CSC V de La Cruz
CSC V de La Cruz
CSC V de La Cruz
_______________
* EN BANC.
404
CORONA, J.:
_______________
405
„After an initial evaluation of the protest, we find that the only issue to
be resolved is whether or not the protestee meets the minimum
experience requirements as of the date of the protesteeÊs appointment to
the contested position. The contested position requires four years of work
experience in position/s involving management per Qualification
Standards Manual prescribed by MC No. 46, s. 1993 and/or four years of
experience in planning, organizing, directing, coordinating and
supervising the enforcement of air safety laws, rules and regulations
pertaining to licensing, rating and checking of all airmen and mechanics
and regulation of the activities of flying schools per ATO Qualification
Standards x x x.
xxx xxx x x x.‰
406
Taking into account his previous positions, Mr. dela Cruz could
not have exercised managerial or supervisory functions for the
required number of years. x x x. Moreover, vis-à-vis the experience
requirements of the approved ATO Qualification Standards, Mr.
dela CruzÊ work experience prior to his appointment to the
contested position did not concur therewith.
We are of the view therefore, that experience-wise, Mr. dela Cruz
did not meet the requirements of the contested position as of the
date of his appointment thereto.
xxx xxx x x x.‰
„x x x x x x x x x.
We reviewed again the documents including the Office Orders
designating protestant dela Cruz to supervisory position which
were obviously issued during the latter part of 1993. A liberal
consideration thereof would come up with a little over one year of
supervisory and managerial experience. Certainly, he was short of
the required number of years of work experience for the contested
position as of the date of the issue of his appointment. Nevertheless,
considering that Mr. dela Cruz has already in his favor at least four
years of continuous supervisory/managerial experience from his
designation as Acting Chief of the Aviation Safety Regulation
Division, supervened by his permanent appointment thereto as
Chief thereof in November 28, 1994, up to present, he has
substantially satisfied the four years experience required for
appointment to the contested position.
x x x x x x x x x.‰
407
_______________
4Rollo, p. 42.
408
_______________
5Rollo, p. 66.
6Rollo, p. 48.
409
_______________
410
_______________
411
_______________
412
_______________
14Rollo, p. 139.
15Rollo, p. 140.
16191 SCRA 238 (1990).
17Rollo, p. 50.
18206 SCRA 621 (1992).
413
_______________
414
_______________
415
SO ORDERED.
··o0o··