully be related to the 2 ¥ 2 contingency table shown in
Table 20.2, as used in analytical epidemiological studies. Similarly, they also apply to the critical
appraisal of, for example, prospective cohort studies, such as the one shown in Table 20.3.
RELATIVE RISK
In terms of analytical epidemiological studies, the relative risk of a disease with respect to a given
risk factor is the ratio of the incidence of the disease in people exposed to that risk factor to the
292 Epidemiology
incidence of the disease in people not exposed to that same risk factor. In Table 20.2, this equates to
the ratio of a/(a + b) to c/(c + d).
In terms of prospective cohort studies, the relative risk is the ratio of the probability of a positive
outcome in the cohort group (exposed) to the probability of a positive outcome in the control group
(not exposed). In Table 20.3, this again equates to the ratio of a/(a + b) to c/(c + d).
Thus, in terms of both Tables 20.2 and 20.3:
Relative risk = a(c + d)/[c/(a + b)]
The relative risk does not have any units, being the ratio of two numbers, and it can take on any
non-negative real value; that is, relative risk ≥0.
ATTRIBUTABLE RISK
This is the incidence of the disease in the group exposed to the risk factor of interest minus the
incidence in the group not exposed to this risk factor. The attributable risk is also known as the ‘risk
difference’ or the ‘absolute excess risk’. In terms of Table 20.2:
= Attributable risk
= risk difference
= absolute excess risk
= absolute risk increase
= [a/(a + b) - [c/(c + d)]
ODDS RATIO
If Table 20.3 is taken to refer to a retrospective study, in which the variable consists of exposure or
non-exposure to a given factor, while the outcome consists of being in the disease group or the
control group, the odds that subjects in the disease group were exposed to the factor are given by a/b.
Similarly, the odds that subjects in the control group were exposed to the factor are given by c/d.
These results follow from the following definition:
Odds of an event taking place = (probability of that event)/(1 - probability of that event)
The odds ratio is the ratio of the odds that subjects in the disease group were exposed to the
factor to the odds that subjects in the control group were exposed to the factor. In terms of Table
20.4, we have:
Odds ratio = ad/(bc)
In the case of retrospective epidemiological studies (see Table 20.2), if the disease is relatively
rare, we have:
a << b ¤ a + b ª b
and
c << d ¤ c + d ª d
Hence, in this case:
Relative risk ª ad/(bc) = odds ratio.
STUDY DESIGN
Confounding
One of the most important confounding factors in studies is age, particularly, for example, in the
calculation of morbidity and mortality rates in epidemiological studies. There are various methods
that may be used to compensate for confounding variables. These include:
∑ standardization (e.g. age can be compensated for by means of age standardization)
∑ stratification
∑ randomization
∑ matching (in terms of the confounder(s)) of controls with patients/subjects/index cases
∑ restriction (to restrict entry into the study of subjects who are not affected by the
confounder(s))
∑ mathematical and statistical modelling techniques.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Dunham, H.W. 1965: Community and Schizophrenia: An Epidemiological Analysis. Detroit: Wayne State University
Press.
Jablensky, A. & Sartorius, N. 1975: Culture and schizophrenia. Psychological Medicine 5:113–124.
Puri, B.K. & Tyrer, P.J. 2004: Sciences Basic to Psychiatry, 3rd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
21
Medical ethics and principles of law
ADVOCACY
An advocate enters into a relationship with the patient, to speak on his or her behalf and to represent
the patient’s wishes or stand up for his or her rights. An advocate has no legal status – the patient
should have an idea of personal preferences so that the advocate truly represents the patient’s
wishes.
APPOINTEESHIP
An appointee is someone authorized by the Department of Social Security to receive and administer
benefits on behalf of someone else, who is not able to manage his or her affairs. It can be used solely
to administer money derived from social security benefits, and cannot be used to administer any
other income or assets. If benefits accumulate, application may need to be made to the Public Trust
Office or the Court of Protection to gain access to the accumulated capital.
POWERS OF ATTORNEY
A power of attorney is a means whereby one person (the donor) gives legal authority to another
person (the attorney) to manage his or her affairs. The donor has sole responsibility for the decision
as to whether power of attorney is given, provided the donor fully understands the implications of
what he or she is undertaking.
An ordinary power of attorney allows the attorney to deal with the donor’s financial affairs
generally, or it can be limited to specific matters. An ordinary power of attorney is automatically
revoked by law when the donor loses his or her mental capacity to manage personal affairs.
An Enduring Power of Attorney allows a person to decide who should manage his or her affairs
if the person becomes mentally incapable. This has been possible since 1985. An Enduring Power of
Attorney continues in force after the donor has lost the mental capacity to manage his or her affairs,
provided it is registered with the Public Trust Office. It is thus of use for people with early dementia
who can set their affairs in order early in the illness provided the illness has not already progressed
to a point where the person is unable to manage personal affairs. Once the donor is unable to
manage personal affairs, the attorney must apply to the Public Trust Office for registration of the
Enduring Power of Attorney to allow the attorney authority to continue to act.
296 Medical ethics and principles of law
COURT OF PROTECTION
This is an office of the Supreme Court. It exists to protect the property and affairs of persons who,
through mental disorder, are incapable of managing personal financial affairs. The Court’s powers
are limited to dealing with the financial and legal affairs of the person concerned. Only one medical
certificate is required, from a registered medical practitioner who has examined the patient.
Guidance to medical practitioners accompanies the certificate of incapacity.
The Court appoints somebody to manage the patient’s affairs on his or her behalf. This person is
called the receiver. It may be a relative, friend, solicitor or other person. The receiver must keep
accounts and spend the patient’s money on things that will benefit the patient. The Court must give
permission before the disposal of capital assets such as property.
TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY
To make a will, a person must be of sound disposing mind. This means that the person must:
∑ understand to whom he or she is giving personal property
∑ understand and recollect the extent of that personal property
∑ understand the nature and extent of the claims upon the person, both of those included and
those excluded from the will.
A valid will is not invalidated by the subsequent impairment of testamentary capacity.
CAPACITY TO DRIVE
The responsibility for making the decision about whether or not a person should continue to drive
is that of the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Authority (DVLA), with a doctor acting only as a source
of information and advice. The driver has a duty to keep the DVLA informed of any condition that
may impair the ability to drive. The doctor is responsible for advising the patient to inform the
DVLA of a condition likely to make driving dangerous. If the patient fails to take this advice, the
doctor may then contact the DVLA directly. Tables 21.1–3 summarize the advice of the DVLA to
British doctors with respect to fitness to drive in patients with psychiatric disorders. In this table,
two types of licence are referred to:
∑ Group 1 licence. A driver with a mobility allowance may drive from the age of 16 years. Licences
are normally issued until age 70, unless restricted to a shorter duration for medical reasons.
There is no upper age limit, but after the age of 70 licences are renewable every three years.
∑ Group 2 licence. These licences can be issued at the age of 21 years and are valid until the age of
45. They are then issued every five years to the age of 65 unless restricted to a shorter duration
for medical reasons. From the age of 65, the licence is issued annually.
Medical ethics and principles of law 297
Table 21.1 Advice of the DVLA to doctors with respect to fitness to drive in patients with psychiatric disorders
Manic–depressive psychosis 6–12 months off the road after an As above for psychosis.
acute episode of hypomania
requiring hospital admission,
depending upon the severity and
frequency of relapses. Licence
restored after freedom from
symptoms during this period and
safe compliance with medication.
1-, 2- or 3-year licence with
medical review on renewal. Loss of
insight or judgement will lead to
recommendation to refuse/revoke.
298 Medical ethics and principles of law
Table 21.2 Advice of the DVLA to doctors with respect to fitness to drive in patients with alcohol problems
Table 21.3 Advice of the DVLA to doctors with respect to fitness to drive in patients with drug misuse and
dependency
Cannabis The regular use of these substances, Regular use of these substances
Ecstasy confirmed by medical enquiry, will will lead to refusal or revocation of
and other ‘recreational’ lead to licence revocation or refusal a vocational licence for at least a
psychoactive substances, for a 6-month period. Independent 1-year period. Independent medical
including LSD and medical assessment and urine assessment and urine screen,
hallucinogens screen, arranged by DVLA, may be arranged by DVLA, may be required.
required.
Amphetamines Regular use of, or dependency on, Regular use of, or dependency on,
Heroin these substances, confirmed by these substances, will require
Morphine medical enquiry, will lead to licence revocation or refusal of a vocational
Methadone* refusal or revocation for a minimum licence for a minimum 3-year
Cocaine 1-year period. Independent medical period. Independent medical
Benzodiazepines assessment and urine screen, assessment and urine screen,
arranged by DVLA, may be required. arranged by DVLA, may be required.
In addition, favourable consultant In addition, favourable consultant
or specialist report will be required or specialist report will be required
on reapplication. before relicensing.
* Applicants or drivers on
consultant-supervised oral
methadone withdrawal programme
may be licensed, subject to annual
medical review and favourable
assessment.
Seizure(s) associated with illicit A seizure or seizures associated Vocational Epilepsy Regulations
drug usage with illicit drug usage may require a apply.
licence to be refused or revoked for
a 1-year period. Thereafter, licence
restoration will require independent
medical assessment, with urine
analysis, together with favourable
report from own doctor, to confirm
no ongoing drug misuse. In
addition, patients may be assessed
against the Epilepsy Regulations.
NB: A person who has been relicensed following illicit drug misuse or dependency must be advised as part of his/her follow-up
that if his/her condition recurs he/she should cease driving and notify DVLA Medical Branch.
22
Legal aspects of psychiatric care
NOTE
The Mental Health Act 1983 for England and Wales is detailed in this chapter; the equivalent
Scottish treatment orders are also given. The mental health legislation relevant to your country of
practice should be obtained and you should be familiar with its contents and use. The Misuse of
Drugs legislation for England and Wales is considered in Chapter 26.
DEFINITIONS
Section 1 of the Act contains the following definitions:
∑ Mental disorder – Mental illness, arrested or incomplete development of mind, psychopathic
disorder and any other disorder or disability of mind.
∑ Patient – A person suffering from or appearing to suffer from mental disorder.
∑ Severe mental impairment – A state of arrested or incomplete development of mind which
includes the severe impariment of intellignence and social functioning and is associated with
abnormally aggressive or seriously irresponsible conduct on the part of the person concerned.
∑ Mental impairment – A state of arrested or incomplete development of mind (not amounting to
severe mental impairment) which includes significant impairment of intelligence and social
functioning and is associated with abnormally aggressive or seriously irresponsible conduct on
the part of the person concerned.
∑ Psychopathic disorder – A persistent disorder or disability of mind (whether or not including
significant impairment of intelligence) which results in abnormally aggressive or seriously
irresponsible conduct on the part of the person concerned.
∑ Medical treatment – Includes nursing, and care and rehabilitation under medical supervision.
∑ Responsible Medical Officer (RMO) – The registered medical practitioner in charge of the
treatment of the patient (i.e. the consultant psychiatrist); if that person is not available, the
doctor who for the time being is in charge of the patient’s treatment may deputize.
302 Legal aspects of psychiatric care
∑ Approved doctor – A registered medical practitioner approved under Section 12 of the Act by the
Secretary of State (with authority being delegated to the Regional Health Authority) as having
special experience in the diagnosis or treatment of mental disorder.
∑ Approved social worker (ASW) – An officer of a local social services authority with appropriate
training who may make applications for compulsory admission; hospital senior social workers
usually hold lists of approved social workers.
∑ Nearest relative – The first surviving person in the following list, with a full blood relative taking
preference over half blood relatives, and the elder of two relatives of the same description or level
of kinship taking preference also:
∑ husband or wife
∑ son or daughter
∑ father or mother
∑ brother or sister
∑ grandparent
∑ grandchild
∑ uncle or aunt
∑ nephew or niece.
Preference is also given to a relative with whom the patient ordinarily lives or by whom he or she
is cared for.
Note that the term mental illness is not formally defined; its operational definition is a matter of
clinical judgement in each case. The Act states that a person may not be dealt with under the Mental
Health Act as suffering from mental disorder ‘by reason only of promiscuity or other immoral
conduct, sexual deviancy or dependence on alcohol or drugs’.
Table 22.1 Civil treatment orders under Mental Health Act 1983
CONSENT TO TREATMENT
See Table 22.2.
304 Legal aspects of psychiatric care
Table 22.2 Consent to treatment under Mental Health Act 1983 – consent to treatment should be informed and
voluntary (implies mental illness, e.g. dementia, does not affect judgement)
Section 47 Mental disorder Home Secretary Two doctors: one Until earliest date of Once in the first 6 months
Transfer of a sentenced approved under release from sentence Then once in the next 6 months
prisoner to hospital Section 12 Thereafter, once a year.
Section 48 Mental disorder Home Secretary Two doctors: one Until date of trial Once in the first 6 months
Urgent transfer to approved under Then once in the next 6 months
hospital of remand Section 12 Thereafter, once a year.
prisoner
Section 49 Added to Section 47 or Home Secretary – Until end of Section 47 As for Section 47 and 48 to
Restriction direction Section 48 or 48 which applied
Effect: leave, transfer or
discharge only with consent
of Home Secretary
Reproduced with permission from Puri, B.K., Laking, P.J. & Treasaden, I.H. 2002: Textbook of Psychiatry, 2nd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Mental Health (Scotland) Act 1984 307
Table 22.4 Equivalent Scottish and English Mental Health Act treatment orders
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Puri, B.K., Brown, R., McKee, H & Treasaden, I.H. 2004: Mental Health Law Handbook. London: Arnold.
Puri, B.K., Laking, P.J. & Treasaden, I.H. 2002: Textbook of Psychiatry, 2nd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
This page intentionally left blank
23
Classification
ICD-10
MENTAL RETARDATION
F70 Mild mental retardation
F71 Moderate mental retardation
F72 Severe mental retardation
F73 Profound mental retardation
F78 Other mental retardation
F79 Unspecified mental retardation.
DSM-IV-TR
The fourth edition of the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, text revision (DSM-
IV-TR), published by the American Psychiatric Association in 2000, is a multiaxial classification
with the following five axes:
Axis I: Clinical disorders, and other conditions that may be a focus of clinical attention
Axis II: Personality disorders, and mental retardation
Axis III: General medical conditions
Axis IV: Psychosocial and environmental problems
Axis V: Global assessment of functioning.
∑ Schizoaffective disorder
∑ Delusional disorder
∑ Brief psychotic disorder
∑ Shared psychotic disorder
∑ Psychotic disorder caused by a general medical condition
∑ Substance-induced psychotic disorder
∑ Psychotic disorder NOS.
MOOD DISORDERS
∑ Depressive disorders
∑ Bipolar disorders.
ANXIETY DISORDERS
∑ Panic disorder without agoraphobia
∑ Panic disorder with agoraphobia
∑ Agoraphobia without history of panic disorder
∑ Specific phobia
∑ Social phobia
∑ Obsessive–compulsive disorder
∑ Post-traumatic stress disorder
∑ Acute stress disorder
∑ Generalized anxiety disorder
∑ Anxiety disorder caused by a general medical condition
∑ Substance-induced anxiety disorder
∑ NOS.
SOMATOFORM DISORDERS
∑ Somatization disorder
∑ Undifferentiated somatoform disorder
∑ Conversion disorder
∑ Pain disorder
∑ Hypochondriasis
∑ Body dysmorphic disorder
∑ NOS.
FACTITIOUS DISORDERS
DISSOCIATIVE DISORDERS
∑ Dissociative amnesia
∑ Dissociative fugue
∑ Dissociative identity disorder
∑ Depersonalization disorder
∑ NOS.
EATING DISORDERS
∑ Anorexia nervosa
∑ Bulimia nervosa
∑ NOS.
SLEEP DISORDERS
∑ Primary sleep disorders
∑ Dyssomnias
∑ Parasomnias
∑ Sleep disorders related to another medical disorder
∑ Other sleep disorders.
MENTAL RETARDATION
∑ Mild mental retardation
∑ Moderate mental retardation
∑ Severe mental retardation
∑ Profound mental retardation
∑ Mental retardation, severity unspecified.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
American Psychiatric Association 2000: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, text revision.
Washington, DC: APA.
World Health Organization 1992: The ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders. Geneva: WHO.
24
Physical therapies
NOTE
Pharmacotherapy is considered in Chapters 15–18.
The following are key historical points in the development of electroconvulsive therapy:
∑ During the early twentieth century it was hypothesized that schizophrenia and epilepsy are more
or less mutually exclusive disorders.
∑ In 1934, Meduna, on the basis of this hypothesis, attempted to treat schizophrenia by inducing
seizures chemically.
∑ In 1938, Cerletti and Bini induced seizures electrically.
∑ cerebral aneurysm
∑ recent myocardial infarction
∑ cardiac arrhythmia
∑ intracerebral haemorrhage
∑ acute/impending retinal detachment
∑ pheochromocytoma
∑ raised anaesthetic risk
∑ unstable vascular aneurysm or malformation.
SIDE-EFFECTS OF ECT
The main early side-effects include:
∑ headache
∑ temporary confusion
∑ some loss of short-term memory.
ECT may cause depressed patients with bipolar mood disorder to become manic. In the long
term, patients may complain of memory impairment.
Administration of ECT
∑ A patient receiving ECT in the morning should remain ‘nil by mouth’ from the previous
midnight.
∑ A muscle relaxant is administered in order to prevent violent movements during the convulsion.
∑ Atropine is administered in order to reduce secretions and prevent the muscarinic actions of the
muscle relaxant.
∑ If there is any possibility that the patient may have low or atypical plasma pseudocholinesterase
enzymes, the anaesthetist must be informed as this could lead to prolonged muscle paralysis
with the muscle relaxant.
∑ Bilateral or unilateral (to the non-dominant cerebral hemisphere) ECT is administered under a
short-acting general anaesthetic.
∑ A bite is placed in the patient’s mouth in order to prevent damage from biting during the
convulsion.
THE GUIDANCE
The NICE guidance contained the following ten main points.
Point 1
It is recommended that ECT be used only to achieve rapid and short-term improvement of
severe symptoms after an adequate trial of other treatment options has proven ineffective
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) 319
Point 2
The decision as to whether ECT is clinically indicated should be based on a documented assessment
of the risks and potential benefits to the individual, including:
∑ the risks associated with the anaesthetic
∑ current co-morbidities
∑ anticipated adverse events, particularly cognitive impairment
∑ the risk of not having treatment.
Point 3
The risks associated with ECT may be enhanced in the following groups:
∑ pregnant women
∑ older people
∑ children and young people.
Therefore clinicians should exercise particular caution when considering ECT treatment in these
groups.
Point 4
Valid consent should be obtained in all cases in which the individual has the ability to grant or refuse
consent. The decision to use ECT should be made jointly by the individual and the clinician(s)
responsible for treatment, on the basis of an informed discussion. This discussion should be enabled
by the provision of full and appropriate information about the general risks associated with ECT
(see guidance point 9 below) and about the risks and potential benefits specific to that individual.
Consent should be obtained without pressure or coercion, which may occur as a result of the
circumstances and clinical setting, and the individual should be reminded of his or her right to
withdraw consent at any point. There should be strict adherence to recognized guidelines about
consent, and the involvement of patient advocates and/or carers to facilitate informed discussion is
strongly encouraged.
Point 5
In all situations in which informed discussion and consent is not possible, advance directives should
be taken fully into account and the individual’s advocate and/or carer should be consulted.
Point 6
Clinical status should be assessed following each ECT session and treatment should be stopped
when a response has been achieved, or sooner if there is evidence of adverse effects. Cognitive
function should be monitored on an ongoing basis, and at a minimum at the end of each course of
treatment.
Point 7
It is recommended that a repeat course of ECT should be considered under the circumstances
indicated in guidance point no. 1 (above) only for individuals who have severe depressive illness,
catatonia or mania and who have previously responded well to ECT. In patients who are
experiencing an acute episode but have not previously responded, a repeat trial of ECT should be
320 Physical therapies
undertaken only after all other options have been considered and following discussion of the risks
and benefits with the individual and/or where appropriate the carer/advocate.
Point 8
As the longer-term benefits and risks of ECT have not been clearly established, it is not
recommended as a maintenance therapy in depressive illness.
Point 9
The current state of the evidence does not allow the general use of ECT in the management of
schizophrenia to be recommended.
Point 10
National information leaflets should be developed through consultation with appropriate
professional and user organizations to enable individuals and their carers/advocates to make
informed decisions regarding the appropriateness of ECT for their circumstances. The leaflets
should be evidence-based, include information about the risks of ECT and availability of alternative
treatments, and be produced in formats and languages that make them accessible to a wide range of
service users.
CRITICISMS OF GUIDANCE
A number of criticisms have been made of the above NICE guidelines on the use of ECT. For
example, Cole and Tobiansky (2003) have made the following points:
∑ The potential benefits of maintenance ECT (also known as continuation ECT) seem to have
been discounted.
∑ The recommendations have not acknowledged thedifferent potential for memory disruption
and cognitive side-effects arising from bilateral as opposed to unilateral ECT.
∑ In severelydepressed patients who have previously shown a good responseto ECT, it may be
appropriate to considerit as a first-line treatment.
∑ While the NICE guidelines do not recommend ECTas a treatment for moderate depressive
episodes, it should be noted that the randomizedcontrolled trials that form the evidence base
for ECT were carried out mainly on moderately or moderatelyseverely depressed patients,
excluding those with severe depressiveepisodes who were unable to give informed consent.
Certain of these points have in fact been addressed by NICE in statements relating to the clinical
effectiveness of ECT (see below). In their editorial considering these NICE guidelines, Carney and
Geddes (2003) concluded that:
For too long electroconvulsive therapy has been a neglected service with widespread unexplained
variations in practice and a low priority with managers: repeated audits by the Royal College of
Psychiatrists have shown that many hospital trusts fail to adhere to the college’s standards. The
recommendations from NICE, together with the recently announced accreditation service from the
Royal College of Psychiatrists, should provide the stimulus to ensure that services are brought up to
acceptable standards throughout the United Kingdom.
We predict that most parties will be reasonably satisfied with the NICE appraisal. Those concerned
about potential overuse of the treatment can be reassured with the restrictions, increased safeguards,
and improved consent procedures. Clinicians with the responsibility for helping the most severely ill
patients will still have access to an effective treatment. So far, the process appears to have resulted in
Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) 321
an approach that is both evidence-based and broadly acceptable to most stakeholders. If this indeed is
the result, it will be a substantial achievement in such a difficult area of clinical practice and a finely
judged performance by NICE.
Point 1
The evidence presented in the Assessment Report was primarily drawn from a recent Cochrane
Review of ECT in schizophrenia and a systematic review commissioned by the Department of
Health on the use of ECT in schizophrenia, depressive illness and mania. Both reviews are of high
quality and consider a total of 119 randomized controlled trials (RCTs) and a number of
observational studies. Evidence submitted by patient and professional groups was also considered.
Point 2
There were problems with the design of many of the RCTs. A large proportion were conducted
before the introduction of modern techniques of administering ECT, and therefore do not reflect
current practice. There were large variations in the parameters of the ECT administered that
included the machine used, the number of sessions, the dosage and waveform, electrode placement,
and the type and dosage of concomitant therapy. A number of studies used fixed dosage rather than
individual thresholds. There was little evidence to support the routine prescription of a set number
of treatment sessions per course of ECT or of the value of continuation (maintenance) ECT. The
validity of many of the measurement scales used in the studies to measure outcome has not been
clearly established and no study adequately captured either users’ views or quality of life.
Point 3
The Assessment Report reviews data from 90 RCTs in individuals with depressive illness, of different
grades of clinical severity, who were referred for ECT. Overall, these RCTs provide evidence that real
ECT (that is, where an electric current was applied) is more effective than sham ECT (where no
electric current was applied) in the short term.
The data provide evidence that the stimulus parameters have an important influence on efficacy;
at the end of a course of treatment, bilateral ECT was reported to be more effective than unilateral
ECT. Raising the electrical stimulus above the individual’s seizure threshold was found to increase
the efficacy of unilateral ECT at the expense of increased cognitive impairment.
In trials comparing ECT with pharmacotherapy, ECT had greater benefit than the use of certain
antidepressants but the trials were of variable quality and inadequate doses and durations of drug
therapy were frequently used. The combination of ECT with pharmacotherapy was not shown to be
superior to ECT alone, although the duration of the RCTs was insufficient to show whether
pharmacotherapy was beneficial. Compared with placebo, continuation pharmacotherapy with
tricyclic antidepressants and/or lithium reduced the rate of relapses in people who had responded
to ECT.
Preliminary studies indicate that ECT is more effective than repetitive transcranial magnetic
stimulation (rTMS).
Point 4
Evidence from 25 RCTs suggests that ECT may be effective in acute episodes of certain types of
schizophrenia and reduce the occurrence of relapses, although the results are not conclusive and the
322 Physical therapies
design of many of the studies did not reflect current practice. The data on differing efficacy related
to electrode placement and stimulus parameters are equivocal and firm conclusions could not be
drawn.
No RCT investigated the use of ECT in comparison with atypical antipsychotics, and the studies
that included individuals with treatment-resistant schizophrenia did not consider the use of
clozapine. The combined weight of evidence suggests that ECT is not more effective, and may be less
effective, than antipsychotic medication. The combination of ECT and pharmacotherapy may be
more effective than pharmacotherapy alone, but the evidence is not conclusive.
Point 5
The four RCTs reviewed in the Assessment Report suggest that ECT may be of benefit in the rapid
control of mania and catatonia and this suggestion is supported by evidence from a number of
observational studies and testimony from clinical experts. However, the evidence on which to base
any general conclusions about the effectiveness of ECT or to determine the most appropriate
therapeutic strategy is weak.
Point 6
There is clear evidence that cognitive impairment occurs both immediately after administration of
ECT and following a course of therapy, and this may cause considerable distress to those affected.
The impairment is greater in individuals who have had electrodes applied bilaterally than in those
who have had them placed unilaterally, and unilateral placement to the dominant hemisphere
causes more impairment than placement to the non-dominant hemisphere. A reduction in the risk
of cognitive impairment is, however, mirrored by a reduction in efficacy.
There is some limited evidence from RCTs to suggest that the effects on cognitive function may
not last beyond six months, but this has been inadequately researched.
There is also evidence to suggest that the impairment of cognitive function associated with ECT
differs between individuals and that it is linked to the dose administered, although the relationship
with the seizure threshold has not been adequately defined. There is no evidence to suggest that the
effect of ECT on cognitive function differs between diagnoses.
Point 7
In addition to testimony from user groups, a systematic review of evidence from non-randomized
studies relating to patients’ accounts and experiences of ECT was also considered. This provided
important evidence on the experiences of individuals receiving ECT, particularly cognitive
impairment and its impact, and the validity of neuropsychological instruments used in clinical
trials.
There was evidence that the measurement scales used in RCTs do not adequately capture the
nature and extent of cognitive impairment, and qualitative studies have indicated that the
impairment may be prolonged or permanent. Additionally, there was testimony that individuals are
not provided with sufficient information on which to base a decision regarding consent. Also, some
individuals are unaware of their rights to refuse treatment, or may feel unable to do so because of
the perceived threat of detainment under the Mental Health Act.
Point 8
There was no evidence to suggest that the mortality associated with ECT is greater than that
associated with minor procedures involving general anaesthetics, and there were limited data on
mortality extending beyond the trial periods.
The six reviewed studies that used brain-scanning techniques did not provide any evidence that
ECT causes brain damage.
Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation 323
While there is no evidence to suggest that benefits and safety are age-dependent, there are no stud-
ies on the impact of ECT on the developing brain. Furthermore, it is likely that co-morbidities could
increase the risk of harm. The use of ECT during pregnancy is known to cause complications, but the
risks associated with ECT need to be balanced against the risks of using alternative (drug) treatments.
ECT rTMS
Anaesthesia Required Not required
Seizure Required Not required
Treatment frequency 2–3 per week Every day
Occurrence of amnesia Yes No
Focality Relatively non-focal More focal
Tissue impedance Shunting occurs No shunting
Pulse width 0.5–2 ms 0.2 ms
324 Physical therapies
PHOTOTHERAPY
This is treatment with high-intensity artificial light, and may be used to treat patients suffering from
seasonal affective disorder (SAD).
The light boxes used typically emit light of a strength of around 10 000 lux. By comparison,
on a sunny day the level of illumination may reach 100 000 lux, while the home environment
may typically be illuminated at around 250 lux. The light spectrum used tends to be balanced,
but usually with potentially harmful ultraviolet B (UVB) frequencies filtered out. Patients are
usually instructed to sit at a specified distance from the light box for a specified length of time
each day.
SLEEP DEPRIVATION
INDICATIONS
The clinical indications for sleep deprivation in mood disorders include:
∑ as an antidepressant in treatment-resistant patients
∑ to augment the response to antidepressants
∑ to hasten the onset of action of antidepressant medication or of lithium
∑ as a prophylaxis in recurrent mood cycles
∑ as an aid to diagnosis
∑ to predict the response to antidepressants or ECT.
ADMINISTRATION
In total sleep deprivation, the patient is kept awake for 36 hours. One variation is late partial sleep
deprivation, in which the patient is kept awake from 2 a.m. until 10 p.m. Another variation entails
depriving the patient only of rapid-eye-movement (REM) sleep.
PSYCHOSURGERY
Psychosurgery practice
Current methods for making sterotaxic lesions include:
∑ electrocautery
∑ radioactive yttrium implantation
∑ thermocoagulation
∑ gamma knife.
Some of the specific operations that may be used currently include:
∑ frontal-lobe lesioning
∑ cingulotomy
∑ capsulotomy
∑ subcaudate tractotomy
∑ limbic leucotomy.
Vagal nerve stimulation (VNS) is generally carried out by surgically implanting a vagus nerve
stimulator (a pulse generator) into the subcutaneous tissues of the upper left chest, in order to
deliver pulsed electrical stimulation to the cervical vagal trunk. VNS is of particular use in the
treatment of epilepsy.
The first use of VNS in humans was by Penry and Dean (published in 1990) for the prevention
of partial seizures. Later, a neurocybernetic prosthesis implant was used in a patient with depression
at the Medical University of South Carolina (Charleston, USA).
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Carney, S. & Geddes, J. 2003: Electroconvulsive therapy: recent recommendations are likely to improve standards
and uniformity of use. British Medical Journal 326:1343–1344.
Cole, C. & Tobiansky, R. 2003: Electroconvulsive therapy: NICE guidance may deny many patients treatment that
they might benefit from. British Medical Journal 327:621.
Lisanby, S.H. & Sackeim, H.A. 2002: Transcranial magnetic stimulation and electroconvulsive therapy: similarities
and differences. In Pascual-Leone, A., Davey, N.J., Rothwell, J., Wassermann, E.M. & Puri, B.K. (eds) Handbook
of Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation. London: Arnold.
Pascual-Leone, A., Davey, N.J., Rothwell, J., Wassermann, E.M. and Puri, B.K. (eds) 2002: Handbook of Transcranial
Magnetic Stimulation. London: Arnold.
Puri, B.K., Laking, P.J. & Treasaden, I.H. 2002: Textbook of Psychiatry, 2nd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Rush, A.J., George, M.S., Sackeim, H.A. et al. 2000: Vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) for treatment-resistant
depressions: a multicenter study. Biological Psychiatry 47:276–286.
Schachter, S. & Schmidt, D. (eds) 2001: Vagus Nerve Stimulation. London: Martin Dunitz.
Trimble, M.R. 1996: Neuropsychiatry, 2nd edn. Chichester: John Wiley.
25
Organic psychiatry
General issues
In ICD-10, organic mental disorders are grouped on the basis of a common demonstrable aetiology
being present in the form of cerebral disorder, injury to the brain, or other insult leading to cerebral
dysfunction, which may be:
∑ primary – disorders, injuries and insults affecting the brain directly or with predilection, such as
Alzheimer’s disease
∑ secondary – systemic disorders affecting the brain only in so far as it is one of the multiple
organs or body systems involved (e.g. hypothyroidism).
By convention the following disorders are excluded from the category of organic mental
disorders and considered separately:
∑ psychoactive substance use disorders (including brain disorder resulting from alcohol and other
psychoactive drugs)
∑ certain sleep disorders
∑ the causes of learning disability (mental retardation).
The dementias and delirium are considered in Chapters 11 and 38, while Wernicke’s
encephalopathy and Korsakov’s syndrome are considered in Chapter 26. The clinical features of
focal cerebral disorders have been outlined in Chapter 10.
The causes of dementia are conveniently summarized here:
∑ degenerative diseases of the central nervous system:
∑ Alzheimer’s disease
∑ Pick’s disease
∑ Huntington’s disease
∑ Creutzfeldt–Jakob disease
∑ normal-pressure hydrocephalus
∑ multiple sclerosis
∑ Lewy body disease
∑ intoxication
∑ alcohol
328 Organic psychiatry
The treatment, course and prognosis for the following disorders are essentially those of the
underlying pathology.
ORGANIC HALLUCINOSIS
In ICD-10, organic hallucinosis is defined as being a disorder of persistent or recurrent
hallucinations, in any modality but usually visual or auditory, that occur in clear consciousness
Organic mental disorders 329
without any significant intellectual decline and that may or may not be recognized by the subject as
such; delusional elaboration of the hallucinations may occur, but often insight is preserved. The
causes of organic hallucinosis are shown in Table 25.1.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
ACUTE INTOXICATION
This is a transient condition following the use of a psychoactive substance, resulting in disturbance
of one or more of the following:
∑ consciousness level
∑ cognition
∑ perception
∑ affect
∑ behaviour.
Its intensity is closely related to dose, lessening with time, and the effects disappear when
following cessation of the intake of the psychoactive substance. Recovery is usually complete.
Pathological intoxication applies only to alcohol, and refers to sudden aggressive behaviour, out of
character, after drinking small amounts which would not produce intoxication in most people.
HARMFUL USE
This is use that is causing damage to physical or mental health. It does not refer to adverse social
consequences.
DEPENDENCE SYNDROME
This is diagnosed if three or more of the following have been present together at some time in the
previous year:
∑ compulsion to take the substance
∑ difficulties in controlling substance-taking behaviour: onset, termination or levels of use
∑ characteristic physiological withdrawal state when substance reduced or withdrawn; use of
substance to avoid or relieve withdrawal symptoms
∑ increased tolerance, so larger doses are required to achieve effect originally produced by lower
doses
∑ progressive neglect of other activities with increasing time spent in acquiring, taking or
recovering from the effects of the substance
∑ persisting with substance use despite evidence of harmful consequences.
WITHDRAWAL STATE
Symptoms occur upon withdrawal or reduction of a substance after repeated, usually high dose, and
prolonged use. Onset and course are time-limited, dose-related and differ according to the
substance involved. Convulsions may complicate withdrawal.
PSYCHOTIC DISORDER
Psychotic symptoms occur during or immediately after psychoactive substance use, in relatively
clear sensorium (some clouding of consciousness but not severe confusion). It is not a
manifestation of drug withdrawal or a functional psychosis. The characteristics of the psychosis
vary according to the substance used, but the following are common:
∑ vivid hallucinations in more than one modality
∑ delusions
∑ psychomotor disturbances
∑ abnormal affect.
Stimulant-induced psychotic disorders are generally related to prolonged high-dose use.
Typically it resolves at least partially within 1 month and fully within 6 months.
In ICD-10, further subdivisions may be specified:
∑ schizophrenia-like
∑ predominantly delusional
∑ predominantly hallucinatory (includes alcoholic hallucinosis)
∑ predominantly polymorphic
∑ predominantly depressive symptoms
∑ predominantly manic symptoms
∑ mixed.
AMNESIC SYNDROME
This is induced by alcohol or other psychoactive substances. Requirements for diagnosis include:
∑ chronic prominent impairment of recent memory; remote memory may be impaired; difficulty
learning new material; disturbance of time sense
∑ immediate recall preserved; other cognitive functions are usually relatively preserved and
consciousness is clear
∑ a history of chronic and usually high-dose use of alcohol or drugs.
Confabulation may be present, but not invariably so. Korsakov’s psychosis is included here.
ALCOHOL
The concentration of alcohol in beverages is stated in terms of ‘proof ’ scales. In the USA, one-degree
(1°) proof is equal to a concentration of 0.5% by volume (v/v). In the UK, one-degree proof is equal
to 0.5715% by volume (v/v).
One unit of alcohol is approximately 8–10 g of ethanol (C2H5OH), and is the amount contained
in:
∑ a standard measure of spirits
∑ a standard glass of sherry or fortified wine
∑ a standard glass of table wine
∑ one half-pint of beer or lager of standard strength (3–3.5% by volume).
LEVELS OF CONSUMPTION
Up to 21 units of alcohol per week for men, and up to 14 units of alcohol per week for women, not
consumed in one go and not consumed every day, are considered to be low-risk levels of intake.
Women are more susceptible to the harmful effects of alcohol because their lower lean body mass
results in higher blood alcohol levels per unit taken.
Consumption in greater amounts constitutes excessive consumption, carrying much greater risks
of developing alcohol-related disability and alcohol dependence.
∑ Increasing hazard corresponds to an intake of alcohol of between 21 and 50 units per week for
men, and between 14 and 35 units per week for women.
∑ Dangerous levels of alcohol consumption correspond to an alcohol intake of over 50 units per
week for men, and over 35 units per week for women.
Abstinence or minimal alcohol intake is recommended in pregnancy, because of the risk of the
development of fetal alcohol syndrome.
ALCOHOL-RELATED DISABILITIES
Excessive alcohol intake can lead to:
∑ physical morbidity
∑ psychiatric morbidity
∑ social morbidity.
Gastrointestinal disorders
These include:
∑ nausea and vomiting, particularly in the morning, prevented by drinking more alcohol
∑ gastritis
∑ peptic ulcers
∑ diarrhoea
∑ Mallory–Weiss tears
∑ oesophageal varices.
Malnutrition
This may result from:
∑ poor intake
∑ malabsorption
∑ impaired metabolism.
Results of malnutrition may include:
∑ thiamine deficiency presenting with Wernicke’s encephalopathy acutely, leading in a high
proportion of cases to Korsakov’s psychosis (may also present with high output heart failure of
beri-beri)
∑ niacin deficiency (vitamin B3) presenting with pellagra, causing confusion, diarrhoea and light-
sensitive rash
∑ vitamin C deficiency presenting with skin haemorrhages and gingivitis.
Liver
Hepatic damage is another important result of excessive alcohol intake. Fatty infiltration leading to
an acute increase in the size of the liver occurs within a few days of excessive intake; it may cause
pain in the right hypochondrium, nausea and vomiting, but is usually not detected. It is reversible
with abstinence. Alcoholic hepatitis may occur secondary to long-term heavy daily drinking.
Liver cell necrosis and inflammation occurs, presenting with right hypochondrial pain and
jaundice, sometimes accompanied by ascites and encephalopathy.
Cirrhosis with permanent fibrotic changes occurs. This may present with signs of liver failure,
including:
∑ ascites
∑ encephalopathy
∑ bleeding oesophageal varices.
However, cirrhosis may be symptomless initially.
Pancreas
Acute and chronic pancreatitis lead to food malabsorption and diabetes in some cases.
Cardiovascular system
Cardiovascular system disorders include:
∑ hypertension, poorly responsive to conventional treatment but responsive to abstinence
∑ cardiac arrhythmias particularly after binge-drinking (holiday heart syndrome)
∑ cardiomyopathy, presenting with gradual onset of heart failure (the prognosis is poor with
continued drinking)
∑ haemorrhagic and thrombotic CVA, even in the young.
338 Psychoactive substance use disorders
Blood
Haematological changes may occur, since alcohol is a bone marrow toxin, resulting in the following:
∑ macrocytosis
∑ folate deficiency
∑ impaired clotting caused by vitamin K deficiency and/or reduced platelet functioning
∑ iron-deficiency anaemia, often as a result of gastrointestinal haemorrhage.
Neoplasms
There is an increased incidence of the following types of cancer:
∑ oropharygeal
∑ oesophageal
∑ colorectal
∑ pancreatic
∑ hepatic
∑ lung.
Pregnancy
Excessive alcohol consumption in pregnancy can lead to permanent fetal damage. Features of the
resulting fetal alcohol syndrome include:
∑ low IQ (mean 70)
∑ cardiac abnormalities (e.g. atrial septal defect)
∑ low-set ears
∑ absent philtrum
∑ long upper lip with narrow vermilion border
∑ depressed bridge of the nose
∑ small nose
∑ ocular hypertelorism
∑ microcephaly
∑ strabismus
∑ pectus excavatum
∑ poor growth
∑ increased neonatal mortality.
Trauma
Accidents and trauma may result from alcohol consumption. These include:
Alcohol 339
∑ road accidents
∑ assaults (including head injuries)
∑ falls (including head injuries)
∑ drowning
∑ burns
∑ death by fire.
The most common traumatic injuries include:
∑ rib fractures
∑ head injuries
∑ subdural/extradural haematomata
∑ long-bone fractures.
Infections
There is an increased risk of infections such as tuberculosis and pneumonia, particularly in the
homeless.
Metabolism
A variety of metabolic abnormalities may occur, including:
∑ alcohol-induced lactic acidosis
∑ alcoholic ketoacidosis
∑ hyperlipidemia in one-third of alcohol-dependent subjects (low levels of intake appear
protective, however)
∑ hypoglycaemia
∑ hyperuricaemia
∑ haemochromatosis
∑ porphyria cutanea tarda.
Nervous system
Neurological disorders that are associated with excessive drinking include:
∑ peripheral neuropathy resulting in numbness and paraesthesias in glove and stocking distribution
∑ cerebellar degeneration, affecting mainly the vermis, resulting in ataxia of gait
∑ convulsions occurring mainly secondary to alcohol withdrawal, within the first 48 hours (also
secondary to brain damage or hypoglycaemia)
∑ optic atrophy
∑ central pontine myelinolysis.
Marchiafava–Bignami disease is a rare fatal demyelinating disease characterized neuropatho-
logically by widespread demyelination affecting the central corpus callosum, and often also the
340 Psychoactive substance use disorders
middle cerebellar peduncles, the white matter of the cerebral hemispheres, and the optic tracts. It
presents clinically with emotional disturbance and cognitive impairment followed by epilepsy,
delirium, paralysis and coma.
Mood disorder
Chronic heavy drinking can itself produce severe, usually transient depressive symptoms, which
generally improve with abstinence. If symptoms persist with abstinence, antidepressants should be
considered. The suicide rate is at least 50 times greater in alcoholics than in the general population.
Between one-quarter and one-third of completed suicides occur in alcoholics and up to four-fifths
of those who kill themselves have been drinking.
Personality disorder
Those with sociopathic personality disorder engage in excessive drinking and those who drink
heavily often engage in antisocial acts. If antisocial behaviour predates alcoholism by several years
then the primary diagnosis is of personality disorder.
Cloninger (1987) described two types of alcoholic:
∑ Type 1 (milieu-limited). This is the least severe, occurring in men and women, in dependent,
anxious, rigid, less aggressive types, whose biological father or mother may have a mild adult-
onset alcohol problem. It is thought that genetic predisposition and postnatal provocation are
required to initiate this type of alcoholism.
∑ Type 2. This is severe and of early onset, occurring in men who are socially detached and
confident, whose biological fathers (but not mothers) often have teenage-onset alcoholism and
criminality. This type is thought by some to be alcoholism secondary to sociopathic personality
disorder. Genetic predisposition has a powerful aetiological effect, with little contribution from
the environment.
There does not appear to be a relationship between schizophrenia and alcoholism other than that
occurring by chance. Genetic studies find that people suffering from alcoholism and schizophrenia
have a predisposition to each condition separately.
Alcoholic hallucinosis
A rare disorder caused by chronic alcohol intake is alcoholic hallucinosis, characterized by auditory
hallucinations in clear consciousness. It is distinguished from schizophrenia by the following
features:
Alcohol 341
Pathological jealousy
Pathological jealousy is a well-recognized association with alcoholism, but may occur with other
conditions such as schizophrenia and depression.
Neurotic disorders
Neurotic disorders may predispose to alcoholism in an attempt by the patient to self-medicate.
Generalized anxiety, panic attacks and phobic disorders, particularly agoraphobia, may precede
alcoholism. The patient should be reassessed once abstinent and any underlying condition should
be appropriately managed.
Psychosexual disorders
Psychosexual disorders are a common association with excessive alcohol intake. In men,
intoxication leads to erectile impotence and delayed ejaculation. Chronic heavy drinking in men can
cause:
∑ loss of libido
∑ reduction in the size of the testes
∑ reduction in the size of the penis
∑ loss of body hair
∑ gynaecomastia.
In women, chronic heavy drinking can cause:
∑ menstrual cycle abnormalities
∑ loss of breast tissue
∑ vaginal dryness.
Delirium tremens
In chronic heavy drinkers a fall in the blood alcohol concentration leads to withdrawal symptoms
including delirium tremens. The peak onset is within two days of abstinence and it usually lasts for
about five days. There is a prodromal period with:
∑ anxiety
∑ insomnia
∑ tachycardia
∑ tremor
∑ sweating.
The onset of delirium is marked by:
∑ disorientation
∑ fluctuating level of consciousness
∑ intensely fearful affect
∑ hallucinations
∑ misperceptions
∑ tremor
∑ restlessness
∑ autonomic over-activity.
The hallucinations are often visual and are commonly Lilliputian in nature. Auditory and tactile
hallucinations, and secondary delusions, may also be present. There is a mortality rate of about 5%,
associated with cardiovascular collapse or infection. The treatment of delirium tremens is
supportive with sedation, fluid and electrolyte replacement, high-potency vitamins (especially
thiamine to prevent an unrecognized Wernicke’s encephalopathy progressing to Korsakov’s
psychosis – see below).
Withdrawal fits
Withdrawal fits may take place within 48 hours of stopping drinking.
Wernicke’s encephalopathy
Wernicke’s encephalopathy is caused by severe deficiency of thiamine (vitamin B1), which is usually
caused by alcohol abuse in Western countries. Other causes include:
Alcohol 343
Korsakov’s syndrome
Korsakov’s syndrome is an alcohol-induced amnesic syndrome that, as mentioned above, is
frequently preceded by Wernicke’s encephalopathy. It has been described as being ‘an abnormal state
in which memory and learning are affected out of all proportion to other cognitive functions in an
otherwise alert and responsive patient’ (Victor et al., 1971). Clinical features include:
∑ retrograde amnesia
∑ anterograde amnesia
∑ sparing of immediate recall
∑ disorientation in time
∑ inability to recall the temporal sequence of events
∑ confabulation
∑ peripheral neuropathy.
Neuropathologically there is scarring and atrophy of the mammillary bodies and anterior
thalamus, with substantial frontal lobe dysfunction on neuroimaging. Improvement may occur
with abstinence and high-dose thiamine and replacement of other B vitamins, which should be
continued for 6 months.
Alcoholic dementia
Those who have abused alcohol for some years commonly suffer mild to moderate cognitive
impairment, which may improve over a number of years of abstinence. Women, who are known to
suffer physical complications of alcohol abuse earlier than men, also develop cognitive impairment
344 Psychoactive substance use disorders
earlier in their drinking histories. A CT or structural MRI scan of the brain in alcoholics commonly
shows ventricular enlargement and sulcal widening, which does not correlate with the degree of
cognitive impairment and largely reverses with abstinence.
Chronic alcoholics show a coarsening of personality which appears to be related to frontal lobe
atrophy.
Alcohol dependence
Edwards and Gross (1976) described the alcohol-dependence syndrome which was later also
applied to other psychoactive substances:
1 Increased tolerance. Repeated doses of the drug produce less effect, resulting in escalating doses
to achieve the original effect. The rate at which tolerance develops varies with the substance
used: it is generally rapid with heroin, but much slower with alcohol.
2 Repeated withdrawal symptoms. A fall in blood alcohol concentration leads to unpleasant
withdrawal symptoms within 12 hours of the last intake, relieved by drinking more alcohol.
3 Subjective awareness of a compulsion to drink. Attempted abstinence leads to tension and an
increased craving for alcohol.
Alcohol 345
4 Salience of drink-seeking behaviour. Acquiring and drinking alcohol take primacy over other
activities such as family, career and social position.
5 Relief or avoidance of withdrawal symptoms. This is achieved by further drinking.
6 Narrowing of the drinking repertoire. The pattern of drinking becomes increasingly stereotyped
with increasing dependence. A daily routine develops and a certain drink will be favoured over
others.
7 Rapid reinstatement following abstinence. After a period of abstinence the drinker may attempt to
drink in moderation. The intake is likely to escalate rapidly as tolerance and dependence
reappear within a few days.
PERSONALITY FACTORS
It has been suggested that some problem drinkers are predisposed to harmful drinking by their
personality; however, studies in this area give contradictory results. It is known that those with
sociopathic personality disorder have a high prevalence of heavy drinking and alcoholism. However,
there is no typical pre-alcoholic personality.
BIOLOGICAL FACTORS
The EEG of sober, awake alcoholics shows an excess of fast activity and a deficiency of a, q and d
activity. The sons of alcoholics also show an excess of fast activity when compared to controls,
leading to speculation that this may be a specific marker for alcoholism.
Electrically evoked responses show reduced P3 voltage in both abstinent chronic alcoholics and
in the young sons of alcoholics when compared to controls.
The metabolism of alcohol is genetically determined and varies between individuals. Over half of
Orientals develop an unpleasant flushing response when alcohol is ingested, related to the
accumulation of acetaldehyde, caused by the absence of the isoenzyme ALDH2: aldehyde
dehydrogenase. It is thought that this intolerance of alcohol protects them from developing
alcoholism, since it is much less prevalent in those of oriental heritage.
Ethanol at low concentrations (5–10 mmol/L) inhibits the action of NMDA-glutamate
controlled ion channels, and potentiates the actions of GABA type A controlled ion channels. These
are the main excitatory and inhibitory systems of the brain; the overall effect of ethanol is therefore
as a central nervous depressant.
At slightly higher ethanol concentrations the actions of voltage-sensitive calcium channels and
channels controlled by serotonin are affected.
Ethanol promotes the CNS release of dopamine particularly from the nucleus accumbens.
Chronic administration of ethanol produces alterations in the GABA, NMDA and voltage-
sensitive calcium channel systems. Reduction in the production of subunits of the GABA receptors
are seen particularly in mice prone to withdrawal convulsions. Chronic ethanol administration also
causes an up-regulation of NMDA receptors in mouse hippocampus, more evident in mice prone to
withdrawal convulsions. Both of these receptor changes promote CNS excitability and increase the
likelihood of convulsions.
Excessive glutamate stimulation is toxic to the nerve cell and results in damage or cell death.
Although ethanol exposure is the cause of increased numbers of NMDA receptors, its presence
protects against the neurotoxicity of glutamate over-stimulation. The acute withdrawal of ethanol
in the dependent subject results in convulsions and neurotoxicity.
PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS
There are three main components to psychological theories of dependence:
∑ Withdrawal avoidance. Prolonged drug use results in tolerance, with CNS adaptation to allow
normal functioning despite the chronic presence of the psychoactive drug. If the drug is
suddenly withdrawn, this adaptation results in drug-withdrawal symptoms, which are usually
opposite to the effects of the drug. Thus in terms of this theory the dependent person continues
drug use in order to avoid the adverse effects of drug withdrawal.
∑ Positive effects of the drug. According to this theory, the pleasant effects of the drug reinforce
drug-taking behaviour, despite adverse social and physical consequences.
∑ Motivational distortion. According to this theory, the repetition of drug-taking behaviour, or the
effects of the drugs themselves, change the motivational system supporting that behaviour.
Alcohol 347
Habit strength is a term describing the strength of the link between a stimulus that cues a
behaviour. It is possible that it involves habituation at the neuronal level.
Each of these theories accounts for some but not all aspects of addiction.
CULTURAL FACTORS
There are high rates of alcoholism in countries where alcohol is drunk routinely with family meals,
and in places where it is cheap.
PSYCHIATRIC ILLNESS
This can predispose patients to harmful drinking, particularly anxiety disorders, phobic disorders,
depression and bereavement and mania.
Investigations
Blood investigations include alcohol levels in the intoxicated (breathalyzers can be useful to give an
indication of levels of recent drinking). Alcoholism is the most common cause of raised mean
corpuscular volume (MCV), and it is raised in 60% of alcohol abusers. Since the life of a red blood
cell is 120 days, the MCV should return to normal 4 months after continued abstinence. Raised g-
glutamyl transferase may occur; this is good for screening as an indication of recent alcohol use, but
it can be raised after only one heavy drinking session. Liver function tests (e.g. aspartate
transaminase) may be abnormal, particularly during acute alcoholic hepatitis, less so in fatty liver,
and may be normal in cirrhosis.
Treatment
Detoxification can usually be conducted as an outpatient unless severe withdrawal effects such as
delirium tremens or convulsions are likely to occur; the patient’s mental state causes concern; or
there are severe social problems, in which case inpatient care should be organized. The aim should
be for abstinence; education, support and counselling will be required.
348 Psychoactive substance use disorders
After the assessment of the severity of withdrawal symptoms, a substitute sedative is started.
Benzodiazepines such as diazepam or chlordiazepoxide are commonly used in a reducing regimen.
Ethanol withdrawal increases glutamate in the brain which damages neurones. Repeated withdrawal
causes increased neuronal death. Valium withdrawal is not neuroprotective. However, acamprosate
blocks increased glutamate in withdrawal and is neuroprotective. Acamprosate should be started
with detoxification if it is intended for use afterwards. Attention should be paid to the state of
hydration and nutrition of the patient. Thiamine should always be given. If malabsorption is likely,
intravenous thiamine and other B vitamins should be given in the first instance. A glucose load
should be avoided as this can precipitate or exacerbate thiamine deficiency; ascorbic acid may also
be required. The suicide risk should be assessed.
Alcoholics Anonymous is a self-help group which some alcoholics find helpful. Al-Anon
supports the families of alcoholics, and Al-Ateen the teenage children of alcoholics.
Supportive therapy is helpful. Other forms of psychotherapy are also useful. Cognitive–
behavioural models appear to be particularly effective in relapse prevention. Such therapies include
cue exposure, relapse prevention strategies, contingency management, social skills and assertiveness
training.
Medication can be used in the detoxified alcoholic to help maintain abstinence.
Aversive agents, disulfiram (Antabuse) and citrated calcium carbimide, both inhibit aldehyde
dehydrogenase leading to the accumulation of aldehyde if alcohol is ingested. The patient
experiences very unpleasant symptoms of flushing, headache, palpitations, tachycardia, nausea and
vomiting with ingestion of small amounts of alcohol, and air hunger, arrhythmias and severe
hypotension with large amounts of alcohol. These agents are contraindicated in ischaemic heart
disease, in pregnancy or if there is a history of convulsions. Patients must be well motivated and
aware of the risks of taking alcohol with these agents. Efficacy requires compliance with taking the
aversive agent; involving the spouse or partner in administration can improve the success rate.
Acamprosate, in combination with counselling, may also be helpful in maintaining abstinence. It
should be initiated as soon as is possible after the achievement of abstinence. It should be
maintained if a relapse occurs. Acamprosate is contraindicated in cases in which there is renal or
hepatic impairment, noradrenaline and also during pregnancy and lactation. Side-effects of this
drug include diarrhoea, nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain and pruritus.
Prognosis
Good prognostic factors include:
∑ good insight
∑ strong motivation
∑ good social and family support.
Relapse can be precipitated by:
∑ emotional stress
∑ interpersonal conflict
∑ social pressures.
Long-term follow-up of alcoholics over a period of 10 years finds that:
∑ 25% continue troubled drinking
∑ 12% are abstinent.
The remainder follow a pattern of intermittent troubled drinking and abstinence.
Non-alcoholic psychoactive substances: legal aspects in the United Kingdom 349
NOTE
Colloquial names for some abused drugs are given in Table 26.1.
Notifications were compiled in the Addicts Index, which provided epidemiological information
for use in the planning of services. A doctor could also contact the Index by telephone to check
whether a presenting patient was currently known to another service. It thus acted as a safeguard
against multiple scripting.
From 1 May 1997, the Addicts Index was closed and the statutory duty for doctors to notify
details of addicts to the Addicts Index was removed.
MISUSE OF DRUGS ACT 1971 (MODIFICATION) ORDER 2003 AND MISUSE OF DRUGS
REGULATIONS 2003
Changes were made to the legislation on the misuse of drugs by these regulations, which came into
force on 1 July 2003. The following eight substances were brought under the control of the Misuse
of Drugs Act 1971 and its associated subordinate legislation for the first time:
remifentanil 4-androstene-3, 17-dione
dihydroetorphine 19-nor-4-androstene-3, 17-dione
gamma-hydroxy-butyrate 5-androstene-3, 17-diol
zolpidem 19-nor-5-androstene-3, 17- diol.
Remifentanil and dihydroetorphine are controlled as class A drugs. Both are powerful opiates
and have similar pharmacological properties to existing class A drugs. Both are listed under
Schedule 2 of the Misuse of Drugs Regulations 2001.
4-hydroxy-n-butyric acid or gamma-hydroxy-butyrate (GHB) and zolpidem are controlled as
class C drugs. Both are listed under Schedule 4 (Part I) of the 2001 Regulations. GHB has been used
Non-alcoholic psychoactive substances: legal aspects in the United Kingdom 351
as an anaesthetic and to treat alcohol and drug dependence but has also been misused by clubbers.
Zolpidem is a prescription medicine (a non-benzodiazepine hypnotic with a short duration of
action) and acts in a similar same way as some sedatives such as benzodiazepines.
The following four anabolic substances are listed in Schedule 4 (Part II) of the 2001 Regulations:
4-androstene-3, 17-dione 5-androstene-3, 17-diol
19-nor-4-androstene-3, 17-dione 19-nor-5-androstene-3, 17- diol.
They are now controlled as class C drugs.
According to the Home Office, there is some evidence to suggest that some of the above eight
substances have been produced in clandestine laboratories for the illicit drugs market in the last few
years, and there have been a few police seizures of some of these substances in the UK.
Note that Schedule 2 drugs are subject to the additional prescription requirements of Regulation
15 (see below; amongst other things, prescriptions must be handwritten by doctors). Regulations 14
(documentation), 16 (supply on prescription), 18 (marking of containers), 19, 20, 21, 23 (keeping
and preservation of registers), 26 (furnishing of information) and 27 (destruction) also apply to
Schedule 2 drugs. Most Schedule 2 drugs are also subject to the statutory safe custody requirements.
Schedule 4 (Part I) includes benzodiazepines (e.g. diazepam, lorazepam and nitrazepam).
Gamma-hydroxy-butyrate (GHB) and zolpidem have been added to the list of drugs in Schedule 4
(Part I). Persons already authorized by the Regulations (e.g. doctors and pharmacists), or by a
written Home Office authority to produce, supply or possess Schedule 4 (Part I) drugs, are
automatically so authorized in respect of GHB and zolpidem. In other cases an appropriate written
Home Office authority is required. The Regulation 15 prescription requirements (including
handwriting) do not apply to Schedule 4 (Part I) drugs. Regulations 22, 23 (keeping and
preservation of records), 26 (furnishing of information) and 27 (destruction – holders of written
authorities to produce only) also apply to Schedule 4 (Part I) drugs. Schedule 4 (Part I) drugs are not
subject to the safe custody requirements.
Schedule 4 (Part II) now comprises 54 anabolic substances; examples are nandrolone and
testosterone (and the four newly added anabolic substances: 4-androstene-3, 17-dione; 19-nor-4-
androstene-3, 17-dione; 5-androstene-3, 17-diol; and 19-nor-5-androstene-3, 17-diol). Persons
already authorized by the 2001 Regulations (e.g. doctors and pharmacists) or by a written Home
Office authority to produce, supply or possess Schedule 4 (Part II) drugs are authorized in respect
of the four newly added drugs; in other cases an appropriate written Home Office authority is
required. (Note that possession licences are not required if the substances are in medicinal product
form.) The Regulation 15 prescription requirements (including handwriting) do not apply to
Schedule 4 (Part II drugs). Regulations 22, 23 (keeping and preservation of records), 26 (furnishing
of information) and 27 (destruction – holders of written authorities to produce only) also apply to
Schedule 4 Part II drugs. Schedule 4 Part II drugs are not subject to the statutory safe custody
requirements.
∑ the dose
∑ the words ‘for dental treatment only’ if issued by a dentist.
A prescription may order a controlled drug to be dispensed by instalments. If so, the amount of
the instalments and the intervals to be observed must be specified. Prescriptions ordering ‘repeats’
on the same form are not permitted. A prescription is valid for 13 weeks from the date stated
thereon.
It is an offence for a prescriber to issue an incomplete prescription, and a pharmacist is not
allowed to dispense a controlled drug unless all the information required by law is given on the
prescription.
OPIOIDS
Note: Drugs derived from opium poppies are known as opiates. Synthetically derived opiates are
known as opioids.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
The number of addicts notified to the Home Office has increased dramatically over the last 30 years.
This is thought to be related to the wider availability of cheap opiates imported from the Middle
East. Youth culture has become much more accepting of drug use, and poly-drug use is much more
common than it used to be. The approximate numbers of notifications have been:
1960 500
1980 5000
1990 15 000
Most heroin users are aged between 20 and 30 years. The steepest increase has occurred in those
aged 16–24 years. The male:female ratio is 2:1.
DRUG ACTION
The stimulation of opiate receptors produces analgesia, euphoria, miosis, hypotension, bradycardia
and respiratory depression.
Opioid receptors fall into different types, each of which has subtypes. The main types are m, k and
d receptors. The effects of a particular opiate drug depend upon the combination of receptors
stimulated. Most of the effects of morphine are mediated through m receptors.
Euphoria is initially intense and is related in part to the method of administration. Thus methods
delivering a large bolus quickly to the CNS are associated with a greater initial rush. Intravenous and
inhalational techniques fulfil these conditions, oral and subcutaneous methods do not.
Dependence may arise within weeks of regular use.
Opioids 353
HARMFUL EFFECTS
Effects of the drug itself
Overdose can be caused by the uncertain concentration of street drugs, or to reduced tolerance
following a period of abstinence (e.g. upon release from prison). The clinical features of opiate
overdose include stupor or coma, pinpoint pupils, pallor, severe respiratory depression, and
pulmonary oedema. Supportive treatment and administration of an opioid antagonist such as
nalaxone is indicated. The half-life of opioid antagonists is less than that of most opiate drugs, so the
patient must be observed for several hours to ensure that the underlying opiate overdose has passed.
Intoxication
These include accidents.
Inhalation
The inhalation of heroin commonly exacerbates or causes lung conditions such as asthma. There are
increased rates of pneumonia and tuberculosis in those who are HIV-positive.
Intravenous use
The hazards of intravenous use are many, and include the transmission of infection through the use
of shared needles. HIV and hepatitis B, C and D are commonly transmitted through this route.
Those who are HIV-positive have a poorer outcome if they continue to inject.
Bacterial infection
Bacterial infection results from the lack of aseptic technique; the risk is not eliminated by using
clean needles since the drug itself is not of pharmaceutical quality, has often been adulterated with
other substances, and is often not suitable for intravenous administration because of the presence of
non-soluble components.
Skin infection
Skin infection at injection sites leads to abscess formation, and thrombophlebitis. Staphylococcus
aureus and Streptococcus pyogenes are often responsible.
Blood infection
Most injecting results in transient bacteraemia. This can result in septicaemia and/or bacterial
endocarditis, even in those with previously normal heart valves. Septic emboli may be carried to
distant sites. Septic embolism can result in osteomyelitis.
Fungal infection
Systemic fungal infections have been reported which are difficult to treat and result in death or
blindness because of ophthalmic involvement.
354 Psychoactive substance use disorders
Vascular complications
Vascular complications include the obliteration of the lung vascular bed with continued prolonged
injection of particulate matter. The same effect is seen in the lymphatic system, resulting in puffy
hands. Deep vein thrombosis may develop at the site of femoral administration. Arterial
administration can result in occlusion caused by spasm or embolism. The loss of a limb may result.
Social effects
Because of the effects of tolerance and dependence, heroin users usually escalate the dose of drug
taken in an attempt to continue to achieve the euphoriant effects and to keep the unpleasant
withdrawal effects of the drug at bay. The result is often that the addict turns to acquisitive crime in
order to fund the growing drug habit. It is estimated that the stabilization of heroin addicts on to
methadone costs the NHS over £1000 per year per addict, but that this saves society over £30 000 per
addict in drug-related crime. Relationships and family commitments usually come second to drug-
related activities, and family breakdown often results. It is difficult to continue in employment when
seriously addicted to heroin.
Methadone (Physeptone)
Methadone is a synthetic opiate (opioid) which can be taken orally or intravenously. Its half-life is
longer than that of heroin (16–24 hours), allowing once-daily oral prescribing. It has little euphoric
effect when administered orally, but has some street value, particularly in injectable form. It is
frequently prescribed in the management of opiate dependence. In this case the elixir is the
preferred preparation as it is less likely to be abused. Tablet form and sugar-free elixir should not be
used routinely as both are more likely to be injected.
Dipipanone (Diconal)
Diconal consists of a combination of the opiate analgesic dipipanone and cyclizine. Intravenous use
produces intense euphoria, but there is a danger of CVA, arterial spasm and gangrene if injected into
an artery.
Codeine
Misuse of codeine preparations is common. Preparations include DF118 (dihydrocodeine 30 mg)
and codeine linctus (codeine phosphate 15 mg/5 mL).
HARM MINIMIZATION
The aims are to stop or reduce the use of contaminated injecting equipment, to prevent the sharing
of injecting equipment, to stop or reduce drug use, to stop or reduce unsafe sexual practices, to
encourage health consciousness and a more stable lifestyle, and to establish and retain contact with
the drug services.
To achieve these aims, education about the potential hazards is important. Sterile injecting
equipment and condoms should be provided, non-immune individuals should be offered hepatitis
B vaccination, and substitute oral opiates such as methadone should be prescribed.
SUBSTITUTE PRESCRIBING
Non-opiate substitutes
If dependence is not severe, reassurance, support and symptomatic treatment with non-opiate
drugs may suffice. The following may be used:
∑ clonidine – an a-adrenergic antagonist that can give some symptomatic relief in opiate
withdrawal (hypotension can be a problem)
∑ lofexidine – which acts centrally to reduce sympathetic tone (reduction in blood pressure is less
marked than that produced by clonidine)
∑ propranolol – for somatic anxiety
∑ thioridazine – relieves anxiety in low doses
∑ promethazine – a sedative antihistamine effective for mild withdrawal
∑ benzodiazepines – for anxiety (do not give for longer than 2 weeks).
356 Psychoactive substance use disorders
Substitute opioids
Oral methadone mixture 1 mg/mL is the usual choice. Any doctor can prescribe methadone to a
drug misuser. Daily dispensing reduces the risk of overdose and abuse.
∑ For maintenance, a substitute opiate is prescribed indefinitely in an effort to stabilize the addict’s
life, and reduce risks of intravenous use.
∑ For long-term withdrawal, substitute prescribing takes place over a period of months to years
with the long-term aim of opiate abstinence.
∑ For rapid withdrawal, withdrawal takes place over a period of weeks by the use of a substitute
drug in decreasing doses.
∑ For gradual withdrawal, withdrawal takes place over a period of months by the use of a
substitute drug in decreasing doses.
Treatment should be undertaken initially by the general practitioner, possibly with help from the
local community drugs team. If these approaches fail, referral to the more specialized drug
dependency unit may be required.
People who are dependent on more than one drug, those with a history of several failed attempts,
those with coexisting mental or physical disease, those who are violent or highly manipulative, and
those requiring injectable or high doses of substitute drugs should be considered for specialist
referral.
PSYCHOLOGICAL METHODS
Therapeutic outcome is improved if substitute prescribing is combined with various forms of
behaviour therapy.
Motivational interviewing
Confrontational approaches have traditionally been used to deal with issues of denial. However, it
seems that confrontational techniques increase rather than reduce resistance to treatment.
Motivational interviewing is a cognitive–behavioural approach that takes into account the patient’s
stage of preparedness for change, and prompts the patient to consider the favourable reasons to
change.
Relapse prevention
Described by Marlatt, this is a short-term intervention with extensive follow-up and preparation of
the patient to anticipate urges to return to the drug-taking behaviour for a considerable period after
abstinence has been achieved.
People undergoing relapse prevention therapy are more likely to internally attribute change, and
are more likely to remain opiate-free during follow-up, or to contain a temporary relapse. The
internal attribution of control over drug use maximizes treatment effects.
Naltrexone is a long-acting opioid antagonist which precipitates a withdrawal syndrome in the
opiate-dependent person. It is used in the detoxified addict who requires additional help to remain
drug-free. The euphoriant effects of opiates are abolished, thus aiding abstinence. It is particularly
helpful if a partner administers it, and if used in conjunction with cognitive–behavioural therapy.
PROGNOSIS
The mortality rate for intravenous drug abusers is twenty times that of their non-drug-using peers.
Since the 1980s the prevalence of HIV infection among intravenous drug users has increased to
approximately 50–60% in some groups (e.g. New York, Edinburgh), and mortality among this
group has increased further.
Stimulants 357
STIMULANTS
EPIDEMIOLOGY
There has been an epidemic of cocaine use in the USA. It remains relatively expensive in the UK,
although its use is increasing. Amphetamines tend to be the preferred stimulant of abuse in the UK.
Fewer than 10% of cocaine addicts are notified to the Home Office.
DRUG ACTION
Cocaine blocks dopamine uptake at the dopamine re-uptake site. Extracellular levels of dopamine
are markedly increased. Dopaminergic activity, particularly at the nucleus accumbens, has been
found to have a major role in the pleasurable and reinforcing effects of cocaine, amphetamine,
phencyclidine, nicotine and alcohol. Genetic polymorphisms at the dopamine re-uptake site may
contribute to an individual’s liability to become dependent.
Acute effects last about 20 minutes and include euphoria, reduced hunger, tirelessness, agitation,
tachycardia, raised blood pressure, sweating, nausea, vomiting, dilated pupils, and impairment of
judgement and social functioning. High doses may lead to an acute toxic psychosis with marked
agitation, paranoia and auditory, visual and tactile hallucinations (cocaine bug).
Chronic use leads to tolerance, withdrawal symptoms and a chronically anxious state, possibly
caused by dopamine depletion.
DRUG WITHDRAWAL
Following the initial rush of wellbeing and confidence, when the effects of the drug wear off there
follows a rebound crash. This consists of dysphoria, anxiety, irritability, depression, fatigue and
intense craving for the drug. The crash phase lasts nine hours to four days. The withdrawal phase of
1–10 weeks is the period of the greatest risk of relapse. The final phase is of unlimited duration,
when stimuli can trigger craving.
HARMFUL EFFECTS
At high doses, convulsions, hyperthermia, coma and death may occur. Excessive use can also lead to
hypertension with cardiac failure, myocardial infarction, subarachnoid haemorrhage and
cerebrovascular accidents.
Perforation of the nasal septum can follow long-term administration by the nasal route because
of the vasoconstriction caused by cocaine. Intravenous use carries with it the risks described above.
358 Psychoactive substance use disorders
Cocaine abusers often take sedatives, including heroin, alcohol and benzodiazepines. As well as
taking the edge off the high produced by cocaine, some of the metabolites of the cocaine–alcohol
interaction have been found to have a much longer half-life than cocaine alone. It is possible that
this prolongation of the effects of cocaine contributes to its use with alcohol.
Long-term stimulant abuse results in a stereotyped compulsive repetitive pattern of behaviour
and paranoid psychosis resembling schizophrenia.
Caffeine
Caffeine is widely available in coffee, tea and chocolate, and is added to soft drinks and proprietary
cold preparations.
Coffee contains about 80–150 mg of caffeine per cup depending upon the brewing method. Peak
blood levels occur 15–45 minutes following oral administration; the half-life is 6 hours. Metabolism
is increased by smoking, and reduced by oral contraceptives and pregnancy. Neonates cannot
metabolize caffeine, therefore there is a very long half-life.
DRUG EFFECTS
A dose of 80–200 mg produces mood elevation, increased alertness and clarity of thought, increased
gastric secretion, tachycardia, raised blood pressure, diuresis, and increased productivity.
In overdose (greater than 250 mg per day) caffeinism occurs. This results in anxiety, restlessness
and nausea, and facial flushing.
At levels of intake in excess of 600 mg per day, dysphoria replaces euphoria, anxiety and mood
disturbances become prominent, and insomnia, muscle-twitching, tachycardia and sometimes
cardiac arrhythmias occur.
DRUG WITHDRAWAL
At high daily doses a withdrawal syndrome occurs with abstinence. This comprises restlessness,
irritability, dizziness, severe headache, rhinorrhoea, depression and poor work performance.
Desipramine has been found to reduce the intensity of cocaine craving irrespective of other
psychopathology. Most patients can be managed as outpatients, but some become acutely suicidal
and need observation.
Psychological support is helpful, and relapse prevention techniques incorporated into treatment
packages increase the chances of success.
SEDATIVES
Central nervous system sedatives depress CNS activity with little analgesic effect. They include
alcohol (see above), barbiturates, benzodiazepines and carbamates. All the CNS depressants have
abuse potential and cause both psychological and physical dependence. Cross-tolerance between
groups occurs, and the withdrawal syndromes are similar. When taken repeatedly in high doses all
these drugs produce sadness/depression, a worsening of confusional states, and withdrawal
syndromes in which anxiety is prominent.
Benzodiazepines
Widely prescribed, these have widespread physical dependence among licit users, and are very
popular with illicit substance abusers.
The most common route of administration is oral, but some abusers attempt to inject the
contents of capsules or ground tablets intravenously.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Over one million of the UK population use benzodiazepines continuously for more than one year.
DRUG ACTION
This group of sedatives potentiates the inhibitory actions of the GABA-A receptor in the limbic
areas of the brain. They have anxiolytic, hypnotic and anticonvulsant properties at normal doses.
The clinical signs of intoxication include slurred speech, uncoordination, unsteady gait, impaired
attention or memory, psychological effects such as paradoxical aggression and disinhibition, lability
of mood, impaired judgement and impaired social or occupational functioning.
DRUG WITHDRAWAL
Tolerance occurs rapidly. There is rebound anxiety after 4 weeks of use; dependence is seen in 45%
of users after 3 months.
The onset and intensity of withdrawal symptoms are related in part to the half-life of the drug
used (shorter half-lives lead to a more abrupt and intense withdrawal syndrome). The withdrawal
syndrome is also related to the dose used. Onset is usually within 1–14 days after drug
reduction/cessation, and may last for months.
Withdrawal symptoms include somatic effects such as autonomic hyperactivity (tachycardia,
sweating, anorexia, weight loss, pyrexia, tremor of hands, tongue and eyelids, GI disturbance, sleep
disturbance with vivid dreams due to REM rebound), malaise and weakness, tinnitus and grand mal
convulsions.
360 Psychoactive substance use disorders
There are cognitive effects with impaired memory and concentration. There are also perceptual
effects with hypersensitivity to sound, light and touch, depersonalization and derealization.
Delirium may develop within a week of cessation, associated with visual, auditory and tactile
hallucinations, and delusions.
Affective effects such as irritability, anxiety and phobic symptoms may also occur.
HARMFUL EFFECTS
In a high-dose abuser, severe withdrawal symptoms occur if the person is unable to acquire the
usual dose of drug. As in these doses the drugs have usually been acquired illicitly, supply cannot be
guaranteed.
Benzodiazepines are relatively safe in overdose, but are liable to produce respiratory depression,
and in combination with other drugs they can be lethal.
The injection of street benzodiazepines incurs all the dangers of injecting described above, but is
particularly liable to cause limb ischaemia and gangrene, with resulting amputation.
MANAGEMENT
Withdrawal from sedative drugs is potentially lethal and should usually be managed on a medical
ward.
Barbiturates
Although the prescribing of barbiturates has largely been superseded by the safer benzodiazepines,
they still appear in the form of phenobarbitone, amylobarbitone and quinalbarbitone (Tuinal) and
are widely available.
DRUG ACTION
Barbiturates potentiate action at the GABA-A receptor thus increasing CNS depression. This is
particularly marked in the reticular activating system and cerebral cortex.
Clinical effects include impaired concentration, reduced anxiety and dysphoria. In increasing
doses dysarthria, ataxia, drowsiness, coma, respiratory depression and death occur.
Chronic use results in tolerance caused by hepatic enzyme induction, cross-tolerance with
alcohol, personality change, persistent intoxication, labile affect, poor concentration, impaired
judgement and incoordination.
DRUG WITHDRAWAL
This causes anxiety, tremor, sweating, insomnia with marked REM rebound, irritability, agitation,
twitching, vomiting, nausea, tachycardia, orthostatic hypotension, delirium and convulsions.
HARMFUL EFFECTS
Barbiturates are dangerous in overdose. Their therapeutic index is low. Tolerance to psychotropic
effects exceeds tolerance to respiratory depression.
Parenteral administration of oral preparations is attempted by some addicts, incurring all the
risks described.
Hallucinogens 361
MANAGEMENT
A gradual tapering of the dose is considered to be the most appropriate way to manage barbiturate
dependence. Short-acting compounds should first be substituted by long-acting compounds,
diazepam being the most commonly used form for the purposes of withdrawal. After stabilizing on
diazepam, dose reduction is commenced. At high doses this can occur quite rapidly (e.g. at 5 mg per
week) until the patient starts to complain of unpleasant effects, when the rate of reduction can be
reduced. If symptoms of depression are present an antidepressant is indicated. Propranolol may
help with some of the somatic symptoms of anxiety.
Psychological support is very important, with weekly contact initially. The family should be
involved in the process.
The withdrawal of barbiturates similarly needs phased withdrawal; inpatient admission is often
necessary.
HALLUCINOGENS
Hallucinogens are substances that give rise to marked perceptual disturbances when taken in
relatively small quantities.
DRUG ACTION
The substance acts at multiple sites in the central nervous system, the effects being thought to be
related to 5-HT antagonism. The effects are dose-related.
Psychic effects include the heightening of perceptions, with perceptual distortion of shape,
intensification of colour and sound, apparent movement of stationary objects, and changes in sense
of time and place. Hallucinations may occur, but are relatively rare. The user usually retains insight
into the nature of the experiences. Delusions (e.g. belief in the ability to fly) may occur. Emotional
lability, heightened self-awareness and ecstatic experiences can occur. Synaesthesias in which a
stimulus in one sensory modality is experienced in another modality (e.g. hearing colours) are
common.
The physical effects are sympathomimetic, with tachycardia, hypertension and dilated pupils.
Unpleasant experiences may occur (bad trips), and these are more likely in the inexperienced, or
if the ambient mood is disturbed. Users generally avoid being alone, in case of bad trips or
dangerous behaviour while under the influence. The features of adverse experiences include anxiety,
depression, dizziness and disorientation, and a short-lived psychotic episode characterized by
hallucinations and paranoid delusions. With heavy use, an acute schizophreniform psychosis may
persist.
Flashback phenomena (post-hallucinogen perception disorder) occur, in which aspects of the
LSD experience occur spontaneously some time after LSD use. These are usually fleeting.
362 Psychoactive substance use disorders
DRUG WITHDRAWAL
Physical withdrawal symptoms do not occur following the abrupt discontinuation of LSD or other
hallucinogens.
HARMFUL EFFECTS
Accidents may occur while under the influence of hallucinogens, such as jumping from a height
because of the delusional belief that the user can fly.
Flashback phenomena occur many months after drug elimination, giving rise to the possibility
that these substances may cause permanent neurological changes.
Mescaline
Mescaline is the active component of the Mexican peyote cactus. Mescaline is similar to
noradrenaline. It is hallucinogenic, and is orally administered.
LSD is 200 times as potent as psilocybin, which is 30 times as potent as mescaline.
DRUG ACTION
MDMA produces a positive mood, with feelings of euphoria, intimacy and closeness to others. The
stimulant effects resemble those of amphetamine, and hallucinogenic effects resemble those of LSD.
The physical effects include anorexia, tachycardia, jaw-tightening and bruxism, and sweating.
HARMFUL EFFECTS
Deaths have occurred in those with pre-existing cardiac disease caused by cardiac arrhythmias. In
the fit user at normal doses deaths have occurred as a result of hyperpyrexia, resulting in
disseminated intravascular coagulation, rhabdomyolysis, and renal failure.
Convulsions can also occur. Most deaths of this nature occur when the user has been dancing
vigorously for a considerable period, in high ambient temperatures, with inadequate fluid
replacement. MDMA has a direct effect upon the thermoregulatory mechanisms which compound
these conditions.
Hypertensive crises may occur leading to CVA in some.
Toxic hepatitis has been reported in MDMA users possibly related to impurities in the
preparation.
Psychiatric conditions (psychosis, depression, anxiety) in previously vulnerable individuals can
occur following MDMA use.
Neurotoxicity is an established fact. Serotonergic nerve terminals are damaged by this drug, and
although rat studies indicate that this is reversible, primate studies indicate the opposite. The long-
term consequences of MDMA-induced serotonergic neurotoxicity in humans are not known.
MANAGEMENT
Abrupt discontinuation is recommended, there being no advantage to gradual withdrawal.
Psychiatric disturbance should be treated accordingly.
DRUG ACTION
Tetrahydrocannabinol has anticholinergic effects, and its action is particularly marked in the
hippocampus. It thus has adverse effects on memory, cognition and other higher mental functions.
The psychological effects include euphoria, relaxation, suspiciousness, a feeling that time has slowed
down, impaired judgement, heightened sensory awareness and social withdrawal. Hunger and
anxiety may occur. Physical effects include tachycardia, raised blood pressure, dry mouth, thirst,
constipation, reduced intraocular pressure, ataxia and, rarely, photophobia and nystagmus. In high-
dosage perceptual distortions, confusion, drowsiness, bradycardia, hypotension, hypothermia,
bronchodilatation and peripheral vasoconstriction can occur. An acute toxic psychosis which
resolves with abstinence may occur.
364 Psychoactive substance use disorders
DRUG WITHDRAWAL
In chronic users, cessation of cannabis is often followed by a withdrawal syndrome consisting of
irritability, restlessness, anorexia, nausea and insomnia. Craving and psychological dependence do
not occur.
HARMFUL EFFECTS
Chronic cannabis use can lead to a deterioration in personality. An increase in aggressiveness may
also occur. Flashbacks, and prolonged depersonalization and derealization, may occur.
Cognitive and psychomotor impairment resulting from even small amounts of cannabis make
the performance of skilled tasks (such as driving) hazardous.
VOLATILE SOLVENTS
Volatile substances are inhaled (glue-sniffing) in order to experience their psychoactive effects.
Solvents from glue (such as toluene), correction fluids (for example, trichloroethane), butane gas
and other aerosol propellants are popular.
Solvents have been tried by 3–5% of 15-year-olds. Often fumes are rebreathed from a plastic bag,
but sometimes an aerosol is sprayed directly into the oropharynx (this is particularly dangerous).
Rapidly absorbed, its effects last about 30 minutes.
DRUG ACTION
The clinical effects include euphoria, disinhibition, dizziness, perceptual distortions and frank
hallucinations, tinnitus, ataxia, confusion, slurred speech, nystagmus, decreased reflexes, tremor and
muscle weakness. High doses cause stupor and death. Aspiration of vomit can occur at any time.
DRUG WITHDRAWAL
There is no physical withdrawal syndrome.
HARMFUL EFFECTS
Acute intoxication can lead to fatal accidents, particularly through falling or drowning. However,
the greatest risk of death is during an episode of sniffing. Butane squirted directly into the mouth
can cause cardiac arrest. Propellants squirted directly into the mouth are cooled to -20°C, which can
cause burns to the throat and lungs, and may freeze the larynx, causing cardiac arrest through vagal
nerve stimulation. Rebreathing from plastic bags can result in asphyxiation.
There are approximately 100 deaths per annum in the UK, with 20% of these occurring in first-
time users, and the majority in those aged under 20 years.
There are reports of long-term damage to the CNS, heart, liver and kidneys. Chronic use may
cause a persistent cerebellar syndrome, and peripheral neuropathy.
MANAGEMENT
Abrupt discontinuation is recommended. Advice from social services and/or a child psychiatrist
may be needed.
Bibliography 365
Drug abuse in pregnancy often results in poor antenatal care and the risk of infection. Women at
this time may have an increased motivation to change their behaviour, and it is important to take
this opportunity to engage them in services. Education and harm minimization should be
attempted.
ANTENATAL CARE
Drug misusers are at a high risk of obstetric complications. There is a high incidence of intrauterine
growth retardation and premature labour. HIV-positive women need counselling about risks to
themselves and their fetus.
Drug withdrawal is best attempted gradually during the second trimester of pregnancy. If this is
not possible then attempts should be made to ensure that the practice is as safe as possible (e.g.
changing to non-injecting modes of administration). Sudden withdrawal should be avoided
because of the risk of intrauterine death. Abstinence 4–6 weeks before birth minimizes the risks of
neonatal withdrawal symptoms.
If the mother is HIV-positive or receiving high doses of opioids, breast-feeding should be
avoided.
POSTNATAL CARE
Following the birth, an assessment should be made of the amount of social support the mother is
likely to need. Continuing support after delivery is essential.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
SCHIZOPHRENIA
HISTORY
∑ In 1860, Morel used the term démence précoce for a disorder of deteriorating adolescent psychosis.
∑ In 1863, Kahlbaum described katatonie.
∑ In 1871, Hecker described hebephrenie.
∑ In 1894, Sommer included deteriorating paranoid syndromes in the concept of primary
dementia.
∑ In 1868, Griesinger believed that insanity could develop in the absence of mood disturbance,
primary insanity (primäre Verücktheit), and that all functional psychoses were expressions of
single disease entity (Einheitspsychoses).
∑ In 1896, Emil Kraepelin grouped together catatonia, hebephrenia and the deteriorating
paranoid psychoses under the name dementia praecox. He differentiated dementia praecox with
its poor prognosis from the manic depressive psychoses with their relatively better prognoses.
He considered dementia praecox to be a disease of the brain.
∑ In 1911, Bleuler introduced the term schizophrenia, applied it to Kraepelin’s cases of dementia
praecox, and expanded the concept to include what today may be considered schizophrenic
spectrum disorders. He considered symptoms of ambivalence, autism, affective incongruity and
disturbance of association of thought to be fundamental (the ‘four As’), with delusions and
hallucinations assuming secondary status. Bleuler was influenced by the writings of Sigmund
Freud. He added schizophrenia simplex to Kraepelin’s list.
∑ In 1931, Hughlings-Jackson considered positive symptoms as ‘release phenomena’ occurring in
healthy tissue; negative symptoms were attributed to neuronal loss.
∑ In 1959, Kurt Schneider emphasized the importance of delusions and hallucinations in defining
his first-rank symptoms.
∑ In 1960, Langfeldt sought to distinguish between schizophrenia and the better-prognosis
schizophreniform psychoses; process versus non-process schizophrenia.
∑ In 1972, Cooper compared patients admitted to psychiatric hospitals in New York and London.
He found identical symptomatology, but schizophrenia diagnosed nearly twice as often in New
York compared to London.
368 Schizophrenia and delusional (paranoid) disorders
∑ In 1973, the WHO conducted the International Pilot Study of Schizophrenia. This study found,
using narrow criteria, a one-year incidence of schizophrenia of 0.7–1.4 per 10 000 population
aged 15–54, across all countries. It was confirmed that psychiatrists in the USA and the former
USSR diagnosed schizophrenia twice as often as those in seven other countries (Columbia,
Czechoslovakia, Denmark, Nigeria, India, Taiwan and the UK). This led to a realization that
psychiatric diagnoses had to be defined operationally.
CLASSIFICATION OF SCHIZOPHRENIA
(i) a significant and consistent change in the overall quality of some aspects of personal behaviour
(e.g. loss of interest, aimlessness, idleness, self-absorbed attitude, social withdrawal).
Diagnostic guidelines require a minimum of one clear symptom (two if less clear-cut) belonging
to groups (a) to (d), or symptoms from at least two of the groups (e) to (h) should have been present
for most of the time during a period of one month or more.
Symptom (i) applies only to a diagnosis of simple schizophrenia, and a duration of at least one
year is required.
Schizophrenia is not diagnosed if extensive affective symptoms are present, unless they postdate
the schizophrenic syndrome. If both schizophrenic and affective symptoms develop together and
are evenly balanced, the diagnosis of schizoaffective disorder is made.
Schizophrenia is not diagnosed in the presence of overt brain disease, or during drug
intoxication or withdrawal.
The pattern of course is classified as: (i) continuous; (ii) episodic, progressive deficit; (iii)
episodic, stable deficit; (iv) episodic, remittent; (v) incomplete remission; (vi) complete remission.
Subtypes
In ICD-10 the following subtypes of schizophrenia are distinguished:
∑ Paranoid schizophrenia. This is the commonest subtype. Hallucinations and/or delusions are
prominent. Disturbances of affect, volition, speech and catatonic symptoms are relatively
inconspicuous. Auditory, olfactory, gustatory and somatic hallucinations, and visual
hallucinations may occur. Commonly there are delusions of control, influence, passivity and
persecution.
∑ Hebephrenic schizophrenia. The age of onset is usually between 15 and 25 years. There is a poor
prognosis. Affective changes are prominent. Fleeting and fragmentary delusions and
hallucinations, irresponsible behaviour, fatuous, disorganized thought, rambling speech, and
mannerisms are common. Negative symptoms, particularly flattening of affect and loss of
volition, are prominent. Drive and determination are lost, goals abandoned, behaviour becomes
aimless and empty. The premorbid personality is characteristically shy and solitary.
∑ Catatonic schizophrenia. One or more of the following behaviours dominate: stupor, excitement,
posturing, negativism, rigidity, waxy flexibility, command automatism and perseveration of
words or phrases. Catatonic symptoms alone are not diagnostic of schizophrenia; they may be
provoked by brain disease, metabolic disturbance, alcohol and drugs and mood disorders.
Psychomotor disturbances may alternate between extremes; violent excitement may occur. It
may be combined with a dream-like state with vivid scenic hallucinations.
∑ Simple schizophrenia. There is an insidious onset of decline in functioning. Negative symptoms
develop without preceding positive symptoms. Diagnosis requires changes in behaviour over at
least a year, with marked loss of interest, idleness and social withdrawal.
∑ Residual or chronic schizophrenia. This is characterized by negative symptoms. There is past
evidence of at least one schizophrenic episode, and a period of at least one year in which
frequency of positive symptoms has been minimal and negative schizophrenic syndrome has
been present. There is absence of depression, institutionalization, or dementia or other brain
disorder.
∑ Undifferentiated schizophrenia. General criteria for schizophrenia are satisfied, but not
conforming to the above syndromes.
∑ Post-schizophrenic depression. This is a depressive episode arising after a schizophrenic illness.
Schizophrenic illness must have occurred within the last 12 months, some symptoms still being
present. Depressive symptoms fulfil at least the criteria for a depressive episode, and are present
for at least 2 weeks. There is an increased risk of suicide.
Classification of schizophrenia 371
Disorganization syndrome
There is hypoperfusion of the right ventral prefrontal cortex, and increased activity in anterior
cingulate and dorsomedial thalamic nuclei which project to the prefrontal cortex. There is relative
hypoperfusion of Broca’s area and bilateral hypoperfusion of parietal association cortex. Evidence
suggests that in primates the ventral prefrontal cortex plays a role in suppression of interference
from irrelevant mental activity. The anterior cingulate plays a role in attentional mechanisms. The
suggestion is that these patients are engaged in an ineffective struggle to suppress inappropriate
mental activity.
EPIDEMIOLOGY OF SCHIZOPHRENIA
STATISTICS
∑ The incidence of schizophrenia is between 15 and 30 new cases per 100 000 of the population
per year.
∑ The point prevalence is approximately 1%.
∑ The lifetime risk is approximately 1%.
∑ The age of onset is usually between 15 and 45 years, earlier in men than in women.
∑ It is equally common in males and females. There is a higher incidence in those not married.
∑ It is most common in social classes IV and V.
∑ Prevalence varies geographically. Rates from urban areas are generally higher than in rural areas,
with marked exceptions – the highest prevalence measured (17.4 per 1000 population) was from
a sparsely populated rural area in the west of Ireland.
THEORIES
The following are theories accounting for geographical variance in the prevalence of schizophrenia:
∑ Social drift. Goldberg and Morrison (1963) studied fathers’ birth certificates, and found
schizophrenic males had lower social class distribution than their fathers. They attributed these
findings to social drift; i.e. migration of those affected to areas where social demands may be
less. Men were more likely to drift into inner city areas.
∑ Social residue. Healthy people migrate away from undesirable areas, leaving schizophrenics
behind.
Aetiology of schizophrenia 373
∑ ‘Breeder’ or social causation. This theory assumes that environmental factors are either causative
or have to be present for the predisposed individual to develop schizophrenia. Castle et al.
(1993) found that schizophrenic patients in Camberwell were more likely to have been born in a
socially deprived area and to have fathers with manual jobs. Those developing schizophrenia
were more likely than controls to have been born into socially deprived households. This
suggested that some environmental factor of aetiological importance in schizophrenia is more
likely to affect those born into households of lower socioeconomic status and in the inner city.
Theories emphasizing environmental influences need not exclude the importance of biological
factors, such as exposure to toxins, increased incidence of obstetric complications and a higher rate
of infectious disease in cities. Social factors more common in cities include stressful life-events,
social isolation and social over-stimulation.
AETIOLOGY OF SCHIZOPHRENIA
Genetics in schizophrenia
Twin, family and adoption studies have consistently demonstrated familial aggregation of
schizophrenia, largely attributable to genetic factors.
Family studies
Table 27.2 shows the approximate lifetime risks for the development of schizophrenia in the
relatives of patients with schizophrenia.
Table 27.2 Approximate lifetime risks for the development of schizophrenia in the
relatives of patients with schizophrenia
Twin studies
The concordance rate for monozygotic (MZ) twins is approximately 45%, that for dizygotic (DZ)
twins approximately 10% (Gottesman & Shields, 1972).
Studying adult offspring of 21 MZ and 41 DZ twin pairs discordant for schizophrenia,
Gottesman and Bertelsen found the risk of developing schizophrenia was 17% among the adult
children of the MZ and DZ probands, 17% among the offspring of phenotypically normal MZ co-
twins, and only 2% among the offspring of phenotypically normal DZ co-twins. This suggests that
the normal MZ co-twins carried and transmitted the relevant genotype without expressing it
themselves.
374 Schizophrenia and delusional (paranoid) disorders
Adoption studies
When children of schizophrenic mothers have been adopted soon after birth by non-schizophrenic
families, they have a similar likelihood of developing schizophrenia (approximately 13%) as the rates
suggested by family studies. There appears to be no such increased risk of developing schizophrenia
in the children of non-schizophrenic parents who are similarly adopted (Kety et al., 1971).
The following are possible modes of inheritance:
∑ Single major locus. Some forms possibly exist but would account for a very small proportion of
observed cases. To date no single genetic focus responsible for the development of schizophrenia
has been reliably demonstrated.
∑ Polygenic. There might be a threshold of gene numbers required for expression of schizophrenia.
∑ Multifactorial. There may be aetiological heterogeneity with various genetic and environmental
subtypes. There is probably a spectrum of causes ranging from wholly genetic, through those
with mixed aetiology, to the totally environmental.
Linkage studies
Bassett and associates reported a man who presented with schizophrenia plus minor physical
abnormalities both shared by his maternal uncle. Cytogenetic analysis revealed translocation of part
of chromosome 5; this led the writers to postulate that this segment of chromosome 5 may be site
of a putative schizophrenia gene.
Sherrington and associates collected seven extended schizophrenic families from Iceland and
England, probed chromosome 5 and found evidence highly suggestive of linkage between markers
on chromosome 5 and schizophrenia. However, this finding has never been replicated and the study
has subsequently been criticized on methodological grounds.
There are problems in applying linkage methodology to schizophrenia:
∑ Schizophrenia is probably genetically heterogeneous.
∑ Linkage analysis is usually applied to conditions transmitted by simpler Mendelian inheritance.
∑ Diagnostic and penetrance problems probably require a much higher lod score than the usual
+3 before linkage for psychiatric diagnoses can be regarded as proved.
Personality in schizophrenia
Only schizotypal personality disorder is aetiologically related to schizophrenia. Among the
schizotypal criteria, eccentricity, affect constriction and excessive social anxiety are linked to
schizophrenia. There may be a milder phenotype along the schizophrenia spectrum.
Table 27.3 Relapse rates of 128 schizophrenics over a 9-month period (Vaughn & Leff, 1976)
TOTAL GROUP
Low expressed emotion High expressed emotion
n = 71 (13%) n = 57 (51%)
There was a poverty of the social milieu of patients with chronic schizophrenia, associated with
increased negative symptoms, particularly social withdrawal, affective blunting and poverty of
speech (Wing & Brown, 1961).
Neurotransmitters in schizophrenia
DOPAMINE
The mesolimbic–mesocortical system is a dopaminergic system originating in the ventral tegmental
area of the brain. The mesolimbic system projects to the limbic system, while the mesocortical
system innervates the cingulate, entorhinal and medial prefrontal cortices.
The dopamine hypothesis of schizophrenia asserts that the clinical features are the result of central
dopaminergic hyperactivity in the mesolimbic–mesocortical system. The following is put as
evidence in favour of the dopamine hypothesis:
∑ All clinically effective antipsychotic drugs occupy a substantial proportion of D2 receptors in the
brain (70–80% D2 receptor occupancy in the striatum at normal doses).
∑ Amphetamine, a dopamine agonist, can cause a state similar to that of acute schizophrenia.
∑ Dopamine agonists exacerbate psychotic symptoms.
∑ Comparing actions of a and b isomers of flupenthixol in patients with acute schizophrenia, only
those receiving the dopamine antagonist improved (Johnstone et al., 1978).
∑ Postmortem studies have found increased D2 receptors in the basal ganglia and limbic regions of
schizophrenic brains.
∑ In animals, administration of dopamine agonists produces a behavioural picture said to be
similar to human psychosis. This is reversed by giving dopamine antagonists.
∑ In drug-naive schizophrenics, the number of D2 receptors in the striatum was 2–3 times that of
controls as measured by PET (Wong et al., 1986).
Evidence against the dopamine hypothesis includes:
∑ The concentration of dopamine metabolite HVA (homovanillic acid) in the cerebrospinal fluid
in schizophrenics has generally not been found to be higher than in control subjects.
∑ D2 receptor blockade caused by antipsychotics is an acute effect, but the therapeutic effect is
observed 3–4 weeks later.
∑ 15–30% of schizophrenics fail to respond to dopamine antagonists.
∑ Antipsychotics have a better effect on positive than on negative symptoms.
∑ Clozapine, an effective antipsychotic, has less D2 blocking activity than conventional
antipsychotics.
∑ Some studies have failed to replicate Wongs’ findings of increased D2 receptors in striatum of
brains of living schizophrenics.
∑ Clozapine acts in part by antagonism of D1, D2, and particularly D4 receptors; it is effective
during long-term use in up to 60% of neuroleptic-resistant patients.
∑ D1 antagonist alone failed to show antipsychotic efficacy. Specific D3 and D4 antagonists have
not yet been studied.
∑ During treatment with haloperidol, the ratio of dopamine metabolite (HVA) to serotonin and
noradrenaline metabolites in CSF of schizophrenics increased significantly and correlated with
reduction of symptoms. This supports the hypothesis that interactions between different
monoamine neurotransmitters are involved in expression of schizophrenic symptoms.
SEROTONIN (5-HT)
There is some evidence that serotonergic dysfunction may be associated with schizophrenia:
∑ The hallucinogen LSD (see Chapter 26) acts at serotonin receptors.
∑ Antipsychotic risperidone is a potent 5-HT2 receptor antagonist (it also blocks D2 receptors,
however).
∑ Ritanserin, a selective 5-HT2 antagonist, reduced negative symptoms when given as adjunctive
therapy in neuroleptic-treated schizophrenics.
GLUTAMATE
Glutamate stimulates the NMDA receptor. Phencyclidine (‘angel dust’ – see Chapter 26) causes
schizophrenic-like effects by blocking NMDA receptors. A balance exists between excitatory
glutamatergic and inhibitory dopaminergic terminals in the corpus striatum, regulating GABAergic
neurones. These function in the ‘thalamic filter’ which seems to be hypoactive in schizophrenia.
According to this theory, hypoactivity of GABA neurones is corrected by either reducing
dopaminergic activity, or increasing glutamatergic activity.
Histological studies
Compared to controls, the brains of schizophrenics have shown in some studies:
∑ hippocampal pyramidal cell disarray
∑ reduced hippocampal cell numbers
∑ reduced cell numbers in the entorhinal cortex
∑ reduced hippocampal cell size
∑ disturbed cytoarchitecture in the entorhinal cortex.
MANAGEMENT OF SCHIZOPHRENIA
Hospitalization
Those with acute schizophrenia often require admission to hospital, if necessarily compulsorily, for
assessment, investigations and treatment. Before discharge, Section 117 of the Mental Health Act
1983 for detained patients, and the care-programme approach for all patients, requires that an
‘assessment of needs’ be made. A key worker should be assigned to monitor a patient’s progress and
to administer depot medication.
Attendance at a day hospital or centre may be considered, and there should be appropriate
communication with the patient’s general practitioner.
Electroconvulsive therapy is used in the treatment of catatonic stupor.
See Appendix 1 for a summary of the National Institute of Clinical Excellence (NICE) guidelines
on core interventions in the treatment and management of schizophrenia in primary and secondary
care.
Expressed emotion
Psychoeducational family programmes to increase medication compliance and coping with
stressors are successful in reducing the risk of relapse. Families with high expressed emotion (EE)
were identified using the Camberwell Family Interview. Education and family sessions in the home
run in parallel with a relatives group. The programme is aimed at teaching problem-solving skills,
lowering criticism and over-involvement, and reducing contact between patients and relatives
whilst expanding social networks.
Suicide
Ten per cent of schizophrenics commit suicide, and for most sufferers it happens early in their
illness. Roy (1982) reported that suicide was more likely in the following cases:
∑ being male
∑ being young
∑ being unemployed
∑ having chronic illness, relapses and remissions
Delusional (paranoid) disorders 381
ICD-10 issues
According to ICD-10, a delusional disorder is an ill-defined condition, manifesting as a single
delusion or a set of related delusions, being persistent, sometimes lifelong, and not having an
identifiable organic basis. There are occasional or transitory auditory hallucinations, particularly in
the elderly.
Delusions are the most conspicuous or only symptom and are present for at least 3 months. For
the diagnosis there must be no evidence of schizophrenic symptoms or brain disease.
ICD-10 includes the previously used term late paraphrenia, although there is some evidence that
there are differences between persistent delusional disorder and late paraphrenia. Howard et al.
(1994) showed, using MRI scans in a group of late-onset schizophrenics and late-onset delusional
disorders, that lateral ventricle volumes in the delusional disorder patients were much greater than
those of schizophrenics, and almost twice those of controls.
Monodelusional disorders feature a stable, encapsulated delusional system, which takes over
much of a person’s life. The personality is preserved.
examined for semen stains, belongings may be searched and the partner may be interrogated and
followed. It is more common in men.
Pathological jealousy may be associated with the following conditions:
∑ organic disorders and psychoactive substance use disorders (e.g. alcohol dependence, cerebral
tumour, endocrinopathy, dementia, cerebral infection, use of amphetamines or cocaine)
∑ paranoid schizophrenia
∑ depression
∑ neurosis or personality disorder.
Treatment should be directed at the underlying disorder. If no primary cause is identified,
pharmacotherapy with a neuroleptic and/or psychotherapy may be helpful. There may be a risk of
violence to the partner and it may be best to recommend that the couple separate.
COTARD’S SYNDROME
This condition, also called délire de négation, is a nihilistic delusional disorder in which the patient
believes that, for example, all his or her wealth has gone or that relatives or friends do not exist. It
may take a somatic form with the patient believing that parts of his or her body do not exist. It can
be secondary to very severe depression or to an organic disorder.
CAPGRAS SYNDROME
Although Capgras syndrome is also called illusion des sosies, or illusion of doubles, it is not an
illusion but a delusional disorder. The essential feature of this rare condition is that a person who is
familiar to the patient is believed to have been replaced by a double. It is more common in females.
Common primary causes are schizophrenia, mood disorder and organic disorder. Derealization
often occurs.
FREGOLI SYNDROME
In this very rare delusional disorder the patient believes that a familiar person, who is often believed
to be the patient’s persecutor, has taken on different appearances. Primary causes include
schizophrenia and organic disorder.
SCHIZOAFFECTIVE DISORDERS
Types of disorder
The term ‘schizoaffective psychosis’ was introduced by Kasanin in 1933 to describe a condition with
both affective and schizophrenic symptoms, with sudden acute onset after good premorbid
functioning, and usually with complete recovery.
ICD-10 describes these as disorders in which both affective and schizophrenic symptoms are
prominent within the same episode of illness, either simultaneously or within a few days of each
other. It distinguishes various types:
∑ manic type – the person usually makes a full recovery
∑ depressive type – prognosis not as good as that of the manic subtype, with a greater chance of
developing ‘negative’ symptoms
∑ mixed type.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Andreasen, N.C. 1983: Scale for the Assessment of Negative Symptoms (SANS). Iowa City: University of Iowa.
Andreasen, N.C. 1984: Scale for the Assessment of Positive Symptoms (SAPS). Iowa City: University of Iowa.
Andreasen, N.C., Swayze, V.W., Flaum, M. et al. 1990: Ventricular enlargement in schizophrenia evaluated with
computed tomographic scanning. Archives of General Psychiatry 47:1008–1015.
Bassett, A., McGillivray, B., Jones, B. & Pantzar, J. 1985: Partial trisomy chromosome 5 cosegregating with
schizophrenia. Lancet i:1023–1026.
Bracha, H.S., Torrey, E.F., Bigelow, L.B. et al. 1991: Subtle signs of prenatal maldevelopment of the hand ectoderm
in schizophrenia: a preliminary monozygotic twin study. Biological Psychiatry 30:719–725.
Brown, G.W. & Birley, J.L.T. 1968: Crises and life changes and the onset of schizophrenia. Journal of Health and
Social Behaviour 9:203.
Castle, D.J., Scott, K., Wessely, S. & Murray, R.M. 1993: Does social deprivation during gestation and early life
predispose to later schizophrenia? Social Psychiatry and Psychiatric Epidemiology 28:1–4.
Chua, S.E. & McKenna, P.J. 1995: Schizophrenia – a brain disease? A critical review of structural and functional
cerebral abnormality in the disorder. British Journal of Psychiatry 166:563–582.
DeLisi, L.E., Henn, S., Bass, N. et al. 1994: Depression in schizophrenia: is the Kraepelinian binary system dead?
Proceedings of the 9th World Congress of Psychiatry 1993. Macclesfield: Gardiner–Caldwell Communications.
Duinkerke, S.J., Botter, P.A., Jansen, A.I.I. et al. 1993: Ritanserin, a selective 5-HT2/1c antagonist, and negative
symptoms in schizophrenia: a placebo-controlled double-blind trial. British Journal of Psychiatry
163:451–455.
Feighner, JP., Robins, E., Guze, S.B., Woodruff, R.A. Jr, Winokeer, G. & Munoz, R. 1972: Diagnostic criteria for use in
psychiatric research. Archives of General Psychiatry 26:57–63.
Goldberg, E.M. & Morrison, S.L. 1963: Schizophrenia and social class. British Journal of Psychiatry 109: 785–802.
Goldstein, J.M., Faraone, S.V., Chen, W.J. & Tsuang, M.T. 1993: The role of gender in understanding the familial
transmission of schizoaffective disorder. British Journal of Psychiatry 163:763–768.
Gottesman, I.I. & Shields, J. 1972: Schizophrenia and Genetics: A Twin Study Vantage Point. New York: Academic
Press.
Howard, R.J., Almeida, O., Levy R. et al. 1994: Quantitative magnetic resonance imaging volumetry distinguishes
delusional disorder from late onset schizophrenia. British Journal of Psychiatry 165:474–480.
Johnstone, E.C., Crow, T.J., Frith, C.D., Husband, J. & Kreel, L. 1976: Cerebral ventricular size and cognitive
impairment in chronic schizophrenia. Lancet ii:924–926.
Johnstone, E.C., Crow, T.J., Frith, C.D. et al. 1978: Mechanism of the antipsychotic effect in the treatment of acute
schizophrenia. Lancet ii:848–851.
Kahn, R.S., Davidson, M., Knott, P. et al. 1993: Effect of neuroleptic medication on cerebrospinal fluid monoamine
metabolite concentrations in schizophrenia. Archives of General Psychiatry 50:599–605.
Kane, J.M. & Freeman, H.L. 1994: Towards more effective antipsychotic treatment. British Journal of Psychiatry
165 (Suppl. 25):22–31.
Kane, J.M., Honigfield, G., Singer, J. et al. 1988: Clozapine for the treatment-resistant schizophrenic: a double-
blind comparison with chlorpromazine. Archives of General Psychiatry 45:789–796.
Kety, S.S., Rosenthal, D., Wender, P.H. et al. 1971: Mental illness in the biological and adoptive families of adopted
schizophrenics. American Journal of Psychiatry 128:302.
Bibliography 385
Leff, J., Thornicroft, G., Coxhead, N. et al. 1994: The TAPS project: 22. A five-year follow-up of long-stay
psychiatric patients discharged to the community. British Journal of Psychiatry 165 (Suppl. 25):13–17.
Lewis, S.W. & Murray, R.M. 1988: Obstetric complications, neurodevelopmental deviance and risk of
schizophrenia. Journal of Psychiatric Research 21:473.
Liddle, P.F., Friston , K.J., Frith, C.D. et al. 1992: Patterns of cerebral blood flow in schizophrenia. British Journal of
Psychiatry 160:179–186.
Lieberman, J.A. & Sobel, S.N. 1993: Predictors of treatment response and course of schizophrenia. Current Opinion
in Psychiatry 6:63–69.
Mednick, S.A., Machon, R.A., Huttunen, M.O. & Bonnet, D. 1988: Adult schizophrenia following prenatal exposure
to an influenza epidemic. Archives of General Psychiatry 45:189–192.
Meltzer, H.Y., Myung, A.L. & Ranjan, R. 1994: Recent advances in the pharmacotherapy of schizophrenia. Acta
Psychiatrica Scandinavica 90 (Suppl. 384):95–101.
Murray, R.M., Lewis, S.W., Owen, M.J. & Foester, A. 1988: Neurodevelopmental origins of dementia praecox. In
Bebbington, P. & McGuffin, P. (eds) Schizophrenia: The Major Issue. London: Heinemann.
Murray, R.M., O’Callaghan, E., Castle, D.J. & Lewis, S.W. 1992: A neurodevelopmental approach to the
classification of schizophrenia. Schizophrenia Bulletin 18:319–332.
Roy, A. 1982: Suicide in chronic schizophrenia. British Journal of Psychiatry 141:171–177.
Sherrington, R., Brynjjolfsson, J., Petursson H. et al. 1988: Localisation of a susceptibility locus for schizophrenia
on chromosome 5. Nature 336:164–167.
Spitzer, R.L., Endicott, J. & Robins, E. 1975: Research Diagnostic Criteria (RDC) for a Selected Group of Functional
Disorders. New York: New York State Psychiatric Institute.
Syvälahti, E.K.G. 1994: Biological factors in schizophrenia: structural and functional aspects. British Journal of
Psychiatry 164 (Suppl. 23):9–14.
Torgersen, S. 1994: Personality deviations within the schizophrenia spectrum. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica
(Suppl. 384):40–44.
Tsuang, M.T. 1991: Morbidity risks of schizophrenia and affective disorders among first-degree relatives of
patients with schizoaffective disorders. British Journal of Psychiatry 158:165–170.
Vaughn, C.E. & Leff, J.P. 1976: Influence of family and social factors on the course of psychiatric illness. British
Journal of Psychiatry 129:125–137.
Weinberger, D.R., Berman, K.F. & Zec, R.F. 1986: Physiological dysfunction of dorsolateral prefrontal cortex in
schizophrenia: I. Regional cerebral blood flow evidence. Archives of General Psychiatry 43:114–124.
Wing, J., Cooper, J.E. & Sartorius, N. 1974: The Description of Psychiatric Symptoms: An Introduction Manual for
the PSE and CATEGO System. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wing, J.K. & Brown, G.W. 1961: Social treatment of chronic schizophrenia: a comparative survey of three mental
hospitals. Journal of Mental Science 107:847.
Wing, J.K. & Brown, G.W. 1970: Institutionalism and Schizophrenia. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
Wong, D.F., Wagner, H.N., Tune, L.E. et al. 1986: Positron emission tomography reveals elevated D2 dopamine
receptors in drug naive schizophrenics. Science 234:1558–1563.
World Health Organization 1973: Report of the International Pilot Study of Schizophrenia. Geneva: WHO.
World Health Organization 1992: The ICD-10 Classification of Mental and Behavioural Disorders. Geneva: WHO.
This page intentionally left blank
28
Mood disorders, suicide and parasuicide
HISTORY
∑ In 1921, Kraepelin divided the functional psychoses into two broad categories, dementia praecox
and manic–depressive insanity. He thought of the latter as a disorder in which discrete episodes
of illness alternated with clearly defined well periods during which patients returned to their
previous state of health.
∑ In 1949, Cade first initiated the use of lithium, but it was not widely used until the 1960s.
∑ In the 1950s, tricyclic and monoamine oxidase inhibitor (MAOI) antidepressants were
introduced.
∑ In the 1970s, anticonvulsants were first used for bipolar disorders. Specific psychological
treatments (e.g. cognitive therapy) were introduced.
∑ In the 1980s, selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (SSRIs) were introduced.
ICD-10 classifications
BIPOLAR AFFECTIVE DISORDER
There are repeated episodes of mood disturbance, sometimes elevated, sometimes depressed.
Repeated episodes of mania are classified as bipolar (sufferers resemble those who also have
depressive episodes in their family history, premorbid personality, age of onset and prognosis). It
includes:
∑ bipolar affective disorder with:
∑ current episode hypomanic, or
∑ current episode manic without psychotic symptoms, or
∑ current episode manic with psychotic symptoms
∑ bipolar affective disorder with:
∑ current episode having mild/moderate depression, or
∑ current episode having severe depression without psychotic symptoms, or
388 Mood disorders, suicide and parasuicide
MANIC EPISODE
The fundamental disturbance is an elevation of mood to elation, with concomitant increase in
activity level. Three degrees of manic episode are specified by ICD-10, all used for a single manic
episode only:
∑ Hypomania. There is persistent elevated mood, increased energy and activity, feelings of
wellbeing, and reduced need for sleep. Irritability may replace elation. Work is considerably
disrupted. There are no hallucinations or delusions.
∑ Mania without psychotic symptoms. Mood is elevated, with almost uncontrollable excitement.
There is over-activity, pressured speech, reduced sleep, distractible, inflated self-esteem, and
grandiose thoughts. Perceptual heightening may occur. The person may spend excessively,
become aggressive, amorous, or facetious.
∑ Mania with psychotic symptoms. The symptoms are as above, but with delusions and
hallucinations, usually grandiose. There may be sustained physical activity, aggression and self-
neglect.
DEPRESSIVE EPISODE
There is depression of mood, reduced energy and fatiguability. Mood is pervasively depressed.
Other features are reduced attention and concentration, lowered self-esteem, ideas of guilt and
worthlessness, pessimistic thoughts, thoughts of self-harm or suicide, and disturbed sleep.
Somatic changes include reduced appetite leading to weight loss (at least 5% of bodyweight in a
month), constipation, early morning wakening (more than 2 hours before usual), diurnal variation
of mood, anhedonia, loss of normal reactivity of mood, reduced libido, amenorrhoea, and
psychomotor retardation or agitation.
A duration of 2 weeks is required for the diagnosis. This applies to the first episode only. Severity
is graded:
∑ mild depressive episode
∑ moderate depressive episode
∑ severe depressive episode without psychotic symptoms
∑ severe depressive episode with psychotic symptoms.
OTHER CLASSES
Dysthymia
This is a chronic, less severe depression, usually with an insidious onset. Symptoms include excessive
guilt, difficulty in concentrating, loss of interest, pessimism, low self-esteem, low energy, irritability
and reduced productivity. For the diagnosis it must be present for at least 2 years. ICD-10 and DSM-
IV-TR criteria are similar.
Double depression
This is a major depression superimposed upon dysthymia.
390 Mood disorders, suicide and parasuicide
Depressive stupor
The person is unresponsive, akinetic, mute and fully conscious. Following an episode, the patient
can recall the events that took place at the time. Episodes of excitement may occur between episodes
of stupor.
Masked depression
In masked depression, depressed mood is not always complained of, rather somatic or other
complaints. It is more common in the undeveloped world and in those unable to articulate their
emotions (e.g. those with learning disability or dementia). The presence of biological symptoms is
helpful in making the diagnosis. Diurnal variation in abnormal behaviour may mirror diurnal
variation in mood.
Atypical depression
This is depression characterized by reversed neurovegetative symptoms such as psychomotor
retardation, hypersomnia and hyperphagia with weight gain.
Bereavement reactions
Grief usually has three phases. The stunned phase lasts from a few hours to a few weeks. This gives
way to the mourning phase, with intense yearning and autonomic symptoms. After several weeks the
phase of acceptance and adjustment takes over. Grief typically lasts about six months.
Atypical grief is divided by Parkes (1985) into:
∑ unexpected grief syndrome
∑ ambivalent grief syndrome
∑ chronic grief.
DEPRESSIVE EPISODES
Problems are encountered in epidemiological studies of mood disorders because of the differing use
of diagnostic categories, screening instruments and definitions of caseness.
Aetiology of mood disorders 391
Broadly, depressive episodes are more common in females: the annual incidence in men in the
population is between 80 and 200 per 100 000, the corresponding figure for women being between
250 and 7800 per 100 000. There is a raised incidence in those who are not married. The point
prevalence in Western countries is 1.8–3.2% for men and 2.0–9.3% for women.
The point prevalence of depressive symptoms is 10–30% (women 18–34%, men 10–19%). In the
general population of Western countries, the lifetime risk of suffering from depressive episodes is
5–12% for men and 9–26% for women.
The average age of onset of depressive episodes is around the late thirties; however, they can start
at any age.
Brown and Harris (1978) found that 15% of urban women had severe depressive symptoms, and
there was a higher prevalence in working-class than in middle-class women.
Genetic factors
Family studies
In unipolar probands there is an increased risk of unipolar depression in first-degree relatives, but
the amount of bipolar illness is virtually the same as in the general population (combined risk =
7–8%). In bipolar probands there is an increased risk of both bipolar and unipolar disorder in first-
degree relatives (combined risk = 18–20%).
Twin studies
In a large Danish twin study of affective disorder (Bertelson et al., 1977), the concordance rate for
monozygotic (MZ) twins was 67%, compared with 20% for dizygotic (DZ) twins. The MZ to DZ
concordance ratio for bipolar disorder of 79:19 compared with 54:24 for unipolar disorder.
Adoption studies
In adoptees with bipolar disorder, 28% of biological parents suffer from a mood disorder compared
with 12% of adoptive parents. By comparison, 26% of the biological parents of bipolar non-
adoptees were found to suffer from a mood disorder.
Molecular genetics
In certain families, manic depressive illness has been cross-linked to colour blindness and glucose-
6-phosphate deficiency.
Egeland et al. (1987) found linkage to chromosome 11 in an old-order Amish pedigree. This
finding is now thought to have been a statistical artefact and has not been replicated. In linkage
studies of complex diseases such as manic depressive disorder, spurious linkage may be produced
because of phenotypic misclassification and misspecification of the disease model.
392 Mood disorders, suicide and parasuicide
∑ The cerebrospinal fluid level of the serotonin metabolite 5-hydroxyindole-acetic acid (5-HIAA)
is often reported as being reduced in depressed patients.
∑ Impaired repression at a 5-hydroxytryptamine 1A receptor gene polymorphism is associated
with major depression and suicide (Lemonde et al., 2003).
∑ The antidepressant effects of light therapy combined with sleep deprivation are influenced by a
functional polymorphism within the promoter of the serotonin transporter gene (Benedetti et
al., 2003).
Evidence against the monoamine hypothesis includes the following:
∑ Antidepressant pharmacotherapy takes at least a fortnight to effect a clinical improvement. This
time interval is much greater than the relatively rapid onset of biochemical action.
∑ Not all drugs that act as monoamine re-uptake inhibitors have a therapeutic antidepressant
action (e.g. cocaine).
Serotonin
Additional evidence for abnormal serotonergic function in mood disorders includes the following:
∑ In subgroups of depressed patients, low levels of 5-HIAA have been reported in cerebrospinal
fluid.
∑ In depressed patients, a low density of brain and platelet serotonin transporter sites has been
found, as well as a high density of brain and platelet serotonin binding sites.
∑ Dietary tryptophan depletion induced a prompt relapse in depressed patients who had
responded to SSRIs.
∑ There is a low plasma tryptophan in depressed patients.
∑ All SSRIs are clinically effective antidepressants.
∑ Serotonin function is reduced in depression and may be normalized with active treatment.
administration of the long-acting potent synthetic steroid dexamethasone the previous evening. In
normal subjects, dexamethasone leads to a suppression in the level of cortisol over the next 24 hours
through negative feedback. In depressed patients with biological symptoms, non-suppression of
cortisol has been reported in over 60%. The DST has not proved to be a useful laboratory test for
depression because a relatively high level of cortisol non-suppression has been found in other
psychiatric disorders. The DST can be affected by factors such as age, bodyweight, drugs, ECT and
endocrinopathies. The DST is usually state-dependent and in most subjects normalizes as the
patient recovers.
Corticotropin-releasing factor (CRH or CRF) is an important hypothalamic peptide in the
regulation of appetite and eating. In the CRH stimulation test the administration of CRH to normal
humans leads to the release of corticotropin. In depression there is a consistent reduction of
corticotropin response.
The noradrenergic neurones of the locus coeruleus express glucocorticoid receptors, through
which corticosteroids can regulate its functioning. It is hypothesized that steroids may be important
in causing and perpetuating depression.
MELATONIN
Patients with depression have disordered biological rhythms – short REM latency (time from
falling asleep to onset of REM sleep), early morning wakening, and diurnal mood variation. The
suprachiasmatic nucleus (SCN) of the hypothalamus plays a major role in regulating diurnal
rhythms. Information about light conditions from the retina, via the retinohypothalamic path-
way, controls the SCN. This influences the pineal which excretes melatonin. The biosynthesis of
melatonin from its precursor, serotonin, occurs via N-acetylation followed by O-methylation.
The step involving serotonin N-acetyltransferase is probably rate-limiting and is stimulated at
night. Melatonin receptors are numerous in the SCN and parts of the hypothalamus where
releasing and inhibiting hormones end. Darkness stimulates melatonin release and light blocks
its synthesis. When compared with normal subjects, patients with seasonal affective disorder
(SAD) have been found to have an increased sensitivity of melatonin biosynthesis to inhibition
by phototherapy.
Pharmacotherapy
UNIPOLAR DEPRESSION
Categories
Frank et al. (1991) have categorized outcomes of treatment according to the ‘5 Rs’:
∑ Response.
∑ Remission. This is a return to the patient’s premorbid self.
∑ Relapse. This is a return of depressive symptoms in the time between initial response and
recovery. Risk is particularly high (40–60%) following the withdrawal of antidepressants within
the first 4 months of achieving a response. The risk of relapse is reduced to 10–30% by
continuation of pharmacotherapy.
∑ Recovery. A patient who has achieved a stable remission for at least 4–6 months is assumed to
have recovered from the index episode.
∑ Recurrence. This is a return of depression after recovery from the index episode. Risk factors for
recurrent depression include frequent and/or multiple prior episodes, seasonal pattern, and a
family history of mood disorder.
Acute treatment
This is initial treatment which aims to achieve a response.
Continuation treatment
This begins when a patient has achieved a significant response to treatment. The aim is to prevent
relapse and consolidate response into remission.
Maintenance treatment
This follows continuation treatment for those patients with a history of recurrent depression. A
recurrence rate of 85% is seen in those patients with recurrent depression within 3 years following
the discontinuation of pharmacotherapy. After 6 months, continuation becomes maintenance
treatment by arbitrary definition.
In an MRC trial in 1965, 269 patients with operationally defined depression were randomly
assigned to treatment groups, with the following results at 4 weeks:
∑ a tricyclic antidepressant (imipramine) response rate of 53%
∑ an MAOI (phenelzine) response rate of 30%
∑ a placebo response rate of 39%
∑ an ECT response rate of 71%.
Drugs
The first-line treatment of depression is with antidepressants. It is important that patients receive an
adequate dose for an adequate duration, conventionally 6 weeks. Antidepressants should be
continued for 4–6 months after the amelioration of symptoms of the acute episode. Maintenance
therapy usually with the same agent is used to treat the acute and continuation phases.
Lithium is efficacious in preventing recurrent depressive episodes, but less so than tricyclic
antidepressants.
Patients maintained on the full effective treatment dose of antidepressants have proportionately
fewer relapses than those whose dose is cut down to a lower maintenance level.
Management of mood disorders 397
ATYPICAL DEPRESSION
This responds better to monoamine oxidase inhibitors than to tricyclic antidepressants.
PSYCHOTIC DEPRESSION
Spiker et al. (1985) found a superior response when an antidepressant and an antipychotic were
used in combination, in delusional depression:
∑ 41% responded to amitriptyline alone
∑ 19% responded to perphenazine alone
∑ 78% responded to a combination of amitriptyline and perphenazine.
Psychosocial treatments
PSYCHOTHERAPIES
This includes interpersonal therapy, cognitive therapy and behavioural therapy. Most progress has
been made with psychotherapies for the acute treatment of major depression. Numerous trials have
398 Mood disorders, suicide and parasuicide
demonstrated the efficacy of psychotherapy in reducing the acute symptoms of depression, with
greatest efficacy in more mildly ill patients. They are associated with a longer lag period for response
than drug treatment. They may be a promising alternative to drugs during long-term maintenance
treatment.
ICD-10 describes persistent and usually fluctuating disorders of mood in which individual episodes
are rarely sufficiently severe to warrant being described as hypomanic or mild depressive episodes.
They may last for years at a time, sometimes for the greater part of adult life and involve
considerable subjective distress and disability.
In ICD-10, the persistent mood disorders are classed with the mood disorders rather than with
the personality disorders because of evidence from family studies which suggests that the persistent
mood disorders are genetically related to other mood disorders.
The two most important persistent mood disorders are cyclothymia and dysthymia.
Suicide and parasuicide (deliberate self-harm) 399
CYCLOTHYMIA
Cyclothymia is defined in ICD-10 as:
A persistent instability of mood, involving numerous periods of mild depression and mild elation. This
instability usually develops early in adult life and pursues a chronic course, although at times the mood
may be normal and stable for months at a time. The lifetime risk of cyclothymia is between 0.4 and
3.5%, sex ratio equal. First-degree relatives of patients with cyclothymia are more likely than the
general population to suffer from depressive episodes and bipolar disorder.
Some are treated successfully with lithium and/or with individual or group psychotherapy.
DYSTHYMIA
Dysthymia, also called depressive neurosis, is defined in ICD-10 as:
A chronic depression of mood which does not fulfil the criteria for recurrent depressive disorder . . . .
The balance between individual phases of mild depression and intervening periods of comparative
normality is very variable. Sufferers usually have periods of days or weeks when they describe
themselves as well, but most of the time . . . they feel tired and depressed; everything is an effort and
nothing is enjoyed. They brood and complain, sleep badly and feel inadequate, but are usually able to
cope with the basic demands of everyday life.
Dysthymia is probably more common in women than in men. It is more common in first-degree
relatives of patients with a history of depressive episodes than in the general population.
Treatment with antidepressants, individual psychotherapy or cognitive therapy may be helpful.
Suicide
EPIDEMIOLOGY
The annual incidence of suicide in England and Wales is approximately 1 in 10 000 of the
population. It is more common in men than women and also more common in those aged over 45
years. The highest rates are in those who are divorced, single or widowed. The highest rates are in
social classes I and V.
Suicide is associated with unemployment and retirement. Suicide rates fell in England and Wales
during the First and Second World Wars.
There is a seasonal variation in suicide rates. In the northern hemisphere, suicide rates are
highest during the months of spring and early summer. In the southern hemisphere, rates are
highest in the months corresponding to spring and early summer.
There is evidence that the availability of method affects gross suicide rates as well as the
choice of method. Suicide rates by hanging were constant until the 1960s when there was a rise
after the abolition of capital punishment. A massive reduction in the number of deaths caused
by gassing followed the switch from coal gas to the safer North Sea gas in the 1960s. A marked
rise in poisoning in the early 1960s was because of the increased availability of medicines such as
barbiturates.
400 Mood disorders, suicide and parasuicide
AETIOLOGY OF SUICIDE
Statistics
Ninety per cent of people who commit suicide suffer from a psychiatric disorder. Of these,
approximately 50% suffer depression, 25% alcoholism, 5% schizophrenia and 20% other (e.g.
personality disorder, chronic neuroses, and psychoactive substance abuse disorders). The rate of
suicide is increased by 50 times the population rate among psychiatric inpatients. There is also an
association with physical illnesses, particularly chronic painful illnesses, epilepsy (especially
temporal lobe epilepsy), cancer, peptic ulcer and gastric ulcer disease.
Following an act of deliberate self-harm the risk of completing suicide in the subsequent year is
approximately 100 times that in the general population, and remains high in subsequent years.
Associations
Positive associations with suicide in the general population include:
∑ being male
∑ being elderly
∑ having suffered loss or bereavement
∑ being unemployed
∑ being retired
∑ childlessness
∑ living alone in a big, densely populated town
∑ a broken home in childhood
∑ mental or physical illness
∑ loss of role
∑ social disorganization, including overcrowding, criminality, drug and alcohol misuse.
Negative associations include:
∑ religious devoutness
∑ lots of children
∑ times of war.
Risk factors
Risk factors by psychiatric diagnosis are as follows:
∑ Schizophrenia. There is a 10% mortality from suicide. Roy (1982) characterized schizophrenics
who commit suicide as young, male and unemployed, with chronic relapsing illness. Fewer
schizophrenic patients give warning of their intention to commit suicide than patients in other
diagnostic groups (23% versus 50%). The suicide is usually after recent discharge, with good
insight.
∑ Affective psychosis. There is a 15% mortality from suicide. Men are older, separated, widowed or
divorced, living alone and not working. Women are middle-aged, middle-class, with a history of
parasuicide and threats made in the last month. Those with obsessive–compulsive symptoms are
about six times less likely to commit suicide than those without.
∑ Neuroses. Nearly 90% have a history of parasuicide, and a high proportion have threatened
suicide in the preceding month. There is a tendency after a failed attempt to resort to more
violent means. There is a high risk in depressive neurosis and panic disorder, but a lower risk in
obsessive–compulsive disorder.
∑ Alcoholism. There is a 15% mortality from suicide. It tends to occur later in the course of the
illness, and those affected are often also depressed. Associated with completed suicide is poor
physical health, a poor work record, previous parasuicide and a recent loss of a close relationship.
Suicide and parasuicide (deliberate self-harm) 401
∑ Personality disorder. High risk factors are lability of mood, aggressiveness, impulsivity, alienation
from peers and associated alcohol and substance misuse.
Biochemical disturbances
Low 5-HIAA concentration in cerebral spinal fluid is associated with increased suicidal behaviour
and aggression. Irrespective of the clinical diagnosis, the group in which CSF concentration of 5-
HIAA is low often includes persons who have attempted a violent method of suicide. Serotonin may
play an important role in the biology of aggression and the control of impulsive behaviour.
Postmortem ligand binding studies have found increased numbers of 5HT2 receptors in the
prefrontal cortex of suicide victims, particularly those who used violent means. Low concentrations
of serum cholesterol have been found to be prospectively associated with an increase in the risk of
violent death or suicide. Biological mechanisms linking low serum cholesterol concentration and
suicide have been hypothesized.
Sociological theory
Durkheim in 1897 used the phenomenon of suicide to describe society (see also Chapter 7). He
described four types of suicide:
∑ Altruistic. The individual sets no value on life and renounces his or her personal being in order
to be engulfed into something wider (e.g. religious or terrorist suicides).
∑ Egoistic. Suicide springs from excessive individuation of the individual from society.
∑ Anomic. This relates to how society regulates the individual. Suicide results from the fact that a
human’s activities lack regulation.
∑ Fatalistic. This is a rare type of suicide, the opposite of anomic, deriving from excessive
regulation by oppressive regimes.
If there is a serious risk of suicide the patient should be admitted to hospital. Any psychiatric
disorder from which the patient suffers should be treated appropriately. If the patient is suffering
from severe depression, electroconvulsive therapy may be required. Patients with manic depression
have a mortality up to three times that of the general population, with suicide and cardiovascular
disease being primarily responsible. In patients treated with lithium prophylaxis, cumulative
mortality does not differ from that of the general population. A minimum of 2 years of lithium
treatment is needed to reduce the high mortality resulting from manic depression. It is proposed
that lithium exerts its anti-suicide effect as a result of improved serotonergic transmission.
Parasuicide
EPIDEMIOLOGY
There is an annual incidence of about three in 1000, but this is probably an under-estimate. It is
most common in females and in those aged below 35 years. The highest rates are in those who are
divorced or single, among the lower social classes, unemployed, and living in overcrowded urban
areas in which there are high rates of juvenile delinquency.
Ninety per cent of cases involve deliberate self-poisoning with drugs. Forty per cent use minor
tranquillizers and a further 30% use salicylates and paracetamol.
AETIOLOGY OF PARASUICIDE
Compared with the general population, life events are more common in the 6 months before an act
of parasuicide. These include the break-up of a relationship, trouble with the law, physical illness
and the illness of a loved one.
Predisposing factors include:
∑ marital difficulties
∑ unemployment
∑ physical illness, particularly epilepsy
∑ mental retardation
∑ parental neglect or abuse.
Motives include interruption, attention, communication, or a true wish to die.
The presence of psychiatric disorders should be looked for, and any previous history of suicide
attempts should be asked about. Social and financial support should also be detailed. Do not avoid
asking about suicidal intent.
MANAGEMENT OF PARASUICIDE
The individual should be treated medically as appropriate. Assess fully. Identify the risk factors.
Reduce the immediate risk and treat the causes. If the patient suffers from a psychiatric disorder this
should be treated appropriately.
Management of suicidal feelings involves the following:
∑ Allow ventilation. Talking out avoids acting out.
∑ Strike a bargain on medication. Ask whether the person can cope with the responsibility of a
bottle of tablets. If ‘no’, then admit to hospital.
∑ Agree a list of problem areas.
∑ Establish possible practical help.
∑ Allow for an under-estimate of the true risk.
Prevention involves:
∑ recognizing high-risk cases and taking them seriously
∑ asking patients about their suicidal ideas
∑ not removing hope
∑ prescribing the safest drugs
∑ treating underlying illness adequately.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ahrens, B., Måller-Oerlinghausen, B. & Grof, P. 1993: Length of lithium treatment needed to eliminate the high
mortality of affective disorders. British Journal of Psychiatry 163 (Suppl. 21):27–29.
Beck, A.T., Rush, A.J., Shaw, B.F. & Emery, G. 1979: Cognitive Therapy of Depression. New York: Guilford Press.
Benedetti, F., Colombo, C., Serretti, A. et al. 2003: Antidepressant effects of light therapy combined with sleep
deprivation are influenced by a functional polymorphism within the promoter of the serotonin transporter
gene. Biological Psychiatry 54:687–692.
404 Mood disorders, suicide and parasuicide
Bertelson, A., Harvald, B. & Hauge, M. 1977: A Danish twin study of manic–depressive disorders. British Journal of
Psychiatry 130:330.
Brown, G.W. & Harris, T. 1978: Social origins of depression. London: Tavistock.
Cassano, G.B., Tundo, A. & Micheli, C. 1994: Bipolar and psychotic depressions. Current Opinion in Psychiatry
7:5–8.
Egeland, J.A., Gerhard, D.S., Paus, D.L. et al. 1987: Bipolar affective disorders linked to markers on chromosome 11.
Nature 325:783–787.
Frank, E., Prien, R.F., Jarrett, D.B. et al. 1991: Conceptualization and rationale for consensus definitions of terms in
major depressive disorder: response, remission, recovery, relapse, and recurrence. Archives of General
Psychiatry 48:851–855.
Gallerani, M., Manfredini, R., Caracciolo, S. et al. 1995: Serum cholesterol concentrations in parasuicide. British
Medical Journal 310:1632–1636.
Heikkinen, M., Aro, H. & Lînnqvist, J. 1994: Recent life events, social support and suicide. Acta Psychiatrica
Scandinavica (Suppl. 377):65–72.
Hirschfield, R.M.A. 1994: Major depression, dysthymia and depressive personality disorder. British Journal of
Psychiatry 165 (Suppl. 26):23–30.
Keller, M.B. 1994: Depression: a long-term illness. British Journal of Psychiatry 165 (Suppl. 26):9–15.
Kendler, K.S., Kessler, R., Walters, E.E. et al. 1995: Stressful life events, genetic liability and onset of an episode of
major depression in women. American Journal of Psychiatry 152:833–842.
King, E. 1994: Suicide in the mentally ill: an epidemiological sample and implications for clinicians. British
Journal of Psychiatry 165:658–663.
Kraepelin, E. 1921: Manic Depressive Insanity and Paranoia (ed. G.M. Robertson, trans. R.M. Barclay). Edinburgh:
Churchill Livingstone.
Lemonde, S., Turecki, G., Bakish, D. et al. 2003: Impaired repression at a 5-hydroxytryptamine 1A receptor gene
polymorphism associated with major depression and suicide. Journal of Neuroscience 23:8788–8799.
Medical Research Council 1965: Clinical trial of the treatment of depressive illness. British Medical Journal i:881.
Nemeroff, C.B., Knight, D.L., Franks, J. et al. 1994: Further studies on platelet binding in depression. American
Journal of Psychiatry 151:1623–1625.
Parkes, C.M. 1985: Bereavement. British Journal of Psychiatry 146:11–17.
Roy, A. 1982: Suicide in chronic schizophrenia. British Journal of Psychiatry 141:171–177.
Spiker, D.G., Cofskyweiss, J., Dealy, R.S. et al. 1985: The pharmacological treatment of delusional depression.
American Journal of Psychiatry 142:430–436.
Symonds, R.L. 1991: Books reconsidered. Suicide: A Study in Sociology by Emile Durkheim. British Journal of
Psychiatry 159:739–741.
Syvälahti, E.K.G. 1994: Biological aspects of depression. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica (Suppl. 377):11–15.
Terayama, H., Nishino, Y., Kishi, M. et al. 2003: Detection of anti-Borna Disease Virus (BDV) antibodies from
patients with schizophrenia and mood disorders in Japan. Psychiatry Research 120:201–206.
Thase, M.E. 1993: Maintenance treatments of recurrent affective disorder. Current Opinion in Psychiatry 6:16–21.
Tuckman, J. & Youngman, W.F. 1968: A scale for assessing risk of attempted suicides. Journal of Clinical
Psychology 24:17–19.
Vaughn, C.E. & Leff, J.P. 1976: The influence of family and social factors on the course of psychiatric illness: a
comparison of schizophrenic and depressed neurotic patients. British Journal of Psychiatry 129:125–137.
29
Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform
disorders
HISTORY
∑ In 1869, Beard introduced neurasthenia, comprising almost all current anxiety disorders.
∑ In 1893, Hecker subdivided neurasthenia into different syndromes.
∑ In 1900, Sigmund Freud distinguished between:
∑ actual neuroses: somatic causation, comprising neurasthenia, anxiety neurosis (generalized
anxiety, panic disorder and agoraphobia) and hypochondriasis
∑ psychoneuroses: psychological causation, comprising hysteria and obsessions (simple phobia,
social phobia and obsessive–compulsive disorder).
∑ Libidinous impulses reaching the ego generate anxiety; repression and symptom formation
follow.
∑ Fright neurosis, not related to repressed libido, was also described, similar to current post-
traumatic stress disorder.
CLASSIFICATIONS OF NEUROSIS
NEUROTIC SYNDROME
Neurosis is increasingly split into categories, but there is debate as to the validity of this. Tyrer et al.
(1993) favour a general neurotic syndrome, supported by the following facts:
∑ A lifetime experience of more than one neurosis is more common, while the frequency of a
single neurotic diagnosis is less common than expected.
∑ Tyrer randomly assigned various neurotic groups to diazepam, dothiepin,
cognitive–behavioural therapy, placebo and a self-help treatment programme. No difference in
treatment response between diagnostic groups was found. Diazepam was less effective than
dothiepin, cognitive–behavioural therapy or self-help, which were of similar efficacy in all
groups.
∑ The effects of treatment were independent of neurotic subtype, so division of the neuroses into
subtypes was not supported.
406 Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform disorders
ICD-10
The traditional division between neurosis and psychosis is not used in ICD-10. The following are
delineated:
∑ Phobic anxiety disorders: agoraphobia, with and without panic disorder; social phobias and
specific phobias
∑ Other anxiety disorders: panic disorder, generalized anxiety disorder and mixed anxiety and
depressive disorder
∑ Obsessive–compulsive disorder
∑ Reaction to severe stress, and adjustment disorders: acute stress reaction, post-traumatic stress
disorder, and adjustment disorders
∑ Dissociative (conversion) disorders: dissociative amnesia, fugue and stupor; trance and possession
disorders; dissociative motor disorders, convulsions, anaesthesia and sensory loss; Ganser’s
syndrome, and multiple personality disorder
∑ Somatoform disorders: somatization disorder; hypochondriacal disorder; somatoform
autonomic dysfunction and persistent pain disorder
∑ Other neurotic disorders: neurasthenia and depersonalization–derealization syndrome.
GENERAL ISSUES
Mortality
There is increased mortality in severe neurotic disorder. The relative risk of death in the decade
following treatment for neurosis is 1.7. The biggest cause of increased risk is accidental death,
particularly suicide (relative risk = 6.1). There is also a major excess of deaths from nervous,
circulatory and respiratory disease. Suicide is most likely in the first year after discharge.
The Greek word phobos means panic or terror. In phobic anxiety disorders, anxiety is evoked
predominantly by certain well-defined situations, characteristically avoided. Contemplation of a
feared situation generates anticipatory anxiety.
In defining fear as phobic the following are considered:
Phobic anxiety disorders 407
PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS
∑ Pavlovian classical conditioning. Watson, in the ‘Little Albert’ experiment on an 18-month-old
child, produced fear of a toy white rat by presenting it repeatedly with a loud noise. Fear is later
generalized to all furry objects (see Chapter 1).
408 Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform disorders
COMORBIDITY
There is overlap between anxiety disorders. For example, 55% of agoraphobics have social phobia
and 30% of social phobics also have agoraphobia.
Persons with major depression have 15 times the risk of having agoraphobia and nine times the
risk of simple phobia as controls.
Twenty-five per cent of phobics report alcohol abuse/dependence; there are higher rates in
agoraphobics and social phobics than in simple phobias.
PHARMACOLOGICAL APPROACHES
Monoamine oxidase inhibitors are effective in agoraphobics and social phobics: 80–90% of pure
social phobics are almost asymptomatic at week 16, but patients withdrawn from the active drug
relapse (Versiani et al., 1992).
Using fluoxetine, buspirone, phenelzine or moclobemide, two-thirds of socially phobic patients
show significant improvement.
Benzodiazepines may help prevent the reinforcement of fear through avoidance.
ICD-10
∑ Symptoms are manifestations of anxiety and are not secondary to other symptoms such as
delusions or obsessional thoughts.
∑ Anxiety is restricted to at least two of the following: crowds, public places, travelling away from
home and travelling alone.
∑ Avoidance of the phobic situation is prominent.
Course
Symptoms fluctuate, but the course is prolonged. Eighty per cent of agoraphobics are not free of
symptoms after 5 years.
SOCIAL PHOBIAS
Social phobias are characterized by a fear of scrutiny by others in small groups. This may progress
to panic attacks. Avoidance is often marked.
ICD-10
∑ Symptoms are manifestations of anxiety and not secondary to other symptoms.
∑ Anxiety is restricted to or predominates in particular social situations.
∑ The phobic situation is avoided whenever possible.
Course
The course is continuous but it may improve gradually. Alcohol and drug abuse are common.
ISOLATED PHOBIAS
Isolated phobias are restricted to highly specific situations. The seriousness of the handicap depends
on how easily a feared situation can be avoided.
ICD-10
∑ Symptoms are manifestations of anxiety and not secondary to other symptoms.
∑ Anxiety is restricted to the particular phobic situation.
∑ The phobic situation is avoided whenever possible.
Course
Childhood phobias are always improved after 5 years. In adult phobias, 20% are unchanged, 40%
are better, 40% are worse after 5 years.
PANIC DISORDER
This involves recurrent unpredictable attacks of severe anxiety lasting usually for a few minutes only.
There can be a sudden onset of palpitations, chest pain, choking, dizziness, depersonalization and
derealization, together with a secondary fear of dying, losing control or going mad. It often results
in a hurried exit and a subsequent avoidance of similar situations; it may be followed by persistent
fear of another attack.
410 Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform disorders
ICD-10
∑ There is absence of phobias and depressive disorder.
∑ Several attacks occur within one month:
∑ where there is no objective danger
∑ not confined to predictable situations
∑ with freedom from anxiety symptoms between attacks.
COMORBIDITY
One-third develop secondary depression following the onset of panic disorder. If depression does
occur, the course is poorer. Agoraphobia usually occurs with panic disorder, but can occur
separately.
There is an increased lifetime prevalence of alcohol abuse/dependence (54%) and drug
abuse/dependence (43%) in persons with panic disorder. Some use substances as a complication of
panic disorder; others develop panic disorder as a result of withdrawal from substances.
Major controversy surrounds the relationship between anxiety disorders and depression. There
is evidence supporting the unitary position, that anxiety and depression lie along the same
continuum:
∑ high overlap of symptoms (65% of anxious patients have depressive symptoms) (Roth et al.,
1972)
∑ difficulty separating primary disorder in patients experiencing both panic attacks and
depression
∑ no differences in family history for anxiety and mixed anxiety depression groups.
Panic disorder 411
LIFE EVENTS
There is an excess of stressful life events in the year prior to the onset of panic disorder, especially
illness or death of a cohabitant or relative.
PHYSIOLOGICAL FACTORS
Pitts and McClure (1967) provoked panic attacks in patients with anxiety neurosis but not controls,
by the intravenous infusion of sodium lactate. There were higher levels of autonomic arousal in
preinfusion panickers compared to non-panickers.
No single biochemical or neuroendocrine finding explains lactate-induced panic. Yohimbine, a
presynaptic a2-adrenergic autoreceptor blocker, induced panic attacks in a subgroup of individuals.
This group showed increased noradrenergic activity and blunted growth hormone response to
clonidine, supporting the hypothesis of a dysregulation of the noradrenergic system and possibly
the hypothalamus–pituitary–adrenal axis in a subgroup of panic-disorder patients. There were very
low rates of non-suppression during a dexamethasone suppression test in panic disorder.
Panic attacks are associated with a reduced blood flow in the frontal lobes. Panic-disorder
patients not having a panic attack have reduced perfusion of the hippocampus bilaterally and an
increase in blood flow to the right inferior frontal cortex.
Mitral valve prolapse occurs in 40% of panic-disorder patients compared to 9% of controls.
Patients suffering from mitral valve prolapse do not suffer more panic disorder than controls. An
aetiological role for mitral valve prolapse in panic disorder is unlikely.
Panic-disorder patients have abnormal sleep breathing with increased irregularity in tidal
volume during REM sleep and an increased rate of microapnoeas. One aetiological theory of panic
disorder proposes that patients have a hypersensitive respiratory control system operating at the
level of brainstem chemoreceptors. Their ‘suffocation’ alarm is thus at a pathologically low set point.
Enhanced CO2 sensitivity results in more frequent sighing to reduce CO2 levels; this results in
breathing pauses because the CO2 stimulus for breathing is withdrawn.
Seventy-five per cent of patients with panic disorder and agoraphobia responsive to treatment
with imipramine relapse within 6 months of drug discontinuation, compared to none maintained
on treatment. There is superior resistance to relapse in patients treated for longer periods,
suggesting that treatment may alter subsequent course in an enduring manner.
Benzodiazepines (e.g. alprazolam in high dosage) reduce the frequency of panic attacks in the
short term. There is the need to maintain treatment in the long term, with the risk of dependency.
The re-emergence of symptoms following discontinuation of therapy is problematic.
PSYCHOLOGICAL TREATMENT
Cognitive–behavioural therapy involving the cognitive restructuring of catastrophic interpretations
of bodily experience is efficacious in panic disorder, as are exposure techniques which generate
bodily sensations of fear during therapy with the aim of habituating the subject to them.
Agoraphobic avoidance is treated by situational exposure and relaxation techniques.
Marks et al. (1993), comparing alprazolam and exposure therapy in patients suffering from panic
disorder and agoraphobia, found the effect size of exposure was twice that of alprazolam; during
follow-up gains from alprazolam disappeared, but exposure gains were maintained. Treatment with
a combination of exposure and alprazolam impaired improvement seen in the exposure-alone
group.
Course
The course is highly variable. Sixty per cent suffer mild impairment. Ten per cent suffer severe
disability. Poor outcome is predicted by lower social class and long duration of illness.
The diagnostic reliability of generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) is lower than that of other anxiety
disorders. Patients report uncontrollable worry. A negative response to the question ‘Do you worry
excessively over minor matters?’ virtually rules out GAD as a diagnosis (negative predictive power
0.94). Symptoms of muscle and psychic tension are the most frequently reported by people with
GAD.
GAD is associated with the highest rates of comorbidity of all anxiety disorders.
ICD-10
∑ There is generalized, persistent, free-floating anxiety. Continuous feelings of nervousness,
trembling, muscular tension, sweating, light-headedness, palpitations, dizziness, and epigastric
discomfort are common.
∑ Anxiety presents most days for several weeks. Symptoms include:
∑ apprehension
∑ motor tension
∑ autonomic over-activity.
ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS
Torgersen (1983) reported that probands with GAD had lost their parents by death far more often
than probands with panic disorder, suggesting that environmental factors contribute to a higher
vulnerability for the development of GAD.
PSYCHOLOGICAL THERAPIES
Patients respond less favourably to conventional cognitive–behavioural treatments than in other
anxiety disorders. Treatments tend to be non-specific (e.g. relaxation training). Interventions
specifically targeting the worry associated with GAD may be more effective.
Course
Follow-up after 6 years reveals stability of diagnosis; the most common change of diagnosis is to
alcoholism. Sixty-eight per cent have mild or no residual impairment, 9% have severe impairment.
ICD-10
Obsessional symptoms or compulsive acts are present most days for at least two successive weeks
causing distress or interfering with activities. Obsessional symptoms have the following
characteristics:
∑ recognized as the individual’s own
∑ at least one thought or act is resisted unsuccessfully
414 Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform disorders
∑ the thought of carrying out the act must not in itself be pleasurable
∑ thoughts, images or impulses are unpleasantly repetitive.
Obsessional symptoms developing in the presence of schizophrenia, Tourette’s syndrome or
organic mental disorder are regarded as part of these conditions.
Epidemiology of OCD
The Epidemiological Catchment Areas study found that OCD is very rare in children. Rutter found
no cases among 2000 10- and 11-year-olds on the Isle of Wight. Other findings were:
∑ a 6-month prevalence of OCD of 1.3–2.0%
∑ a lifetime prevalence of 1.9–3.0%.
∑ sex ratio equal
∑ bimodal age of onset with peaks occurring at 12–14 and 20–22 years of age (decline in onset
after the age of 35)
The ECA study prevalance findings were consistently higher than earlier accepted estimates.
Aetiology of OCD
GENETIC FACTORS
First-degree relatives of OCD patients have a higher than normal incidence of psychiatric disorders,
most commonly anxiety, phobias, depression and schizophrenia.
First-degree relatives of OCD patients have higher than normal obsessional traits; the risk of
OCD among relatives is higher in early-onset OCD probands, suggesting aetiological heterogeneity.
Twin studies suggest that monozygotic twins are more likely to be concordant than dizygotic
twins for OCD, but the literature conflicts.
Gilles de la Tourette’s syndrome is a familial condition with a substantial genetic basis. Twin and
family studies find high rates of OCD and obsessive–compulsive symptoms among Tourette’s
families. This suggests that some forms of OCD may be related to Tourette’s syndrome.
OCD is equally frequent in families of Tourette’s probands regardless of whether the proband has
OCD. The rate of OCD alone is higher in female relatives and the rate of Tourette’s and tics is higher
in male relatives of a Tourette’s proband. These findings suggest that some forms of OCD are
familial.
Probands with no relatives affected by OCD may represent a sporadic form of OCD which is
aetiologically distinct from the familial form.
NEUROLOGICAL FACTORS
The reported numbers of OCD cases increased following the 1915 and 1926 outbreaks of
encephalitis lethargica.
OCD patients have more abnormal births than expected and more neurological disorders
including Sydenham’s chorea and encephalitis, suggestive of basal ganglia dysfunction. Flor-Henry
observed neuropsychological deficits implicating left frontal lobe dysfunction.
Brain-imaging techniques show morphological changes of basal ganglia structures in OCD.
Fronto-striatal abnormality is present. Functional neuroimaging studies show increased blood flow
in the basal ganglia, orbital, prefrontal and anterior cingulate cortex. Caudate metabolic rate is
Obsessive–compulsive disorder (OCD) 415
reduced after treatment with drugs or behaviour therapy in those patients responsive to treatment,
with the percentage change in symptom ratings correlating significantly with right caudate change.
PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS
In learning theory, obsessions are thoughts with which anxiety has become associated. Rituals or
neutralizing thoughts terminate exposure to the stimulus; thus anxiety is reduced and the rituals are
negatively reinforced. The use of rituals prevents the natural reduction in anxiety that would occur
if exposure to the stimulus was not cut short by the ritual or neutralizing thought.
In a cognitive model, obsessional distortion concerns exaggerated the responsibility for
thoughts, with a tendency to neutralize thoughts with rituals.
In psychoanalysis, OCD symptoms are seen as defensive responses to unconscious impulses.
Obsessional symptoms arise from intrapsychic anxiety because of the conflicts being expressed by
the defence mechanisms of displacement, undoing and reaction formation. The origin of
obsessional personality is located at the anal-training stage of development; OCD is thought to
represent regression to this stage.
Neuropsychological tests suggest the presence of amnestic deficits with respect to non-verbal
memory and memory for actions. OCD patients also perform poorly on tests of frontal lobe
function, particularly tests of shifting set.
Management of OCD
PHARMACOTHERAPY
Antidepressants are effective in the short-term treatment of OCD. Clomipramine and SSRIs have
greater efficacy than antidepressants with no selective serotonergic properties. Concomitant
depression is not necessary for serotonergic antidepressants to improve symptoms. There are
success rates of 50–79%.
Relapse often follows discontinuation of treatment.
PSYCHOLOGICAL TREATMENTS
Behavioural methods (e.g. modelling, exposure and response prevention) are the most widely
accepted psychological treatments; there are success rates of 60–85%.
The value of cognitive therapy in the treatment of OCD is not conclusive. Psychoanalytic therapy
is not effective in the treatment of OCD.
PHYSICAL TREATMENTS
Psychosurgery may be indicated in the chronic unremitting OCD of at least 2 years’ duration with
severe life disruption, unresponsive to all recognized forms of therapy. Open, uncontrolled studies
show that 65% of patients with OCD are improved or greatly improved with cingulotomy plus
bifrontal operations.
Course
Favourable prognostic factors include:
∑ mild symptoms
∑ predominance of phobic ruminative ideas, absence of compulsions
416 Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform disorders
This is a transient disorder developing in an individual without other mental disorder in response
to exceptional stress. It usually subsides within hours or days. The risk is increased if physical
exhaustion or organic factors are present.
ICD-10
∑ There is an immediate temporal connection between the impact of an exceptional stressor and
onset of symptoms, which is within minutes.
∑ In addition, symptoms:
∑ show a mixed and changing picture – initial state of daze, depression, anxiety, anger, despair,
over-activity and withdrawal may all be seen, with no one symptom predominating for long
∑ resolve rapidly, within a few hours if removal from the stressful environment is possible.
If stress continues, symptoms diminish after 24–48 hours.
ICD-10
∑ PTSD arises within six months as a delayed and/or protracted response to a stressful event of an
exceptionally threatening nature.
∑ Symptoms include repeated reliving of the trauma. Repetitive, intrusive memories (flashbacks),
daytime imagery, or dreams of the event must be present.
∑ Emotional detachment, persisting background numbness, avoidance of stimuli reminiscent of
original event are often present, but are not essential.
∑ Autonomic disturbances (hyperarousal with hypervigilance, enhanced startle reaction, and
insomnia) and mood disorder contribute to the diagnosis but are not essential. Anxiety,
depression and suicidal ideation are not uncommon. The excessive use of alcohol or drugs may
complicate matters.
Aetiology of PTSD
GENERAL FACTORS
About 25% of people exposed to a potentially traumatic event develop PTSD. Low education and
social class, pre-existing psychiatric problems and female gender are vulnerability factors. Viewing
Post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) 417
the dead body of a relative after a disaster is predictive of lower PTSD. Psychopathic traits are
protective.
Sufferers of PTSD report childhood physical sexual abuse more often than expected.
BIOLOGICAL FACTORS
People with PTSD have exaggerated physiological responses (heart rate, skin conductance,
electromyographic response) to traumatic imagery. They have a heightened physiological state
specific to PTSD and which is difficult to simulate. This may be mediated by noradrenergic and
dopaminergic neurotransmitter systems, and the HPA axis.
Initial mobilization and the subsequent depletion of noradrenaline following inescapable shock
in animals indicates a possible catecholaminergic mediation of PTSD symptoms. Drugs effective in
PTSD (MAOIs, tricyclics, benzodiazepines and clonidine) are also effective in preventing
development of learned helplessness in animals when infused into the locus coeruleus.
There are similarities between PTSD symptoms and opioid withdrawal, leading to speculation
that opioid function is disturbed in PTSD. Stress-induced analgesia is reversible by nalaxone in
PTSD veterans exposed to traumatic stimulus.
Management of PTSD
A flexible, staged approach using several techniques is advocated.
PSYCHOLOGICAL THERAPY
Exposure to aversive memories is central, irrespective of the specific therapy used. Exposure to
anxiety-producing stimuli in a supportive setting results in arousal, attenuation and symptom
reduction or habituation. Another common element is some form of cognitive restructuring.
Behavioural techniques are most effective in relation to PTSD following simple trauma. For
more complicated traumas, such as torture, these should be combined with cognitive methods.
PHARMACOTHERAPY
MAOIs and tricyclic antidepressants are beneficial in PTSD, particularly for intrusive symptoms.
SSRIs are helpful with avoidant symptoms.
Carbamazepine, propranolol and clonidine reduce hyperarousal and intrusive symptoms;
fluoxetine and lithium reduce explosiveness and improve mood. Buspirone may lessen fear-induced
startle; it may play an adjunctive role.
Alprazolam is no more effective than placebo, but there have been some positive reports with
clonazepam.
There is an almost total lack of response to placebo in chronic PTSD.
The drugs require at least 8 weeks’ duration before the effects are evident. The magnitude of the
drug effect is limited. Progressive and continued improvement has been noted over several months
in chronic PTSD treated with tricyclics.
Course
Half of patients still have PTSD decades later. A dose–response relationship exists between the
severity of the stressor and the degree of consequent psychological distress.
Most PTSD patients also have depression, anxiety disorders, substance abuse and/or sexual
dysfunction.
ADJUSTMENT DISORDERS
States of distress and emotional disturbance arise in the period after a stressful life event. Individual
predisposition plays a greater role than in other stress-induced conditions, but this condition would
not have arisen without a stressor.
Manifestations vary. They include depressed mood, anxiety, worry, an inability to cope and some
inability to manage the daily routine. Conduct disorders may be associated, especially in
adolescents. Regressive phenomena in children are frequently seen.
Onset is within one month of the stressor. The duration is usually less than 6 months, except for
prolonged depressive reaction.
Grief reactions considered abnormal because of their form or content are included in this
category.
ICD-10
The following adjustment disorders are outlined in ICD-10:
∑ brief depressive reaction – less than 1 month
∑ prolonged depressive reaction – less than 2 years
∑ mixed anxiety and depressive reaction
∑ predominant disturbance of emotions and/or conduct.
ICD-10
Dissociative (conversion) disorders are presumed to be psychogenic in origin. They are associated
with traumatic events, insoluble problems or disturbed relationships. The unpleasant affect
associated with these conflicts is transformed (converted) into symptoms.
Diagnostic guidelines are:
∑ no evidence of physical disorder that may explain symptoms
∑ evidence for psychological causation – a clear association in time with stressful events.
DISSOCIATIVE FUGUE
∑ There are all the features of dissociative amnesia (see above), plus an apparently purposeful
journey away from home. A new identity may be assumed.
∑ It s precipitated by severe stress.
∑ There is amnesia for the duration of the fugue, but self-care and social interaction are
maintained.
∑ It lasts for hours to days, but recovery is abrupt and complete.
DISSOCIATIVE STUPOR
∑ The sufferer is stuporose, with no evidence of a physical or other psychiatric cause.
∑ Onset is sudden and stress-related.
∑ The person sits motionless for long periods, speech and movement absent. Muscle tone, posture,
breathing and eye movements indicate that the individual is neither asleep nor unconscious.
DISSOCIATIVE CONVULSIONS
∑ Pseudoseizures mimic epileptic seizures, but tongue biting, serious bruising and incontinence of
urine are uncommon.
∑ Loss of consciousness is absent or replaced by stupor or trance.
420 Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform disorders
The spectrum of dissociation (multiple personality disorder is most extreme) with increasingly
complex and symptomatic forms is related to increasingly severe childhood trauma.
Levels of psychological distress are highly correlated with dissociative experiences.
Of 100 substance-dependent subjects, 39 had dissociative disorder and 43 reported childhood
abuse. Patients with dissociative disorder may use substances to block out more severe abuse
memories and suppress dissociative symptoms.
Course
Dissociative states tend to remit after a few weeks or months. Chronic states of more than one or two
years are often resistant to therapy. Those with acute, recent onset, a good premorbid personality
and resolvable conflict have a better prognosis.
In a classic paper, Slater (1965) reported on a 9-year follow-up of 85 patients who were diagnosed
as hysterics by senior psychiatrists and neurologists. He found that 33% developed definite organic
illness; 15% had a major mental illness; 12 patients died, four from suicide of whom two had
demyelinating neurological conditions, and eight from natural causes which could have accounted
for their original presentations. Of the original sample of 85, he was left with seven young patients
who had experienced acute psychogenic reactions in the form of a conversion syndrome, and 14
who were suffering from lasting personality disorders. Slater concluded that the diagnosis of
hysteria should not be made.
SOMATOFORM DISORDERS
ICD-10
∑ There is repeated presentation of physical symptoms with persistent requests for medical
investigations.
∑ No physical basis is found.
∑ Attempts to discuss possible psychological causation are resisted.
Somatization disorder
There are multiple, recurrent, frequently changing physical symptoms. Most patients have multiple
contacts with primary and specialist medical services; there are many negative investigations.
Gastrointestinal and skin symptoms are most common. Sexual and menstrual complaints are also
common. Onset after the age of 40 may indicate the onset of affective disorder.
ICD-10 requires the presence of all the following:
422 Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform disorders
∑ 2 years of multiple and variable physical symptoms, with no physical explanation found
∑ persistent refusal to accept the advice of several doctors
∑ impairment of functioning attributable to symptoms and resulting behaviour.
The possibility of developing an independent physical disorder should be considered.
The emphasis on symptoms and their effects distinguishes this from hypochondriacal disorder
(see below) where the emphasis of concern is on possible underlying disease.
Briquet’s syndrome or St Louis hysteria is a multiple somatization disorder.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
∑ There is a 0.2–0.5% prevalence in the UK.
∑ Three per cent of repeated gut clinic attenders have somatization disorder.
∑ Using abridged criteria (four unexplained symptoms in males, six in females), the prevalence is :
∑ community – 4.4%
∑ patients with medically unexplained symptoms – 32%.
∑ It is far more common in women than men.
∑ It usually starts in early adult life.
AETIOLOGY
Genetic factors
Torgersen (1986) reported an MZ to DZ concordance in somatoform disorder of 29:10. This
suggests that somatoform disorder has a familial transmission.
Environmental factors
The South London somatization study reported by Craig et al. in 1993 was a longitudinal study in
primary care; it compared somatizers with those with pure emotional disorder and those with pure
physical disorder. The physical symptoms of somatizers were less likely to improve; one-third went
on to develop chronic somatoform disorders.
Changes in physical symptoms mirrored changes in emotional arousal. Somatizers were more
likely to report parental physical illness and to have had more physical illness themselves in
childhood. Emotionally disordered subjects reported more parental lack of care.
It was hypothesized that physical illness in childhood lessened the distress of lack of care,
resulting in somatic rather than emotional responses as a means of attracting care or lessening
hostility, which endures into adult life.
MANAGEMENT
Engage the patient and spouse. Conduct no more investigations, but listen empathically. Elicit
childhood experience of illness and parental disability. Link physical symptoms to relevant life
events (the reattribution model of Goldberg). Reduce all medication apart from antidepressants for
the depressed. Limit the expectations of cure.
Alexithymia (limited ability to describe emotions verbally) is common in somatoform disorder.
Traditional psychotherapy with alexithymic individuals is difficult. A more reality-based
educational and supportive approach is better.
COURSE
The course is chronic and fluctuating. Treatments use disproportionate health resources. If engaged
as above, this significantly reduces the use of resources. However, depression and anxiety are often
present and may require treatment.
Other neurotic disorders 423
Hypochondriacal disorder
This is a persistent preoccupation with the possibility of having serious disease. Attention is usually
focused on one or two organ systems only. It occurs in both men and women, with no familial
characteristics.
ICD-10
∑ There is a persistent belief in the presence of at least one serious physical illness, despite repeated
investigations revealing no physical explanation of presenting symptoms, or persistent
preoccupation with presumed deformity.
∑ There is a persistent refusal to accept the advice of several different doctors that there is no
physical illness underlying the symptoms.
If depressive symptoms are prominent and precede the onset of hypochondriacal ideas, then
depressive disorder may be primary.
ICD-10
∑ There are persistent and troublesome symptoms of autonomic arousal.
∑ Symptoms are referred to a specific organ system, with no evidence of organ pathology.
∑ There is distress about the possibility of disorder of the organ system, not responsive to repeated
reassurance.
NEURASTHENIA
ICD-10
∑ There are persistent, distressing complaints of increased fatigue after mental effort, or persistent,
distressing complaints of bodily weakness and exhaustion after minimal effort.
∑ At least two of the following are reported: muscular aches; dizziness; headaches; sleep
disturbance; inability to relax; irritability or dyspepsia.
DEPERSONALIZATION–DEREALIZATION SYNDROME
It is uncommon to experience these in an isolated form.
424 Neurotic, stress-related and somatoform disorders
ICD-10
∑ There are depersonalization symptoms and/or derealization symptoms.
∑ Insight is maintained.
∑ There is a clear sensorium and absence of toxic confusional state or epilepsy.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Andrews, G., Stewart, G., Morris-Yates, A. et al. 1990: Evidence for a general neurotic syndrome. British Journal of
Psychiatry 157:6–12.
Boer, J.A. den 1988: Serotonergic Mechanisms in Anxiety Disorders. An Enquiry into Serotonin Function in Panic
Disorder. PhD thesis, University of Utrecht.
Brown, T.A., Barlow, D.H. & Liebowitz, M.R. 1994: The empirical basis of generalized anxiety disorder. American
Journal of Psychiatry 151:1272–1280.
Craig, T.K.J., Boardman, A.P., Mills, K. et al. 1993: The South London somatisation study: I. Longitudinal course and
the influence of early life experiences. British Journal of Psychiatry 163:579–588.
Davidson, J. 1992: Drug therapy of post-traumatic stress disorder. British Journal of Psychiatry 160:309–314.
Dick, C.L., Bland, R.C. & Newman, S.C. 1994: Panic disorder. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica (Suppl. 376):45–53.
Dick, C.L., Sowa, B., Bland, R.C. and Newman, S.C. 1994: Phobic disorders. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica (Suppl.
376):36–44.
James, I.A. & Blackburn, I.-M. 1995: Cognitive therapy with obsessive–compulsive disorder. British Journal of
Psychiatry 166:444–450.
Kendler, K., Neale, M., Kessler, R. et al. 1993: Major depression and phobias: the genetic and environmental
sources of comorbidity. Psychological Medicine 23:361–371.
Kendler, K., Neale, M., Kessler, R. et al. 1993: Panic disorder in women: a population based twin study.
Psychological Medicine 23:397–406.
Klerman, G.L. 1986: The National Institute of Mental Health’s Epidemiologic Catchment Areas (NIMH-ECA)
program: background, preliminary findings and implications. Social Psychiatry 21:159–166.
Kolada, J.L., Bland, R.C. & Newman, S.C. 1994: Obsessive–compulsive disorder. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica
(Suppl. 376):24–35.
Leckman, J.F., Weissman, M.M., Merikangas, K.R. et al. 1985: Major depression and panic disorder: a family study
perspective. Psychopharmacological Bulletin 21:543–545.
Loewenstein, R.J. & Ross, D.R. 1992: Multiple personality and psychoanalysis: an introduction. Psychoanalytic
Inquiry 12:3–48.
Marks, I.M. & Gelder, M.G. 1966: Different ages of onset in varieties of phobia. American Journal of Psychiatry
123:218–221.
Marks, I.M., Swinson, R.P., Basoglu, M. et al. 1993: Alprazolam and exposure alone and combined in panic disorder
with agoraphobia. British Journal of Psychiatry 162:776–787.
McIvor, R.J. & Turner, S.W. 1995: Assessment and treatment approaches for survivors of torture. British Journal of
Psychiatry 166:705–711.
Pauls, D.L., Alsobrook, J.P., Goodman, W. et al. 1995: A family study of obsessive–compulsive disorder. American
Journal of Psychiatry 152:76–84.
Piccinelli, M., Pini, S., Bellantuono, C. et al. 1995: Efficacy of drug treatment in obsessive–compulsive disorder: a
meta-analytic review. British Journal of Psychiatry 166:424–443.
Pitts, F.N. & McClure, J.N. 1967: Lactate metabolism in anxiety neurosis. New England Journal of Medicine
13:29–36.
Robins, L.N. 1966: Deviant Children Grown Up. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.
Bibliography 425
Roth, M., Gurney, C., Garside, R.F. et al. 1972: Studies in the classification of affective disorders: the relationship
between anxiety states and depressive illnesses: I. British Journal of Psychiatry 121:147–161.
Sims, A. & Prior, P. 1978: The pattern of mortality in severe neuroses. British Journal of Psychiatry 133:299–305.
Slater, E. 1965: Diagnosis of hysteria. British Medical Journal i:1395–1399.
Spector, J. & Huthwaite, M. 1993: Eye-movement desensitisation to overcome post-traumatic stress disorder.
British Journal of Psychiatry 163:106–108.
Stein, M.B., Millar, T.W., Larsen, D.K. et al. 1995: Irregular breathing during sleep in patients with panic disorder.
American Journal of Psychiatry 152:1168–1173.
Tallis, F. 1995: Reading about obsessive–compulsive disorder. British Journal of Psychiatry 166:546–550.
Torgersen, S. 1983: Genetic factors in anxiety disorders. Archives of General Psychiatry 40:1085–1089.
Torgersen, S. 1985: Hereditary differentiation of anxiety and affective neuroses. British Journal of Psychiatry
146:530–534.
Torgersen, S. 1986: Genetics of somatoform disorders. Archives of General Psychiatry 43:502–505.
Tyrer, P., Seivewright, N., Murphy, S. et al. 1988: The Nottingham study of neurotic disorder: comparison of drug
and psychological treatments. Lancet ii:235–240.
Tyrer, P., Seivewright, N., Ferguson, B. et al. 1993: The Nottingham study of neurotic disorder: effect of personality
status on response to drug treatment, cognitive therapy and self-help over two years. British Journal of
Psychiatry 162:219–226.
Versiani, M., Nardi, A.E., Mundim, F.D. et al. 1992: Pharmacotherapy of social phobia: a controlled study with
moclobemide and phenelzine. British Journal of Psychiatry 161:353–360.
This page intentionally left blank
30
Disorders specific to women
Symptoms of PMS
Premenstrual syndrome includes emotional and/or physical symptoms occurring premenstrually
(late luteal phase) but remitting usually during the week before menstruation (follicular phase).
More than 150 symptoms have been implicated in PMS. There are considerable differences in the
patterns of symptoms, but there is strong support for cycle-related variability in most subjects. The
existence of PMS as a discrete entity has often been questioned; there is a lack of consensus about its
definition.
The common symptoms experienced by those women suffering PMS are listed in Table 30.1.
Epidemiology of PMS
Forty per cent of women experience some cyclical premenstrual symptoms; 2–10% report severe
symptoms. There are associations with the following:
428 Disorders specific to women
Aetiology of PMS
GENETIC FACTORS
Highly significant correlations between mother and daughter have been reported on a variety of
menstrual variables including premenstrual tension.
Condon (1993) reported concordances for global PMS scores:
∑ 0.28 in DZ twin pairs
∑ 0.55 in MZ twin pairs.
Concordances for MZ twins exceeded those of DZ twins on every subscale. The findings support the
hypothesis that the familial aggregation of PMS symptoms is determined largely by genetic factors.
NEUROENDOCRINE FACTORS
Beta-endorphin
Anxiety, food cravings and physical discomfort in PMS subjects are associated with a significant
decline in b-endorphin (these symptoms are also found in opiate withdrawal).
Serotonin
Post-synaptic serotonergic responsivity is altered during the late luteal phase of the menstrual cycle.
It is thought that gonadal hormones cause changes in the levels of activity of serotonergic systems.
Carbohydrate craving and depression are linked to serotonergic brain changes which are marked in
the late luteal phase.
Plasma taken from subjects suffering from PMS inhibits serotonin uptake in rat brain
synaptosomes to a greater degree than serum taken from controls.
Noradrenaline
MHPG (3-methoxy-4-hydroxyphenylglycol, a metabolite of noradrenaline) in cerebrospinal fluid is
elevated in PMS subjects premenstrually.
Androgens
Serum androgens are higher in women with premenstrual irritability and dysphoria than in
controls. Serum-free testosterone levels are significantly higher in PMS subjects than in matched
controls around ovulation, and 17-hydroxyprogesterone levels are higher in PMS women in the
luteal phase.
Other
Various hypotheses have been explored, particularly in relation to the balance between oestrogen
and progesterone with a relative lack of progesterone, excessive production of prolactin, aldosterone
or antidiuretic hormone. None are conclusive.
Premenstrual syndrome (PMS) 429
NEUROPHYSIOLOGICAL FACTORS
The following have been reported:
∑ There are consistent cycle-dependent changes in electroencephalographic recordings, most
prominent in the a range.
∑ There are alterations in response to dichotic auditory stimuli premenstrually in comparison
with the follicular phase, most markedly in sufferers of PMS.
∑ There are alterations in skin conductance in response to auditory stimuli premenstrually in
comparison with the follicular phase, most markedly in sufferers of PMS.
PERSONALITY FACTORS
Neuroticism may be an important determinant of women’s experiences and reports of their
menstrual cycle, and is higher in those reporting PMS.
Women with coronary-prone type-A behaviour experience 50% more PMS symptoms than
women with non-coronary-prone type-B behaviour.
PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS
Psychological views of PMS attribute it to an impoverishment of the ego in relation to feminine self-
acceptance and identification with the mother. It is suggested that popular beliefs that derogate
femininity are internalized and form part of the socialization of women.
Self-report of PMS is strongly related to psychosocial stress, particularly unusual stress and
unhappy relationships.
Management of PMS
Treatment should be supportive and directed towards symptom relief, psychosocial support, stress
reduction and dietary change. No single medication has proven effective in the treatment of PMS.
Antidepressants
Favourable results are sometimes found particularly when a serotonergic antidepressant is used.
Psychic, but not somatic, symptoms improve. A 70% reduction in premenstrual irritability and
depressed mood is found using clomipramine, compared to a 45% reduction with placebo. Similar
results have been obtained using fluoxetine, adding support to the hypothesis that a serotonergic
imbalance is involved in premenstrual psychic symptoms.
Other treatments
Other treatments used for which there are conflicting reports of efficacy include:
∑ alprazolam – some reports of usefulness, but double-blind placebo-controlled trial showed
absence of any therapeutic benefit
∑ hysterectomy – no change in cyclical mood changes following hysterectomy
∑ vitamin B6 – produces a reduction in prolactin synthesis; use advocated, but little evidence of
improvement in PMS symptoms
∑ progesterones – use advocated, but little evidence of improvement in PMS symptoms
∑ diuretics – produce some relief in symptoms of bloatedness, but no improvement in psychic
symptoms
∑ bromocriptine – effective only in the relief of breast symptoms.
CYCLIC PSYCHOSIS
A few reports of cyclic psychoses related to menstruation exist in the literature. Psychotic symptoms
appear suddenly a few days before menstruation, resolve with the onset of menstrual bleeding, and
reappear with the next cycle. Between psychotic episodes the woman appears largely asymptomatic.
Most cases do not show familial psychiatric morbidity. The first psychotic episode usually occurs at
a young age.
The psychiatric picture is non-specific, and changes with every menstruation. Some common
features include psychomotor retardation, anxiety, perplexity, disorientation and amnestic features.
Transitory EEG abnormalities may occur, not amounting to epileptic activity.
It has been suggested that in some cases menstrual psychoses should be regarded as a specific
variant of PMS.
Recommended treatments for menstrual cyclic psychosis include:
∑ bromocriptine which reduces prolactin
∑ progesterone which inhibits ovulation
∑ clomiphene citrate
∑ acetazolamide, a diuretic
∑ psychotropic medications (results inconclusive).
The prognosis is good, and spontaneous remission is usual.
PREGNANCY
Miscarriage
Miscarriage occurs in 12–15% of clinically recognized pregnancies. About one-half are associated
with chromosomal abnormalities. Other recognized causes include uterine malformation, cervical
incompetence, trauma, infection, endocrine disorder, toxins, irradiation and immune dysfunction.
Animal evidence shows that stress leads to abortion in a number of mammallian species
including baboons.
O’Hare and Creed (1995) studied the relationship between life events and miscarriage in 48
case–control pairs matched for known predictors of miscarriage. They found that the miscarriage
group were more likely to have experienced:
Pregnancy 431
CONSEQUENCES OF MISCARRIAGE
A high percentage of women experience profound loss following miscarriage, reporting symptoms
typical of the grief that follows bereavement. Friedman and Gath (1989) found that at 4 weeks after
miscarriage 48% of women were psychiatric cases as measured on the PSE, all suffering depressive
disorders. Many of the women were already recovering at this time.
Symptoms are increased in women who have experienced a previous miscarriage. Many women
are fearful of experiencing loss in a future pregnancy.
Other factors increasing women’s vulnerability to developing depressive symptoms are lack of a
supportive partner, childlessness, neuroticism and previous psychiatric consultation.
Psychiatric morbidity can persist for several months. The duration of bereavement reaction is
appreciably shortened by support and counselling.
Termination of pregnancy
Psychological disturbance occurring in association with therapeutic abortion are severe or
persistent in only a minority, about 10% of women. Depression and anxiety are most common with
psychosis reported very uncommonly, in 0.003% of cases. Of the latter, most have a previous
psychiatric history.
Women at greater risk of adverse psychological sequelae include:
∑ those with a previous psychiatric history
∑ younger women
∑ those with poor social support
∑ those from cultural groups opposed to abortion.
About one-third of women experience feelings of loss, guilt and self-reproach at 6 months after
abortion, particularly those ambivalent towards the termination of pregnancy. Those requiring
therapeutic abortion because of fetal abnormalities or medical complications have poorer
psychological outcomes.
Gilchrist et al. (1995) studied psychiatric morbidity following termination of pregnancy
compared with other outcomes of unplanned pregnancy in a large prospective cohort study. They
found:
432 Disorders specific to women
∑ Rates of total psychiatric disorder were no higher after termination of pregnancy than after
childbirth.
∑ Women with a previous psychiatric history were most at risk of disorder after the end of their
pregnancy, whatever its outcome.
∑ Women without a past history of psychosis had a lower risk of psychosis after termination than
after childbirth.
∑ In women without a past psychiatric history, deliberate self-harm was more common in those
who were refused a termination (relative risk = 2.9), or who had a termination (relative risk =
1.7).
∑ There was no overall increase in psychiatric morbidity in those having a termination of
pregnancy.
PUERPERAL DISORDERS
General issues
There are associations between the puerperal mental conditions. Severe postnatal blues can progress
to postnatal depression; there may also be an association between postnatal blues and puerperal
psychosis, since there is an excess of onset of the latter towards the end of the first week post-partum.
ICD-10 does not categorize puerperal mental disorders separately unless they do not meet
criteria for disorders classified elsewhere. Thus under the chapter ‘Behavioural syndromes
Puerperal disorders 433
associated with physiological disturbances and physical factors’ is a section (F53) Mental and
behavioural disorders associated with the puerperium, not elsewhere classified which includes mild,
severe and other mental and behavioural disorders associated with the puerperium.
Postnatal blues
Postnatal blues is a brief psychological disturbance, characterized by tearfulness, emotional lability
and confusion in mothers occurring in the first few days after childbirth.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
It occurs in about 50% of women, peaking at the third to fifth day post-partum.
AETIOLOGY
There is some evidence of links with biological factors, including:
∑ a history of premenstrual tension
∑ serum calcium levels
∑ monoamines, serum tryptophan, platelet a2-adrenoceptors
∑ progesterone withdrawal post delivery – women experiencing severe blues have higher antenatal
progesterone levels, a steeper rise in the last 2 weeks of pregnancy, a bigger decrement from
antenatal levels to the day of peak blues score, and lower progesterone levels on the day of peak
blues.
Postnatal blues have also been positively associated with:
∑ poor social adjustment
∑ poor marital relationship
∑ high scores on EPI neuroticism scale
∑ fear of labour
∑ anxious and depressed mood during pregnancy.
There is no association between the development of postnatal blues and life events, demographic
and social factors or obstetric factors.
Postnatal women differ significantly from women undergoing elective gynaecological surgery in
the frequencies of different symptoms at different times, suggesting that postnatal mood swings are
characteristic of the puerperium and are not simply non-specific reactions to stress.
MANAGEMENT
The woman should receive reassurance.
Postnatal depression
Postnatal depression is a depressive illness not qualitatively different from non-psychotic depression
in other settings. It is characterized by low mood, reduced self-esteem, tearfulness, anxiety,
particularly about the baby’s health, and an inability to cope. Mothers may experience reduced
affection for their baby, and may have difficulty with breast-feeding.
434 Disorders specific to women
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Postnatal depression occur in 10–15% of post-partum women usually within 3 months of
childbirth. Those women who are emotionally unstable in the first week after childbirth are at an
increased risk of developing postnatal depression.
Postnatal depression is not associated with social class or parity.
AETIOLOGY
Environmental factors
Of the puerperal psychiatric conditions, postnatal depression has the least biological cause. Onset
after childbirth is spread over a few months, and studies have repeatedly indicated the importance
of social stress in its causation.
Paykel et al. (1980) found the strongest associated factor in mild post-partum depressives was the
occurrence of recent stressful life events. Younger age, poor marital relationships and absent social
supports were also notable. Early post-partum blues was associated with postnatal depression in the
absence of life events, suggesting a small subgroup of postnatal depression with a hormonal
aetiology. A past psychiatric history was a strong risk factor with or without life events.
Murray et al. (1995) found that postnatal depression, but not control depression, was associated
with a poor relationship with the woman’s own mother.
Postnatal depression is more contingent upon the acute biopsychosocial stresses caused by the
arrival of a child, whereas depression not associated with childbirth is more closely related to longer-
term social adversity and deprivation.
Hormonal factors
Despite the modest association between progesterone levels and post-partum blues, no direct
association has been demonstrated between progesterone levels and postnatal depression.
Oestrogens affect dopaminergic transmission in the CNS; their precipitate drop after delivery
may be responsible for psychosis, and possibly also depression in predisposed women.
Puerperal women, whether depressed or not, are non-suppressers in terms of the
dexamethasone-suppression test. However, no associations have been found between postnatal
depression and cortisol.
Transient hypothyroidism, sometimes preceded by hyperthyroidism, occurs in up to 5% of
women in the post-partum year, peaking at 4–5 months. Such post-partum thyroid dysfunction is
associated with depression. It is estimated that 1% of post-partum women in the general population
will experience a depressive episode associated with thyroid dysfunction.
MANAGEMENT
The education of health visitors and midwives is necessary to identify cases early. The Edinburgh
Postnatal Depression Scale is a 10-item self-report questionnaire, used by health visitors to identify
postnatal depression during the course of their normal contacts with new mothers.
Non-directive counselling by health visitors individually or in groups is effective in one-third of
cases. Self-help groups and mother-and-baby groups are useful to combat isolation.
In those with more severe symptomatology, or those unresponsive to counselling,
antidepressants are required. If depression is severe, admission, preferably with the baby to a
mother-and-baby unit, may be required. Suicidal mothers may have thoughts of taking their babies
with them, so questions about the safety of the child should form part of the normal assessment of
mothers of young children. ECT may be required, particularly if worthlessness, hopelessness and
despair are present.
Puerperal disorders 435
OUTCOME
If undetected, postnatal depression may last up to 2 years with serious consequences for the marital
relationship and the development of the child. There is good evidence for a link between depressive
disorders in mothers and emotional disturbance in their children.
The following are more frequent in the children of mothers suffering postnatal depression:
∑ insecure attachment
∑ behaviour problems
∑ difficulties in expressive language
∑ fewer positive, and more negative facial expressions
∑ mild cognitive abnormalities
∑ less affective sharing
∑ less initial sociability.
Social and marital difficulties are often associated with reduced quality of mother–child
interactions.
Cooper and Murray (1995) distinguished between those whose postnatal depression was a recur-
rence of previous affective disturbance, and those for whom postnatal depression had arisen de novo.
Those who were suffering from a recurrence of depression were at raised risk of further non-post-
partum episodes but not post-partum episodes. Those for whom the depression had arisen de novo
were at raised risk for further episodes of postnatal depression but not for non-post-partum episodes.
The relapse rate for subsequent non-psychotic depression is 1 in 6.
Puerperal psychosis
The risk of developing a psychotic illness is increased 20-fold in the first post-partum month.
Certain symptoms that are distinctive are:
∑ abrupt onset, within the first 2 weeks after childbirth
∑ marked perplexity, but no detectable cognitive impairment
∑ rapid fluctuations in mental state, sometimes from hour to hour
∑ marked restlessness, fear and insomnia
∑ delusions, hallucinations and disturbed behaviour, which develop rapidly.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Kendell et al. (1987) linked psychiatric and obstetric registers in Edinburgh and found the number
of admissions for psychotic disorders to be substantially elevated in the puerperium. This is shown
in Table 30.2.
Eighty per cent of puerperal psychoses are affective. Schizophreniform psychoses often have
manic features. Those with a previous history of manic depressive illness have a substantially higher
risk than those with a history of schizophrenia or depression.
The following factors are associated with women developing puerperal psychoses:
∑ increased rate of Caesarean section
∑ higher social class
436 Disorders specific to women
Table 30.2 Number of admissions to mental hospitals per month in the pre-
and post-partum periods
Non-psychotic Psychotic
15 months pre-conception 8 2
During pregnancy 5 2
1st post-partum month 17 51
2nd post-partum month 14 25
3rd post-partum month 10 13
4th post-partum month 8 9
5th post-partum month 6 6
Mean for next 18 months 9 4
AETIOLOGY
Genetic factors
∑ Family studies of puerperal psychosis point to a familial aggregation of psychiatric disorder,
particularly affective illness.
∑ Children of probands who have had puerperal psychosis have an increased psychiatric
morbidity.
∑ Female relatives of puerperal probands have a higher rate of puerperal illness than the general
population, but the majority of illness in the relatives of probands is non-puerperal.
∑ The weight of evidence from clinical and family studies suggests that most cases of puerperal
psychosis of early onset are closely related to bipolar disorder.
Environmental factors
There is no evidence of any excess of life events in puerperal psychotics compared to matched
normal puerperal controls. The absence of social stress in this group contrasts with the findings for
post-partum depression and disorders with onset in pregnancy. These findings suggest that the
aetiology of severe puerperal psychosis is predominantly biological and interactive with previous
vulnerability.
Hormonal factors
The pathophysiology of puerperal psychosis is not well understood but it is likely that the
precipitous fall in the levels of circulating sex steroid hormones such as oestrogen occurring at the
time of parturition plays an important role.
In animals, the administration of oestrogen leads to increased striatal dopamine binding, and
oestrogen withdrawal leads to dopamine receptor supersensitivity.
Wieck et al. (1991) have reported increased sensitivity of dopamine receptors in the
hypothalamus associated with the onset of affective psychosis following childbirth. It is possible that
these changes in sensitivity are mediated by changes in circulating oestrogen levels.
Supersensitivity of dopamine receptors is then thought to precipitate psychosis.
Menopause 437
MANAGEMENT
The identification of high-risk patients during pregnancy is important in the planning of postnatal
management. Admission to a psychiatric hospital is usually essential, and it is usually preferable to
admit mothers with their babies.
The following are some advantages of joint admission:
∑ Most psychotic mothers are capable of looking after their babies with supervision and support.
∑ There is evidence suggesting that joint admission may reduce the duration of illness and relapse
rates.
The following are some disadvantages of joint admission:
∑ There is a risk of non-accidental injury to the child from the mother or fellow patients. A nurse
should be dedicated to the care and supervision of the child and a lockable nursery should be
provided.
∑ Joint admission needs higher staffing levels.
∑ The long-term effects of admission upon the development of the child are not known.
∑ The woman’s partner needs support and education.
Therapy
∑ Phenothiazines and lithium are effective in the treatment of manic episodes. Control of lithium
levels in the immediate post-partum period can be difficult because of fluid and electrolyte
changes.
∑ ECT is particularly effective in the treatment of puerperal psychoses, and accelerates recovery in
all diagnostic categories. It is used generally if the drug treatment has failed.
∑ In breast-feeding mothers, lithium is contraindicated because it is excreted into breast milk and
is toxic to the baby.
∑ Neuroleptics can be administered to breast-feeding mothers, but high doses should be avoided
and the baby should be observed for signs of drowsiness, such as a failure to feed adequately.
∑ Neuroleptics should be maintained for at least 3 months following recovery. If there are further
manic or depressive episodes, lithium should be considered.
COURSE
Following discharge from hospital the mother will require close support and follow-up. An
assessment of the mother–baby interaction should be made prior to discharge.
The initial prognosis is quite good. Cases often settle within 6 weeks, and most are fully recovered
by 6 months. A few, however, have a protracted course.
After one episode of puerperal psychosis the risk of a further episode in each subsequent
pregnancy is between one in three and one in five. For those with a previous psychiatric history or a
family history the risk is higher; for those whose puerperal episode was associated with life events or
Caesarean section the subsequent risk is lower.
MENOPAUSE
General population surveys indicate no major effect of the menopause on a variety of common
psychiatric symptoms. If anything, women in the post-menopausal years show less evidence of
psychiatric disturbance than younger women.
438 Disorders specific to women
Anxiety and depression in post-menopausal women do not respond to oestrogen therapy, but
may respond to antidepressants. Where sexual symptoms are present, hormone replacement
therapy may be effective. There is some evidence that hormone replacement therapy ameliorates
psychological symptoms after surgical menopause.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ashby, C.R., Carr, L.A., Cook, C.L. et al. 1992: Inhibition of serotonin uptake in rat brain synaptosomes by plasma
from patients with pre-menstrual syndrome. Biological Psychiatry 31:1169–1171.
Ballinger, C.B. 1990: Psychiatric aspects of the menopause. British Journal of Psychiatry 156:773–787.
Bancroft, J. & Rennie, D. 1993: The impact of oral contraceptives on the experience of premenstrual mood,
clumsiness, food craving and other symptoms. Journal of Psychosomatic Research 37:195–202.
Condon, J.T. 1993: The pre-menstrual syndrome: a twin study. British Journal of Psychiatry 162:481–486.
Cooper, P.J. & Murray, L. 1995: Course and recurrence of postnatal depression: evidence for the specificity of the
diagnostic concept. British Journal of Psychiatry 166:191–195.
Craddock, N., Brockington, I., Mant, R. et al. 1994: Bipolar affective puerperal psychosis associated with
consanguinity. British Journal of Psychiatry 164:359–364.
Dowlatshahi, D. & Paykel, E.S. 1990: Life events and social stress in puerperal psychoses: absence of effect.
Psychological Medicine 20:655–662.
Eriksson, E., Sundblad, C., Lisjo, P. et al. 1992: Serum levels of androgens are higher in women with pre-menstrual
irritability and dysphoria than in controls. Psychoneuroendocrinology 17:195–204.
Friedman, T. & Gath, D. 1989: The psychiatric consequences of spontaneous abortion. British Journal of Psychiatry
155:810–813.
Giannini, A.J., Melemis, S.M., Martin, D.M. et al. 1994: Symptoms of pre-menstrual syndrome as a function of
beta-endorphin: two subtypes. Progress in Neuropsychopharmacology and Biological Psychiatry 18:321–327.
Gilchrist, A.C., Hannaford, P.C., Frank, P. et al. 1995: Termination of pregnancy and psychiatric morbidity. British
Journal of Psychiatry 167:243–248.
Hannah, P., Adams, D., Lee, A. et al. 1992: Links between early post-partum mood and post-natal depression.
British Journal of Psychiatry 160:777–780.
Harris, B. 1994: Biological and hormonal aspects of postpartum depressed mood: working towards strategies for
prophylaxis and treatment. British Journal of Psychiatry 164:288–292.
Hicks, R.A., Olsen, C. & Smith Robinson, D. 1986: Type A-B behaviour and the pre-menstrual syndrome.
Psychological Reports 59:353–354.
Iles, S., Gath, D. & Kennerley, H. 1989: Maternity blues: II. A comparison between post-operative women and
post-natal women. British Journal of Psychiatry 155:363–366.
Kantero, R. & Widholm, O. 1971: Correlations of menstrual traits between adolescent girls and their mothers. Acta
Obstetrica and Gynecologica Scandinavica 14 (Suppl. 14):30–36.
Kendell, R.E., Chalmers, J.C. & Platz, C.L. 1987: Epidemiology of puerperal psychoses. British Journal of Psychiatry
150:662–673.
Kennerley, H. & Gath, D. 1989: Maternity blues: III. Associations with obstetric psychological and psychiatric
factors. British Journal of Psychiatry 155:367–373.
Logue, C.M. & Moos, R.H. 1986: Pre-menstrual symptoms: prevalence and risk factors. Psychosomatic Medicine
48:388–414.
Murray, D., Cox, J.L. Chapman, G. et al. 1995: Childbirth: life event or start of a long term difficulty? Further data
from the Stoke-on-Trent controlled study of postnatal depression. British Journal of Psychiatry 166:595–600.
O’Hare, T. & Creed, F. 1995: Life events and miscarriage. British Journal of Psychiatry 167:799–805.
Bibliography 439
Paykel, E.S., Emms, E.M., Fletcher, J. et al. 1980: Life events and social supports in puerperal depression. British
Journal of Psychiatry 136:339–346.
Pearce, J., Hawton, K. & Blake, F. 1995: Psychological and sexual symptoms associated with the menopause and
the effects of hormone replacement therapy. British Journal of Psychiatry 167:163–173.
Schmidt, P., Grover, G.N. & Rubinow, D.R. 1993: Alprazolam in the treatment of pre-menstrual syndrome: a
double-blind placebo-controlled trial. Archives of General Psychiatry 50:467–473.
Stein, A., Gath, D.H., Bucher, J. et al. 1991: The relationship between post-natal depression and mother-child
interaction. British Journal of Psychiatry 158:46–52.
Stein, D., Hanukoglu, S., Blank, S. et al. 1993: Cyclic psychosis associated with the menstrual cycle. British Journal
of Psychiatry 163:824–828.
Sundblad, C., Hedberg, M.A. & Eriksson, E. 1993: Clomipramine administered during the luteal phase reduces the
symptoms of pre-menstrual syndrome: a placebo controlled trial. Neuropsychopharmacology 9:133–145.
Warner, P. & Bancroft, J. 1990: Factors related to self-reporting of the pre-menstrual syndrome. British Journal of
Psychiatry 157:249–260.
Wieck, A., Kumar, R., Hirst, A.D. et al. 1991: Increased sensitivity of dopamine receptors and recurrence of
affective psychosis after childbirth. British Medical Journal 303:613–616.
Zolese, G. & Blacker, C.V.R. 1992: The psychological complications of therapeutic abortion. British Journal of
Psychiatry 160:742–749.
This page intentionally left blank
31
Sexual disorders
HISTORY
∑ In 1910, Havelock Ellis, a British pioneer, was the first to subject normal as well as pathological
sexuality to scientific investigation.
∑ Starting in 1948, Kinsey and associates conducted landmark research into human sexual
experience in thousands of men and women. A wide range of human sexual expression was
noted. Methodological problems included non-random sampling. Volunteers were recruited
from a variety of sources, with a non-representative excess of college-educated people.
Criminals and sex offenders were also over-represented. Despite these shortcomings, their
findings have been generalized to the wider population and remained authoritative for decades
in the absence of methodologically superior work.
∑ In 1981, acquired immune deficiency syndrome (AIDS) was first described in the USA. It was
initially believed to be confined to a small group of promiscuous homosexual men.
Subsequently a primarily heterosexual worldwide epidemic of major proportions has
developed.
∑ The proportion occurring before age 16 has increased over time. Fewer than 1% of women aged
55 or over report heterosexual intercourse before the age of 16, compared to 20% of those in
their teens.
∑ There has been a convergence in behaviour of men and women over time.
∑ People today are more likely to use contraception (usually condoms) than those of a previous
generation. However, the earlier first intercourse occurs, the less likely it is that contraception is
used.
∑ Early intercourse is associated with lower social class and lower educational level.
∑ Now there is more planning and less spontaneity than formerly.
∑ The majority of intercourse occurs within an established relationship.
∑ Young women tend to be initiated by an older male. Men’s first partners tend to be age peers.
∑ It is very rare for men’s first sexual intercourse to be with a prostitute.
HETEROSEXUAL PARTNERSHIPS
∑ Age and marital status are associated with multiple partnerships. The young and those
previously married or single (including cohabitees) are most likely to report high partner
numbers.
∑ There is increasing partner change with increasing social class.
∑ There are increasing numbers of partners over historical time.
∑ The proportion reporting multiple partnerships in the last five years declines with increasing
age.
∑ Serial monogamy is more common in those aged 16–24. Concurrent partnerships are more
common in those over the age of 35.
∑ Sex with a prostitute in the last five years is most common in the 25–34 year age group.
∑ Raised odds of ever using a prostitute are associated with age, previous marriage or current
cohabitation, working away from home, and a history of having a homosexual partner.
HETEROSEXUAL PRACTICES
∑ Frequency of heterosexual sex (oral, vaginal or anal intercourse) shows wide variability, with a
small proportion of the population reporting a very high frequency of sexual contact.
∑ Age is closely related to the number of acts, frequency peaking in mid-twenties, then gradually
declining.
∑ Frequency is affected by partner availability, being highest in married and cohabiting groups of
all ages.
∑ There is a strong association in all age groups between length of relationship and frequency of
sex: a much lower frequency in longer relationships.
∑ Vaginal intercourse predominates. Seventy-five per cent have experience of non-penetrative sex
and 70% have some experience of oral sex. Any experience of anal intercourse is reported by
14% of men and 13% of women.
∑ Practice of oral sex has increased, but not as a substitute to vaginal intercourse.
∑ Those not married have a wider repertoire of sexual practice. Prevalence of oral, anal and non-
penetrative sex increases with increasing numbers of partners.
∑ Those outside married or cohabiting relationships have less frequent sex overall, but are more
likely to have multiple partners, a wider range of practices and recent experience of high-risk
practices.
History 443
SEXUAL ATTITUDES
∑ Acceptance of premarital sex is now nearly universal, as is its practice.
∑ Disapproval of infidelity extends to all age groups, the young being marginally more tolerant
than older people.
∑ The British public show widespread condemnation of homosexual relationships. Women are
more tolerant than men.
∑ Sex is not considered the most important part of a relationship; a monogamous relationship is
considered more likely to lead to greater sexual satisfaction.
PHYSICAL HEALTH
∑ Multiple sexual partnerships are significantly associated with smoking and increasing levels of
alcohol consumption.
∑ Attendance at a clinic for sexually transmitted diseases (STDs) is strongly associated with the
number of heterosexual partners and a history of homosexual partnerships.
∑ There is a strong relationship between sexual behaviour and the probability of STD clinic
attendance, abortion and HIV testing.
∑ No relationship is detected between the numbers of heterosexual partners and experience of
infertility or miscarriage.
∑ The likelihood of termination of pregnancy increases markedly with the numbers of
heterosexual partners.
PERCEIVED RISK
∑ Fewer than 10% of the British public is at risk of unplanned pregnancy.
∑ The use of oral contraception declines steeply with age; condom use is most prevalent in the
young; sterilization increases with age.
444 Sexual disorders
∑ The message to use condoms to prevent the risks of STD has been more acceptable than the
message to restrict numbers of partners.
∑ The perceived risk of HIV infection is higher among those reporting higher risk behaviours.
∑ Despite the uptake of messages about condom use, there is little sign of the widespread adoption
of other safer sex practices among those reporting heterosexual behaviour.
SEXUAL DYSFUNCTION
The normal sexual response cycle consists of: desire; arousal, mediated by the parasympathetic
nervous system; plateau; orgasm, mediated by the sympathetic and central nervous system;
resolution (longer in males and increases with age).
With sexual dysfunctioning the individual is unable to participate in a sexual relationship as he
or she would wish. Both psychological and somatic processes are usually involved in the causation
of sexual dysfunction. Women present more commonly with complaints about the subjective
quality of sexual experience; men present with a failure of specific sexual response.
ICD-10 classification
ICD-10 categorizes Sexual dysfunction not caused by organic disorder or disease under ‘Behavioural
syndromes associated with physiological disturbances and physical factors’, as follows:
∑ Lack or loss of sexual desire. This is not secondary to other sexual difficulties. It does not preclude
sexual enjoyment or arousal, but makes initiation of sexual activity less likely.
∑ Sexual aversion. Sexual interaction is associated with strong negative feelings of sufficient
intensity that sexual activity is avoided.
∑ Lack of sexual enjoyment. Sexual responses and orgasm occur normally but there is a lack of
pleasure. This is much more common in women.
∑ Failure of genital response. In men this is primarily erectile dysfunction. In women it is primarily
due to vaginal dryness.
∑ Orgasmic dysfunction. Orgasm does not occur or is delayed. It is more common in women than
men.
∑ Premature ejaculation. This is the inability to control ejaculation sufficiently for both partners to
enjoy the sex act.
∑ Non-organic vaginismus. This is occlusion of the vaginal opening caused by spasm of the
surrounding muscles. Penile entry is either impossible or painful.
∑ Non-organic dyspareunia. Pain during intercourse may occur in both sexes. The term is used
only if an organic cause is not present, and if there is no other primary sexual dysfunction.
∑ Excessive sexual drive. This usually occurs in men or women during late teenage or early adult
years. If it is secondary to mental illness (e.g. mania) the underlying disorder is coded.
Sensate-focus therapy
Masters and Johnson (1970) described behavioural psychotherapy involving a couple in graded
assignments which may be modified according to the particular problem presenting. The process is
used extensively in the treatment of sexual disorders affecting both men and women. It consists of a
Erectile dysfunction 445
combination of specified homework tasks together with setting specific limits to the extent of sexual
contact allowed.
∑ Stage 1: Touching partner without genital contact for subject’s own pleasure.
∑ Stage 2: Touching partner without genital contact for subject’s and partner’s pleasure.
∑ Stage 3: Touching partner with genital contact, but intercourse not permitted.
∑ Stage 4: Simultaneous touching of partner and being touched by partner with genital contact,
but intercourse not permitted.
∑ Stage 5: If both feel ready, the female invites the male to put his penis into her vagina. Female in
the top position heightens female control and allows the male to relax. No thrusting is allowed.
Initial containment is brief, being lengthened with each session.
∑ Stage 6: Vaginal containment with movement is allowed. Different positions are encouraged.
This does not inevitably lead to climax. The couple should practise stopping before climax.
Provided physical contact is pleasurable orgasm is not necessary.
ERECTILE DYSFUNCTION
NORMAL PHYSIOLOGY
Erection is a neurovascular phenomenon requiring an intact arterial supply and intact venous
valves, allowing cavernosal pressures to rise to those approaching systolic blood pressures. Vascular
changes are brought about by the parasympathetic autonomic nervous system (S2, 3, 4) influenced
by tactile stimuli and central limbic and cognitive mechanisms. Psychic erections are mediated by
thoracic sympathetic outflow, whereas reflex erections result from sacral parasympathetic outflow.
Androgens also influence erection, particularly those occurring in sleep, via the limbic system.
ORGANIC CAUSES
Local organic causes
∑ Peyronie’s disease. There is progressive fibrosis in the tunica albuginea and sometimes also in the
cavernosa, resulting in curvature of the penis on erection. The cause is unknown.
∑ Congenital deformities. Examples are hypospadias and epispadias, or the absence of suspensory
ligaments.
∑ Priapism. Although rare, priapism may result in impotence if not treated adequately within 24
hours.
446 Sexual disorders
Endocrine causes
∑ Diabetes causes a combination of arteriopathy and neuropathy. Two-thirds of diabetic males
have erectile impotence. Of these it is complete in two-thirds and partial in the remaining third.
A few also complain of other difficulties such as premature ejaculation. Onset is insidious, the
course progressive with marked decline in sexual activity and desire.
∑ Nocturnal erections are androgen-dependent. Studies are conflicting on the role of androgens in
erectile disorders. Effects are probably mediated through lowered sexual interest.
∑ Hyperprolactinaemia may be secondary to hypothalamic/pituitary disease. It occurs in those on
phenothiazines, and sometimes in alcoholics.
∑ Naltrexone (endorphin) therapy significantly improves impotence in males with an apparent
non-organic cause. Alteration in central opioid tone may be responsible.
Neurological causes
∑ There may be peripheral or autonomic neuropathy (e.g. in diabetes, alcoholism).
∑ Radical pelvic surgery may cause autonomic neurological disruption.
∑ There may be a spinal cord lesion (e.g. transection, multiple sclerosis).
Vascular causes
∑ Arterial disease can interfere with the blood supply to pelvic organs.
∑ Venous valves may be incompetent.
PHARMACOLOGICAL FACTORS
Alcohol has complex effects, including neuropathy and indirect effects on sex steroids and
gonadotrophins. Oestrogen levels are raised causing gynacomastia and testicular atrophy in
advanced liver disease. Raised blood alcohol levels inhibit sexual responses through central
inhibitory effects. Psychosocial factors are also prominent in these patients.
Ganglion blockers (antihypertensives) interfere with both sympathetic and parasympathetic
postganglionic transmission and cause both impotence and ejaculatory failure. Propranolol crosses
the blood–brain barrier and may exert its effect centrally. Alpha-adrenergic blockers are not
associated with erectile failure, but cause ejaculatory failure.
PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS
The classical history of the disorder that is suggestive of a psychological cause comprises lack of
sexual interest but continued morning erections.
Psychoanalytic concepts
Sexual physiological changes result from the interplay between conscious and unconscious thoughts
and feelings, and interpersonal relationships. Anxiety and fear, whether conscious or unconscious,
can interfere with vascular changes required for erection. Arousal-phase disorders of erectile
dysfunction in men are common. Interference with abandonment to erotic feelings can impair
arousal in men and lead to difficulties with erection.
Psychoanalytic formulations of erectile disorders recognize anxiety about the persecutory object
and unresolved Oedipal conflicts. Deep ambivalence about intimate involvement leading to fear of
sexual failure is common.
Erectile dysfunction 447
In younger men with primary impotence, Oedipal conflicts are said to predominate, whereas in
secondary impotence, neurotic partnership conflicts at a pre-Oedipal level, and narcissistic crises in
middle age are said to predominate.
Cognitive concepts
Erectile disorder is considered to be a sign of negative self-image within a depressive view of the
relationship, and is linked to abandonment fear.
Subjects with psychogenic erectile impotence have a situational sexual disorder in which sexual
anxiety plays an important role. Compared to those with organic impotence or to controls, they
view themselves as more insecure and tend to over-idealize their partners and their mothers.
Consideration should also be given to the following:
∑ fear of hurting the female
∑ fear of pregnancy
∑ distaste for female genitalia
∑ placing the partner on a pedestal
∑ non-sexual stress
∑ unsympathetic or angry partner
∑ trying too hard.
blood flow. Such drugs should be used with caution if the penis is deformed (for example, in
angulation, cavernosal fibrosis, and Peyronie’s disease).
Apomorphine
Sublingually administered apomorphine is licensed for the treatment of erectile dysfunction.
Vasovagal symptoms (including sweating and syncope) can occur infrequently.
Suction devices
Vacuum tumescence constriction therapy is efficacious and useful in those with organic as well as
psychogenic impotence. These devices provide a safe method of obtaining an erection adequate for
Premature ejaculation 449
penetration in up to 90% of patients. Many couples derive substantial benefit from their use, but the
disadvantages of a not fully rigid erection, lack of spontaneity, decreased sensation and delayed or
absent ejaculation in some limit their acceptability.
Vascular surgery
Correction of venous leak may be successful if a specific leak is detected. Arterial surgery is less
successful. Large vessel reconstruction for proximal arterial obstruction generally gives poor results,
as most patients also have distal arterial disease.
PSYCHOLOGICAL TREATMENTS
Counselling
Practical advice about sexual technique is essential for all forms of treatment, even if the main
treatment is physical.
Psychotherapy
Cognitive–behavioural methods report success rates of 70% for erectile impotence. Couple therapy
appears to be superior to surrogate or individual therapies. Factors associated with successful
outcome include the state of the marriage, better pre-treatment communication, better general
sexual adjustment, female partner’s interest and enjoyment of sex, absence of psychiatric history in
the female partner, and early engagement in homework assignments.
Sensate focus therapy may need to be combined with other methods, such as improvement in
communication skills. Once erections are starting to occur a form of ‘paradoxical intent’ may be
used, in which the couple is instructed to get rid of the erection as soon as it occurs, and then to
resume touching. The purpose is to demonstrate that erections do not need to be used as soon as
they arise.
Psychodynamic therapists challenge disturbing fantasies, and prevent their re-enactment. The
patient is offered a psychotherapeutic ‘holding’ to counteract the unsafe internal world. Gradually
he becomes freed from his sexually disempowering psychic reality to respond to the external reality
of erotic stimulation. Behavioural interventions may also be incorporated into the treatment.
PREMATURE EJACULATION
NORMAL PHYSIOLOGY
Orgasm, seminal emission and ejaculation are physiologically distinct processes, and are potentially
separable.
450 Sexual disorders
Ejaculation is the forceful expulsion of semen from the urethra. If semen is released from the
urethra without force it is emission. Before orgasm the male becomes aware that ejaculation is
imminent and it follows within 1–3 seconds – ‘ejaculatory inevitability’. Ejaculation and emission
are mediated by the a-adrenergic sympathetic nervous system. Androgens have a role, since the first
sexual consequence of castration is the inability to ejaculate, which is rapidly restored with
androgen replacement.
In severe premature ejaculation, emission alone may occur with no ejaculatory component,
minimal or absent orgasm and a long refractory period.
In youth, males have a tendency to ejaculate quickly. This usually diminishes with increasing age
because of increasing control with experience, an ability to recognize the approach of ejaculatory
inevitability, the dampening in responsiveness with age, and the lessening of novelty which arises in
a stable relationship.
PHYSICAL FACTORS
There are few physical causes. Drugs do not cause premature ejaculation. It is possible that the
autonomic control of ejaculation is very sensitive and therefore more difficult to control in some
individuals.
Those with premature ejaculation do not have penile hypersensitivity compared to controls.
No differences in the pituitary gonadal system are found between those with erectile impotence,
premature ejaculation and normal controls.
stop, allow his arousal level to subside slightly and then return to being caressed, repeating the
process again when arousal increases.
If difficulty is experienced using this method, then the ‘squeeze technique’ is used. Just before
ejaculation becomes inevitable, stimulation is stopped and the tip of the penis is grasped firmly for
about 10 seconds, reducing the reflex ejaculatory response.
At therapeutic doses some antidepressants (e.g. fluoxetine) have a beneficial effect in men with
premature ejaculation.
ANORGASMIA
NORMAL PHYSIOLOGY
The final stage of sexual excitement may be orgasm. In both sexes if no orgasm occurs, there is a slow
resolution of physical and psychological changes associated with sexual excitement. Apart from
ejaculation for which there is no female counterpart, the correlates of orgasm are similar in the
sexes. Heart rate and blood pressure increase, there is a sudden increase in skeletal muscle activity
involving almost all parts of the body. Rhythmic muscle contractions in the male genital tract expel
semen; in females there is transient rhythmical contraction of the uterus and vagina. Psychologically
there is an instant sense of relief; at its most extreme there can be a virtual loss of consciousness, and
relaxation ensues.
The exact mechanism of orgasm is not known. In addition to local spinal mechanisms, the
central nervous activity is also involved. EEG recordings during intense orgasm show changes which
have been likened to those occurring during epileptic fits.
Epidemiology of anorgasmia
The prevalence in community samples is around 5–10% for inhibited female orgasm, and 4–10%
for inhibited male orgasm. Among attendees at a sexual disorders clinic, 5% of males and 7% of
females present primarily with orgasmic dysfunction. In females the prevalence of anorgasmia
reduces with increasing age.
Aetiology of anorgasmia
Little is known.
PHYSICAL FACTORS
∑ In primary complete anorgasmia in both sexes, the bulbocavernosus reflex has been reported to
be absent in a proportion; this is strongly correlated with the failure of treatment.
∑ Sometimes local pain, possibly secondary to muscle spasm, or in local viscera (uterus, rectum)
can create fear of orgasm.
∑ Opiates appear to have a direct inhibitory effect, and antiserotonergic drugs inhibit orgasm.
∑ Female anorgasmia has been reported in association with tricyclic, MAOI, and SSRI
antidepressants, and neuroleptic drugs.
452 Sexual disorders
PSYCHOLOGICAL FACTORS
The aetiology of anorgasmia is usually psychological. Anxiety inhibits orgasm in women but can
hasten emission in men. Sex may be viewed as bad, disgusting or threatening the need to remain in
control at all times. There may be a fear of pregnancy or venereal disease.
Management of anorgasmia
Sociocultural expectations and deficits in skills and sexual techniques are the two most important
factors present in most cases. Direct masturbation training is the treatment of choice.
Treatment may take place in individual, couple or group settings. Tasks include relaxation,
fantasizing and masturbation. Treatment is often successful, but the generalization of orgasm
induced by masturbation to that induced by intercourse does not always occur.
VAGINISMUS
NORMAL PHYSIOLOGY
When sexually aroused, the upper two-thirds of the vagina are lax and capacious, whereas the lower
third is closely invested by the surrounding musculature of the pelvic floor. The strongest of these
muscles is the levator ani which forms a U-shaped sling around the posterior and lateral vaginal
wall. Intense spasm in a nulliparous woman can virtually occlude the vagina. If these muscles are too
tense, vaginal entry is impaired and painful – a condition known as vaginismus. A vicious circle
ensues; pain or anticipation of pain causes further muscle contraction thereby increasing the
likelihood of experiencing pain.
Epidemiology of vaginismus
Ten per cent of women presenting to a sexual disorders clinic have a primary presentation of
vaginismus.
Aetiology of vaginismus
The majority of cases are primary. The problem was evident at first attempt at intercourse, and
usually the woman has been reluctant to introduce anything to her vagina previously.
Occasionally onset can be related to a traumatic episode such as a painful vaginal examination or
rape.
Sometimes vaginismus results from ambivalence about the relationship, or it may be secondary
to reluctance to assume the mature adult’s role. Irrational fears may also underlie the condition.
Management of vaginismus
Emphasis is upon helping the woman to gain comfort in exploring her own genitalia and inserting
her finger. Finger insertion may be all that is required, combined with sensate-focus techniques.
Disorders of gender identity 453
Additional dilatation may be required using graded dilators. Initially carried out on her own, the
partner is included when her confidence has increased.
Classification
The ICD-10 classification codes Gender identity disorders under ‘Disorders of adult personality and
behaviour’.
TRANSSEXUALISM
There is the desire to live as a member of the opposite sex; discomfort with anatomic sex; a wish to
change body into that of the preferred sex.
It must have been persistently present for two years; it must not be a symptom of another mental
disorder such as schizophrenia, or be associated with an intersex, genetic or sex-chromosomal
abnormality.
DUAL-ROLE TRANSVESTISM
This includes the wearing of clothes of the opposite sex for part of the time to enjoy the temporary
experience of membership of the opposite sex, without the desire for a more permanent sex change.
No sexual excitement accompanies this cross-dressing, distinguishing it from fetishistic
transvestism.
SEXUAL DEVIATION
Classification
The ICD-10 classification codes sexual deviation as Disorders of sexual preference under ‘Disorders
of adult personality and behaviour’.
FETISHISM
Fetishism is the reliance on some non-living object as a stimulus for sexual arousal and gratification.
It is often an extension of the human body such as clothing or footwear. It is often characterized by
texture such as plastic, rubber or leather.
Fetishism is diagnosed only if the fetish is the most important source of sexual stimulation.
Fantasies are common but do not amount to disorder unless they are so compelling that they
interfere with sexual intercourse and lead to distress.
FETISHISTIC TRANSVESTISM
Fetishistic transvestism is the wearing of clothes of the opposite sex to obtain sexual excitement.
More than a single item is worn, often an entire outfit. It is clearly associated with sexual arousal;
there is no wish to continue cross-dressing once orgasm occurs, distinguishing this from transsexual
transvestism.
EXHIBITIONISM
Exhibitionism is the recurrent or persistent tendency to expose the genitalia to strangers or people
(usually of the opposite sex) in public places. There is usually sexual excitement at the time, often
followed by masturbation. The tendency may only manifest at times of emotional stress or crisis,
without such behaviour between.
It is almost entirely limited to heterosexual males, exhibiting to adult or adolescent females,
usually from a safe distance in a public place. For some it is their only sexual outlet; for others they
may also continue a normal sex life.
A reaction in the victim heightens the excitement in the perpetrator.
VOYEURISM
Voyeurism is the persistent tendency to look at people engaging in sexual behaviour or undressing.
It usually leads to sexual excitement and masturbation. The victim is usually unaware.
PAEDOPHILIA
Paedophilia is the sexual preference for children, usually prepubertal or pubertal. Some are attracted
to either one or both sexes.
It is rare in women. Included in this diagnosis are those men who retain a preference for adult sex
partners, but when frustrated in their efforts turn to children as substitutes.
SADOMASOCHISM
Sadomasochism is the preference for sexual activity that involves the infliction of pain or
humiliation. It is diagnosed only if this is the most important source of sexual stimulation.
Antisocial sexual behaviour 455
SEXUAL ORIENTATION
Sexual disorientation alone is no longer classed as a disorder. ICD-10 allows for variations of sexual
development or orientation that are problematic for the individual:
∑ heterosexual
∑ homosexual
∑ bisexual
∑ other, including prepubertal.
Evidence suggestive of a genetic basis to sexual orientation is provided in twin studies with 52%
MZ to 22% DZ concordance in homosexual males, and 48% MZ to 16% DZ concordance in female
homosexuals. Hamer et al. (1993) carried out a family pedigree study in which the distribution of
homosexuality in the male relatives suggested a sex-linked inheritance. They found convincing
evidence in this family of a correlation between homosexual orientation and the inheritance of
polymorphous markers at the Xq28 region of the X chromosome.
The acceptability of sexual behaviour is determined by society and is incorporated into the law.
What constitutes unacceptable behaviour varies largely between cultures and within the same
culture over time.
Antisocial sexual behaviours can be divided into two groups:
∑ ‘normal’ activities carried out inappropriately, without consent or with the wrong age group
∑ sexual activity which is morally perverse.
∑ Sociopathic rapist. These have poor social adjustment with criminality, a poor work record,
involve substance abuse, and have unstable relationships. Rape is often impulsive, with
immediate gratification and little regard to the consequences. Threats of violence are common.
∑ Sexually inadequate rapist. These are shy, timid and insecure, lacking social skills. They often
plan a rape against an attractive or sexually threatening woman.
∑ Sadistic rapist. These have a deep-rooted hatred of women arising from early relationships. The
object of the rape is the infliction of humiliation and suffering; intercourse may be trivial in
comparison to humiliating acts and the serious injuries inflicted. The rape is often carefully
planned; precautions are taken to avoid detection.
∑ Psychotic rapist. These constitute a very small proportion of rapists. The rape is often bizarre,
violent and terrifying for the victim.
PAEDOPHILIA
Paedophilia is the sexual attraction and preference for partners who are physically immature.
Offenders are mostly men. Some prefer child victims of the opposite sex, some of the same sex.
About 10% are bisexual in their preference.
Adolescent offenders have a better prognosis than older offenders.
The mentally immature offender with poor social skills may prefer child sexual partners because
they are the only people with whom the person can relate at a general level.
The persistent middle-aged offender often has evidence of personality problems with poor
relationships and unstable work patterns. These offenders usually have low rather than high sex
drives. There is often an emotional bond between them and their child victims.
Some paedophiles are more dangerous than those described above. This offender has evidence of
a serious personality disturbance affecting more aspects of his or her life than choice of sexual outlet.
Killing a child as part of a sexual offence is rare. It usually results from a state of panic, or from a
desire to dispose of the evidence.
INCEST
Incest is generally forbidden across cultures. In law it is an offence for a man to have sexual
intercourse with a woman he knows to be his daughter, grand-daughter, mother, sister or half-sister,
and for a woman over 16 to allow a man whom she knows to be her son, father, grandfather, brother
or half-brother to have sexual intercourse with her.
Sibling incest relationships are the most common, but father–daughter relationships are most
commonly seen in court. They often reflect some breakdown in the marital relationship.
Incestuous families are characterized by alienation, disorganization and disintegration. They are
rarely reported to the police.
Sibling incest is often the result of experimentation. It is more likely if there is a lack of parental
control. Youngest sisters are the most vulnerable.
INDECENT EXPOSURE
Indecent exposure is an offence under the 1824 Vagrancy Act: ‘openly, lewdly and obscenely
exposing his person with intent to insult any female’. It is one of the most common sexual offences.
Exhibitionism, the exposing of genitals to the opposite sex, is categorized into the following two
main groups:
∑ Type I – inhibited young men of relatively normal personality and good character who struggle
against the impulse but find it irresistible. They expose with a flaccid penis and do not
Bibliography 457
masturbate. They expose to individuals, not seeking a particular response. The frequency of
exposure is often related to other sexual stresses and anxieties, such as marital conflict or
pregnancy in the spouse.
∑ Type II – less inhibited, more sociopathic men. Individuals expose with erect penis in a state of
excitement, and may masturbate. Pleasure is obtained and little guilt is shown. The person is
more likely to expose to a group of women or girls, and may return repeatedly to the same place.
The person seeks a response from the victim, either shock or disgust. There are fewer attempts to
resist the urge to expose. The behaviour is associated with other psychosexual disorders and
other types of offences. This may lead on to more serious sexual offences.
Eighty per cent do not reoffend if they are charged with a first offence. The chances of
reconviction rise dramatically with the second offence. There is a small group of recidivists who
persist, but these tend to reduce in their forties. It is generally a harmless non-violent offence, except
in a minority who may progress to more violent offences.
There is a good prognosis associated with being married, good social relationships and work record.
Others
∑ Fetishism may come to the attention of the police if articles used are stolen (e.g. women’s
underwear).
∑ Sadomasochism may result in conviction for assault if extreme injury results, even if both parties
consent.
∑ Transvestites may be charged with behaviour likely to cause a breach of the peace if they cross-
dress in public.
∑ Frotteurism is the practice of rubbing the penis against another person in a clandestine way in a
public place. It is liable to charges of either indecent assault or offence against public order.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Bancroft, J. 1983: Human Sexuality and its Problems. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Bancroft, J. 1994: Homosexual orientation: the search for a biological basis. British Journal of Psychiatry
164:437–440.
Bancroft, J. 1995: Sexual disorders. In Kendell, R.E. & Zealley, A.K. (eds) Companion to Psychiatric Studies, 5th edn.
Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Brindley, G.S. & Gillian, P. 1982: Men and women who do not have orgasms. British Journal of Psychiatry
140:351–356.
Cooper, A.J., Cernovsky, Z.Z. & Colussi, K. 1993: Some clinical and psychometric characteristics of primary and
secondary premature ejaculators. Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy 19:276–288.
458 Sexual disorders
Derogatis, L.R., Schmidt, C.W., Fagan, P.J. et al. 1989: Subtypes of anorgasmia via mathematical taxonomy.
Psychosomatics 30:166–173.
Fabbri, A., Jannini, E.A., Gnessi, L. et al. 1989: Endorphins in male impotence: evidence for naltrexone stimulation
of erectile activity in patient therapy. Psychoneuroendocrinology 14:103–111.
Gilbert, H.W. & Gingell, J.C. 1991: The results of an intracorporeal papaverine clinic. Sex and Marital Therapy
6:49– 56.
Gregoire, A. 1992: New treatments for erectile impotence. British Journal of Psychiatry 160:315–326.
Hamer, D.H., Hu, S., Magnuson, V.L. et al. 1993: A linkage between DNA markers on the X chromosome and male
sexual orientation. Science 261:321–327.
Hawton, K., Catalan, J. & Fagg, J. 1992: Sex therapy for erectile dysfunction: characteristics of couples, treatment
outcome and prognostic factors. Archives of Sexual Behaviour 21:161–175.
Hiller, J. 1993: Psychoanalytic concepts and psychosexual therapy: a suggested integration. Sex and Marital
Therapy 8:9–26.
Janssen, P.L. 1985: Psychodynamic study of male potency disorders: an overview. Psychotherapy and
Psychosomatics 44:6–17.
Johnson, A.M., Wadsworth, J., Wellings, K. et al. 1994: Sexual Attitudes and Lifestyles. Oxford: Blackwell
Scientific.
Kinsey, A.C., Pomeroy, W.B. & Martin, C.E. 1948: Sexual Behaviour in the Human Male. Philadelphia: W.B.
Saunders.
Kinsey, A.C., Pomeroy, W.B., Martin, C.E. et al. 1953: Sexual Behaviour in the Human Female. Philadelphia: W.B.
Saunders.
Kockett, G. 1980: Symptomatology and psychological aspects of male sexual inadequacy: results of an
experimental study. Archives of Sexual Behaviour 9:457–475.
Marshall, W.L., Jones, R., Ward, T. et al. 1991: Treatment outcome with sex offenders. Clinical Psychology Review
11:465–485.
Masters, W.H. & Johnson, V.E. 1970: Human Sexual Inadequacy. London: Churchill Livingstone.
Mishra, D.N. & Shulka, G.D. 1988: Sexual disturbances in male diabetics: phenomenological and clinical aspects.
Indian Journal of Psychiatry 30:135–143.
Pena, L.E. 1987: An analysis of female primary orgasmic dysfunction. Revista de Analisis del Comportamiento
3:151–163.
Pirke, K.M. et al. 1979: Pituitary gonadal system function in patients with erectile impotence and premature
ejaculation. Archives of Sexual Behaviour 8:41–48.
Rowland, D.L., Haensel, S.M., Blom, J.H. et al. 1993: Penile sensitivity in men with premature ejaculation and
erectile dysfunction. Journal of Sex and Marital Therapy 19:189–197.
Segraves, R.T., Taylor, R., Schoenberg, H.W. et al. 1982: Psychosexual adjustment after penile prosthesis surgery.
Sexuality and Disability 5:222–229.
Snaith, P., Tarsh, M.J. & Reid, R. 1993: Sex reassignment surgery. British Journal of Psychiatry 162:681–685.
Spector, I.P. & Carey, M.P. 1990: Incidence and prevalence of the sexual dysfunctions: a critical review of the
empirical literature. Archives of Sexual Behaviour 19:389–408.
Tondo, L., Cantone, M., Carta, M. et al. 1991: An MMPI evaluation of male sexual dysfunction. Journal of Clinical
Psychology 47:391–396.
Trick, R.L. & Tennant, T.G. 1981: Forensic Psychiatry: An Introductory Text. London: Pitman Medical.
32
Sleep disorders
CLASSIFICATION
INSOMNIA
CLINICAL FEATURES
The main result of true insomnia is daytime tiredness.
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
Important disorders that may cause insomnia, and that should therefore be excluded, include:
∑ depressive disorders
∑ mania
∑ anxiety disorders
∑ organic disorders (see Table 32.1).
460 Sleep disorders
AETIOLOGY
Table 32.1 gives the main causes of insomnia.
MANAGEMENT
The management of insomnia covers ‘sleep hygiene’, including:
∑ reduced lighting
∑ a comfortable bed
∑ a familiar and acceptable level of noise
∑ regular daytime exercise
∑ progressive muscle relaxation techniques for any associated anxiety
∑ a moderate intake of easily digested warm food
∑ sleep conditioning
∑ hypnotics (note the CSM guidelines on the prescription of benzodiazepines)
∑ behavioural approaches, particularly with children.
HYPERSOMNIA
CLINICAL FEATURES
Excessive daytime sleepiness and sleep attacks occur regularly or recurrently for short periods,
causing a disturbance of social or occupational functioning.
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
Important differential diagnoses include:
∑ narcolepsy
∑ sleep apnoea
∑ organic disorders
∑ fatigue states
∑ Kleine–Levin syndrome.
AETIOLOGY
The common causes of hypersomnia are:
∑ as an early symptom of depressive disorder
∑ unknown cause: idiopathic.
MANAGEMENT
Treat any identified underlying cause. In idiopathic hypersomnia, amphetamines and other
stimulants are occasionally used.
Disorders of the sleep–wake cycle are characterized by sleep occurring out of phase with
environmental and social cues (Zeitgebers).
DEFINITIONS
∑ Entrainment failure (rare). This refers to the independent running of the sleep–wake cycle.
∑ Delayed sleep-phase syndrome (rare). The sleep length is normal, there are no other psychiatric
symptoms, but sleep takes place later than usual.
∑ Advanced sleep-phase syndrome. The sleep length is normal, there are no other psychiatric
symptoms, but sleep takes place earlier than usual.
462 Sleep disorders
MANAGEMENT
Treat any primary disorder. If entrainment failure is secondary to a lack of sleep–wake cues in a
modality such as vision (because of poor vision, say) then cues from other modalities and a careful
routine may be employed. Advancing sleep in small increments may help in cases of delayed sleep-
phase syndrome.
PARASOMNIAS
The parasomnias are phenomena occurring as part of or alongside sleep; they are shown in
Table 32.2.
Sleepwalking (somnambulism)
Night terrors (pavor nocturnus)
Nightmares or dream anxiety
Bruxism (teeth grinding)
Nocturnal enuresis
Headbanging (jacatio capitis nocturnus)
Sleep paralysis
Nocturnal painful erections
Cluster headache
Physical symptomatology occurring at night, e.g. paroxysmal nocturnal
dyspnoea, sleep epilepsy
Sleep myoclonus
Reproduced with permission from Puri, B.K., Laking, P.J. & Treasaden, I.H. 2002:
Textbook of Psychiatry, 2nd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
In this disorder there occurs a state of altered consciousness in which, while asleep, the individual
arises and walks.
Sleep walking occurs at least once in 15% of children aged 5–12 years, and in 0.5% of adults.
Females are more affected than men (sex ratio (F:M) = 4:3).
CLINICAL FEATURES
The sufferer is difficult to awaken during an episode, and may suffer injury if sleeping in an
unfamiliar setting. Although complex behaviours, including attempted homicide, have been
described as occurring during somnambulism, in general this is not common.
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
Important differential diagnoses include:
Night terrors 463
AETIOLOGY
Somnambulism is familial in up to 20% of cases. There are no characteristic EEG changes. Sleep
laboratory studies do not lend credence to the view that somnambulism represents the acting out of
dreams.
MANAGEMENT
The person’s night-time surroundings should be made safe in order to reduce the risk of injury
during episodes. Reassurance and, sometimes, family work, anxiety-reduction techniques and small
doses of hypnotics, may help.
NIGHT TERRORS
Night (sleep) terrors occur during sleep stages 3–4, and therefore usually one to two hours after
sleep starts. In children, night terrors are common and occur on a frequent basis in 1–4%. They are
far less common in adulthood.
CLINICAL FEATURES
The affected person, usually a child, awakes terrified and screaming, but little is recalled the
following morning. Enuresis may occur during an episode.
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
The main differential diagnosis is nightmares.
AETIOLOGY
Aetiological factors that have been suggested include:
∑ stress
∑ previous loss of sleep
∑ familial
∑ induction by benzodiazepine antagonists (hence the theories about benzodiazepine receptor
changes or endogenous substances acting on benzodiazepine receptors)
∑ upper airway obstruction in children.
MANAGEMENT
Methods that may be tried include:
∑ reassurance – of the child and the parents
∑ changing the settling routine
∑ keeping a diary and then waking the child just before each episode is expected.
464 Sleep disorders
NIGHTMARES
CLINICAL FEATURES
Nightmares tend to occur during middle and late sleep; they usually occur during REM sleep, but
occasionally during stages 1–2. They cause awakening, when the dream is remembered.
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
The main differential diagnosis is night (sleep) terrors.
AETIOLOGY
Aetiological factors that have been suggested include:
∑ negative dreams associated with:
∑ daytime depression
∑ daytime anxiety
∑ daytime stress
∑ hypnotic withdrawal
∑ alcohol withdrawal
∑ medications:
∑ b-adrenoceptor antagonists
∑ reserpine.
MANAGEMENT
Any underlying disorder may require treatment. The nightmares themselves do not need to be
treated.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Laking, P.J. 2002: Sleep disorders. In Puri, B.K. Laking P.J. & Treasaden, I.H. (eds) Textbook of Psychiatry, 2nd edn.
Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Parkes, J.D. 1985: Sleep and its Disorders. London: W.B. Saunders.
33
Personality disorders
HISTORY
PERSONALITY DEVELOPMENT
∑ Normothetic theories are concerned with personality structure based on studies of populations.
∑ Ideographic theories relate to individual uniqueness, based on the study of the individual.
Constructs are arranged into hierarchies. Superordinate constructs are central to the individual’s
sense of identity; subordinate constructs are less so.
According to this theory, anxiety results when the individual is presented with events outside the
range of personal constructs. Hostility comprises the imposition of constructs upon another.
Bannister’s repertory grid can be used to assess an individual’s attitudes with respect to a series of
bipolar constructs. (It can also be used to measure formal thought disorder.)
ROGER’S SELF-THEORY
Each individual has a drive to fulfil himself or herself and develop an ideal self within a phenomenal
field of subjective experience. The most important aspect of personality is the congruence between
the individual’s view of the self and reality and his or her view of the self compared to the ideal self.
If an individual acts at variance to his or her own self-image, anxiety, incongruence and denial
result. The congruent individual is able to grow (self-actualization) and achieve personal potential
both internally and socially.
PSYCHOANALYTIC THEORY
Behaviour and feelings are explained by unconscious drives and conflicts.
∑ The id is derived from the libido. Irrational, impulsive instincts are unable to postpone
gratification, and are present at birth.
∑ The ego develops as the child grows. A conscious mind balances the demands of the id with the
realities of the outside world. Anxiety results if the ego is unable to control the energies of the id.
∑ The superego comprises the internalization of the views of parents and society, like a conscience.
The id, the ego and the superego are in balance with each other.
SITUATIONIST APPROACH
The external situation is considered the most powerful determinant of behaviour. Situationists
maintain that traits result from differences in learning experiences. Behaviour changes according to
the situation in which an individual finds himself or herself. Proponents dismiss the trait theory.
Mischel (1983) argues against the existence of any stable personality dimension because of the poor
correlation between behaviour or attitudes in one situation compared with another.
INTERACTIONIST MODEL
Behaviour depends upon the situation as well as personality traits.
Eysenck’s theory
Factor analysis of rating scale data yields orthogonal dimensions, assumed to be normally
distributed:
∑ neuroticism/stability
∑ extroversion/introversion
468 Personality disorders
∑ psychoticism/stability
∑ intelligence.
Personality inventories have been used to measure these traits. The MPI (Maudsley Personality
Inventory) was superseded by the EPI (Eysenck Personality Inventory), which in turn was
superseded by the EPQ (Eysenck Personality Questionnaire) – measuring psychoticism and
containing a lie scale.
These are primarily categorical classifications, but they incorporate a dimensional approach,
allowing the recording of personality traits subthreshold for a diagnosis of personality disorder.
ICD-10 classifications
Severe disturbance in characterological constitution and behavioural tendencies, involving several
areas of the personality, is associated with personal and social disruption. This diagnosis is usually
inappropriate before the age of 16–17 years.
ICD-10 and DSM-IV-TR classifications 469
DSM-IV-TR classification
GENERAL DIAGNOSTIC CRITERIA
A Enduring pattern of inner experience and behaviour, deviates markedly from expectations of
individual’s culture. Manifested in:
∑ 1 – cognition
∑ 2 – affectivity
∑ 3 – interpersonal functioning
∑ 4 – impulse control.
B Inflexible and pervasive across a range of situations.
C Leads to significant distress or impairment in social, occupational, or other areas.
D Stable, of long duration, onset can be traced back to adolescence or early adulthood.
E Not a manifestation or consequence of another mental disorder.
F Not caused by the effects of a substance or a general medical condition.
Clusters
Personality disorders are grouped into three clusters:
∑ Cluster A: paranoid, schizoid, and schizotypal personality disorders – odd or eccentric
∑ Cluster B: antisocial, borderline, histrionic, and narcissistic personality disorders – dramatic,
emotional, or erratic
∑ Cluster C: avoidant, dependent, and obsessive–compulsive personality disorders – anxious or
fearful.
Axis
Personality disorders under DSM-IV are coded on Axis II, and listed in their order of importance.
Specific maladaptive personality traits and the use of defence mechanisms may also be listed on Axis
II.
1 neither desires nor enjoys close relationships, including being part of a family
2 chooses solitary activities
3 has little interest in sexual experience with another person
4 takes pleasure in few activities
5 lacks close friends or confidants
6 is indifferent to praise or criticism of others
7 shows emotional coldness, detachment, or flattened affect.
B. Does not occur exclusively during the course of schizophrenia, mood disorder, other psychotic
disorder, or pervasive developmental disorder; not caused by the effects of a general medical
condition.
METHODOLOGICAL PROBLEMS
Various methodological problems are encountered with prevalence studies:
Epidemiology of personality disorders 475
STATISTICS
A gradient exists in the prevalence of personality disorders from community to inpatient setting
(see Table 33.1). The following are the approximate prevalences of personality disorder:
∑ community 10%
∑ general practice 20%
∑ psychiatric outpatients 30%
∑ psychiatric inpatients 40%.
Prevalence
Personality disorder Community Outpatients Inpatients
Paranoid 0.5–2.5% 2–10% 10–30%
Schizoid Uncommon
Schizotypal 3%
Antisocial 3% in males 3–30%
1% in females
Borderline 2% 10% 20%
Histrionic 2–3% 10–15%
Narcissistic Less than 1% 2–16%
Avoidant 0.5–1.0% 10%
Dependent The most frequently reported
Obsessive–compulsive 1% 3–10%
ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS
Psychodynamics
The failure to negotiate stages of psychosexual development and the characteristic use of defence
mechanisms are said to result in disorders of personality. For example:
∑ Paranoid personality is the result of the projection of homosexual impulses. Later it was thought
that excessive parental rage causing feelings of inadequacy resulted in projection on to others of
hostility and rage.
∑ Borderline personality results from early traumatic experiences occurring within a context of
sustained neglect resulting in enduring rage and self-hatred.
∑ Histrionic personality results from difficulties in the Oedipal phase of psychosexual development.
∑ Dependent personality results from fixation at the oral stage of psychosexual development.
∑ Obsessive–compulsive personality results from difficulties in the anal stage of psychosexual
development.
Object relations
Personality is taken to be shaped by the child’s early parental relationships. Dependent personality
traits are thought to result from parental deprivation, obsessive–compulsive traits from the struggle
with parents for control, and hysterical traits from parental seduction and competition.
For example, borderline personality is the result of a lack of stable involved attachment during
development. This leads to an inability to maintain a stable sense of self or others without ongoing
contact.
NEUROLOGICAL FACTORS
Eighty per cent of children with minimal brain dysfunction syndrome suffer from various
personality disorders in adult life.
EEG studies in antisocial personality disorders demonstrate abnormalities which have led to
speculation that psychopathic behaviour reflects cortical immaturity. Abnormalities found in this
group more often than in normals include:
∑ generalized widespread slow (q) wave activity
∑ ‘positive spike’ abnormality over temporal lobes
∑ localized temporal slow wave activity.
These abnormalities are more likely to occur in highly impulsive and aggressive psychopaths.
Psychopaths have lower cortical arousal, measured by slower cortical evoked potentials.
Autonomic arousal is also lower, leading to speculation that sensation-seeking behaviour may be an
attempt to increase cortical arousal.
Goyer et al. (1994) in a PET scanning study of personality disordered subjects found a significant
inverse correlation between a history of aggressive impulse difficulties and regional cerebral
Aetiology of personality disorders 477
metabolic rates in the frontal cortex. Those subjects with borderline personality disorders had
significantly reduced frontal cortex metabolism.
GENETIC FACTORS
Normal personality appears to be at least moderately heritable:
∑ Breeding over generations of animals (e.g. dogs) produces strains with more or less aggressive
temperaments.
∑ Psychophysiological characteristics are partly genetically inherited. For example, EEGs of
monozygotic (MZ) twins are easily distinguished from those of dizygotic (DZ) twins, even
when they are reared apart; the habituation of galvanic skin response is largely genetically
determined.
∑ Large representative twin studies using model-fitting approaches consistently find a heritability
of 35–50% for traits measured by questionnaire. Although 50% of the variance in personality
traits is environmental, a shared family environment has consistently shown a negligible
contribution to the variance.
∑ Monozygotic twins reared apart are more alike on personality measures than those raised
together. It is suggested that twins reared together react against one another in an attempt to
establish individual identities.
Table 33.2 Percentages of convictions in male adoptees and the biological and adoptive parents
Conviction rate
Neither biological nor adoptive parent convicted 13.5%
Adoptive parents convicted. Biological parents not convicted 14.7%
Adoptive parents not convicted. Biological parents convicted 20.0%
Adoptive and biological parents convicted 24.5%
478 Personality disorders
It is suggested that family background plays a part in subsequent criminality, but only when there
is already a genetic predisposition. The risk of criminality is increased in those with prolonged
institutional care, multiple temporary placements and those where the socioeconomic status of
their adoptive home is low.
Assessment can be difficult. Personality traits are egosyntonic, such that patients are often not aware
of them and will not complain of them. In the diagnosis of personality disorder, multiple sources of
information should be used, including an informant who has known the patient for a considerable
time.
Personality traits should:
∑ be enduring, not transient
∑ be pervasive across situations
∑ be early in onset
∑ cause distress or impairment.
Account should be taken of social and cultural norms when considering behaviour or symptoms.
Axis I symptom disorder and medical illness should be identified since they may complicate the
diagnosis.
Many difficulties of adolescence resolve as the person matures. Personality disorder should be
diagnosed with care in adolescence.
Most research focuses upon the management of ‘borderline’ patients, partly because these are the
patients commonly presenting in clinical practice. It is usually the case that both psychotherapy and
drug therapy will be used in a patient with personality disorder.
Management of personality disorders 479
Psychotherapy
PSYCHOANALYSIS
Psychoanalysis or intensive psychoanalytic psychotherapy is considered by many psychotherapists to
be the treatment of choice for borderline individuals. The duration of therapy is 2–7 years.
Treatment consists of interpretation of the transference and primitive defence mechanisms, the
neutrality of the therapist and a consistent limit setting. Attention is particularly focused on the
present rather than interpreting childhood experience.
An alternative is supportive psychotherapy which aims to strengthen a patient’s adaptive
functioning through education, suggestion and a facilitating interpersonal relationship. The
interpretation of transference, defence mechanisms and regression and dependency are avoided,
since they are considered likely to lead to suicide or other forms of acting out.
GROUP PSYCHOTHERAPY
Group psychotherapy has been traditionally avoided because borderline patients are considered too
demanding and disruptive. However, gentle confrontation delivered by a group is considered by
some to be effective, rendering egosyntonic traits more egodystonic.
Most groups can contain no more than one or two borderline patients. Apart from the cost, there
is no evidence to recommend group therapy over individual therapy.
FAMILY THERAPY
This is frequently offered to borderline adolescent patients, and is regarded by many as the
treatment of choice for these patients.
Physical treatments
Placebo-controlled drug trials among those with personality disorder show small specific drug
effects as well as large placebo effects.
Neuroleptic drugs
Low-dose neuroleptic treatment has been shown to be beneficial particularly in the management of
borderline subjects in a majority of trials. Low-dose flupenthixol significantly reduced the number
of suicide attempts by 6 months when compared to placebo and mianserin in a mixed group of
parasuicidal personality-disordered subjects.
Low-dose neuroleptics improve a broad spectrum of neurotic symptoms as well as reducing
behavioural dyscontrol and numbers of suicide attempts, compared to placebo.
Antidepressants
Some patients with borderline or schizotypal personality disorder improve with tricyclic
antidepressants on ratings of depressed mood, impulsive and manipulative behaviour, but there is
significant potential for paradoxical effects and rage reactions. As a result they are not particularly
recommended in the management of personality disorders unless major depression co-occurs.
Depression complicated by personality disorder is only half as likely to respond to tricyclic drug
treatment compared to pure major depression, however.
Selected borderline subjects respond to monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs), particularly
where there is a history of childhood hyperactivity.
Serotonergic dysfunction has been implicated in key symptoms, particularly depression,
impulsivity and obsessive–compulsive phenomena. Selective serotonin re-uptake inhibitors (e.g.
fluoxetine) at doses of 20–80 mg per day result in the improvement in depressed mood and
impulsivity as well as reducing self-mutilation. Sertraline used in impulsive aggressive patients
results in marked improvements in overt aggression and irritability, evident from the fourth week of
treatment.
Electroconvulsive therapy
The immediate response is good in depressed borderline subjects, but the relapse rate is high.
Lithium
In male convicts with a pattern of recurring easily triggered violence, a marked reduction in
infractions resulted from treatment with lithium. The reduction in aggressive episodes requires
lithium levels above 0.6 mmol/L. Major infractions such as assault or threatening behaviour are
responsive to lithium in about 60%; minor infractions are unresponsive.
Outcome 481
Lithium is helpful in a small numbers of patients with diverse personality disorders. Affective
features, a family history of affective disorder or alcoholism may help selected subjects. A 2-month
trial of lithium may be necessary to establish responders.
Carbamazepine
Impulsive aggression is the most serious symptom of personality disorder. In patients with
behavioural dyscontrol, aggressive acts are reduced by about two-thirds and the severity of the
outburst is improved. It is helpful even in the absence of epileptic, affective or organic features.
Benzodiazepines
These are contraindicated in personality disorder because of their propensity to disinhibit, induce
rage reactions and states of dependence.
Psychostimulants
Psychostimulants such as dexamphetamine and pemoline may occasionally, sometimes
dramatically, help personalities with aggression and hostility, particularly where there is an earlier
history of drug-responsive attention-deficit disorder. However, because of their psychotogenic
effects and addictive properties, extreme caution is used in prescribing.
OUTCOME
The personality disorders have a high morbidity and mortality. The standardized mortality ratio for
the 20- to 39-year-old age group is raised six-fold, similar to that rise reported for the major
functional psychoses.
Patients with personality disorder have high rates of comorbidity with both axis I and axis II
conditions. Response to treatment of an axis I disorder is almost always worse in the presence of
personality disorder. Patients are at a high risk of suicide.
In those borderline cases treated with psychotherapy, the aim of supportive psychotherapy may
be to diminish suicidal behaviour and impulsive acts while awaiting a remission since the long-term
prognosis of this disorder is good. A 15-year follow-up of 100 borderline personality-disordered
patients found that 75% were no longer diagnosed as borderline. All scales showed a reduction of
symptomatic behaviour, with a clear functional improvement. However, there is a high risk of
suicide, with 8.5% completing suicide in the 15-year follow-up period. Those patients with chronic
depression, good motivation, a psychological attitude, low impulsiveness and a stable environment
are most responsive to treatment.
In those with antisocial personality disorders there is a significant association between the ability
to form a relationship with the therapist and treatment outcome. In confined settings such as prison
or in the military, confrontation by peers may bring changes in social behaviour. Prevalence seems
to decrease with increasing age.
Schizotypal personality disorder has a relatively stable course, with only a small proportion of
individuals going on to develop schizophrenia.
Some types of personality disorder (antisocial and borderline) tend to become less evident or to
remit with age, whereas this appears to be less true for some other types (obsessive–compulsive and
schizotypal).
482 Personality disorders
BIBLIOGRAPHY
American Psychiatric Association 1994: Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th edn.
Washington, DC: APA.
Brennan, P.A. & Mednick, S.A. 1993: Genetic perspectives on crime. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica (Suppl.)
370:19–26.
Coccaro, E.F., Bergeman, C.S. & McClearn, G.E. 1993: Heritability of irritable impulsiveness: a study of twins
reared together and apart. Psychiatry Research 48, 229–242.
DeBattista, C. & Glick, I.D. 1995: Pharmacotherapy of the personality disorders. Current Opinion in Psychiatry
8:102–105.
Freeman, C.P.L. 1995: Personality disorders. In Kendell, R.E. & Zealley, A.K. (eds) Companion to Psychiatric Studies,
5th edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Gelder, M., Gath, D. & Mayou, R. 1985: Oxford Textbook of Psychiatry. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Goyer, P.F., Andreason, P.J., Semple, W.E. et al. 1994: Positron emission tomography and personality disorders.
Neuropsychopharmacology 10:21–28.
Higgitt, A. & Fonagy, P. 1992: Psychotherapy in borderline and narcissistic personality disorder. British Journal of
Psychiatry 161:23–43.
Kety, S.S., Rosenthal, D., Wender, P.H. et al. 1971: Mental illness in the biological and adoptive families of adopted
schizophrenics. American Journal of Psychiatry 128:302–306.
Linehan, M.M., Armstrong, H.E., Svarez, A. et al. 1991: Cognitive–behavioural treatment of chronically
parasuicidal borderline patients. Archives of General Psychiatry 48:1060–1064.
McGuffin, P. & Thapar, A. 1992: The genetics of personality disorder. British Journal of Psychiatry 160:12–23.
Mednick, S.A., Gabrielli, W.F. & Hutchings, B. 1984: Genetic influences on criminal convictions: evidence from an
adoption cohort. Science 224:891–894.
Miller, L.J. 1989: Inpatient management of borderline personality disorder: a review and update. Journal of
Personality Disorders 3:122–134.
Mischel, W. 1983: Alterations on the pursuit of predictability and consistency of persons: stable data that yield
unstable interpretations. Journal of Personality 51:578–604.
Paris, J., Brown, R. & Nowis, D. 1987: Long-term follow-up of borderline patients in a general hospital.
Comprehensive Psychiatry 28:530–535.
Robins, L.N. 1966: Deviant Children Grown Up. Baltimore: Williams & Wilkins.
Stein, G. 1992: Drug treatment of the personality disorders. British Journal of Psychiatry 161:167–184.
Swanson, M.C.J., Bland, R.C. & Newman, S.C. 1994: Antisocial personality disorders. Acta Psychiatrica
Scandinavica (Suppl.) 376:63–70.
Tyrer, P. & Ferguson, B. 1987: Problems in the classification of personality disorder. Psychological Medicine
17:15–20.
World Health Organization 1992: Tenth Revision of the International Classification of Diseases. Geneva: WHO.
34
Child and adolescent psychiatry
CLASSIFICATION
The ICD-10 classification of behavioural and emotional disorders with onset usually occurring in
childhood and adolescence is shown in Table 34.1.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Preschool
The main epidemiological study is the Waltham Forest Study (by Richman and colleagues) in the
early 1970s of 3-year-olds, carried out in the London borough of that name. The Vineyard study
(Martha) essentially confirmed its findings. The main findings included:
∑ 7% prevalence of moderate to severe behavioural and emotional problems, slightly greater in
boys than girls
∑ 15% prevalence of mild behavioural and emotional problems
∑ strong associations found with:
∑ maternal depression
∑ poor parental marriage
∑ delayed development of language
∑ strong continuities of behaviour and language disorders over the early school years.
Middle childhood
The main epidemiological studies are the Isle of Wight and Inner London Borough studies (by
Rutter and colleagues) in the 1960s, of 10- and 11-year-olds. Recent studies in Norway and Puerto
Rico essentially confirmed the findings. The main findings included:
∑ 6.8% overall point prevalence of child psychiatric disorder in the Isle of Wight
∑ 4% prevalence of conduct disorder
∑ 2.5% prevalence of emotional disorder
∑ male to female sex ratio of 1.9:1
484 Child and adolescent psychiatry
Table 34.1 F90–F98: Behavioural and emotional disorders with onset usually occurring in childhood and
adolescence (ICD-10)
∑ an overall point prevalence of child psychiatric disorder in inner London twice that in the Isle of
Wight.
Adolescence
∑ 10–20% prevalence of psychiatric disorder
∑ a male to female sex ratio of approximately 1:1.5.
AETIOLOGY
In general the aetiology of psychiatric disorders in children and adolescents is multifactorial.
ASSESSMENT
The information to be obtained in a child psychiatric interview is shown in Table 34.2.
Depressive disorder occurs in 0.5–8% of 14- to 15-year-olds. Compared with adults, depressive
disorder in childhood and early adolescence is more likely to present with:
∑ running away from home
∑ lowered academic performance
∑ separation anxiety/school refusal
∑ somatic pain, particularly of head, abdomen or chest
∑ antisocial behaviour (mostly in males).
Note: no antidepressant is licensed for use in under 18s in the UK. There is little or no evidence of
tricyclic efficacy.
∑ 2003: SSRIs (not fluoxetine) + venlafaxine contraindicated for MDD in youth.
SCHOOL REFUSAL
School refusal is refusal to attend or stay at school because of anxiety and in spite of parental or
other pressure.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Boys and girls are equally represented. There are three main incidence peak ages:
∑ separation anxiety at age 5 years
∑ at age 11 years, which may be precipitated by the change from junior to secondary schooling
∑ at age 14–16 years, which may be a symptom of a psychiatric disorder:
∑ depressive disorder
∑ a phobia (e.g. social phobia).
The most common presentation is the one at 11 years.
486 Child and adolescent psychiatry
MANAGEMENT
The mechanisms underlying the school refusal should be identified. If the condition is acute, a
return to school should be arranged as soon as possible (the Kennedy approach), whereas, if the
condition is chronic, a graded return to school should be arranged. Any specific problems (e.g.
social phobia) should be addressed. If the individual does not return to school, then inpatient
treatment may be necessary.
HYPERKINETIC DISORDERS
EPIDEMIOLOGY
∑ There is a point prevalence of 1.7%.
∑ They occur more often in males.
∑ The incidence decreases with increasing age group.
∑ The incidence increases with social adversity.
CLINICAL FEATURES
The cardinal features are:
∑ impaired attention
∑ over-activity
∑ impulsivity.
These should:
∑ occur in more than one environmental situation
∑ begin before the age of 6 years
∑ be of long duration.
The diagnosis is made far more commonly in the USA than it is in Britain.
Other associated features that may occur include:
∑ social disinhibition
∑ recklessness
488 Child and adolescent psychiatry
∑ learning difficulties
∑ clumsiness.
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
The main differential diagnoses are:
∑ pervasive development disorders
∑ conduct disorder
∑ anxiety disorder.
AETIOLOGY
Possible causes that have been proposed include:
∑ brain abnormality
∑ genetic contribution
∑ dietary factors
∑ food allergy.
MANAGEMENT
A full assessment, including psychometric testing, should be carried out. Behavioural management
approaches and pharmacotherapy with stimulants (methylphenidate or dexamfetamine) may be
used (but beware side-effects). Atomoxetine was approved by the FDA in January 2003 for ADHD,
and is awaiting a UK license. Selective noradrenaline reuptake inhibitor, non-stimulant, non-
controlled. Second-line drugs that are occasionally used include tricyclic antidepressants and
haloperidol.
CONDUCT DISORDERS
EPIDEMIOLOGY
∑ The point prevalence was 4% in 10- and 11-year-olds in the Isle of Wight study (higher in inner
London); with aggressive components in 1.1%.
∑ They occur more often in males.
∑ Aggressive (rather than antisocial) symptoms are more common in younger children.
DIAGNOSIS
According to ICD-10, conduct disorders are characterized by a repetitive and persistent pattern of
dissocial, aggressive or defiant conduct, which when at its most extreme amounts to major
violations of age-appropriate social expectations, and is therefore more severe than ordinary
childish mischief or adolescent rebelliousness.
Conduct disorders 489
DIFFERENTIAL DIAGNOSIS
Conduct disorder overlaps with hyperkinetic disorders and emotional disorders. In the former case,
the diagnosis should be hyperkinetic disorder if the criteria for this are met, whereas in the latter
case in ICD-10 a diagnosis should be made of mixed disorder of conduct and emotions.
CLINICAL FEATURES
The antisocial behaviour may manifest in different ways, such as:
∑ temper tantrums in early and middle childhood
∑ oppositional defiant behaviour in older children.
AETIOLOGY
Possible causes that have been proposed include:
∑ life events:
∑ bereavement
∑ parental divorce
∑ separation from parents
∑ social:
∑ poor school
∑ aberrant peer group
∑ socially disadvantaged
∑ parental:
∑ rejection
∑ inconsistency
∑ punitiveness
∑ negativism
∑ modelling of aggression
∑ failure to set rules
∑ failure to monitor
∑ maternal depression
∑ individual:
∑ anxiety
∑ depression
∑ difficult temperament
∑ low IQ
∑ educational retardation
∑ neurological impairment.
MANAGEMENT
A full assessment should be carried out. Management strategies that may be employed include:
∑ behavioural management techniques
∑ cognitive therapy
∑ group therapy.
490 Child and adolescent psychiatry
ELECTIVE MUTISM
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Elective mutism usually manifests in early childhood, and boys and girls are equally represented.
The prevalence is below 0.8 per 1000 children.
DIAGNOSIS
According to ICD-10, elective mutism is characterized by a marked, emotionally determined
selectivity in speaking, such that the child demonstrates language competence in some situations
but fails to speak in other (definable) ones.
CLINICAL FEATURES
In addition to the features given above, elective mutism tends to be associated with personality
features such as:
∑ social anxiety
∑ withdrawal
∑ sensitivity
∑ resistance.
MANAGEMENT
Management approaches include:
∑ excluding any speech abnormalities
∑ behavioural approaches
∑ use of tape recordings or the telephone
∑ play therapy
∑ art therapy
∑ family therapy.
TIC DISORDERS
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Between 10% and 24% of children manifest tics during development. Tourette’s syndrome
(combined vocal and multiple motor tic disorder) accounts for a lifetime prevalence of 1.01–1.6%,
with a male to female ratio of about 2:1. The average age of onset is 7 years (range 2–15 years).
CLINICAL FEATURES
Common simple motor tics include (ICD-10):
eye-blinking shoulder-shrugging
neck-jerking facial grimacing.
Common simple vocal tics include (ICD-10):
throat-clearing sniffing
barking hissing.
Common complex motor tics include (ICD-10):
hitting oneself hopping
jumping.
Common compex vocal tics include (ICD-10):
coprolalia repeating certain words
palilalia.
AETIOLOGY
The causes of tics are shown in Table 34.3.
Family Individual
Family clusters reported, especially Tourette’s No gross neurological abnormalities
Prevalence of multiple tics in 14–24% of Increased incidence of ‘soft’ neurological signs and
first-degree relatives of patients with Tourette’s ‘non-specific’ EEG changes
Increased family psychopathology in families of Some verbal–performance discrepancies in
ticqueurs, although may be cause or effect functioning
Some neuroleptic medications effective in controlling
tics
Tics exacerbated by dopamine agonists
Wide range of psychological mechanisms proposed
for tic disorders, from the psychoanalytic to the
classically behavioural
Tic movement have been shown to mimic involuntary
startle responses to sudden stimulus
Reproduced with permission from Puri, B.K., Laking, P.J. & Treasaden, I.H. 2002: Textbook of Psychiatry, 2nd edn. Edinburgh:
Churchill Livingstone.
492 Child and adolescent psychiatry
MANAGEMENT
Points in the management of tic disorders include:
∑ a full assessment, including a physical and detailed neurological examination
∑ reassurance of the patient and family
∑ advice to the family or other carers not to be annoyed or anxious at the occurrence of potentially
embarrassing tics such as coprolalia
∑ liaison with the school
∑ psychological treatments
∑ behavioural techniques such as massed practice
∑ relaxation therapy
∑ hypnotherapy
∑ pharmacotherapy (but beware side-effects)
∑ haloperidol
∑ pimozide
∑ sulpiride
∑ SSRIs.
NON-ORGANIC ENURESIS
DEFINITION
According to ICD-10, non-organic enuresis is characterized by the involuntary voiding of urine, by
day and/or by night, which is abnormal in relation to the individual’s mental age and which is not a
consequence of a lack of bladder control resulting from any neurological disorder, epilepsy, or a
structural urinary tract abnormality. It is generally not diagnosed before the age of 5 years, and may
be subdivided into:
∑ primary: urinary continence never achieved
∑ secondary: urinary continence has been achieved in the past.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
∑ Prevalence. The prevalence at different ages has been found to be:
∑ 7 years – 6.7% in boys and 3.3% in girls
∑ 9–10 years – 2.9% in boys and 2.2% in girls
∑ 14 years – 1.1% in boys and 0.5% in girls.
∑ Sex ratio:
∑ Male to female = 1:1 at the age of 5 years; approximately 2:1 in adolescence.
∑ Secondary enuresis is more common in boys.
Non-organic encopresis 493
CLINICAL FEATURES
Non-organic enuresis may be associated with emotional problems, although it should be noted that
the latter may be secondary to the enuresis itself.
AETIOLOGY
Possible causes that have been proposed include:
∑ genetic – 70% have a first-degree relative with late attainment of continence
∑ stressful life events – a doubling of frequency
∑ delayed toilet training
∑ developmental delay – twice as common in enuretic children as in controls
∑ bladder structure – enuretic children are more likely than non-enuretics to have a different
shape of bladder baseplate and to have a reduced functional bladder volume.
MANAGEMENT
Points in the management include:
∑ a full assessment including a physical assessment to exclude a physical cause; look for evidence
of:
∑ urinary frequency
∑ haematuria
∑ dysuria
∑ urgency
∑ urinary microscopy and microbiological analysis
∑ observation period
∑ star chart – relapse rate of approximately 40%
∑ pad and buzzer or, in older children, a pants alarm – relapse rate of approximately 40%
∑ low-dose tricyclic antidepressants – but there are side-effects and there is a high rate of relapse
on discontinuation; can be useful for short time periods (e.g. school trips)
∑ nasal desmopressin – should not be continued for more than 3 months without stopping for a
week for full reassessment
∑ exercises to increase the functional capacity of the bladder
∑ habit training.
NON-ORGANIC ENCOPRESIS
DEFINITION
According to ICD-10, non-organic encopresis is the repeated voluntary or involuntary passage of
faeces, usually of normal or near-normal consistency, in places not appropriate for that purpose in
the individual’s own sociocultural setting. It may be subdivided into:
494 Child and adolescent psychiatry
EPIDEMIOLOGY
∑ Prevalence. At the age of 5 years, the prevalence is 1.5%. In 12-year-olds, the Isle of Wight study
found a prevalence of 1.3% in boys and 0.3% in girls.
∑ The male to female sex ratio is between 3:1 and 4:1.
CLINICAL FEATURES
The presentation of this disorder is summarized in Table 34.4.
AETIOLOGY
Causes of non-organic encopresis are shown in Table 34.5.
MANAGEMENT
Points in the management include:
∑ a full assessment, but take care in carrying out an anal and rectal examination as informed
consent is required from the child who may have been sexually abused (if there is evidence of
sexual abuse, the appropriate procedures should be brought into play)
Bibliography 495
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Black, D. & Cottrell, D. (eds) 1993: Seminars in Child and Adolescent Psychiatry. London: Gaskell.
Graham, P. 1986: Child Psychiatry: A Development Approach. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Hoare, P. 1993: Essential Child Psychiatry. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Laking, P.J. 2002: Child and adolescent psychiatry. In Puri, B.K., Laking, P.J. & Treasaden, I.H. (eds) Textbook of
Psychiatry, 2nd edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
This page intentionally left blank
35
Learning disability
CLASSIFICATION
MENTAL RETARDATION
ICD-10 defines mental retardation as being a condition of arrested or incomplete development of
the mind, which is especially characterized by impairment of skills manifested during the
developmental period, which contribute to the overall level of intelligence; i.e. cognitive, language,
motor and social abilities.
The following is a summary of the ICD-10 classification of mental retardation:
F70 Mild mental retardation
IQ range 50–69
Delayed understanding and use of language
Possible difficulties in gaining independence
Work possible in practical occupations
Any behavioural, social and emotional difficulties are similar to the ‘normal’
F71 Moderate mental retardation
IQ range 35–49
Varying profiles of abilities
Language use and development variable (may be absent)
Often associated with epilepsy, neurological and other disability
Delay in achievement of self-care
Simple practical work possible
Independent living rarely achieved
F72 Severe mental retardation
IQ range 20–34
More marked motor impairment than F71 often found
Achievements at lower end of F71
F73 Profound mental retardation
IQ difficult to measure but <20
498 Learning disability
EPIDEMIOLOGY OF IMPAIRMENT
The prevalence of learning disability – defined as having an intelligence quotient (IQ) of less than
70 – is 3.7%, which is considerably higher than would be expected from the normal distribution of
IQ. The levels of coexistence of different impairments are shown in Table 35.1.
Clinical features of learning disability 499
PSYCHIATRIC DISORDER
The Isle of Wight study (see Chapter 34) found:
∑ The presence of a physical disorder not affecting the brain was associated with a two-fold
increase in the prevalence of psychiatric disorder.
∑ Brain damage was associated with a five-fold increase in the prevalence of psychiatric disorder.
∑ Brain damage + epilepsy was associated with a ten-fold increase in the prevalence of psychiatric
disorder.
BEHAVIOURAL PHENOTYPES
The associations of behaviour with specific syndromes are summarized in Table 35.2.
CHALLENGING BEHAVIOURS
Common challenging behaviours that occur are shown in Table 35.3.
SELF-ESTEEM
Low self-esteem is common in people with learning disabilities.
500 Learning disability
Violence to self or others Biting, hitting, spitting, headbanging, scratching, pinching, tantrums,
property damage
Behaviours out of usual context Shouting, undressing, running away, masturbation, urination,
defecation, sexual behaviours towards others, vomiting, passivity,
oppositional behaviour
Generally inappropriate behaviours Rocking, flapping, stealing, kleptomania
FAMILY CHANGES
Figure 35.1 shows the psychological processes that may occur in families having an impaired or
disabled member.
Over-protection/rejection
Grief
Valid Chronic sorrow
Guilt
Projection Invalid Isolation
of grief
Relatives Disharmony
Anger
Professionals Scapegoating
Acceptance Infantilization
Ego-centred
work
Over-indentification
‘Other’-centred
work
Figure 35.1 Psychological processes in families with an impaired or disabled member. (Reproduced, with
permission, from Bicknell, J. 1983: The psychopathology of handicap. Br J Med Psychol 56:167–178.)
DOWN’S SYNDROME
The clinical features of Down’s syndrome include:
∑ bradycephaly
∑ widely spaced eyes with epicanthic folds and oblique palpebral fissures
∑ Brushfield spots
∑ small nose and mouth
∑ horizontally furrowed tongue
∑ high arched palate
∑ malformed ears
∑ broadening and shortening of the neck and hands
∑ single transverse palmar crease
∑ curvature of the fifth finger
∑ an increased range of joint movements
∑ hypotonia
∑ increased incidence of cataract
502 Learning disability
FRAGILE X SYNDROME
The clinical features of fragile X syndrome include:
∑ elongated facies
∑ oedema
∑ tissue thickening
∑ prognathism
∑ large everted ears
∑ single transverse palmar crease
∑ soft velvety skin
∑ large forehead
∑ blue eye colour
∑ high arched palate
∑ increased incidence of connective tissue disorders
∑ hyperextensible joints
∑ flat feet
∑ delay in language acquisition with cluttering speech
∑ learning disability
∑ mitral valve prolapse in 80%
∑ macro-orchidism in 70% after puberty.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Clarke, A.M., Clarke, A.D.B & Berg, J.B. (eds) 1985: Mental Handicap: The Changing Outlook. London: Methuen.
Laking, P.J. 2002: Psychiatry of disability. In Puri, B.K., Laking, P.J. & Treasaden, I.H. Textbook of Psychiatry, 2nd
edn. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Russell, O. 1985: Mental Handicap. Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
This page intentionally left blank
36
Eating disorders
ANOREXIA NERVOSA
Classification
ICD-10
This condition is characterized by deliberate weight loss resulting in under-nutrition with
secondary endocrine and metabolic disturbance. It requires the presence of all the following:
(a) Bodyweight maintained at 15% below expected; Quetelet’s body mass index <17.5 kg/m2.
(Quetelet’s body mass index = mass/height2; age 16 or over.)
(b) Weight loss self-induced by the avoidance of fattening foods and one or more of the following:
self-induced vomiting; self-induced purging; excessive exercise; the use of appetite suppressants
and/or diuretics.
(c) Body-image distortion: a specific psychopathology comprising a dread of fatness which persists
as an intrusive, over-valued idea; a low weight threshold is imposed on self.
(d) Amenorrhoea in women; loss of sexual interest and potency in men; endocrine disorder of
hypothalamus–pituitary–gonadal axis (HPA); elevated growth hormone and cortisol levels;
abnormal peripheral metabolism of thyroid hormone; abnormalities of insulin secretion.
(e) If onset is prepubertal, the sequence of pubertal events delayed or arrested; puberty is often
completed with recovery, but menarche late.
DSM-IV-TR
Diagnostic features
A Individual refuses to maintain minimally normal bodyweight (< 85% normal weight)
B Intense fear of gaining weight (loss of appetite rare)
C Disturbance in perception of shape or size of body
D Amenorrhoea (absence of at least three consecutive menstrual cycles).
506 Eating disorders
Subtypes
These are used to specify the presence or absence of regular binge eating or purging during the
current episode.
∑ Restricting type. Weight loss is accomplished through dieting, fasting or excessive exercise.
∑ Binge eating/purging type. There is regular binge eating or purging (or both) during the current
episode. Most engage at least weekly. This group are more likely to have other impulse-control
problems, to abuse alcohol or drugs, to exhibit mood lability, and be sexually active.
∑ amenorrhoea/loss of libido
∑ reproductive system atrophy (shrunken uterus and ovaries with cystic multifollicular ovarian
changes)
∑ osteoporosis from low calcium intake and absorption, reduced oestrogen and increased cortisol
secretion:
∑ bone pain and deformity
∑ bone density reduction with increasing years of amenorrhoea
∑ pathological fractures after about 10 years
∑ hypoglycemia
∑ dehydration
∑ hypothermia, cold intolerance
∑ seizures
∑ delayed gastric emptying
∑ acute gastric dilatation
∑ pancreatitis
∑ tetany
∑ degeneration of myenteric plexus of bowel:
∑ cathartic colon
∑ constipation
∑ reduced growth, delayed puberty
∑ cardiac and skeletal muscle-wasting
∑ purpura secondary to reduced collagen in skin and bone marrow suppression
∑ mitral valve prolapse
∑ proximal myopathy
∑ impaired liver function
∑ impaired renal function caused by chronic dehydration and hypokalemia
∑ diffuse EEG abnormalities, reflecting metabolic encephalopathy (may result from fluid and
electrolyte disturbances)
∑ increase in the ventricular:brain ratio secondary to starvation.
ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS
Non-genetic factors are thought to play a crucial role in the aetiology of anorexia nervosa.
Anorexia nervosa 509
The family
Minuchin et al. (1978) found that relationships in families of anorexics are characterized by over-
protection and enmeshment. Kendler found that a typical anorexic came from an inward, often
over-protected and highly controlled family.
Higher rates of childhood sexual abuse are reported by eating-disordered patients than by
controls. Childhood sexual abuse appears to be a vulnerability factor for psychiatric disorder in
general, not for eating disorders in particular.
Sociocultural factors
There is a cult of thinness. Anorexic and bulimic women viewing fashion images of women show a
25% increase in their body size estimation afterwards. The media presentation of idealized women
is likely to have some effect upon eating-disordered subjects.
Among 15-year-old schoolgirls, the relative risk of developing anorexia nervosa was eight times
greater in those who dieted compared to those who did not in a prospective study.
Immigrants from low-prevalence to high-prevalence cultures may develop anorexia nervosa as
thin-body ideals are assimilated. Cultural factors influence the manifestation of the disorder: in
some cultures, for example, body-image disturbance may not be prominent and the expressed
motivation for food restriction may have a different content, such as epigastric discomfort or
distaste for food.
Physical illness
An excess of physical illnesses in childhood has been found in those with anorexia nervosa. Physical
illness may be a risk factor for the later development of anorexia nervosa, possibly by inducing
pathology in the family dynamics.
Cases of anorexia nervosa have been reported with onset immediately related to a glandular
fever-like illness. The disruption of the central CRH regulation has been suggested as the mediator
of this.
Psychological factors
Psychodynamic theories include: fantasies of oral impregnation; dependent relationships with a
passive father; guilt over aggression toward ambivalently regarded mother.
Operant conditioning theories include: phobic avoidance of food resulting from sexual and
social tensions generated by physical changes associated with puberty.
Personality
Anorexics have a high prevalence of defined personality disorders and an excess of obsessive,
inhibited and impulsive traits. It is suggested that in an environment that emphasizes thinness as a
criterion for self-worth, vulnerable individuals cope with the challenges of adolescence by repetitive
reward-seeking behaviour.
Braun et al. (1994) found that 69% of eating-disordered patients had at least one personality
disorder; these were also more likely to have an affective disorder or substance dependence than
those without personality disorder.
Anorexics are more likely to suffer from anxious–avoidant personality disorders (cluster C),
whereas dramatic–erratic personality disorders (cluster B) are more common in bulimics.
NEUROTRANSMITTERS
Brain serotonin systems are implicated in the modulation of appetite, mood, personality variables
and neuroendocrine function. An increase in intrasynaptic serotonin reduces food consumption; a
reduction in serotonin activity increases food consumption and promotes weight gain.
510 Eating disorders
Kaye et al. (1991) found increased cerebrospinal fluid concentrations of major serotonin
metabolite 5-HIAA in long-term weight-restored anorectics, which may indicate an increased
serotonin activity contributing to pathological feeding behaviour.
It has been suggested that amenorrhoea is caused by primary hypothalamic dysfunction. This is
supported by the fact that a return to normal menstruation lags behind the return of bodyweight,
and amenorrhoea sometimes precedes weight loss. This, however, is not proven.
Amenorrhea is caused by abnormally low levels of oestrogen, because of the diminished pituitary
secretion of follicle-stimulating hormone and luteinizing hormone (LH). This is usually a
consequence of weight loss but, in a minority of individuals, it may actually precede it. In
prepubertal females, menarche may be delayed.
FEEDING
While the person is emaciated the initial aim of therapy is weight gain. Aim for 1 kg, and not more
than 2 kg, weight gain per week. The premorbid weight, or the weight at which periods stopped plus
5 kg, are guides to a healthy weight. Psychotherapy at this stage is difficult, so wait until the weight
has ceased to be dangerously low.
There is slowed gastric emptying, so meals must be introduced slowly to reduce the risks of
gastric dilatation or rupture. If the patient is very emaciated, liquid feeds may be better initially.
Gradually build up from 1000 to 3500 kcal per day.
There may be reduced circulating oestrogens, a shrunken uterus, and small amorphous ovaries.
As weight is gained, the uterus increases in size and the ovaries become multifollicular. At normal
weight the ovaries become follicular; this is detected by pelvic ultrasound and can be used to
indicate correct weight.
PSYCHOTHERAPY
Family therapy is the treatment of choice, particularly in young restricting anorexics (age under 22
years) with a duration of illness less than 4 years. Therapy is directive, and parents are encouraged
to take control of eating. Work also covers issues of individuation and separation. Parental
counselling also may be effective.
For older anorexics, cognitive–behavioural therapy is the treatment of choice.
PHARMACOTHERAPY
Chlorpromazine is sometimes used to promote weight gain. Beware of postural hypotension,
arrhythmias and hypothermia.
Anorexia nervosa is a serious disorder with substantial mortality. Hsu et al. (1979), in a 4- to 8-
year follow-up of 100 cases of severe anorexia nervosa treated at a specialist centre, found 48 had
good outcome, 30 intermediate, 20 poor; two had died of inanition.
Poor outcome is associated with a longer duration of illness, an older age of onset and
presentation, lower weight at onset and at presentation, the presence of bulimia, anxiety when
eating with others, vomiting, poor childhood social adjustment and poor parental relationships.
The more intractable the illness, the poorer the outcome.
Sullivan (1995) found that the aggregate mortality rate for anorexia nervosa is 5.6% per decade.
This is 12 times the annual death rate due to all causes for females aged 15–24. The aggregate
mortality rate for anorexia nervosa is substantially greater than that reported for psychiatric
inpatients and the general population.
The causes of death were complications of eating disorder in 54% and suicide in 27%. Suicide
rates are 200 times greater than in the general population.
BULIMIA NERVOSA
Classification
ICD-10
Bulimia nervosa is characterized by repeated bouts of over-eating, excessive preoccupation with the
control of bodyweight, leading to extreme measures to mitigate against the fattening effects of food.
It shares the same specific psychopathology of fear of fatness as anorexia nervosa.
A diagnosis under ICD-10 requires all of the following:
(a) Persistent preoccupation with eating and an irresistable craving for food; episodes of over-
eating in which large amounts of food are consumed in short periods of time.
(b) Attempts to counteract the fattening effects of food by one or more of the following: self-
induced vomiting; purgative abuse; alternating periods of starvation; use of drugs (appetite
suppressants, thyroid preparations, diuretics). Diabetic bulimics may neglect insulin treatment.
(c) Morbid dread of fatness. Patient sets weight threshold well below healthy weight. Often there is
a history previously of anorexia nervosa.
DSM-IV-TR
Diagnostic features
A Recurrent episodes of binge eating, characterized by the following:
∑ 1 – eating, in a discrete period of time (e.g. within any 2-hour period), an amount of food
that is definitely larger than most people would eat during a similar period of time and
under similar circumstances
∑ 2 – a sense of lack of control over eating during the episode.
B Recurrent inappropriate behaviour to prevent weight gain (e.g. self-induced vomiting; misuse of
laxatives, diuretics, enemas, or other medications; fasting; or excessive exercise).
C Binge eating and inappropriate compensatory behaviours both occurring, on average, at least
twice a week for 3 months.
D Self-evaluation unduly influenced by body shape and weight.
E Disturbance not occurring exclusively during episodes of anorexia nervosa.
512 Eating disorders
Subtypes
∑ Purging type. There is regularly self-induced vomiting or misuse of laxatives, diuretics, or
enemas during the current episode.
∑ Nonpurging type. The individual has used inappropriate compensatory behaviours, such as
fasting or excessive exercise, but has not regularly engaged in self-induced vomiting or the
misuse of laxatives, diuretics or enemas during the current episode.
BINGE-EATING DISORDER
In this variation, there are recurrent episodes of binge eating in the abscence of the regular use of
inappropriate compensatory behaviours characteristic of bulimia nervosa.
ENVIRONMENTAL FACTORS
Prior to illness onset, bulimics are more likely to be over-weight than their peers.
Rigid dieting is the most common precipitant of binge eating. Gross bingeing is the most
common precipitant for self-induced vomiting. Dieting may affect appetite and satiety mechanisms.
Second World War veterans who had been prisoners of war and suffered weight loss report more
binge eating afterwards than veterans who had not been prisoners. Data is supportive of an
aetiological role for eating restraint in promotion of bingeing.
Many normal-weight bulimics are the eldest or only daughters. Lacey et al. (1991) postulates that
at times of parental marital discord the mother can use her daughter as an easily available therapist,
burdening the child at an age when she cannot deal with the expressed emotions.
Bulimics report more sexual abuse in childhood than controls.
NEUROTRANSMITTERS
Many abnormalities in eating disorders are secondary to dieting, weight loss, and binge/purge
behaviour.
Serotonin is involved in the mediation of satiety responses to feeding as well as the regulation of
mood, anxiety and impulsive behaviour. There is evidence in normal-weight bulimics of altered
post-synaptic 5HT1c receptor sensitivity, and depression associated with dysregulation of pre-
synaptic 5HT function.
There is further support for the 5HT dysregulation hypothesis from findings that cerebrospinal
fluid (CSF) concentrations of the serotonin metabolite 5HIAA and dopamine metabolite HVA are
inversely correlated with a frequency of binge eating in the month prior to admission.
Beta-endorphin concentration in CSF of bulimics is significantly reduced, possibly related to
chronic activation of the HPA axis secondary to dieting.
Cholecystokinin-8 (CCK-8) is involved in regulating satiety and anxiety. It is dependent upon an
intact 5HT function. Bulimics have lower CSF CCK-8 concentrations than controls. A central, but
not peripheral CCK dysfunction is implicated in bulimia nervosa.
Arginine–vasopressin (AVP) CSF concentrations are high in bulimics. An increased central AVP
may be related to obsessive preoccupation with the aversive consequences of eating and weight gain.
It also interacts with 5HT.
There is a general reduction of sympathetic responsivity and activation of HPA activity in
bulimia nervosa, probably as a result of long-term neuroendocrine adaptation to caloric restriction.
PERSONALITY
∑ Personality disturbance is more common in patients with eating disorders than in the general
population. On the Eysenck Personality Inventory, bulimics score higher for psychoticism and
neuroticism than do anorexics and controls. On the MMPI, bulimics have elevated scores for
psychopathic deviance.
∑ Low self-esteem, low paternal care, external locus of control and high neuroticism scores are risk
factors for bulimia.
∑ Bulimics are more likely than anorexics to abuse substances (20%). Lifetime rates of alcohol
dependence are high.
∑ The prevalence of social phobia in eating-disordered subjects, especially in bulimics, far exceeds
that in the general population.
∑ Bulimics have high rates (40%) of major depression. There is significant comorbidity between
anorexia and bulimia.
Bulimia nervosa 515
BEHAVIOURAL THERAPY
This aims to stop bingeing and purging by restricting exposure cues that trigger binge/purge
behaviour, developing alternative behaviours and delaying vomiting.
COGNITIVE–BEHAVIOURAL THERAPY
This includes psychoeducation, self-monitoring and cognitive restructuring. Eating regular meals is
very important.
PHARMACOTHERAPY
Imipramine, phenelzine, amitriptyline, nortriptyline, desipramine and fluoxetine are all superior to
placebo in double-blind controlled trials. The dose required is similar to the antidepressant dose.
There is a 50–70% reduction in bingeing. The magnitude of the change is smaller than with
psychotherapy.
Lithium, anticonvulsants, serotonin promoters and opiate antagonists have all been used
successfully.
Cognitive and/or behavioural therapies are the treatment of choice. Antidepressants alone are
not adequate.
∑ low self-esteem
∑ substance abuse.
Bulimics with multi-impulsive personality disorder do less well than those with bulimia alone.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Braun, D.L., Sunday, S.R. & Halmi, K.A. 1994: Psychiatric comorbidity in patients with eating disorders.
Psychological Medicine 24:859–867.
Brewerton, T.D. & Ballenger, J.C. 1994: Biological correlates of eating disorders. Current Opinion in Psychiatry
7:150–153.
Collings, S. & King, M. 1994: Ten-year follow-up of 50 patients with bulimia nervosa. British Journal of Psychiatry
164:80–87.
Fahy, T.A., Eisler, I. & Russell, G.F.M. 1993: Personality disorder and treatment response in bulimia nervosa. British
Journal of Psychiatry 162:765–770.
Fairburn, C.G. 1993: Eating disorders. In Kendell, R.E. & Zealley, A.K. (eds), Companion to Psychiatric Studies.
Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone.
Fombonne, E. 1995: Anorexia nervosa: no evidence of an increase. British Journal of Psychiatry 166:462–471.
Freeman, C.P.L., Barry, F., Dunkeld-Turnbull, J. & Henderson, A. 1988: Controlled trial of psychotherapy for bulimia
nervosa. British Medical Journal 296:521–525.
Garfinkel, P.E., Lin, E., Goering, P. et al. 1995: Bulimia nervosa in a Canadian community sample: prevalence and
comparison of subgroups. American Journal of Psychiatry 152:1052–1058.
Hamilton, K. & Waller, G. 1993: Media influences on body size estimation in anorexia and bulimia: an
experimental study. British Journal of Psychiatry 162:837–8340.
Holland, A.J., Sicotte, N. & Treasure, J.L. 1988: Anorexia nervosa: evidence for a genetic basis. Journal of
Psychosomatic Research 32:561–571.
Hsu, L.K.G., Crisp, A.H. & Harding, B. 1979: Outcome of anorexia nervosa. Lancet i:61–65.
Hudson, J., Pope, H.G., Jenas, J.M. et al. 1983: Family history of anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. British
Journal of Psychiatry 142:133–138.
Kaye, W.H., Gwirtsman, H.E., George, D.T. et al. 1991: Altered serotonin activity in anorexia nervosa after long-
term weight restoration. Archives of General Psychiatry 48:556–562.
Keel, P.K. & Mitchell, J.E. 1997: Outcome in bulimia nervosa. American Journal of Psychiatry 154:313–321.
Kendler, K.S., Maclean, C., Neale, M. et al. 1991: The genetic epidemiology of bulimia nervosa. American Journal of
Psychiatry 148:1627–1637.
Lacey, H.J., Gowers, S.G. & Bhat, A.V. 1991: Bulimia nervosa: family size, sibling sex and birth order. A catchment
area study. British Journal of Psychiatry 158:491–494.
Minuchin, S., Rosman, B.C. & Baker, L. 1978: Psychosomatic Families: Anorexia Nervosa in Context. Cambridge,
MA: Harvard University Press.
Palmer, R.L. & Robertson, D.N. 1995: Outcome in anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa. Current Opinion in
Psychiatry 8:90–92.
Park, R.J., Lawrie, S.M. & Freeman, C.P. 1995: Post-viral onset of anorexia nervosa. British Journal of Psychiatry
166:386–389.
Patton, G.C., Johnson-Sabine, E., Wood, K. et al. 1990: Abnormal eating attitudes in London schoolgirls (a
prospective epidemiological study): outcome at twelve months follow-up. Psychological Medicine
20:383–394.
Patton, G.C., Wood, K. & Johnson-Sabine, E. 1986: Physical illness and anorexia nervosa. British Journal of
Psychiatry 149:756–759.
Bibliography 517
Quadflieg, N. & Fichter, M.M. 2003: The course and outcome of bulimia nervosa. European Journal of Child and
Adolescent Psychiatry 12 (Suppl. 1):99–109.
Robins, L.N. & Regier, D.A. (eds) 1991: Psychiatric Disorders in America: The Epidemiologic Catchment Area Study.
New York: Free Press.
Sohlberg, S. & Strober, M. 1994: Personality in anorexia nervosa: an update and a theoretical integration. Acta
Psychiatrica Scandinavica 89 (Suppl. 378):1–15.
Sullivan, P.F. 1995: Mortality in anorexia nervosa. American Journal of Psychiatry 152:1073–1074.
Vize, C.M. & Cooper, P.J. 1995: Sexual abuse in patients with eating disorders, patients with depression and
normal controls: a comparative study. British Journal of Psychiatry 167:80–85.
Walters, E.E. & Kendler, K.S. 1995: Anorexia nervosa and anorexia-like syndromes in a population-based female
twin sample. American Journal of Psychiatry 152:64– 71.
This page intentionally left blank
37
Cross-cultural psychiatry
For the purposes of this chapter, culture is defined as the learned way of life of a group of people
bound together by a common social heritage. People of the same cultural group behave, think and
give meaning to life in a similar way, and share a set of values and beliefs.
INTERNATIONAL COMPARISONS
Schizophrenia
Kraepelin delineated dementia praecox and manic depression. In 1904 he visited the asylum of
Buitenzorg in Java to examine the similarities and differences between European patients and those
from another culture. He was satisfied that he could recognize cases of dementia praecox in Java,
giving credence to his diagnostic distinction. This represents one of the first investigations in
transcultural psychiatry.
society. Those from developing countries had a better prognosis than those from the developed
world.
Neurosis
Using standardized interviewing and case-finding techniques, the prevalence rates for neurosis in
developing countries are comparable with or higher than those found in the West, contrary to what
was previously believed.
In many Third World countries, hysteria represents a high proportion of psychiatric practice. In
the West there has been a substantial decrease in the numbers of patients with hysteria, and a
compensatory rise in the incidence of anxiety and depression. It is suggested that this can be seen as
a shift from a somatic to a psychological mode of communication of emotional distress. The
tendency to express distress in a psychological form is associated with higher social class and
education. Catatonia could similarly be viewed as a non-verbal manifestation of schizophrenia.
Orley and Wing (1979) investigated the rates of psychiatric illness in two villages in East and West
Africa. The rates of depression and anxiety showed large differences (22% and 10% respectively).
Compared to rates in Western countries (10–12%) these rates are high. Communities in the
developed and undeveloped world are heterogeneous, a point emphasized by the ‘new cross-cultural
psychiatry’ (see below).
In comparing the psychopathology of Jewish and gentile East London depressives,
hypochondriasis and tension are much more common in the Jewish group, whereas guilt is more
common in the gentiles. Guilt is culturally determined and more common in Christians.
Somatic symptoms of depression appear to be universal, but the concept of depression of mood
is not recognized in all cultures; many cultures do not have the language to express the feeling of
International comparisons 521
depression as described in the West. Instead such terms as ‘sinking heart’ or ‘soul loss’ are found. In
China, 87% of people suffering from neurasthenia fulfil the criteria for major depression and
respond to treatment with antidepressants.
CLASSIFICATORY SYSTEMS
Europe and North America have greatly influenced the models of mental illness and the
classification of mental illness over the last century. ICD-10 has been criticized in cross-cultural
terms. The international group of psychiatrists involved in drawing up the first draft consisted of 47,
only two of whom were from Africa. Thus conditions encountered in many other cultures which do
not resemble Western categories have been assigned the title ‘culture bound’ conditions, or ‘masked’
representations of ‘real’ illness.
CULTURE-BOUND SYNDROMES
Debate exists about what constitutes a culture-bound syndrome. The term is used to describe
disorders which are considered unique to a given culture (cultural determinist view). However, the
522 Cross-cultural psychiatry
question of whether the classically described ‘culture-bound syndromes’ are actually unique to the
given culture, or are in fact universal phenomena merely influenced by culture (universalist view),
has not been settled. The following syndromes are frequently cited.
Amok
Occurring in Malays, amok consists of a period of withdrawal, followed by a sudden outburst of
homicidal aggression in which the sufferer will attack anyone within reach. The attack typically lasts
for several hours until the sufferer is overwhelmed or killed. If alive, the person typically passes into
a deep sleep or stupor for several days, followed by amnesia for the event. It almost always occurs in
men.
It was first described in Malays in the mid-sixteenth century. It is believed to have originated in
the cultural training for warfare among Malay warriors. Later it became a personal act by an isolated
individual, apparently motiveless, but the motive could be understood as the restoration of self-
esteem or ‘face’.
It was very common in Malaya at the beginning of the nineteenth century, but the incidence was
reduced when the British took over the administration of Malaya. Today it has virtually disappeared.
It is most common in Malays, but reports of amok from other countries exist, questioning its
position as a culture-bound syndrome; it is clear, however, that there is a strong cultural element.
Among Malay cases in mental hospitals, the most common diagnosis is schizophrenia.
Depression, acute brain syndrome and hysterical dissociation have also been found in some cases.
The majority do not have a mental illness. Attacks are often preceded by interpersonal discord,
insults or personal loss, and social drinking.
Koro
This is common in south-east Asia and China; it may occur in epidemic form. It involves the belief
of genital retraction with disappearance into the abdomen, accompanied by intense anxiety and the
fear of impending death.
Cases of a similar condition have been described in non-Chinese subjects. In these cases the
syndrome is often only partial, such as the belief of genital shrinkage, not necessarily with retraction
into the abdomen; it usually occurs within the context of another psychiatric disorder and resolves
once the underlying illness has been treated.
Debate about the cultural specificity of this disorder continues. Some argue that the culturally
determined syndrome is clearly different from the symptom of genital retraction occurring in some
non-Chinese psychotic subjects.
The development of koro has been associated with psychosexual conflicts, personality factors
and cultural beliefs in the context of psychological stress.
Dhat
This is commonly recognized in Indian culture, and is also widespread in Nepal, Sri Lanka,
Bangladesh and Pakistan. It includes vague somatic symptoms (fatigue, weakness, anxiety, loss of
appetite, guilt, etc.) and sometimes sexual dysfunction (impotence or premature ejaculation) which
the subject attributes to the passing of semen in urine as a consequence of excessive indulgence in
masturbation or intercourse.
Patients are typically from a rural area, from a family with conservative attitudes towards sex and
of average or low socioeconomic status. Literacy and religion are unimportant.
Bhatia and Malik (1991) studied male patients attending a sexual problems clinic in New Delhi.
They found that 65% arrived with a primary complaint of dhat syndrome. Twenty-three per cent of
these also complained of impotence or premature ejaculation. The age of presentation is early
twenties, with about 50% unmarried. Most are literate. Although some suffered from depression
Psychiatry and black and ethnic minorities in Britain 523
and anxiety, those with dhat syndrome differed from the others only in the relative absence of
depression and anxiety. Treatment with anxiolytics or antidepressant drugs resulted in significant
improvement, however.
Dhat syndrome is considered by many to be a true culture-bound condition. The belief in the
precious properties of semen is ingrained in Indian culture.
Windigo
This is described in North American Indians, and ascribed to depression, schizophrenia, hysteria or
anxiety. It is a disorder in which the subject believes he or she has undergone a transformation and
become a monster who practises cannibalism. However, it has been suggested that windigo is in fact
a local myth rather than an actual pattern of behaviour.
Latah
This usually begins after a sudden frightening experience in Malay women. It is characterized by a
response to minimal stimuli with exaggerated startles, coprolalia, echolalia, echopraxia and
automatic obedience. It has been suggested that this is merely one form of what is known to
psychologists as the ‘hyperstartle reaction’ and is universally found.
Piblokto
This dissociative state is seen among Eskimo women. The patient tears off her clothing, screams and
cries and runs about wildly, endangering her life by exposure to the cold. It may result in suicidal or
homicidal behaviour.
Britain is a multiracial society. In some large cities, ethnic minorities represent 20% or more of the
total population. Ethnic minority groups are of two types:
∑ immigrants
∑ second- or third-generation residents.
524 Cross-cultural psychiatry
The stresses incurred by these two groups are different. Ethnic minority groups are heterogeneous
in terms of religion and cultural background.
Immigrants
People migrate for various reasons, and so adjustment will depend on many factors including
those operating before migration, the reasons for migration and factors operating in the host
society.
Types of migrant
∑ Settlers are likely to be prepared for a new way of life.
∑ Exiles have been forced to migrate. This may result in grief reaction for their old way of life. They
may have suffered torture or other atrocities before migration.
∑ Migrant workers are less likely to put down roots in the host country. They may be supporting
their family financially at home.
∑ Other: students, business people etc.
These results have caused controversy, with criticisms of misdiagnosis due to unfamiliar
culturally determined patterns of behaviour, acute psychotic reactions being mistaken for
schizophrenia, or racism accounting for the observed differences. However, well-designed studies
dealing with methodological problems fail to substantiate these criticisms. Harvey et al. (1990)
studied consecutive Afro-Caribbean and white British psychotic inpatients prospectively and found
no differences in the course of illness or the pattern of symptoms. This caused them to reject the
hypothesis that misdiagnosis accounts for the higher rates of schizophrenia in this group.
Schizophrenia as defined by operational research criteria is more common in people of Afro-
Caribbean origin living in the UK.
Sugarman and Craufurd (1994) found a lifetime morbid risk of schizophrenia in the parents of
Afro-Caribbean subjects to be the same as the risks to parents of British white schizophrenic
subjects (8.9% and 8.4% respectively). However, for the siblings of Afro-Caribbean probands the
risk was 15% compared to 1.8% for white siblings. Among the siblings of UK-born Afro-Caribbean
probands, the risk was even higher at 27.3%. These observations suggest that schizophrenia in Afro-
Caribbean patients is no less familial than the rest of the population (as evidenced by the similar
risks to parents), but that the increased risk is caused by environmental factors capable of
precipitating schizophrenia in those who are genetically predisposed to it.
The environmental factor postulated has not been identified to date. There is no evidence of
increased rates of schizophrenia in the West Indies and therefore no evidence that Afro-Caribbeans
carry a greater genetic loading for schizophrenia.
Admission rates for Asians are similar to Europeans, except for the 16- to 29-year age group, who
tend to have lower psychiatric admission rates than Europeans. This gives rise to concerns that
services are not reaching this particular group.
SUICIDE
Raleigh and Balarajan (1992) reported suicide rates among British ethnic minority groups
compared to the indigenous British white population.
∑ Suicide rates were high among young Indian women (age-specific SMRs of 273 and 160 at ages
15–24 and 25–34 respectively), but low among Indian men (SMR 73).
∑ Suicide rates were low in Caribbeans (SMRs 81 and 62 in men and women respectively).
∑ Suicide rates were high in East Africans (SMRs 128 and 148 in men and women respectively),
and were largely confined to the younger age groups.
∑ Immigrant groups had a higher rate of suicide by burning, with a nine-fold excess among Indian
women.
High suicide rates among young Indian women are reported within India and in countries
where Indian immigrants have settled. High expectations of academic and economic success, the
stigma of failure, the authority of their elders and the expected unquestioning compliance of
younger family members is thought to predispose to suicide in this culture. Among Indian
women these pressures are accentuated by expected submission and deference to males and
elders. Rates of suicide and attempted suicide in this group are not greatly different from those
in the country of origin, suggesting that the increased rates are not particularly related to issues
of migration. In India, dowry-related self-burning is well known. The common causes of suicide
by burns in young women include marital problems and interpersonal difficulties with other
family members.
In contrast, suicide rates among older Indian women are low, which is thought to accord with the
greater respect given to them by virtue of their age.
526 Cross-cultural psychiatry
APPROACHES TO MANAGEMENT
Communication
In areas with large numbers of ethnic minorities, the service should provide for interpreters to be
available for translation. It is preferable that these people have training in psychiatric and
Bibliography 527
sociological terms and concepts, as well as competence in both languages. Cultural competence is
required as well as a knowledge of the language. Relatives may need to be used, but caution must be
taken to ensure that the patient’s best interests are being represented.
Family
Involve the family and mobilize the community for support. They may assist in the process of
assessment in helping to understand the context of experience and circumstances.
Psychotherapy
Religious leaders and healers can provide important alternative sources of support. Psychotherapy
with ethnic minority groups needs to recognize a different philosophical framework and personal
development. Thus the Western concern with personal autonomy and independence may not be
relevant in those cultures which emphasize the interdependence of the family and the community.
Culturally consonant therapy should be offered.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Ball, R.A. & Clare, A.W. 1990: Symptoms and social adjustment in Jewish depressives. British Journal of Psychiatry
156:379–383.
Bebbington, P.E., Feeney, S.T., Flannigan, C.B. et al. 1994: Inner London collaborative audit of admissions in two
health districts: II. Ethnicity and the use of the Mental Health Act. British Journal of Psychiatry 165:743–749.
Bhatia, M.S. & Malik, S.C. 1991: Dhat syndrome: a useful diagnostic entity in Indian culture. British Journal of
Psychiatry 159:691–695.
Cole, E., Leavey, G., King, M. et al. 1995: Pathways to care for patients with a first episode of psychosis: a
comparison of ethnic groups. British Journal of Psychiatry 167:770–776.
Dunn, J. & Fahy, T.A. 1990: Police admissions to a psychiatric hospital: demographic and clinical differences
between ethnic groups. British Journal of Psychiatry 156:373–378.
Goodman, R. & Richards, H. 1995: Child and adolescent psychiatric presentations of second-generation Afro-
Caribbeans in Britain. British Journal of Psychiatry 167:362–369.
Guinness, E.A. 1992: Profile and prevalence of the brain fag syndrome: psychiatric morbidity in school
populations in Africa. British Journal of Psychiatry 160 (Suppl. 16):42–52.
Harvey, I., Williams, M., McGuffin, P. et al. 1990: The functional psychoses in Afro-Caribbeans. British Journal of
Psychiatry 157:515–522.
Hauff, E. & Vaglum, P. 1995: Organised violence and the stress of exile: predictors of mental health in a
community cohort of Vietnamese refugees three years after resettlement. British Journal of Psychiatry
166:360–367.
Hotopf, M. & Mullen, R. 1992: Koro and Capgras syndrome in a non-Chinese subject. British Journal of Psychiatry
161:577.
Kleinman, A. 1977: Depression, somatisation and the new ‘cross-cultural psychiatry’. Social Science and Medicine
11:3–10.
Kleinman, A. 1987: Anthropology and psychiatry: the role of culture in cross-cultural research on illness. British
Journal of Psychiatry 151:447–454.
Kon, Y. 1994: Amok. British Journal of Psychiatry 165:685–689.
Leff, J., Wig, N.N., Bedi, H. et al. 1990: Relatives’ expressed emotion and the course of schizophrenia in
Chandigarh: a two-year follow-up of a first-contact sample. British Journal of Psychiatry 156:351–356.
Littlewood, R. 1990: From categories to contexts: a decade of the ‘new cross-cultural psychiatry’. British Journal
of Psychiatry 156:308–327.
528 Cross-cultural psychiatry
Murphy, J.M. 1994: Anthropology and psychiatric epidemiology. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica (Suppl.)
385:48–57.
Orley, J. & Wing, J.K. 1979: Psychiatric disorders in two African villages. Archives of General Psychiatry
36:513–521.
Patel, V. & Winston, M. 1994: ‘Universality of mental illness’ revisited: assumptions, artefacts and new directions.
British Journal of Psychiatry 165:437–440.
Raleigh, V.S. & Balarajan, R. 1992: Suicide and self-burning among Indians and West Indians in England and
Wales. British Journal of Psychiatry 161:365–368.
Sartorius, N., Jablensky, A., Korten, A. et al. 1986: Early manifestations and first contact incidence of
schizophrenia in different cultures. Psychological Medicine 16:909–928.
Shepherd, M. 1995: Two faces of Emil Kraepelin. British Journal of Psychiatry 167:174–183.
Smyth, M.G. & Dean, C. 1992: Capgras and koro. British Journal of Psychiatry 161:121–123.
Sugarman, P.P.A. & Craufurd, D. 1994: Schizophrenia in the Afro-Caribbean community. British Journal of
Psychiatry 164:474–480.
Thomas, C.S., Stone, K., Osborn, M. et al. 1993: Psychiatric morbidity and compulsory admission among UK-born
Europeans, Afro-Caribbeans and Asians in central Manchester. British Journal of Psychiatry 163:91–99.
World Health Organization 1973: Report of the International Pilot Study of Schizophrenia. Geneva: WHO.
38
Old-age psychiatry
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Fifteen per cent of the population of England and Wales is aged over 65. The age dependency ratio
(defined as the population aged over 65 as a percentage of the working population) is projected to
rise, so as the aged population rises there will be fewer people of working age to support them.
Within the elderly population, disability rises steeply with age, from 16 per 1000 who are in their
sixties to 133 per 1000 who are aged over 80.
The prevalence of psychiatric morbidity in those aged over 65 is:
∑ dementia 5%
∑ depression 13.5%
∑ phobic disorders 10%
∑ generalized anxiety 4%
∑ personality disorder 1%
∑ paranoid states 0.5%
∑ panic disorder – rare.
The prevalence of dementia rises exponentially with age, doubling every 5.1 years. Thus the
prevalence in the over-65s is 5%, and in the over-80s it is 20%.
GENETIC FACTORS
Programmed ageing is supported by the observation of the Hayflick limit: human diploid cells
cultured in vitro have a finite lifespan. Upon repeated subculture of normal cells, mitosis ceases
independently of culture conditions. This evidence supports theories of genetically programmed
ageing. Cells derived from tumour tissue do not display this limit.
530 Old-age psychiatry
It is speculated that this effect is caused by the progressive loss of DNA sequences in the telomere
involved in the maintenance of DNA stability and replication.
Changes in ageing probably do not involve defects in DNA, but may involve errors in the control
of DNA expression: epigenetic defects.
NON-GENETIC THEORIES
Wear-and-tear theories
Age-related decline in organ function is thought to be responsible for ageing. It is no longer thought
tenable as a central cause of ageing; it is probably secondary to ageing.
Mitochondrial decline
Across species, mitochondria show a reduction in numbers, an increase in size and structural
changes in old organisms. Damage to mitochondrial membranes caused by free radicals is thought
to contribute to these changes.
NEUROBIOLOGY OF AGEING
In normal ageing there is a slow reduction in weight and volume of the human brain, with a
proportionate increase in the size of the ventricles and subarachnoid space after the age of 50 years.
The brain is over-provided with nerve cells, so a loss of cells does not necessarily result in a loss
of function. Some parts of the brain show no loss in nerve-cell numbers with normal ageing (e.g.
dentate nucleus of cerebellum). Nerve-cell loss is known to occur in parts of the cerebral cortex, the
pyramidal and granule cells of the hippocampus, substantia nigra and Purkinje cells of cerebellum.
In normal ageing, especially after the age of 85, a shrinkage of nerve cells is known to occur in the
cerebral cortex and putamen.
Nerve-cell connections are reduced in some cells with compensatory increases seen in others in
normal ageing.
Lipofuscin accumulates in the cytoplasm of nerve cells from childhood.
Tau protein, involved in linking neurofilaments and microtubules, accumulates in a small
proportion of ageing nerve cells particularly in the hippocampus and entorhinal cortex, resulting in
neurofibrillary tangles. Senile plaques are made up of a core of extracellular amyloid surrounded by
abnormal collections of neuritic processes. In the normal ageing brain these are found in the
neocortex, amygdala, hippocampus and entorhinal cortex.
Rod-shaped Hirano bodies are found near the hippocampal pyramidal cells. These comprise the
microfilament actin. Accompanying their presence is a granulovacuolar degeneration in the
pyramidal nerve cells.
Abnormal intracellular inclusions called Lewy bodies are found in the substantia nigra and locus
ceruleus in some normal old people. They comprise a spherical body in the cytoplasm of a nerve
The psychology of ageing 531
cell. They have a laminated appearance with a dense granular core and fibrillary material radiating
to the periphery.
In normal old brains amyloid can be found deposited in the walls of blood vessels. Deposits are
usually small, widespread, in superficial cortical and leptomeningeal vessels overlying the cerebral
lobes. Amyloid is also deposited in irregular patches in the normal ageing cerebral cortex. It is called
b amyloid (A4 amyloid) and is the same as that located at the centre of neuritic or senile plaques.
All the above neuropathological changes occur in Alzheimer’s disease but to a much greater
extent.
COGNITION
Intellectual functioning
Intelligence peaks at the age of 25 years. It levels off until the age of 60–70 and declines thereafter.
Many studies have demonstrated an accelerated decline in cognitive functioning in those who are
closest to their death. This has been referred to as the terminal drop, and poor health may be the
cause.
Using the WAIS-R, a classic pattern of intellectual decline is seen, with performance IQ declining
more rapidly than verbal IQ. Factors thought to account for this pattern include the following:
∑ Speed of processing. This makes some contribution to the age-related decline but is not the whole
explanation.
∑ Familiarity/novelty. Tasks that have been learnt over a lifetime, relying on over-learned abilities,
are most resistant to age-related changes (crystallized intelligence). Tasks requiring the less-
practised processing of new information are most sensitive to age-related decline (fluid
intelligence).
Although intelligence declines with age, there are considerable individual differences.
∑ Problem-solving. The ability to abstract a concept and apply it to a new situation declines with
age, most prominently after the age of 70. The elderly have more problems if tasks are presented
in an abstract manner.
∑ Creativity. Scientific creativity peaks in the 30s, whereas artistic creativity peaks in the 50s.
Humans seem to be most creative when they are producing the greatest volume of work:
intellectual vigour.
PSYCHOMOTOR SPEED
Reaction time increases with age, with most slowing occurring in the central processing of
information. Older people are less able to maintain a state of readiness, and less likely to choose
flexible active information-processing than younger people.
MEMORY
∑ Short-term memory. Short-term memory as tested by the digit span does not change with age.
∑ Working memory. Memory tasks requiring monitoring or complex decision-making are
performed more poorly in the elderly than in the young. Decline is increased with the
complexity of the task or increased memory load.
532 Old-age psychiatry
∑ Long-term memory. The retrieval of information in the elderly is impaired; thus uncued recall
shows an age-related decrement, but cued recall reduces the extent of the decrement. Memory is
more durable if it is encoded at a semantic level, rather than at a phonological or orthographic
level. Older subjects are less likely to code at the semantic level. Memory performance in the
elderly is best if the meaning is easily extracted.
Memory of source is impaired in the elderly, which is thought to be related to deficits in frontal
lobe functioning.
Memory of distant events becomes poorer the more remote the patient is from the event.
Retention of knowledge is retained with age. Knowledge-based skills are relatively preserved into
old age.
IMPORTANCE OF LOSS
People experience unique problems after the age of 65. Activities are limited by declining physical
strength and some suffer debilitating illness. Loss of employment with retirement may result in
feelings of reduced self-worth and low self-esteem. The ageing individual increasingly suffers the
loss of family and friends through death.
Erikson describes the psychosocial changes that individuals negotiate as they develop. The last of
these – integrity versus despair – is concerned with the way the individual approaches death. A well-
lived life is more likely to result in a sense of integrity and wholeness at this time of reflection upon
life achievements. Those with regrets and thoughts of opportunities missed are more likely to
approach death with a sense of despair.
PERSONALITY CHANGES
Most studies of personality in older age support the concept of the stability of personality with age.
Adjustment to ageing can be explained by different models which may apply in different
individuals. The activity theory entails the successfully adjusted individual as being fully engaged
with life, with interests and social contact. The disengagement theory suggests that the individual
focuses increasingly on his or her inner world as adjustment is made to diminished family and social
roles.
High anxiety levels in the elderly are correlated with physical ill-health, but most chronic
neurotic conditions improve in old age. Anxiety-prone personalities arise from a more biological
origin, whereas insecure personalities arise more from early environmental events. Dysthymic
personalities seem to persist into old age.
ATTITUDES
Popular Western culture devalues old age, with women perceived more negatively than men.
Children are least likely, and young/middle-aged adults are most likely, to devalue the elderly.
Most elderly people are able to lead independent lives, are financially secure and are not lonely.
However, the common perception of the elderly is as dependent, confused, lonely, rigid, depressed
and passive people.
The majority of old people cope well with ageing, reporting high life satisfaction, good cognitive
skills, openness to new experience and a positive view of themselves. These are considered to display
Social and economic factors in old age 533
an integrated personality. Those that cope less well display either passive–dependent or
disintegrated personalities.
Factors that influence a person’s self-view include personality, gender, health and socioeconomic
status.
Deviance from social norms generally decreases with age, while the prevalence of stigmatizing
conditions increases.
STATUS
As people age the number of social roles they occupy decreases. This may reduce their social worth.
Much of the decline in the status of the elderly is associated with their reduced socioeconomic
circumstances.
The status of elderly people is high in preliterate societies and low in modern societies. The
factors thought to contribute to this effect include the reduction in the usefulness of the elderly as
repositories of knowledge, the break-up of the extended family, and the reduced importance of land
inheritance.
In modern society, industrial capitalism is thought to have contributed to the declining social
status of the elderly mainly through the imposition of a retirement age and stigmatizing age-related
financial provision. The proportion of over-65s with a wage has steadily declined through state-
imposed retirement for all, irrespective of their ability to work. This has led to poverty and the
stigmatization of the old, with a loss of work role and work-related life satisfaction.
ACCOMMODATION
The likelihood that elderly people will live alone, away from their families, depends on a number of
factors, and is relatively common in Britain. The ageing population is living longer and is thus more
likely to live alone at some stage in their later years. Increasing home ownership increases the
chances that the elderly will live alone for longer.
For health reasons, large proportions of the very old live in institutional care or with relatives or
friends. Old people living alone make more use of statutory services than those living with others.
Disengagement theories which hold that older people gradually withdraw from society in
preparation for death have now lost favour. Instead, activity theories encourage the maintenance of
social interaction and role. Elderly people do maintain a high level of social contact with others.
Unhappiness is associated with a lack of friends in a social network.
SOCIOCULTURAL DIFFERENCES
Gender
Ageing women are more stigmatized than ageing men. They are more likely to live alone and are
more likely to be poor.
534 Old-age psychiatry
Social class
Almost half of pensioners from social classes I and II have money in addition to the state pen-
sion, from private pension schemes and savings, compared to only 5% of those in social classes
IV and V.
Ethnicity
There are competing theories about the effect of ethnicity and ageing:
∑ The age as leveller hypothesis argues that, because all old people are socially disadvantaged, the
relative disadvantage experienced by ethnic minorities reduces in old age.
∑ The double jeopardy hypothesis argues that disadvantages are exacerbated with age.
Problems experienced by the ageing ethnic minority subject are no different from those facing all
ethnic minority groups. Language difficulties are common, and lack of income is most common in
Asian people who have travelled from abroad to join their families and lack pension entitlement.
Clearance
This is the major determinant of steady-state plasma drug concentration. Reduced renal clear-
ance is particularly important with respect to lithium. The reduction of renal clearance is pre-
dictable with age but the reduction with age of hepatic clearance is not as straightforward. All
other psychotropic drugs are cleared by hepatic biotransformation, which is variably reduced
with age.
Distribution
This is determined by the drug’s relative solubility in lipid as opposed to water, proclivity for various
body tissues, and plasma protein binding. Most psychotropic drugs, being lipophilic, have a
relatively small plasma concentration compared to the total amount of drug in the body.
Psychopharmacology of old age 535
Absorption
Although structural and functional changes in the gastrointestinal tract are known to occur in
ageing, there is no evidence that the rate or extent of absorption of orally administered psychotropic
medications is changed in the elderly.
DRUG INTERACTIONS
The incidence of side-effects and adverse drug reactions increases with age. The causes that may
contribute to this include:
∑ ≠ incidence of coexisting physical illness
∑ ≠ number of prescriptions with age
∑ Ø compliance
∑ changed pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics exposing the body to higher drug levels
∑ ≠ risk for acute organic brain syndrome with age.
PRACTICAL CONSIDERATIONS
Antipsychotics
The elderly are more sensitive to antimuscarinic (anticholinergic) side-effects. Parkinsonian side-
effects are more likely in the elderly, in women, and in those with organic brain disease. The
prevalence of tardive dyskinesia increases with age and is more common in women. The length of
treatment is more strongly related than the absolute dose. Acute dystonias, although common in the
young, are rare in the elderly.
An alert has been issued on the use of risperidone and olanzapine in dementia related psychosis
and dementia related behavioural disturbance. They are no longer approved for these indications
because of:
1. A twofold increase in mortality compared to placebo
2. A threefold increase in cerebrovascular adverse events compared to placebo.
Prescribers should consider carefully the risk of cerebrovascular events before treating any
patient with a previous history of stroke or TIA. Consideration should also be given to risk factors
for cerebrovascular disease including hypertension, diabetes, current smoking and atrial fibrillation.
Tricyclic antidepressants
With ageing there occurs:
∑ ≠ plasma half-life
∑ ≠ steady-state levels
∑ ≠ volume of distribution
∑ ≠ postural hypotension.
Heart disease is a relative contraindication. Again, the elderly are particularly prone to
antimuscarinic (anticholinergic) side-effects, which may result in acute brain syndromes, urinary
retention, and glaucoma.
MAOIs
Extreme caution is needed if considering prescribing these to patients with hypertension and
cardiovascular disease.
536 Old-age psychiatry
Lithium
Because of lowered renal clearance, lithium doses in the elderly are approximately 50% lower than
in the young. Diuretics may reduce renal clearance even further, increasing the risk of lithium
toxicity.
Benzodiazepines
Accumulation in the elderly is not more likely to occur than in the young. The elderly are at an
increased risk of delirium and falls.
NEEDS OF CARERS
Community care of the mentally ill, especially dementia sufferers, results in significant strain on the
informal carers. Families provide the most practical and emotional help to the elderly population.
This is usually provided by a very close relative, such as a spouse or a daughter, and usually falls
largely on one relative. Female carers outnumber males 2:1. Most carers are willing and wish to keep
the patient at home, but the strain on them is great. The carers of demented elderly people have
more problems than others, which increase with the degree of dementia. The sources of stress
include:
Assessment of a referral 537
∑ practical – e.g. elderly person requiring help with personal and household tasks and care
∑ behavioural – e.g. nocturnal disturbance, incontinence, wandering and aggression
∑ interpersonal
∑ social – e.g. restrictions on the carer’s personal life.
The British government’s Health of the Nation document recognizes the important role of carers
and directs services specifically to their support.
ASSESSMENT OF A REFERRAL
Psychiatric assessment
Prior to assessment, establish what the referrer wishes to know, and what the patient and the carers
have been told to expect. It is useful to interview an informant, and that is essential in those with
organic brain syndromes.
The most informative setting for the initial assessment is within the person’s home.
Coordination is required to ensure that informants are available. The psychiatrist should be vigi-
lant for unrecognized physical illness presenting with psychiatric symptoms, and if this is sus-
pected should ensure that the patient receives the appropriate medical interventions. Examination
at home allows an assessment of the patient’s coping in the immediate environment, including
visuospatial orientation and the ability to manage independently. It also allows assessment of
local resources such as neighbours’ and relatives’ availability, and any evidence of the unwise use
of alcohol.
If the first assessment occurs on a medical ward as a liaison visit, the medical notes should be read
and the medical and nursing staff should be interviewed before the patient is seen. Carers should be
contacted to supplement the information gathered on the ward. The patient interview should take
place in the most private conditions available.
PSYCHIATRIC HISTORY
Following the introduction of the psychiatrist, the patient should be asked whether he or she has
any problems to discuss. An assessment of how the patient deals with questioning is made
throughout. The interview should be unhurried, allowing the patient to relate a full family and
personal history.
Details of past medical and past psychiatric history are very important, as are any medications
the patient is currently taking. It is also helpful to have some understanding of the patient’s
premorbid personality, which is best accessed through informants.
Establish whether the patient has a history of heavy drinking either currently or at some time in
the past. A history of smoking is also needed.
ability to live independently. Distinguish whether the problem is recent or chronic. Any evidence of
physical illness such as cerebrovascular disease may also be observed.
The patient’s behaviour may be suggestive of pathology. Observe for signs of psychomotor
retardation or agitation, perplexity or behavioural disturbance. An inability to focus or sustain
attention appropriately may be a sign of clouded consciousness.
Patients with acute or chronic brain syndromes often display a number of behaviours which can
jeopardize their placement in the community. Examples of such behaviours include day/night
reversal, wandering, aggression, sliding or throwing themselves to the floor, stripping off their
clothes and the smearing of faeces.
Speech
Cognitive impairment may result in circumlocution, paraphrasia and polite evasions hiding a lack
of depth and detail in speech. Severe hearing impairment may be overcome by communication
through gesture and/or writing.
The elderly with mixed affective states may demonstrate a ‘slow flight of ideas’.
Thought
Early dementia may be noticeable only after a lengthy interview with a repetition of themes, a lack
of internal logic, and a limitation of discussion inconsistent with the level of intelligence.
Mood
Depression is common and is often missed in the elderly. Mania, too, is easily missed in the elderly
and should always be considered.
Cognitive examination
If a patient is unable to give a reasonable account of himself or herself, it is often helpful to conduct
the cognitive assessment earlier in the interview. If the person has given a history, aspects of
cognitive functioning will already have been indirectly assessed.
THE EXAMINATION
The following aspects are assessed:
∑ orientation – to time, place and person
∑ attention and concentration – assessed using ‘serial sevens’ or naming months of the year
backwards if numerical abilities are not good
∑ immediate memory – assessed using digit span (normal 7 6 2)
∑ short-term verbal memory – assessed using name and address with six parts, repeated
immediately to assess registration, then again after 5 minutes with intervening distraction to
prevent rehearsal, also using Babcock sentence
∑ short-term non-verbal memory – assessed by immediate recall (registration) of a geometric
shape, then recall after 5 minutes with intervening distraction to prevent rehearsal
∑ long-term memory – assessed during history-taking (ask date and place of birth)
∑ general knowledge – assessed by asking historical and recent commonly known facts (e.g. the
current prime minister, monarch and family, the president of the USA, the colours of the Union
Jack, the names of capital cities)
Assessment of a referral 539
∑ verbal fluency – number of words beginning with T in one minute, or the number of four-legged
animals in one minute
∑ calculation – assessed by asking a simple calculation such as a subtraction
∑ writing
∑ spatial – including bodily awareness
∑ recognition – of objects and faces
∑ appropriate use of everyday objects
∑ naming things – to detect nominal dysphasia
∑ receptive and expressive use of written and spoken language
∑ perseveration – suggestive of frontal lobe dysfunction
∑ tests of praxis – such as drawing a square or a clock face (constructional apraxia), asking the
patient to make a fist, oppose thumb and little finger, fold a piece of paper and place it in an
envelope
∑ tests of gnosis – such as picture recognition, tactile recognition.
Physical examination
All elderly people presenting to psychiatry should have a full physical examination. Check the
person’s temperature (using a low-reading thermometer) and state of hydration if clouding of
consciousness is suspected.
Primitive reflexes are found mostly in dementing patients, although they may occur transiently
in acute confusional states. Examples include the palmomental reflex, grasp reflex, pout reflex,
sucking reflex and glabellar tap.
Tremors and involuntary movements are more common in old age, but be alert to the possibility
of a cerebrovascular event, the onset of Huntington’s or Wilson’s disease or, more commonly,
treatment with dopaminergic preparations such as L-dopa for Parkinson’s disease.
Increasing sensory impairments in old age, particularly of hearing and vision, predispose to
paranoid states. Closed angle glaucoma is a contraindication to the use of drugs with
anticholinergic side-effects, such as phenothiazines and tricyclic antidepressants.
Investigations
A chest X-ray is required in all sick elderly people, even if the chest is apparently clear on physical
examination. Pneumonia, tuberculosis and carcinoma can all present with acute confusional states,
or depression. An ECG is also required.
The prevalence of thyroid disease increases in old age. Physical signs are often unreliable in the
elderly, so TSH screening should be performed in all. Hyperthyroidism can be mistaken for anxiety
states, hypomania or delirium. Hypothyroidism can present as depression with psychomotor
retardation, dementia or delirium.
Routine investigations in the hospitalized elderly should include FBC with differential WCC,
ESR, U&E, creatinine, LFTs with calcium and proteins, glucose, TSH, ECG, chest X-ray, and a mid-
stream urine examination.
STRUCTURAL IMAGING
In normal ageing there is progressive cortical atrophy and increasing ventricular size. Imaging can
identify potentially treatable intracranial lesions.
540 Old-age psychiatry
Structural imaging is helpful in discovering the aetiology of dementia, although it does not
establish the diagnosis, which is determined clinically. The distribution of cerebral atrophy helps to
distinguish different types of dementia.
Alzheimer’s disease
Normal CT scans of brain do not reliably differentiate normals from those with Alzheimer’s disease,
with approximately 20% overlap between these groups. This limits the usefulness of scanning in the
individual patient. Generally cortical atrophy and ventricular enlargement are greater than in
controls, with increasing cognitive dysfunction correlating with increasing cerebral atrophy, but
more so with increasing ventricular size. An increase in ventricular size over a span of one year is
suggestive of Alzheimer’s disease.
The clinical usefulness of neuroimaging can be improved by using a temporal lobe orientation in
CT scanning which allows an accurate measurement of the medial temporal lobe. Using conven-
tional angle CT scans it is almost impossible to measure this. In Alzheimer’s disease a dramatic thin-
ning of the width of the medial temporal lobe in the region of the brainstem is seen. SPET scans also
reveal significantly reduced parietotemporal perfusion in these subjects. Combining SPET scans
with temporal-lobe-oriented CT scans improves the diagnostic accuracy of Alzheimer’s disease by
an order of magnitude over that derived using clinical criteria (likelihood ratio 30 vs 2.6).
Pick’s disease
Gross atrophy is seen in the frontotemporal regions (knife-blade atrophy), but the diagnosis cannot
be made on this evidence alone.
Huntington’s disease
Gross shrinkage of the caudate nucleus (‘loss of shouldering’) supports a clinical diagnosis of this
disease.
Multi-infarct dementia
Focal pathology suggestive of cerebrovascular infarcts and/or white matter changes suggestive of
small vessel vascular disease supports this diagnosis.
Normal-pressure hydrocephalus
Enlarged ventricles without cortical atrophy in the presence of normal CSF pressure on lumbar
puncture supports this diagnosis.
ELECTROENCEPHALOGRAPHY (EEG)
In normal ageing (after the age of 60) the following changes occur in the EEG:
∑ slowing of a rhythm
∑ increased q activity particularly in the left temporal region
∑ increased d activity particularly in the anterior regions
∑ diminished b activity (only in those aged over 80).
Dementias
In Alzheimer’s disease the EEG may be normal (6%) or show minor non-specific changes. The
following changes may occur:
∑ diffuse slowing in early stages
∑ reduced a and b activity, plus increased q and d activity as the disease progresses
∑ paroxysmal bifrontal d waves (more common than in normal ageing).
Assessment of a referral 541
In Pick’s disease the EEG is more likely than in Alzheimer’s disease to be normal, and shows less
slowing of the a waves.
In vascular dementia the tracing shows asymmetry and localized slow waves, with a sparing of
background activity.
In Creutzfeld–Jacob disease a slow background rhythm with paroxysmal sharp waves is
characteristic.
In Huntington’s disease a low-voltage pattern may be seen.
Delirium
Most conditions causing delirium cause slowing of the EEG tracing:
∑ Metabolic causes:
∑ hepatic encephalopathy – slowing of rhythm with posterior preservation; triphasic waves are
highly indicative
∑ acute renal failure – low-voltage activity with posterior slowing
∑ bursts of q activity
∑ hypocalcaemia – slowing with bursts of spikes
∑ hypercalcaemia – runs of 1- to 2-second waves
∑ hyperthyroidism – acceleration of a rhythm
∑ hypothyroidism – low-voltage EEG.
∑ Drugs:
∑ phenothiazines – increase voltage, slow a activity, reduce b activity; in overdose, paroxysmal
slow waves are characteristic
∑ antidepressants – increase EEG activity but reduce a rhythm; in overdose, widespread a
activity and spikes
∑ benzodiazepines – increase b waves, especially frontal; in overdose, prominent fast activity
unresponsive to stimuli
∑ lithium – slow a rhythm with occasional, sometimes focal, spikes; in overdose, diffuse
slowing, triphasic waves and paroxysmal abnormalities.
Of those with delirium, 90% of patients have abnormal traces. Delta activity, asymmetry in d
waves and localized spike and sharp wave complexes occur more frequently in those with
intracranial pathology. Alpha activity correlates with cognitive functioning, and d activity correlates
with the length of illness.
Psychological assessment
Changes in psychological functions such as mood, personality, behaviour and cognition are often
the first signs of psychiatric illness in the elderly. Various scales have been devised to provide for the
accurate and objective assessment of all aspects of psychological functioning in the elderly. The
simpler tests can be used by non-psychologist disciplines in their assessment and monitoring of
the elderly mentally ill. Psychologists can help other disciplines in their roles, and take on the
psychometric assessments of those patients with confusing or particularly demanding clinical
pictures.
PSYCHOMETRIC TESTING
This quantifies the level and range of ability. Serial measures can be used to monitor the effect of
interventions, or to measure progress of the patient’s condition over time.
542 Old-age psychiatry
It is essential, when any particular test is used in the elderly, that it has been validated in the
elderly population, and that its predictions have also been validated.
EXPERIENTIAL ASSESSMENT
This tries to clarify the nature of impairment. By understanding the nature of the impairment it is
possible to develop interventions which ameliorate the impairment.
Social assessment
This involves a detailed assessment of:
∑ living conditions
∑ personal care
∑ dynamics of family/carer
∑ support network
∑ financial situation
Psychological reactions to physical disease 543
∑ family structure
∑ level of independence
∑ physical functioning in the person’s environment.
Assessment is usually conducted by a social worker, but it may also be undertaken by other
disciplines in the multidisciplinary team with appropriate training and supervision.
Theories of ‘successful ageing’ maintain that elderly people select a range of activities they want or
need to do, then optimize their performance of these activities, and compensate for losses of
physical or mental abilities.
Because of the increased prevalence of multiple pathology, adverse social circumstances and loss
in old age, the understanding of the psychological consequences of physical disease must take into
account physical, mental and social factors.
Sensory impairment
Most commonly seen are impairment of hearing and/or vision. These have a dramatic impact upon
the individual’s ability to communicate with others which may cause social withdrawal, reduced
activity and apparent cognitive decline. They may increase the risks of depression and paraphrenia
in the elderly although this is not proven.
Alzheimer’s disease
CLINICAL FEATURES
Alzheimer’s disease (AD) is a diagnosis that can be made with accuracy only at post-mortem.
However, it is possible to make a reasonably accurate diagnosis on the basis of clinical findings.
AD may present at any stage of the illness. Clinical features are most easily considered in stages:
∑ Early stage – until about 2 years:
∑ impaired concentration
Dementia in old age 545
∑ memory impairment
∑ fatigue and anxiety
∑ fleeting depression of mood
∑ exaggeration of pre-existing personality traits
∑ unusual incidents cause increasing concern
∑ occasional difficulty with word-finding
∑ altered handwriting
∑ perseveration of words and phrases.
∑ Intermediate stage:
∑ further deterioration in above
∑ neurological abnormalities start to appear
∑ 5–10% develop epilepsy
∑ apraxias and agnosias develop
∑ disorientation in time and space
∑ get lost in familiar surroundings
∑ speech problems with nominal dysphasia, receptive dysphasia, expressive dysphasia,
dysarthria, reduced vocabulary
∑ groping for words, mispronunciation, reiteration of parts of words (logoclonia), echolalia
∑ reduced ability to read and write
∑ concurrent progressive memory loss involving recent and past events
∑ misidentification (e.g. mirror sign)
∑ emotional lability
∑ catastrophic reaction (extreme anxiety and tearfulness when unable to complete a task)
∑ motor restlessness or inertia.
∑ Late stage:
∑ all intellectual functions grossly impaired
∑ considerable neurological disability
∑ increased muscle tone
∑ wide-based unsteady gait
∑ personality changes, often with fatuous gross euphoria
∑ no communication
∑ failure to recognize self or family
∑ speech replaced by jargon dysphasia.
∑ Final stage:
∑ no personality
∑ no communication
∑ emaciated
∑ incontinent
∑ limb contractures
∑ death often from pneumonia and inanition.
AETIOLOGY
As mentioned in Chapter 11, the neuropathological findings in Alzheimer’s disease include:
∑ intracytoplasmic neurofibrillary tangles
∑ extracellular senile (argyrophilic) plaques which comprise a central core of amyloid, silica and
aluminium
∑ granulovacuolar degeneration
∑ amyloid deposited in walls of blood vessels.
546 Old-age psychiatry
These are found in normal ageing but are more extensive in Alzheimer’s disease. Similar
neuropathology is observed in the brains of those with Down’s syndrome (trisomy 21) who survive
into middle age.
There is significant loss of neurones in the brains of Alzheimer’s disease patients compared to
controls. Most neuronal loss is found in the superior, middle and inferior frontal gyri, superior and
middle temporal gyri and the cingulate gyrus.
The cause of Alzheimer’s disease is not known but there are several theories.
Ageing
There is no clear neuropathological division between Alzheimer’s disease and normal ageing,
leading to speculation as to whether Alzheimer’s disease is a discrete disease entity or the extreme
end of a normal spectrum of age-related decline. However, the distribution of neurohistological
findings suggests the former. Plaques and tangles are commonly found in the ageing hippocampus,
but much more rarely in the neocortex as is seen in Alzheimer’s disease.
Neurotransmitter abnormalities
Neurotransmitter abnormalities include a wide range of changes in catecholamines and
neuropeptides. Of most interest is the low cortical cholinergic activity and reduced choline
acetyltransferase especially in the temporal cortex. This is thought to be secondary to the
degeneration of neurones in the nucleus basalis of Meynert which provides the cortex with its
cholinergic projection.
Genetic factors
Genetic factors must account for the disease in some patients. It is familial in some families,
especially those in which the onset is early (under 65, presenile dementia). It is also hypothesized
that late-onset Alzheimer’s disease is an autosomal dominant trait with age-dependent expression
and low penetrance, resulting in apparent sporadic cases. The finding of Alzheimer’s disease in
many patients with Down’s syndrome who reach middle age has focused interest on chromosome
21 on which is located the amyloid precursor protein gene. Research has demonstrated that a defect
in this gene is not the cause of Alzheimer’s disease, but there is increasing agreement that in both
familial and sporadic Alzheimer’s disease the post-translational processing of amyloid precursor
protein is abnormal. Work is now ongoing to investigate other genetic modifications on
chromosome 21 which may contribute to the abnormal deposition of amyloid.
Environmental factors
Aluminium. The brains of those with Alzheimer’s disease contain more total aluminium than those
of controls. Aluminium is found in the areas of the brain most affected in Alzheimer’s disease,
particularly in the neurones containing tangles, and in the core of senile plaques. Some studies have
reported higher concentrations of aluminium in drinking water associated with a higher prevalence
of Alzheimer’s disease, but these are not consistent. Those receiving haemodialysis accumulate
aluminium from the dialysate. Before this was recognized patients developed severe dementia. Steps
are now taken to reduce the burden of aluminium accumulation in those receiving haemodialysis.
Aluminium probably accumulates in the brains of those with Alzheimer’s disease secondary to the
disease process rather than being directly causative. It remains possible that aluminium is a
contributory factor in some cases of Alzheimer’s disease.
Head injury. In sporadic Alzheimer’s disease there is an increased risk in those who have
experienced head injury within the preceding 10 years.
Infection. It is hypothesized that an infectious agent entering via the transolfactory route may be
Dementia in old age 547
responsible for some cases of Alzheimer’s disease. Herpes simplex type 1 is known to have a
predilection for those brain areas particularly affected in Alzheimer’s disease and is suspected by
some as a possible cause. However, this remains speculative.
MANAGEMENT
A multidisciplinary team is essential, as are close links with physicians, general practitioners, social
services and the voluntary sector. The Alzheimer’s Disease Society can provide carers with valuable
information about local facilities, and often run local counselling and sitting services.
Driving should cease as soon as there is any evidence that it may be unsafe. The patient should be
asked to inform the DVLC, but if they fail to do so, the doctor has a duty to inform them.
Small doses of neuroleptic medication may be needed in those patients who are agitated,
distressed, aggressive or who have sleep reversal. The elderly, and particularly those with organic
brain syndromes, can be exquisitely sensitive to the adverse effects of psychotropic drugs, so caution
should be taken with starting doses. Caution with atypical antipsychotics which have been
withdrawn for this indication.
Those with Alzheimer’s disease are predisposed to developing depression which may require
treatment with antidepressant medication, preferably using preparations with few antiadrenergic
and anticholinergic (antimuscarinic) side-effects (e.g. SSRIs).
Psychological approaches include the behavioural management of problem behaviours, reality
orientation, reminiscence therapy and music therapy.
Those with Alzheimer’s disease are more sensitive to cerebral insults and are more prone to
developing superimposed acute organic brain syndromes (delirium) than healthy people. A sudden
deterioration in functioning should prompt a search for superimposed potentially treatable
pathology.
See Appendix 2 for a summary of the NICE technology appraisal guidance for Alzheimer’s
disease.
PROGNOSIS
Disease progression varies considerably from subject to subject. The younger the age of onset the
more rapid the decline. In those aged under 50 the mean survival time is about 7 years, whereas in
those aged between 55 and 74 the mean survival is increased to about 9 years.
Poor prognostic factors include:
∑ significant language impairment
∑ poor cognitive functioning
∑ clinical evidence of parietal lobe involvement
∑ CT scan showing reduced density of left parietal region.
Vascular dementia
CLINICAL FEATURES
Vascular dementia is characterized by a stepwise deteriorating course with a patchy distribution of
neurological and neuropsychological deficits. There is evidence of vascular diseases on physical
examination (hypertension, hypertensive changes on fundoscopy, carotid bruits, enlarged heart,
focal neurological signs suggestive of cerebrovascular accident).
548 Old-age psychiatry
Binswanger’s disease
This is a progressive subcortical vascular encephalopathy with CT scan revealing markedly enlarged
ventricles secondary to infarction in hemispheric white matter. Infarcts are observed to affect
periventricular and central white matter. The age of onset is 50–65, with a gradual accumulation of
neurological signs, dementia and disturbances in motor function including pseudobulbar palsy.
There is often a history of severe hypertension, systemic vascular disease and stroke.
Leuko-araiosis
This was used by Hachinski to describe CT scan appearances of reduced density of white matter. It
differs from infarcts in that it affects only white matter, is patchy and diffuse and does not result in
the enlargement of cerebral sulci or ventricles. It is found in non-demented subjects as well as those
with degenerative and vascular dementia.
AETIOLOGY
There is an excess of vascular dementia in males, which is probably caused by an increased
prevalence of cardiovascular disease in men. Hypertension is the most frequent risk factor among
those with vascular dementia. Risk factors known to increase the risk of stroke also increase the risk
of vascular dementia; e.g. cigarette smoking, heart disease, hyperlipidaemia, and moderate alcohol
consumption.
MANAGEMENT
As well as the general management of the dementing patient and carers as outlined earlier in the
chapter, with vascular dementia it is worth attempting to treat the underlying cardiovascular
condition in order to slow or halt the progression of the condition. The treatment of hypertension
is important. Depression may respond to an antidepressant.
PROGNOSIS
The rate of progression to death is similar in this group to those suffering from Alzheimer’s disease
(see above). Poor prognostic factors include:
Dementia in old age 549
∑ severity of dementia
∑ bedridden
∑ urinary incontinence.
CLINICAL FEATURES
Frontal lobe dementias have a younger age of onset than Alzheimer’s disease, with a larger
proportion presenting in the under-65 group. There is a slow insidious onset with marked frontal
lobe features including disinhibition with reduced social awareness and lack of judgement.
Shallowness, lability of affect, inappropriate jocularity (Witzelsucht) and apathy are typical.
Persistent pain, hyperalgesia, and Kluver–Bucy syndrome may also occur. Obsessionality in daily
routine and language difficulties characterized by reduced spontaneity, reduced output, stereotyped
phrases, perseveration, echolalia and finally mutism are seen. Memory loss is variable, and not as
marked as in Alzheimer’s disease, and agnosias and dyspraxias are less common.
CT scan reveals frontotemporal atrophy.
AETIOLOGY
Genes are clearly implicated, with one-half of cases showing a family history. Little else is known
about the aetiology of these conditions.
CLINICAL FEATURES
Cognitive deficits seem to occur in most subjects with Parkinson’s disease; it is possible that those
considered to be suffering from dementia are simply those at the extreme end of cognitive decline
in this condition.
550 Old-age psychiatry
AETIOLOGY
This is not known. It is known that in Parkinson’s disease there is damage to the ascending
monoaminergic system affecting central dopamine, serotonin and noradrenaline systems. There is
also damage to substantia innominata, causing cortical cholinergic disruption.
All patients with Parkinson’s disease have Lewy bodies in their cerebral cortex, with a subset
having more Lewy bodies than most. Not all of these have dementia, although it appears that all
have some evidence of cognitive decline.
MANAGEMENT
Exclude treatable pathology, such as depression or acute brain syndrome.
Treatment with anti-parkinsonian drugs does not improve the cognitive manifestations of the
disease. Avoid anticholinergic drugs if possible.
Transplants of fetal nerve cells is experimental and may improve the outlook for those with
Parkinson’s disease. It is not known how helpful this will be in the treatment of dementia of
Parkinson’s disease.
CLINICAL FEATURES
Memory impairment progresses into dementia and a motor disorder often suggestive of Parkinson’s
disease. The dementia is often like that of Alzheimer’s disease but is more likely to have features
suggestive of an acute brain syndrome such as a fluctuating mental state, altered conscious level and
hallucinations.
Cortical Lewy body disease is diagnosed in those presenting with dementia suggestive of
Alzheimer’s disease, but in whom parkinsonian features develop.
PROGNOSIS
There is terminal decline.
Dementia in old age 551
Normal-pressure hydrocephalus
CLINICAL FEATURES
There is insidious onset of dementia with psychomotor retardation, unsteady gait and urinary
incontinence. Onset is usually in the 60s or 70s. Behavioural disturbance, hallucinations and
paranoia are uncommon.
The diagnosis is made on the basis of clinical presentation, with a CT scan of the brain revealing
dilated ventricles (especially the third ventricle) without cortical atrophy, with normal CSF
pressures.
AETIOLOGY
There is obstruction to outflow of cerebrospinal fluid from the subarachnoid space, but the
ventricular system remains in communication with the subarachnoid space thus allowing CSF to
flow out of the ventricular system. This scenario is associated with:
∑ subarachnoid haemorrhage
∑ cerebrovascular disease
∑ meningoencephalitis
∑ post-intracranial surgery.
MANAGEMENT
Insertion of a shunt will allow the drainage of CSF from the ventricles to the heart.
PROGNOSIS
The best results are seen in those with a full clinical syndrome, a short history and an obvious cause
for their condition. Mental and physical improvement is likely after surgery.
One-third of those undergoing surgery will develop complications such as:
∑ shunt infection and malfunction
∑ epilepsy
∑ subdural haematoma.
CLINICAL FEATURES
There may be a brief prodromal period of anxiety, depression or hallucinations. Sudden onset and
rapid progression of dementia, pyramidal and extrapyramidal deficits present usually in the 50- to
60-year age group.
Physical features include limb spasticity, muscular wasting and fasciculation, tremor, rigidity,
choreiathetoid movements, myoclonus, dysarthria and dysphagia. Convulsions may occur.
In addition to the above classic form, three variant forms are described:
552 Old-age psychiatry
∑ Heidenhain form. Prominent visual defects may result in cortical blindness. Extrapyramidal
symptoms and myoclonus occur.
∑ Ataxic form. There is rapidly progressive cerebellar ataxia, with involuntary movements and
myoclonic jerks. Finally muteness and generalized rigidity occur.
∑ Cortical form. This includes parietal lobe symptoms.
The EEG is always abnormal in CJD, showing an increase in slow-wave activity, a reduction in a
rhythm; as the disease progresses, bilateral slow spike wave discharges may accompany myoclonic
jerks.
AETIOLOGY
Microscopy of brain material reveals vacuolar changes in grey matter particularly in cerebral and
cerebellar cortex, creating characteristic spongiform appearances. There is a loss of nerve cells and
reactive astrocytosis. About 10% of cases appear to be familial.
The disease is transmissible to laboratory animals by intracerebral inoculation, with symptoms
developing years later. The efect is similar to spongiform encephalopathies observed in animals
(scrapie in sheep, bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE) in cows). Prion protein is responsible
for transmission. This is an unusual infective agent since it does not appear to contain nucleic
acid, being made up entirely of protein. It differs from normal cell-membrane-derived proteins in
that it is highly resistant to degradation by cellular proteases, heat or conventional chemical disin-
fectants.
CJD has been transmitted in man through dural grafts; through human pituitary-derived growth
hormone used to treat children with growth hormone deficiency; and through cross-contamination
from instruments used in brain biopsy. Pathologists and those handling human brain tissue are also
at increased risk of developing this condition.
A form of CJD known as the BSE variant has been identified in humans. It has a slightly different
clinical presentation. There can be onset in younger people. It is rapidly progressive and is thought
to be associated with eating or being otherwise exposed to cattle infected with BSE.
Other human diseases related to CJD in humans include kuru and Gerstmann–Sträussler
syndrome. Kuru results from eating human brain and causes a cerebellar degeneration.
Gerstmann–Sträussler syndrome is inherited with cerebellar ataxia forming a prominent clinical
feature. Both are extremely rare.
PROGNOSIS
There is terminal decline.
CLINICAL FEATURES
There is initial lethargy, apathy, cognitive disturbance, reduced libido and general withdrawal. As the
condition progresses evidence of dementia becomes apparent with cognitive disturbance,
incontinence, ataxia, hyperreflexia and increased muscle tone.
Dementia in old age 553
AETIOLOGY
Although HIV infection results in complications such as opportunistic cerebral involvement of
cytomegalovirus, and cerebral lymphoma, the encephalopathy of HIV is thought to be directly
caused by HIV which is a neurotropic virus.
Pathology is found in the white matter of cerebral and cerebellar hemispheres and in deep
grey matter. Multinucleated giant cells deriving from macrophages are found in the affected
brain tissue.
CLINICAL FEATURES
The onset is usually between the ages of 35 and 45, but childhood onset accounts for 10–20% of
cases. The onset is insidious, with fidgety movements or non-specific psychiatric symptoms in the
early stages.
Movement disorder consists of choreiform movements in the head, face and arms, ill-sustained
and jerky voluntary and involuntary movements affecting all muscles, and a distinctive wide-based
gait with sudden lurching.
Psychiatric disturbance is variable but common. Initial insight may result in depression.
Prodromal personality changes, antisocial behaviour with substance misuse, affective and
schizophreniform disorders are sometimes seen. Insight gives way to mild euphoria with explosive
outbursts, irritability and rage. There is a slowly progressive intellectual impairment, with some
patients profoundly demented in the final stages, whereas others remain reasonably aware.
AETIOLOGY
Transmission is mostly by a fully penetrant single autosomal-dominant gene (located on
chromosome 4), affecting 50% of offspring (see Chapter 19 for more details). Occasionally sporadic
cases occur.
Pathological appearances include a marked atrophy of head of caudate nucleus and putamen,
severe generalized neuronal loss resulting in cortical atrophy which is most marked over the frontal
lobes, with ventricular dilatation.
MANAGEMENT
Tetrabenazine helps to reduce the movement disorder. Antidepressants, ECT and minor
tranquillizers may be helpful in the early stages, with phenothiazines in low dose in later stages to
control behavioural disturbance.
Genetic counselling for family members should be offered.
554 Old-age psychiatry
PROGNOSIS
The duration to death is 12–16 years.
CLINICAL FEATURES
The condition develops 5–25 years after primary infection with Treponema pallidum. The onset is
usually gradual with depression a dominant symptom. There is then slowly progressive memory
and intellectual impairment. Frontal lobes are particularly involved, resulting in characteristic
personality change with disinhibition, uncontrolled excitement, and over-activity which may be
mistaken for hypomania. Grandiose delusions are present in only 10%.
Physically there is slurred speech, a tremor of lips and tongue and Argyll Robertson pupil in 50%.
As the condition progresses there is increasing leg weakness leading to spastic paralysis.
The Wasserman Reaction on CSF examination is always positive, with lymphocytosis, raised
protein and raised globulin.
AETIOLOGY
The disease is a terminal consequence of syphilis. There is marked cerebral atrophy with meningeal
thickening, resulting from neuronal loss and astrocyte proliferation. The presence of iron pigment
in microglia and perivascular spaces is specific for the disease. Spirochaetes are found in the cortex
in 50% of cases.
This is a state of fluctuating global disturbance of the cerebral function, abrupt in onset and of short
duration, arising as a consequence of physical illness or toxic effects.
It is most common at the extremes of life both in the very young and the elderly. This may be
caused by reduced cerebral reserve, a concurrence of multiple physical problems and a higher
prevalence of polypharmacy in the elderly.
It affects 10–25% of the over-65s admitted to medical wards. Those with dementia are
particularly vulnerable to developing superimposed delirium.
CLINICAL FEATURES
AETIOLOGY
Although delirium presents with global disturbance of cognitive function, certain neurological
pathways seem to be specifically involved. Autonomic disturbance implicates the brainstem.
Cholinergic and adrenergic pathways are also thought to mediate delirium.
Any physical insult can result in delirium particularly in a predisposed individual. In the elderly
the following causes are the most common:
∑ hypoxia
∑ infection
∑ metabolic disturbance
∑ iatrogenic
∑ CNS disease
∑ epilepsy.
MANAGEMENT
Delirious patients should be fully investigated physically. The treatment of delirium is the treatment
of the underlying condition.
Hydration and nutrition should be monitored. Vitamin supplements, particularly thiamine,
should be administered if there is any possibility of previous alcohol abuse or malnutrition.
Confusion is minimized if the delirious patient is nursed as consistently as possible by the same
staff, in a well-illuminated environment. The patient should be aided in his or her orientation by
providing environmental cues such as signposting and repeating information slowly and regularly.
Drugs known to exacerbate delirium should be avoided if possible. Sleep reversal may respond to
small doses of temazepam or thioridazine. Disturbed behaviour not amenable to other
interventions, such as gentle reassurance, may respond to treatment with a neuroleptic. Haloperidol
is the most frequently used in this situation because it is effective and safe.
PROGNOSIS
Between 30% and 40% of delirious patients on medical wards die of the underlying condition.
However, those who recover have a good prognosis, and only 5% go on to develop dementia.
Depressive symptoms affect 11–16% of the over-65s. About 3% suffer major depression.
556 Old-age psychiatry
Female first admissions for affective illness peak at age 80, then fall off. Male first admissions
continue to climb until the end of life, overtaking women at the age of 85.
The prevalence of depression declines with advancing age despite the above findings. This may
be because of a survivor effect with fewer young depressed surviving to old age, or it may imply that
depression in older age is more likely to require inpatient admission.
CLINICAL FEATURES
Elderly depressives present with much the same features of depression as younger people, but the
following may be more common in the elderly:
∑ hypochondriacal preoccupations
∑ psychomotor retardation or agitation
∑ paranoid and delusional ideation
∑ neurovegetative symptoms
∑ depressive pseudodementia
∑ behavioural disturbance (e.g. food refusal, aggressive behaviour, shoplifting, alcohol abuse)
∑ minimization/denial of low mood
∑ complaints of loneliness
∑ complaints disproportionate to organic pathology and pain of unknown origin
∑ onset of neurotic symptoms.
DIAGNOSIS
Because the elderly commonly suffer from coexistent physical disorders affecting neurovegetative
functioning, the diagnosis of depression can prove more difficult than in the young. A careful
history usually suffices to address this difficulty. The Geriatric Depression Scale is helpful since it
focuses almost entirely on cognitive rather than physical symptoms of depressive disorder and is
easy to administer.
AETIOLOGY
Genetic factors
The genetic contribution to depressive illness reduces with age. The risk of depression in first-degree
relatives is lowered with the increasing age of onset of depression in the proband. The risks to
relatives are also lower if there has been only a single episode, whereas they are increased with
recurrent depression in the proband.
Neurobiological factors
Felix Post (1968) suggested that subtle cerebral changes may make ageing persons increasingly liable
to affective disorders.
A subgroup of elderly depressives have ventricular enlargement on a CT scan of the brain. They
are characterized as being older, with a later age of onset, more neurovegetative symptoms, and a
higher death rate at 2 years than elderly depressives without ventricular enlargement. CT scan
appearances in late-onset depressives are more comparable to those with Alzheimer’s disease than
to those with early-onset depression or normal controls. Thus early- and late-onset depression may
be different disorders, and the late-onset type may have a stronger association with neurological
dementing disorders than the early-onset type.
Depression in old age 557
Depressed patients with ischaemic brain lesions have more vascular risk factors and less family
history of mood disorders than those without.
In a proportion of elderly depressives, subtle brain disease is a risk factor.
Physical illness
Depression can present secondary to a variety of physical conditions, and may sometimes be the
first indication of ill-health. The following are the main causes of secondary depression which is
more common in the elderly:
∑ occult carcinoma, particularly of lung and pancreas
∑ chronic obstructive airways disease (COAD)
∑ cerebrovascular accident (CVA)
∑ myocardial infarction (MI)
∑ hypercalcaemia
∑ Cushing’s disease
∑ hypo- and hyperthyroidism
∑ alcoholism
∑ pernicious anaemia
∑ iatrogenic – steroids, b-blockers, methyl-dopa, reserpine, clonidine, nifedipine, digitalis, L-dopa,
tetrabenazine
∑ infections – brucellosis, neurosyphilis, influenza.
Personality
It is suggested that personality dysfunction is associated with some late-life depression.
Environmental factors
Murphy (1982) found an association between the onset of depression and severe life events
occurring significantly more commonly in the previous year compared to healthy controls. These
included physical illness, separation, bereavement, financial loss and enforced change of residence.
MANAGEMENT
The depressed elderly person should be treated in much the same way as a depressed younger
person, with antidepressants in an adequate dose for an adequate duration. The choice of
antidepressant will depend on concurrent physical morbidity, and the dose is generally lower,
particularly when commencing a new drug.
Although tricyclic antidepressants are not absolutely contraindicated in the elderly, they have
cardiotoxic properties and cause sedation and confusion in some. Thus lofepramine is often
preferred. Alternatively trazodone and SSRIs are sometimes better tolerated.
Deluded depressed patients require the addition of a neuroleptic.
ECT remains the most effective treatment for depression and is the treatment of choice in those
with life-threatening depression. It is generally well tolerated, although memory problems may
follow, so unilateral electrode placement is sometimes considered preferable. It is contraindicated in
those with raised intracranial pressure, and is inadvisable within 3–6 months of a cerebrovascular
accident, pulmonary embolus or myocardial infarction. However, the anaesthetist’s views should be
sought in any patient over whom there is particular concern. The liable consequences of
inadequately treated or resistant depression should be weighed against the potential adverse effects
of a general anaesthetic and ECT. Monoamine oxidase inhibitors should be discontinued at least 10
days prior to giving ECT.
558 Old-age psychiatry
About two-thirds of cases resistant to first-line therapy show an improvement with lithium
augmentation. Generally this is well tolerated, although the levels need careful monitoring in those
with impaired renal function or those on diuretics.
Psychotherapy can be considered, although this should usually be in addition to drug therapy.
Socially isolated elderly depressed patients are at a high risk of committing suicide, so it is
important that they be treated energetically.
PROGNOSIS
Depression in old age is a heterogeneous condition and therefore has a heterogeneous outcome.
Seventy per cent of elderly depressives recover within a year, but 20% relapse. The death rate is
higher for late-life depressives than for non-depressed patients.
Chronicity in late-life depression is more common in those with:
∑ active medical illness
∑ high severity of depression
∑ melancholic features
∑ delusions
∑ cognitive impairment
∑ morphologic brain abnormalities.
The development of a transient dementia syndrome during a depressive episode, the onset of the
first depressive episode in very old age, and abnormalities in brain morphology may be predictors
of dementia in an elderly person with major depression.
In most elderly people suffering from mania, the age of onset was usually in their young adult life.
However, in the elderly population, the onset of the first manic episode is bimodally distributed
with peaks at ages 37 and 73. Mania in the elderly is relatively uncommon, comprising about 5% of
elderly psychiatric admissions.
AETIOLOGY
Genetic factors
Late-onset cases appear to have less genetic loading than younger-onset cases, with fewer of the
former giving a family history of affective disorder.
Organic factors
Secondary mania is that arising in a patient with no previous history of affective disorder, soon after
a physical illness such as cerebral tumour or infection. However, evidence suggests that this is more
likely to arise in those genetically predisposed to a bipolar affective disorder by virtue of a family
history of such.
People with late-onset mania have a greater number of large subcortical hyperintensities on
brain magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) compared to controls. It is thought that some cases of
late-onset mania are a subtype of secondary mania attributable to changes in the brain’s deep white
matter.
Paraphrenia in old age 559
CLINICAL FEATURES
These are similar to the features in younger adults, but it is thought that the following are more
common in elderly manic patients:
∑ garrulousness
∑ slow flight of ideas
∑ cognitive impairment
∑ irritable surliness
∑ mixed affective states
∑ depression following soon after mania recovers.
MANAGEMENT
Most patients require treatment in hospital. Treatment is with neuroleptics and/or lithium, with the
addition of carbamazepine if this is not fully effective. If the person is unresponsive or intolerant to
this combination, ECT can be effective for manic or mixed affective states. Lithium prophylaxis is
advisable in the longer term.
PROGNOSIS
The outlook is the same as in bipolar disorder. Recurrence is usual and therefore mood stabilizers
are advisable in the longer term.
EXPLANATORY NOTE
Paraphrenia is a term introduced originally by Kraepelin in 1909 to describe a psychotic condition
characterized by the relatively late age of first onset, chronic delusions and hallucinations, the
preservation of volition and a lack of personality deterioration. The term quickly lost favour until
Roth reintroduced it in 1955 to describe late paraphrenia, a condition with age of first onset after 60
years, well-organized delusions with or without hallucinations, and a well-preserved personality
and affective response.
ICD-9 allowed the diagnosis of paraphrenia, but this has been dropped from ICD-10. In ICD-10,
late-onset disorders are not differentiated from early-onset disorders, so most paraphrenias are
coded in ICD-10 under schizophrenia or delusional disorders.
Despite this development in the ICD-10 classification of late-life psychoses, evidence suggests
that some late-onset delusional disorders are distinct from schizophrenia, and the use of the term
late paraphrenia therefore persists.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
Good epidemiological studies in this area have not been completed. It is estimated that in
Camberwell (London) there is an annual incidence of late paraphrenia of 17–26 per 100 000. There
is a well-established preponderance of females over males in late paraphrenia. Late paraphrenics are
more likely to be unmarried, and have a lower fecundity than controls.
560 Old-age psychiatry
CLINICAL FEATURES
Osvaldo et al. (1995) studied the psychopathology of late paraphrenics and found the following:
∑ All had at least one type of delusion. These most frequently involved persecution and self-
reference; delusions of thought broadcast, sin, guilt and grandiosity were also present.
∑ Forty-six per cent had at least one Schneiderian first-rank symptom.
∑ Eighty-three per cent had some hallucinatory experience, most commonly auditory, but also
visual, somatic, and olfactory.
∑ Thought disorder and catatonic symptoms were almost never seen.
∑ Inappropriate affect was not seen.
∑ Negative symptoms were seen frequently but were mild.
∑ Other psychiatric symptoms such as worry, irritability, poor concentration, self-neglect and
obsessive features were all seen more commonly in late paraphrenics than in controls.
AETIOLOGY
Genetic factors
There is an increased risk of schizophrenia in the first-degree relatives of paraphrenics, but it is less
than the risk to the relatives of younger-onset schizophrenics.
Paraphrenia is partly genetically determined, but the part played by inheritance requires further
study.
Personality
In a subset of paraphrenic patients there is a history of those who have long-standing paranoid
personalities which are thought to predispose to the development of paraphrenia in old age.
Sensory impairment
Hearing impairment is associated with the development of paranoid symptoms. The characteris-
tics most strongly associated with late paraphrenia are the early age of onset of hearing impair-
ment, long duration and profound hearing loss. Auditory hallucinations are most consistently
associated with hearing loss. It is thought that deafness may exert its action through increased
social isolation, withdrawal and suspiciousness. Late paraphrenia has also been associated with
visual impairment.
Brain disease
Compared to normal controls, late paraphrenics have significantly larger cerebral ventricles and are
more cognitively impaired.
Miller et al. (1991), in an MRI study of non-demented late paraphrenics, found that organic
brain pathology was common. In a group selected to exclude obvious organic pathology, the
following abnormalities were found:
∑ Forty-two per cent had structural brain abnormalities, with white matter lesions particularly
evident in temporal, occipital and frontal areas.
∑ Fifty-eight per cent had neuromedical illness, such as tumours and metabolic disorders.
∑ Twenty-five per cent had evidence of silent cerebral vascular disease, most commonly associated
with hypertension.
∑ Neuropsychological testing revealed deficits in intellectual, frontal lobe and verbal memory
functions.
Anxiety in old age 561
MANAGEMENT
Assessment and management are usually best undertaken in the patient’s home where the
psychopathology is most likely to be evident. Time must be spent developing a rapport and trying
to engage with the patient. Day-centre attendance may be helpful in increasing socialization.
If sensory impairment is present there is evidence that the condition can improve upon
treatment of the deficit (e.g. a hearing aid for the deaf person).
The treatment of metabolic disorders or other physical conditions may bring about an
improvement in the mental state. The treatment of hypertension may prevent a deterioration if this
is caused by silent cerebrovascular disease.
Neuroleptic medication may bring about an improvement. A substantial minority show no
significant response, and about one-quarter show a full response to treatment. Treatment response
is associated with improved compliance, the use of depot medication, an involvement of a CPN, and
lower medication doses.
PROGNOSIS
Some patients make little or no response to treatment, while others make a full response. Long-term
contact with psychiatric services is required.
Anxiety disorders are often chronic, but about one-third of cases in the elderly have an onset after
the age of 65 years.
Phobias
Phobias are quite evenly distributed across the age groups, with lower rates in the over-75s
compared to the 65- to 75-year group. Phobias are the most common psychiatric disorder in elderly
women in a community sample. Specific phobias are more common than agoraphobia or social
phobia. The 1-month prevalence for phobic disorders is approximately 10%.
Panic disorder
This is rarely encountered in the elderly. The 1-month prevalence for panic disorder in <1%.
CLINICAL FEATURES
Features are generally similar to those seen in younger adults, but the following are more common
in the elderly:
∑ anxious preoccupation with physical illness, finance, crime and family
∑ subjectively impaired sleep which may be a normal part of ageing
∑ somatic symptoms of anxiety may be misattributed to physical causes
∑ abuse and over-prescription of sedative drugs.
562 Old-age psychiatry
AETIOLOGY
Environmental factors
Early parental loss is associated with phobic disorders in younger and older adults.
Physical illness
Anxiety disorders and neuroses are associated with increased mortality and increased
cardiovascular, respiratory and gastrointestinal morbidity.
The onset of agoraphobia after the age of 65 is often associated with a physical insult such as a
myocardial infarction, surgery or a fracture.
Anxiety symptoms can be caused by a number of physical disorders, and a full physical
examination should form a part of the assessment of the elderly anxious patient. Causes include:
∑ cardiovascular (e.g. myocardial infarction, cardiac arrhythmia, postural hypotension)
∑ respiratory (e.g. pulmonary embolism, asthma, hypoxia, COAD)
∑ endocrine (e.g. hyper/hypothyroidism, hypoglycaemia, phaeochromocytoma)
∑ neurological (e.g. epilepsy, cerebral tumour, vestibular disease)
∑ drug-induced (e.g. caffeine, sympathomimetics, sedative withdrawal).
Comorbidity
There are high levels of comorbidity with other psychiatric conditions, particularly depression.
Late-onset cases of anxiety are almost always associated with depression, which may be either a
primary or secondary association.
MANAGEMENT
Although there is less formal evaluation of therapies for anxiety disorders in the elderly, there is
evidence that they do respond to psychological interventions including behavioural, cognitive and
anxiety-management training.
Benzodiazepines and other sedatives are not generally indicated in the treatment of persistent
anxiety disorders, particularly not in the elderly because of the problems of tolerance, dependence,
confusion and falls.
Some anxiety disorders will respond to treatment with an antidepressant, particularly the SSRIs
which are specifically helpful in depression associated with anxiety, and panic disorder.
Neuroleptics are sometimes helpful for their anxiolytic properties, but caution is required when
prescribing any sedative in the elderly.
Personality change
Introversion increases with ageing. At an extreme level this can result in the ‘senile squalor’ or
Diogenes syndrome in which the elderly recluse lives a limited life in advanced squalor with extreme
hoarding of rubbish. Alcohol or frontal lobe dysfunction may play a part in this condition, although
characteristically the syndrome is unaccompanied by any psychiatric disorder sufficient to account
for the state in which the patient lives. Thus it is usually inappropriate to invoke the Mental Health
Act; instead, Section 47 of the Public Health Act is usually used to deal with these situations if
required.
Further considerations in old-age psychiatry 563
The prognosis is poor with almost inevitable relapse. Day-care may help, and institutional care is
often required.
DRUGS
Illicit drug abuse is not a great problem in the elderly, but addiction to prescribed benzodiazepines,
opiates and other analgesics, barbiturates and laxatives is problematic. In the USA where the very
564 Old-age psychiatry
elderly comprise 12% of the population, they are responsible for the consumption of 50% of
prescribed hypnotics.
Doctors need to take care in their prescribing, to prevent the initiation of prescribed drug
addiction. It is often worth attempting to wean even elderly persons from their drug of addiction,
since abstinence can greatly improve the quality of life. However, there is a group, particularly the
very elderly, who are better left on the drug if they strongly object to withdrawal.
Sexual activity
NORMAL SEXUAL BEHAVIOUR IN OLD AGE
Sixty per cent of married couples aged 60–75 and 25% of those over 75 are sexually active. One-fifth
of men aged over 80 have sexual intercourse at least once a month. Thus sexual activity and sexual
interest continue into old age.
The determinants of sexual activity in old age include:
∑ age
∑ gender – men are more sexually active than age-matched women
∑ married status
∑ own physical health
∑ physical health of partner
∑ enjoyment of sex.
Loss of, or illness in, a partner is a common reason for the cessation of sexual activity in the
elderly.
Elderly people in residential homes or hospitals should be provided with the privacy required to
continue sexual expression with a consenting partner or by masturbation if they wish. The attitudes
of staff and family may need to change through a process of education and discussion.
Sleep disorders
Forty per cent of older adults complain of chronic sleep problems, and use a disproportionate
amount of night-time sedation, often on a long-term basis.
The cause of sleep disturbance in the elderly is multifactorial. Assessment therefore requires a
careful history, with selective investigation.
Sleep apnoea
Sleep apnoea is an extremely common disorder affecting a quarter of independently living old
people, and higher proportions of those in institutional care. However, the presence of sleep-related
breathing disturbance in the absence of daytime sleepiness or impaired daytime functioning is
probably not clinically significant.
Sleep apnoea is associated with increased morbidity and mortality. It is associated with daytime
fatigue, memory problems, hypertension and cardiac arrhythmias. It is further associated with the
increased risk of a stroke, even after controlling for other risk factors such as hypertension, cardiac
arrhythmia and obesity.
Circadian rhythms
Some sleep disturbance in old age is associated with changes in the systems that regulate circadian
rhythm.
In older age the body’s circadian rhythms lose strength, with a breakdown in timing and
amplitude. Proposed interventions include:
∑ fitness training
∑ evening bright-light exposure
∑ melatonin supplementation in those deficient.
All these methods have brought about an improvement but are of only limited usefulness. Fitness
training and bright-light exposure require a lot of time and effort, and are continued after trials in
only a minority of subjects. Melatonin is not commercially available in reliable formulations, and in
some can cause depression.
reassurance. In other patients, attention to issues of sleep hygiene is required. This involves
addressing behaviour such as the excessive use of caffeine-containing drugs, and environmental
conditions improving the conduciveness to sleep, such as ensuring the bedroom is peaceful and
dark, without stimulation, and keeping regular sleep hours without daytime napping.
Bereavement
Mood disorders associated with bereavement are prevalent in later life and are associated with
morbidity and chronicity similar to other late-life depression. In a study of late-life widows, 24%
were depressed at 2 months after the loss, 23% at 7 months, and 16% at 13 months. Risk factors for
depression at 13 months included a past history of mood disorder, intense grief or depression early
after the loss, and few social supports.
ADAPTATIONS IN THERAPY
Patients treated include those suffering from depression, phobias, anxiety neurosis and hysteria.
Psychosomatic disorders in patients over the age of 60 are not considered treatable with psychotherapy.
It is suggested that the treatment of choice for neurotic disorders in the 55- to 75-year age group
is one to two 50-minute sessions per week for between several months to two years. In those with
reactive crises, short-term low-frequency dynamic therapy of 5–20 sessions is indicated until the age
of about 80.
Older adults have completed their psychosexual and psychosocial development, but still have to
cope with psychosocial tasks such as retirement, loss of partner, ill-health and impending death.
They also have to struggle with unresolved unconscious psychological conflict and
intergenerational difficulties.
With age the ego adapts by deploying increasingly mature defence mechanisms. The superego
similarly adapts. However, the unconscious id is largely unchanged with time. Inner psychological
conflict can persist from childhood.
unconsciously assumes the position of a powerful parent. With the elderly patient the transference
is likely to be reversed whereby the therapist experiences the unconscious transference of their own
parental relationships. It is essential that supervision be provided such that the therapist is aware of
these issues as they arise in therapy. Similarly, early in therapy the patient is likely to transfer past
experiences with younger people, such as his or her own children; but as the therapy progresses the
patient will develop the more classical transference relationships.
COMMON THEMES
In older age an increasing number of threatening and loss events occur. The therapist must work
with the patient to mourn the losses, thus freeing the patient to continue to take up new
opportunities and relationships. Decreasing independence and increasing dependence are often
central themes in therapy. Coming to terms with the past and changed relationships and power
structures are also relevant.
For the isolated elderly person, group work may be more appropriate than individual therapy.
ELDER ABUSE
The abuse of elderly people by their carers has received increasing attention since the 1970s. Its
prevalence is difficult to estimate and depends on the definition of abuse – which can range from
irritability and verbal abuse, to sexual and physical abuse.
Among patients referred for respite care to geriatric wards in London, there was a high morbidity
for dementia. Almost half of the carers admitted to some form of abuse, verbal more commonly
than physical. Verbal abuse was associated with poor pre-morbid relations between patient and
carer, and depression and anxiety in the carer. Physical abuse was associated with poor
communication by the patient and high alcohol consumption in the carer. Few patients admitted to
any abuse by their carers.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Brun, A. 1987: Frontal lobe degeneration of the non-Alzheimer type: I. neuropathology. Archives of Gerontology
and Geriatrics 6:193–208.
Department of Health 1991: Epidemiological Overview of the Health of Elderly People. London: Central Health
Monitoring Unit.
568 Old-age psychiatry
Jacoby, R. & Oppenheimer, C. (eds) 1991: Psychiatry in the Elderly. London: Oxford University Press.
Kay, D.W.K., Beamish, P. & Roth, M. 1964: Old age mental disorders in Newcastle upon Tyne: I. A study of
prevalence. British Journal of Psychiatry 110:146–158.
McDonald, C. 1969: Clinical heterogeneity in senile dementia. British Journal of Psychiatry 115:267–271.
Miller, B.L., Lesser, I.M., Boone, K.B. et al. 1991: Brain lesions and cognitive function in late-life psychosis. British
Journal of Psychiatry 158:76–82.
Murphy, E. 1982: Social origins of depression in old age. British Journal of Psychiatry 141:135–142.
Lindesay, J., Briggs, K. & Murphy, E. 1989: The Guy’s/Age Concern survey: prevalence rates of cognitive
impairment, depression and anxiety in an urban elderly community. British Journal of Psychiatry
155:317–329.
Osvaldo, P., Almeida, R., Howard, R.J. et al. 1995: Psychotic states arising in late life (late paraphrenia):
psychopathology and nosology. British Journal of Psychiatry 166:205–214.
Osvaldo, P., Almeida, R., Howard, R.J. et al. 1995: Psychotic states arising in late life (late paraphrenia): the role of
risk factors. British Journal of Psychiatry 166:215–228.
Post, F. 1968: The factor of ageing in affective illness. In Coppen, A. & Walk, A. (eds) Recent Developments in
Affective Disorders. Ashford: Headley Brothers, 105–116.
Schneider, L.S. 1993: Treatment of depression, psychosis, and other conditions in geriatric patients. Current
Opinion in Psychiatry 6:562–567.
Zisook, S. & Peterkin, J.J. 1993: Mood disorders and bereavement in late life. Current Opinion in Psychiatry
6:568–573.
39
Forensic psychiatry
EPIDEMIOLOGY OF OFFENDING
Sex ratio
The sex ratio of convicted males to females in the UK is approximately 5:1.
JUVENILE DELINQUENCY
AETIOLOGY
The aetiology is multifactorial and is not associated with an established psychiatric disorder. Factors
associated with the development of delinquency include:
∑ unsatisfactory child-rearing
∑ low IQ
∑ conduct disorder in childhood
∑ parental criminality
∑ large family size.
∑ counselling
∑ establishing a good relationship with a parent or counsellor
∑ improvement in the home environment
∑ a good experience in school
∑ a good peer group
∑ successful employment
∑ a good relationship or marriage.
Approximately 50% have stopped their delinquent behaviour by the age of 19 years.
In England and Wales, criminal responsibility starts at the age of 10 years. In Scotland it starts at the
age of 8 years.
Definitions
∑ Dolci incapax. Criminal responsibility is partial between the ages of 10 and 14 years. After the age
of 14 years an individual is legally responsible for his or her actions unless caused by:
∑ a mistake
∑ an accident
∑ duress
∑ necessity
∑ mental disorder.
∑ Actus rea. This is an unlawful act.
∑ Mens rea. This is guilty intent, and is required in addition to an unlawful act for certain offences,
such as murder and rape.
EPIDEMIOLOGY
The prevalence of mental abnormality in all offenders is estimated to be 1%. The prevalence of
mental abnormality in those in prison in the UK is estimated to be up to 33%.
Para 1 Introduction: Inform the court of when and where the patient was seen, at whose request, what
information was available, e.g. statements related to the case, who were the informants, and
sometimes what information was not available. State the current offences(s) with date for which
charged.
Para 2 Inform the court of his/her past medical history and of the result of medical examination, e.g.
‘Physical examination revealed no abnormality’.
Para 3 Report the important, relevant points of the family history, including family psychiatric disorder and
criminality.
Para 4 Personal history: Report the important points of his/her personal history, i.e. physical development,
e.g. birth, milestones, bedwetting (enuresis), schooling (e.g. bully/bullied, truancy), occupational
history (which will include difficulties sustaining employment or with colleagues at work).
Para 5 Report his/her sexual and marital history: be reasonably discreet as the report may be read in open
court.
Para 6 Report details of his/her personality in terms of social interaction, emotions, habits, e.g. drinking,
gambling, drugs.
Para 7 Report past forensic history, e.g. past convictions. This is, however, inadmissible.
Para 8 Report past psychiatric history (dates, diagnoses, relevant details and relationship of mental
disorder and treatment to offending).
Para 9 Report circumstances leading to current offence(s) and the defendant’s state of mind at the time of
the offence. Restrict discussion to the phenomena observed, e.g. ‘For the time of the offence he
gives a history of tearfulness, loss of hope, poor sleeping’, etc., ‘These are symptoms of the mental
illness of depressive disorder’, etc.
Para 10 Report the result of the interview: ‘He showed/did not show evidence of mental illness or mental
impairment’. Then give a brief outline of the evidence, e.g. ‘He muttered to himself, looked around
the room as though hallucinating’ etc., or list symptoms detected and say ‘These are symptoms of
the severe mental illness of schizophrenia’ etc.
Information in paragraphs 1–10 should be factual, verifiable and ideally agreed by all, even if
others’ opinions of these facts differ from your own.
Para 11 The final paragraph should express your opinion. The court will be interested particularly in your
opinion regarding:
(a) Is the defendant fit to plead and stand his/her trial?
(b) Is he/she suffering from a mental disorder, i.e. mental illness, a form of mental impairment or
psychopathic disorder?
(c) Where appropriate, comment on issues of responsibility, e.g. not guilty by reason of insanity;
diminished responsibility in cases of homicide.
(d) If suffering from mental disorder, can arrangements be made for his/her treatment in the
National Health Service (arrange this if you think they can).
Make suggestions to the court about which Mental Health Act order would be appropriate, e.g.
Sections 37/41 in England and Wales, or suggest treatment as a condition of a Probation Order, e.g.
‘In my opinion this man suffers from the severe mental illness schizophrenia, characterized by
delusions (false beliefs) and hallucinations (voices, or visions). I consider he would benefit from
treatment in a psychiatric hospital. I have made arrangements for a bed to be reserved for him at X
hospital under Section 37 of the Mental Health Act 1983 if the court considers that this would be
appropriate. I additionally recommend, if the court so agrees, that he be made subject to
restrictions under Section 41 of the Mental Health Act 1983 to protect the public from serious
harm and to facilitate his long-term psychiatric management, including specifying the conditions
of his discharge from hospital, e.g. of residence and compliance with out-patient psychiatric
treatment.’ As an alternative: ‘In my opinion this man does not suffer from mental illness, mental
impairment nor psychopathic disorder and is not detainable in hospital under the Mental Health
Act 1983. He has an anxious and dependent personality disorder, requires considerable support and
572 Forensic psychiatry
would benefit from group psychotherapy as an out-patient. The court may consider that it would be
an appropriate disposal to help this man if he were to attend an out-patient group under my
direction at X Health Centre as a condition of probation.’
Comment should be made on any mitigating circumstances, e.g. marital/work stress, and on the
prognosis. Express any doubts you may have as to the likelihood of benefit from treatment.
If you have no psychiatric recommendation, say so, e.g. ‘I have no psychiatric recommendation to
make in this case’.
Finally, if essential information is lacking or if time is not sufficient to make the necessary
arrangements for a hospital bed, then do not hesitate to state your findings up to date, state what
you would like to do, and ask for a further period of remand.
Reproduced with permission from Puri, B.K., Laking, P.J. & Treasaden, I.H. 2002: Textbook of Psychiatry, 2nd edn. Edinburgh:
Churchill Livingstone.
OUTCOME OF SENTENCING
The outcome of sentencing of mentally abnormal offenders in England and Wales is shown in Table
39.2.
MENTAL DISORDER
Mental disorders that may be associated with offending include:
∑ Schizophrenia. This is mostly associated with minor offending secondary to deterioration in
personality and social functioning.
∑ Depressive disorder. This is under-represented in offenders. It is associated with homicide and
shoplifting.
∑ Epilepsy. This is over-represented in prisoners but offending in epileptics is rarely ictal.
∑ Morbid delusional jealousy (Othello syndrome). This is associated with repetitive and serious
injury to the spouse/partner.
Alcohol and drugs that have been taken voluntarily do not, in general, lessen the individual’s full
legal responsibility. While amnesia is not a legal offence, its underlying cause may well be.
FITNESS TO PLEAD
A mentally disordered offender is unfit to plead if, at the time of the trial (but not necessarily at the
time of the offence), he or she is unable to carry out one or more of the following:
∑ instruct counsel
∑ appreciate the significance of pleading
Dangerousness 573
∑ challenge a juror
∑ examine a witness
∑ understand and follow the evidence of court procedure.
MCNAUGHTEN RULES
To be found not guilty by reason of insanity, it has to be proved to a court that, at the time of the
offence, the offender laboured under such defect of reason that he or she met these Rules, namely:
∑ that by reason of such defect from disease of the mind, the individual did not know the nature or
quality of his or her act
∑ the individual did not know that what he or she was doing was wrong.
Diminished responsibility
In the case of a charge of murder, a defence of diminished responsibility (Homicide Act 1957) may
be brought in; whereupon it has to be shown that, at the time of the offence, the offender suffered
from:
such abnormality of mind, whether caused from a condition of arrested or retarded development of
mind or any inherent causes or induced by disease or injury, as substantially impaired [the individual’s]
mental responsibility for [his or her] act.
INFANTICIDE
In England and Wales, infanticide is a type of unlawful homicide in which:
a woman by any wilful act caused the death of her child under the age of 12 months, but at the time
of the act or omission the balance of her mind was disturbed by reason of her not being fully recovered
from the effect of giving birth to the child, or the effect of lactation consequent upon the birth of the
child.
AUTOMATISM
In this rare plea, usually in cases of homicide, the defendant pleads that, at the time of the offence,
his or her behaviour was automatic.
DANGEROUSNESS
Dangerous individuals are people who have caused or who might cause serious harm to others. Its
features include:
∑ repetition
∑ incorrigibility
∑ unpredictability
∑ untreatability
∑ infectiousness.
574 Forensic psychiatry
The best predictor of future dangerous behaviour is the individual’s past behaviour. Shorter-
term prediction is better than longer-term prediction. Dangerousness is associated with the
availability of weapons, morbid jealousy, and the sadistic murder syndrome.
CIVIL ASPECTS
TESTAMENTARY CAPACITY
This is considered in Chapter 21.
TORT
A mentally disordered person is considered incapable of committing a tort (a civil wrong to an
individual or to the reputation or estate of an individual) unless the disorder did not preclude an
understanding of the nature or probable consequences of the act.
CONTRACTS
A contract requires free full consent and is void if an individual was of unsound mind at the time of
making the contract.
MARRIAGE
Being a contract, marriage is void if an individual had a mental disorder at the time of marriage such
that the nature of the contract was not appreciated at that time. A marriage may be annulled for any
of the following reasons:
∑ The partner has a mental disorder at the time of marriage so as not to appreciate the nature of
the contract.
∑ One partner did not disclose that he or she suffered from epilepsy or a communicable venereal
disease.
∑ Either party was under 16 years at the time of marriage.
∑ Pregnancy by another male at the time of marriage was not disclosed.
∑ There was non-consummation.
∑ One of the partners was forced to agree to the marriage by duress.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
NICE GUIDANCE
PSYCHOLOGICAL TREATMENTS
∑ Cognitive behavioural therapy should be available to patients with schizophrenia.
∑ Family interventions should be available.
∑ Counselling and supportive psychotherapy are not recommended in routine care.
MEDICATION ADVICE
∑ Continuation of antipsychotic drugs for 1 or 2 years after a relapse is recommended.
∑ Withdrawal of antipsychotic medication should be gradual and monitored.
∑ Following the withdrawal of drugs, patients should continue to be monitored for signs of
relapse for at least 2 years after the last acute episode.
PROMOTING RECOVERY
Primary care
∑ General practices should develop case registers for people with schizophrenia.
∑ GPs should regularly monitor the physical health of patients with schizophrenia. Particular
attention should be paid to endocrine disorders, e.g. diabetes, hyperprolactinaemia, blood
pressure, lipds, side effects of medication and lifestyle risk factors, e.g. smoking.
∑ GPs should re-refer patients to secondary care particularly if:
∑ treatment adherence is problematic;
∑ there is poor response to treatment;
∑ co-morbid substance misuse is suspected;
∑ level of risk to self or others is raised;
∑ when patient first joins the practice.
Secondary Care
∑ A full assessment of health and social care needs should be made regularly.
∑ Carers should have their needs assessed.
SERVICE INTERVENTIONS
∑ Assertive outreach teams should be developed for patients who engage poorly with services, are
high users of in-patient care, or are homeless.
∑ Crisis resolution and home treatment teams should be available for those in acute crisis.
∑ The CPA ensures services are managed and integrated.
PSYCHOLOGICAL INTERVENTIONS
Cognitive behavioural and family interventions should be available.
NICE guidance 577
PHARMACOLOGICAL INTERVENTIONS
Antipsychotics are indispensable to prevent relapse.
∑ Continuous dosage regimens are preferred.
∑ Depots should be considered an option.
EMPLOYMENT
Employment schemes should be developed to help those with schizophrenia to work.
RAPID TRANQUILLISATION
Staff should be trained in de-escalation and rapid tranquillisation. Offer oral medication first. If
intramuscular administration is necessary, lorazepam, haloperidol and olanzapine are preferred.
Vital signs should be monitored regularly.
National Institute for Clinical Excellence (2002) Core interventions in the treatment and management of schizophrenia in
primary and secondary care. NICE Clinical Guideline No. 1. London: National Institute for Clinical Excellence. Available
from: www.nice.org.uk.
This page intentionally left blank
Appendix 2
Alzheimer’s disease
NICE has recommended that, for the adjunctive treatment of mild and moderate Alzheimer’s
disease in patients with a mini-mental state examination (MMSE) score above 12 points, donepezil,
galantamine and rivastigmine should be available under the following conditions:
∑ Alzheimer’s disease must be diagnosed in a specialist clinic.
∑ Treatment is initiated by specialists but continued by GPs under a share-care protocol.
∑ Carers views are sought before and during drug treatment.
∑ The patient is reassessed 2-4 months after treatment is started; treatment should be continued
only if MMSE has improved.
∑ Patient should be assessed every 6 months. Treatment continues only if MMSE score remains
above 12 points.
Memantine is an NMDA receptor antagonist that affects glutamate transmission. It is licensed for
treating moderate to severe Alzheimer’s disease.
Donepezil is a reversible inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase that can be given once daily.
Rivastigmine is a reversible non-competitive inhibitor of acetylcholinesterases, given twice daily.
Galantamine is a reversible inhibitor of acetylcholinesterase and it also has nicotinic receptor
agonist properties. It is given twice daily.
Acetylcholinesterase inhibitors can cause unwanted dose-related cholinergic effects and should
be started at a low dose and the dose increased according to response and tolerability.
National Institute for Clinical Excellence (2001) Guidance on the use of donepezil, rivastigmine and galantamine for the
treatment of alzheimer’s disease. NICE Technology Appraisal Guidance No. 19. London: National Institute for Clinical
Excellence. Available from: www.nice.org.uk.
This page intentionally left blank
Index
[N.B. Italic page numbers refer to tables; bold page numbers refer to figures]
behavioural disorders 147–9, 310, 311, 537 BNF see British National Formulary
Behavioural Inattention Test 94 body image 157
behavioural phenotypes 500 borderline personality disorder 472–3
behavioural treatments 7–10, 515 Boston Naming Test 93
behaviours, integrated 215–20 box-and-whisker plots 112
beliefs, abnormal 152–3 boxplots 112
Bender–Gestalt Test 94 brain
Benton Visual Retention Test 94–5 ageing 530–31
benzodiazepines cerebellar pathology 201
alcohol withdrawal 348 cerebral dominance for language 58
approved names 239–40 cerebrovascular disease 544
CSM guidance 270 cortical Lewy body disease 550
elderly patients 535 distribution of drugs 247
history 236 frontal lobes 60–61, 97–9, 174–5, 549
mode of action 255 hippocampus 180
overview 359–60 hypothalamus 40, 215, 216, 218
personality disorder 481 neuroanatomy 171–90, 173, 182
scheduling 351 paraphrenia in old age 560
side effects 268–9 structural abnormalities 377
bereavement tumours 196–8
ageing experience 532 brain fag syndrome 523
loss of a parent 67 brain–steroid axis 394–5
miscarriage/TOP 431 brain–thyroid axis 395
Mu-Ghayeb 15 brainstem cholinergic pathway 189–90
normal/abnormal grief 82–3, 390 Britain 523–7, 570
in old age 566 British National Formulary (BNF) 270, 271
Bernoulli distribution 107 British sexual behaviour 441–4
beta-endorphin, PMS 428 Broca’s area 58, 61
biases 126 bulimia nervosa 511–16
binary theorists 383 bureaucracy 132
binaural masking 18 buspirone 255, 269
binge eating 506
binomial distribution 107 caffeine 358
Binswanger’s disease 548 calcium ion channels 227
biochemical disturbances California Psychological Inventory (CPI) 37
alcohol abuse 338, 346 California Verbal Learning Test 95
anorexia nervosa 507–8 Cambridge Examination for Mental Disorders of the
bulimia nervosa 513 Elderly (CAMDEX) 101–2
PTSD 417 Cambridge Neuropsychological Test Automated
suicide 401 Battery (CANTAB) 100–101
biological determinism of sexual orientation 76–7 CAMDEX see Cambridge Examination for Mental
bipolar mood disorder 238, 387–8, 389, 391, 397 Disorders of the Elderly
black minorities 523–7 cannabis 300, 363–4
Black Report (1980) 131 Cannon–Bard theory 42
blackouts, alcoholic 342 canonical correlation analysis 121
Blessed’s Dementia Scale 101 CANTAB see Cambridge Neuropsychological Test
Block and Haan 80 Automated Battery
blood abnormalities 338, 507–8 Capgras syndrome 382
blood–brain barrier 247 carbamazepine 255, 265, 481
584 Index
magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) 209–210 Mental Health (Scotland) Act, 1984 307
magnetic seizure therapy (MST) 323 mental operations 23–8, 165–6
malnutrition 337 mental retardation 139, 311, 315, 497–8
mandibular division of trigeminal nerve 184–5 mentally abnormal offenders 570–73, 572
mania 141, 558–9 mescaline 362
manic episode 388 mesial temporal region 175–6
manic–depressive psychosis 297 mesolimbic–mesocortical dopaminergic pathway
Mann–Whitney U Test 117–18 189
MAOIs see monoamine oxidase inhibitors meta-analysis 126–7
marital schism 137 metabolism 248–9, 339
marital skew 137 metacentric chromosomes 274
marriage 574 metastases, cerebral 197
Marx, Karl Heinrich 132–3 methadone 354
masked depression 390 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine (MDMA)
masking 18 362–3
Maslow’s hierarchy of needs 33, 41 mGluRs 230
matching hypothesis 81 mind models 160, 162–3
maternal deprivation 65 Mini-Mental State Examination (MMSE) 100
maxillary division of trigeminal nerve 184 Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory
maximum-likelihood score 280 (MMPI) 35–7, 468
MDMA see 3,4-methylenedioxymethamphetamine miscarriage 430–31
measurement see psychometry Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 349
medical conditions 315 Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 (Modification) Order
medical ethics 295–300 2003 350–51
medication see drugs Misuse of Drugs (Notification of and Supply to
medicolegal issues 295–300, 301–7, 349–52, 567 Addicts) Regulations 1973 349
medulloblastomas 198 Misuse of Drugs Regulations, 2001 350
meiosis 274 Misuse of Drugs Regulations, 2003 350–51
melanocyte-stimulating hormone (MSH) 214 mitochondria 277, 530
melatonin 395 mitosis 274
memory 16–23, 57–8 mixed affective states 390
ageing 531–2 MMPI see Minnesota Multiphasic Personality
disorders 155 Inventory
elaboration 23 MMSE see Mini-Mental State Examination
encoding/registration 18–19 modelling 4–5, 10
influences on 17 molecular cloning 279
information processing 19–22 molecular genetics 279, 391
interference 23 monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) 235, 238–9,
retrieval 17, 18, 19, 22 253–4, 267–8, 535
schemata 23 monoamine oxidase (MAO) 231, 232
short-term 57, 531 mood disorders
storage 16, 19 aetiology 391–5
tests 94–6 alcohol abuse 340
working memory 17, 19–21 epidemiology 390–91
Mendel’s first/second law 275 ICD-10 classifications 387–91
meningeal tumours 197 management 396–8
menopause 437–8 organic 330
mental age (MA) scale 91 overview 150–51
Mental Health Act, 1983 301–6 parasuicide 402–3
592 Index