Leadership Report
Leadership Report
Leadership Report
Page 2 of 66
LEADERSHIP
SUBMITTED TO: Dr. Fazal Khalidi PREPARED BY: Muneeb Rashid I.D # 12981 Umair Yaqoob Izhar I.D # 10109 Omair Hanif Khimani I.D # 10905 Ajay Mandhan I.D # 13200 Abdul Salam Malik I.D # 10914 Kamran Ali Khowaja I.D # 13135
Page 3 of 66
MEMORANDUM OF TRANSMITTAL
TO FROM : Dr. Fazal Khalidi, Assistant Professor of Management at IoBM : Muneeb Rashid Umair Yaqoob Izhar Omair Hanif Khimani Ajay Mandhan Abdul Salam Malik Kamran Ali Khowaja : 11 December 2012
DATE
SUBJECT : A Detailed Report on Leadership at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. We are pleased to submit our report on Leadership at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. to you. During all the phases and stages of this report including analysis, writing and designing the report, we have gained very useful knowledge and experience with respect to the application of the concepts of Leadership in real life at organizations and specially at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. We have tried the best of our efforts to apply all the relevant concepts appropriately and properly to develop this report. We hope that the report will serve its purpose. We acknowledge your help and support for this report and we look forward to your feedback as it will be the most valuable feature for us in the entire process.
Page 4 of 66
LETTER OF ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
11 December 2012
Dear Readers, All praises and thanks to Almighty ALLAH, Who is the Lord and Creator of this universe and by Whose power and glory all good things are accomplished. He is the most merciful, Who bestowed upon us the potential, ability and an opportunity to work on this report. We are thankful to the Last and Final Messenger of Allah, Prophet Mohammad (P.B.U.H) for leaving an unbeatable example of leadership which we can feel proud to own, learn and follow. We are also thankful to our parents for bearing with our hectic schedules and always being a marvelous support. We would like to extend sincere gratitude to our respected mentor Dr. Fazal Khalidi for his constant support, encouragement and guidance, without which we could not have successfully achieved our task. Moreover he gave us the opportunity to search and write a report on the topic: Leadership at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. Being a vast topic it has offered much for our learning purposes. Cordially, Muneeb Rashid Umair Yaqoob Izhar Omair Hanif Khimani Ajay Mandhan Abdul Salam Malik Kamran Ali Khowaja
Page 5 of 66
TABLE OF CONTENTS
SR. NO.
1.
PARTICULARS
Memorandum of Transmittal
PAGE NO.
4
2.
Letter of Acknowledgement
3.
Executive Summary
4.
5.
Articles and Summaries Abdul Salam Malik- Article 1 and summary Ajay Mandhan- Article 2 and summary Muneeb Rashid- Article 3 and summary Umair Yaqoob Izhar- Article 4 and summary Omair Hanif Khimani- Article 5 and summary Kamran Khowaja- Article 6 and summary 12 14 27 30 34 39
6.
Page 6 of 66
Business Lines World class manufacturing system Process and technology Quality
46 46 47 48
7.
Leadership and application of leadership concepts at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. Styles of leadership Practical adaptation of leadersip concepts at Dollar Organizational culture and its importance Work culture at Dollar industries pvt ltd Monetary motivators used by Dollars management Other ways to motivate employees 50 51 52 52 53 53
8.
Leadership-Worker relationship Leader-worker relationship at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. How to build effective relationships with employees 54 54
9.
Consistency at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. Consistency at Dollar Industries ltd Caring culture Caring culture at dollar industries (pvt) ltd. Communication Team building activities Team building activities at Dollar Industries pvt ltd 54 55 55 55 56 56
10.
Page 7 of 66
Mentoring at Dollar Industries pvt ltd Who should be mentored ? Is mentoring right for you ? Cost effective Employee retention Talent development Recruitment and On boarding Diversity enhancement Knowledge sharing
57 58 58 58 58 59 59 59 59
11.
Born leaders or made Leaders Dollar managements belief on Born leaders or made leaders 60
12.
Conclusion
61
13.
Recommendations
62
14.
Bibliography
63
15.
Appendix
64
16.
Glossary
65
17.
Index
66
Page 8 of 66
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In todays world of innovation, and highly technical competition, it has become very important for the organizations to have leaders who can lead them from the front, giving them the competitive advantage in this tough race. Most of the worlds well established organizations have highly relied on managements commitment towards their success, and has created some great leadership examples turning the faith of their respective companies A detailed meeting was arranged with Mr. Shahid Ghazanfer (Manager Personnel And Admin) of Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. to learn about the Leadership practices at the company. This meeting was arranged by the reference of our group member Muneeb Rashid as he has earlier done an internship at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. under Mr. Faisal Ajmal (Assistant Manager HR). Dollar Industries has developed a family within their organization which has promised high commitment towards its employees, and well defined policies. The foremost priority to the organization after the customer satisfaction comes the employee satisfaction. Rather than going after greater profit margins, they believe in greater caring of their employees as the foundation of the company, which therefore when gets stronger once, reaching a height turn out to be no more a problem. And the best outcome of this is Dollars introduction of the monetary motivators, mentoring process, higher incentives, highly recommended team building extracurricular activities, and some non formal gatherings. Dollar is an organization that never compromises on its ethical values. As most of the people working are Muslims, an Islamic work place culture has been developed and interest has never been a part of the company. Beside that there are a few cons which are made unnoticed by the pros of the company. The mentors need to be highly trained and do some serious counseling as few of the employees might not be very strong at their will powers with the ongoing situation of the country and inflation. And they need to be more active in employee involvement, encouraging the decision making at lower level employees. Leadership is one of the most important ingredients that are required for the organizational success. Dollar is one of those companies that not only understand but also implement the concepts of true leadership as they treat their employees like human beings and not like their possession.
Page 9 of 66
ORIGIN OF REPORT
This report has been prepared to understand the working and implementation of LEADERSHIP POLICIES & SYSTEMS at DOLLAR INDUSTRIES (PVT) LTD. in the actual business environment.
METHODOLOGY
We have collected the main matter for our report by having a face-to-face discussion with Mr. Shahid Ghazanfer, who is the Manager Personnel and Admin at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. We have also researched about the leadership from various books and websites and then correlated the same study with relevant aspects that were found at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd.
LIMITATIONS
One limitation that we face during making of this report was the limited accessibility of few tangible records of the company over the internet.
Page 10 of 66
Page 11 of 66
STARBUCKS
In an article for Evolved Employer Melissa Anderson says there are three reasons why holistic leadership means becoming a better employer. She uses the recently published book by Starbucks Chairman and CEO Howard Schultz, Onward: How Starbucks Fought for Its Life without Losing Its Soul as a best practice case. Schultz is credited with growing the company from a small Seattle-based chain to the huge multinational company it is today. After stepping down from the companys leadership in 2000, Schultz returned as CEO in 2008 to prompt a turnaround. While the company had been faltering as a result of carcinogenic growth, Schultz said the company is now enjoying record-breaking profits. Schultz has explained the reason behind the companys turnaround was a strong investment in the customer experience. At a very basic level, he explained, Starbucks has focused on its people, rather than strictly on its profit margins. Here are three ways the company leveraged relationships to fuel its success. 1. Reorienting Stores around Relationships Schultz said one of the best things hes done to bring the focus back to the employee/customer relationship was to quit reporting on monthly store profits. In an interview with the McKinsey Quarterly, he said, An albatross around the neck of most retailers and restaurant companies is this metric that Wall Street created many, many years ago: the calculation of the growth of stores open for more than one year. He continued:So I announced, one day when I came back, that we were going to stop reporting monthly comps. what I was trying to do was make sure that our people were managing the business for the most appropriate constituent, which is the customer. 2. Rebuilding the Connection to the Community Refocusing on the community has meant a stronger commitment to community service for the company. This has meant initiating not only projects at the corporate level, but also encouraging employees to volunteer within their communities. As Schultz told KUSA, I think that from the very beginning weve tried to balance a need to make a profit with a deep sense of social conscious and giving back to the community. So its not just about whats going on in our stores, its really demonstrating the humanity of our company. 3. Refocusing on the Employee Experience Finally, Schultz has worked to rebuild the employee experience at Starbucks ensuring its not just a coffee shop or a fast food restaurant, but a place were people are energized to work. As Carmine Gallo reported in Forbes.com, Schultz said the Starbucks experience really starts with its people, so its critical that they are engaged with the companys mission.
Page 12 of 66
In fact, Schulz said that one of his biggest business challenges is getting the right people on board. He told McKinsey: [Our biggest growth constraint is] human capital. We want to attract world-class people who have values that are well aligned with the culture of the company. And we want to make sure that the growth of Starbucks in the future doesnt in any way cover up the mistakes weve made in the past.
Page 13 of 66
Page 14 of 66
Page 15 of 66
Page 16 of 66
Page 17 of 66
Page 18 of 66
Page 19 of 66
Page 20 of 66
Page 21 of 66
Page 22 of 66
Page 23 of 66
Page 24 of 66
Page 25 of 66
The other attributes of leader are flexibility, integrity, judgement and respect for others all these are important in the making of complete leader In todays time leadership has may roles to play out of which one important role is competitive strategic leadership, initiatives like building depth of leadership talent in the organization and expediting large scale change .Leadership programmes that seek to facilitate strategic change have a number of common design elements such as strategic framework, sophisticated assessment processes, content customized to promote strategic objectives etc.
Page 26 of 66
Page 27 of 66
Page 28 of 66
SUMMARY OF ARTICLE 3 BY MUNEEB RASHID (12981) Why Companies Fail And How Their Founders Can Bounce Back (By Carmen Nobel)
As it is said: A person never loses until he thinks so - This article shows the bright side of business failures and differentiates enterprise failures from personal failures. The author mentions the advantages of a business failure that how a failed plan would compel people in an organization to be more diligent and look out for new ways, such an event opens new opportunities and provides a good chance for an organization to learn from their mistakes and improve. While differentiating between the enterprise failure and the personal failure concept, the author states: Enterprise failure can be an asset, but personal failure is ruinous, why an enterprise failure an asset can be understood easily from the previous paragraph but why personal failure is ruinous adds a color of leadership qualities into the article where entrepreneurs are warned to abide by the proper leadership traits and not to resort to any unethical activity in order to save a business plan because failure in business is a norm and if someone is too stubborn and does not accept his failures will not be able to grow but rather come across a bigger disaster if he resorts to unethical activities. The author goes on a little further to create acceptance of failure as a mechanism for prosperity when he uses examples of the perception of failure in the mind of an entrepreneur, for instance if an entrepreneur perceives failure as failing to see the projected returns on investment, then the failure rate is 70% 80% and if failure is defined as declaring a projection and then falling short of meeting it, then the failure rate is whopping 90% - 95% and another point that the difference between growing economies and stagnant economies is the acceptance of failure. People usually invest-in a lot in their dreams and thus forget to keep their values strengthened. The article tells the importance of means rather than the ends and presents failure as a normal thing and something to be always ready for and something which is supposed to be taken lightly, and as an opportunity to learn, improve, grow and prosper.
Page 29 of 66
ARTICLE 4 BY UMAIR YAQOOB IZHAR (10109) Four Myths About Mentoring (By Amy Gallo)
When people think of mentoring, they often think of an older executive counseling a young upstart. The senior leader advises the junior employee on his career, how to navigate the world of work, and what he needs to do to get ahead. But mentoring has changed a lot in the last few decades. Just as the notion of a 50-year linear career with a single company or in one industry is outdated, so is the idea that career advice must come from a wise old sage. The traditional mentor-mentee relationship is not necessarily a thing of the past, but it's no longer the standard. Now, there are many ways to get the information and guidance you need.
Page 30 of 66
Myth #2: Mentoring is a formal long-term relationship Because the world moves fast and people change jobs and careers more often, a long-term advising relationship may be unrealistic and unnecessary. "Mentoring can be a one-hour mentoring session. We don't have to escalate it to a six-month or year-long event," says Willyerd. Instead of focusing on the long term, think of mentoring as something you access when you need it. "It may not be big agenda items that you're grappling with. You don't need to wait until you have some big thing in your career," says Meister. In today's world, she says, mentoring is "more like Twitter and less like having a psychotherapy session." Of course, the advice and guidance may be richer and more relevant if it comes from someone who knows you well and understands your goals. You still need to build relationships so that when you require advice, you have the connections in place. However, there may be times when you look to people who don't know you as well or at all to get one-off counsel from an outsider's perspective. And in these cases, Willyerd suggests you may want to avoid using the word "mentor" altogether. "You can simply say, 'I'd really like to get your advice on something'," she says. Myth #3: Mentoring is for junior people Many people assume that they only need a mentor when they are first starting out in their careers. "We used to think it was people at early stages of their career who needed mentoring, those just out of MBA programs. Now we understand that people at every stage benefit from this kind of assistance," says Kram. In their book, The 2020 Workplace, Meister and Willyerd talk about reverse mentoring in which a more junior person advises a senior person on things like new technology. The reality is "There are lots of points in a corporate career when you need a mentor," says Meister. Though you shouldn't wait for them to come up, transitions are a particularly good time to seek out a mentor. Whether you are making a career change, taking on a new role, or contemplating leaving a job, advice from someone who has done it before can be helpful. "You may need a mentor when the environment around you is changing rapidly and you haven't had a chance to keep up with the changes," says Meister. "Or as you try to navigate the complexities of your organization," adds Willyerd. Myth #4: Mentoring is something more experienced people do out of the goodness of their hearts "It can be an honor to ask someone to be a mentor," says Willyerd. But the respect isn't the only reason people agree to help. Mentoring should be useful to both parties involved. Before seeking out a mentor, think about what you have to offer him. Can you provide a unique perspective on the organization or his role? Do you bring valuable outside information that might help him be successful in his job? Whatever it is, be sure that you are clear with your prospective advisor
Page 31 of 66
about what's in it for him. This does not have to be a direct barter. Even the promise of future help, if and when it's needed, can be enough to convince a mentor to give up his time and energy. So, do you need mentoring? Now that you have a better understanding of what mentoring can be, do you need it? "The place to start is with self-assessment and find out what are the challenges in front of you right now and why. Then ask yourself, do you have the relational resources to handle those challenges?" says Kram. If the answer is no, it may be time to seek out a mentor or several. Remember that mentoring can take many shapes and formsthe key is to find the right kind of advice from the right person at the right time. Case Study #1: Using multiple mentors In January 2000, Soki Choi left Accenture Sweden to start her own company developing applications for mobile phones. A mere four years later, the company was acquired and Soki was left with a large decision about what to do next. Should she take a job with another Swedish telecom company? Should she start another business? "Suddenly I didn't have a natural "next step" in my career," she explains. Since she was a child, she had dreamed of doing medical research, but felt it was too late in life to pursue that path, especially without an MD. However, the desire nagged her. One day that spring, she read a story about Sweden's prestigious research hospital, the Karolinska Institute, merging with the university hospital in Huddinge and decided she had to explore the possibility of a medical PhD. She wanted multiple perspectives on this potential career change, so she sought the advice of three different people. Her first thought was of Ewa Stlldal, the CEO of a major medical research foundation that she had met several years previously on a delegation trip to the US with the Swedish Ministry of Industry. "She listened and took my thoughts seriously. She then connected me to her research and medical network, and in particular to an entrepreneurial professor in medical management," she says. Soki also contacted Bjorn Svedberg, the former CEO of Ericsson. She first met Bjorn in her role as a board member of PTS, the National Post & Telecom Agency which advises the Swedish government on telecom and infrastructure planning. Soki respected him and wanted to know what he thought of this potential career shift. "I specifically asked him if he thought it was a good idea to take on PhD studies in the midst of a critical time of my professional career," she says. Bjorn, who was in his 80s, revealed to Soki that he wished he had done what she was considering and he strongly urged her to pursue her dream. Soki's third advisor was Martin Lorentzon. Martin is only 5 years older than Soki and had a similar career trajectory in that he also left a steady job to start his own company. He had served as a "go-to" person for Soki while she was building her business. "Martin was much more of a direct, operational, and continuous mentor," she said. He also encouraged her to do what she thought would make her most happy.
Page 32 of 66
Soki is about to complete her PhD at the Karolinska Institute. Without the advice and help of her mentors, Soki thinks she would've taken one of the many job offers she had in 2004 and would still be in the telecom field, rather than pursuing her dream.
In the case study given at the end of the article, it is described that how mentoring process can change and alter your choices. The case of a girl named Soki is given who left her job in a Swedish company, then started her own business and that too was bought by someone. As her childhood dream, she always wanted to study medical research so she went up to three different people who acted as mentors for her. All of them gave her the positive responses and finally she decided to continue with her choice of medical research. Soki is about to complete her PhD at the Karolinska Institute. Without the advice and help of her mentors, Soki thinks she would've taken one of the many job offers she had in 2004 and would still be in the telecom field, rather than pursuing her dream.
Page 33 of 66
You have way too much to do, you're buried in work, and it seems there's no way out from under it all. But there is: delegation. Yes, yes, you know it's important to do and you know it will save you time and help others develop new skills. So why aren't you doing it? What the Experts Say: Delegation is a critical skill. "Your most important task as a leader is to teach people how to think and ask the right questions so that the world doesn't go to hell if you take a day off," says Jeffrey Pfeffer, the Thomas D. Dee II Professor of Organizational Behavior at Stanford University's Graduate School of Business and author of What Were They Thinking?: Unconventional Wisdom About Management. Delegation benefits managers, direct reports, and organizations. Yet it remains one of the most underutilized and underdeveloped management capabilities. A 2007 study on time management found that close to half of the 332 companies surveyed were concerned about their employees' delegation skills. At the same time, only 28% of those companies offered any training on the topic. "Most people will tell you they are too busy to delegate that it's more efficient for them to just do it themselves," says Carol Walker, the president of Prepared to Lead, a consulting firm that focuses on developing young leaders. But both Walker and Pfeffer agree that it's time to drop the excuses. Here's how. Watch for warning signs You may not realize that you're unnecessarily hoarding work. There are warning signs, however. "A classic sign of insufficient delegation is that you are working long hours and feel totally indispensable, while your staff isn't terribly energized and keeps strangely regular hours," says Walker. You may also feel that your team doesn't take ownership over projects and that you're the only one that cares. If they use phrases like, "I'm happy to help you with this," it may be an indication that you're doling out tasks, not handing over responsibility. Understand why you're not delegating There are plenty of reasons why managers don't delegate. Some are perfectionists who feel it's easier to do everything themselves, or that their work is better than others'. Pfeffer calls this "self-enhancement bias." Some believe that passing on work will detract from their own importance, while others lack self-confidence and don't want to be upstaged by their subordinates. No matter how self-aware you are, don't assume that you're immune to these biases, Pfeffer advises. Instead, you need to proactively ask yourself what you're going to do to counterbalance them. Walker notes that letting go of these misconceptions can be extremely
Page 34 of 66
difficult and often organizational culture doesn't help. "Giving up being 'the go-to expert' takes tremendous confidence and perspective even in the healthiest environments," she says. "It's even more challenging in the average company, where being a good manager is seen as a 'nice to have,' but where producing the core deliverable is what is truly esteemed." But accepting that you can't do everything yourself is a critical first step to delegating. Measure how you're doing Once you've recognized what's standing in your way, the next logical step is to adjust your behavior. In reality, however, very few people know what to change or how to change it. "If you asked most managers how they spent their day, they are not going to be able to recall it accurately," says Pfeffer. He advises keeping a daily diary of how you spend your time. After a week, you'll start to see patterns. "You're likely to find that a lot of time is spent on low-leverage activities that can be delegated," says Pfeffer. Choose the right people Some managers fear delegation because they've been burned in the past. It's important that you pass on work to people who have the necessary skills and are motivated to get the job done right. Ideally, you should be able to delegate some form of work to everyone on your team. If you push work as far down the hierarchy as possible, you will free up time and help all your staff members grow. Integrate delegation into what you already do Delegation shouldn't be yet another task. Make it part of your process for creating staff development plans. Discuss which types of projects and tasks you will pass on to them so that they can build the skills they need. "Make sure it's written down as part of their performance goals and discuss how you will be mutually accountable for making it happen," says Walker. Then create a cheat sheet that lists each person's development plan and put it somewhere visible. "This should help to spur your thinking about opportunities to delegate as they arise normally in your work. And the assignment will be welcomed because the employee understands clearly how it fits into the development plan," says Walker. Ask others to hold you accountable Give your direct reports permission to call you out when you haven't delegated something you should. Remember that it's never easy to give your boss feedback, so be crystal clear that you are open to and expect this kind of input. Also, let them know that they're responsible for their own growth and if they see a project they want to take on, they should ask for it.
Page 35 of 66
Really let go After you delegate, your job as a manager is to observe and support your direct reports, not dictate what they do. "It's not about making the decisions for them. Develop their critical thinking skills so they become better at intervening in their own situations," Pfeffer says. Give your employees space. "If you want people to learn, you have to permit them to make mistakes and figure out how to correct them," says Pfeffer. Micromanaging defeats the whole purpose. Be careful though. It's possible to be too hands off. "While you don't want to tell people how to do the job, you must be in a position to evaluate their performance and development," says Walker. Don't walk away from a task you've delegated. Stay involved but let your employee lead the way. Learn from experience Once you've started delegating more, pay attention to the results, and learn from your mistakes. Ask yourself how you can tweak your approach. Can you delegate more involved tasks? Should you give your direct reports more freedom? Do you need to monitor progress more closely? Be patient with yourself while you practice. "You're going from an 'I'm going to do everything because I know better than everyone' mindset to 'I'm going to let people learn' mindset," says Pfeffer. It may take time, but the payoff is great. Principles to Remember: Do: Take note if you're overwhelmed and your team members don't seem to have enough to do, it's a warning sign Keep a visual reminder of your team's development goals so you can easily identify opportunities to delegate Ask your direct superiors to call you out when you haven't delegated enough Don't: Assume that you aren't biased about other people's performance Give someone else responsibility for something and then micromanage the task to death Be impatient practice and learn from your mistakes
Page 36 of 66
way to orient the employee. Also, "having a fresh pair of eyes look at our business uncovered a few blind spots," he says. Russell realizes trusting a newcomer with such an important task was perhaps a gamble. But he felt the risk could be mitigated by "instructions, open lines of communication for questions and comments, and regular checkpoints.
lead to better ideas and processes. Finally, the managers should know when the worker needs to be rewarded or appraised. The employee involvement model was also a helpful tool in my understanding, thus I have mentioned it here. The Employee Involvement Model provides a continuum for leadership and involvement that includes an increasing role for employees and a decreasing role for supervisors in the decision process. Tell: the supervisor makes the decision and announces it to staff. The supervisor provides complete direction. Sell: the supervisor makes the decision and then attempts to gain commitment from staff by selling the positive aspects of the decision. Sell is useful when employee commitment is needed, but the decision is not open to employee influence. Consult: the supervisor discusses key issues with his staff and asks them for their input. This allows the staff members to come forward with their ideas and mention how they feel they can perform better. Join: the supervisor invites employees to make the decision with the supervisor. The supervisor considers his voice equal in the decision process. The key to a successful join is when the supervisor truly builds consensus around a decision and is willing to keep his influence equal to that of the others providing input.
Leaders are decision makers. They do not procrastinate. They know what needs to be done and they make sure that it gets done. Leaders know how to delegate effectively. Do not be fearful of messing up. When leaders mess up they take responsibility, learn from the mistake, and next time take their game up a notch. Followers tend to blame others. Take a step in confidence, hold yourself up high. Pin your shoulders back, walk with a confident posture! Posture is important. Talk with confidence and learn how to speak in others. If that is not for you, then take a public speaking course, just get out there and do it. Step outside your comfort zone and take your leadership to the next level. Do not get management and leadership mixed up. Leaders decide direction and management heads towards that direction. Lead people, manage things. A practical way to develop leadership in your world today is getting involved/more involved in home business opportunities. Positioning yourself to inspire people will really catapult you ahead. It will also take you out of your comfort zones, which is a fantastic place to be in order to develop your weaknesses into strengths. "Management is efficiency in climbing the ladder of success; leadership determines whether the ladder is leaning against the right wall." - Stephen R. Covey
Stage 2: and following through by intentionally seeking to influence followers (both established and potential), to perform the various tasks needed to realize the vision, to their full potential, for as long as possible,
Page 40 of 66
Stage 3: until the vision and goals are realized. One can look at this definition as a check-list to Leadership; Do I have a vision; a picture of a desired end state that is compelling to others? Are people performing to their full potential? Who do I need to help me realize this vision? Am I intentionally seeking to influence people to perform their best? What else needs to be done, and who should do it? Now, I realize individuals may find themselves at various points in a given stage, before they choose to engage in the process of leadership. For instance, one may be working in a division, or an organization, that already has a clearly established vision, set goals, etc. In such a case, assuming that the individual agrees with the vision, the leadership process begins at Stage 2. We all must realize that part of the difficulty of leadership is that some people are great visionaries, but lack the competence and EQ to influence others to rally around their vision. Others, may not be great visionaries, but are very influential and inspirational to those around them. What I have observed in studying leadership, is that very few leaders have all the gifts and talents themselves; what many of the great ones do have, is a self awareness of what talents they do have, and the self confidence and security to surround themselves with others who can compliment them, and compensate for their own lack of skills. In closing, let me make one point clear; it is my intent to encourage as many people as possible to exercise leadership as often as they possibly can, for as long as they can! When people are lost because they lack a vision, and you happen to see an end goal that they can not see, then at least exercise Stage 1 of leadership. By doing so, it doesnt necessarily mean you will emerge as their leader, but you will have engaged in leadership. If one of your colleagues is not performing to their full potential, intervene and intentionally try to influence them to raise their performance. Remember, human performance is nothing more than the function of ones skill and will to perform a task; therefore, if one is not performing to their potential, it is either because they lack the skill, or the will, to do their job. Figure out what is impeding their performance and try to either coach them to build their skills, or inspire, challenge, and motivate them to raise their will to perform. Lets be clear; Everyone can not become a leader, but every one can engage in a lot more leadership!leadership nowLeadership is the one and only path to becoming a leader.
Page 41 of 66
Page 42 of 66
COMPANY PROFILE
Dollar is the leading writing instruments and stationery manufacturer in Asia, with exports to more than 50 countries in all five continents. Created more than half-a-century ago, the Dollar of stationery has attained the status of a heritage brand and a household name in Pakistan. Persistent innovation coupled with an ever expanding range, have earned DOLLAR an enviable brand loyalty among all walks of life and in all age groups. Excellent product performance, exceptional reliability & continuous improvements have developed a blind consumer faith in Dollar products. History The DOLLAR of Stationery was created more than half-a-century ago in 1954 when Mohammad Siddiq started formulating and producing inks in a small place situated in the old town of Karachi. At that time fountain pen was the primary instrument used for writing. Back then, prevailing brands in pens and inks were mostly imported from Europe and the US. Vision To be amongst the top 10 Stationary Companies, on a sustainable basis. Mission To be able to provide practical yet exciting written communication solution, allowing users to express their ideas, effortlessy. Leadingwith Values ! Dollar a responsible corporate citizen- fully recognizes its Responsibility towards: The countries and societies it deals with The environment it operates in The people it works with
This philosophy translates into action in the shape of three, guiding C principles : Conviction for doing good Commitment to nature Courage to nurture
People are one of the most important assets We recognize that one of our most important assets is our people, who work in our business, and, also, to a large extent the people who work for our business. We strive to constantly improve their standards__as far as possible__through our own Human Resource Management and Training systems. To us our people are also one of the most important stakeholders in our business. With this approach we try to provide a sustainable standard of living for them and offer them good working condition.
Page 43 of 66
Let us be responsible to the next generations Dollar fully realizes and appreciates the importance of a sustainable and environment-friendly Operations. To fulfill what it calls its "Green Objective", DOLLAR has put in extraordinary efforts to bring its Manufacturing units in line with ISO-14001 stipulations. Some of the initiatives include: Planned elimination of all types of wastes. Prompt recycling of all material waste that inevitably churns out from different production processes
Total air pollution control by imposing a progressive ban on the use of hazardous chemicals, solvents, rogue dyes, and, powdered colorants and pigments that are used in processing plastics. "Solid waste management", a concept that DOLLAR pioneered in some of the areas where it operates. Apart from enforcing a strict regime on itself, DOLLAR has persuaded the importance of environment-friendliness to its neighbor industries. Quality is in everything that we do To continuously live up to the image of a quality company we always focus on international standards and cross country developments in the area of Quality Management Systems. We sustain this state Through creating synergies amongst the functional areas of our business.
Technology is the route to excellence We recognize the important role of technology in developing business. We continuously strive to use the appropriate utilization of cutting edge technology --- both in our processes as well as operations.
Page 44 of 66
BRANDS
Besides producing its own-branded items, DOLLAR also manufactures and exports private labeled / OEM stationery products for some of the leading international brands.
Page 45 of 66
BUSINESS LINES
Management & Quality Systems Acquiring and sustaining a credible reputation of a Quality Company is impossible without putting in place sound Management & Quality Systems. Besides passing through a rigorous BPR program around the turn of the century, DOLLAR has taken further strides towards excelling in all business areas. DOLLAR has chained itself towards proven management techniques including TQM, TQC, Kaizen and Quality Circles. DOLLAR's Goal is perennial customer confidence-cum-conviction that they are dealing with a company whose sole priority is guaranteeing the highest possible quality and reliability. Automatic all-inline Assembling & decoration lines Advanced computer aided design (CAD) and computer aided-manufacturing (CAM)
A Rare Facility Dollar products are designed, developed and produced in a world class manufacturing base. Dollar happens to be amongst those rare writing instrument manufacturers around the world, who have such extensive, technologically advanced, and vertically integrated production facilities, all in-house:-
Design & Development facilities that include product design, package design and graphic design. Nib and Point manufacturing which employs advanced, watch-degree precision metal and fibre working machines, operating with tolerances close to a hundredth of a millimeter! This ensures high quality and consistent write out of the pens and markers. Research, development, formulation and control of inks that are used in various writing instruments. Advanced machining facilities for producing moulds, tools, dies, jigs etc. that are required for the production of writing instruments. Precision plastic-processing machines, producing pen parts to the accuracy of one tenth of a millimeter. Fully automatic, all-in-line integrated assembling machines that ensure continuous zerodefect production. Sophisticated, in-line, multi-colour decoration equipment including silk screen, hot foiling and tampon printing processes for printing vivid graphics on pens that capture the consumers imagination.
Technology in our business We recognize the important role of technology in our business. We continuously strive in appropriately utilizing cutting edge technology --in both operations and processes.
Operational excellence Dollar considers efficiency of operations as the single most important factor, critical to the success of its business. In order to effectively meet the globalization challenges, Dollar has worked through a "technologyenabled business process re-engineering programme" (BPR) in association with Deloitte --- the world's leading consulting firm. The forward looking Dollar radically transformed its Information Technology Strategy with the bold introduction of the state-of-the-art Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) Oracle E-business suite, Business Intelligence, Performance Management and Customer Relationship Management Tools thereby placing itself on the cutting edge of technology. This bold move has enabled Dollar to gauge organizational effectiveness in terms of costs, cycle times, service and quality standards that serve customer needs and ensure customer satisfaction. This strategic initiative has not only aligned different spheres of its operations but has also brought Dollar in-line with business practices of the world's leading corporations who deploy strategic information tools as a measure of attaining and maintaining global competitiveness.
Page 47 of 66
QUALITY
Acquiring and sustaining a credible reputation of a Quality Company is impossible without putting in place sound Management & Quality Systems. Since the turn of the century, DOLLAR has taken several strides towards excelling in all business areas. Attainment of ISO 9001, through Lloyds of England, was just a part of the cosmic quality vision that DOLLAR pursues. DOLLAR has further chained itself towards proven management techniques including TQM, TQC, Kaizen and Quality Circles. DOLLAR's Goal is Perennial Customer confidence-cum-conviction that they are dealing with a company whose sole priority is guaranteeing the highest possible quality and reliability. Quality Policy 1. Strive to deliver Quality at an affordable price 2. Are committed to innovating and continually improving products, services, processes and systems 3. Attach a higher priority to Quality over costs and delivery
Page 48 of 66
LEADERSHIP
AND
Page 49 of 66
STYLES OF LEADERSHIP
Participative/Democratic Leadership
This leadership style is self-explanatory as it focuses on more equality and participation of team members. Although you still have the final decision the team members believe that their voice actually makes a difference in the overall results. Pros: High Job satisfaction, more productive, skills development and better quality of work. Cons: Slow decision making, loss of efficiency and time wasting. Task Driven Leadership
This theory focuses almost completely on the task which needs to be achieved. These leaders monitor the processes and systems while almost entirely putting value on accomplishment of the task. Pros: Deadlines are met, development of time wasting team members and shows capability of leader. Cons: Motivational problems, less value on team members and severe boundaries which limit innovation. Autocratic Leadership
Throughout these theories Autocratic Leadership is probably the most infamous and often rejected. There are definitely situations where this is needed, although few and far between. Autocratic leadership is basically you as the leader having complete power over your team/people. Often abused in history, which I guess is why it is infamous! Pros: incredible efficiency, work gets done and decisions are made quickly. Cons: Resentment of team members, high staff turnover and absenteeism. Bureaucratic Leadership
This leadership style is often misinterpreted and disgusted by leaders. Bureaucratic Leaders follow the rules to the max and make sure everyone else follows every little procedure that the book has in it. This is often used in environments where breaking a rule or making a mistake can cause a lot of damage and/or serious injury. Page 50 of 66
Pros: Great for routine tasks, stopping workplace injuries and in workplaces that deal with large amounts of money. Cons: Ineffective in most teams, refuses innovation and creativity, and makes flexibility a sin. Charismatic Leadership
This is one of the most effective and most used leadership traits in modern teams. Often used in transformational leadership it is often positive and people building. These leaders use charisma and energy to lead others. Pros: Transform organizations, energetic and motivating and encourages creativity and innovation. Cons: The focus can be on themselves, large risks, often teams fall apart when leader leaves and false self belief. These are five of the most prominent theories. We'll definitely develop these in the future and show more detail in how they respond to situations. These leadership theories are essential for team leadership as you must know how to lead in different circumstances. In your leadership-lifetime you'll need to assimilate a few of these.
A focus on individual development for the long term is encouraged at Dollar Page 51 of 66
Beliefs, thought processes, attitudes of the employees. Ideologies and principles of the organization.
A healthy work culture leads to satisfied employees and an increased productivity. Employees must be cordial with each other. Each employee should be treated as one. Appreciating the top performers is important. Encourage discussions at the workplace. Organization must have employee friendly policies and practical guidelines. The Hitler approach does not fit in the current scenario. Promote team building activities to bind the employees together.
Page 52 of 66
Family support and support relating to health and other needs is provided by the company Culture characterized by ethical values all the gifts given to company personnel in an individual capacity are considered as gifts for the company and are handed over to the management. Image of the company is the priority of the employees
the
Salaries: fixed amounts per month or year for performing a role; these are common for most managerial positions (e.g. Accountant, Payroll Manager) Benefits in kind (fringe benefits) very common in businesses of all kinds; these include staff discounts, contributions to travel costs, staff uniforms etc Time-rate pay: pay based on time worked; very common in small businesses where employees are paid per hour. Piece-rate pay: pay per item produced becoming less common Commission: payment based on the value of sales achieved. Other performance-related pay: e.g. bonuses for achieving targets Shares and options: less common in small businesses, but popular in businesses whose shares are traded on stock markets Pensions becoming less common and generous. Small businesses tend not to offer pension benefits.
Page 53 of 66
Dollar company tries to build and enhance the level of motivation with its employees giving them task which are clear creative and which can be done by putting some efforts and try to increase the level of employee motivation.
CARING CULTURE
Fostering a caring atmosphere at work can lead to better trust among co-workers. Show your employees that they matter to you by expressing your appreciation for their hard work and professional work ethic, and illustrate their importance to your small business by pointing out the role they play within it. At meetings, verbally highlight why each individual employee is integral to your small business's goals and objectives. Involving employees and publicly bringing attention to every person's importance in your business can increase how much employees will trust and rely on each other.
COMMUNICATION
Communicate openly with your employees to build a sense of trust in your workplace. This may include holding informal staff meetings to discuss your business's mission, values or goals, and listening to each of your employees' questions, concerns or advice. Encourage your employees to ask one another for professional advice related to projects or tasks at hand, and persuade them to hold smaller staff meetings to complete goals. Harboring an atmosphere where communication is positive, consistent and informal can motivate employees to trust one another. Company usually tries to stay in touch with employees and remove all un usually jargons so that it enhance the employee commitment that yes he is listened and arrange some events annually so that employee can communicate.
Page 55 of 66
TEAM-BUILDING ACTIVITIES
Make coworkers feel like they are on the same team by holding team-building activities. These activities can include afterwork happy hours once a month, catered staff meetings where employees are asked to voice their thoughts on company progress and strategy, or celebrations to commemorate when important deadlines or other milestones are met in your business. These types of team-building activities can create a sense of unity among your employees, which can lead to a higher level of trust among them. Many workplaces celebrate annual holidays and events. Over time, as you celebrate annual holidays and events in your workplace, you form traditions and give your employees fodder for stories about their workplace. These stories and the photos from the events help form the company culture, the environment you provide for people at work. Employees like to celebrate holidays and annual events at work. If you involve them in creating the plans and traditions, celebrating holidays and annual events in the workplace improves employee morale, motivation, and engagement.
Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. also organizes Eid Millan parties in the company premises where they not only invite the current employees but also those employees who have left the company which shows that means they give importance to the people who work for them such values improve the image of the company in the minds of the ex-employees and is also beneficial for the company as
Page 56 of 66
this will make them meet the current employees of the company and share their experiences and enhance the learning of the current employees.
Page 57 of 66
b) Employee Retention : Mentoring programmes are the closest thing to guarantee of employee retention. Employees feel sense of loyalty towards them from organization when they are mentored. They feel nurtured when they achieve their goal and guidance. Page 58 of 66
c) Talent Development : Mentoring is a process that makes an employee realizes his / her full potential through exposure to situations in which employees do self-awareness and self-direction practices. d) Recruitment and On boarding : Once an organization offers mentoring programmes it automatically makes the hiring procedure and hiring step simple for the organization as competent individuals are attracted to organizations therefore organization dont have to search deep for required. e) Diversity Enhancement : Mentoring programme is so crucial to diversity enhancement that female and international employees accept the fact that mentoring programmes in an organization makes them decide whether to join an organization or not f) Knowledge sharing : It is very important for organizations to maintain knowledge through experienced and senior employees. Mentoring programmes provide direct opportunities for knowledge sharingenhancing and tapping knowledge capital within an organization.
Page 59 of 66
THE BELIEF OF THE MANAGEMENT AT DOLLAR INDUSTRIES (PVT) LTD. REGARDING THE CONCEPT: BORN LEADER OR MADE LEADER
Leadership is a very broad and vast term , throughout history human civilization has come across great leaders who served humanity for different purposes and it has also come across some leaders who have in fact caused harm to humanity for example Adolf Hitler . Whether leaders served for good or bad but the fact they were born leaders or transformed leaders cannot be ignored. Throughout history since appearance of concept of leadership on the face of earth there have been different theories and concepts about leadership which revolve around the debate that are born or transformed leaders better, which kind of leaders can lead the organizations better. The Management believes that attitudes are difficult to be taught but skills can be developed so they give more attention to a persons attitude during the process of hiring because if such a person is hired who is not compatible with the companys culture than there will be a lot of friction which will result in low performance and high turnover. Therefore they hire people who are compatible with the companys culture and then work on their training and teach them how to become leaders. At Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. currently both kinds of leaders are given equal importance and opportunities to lead the company. Leaders having natural attitude to guide and mentor subordinates are efficient in some departments where new skills are not be learned but on the other hand transformed leaders in the departments where new skills play important role and could be learned in days . All the hiring at dollar industries is highly merit based individual with exceptional attitudes and expertise hired so that it maintains its high standards. The hiring process involves scanning of applicants, preliminary interviews, and panel interviews and in the last selection takes place.
Page 60 of 66
CONCLUSION
Leadership is an ability of influencing someone for achievement of a goal. A leader is a change agent and must be caring, daring, and sharing, leaders are the ones who do not go after power but power comes to them. The learning from working on this report is that leadership is more about personality traits and characteristics of a person rather than an official designation, as we know that every manager is not a leader, so if there is a clash between the word and work of a leader then he will bounce in the eyes of his followers just like a cheque bounces when the signature on the cheque does not match the example provided at the opening of the account. Leadership is one of the most important ingredients that are required for the organizational success, may it be a business organization, a sports team, a revolutionary organization, a political party or even if it is a family because a family is itself a small organization. Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. is one of those companies that not only understand but also implement the concepts of true leadership as they treat their employees like human beings and not like their possession. From the examples of application of the leadership concepts at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd. it can be learned that how important this ingredient is and how much investment it requires, and companies invest in it because such activities give them the benefit of sustainability and the employees loyalty, trust, commitment, high morale.
Page 61 of 66
RECOMMENDATIONS
Although Dollar Industies (Pvt) Ltd. has not left much room for us to give our recommendations to them at least on the topic of leadership, but still some recommendations are given below, as we know that there is always room for improvement and that the learning process of a human being keeps on going throughout his life. Recommendation 1: It was learned during the meeting that the company encourages their senior employees to do mentoring of their subordinates, but as the mentoring process is highly important and very beneficial for any organization, we would recommend the company to particularly hire a few personnel who are trained and qualified specially for mentoring others and assign them this job so that the employees can get more authentic and specialized counseling service. We would also like to recommend the assigning of scheduled appointments to different employees for mentoring with these specialists. In this way the mentoring process can be performed in a much organized manner. Recommendation 2: The company appreciates its employees to come up with new ideas and suggestions. They also acknowledge these ideas and suggestions with letters of appreciation and rewards. Our recommendation for this process would be make it more organized and participative, which can be done in a lot of ways, such as by giving extra budget to senior employees to work on their innovative ideas or by even keeping a scheduled half-yearly or annual function in which people can speak out their ideas in front of the whole Board of Directors, this will increase motivation and people will then do proper research work on their ideas before presenting them and this will bring to the company more filtered and well furnished ideas and suggestions.
Page 62 of 66
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Following are the sources from which we took help for the making of this report: www.dollar-stationery.com www.google.com http://hbswk.hbs.edu hbr.org Course Book: Organizational Behavior (Fourteenth Edition) By:o Stephen P. Robbins o Timothy A. Judge o Neharika Vohra.
Page 63 of 66
APPENDIX
Following is the questionnaire which was used by our group member during the meeting with Mr. Shahid Ghazanfer (Manager Personnel and Admin) at Dollar Industries (Pvt) Ltd :-
1. What is the general style of leadership that is followed in your company? 2. How much do you believe in the leadership theories? 3. Is any theory adopted practically? 4. Please tell about the Leader-worker relationship here. 5. What is the Organizational Structure of your company? 6. What is the level of trust and participation of the workers? 7. What is the image of the leader in your company? 8. Is there any mentoring process that takes place? 9. Born leaders or made leaders What are your views? 10. What is the role of the Managers, Directors and Shareholders in your company? 11. What is the level of independence and self-actualization given to the workers? 12. What is the selection process of the leaders? 13. Are the workers trained and promoted to become leaders?
Page 64 of 66
GLOSSARY
Commensurate: corresponding in amount, magnitude, or degree Diligent: constant in effort to accomplish something Remuneration: something that rewards Discerning: showing good or outstanding judgment and understanding Harbouring: to keep or hold in the mind Barter: to bargain away unwisely or dishonorably Procrastinate: to defer action Continuum: a continuous extent, series, or whole. Kaizen: continuous improvement process Carcinogenic: agent that tends to produce a problem Compel: to force or drive, especially to a course of action Ruinous: destructive; disastrous Contemplating: to consider thoroughly Partialities: a special fondness, preference, or liking Unison: a process in which all elements behave in the same way at the same time Self-explanatory: obvious. Perennial: lasting for an indefinitely long time Consensus: general agreement or concord Micromanage: to manage or control with excessive attention to minor details Counterbalance: or influence acting in opposition Entrepreneurial: a person who organizes and manages any enterprise, especially a business, usually with considerable initiative and risk Stagnant: characterized by lack of development, advancement, or progressive movement
Page 65 of 66
INDEX
Reorienting Stores Around Relationships 12 Rebuilding The Connection To Community 12 Refocusing On The Employee Experience Charisma 26 Individual consideration 26 Intellectual simulation 26 Courage dependability 26 Competitive strategic leadership 26 Why companies fail 29 What the expert says One perfect mentor30 Mentoring a formal long-term relationship 30 Mentoring is for junior people 31 Mentoring is done by experience people 31 Do you need mentoring 31 Multiple mentors Experts say 33 Watch for warning signs 34 Understand why you are not delegating 34 Measure how you are doing Choose the right people Ask others to hold you accountable 35 Really let go 35 Learn from experience 35 Principles to remember 36 Employee involvement model 38 Stages of leadership 40 Leading with values 45 First class business in a first class way 46 Customer lead our business 46 People are one of the most important assets 46 Let us be responsible to the next generation 48 Technology is the route to excellence 48 34 34 31 30 12 Brands 49 World class manufacturing systems 53 Process and technology 54 Technology in our business 54 Operational excellence Quality 54 Quality policy 55 Application of leadership theories 56 styles of leadership participative 57 task driven 57 autocratic bureaucratic 57 charismatic leadership 57 Practical adaptation of leadership theories at dollar industries 58 Organizational culture and its importance 58 What is work culture 58 Work culture at dollar industries 59 Monetary motivators 59 Other ways to motivate employees 59-60 Leadership worker relations at dollar industries 60 How to built effective relationship with employees 60 Consistency at dollar industries 61 Caring culture 61 Communication 61 Team building activities 62 Team building activities at dollar industries 62 Mentoring process 63 Mentoring at dollar industries 63 Who should be mentored 64 Is mentoring right for you 64 Benefits of mentoring 64-75 Born or made leaders 65 66 57 54
Page 66 of 66