Milked 053017

MILKED
Immigrant Dairy Farmworkers

in New York State
Milked: Immigrant Dairy Farmworkers in New York State
MILKED
Immigrant Dairy Farmworkers in New York State
by Carly Fox, Rebecca Fuentes, Fabiola Ortiz Valdez,

Gretchen Purser, Kathleen Sexsmith
Suggested citation: Carly Fox, Rebecca Fuentes,

Fabiola Ortiz Valdez, Gretchen Purser, and Kathleen
Sexsmith. 2017. Milked: Immigrant Dairy Farmworkers
in New York State. A report by the Workers Center
of Central New York and the Worker Justice Center of
New York.
1
Milked: Immigrant Dairy Farmworkers in New York State Milked: Immigrant Dairy Farmworkers in New York State
The state of New York is one of the states

that produces dairy productsfor example,
cream, cheese, yogurt, milkas well as fruit and
vegetables, for the whole family, around the world.
We, as farmworkers, feed everyones families, Table of Contents
[but] the employers treat us like slaves: they dont
give us the necessary training, they intimidate us Executive Summary . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
with the police, there are injuries at work that do
Fighting for the Right to Organize . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 14
not receive medical attention, physical assaults by
supervisors, and people have even died. Its not New Yorks Dairy Industry and its
fair. The housing where we live in is in very bad New Immigrant Workforce . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 18
condition, there are even cockroaches and bugs.

Milking Cows, Milking Workers . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26
Some of the employers pay the minimum wage and
others do not. We work 6 days per week, 12 to 14 Long Hours for Low Wages . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 32
hours per day, and they dont pay overtime. We
Dangerous Dairies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 40
dont have the same rights as other workers, that
is why were fighting for our right to organize. All Stuck in Place . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 52
of these injustices we are seeing today, its not fair.
Conclusions and Recommendations . . . . . . . . . . . . . 62
We are all human beings and we deserve respect
and dignity. The time has come for all of this
injustice to change.
Crispin Hernandez, member of the Workers

Center of Central New York and plaintiff seeking the right
to organize for New York farmworkers, Hernandez v. New
York State
2 3
Notes
About WJCNY and WCCNY

The Worker Justice Center of New York
(WJCNY) pursues justice for those denied
human rights with a focus on agricultural
and other low-wage workers, through legal
representation, community empowerment
and advocacy for institutional change.
For more information, see our website: http://www.wjcny.org/
The Workers Center of Central New York (WCCNY)

is a grassroots organization focused upon workplace
and economic justice. Through community
organizing, leadership development, popular
education and policy advocacy, the Workers Center
of Central New York empowers low-wage workers to
combat workplace abuses and improve wages and
working conditions.
For more information, see our website: https://workerscny.org/en/home/
Acknowledgements
This report was made possible through the generous support of the
Sociological Initiatives Foundation. We benefited greatly from the
research assistance of many individuals. We wish to thank Leslie Gates,
Maggie Gray, Anlly Palacios and Jonathan Sclar for providing valuable
analysis of the structure of the dairy industry and/or health and safety
challenges on dairy farms. We also wish to thank all who helped
conduct, transcribe, or translate interviews, including Agustin Omar
Rodriguez, Yanira Rodriguez, Romeo Garcia, Elizabeth Daniele, Lydia
Herrick, Ilmer Trejo, and Cecilia Cortina. We wish to thank Ken Wolkin,
Emma Kreyche, and Lewis Papenfuse from WJCNY, as well as WJCNY
intern, Mark Leonhard, for his research assistance. We also greatly
appreciate feedback on a draft of this report from David Griffith, Leslie
Gates, Maggie Gray, Andrea Callan, Amy Sugimori, Jose Oliva, Adrienne
DerVartanian, Tom Fritzsche, and Greg Schell. Finally, we wish to thank
the farmworkers who assisted with survey design, focus groups, and the
analysis: Agustn Omar Rodriguez, Jose G., Jose C., Salvador P., Lazaro
A., Crispin H., and Antonio S.
Occupational Photojournalist, Earl Dotter (www.earldotter.com),

generously provided the Cover Photograph and the images on the
following pages of this report: 27, 28, 33, 35, 42 and 48. Design Action
worked on the layout and design.
4 5
Methodology Participant Socio-demographics

The findings in this report are based on face-to-face, semi-structured
interviews conducted in 2014 and 2015 with 88 immigrant dairy
farmworkers on 53 different dairy farms in New York State. We used GENDER: 90% men, 10% women
a combination of snowball sampling and direct worker outreach,
COUNTRY
sometimes arriving on farms where we had no prior knowledge of, or
OF ORIGIN: 61% Mexico, 34% Guatemala, 2% Honduras,
relationship to, the workers. We made a deliberate effort to survey
2% Puerto Rico
workers on farms across New York States Central (13 farms), Eastern
(3 farms), Western (30 farms), and Northern (7 farms) dairy-producing IMMIGRATION
regions. The interviews consisted of 225 questions covering participants STATUS: 93% undocumented
demographic backgrounds, work histories, wages and working
conditions, housing conditions, social integration, encounters with LANGUAGE: 73% speak little to no English, 27% speak some
immigration enforcement agents, and interests in organizing for change. English.
We also conducted five focus groups with dairy farmworkers who lead
AGE: 20% less than 25, 41% between 25 and 34, 26%
local organizing efforts. All interviews and focus groups were conducted
between 35 and 44, 11% 45 and older
in Spanish. The report is also informed by primary documents, academic
articles, and other published literature on dairy farm labor. Most of the RELATIONSHIP
workers are identified by pseudonyms. All quotes that appear without STATUS: 62% married, 30% single, 8% divorced or widowed.
other citation are from our interviews.
PARENTAL
Immigrant dairy farmworkers are a hidden population that is difficult to STATUS: 70% have children, 30% do not have children
access because of their vulnerable immigration status, work schedules,
and geographic isolation on rural farms. There is no database of the
population of dairy farmworkers in New York from which our sample
could be drawn, making it difficult to determine with precision their The size of the farm plays an important role in shaping farmworkers
total numbers and socio-demographic profile. This study was realized living and working conditions. Of our respondents:
through the time-consuming and labor-intensive process of direct
20% work on small farms (fewer than 499 cows)
worker outreach, without employer mediation. As a community-based,
participatory action research project, farmworkers were actively involved 42% work on large farms (500-1000 cows)
in the study itself, helping to develop the interview questions, lead focus
groups, and transcribe and analyze the data. They also contributed some 38% work on very large farms (more than 1,000 cows)
of the photographs used in this report.
Thus approximately 80% of the sample works on a large or very large

farm. While it is impossible to know exactly how undocumented workers
are distributed across small and large dairy farms in New York, they tend
to be concentrated on larger farms, where the need for milking labor is
greater and family labor tends not to be available in sufficient numbers.1
6 7
Executive
Summary
Producing milk is a fully modern business, unrecognizable

in comparison to the dairying of even a few decades ago.
Todays dairy farmers strive for growth, consolidation,
efficiency, and automation to stay competitive in a globalized
sector increasingly controlled by multinational corporations.
Yet, as the technology and science revolutionizing the dairy
industry accelerate at a breakneck pace, a race to the bottom
is occurring in the treatment and working conditions of the
immigrant laborers who toil in milking parlors and barns.
New Yorks dairy production and processing industry generates $14

billion a year and is the star sector of the states agricultural economy.
The industry today is propelled by New Yorks yogurt boom. The
states rise to the number one Greek yogurt producer in the nation
has been driven by several major multinational investments, not to
mention significant direct financial support and regulatory easing by the
administration of Governor Andrew Cuomo.
8 9
Milked: Immigrant Dairy Farmworkers in New York State presents Long Hours for Low Pay
the results of a 2014-15 survey of 88 mostly undocumented Mexican
and Central American farmworkers who live and work on 53 different Immigrant dairy farmworkers earnings hover just above the
dairy farms in Upstate New York. This report finds that this spectacular minimum wage. Workers surveyed most typically earned $9/hour (at
growth of the dairy industry has been achieved at the cost of basic labor a time when the minimum wage was $8.00/hour in 2014 and $8.75/
rights for the immigrant farmworkers who keep modern milking parlors hour in 2015).
running.
On average, they work 12 hours per day. Like all agricultural workers
in New York, they are excluded from the right to a day of rest and
the right to overtime pay.
A changed industry, a new workforce
Forty-five percent feel rushed on the job. Breaks are sometimes as
Changes in the milk production process and the consolidation of dairy short as five minutes long in a 12-hour workday.
farming created significant new demand for immigrant labor on New
York dairy farms in the early 1990s. Farms consolidated and became Twenty-eight percent of immigrant dairy farmworkers have
fewer, larger, and more efficient. In response, farmers turned to Latino knowingly experienced at least one instance of wage theft; still
immigrants to fill positions in their 24-hour milking parlors as milking others suspect it, but have difficulty interpreting their pay stubs
work became semi-automated, fast-paced, stressful, and exhausting. and do not know for certain. Wage theft experiences include denial
Dairy farmworkers in the state are almost all undocumented and live of a final paycheck, being paid for scheduled hours and not for
in tremendous fear of detention by police or border patrol agents in extra hours worked, unpaid training, or non-reimbursement for
the heavily patrolled border region between the U.S. and Canada. personal protective equipment.
The Trump administrations aggressive plans to detain and deport
undocumented immigrants have only exacerbated workers fears. Thus, Dangerous Dairies
they remain, for the most part, on the farm where they are constantly
available for long shifts for low pay, and vulnerable to wage theft and Two-thirds of dairy farmworkers surveyed have experienced one or
hazardous working conditions. Moreover, they suffer isolation from the more injuries while on the job. Sixty-eight percent of those injured
broader community that could offer them support. said the damage was serious enough to require medical attention.
Most reported the injury to their boss, but some were too afraid or
were not confident enough in their English skills to tell their boss
Summary of Findings what had happened.
One-third of workers received no job training of any kind. Of those

Milking Cows, Milking Workers who were trained, that training was often insufficient either because
Sixty-two percent report that American workers are treated better it was brief (as little as ten minutes), offered in English, or conducted
than the Latino immigrant workers on the farm, particularly because by immigrant co-workers who were not trained to educate others
they are perceived to do easier work for better pay. thoroughly.
Forty-eight percent report that they have suffered bullying or Farmworkers principal safety concerns are: aggressive cows
discrimination in the workplace. One fifth report that their boss, and bulls (as reported by 71% of interviewees), operating heavy
manager or other workers have made explicit reference to their machinery (35%), using chemicals (18%), and slippery or insecure
ethnicity or citizenship status in a demeaning or intimidating conditions of farm working environments (11%). These dangers are
manner. exacerbated by the lack of job and safety training.
Twenty-eight percent of workers surveyed report aggressive, More than 80% of dairy farmworkers in New York are estimated to
disrespectful, or inconsistent behavior on the part of their boss. live and work on farms with too few workers to fall under OSHA
jurisdiction for inspection and sanctioning. Even though 80% of our
Eighty-eight percent of workers surveyed believe their employers sample works on a farm with at least 500 cows, many of these farms
care more about the cows than about workers well-being. still do not have a sufficiently large non-family workforce to fall
under OSHAs ambit for inspections. In fact, the Occupational Safety
and Health Administration is prohibited from regulating small farms,
even when someone dies on the job.
10 11
Stuck in Place Summary of Recommendations

Ninety-seven percent of workers live in on-farm housing provided We can improve the conditions of this vital, yet vulnerable, workforce.
by their employers. These accommodations are usually old farm And farmworkers themselves, through their organizing, are leading the
houses or trailers, but sometimes they are makeshift rooms off the way with the rallying call: milk cows, not workers. Its now time for the
barn or milking parlor. state, industry, and consumers to take action.
Dairy farmworkers often live in substandard housing: 58% report Governor Andrew Cuomo, the New York State Legislature, and the
bug or insect infestations in their homes, 48% have no locks on New York State Attorney General need to do more to protect the rights
their doors, 32% have holes in their walls or floors, and 32% have and improve the working conditions of immigrant farmworkers. They
insufficient ventilation. must eliminate the exemption of farmworkers from basic labor rights
including the right to organize, the right to a day off, and the right
Due to their fear of immigration enforcement, inability to obtain
to overtime payallow undocumented immigrants to obtain drivers
a NY drivers license, and/or long work hours, immigrant dairy
licenses, provide oversight of workplace health and safety for dairies,
farmworkers leave the farm premises, on average, as infrequently as
and ensure that all farmworkers live in safe and dignified housing with
once every eleven days. Some leave only for medical emergencies,
the right to receive visitors.
resulting in almost total immobility and the widespread feeling of
being locked up [encerrado] Dairy companies should implement and enforce worker-led codes
of conduct for ethical labor practices for their fresh milk suppliers,
Fifty-seven percent say they do not feel any sense of belonging to
purchasing only from those farms that participate in rigorous labor rights
the local community. Sixty-two percent report feeling isolated and
monitoring conducted independent of the dairy purchaser or supplier.
80% report feeling depressed.
Several model programs already exist that could be adapted to, and put
into place in, the New York dairy industry.
Finally, consumers of milk and milk products must use their voices to
push for change, holding prominent dairy companies accountable for
working conditions throughout the supply chain.
12 13
Fighting for
the Right to
Organize
Crispin Hernandez followed in the footsteps of his brothers
who had come to work on dairy farms in New York. As he was
preparing to leave, the body of a young man named Genaro
was shipped back to his home town. Genaro had been a dairy
worker in NY and was killed in a work-related accident. It
felt very sad, Crispin recalls. I felt very nervous about going
to the same place where Genaro had been. Despite feeling
scared and anxious about the hazards ahead, Crispin left to
work in the New York dairy industry, determined to improve life
for his family.
Crispin worked in the dairy industry for three years. He is one of the
thousands of workers who have experienced the hardships of living
and working on a dairy farm. Crispin describes the work as dangerous,
strenuous, relentless, and fast-paced, all performed while under constant
surveillance. At Marks Farms, one of the biggest farms in the state and
a member of the national cooperative Dairy Farmers of America, which
supplies large food companies like Chobani, he and his coworkers
worked twelve hours a day, six days per week. He describes what its
like to work on a farm with roughly 4,500 milking cows: Sometimes you
cannot take your half hour break to eat lunch. If you take a break to drink
water or go to the bathroom, you can fall behind.
14 15
Consecutive 12-hour work shifts left him exhausted, which exacerbated

the significant dangers he already faced on the job. There are many
accidents in dairies and many workers have died, Crispin explains.
Many arent trained. When I started working there, a cow stepped on
my hand. The owner and her daughter were there and they saw that my
hand was bleeding and they didnt care. They didnt tell me to go to
the hospital and they didnt give me a day off. Crispin, along with his
co-workers, felt frustrated with the farm owners and supervisors who did
nothing to minimize the health and safety hazards on the farm. Working
with cows is very dangerous, and the owners dont care. They even
charge us for the gloves that we need to work with! That is not fair.
Like all workers at the farm, Crispin lived in employer-provided housing

located just a few hundred yards away from the milking parlor. It was
challenging for Crispin to share such a small space with four other
workers, especially because the farm owner refused to perform basic
maintenance of the property. Living in worker housing and lacking access
In May 2016, Crispin, the WCCNY and the WJCNY, represented by the
to a car, Crispin felt a suffocating level of social isolation. A quick ride
New York Civil Liberties Union (NYCLU), sued the state of New York,
from a local person who charges for rides (a raitero) to the grocery store,
claiming that the State Employment Relations Act unconstitutionally
to the doctor, or to a nearby restaurant was expensive compared to his
excludes farmworkers (as well as domestic workers) from collective
wages. Crispin and his co-workers were even charged for rides to the
bargaining rights - rights that would protect workers from employer
hospital when a medical emergency, or when other emergencies arose.
retaliation for organizing in their workplaces. Just hours after the lawsuit
Leaving for social outings was thus a luxury that he and his coworkers
was filed, Governor Andrew Cuomo announced that his administration
could hardly afford. Honestly, you feel locked up not being able to
would not fight the lawsuit in court. I agree with the NYCLU that the
leave.
exclusion of farm workers from the labor relations act is inconsistent with
Crispin and his co-workers suffered routine verbal abuse and occasional our constitutional principles he said. We will not tolerate the abuse
physical violence in the workplace. They treated us like slaves, Crispin or exploitation of workers in any industry. This clear and undeniable
declares. They yelled at us and threatened to fire us if we didnt work injustice must be corrected.2 The New York Farm Bureau, a powerful
exactly like they said. In March 2015, a worker was physically assaulted agricultural industry lobby organization, has intervened in the case as
by a manager on the farm. Crispin was one of the workers willing to a defendant, determined to maintain the status quo of an excluded
make public what happened. He was glad when the Workers Center and disempowered farm workforce.3 If a favorable decision is reached
of Central New York (WCCNY) and the Worker Justice Center of New by the New York State Supreme Court, Hernandez v. New York State
York (WJCNY) organized a well-publicized protest against worker would extend rights to collective bargaining to the more than 60,000
mistreatment and violence on the farm. I want people to know that farmworkers across New York State.
these things happen, Crispin explained. We all have rights, but
Honestly, all of us deserve justice and dignity, all human beings,
because we are farmworkers, they treat us like that.
Crispin explains. Because of those injustices that happen and keep
Crispin and a co-worker tried to organize a workers committee to happening, I decided to organize. Thanks to everybodys support, we
address health and safety issues in the workplace with assistance from are here nowlittle by little, we are making the road to justice We will
WCCNY. But one of the workers meeting was interrupted when the son win the protected right to organize for all agricultural workers and we will
of the farm owner called the police in an effort to banish the WCCNY continue to fight for dignity and respect.
organizer from the farm, and to stifle the workers attempt at collective
Crispin remains an active leader in WCCNY and a tireless advocate for
organizing. Although intimidated, the workers carried through with their
worker and immigrant rights, participating in rallies and talking with
meeting.
media outlets about the living and working conditions on dairy farms
One week later, Crispin and his co-organizer were summarily fired. across New York State. We dont have the same rights as other workers,
that is why were fighting for our right to organize. All of these injustices
Crispins firing was a brazen act of employer retaliation. But so too was we are seeing today, and its not fair. We are all human beings and we
it a reflection of a Jim Crow-era law that denies farmworkers the right to deserve respect and dignity. The time has come for all of this injustice to
organize without fear of retaliation. change and to live in peace and a better country for everyone.
16 17
New Yorks
Dairy Industry
and its New
Immigrant
Workforce
New York is a major dairy state. In 2015, it ranked fourth
nationally in terms of milk production (at 14.1 billion lbs of
fluid milk)4,5 and third nationally in terms of the number of dairy
farms (5,427 milk cow farm operations).6 Dairy farming holds
great economic importance to the Upstate New York region,
with milk sales representing 50% of total agricultural sales.
In fact, New York is more economically dependent on dairy
farming than its major competitor states.7
Yet, the state has lost nearly half of its dairy farms since 1997, reflecting
national trends towards the concentration of milk production on to fewer
and larger farms.8 As the remaining farms have gotten larger9, dairy
cattle have also become more productive.10 This reflects changes to the
production process designed to maximize milk production efficiency,
including the introduction of high protein cattle feed and production-
boosting hormone injections, the automation of milking parlors, and
the milking of the entire herd three (up from two) times per day. These
transformations have altered the labor process in fundamental ways.
Milking work under these conditions is more monotonous, impersonal,
fast-paced, and tiring. Moreover, it must be performed around the clock.
18 19
New York farmers claim it is nearly impossible to find a local labor source
to milk cows.11 Their difficulties recruiting and retaining local residents Distribution of large dairy
as a labor source are likely due to the above mentioned changes in farms in New York State
the work process, to the declining interest of younger generations in
farming, and to the arrival of industries to the rural Upstate region that
offer more competitive compensation and benefits than dairy farms,
such as prisons.12
In the mid 1990s New York dairy farmers began hiring an immigrant
labor force, primarily from Mexico and Guatemala, for their milking
parlors.13 They followed a national trend whereby immigrant labor
accounts for an estimated minimum 51% of all U.S. dairy labor.14 While
the exact number of immigrant farmworkers on New York dairies is
unknown, another 2016 study conducted on primarily large, New
York dairy farms (over 500 milking cattle) found that, in the majority of
cases, Latino immigrants are a larger share of their workforce than U.S.
citizens.15 While some immigrant workers hold work authorization, the
majority are undocumented.16
The dairy industry has now become utterly dependant on immigrant

labor to spur on local economies and keep milk cheap.17 In fact, if all
immigrant dairy workers in the U.S. were to suddenly disappear, the
dairy industry as a whole would collapse, the national economy would Dairies with 500 or more cows
lose more than 200,000 jobs, and milk prices would rise by 90%.18 It is
for these reasons that more than three quarters of dairy farmers report >250 0
medium or high concern about the possibility of an Immigration and

Customs Enforcement raid on their farm.19 These fears have only grown
in the wake of the Trump administrations immigration enforcement
activities.20
Large farms are the most efficient in milk production: dairies with 500 or
more milking cows account for only 10% of the farms in the state (246
New Yorks Consolidated and Globalized Dairy farms), but represent approximately 50% of milk sales.23 Meanwhile,
Supply Chain the smallest farms (those under 100 milking cows) account for around
three-quarters of all dairy farms, but only about a quarter of milk sales.24
New York dairy farming has undergone significant consolidation in Despite this stark imbalance, the New York dairy sector is relatively less
recent decades. New York has at least 103 very large dairy farms (1,000 consolidated than those of several other states.25
or more milking cows); but just 15 years earlier, in 1997, there were only
21.21 Large farms are clustered in the Western (Wyoming, Genesee, New York farmers belong to several of the largest cooperatives in
and Livingston, and Ontario Counties), Central (Cayuga and Onondaga the nation
Counties), and Northern (Jefferson, St. Lawrence, and Clinton Counties)
Most dairy farmers are members of dairy cooperatives, which purchase
regions. Several very large dairies in the state have revenues estimated
milk from farmers to either process it themselves, or sell it on to a dairy
up to $2.5 million, and the largest is estimated to have sales of $5 million
manufacturer. The largest cooperatives with membership in New York
per year.22
State and their major brands are shown in the accompanying table. In
addition to their own-brand products, several cooperatives have made
major deals to supply fresh milk to the corporate dairy manufacturers
that have made New York the heartland of Greek yogurt production in
the last decade.26
20 21
Major Dairy Farmer Cooperatives Operating in New York State Top global dairy manufacturers have operations in New York
Cooperative Headquarters Total Major brands The vast majority of New Yorks dairy processors are small companies
members with annual sales of less than $1 million.32 However, seven of the top 100
dairy processors in North America are headquartered in New York State:
Dairy Farmers MO 14,000 Hiland Dairy, Dean Foods, Borden (cheese), Cache Danone Co., Chobani, Upstate Niagara Cooperative, Fage USA, Byrne
of America (national) Valley (cheese), Kellers Creamery (butter), Plugra Dairy, Fieldbrook Foods Corp, and Stewarts Ice Cream.33 Additionally,
(butter), Kemps (various), California Gold (milk), three top global dairy processors, Dean Foods, Dairy Farmers of
Sport Shake (sports beverage), La Vaquita (cheese), America, and Kraft have processing plants in New York State.34
Guidas Dairy (various), Dairy maid (various)
Governments Role in Shaping New Yorks Dairy

Upstate Niagara Buffalo, NY Approx. 400 Upstate Farms (various), Valley Farms (milk, cream), Industry
(New York) Intense Milk (flavored milk), Bison Foods (sour
cream, dips), A protected industryfor farmers
The cultural and historical importance of dairy farming in the U.S.,

Agri-Mark MA 1,200 (New McCadam (cheese), Cabot (cheese), Agri-Mark
combined with a powerful national milk lobby, ensure that significant
England and
federal support continues to be funneled to dairy farmers. In 2014, in
New York)
the face of rising feed costs to dairy farms, the federal dairy support
program was revamped with the creation of the Dairy Margin Protection
Organic Valley WI 1,800 Organic Valley (yogurt, milk, butter, cheese, protein Program, a voluntary insurance program that is novel in that payments
(national) drinks, cream, cream cheese) are triggered by a declining margin between milk and grain prices rather
than a falling farm milk price alone.35 This Program replaced the Milk
Income Loss Contract (MILC) Payment Program, and offers a substantially
Lowville Lowville, NY 165 (New McCadam (cheese), own brand cheese curd
better deal for farms: whereas MILC paid out $1.6 billion 2009-2014,
Producers York)
the MPP would have paid out $2.5 billion, had it already been in
place.36 Given that these subsidies disproportionately accrue to larger
milk producers, such programs help big farms get bigger, intensifying
consolidation pressures in the sector.
New York Dairy Processing Helps Globalize the Dairy Industry New York receives a major share of federal dairy subsidies. Between
1995 and 2014 the state received the second highest number of
Despite the decline in national milk consumption,27 value-added subsidies after Wisconsin, a total of more than $500 million, or 9.1% of
products like cheese, cottage cheese, yogurt, and frozen desserts federal dairy subsidies over this period.37 Wyoming County, which has
have allowed the U.S. dairy processing sector to develop into a the highest number of large farms, received the most subsidies over this
mega-industry. New York has played a significant role in the rise of period, at more than $29 million.38 State and national farm lobbies fight
manufactured dairy products. The state became the number one yogurt to keep this public funding, even though they are strongly opposed to
producer in the country in 2012, having tripled its production from 2007 strengthening regulations for labor and workplace safety rights.
levels.28 New York also produces more sour cream, cream cheese, and
cottage cheese than any other state.29 It is a major dairy exporting state, Dairy is the cornerstone of Upstate New York rural economic
ranking third in the country with $375.1 million in dairy exports in 2015.30 development plans
Accordingly, the dairy processing sector has expanded its number of
manufacturing facilities by approximately 80% between 2008 and 2014, The dairy industry is worth a total $14.1 billion to the New York economy,
to 368 facilities.31 and the administration of Governor Andrew Cuomo has worked hard to
support this industry and the jobs it provides for struggling rural and rust
belt communities.
22 23
At the farm level, economic supports and the easing of environmental

burdens have helped some farmers to modernize and grow their
businesses. For example, the state government announced plans in
2012 to invest hundreds of thousands of dollars in a Dairy Acceleration
Program that provides business assistance to farmers looking to expand
their operations.39 A now closed New York State Energy Research and
Development Authority program provided a total of $20 million to the Why a Guestworker Program
is Not a Solution for the
states largest dairies to install anaerobic digesters that convert farm
wastes into energy. The government has also eased environmental
Dairy Industry
regulations for some farmers through a controversial move waiving
CAFO (Concentrated Animal Feeding Operation) permit requirements
for farms in the 200-299 milking herd range, which has raised concerns
over environmental runoff into local waterways and its impacts on human
health.40, 41 Worried about the stability of their workforce, the Farm Bureau and
other dairy farmer associations are eager to expand the current
The state government has also encouraged the industrys growth seasonal agricultural H-2A guestworker program to the year-round
through generous financial incentives. Millions of dollars in tax credits dairy industry.45 The current H-2A program allows agricultural
to large national and multinational corporations and direct financial employers to hire foreign guestworkers on temporary work visas to fill
interventions and grants to local companies demonstrate the sectors seasonal jobs. To participate in the program, employers must be able
significant political importance.42 to document that they are facing a shortage of U.S. workers, and that
hiring foreign workers will not have an adverse impact on the wages of
Perhaps most illustrative of the states approach is the creation in 2014 U.S. workers.46 In January 2017, Representatives Elise Stefanik (R-New
of the Strategic Interagency Task Force on Lessening Obstacles to York, 21st) and Chris Collins (R-New York, 27th) introduced a bill to
Agriculture (also known as SILO), which bring farmers and the state Congress called The Family Farm Relief Act of 2017, which would
agencies that regulate agriculture together to develop recommendations establish a process for the year-round dairy industry to use H-2A visas
to make the overall regulatory framework more streamlined. The for a maximum three-year period of admission that can be renewed
naming of this Task Force explicitly framesindustry regulations, every three months after the end of each period.47
includingprotections for workers rights, as hurdles to be overcome.
However, a guestworker program would do little to improve the
The power of New Yorks dairy lobby living and working conditions of dairy farmworkers, as documented
in this report. H-2A programs fail to consistently protect labor rights.
Despite the trend towards consolidation, dairy farmers remain united A guestworker program would render most existing undocumented
in their demands at the state and federal political levels. Within New farmworkers ineligible for visas, encouraging farmers to replace
York, a group of 18 associations representing the states 35,500 dairy, them with visa-holders and putting them out of a job and a home. It
fruit, vegetable, and crop farms, including the New York Farm Bureau, would not offer guestworkers a path to citizenship, and would make it
quickly joined forces to criticize the Governors decision to support the impossible for workers to bring their families to settle longer term in
constitutional right of farmworkers to collective bargaining.43 They also the U.S. Finally, a guestworker program would tie workers legal right
argue that measures to provide for equal rights for farmworkersto a to work and reside in the U.S. to their job with a single employer.48
weekly day of rest and overtime pay, primarilywould deny farming its Leaving the job they were offered with the visa obliges H-2A workers
exceptional qualities as an industry determined by a Mother Nature to leave the U.S. Therefore, under such a program, workers risk both
who doesnt work by a time clock, negating the basic and equal rights being blacklisted from future agricultural jobs, as well as losing their
of their employees. As Dean Norton, the former president of the Farm U.S. work visa if they speak up about poor working conditions. This
Bureau, declared, There is only one person who has a say in the length denies them one of their greatest expressions of agency: the freedom
of our workday, and that is the good lord above.44 to quit when facing abusive or indecent working conditions and to
seek employment elsewhere.
24 25
Milking Cows,
Milking Workers
Most immigrant farmworkers begin and stay in milking parlor

jobs with little hope for a promotion. Larger farms have a more
specialized division of labor, sometimes creating opportunities
for promotion to milking parlor supervisor, herdsman, assistant
herdsman, or calf feeder. However, legal status, language
barriers, and farmers fear of putting their workers out on public
roads create a glass ceiling that usually impedes promotion to
higher-paid and higher-status positions, such as outdoors crop
work or managerial roles.
26 27
The New Division of Labor on New Yorks Large Caring for calves: This task is sometimes offered to female
workers as it is associated with feminized traits of gentility,
Dairy Farms patience, and care. Calves typically are tethered to tiny
The jobs that immigrant dairy farmworkers typically perform are: individual huts in rows in the fields near the main barn(s). Caring
for them entails providing sufficient water, milk (and, for older
Milker: Milkers typically work in groups of 2 to 4. Coordination calves, grain feed), and monitoring for any symptoms of illness
is key because the process moves extremely fast, and involves in an effort to minimize mortality rates. Often, but not always,
several steps that must be performed with great precision to a small motorized cart is provided so that workers do not have
ensure no bacteria enter the milk supply. In the following order, to carry heavy buckets to huts. Workers also clean the calf stalls
the process involves herding cows into place on platforms, and other equipment using bleach.
dipping (cleaning teats with a germicide solution), drying
teats off, stripping (squirting a bit of milk by hand to check Cow feeder: There are few farms left in Upstate New York
for clots suggestive of an infection), massaging teets to where cattle graze on green pastures. In modern dairying, cows
stimulate milk production, attaching suction equipment (which are fed a scientifically-composed high-protein diet to maximize
automatically comes off when the udders run dry), and herding their milk productioneven though their stomachs are not
cows out from the parlor. Milkers also thoroughly hose down designed to digest it. Usually, formulas for feed are provided
the parlor after their shift. Milkers have told us that their job is by a cow nutritionist and harvested, chopped, purchased, and
the most physically demanding on the farmand also the most mixed by farm employees and farm management (who are
essential for generating farm incomeyet, they feel they are the almost always local workers). Diets must be carefully managed
lowest paid and least valued workers. separately for lactating and dry cows. A small tractor called
a skidsteer is used to clear away unconsumed grains and
Farm income depends directly on the flow of fresh spread new feed in wide trenches in front of cow pens inside
milk and therefore milking is a time-sensitive, often barns. This job is sometimes held by immigrant workers, and is
stressful process. In a perfectly efficient parlor, considered a promotion because it does not require much work
milking machines or sides are changed five times outdoors or long hours on ones feet.
per hour, meaning that, ideally, in a typical double-
12 parlor (two sides of 12 milking machines), 120 Herdsman/Assistant Herdsman: Sometimes, particularly on
cows are milked per hour.49 large farms, immigrant workers with an affinity for cow work are
promoted to herdsmen or assistant herdsmen. The herdsman is
Every step from when cows are loaded into the the care manager for the milking herd and other cattle on the
parlor until they exit is timed to the second, farm. His or her duties involve overseeing the health of cattle,
and farmers often monitor the speed of work to administering injections such as medication or growth hormones,
maximize their milk productivity per worker per breeding or overseeing breeding, and managing other aspects
hour. In these conditions, farmers often prefer a of the herds wellbeing related to cow comfort, barn cleanliness,
younger, more agile workforce. New workers who and the milking process. This job is often paid as a weekly salary
cannot keep up with the pace see their jobs quickly rather than per hour, because herdsmen are called at all hours
disappear. to check on sick cattle or attend to urgent needs. Immigrant
farmworkers are sometimes promoted to this role, although
Cow pusher: Often, immigrant workers are farmers are reluctant to do so because of the risk of a worker
assigned alternating pushing and milking shifts being deported following a significant investment in training.
throughout the work week. Pushing involves
bringing cows from the barn to a holding stall just Foot bather and trimmer: Trimming feet is a challenging
outside the milking parlor so they can be quickly and high-status job given to workers considered skilled with
herded into place for milking. Pushing requires handling difficult cows. Cows become lame when their hooves
special attention to keeping the different groups are infected with bacterial growth, or suffer rotting or abscesses.
of cows separated (cows are divided according to The trimming process usually involves a handheld power tool
how recently they have begun to produce milk, and that grinds or trims hooves, while the cow is restrained in an
thus how much milk they are expected to produce), apparatus called a hoof trimming crush.
and is not usually an entry-level task. Pushers
work alone, including overnight, but must keep in Other duties: Particularly on small farms, workers are often
communication with the milking team to ensure expected to perform a wider range of chores which may include
there is no delay in the milking process. feeding calves, cleaning stalls and barns, cleaning and adding
material to cow beds, bunker silo packing, and others.
28 29
Unequal Treatment on the Farm A fifth of our respondents reported that their boss, managers or other
workers have made explicit reference to their ethnicity or citizenship
The overwhelming majority of farmworkers surveyed have American status in a demeaning or intimidating manner. Sometimes theyve said
supervisors, although a few work under the supervision of those with that were illegal, that this is not our land, and that we should go back,
Mexican, Guatemalan, or other nationalities. These supervisors are often one worker reported. Another said that when his boss gets mad he calls
the farm owner, one of the farmers adult children, or hired local managers them stupid Mexicans. Another said that on his last day at a farm, the
(on larger farms). Seventy-two percent of all surveyed feel that their boss told him to go back to the border. Norma said that One time, a
supervisor treats them well, but the remainder (28%) report aggressive, supervisor told me that since I was an illegal immigrant, I had to learn
disrespectful, or inconsistent behavior on the part of their boss. how to speak English if I wanted to keep my job. Federico explained,
Even though we dont know English, we know when the boss talks to us
As agricultural employees, citizen and immigrant workers alike are exempt in a rude way. We might not know the language and the words, but our
from basic labor protections. But most respondents (62%) report that hearts know it and feel it.
American workers are nevertheless treated better than Latino immigrant
workers on the farm. The most common observation, when asked for
examples, was that Americans do easier work for better pay. As one Valuing cows over workers
worker reported, They always make the undocumented worker do the
heaviest work. The American workers do the easiest work and they do it Nearly all (88%) respondents reported that their boss cares more about
at their own pace. They also noted that American workers have all the the cows than the workers. The predominant reason workers offered
rights, including days off and an hour for lunch, and that they are treated for feeling this way related to the fact that cows are the source of profit
more respectfully. Some highlighted how American workers can rest and for the farm owner. As one worker put it: They produce milk and thats
goof around while on the job, whereas immigrant workers are scolded for where the profit is. Another said, you can get another worker for
doing the same. Saul, a 35 year-old worker from Mexico, said: You can less than it costs to replace a cow. Similarly, a worker reported that a
see that when they (American white workers) are just sitting or resting, supervisor explicitly told her that a cow is worth more than a worker and
nobody says anything to them. But if we do it, they always say something. that a worker is easier to replace.
Also, American workers always have a higher pay than us.
Another common sentiment among interviewees was that their boss
About a quarter of those surveyed (27%) report that American and was more concerned with providing for the well-being and comfort
immigrant workers are treated equally. Only 4% believe that the of cows than in meeting their own needs (as comfortable conditions
immigrant workers are treated better than the American workers. As one for temperature and sleeping are associated with higher levels of milk
worker explained, They treat the Mexicans betterwere the ones who production). One worker said, The cows are what gives him business.
make them the most money. They buy cows sawdust and other things. They [the cows] sleep better
than we do sometimes. Similarly, respondents report that their boss
appears to care more about the cows than about workers health and
Bullying and discrimination safety. One said, If a worker gets hurt, it matters to him less than a sick
cow. Another reported that, One time at work, a cow hit me hard, and
Nearly half (48%) of all respondents report that they have suffered the owner came and only asked how the cow was. He did not ask about
bullying or discrimination in the workplace. One time, a worker me. He did not care about me.
explained, I got to work and the boss told me leave. When I was
leaving the barn, the boss grabbed me and pushed me out. Another
worker recounted how his boss constantly surveils workers: What
happens is that the owner meddles in our personal lives. He is just
monitoring everybody. He even counts your time when we go to the
bathroom. Maria talked about suffering gender discrimination and
sexual harassment: Nobody wants to hire a woman unless she is a
veterinarian or formally trained in something. She continued, as a
woman, it is very hard to get this kind of work. They wont give us full
time work and the men are very machista.
30 31
Long Hours
for Low Pay
Farmworkers are excluded from many of the basic labor rights
and protections that workers in most other sectors of the labor
market take for granted. Excluded from the National Labor
Relations Act of 1935, they do not have the right to organize
or engage in collective bargaining. They are also excluded
from the overtime provisions of the Fair Labor Standards
Act. In addition, the New York State Employee Relations Act
specifically exempts farmworkers from the right to collectively
bargain, while the New York State Labor Law excludes
farmworkers from overtime pay and the right to a day off.50
This means that dairy farmworkers depend on the generosity of farm

owners for a full day of rest. The vast majority work 6 days per week,
but they have no legal guarantee of a day off from work. Ten percent of
workers surveyed report working seven days a week with no day off.
Alvaro, a 25 year-old worker from Mexico, works 85 hours per week.

He considers the work both difficult and monotonous. Despite his
extraordinarily long hours, his boss will not give him a break, even when
he finishes his work early. And when he and coworkers complained, they
were threatened with being fired. When we couldnt take it any longer,
he said, they would say you can leave if you want to.
32 33
Workers reported working anywhere from 6 to 15 hours each day,

though they typically work 12 hours a day. Scheduling practices tend to
be different depending on the size of the farm. On larger farms with fast-
paced milking parlors, shifts are usually 12 consecutive hours per day. On
smaller farms, shifts might be shorter but more frequent (for example,
8 hours on, 8 hours off, 8 hours on, etc.), never allowing more than a
few hours to rest at any point in the day or night. One worker described
the temporal disorientation caused by this kind of around the clock
scheduling practice: For me, the night is day, and the day is night.
Ninety percent of workers reported that they get a break to rest or eat
during their shift. These breaks usually last between 30 minutes and one
hour. Unfortunately, breaks are sometimes as brief as a few minutes. For
example, Diego, a 24 year-old dairy worker from Mexico, works between
76 and 78 hours per week, averaging 12 hours each day. Although Diego
is supposed to have a daily 30-minute break, on many occasions he finds
himself having to work straight through:
I start working at 4:00 am and work until 12:00 pm, then I work
from 12:30 pm until 4:00 pm or 4:30 pm. There is very little time to
rest, and sometimes there is no time to have a breaksometimes
we just have to work like that.
Of the 88 workers we interviewed, 45% report that they feel rushed

and/or hurried on the job. Some report that they are timed while they
work so they always have to work fast. Still others report that they feel
rushed because theyre under constant surveillancevia video cameras
in the barnsor because they can fall behind if a machine breaks down
or something out of the ordinary occurs. Bertha, a worker from Mexico,
said: Here you get no extra time. If they (supervisors) see you resting, Certainly, some workers want to work as many hours as possible, given
they will give you more work to do. their relatively low rate of hourly pay and their need to send remittances
to their families and pay back migration debts. This is certainly true of
One worker described the relentless pace of milk production in these
Ernesto, a 46 year-old dairy worker from Guatemala. He works a daily
terms:
15-hour shift, from 5:00 am to 8:00 pm, with a one-hour unpaid break.
The first group of workers finishes milking at 9:00 am. By noon, As he explained, working such long hours hardly feels like a choice:
the milk has to be ready for pick up. There is only one person who
We work a little more, and we get a little more money (the
milks in each shift. The cow pusher used to help but not anymore.
money) still might not be enough, but we have no options,
Now I have to: bring in the cows, clean, give them food and do
there are no options Some days we dont sleep enough, some
whatever comes up, and then I have to hurry and milk all the cows
Mondays we only sleep 4 or 5 hours but our body gets used
in 4 hours. That is very hard to do. And sometimes there are cows
to it.
who are in labor and I have to go and help them, but even then,
they (supervisors) are rushing me. I feel very rushed all the time
and that makes the work very dangerous. I can have an accident if
I am too tired and if I am not careful. Also, I havent had vacations
or a day off per week in 3 years.
34 35
Low and Stagnant Wages Forty-four percent of workers get no vacation days. Of those who do
get vacation time, 68% report that it is paid. A slight majority of the
Most workers on dairies earn an hourly wage that places them near dairy workers we surveyed have at one time or another received a gift
or, depending on how many people in the U.S. they support, below or bonus from their employer, typically for Christmas or for exceptional
the poverty line. However, they are comparing these wages to the milk quality. However, most workers state that these bonuses are
dramatically lower incomes that they would be earning back home. not always consistent and that the policies around them are unclear,
Poverty in their home countries, then, is in large part what make particularly regarding the quality of milk.53
immigrants such an ideal workforce from the perspective of U.S.
employers, as it is what drives immigrants to willingly put up with wages When bonuses are withdrawn without explanation, workers feel
and working conditions that few, if any, American workers would accept. uninformed about their job performance and may lose out on an income
supplement they had relied upon.
The workers we interviewed reported earnings of, on average, $9.32/
hour.51 Since the median and mode for hourly pay were both $9.00/hour, All the workers surveyed for this project have had deductions from their
it is clear that a few higher-paid outliers slightly pull up the average.52 Full pay, specifically local and federal taxes. Social security is almost always
time employment with a 40-hour work week at $9.00/hour amounts to deducted from workers pay, even though they are generally in no
$18,000 a year. Working 72 hours per week (the most common number position to collect social security in the future, or any government aid
of hours worked per week by workers surveyed), their average pre-tax for that matter. Other examples of paycheck deductions include housing
earnings would be $33,696 per year. (rent), Medicaid, retirement savings contributions, utilities (telephone,
cable, gas), and housing-related repairs (broken down appliances, pest
Workers whose families reside in New York shared stories of economic control, etc.). Understanding what these deductions are and why they
hardship and disillusionment with their economic reality in el Norte. are in place can be challenging for workers. On occasion, workers dont
Jose and his wife Elsa, dairy workers from Mexico, have struggled to understand why they have deductions such as Medicaidconsidering
support their four children on their two incomes. Unable to afford to rent they or their employers usually pay directly for their healthcare or
a place of their own, they have lived for over a decade in overcrowded why their employer marks those deductions by hand on their pay stubs.
farm housing, sharing the space with at least four other dairy workers. Given that deductions appear in English, some workers simply cannot
decipher their pay stubs.
They experienced extreme financial hardship in 2015 when Jose required
an emergency operation on his brain. For weeks, he was incapacitated
and unable to work. Elsas wages were not enough to support their
family and cover the bills. The family got through those troubled times
thanks to the financial donations of friends and supportive community
members.
Moreover, workers receive infrequent raises. With the exception of a

few outliers, wages undercovered during our research tend to hover
at $9.00/hourat a time when the New York State minimum wage
was $8.00/hour (2014) and $8.75/hour (2015)regardless of how long
workers have been on the farm. Two-thirds reported that they have had
a pay increase at one point, but typically by no more than 25 cents.
Often, these increases were merely reflecting increases in the New York
minimum wage. As one worker explained, One time they increased my
pay by 10 cents. Thats an insult to me.
36 37
Others were never paid for their first week of employment. Rather, they
were told that it was unpaid training. Still others had their pay illegally
Wage Theft Prevention Act docked when they made mistakes, like mixing up cows at different
stages of milk production freshening, or after getting injured.
In 2011, New York State enacted the Wage Theft Prevention Act to assist with the recovery of unpaid Finally, wage theft occurs when farmers require workers to pay for their
or underpaid wages and to increase penalties for employers who fail to follow labor laws in all own protective equipmentgloves, glasses, masks, boots, etc.as was
industries. The only legal pay deductions are those required by law, such as social security, income the case for one quarter of our respondents. As Crispin explained: They
tax, and court-ordered garnishments, and those that are considered benefits and that the worker has (the farm) gave us short gloves to handle the chemicals, but they know
authorized in writing, such as insurance premiums, savings, or allowances for meals and lodging (if that it wasnt enough for us to avoid touching the chemicals and to do
permitted by law). the cleaning; they gave us the option of buying larger gloves from a
different box, or we could buy our own at the store. That was not fair.
Wage theft Demanding Stolen Wages

An important finding of this study is that 28% of the workers surveyed
have knowingly received less pay than what they were owed while
working on a New York dairy farm. Given the number of farmworkers
who admit to not understanding their pay stubs, the actual rate of wage
theft may be higher.
Wage theft takes several forms. Most of the wage theft cases occurred
because workers checks didnt account for all the hours they had
worked. Twenty-five percent of workers reported that when they work
fewer hours than normal, their checks reflect the difference, but when
they work more hours than normal, the additional hours are not paid.
Some workers said their employers still did not pay even after they
pointed out the discrepancy.
Francisco, a 30 year-old worker from Mexico, shared his experience with

wage theft:
During the winter, there is no heat and everything in the barns

freezes. Sometimes it takes us a long time to unfreeze the
machines, and he (the owner) doesnt pay us the hours we spend
unfreezing the machines I worked at another farm and the
same thing happened to me like 5 or 6 times in 15 months. I
dont think I can recuperate the money, the owner is going to ask
me for proof. They owed me $600, so like a weeks pay
Sometimes long periods of work are unpaid. In some of the cases,

getting the last paycheck owed when leaving a job was especially When Alberto (right), a dairy worker from Mexico, realized that he was not getting paid for the
difficult. In the case of Armando, a 35 year-old worker from Mexico, number of hours he was working, he decided to quit. After giving notice, he spoke to a few of his
the farm owner owed him his last two weeks pay, around $900. When co-workers to educate them about the wage theft that they, too, were experiencing. One of them
he confronted the owner, she said that Armando would not be paid tipped off the owner that he had spoken out and when Alberto went to retrieve his final paycheck,
because he didnt give two weeks notice. Daniel, a 35 year-old worker the owner ripped it up in his face.
from Mexico, had a similar experience. As he explained: They still owe Alberto left the farm and soon thereafter sought help retrieving his stolen pay from WJCNY. He
me the last [check], like 30 hours I told the farm owner, but he said that wrote a demand letter and delivered it himself to the manager. Eventually Alberto filed a wage
I didnt work fast enough, so I was fired and wasnt going to get paid. theft complaint with the New York State Department of Labor. After a year, Alberto was finally
paid the wages he was owed.
38 39
Dangerous
Dairies
On Sunday, November 9, 2014, Marco Antonio was working

alone, covering another workers job duties on his day off and
gathering feed for the cows. When he failed to start milking the
cows at the usual hour, his coworkers went looking for him.
Originally from Huehuetenango, Guatemala, Marco had come to New

York to support his wife and children back home. He had been working
at the same farm for three years. As a dedicated worker, husband, and
father, his tardiness that day was out of character.
Concerned with his whereabouts, his coworkers went looking for him
at the family-owned organic dairy farm in Penn Yan, NY. Shortly after
5:00pm, they found him: dead and alone. He was only 31 years old.
Marco had been in the grain silo cleaning an auger, a task for which he
had never received training. When his co-workers found him, his body
lay limp and lifeless, mangled in the still-rotating machinery.
The details of Marcos tragic death serve as an apt metaphor for an

industry that churns out workers in its never-ending quest to churn out
more and more milk.
40 41
Neither an Isolated nor An important finding of this study is the number of workers who believe
that they themselves must bear the sole burden of ensuring their
Inevitable Case personal safety on the job. In response to the question What steps do
Marcos death was not an isolated incident. you take to protect yourself from workplace accidents?, workers more
In fact, on February 5, 2013, just a year or less unanimously indicated that they have to take safety into their own
earlier, another immigrant farmworker was hands: We have to look after ourselves when we work,
killed under similar circumstances. Francisco We have to be alert, Be aware, and Pay attention.
Ortiz, originally from Veracruz, Mexico, was These answers indicate that they do not have have
We came here
crushed to death by a skid steer loader while sufficient recourse to means for preventing accidents
working on a small dairy farm in Ithaca, NY. and injuries on the farm.
His wife, Mayra, laments that her husband
had long complained about the dangers of
working with the ill-functioning machine that Workplace Injuries
eventually took his life.
Part of the challenge of reporting on dairy worker to make a life
for ourselves
The toll of workplace fatalities in New Yorks health and safety is that there is no official tracking, or

dairy industry is striking: 69 farmworker statewide database, of injuries sustained on farms. As
fatalities have been reported in the decade a result, we have little overall sense of the gravity of
between 2006 and 2016, according to the
New York State Department of Health.54
workplace danger in this industry.
not to lose it.
Yet, our interviews with dairy farmworkers were
These deaths were preventable. Changes in revelatory. Two-thirds of workers surveyed report having
both governmental policies and workplace been injured at least once, if not multiple times, while Roberto, 36 year-old
practices would greatly minimize the dangers working on a dairy farm. Of those workers, more than worker from Mexico
farmworkers face on dairies. two-thirds (68%) sustained an injury so severe that they
required medical attention, even though not all (89%)
Only a small minority of farms are subject to successfully received it. The most commonly reported
any kind of governmental oversight, meaning injuries include kicks to the head, crushed limbs, eye
that farm owners can essentially choose injuries due to chemical exposure, cuts, and broken and
whether or not to comply with existing safety fractured bones.
standards. Indeed, Congressional riders
to OSHAs funding prevents OSHA, the Most of those injured (83%) reported the workplace accident to their
federal agency charged with oversight of boss. The others lamented that they didnt report their injuries because,
workplace health and safety, from inspecting for instance, we want to be seen as good workers, we came here to
or enforcing compliance with its standards on work, not to complain, or we dont speak English.
small farms. Farms that employ fewer than 11
Workers reported that they face difficulty getting needed support when
non-family workers, like the ones where both
injuries unfortunately occur. More than a third of those injured (39%)
Marco and Francisco were killed, are entirely
reported that they needed workers compensation. But only a third of
unregulated.55 Even deaths on small farms
those who needed it actually applied, either because they didnt know it
do not trigger an OSHA inspection; of the
was an option given their undocumented status, or because they feared
34 deaths that occurred on dairy farms in New York between 2007 and
employer reprisal. Several workers reported that they werent even
2012, OSHA did a follow-up inspection for a mere four.56 It is estimated
permitted days off to recuperate from their injuries. One worker even
only 18% of New York dairy farmworkers are employed on farms eligible
said that the manager and farm owner told him that he did not have the
for OSHA inspection and enforcement activities.57
right to compensation, and another worker reported that his manager
tried to minimize his injury and told him that workers compensation
wasnt necessary.
42 43
Lazaro:I was lucky I didnt

lose my eye.
After his company eliminated his office job in 2013, Lazaro, 55 years old, decided to leave his
home in Mexico City to seek work in New York so that he could support his elderly parents, his
wife, and the university studies of his two children.
Lazaro worked on a small dairy farm in Central New York. As the only Latino employee, he was
responsible for milking cows in the parlor, cleaning out the stables, and caring for the calves.
He worked between 9 and 12 hours a day, 7 days per week. He was paid a weekly flat rate
of $500, which meant that some weeks, his compensation was well below the legal minimum
wage. Yet, fear of losing his job made him reluctant to complain to his employer.
One day, Lazaro was performing his usual routine of pushing cows. Although there were two
bulls in the mix, he had received no warning from his employer and no guidance as to how
to behave around the bulls to keep them calm. The only training he had received was in a
language he did not understand (English) and it failed to cover all of the tasks for which he was
given responsibility. One of the bulls charged him. Lazaro ducked behind the metal protectors
around the cow beds, but the bull approached him from behind and flung him face-forward.
Lying on the ground, Lazaro felt his face burning. He was bleeding profusely. His employer
helped him up, but instructed him to wait in a chair near the milk tank while he finished the
remaining three hours of Lazaros shift milking cows. During those hours, Lazaro did not have
the opportunity to inspect his face in a mirror. But he suspected that his facial injury was
serious. While he waited, he grabbed one of the cloths that is normally applied to cow udders
and applied iodine to his injury.
Eventually, seeing the significant amount of blood, Lazaros employer called one of his family
members to take Lazaro to the hospital. He received five stitches for a long cut extending from
his eye to his cheek. Though he needed a sixth stitch, the doctors opted not to provide it, as it
would have risked damage to his eyeball. He had two broken teeth and two fractured ribs. The
doctor told Lazaro that he was lucky that these were his only injuries; given the serious nature
of the incident, he could have lost his eye or even his life.
Following the accident, Lazaro received no compensation for the days he was unable to work.
His employer fired him within a week, claiming that he was no longer physically capable of
performing the duties required by his job. For a few days, Lazaro survived on backpay for
work performed prior to the accident. But he had no family locally to support him and he was
unaware that he could apply for Workers Compensation. Lazaro moved in with a friend and
spent over a month recovering. He was told that he needed to see an eye specialist as well as
a bone specialist for his injuries. He has not had the financial means to do so.
Lazaro joined the Workers Center of Central New York to fight for greater OSHA oversight
of what he considers the deplorable conditions workers face on dairy farms. As he wrote in
a letter to the Syracuse Post Standard, We ask that the politicians that are looking out for
the farmers and their interests become more conscientious about those of us who work in
the dairies. We are not asking for anything special, just that our right to workplace health and
safety is valued.58
44 45
Sources of danger on dairy farms

As indicated in the graph below, respondents identified four primary
sources of danger on dairy farms: cows, machinery, chemicals, and farm/
parlor conditions. It should be noted that because of the length and
timing of shifts, the dangers listed below are exacerbated when workers
are exhausted.
Cows and Bulls
By far the most significant source of danger, according to the workers

What are the most significant sources of danger on the farm? surveyed, are the cows themselves. Workers highlighted cows
propensity to kick and push as the most serious causes for concern.
One worker exclaimed,its an animal!, one that while generally
peaceful, weighs 1,000 to 1,500 pounds and can be unpredictable.
Another worker explained the greatest risk in these terms: Proximity to
80% aggressive animals, without there being any indication of which animals
are aggressive. Thus many workersthough they express affection for
the cows and may enjoy working with themhave learned that they
70% have to be cautious at all times. As one worker put it, Cows kick. I dont
71% have much trust in them.
60% To dairy farmworkers, cows getting milked for the first time (vacas
frescas) are particularly dangerous because they are nervous and
therefore even more unpredictable. They also face considerable danger
50% from bulls if they are left in the pens intermingling with the dairy cows.
This, for instance, was what befell Lazaro, whose attack by a bull left him
with broken ribs and a serious facial injury.59
40%
Pinned
30% 35%
Crushed
Kicked
20% Charged
18%
Mounted
10%
11% 4% 1% 4% 4% Bitten
0% Stepped On
Trampled
ls
ns
rs
w
Pi
r
al
no
ul
ne
ke
tio
hi
ic
Gored
e
B
tK
or
yt
hi
ur
m
di
s/
er
ac
ow
he
an
ow
on
'
on
Ev
M
C
rC
C
D
d
lo
e
nc
ar
/P
rie
rm
pe
Fa
ex
In
46 47
Workers also face the ever-present danger of getting Farm Conditions

trapped between a cow or bull and a fence or gate.
Herding the cows to the milking parlor, as one The fourth most commonly cited source of danger is conditions on the
worker explained, always comes with the risk of being farms and in the parlors. Workers highlighted a wide range of concerns
crushed. related to the physical workplace. Several noted the tight quarters of the
milking parlor, which made their job more difficult and dangerous. Many
Machinery brought up slippery floors, particularly when it is snowing, but also as
a result of cow urine and feces. Holes, cracks and unevenness in floors
The second most commonly cited source of danger, or staircases can lead to tripping or falling, One worker noted that the
according to the workers we surveyed, is using machinery farm where he workedand the equipment withinis very old and is
without adequate training. As one worker put it, the therefore more likely to bring about a fatal accident.
greatest danger comes from having to work with
machines that we dont know how to use. The risk of Several workers highlighted their exposure to difficult climatic conditions
injury is exacerbated when these machines are old and throughout the long Upstate winter or during summer storms,
insufficiently maintained. Often, when the machines particularly when performing outdoor tasks like caring for calves. Manure
break down, workers feel they have little choice but to try pits, when lacking appropriate safety stops or warning signs, present the
to fix them, even when they havent been trained to do risk of drowning or of fatal inhalation of noxious gases, as well as oxygen
so. deficiency. And confined spaces such as grain storage bins, hoppers,
manure storage units, and milk storage units can lead to asphyxiation
Workers also face risks when working with the machinery and entrapment. Finally, noise from farm equipment can lead to hearing
in the milking parlor. They highlighted the possibility of loss, especially when protective equipment is not provided.
getting hit by a tube or pipe when cleaning the milking
equipment. They also mentioned exposed cables and
the possibility of slipping on the rods of the machinery. Worker Training
Similarly, exposed wires and PTO (power take off) from
tractors and other machines put workers at risk. One third of the immigrant dairy workers we surveyed reported having
received no job training of any kind. This is concerning, especially when
Chemicals one considers that the agricultural sector is one of the most dangerous
sectors of the labor market and that immigrant workers tend to be
Chemicals are the third most commonly reported source employed in roles that are the most hazardous.61
of danger on dairy farms. Dairy workers are regularly
exposed to hazardous chemicalsincluding iodine, Two thirds of interviewees did indicate that they received training.
acid, chlorine, bleach, peroxide, copper sulfate, and However, that training was not always sufficient. For some, training
formaldehydewhen applying teat dips, caring for focused exclusively on ensuring the production of high quality milk;
cows hooves, cleaning the milk tank, and cleaning matters of workplace health and safety were not even mentioned. As one
parlor equipment. Without proper training in the uses worker explained, I barely had training, like one minute. I figured it out
of such chemicals, workers are at risk of skin, eye, and lung irritation after some time. One just simply has to learn as they go. For still others,
or inflammation. This risk is exacerbated when farms lack accessible the training was rudimentary and carried out in a language (English) they
eyewash stations. Working with chemicals without proper training could barely understand. Several thus reported that training involved an
can also have long term health consequences, such as cancer and awkward display of pantomime, rather than a thorough explanation of
permanent damage to the nervous system.60 the requirements and precautions of the job.
Workers thus usually learn the ropes, and how to identify dangers, from
each other or on their own. Mary, a worker from Mexico, is a case in
point. As the only female worker on her farm, she suffers considerable
harassment. She explained how the lack of training combined with these
gendered dynamics led to several work-related accidents. The only
training I got lasted five minutes. The men would laugh behind my back
and they wouldnt tell me how to be careful and about the dangers of
the farm.
48 49
Edgar, too, spoke about the dangers that stem from the lack of training.
Yesterday, he began, I washed with the red acid. No, Edgar, a Why there is no OSHA oversight of
90+% of New York dairy farms?
supervisor told him. That red liquid is dangerous. Why didnt you
tell me? And its like that, things just slip by. I washed myself but I was
hurting here and little pieces [of skin] were falling off me. When someone
doesnt know something, they dont train them. Sometimes, someone
The Occupational Safety and Health Act was passed in 1970 to ensure that every worker
grabs something without knowing what its for. Sometimes, there are
had the right to health and safety in the workplace. The Occupational Safety and Health
gallons of liquid spray without labels. So thats bad, too, because we
Administration (OSHA) is the agency charged with enforcing this federal law. Since 1976,
dont know what they contain.
however, Congress has limited OSHAs oversight of farms that employ fewer than 11 non-family
While 82% of our respondents reported that they work with machinery workers. Every year, the Labor, Health and Human Services, and Education Appropriations Bill
(including tractors, Bobcats, skid steers, augers, and milking machines), which funds OSHAhas included a rider to the Act. This addition specifies that OSHA cannot
only 66% of those workers had received training on how to properly inspect small farms and low-hazard operations, if it wants funding. This means that small farms
operate that machinery. Similarly, while 90% of respondents reported are entirely unregulated when it comes to workplace health and safety.
that they work with chemicals, only 58% of those workers had been
trained on how to use those chemicals safely. Even fewer51%were How did this come to be?
instructed on what they should do in the event of a chemical accident. Farmer coalitions and industry representatives consistently fight against regulation. They
As Alvaro, a young Guatemalan man who has worked on four different promote their interests by propagating romanticized and antiquated narratives of farm labor:
dairy farms since 2010, explained: No one trained me on how to use of small family farms representing the traditional American way of life that would be damaged
chemicals safely. Theres no emergency training about what to do. We by government oversight. Members of Congress echo these narratives in an effort to keep farm
just have to figure it out. But many dont know how to figure it out, owners happy by keeping OSHA off of family farms. However, even the largest farms are
[because they] cant read. usually family-owned, and they employ tens of thousands of workers who deserve basic safety
and health protections like those in any other industry.
Access to Protective Equipment What are the effects of the rider?

Seventy-three percent of respondents judge the personal protective The rider means that working conditions on small farms depend on farm owners voluntary
equipment they receive as adequate for protecting them against compliance with health and safety regulations. It also means that there is no enforcement
workplace injuries. Slightly more than one-fourth of all respondents mechanism, should those conditions be lacking: OSHA cannot conduct inspections or impose
judge the equipment to be inadequate. Moreover, since a majority fines, which otherwise would incentivize farmers to take steps towards injury prevention. OSHA
of our respondents did not receive sufficient training, they might not also cannot collect information about health and safety standards on small farms. That data is
have knowledge of the protective equipment that is needed. Alvaro, vital to demonstrate safety and health problems on small farms and thereby bring them under
for instance, quoted above, reported that he has no other protective OSHAs jurisdiction.
equipment than plastic overalls. Many others reported having nothing
In 2013, given the high number of hazards, accidents, and fatalities on dairy farms, WJCNY and
other than gloves: They dont give anything for work with machines,
WCCNY launched a campaign to push OSHA to implement a Local Emphasis Program (LEP)
just plastic gloves, the type used to milk cows or lift manure. Still others
for the New York dairy industry, modeled after a successful effort in Wisconsin. The LEP would
reported receiving literally nothing: Not onenothing, nothing, there
permit the agency to conduct unannounced inspections at dairies across the state.
was nothing, not even sleeves to cover my arms, or gloves, none of
that. Of those who do have personal protective equipment, 25% were After organizing a delegation of injured workers to present to the press and to OSHA, WJCNY
illegally required to pay for it out of pocket. and WCCNY secured the launch of an LEP on New York State dairy farms. Workers had the
opportunity to train OSHA inspectors about what to expect, and toured the state educating the
public and workers about dairy farm conditions.
The agricultural business industry, however, lobbied seven congressional representatives to

advocate for an indefinite delay of the program. WJCNY and WCCNY organized a counter-
response and the LEP moved forward.
While not a complete solution to the dangers workers face, the LEP is nevertheless a step in the
right direction. It has been renewed two years in a row and is still in place today. It is improving
the safety conditions of farms with more than 10 non-family workers, as employers have made
efforts to bring their farms into compliance with OSHA standards. And workers are more aware
of their rights with respect to safety protections.
50 51
Stuck in Place
For immigrant farmworkers, the dairy farm provides the

whole context of their New York-based lives: job, home, and
community. This is because workers live in employer-provided
housing on the farm itself, and are often fearful to leave the
farm property because of intensive immigration enforcement
activity by Border Patrol agents and even local law enforcement
agents. Without access to New York drivers licenses, they feel
poorly integrated into the community. They are caught in a
transnational limbo far away from their home countries, but
feeling not much closer to the New York communities where
they live and work.
52 53
Farmworker Housing By and large, farmworker housing is in great need of improvement.

Respondents were asked if they had experienced a number of different
Most dairy farmworkers are dependent on their farm employers even housing-related problems. A majority (58%) of farmworkers interviewed
for a place to live. In our survey, 97% of respondents live in employer- face problems with bug or pest infestations in their homes. Nearly half
provided housing, which is usually offered to them with the job. Only report having no locks on their doors, leaving many to feel that there
three percent of respondents rented an apartment off the farm. Thus, is insufficient security in their house, mostly because anyone can enter
for the vast majority of farmworkers, the boss is the landlord and the at any time. Additionally, nearly a third of respondents report a lack of
landlord is the boss. Loss of ones job goes hand in hand with loss of potable water.
ones home.
On-farm housing is almost always a trailer that has been erected for Issues with Housing
workers, or an old farmhouse. Sometimes, on large farms, farmers Bugs or insects 58%
construct dormitories for workers. Two percent of
our respondents described living in a dormitory. One
worker reported living in a concrete square, and
No locks on doors 48%
another even reported living in a makeshift apartment
constructed off of the milking parlor, getting no Holes in the floor or walls 32%
reprieve from dangerous methane gases, foul odors,
and noise from the animals. Insufficient ventilation 32%
Living on the farm presents some conveniences for Bathroom in poor conditions 30%
farmworkers who do not have to pay for rides to work
or travel overnight for graveyard shifts. A significant Insufficient heating 30%
majority (80%) do not pay rent. Of the remaining
20%, several reported that they do not know how
much they pay in rent, in part because its deducted
No potable water 30%
from their paychecks.
Stove broken down (> 2 days) 30%
Meanwhile, having workers living right on the farm
property helps farmers ensure that workers are Broken roof 29%
constantly available for work. In fact, most live less
than 5 minutes by foot from the milking parlor Electricity shut off 8%
literally just steps away. Only 6 respondents (7%)
reported living at a distance from the farm that would
Overcrowding of housing is also a concern with workers reporting having
require transportation (anywhere between one mile, and 25 minutes
only one bathroom or one stove for upwards of 12 people. We have
by car). Two workers described having to walk 45 minutes to the farm,
observed bed-sharing between workers who alternate day and night
sometimes at 4:00am, usually alone, and including in winter conditions.
shifts, and even one worker who slept in the bathtub when there was
The decency and safety of housing conditions is up to the farmer. Even insufficient space in the living quarters.62
though county public health departments and local code enforcement
These issues persist even though 88% of those with a housing complaint
have jurisdiction to inspect dairy farmworker housing, in practice we
informed the owner about the problem(s). More than half felt that
have never encountered a farm where such inspections are conducted
the owner did not respond adequately to the complaint, either doing
on a routine basis. Moreover, because year-round dairy farmworkers
nothing or dragging his or her feet in resolving the problem. As one
are not considered migrant and seasonal, they are excluded from
worker explained, They say theyre going to fix it, but sometimes they
provisions for housing standards and inspection of migrant labor camps
take a long time. They always say theres no money. Theyre all like
under the federal Migrant and Seasonal Agricultural Worker Protection
that. Workers sometimes try to take matters into their own hands when
Actwhich, although inadequate, do at least assign state or federal
owners are unwilling to address their concerns. One worker explained
governmental responsibility for inspecting farmworker housing. Sixty-two
how he and his co-workers had bought treatments for cockroaches, but
percent of our interviewees report that no one ever inspects their
that their efforts proved insufficient and the problem was never resolved.
housing. Thirty-eight percent report that inspections are conducted by
The few who did not report their housing complaints to the farm owner
someone who works on the farm, either routinely or in response to a
acknowledged that their decision was due to fear, lack of confidence,
request from workers.
and/or disillusionment that anything would really change.
54 55
Living in Isolation Farmworkers have good reason to fear leaving the farm. This is because
a large proportion of the rural Upstate region falls within 100 miles of
Exactly half (50%) of the respondents live with at least one family the international border, a zone where Border Patrol has the right to
member, including a significant other, and the other 50% live with set up immigration checkpoints, and to pull over and search vehicles
no family members. In such situations, visits from family members or when they have reasonable suspicion that an immigration violation
friends working on farms nearby are critical to reducing workers sense has been committed.64 In practice, Border Patrol agents have frequently
of loneliness and isolation. However, 20% of respondents said that the overstepped these powers: they routinely ignore or misunderstand
farm owner has a rule prohibiting them from having visitors in their the limits of their legal authority in the course of individual stops.65
house. Many of these workers report that the farm owner has specifically Moreover, it is not uncommon for law enforcement, particularly in the
banned women from coming over, presuming that they would be sex rural areas where dairy farms are located, to collaborate with Border
workers. Several reported that their boss requires workers to obtain Patrol and ICE agents to detain undocumented workers. For example,
permission before having any visitors. in March 2017while putting the finishing touches on this reporttwo
members of a dairy farmworker family were pulled over by local police
Access to farm housing by advocates and service providers is limited not on their way to church for speeding. Local police called Border Patrol
only because of geographical isolation, but because neither state nor and the women and their five children and younger brother were taken
federal law protects the right of visitors to the local Border Patrol station. That night one of the mothers was
to access farm housing. The New York forcibly separated from her three U.S. citizen children, including an
State Attorney General has issued an infant, until the next day.
opinion stating that farmworkers should
have the right to visitors: In our view, Forty-one percent of our respondents reported having been detained
migrant farmworkers living in labor at least once by law enforcement officials. Of these, 33% had been
camps are tenants within the meaning detained by local police, 24% by the sheriff, 21% by a state trooper, and
of New York States Real Property 21% by a Border Patrol agent.
Law. As tenants, migrant farmworkers
have the common law right to receive Many of these workers report having been stopped for speeding, broken
guests of their choice [such as] doctors, headlights, or suspicion regarding their immigration status. This was the
lawyers, labor union representatives, case for Ignacio, who explained, The police have stopped me three
the clergy or other persons during times[once] they called immigration. It was a checkpoint and I didnt
non-working hours without interference have normal headlights, only high beams.
by their employers or owners of the
Similarly, Edgar, a 40 year-old worker from Guatemala, was walking
labor camps.63
to the store one night when local police, looking for a man who had
Nevertheless, unless this opinion is committed a robbery, stopped him. Even when they realized that Edgar
supported by legislation that clearly was not the person for whom they were looking, they asked for his ID.
establishes the legal right of workers When Edgar showed them his Guatemalan passport, they told him that
in employer-provided housing to his ID was garbage and reported him to immigration officials, who
be visited in their living quarters, subsequently put him in deportation proceedings. A startling 37% of our
employers can continue to screen respondents have experienced the deportation of a family member or
visitors and even deny their access to other close person upon whom they rely for support.
farmworkers housing.
Immobility
The Ever-Present Threat of Seventy eight percent of our respondents reported that they do not
Deportation have a car. For some, this is because their boss explicitly restricts their
mobility: over a fifth of our respondents (22%) reported that their boss
Many farmworkers feel trapped on prohibits them from having their own cars. Most reported that they do
the farms due to their round-the-clock not have a car because they lack the requisite documents to drive.
work schedules, lack of access to
transportation, and fear of immigration
enforcement officials.
56 57
I would like to
New York State is one of the thirty-eight states Feeling Isolated and Alone
have a legal
in the country that restricts immigrants access to
drivers licenses.66 Under current regulations, the Because of these difficulties accessing transportation, workers often go
immigration
New York Department of Motor Vehicles requires long periods of time without ever leaving the farm. The average length
that license applicants provide a valid social of time they go without leaving the farm is a little more than 11 days. Six
security number. As a result, most undocumented percent of workers surveyed reported leaving the farm as infrequently as
status for one immigrant workers are unable to obtain drivers

licenses and are consequently unable to secure car
once a month. A couple of workers in the Northern border area, where
immigration enforcement activities are most intense, resolutely declared
reason only:
insurance. Immigrant dairy farmworkers are thus that they only leave the farms for medical emergencies, sometimes
entirely dependent on their bosses, managers, staying within the confines of the farm property for years on end.
co-workers, andmost commonlyraiteros for
so I can drive. rides off of the farm. Even when workers have access to a car or to a raitero, the fear of
immigration agents can prevent them from taking the risk.68 Indeed,
That is very
A raitero or raitera67 is someone who charges 50% of our respondents report that they fear leaving the farm. Of these
immigrants a fee in exchange for a ride. Because workers, the vast majority (75%) report that the fear is so strong that it
this kind of work is under the table and therefore impedes them from venturing out.
difficult for unregulated, raiteros can prey on immigrants
lack of alternatives by charging any amount they You feel isolated when you dont go out, Juan, a 25 year-old worker
from Mexico, explained If I felt safe going out, I could get a raitero to
everybody, not please. According to our data, the fees charged
by raiteros can vary from $10 for a fifteen minute bring me to the city so I can distract myself. But, like I said, I cant. If I go
to the city, people will see that I am Mexican. Gerardo, a 27 year-old
just for me.
car ride to $50 for a thirty minute car ride. Simply
leaving the farmto access basic services, run from Guatemala, feels the same way. At the time of our interview, he was
errands, attend church, or visit with friends and residing with his then-pregnant wife. He felt tremendous pressure and
We need to be familycan cost workers dearly. anxiety about being able to get rides to the clinic for appointments and
in case of an emergency. At the same time, he felt increasingly fearful
able to drive
As David, a 23 year-old worker from Mexico, when leaving the farm. When I was alone, he explained, I was not
explained: I dont have a car because I dont have really afraid. But now that I have my wife and daughter here with me, I
a license. There are people who bring us to the feel it more.
to the clinic, to store, the raiteros. I try to go only when I need

something, only every 8 or 15 days. The raiteros Mary shares this fear. Even though she owns a car and her children are
U.S citizens, she does not feel safe leaving the farm for fear of being
go out and buy
are Americans and they charge me between $40

and $50 every time. detained. And Marys employer reinforces that fear: He (farm owner)
tells us that he knows the county police, so we are safe here, but that we
food Omar, a 30 year-old worker from Mexico, said: I

cant have [a car] because I dont have a license.
shouldnt leave the county because something can happen to us.
I use raiteros to go and buy food. There are two

people who we can call. They charge me about Community Exclusion
$40. There are only six of us here, so we all have to
take turns to go out once a week. More than half (57%) of the workers we interviewed declared that they
Gerardo, 27 year-old from do not feel like they are members of the community in which they live.
Guatemala Of course, some farm owners are quite These workers painted a striking picture of social exclusion and isolation
sympathetic to the workers plight and do what from the broader community, captured in Norbertos claim, They dont
they can to help by offering rides. Gerardo, for know of my existence. Or, as Gerardo put it, Ive lived here for years
instance, said of his boss: He helps me when I and I dont know anybody. One worker insightfully linked this issue of
need it, driving him to the hospital, to buy food, isolation to the groups political disempowerment: If we are far away
or to send money home. Jorge, another worker from society, we are without benefits, licenses, without things that we
from Guatemala, said his boss takes [him] to the could benefit from... we cant have rights like voting... we do not feel
store and to buy medicine. part of the community.
58 59
Juan, a 25 year-old worker from Mexico, has no car, no license, and Perhaps as a result of these feelings of isolation, workers develop
leaves the farm only once every 2 weeks. I would like to be part of kinship and solidarity among themselves. Even though they have
the community where I live, he explained. I would like to be able their conflicts and disagreements, 68% of respondents reported that
to study. Alfredo is another worker in his late twenties from Mexico. workers on their farm support one another, particularly when it comes to
Like Juan, he does not have a car. Even if he could secure a license, he covering work shifts and helping each other on the job. If somebody
realizes that he would scarcely be able to afford a car. He leaves the farm has a commitment, one worker reported, we cover his shifts. Ana
once a week on average, and has not been able to develop relationships said she has trouble lifting heavy machinery, but that I have support
with other members of the community. Its like we are locked up! from my co-workers while I work, for example with the machines that
freeze during the winter and are very heavy for me to move. This
Other workers feelings of isolation stem from perceived discrimination, support can be received from American workers as well: Sometimes
or ostracization, by the broader community. For these workers, its I have a problem with a cow and they (American workers) help me.
less their invisibility and more their hypervisibility (as Latinos or Immigrant farmworker solidarity also goes beyond the workplace: We
foreigners) that they find to be the basis of their social isolation. As support each other lending money, like when a worker died, we all
Fernando, a 26 year-old from Mexico, explained: I would like to be able donated.Another said, When someone gets sick, we help each other.
to meet new people, and not have to hide from them. Or, as David put
it, I dont feel like a member of the town where I live. I feel like people By not leaving the farm as often as they might want to, some workers
look at me funny. I think its because they dont like Latinos. Certain organize musical groups and make use of the farms fields during the
people look at us in a very bad way. summer to organize and attend soccer tournaments as well as church
gatherings. Ramona, a 35 year-old worker from Mexico, said: I used to
Workers were asked if and how often they experienced feelings of be totally depressed every day...but I was able to adapt to the isolation,
isolation and depression. The data shows that an overwhelming majority and I started to pray. Others reported that they throw themselves into
of respondents feel isolated (62%) and/or depressed (80%). their work so as to cope with their feelings of depression and isolation.
As one worker explained, I work seven days a week just so I dont feel
Some workers feel depressed and isolated every day, such as Martin,
this way [depressed].
a 28 year-old worker from Mexico: I get depressed every day, every
day. But I try to not to think about it and to do other stuff. As Luis, a 21
year-old worker from Mexico, explained: I feel depressed every time
that I think about family. That feeling does not leave youI try to remind
myself that it is worth being here. Other workers such as 26 year-old
Manuel and 34 year-old Esteban, stated that the main reason why they
feel isolated is because of language barriers. As Manuel put it: I cant
connect to people around me because I cant communicate with them.
Some workers with family close by had these feelings less often than
others. As Cesar, a 28 year-old from Mexico, explained: We dont really
leave the farmI dont feel very isolated because I have family here, but
I do feel depressed for not being able to see my family back home. I feel
depressed at least once a month, I would like to have papers to go and
see themI try to do whatever I can to forget.
60 61
Respondents also lamented language barriers in their efforts to hold

employers accountable for labor violations. As a worker named Federico
explained, Not knowing English is a big barrier for me to defend
myself from my boss. Ernesto recounted the difficulty he faced trying
to negotiate with his employer. Ive had communication problems with
my employer because I dont know English. I was owed two weeks
pay when I left that farm. It was a full three years later by the time
Ernesto had learned enough English to go back to the farm and tell the
employer to pay me.
Workers also noted their staggered and unrelenting work schedules as

key impediments to organizing. As one worker explained, We almost
never see each other because we have different schedules. Yet another
Conclusions and
matter-of-factly statedreferring to the long hours most farmworkers
workthat theres no time for anything.
Finally, workers pointed to workforce differences and inequalities

as impediments to the collective solidarity necessary for organizing.
Recommendations
A third of our respondents (32%) reported that the workers on their
farm do not support one another and nearly half (45%) reported having
been mistreated by a Latino coworker at some point on a dairy farm.
Various reasons were given for the lack of mutual support. Some
highlighted cultural differences between Mexicans and Guatemalans.
Others noted how envy and inequality in the labor force can undermine
group solidarity. One worker explained that the ones who are paid
well, they dont say anything when it comes to claiming our rights.
Other workers noted that those who have more English skills receive
preferential treatment from employers. The ones that know English, a
Organizing Challenges worker reported, humiliate those who dont know how to speak it. And
the ones who have been here longer feel superior to the rest. These
The challenges of organizing immigrant dairy farmworkers are significant. internal divisions in the labor force can undermine efforts to achieve
These challenges are reflected in the fact that just shy of half of our higher wages or improved conditions of life and work on the farm.
respondents (48%) confided that, despite their numerous job-related
concerns, they have never raised a complaint to the boss.
First and foremost is the fear of employer reprisalintricately linked Organizing Priorities
to the fear of deportationin response to collective efforts to obtain a
Despite these formidable challenges, immigrant dairy farmworkers in
raise or better conditions. Workers cited fear of confronting the boss,
New York are organizing both on and across farms, pushing back against
lack of confidence, feelings of distrust and disillusion, and fear of
workplace violence and harassment, recuperating stolen wages, and
being fired for being the person who tries to organize as reasons why
lobbying for improvements to farm housing and working conditions.
they have not raised complaints. As one worker explained: Regarding
salary, I always say [to coworkers], lets ask for more, but they all say no,
WCCNY and WJCNY have taken on distinct but complementary roles
because were going to get fired. Another worker admitted, whenever
in leading this work. Both provide tools for worker empowerment and
there are problems, I vote with my feet. Its better to just quit. Still
leadership development. WCCNY also crafts organizing campaigns
another said that the workers on his farm have not organized because,
and helps workers develop strategies (legislative or otherwise) to
despite their complaints about pay and working conditions, we dont
solve workplace problems. WJCNY provides the legal support for
want to rock the boat because it could get much, much worse. This
workers efforts to fight injustice. These organizations have helped
palpable fear of job loss and consequent eviction underscores the
workers connect, mobilize, and achieve a number of campaign victories
importance of the lawsuit before the NY State Supreme Court, which,
concerning dairy farm working conditions.
if successful, would have the impact of protecting farmworkers from
employer retaliation (referenced earlier in this report).
62 63
Recommendations
Clearly, the federal government has a significant role to play in putting
policies into place to eliminate once and for all the exclusion of
farmworkers from basic labor protections, to create a path to legalization
for undocumented immigrants, and to bring about better regulation
of the dairy industry. First and foremost would be the passage of a
comprehensive immigration reform bill that includes a feasible path
to citizenship for dairy workers and other immigrants without legal
immigration status currently in the country. Moreover, U.S. Congress
should not re-authorize the small farming operations exception from
the OSHA Appropriations Act.69 Finally, U.S. Congress needs to bring to
an end the racist legacy of farmworkers exclusion from the rights and
protections afforded to most other workers, including the right to organize
and engage in collective bargaining and the right to overtime pay.
But such policy changes at the federal level will be slow to occur, if
at allparticularly under the Trump administration. Therefore, direct
Carrying out this study has been instrumental to WJCNY and WCCNY action must be taken by the State of New York, the dairy industry, and
outreach efforts, as the survey proved a useful tool for making contact consumers to help mitigate the precarious conditions in which immigrant
with new workers when visiting farms, and involving them in organizing dairy farmworkers live and work.
efforts. WCCNY and WJCNY began to facilitate weekly conference
calls with workers to collectively strategize around the issues of wage
theft, workplace violence, and health and safety on dairies. These
workers networks were key in building the leadership and solidarity that RECOMMENDATIONS FOR THE NEW YORK STATE
undergirded several subsequent actions, including the well-publicized GOVERNMENT AND ITS AGENCIES
protest against worker abuse at Marks Farm, and the campaign for the
implementation of the OSHA Local Emphasis Program for the New York The government of New York has played a major role supporting the
dairy industry. development and growth of the dairy industry. Now it is time for the
government to focus on guaranteeing the basic labor and human rights of
While these victories are encouraging, much work remains to be done to the thousands of immigrant workers who propel the growth of this industry.
improve the living and working conditions of dairy farmworkers. Asked to
select the most important issues for improving work and life on dairies, In 2015, Governor Cuomo announced the creation of the first-of-its
the workers surveyed most commonly identified higher wages (including kind multi-agency Exploited Workers Task Force, whose mandate is
the right to overtime pay), improvements to housing, improvements to identify and eliminate worker exploitation throughout New York
to workplace safety, immigration reform, and greater opportunities to State. The Task Forces website declares that everyone deserves the
participate in the community. full protection of the law regardless of immigration status. We will not
tolerate worker exploitation, period.70 This is an exciting and laudable
development and a clear reflection of the states support for immigrant
workers rights. However, ending worker exploitation will require
changing the law, in addition to ensuring workers its full protection.
Towards that end, and with workers stated priorities in mind, we
recommend the following:
The right to fair and decent work and the right to organize
The New York State Legislature should finally pass the Farmworker Fair
Labor Practices Act, to provide New York farmworkers with the basic
labor rights that all other New York workers enjoy, including a day of
rest, overtime pay, disability pay, and the protected right to organize.
64 65
The ability to participate in the community RECOMMENDATIONS FOR DAIRY PROCESSING

New York State should restore equal drivers licenses by passing
COMPANIES AND CONSUMERS
Assembly Bill 4050 and companion legislation in the State Senate. Dairy companies also have a key role to play in mitigating the precarious
This legislation would establish a New York ID exclusively for driving conditions described in this report and consumers must push these
purposes (not for traveling or voting), regardless of immigration companies to coordinate actions along their supply chains that improve
status. labor and human rights protections on dairy farms. Several worker-led
codes of ethics for agricultural production have been implemented
New York State should ensure that English language classes are
successfully on U.S. farms and can be adopted in the New York dairy
available to all farmworkers regardless of their age or the duration
industry.
of time they have been employed on a particular farm, by creating
new programs beyond the existing Migrant Education program,
which has significant eligibility constraints. Creation of a worker-driven and independently monitored social
responsibility program for New York dairy farms
The right to safe and dignified housing Purchasers of dairy products should ensure that their entire dairy supply
chains comply with workers human rights by fulfilling the elements of
The New York Departments of Labor and Health should be
one or more of the Coalition of Immokalee Workers Fair Food Program,
charged with ensuring safe and dignified housing conditions to
Migrant Justices Milk with Dignity Program, and the Food Chain
dairy and other non-seasonal agricultural workers. The assigned
Workers Alliances Good Food Purchasing Program. Purchasers should
agency should safeguard workers living quarters by establishing
do so by making legally binding commitments to source dairy products
basic maintenance codes, conducting annual inspections of all
only from farms that participate in rigorous labor rights monitoring
employer-provided farmworker housing, and holding farm owners
conducted independent of the dairy purchaser or supplier. This third-
accountable for inadequate housing through fines and other
party monitoring should enforce standards for working and housing
penalties. The New York Department of Health sanitary code should
conditions that are set by worker-led organizations, and should include
be updated to ensure non-migrant housing, such as that occupied
a mechanism for the monitoring body to enforce the resolution of
by dairy farmworkers, is also covered by its Sanitary Code Title 10.
complaints raised by workers.
The New York Attorney Generals office should update Formal
Opinion No. 91-F7 (1991) concerning the common law right of
visitor access to migrant farmworker labor camps to extend to dairy
farmworker housing. The Attorney General should work with the
New York State Department of Labor and the various associations of
law enforcement agencies in New York to educate farmers and law
enforcement officers about the updated policy.
The right to a safe and healthy workplace
The New York State Department of Labor should take responsibility

for health and safety oversight for dairies with less than 11
non-family workers, which are excluded from federal OSHA
jurisdiction. This should include creating an inspection protocol and
assuming responsibility to inspect smaller dairy farms for violations
of industry-accepted health and safety standards and practices that
apply to all other farms. These inspections should occur when a
complaint, accident or fatality has been reported, and fines should
be imposed on farms found not to be in compliance with accepted
or prescribed standards.
66 67
WORKERS VOICES: if you could say one That they should support us because we produce this milk.
thing to the public, what would it be? Behind a glass of milk there is a worker who
always works hard.
To support our organizing, and for them to organize as
well, no matter the kind of job people do. We are here to produce good quality milk.
To value the work of us Latinos, particularly because we I would tell people to get to know a worker so they can
do the jobs that Americans dont want to do. know how we fight for our lives with strength and sweat.
I want people to know about our situation, what it I just want them to know about us.
costs us to be here, and how hard is to do our job.
It is because of me that you are drinking milk.
We have to explain to the public that Hispanic workers
are treated very badly. To appreciate the work that we do, that we suffer a lot
of humiliation, that we make a great effort and we are not
This milk comes from the cows, but people need to know paid enough.
that immigrants are the ones who milk the cows.
To be more informed about agricultural production. This is
We came here to work, but not like slaves. hard work and it is mostly Latinos doing it.
People should know that the milk they drink Wherever there are Latinos, there is growth.
takes a lot of work. We help companies and industries get bigger.
People should know who we are, that we are the basis To keep drinking milk!
of agricultural products like milk. People need to know
who works hard and that it is not the farm owners who are To the people in Mexico: el Norte is not what they say it is.
working hard.
Dont discriminate or judge us, because thanks to us you

I would say to the public to value the work that Latinos do so can drink milk.
that they can consume milk. I would tell them all the effort that
is behind it, that the work wears on workers and on the cows.
I want the government to know that we didnt come
here to cause trouble. We came here to work hard. I
We immigrants do the dirty, heavy, and low paid work behind want them to acknowledge that.
the gallons of milk that you and your family consume.
68 69
Endnotes New York State. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University,

Dyson School of Economics and Management.
23 New York Farm Viability Institute. http://nyfvi.
org/default.aspx?PageID=2441
pdf?v=42507
36 United States Department of Agriculture.
12 This shift is precisely what inspired the 24 New York Farm Viability Institute. http://nyfvi. 2015. Dairy Margin Protection Program2015
founding of Milk Not Jails (https://milknotjails. org/default.aspx?PageID=2441 Status. https://www.fsa.usda.gov/Assets/
1 As suggested by other surveys of New York wordpress.com/), a grassroots campaign that USDA-FSA-Public/usdafiles/MPP-Dairy/
dairy farmworkers. See Maloney, Thomas R., 25 Gates and Palacios. 2016.
aims to end upstate New Yorks dependency mpp-dairy_summary_graphics_110415.pdf
Libby Eiholzer, and Brooke Ryan. 2016. Survey on the prison economy and, instead, revitalize 26 For example, Dairy Farmers of America is the
of Hispanic Dairy Workers in New York State 37 Environmental Working Group. 2014.
its agricultural economy. sole supplier of milk to the Chobani yogurt
2016. Charles H. Dyson School of Applied facility in Upstate New York. Alpina Foods Dairy Subsidies. https://farm.ewg.org/
Economics and Management College of Agri- 13 Maloney, Eiholzer and Ryan. 2016.; Schewe, progdetail.php?fips=36000&progcode=-
committed to only purchasing milk from within
culture and Life Sciences, Cornell University; Becky and Bernadette White. 2017. Who 30 miles of their Batavia, NY facility, including dairy&page=states&regionname=NewYork
and, Maloney, Thomas R. and Nelson L. Bills, Works Here? Contingent Labor, Nonfa- from Upstate Niagara Cooperative. See: 38 Environmental Working Group. 2014.
Survey of New York Dairy Farm Employers mily Labor, and Immigrant Labor on Hamilton, Emily and Mary Jo Dudley. 2013. Dairy Subsidies. https://farm.ewg.org/
2011. Charles H. Dyson School of Applied U.S. Dairy Farms. Social Currents. DOI: The Yogurt Boom, Job Creation, and the progdetail.php?fips=36000&progcode=-
Economics and Management College of Agri- 10.1177/2329496516686539. Role of Dairy Farmworkers in the Finger Lakes dairy&page=county&yr=2014regionname=N-
culture and Life Sciences. Cornell University. 14 Flynn Adcock, David Anderson, and Parr Regional Economy. PathStone Corporation, ewYork
2 New York State. 2016. Statement from Rosson. 2015. The economic impacts of Cornell Farmworker Program, and Cornell 39 New York State. 2013. Governor Cuomo
Governor Andrew M. Cuomo Regarding Rights immigration on U.S. dairy farms. A survey Cooperative Extension. Announces New York State is Now Top Yogurt
of Farm Workers. https://www.governor. report conducted by Texas Agrilife Research, 27 United States Department of Agriculture. Producer in The Nation, Delivers on Key
ny.gov/news/statement-governor-andrew-m- Center for North American Studies (CNAS), 2013. Why Are Americans Consuming Less Promises Made at Yogurt Summit to Help Dairy
cuomo-regarding-rights-farm-workers and National Milk Producers Federation Fluid Milk? A Look at Generational Differences Farmers. https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/
(NMPF). Washington, DC: National Milk in Intake Frequency. https://www.ers.usda.gov/ governor-cuomo-announces-new-york-state-
3 New York Farm Bureau. 2016. Press Release. Producers Federation.
http://www.nyfb.org/img/topic_pdfs/file_ webdocs/publications/err149/37651_err149. now-top-yogurt-producer-nation-delivers-key-
ll0m38h7c4.pdf 15 Maloney, Eiholzer and Ryan. 2016. pdf?v=41423 promises
4 Progressive Dairyman. 2015. 2015 U.S. dairy 16 Harrison, Jill Lindsey and Sarah E. Lloyd. 2012. 28 New York State. 2014. Governor Cuomo 40 Smolen, Michael D and Lithochimeia, Inc.
statistics. http://www.progressivepublish.com/ Illegality at Work: Deportability and the Announces New York State Reclaims Its Status 2013. Analysis of the Impact of Proposed
downloads/2016/general/2015_pd_stats_ Productive New Era of Immigration Enforce- as the Third Highest Producer of Milk in the Changes to New York CAFO Rules 6 NYCRR
lowres.pdf ment. Antipode 44(2): 365-385. Nation. https://www.governor.ny.gov/news/ Parts 360 and 750. http://www.riverkeeper.
17 Harrison, Jill Lindsey and Sarah E. Lloyd. 2013. governor-cuomo-announces-new-york-state- org/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/Appen-
5 Note that New York was ranked third nationally reclaims-its-status-third-highest-producer-milk- dix-A-Lithochimeia-Report.pdf
in 2013, production levels are close overall to New Jobs, New Workers, and New Inequal-
ities: Explaining Employers Roles in Occu- nation 41 A New York State Energy Research and Devel-
Idaho.
pational Segregation by Nativity and Race. 29 New York State. 2014. Governor Cuomo High- opment Authority program to install anaerobic
6 New York Farm Viability Institute. 2017. Which Social Problems 60(3): 281-301. lights the 2014 New York State Yogurt Summit. digesters, which convert agricultural waste,
counties in NY have the largest dairy farms? http://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor- including cow manure, into electricity, lowering
http://nyfvi.org/default.aspx?PageID=2441 18 Adcock et al. 2015.
cuomo-highlights-2014-new-york-state-yogurt- energy costs particularly for larger dairies, but
7 Gates, Leslie and Anlly Palacios. 2016. A 19 Adcock et al. 2015. summit at of the time of writing has been closed.
Preliminary Report on New Yorks Dairy 20 Sommerstein, David. 2017. Dairy Farmers 30 This number represents a decrease from 42 As just two examples, the Alpina Foods plant
Industry. Binghamton University. Fear Loss of Labor Under Trump Immigration $500.3 million in exports in 2014 and $474.6 in Batavia received tax incentives worth 25% of
8 United States Department of Agriculture Actions. National Public Radio (January 16). million in 2013. Source: USDA Economic their $15 million investment in a yogurt facility
Economic Research Service. 2014. Milk http://www.npr.org/2017/01/26/511851724/ Research Service: https://www.ers.usda.gov/ near the town of Batavia from New York State.
Production Continues Shifting to Large-Scale dairy-farmers-fear-loss-of-labor-under-trump- data-products/state-export-data.aspx Muller Quaker received $15.3 million in tax
Farm. https://www.ers.usda.gov/amber- immigration-actions ; Pager, Tyler. 2017. credits from the State and another $12 million
31 New York State. 2014. Governor Cuomo High-
waves/2014/december/milk-production-con- Amid Trumps Immigration Crackdown from Genesee County in tax savings for their
theres fear on farms. The Boston Globe lights the 2014 New York State Yogurt Summit.
tinues-shifting-to-large-scale-farms/ http://www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor- own plant in the same area (from sources cited
(March 14). https://www.bostonglobe.com/ in: Hamilton, Emily and Mary Jo Dudley. 2013.
9 According to the USDA NASS, there were news/nation/2017/03/13/immigration-crack- cuomo-highlights-2014-new-york-state-yogurt-
summit The Yogurt Boom, Job Creation, and the
699,404 dairy cattle in New York in 1997; in down-strains-farms-nationwide/Hr9oqoJ1dE- Role of Dairy Farmworkers in the Finger Lakes
2012 this figure was 610,712. Thus the decline NI3ekKw3HHdO/story.html 32 Gates and Palacios. 2016. Regional Economy. PathStone Corporation,
in the number of farms far exceeds the decline
21 United States Department of Agriculture 33 Dairy Foods. 2015. Top 100 Dairy Companies. Cornell Farmworker Program, and Cornell
in the state dairying herd.
National Agricultural Statistics Service. 2012 http://www.dairyfoods.com/2016-dairy-100 Cooperative Extension.) When Kraft-Heinz
10 Annual milk production per cow has risen Census Data. In 2015-2016 Agricultural Statis- threatened to close several dairy products
steadily. Annual Agricultural Statistics Bulletin, 34 Gates and Palacios. 2016. processing facilities throughout the Upstate
tics Annual Bulletin, NY. https://www.nass.
New York 2015-2016. USDA National Agricul- usda.gov/Statistics_by_State/New_York/Publi- 35 United States Department of Agriculture. region, the Governor committed to providing
tural Statistics Service. cations/Annual_Statistical_Bulletin/ 2016. Changing Structure, Financial Risks, $20 million over 5 years to keep the plans
11 Maloney, Thomas and David Grusenmeyer. and Government Policy for the U.S. Dairy open and to modernize the facilities. (https://
22 Manta. 2016. Dairy Farms in the United States.
2005. Survey of Hispanic dairy workers in Industry. https://www.ers.usda.gov/webdocs/ www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-cuomo-
http://www.manta.com/c/mmf3f6z/marks-farm publications/err205/56832_err205_summary. and-senator-schumer-announce-agreement-
70 71
Milked: Immigrant Dairy Farmworkers in New York State
kraft-heinz-save-nearly-1000-risk-jobs) The 51 The minimum wage in New York was increased about farm workers safety. The Times Union 66 Currently only twelve states offer drivers
state government also supported the dairy during the course of our research. For 2014, (June 8). http://www.timesunion.com/local/ licenses to undocumented immigrants: Cali-
processing sector in 2015 by awarding a $2.5 the minimum wage was $8.00/hour; on article/Dairy-dangers-As-production-rises- fornia, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware,
million grant, plus $1.5 million in tax credits, to December 31, 2014 it was increased to $8.75. so-do-5536860.php#photo-6419365 Hawaii, Illinois, Maryland, New Mexico,
Cayuga Marketing LLC for creating local jobs It was then increased again to $9.00/hour Nevada, Utah, Vermont, Washington, and the
60 Migrant Clinicians Network. Immigrant Dairy
and reducing foreign dairy imports. https:// on December 31, 2015, but our interviews District of Columbia. See National Conference
Worker Health and Safety: Lesson 5: Working
www.governor.ny.gov/news/governor-cuo- were completed by that point. In 2017, the of State Legislatures. 2015. States Offering
safely around chemicals, confined spaces, and
mo-announces-181-million-fund-projects-gen- minimum has been raised to $9.70. Drivers Licenses to Immigrants. http://www.
silos. http://www.migrantclinician.org/files/
erating-economic-opportunity-throughout) ncsl.org/research/immigration/states-offer-
52 This figure excludes those who never staff/seguridad-eng-5-v2015-03.pdf
ing-driver-s-licenses-to-immigrants.aspx
43 New York Farm Bureau. 2016. Letter to answered this question and those who 61 Baker, Daniel and David Chappelle. 2012.
Andrew M. Cuomo. http://www.nyfb.org/img/ reported weekly as opposed to hourly earn- 67 The word raitero or raitera is a play on the
Health status and needs of latino dairy farm-
uploads/file/LawsuitLettertoCuomo6-06-16. ings. word ride, as in car ride.
workers in Vermont. Journal of Agromedicine
pdf 53 In an effort to understand this process better, 17(3): 277287. 68 For an account of how the policing of auto-
44 Downen, Robert. 2017. In fight to unionize, two workers who participated in this research mobility leads to increased immobility of
62 This American Life, Episode 556: Same Bed,
NY farm workers eye international human and organizers from the WCCNY requested undocumented immigrants, see Stuesse,
Different Dreams (May 1, 2015). https://
rights laws. Times Union (February 27). a meeting with one of the cooperatives that www.thisamericanlife.org/radio-archives/
Angela and Coleman, Mathew. 2014. Auto-
http://www.timesunion.com/news/article/ buys the milk. The main reason for meeting mobility, Immobility, Altermobility: Surviving
episode/556/transcript
Paid-less-and-working-longer-NY-farm-wor- with DFA was to inform the cooperative about and Resisting the Intensification of Immigrant
kers-eye-10963385.php labor practices at Marks Farm, in particularly 63 Attorney General of New York. F91-7 (Ops. Policing. City & Society 26(1): 51-72.
the recent firing of two workers and farms N.Y. Atty. Gen. 1991). https://casetext.com/
45 Maloney, Eiholzer and Ryan. 2016. 69 OSHA Instruction CPL 02-00-051, Enforcement
practices around bonuses. The workers at case/opn-no-f91-7
Limitations and Appropriations under the
46 U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services. the meeting posed the question of why they 64 American Civil Liberties Union. The Consti- Appropriations Act.
2017. H-2A Temporary Agricultural Workers. sometimes do, and sometimes do not, get tution in the 100-mile Border Zone. https://
https://www.uscis.gov/working-united-states/ bonuses even when the milk is of the same 70 New York State. End Worker Exploitation.
www.aclu.org/other/constitution-100-mile-bor-
temporary-workers/h-2a-temporary-agricultur- high quality. The coop representative said that https://www.ny.gov/programs/end-worker-ex-
der-zone
al-workers the distribution of bonuses was a decision ploitation
made solely by the farm owners. 65 American Civil Liberties Union. The Consti-
47 Congress. Gov. All Bill Information (Except tution in the 100-mile Border Zone. https://
Text) for H.R.281 - Family Farm Relief 54 Personal communication with New York State www.aclu.org/other/constitution-100-mile-bor-
Act of 2017 https://www.congress.gov/ Department of Health representative, Feb 26, 2016. der-zone
bill/115th-congress/house-bill/281/all-info
55 Technically, all farms are supposed to comply
48 Farmworker Justice. 2011. No Way To Treat with OSHA agricultural standards. However,
a Guest: Why the H-2A Agricultural Visa OSHA is only permitted to do health and
Program Fails U.S. and Foreign Workers. safety inspections and to impose sanctions
https://www.farmworkerjustice.org/sites/ on farms with 11 or more non-familial, hired
default/files/documents/7.2.a.6%20fwj.pdf laborers. The only exception to this is for farms
49 Schulte, Hal F. III. 2005. Time is Money: with temporary labor camps. However, given
Parlor efficiency is important but dont sacri- the year-round schedule of milk production,
fice milk quality for the sake of speedy cow virtually no dairy farms have temporary labor
throughput. Cornell University College of camps.
Veterinary Medicine. https://ahdc.vet.cornell. 56 Gray, Maggie. 2016. Death and Dairy in New
edu/sects/QMPS/FarmServices/parloreffi- York State (June 9). http://news.adelphi.edu/
ciency.cfm au_news/dairy-death-in-new-york-state/
50 There are several ongoing efforts aimed at 57 Keller, Julie C., Gray, Margaret, and Harrison,
removing these exclusions. The Farmworkers Jill Lindsey. 2017. Milking Cows, Breaking
Fair Labor Practices Act, or the Farmworkers Bodies: Health Inequality in the Dairy
Bill of Rights, is a bill before the New York Industry. New Labor Forum 26(1): 36-44.
State Legislature that aims to grant farm-
58 Alvarez, Lazaro. 2014. Letter to the Editor:
workers many of the rights from which they
are currently excluded, including collective Dairy farmworkers seek support for farm safety
bargaining rights, the right to overtime inspection in New York. Syracuse Post Stan-
compensation, and the right to a day of rest. dard (February 3). http://www.syracuse.com/
The current lawsuit against New York state- opinion/index.ssf/2014/02/dairy_farmworkers_
-for which WCCNY, WJCNY, and Crispin seek_support_for_farm_safety_inspections_in_
Hernandez are the main plaintiffs--aims to new_york_your_lett.html
ensure farmworkers right to organize without 59 Bernstein, Joanna Zuckerman. 2014. Dairy
retaliation. Dangers: As production rises, so do concerns
72

Milked 053017

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Milked 053017

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Milked 053017

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

MILKED

Immigrant Dairy Farmworkers

by Carly Fox, Rebecca Fuentes, Fabiola Ortiz Valdez,

Suggested citation: Carly Fox, Rebecca Fuentes,

The state of New York is one of the states

condition, there are even cockroaches and bugs.

Crispin Hernandez, member of the Workers

About WJCNY and WCCNY

For more information, see our website: http://www.wjcny.org/

The Workers Center of Central New York (WCCNY)

For more information, see our website: https://workerscny.org/en/home/

Occupational Photojournalist, Earl Dotter (www.earldotter.com),

Methodology Participant Socio-demographics

Thus approximately 80% of the sample works on a large or very large

Producing milk is a fully modern business, unrecognizable

New Yorks dairy production and processing industry generates $14

One-third of workers received no job training of any kind. Of those

Stuck in Place Summary of Recommendations

Consecutive 12-hour work shifts left him exhausted, which exacerbated

Like all workers at the farm, Crispin lived in employer-provided housing

The dairy industry has now become utterly dependant on immigrant

medium or high concern about the possibility of an Immigration and

Governments Role in Shaping New Yorks Dairy

The cultural and historical importance of dairy farming in the U.S.,

At the farm level, economic supports and the easing of environmental

Most immigrant farmworkers begin and stay in milking parlor

This means that dairy farmworkers depend on the generosity of farm

Alvaro, a 25 year-old worker from Mexico, works 85 hours per week.

Workers reported working anywhere from 6 to 15 hours each day,

Of the 88 workers we interviewed, 45% report that they feel rushed

Moreover, workers receive infrequent raises. With the exception of a

Wage theft Demanding Stolen Wages

Francisco, a 30 year-old worker from Mexico, shared his experience with

During the winter, there is no heat and everything in the barns

Sometimes long periods of work are unpaid. In some of the cases,

On Sunday, November 9, 2014, Marco Antonio was working

Originally from Huehuetenango, Guatemala, Marco had come to New

The details of Marcos tragic death serve as an apt metaphor for an

Lazaro:I was lucky I didnt

Sources of danger on dairy farms

Cows and Bulls

By far the most significant source of danger, according to the workers

Workers also face the ever-present danger of getting Farm Conditions

Access to Protective Equipment What are the effects of the rider?

The agricultural business industry, however, lobbied seven congressional representatives to

For immigrant farmworkers, the dairy farm provides the

Farmworker Housing By and large, farmworker housing is in great need of improvement.

status for one immigrant workers are unable to obtain drivers

to the clinic, to store, the raiteros. I try to go only when I need

food Omar, a 30 year-old worker from Mexico, said: I

I use raiteros to go and buy food. There are two

Respondents also lamented language barriers in their efforts to hold

Workers also noted their staggered and unrelenting work schedules as

Finally, workers pointed to workforce differences and inequalities

The ability to participate in the community RECOMMENDATIONS FOR DAIRY PROCESSING

The right to a safe and healthy workplace

The New York State Department of Labor should take responsibility

Dont discriminate or judge us, because thanks to us you

Endnotes New York State. Ithaca, NY: Cornell University,