111 2 PDF
111 2 PDF
111 2 PDF
D. Haywick (2016-17)
Dr. Haywick refers to all living creatures as beasties. There are big beasties (elephants and whales),
small beasties (dogs and cats) and micro beasties (plankton etc).
D. Haywick (2016-17)
Source: Windley, B.F. 1977. The Evolving Continents. John Wiley 385p.
To put it bluntly, the geological world did not take kindly to Wegeners radical idea.
Remember, by this time, scientists expected hard evidence and testing of hypotheses rather than
simple ideas. Moreover, a very famous geologist at the time (Dana) had recently argued very
convincingly that the oceans and continents were firmly rooted in place (e.g., no drifting was
permitted). So if you were a geologist at the time, who would you believe? A well established
geo-God (Dana) or a non-geologist newbee (Wegener). True, there was some evidence for
continental separation (e.g., the fossils), but argued the scientists, maybe the animals just rafted
across the sea on top of a tree. Today, the terrestrial fossil content of rocks on both sides of the
south Atlantic Ocean when taken in conjunction with lots of other data is considered vital
evidence of the earlier existence of super continents; however, 90+ years ago, the fossils alone
could not do it. Continental Drift was delegated to the quasi-science shelf of libraries because it
did not have enough supporting evidence. I collect old geology books and it is interesting how
some researchers ridiculed Wegeners idea. I wonder what they thought when Wegener was
proven almost right.
Are you interested about what geologists of the time believed in? Are you curious about what the
accepted theory of mountain building was in 1912? The check out the link below (its to a GY
112 lecture).
http://www.usouthal.edu/geology/haywick/GY112/112lect6.pdf
Wegeners ideas remained purely speculative for about 40 years. In the interim, the world went to
war twice. Most people remember these World Wars as a time of death, destruction and overall
nastiness. They did do one thing that would prove invaluable to science in general (and geology
in particular): they produced new technology. Wegeners ideas were born again following World
War II.
B) The Plate Tectonic Revolution
Did you see the movie U571? Remember that scene when the submarine is diving beneath the
German destroyer and they almost hit the bottom of the boat? Scary stuff huh? That was fiction.
In World Wars I and II, it was more likely that a sub would run into a submarine mountain than
D. Haywick (2016-17)
another boat. The surface of the ocean may appear to be flat, but the bottom of the ocean is NOT.
The earliest mariners suspected this and WWI/WWII submariners knew this (thank God for
sonar!), but until the end of WWII, no one made any attempt to map out the ocean floors. The
technology was not available yet. Once the war ended, a number of surveys were initiated and the
submarine highs and lows were finally mapped out. Surprise, surprise; instead of a random
distribution, topographic highs and lows were arranged in linear fashion. There were underwater
mountain ranges (called mid oceanic ridges) and deep valleys (called trenches or troughs).
Most mid oceanic ridges were dominated by volcanoes, thermal vents and active lava flows. One
in particular (the Mid Atlantic Ridge) ran right down the middle of the Atlantic
This was pretty neat stuff. A few years later, a new discipline of geology was initiated that would
forever change the way geologists looked at the world. Researchers learned that some ironbearing minerals and rocks preserved the Earths magnetic orientation at the time of their
formation. Igneous rocks formed 100 million years ago (100 Ma) were like compasses. Provided
that you could read the paleomagnetic signature, you could determine the orientation of the
rocks relative to the north-south poles at that time. Well it is pretty easy to read the paleomagnetic
signature of rocks. The interesting thing is that the poles were not consistent over time. In the past
(and presumably this will also occur in the future), the north and south poles reversed themselves
every few 10s of thousands of year (10s of Ka). Successive lava flows recorded these reversals:
D. Haywick (2016-17)
When marine geologists started to sample across the Mid Atlantic and other oceanic ridges, they
made an amazing discovery. The paleomagnetic signatures of the rocks recorded numerous
reversals, but in a striped pattern (see image to right from http://www.calstatela.edu)
The youngest rocks occurred down the
middle of the oceanic ridges (remember the
middle of the oceanic ridges were
characterized by active volcanoes) and the
oldest rocks occurred along the continental
margins. Most importantly, the age pattern
was symmetrical around the ridges. The
explanation for these data is pretty clear.
The volcanically active mid-oceanic ridges
must be areas were new oceanic crust is
being formed and from here, the crust
spreads out laterally. Wegener was kind of
right. The continents are drifting apart, but
it is not just the continents that are moving.
The continents and large parts of the
oceans are moving relative to one another. We now envision the Earths surface as being broken
up into a series of plates (officially tectonic plates) and refer to the motion of continents/oceans
plate tectonics. It wasnt until the middle to late1960s that plate tectonic theory was generally
accepted by the majority of the planets geologists. Plate tectonics, which is as important to
geologists as evolution is to biologists is less than 50 years old. We are still refining it. These are
interesting times to be a geoscientist.
D. Haywick (2016-17)
Once the idea of plate tectonics was widely accepted, geologists sat down and really looked at the
Earth. The evidence of plate tectonics started to jump out at people:
1) Fossil and rock suites that match up on opposite sides of continental shorelines (Wegener was
right!)
2) Localization of mountains, volcanoes, earthquakes and trenches along lines on the Earths
surface (they show the location of plate boundaries)
Well be spending a good
chunk of an upcoming
lecture or two discussing
volcanoes
and
earthquakes. For now,
consider just where most
of them take place. The
map to the right comes
from http://pubs.usgs.gov
and shows the distribution
of earthquakes from 19781987:
There is nothing random about where most of the volcanoes and earthquakes occur; they are on
plate boundaries. If Wegener had this information when he proposed continental drift, it likely
would have be accepted a lot earlier that it was.
D. Haywick (2016-17)
C) The Earth's interior & seismic waves (very detailed notes; more on this topic later in the semester)
If we all lived in a Star Trek universe, exploring the interior of the Earth would be comparatively
easy. All you'd have to do is use scanners or beam a chunk of it up to the Enterprise and let Data
or Spock examine it with a tricorder. Unfortunately, we are a long way from that type of
exploration.
Today, there are really only a few ways that we can explore the interior
of the Earth. I can think of 3 ways:
1) Drill a hole: Geologists have been drilling holes into the Earth since
the late 1800's. This is easy. All you need is a drilling rig, some drilling
pipe and a drill bit. If I have the time (and remember to bring them in),
will see some examples of drill bits in the lecture. They look pretty
impressive (especially the big ones!), but they really are simple devices.
They have rotating tungsten-carbide cutters that grind away the rock as
they turn. A bit is attached to a length of drill pipe and the whole thing
is turned in the rig complex. As the bit descends deeper into the Earth,
pipes are added to the assemblage extending its penetration. Today,
petroleum geologists regularly drill holes that exceed 20,000 feet
D. Haywick (2016-17)
D. Haywick (2016-17)
D. Haywick (2016-17)
D. Haywick (2016-17)
10
D. Haywick (2016-17)
11
Earth was liquid in the first place. There is also a P-wave shadow zone, but it is much less
obvious on the BBC figure.
I am going to leave you hanging at this point with respect to the consequences of seismic wave
and earthquakes. We need to return to plate tectonics. However, later in the course, we will return
to earthquakes when we go into detail about structural geology and faulting. We will also talk
about the damage caused by seismic waves in a lecture I call Death and Destruction 101.
So back to plate tectonics. Seismic waves allowed geologists back in the 1930's to resolve several
layers inside of the Earth. The discoverer of the core (a female seismologist named Inge
Lehmann) observed wave refractions that she deduced had to be coming off a more dense layer
below the surface. We now recognize 4 major layers 2. From top to bottom, these are:
1) inner core,
2) outer core
3) mantle
4) crust
The thickness and properties of each of these layers are summarized in the table and figure below:
Layer
Name
Depth (Thickness)
Composition
State
Crust
0-35 km (5 - 35 km)
Rock
Solid
4
Mantle
35-2900 km (2865 km)
"Rock"
Solid-Ductile
3
Outer Core
2900-5100 km (2200 km) Iron/nickel
Liquid
2
Inner
Core
5100-6370
km
(1270
km)
Iron/nickel
Solid
1
New studies (post 2010) are starting to resolve even more subtle layering within the Earth's core. Some
are suggesting a possible sulfur-rich inner-inner core. Others imply an inner-inner core enriched in other
metals like potassium or even uranium. Both of these metals have radioactive isotopes which might also
explain the continued high temperatures of the inner Earth.
D. Haywick (2016-17)
12
portion of the Earths mantle that flow up toward the crust and then down again as the currents
cool. There is still considerable discussion about how convection actually . Some studies suggest
that convection currents originate at the mantle-core interface. Others suggest a stratified mantle
where convection occurs at different levels. A new study (2002) has questioned the ultimate
source of the heat from the core. It cant be left over heat from the origin of the solar system. The
Earth is over 4.5 billion years old (4.6 Ga) and would have cooled to a solid if there was not an
additional source of heat. We now know what that source is; radioactivity. As mentioned in the
footnote on the previous pages, new research has suggested that the Earth may contain an innerinner core composed of an iron-uranium or potassium alloy rather than iron/nickel as previously
concluded. Alternatively the radioactivity might just be spread throughout the Earth's interior. I
personally dont go for the uranium core idea because we do not find evidence of this in the solar
system (e.g., some iron/nickel meteorites would be highly enriched in uranium were uranium a
common element in planetary cores). But then again, who knows. It will be a long time before we
ever get to directly sample the core of the Earth (or any other planet for that matter).
What ever the ultimate source of the heat, convection currents rise toward the surface of the Earth
and when it gets near the surface, it spreads out:
D. Haywick (2016-17)
13
Source: University of
North Dakota
Most geological action is concentrated along the edges where the plates rub past one another.
These are the so-called plate boundaries and 3 distinct types are recognized:
D. Haywick (2016-17)
14
Source: http://www2.nature.nps.gov)
The actual name for the Australian Plate is the Australian-Indian Plate as both of these continent
bearing sections (as well as the ocean between them) are moving as a single body. At least for now. Your
humble instructor has some ideas about what might happen in the future about this tectonic plate. Why not
ask him in an upcoming class?
D. Haywick (2016-17)
15
comprises the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, is getting wider every year in the same way that New Zealand
is getting thinner. There is good marketing potential for a weight loss product using plate
tectonics is any of you are majoring in advertising.
Alfred Wegener
continental drift
hypothesis versus theory
super continent(s)
trenches and troughs
mid oceanic ridges (incl. Mid Atlantic Ridge, East Pacific Rise)
Paleomagnetism
plates (tectonic)
plate tectonics
Crust, mantle, inner and outer core
geophysics
convection (currents)
lithosphere
asthenosphere
divergent, convergent and transform plate boundaries
subduction
various tectonic plates (e.g., North American, Australia-Indian, Pacific etc.)
Island Arc
Magma
Country rock
Hot Spots