Nothing Special   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

Whither The Great Recessio - Reading The Tea Leaves - 30 Aug 2009

Download as doc, pdf, or txt
Download as doc, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2

Nasser Saidi: Economics & Governance

Nasser Saidi

Whither the Great Recession? Reading the tea leaves


Posted: 30-Aug-2009

With the end of summer drawing close, questions concerning the trajectory of the world economy
in the second half of 2009 will intensify. The second quarter saw a global improvement in
economic conditions, but with striking diversity. Emerging Asia recorded sustained GDP growth
led by China, while North America continued its slump, driven by profound adjustments in the
U.S. (especially the labor market) and a weak auto sector (GM and Chrysler) despite the ‘cash for
clunkers’ intervention. Europe was in the middle, with credit leveraged countries that resemble
the U.S. (U.K., Ireland, Spain, Ukraine, the Baltics) and countries following in the wake of Asia
thanks to recovery in industrial production (Germany, France, Poland, Scandinavia). The third
quarter will evidence a crucial test for the global economy, i.e. whether the stabilization in Q2 will
be followed by a recovery or whether there will be a ‘double dip’ recession. The forward looking
equity markets are heavily betting on a synchronized global recovery; while the bond markets are
comparatively bearish foreseeing a continuation of easy monetary policy –in the form of direct
monetary injections or ‘quantitative easing’- and weak growth, more of a U- or W shaped
outcome. Both markets cannot be right.

Such a dichotomy is likely to persist and generate volatility in financial and commodity markets:
the economic tea leaves portray a mixed picture so bulls and bears can find comfort in their
convictions by attaching more importance to some data and neglecting other news. As
economists, however, we should take higher ground and look beyond the short term. While
‘timing’ the end of the Great Recession is an interesting exercise, understanding the economic
and financial factors shaping adjustment and sustained growth is more important from a GCC
perspective. As commodity exporters increasingly integrated into the world economy, our focus
should be on structural change and longer term forces at work.

The roots of the Great Recession and financial crisis can be traced back to the dotcom bubble.
When the bubble exploded, US policy makers shunned the idea of engineering an orderly
readjustment of the economy with the inevitable fall in standards of living to more sustainable
levels (i.e. levels compatible with long term growth patterns and productivity growth, not those
artificially boosted by the stock market exuberance of the roaring nineties). Instead the authorities
went in the opposite direction substituting the collapsing stimulus from private investment with a
hike in private consumption supported by lower taxes, lower interest rates and higher
indebtedness of households. Household leverage, measured by the ratio of debt to personal
disposable income, increased modestly from 55% in 1960 to 65% by the mid-1980s. Then, over
the next two decades, leverage proceeded to more than double, reaching an all-time high of
133% in 2007, with the sharpest acceleration occurring since 2000. That dramatic rise in debt
was accompanied by a steady decline in the personal saving rate, a process that enabled
personal consumption expenditures to grow faster than disposable income, providing a significant
boost to U.S. economic growth over the period.

Similarly, loose US fiscal policy with increased military & security spending reversed a budget
surplus in 2000 into sustained deficits that are expected to peak at some 11.2% of GDP this year.
In this policy stance the US government was fully supported by the Federal Reserve which
maintained interest rates abnormally low, fuelling debt and leverage across the financial system
and disregarding asset price inflation. In essence in the early years of this century while the
corporate sector was rebuilding its balance sheet to purge the debt overhang of the nineties, the
household sector was led to increase its consumption and its already unsustainable liabilities,
(sustained by home equity loans and mortgage refinancing). Before the US economy can be put
back on a sound footing and sustained growth, the imbalances accrued over the last ten years
need to be tackled and credibly resolved. The dilemma for economic policy is trying to address
two conflicting objectives: reviving economic growth through a stimulus for increased spending
and household (and financial sector) deleveraging which requires increased personal saving and
lower consumption rates!
Nasser Saidi: Economics & Governance
Nasser Saidi

Whither the Great Recession? Reading the tea leaves


Posted: 30-Aug-2009

The process of adjustment and restructuring has barely started. At present a meltdown of the
world economy has been avoided thanks to a massive injection of public money. In other words
private debt in the US (and the UK) has been swapped by public liabilities together with a de facto
nationalization of the banking sector. The process of recapitalizing and restructuring the banking
system is just starting: the stock markets appear to have forgotten that the toxic assets are still in
the balance sheet of the banks and that credit to companies continues to be scarce and is
rationed!

But to restore sustainable growth, the current account deficit of the US and other profligate
countries must be drastically reduced while the economies of heavy exporters such as China and
Germany must shift to a greater focus on domestic sources of growth. This process will not be a
matter of one quarter or even a few quarters as many market participants seem to believe. The
Great Recession is still unfolding, with continuing heavy job losses in the US and more to come in
Europe, where social protection is stronger, this adjustment will face several hurdles and set
backs. Moreover once the world economy stabilizes, the US, UK and other EU countries will face
to face the burden of dealing with the unprecedented peacetime build-up of the stock of public
debt and reforming the financial architecture. For the GCC countries the outlook and
developments in emerging Asia will be more important than those for the advanced economies of
the west.

Copyright © 2010 ABQ Zawya Ltd. All rights reserved.


Company information provided by www.zawya.com

You might also like