Epydemiologi Amebiasis
Epydemiologi Amebiasis
Epydemiologi Amebiasis
578–583
Copyright © 2002 by The American Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene
Abstract. The recent identification of Entamoeba dispar as a separate species, which is nonpathogenic for humans
but morphologically indistinghuishable from Entamoeba histolytica, has prompted the World Health Organization to
recommend reinforced efforts for reassessment of the epidemiology of amebiasis and, in particular, of E. histolytica. In
this regard, the distribution of amebic liver abscess (ALA) cases were analyzed in the province of Thua Thien Hué (TT
Hué) in central Vietnam, a region known for its high incidence of invasive amebiasis. In addition, in a particular area
of Hué City, a parasitologic and seroepidemiologic survey was performed to identify possible risk factors for transmis-
sion of E. histolytica. Based on the analysis of hospital charts from April 1990 to April 1998, 2,031 cases of ALA were
identified, indicating an ALA incidence of at least 21 per 100 000 inhabitants per year. Incidence varied substantially
between the various districts of TT Hué and directly correlated with population density. The risk for ALA was
significantly higher in summer and was age and sex dependent because 95% of the cases were adults, of which more than
80% were males. There was no clustering of cases within households and recurrent cases of ALA occured more
frequently than predicted in the study population. Despite the higher incidence of ALA in males, the parasitologic and
seroepidemiologic survey revealed a significant higher infection rate for intestinal protozoon parasites, including E.
histolytica in females. Besides level of education and access to a toilet or tapwater, use of river water was identified as
an important risk factor for E. histolytica infection.
578
EPIDEMIOLOGY OF AMEBIASIS IN CENTRAL VIETNAM 579
fever, abdominal pain and tenderness), ultrasound results 1990 and April 1998. Over the eight-year observation period,
(space-occupying, round, hypoechoic liver lesions), and a the number of ALA patients admitted to the hospital was
good response to therapy with metronidazole or dehydro- relatively stable, approximately 260 cases per year, with a
emetine as shown by disappearance of clinical symptoms and slightly but not significantly higher number in 1993 (Figure 1).
reduction in abscess size. Serologic analysis for E. histolytica However, a significant difference in the number of ALA ad-
using a commercially available enzyme-linked immunosor- missions was found between the dry, hot summer season from
bent assay (ELISA) was conducted on 200 of these patients, April to September (56% of cases) and the rainy and cooler
of which 189 (94.5%) were positive. The address, age, gender, winter season from October to March (44%; P < 0.001).
and date of admission of the various ALA patients were ob- Complete addresses were available for 1,813 of ALA pa-
tained based on information listed in their hospital charts. tients, which indicated that the majority of the cases (1,763)
The male and female distribution in the various age groups were residents of the nine districts in the province of TT Hué
was calculated on the basis of the 1989 Vietnam census. The (Figure 2). Only a few cases (50) were from the neighboring
area and the number of inhabitants of the various districts of provinces of Quang Tri and Quang Nam. The highest inci-
the province of TT Hué and the commune of Phu Cat, Hué dence of ALA was found in the district of Hué City and
were obtained from the 1999 statistical yearbook of the TT lowest incidence was found in the districts of A Luoi and Nam
Hué statistical office.12 Dong. The latter two districts are located in the mountain
Parasitologic and serologic survey. According to the infor- area along the border with Laos. With the exception of Quang
mation obtained from the hospital files, Phu Cat, one of the Dien, the incidence of ALA in the various districts showed a
25 communes into which Hué City is divided, was identified as direct correlation with population density (Table 1).
the area of highest ALA incidence. A closer look revealed Data on gender were available for 2,023 ALA patients and
that a considerable number of ALA patients were residents of data on gender and age were available for 1,911 patients. The
an area within Phu Cat that comprised a very dense populated results indicate that ALA was rare in children, since more
triangle between Chi Lang Street, Bach Dang Channel, and than 95% of all ALA patients were adults (> 15 years old)
the Perfume River. All 961 households within the triangle with a peak incidence in the 30–49-year-old age groups. In
were randomized and 50% of the households were visited addition, incidence of ALA was sex dependent and was much
between January and July 1999. After informed consent was higher in males. Overall, the male to female ratio was 4 to 1.
obtained, all adult household members between 20 and 55 However, the ratio varied with age. Whereas in children no
years old were interviewed using a structured questionnaire substantial sex differences were found for the incidence of
to obtain information about household characteristics, living ALA, the male to female ratio of adult ALA patients was
conditions, personal habits, and educational level. In addition, approximately 7:1 for the 30–49-year-old age groups and ap-
stool and serum samples were collected. Stool samples were proximately 2.5:1 for the age groups more than 60 years old
analyzed using the E. histolytica-specific lectin coproantigen (Figure 3). There were no substantial differences in the age
ELISA (TechLab, Inc., Blacksburg VA) according to the and sex distribution of ALA patients between the various
manufacturer’s instructions. In addition, stool samples were districts.
examined microscopically for the presence of protozoan para- Lack of induction by ALA of long-lasting immunity against
sites and helminth eggs using the formol-ether-concentration development of recurrent ALA. In patients living in Hué
technique and subsequent staining with Lugol’s iodine solu- City, nine current ALA, were reported, all of which occurred
tion.13 Serum samples were tested for the presence of anti- in males. The average time between the first and the second
bodies to E. histolytica using an ELISA based on a recombi- abscess was 27 months (range ⳱ 6–40 months). The mean
nant E. histolytica surface antigen as previously described.14 observation period for all 666 males with ALA from Hué City
This assay has been shown to be highly specific, even when was 4.13 years. Thus, the risk for a man to develop a second
used in amebiasis-endemic countries, and it is able to detect ALA within one year was 0.33%, which is more than five
antibodies to E. histolytica for approximately 6–12 months times higher than the risk for males to develop an ALA
after successful anti-amebic therapy.15
Statistical analysis. All data collected were computer-coded
and analyzed by use of Jandel Sigma Stat (Chicago, IL), SPSS
(Chicago, IL), or StatView (Cary, NC) software. Binomial or
chi-square tests were used for comparisons between two
groups. Multiple logistic regression was used to test for the
simultaneous involvement of several factors that might influ-
ence anti-amoeba antibody status. A P value < 0.05 was con-
sidered to be statistically significant. For the determination of
relative risks (RRs), the program RELRISK (Ott J, http:link-
age.rockefeller.edu) was used. Confidence intervals and stan-
dard errors were determined by standard methodology.
RESULTS
Association of the incidence of ALA with population den-
sity and its predominance in adult males. Based on the infor- FIGURE 1. Annual number of patients with amebic liver abscess
mation found in the hospital files, 2,031 patients with ALA (ALA) admitted to the Central Hospital of Hué, Vietnam from 1991
were treated at the Central Hospital of Hué between April to 1997.
580 BLESSMANN AND OTHERS
TABLE 1
Population density and incidence of ALA in the various districts of
the province of Thua Thien Hué
Inhabitants Incidence‡
District Inhabitants* (km2)* ALA cases [95% conf. interval]
the individuals had anti-E. histolytica antibodies in serum. poechoic liver lesions, and showed a good response to anti-
Interestingly, in contrast to the sex distribution of ALA pa- amebic treatment. In addition, these patients had a 94.5%
tients, protozoan parasites as well as anti-amoebic antibodies prevalence of anti-amoebic antibodies. Moreover, in a recent
were significantly more prevalent in females (Figure 4). study, liver abscess aspirates of 50 consecutive ALA-
River water as a source of E. histolytica infections. To iden- suspected patients were cultured for the presence of aerobic
tify possible risk factors for E. histolytica transmission, anti- or anaerobic bacteria, of which 49 (98%) were shown to be
amoebic antibody status of individuals was compared with sterile, excluding the differential diagnosis of pyogenic ab-
household characteristics and living conditions (Table 2). The scesses (Blessmann J and others, unpublished data). The pe-
results indicated no association between the outcome of se- riod between April 1990 and April 1998 was chosen as be-
rology and the number or density of people per household. In cause it represented the time span when the Central Hospital
contrast, a strong association was found between the absence of Hué was the only medical care unit in the entire province
of anti-amoebic antibodies and a higher educational level, where ultrasound was available. Since treatment of ALA in
access to toilets, or access to tap water. In addition, anti- central Vietnam is generally performed by a combination of
amoebic antibodies were significantly more prevalent in indi- abscess puncture and metronidazole therapy,11 all suspected
viduals who regularly use river water. Interestingly, the latter ALA cases from various parts of the province were usually
finding was independent from whether or not these individu- sent to the Central Hospital of Hué. However, according to
als had access to toilets or tap water, suggesting that river information provided by local physicians and health authori-
water constitutes an important source for E. histolytica infec- ties, some less severe cases of ALA may have been treated
tions. This result was further confirmed by multiple logistic with metronidazole alone and were not sent to the hospital.
regression analysis. When age, gender, educational level, Thus, the data from the hospital charts were suitable to de-
number of household members, living area, access to a toilet termine the distribution of ALA cases with respect to gender,
or tap water, and use of river water were used as explanatory age and living site, but probably underestimated the true in-
variables significant influences on antibody positivity were cidence of ALA within the TT Hué population. Nevertheless,
found only with the use of river water (P < 0.03, RR ⳱ 2.540) based on the hospital charts, the incidence of ALA was rather
and gender (P < 0.02, RR ⳱ 0.471). All other variables were high since more than 2,000 cases in a population of approxi-
not significant in this analysis. mately one million inhabitants were recorded, which to our
knowledge represents the highest incidence of ALA on a
DISCUSSION regional level ever reported.
Over the eight-year study period, the annual number of
In an attempt to obtain more precise data on the epidemi- ALA cases was rather constant, suggesting a stable epidemio-
ology of amebiasis, we have analyzed the distribution of ALA logic situation for the transmission of E. histolytica and the
cases in the province of TT Hué in central Vietnam, a region development of ALA in the studied population. Conversely,
of high incidence of invasive amebiasis. In addition, in a spe- incidence of ALA varied substantially between the various
cific area of Hué City, a parasitologic and seroepidemiologic districts of the province TT Hué, but was found to correlate
survey was performed to identify possible risk factors for E. directly with population density. Although information is cur-
histolytica transmission. The ALA cases were analyzed by rently lacking about the relationship between population den-
making use of the hospital charts of patients admitted to the sity and incidence of invasive amebiasis, our results are in
Central Hospital of Hué between April 1990 and April 1998. agreement with observations from the Gambia.16 Here, in a
The diagnosis of ALA was most likely correct for the vast nationwide survey, the prevalence of intestinal E. histolytica/
majority of cases included into the study because all patients E. dispar infections also directly correlated with population
had corresponding clinical signs, space-occupying, round, hy- density. Interestingly, in the same study, a higher prevalence
TABLE 2
Correlation between anti-amoebic antibody status and household characteristics
of the parasite was found in the western part of the Gambia, incidence of ALA in males is obviously not due to a higher
which has lower temperatures and a higher humidity com- rate of infection with E. histolytica.10 According to the results
pared with the eastern part of the country. This appears to of our survey in the adult population of Phu Cat, women were
contradict our results, which indicated substantially more found to be more frequently infected with intestinal proto-
cases of ALA during the dry summer season. However, if one zoan parasites and had a significant higher prevalence of anti-
considers that the average time between infection with E. amoebic antibodies. The higher prevalence might be ex-
histolytica and onset of ALA is approximately five plained by an increased exposure to the parasite, since
months,17,18 the higher incidence of ALA in the Vietnamese women primarily serve the household, which includes wash-
population during summer might be the results of increased ing of clothes, dishes, and food at the river bank, as well as
infection rates with E. histolytica during the winter. taking water from the river.
It has not been established whether protective immunity to An unexpected finding of our study was the low prevalence
invasive amebiasis truly develops. Recurrent ALAs have of 0.9% for E. histolytica as shown by the commercially avail-
been repeatedly described, and in a study from Cambodia as able E. histolytica lectin-specific coproantigen ELISA. Al-
many as 8% of the patients developed a second liver ab- though this value is in agreement with results from other
scess.19 However, clinicians in endemic areas have made an- endemic areas,6–8 it does not explain the high incidence of
ecdotal observations that liver abscess infrequently recurs.20 ALA in the Hué population. The results might suggest that
In addition, the analysis of the hospital charts of 1,021 pa- local factors or habits such as the gut flora or diet possibly
tients cured of ALA in Mexico City between 1963 and 1968 contribute to the outcome of E. histolytica infection. Con-
revealed that substantially less of these patients were read- versely, it remains to be established whether the lectin co-
mitted during this time with a diagnosis of ALA than pre- proantigen ELISA is suitable for the detection of E. his-
dicted in the study population. However, there was no knowl- tolytica in stool samples of the Vietnamese population, since
edge of the patients’ current whereabouts or of admissions to the results of this test showed only a weak association with
other hospitals.21 In contrast, the data from Hué City indicate ameba serology. Similar findings were reported from For-
that recurrent ALA occurs more frequently than predicted in taleza, Brazil with the same version of the antigen test,5
the study population. In addition, the number of recurrent whereas a stronger association was found with stool samples
ALAs in our study population is certainly underestimated from Bangladesh, using a newer version of the test.24,25 How-
since knowledge of the clinical course may result in self- ever, based on previous results using stool culture and subse-
treatment of the disease. This became evident during our quent isoenzyme analysis or a polymerase chain reaction
survey in Phu Cat, where we identified at least three patients (PCR) to differentiate amebae,26–28 or using a direct E. his-
with recurrent ALA (confirmed by ultrasound and positive tolytica-specific PCR with stool samples,29 it is evident that
serology) who underwent self-treatment with metronidazole. more than 80% of individuals infected with E. histolytica,
Thus, the number of recurrent ALA cases in the total Hué even when asymptomatic, have anti-amoebic antibodies in
population is believed to be much higher than that predicted serum. Thus, further studies are required using other test sys-
from the hospital charts. Taken together, our findings do not tems such as a direct stool PCR to prove or disprove our
support the concept that ALA induces protection against in- results with the E. histolytica coproantigen ELISA.
vasive amebiasis or at least does not induce long-lasting im-
munity against recurrent ALAs. Furthermore, our results do Acknowledgments: We thank Britta Weseloh for skillful technical
not support the idea of a genetic trait that may predispose for assistance.
the development of ALA,22,23 since no clustering of cases Financial support: This work was funded by the Volkswagen Foun-
within families was found. However, the lack of clustering dation.
may also indicate that fecal-oral spread of the parasite be- Authors’ addresses: Joerg Blessmann, Bertram Muller-Myhsok,
tween family members does not play an important role in Heidrun Buss, and Egbert Tannich, Bernhard Nocht Institute for
transmission of E. histolytica in the study population, and that Tropical Medicine, Bernhard Nocht Str. 74, 20359 Hamburg, Ger-
many, Telephone: 49-40-4281-8477, Fax: 49-40-4281-8512, Email:
the primary source for E. histolytica infection is located out-
tannich@bni.uni-hamburg.de. Linh Pham Van, Phuong Anh Ton Nu,
side the household. This latter idea would be consistent with and Hao Duong Thi, Medical College, University of Hué, 01 Ngo
our findings, which indicate that the use of river water in Hué Quyen, Hué City, Vietnam.
constitutes an important risk factor for E. histolytica infection.
One of the unresolved enigmas in amebiasis is that the
occurrence of ALA greatly predominates in adult males, with REFERENCES
a peak incidence at approximately 40 years of age. This has
been observed in all parts of the world where amebiasis is 1. World Health Organization, 1997. Amoebiasis. WHO Wkly Epi-
demiol Rec 72: 97–100.
endemic,10 and was confirmed in this study. However, none of
2. Walsh JA, 1986. Problems in recognition and diagnosis of ame-
the previous reports comprises such a large collection of ALA biasis. Estimation of the global magnitude of morbidity and
cases, obtained from a circumscribed region within a rela- mortality. Rev Infect Dis 66: 228–238.
tively short period of time which makes our data rather ro- 3. Diamond LS, Clark CG, 1993. A rediscription of Entamoeba his-
bust. In addition, the age and sex distribution of ALA cases in tolytica Schaudinn, 1903 (emended Walker, 1911) separating it
some of the previous reports may be biased due to pre- from Entamoeba dispar Brumpt, 1925. J Eukaryot Microbiol
40: 340–344.
selection of ALA cases (e.g., no children included, reduced
4. Gathiram V, Jackson TFGH, 1985. Frequency distribution of En-
access of women to medical care). Nevertheless, the consis- tamoeba histolytica zymodemes in a rural South African popu-
tent worldwide observation of a substantial higher incidence lation. Lancet i: 719–721.
of ALA in adult males suggests that this is independent of 5. Braga LL, Mendonca Y, Paiva CA, Sales SA, Cavalcante ALM,
cultural or ethnic backgrounds. Moreover, the higher Mann BJ, 1998. Seropositivity for and intestinal Infection with
EPIDEMIOLOGY OF AMEBIASIS IN CENTRAL VIETNAM 583
Entamoeba histolytica and Entamoeba dispar in individuals in Vuth C, Vara O, Hay S, 1995. Aspects cliniques et therapeu-
northeastern Brazil. J Clin Microbiol 36: 3044–3045. tiques de l’amibiase hepatique au Cambodge. Med Trop
6. Haque R, Faruque ASG, Hahn P, Lyerly DM, Petri WA Jr, 1997. (Mars) 55: 37–40.
Entamoeba histolytica and Entamoeba dispar infection in chil- 20. Barriga OO, 1981. The Immunology of Parasitic Infection: A
dren in Bangladesh. J Infect Dis 175: 734–736. Handbook for Physicians, Veterinarians and Biologists. Balti-
7. Gatti S, Mahdi R, Bruno AB, Cevini C, Scaglia M, 1998. A survey more: University Park Press, 41–47.
of amoebic infection in the Wonji area of central Ethiopia. 21. de Leon A, 1970. Prognostico tardio en el absceso hepatico
Ann Trop Med Parasitol 92: 173–179. amibiano. Arch Invest Med 1 (suppl): 205–206.
8. Gathiram V, Jackson TFGH, 1987. A longitudinal study of 22. Arellano J, Granados J, Perez E, Felix C, Kretschmer RR, 1991.
asymptomatic carriers of pathogenic zymodemes of Entam- Increased frequency of HLA-DR3 and complotype SCO1 in
oeba histolytica. S Afr Med J 72: 669–672. Mexican mestizo patients with amoebic abscess of the liver.
9. Ravdin JI, 1995. Amebiasis. Clin Infect Dis 20: 1453–1466. Parasite Immunol 13: 23–29.
10. Acuna-Soto R, Maguire JH, Wirth DF, 2000. Gender distribution 23. Arellano J, Perez-Rodriguez M, Lopez-Osuna M, Velazquez JR,
in asymptomatic and invasive amebiasis. Am J Gastroenerol Granados J, Justiniani N, Santos JI, Madrazo A, Munoz L,
95: 1277–1283. Kretschmer R, 1996. Increased frequency of HLA-DR3 and
11. Linh Van P, Duong Manh H, Pham Nhu H, 1996 Abcès amibiens complotype SCO1 in Mexican mestizo children with amoebic
du foie: ponction écho-guidée. Ann Chi 50: 575–580. abscess of the liver. Parasite Immunol 18: 491–498.
12. Statistical Yearbook, 1999. Phan Duy Thuyen, ed. Thua Thien 24. Haque R, Ali IKM, Petri WA Jr, 1999. Prevalence and immune
Hué, Vietnam: Thua Thien Hué Statistical Office. response to Entamoeba histolytica infection in preschool chil-
13. Moody AH, 1996 Laboratory diagnosis. Cook GC, ed. Mansońs dren in Bangladesh. Am J Trop Med Hyg 60: 1031–1034.
Tropical Diseases. 20th edition. Philadelphia: W.B. Saunders 25. Haque R, Mollah NU, Ali IKM, Alam K, Eubanks A, Lyerly D,
Company, 1738–1742. Petri WA Jr, 2000. Diagnosis of amebic liver abscess and in-
14. Lotter H, Mannweiler E, Schreiber M, Tannich E, 1992. Sensitive testinal infection with the TechLab Entamoeba histolytica II
and specific serodiagnosis of invasive amoebiasis by using a antigen detection and antibody tests. J Clin Microbiol 38:
recombinant surface protein of pathogenic Entamoeba his- 3235–3239.
tolytica. J Clin Microbiol 30: 3163–3167. 26. Jackson TF, Gathiram V, Simjee AE, 1985. Seroepidemiological
15. Lotter H, Jackson TFGH, Tannich E, 1995. Evaluation of three study of antibody responses to the zymodemes of Entamoeba
serological tests for the detection of antiamebic antibodies ap- histolytica. Lancet 30: 716–719.
plied to sera of patients from an area endemic for amebiasis. 27. Ravdin JI, Jackson TFHG, Petri WA Jr, Murphy CF, Ungar BLP,
Trop Med Parasitol 46: 180–182. Gathiram V, Skilogiannis J, Simjee AE, 1990. Association of
16. Bray RS, Harris WG, 1979. The epidemiology of infection with serum antibodies to adherence lectin with invasive amebiasis
Entamoeba histolytica in the Gambia, West Africa. Trans R and asymptomatic infection with pathogenic Entamoeba his-
Soc Trop Med Hyg 71: 401–407. tolytica. J Infect Dis 162: 768–772.
17. Knobloch J, Mannweiler E, 1983. Development and persistence 28. Tannich E, Burchard GD, 1991. Differentiation of pathogenic
of antibodies to Entamoeba histolytica in patients with amebic from nonpathogenic Entamoeba histolytica by restriction frag-
liver abscess: analysis of 216 cases. Am J Trop Med Hyg 32: ment analysis of a single gene amplified in vitro. J Clin Micro-
727–732. biol 29: 250–255.
18. Wynants H, van den Ende J, Randria J, van Gompel A, van den 29. Verweij JJ, van Lieshout L, Blotkamp C, Brienen EAT, van
Enden E, Brands C, Coremans P, Michielsen P, Verbist L, Duivenvoorden S, van Esbroek M, Polderman AM, 2000. Dif-
Colebunders R, 1995. Diagnosis of amoebic infection of the ferentiation of Entamoeba histolytica and Entamoeba dispar
liver: report of 36 cases. Ann Soc Belg Med Trop 75: 297–303. using PCR-SHELA and comparison with antibody response.
19. Guerin B, L’Her P, Lenegre-Thourin I, Pitichit K, Wanda O, Arch Med Res 31(suppl. 4): 44–46.