RB31 6 Cuba
RB31 6 Cuba
RB31 6 Cuba
REFERENCE BOOK
,."',
j
P'l7 /
,/
)
SELECTED READINGS ON
INSURGENT WAR:
CUBA 1953-59
Col. (Ret.) TeflY E. Rowe
4800 Warren WBty
Reno, NV89509
(VIetnam, 1964-72)
This publication contains copyright
material and under no circumstances
will be sold nor commercially used.
,--....
I ---------------------------
Ill. Stl..,.dSta'"';'''F.IA''''.B.h... . .
II'. 'If".od,bo I'....., Pop.I,,''''Cbo C.., _............- ...
V. 'If5.".1 R.v.''',,,,N.......,.i.C.bo? Ri....
J. 26 JUL'{ 1953_THE ..- ................... .-,
5o.,i.. l. 01.II r""q..Mo ....,.
.-,
11. M odo-Qoi i,G..,.....I'.ldo F l
.-.
Ill. C..' 10 p.I od !It<1'< t:.l \10 .
CH?TER ll'Sl'HCL'LS STHL'I"GTH_..... .-,
So.,i.. I. 1957-0.., "oorofo\. dSt"ul.Cloc C Fod.1 C o
.-,
n. no80,,1.01 EI \;, C, _.
.
Ill. 0\. ;..,1 .,..F.I"".".B.,' __ .....
II'. T ..l .. B.."."o.C...C..._ - -.
\' Tloc U.....IVow:l. R""rtTo!><._...
C"o\.l'lUI 5. 195a-PRU.UDETO SUCCESS 1.'1" 1959
S..,i.. I. C O'd....T...II...R""""Toloo,-
II. P' 8.00I0.od h.11"".F.IA'"'" 8.0"......_ _
1Il. 11_Coo 1'00. Did.yClo.",,11. _
IV. TO. 1.._8 t:.pood I...Lo.1",lI..p""'i Ilo'i
\, U..,i L.no.C F'!r''''&''-''.._ .
CIV.I"Tt:H 6. I:PlLDGIJE-CUllo\.. rn; u.,.,,_..01 Stat< (lll6il ...................
JoLIpOFCUflo\.--.-.
INTRODUCTION
"In our country the individual knows that the glorious period in
which it has befallen him to live is one of sacrifice; he has learned
its meaning.
"The men in the Sierra Maestra-and wherever else there was
fighting-learned it first; later, all Cuba came to know it. Cuba,
the vanguard of America, must make sacrifices, because it points
the way to full freedom for the Latin American peoples.
ce the true revolutionary is moved by strong feelings of love.
c' It is impossible to conceive of an authentic revolutionary who lacks
this quality. Herein lie what are perhaps the great dramatic chal-
lenges to a leader: he must combine an impassioned spirit with cool-
ness of mind; and he must make painful decisions unfalteringly.
"The love our vanguard revolutionaries bear for the people and
for the most hallowed causes must be the same indivisible, spiritu-
alized love. Not for them the routine expressions of finite love as
expressed by ordinary men.
"Revolutionary leaders are not often present to hear their chil-
dren's first hesitant words; their wives must also share in their
sacrifice if the revolution is to reach its goal; their friends are to be
found only among their comrades in revolution. For them there is
no life outside the revolution. If they are to sidestep dogmatic ex-
tremes, sterile scholasticism, and isolation from the people, they
must possess a full measure of humanity and a sense of justice and
truth. Theirs is a daily struggle to transform their love of living
humanity into concrtite deeds, into acts that will serve as a mobiliz-
ing force and an example:'
-CHE GUEVARA
Socialism and Man in Cuba
Copyright C 1968 by Monthly Review Press; reprinted by permission of Monthly Review Press at
USACGSC and may not be further reproduced in whole or in part without express permission of the copyright
owner.
ii
I.
II.
III.
IV.
Section
CHAPTER 1
SELECTED SUMMARIES
The Sergeant and the Lawyer, Enrique Meneses - - - - -
Steps Toward Democracy, Fulgencio Batista - - -
The St"uggle Against Batista, Nicholas Rivero - -
Slavery and Its Apologists, Fulgencio Batista - - - -
V. Victory, Enrique Meneses- - - - - - - - - - - -
1-2
1-14
1-26
1-45
1-57
Ii,
t The purpose of this chapter is to provide a general overview of the Cuban Insur-
~ g e n c y A closer inspection of many specific events and major contributing forces
!i, alluded to in this chapter, will occur in succeeding chapters.
" Each of the five sections provides the student of the Cuban Insurgency with a
l:alllghtly different viewpoint or opinion on the events and personalities that shaped the
ventual outcome of the Cuban Insurgency.
1-1
Section I. THE SERGEANT AND THE LAWYER
* * * * * * *
The two men facing up to each other in the Cuban ring were
completely different, both physically and mentally. Batista was
fifty-two and Castro twenty-seven when the attack on the Mon-
cada took place. [1] The President was short, with an olive com-
plexion and mestizo features, while his opponent was tall,
athletic, and fair-skinned. Batista was an ordinary soldier,
though he had promoted himself from sergeant to general.
Castro was a lawyer, more interested in social causes than in
bourgeois litigation. The President had been born in Oriente,
like Castro, but while Batista came from a very humble home,
the rebel had been born into a comfortably-off landowning
family.
But just who were these two men who were to bathe Cuba in
blood and turn her into one of the nerve-centres of the world?
Let us look first at Fulgencio Batista.
On the 12th August 1933 the dictator Gerardo Machado had
been overthrown. For the three weeks following his fall, chaos
and anarchy reigned in the country. Revenge, looting and crime
were rampant throughout the island. The Army, which had
hitherto kept out of politics, became more and more involved.
The breakdown of order and discipline was sorely felt, even by
many of those who had contributed to the downfall of the
corrupt Machado regime. The first to want a return to normality
were the country's conservative elements.
[l See chap 3. J
Reprinted {rom pages 29-49 Fide l Cas tro, by Enrique Meneses. @ 1966 by Enrique Meneses. Published
in the U.S. 1968 by Taplinger Publishing Co., Inc. Reproduced at USACGSC by special permission and may
not be further reproduced in whole or in part without express permission of the copyright owner.
1-2
Fulgencio Batista y Zaldivar was an Army stenographer, and
in the course of his job he learned everything that was being
said and done in the armed forces.
On the 4th September 1933, taking advantage of the chaotic
situation in Cuba, and with the help of some comrades-in-arms
of the same rank, he seized power and dubbed himself colonel
and Chief of the Armed Forces. This military coup passed into
history as 'the sergeants' revolt'.
Batista, to make sure of his power, persecuted political
enemies, opposition newspaper editors, and in fact all the
counter-revolutionaries of the time. However, this persecution
was mild in comparison with what was to happen twenty years
later.
President Batista, despite his authoritarian Government, tried
hard to win the sympathies of the country. A mestizo of work-
ing-class background, he wanted above all to go down in the
history of his country as a man beloved by the people. Although
he had taken power by force, many considered he had brought
back peace and order to the country, and for this alone they were
prepared to tolerate him.
The years passed, and, still seeking popularity, Batista
decided to hold elections. Being unsure of winning sufficient
electoral support, in 1938 he legalized the Comm.unist Party,
which could swing a number of valuable votes to him. Two years
later he was duly elected, and he repaid his debt to the ~
munists by naming two of their members as Ministers without
Portfolio. He also presented the Party with a radio station and
a newpaper.
Under pressure from North America (and confident ofhaving
gained the Army's support) in 1944 Batista again called elections
and this time-a rare event in Cuban history-they were honest
elections. They were won by a medical man, Dr. Ram6n Grau
San Martin, leader of the Opposition. Batista left the country
and the new President controlled the destiny of Cuba until
1948.
Grau San Martin belonged to the Autentico Party or PRC
(Partido Revolucionario Cubano), of which Carlos Prio
1-3
, .
Socarras was also a member. In the Presidential election of
1948 Pdo, up till then one of Grau San Martin's Ministers, was
returned to office. His first measure was to get rid of Lazaro
Pena, Secretary-General of tIie Cuban Workers' Confederation
(CTC) and a well-known Communist. The second was to
authorize the return of Batista, who had oeen living at Daytona
Beach, Florida.
In 1952 new Presidential elections were due, and the date was
fixed for the 1st June.. There were three major candidates:
Carlos Hevia (of the PRC), Batista and Roberto Agramonte.
The last was the head of the recently formed People's Party or
Partido Ortodoxo. This party's aim was to fight against govern-
mental corruption.
It should be pointed out that every sort of corruption had
been sanctioned not only by Batista and Machado but also by
Pdo Socarras. Astronomical sums were salted away by these
three Presidents in North American and European banks. Half
the city of Daytona Beach belonged to Batista. In these circum-
stances, a party which came out against such abuses, against the
immorality of gaming tables which attracted the world's most
notorious gamblers, and against the private lotteries which were
farmed out among the friends and relations of the government
in power, was bound to have the whole country's sympathy.
Every Sunday evening over CQM-TV Eduardo ChiMs de-
nounced the corruption of the rulers and spoke of a just and
honest future for Cuba. One Sunday, worn out by his efforts,
according to some, or because he had made false accusations
without proof, as alleged by others, Eduardo ChiMs took his
own life in the television studio.
The death of ChiMs and its dramatic circumstances increased
the electoral chances of the Ortodoxo Party and its Presidential
candidate, Roberto Agramonte. Another result was that a
young lawyer who had recently graduated from the University
of Havana became a member of the party: Fidel Castro Ruz.
Immediately on joining the Ortodoxos, he offered himself as a
candidate for Congress.
Three months before the elections, the public opinion polls
1-4
gave Agramonte as favourite, followed by Hevia, with Batista
in third place. But these elections were never to be held.
On the 10th March 1952, at 2040 in the morning, Fulgencio
Batista entered Camp Columbia, the principal garrison in the
country, situated a few miles from Havana. In les.s than twelve
hours Batista had deposed Prio Socarras and, without a shot
being fired, made himself once again master of the country.
But let us go back and look at Fidel Castro's life before
Batista's coup d'etat put an end to his electoral aspirations.
Like Batista, Fidel Castro was born in Oriente, on the 13th
August 1926, on his father's farm in Binin, in the District of
Mayari, on the north coast of Oriente Province.
His father, Angel Castro y Argiz, was a Galician. He had come
to Cuba as a soldier in the Spanish Army in 1898, during the
War of Independence. On demobilization he decided to stay in
the island and went to work for the Nipe Bay Company, a
subsidiary of the United Fruit Company of Boston. In 1904 he
became an overseer for United Fruit and in 1920 he sold them a
strategic piece of land, for which he was paid a considerable
sum. From that moment on his fortune gradually increased, and
when he died, on the 21st October 1956, he left his family
more than $500,000. Many of Fidel's enemies maintain that
the foundations of his father's fortune were laid on his iII-
treatment of the countryfolk of the Binin area.
By his first marriage, to a schoolmistress, Angel Castro had
two children: Lidia and Pedro Emilio. Later, by Lina Ruz
Gonzalez, the family cook and a Galician like himself, he had
five more: Angela, Ram6n, Fidel, Raul and Juana. Fidel's
detractors claim that his father only married the cook on the
death of his legal wife, when Fidel was twelve years old.
Fidel and RaUl were sent to Santiago de Cuba to study under
the Jesuits at the Colegio Lasalle, and then to the Colegio
Dolores, also Jesuit. Whep I spoke to Fidel about this period
of his life, he told me that he had been expelled from college to-
gether with Raul for having organized a strike in the dining hall,
claiming that the Jesuits were exercising social discrimination in
distributing the food. Some people allege that such strikes were
1-5
" "
nio I&k... ill I!Io Soomo MMco __ ~ ......
Baliua _tloo.
a by-product of the influence exercised over Fidelby his private
Maths tutor, a certain Captain Safazar, known as 'The Crippfe',
a veteran of the International Brigade in the Spanish Civil War.
In our conversations together, Fidel mentioned only the short-
age of food he was getting compared with his schoolfellows as
the reason for the strike.
In 1942, Fidel was sent to Havana, where he carried on with
his secondary education at the Jesuit College of Belen (Bethle-
hem). In the College's Book of Honour for June 1945, there
appears this report from his teachers: 'He has good qualities,
and is something of an actor'.
As well as being a satisfactory student, Fidel was an excellent
swimmer, a magnificent runner, and a good basketball player,
though some of his schoolmates of that period remember him
as 'very dirty and untidy in his appearance'.
In the autumn of 1945, after spending the summer holidays
in Birl:ln with his family, he returned to Havana and enrolled in
the Facufty of Law.
The University of Havana, like almost all Latin American
Universities at the time, was a hotbed of dissent. Politics
dominated the fife of the 'Alma Mater' and the students' asso-
ciations were simply cells of the various pofitical parties. Castro
entered into the activities of these circles with all his characteris-
tic impetuosity.
He had been only two years at the University when he became
involved in his first rebellious escapade. In 1947 he joined a
group which was preparing to launch an invasion of the
Dominican Repubfic from Cayo Confites with the aim of over-
throwing General Trujillo. The exiled Dominican General Juan
Rodriguez was paying the expenses. Ram6n Grau San Martin
was President of Cuba at the time and he turned a bfind eye
while the scarcely discreet preparations for the landing were
being made in Oriente.
While this was going on the Ministers of Foreign Affairs of
the Pan-American Union were holding a meeting at Petr6-
pofis in Brazil. The Dominican delegate accused Cuba of
mounting an expedition against his country. His documentation
1-8
was so precise that Grau San Martin felt obliged to give orders
to his armed forces to stop the invasion. The Cuban Navy
intercepted tb.e would-be expeditionaries, and Fidel Castro had
to swim for it, with his tommy-gun slung round his neck, to
avoid falling into the hands of the Cuban Naval Police. This
failure, like many more he was to have in the future, drove
Castro to an even more earnest dedication to politics.
Itis interesting to note that at Havana University Fidel
sought the support of the Communists to get himself elected
Vice-President of the Law Students' Association, but as soon as
he had achieved his object he began to attack them violently, so
that he was obliged to go round armed and then to go into
hiding until things had calmed down. This behaviour caused
the President of the Association to tender his resignation, a
step which suited Fidel Castro, who automatically took his
place.
Less than a year after the abortive attempt to overthrow
Trujillo, Castro, accompanied by his friend Rafael del Pino and
other Cuban students, arrived in Bogota, Columbia. On the 9th
April 1948 the Colombian capital was due to play host to the
Ninth Conference of the Pan-American Union, at which
General George C. Marshall, then Secretary of State, was a
member of the U.S. delegation. At the same time as the Con-
ference, and with the object of upsetting it, an Anti-Colonialist
and Anti-Imperialist Student Congress had also been organized
in Bogota. Fidel Castro and his companions were the Cuban
delegates to this Congress, and its principal organizers.
Among the points which Castro had set out in his agenda
there were three main ones: independence for Puerto Rico;
overthrow of the Trujillo dictatorship in the Dominican Repub-
lic; and Panamanian control of the Panama Canal. Colombia
itself was not mentioned in these written proposals. On the 3rd
April, Fidel Castro and his group were expelled from the
Teatro Colon in Bogota for distributing anti-North American
leaflets. In addition to some members of the Colombian Liberal
Opposition Party, the Colombian Communist Party and the
students taking part in the Anti-Imperialist Congress tried to
1-9
secure a boycott of the Pan-American Conference by every
means possible.
The Colombian Government, at the time the Ninth Con-
ference was held, was Conservative. The majority ofthe Liberals,
although in opposition, denounced the Communist efforts
to wreck the conference. One of those who joined in this
denunciation was the populist Liberal leader Jorge Eliecer
Gaitan.
On the 9th April, Gaitan accepted an invitation from the
students of the Anti-Imperialist Congress to take part in a dis-
cussion due to be held at the editorial offices of the Liberal news-
paper El Tiempo. Before that, he went to the Capitol, where the
twenty-one Foreign Ministers were meeting, to listen to some of
the speeches.
He left the Capitol in the company of the editor of El Tiempo,
Roberto Garcia Peiia. The distance he had to cover to reach the
newspaper office was too short to warrant taking a cab. On the
way Gaitan greeted a number of passing acquaintances and
chatted briefly with some of them about the day's events. A
few steps short of the newspaper office, in the Carrera Septima
at the corner of Avenida Jimenez Quesada, a man threw himself
at Gaitan and fired at him point-blank. The crowd which saw
the attack threw themselves on the murderer and beat him to
death on the spot. Gaitan himself, gravely wounded, died in
hospital a short time later.
The news of the murder spread like wildfire through the city,
where the Liberals had a great deal of support, and where
Gaitan in particular enjoyed considerable popularity. The
Liberal students started to march on the Capitol. Among them
was Fidel Castro, accompanied by Del Pino.
One wing of the Capitol housed a police station. The officer
in charge was a Liberal, and as soon as he heard from the
students that Gaitan was dead he began to hand out arms to
them. The demonstrators, thus equipped, turned back to the
main building of the Capitol and succeeded in forcing an en-
trance, wrecking several rooms before they could be ejected by
the troops stationed there to protect the building. The students
1-10
then swept through the city like a tidal wave smashing up every-
thing they could lay their hands on. Shops were looted and then
wrecked.
In the mea1J.time the Communists had quickly organized, and
were driving round the city with loudspeakers announcing the
beginning of 'the Leftist Revolution in the Americas'. An hour
later the Communists of the port of Barranquilla occupied the
Governor's Palace and hoisted the hammer and sickle.
At Liberal headquarters Fidel Castro failed in his attempt to
take over the angry student movement. Four hundred armed
police were keeping an eye on the students, but having no in-
structions their role was completely passive. The Communists
were on one side, the Liberals on the other, and, confronting
them both, the Army.
By now numbers of buildings were on fire in all parts of the
city. President Ospina lost no time in summoning the Liberal
Party leaders and reaching a rapid agreement with them, since
it was obviously ridiculous to blame the Conservatives, the
party in power, for the assassination of a Liberal leader on the
very day of the arrival in the country of the twenty-one American
Foreign Ministers. In announcing the conclusion of the agree-
ment over the radio, President Ospina accused the students of
having instigated all the disturbances of the day before. Fidel
Castro and Rafael del Pino had to seek refuge in the Cuban
Embassy, from which they were smuggled out and flown to
Havana on an aircraft transporting cattle.
It is hard to say exactly what part was played by Castro and
his compatriots in what has gone down to history as 'the
Bogotazo'. What is certain is that Gaitan himself had warned
his own countrymen that the Communist Party planned to
create disturbances during the Ninth Pan-American Conference
and that he was assassinated by someone who was killed before
he could say at whose behest he had committed the crime. The
role of Castro and the Cuban students in the affair remains
obscure, to the point that some people now claim that Castro
himself was behind the murder, in the hope of causing such
popular indignation that the people would take to the streets.
1-11
But whatever the plans for insurrection may have been, they
were thwarted by the agreement. .
Six months after the Bogotazo, on the 12th October 1948, Fidel
C( "
HUMANISTS
The revulsion of the civilized and Christian world to incredibly
long lists of assassinations, tortures and extortions by the Castro
regime has at last become It has taken years for this to
happen, but, as the proverb "God for a witness and time for
the truth."
The cold-blooded assassination of over a hundred innocent
Cubans by Raul Castro in the first days of Red victory (they
were machinegunned and toppled into bulldozed ditches) was
the first act of a carefully planned operation. The destruction of
the Army and its viIIification by propaganda was essential to
the Communist plan of imposing a Red force commanded by
Russian officers. The Castro brothers shrewdly recognized that \
the professional corps of officers and soldiers could not be cor-
rupted and would never acquiesce in the sale of their country to
a foreign power.
Thereafter, the creation of popular militias converted every
school into a garrison and placed the people at the mercy of
armed gangs of frustrated people with an uncontrollable lust for
plunder and blood.
Another virtue which was attributed to the self-styled '1ibera-
tors" was "honesty and efficient administration." Yet the man who
calls himself the Tropical Robespierre has never accounted for
eleven million dollars extorted by his revolutionary forces nor has
he ever attempted to account for the vast income of INRA to the
Court of Accounts, to which my Administration reported in full
and in accordance with the Constitution and the laws. Nor has
he ever made this accounting directly to the people, either in
his marathon televised harangues or otherwise. As for the "effi-
ciency" of the new Administration, the shortest answer is that
Cuba is in ruins, its economy destroyed, its political life under
as primitive a type of absolute personal rule as can be found in
modem history.
The native Cubans who mistook the bearded leader for a Moses
destined to lead them to the promised land, suffered in their
property and Hesh the penalty for their error. At first, they
blamed the colossal blunder of "agrarian reform" on inexperience.
They neglected to urge mercy for the men sent -before firing
squads or to rot in filthy prisons by courts of pliterate and venge-
1-49
ful representatives of the "revolution." Some would justify their
moral inertia by confessing fear of being labeled "Batistianos";
others morbidly acquiesced; still others joined the mobs. The re-
action came too late and was on a global scale only when the
corpses of innocent victims were piled high.
Where were the national organizations of self-styled humani-
tarians? They kept silent during the reign of terror, closed their
eyes to the total violation of human rights, then joined the clamor
of denunciation from the safety of exile when it was fashionable
to do so. Many of them, still unrepentent enemies of democracy,
private property and personal freedom, were presented as heroes
of "Fidelismo without Fidel." That is to say, endorsing the events
of the past, eliminating Castro individually and themselves sup-
planting him as the gravediggers of civilization in Cuba.
Thus, a political ideology arose that took under its banner all
the frustrated and rejected ne'llrotics, the resentful lawyers with-
out clients, the doctors without patients and the vast mass of
drifting opportunists, the men without trades, professions or com-
petence. They were supported, while in exile in the United
States, by glib men who felt sympathy for the mass of radical re-
sentment, frustration and incompetence that had been rejected
even by the Communist dictatorship. To gain an audience, this
new group repeated all the old lies of the Communists, including
particularly the denial that Cuba, when free, had made great ad-
vances in science, culture, the arts, and social justice.
For over three years, the OAS was concerned about the con-
ditions of political prisoners in every American country except
Cuba.
The International Red Cross, which had previously been so re-
ceptive to the false charges of the outlaws of the Sierra Maestra,
remained silent and inert while brutal violations of human rights
were perpetrated daily against the people of my unfortunate
country. Yet, under my Administration, the Red Cross had been
given every facility to investigate the charges leveled by the
Marxists, even when they were absurd and obviously designed to
impress the naive and enrage the ignorant. The press is full of
the enormities perpetrated in Communist Cuba. How can the In-
ternational Red Cross reconcile its zeal of yesterday with its cal-
lous indifference of t.oday?
1-50
'>THE AMERICAN WHITE PAPER ON CUBA
r;.A White Paper on Cuba was published by the United States State
Department in April 1961, a few days before the disastrous and
"half-hearted attempt of the Administration to overthrow the
Castro dictatorship by spending Cuban lives, while withholding
American arms and avoiding official responsibility. .
The New York Times, which was exceptionally well-informed
concerning the inner workings of the New Frontier, reported as
follows on Aptil4, 1961 concerning its origins:
"According to informed sources here, the idea for the pam-
];>hlet was President Kennedy's. He has long been concerned at
the lack of popular understanding in Latin America of the United
States attitude toward the Castro regime . . .
"The pamphlet was written largely by Mr. (Arthur M.) Schle-
singer with the cooperation of Richard Goodwin, a Presidential
assistant dealing with foreign aid,
l
and in consultation with the
.. State Department.
"However, according to these informants, President Kennedy
devoted many hours to the pamphlet, personally going over it
.with Mr. Schlesinger."
The nature of this analysis of the Cuban tragedy can be gath-
ered by the following excerpts from a brilliant speech delivered
by Spruille Braden before the Cuban Chamber of Commerce in
the United States on May 17,1961. A former U. S. Ambassador to
Argentina, Colombia and Cuba and at one time Assistant Secre-
tary of State for Latin American Affairs, Mr. Braden has a keen
understanding of the realities of inter-American affairs.
"That abysmal ignorance in Washington concerning this whole
Cuban situation endures, even at this late date, is clearly appar-
ent in the so-called White Paper issued by the Department of
State on April 3rd.
"This document begins by giving approval, i.e., encouraging
1 Richard Nathan Goodwin was one of the most powerful White House ad-
visors on Latin American affairs during the first years of the Kennedy Ad-
ministration. His qualifications for this job, so important to the security of
his country, were that he had never been to Latin America prior to 1961,
spoke no Spanish and was under thirty. However, he was from Harvard
and a socialist or a liberal extremist of one brand or another.
1-51
what it calls the 'authentic and autonomous revolution of the
Americas,' that is to promote more Fidelismo but without Fidel.
For my part, I prefer to see the sound evolution of the Americas
without the violence, ablolse and waste inherent in all revolutions.
Nor do I consider it wise or proper for my government to advo-
cate 'authentic and autonomous revolutions' all over the Ameri-
can continents. This is an outright intervention which may prove
very costly and disastrous for everyone concerned, and especially
for the U.S.A.
"The State Department continues with an apocryphal history of
the Castro revolution, with many half truths and outright errors.
It is ignorant of the fact that the 26th of July Movement was a
child of the Buro del Caribe, which in turn was the off-spring of
the Comintern. It repeats the old fantasy about Fidel being a
'traitor to the revolution: His revolution was Communist-planned
and inspired from the beginning; he was a traitor to God and
country, but never to his Communist bosses and beliefs. It damns
Batista as a tyrant and impugns the honor and reputation of any-
one and everyone who even remotely had been connected with
him. It implies that the Cuban nation as a whole, until the ad-
vent of Castro, suffered from want, lack of medical care, housing
and other social needs. In an unbelievable display of ignorance,
it praises David Salvador, a notorious Communist, as fighting for
a free labor movement and childishly accepts Pardo Llada's ab-
surd allegation recently that he was anti-Communist ...
"As most of you know, Batista and I, as Ambassador during his
first term, had some pretty severe, head-on collisions. Clearly, I
am not prejudiced in his favor. But, as a matter of simple justice,
I should like to call certain facts to the attention of the authors of
the White Paper ... To speak, as the White Paper does, of the
'rapacity of the leadership' and damn such splendid characters as
Saladrigas and hundreds of others like him, is calumny, cheap
demagoguery and a despicable act, unworthy of a responsible
government and foreign office.
"The White Paper's direct and implied animadversions as to
the poverty and bad economic conditions of Cuba, prior to the
coming of Castro, are inaccurate and evidence the socialistic
prejudices of its drafters.
"How false is the picture drawn by the White Paper can be
shown by a few brief citations: Cuba, previous to 1959, enjoyed
1-52
fi' e largest per capita income of any Latin American republic.
ilc;ross national income was $2,834,000,000 and bank clearings
... in 1958. There was a massive construction of hos-
schools of al] grades, houses for the poor and middle
highways and feeder roads. The standard of living was
';fising; there were 4 to 5 persons for each radio, 13 to 18 for each
set, and 39 to each automobile. I remember the long-
"lioremen getting $27 per day even when I was in Cuba.
" ,"Of course, there still existed much corruption, poverty and il-
iYteracy; and there was the perennial problem of 'el tiempo
muerto' (the dead season). Yet, right on Manhattan Island, not to
,1nention in the rest of the city, there are comparable conditions
iqfpoverty, illiteracy, and crime. And a trip totJ;1e West Virginia,
entucky, and Tennessee hills may be edifying in respect to
", ad rural conditions.
"To sum up, the White Paper is one of the most indefensible
,:(1ocuments I ever have seen issued by a presumably responsible
office. The best that can be said for it is that it displays
ignorance and lack of understanding as to explain in con-
Iderable measure the tragic bungling of the catastrophe in Bahia
tie Cochinos."
GLIGENCE OR TREASON?
(Jj'estifying before the Senate Internal Security Subcommittee on
.June 12, 1961, former U. S. Ambassador to Mexico, Costa Rica
EI Salvador Robert C. Hill testified that, ,in his judgment, the
: New York Times and the State Department contributed to the sei-
zure of Cuba by Castro and the Communists. He added that in
\.xMay 1959 "the Russians themselves identified Raul Castro as a
,)Communist" in an official Communist document duly reported
jJby the U. S. Embassy in Moscow to the State Department.
2
Mr.
,Hill stated that this report was called to the attention of the De-
,C;partment, but was evidently ignored. Hill noted that Ambassa-
') dor to Cuba Earl E. T. Smith was instructed by the State Depart-
ment to be briefed by Herbert L. Matthews of the New York
Times, who "has always been an enthusiastic supporter of Fidel
2 Dispatch #666, May 22, 1959, "Soviet Attitude Toward Latin America,"
American Embassy, Moscow, to Department of State.
1-53
Castro"8 and added: "Individuals in {he State Department and
individuals in the New York Times put Castro in power." 4
Mr. Hill and several other former United States Ambassadors
laid blame for decisions favorable to Castro and adverse to the
interests of the United'States on a certain William Arthur Wie-
land, alias Montenegro, who was in charge of Caribbean and Mex-
ican affairs during the time that free Cuba was undermined, be-
trayed and destroyed. Hill testifled concerning a session on board
an airplane with Dr. Milton Eisenhower, the brother of the Presi-
dent and an influential policy maker on Latin American affairs.
Ambassador Hill and his staff tried to warn Dr. Eisenhower of
the fact that Castro was a Communist or Communist tool, but
they were incessantly interrupted by Wieland. When Wieland
stated that "there is no evidence of Communist infiltration in
Cuba," Colonel Glawe, the U. S. Air Attache, retorted: "You are
either a damn fool or a Communist." IS
Hill testified that, at a conference of American Ambassadors in
El Salvador in 9 5 ~ Philip BonsaI, who had just been named U. S.
Ambassador to Cuba, insisted that nothing be put in the commu-
nique which might seem critical of Fidel Castro as that "would
make his (BonsaI's) job in Cuba very difficult." When Hill ob-
jected, BonsaI replied: "If you cannot be a team player, why not
resign?" 6
Hill also testified concerning the existence of a pro-Castro
cell in the American Embassy in Havana and a "CIA representa-
tive in Havana who was pro-Castro." 7 He told U. S. Ambassador
to Cuba Earl E. T. Smith that he was sorry for him because:
"You are assigned to Cuba to preside over the downfall of Ba-
tista. The decision has been made that Batista has to go. You
must be very careful." 8
Hill added that this decision had been made at a low bureau-
cratic level, not by top officials, but by subordinates. Nonetheless,
it was a firm decision and nobody entering the State Department
8 U. S. Senate, Senate Internal Security Subcommittee, Hearings, Commu-
nist Threat to the United States Through the Caribbean, Part 12, Testi-
mony of Robert C. Hill, June 12, 1961, p. 815.
4 Ibid, p. 821.
IS Ibid, pp. 806-807.
6 Ibid, pp. 816-817.
7 Ibid, p.821.
8 Ibid, p. 807.
1-54
could be unaware of tbe fact that Castro's rise 10 powt'f was be-
ing plotted.' Among other things, FBI officials in Mexico, who
were sent there with tbe full toope,ation of the Govern-
ment, sent rcporl$ on the Communist connections of Castro and
his movement to the State Dep:utment. lIowever, these rcports
were sidetracked -at the desk le\-el- and "had not reached the
upper echelons of the State Department.- II
Thus, the testimony of American Amba.uarlon who belie\'fl in
freedom and patriotism has helped reveal some of the machina-
tions of ultra-liberals- lind pro-Communists who, from the sllclter
of the government departments they had in.6ltrated,
to make possible the creation of the first Soviet state in the New
World. Simultaneously, an audacious propaganda of lies was used
to brainwash the people. Despite Cuba's obvious prosperity llnd
advanced labor, educational and social welfare inslitutiolU, it
....'a.5 alleged that her underdeveloped condition called for a revo-
lution.
This came as an unbelievable shock to those of whn 10v('
peace, who have alwa)'s worked for fair relations beh\'een men
and peoples, who slro\'e to provide the homes of our neighbors
with the same happillCS5 and security that we wanted for our
own homes, who battled continuously for better health, more
education llnd culture, and higher Ih';ng standards for the peo-
ple, and who defended our nation's so\'ereignty and worked for
conditions of order and due procns of law in which all men of
will could Ih'e without fear. We found that we
Jiad struggled for was s.....ept aside in the savage chain of crimes
and moral enormities that followed that ominous New Year's
Day of 1959. In addition, we found and our life's ,,-ark
\i1lilied as that of despoU, killers and mcn indifferent to the
needs and welfare of the people,
WIlcn he was contemplating the horrors of fratricidal war,
Abraham Linroln once said his gre:ltest conso1:ltion was his
knowledge that -e\'CJl this shall pass. On another ClC'Ca5ion he told
a wounded $Oldier. -Remember, Dick, 10 keep close to the peG-
Ibid, p. 808.
II Jbld, p. 819,
, ..
pIe-they are always right and will mislead no one." 11 A consola-
tion for us is the knowledge that, despite the cruelties of the Red
terror and the confusing-and false propaganda of its agents, ad-
mirers and dupes, the common people of Cuba have a greatness
of capacity, comprehension and courage that their oppressors can-
not imagine.
The chains of slavery will not for long bind a people which has
offered so many blood sacrifices for its liberty.
Now I am finished. I have tried to give a factual account of
the services which my associates and I performed, or tried to
perform, for our country. The purpose of this book has been to
present the Cuban story as it is in a setting of hard facts and
stubborn realities. The truth, like liberty against slavery and light
against darkness always and in the long run wins its battle against
lies and slander.
As Milton wrote in Areopagitica:
"Though all the winds of doctrine were let loose to play upon
the earth, so Truth be in the field, we do injuriously by licensing
and prohibiting to misdoubt her strength. Let her and Falsehood
grapple; who ever knew Truth put to the worse, in a free and
t open encoun er.
"
It cannot be otherwise in Cuba.
11 Quoted in Carl Sandburg, Abraham Lincoln: The War Years, Harcourt
Brace & Company, New York, 1939, Vol. III, p. 384.
1-56
Section V. VICTORY
The secrecy surrounding the exact date and hour ofthe general
strike was so complete that next day, when it failed two hours
after it had started, several responsible people in the Twenty-
Sixth of July didn't even know when it was supposed to have
begun.
On the morning of the 9th, things started moving early at
Piedad Ferrer's house. A short-wave transmitter had been in-
stalled in a room usually used for storing clothes. Underneath
the beds were quantities of medical supplies, mixed up with
arms and ammunition. A crowd of youths puffed nervously at
cigarettes in the drawing-room while Piedad and her two
coloured maids served everyone with coffee. A young man with
his hair dyed blond, wearing a white guayabera, arrived about
ten. He was the leader of a commando whose job was to make a
proclamation about the strike over CMQ TV and then blow the
place up. He greeted his men, and as the TV studios were so
near they didn't leave until a quarter to eleven. A fat opera
singer was occupying the screen on CMQ's channel and I
started photographing her, hoping that at 11 o'clock precisely I
should get shots of the proclamation and then of the station
being blown up.
At eleven the singer disappeared from the screen and voices
could be heard in the studio. There was no picture at all, and I
tried hard to hear what the voices were saying. An argu-
ment was going on, but it was impossible to distinguish the
words.
At 11.15 I had made up my mind to go down to Old Havana,
where the Twenty-Sixth of July commandos should have been
attacking armouries, police stations and the Admiralty, when
the members of the CMQ commando came back, shaky, sweat-
ing and pale.
'Those bloody Communists!' muttered the boy with the dyed
hair furiously, collapsing on to a sofa. 'They stopped us doing it.
There were half a dozen Communists there to defend the equip-
ment-that's all we needed! We had to give up when the police
arrived. Probably tipped off by the Communists. It's a miracle
we're still alive.'
1-61
I left them to their despair and set out for Old Havana.
Nothing was happening. I put a few discreet questions to people
who were talking in the street. A few shots, they said, a few
night, and their caution during the day, all combined to contri-
bute to the success of the operation. On the 6th October
Guevara and Cienfuego&joined up with the rebel groups in the
Sierra Escambray.
Presidential elections called by Batista were due on the 3rd
November. Batista's own hand-picked candidate was Dr.
Andres Rivero Agiiero. Opposing him were Carlos Marquez
Sterling, former President Ramon Grau San Martin and
Alberto Salas Amara. Batista financed the campaigns of the
opposition candidates to ensure that they would stand. How-
ever, Castro had threatened anyone taking part in them
whether as voter or candidate. Three-quarters of the people in
Havana abstained from voting, and in the rest of the country
the rate of abstention was even higher, in some places reaching
98 per cent.
Havana, in spite of being permanently out of step with the
rest of the country as far as the rebellion was concerned, was
recovering from the failure of the April strike. Manolo Ray
(whose code name was Campa) had reorganized his network of
resistance groups in the capital.
Throughout the Oriente the watchword of Batista's Army
was 'regroupment'. The garrisons of several small posts, badly
situated and impossible to reach when they needed help, were
withdrawn to larger and more defensible quarters. This strategy
gave the Government far fewer but much stronger bases. On the
other hand, it gave the rebels far more liberty of movement and
allowed them to set up road-blocks on all the major highways
in Eastern Cuba.
Fidel then began his next sally from the Sierra Maestra. To-
gether with his general staff he headed for Bueycito, where he
found on his arrival that the garrison had pulled out when they
learned of his approach. Near Bayamo a rebel force accounted
for 200 dead and twenty-one prisoners out of a total of 1,800
Government troops. Raul Castro, who by now had 2,000 men
under his command, captured Sagua de Tanamo, while CM
Guevara was threatening Sancti Spiritus and Cienfuegos was
poised to take Yaguajay.
, Fidel's own immediate objectives were Santiago de Cuba and
the province of Las Villas. By capturing Santiago he would get
control of Cuba's second city, where he could set up a Pro-
visional and by taking Las Villas he would effec-
tively cut the island in two, leaving the Government forces in
the east completely isolated from Havana. Helped by the
Revolutionary Directorate, Guevara and Cienfuegos attacked
Santa Clara (the capital of Las Villas with 77,000 inhabitants).
On the 24th December Guevara occupied Sancti Spiritus, while
Fidel Castro took Palma Soriano. That night Fidel and Raul
dined with their mother and sisters. It was the first Christmas
they had spent together for many years.
When Guevara marched on Santa Clara, the towns on his
route had fallen to him one after another. During the rebel
advance, which was helped by local resistance movements, the
Army almost always surrendered, but not invariably: there
were some cases where towns had to be taken house by house.
Some senior Army officers in these Provinces knew that they
couldn't save their lives anyway so they resolved to sell them
dearly.
On the 28th December 1958, when he was on the outskirts of
Santiago, Fidel Castro received a visit, by helicopter, from
General Eulogio Cantillo, commandant of the garrison of Mon-
cada, the one Castro had attacked more than five years earlier.
Cantillo's visit was the culmination of a series of contacts be-
tween the two men over a long period. Cantillo told Castro that
Batista was prepared to go if the structure of the Army was left
intact. Castro, however, was conscious of the strength of his
own position. The interview showed that Batista had given up
hope of defeating the revolution. The proposal contained two
elements that Fidel Castro could not accept at any price. Firstly,
Batista was to be allowed to leave the country, while Castro
wanted him brought to trial before the Cuban people. Secondly,
he had always disapproved of the Army's role in Latin America
because of the help it had so often given to dictators: Somoza
in Nicaragua, Trujillo in the Dominican Republic, Perez
Jimenez in Venezuela. He flatly rejected the offer. Cantillo then
1-67
40!_
offered to organize a coup against Batista. and pledged, as a
token of good faith, to surrender Moncada at three o'clock the
next day without a shot being fired. Castro accepted.
The following day, the 29th December, at five in the morning,
Castro made his first speech to a great crowd. In the place where
Dr. Munoz, Guitart and many other of his comrades had died,
five years, six months and seven days before, Fidel Castro ful-
filled his promise to liberate Cuba from Fulgencio Batista. He
had started with 200' men who were reduced to seventy; seventy
who, with another twelve, made up the eighty-two who dis-
embarked at Belie; eighty-two, of whom twelve remained at the
end of the first week in the Sierra; twelve, who in twenty-five
months had wiped out an army of 30,000 professional soldiers.
Fidel Castro was to go through many emotional moments on
his journey along the length of the island to the Presidential
Palace in Havana, but perhaps none was so significant, so full of
drama, as when he spoke at the Moncada on that morning of
the 2nd January 1959. Next to him stood the new President
of Cuba, Manuel Urrutia Lleo, and on his other side Monsignor
Enrique Perez Serantes, Archbishop of Santiago de Cuba, the
man who had not only baptized Fidel Castro but had also saved
his life when Batista wanted to eliminate him after the un-
successful attack on the Moncada.
With more than a thousand men, Fidel Castro set out on the
long march of over 800 miles to Havana. Raul stayed behind in
Santiago as Commander-in-Chief of the Province of Oriente.
The progress of the march to the capital was slow. Many
foreign observers were puzzled, as in similar circumstances
rebel leaders generally take over the Presidential Palace as soon
as possible. But Castro was not in a hurry. Urrutia was the
President and he had already left for the Palace. Castro had
several times expressed his complete lack of interest in taking
any political post in the new Government. He had accepted the
position of representative of the Rebel Armed Forces to the
Presidency almost as if to avoid overdoing his modesty.
But behind that 'modesty', Castro had a well-laid plan. He
wanted to satisfy his yearning for publicity, to enjoy everything
he had missed for twenty-five months, and to project an image
of his personality even larger than the one he had projected
among the peaks of the Sierra Maestra. It is not the same to
imagine a hero from Press photographs as it is to see him in the
1-70
flesh, to be able to touch him, t<1 hear his voice without the
artificial interposition of the radio.
Meanwhile, Cienfuegos had occupied Camp Columbia, the
former symbol of ."Batista; Che Guevara was installed in the
fortress of La Cabana; and Urrutia was in the capital with Jose
Mir6 Cardona as Prime Minister, Humberto Sori Marin as
Minister of Agriculture, Roberto Agramonte as Minister of
Foreign Affairs, Manuel Ray as Minister of Public Health,
Carlos Rafael Rodriguez as Minister of the Interior, and Julio
Martinez Paez as Minister of Public Health.
Only one military problem still remained to be settled. The
members of the Revolutionary Directorate, who were the first to
occupy the Presidential Palace, refused to hand it over until they
had obtained assurances from Castro that the rest of the revo-
lutionary forces would be given the same respect as the members
of the Twenty-Sixth of July. Castro ignored the problem. He
carried on, making speech after speech wherever he happened
to be and whatever the time of day or night. He wove a web of
words around his political ideas and all the reforms he would
make in building a new Cuba, a Cuba which would make a new
start with the New Year.
At last, urged on by his more impatient supporters, Castro
reached Havana. He was reunited with his son Fidelito and
finished the journey to the Presidential Palace with the boy by
his side. By this time Urrutia had managed to reach agreement
with the Revolutionary Directorate.
Castro made a speech from the Palace balcony but kept it
brief. He wanted to reserve the most important speech of his life
until he faced the crowds gathered at Camp Columbia. When
he arrived there, flocks of pigeons were released and one bird
perched for a moment on his shoulder. In the eyes of the people
this was an undoubted sign that Providence, which had been so
long on his side, endorsed his final achievement. He spoke for
hours.
1-71
,.,
2_13
I_SO
Soil
l.iS
l. Th. Two RlOYOluUon.e. TlI_re D.ape.
II. D_raUc Pi..... Fl>ipnclo BeU__
U1. 5eJecled :>UUeuca. FIIl_ BeU_
tv. Wer ..... u.. "-eM l'opIoIaU-. Cbe 0 ......... _
V. '01'.. a 50elal RIOYOIUllon 1<""'....,..,. In Cube? l<lcbolu R1wal"O_
no. pa..-. 01 tIIla 0"""''' lO to pl"QY\". lIl. e1""_ .,lIl <It oplmo" on u..
_...,no",lo """"mono 'n Culla. botb. _01"11 ""'" clurlnc U>o I u y.
no. tlu. or tlI.1a cb.apt COllI" ...,..,. U be tbe ........ tIM lOU. for Se<:tloD v,
a Soetal _1vll.0<I :-;ec.....,..,. 10 C..... r ne ...-,.._. obto.uly ...1....., tiult
...... ...pm. _ ca..- eoeIO_ c __ .-->oD10 C_.
polnta _. 10 oecu_ II ..... lU tiull C etaUoc.uJ.ly-..l
compa......lIl 0111 l..fIt,n ""'.r1c"", """nlrl.o. -\LtI>ouct. lIl. etaU.Un I" aft:_
III re <tuoletl by aaUota. 'hore can 1>11 U'U. _ lila' eo",. of !ho ""'0-
o illa ,,,., tId.1 CU'I"O .a_aetl , ....tlt ....".rated. "'no. plc'ure
_ pl1lb! of aw ...,.. Cuboa prol>ably L'.o __110 bot._ 8a\l_'a ....,.".,..
II W _and 1.Ilat 01 eM avon... ID oecuon IV.
Section I. THE TWO REVOLUTIONS
POLITICAL
Castro's 1953 speech predicted that the first revolu-
tionary law would be restoration of the 1940 Constitu-
tion and made an allusion to a "government of popular
election."
Castro's manifesto of July, 1957, his first political
declaration from the Sierra Maestra, contained a "formal
promise" of general elections at the end of one year and
an "absolute guarantee" of freedom of information, press,
and all individual and political rights guaranteed by the
1940 Constitution.
Castro's letter of December 14, 1957, to the Cuban
; exiles upheld the "prime duty" of the post-Batista pro-
! visional government to hold general elections and the
" right of political parties, even during the provisional
government, to put forward programs, organize, and
participate in the elections.
In an article in Coronet magazine of February, 1958,
Castro wrote of fighting for a "genuine representative
government," "truly honest" general elections within
twelve months, "full and untrammelled" freedom of pub-
. lie information and all communication media, and re-
establishment of all personal and political rights set forth
in the 1940 Constitution. The greatest irony is that he
defended himself against the accusation "of plotting to
replace military dictatorship with revolutionary dictator-
ship."
In his answers to his first biographer, Jules Dubois, in
May, 1958, Castro pledged "full enforcement" of the
1940 Constitution and "a provisional government of en-
2-15
tirely civilian character that will return the country to
nortnality and hold general elections within a period of
no more than one year."
In the unity manifesto of July, 1958, Castro agreed "to
guide our nation, after the fall of the tyrant, to normality
by instituting a brief provisional government that will
lead the country to full constitutional and democratic
procedures."
EcONOMIC
In the 1953 speech, Castro supported grants of land
to small planters and peasants, with indemnification to
the former owners; the rights of workers to share in
profits; a greater share of the cane crop to all planters;
and confiscation of all illegally obtained property. His
land reform advocated maximum holdings for agricul-
tural enterprises and the distribution of remaining land
to farming families; it also provided for encouragement
of "agricultural cooperatives for the common use of
costly equipment, cold storage, and a uniform profes-
sional direction incultivation and breeding." In addition,
the speech expressed the intention of nationalizing the
electric and telephone companies.
The manifesto of July, 1957, defined the agrarian re-
form as distribution of barren lands, with prior indem-
nification, and conversion of sharecroppers and squatters
into proprietors of the lands worked on.
The Coronet article favored a land reform to give
peasants clear title to the land, with "just compensation
of expropriated owners." It declared that Castro had no
plans for expropriating or nationalizing foreign invest-
2-16
ments and that he had suspended an earlier program to
extend government ownership to public utilities. On
nationalization, he wrote:
I personally have come to feel that nationalization is,
at best, a cumbersome instrument. It does not seem to
make the state any stronger, yet it enfeebles private
enterprise. Even more importantly, any attempt at
wholesale nationalization would obviously hamper
the principal point of our economic platform-indus-
trialization at the fastest possible rate. For this purpose,
foreign investments will always be welcome and secure
here.
In May, 1958, he assured Jules Dubois:
Never has the 26th of July Movement talked about
socializing or nationalizing the industries. This is simply
stupid fear of our revolution. We have proclaimed
from the first day that we fight for the full enforce-
ment of the Constitution of 1940, whose norms estab-
lish guarantees, rights, and obligations for all the
elements that have a part in production. Comprised
therein is free enterprise and invested capital as well
as many other economic, civic, and political rights.
, The unity manifesto of July, 1958, which was writ-
ten by Castro, merely called for:
A minimum governmental program that will guar-
antee the punishment of the guilty ones, the rights of
the workers, the fulfillment of international commit-
ments, public order, peace, freedom, as well as the
economic, social, and political progress of the Cuban
people.
Law No.3 of the Sterra Maestra on Agrarian Reform,
~ d t e d October 10, 1958, on the very eve of taking power,
l'
l
2-17
I
was based on the principle that those who cultivate the
land should own it. This law, signed by Fidel Castro and
the then Judge AQ.vocate General, Dr. Humberto Sod
Marin, made no mention of "cooperatives" or "state
farms." Its entire intent was to implement the hitherto
neglected agrarian-reform provision in the Constitution
of 1940.*
Such were the promises that Fidel had made.t The
near unanimity with which Castro's victory was ac-
cepted in January, 1959, was the result not merely of
his heroic struggle and glamorous beard but of the politi-
cal consensus he appeared to embody. This consensus
had resulted from the democratic disappointments in
1944-52 and the Batista despotism of 1952-58. There was
Its full text, which became extremely rare after Castro took
power, may be found in Enrique Gonzalez Pedrero, La Revoluci6n
Cubana (Mexico: Escuela Nacional de Ciencias PoHticas y Sociales,
1959), pp. 143-56.
t Castro's pre-1959 promises are dealt with by Huberman and
Sweezy in a peculiar way. They cite twelve and a half pages of the
1953 speech but omit the five-point program on which Castro said
the revolution was based. This program began: "The first revolu-
tionary law would have restored sovereignty to the people and pro-
claimed the Constitution of 1940 as the true supreme law of the
state, until such time as the people should decide to modify it or to
change it." The others provided for grants of land to small planters
and peasants, with indemnification to the former owners; the right
of workers to share in profits; a greater share of the cane crop to
all planters; and confiscation of all illegally obtained property.
Although the speech makes other important points, this is the only
itemized program in it, and it is hard to see how its omission can
be justified. The unity pact of July, 1958, is handled in the same
way. It contained three points: a common strategy, postwar "nor-
mality," and "a minimum governmental program." I have quoted the
second point in full in the text. Huberman and Sweezy cite a para-
graph in this unity pact that asked the U.S. to cease all military and
other types of aid to Batista, but ignore the three-point program,
which might have put Castro's promises in a somewhat different light.
Mills simply ignores the whole collection of Castro's prepower
pledges.
2-18
broad agreement that Cuba could never go back to the
corrupt brand of democracy of the past, and the Cuban
middle class was ready for deep-going social and political
reforms to make impossible another PrIO Socarras and
another Batista. Castro promised to restore Cuban de-
mocracy and make it work, not a "direct" or "people's"
democracy but the one associated with the 1940 Consti-
tution, which was so radical that much of it, especially
the provision for agrarian reform, was never imple-
mented.
It is, moreover, unthinkable that Castro could have
won power if he had given the Cuban people the slight-
est forewarning of what he has presented them with-a
press and all other means of communication wholly
government controlled, ridicule of elections, wholesale
confiscation and socialization, "cooperatives" that are (as
Huberman and Sweezy admitted) virtually "state farms,"
or a dictatorship of any kind, including that of the pro':'
letariat. It was precisely the kind of promises Castro made
that enabled him to win the support of the overwhelm-
ing majority of the Cuban middle and other classes; a
"peasant revolution" would hardly have been expressed
in quite the same way.
The least that can be said, therefore, is that Castro
promised one kind of revolution and made another. The
revolution Castro promised was unquestionably betrayed.
THE SOCIOLOGICAL IMAGINATION
The Castro mythology tends to distort not only the
original nature of the Cuban revolution but also the
2-19
character of Cuban society. Pages were written by
Huberman and w ~ z y about the peasantry, a single
paragraph about the working class, and almost nothing.
about the middle class. Mills never seems to have made
up his mind which Cubans were speaking through him.
His own list of the Cubans who spoke to him indicates
that there was not a worker, and certainly not a peasant,
in the lot. Without exception, his informants were mid-
dle-class intellectuals and professionals of the type in
power. Sometimes he makes them speak in their own
name; more often they masquerade as the most impover-
ished and miserable of Cuban peasants. They say, "we
squatted on the edge of the road in our filthy huts," as
if they were the "we" and as if this was typical of all
Cubans. The average reader might imagine that Cuba
was nothing but "a place of misery and filth, illiteracy
and exploitation and sloth." This may be a triumph of
propaganda but it is a travesty of sociology.
Cuba before Castro was, indeed, a country with seri-
ous social problems, but it was far from being a peasant
country or even a typically "underdeveloped" one. Its
population was more urban than rural: 57 per cent lived
in the urban areas and 43 per cent in the rural, with the
trend strongly in favor of the former (according to the
Geogra{fa de Cuba, written by Antonio Nunez Jimenez,
the first Director of the Agrarian Reform Institute).
The people dependent on agriculture for a living made
up about 40 per cent, and ofthese over one-quarter were
classified as farmers and ranchers. In 1954, the national
income was divided as follows: the sugar industry, agri-
cultural and industrial, 25 per cent; other agriculture,
2-20
13 'Per cent; other industry and commerce, 40 per cent;
everything else, 21 per cent. In 1950, only 44 per cent
of the total labor force was agricultural.
The standard of living, low by U.S. and West Euro-
pean standards, was comparatively high for Latin Amer-
ica; only three countries, Venezuela, Argentina, and
Chile, rated above Cuba in per capita income; Cuba's
was almost as high as Italy's and much higher than
Japan's. Cuba ranked fifth in Latin America in manufac-
turing, behind Brazil, Argentina, Mexico, and Chile.
Cuba had 1 automobile for every 39 inhabitants (in
Argentina, 1 for every 60; in Mexico, 91; in Brazil, 158),
and 1 radio for every 5 inhabitants (second to Argen-
tina, with 1 for every 3). Cuban tourists were able to
spend more in the United States than American tourists
spent in Cuba. After World War II, Cuban interests
were strong enough to buy a substantial share of U.S.-
owned sugar production, which fell from 70-80 per cent
of the total at its high point in the 1930's to about 35 per
cent in 1958. Government encouragement of "Cubaniza-
tion" would easily have cut the figure in half again in a
short time under a post-Batista democratic regime.-
.I am not trying to suggest that Cuba's economy was a
.. Cuba was, in fact, an unevenly developed country with a rela-
tively high standard of living, as one of the leading Cuban Com-
munists, Anibal Escalante, has admitted: "In reality, Cuba was not
one of the countries with the lowest standard of living of the masses
in America but, on the contrary, one of those with the highest
standard of living, and it was here where the first great patriotic,
democratic, and socialist revolution of the continent burst forth and
where the in;lperialist chain was first broken. If the historical devel-
opment had been dictated by the false axiom expressed above, the
revolution should have been first produced in Haiti, Colombia, or
even Chile, countries of greater poverty for the masses than the
Cuba of 1952 or 1958" (Verde Olivo, July 30,1961).
2-21
healthy one. It was precariously dependent on the fluctu-
ations of a single crop, sugar, which accounted for more
than 80 per cent of Cuban exports and employed about
a half million workers for only three to four months a
year. As the rates of illiteracy show-41.7 per cent in the
rural areas and only 11.6 per cent in the urban areas-
the social development of Cuba was shockingly unbal-
anced in favor of the cities and towns, and Castro's cru-
sade for the peasantry has repaid the Cuban upper and
middle classes for decades of indifference to the welfare
of the land workers.
But this is not the same thing as implying (as Mills
often does) that Cuba was nothing but a land of back-
ward, illiterate, diseased, starving peasants. When he
writes, "We speak Spanish, we are mainly rural, and we
are poor," the first statement is undoubtedly correct, the
second is demonstrably false, and the third is partly true.
Cuba was one of the most middle-class countries in Latin
America.
In effect, this mythology of the Cuban social structure
makes Castro's victory inexplicable. If a "handful" of
middle-class "students and intellectuals" had the active
support of only a few hundred or even a few thousand
peasants, without either the working or middle classes (as
Mills maintains), the Batista regime would never have
toppled. It was the desertion of the middle class-on
which Batista's power was based-that caused his regime
to disintegrate from within and his army to evaporate.
* * * * *
* *
2-22
Section II. DEMOCRATIC PLANS
IN ORDER TO assure internal and international confidence, the
revolution of the "10th of March," 1952, maintained all the
norms, principles and guarantees of the Constitution of 1940,
with modifications only in regulatory measures. In accord with
these norms and principles, there was no attack on the lives
or the property and political rights of citizens. Nor was there
political censure for anyone fulfilling the obligations of public
office. The government tried to reach an agreement with the
opposition for the holding of immediate elections. But most of
the leaders of the opposition, realizing that the times were not
propitious for their success and, in their own interests, wishing
to delay the return to normalcy, refused the offer, and eagerly
set out to promote disorder and violence.
Respect for Tenure
At the same time the government gave an example-without
precedent in a revolution-of in their positions the
officers of all the autonomous bodies which exercise a good
share of public power in the Cuban Government. This was our
attitude in dealing with the Court of Accounts (Tribunal de
Cuentas)-to respect all its justices and subordinates-in deal-
ing with the National Bank of Cuba (Banco Nacional de
Cuba), and with the Bank of Agricultural and Industrial De-
velopment (Banco de Fomento Agricola e Industrial), inaking
new appointments only when an office-holder had resigned; in
From pages 25-31, Fulgencio Batista, Cuba Betrayed (New York, Vantage Press, Inc., 1962). Reprinted
with permission of the publishers at USACGSC and may not be further reproduced in whole or in part with-
out express permission of the copyright owner.
2-23
dealing with 'the Commission of NatiOIial Development (Comi-
si6n de Fomento Nacional); with the Cuban Institute for the
Stabilization of Sugar (lnstituto Cubano de EstabilizaciOn del
Azucar); with the Commission for Arbitration of the Sugar
Industry (Comisi6n de Arbitraje Azucarero), and with all the
bodies connected with social security, whether of the laboring or
professional classes. Among the bureaucracy of other govern-
ment departments, where formerly any change in leadership had
meant a massive wave of dismissals, the revolutionary govern-
ment of the "10th of March" created hardly a stir.
Terrorism and Sabotage
The purpose of all these acts was to stabilize the country, to
create as little upheaval as possible, gaining general confidence
by seeking the national unity indispensable to progress, eco-
nomic liberation and consolidation. But personal ambitions,
political passions, and the desire to restore the old order vied
with these patriotic objectives. They gave rise with diabolical
intensity to the terror which, in the beginning, revealed its
presence through bombs and explosives, in streets, parks, the-
atres, cinemas, restaurants, cabarets and stores. It brought death
or mutilation to children, women and men, most of whom were
not concerned with politics. Then terror attacked the public
services, the aqueducts and the electric works, highways, rail-
ways, bridges, telephone networks, telegraph stations, post of-
fices, and industrial and agricultural centers.
Economic Aggression
In describing this destructive process one must emphasize the
effort made to destroy the economy, not only through the ac-
tions summarized above, but also by attempts to obstruct the
sugar harvests, and by organizing a campaign of slander through
2-24
telephone calls, and propaganda'protected by the absolute free-
dom of the press. * A rumor was spread that "the government
planned to seize bank deposits as well as the contents of safe
,
deposit boxes in order to overcome its and the country's bank-
ruptcy." After repeated failures of this campaign, public confi-
dence was weakened in April, 1958, when a general strike,
which threatened to put important national and foreign banks
in a difficult spot, was called without success.
These then were the negative methods of a struggle, which,
as we have many times repeated, was directed not against the
government but against Cuba.
Attacks on Schools and Children
The lawless campaign accentuated its own vile nature when
it directed aggressive acts against kindergartens, hurling "Molo-
tov cocktails" and attacking buses carrying boys and girls to
their schools.
In the wave of terror and violence which lashed the Island
in the last two years, our government repeatedly tried the
method of pardon, of forgetting offenses and calling for unity
and national concord. What follows is an example of this policy.
Two tnonths before the assassination in HolguIn of Col. Fer-
min Cowley Gallegos, military chief of the zone in which the
Castro family resided, the mother of Fidel and RaUl, Mrs. Ruz
Castro, addressed herself, with Cowley as intermediary, to the
* "We independent journalists who visited Cuba during the first
five years of Batista's second government could never find reasons for
criticizing a Batista tyranny, simply because both the first and second
governments of the ex-Sergeant were distinguished by a sense of de-
mocracy and liberty unsurpassed by any other Latin American coun-
try." (Aldo Baroni-"The Dance of the Hours" "La Danza de las
Horas")-Excelsior, Jan. 12, 1960. Prensa Libre has continued to
republish, in an effort to justify itself to the Castristas, the violent
attacks it printed during the Batista "dictatorship." This fact proves
the truth of the quotation.
2-25
General Chief of Staff. I was to grant a truce, and through
diplomatic safe-conduct or by the withdrawal of our troops
from the region, the two-could take a plane or a ship out of the
country.
There was nothing suspicious about these overtures. Col.
Cowley's job was to protect the Castro Ruz family on the farm
where the widowed mother lived with her children, Ramon
and Juanita. These two children acted as messengers between
the Colonel and Mrs. Ruz Castro.
The Office of the Chief of Staff gave instructions for the with-
drawal of the troops and called a halt to all fighting. A six-man
patrol of marines and soldiers withdrew to relax on the sea
coast. As they were not on duty, they reconnoitered the area
and then spent the night in two abandoned huts.
Trustingly, they took no precautions. They fell fast asleep,
believing that the truce would be observed. About 4:30 in the
morning one of them arose to prepare breakfast. Kindling the
fire was to be, unknowingly, the signal for the consequent
tragedy. Fidel Castro and a group of villains who accompanied
him, making a mockery of his mother's effort and of the truce,
fell "heroically" upon those defenseless troops and slew them
with knife and gun.
Tolerance and Law
Five laws of amnesty, one of them so comprehensive as to
include the assailants of the "Moncada" barracks in 1953, and
their ringleader Castro; wholesale pardons; repeated invitations
to exiled leaders to return to the country; respect for the free-
dom of the press as ordered by the Constitution; and, finally,
the inclusion into the Electoral Code of the demands formulated
by the opposition, particularly the direct and secret vote-these
acts demonstrated the will of any government to maintain peace
and advance progress.
2-26
Work and Credit
If one examines to what extent Cuba advanced, although
deep in the sorrow; confusion and uncertainty of this struggle,
the conclusion is obvious. If neither sugar*, nor minerals, nor
other exports reached high price levels; if agreements could not
be reached with foreign enterprise and if world investment
capital was adversely influenced; if international opinion turned
so hostile to Cuba as to convert Havana embassies illto centers
of conspiracy; if embargoes against the shipment of arms to
the government were established-practically giving the status
of belligerents to terrorists who committed every sort of outrage
and violated laws, and, even enjoyed advantages in certain
countries-then we must ask ourselves: How did Cuba attain
such a high level of solvency and economic development at
this time and under such circumstances?
We must conclude that world opinion had been led astray
by propaganda but that the Cuban Government had the posi-
tive support of internal public opinion, because in no other way
could the miracle of this economic development* *, this height
of prosperity and the high standard of living of labor, have been
possible.
These heights are not reached with guns. They are achieved
through the confidence of businessmen, of investment capital, of
* Ambassador Arthur Gardner, in his depositions before the Sen-
ate Subcommittee on Internal Security said: "...'During the course of
the time that I was there the economy rose tremendously. The building
boom was sensational. If you had been in Havana ten years earlier, as
I had, and then saw it the day I left, you would not recognize the city.
. . . They (Cubans) felt that the time had finally come when they could
begin investing money in Cuba, rather than putting their money, as
they had in previous years, in banks in Switzerland and New York."
Ambassador Earle E. T. Smith, in his depositions before the same
Subcommittee, said: "The year 1957 was the best economic year that
Cuba has ever had."
**See Economic References in - - - [section III, chapter 2] .
2-27
farmers, of all sectors of the population sharing in the produc-
tion and commerce of a country
Constitution and Despotislfl.
Any suspension of constitutional guarantees was always pre-
ceded by national clamor for such action. The people saw how
the Legislative Power acted within the framework of the Con-
stitution to modify the messages of the Executive Power, and
approved or disapproved measures recommended by the Coun-
cil of Ministers (Consejo de Ministros). It made its own deci-
sions, without conflicts on questions of party discipline. In the
area of Judicial Power not one judge, magistrate, or employee
was removed by the revolutionary government. Nor were there
any dismissals when the constitutional government came to
power after the election of 1954. In accordance with the Con-
stitution, the internal control of the judges and courts was
maintained by the Supreme Court (Tribunal Supremo), the
majority of whose members had taken their seats under previous
administrations.
Intelligent public opinion observed the opposite take place
later under Castro; and the world noted it with horror. We have
seen assault, pillage and confiscation of newspapers imposing
a gag of terror on the press. Those who professed to be defend-
ers of the Constitution, rule without obeying it; nor do they
have even their own revolutionary constitution. Those who
claimed to respect the. Judicial Power, defending Manuel Ur-
rutia against the simple criticisms directed against his lies,
destroyed the courts of justice. It must be strange to watch
men who proclaimed the independence of civil power-among
them the lawyer Jose Mira Cardona-converted into puppets
of the Argentine ("CM Guevara) who speaks in the name
of military power and chieftain Castro. It is easy to observe the
2-28
difference between two regimes, because the latter has
usurped all power, while we worked earnestly in harmony with
the other government departments.
There, in constant effort, in respect for laws and property
rights, lies the secret of the economic greatness of Cuba.
2-29
TABLE [1] : INCOME PER CAPITA IN U. S. DOLLARS
Rank Latin American Country Year Income per Capita
1 Venezuela 1958 868
2 Costa Rica 1958 361
3 CUBA ~ ~
4 Chile ~ 291
5 Mexico 1958 260
6 Uruguay 1957 253
7 Panama 1956 246
8 Dominican Republic 1957 239
Section III. SELECTED STATISTICS
U ~ ?-(
* * * * * * *
From pages 277-292, reprinted by permission of the publisher of The Devin-Adair Company from the book
THE GROWTH AND DECLINE OF THE CUBAN REPUBLIC by Fulgencio Batisla. Reproduced sl USA
CGSC by special permission and maynal be further reproduced in whole or in part without express per-
mission of the copyright owner.
2-30
TABLE [2J:PERCENTAGE OF ILLITEl\J\TES TO TOTAL POPULATION
IN UTIN AMERICA. IN 1958
0
Rank Country PercentIlliterate
1 Argentina 8
2 Costa Rica 21
3 .Chile 24
4 CUBA 24
5 Puerto Rico 26
6 Panama 28
7 Uruguay 35
8 Colombia 35
9 Mexico 38
10 Ecuador 44
11 Peru 50
12 Brazil 51
13 DominicanRepublic 57
14 ElSalvador 58
15 Nicaragua 60
16 Paraguay 60
17 Venezuela 60
18 Honduras 65
19 Bolivia 69
20 Guatemala 72
21 Haiti 90
oDatafrom the United Nations Statistical Yearbook, 1959. The Communist
leader, Antonio Nunez Jimenez, claimed in 1959 that the Cuban illiteracy
,ratewasonly22.8%.
TABLE [3J: PERCENrAGE OFNATIONAL INCOMEDEVOTED TO PUBLIC
EDUCATION .IN 1959
0
Rank Country Percent
1 CUBA 3At
2 Argentina 3.Q
3 CostaRica 3.1
4 Peru 3.1
5 Chile 2.6
6 Guatemala 2.3
7 Brazil 2.3
8 Colombia 1.9
oPan American Union, America in Figures, 1960, Washington, D.C. The
comparable U.S. figure for 1957-58 was 4.3%.
t 1957-58. t 195960. 1957.
2-31
TABLE [4] :lNHABlTANTS FER UNIVERSITY SnIDEN'T (1958)
Inhabitants
Rank Country per Student
I Argentina" 135
2 Uruguay 199
3 CUBA 273
4 Mexico 334
5 PanaIna 387
6 Paraguay 496
7 Costa Rica 514
.. UNESCO, Annuaire Internationale d'Education. The comparable figures
are 61 for the United States and 210 for Canada.
TABLE [5]: INHABITANTS PER PHYSICIAN INACTIVE PRACTICE
Rank Country No. Inhabitants Year
I Argentina 760 1956
2 Uruguay 860 1957
3 CUBA 1,000 1957
4 Venezuela 1,700 1957
5 Chile 1,900 1953
6 Mexico 1,900 1956
7 Paraguay 1,900 1957
8 Brazil 2,500 1954
.. Pan American Union, America in Figures, 1960.
TABLE [6]: MORTALITY RATE PER THOUSAND PERSONS (1958)
Rank Country Mortality Rate Rank Country Mortality Rate
I CUBA 5.8 12 Peru 10.3 . '
2 Uruguay 7.0 13 Paraguay 10.6
3 Boliviat 7.7 14 Honduras 11.1
4 Venezuela 7.8 15 Mexico 11.6
5 Argentina 8.1 16 El Salvador 11.7
6 Canada 8.1 17 Chile 12.1
7 DOIninican Rep. 8.4 18 ColoInbia 12.8
8 Nicaragua 8.7 19 Ecuador 15.2
9 Costa Rica 9.0 20 Brazil 20.6
10 PanaIna 9.0 21 GuateInala 21.3
11 United States 9.4
Statistical Abstract of the United States, 1960.
t Probably due primarily to underreporting.
2-32
. TABLE [7J :INFLATIQN IN' LATIN AMERICA
(U.S.DepartmentofCommercedata)
Percent Increase in
Consumer Goods
Rank Country Prices in 1958
1 CUBA 1.4
2 DominicanRepublic 1.9
3 Honduras 2.9
4 Guatemala 3.3
5 Ecuador 3.5
6 CostaRica 4.3
7 Venezuela 4.7
8 EI Salvador 5.9
9 Panama 6.2
10 Nicaragua 6.9
11 Mexico 7.8
12 Uruguay 9.1
13 Colombia 9.6
14 Peru 12.4
15 Brazil 15.4
16 Argentina 19.8.
17 Chile 35.7
18 Paraguay 43.8
19 Bolivia 63.0
TABLE [8J: FOREIGN TRADE: VALUE OF IMPORTS IN
DOLLARS PER CAPITA (1958)'*
Rank Country Value of Imports
1 Venezuela 2,380
2 CUBA 1,320
3 Panama 1,042
4 Costa Rica 865
5 Argentina 590
6 Chile 550
7 Uruguay 537
8 Nicaragua 531
PanAmerican Union, America in Figures, 1960.
2-33
Number of Units
180
~
129
124
102
102
90
76
Year
1958
1958
1956
1957
1956
1958
1957
1957
I) Pan American Union, America in Figures, 1960.
* * * * * *
.*
TABLE [11]: TELEVISION SETS PER 1,000 INHABITANTS (1959) I)
1 CUBA ~
2 Venezuela 29
3 Argentina 19
4 Mexico 17
5 Brazil 13
6 Colombia 10
7 Uruguay 5
8 . Dominican Republic 5
Pan American Union, America in Figures, 1960.
2-34
*
*
* * * * *
TABLE [12J: INFANT MORTALITY. IN LATIN AMERICA 1958: (DEA'!HS
DURING FIRST YEAR PER '!HOUSAND BIR'!HS-SOURCE:
Statistical Abstract of the United States, 1960)
Rank Country Infant Mortality Rate
1 CUBA 37.6
2 Paraguay 55.3
3 Panama 57.9
4 Argentina 61.1
5 Honduras 64.4
6 Nicaragua 69.3
7 Uruguay 73.0
8 Dominican Republic 76.6
9 El Salvador 79.3
10 Mexico 80.0
11 Peru 88.4
12 Costa Rica 89.0
13 Bolivia 90.7
14 Venezuela 91.2
15 Colombia 100.0
TABLE [13J: AVERAGE SIZE OF FARMS IN CERTAIN LATIN AMERICAN
COUNTRIES (1958)
Average Size of Farm&
Country
in hectares
CUBA
56.7
United States 78.5
Mexico 82.0
Venezuela
335.0
* * * * * * *
2-35
TABLE [14];U.S. INVESTMENTS IN LATIN AMERICA
(inmillions of dollars)
Increase or
Country or Area 1956 1958 Decline
All LatinAmerica 7,059 8,730 1,671
1 Venezuela 1,829 2,722 893
2 Brazil 1,218 1,345 127
3 CUBA 777 1,001 224
4 Mexico 690 781 91
5 Chile 676 736 60
6 CentralAmerica 630 737 107
7 Argentina 466 517 51
8 Peru 343 429 86
9 Colombia 298 289 -9
All Other 132 173 41
Percent representedby
Cuba 11.0% 11.5% 13.4%
* * * * *
* *
TABLE [15] :PHYSICIANS PER THOUSAND INHABITANTS, A WORLD
COMPARISON (LATE 1950s)'*
Physicians Population Physicians per
Country (thousands) (millions) 1,000 Population
Italy (1958) 69.9 48.5 1.44
WestGermany (1959) 72.8 51;5 1.41
United States (1958) 217.1 171.2 1.27
Japan (1960) 97.3 90.9 1.07
France (1959) 44.4 44.1 1.01
CUBA (1960)t 6.4 6.4 1.00
UnitedKingdom (1959) 42.5 51;5 0.83
'* Figures for physicians from Statistical Abstract of the United States, 1962,
pp. 935-936. Population data from UNESCO, op. cit.
tTheratioof physiciansto populationwas exactly thesamein1957.
* * * * * * *
2-36
Percent
41.5
0.5
16.6
3.3
0.4
11.7
5.0
20.1
0.9
100.0
TABLE [16] :GAINFULLY EMPLOYED POPULATION OF CUBA (1958)
Category No.
Agriculture, hunting & fishing 818,706
Mining and quarrying 9,618
Manufacturing 327,208
Construction 65,292
Public utilities 8,439
Commerce 232,323
.Transport & communications 104,003
Service 395,904
Other 10,773
TOTAL 1,972,266
* * * * * * *
TABLE [17]: HIGH SCHOOLS, SPECIAL SCHOOLS AND UNIVERSITIES
Total in Created by Created by
Type of Institution 1958 Batista Others
Universities 13 9 4
High Schools 21 15 6
Schools for Teachers 19 11 8
Home economics schools 14 8 6
Commercial schools 19 10 9
Art Schools 7 2 5
Technical Schools 22 15 7
Schools of Journalism, etc. 6 6 0
-
- -
TOTALS 121 76 45
PERCENTAGES 100% 63% 37%
TABLE [18]: SUGAR PRICES, PRODUCTION AND EXPORTS
Crop USA Price World Price Exports
Year (Mils.LongTons) ($ Mils.}
1954 4.75 4.93 3.49 431.5
1955 4.40 4.80 3.42 472.6
1956 4.60 4.86 3.31 523.2
1957 5.51 5.33 5.12 645.0
1958 5.61 5.22 3.45 587.5
1959 5.99 5.40 2.96 491.7
1963t
o The first year of the Communist regime in Cuba.
t 1963 = 3 Mils. or so.
2-37
Year
1939
1954
1958
Year or period
1935-1940 average
1950-1955 average
1955/56
1956/57
1957/58
1958/59
TABLE C19J: NATIONAL OWNERSHIP OF THE SUGAR INDUSTRY
Cuban Mills U.S. Mills Other Ownership
No. Pet. 'No. Pet. No. Pet.
56 22.4% 66 55.1% 52 22.5%
116 57.8% 41 41.0% 4 1.2%
121 62.1% 36 36.7% 4 0.3%
TABLE [20J: SUGAR OUTPUT IN CUBA, U.S.A. AND U.S.S.1\,
Sugar Production in Thsds. Short Tons:
USA USSR CUBA
1,901 2,761 3,183
2,351 3,010 6,078
2,313 4,200 5,229
2,529 5,000 6,252
2,735 5,800 6,372
2,820 6,100 6,600
SUMMARY OF LABOR LEGISLATION IN CUBA
1878 Law restricting child labor..
1909 Arteaga Law, requiring that wages be paid in legal tender,
not in scrip.
1910 Law authorizing construction of houses for workers.
1910 Regulating closing hours of stores.
1913 Commission to study an Employment and Social Security
Code.
1916 Worker's Compensation Law.
1921 Regulation of hours for banks and pharmacies.
1924 Labor commissions set up at Cuban ports.
1931 Establishment of an unemployment fund.
AFTER THE REVOLUTION OF SEPTEMBER 1933:
1933 Law requiring that 50% of every labor force be Cuban.
1933 Trade Union Law.
1934 Law protecting women workers.
1934 Law of collective labor agreements.
1934 Law establishing the right to paid vacations.
1934 Law protecting workers and employees against arbitrary
discharge.
1934 Law affirming the right to join unions and the right to strike.
1934 Eight-hour day law.
2-38
1934 Health and maternityprotection for workers.
1934 National Minimum Wage Commission.
1935 Employment Exchanges Law.
1936 Superior Carmcil onSocial Security.
1936 Organization of an institutetoretrain disabled workers.
1936 National Institute of Prevention and Social Reforms.
1937 Central Board on Maternityand Health.
1941 CompulsoryArbitrationLaw.
1943 National Commission of Social Cooperation.
1945 Regulationofworkinghours insummer.
1948 Lawrequiringbanks to close on Saturdays.
1948 Lawon healthstandards in places of employment.
1952 FinancingofPalaceofLabor.
1953 Labor-Management Technical Committees. 4
1953 Compulsory paymentofuniondues providedbycheckoff.
1955 Law eliminating Communists from the trade unions and
from public employment.
DURING THE FIRST YEAR OF CASTRO COMMUNISM:
1959 Abolition of the rightto organize unions.
1959 Strikes outlawed.
1959 Minimumwagelaws repealed.
1959 Collectivebargainingabolished.
1959 Right to jobsecurity terminated.
1959 Paid vacations abolished.
1959 Compulsoryworkfor theState instituted.
1959 Paymentofwagesinscripauthorized. .
DISABILITY, OLD AGE, RETIREMENT AND DEATH BENEFITS
Number of Funds Beneficiaries
Category in 1958 in 1958
Workers 21 1,400,000
Professionals 20 8,000
Governmentemployees 11 140,000
TOTAL 1,620,000
PercentofCubanlaborforce insured. . . 90%
2-39
Collections in 1955
Collections in 1958
Increase
Consolidated Balance 1955
Expenditures
Contribution to Capital
Total Assets in 1955
Number of Industrial Unions
Number of Union Locals
No. of Collective Contracts in Force
SOCIAL SECURITY: CONSOLIDATED DATA FROM 21 RETIREMENT FUNDS
$ Millions
56.6
68.0
11.4
99.0
74.1
14.9
212.2
TRADE UNIONS IN CUBA: CONFEDERATION OF CUBAN WORKERS (CTC)
Oct. 1944 Dec. 1958
30 33
1,560 2,490
2,624 7,638
.. Havana Province only.
TABLE [21 J: LATIN AMERICAN MONETARY RESERVES OF GOLD AND
CONVERTIBLE FOREIGN EXCHANGE IN MILLIONS OF
DOLLARS
Country
1 Venezuela
2 Brazil
3 CUBA
4 Mexico
5 Uruguay
6 Colombia
7 Argentina
1958
1,050
465
373
372
205
160
129
1960
558
428
144
393
213
153
658
TABLE [22J : CUBA AS A MINERAL PRODUCER (1958)
2-40
Mineral
Cobalt
Nickel
Chronium
Manganese
Copper
Cuba's Po.s/tion in:
The World Americas
First First
Second Second
Eighth Second
Eighth Second
Eleventh Sixth
-------.-
Section IV. WAR AND THE PEASANT POPULATION
T
o explain and justify Fidel Castro's journey toward com-
munism it has often been said that Cuba was an under-
developed country and that in all underdeveloped countries
the economic and social structure must be changed to meet
the people's needs for food, housing, clothing, education, and
other things that are taken for granted in the United States,
Western Europe, and even in Soviet Russia.
Prerevolutionary Cuba is painted as a backward, semicolo-
nial country, in which impoverished and miserable Cuban
peasants were exploited by reactionary large landowners and
big United States corporations which opposed industrializa-
tion and agricultural diversification.
It is indeed true that Cuba needed social and economic
reform, a fact admitted officially by the United States gov-
ernment in a 36-page white paper on Cuba, issued on April
3, 1961, by the Department of State, but written in the White
House by Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr., former Harvard his-
torian and one of President Kennedy's closest assistants. Yet
the picture of Cuba painted by Castro's propagandists was
false. Cuba was a long way from being a typically underde-
veloped country. Prior to Castro's take-over, Cuba was a
From pages 64-81, Castro's Cuba by Nicholas Rivero. Reprinted by permission Rohert B. Luce Campa\"
ny, Inc. at USACGSC and may not be further reproduced in whole Or in part without express permission of
the copyright owner.
2-45
country undergoing development. Its wealth was increasing
from year to year; new were being established; the
livestock industry had attained maturity and constituted an
impressive source of wealth; mining was developing at a
rapid pace. And at the time of Batista's coup of March 10,
1952, the greatest desire of the Cubans was to have an "hon-
est" government. Public pressure for integrity had prompted
the government of President Carlos Prio Socarras to entrust
to honest men the cleanup of two major departments-Edu-
cation and Treasury. And in the abortive elections of 1952
the presidential candidate of the Cuban Revolutionary party
the government party, was an honest man,
Carlos Hevia, an Annapolis graduate of the class of 1919; the
principal opposition party candidate, Professor Agramonte,
also was an honest man.
Dr. Manuel A. de Varona, fonner prime minister of Cuba,
and coordinator-general of the anti-Castro Cuban Democratic
Revolutionary Front, recently stated that it is totally untrue
that Cuba needs a socialist regime to solve the poverty among
underprivileged classes.
In a letter refuting a statement by Mrs. Eleanor Roosevelt
in her column "My Day," that Cuba needed a socialist regime,
Dr. Varona said:
Only fifty years after the birth of Cuba as an independent re-
publiC, free enterprise placed Cuba among the countries with the
highest standard of liVing in the Americas.
In 1952, Cuba occupied third place in per capita income in
Latin America; was second in meat consumption per capita (only
surpassed by Argentina); second in miles of paved roads per
1,000 square miles of territory; second in ratio of doctors to popu-
lation, and third in standard of wages paid to 500,000 sugar work-
ers, surpassed only by Canada and the United States.
In exports, Cuba surpassed all combined Central American 1\e-
2-46
publics and the peso was one of the strongest world currencies on
par with the American dollar.
Our labor laws w ~ among the most advanced in the world,
granting workers certain rights and benefits which cannot be
found even in the United States.
The Cuban people neither want nor need a Socialist regime.
What they desire is a political stability and honesty in public
administration within a democratic free enterprise framework.
The proof of this is that the revolutionary program against Batista,
to which Fidel Castro later pledged himself, was based on these
popular aspirations together with restoration of our democratic
process interrupted by Batista in 1952.
It was also admitted by the International Bank for Recon-
struction and Development that Cuba was not a land of
oppressive poverty in which the common man had practically
nothing. In its "Report on Cuba," 1951, the technical mission
of the IBRD stated:
The general impression of members of the Mission, from obser-
vations and travels all over Cuba, is that living levels of the farm-
ers, agricultural laborers, industrial workers, storekeepers, and
others are higher all along the line than for corresponding groups
in other tropical countries. This does not mean that there is no
dire poverty in Cuba, but simply that in comparative terms
Cubans are better off, on the average, than people of these other
areas.
And the Department of Commerce in a 1956 report on
Cuba, stated: "Cuban national income has reached levels
which give the Cuban people one of the highest standards
of living in Latin America." 1
Cuba's organized labor movement was one of the most
advanced in Latin America, even during Batista's regime.
1 U.S. Department of Commerce, Investment in Cuba (Washington, D.C.:
Government Printing Office, 1956), p. 184. .
2-47
Salaries were high, and even unskilled labor was paid as
much as $6 or $7 a day. Concerning labor conditions in Cuba,
Ernst Schwarz, the executive secretary of the Committee on
Latin-American Affairs of the CIO, said:
The Cuban Confederation of Labor has successfully weathered
the latest political storm caused by the Batista coup in March,
1952. It has been able so to preserve its unity and strength as a
powerful Cuban institution that even the new dictatorial regime
has not dared to touch or eliminate it. The CTC 2 has enabled the
Cuban workers to set an example to others of what can be
achieved by labor unity and strength. Wages are far, above those
paid in many other parts of the Caribbean or, for that matter,
Latin America. In addition, the eight-hour working day forms the
basis for everyone of the collective contracts concluded by the
CTC's affiliated organizations. Modern types of social protection
and insurance are provided in laws, public statutes, or union con-
tracts; while funds maintained and administered in common by
labor, employers, and the authorities provide adequate means to
put them into practice. The sugar workers' union alone, to cite
one example, disposes of such a fund in the amount of half a bil-
lion dollars, and its insurance covers medical attention, sickness,
and accidents during and out of work. The CTC, moreover, has
taken up a place of full responsibility within the Cuban com-
munity as a whole, and at present develops its own economic
program to compensate for the seasonal nature of employment
and production in the sugar industry. Today, the Cpnfederation
counts more than a million members-with its 500,000 sugar work-
ers constituting the most powerful of the thirty-five national federa-
tions affiliated with it and representing every branch of industry
and agriculture on the island. The Confederation has drawn every
fifth Cuban into its ranks, and has thus obtained a .much higher
numerical degree of organization in proportion to population
than, for example, the much larger movement in the United
States.
2 Confederaci6n de Trabatadores de Cuba (Cuban Confederation of
Workers).
2-48
The labor movement in Cuba'is now under the complete
control of the Communists a.nd all the unions have become
instruments of the Ministry of Labor. Months ago free ele-
ments of Cuba's organized labor movement broke relations
with Castro, and many leaders are now in prison. Others
have taken refuge in embassies of countries which have not
as yet broken diplomatic relations with Castro, and a great
number have fled into exile in the United States. David Sal-
vador, one of Castro's closest collaborators in the 26th of.
July Movement against Batista, is at present in prison, and
it has been rumored that he will be executed.
Many of the labor leaders in exile are now united in the
Cuban Revolutionary Democratic Labor Front (Frente Ob-
rero Revolucionario Democratico Cubano ), known by its ini-
tials, FORD. This FORD group belongs to the Cuban Revo-
lutionary Democratic Front, headed by Dr. Manuel A. de
Varona. What makes FORD especially significant is that it
includes some of the most highly qualified trade unionists
with first-class revolutionary credentials. Most of them had
risked their lives in the revolt against Batista, and they are
now taking steps which might lead to action against Castro.
Among these exiled leaders are many who only last Decem-
ber led demonstrations of the powerful electrical workers in
front of the presidential palace, shouting "Cuba yes, Russia
"
no.
Free trade unionism in Cuba is dead. In its place the Cas-
tro regime has introduced factory committees, workers' coun-
cils-Cuba-style soviets-which establish the work norms, the
schedules, the incentives, and the wage scales. Hard-won
labor standards achieved by trade unions through collective
bargaining have been cut 50 per cent. Now discipline is the
key word. Workers are exploited and local leadership is
2-49
* * * * *
It was near the lumber camp of Pino del Agua that we killed the
magnificent horse which the imprisoned corporal had been riding.
The animal was useless to us in such craggy terrain, and we were
low on food. In any case, our customary diet was such that we could
not afford to disdain fresh meat, horse or otherwise. An amusing
touch was provided by our prisoner. As, unaware, he drank his
horse soup and ate his portion of horse meat, he explained that the
animal had been lent him by a friend whose name and address
he gave us, urging us to return it to him as soon as possible.
That day on the radio we learned of the sentencing of our
comrades from the "Granma." In addition, we learned that a
magistrate had cast his personal vote against the sentence. This was
Magistrate Urrutia, whose honorable gesture later brought him the
nomination as provisional President of the Republic. The personal
vote of a magistrate was no more than a worthy gesture-as it
clearly was at that time-but its subsequent consequences were more
serious: it led to the appointment of a bad president, a man in-
capable of understanding the revolutionary process, incapable of
digesting the profundity of a revolution which was not made for
his reactionary mentality. His character and his reluctance to take
a definite stand brought many conflicts. Finally, in the days
celebrating the first post-revolutionary July 26, it culminated in his
From pages 105-125, Reminiscences 0/ the Cuban Revolutionary War, by Che u e ~ a r a Copyright c 1968
by Monthly Review Press; reprinted by permission of Monthly Review Press at USACGSC and may not be
further reproduced in whole or in part without express permission of the copyright owner.
4-34
resignation as President when faced with unanimous rejection by
the people.
On one of those days a contact from Santiago arrived. His name
was Andres, and
he had exact information about the weapons:
they were safe, and would be moved shortly. A delivery point was
fixed in the region of a coastal lumber camp operated by the Babun
brothers. The arms would be delivered with the full knowledge
of these men who felt they could doa lucrative business by helping
the Revolution. (Subsequent developments divided the family, and
three of the Babun sons have the questionable privilege of being
among those captured at the Bay of Pigs.)
It is curious to note that in that period many people tried to use
the Revolution for their own ends by doing small favors for us in
order later to reap rewards from the new government. The Babun
brothers hoped later to have a free hand in the commercial ex-
ploitation of the forestS, all the while pitilessly expelling the peas-
ants, thereby increasing the size of, their latifundia. It was around
that time that we were joined by a North American journalist, the
same type as the Babun family. He was Hungarian by birth, and
his name was Andrew Saint George.
At first he only showed one of his faces, the better one, which was
simply that of a Yankee journalist. But in addition to that he
was an FBI agent. Since I was the only person in the troop who
spoke French (in those days nobody spoke English), I was chosen
to take care of him. Quite frankly, he did not seem to me as dan-
gerous as he turned out to be in our s o n ~ interview, when he
was already openly showing himself as an agent. We were walking
on the edge of Pino del Agua toward the source of the Peladero
river. These were rugged areas and we all carried heavy packs.
On the Peladero river there is a tributary, the Arroyo del Indio.
Here we spent a couple of days, getting food and moving the arms
we had received. We passed through a few peasant settlements
and established a kind of extra-legal revolutionary state, leaving
4-35
sympathizers who were to inform us of anything that happened and
to tell us of the Army's movements. But we always lived in the
wooded mountains; only occasionally, at night, did we urtexpectedly
reach a group of houses ahd then some of us slept in them. But the
majority always slept under the protection of the mountains, and
during the day all of us were on guard, protected by a roof of trees.
Our worst enemy at that time of year was the macagiiera, a
species of horsefly which hatches and lays its eggs in the tree
called Macagua or Macaw tree. At a certain time of year it
reproduces prolifically in the mountains. The macaguera bites
exposed areas of the body; as we scratched, what with all the dirt
on our bodies, the bites were easily infected and caused abscesses.
The uncovered parts of our legs, our wrists, and our necks always
bore proof of the presence of the macagiiera.
Finally, on May 18, we received news of the weapons and also a
tentative inventory. This news caused great excitement in the camp,
for all the men wanted better weapons. We also heard that the
film made by Bob Taber had been shown in the United States
with great success. This news cheered everyone but Andrew Saint
George, who, in addition to being an FBI agent, had his petty
journalist's pride, and he felt somewhat cheated of glory. The next
day he left in a yacht for Santiago de Cuba.
That day we also found out that one of our men had deserted.
Since everyone at the camp knew of the arrival of the weapons, this
was especially dangerous. Scouts were sent to look for him. They
returned with the news that he had managed to take a boat to
Santiago. We assumed that it was to inform the authorities, al-
though later it came out that the desertion was simply brought
about by the man's physical and moral inability to endure the hard-
ships of our life. In any case, we had to double our precautions. Our
struggle against the lack of physical, ideological, and moral prepara-
tion among the men was a daily one; the results were not always
encouraging. The weaker men often asked permission to leave for
4-36
the most petty reasons, and if they were refused, they would usually
desert. We must remember that desertion was punishable by death
directly upon capture.
That night the w ~ p o s arrived. For us it was the most marvelous
spectacle in the world: the instruments of death were on exhibition
before the covetous eyes of all the men. Three tripod machine
guns, three Madzen automatic rifles, nine M-I carbines, ten Johnson
automatic rifles, and a total of six thousand rounds were delivered.
Although the M-I carbines had only forty-five rounds apiece, they
were highly prized weapons, and they were distributed according
to the acquired merits of the men and their time in the Sierra. One
of the M-I'S was given to the present-day Major Ramiro Valdes, and
two went to the advance guard which Camilo commanded. The
other four were to be used to cover the tripod machine guns. One of
the automatics went to Captain Jorge Sotus' platoon, another to Al-
meida's and the third to the General Staff (I had the responsibility
for operating it). The tripods were distributed as follows: one for
Raul, another for Guillermo Garda, and the third for Crescencio
Perez. In this way, I made my debut as a fighting guerrilla, for until
then I had been the troop's doctor, knowing only occasional combat.
I had entered a new stage.
I shall always remember the moment I was given the automatic
rifle. It was old and of poor quality, but to me it was an important
acquisition. Four men were assigned to help me with this weapon.
These four guerrillas have subsequently followed very different
paths: two of them were the brothers Pupo and Manolo Beat6n,
executed by the Revolution after they murdered Major Cristino
Naranjo and fled to the Sierras de Oriente, where a peasant captured
them. Another was a boy of fifteen who was almost always to carry
the enormous weight of the equipment for the automatic. He was
Joel Iglesias, and today is the President of the 16t1enes Rebeldes and
a major in the Rebel Army. The fourth man, today a lieutenant, was
named Onate, but we affectionately labeled him CantinBas.
4-37
The arrival of the weapons did not mean 'lin end to our attempt
at instilling greater ideological and fighting force in the troop. A
few days later, on May 23, Fidel ordered new discharges, among
them an entire squad, and,our force was reduced to 127 men, the
majority of them armed and about eighty of them well armed.
From the squad which, along with its leader, was dismissed,
there remained one man named Crucito who later became one of
our best-loved fighters. Crucito was a natural poet and he had long
rhyming matches with the city-poet, Calixto Morales. Morales had
arrived on the "Granma" and had nicknamed himself "nightingale
of the plains," to which Crucito in his guajiro ballads always an-
swered with a refrain, directed in mock derision at Calixto: Soy
guacaico de la Sierra: "I'm an old Sierra buzzard."
This magnificent comrade had written the whole history of the
Revolution in ballads which he composed at every rest stop as he
puffed on his pipe. Since there was very little paper in the Sierra, he
composed the ballads in his head, so that none of them remained
when a bullet put an end to his life in the battle of Pino del Agua.
In the timber belt we received the invaluable help of Enrique
L6pez, an old childhood friend of Fidel and Raul, who was at
that time employed by the Babuns and served as a supply contact.
He also made it possible for us to move through the entire area
without danger. This region was full of roads used by army trucks;
several times we prepared unsuccessful ambushes aimed at captur-
ing some trucks. Perhaps these failures contributed to the success
of the approaching operation. This victorious battle was to have
greater psychological impact than any other in the history of the
war. I refer to the battle of EI Uvero.
On May 25, we heard that an expeditionary force led by Calixto
S:inchez had arrived in the boat "El Corintia" and had landed at
Mayari; a few days later we were to learn of the disastrous result
of this expedition: Prio [Socarr:is] sent his men to die without ever
bothering to accompany them. The news of this landing showed us
4-38
the'absolute necessity for diverting the enemy forces in order to
allow those men to reach some place where they could reorganize
and begin their actions. We did all this out of solidarity with the
other group, although we did not even know its social composition
oritstruegoals.
Atthis point we had aninterestingdiscussion, led principally by
myself and Fidel. I was of the opinion that we ought not lose the
opportunity of capturing a truck and that we should devote our-
selves to ambushing them on the roads where they passed un.
concernedly. ButFidel had already planned the action at EI Uvero,
and he thought thatit would be much more important and would
bringus amoreresoundingsuccess if we captured the Armypostat
EI Uvero. If we succeeded, it would have a tremendous moral
impactand would be spoken of throughout thecountry; this would
not happen with the capture of a truck, which could be reported
as a highway accident with a few casualties and, although people
would suspect the truth, our effective fighting presence in the
Sierra would never be known. This did not mean that we would
totally reject the idea of capturing a truck, under optimum con-
ditions; but we should not convert this into the focal point of our
activities.
Today, several years after that discussion (which at the time did
not convince me) I must recognize that Fidel's judgment was
correct. It would have bc:en much less productive for us to carry
out an isolated action against one of the patrols which travelled in
the trucks. At that period, our eagerness to fight always led us
impatiently to adopt drastic attitudes; perhaps we could not yet
see the more distant objectives. In any case, we began the final
preparationsforthebattleofEIUvero.
4-39
* * * * :Ii
Having decided on the point of attack, we then had to work
out exactly the form it would take; we had to solve such im-
portant problems as ascertaining the number of soldiers present,
the number of guard posts, the type of communications they used,
the access roads, the civilian population and its distribution, etc.
In all of this we were admirably served by Comrade Caldero, today
a major, who was, I believe, the son-in-law of the administrator of
the lumber camp.
We assumed that the Army had more or less exact data on our
presence in the area, for two informers had been captured and they
carried Army identification documents and confessed to being
sent by Casillas to ascertain our position and our customary meet-
ing places. The spectacle of the two men begging for mercy was
truly repugnant, but at the same time pathetic. However, the laws
of war, in those difficult times, could not be ignored, and both spies
were executed the following day.
That same day, May 27, the General Staff met with all the officers
and Fidel announced that within the next forty-eight hours we
would be fighting. He ordered us to have our men and their
weapons ready for the march. We were not given details at that point.
Caldero would be the guide, for he knew the post of El Uvero
well: its entrances and exits, and its roads of access. That night we
4-40
m
:nr
@
CD
@
CD
DIAGRAM OF COMBAT POSITIONS'
1_ Enemy POltl 1. Rebel Staff Headquarters
II - Sugar Plant 2. a ~ Caltro
III _ Barracks 3. Juan Almeida
IV - Lumber Company Installations 4. Jorge S o t ~ s
5. Guillermo Garda
6. Camllo Clenfuegos
7. Eflgenlo Amellelras
8. Crescenclo P're&
9. Che Guevara
4-41
4-42
* * * * * *
A JUNCTURE has been reached at which political maneuvers
cease to be meaningful and the voice of organized public
opinion is as futile as all other voices. Masks are discarded.
A test of strength is imminent. On one side is naked force.
On the other, the people, truth, and the dragon seed of
revolutionary doctrine, implanted most securely where the
weight of military repression is most crushing, germinating
best in blood-soaked soil, sprouting rebel soldiers overnight.
By the spring of 1958, Batista had but two choices: to
get out, or to fight desperately with all of the weapons of
his arsenal-the army, the treasury, the timidity or indiffer-
ence of investors who preferred the devil they knew to the
one unknown, the careful "neutrality" of the major foreign
power whose single word of condemnation would have been
sufficient to bring the dictatorship crashing down.
He chose to fight.
~ army sent out a call for seven thousand more men,
to bring its strength to twenty-nine thousand.
The forty national institutions-"whose names," said
Congressman Porter, "read like a roster of Who's Who
Among Respectable Organizations"-added their petition
to that of the Church, abandoning all formulae of com-
promise and now demanding, in unmistakable terms "that
the present regime shall cease to hold power . . .';
Batista's reply was to send police seeking the authors of
the petition, who fled into hiding or into exile. (The presi-
dent of the Havana Bar Association, Dr. Jose Mira Cardona,
disguised himself as a priest and hid in a church.)
5-19
Ambassador Smith, insisting that he could obtain guaran-
tees from Washington to safeguard the scheduled June elec-
tions under the existing government, asked to know why
the members of the Joint Committee of Cuban Institutions
had not signed their names to their petition. There is noth-
ing to indicate that he was joking.
Batista would have found the question both grimly amus-
ing and personally reassuring. He had his problems, multi-
plying on every hand, but he must have perceived that, if
all of the pressures of Church and secular society could
not crack the foundations of the dictatorship nor alienate
his principal allies, then he had little to fear but force. And
this he did not fear.
The capital seemed secure, despite the ravages of the
revolutionary campaign in the countryside. The provincial
cities remained under control. The big military garrisons
were in safe hands, and Batista's military intelligence told
him, quite accurately, that his enemies were as yet incapable
of posing a serious military threat against him, however
much they might harass him in the hinterland.
His concern, then, was with terrorism, sabotage, civil
insurrection. Here, too, he felt confident, having leave, ap-
parently, to fight fire with fire, so long as he did it discreetly,
muffling the cries of the casualties under a blanket of
censorship, hiding the true situation behind a smoke screen
of "anti-Communist" propaganda, maintaining, above all,
the myth of his military invulnerability. (Is any further
explanation needed for the "victories" produced by slaugh-
tering peasants?)
The fidelistas, and more particularly the strategists of
the Resistencia, had hoped that a paper dragon would
frighten away Batista's backers, that to create an atmosphere
of insurrection, to threaten the economy without actually
damaging it to any great degree, to militate all segments
of society against the dictator and so discredit him, would
5-20
"
be'sufficient to destroy the regime. Now itwas being dis-
covered, bitterly, that force alone could win respect.
It is with this unhappy realization that the revolution
moves into its"final, military phase, opening indisaster and
bitter anti-climax, ending in a triumph the more surprising
and overwhelming because of what preceded it.
In March the resistance leaders in the cities were still
looking for a short-cut to their objective. It was barely
possible, at least in theory, that they might have found one.
A general strike in the Thirties had given the Machado
regime its coup de grace. *There was more recent encour-
agement to follow such a course, notably the overthrow of
Perez Jimenez, the Venezuelan dictator, in January, 1958.
Batista's position had been appreciably weakened; rebel
strength had increased throughout the island; revolutionary
sentiment was running high among the people. The National
Direction of the M-26, having better understanding of the
actual situation inthe Sierra Maestra than did Batista, anti
anxious to avoid the long campaign that seemed inevitable
if based primarily on military strategy and growth, resolved
to commit their entire resources to what they hoped would
be a final, crushing blow against Batista, a revolutionary
general strike.
Fidel was opposed. He may well have had political con-
siderations in mind. He certainly had serious doubts as to
the possibility of such a solution.
His own appraisal of the resources of the revolution and
those of the dictator told him that only the steady growth
of the process that had started in the Sierra Maestra, the
gradual extension of territaria libre, the day by day ex-
* But not before Franklin Roosevelt, in one of the happier exercises of
the Good Neighbor policy, had whisked the diplomatic rug out from
under Machado's feet and the latter's army had deserted him. In Vene-
zuela, too, military defection preceded a popular rising, It is, in fact,
difficult to find a modern instance in which a mere rising of the people,
unsupported by troops, has overthrown an entrenched regime.
5-21
pansion of the 'rebel fighting force and the elimination, one
by one, of the government outposts,' could cut the lifelines
of the dictatorship.
He did not believe that'the underground was adequately
prepared for a general uprising, despite assurances to the
contrary. He had little faith in Havana, with its large foreign
population, its Spanish merchant class, which formed the
backbone of Cuban conservatism, its traditional disaffection
from the struggles of the nation, its historical position as
the exploiter of the wealth-producing provinces.
He was well aware of the firm grip in which Batista held
organized labor, under the domination of Eusebio Mujal
and his C.T.C. and he recalled all too vividly the fiasco of
the August strike. Having had some early experience of a
similar disaster on a larger scale-as a youngster fighting
briefly on the side of insurrectionary students and police
against the Colombian armed forces in the "bogotazo" of
1947*-he had no illusions concerning such efforts.
He was nevertheless persuaded, against his better judg-
ment.
The Sierra Maestra manifesto of March 12th, agreed upon
by the National Direction of the Movimiento 26, called for
a revolutionary general strike, backed by the armed action
of the revolutionary fighting forces, as the basis of a final
"decisive" blow against Batista.
Other articles in the 21-point declaration of war tended
to support the impression that all would be gambled on a
single cast of the dice-winner take all.
Directions were given for the organization and direction
* He says that his involvement was quite accidental. He was in
Bogota, Columbia, in the summer of 1947, as a delegate of the Havana
FEU, to help make arrangements for an international student conference,
and when fighting broke out, he went along with the Colombian students
in whose company he happened to find himself at the moment, acting on
pure impulse. The uprising was put down, a truce was declared, and
Fidel, then nineteen years old, fled to the Cuban Embassy. The next day
he was flown home, with some other Cuban students.
5-22
men.
The effect produced by this measure among the civilian and
the military population also favored the rebels who, until that
moment, had not commanded enough resources to be consid-
ered belligerents.
The calls for general strikes, accompanied by terrific threats,
which were launched by the head of the Anarcho-Communist
movement, failed. The attitude of organized labor, both as
individuals and as corporate bodies (about 2,000,000 mem-
bers) demonstrated that the rebels lacked popular support. The
commercial streets, the expensive and the cheaper shops, the
theaters and the movies, the hotels and cabarets were crowded
with people from all walks of life. The position taken by the
Cuban Confederation of Labor, the Federations of Industries
and other associations, as well as the manner in which society
went about its business-consuming, spending, and living a
normal and happy existence-prove that the Cuban people were
not only opposed to subversion, but that they also opposed the
violence and terror which, unscrupulously and criminally, were
carried out by the Castro group.
* The United States embargo of arms was a great victory for Fidel
Castro, says Mrs. Phillips in her book (page 351).
5-47
Section III. HOW CASTRO WON
UST WEST OF GUANTANAMO CITY lies a bend in the Central
Highway which is a text-book ambush site-a horseshoe of asphalt almost
a mile from end to end lined every yard on both sides by steep ridges
thick with jungle growth. One hot mornmg early in December, 1958, the
curve was ready for its tate. At eacn end, several 200-pound mines lay
under the road surface and near them, a hidden rebelde rested with sweaty
hands close to the plunger. Seven light m ~ i n e guns were emplaced in the
greenery of the rocky slope, the nearest 40 yards from the road and the
most distant almost on top of the ridge. More than 200 riflemen, many
with automatic weapons, were dug in, two and three to a hole, along the
rise.
But the bearded officer, Capitano Jose Valla, who before the war had
btlen a traffic clerk in an import firm, was not .satisfied.
His people had been manning this ambush site now for thirteen oays,
and in that time they had eaten thirteen .meals. So lie. did not think they
were alert any more. As he walked his lines, he told them they could ex-
pect to be hit at any hour now by a column of Batista's troops many
By Dickie Chapelle from Modem Guer.rilla Warfare ,edited by Franklin Mark Osanka, pages 325-335.
Reprinted by permission of the copyright holder. the Marine Corps Association, publisher of the Marine
Corps Gazette, professional journal for Marine officers. Copyright 1960 by Marine Corps Association.
Reproduced at USACGSC by special permission and may not be further reproduced in whale or in part with-
out express permission of the copyright holder'.
5-48
hundred strong. Other rebel forces were besieging one of the government's
fortresses, that in the town of La Maya ten miles farther west, and he
predicted a relief column would be dispatched to them from the army
garrison at Guantanamo City.
But the captain was increasingly aware that he had given these same
troops this same word every other morning on the site, too.
So today he decided to change the disposition of his forces.
He sent 40 riflemen and an LMG with its crew two miles up the road.
There was an ambush spot there, too, a bush-covered slope lining the left
of the road for a thousand yards. His orders to this advance guard he re-
peated .twice.. They were to hide in. the jungle grass, fire on the relief
column when it was at the pOint nearest them, then leapfrog in three's
and four's back through the cane fields to the main ambush area, keeping
the convoy under fire only as long as they could do it without exposing
themselves.
"That will do no harm and make enough noise so everyone will be
wide awake before we're really hit," he finished.
Just before noon, the enemy column did appear. There was a lead
jeep, an armored car, a tank, three busses heavily loaded with troops, a
rearguard jeep-and one element the captain had not thought about, air
cover. Two Cuban Air Force B-26's were flying wide figure 8's along the
road at an altitude of about 1,000 feet.
The rebels of the advance gnard, well concealed behind chunky bushes
and wide-bladed grass, opened fire. The machine gunner accounted for the
driver and the officer in the lead jeep anc;l a burst from a. BAR killed three
soldiers in the front seat of the first bus. The convoy halted dead in the
road. A handful of soldiers in the crowded busses wrestled their weapons
into firing position but they could not see a target. Neiti'.'lr could the tank
crew, slowly traversing their 77rmn.
Nor could the men in the B-26's. But they knew the fire had come
from the green hillside and they began to strafe it from end to end. They
so persistently stitched back and forth that the rebels one by one looked
quickly up, hesitated and then fell back behind their concealment. A half
dozen began to empty their. weapons at the planes. One B-26 gunner
opened fire with his 20mm. He hit downslope from the rebels, and most
of them continued to empty clip after clip aU the stalled convoy.
The men in the driverless bus panicked and fled back through the
ditches to the cover of nearby cane fields; a scorc r p ~ their rifles as
they ran and three fell wounded or dying. The drivers of the other two
busses backed them for perhaps 50 yards, loaded the men WJ;lO had
been hit, then U-turned where they were to cover the busses. Then the
whole column, leaving only the two wrecked vehicles, was grinding out,
faster and faster, to the east.
5-49
It was all over in a matter of minutes-allover, that is, but for the
verbal pyrotechnics of the rebel captain when the leader of his advance
guard reported. The captam pulled him behind the deserted building of a
cantina near the main ambush site.
"My orders were that you should fire and withdraw, fire and with-
drawl" he shouted over and over at his red-faced junior.
"We would have, we would have, my captain, but that we had no cover
from the 13-26 and-" the lieutenaht began.
"Your excuse shames our dead!" The captain interrupted. "If you had
done what I told you to do, we would have>captured the whole convoy,"
he wenton, rocking on his toes. "This way, what do we-have'! Two wrecks
and some blood on the Central Highway! And thatJs all there is to show-
for 13 days of waiting!"
He opened his hands and put them over his bearded face. The lieu-
tenant turned and walked slowly out of [he yard of the deserted cantina.
Capt Valle probably stated the net tactical gain to the rebel campaign
correctly. But to a looker-on and possibly to the historians, the action was
more significant. It was almost a vignette of the Cuban revolution, an
answer to the question: how did Castro's riflemen time and again turn
back Batista's tanks and planes?
My own conclusion was that they earned all the real estate by maKing
every mistake in the book-but one. They consistently delivered a high vol-
ume of fire. After they started shooting, they rarely let anything-the
enemy's reaction or their own commander's orders-stop them from con-
tinuing to fire until there was nothing left to fire on.
They barely aimed and they did not conserve ammunition. But they
unmistakably communicated their will to fight to an enemy whose superior
equipment was unmatched by the will to use it.
Here is a report from the Cuban fighting:
Personnel
The forc.es of Castro at the time I knew them moved and fired as an
army, not a band 01' mob. Fidel estimated there were 7300 in uniform
(blue or green cotton drill fatigues) by the third week in December. They
were directly supportt:d by an equal number of personnel under military
orders whose dunes included work in towns still policed by Batista and
who hence wore civilian clothing. One in ten of the fighters was a
non-Cuban-Dominican, Mexican, Venezuelan, Nicaraguan, Argentinian.
About one in twenty was a woman; except for one sniper platoon, the
women in uniform were non-combatan:1S who did housekeeping and supply
assignments.
5-50
The basic unit of the rebel army was a 40-man platoon commanded
by a second lieutenant. The rebels insisted there were no differences iii.
rate among the non-officer personnel; in practice, I noticed many "natural
NCO's" with their own following of from six' to a dozen men. The officer
. .
ranks were the same as U.S. ranks lip to major, or commandante, still the
highest rank in Cuban military forces. (The single star on the Cuban Prime
minister's epaulets today signifies this rank, as it did during the fighting.)
In the field, I worked with the command groups of three majors beside
the Castros. Each led about 500 men and 20-odd officers.
This simplified table of organization was reflected in the division of
responsibilities. What we consider S-l functions were almost entirely car-
ried out by the senior officer or his top aides personally. The S-2 and S-4
work was done by. men in mufti. This left the uniformed forces the single
primary concern of operations.
The staffs had no problems of pay-no pay, hence no problem-or of
recruitment, since there were more would-be Fidelistas than rifles with
which to arm them. The sure method by which the volunteer became a
barbudo! was to disarm one of Batista's soldiers (by force or purchase)
and hike into a Castro command post with his rifle, ammo and canteen.
One bOy'of 15 had to be accepted when he reported with a BAR which
he insisted he had gotten the hard way.
More than half the rebelde fighters I knew had been field hands in
the cane fields or coffee plantations of Oriente Province. But a high pro-
portion of the others had city. backgrounds and white collar. experience,
so the over-all literacy rate was very high for Cuba. Probably the most
capable battalion officers (now 0-3 of the Cuban Rebel Army) was
Commandante Antonio Lusson,whose family owns a large cane planta-
tion near to ~ Castro family's own fields.
Most of the enlisted men I knew had undergone a basic training stint
of from two to four months in the most remote reaches of the Sierra
Maestre mountains. They had learned scouting and patrolling there (one
had a copy of FM 21-75 in his pack) but the primary purpose of the
training obviously was to condition the men to extended periods of hunger
and fatigue, to find out which would literally rather fight than eat. Not
many had learned to use their weapons effectively nor to maintain them
in the field; those who had became prized men. But the barbudos almost
without exception had developed a genuine espritde corps.
The wide dissimilarity of military capability among them was prob-
ably less significant than the one common motivation. All Castro's fighting
men were terror victims to the extent that they believed they would be
killed if they went back to their homes while Batista remained in power.
I knew dozens who showed me what they said were marks of torture on
1. "Bearded one"-enrolled regular in Castro's army.
5-51
their bodies, or who told me how they had buriM the bullet-rieldied bodies
of their fathers, sons or brothers.
"I always knew Latins could hate that much, but not that they could
hate that long," is a comment 1 have heard about them. One explanation
is the conviction most of them expressed that they as individuals could
not expect to live if they did not destroy the Batistianos who were then still
policing their home communities.
. The other side of the coin-the personal motivation of government
forces-was a particular target of psychological assault from the first.
Before 1 left the United States, the Castro underground in New York
briefed me on the tactics this way: "We return prisoners without even
intimidating them. We do not exchange them, you understand; not one
of ours has ever been returned in the field. But we just disarm our enemies
when we capture them and send them back through the Cuban Red Cross."
1 was cynical about this claim and once in Cuba, 1 remarked to a rebel
officer that 1 would. be much surprised to see unintimidated, unwounded
prisoners being returned, not exchanged, in the middle of a shooting war.
This remark was a mistake..
That same evening, 1 watched the surrender of hundreds of Batistianos
from a small town garrison. They were gathered within a hollow square
of rebel Tommy gunners and harangued by Raul Castro.
"We hope that you will stay with us and fight against the master who
so ill-used you. If you decide to refuse this invitation--and 1 am not
going to repeat it-you will be delivered to the custody of the Cuban Red
Cross tomorrow. Once you are under Batista's orders again, we hope that
you will not take up arms agains us. But, if you do, remember this-
"We took you tPis time. We can take you again. And when we do,
we will not frighten or torture or kill you, any more than we are doing to
you at this moment. If you are captured a second time or even a third
by us, we will again return you exactly as we are doing now."
This expression of utter contempt for the fighting potential of the
defeated had an almost physical impact on them. Some actually flinched
as they listened.
The following day, 1 could not question that these men were returned
unharmed. I counted 242 across a border check-point marked by two
burned-out car wrecks overlooking Santiago de Cuba.
On the matter of casualty figures over all for the two years of active
fighting, 1 came to accept Castro's estimate of 1,000 rebel dead because
1 was able to verify personally that the rebel dead announced for the ac-
tions 1 saw were correct. (But an even more important and still contro-
versial casualty figure is the rebel total loss from terrorism in the cities
rather than military operations in the country. This is believed to be more
than 10,000 over a five-year period.)
.5-52
.Intelligence
The Fidelista combat intelligence was superb. The Batista command-
ers could not go to the "head" without a perspiring runner arriving a few
minutes later to Castro about it. Most of the informants were volun-
teers-farmers or villagers.
While the bulk of such reports was hardly marked by accuracy, Fidel
himself placed the greatest reliance on them. The night we met for the
first time, he and his command group were standing within 600 yards of
where ahuge enemypatrolwas searching for him.'I assumed he was there
to command an action to hit the patrol orcut It off.
"Oh, no," he explained. "It's too big. They are coming through the
woods in a body, with men in pairs on either side. When the nearest pair
is afew hundred meters away, people will tell me and we will leave."
Enemy scouts did in fact come in ten minutes after his departure. In
their asperity, they burned to the ground the farmer's house beside v.;:hiclt
he had been conferring. The farmer became a fighting Fidelista before the
ashes of his house had cooled, bringing a Springfield rifle he had kept
buried apparently for just this eventuality.
One tradition of the Castro forces had a special usefulness to their
intelligence--the matter of the beards. The nucleus of the Castro forces
grew thembecause therewere- no razors on l'icoTurquino where they hid.
Butin time the beards served as an identification device. When you saw a
manwith asix-monthgrowthofhairanawhiskers,youcouldbesurehehad
notbeen incontactwith the Batistasoldieryfor a long time, since to them
a beard was cause for summary arrest.
Operations
During the early months of the the onlymilitary tactic used
by the rebels was to ambush small J?,oVl'rnment patrols for their weapons.
As the patrols grew larger, the rebel&: underground furnished mines, and
the Fidelistas were able tofum backseveralpunitive thrusts made atthem
in mountains by ringing their strongholds with the mines.
Their experience in stopping movement along roads and trails led to
the tactic bywhich they won much of OrienteProvince. Itsgeneral objec-
tive was to isolate the government garrisons by halting all surface traffic.
The rebels blew up the railroad bridges first, then mined the side roads
andfinally themain artery across Cuba, the CentralHighway. Theyhalted
and burned every bus, car and tnlck;even today, the wreckage of this
phase of the campaign still litters the ditches. Non-combatants were
walked at gunpoint back to wherever they came from--except for those
5-53
5-54
abducted, including the U.S. servicemen and technicians held for 27 days
in July of 1958.
By early December, the roads and most of the countryside had come
under rebel control after dark; by daylight, nothing moved but Batista's
forces in not less than company strength and usually with tanks and air
cover.
But most town and village cuartels" were still fully garrisoned, and the
government controlled the built-up areas.
Against them, Castro's forces used three kinds of offensive action:
combat patrols, assault and encirclement. But each of these terms is only
correct in the most limited sense.
The patrols V(erenight marches, off the roads, of one or two platoons
with the objective of shaking up a garrison behind its concrete walls.
Weapons included rifles, BARs, Tommy guns and one or two LMG. On
one patrol, the men brought an 81mm mortar with five rounds for it. On
another, they carried a 20mm cannon recovered from a wrecked Cuban
Air Force plane. For it they had only notoriously undependphle home-
made ammo.
The patrols crept close to the cuartel walls (at Maffo, within 40 yards)
and opened fire. They sustained it no matter what came back at them
until their ammo ran low or, as happenjld twice, the garrison set fire to
their trucks. At San Luis, the garrison resisted two such raids vigorously
and the day after the second, withdrew in jeeps and a truck into the near-
est larger cuartel. Their column tore by a rebel ambush which happened
to be facing the wrong way and not a shot was fired.
The tactic which the ~ e l s called an assault was not an assault at all
as we use the word."lt meant the rebel commanders would infiltrate their
troops by dark to positions as close to an objective as they could find con-
cealment. They would then keep it under uninterrupted small arms fire 24
hours a day. But they would not advance nor would they use demolitions.
In the fortress at La Maya, they so trapped 525 people, 125 of them
the wives and children of government soldiers, for seventeen days. In
Maffo, there were 150 Batistianos Who held out for fourteen days and
then surrendered. The artillery available on either side was negligible. The
rebels used one 20mm cannon with comedy effect because of poor home-
made ammo, and the garrison at Maffo one night expended nine mortar
shells-presumably all it had-against a rebel sound truck that had been
haranguing the troops to surrender. On this occasion, the accuracy was
outstanding; four rebels were killed and 13 wounded.
In spite of the fact that small arms fire spattenngconcrete walls
hardly sounds effective, these encirclements of the Batista cuartels were
the decisive actiOlls of the revolution. In the fight for Santa Clara, the final
;2. Fllrtitled barracks.
and largest action, itwas a trainload of troops which the rebels encircled,
not, a fortress. And in this one case those who could fire from buildings
had better cover than the troops opposmg memo
However, in the fighting which I'saW, the.rebels only sought out con-
cealment and did almost without dug-in or sandbagged positions. Often
theyexposed themselves deliberately for no logical military purpose. Once,
when a whole platoon was disconsolate because their rifle grenades were
misfiring, their.battalion commander himself led a dozen in a charge out
of their concealment. An enemy blockhouse lay 150 yards away and per-
haps some of his men assumed that he planned to flank it. But without
grenades, demolitions or mortar fire, he charged out 50 yards, then dis-
posed his men behind the foot-high cover of the foundation of a wrecked
building, and from there emptied several BAR magazines into the con-
crete blockhouse walls. He then ran his people back through a crescendo
ofincoming fire from the blockhouse to their concealed positions. But for
skinned knees and elbows, no casualties resulted. The effect on morale
was excellent. But the blockhouse was no less lethal than before.
Why were the government garrisons unable to break out of their
cuartels and blockhouses?
Surely they could have broken the ring of besiegers. But there would
have beencasualties, and the countryside was actively hostile.
Why 'were the cuartels not reinforced? Or better resupplied?
Until the last weeks of the fighting, the larger were, in effect, rein-
forced by the fleeing garrisons from the smaIler.
But as to why these in turn did not hold out, purely tactical answers
are not enough. When the 525 people from the La Maya fortress sur-
rendered,theystillhadfood, waterand ammo. Therewere sevenwounded,
two of them dying, in the group. Nine people had been killed and buried
inside the walls (and seven of the rebels had been killed, two from the
air).The Cuban AirForcehad not been successful in its resupply efforts.
But it had never tried drops directly within the cuartel walls, presumably
because of the risk ofhitting some of the people with falling packages.
Which raises whatwas .0me agreatmystery ofthe actions I observed:
the astonishingly poorperformance of the B-26's. True, they bombed and
strafed the town of LaMaya twice a day atleast and the roads around it
atall hours. Buttheydidthis so badlythatI 'was able to photograph them
sometimestwice afterthey hadbegun theirruns andthen, usually leisurely,
tomove to shelter.
TheCubanAirForceB-26's-inpairsflying in echelon-usuallycom-
mitted in the adjoining county and then strafed'from an altitude of 300
to 500 feet. They proved they knew how to do better when they were
covering an unarmed DC-3 making a resupply drop; then they came in
at right angles to each other and went up the streets with wingtips at
housetop level.
5-55
I came to two conclusions about the curious B-26 performances:
First, the claims of the pilots at their subsequent trials that they did
everything short of to avoid killing non-combatants are en-
tirely valid. (Yon remember,J:'idel set aside two trials acquitting Ilyerll on
this issue and ordered a third, after which came executions and priSOI1
sentences. )
Second, the psychological impact of the B-26 operations on the people
of rurl\1 Cuba will be a major barrier to friendly U.S.-Cuban relations for
a generation to come, It is no use to point out that we sent Batista these
planes for another purpose and stopped sending them at all in March of
1958. The planes, no matter how poorly flown, utterly terrorized the
prol'ince and, moral judgments entirely aside, the fact is that we are
heartily hated because they caused such fear.
At the time, incidentally, the rebels, without aircraft or ack-ack, did
not ignore the planes but emptied rilles and BARs up at them no matter
what the range. I never saw a hit scored but the psychological effects were
dramatic.
Supply
This was a controlling factor in, the entire Castro offensive.
On the matter of food. alone, the rebels' survival as a cohesive fighting
unit was frequently in doubt. Being both guest and woman, I always had
more to eat than anyone else, but at one point I lived on raw sugar cane
for two days, and at another time I ate only one meal a day for five days
in a row. The characteristic "hot chow" of the rebels in the field was a
mush of rice with pieces of fresh"killed beef in it, served from a bucket
hung on a pole which was carried by two runners from one foxhole to
another.
Personal equipment was severely limited. Cotton drill shirts and P411ts
were issued,but good footwear, canteens and blarikelS were not, and the
rebelde's shoulder patches and insignia of rank were sewn anlt
embroidered by his wife or one of the village women.
How Castro received his arms and ammunition was a subject of acri-
monious international debate for a long time.
Before I went to Cuba, I was told that most weapons and ammo were
smuggled in by air from the United States, Mexico and Venezuela. Dic-
tator Batista's secretary of state once gave me a personal interview on a
holiday to complain bitterly that American laxity in arresting the smugglers
was the reason the government could not defeat the rebels.
But there is little evidence for this thesis. Recently I met a Cuban flier
who had flown arms from the United States to Cuba for months during
the revolution. He said he had been told in Miami that U.S. law enforce-
5-56
ment agencies were alerted in early 1958 to look for a fleet of heavily-
loaded station wagons and several DC-3's.
"So what we did was to fly the stuff in apairof Cessna 182's. We got
itoutto landing strips near Key West in an outboard fishing boat loaded
'ona trailer. Once I was driving the trailer and I had a flat. The police
helped me change the tire atthe side of the highway without ever looking
under the tarp which covered my boat. If they had folded it back, they
would have found twelve Tommy guns and the ammo for them."
AfterIhadbeenwith the Fidelistas for afew weeks, I no longer ques-
tioned their on-the-spot insistence that only about 15 Pllr cent of their
weapons were so "imported." All the rest, they said, were captured.
The weapons which I saw were not new, and the greatmajority were
ofthe type which we furnishedtoBatista-Springfields, M-l's, BARs and
Tommy guns. And Colt .45 automatics, many of the latter demonstrably
captured weapons with butt-plates still carrying the insignia of the Cubllrt
Army.
Inthe case of 30 cal. ammo, I saw itbeing capturedduring the battIe
ofLaMaya. Theaction around thetowninvolved more than 250rebeldes
actually firing on the 'line day and night for two and a half weeks. Yet
when the battIe was over, the rebel ammo inventory was fatter than when
it began. Four times during the siege a government DC-3 hadJIlade an
air drop (no parachute; they just pushed the packages out of the door)
ofammo for the fortress, and four times the rebels hadcharged outunder
heavy fire and dragged the packages back behind their own lines. From
these bundles the rebels also gained large quantities of medical supplies
and some of the bestcigarettes I ever smoked.
Two weapons widely used by the rebels were manufactured right in
Cuba itself by the underground.
One was the 200-pound land mine, made at first from explosive
salvaged out of unexploded aerial bombs that had been dropped by the
CubanAir Force. The mines usually were emplaced tobe detonated elec-
trically by a soldier on command.
The other homemade device was a rifle grenade which resembled no
other grenade of which I've ever heard. It was a firecracker shape about
eight inches long with a conical cap on one end. It was detonated by a
fuse of cotton string. To fire it, you affixed it to the end of a rifle, lit the
fuse and pulled the triggc:r. Intheory, the grenade exploded four seconds
later. I watched more than a score of these fired. Each time something
inhibitedthe clean get-away ofthe grenade from the rifle and itdetonated
within 50 yards of take-off.
A special logistic problem to the rebels was motor transport. Their
few dozen vehicles were jeeps, either captured from the government or
expropriated at gunpoint from oil and mir.ing companies. (I remember
there was a"duty ambulance" at the battIe Jiguani-a sky-blue enameled
5-57
panel truck marked EAT STAR CANDIES.) Impulsive driving and no main-
tenance" at all constantly reduced the availability of vehicles. But the
limited mileage of roads and jeepable tracks in rural Cuba probably re-
duced the importance of motor transport to both sides in the fighting.
Summary
At the climax of the revolution, the personnel in the field under Fidel
Castro's direct orders numbered about 15,000, half in uniform, including
a high proportion of men mentally and physically superior. There was
ultimate motivation throughout, and discipline within small units was good.
The men were almost totally lackh'1g in marksmanship ability, conven-
tional military know-how, and eJ[perience in fighting as a cohesive force
of any size. Their attitude toward their enemies was one of contempt
leavened with compassion.
Their combat intelligence was unexcelled in quantity and of depend-
able accuracy. It was not org-mized on any military basis but originllted
in the civilian population which felt itself a direct participant in every
action, and generally welcomed the rebels as liberators from terrorism.
The Castro defensive operations depended largely on this intelligence
and on foot mobility; the rebels simply did not remain where they were
sought.
Their offensive operations rested on tactics involving the highest degree
of surprise,. the fewest men, the lowest risk and the greatest freedom to
disengage. These included road ambushes, raiding patrols, infiltration, and
sustained siege by small arms fire. No dependence on artillery or motor
transport was developed.
Their logistics were primitive and in other than the near-ideal weather
and terrain conditions of Cuba would have been disastrous. Their food
supply 'Was not adequate by any ordinary standard. Their primary source
of arms and ammunition was the enemy, although perhaps 15 per cent
were smuggled into Cuba.
Their conspicuous military virtue was their ability to maintain a high
volume of fire under conditions which would have discouraged less moti-
vated fighters. This virtue fully exploited the major weakness of the well-
equipped government forces, which was a near-paralysis of the will to
fire at all. If there is any military lesson from the Cuban revolution 'for
all Americans, in and out of uniform, I think this is .it:
Machinery does not win wars. Men do.
5-58
Seelion IV. THE INSURGENTS EXPAND INTO LAS VILLAS PROVINCE
WE KNEW OF the daring plan to transfer rebel groups from
Oriente to Las Villas.
Individuals and even families who served the country gener-
ously and patriotically had been victimized because chiefs or
agents imprudently mentioned their names in connection with
their services. We therefore ordered the commands to omit real
names, even in private conversation when referring to their ac-
tivities or to data obtained from reliable sources. Even the Pres-
ident of the Republic was to receive his report in this new for-
mat. For example: X-3 would signify information which was
probably true, delivered by someone who could be trusted, but
who had not been in direct contact with the facts; X-4 would be
genuinely true information. Through these channels we would
be informed of the movements and important concentrations of
the enemy.
This system greatly reduced the possibility of the enemy
learning our sources of information. It permitted our leaders to
know those who might sabotage the military and political plans
of the Government from inside or out.
The reports coming from X-3 and X-4 made me certain that
the groups of saboteurs directed by Fidel Castro's lieutenants
were trying to put into effect a plan to destroy communications
(highways, roads, railways, telephone and telegraph) in the en-
tire Province of Las Villas. This plan to cut the Island in two
was to be put in operation the second half of December and was
to be completed in January.
From pages 84-91, 110-114, and 127-133, Fulgencio Batista, Cuba Betrayed (New York, Vantage
Press. Inc., 1962). Reprinted with permission of the publishers at USACGSCand may not be further repro-
duced in whole or in part without express permission of the copyright owner.
5-59
The plan included the isolation of each squadron, company
and military post defending the centers of population and the
surrounding rural areas. With rebel infiltration to the North and
to the South, the movement of our troops would be severely
limited.
Isolation of the Provinces
The Joint Chief of Staff called the commander of Las Villas
to warn him of the danger to the towns if they were cut off from
all communication. When Rio Chaviano came to Havana, I per-
sonally ratified the orders given by Gen. Tabernilla Dolz.
The section of the Central highway between Santa (;lara and
Jatibonico joins the main highways which connect the North and
the South with the Central area and, at the same time, with the
Eastern region through Camagiiey and with the Western region,
passing through Matanzas and the city of Havana. The extreme
section of Pinar del Rio Province, west of Havana, would be of
little or no importance, if the capital could not communicate
with the other provinces. This section of the Central Highway
has very important bridges which, once destroyed, would re-
quire many days of labor, under heavy guard, to repair.
When the rebels began to destroy the bridges and highways,
to cut off Oriente and isolate the capital, the former service of
Highway Patrol (Vigilancia de Carreteras) was reorganized.
For the highest efficiency, its units were given patrol cars
manned by a crew of four, each fully armed. They made their
runs in pairs, staying only one kilometer apart and communi-
cating by radio-telephone.
Preference was given to the Eastern Provinces and to Las
Villas. The General Staff ordered the cars into service as soon
as they were available, for sabotage was increasing.
5-60
* * * * * * *
THE SO-CALLED INVADING columns which had left the Sierra
Maestra for Las Villas arrived at Camagiiey almost without en-
countering the regular troops. To go f110m the Bayamo zone to
Jobabo, which formed the boundary of Camagiiey with Oriente,
the rebels had "acquired" the services of Lieuts. Rodolfo Villa-
mil and Ubineo Leon who, for money (according to statements
of enemy officers), permitted them to cross the area without dif-
ficulty. *In one of the "Kangaroo" trials, held like a Roman cir-
cus, one of the rebel chiefs is said to have declared that it cost
the invaders many thousands of dollars to get to Camagiiey
Province. Thiswas in answer to Col. Victor Duenas' statement
that he had been sympathetic to their cause.
Upon relieving Col. Duenas of his command because of in-
efficiency, the General Staff of the Army appointed Col. Leo-
poldo Perez Coujil to replace him. Under his leadership the
reinforced troops made contact with the rebel columns that had
*Capt. Humberto Olivera Perez refers to Maj. Armando Gonzalez
Finales as a double traitor who, for a fee, allowed the Castro guerrillas
to pass through territory under his command. When the Castro hordes
took over on January 1st, 1959, Gonzalez Finales was under arrest for
his treacherous conduct. He was liberated by Guevara and designated
chief of the Army purging commission.
Capt. Rodriguez Tamayo said that he had personally dealt with
Lieutenants Rodolfo Villamil and Ubineo Le6n in the purchase of the
Charco Redondo Mines Army post in Oriente province. The deal in-
cluded the arms and ammunitions, as also the soldiers. Rodriguez
Tamayo added that Castro congratulated him on the deal and that he
personally paid $50,000 to Lieutenants Villamil and Le6n who, there-
upon joined the rebel forces with 48 men and all the equipment.
"Through this office in the Department of the Adjutant General, Lieut.
Rodolfo Villamil tried more than once to set up a conspiracy. Villamil
and another officer, Lieut. Le6n, began to sound out the spirit of the
troops, with their eyes on a possible internal conspiracy ... a letter from
Fidel Castro, their old buddy of student days at Belen School and the
Alma Mater, found them at their camp in Cerro Pelado." (Bohemia,
Jan. 11, 1959.)
5-61
advanced into Camagiiey. The Field Commander of these troops
was Armando Suarez Susquet, who kept his men mobile and
showed great courage without ruthlessness. He was seriously
wounded in action. .
Despite the strategic distribution of the Rural Guard and the
reinforcements sent to Camagiiey, the rebel columns, supported
by a few rural industrialists, penetrated Las Villas Province and
took over the military posts, widening their activities into the
lowlands and along the inter-urban highways.
Itshould be noted that certain company officers, like Capt.
Abon Lee, were active and loyal and tried to prevent the cross-
ing of the Red-Black groups over the extreme end of Camagiiey
Province. The tactics used, however, failed.
* * * * * * *
To DEFEAT THE groups which the rebels now called "columns,"
new troops were sent to Las Villas. The squadrons of the Rural
Guard, and the infantry units stationed at headquarters, had
been reinforced. Some 10 companies, each composed of 100
men, were working to dislodge the rebel infiltrations operating
weakly in the mountains of the Central Range, south of Santa
Clara. These troops were reinforced by three large battalions,
each formed by more than 400 men. This contingent and the
new Highway Pj:l:trol should have been able to open an efficient
attack. Unfortunately, the leadership was inadequate and the
operation failed.
In Oriente Province it had taken the rebels almost two years
to immobilize the military detachments; in Las Villas, with Rio
Chaviano as chief of the military district, they succeeded in
weeks. The opportune warning of the plan to break the com-
*Lieut. Col. Armando Suarez Susquet was removed from the mili-
tary hospital while seriously ill, and brought to Camagiiey, where he
was shot, almost in a state of unconsciousness, under orders of "Com-
mander Huber Matos, "military chief" of the Province.
5-62
munication lines of Las Villas-given a month and a half previ-
ously-had served little purpose. By the beginning of December,
important bridges on the Central Highway, designated by the
Army Central Staff as those marked by the rebels for destruc-
tion, were being attacked and destroyed.
What seemed without basis, or merely rumors, was becoming
actual fact, and there was a growing distrust of the guilty chiefs.
To repair the bridges which had been dynamited or destroyed
with blow-torches, as well as great stretches of the Central High-
way and others, an operation was hurriedly formed which in-
cluded the Commission of National Development, the Ministry
of Public Works, important sections of the railroads, and the
Army Corps of Engineers. The Development Commission made
its budgets and arranged for the employment of workers and
technicians who would carry out the reconstruction under the
protection of numerous mobile squadrons. The Western Rail-
ways (Ferrocarriles Occidentales) prepared a train with ar-
mored cars and coaches, electric plants, and tools. The armored
train-as it was called-could move 600 men into the affected
~ e s To increase the efficiency of this service the last available
arms in the main garrisons of Havana were collected. The train
would be undel1 the command of the Chief of the Engineer
Corps, Col. Florentino Rosell y Leyva, under whose supervision
it was armored and equipped. The Chief of the Engineer Corps,
was to carry out the plan, which would effect fast reconstruc-
tion of the roads.
More Men for R,o Chaviano
At that time some of our units had been isolated due to the de-
struction of the roads. Other units had been needlessly sur-
rendered, through the strange conduct of their chiefs who let
themselves be cut off so easily.
5-63
.
One midnight, a week before the desertion of Col. Rosell, the
Chief of the Joint General Staff, accompanied by Gen. Rio
Chaviano, military chief of !--as Villas, came to see me at Ciudad
Militar. Gen. Tabernilla told me that the military chief of Las
Villas wanted to inform me personally of the serious situation
facing the territory under his command. He read a report out-
lining the situation and the urgent need for more men and arms,
although there were neither reserves of troops nor available
arms. Col. Rosell was ordered to organize immediately the train
and the 600 men for the road repairs. He was to set out at once
and work in combination with Rio Chaviano to destroy the en-
emy and regain the lost zones, and to reconstruct the highway
and railway wherever possible. The two remained in contact
with Gen. Francisco Tabernilla Dolz and informed him the next
day that the situation was most serious, that it was too late to
do battle in the provinces. This strange statement had been pre-
ceded by three weeks of continuous surrender or withdrawal of
military groups.
The following night Col. Irenaldo Garcia Baez, Chief of Mil-
itary Intelligence, visited me at the Presidential Palace. He in-
formed me that the Joint Chief of Staff had held conversations
in his office with Gen. Alberto del Rio Chaviano and Col. Flo-
rentino Rosell before departing on the mission. He said that in
his capacity as head of the SIM he had been at the headquarters
of the General Staff and had incidentally attended this meeting.
Among those present, he said, had been Gen. Eulogio Cantillo,
Gen. "Silito" Tabernilla Palmero, Chief of the Infantry Division
and Commissioner of the President's Military Office. He report-
ed to me-said Lieut. Col. Garcia Baez-because he was aston-
ished to hear the instructions which the Chief of the Joint Gen-
eral Staff gave to the military leaders who were to fight the
rebels and reconstruct ground communications. He added that,
5-64
in conclusion, Gen. TaberniHa Do1z had told them that "he
considered our cause lost," discouraging those who had the tre-
mendous task of fighting for victory. *
*"I was not present at the meeting of Gen. Tabernilla Dolz with Gen-
erals Cantillo Porras and Rio Chaviano, and Col. Rosell y Leyva and the
<>thers, in which it was agreed to come to an understanding with the
rebels. This meeting took place in the dawn of December 23, and 1 was
at home sick from Sunday, the 21st, through Tuesday. 1 learned of this
meeting later." (Paragraph from a letter of Gen. Rodriguez Avila to Col.
Estevez Maymir dealing with a letter from Gen. Tabernilla Dolz, July 12,
1959.)
"I had to tell you, for the first time in many years, that you ought not
to have attended the conversations which your father had with chiefs
and superior officers. 1 learned, through channels not the most appropri-
ate, that my Chief of the Joint General Staff had met with military lead-
ers of the Province to discuss a truce with the enemy and, later, surrender
and defeat ... you knowwho was there and what opinion Was expressed
to the two generals to whom the last available arms Were given." Letter
of General Batista to Gen. "Silito" Tabernilla, Feb. 5, 1959.)
"My presence at the meeting to which. you make reference was acci-
dental. There was no talk of coritacting the enemy in my presence. 1 did
hear for a few moments the traitor Rio Chaviano explain the seriousness
of the situation in the Province. Gen. Robaina, Lieut. Col. Irenaldo
Garcia Baez and the traitors Rio and Rosell were present." (Letter of
Gen. "Silito" Tabernilla to Gen. Batista, Feb. 13, 1959.)
* * *
*
* *
*
5-65
Seclion V. BATISTA LEAVES CUBA
ONE DAY, AS I was lunching, an aide informed me that he had
overheard an officer saying that Gen. Eulogio Cantillo had been
ordered by the Joint Chief of Staff to hold an interview with
the rebel leader Fidel Castro. * At this time, Gen. Canti1lo was
chief of a vast territory, the most vital and strategic, Oriente
Province. He was in command of more than 15,000 men with
the best armament available and most of the Army's armored
units. His headquarters were in the eastern capital and Naval
land forces and sea units were also under his control.
The same afternoon I had a visit from my son Ruben. He told
me that Lieut. Col. Jose Martinez Suarez was anxious to speak
to me about an important problem. I made an appointment for
8 that night.
Martinez Suarez informed me that Gen. Cantillo had left for
Oriente that day on orders of Gen. Tabernilla Dolz. When Can-
tillo came to the offices of the Joint Command in Havana, he
* On Dec. 22, 1958, at a meeting between several generals and colo-
nels at the headquarters of the Joint Command, it was agreed to establish
contact with the terrorist rebels to hear plans for a truce and then sub-
mit them, as they said, to the consideration of Gen. Batista. Later, al-
ready in exile in Miami, Gen. "Silito" Tabernilla told me that the order
was issued by his father, Gen. Francisco Tabernilla Dolz, anxious to
achieve a settlement. (Words of Lieut. Col. Irenaldo Garcia Baez, ex-
Chief of the S.I.M. on June 22, 1959, on a visit to the Hotel Jaragua,
Santo Domingo, when he spoke to a group of people which included
Doctors Andres Domingo and Florencio Guerra, Maj. Manuel Ator-
resagasti, Capt. Arsenio Labrada, and Lieutenants Cesar Noble and
Rogelio Gonzalez.)
5-66
never returned to his command without seeing me, and I ex-
pressed my surprise to Lieut. Col. Martinez Suarez. "He could
not see you, MI. President. His orders were to leave immediate-
ly and they placed a helicopter at his disposal in Santiago to
take him to Castro for the interview."
"In this case," I had to say it, "if what you say is true, I shall
remove the commanders of the Army this very night."
"1 am certain that Gen. Cantillo has left for Oriente to carry
out these instructions. You know that in all the commands, from
Las Villas to Oriente, the units which have not been surrounded
or surrendered are crippled or isolated. 1 beg you," Martinez
Suarez said, "not to mention my name, because it could cost me
my life; but I spoke to Gen. Cantillo before he left for Santiago
de Cuba. 1 believe, Mr. President," he continued, "that it is a
little late, because a truce has been ordered by the Chief of the
Armed Forces at Santiago de Cuba, Col. Rego Rubido, and the
Chief of the Naval District, Commodore Carnero, so that an
agreement can be reached with Fidel Castro."
I immediately telephoned the Chief of the Army General
Staff, Gen. Pedro Rodriguez Avila, to determine whether Gen.
Cantillo had really gone to Oriente. He confirmed it, stating
that the Joint Chief of Staff had issued the order, and added
that the Chief of the Air Force, Brig. Carlos Tabernilla, was
hurriedly repairing a helicopter to be dispatched without delay
to Santiago de Cuba for the use of the General. Upon asking
him the reason for the urgent departure, he answered that
he did not know. 1 told him I would call Gen. Tabernilla
DoIz on another phone, but would not tell him what I had
learned. I made the call and the Joint Chief of Staff stam-
mered out that he had authorized the departure of Gen.
Cantillo because the latter had said it was necessary to re-
group his command immediately, due to the very bad situa-
tion in the Province. I ordered him to make an appointment
5-67
with Gen. Rodriguez Avila and the Chief of the Navy, Admiral
Jose Rodriguez Calder6n, to meet at my residence in Columbia
at midnight, three hours later.'"
a priest who was in contact with Fidel Castro and for that
reason had wanted to go to Santiago de Cuba; but that he-
Tabernilla-had nQt authorized any meeting. In his presence,
I gave direct orders to the Army Chief of Staff, Gen. Pedro
Rodriguez Avila, to send a radio message in code to Gen. Can-
tillo immediately, ordering him to suspend any appointment he
had made, directly or indirectly, with the rebel leaders, and to
appear at once at headquarters.
Gen. Cantillo did not reply to the dispatch, nor did he return
the next day. I ordered Gen. Rodriguez Avila to investigate
and be on the alert for the return of Cantillo. Forty-eight hours
after I had sent the radio message, the Army Chief of Staff in-
formed me that Cantillo had left Santiago de Cuba. I posted an
aide at the airport, with instructions to bring him to my private
house at my farm before communicating with anyone.
I received Gen. Cantillo in the library behind closed doors.
When I asked him why he had gone to Oriente without seeing
me, he answered that when he had informed the Joint Chief of
Staff of the problems of his command, Gen. Tabernilla had
insisted that he contact Fidel Castro. He then remembered that
a priest, Father Guzman, had sent him a message to the effect
that he could serve as intermediary for a meeting with the rebel
leader. Gen. Tabernilla had ordered him to set out immediately,
make contact with the priest and arrange a personal interview
with Fidel Castro to determine "what he wanted."'"
* "We wrote to Gen. Cantillo through Father Guzman. We did not
receive a reply. In a few days, he and Fidel met at the Oriente sugar mill.
Maj. Francisco Sierra Talavera and I participated in the conversation."
(Statement of Maj. Jose Quevedo to Bohemia magazine, Jan. 18,
1959)
** In the hospice of "EI Cobre," in the Sanctuary of the Patroness of
Cuba, in Oriente, where Fidel Castro had one of his provisional head-
quarters, the revolutionary chief held a council with his commanders.
Something was amiss. He had a foreboding of what had happened and
feared the worst.
5-69
"The attack on Santiago de Cuba, planned for Dec. 28, had been de-
ferred because of a solemn promise given by Gen. Cantillo at a secret
meeting with him.
"This history of Gen. Eulogio Cantillo's treachery goes back to a re-
cent date, Dec. 24, when the interview took place at Oriente Sugar Mill,
at Palma Soriano, between the military chief, who arrived in a helicopter,
and the top rebel leader.
"Cantillo spoke in the name of the Army, whose determination to
fight had been merely an illusion for some time. They spoke for four
hours. A Catholic priest and several officers, worn with worry for the
peace of Cuba, were present at the historical discussion. After consider-
ing all essential points, they arrived at an agreement to realize a synchro-
nized revolutionary military movement." (Bohemia magazine, Jan. 11,
1959.)
5-70
* * * * * * *
About [1] 9 that night the Army Chief of Staff reported to me
that we could not.hold Las Villas, for even the seat of the mili-
tary command of the Province was surrounded by the rebels.
He said that Lieut. Col. Carlos San Martin Fresneda had ar-
rived from Santa Clara, having made a miraculous escape at
the moment the rebels had seized the airport, their guns firing
at his military plane.
At 10, Gen. Eulogio Cantillo Porras returned and went to
"Kuquine," my farm, to report to me. Nothing could be done
to recover Oriente and much less to transfer forces to Las Vil-
las. Fidel Castro insisted that the Army and Navy forces in
Santiago mutiny, or, ifthat failed, that Cantillo surrender to
him the forces under the command of Col. Jose Rego Rubido
of the Army and Commodore Manuel Carnero of the Navy ...
"The situation is serious, Mr. President, and we must make a
quick decision." He added that Fidel Castro would enter Santi-
ago de Cuba in a matter of hours, knowing that the troops
would surrender when the report had spread. . .. *
... "On Jan. 1, at a meeting in Cespedes Park in Santiago de Cuba, Fidel
Castro said: 'The agreement with Cantillo was for a mutiny on the 31st,
at 3 in the afternoon, with the preliminary cooperation of the rebel
troops, unconditionally supported by the Army. At the moment of the
mutiny of the Santiago de Cuba garrison, several rebel columns would
enter the city and fraternize with the people. The tanks found in Santiago
would be surrendered to Castro, not for combat purposes, but in antici-
pation of the chance that the movement would fail in Havana and make
it necessary to place vanguards as close as possible to the capital. He re-
lated details of the very different conduct of Col. Rego Rubido. 'Col.
[131 December 1958.]
5-71
There was'little to discuss and no authority could be exer-
cised to apply disciplinary procedures against the Chiefs who
figured that all was lost. I had to meet with the highest echelons
with basic commands, so' I ordered them to assemble, although
the main leaders would surely be in the Executive Mansion of
Columbia to greet me in the last hours of the year 1958. I
expected the President-Elect, the Vice-President of the Repub-
lic, and the chairmen of the Senate and of the House of Repre-
sentatives. At 11: 30 the Adjutant on duty and the Army Chief
of Staff were still making calls. Other officers were calling the
leaders of the Government political parties and the Congres-
siona1leaders.
I told Gen. Cantillo to wait for me at Columbia, as he had
to attend the meeting of the military chiefs to determine the
best plan.
Reflections
While an automobile was taking me to my residence at Camp
Columbia, I pondered on how to solve the situation without
bringing chaos. I thought of the men who were still fighting and
of the wounded in the hospitals; of so many women and men
in the Government departments, the hundreds of widows and
orphans for whom we were setting up homes, pensions through
the ministries, and education in great' centers which, like the
Civic Military Institute, lodged in comfort the children of sol-
Rego Rubido, chief of the Santiago de Cuba redoubt, was as surprised as
I by the Columbia coup d'etat, which was completely separate from the
agreement.'" (Bohemia, Jan. 11, 1959.)
"Fidel suspected even more of Cantillo when the latter admitted that
Gen. Francisco Tabernilla knew the plans. During the interview Can-
tillo said that the '26 of July' Movement did not have the confidence of
the United States Embassy, which made him believe that there were con-
tacts with the North American diplomats." (RaUl Chibas to Herbert
Matthews-Bohemia, Jan. 11, 1959.)
5-72
diers, workers and peasants who had died doing their duty.
Images and ideas passed rapidly through my mind: those guilty
through negligence or disloyalty, through fear or greed; Oriente,
Las Villas and the infamy of those who had sold out our sol-
diers and surrendered their Provinces, and the valor of those
who had defended it without any hope of success....
The duty of a ruler, in such grave circumstances, is to make
decisions for the best interests of the nation. In short, the people
and history will judge .the statesman more harshly than the
father.
Personal Attendance and Forced Discretion
The upstairs living-room of the house at Columbia was full.
Relatives, military figures, friends and politicians were there.
Many ladies, also, had come to greet my wife. I arrived at 12
on the dot and greeted my wife's friends and spent a few min-
utes talking with each one. While waiting for those who had
been delayed, I spoke separately with Admiral Jose Rodriguez
Calderon; with the Joint Chief of Staff, Gen. Tabernilla Dolz;
with the Chief of the Army, Gen. Pedro RodrIguez Avila; with
Gen. Roberto Fernandez Miranda, Chief of the Military Dis-
trict of La Cabana; with the Chief of the Infantry Division, Gen.
FI)ancisco Tabernilla Palmero ("Silito"); and with the Chiefs
of Operations of the Army Staff, of the Air Force, of the Gen-
eral Army Administration, and officers of lesser commands.
The general impression was the same as Cantillo's, although
some were disposed to fight and to die if necessary. I dispatched
my aides, Lieut. Col. Cosme Varas and Maj. Atorresagasti, to
summon the chiefs to my office on the first floor.
. At this point Gen. RodrIguez Avila told me that a Dominican
mission had come to Havana to discuss military cooperation.
I asked him who had summoned this mission and with whom
5-73
they were in contact. He knew only -that the three men who
made up this unknown commission had been having talks with
the Joint Chief of Staff and with Pedraza; he did not know their
origin or why they were.in Cuba. I showed my displeasure over
such contacts, ordered that the three delegates of the Dominican
Government be sent to the camp and asked to leave tonight for
their country. Pedraza and Rodriguez Avila were appointed to
take care of this.
Representing the political groups, we had the President of the
Progressive Action Party (Accion Progresista) and the Mayor
of Havana, Justo Luis Pozo, accompanied by his son, Dr. Ro-
lando Pozo, and Senator Jorge Garda Montes; for the Demo-
cratic Party there were Senators Santiago Rey and Guillermo
Aguilera; the President-Elect Andres Rivero AgUero; Chairman
of the Senate, Anselmo Alliegro, and Chairman of the House
of Representatives, Gaston Godoy, who had been elected Vice-
President of the Republic.
They went to the dining-room, where I waited. I told them
to remain until I had finished an interview. I referred, without
letting on, to my meeting with the military chiefs.
Some relatives and friends were leaving, and I had not yet
had the opportunity to tell them of the serious situation. When
I told my wife I would be right down, she asked me if some-
thing was wrong. I answered quickly that we ought to be pre-
pared to leave, without indicating whether it was to the Palace
or "Kuquine." I had been gradually preparing her for the worst
for, if the result of the meeting were unfavorable, I did not pro-
pose to continue in power and provoke any needless spilling of
blood. Yet we had to make one last supreme effort. If we could
resist two months, until the end of my Administration, the
Republic could avoid a violent change of government with its
unfortunate consequences.
5-74
The. Decisive Meeting
The room where we met was cramped. It was 2 in the morn-
ing. The Chiefs.talked for a few moments and all agreed that
it was impossible to continue the struggle.
The Chief of the Infantry Division gave a resume of his
report of the exhausted condition of his command and the in-
ability of most of his officers to urge a small group of tired men
into battle.... The Chief of the District of La Cabana ex-
plained that the fortress and the camp could count on no more
than the minimum of troops necessary to keep them going; that
his men were ready to sacrifice themselves, but that there were
no reserves, and he was faced with the same problem as Co-
lumbia.
The Navy was more sound, although its ground units and
personnel were working without relief. The Chief was of the
same opinion as the others. Pedraza suggested that a reinforce-
ment might be possible with Dominicans, as Trujillo's unknown
delegates had proposed ... but he himself maintained the same
opinion.
In conclusion, after the disloyalties, surrenders, and treach-
eries, with only a scrap of the Army left, there was only the
prospect of a mountain of bodies, with the Red Horsemen of
the Apocalypse seizing the remains of the Republic.
Resignation and Provisional Government
The resignation and surrender of the Government to a mili-
tary junta was recommended. I preferred a constitutional form.
If the obstacle was Batista, if they desired a comparable govern-
ment which would declare an end to the civil war and rule
under the Constitution of 1940 without suspension of guarantees
or use of extraordinary measures, if the rebel chieftain pro-
5-75
claimed that 'his groups were not fightirtg the Army but Batista,
and if they were truly patriots fighting for freedom and democ-
racy-a provisional constitutional government was the correct
solution to the conflict.
When we summoned the political leaders and officials who
were asked to wait in the first-floor salon, some had already
departed.
The Vice-President of the Republic, Mayor-elect of Havana,
and President of the Liberal Party, Rafael Guas IncIAn, could
not be located. He would have been next in line of succession,
but he was not present and had thus yielded his right. Therefore,
the President of the Senate, Anselmo Alliegro, was designated
to pass on the Presidency to the oldest justice of the Supreme
Court. Thus the Provisional Government was formed in accord-
ance with the provisions of the Constitution and with Gen.
Eulogio Cantillo as Chief of the Army.
The military leaders and civilians witnessed my resignation.
I was answering the appeal to my patriotism which had once
been made by the Church, the industrialists, and the merchants,
and was now being made by the military chiefs because they
could not restore order.
In the document I implored God's favor to light the way for
the Cubans and to grant them the grace of living in peace and
'" "Justice Piedra agreed to assume the Presidency, with Cantillo as
Army Chief of Staff. They decreed a halt in the operations of the Army,
inviting the rebels to do the same. At 10 a.m., when the reporters left the
Provisional President, they said: 'Justice Piedra was accompanied by his
colleagues Alvarez Tabio and More Benitez, physicians Cuervo Rubio
and Nunez Portuondo and Dr. Raul de Cardenas. Piedra read a speech
addressed to the people of Cuba which stated that he had given the cease
fire order and hoped that those who 'invoking the principles of liberty
and the Constitution had taken up arms' would now adopt the same
measure. ' Fidel Castro refused to accept the cease fire order on the desig-
nation of Justice Piedra as Provisional President." (Bohemia, Jan. II,
1959.)
5-76
harmony. In handing over the Government to my successor, I
begged the people to be on their best behavior so that he would
not be a victim of the hatreds and passions which had disgraced
the Cuban family. In the same way I urged all members of the
Armed Forces and the agents of law and order to obey their
leaders under the authority of the new Government.
5-77
CHAPTER 6
EPILOGUE-CUBA
"
... ,..,1lI ' .....
,..
_.-
o .._ .-u
C_..' '
f
PIN"" DEl RIO
c . ah
-,.
_.-