A Market Research Report 2001 MasterCard International Incorporated. All rights reserved. The information contained herein is proprietary and confidential to MasterCard International and its members and may not be used for any other purpose. This material may not be copied, distributed, published, or disclosed, in whole or in part, in any medium, without the prior written permission of MasterCard International. Research Highlights Shopping cart abandonment continues to be a widespread problem for online retailers. One major reason is the length and difficulty of merchant checkout form completion. Close to 20 percent of online shoppers have already installed an e-wallet, primarily to fill out online forms. 94 percent of users surveyed had positive e-wallet experiences and most intend to continue using their e-wallet. Financial institutions or credit card companies are most preferred as e-wallet providers. Online shoppers using issuer-supplied e-wallets report increased online spending and greater loyalty to the cards. Users are interested in having a variety of features in their e-wallet, including financial functions. page 2 page 3 page 4 page 5 page 6 pages 7-8 Estimated Quarterly U.S. Retail E-Commerce Sales (Billions of Dollars, U.S.) (Data not adjusted for seasonal, holiday, or trading day differences and does not include travel, financial goods, or tickets) Source: U.S. Department of Commerce Q4 1999 Q1 2000 Q2 2000 Q3 2000 Q4 2000 $5.198 $5.240 $6.393 $8.686 $5.526 10 8 6 4 2 0 1. Retail E-Commerce Sales in Fourth Quarter Were $8.7 Billion, Up 67.1 Percent from Fourth Quarter 1999, Census Bureau Reports, U.S. Department of Commerce News, February 16, 2001. 2. The Payments Agents: The Next Generation of E-Wallets, IDC, December 2000. 3. E-Commerce Payment and Shopping Tools: U.S. Tracking Study, Wave 2, MasterCard International, March 2001. 1 Research Methodology This research took place fourth quarter 2000 and consisted of 450 random online "interviews" with U.S. residents who are members of Greenfield Onlines proprietary panel. All respondents had an electronic wallet installed or activated in the previous six months; made an online purchase during that same time period; and owned a multi-purpose credit, charge, and/or debit card. Some of the findings included in this publication were taken from other MasterCard proprietary studies and are noted as such. Executive Summary In recent years, Internet commerce has grown steadily, with e-retail sales accounting for an increasing percentage of total retail sales. Yet, there is still huge potential for additional growth. U.S. retail e-commerce sales for fourth quarter 2000 reached $8.69 billion (an increase of nearly 36 percent over the previous quarter). 1 By 2004, U.S. consumer spending online will reach $163.2 billion. 2 A variety of tools has been developed to enhance the online shopping consumer experience with the ultimate goal of increasing online purchasing. One tool is the digital wallet, or "e-wallet." The earliest e-wallets sought to streamline the shopping experience by helping consumers fill out online forms. Over the relatively short period that e-wallets have been available to consumers, their capabilities have evolved to offer more functionality. Today, close to 20 percent of online shoppers have already installed an e-wallet. 3 How do online shoppers feel about e-wallets? How do e-wallets impact online spending behavior? To answer these and other fundamental questions, MasterCard
launched the Electronic Wallet Usage
Study in late 2000 to achieve the following: Assess the e-wallet usage experience Gain insight into e-wallet users attitudes toward different e-wallet providers Understand the functions that make e-wallets desirable Shopping Cart Abandonment Time-consuming checkout procedures add to shopping cart abandonment. Various studies have reported that a majority of online shoppers load their shopping carts only to abandon them before checking out. Previous MasterCard research has shown that 80 percent of online shoppers had abandoned shopping carts at least once in the previous three months. 4 One year later, online shoppers still experience the same problems with the checkout process. Shopping cart abandonment continues to be a problem for online retailers, with fewer than two percent of visits to these sites resulting in purchases. 5 Major Reasons for Shopping Cart Abandonment 55% 45% 44% 40% 21% 20% 14 % Higher than expected shipping charges Just window shopping/comparing prices Website was not working properly Took too long/required too many fields Website requested too much personal information Was unable to use a coupon or discount code on site Website was not secure for online shopping 4. U.S. Consumer Internet Use and E-Shopping Report, MasterCard International, February 2000. 5. Clinching The Holiday E-Sale, Rewick, Jennifer, The Wall Street Journal, October 9, 2000. 2 3 Awareness and Use of E-Wallets The first step toward stronger e-wallet usage is increasing consumer awareness and understanding of the technology. The next step is to ensure a positive consumer experience to encourage continued use of e-wallets after initial activation. Ninety-four percent of users surveyed had positive e-wallet experiences, and most of those intend to continue use in the future. As a result of growing awareness and positive consumer experiences with e-wallets, the overall utilization rate has risen from 14 percent to 17 percent in the six months from Spring 2000 to Fall 2000. 6 Awareness of E-Wallets Spring 2000 Fall 2000 43% 50% 45% 52% 24% 32% Total Online Buyers Online Non-Buyers 60% 50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% Source: "E-Commerce Payment and Shopping Tools: U.S. Tracking Study, Wave 2," MasterCard International, March 2001 Use of E-Wallet vs. Merchant Accounts (Percent Ever Used) Spring 2000 Fall 2000 Source: "E-Commerce Payment and Shopping Tools: U.S. Tracking Study, Wave 2," MasterCard International, March 2001 14% 17% 23% 26% E-Wallets Merchant Account 30% 25% 20% 15% 10% 0% 5% 6. E-Commerce Payment and Shopping Tools: U.S. Tracking Study, Wave 2, MasterCard International, March 2001. Online shoppers are happy with their e-wallet experiences and intend to continue use. The vast majority of e-wallet users indicate that this tool has enhanced online shopping. Nearly nine-in-ten are somewhat likely to use an e-wallet in the near future, with six-in-ten having a high likelihood of doing so. Satisfaction with E-Wallets and Intended Future Use Positive Experiences with Use of E-Wallets Positive Experiences Using E-Wallets (net) 94% Base: Experienced Electronic Wallet Users (n = 415) 81% 69% 60% 58% 53% 42% 31% 26% Saved time filling out forms Successfully filled out forms E-Wallet helped fill out forms more accurately Password retrieval function worked when needed Felt credit card information was securely stored by e-wallet through e-wallet Used coupon or discount offer
Was able to store multiple credit card numbers and shipping addresses E-Wallet automatically popped up when blank forms appeared 4 Likelihood of Using an E-Wallet in the Next Three Months Extremely/Very/Somewhat Likely 84% Extremely/Very Likely 62% Extremely Likely 39% Very Likely 23% Somewhat Likely 22% Not Very Likely 11% Not At All Likely 5% Base: Experienced Electronic Wallet Users (n = 415) 5 Preferences for Type of E-Wallet Providers Users prefer to have financial institutions provide their e-wallets. Most wallet users want a traditional credit card company or financial institution to provide their e-wallet because of the perceived security and access to financial and banking functions. Moreover, about 50 percent of consumers who use the two most popular Internet e-wallets would prefer a wallet hosted by a credit card company. Type of Company Preferred to Host/Support an E-Wallet Traditional Credit Card Company/Financial Institution Internet Service Provider (ISP) 36% 11% 53% This represents a substantial card issuer opportunity Internet Company Base: Experienced Electronic Wallet Users (n = 415) Characteristics Associated with Different Types of E-Wallet Providers Base: Experienced Electronic Wallet Users (n = 415) 67% 24% 9% Security 61% 28% 11% Provides access to other financial banking functions 60% 28% 13% Privacy 53% 36% 11% Extent to which is accepted by various merchants 41% 46% 13% Variety of features or services 37% 51% 13% Works like it is supposed to work 26% 58% 16% Provides access to shopping offers/discounts Traditional Credit Card Company or Financial Institution Internet Company Internet Service Provider 6 Enhanced Loyalty Successful experiences with e-wallets strengthen the issuer/cardholder relationship and are likely to result in increased online spending and card usage. One-in-four consumers now using e-wallets provided by their credit card issuers indicate that their online spending and associated card usage has increased as a result of having an issuers e-wallet. And, a substantial number of those who have not yet been offered an e-wallet anticipate adding to their online spending with that issuers card, if an e-wallet were offered to them. Most e-wallet users can accurately identify specific brands of e-wallets, indicating that they are cognizant of the existing offerings and can differentiate among them. With e-wallet users indicating positive experiences, issuer-provided e-wallets promise to strengthen and grow the relationship with this segment. Spending Changes with Use of Card Issuer's E-Wallet This data is directional given small base size. Percent that said online spending with the card associated with the issuer's e-wallet has increased Percent that said online dollar volume of spending has increased overall 23% 23% Anticipated Spending Increases 28% Base: Not Yet Offered Card Issuer E-Wallet (n=343) Percent that anticipate increased online spending on the card account associated with the issuer's e-wallet 7 Features Desired in E-Wallets Strong interest exists among current e-wallet users for additional functionality. While "basic" wallet functions, like form-filling and password storage, are still the foundation of e-wallets, a substantial number of users show interest in having e-wallets perform additional functions. Such functions might include generating a temporary account number linked to their credit card account for online purchases ("pseudo-account numbers"); providing shopping offers, discounts, and coupons; and acting as a repository for their online purchasing history. Percent Rating Extremely/Very Important Fills out online merchant forms automatically 79% Inputs merchant account password instantly at merchant site 64% Stores merchant account passwords for merchant sites 64% Stores passwords for sites other than just merchant sites 63% Stores payment information for a credit card 58% Stores information for multiple credit cards 50% Stores multiple shipping addresses 45% Generates a temporary account number linked to your credit card account for online purchases 43% Provides shopping offers, discounts, and coupons 42% Provides a centralized history of online purchases 42% Provides a comparison shopping tool 35% Provides a merchant directory for online stores on the e-wallets website 29% Offers a person-to-person online payment service 29% Provides easy access to major search engines, the stock market, and shopping sites all in one place 25% Gives access to other online banking functions 22% Is automatically activated when a smart card is inserted into a card reader 20% Provides a special e-mail address for merchant mail 19% Base: Experienced Electronic Wallet Users (n = 415) 8 Financial Functions Desired in E-Wallets Online banking and other financial activities are logical extensions of existing e-wallet functions. Users already have experience with online banking and other financial activities, which an e-wallet can help simplify. Furthermore, existing e-wallet users report an interest in using their e-wallets for these activities. Online Financial Activities with Which E-Wallet Users Have Experience Base: Experienced Electronic Wallet Users (n = 415) 89% 55% 48% 35% 23% Purchased merchandise or services online Applied for a credit card or charge card Paid bills Participated in an online auction Transferred balances Likelihood of Using E-Wallet to Perform Financial Functions in the Future Base: Experienced Electronic Wallet Users (n = 415) 58% 54% 35% 34% 29% Check credit or charge card statements Check bank balances Pay bills Transfer funds from one account to another Send money to another person Summary Awareness of e-wallets has grown over the last 12 months among both online buyers and non-buyers. The vast majority of current e-wallet users have been pleased with their e-wallets ability to save them time and simplify the online shopping experience by automatically remembering passwords, billing information, and shipping addresses. In addition, a sizeable proportion of current e-wallet users report increased online spending and a greater tendency to use the card associated with their issuers e-wallet. Positive experiences with e-wallets, coupled with the fact that a majority of current e-wallet users prefer a wallet issued by a traditional credit card company or financial institution, represent a substantial opportunity for MasterCard card issuers. Our research indicates that cardholders would use their "trusted" e-wallet not only to shop online more often, but also to engage in other financial activities. This would serve not only to enhance the cardholder-issuer relationship, but also to reinforce the issuers brand as well. Clearly, users understand that e-wallets are multi-dimensional and can act as platforms for related financial functions. In addition, strong interest was shown in offering some of the newer financial applications via an e-wallet including access to online banking applications and person-to-person payments. Interest was also demonstrated in substitute account numbers and smart card activation. Working with our member financial institutions, MasterCard is uniquely positioned to capitalize on emerging technologies by offering cardholders ubiquitous access to their payment accounts. Utilizing new technologies, such as electronic wallets, smart cards, and wireless devices, MasterCard members will be able to deliver payment services at a point-of-interaction that is closest and most convenient to their customers. MasterCards strategic alliances in the e-wallet arena will provide members with greater choices when developing their e-wallet strategy, not only for online activities but also for mobile commerce, set-top boxes, and other emerging transaction channels. A wide variety of solutions is available, and each provides a unique set of issuer and consumer benefits. To learn more about MasterCards e-wallet strategy and programs, contact your Member Relations Representative today. EC501-RES MasterCard International Incorporated 2001
Tariq H Ismail Et Al., Review of Literature Linking Corporate Performance To Mergers and Acquisitions, Review of Financial and Accounting Studies Journal, Issue 1, 2011.