March 13, 2013 PM

3655
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
IN RE: OIL SPILL BY THE OIL RIG

DEEPWATER HORIZON IN THE
GULF OF MEXICO ON APRIL 20, 2010
*
*
*
*
Applies to:
*
*
Docket 10-CV-02771,
*
IN RE: THE COMPLAINT AND
*
PETITION OF TRITON ASSET
*
LEASING GmbH, et al
*
*
Docket 10-CV-4536,
*
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v.
*
BP EXPLORATION & PRODUCTION,
*
INC., et al
*
*
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Docket 10-MD-2179
Section J
New Orleans, Louisiana
March 13, 2013
13
14
DAY 11, AFTERNOON SESSION

TRANSCRIPT OF NONJURY TRIAL
BEFORE THE HONORABLE CARL J. BARBIER
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE
15
16
17
18
19
Appearances:
For the Plaintiffs:
Domengeaux Wright Roy

& Edwards, LLC
BY: JAMES P. ROY, ESQ.
556 Jefferson Street, Suite 500
Post Office Box 3668
Lafayette, Louisiana 70502
For the Plaintiffs:
Herman Herman & Katz, LLC

BY: STEPHEN J. HERMAN, ESQ.
820 O'Keefe Avenue
New Orleans, Louisiana 70113
20
21
22
23
24
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3656
1
2
3
Appearances:
For the Plaintiffs:
Cunningham Bounds, LLC

BY: ROBERT T. CUNNINGHAM, ESQ.
1601 Dauphin Street
Mobile, Alabama 36604
For the Plaintiffs:
Lewis Kullman Sterbcow & Abramson

BY: PAUL M. STERBCOW, ESQ.
601 Poydras Street, Suite 2615
For the Plaintiffs:
Breit Drescher Imprevento

& Walker, PC
BY: JEFFREY A. BREIT, ESQ.
600 22nd Street, Suite 402
Virginia Beach, Virginia 23451
For the Plaintiffs:
Leger & Shaw

BY: WALTER J. LEGER JR., ESQ.
600 Carondelet Street, 9th Floor
For the Plaintiffs:
Watts Guerra Craft, LLP

BY: MIKAL C. WATTS, ESQ.
4 Dominion Drive
Building 3, Suite 100
San Antonio, Texas 78257
For the Plaintiffs:
Williams Law Group, LLC

BY: CONRAD "DUKE" WILLIAMS, ESQ.
435 Corporate Drive, Suite 101
Houma, Louisiana 70360
For the Plaintiffs:
Thornhill Law Firm

BY: TOM THORNHILL, ESQ.
1308 Ninth Street
Slidell, Louisiana 70458
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3657
Appearances:
For the Plaintiffs:
deGravelles Palmintier Holthaus

& Frug, LLP
BY: JOHN W. DEGRAVELLES, ESQ.
618 Main Street
Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70801
For the Plaintiffs:
Williamson & Rusnak

BY: JIMMY WILLIAMSON, ESQ.
4310 Yoakum Boulevard
Houston, Texas 77006
For the Plaintiffs:
Irpino Law Firm

BY: ANTHONY IRPINO, ESQ.
2216 Magazine Street
For the United States

of America:
U.S. Department of Justice

Torts Branch, Civil Division
BY: R. MICHAEL UNDERHILL, ESQ.
450 Golden Gate Avenue
7-5395 Federal Bldg., Box 36028
San Francisco, California 94102

of America:

Environment & Natural Resources
Environmental Enforcement Section
BY: STEVEN O'ROURKE, ESQ.
SCOTT CERNICH, ESQ.
DEANNA CHANG, ESQ.
RACHEL HANKEY, ESQ.
A. NATHANIEL CHAKERES, ESQ.
Washington, D.C. 20044

of America:

Torts Branch, Civil Division
BY: JESSICA McCLELLAN, ESQ.
MICHELLE DELEMARRE, ESQ.
JESSICA SULLIVAN, ESQ.
SHARON SHUTLER, ESQ.
MALINDA LAWRENCE, ESQ.
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3658
1
2
3
Appearances:
of America:

Fraud Section
Commercial Litigation Branch
BY: DANIEL SPIRO, ESQ.
KELLEY HAUSER, ESQ.
ELIZABETH YOUNG, ESQ.
Ben Franklin Station
For the State of

Alabama:
Attorney General of Alabama

BY: LUTHER STRANGE, ESQ.
COREY L. MAZE, ESQ.
WINFIELD J. SINCLAIR, ESQ.
500 Dexter Avenue
Montgomery, Alabama 36130
For the State of

Louisiana:
Attorney General of Louisiana

BY: JAMES D. CALDWELL, ESQ.
1885 North Third Street
Baton Rouge, Louisiana 70804
For the State of

Louisiana:
Kanner & Whiteley, LLC

BY: ALLAN KANNER, ESQ.
DOUGLAS R. KRAUS, ESQ.
701 Camp Street
For BP Exploration &

Production Inc.,
BP America Production
Company, BP PLC:
Liskow & Lewis, APLC

BY: DON K. HAYCRAFT, ESQ.

Production Inc.,
Company, BP PLC:
Kirkland & Ellis, LLP

BY: J. ANDREW LANGAN, ESQ.
HARIKLIA "CARRIE" KARIS, ESQ.
MATTHEW T. REGAN, ESQ.
300 N. Lasalle
Chicago, Illinois 60654
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3659
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
Appearances:
Production Inc.,
Company, BP PLC:
Covington & Burling, LLP

BY: ROBERT C. "MIKE" BROCK, ESQ.
1201 Pennsylvania Avenue, NW
For Transocean Holdings

LLC, Transocean Offshore
Deepwater Drilling Inc.,
Transocean Deepwater Inc.:
Frilot, LLC
BY: KERRY J. MILLER, ESQ.

Sutherland Asbill & Brennan, LLP

BY: STEVEN L. ROBERTS, ESQ.
RACHEL G. CLINGMAN, ESQ.
1001 Fannin Street, Suite 3700

Munger Tolles & Olson, LLP

BY: MICHAEL R. DOYEN, ESQ.
BRAD D. BRIAN, ESQ.
LUIS LI, ESQ.
355 S. Grand Avenue, 35th Floor
Los Angeles, California 90071

Mahtook & Lafleur

BY: RICHARD J. HYMEL, ESQ.
600 Jefferson Street, Suite 1000
Lafayette, Louisiana 70501

Hughes Arrell Kinchen, LLP

BY: JOHN KINCHEN, ESQ.
2211 Norfolk, Suite 1110
For Cameron International

Corporation:
Stone Pigman Walther Wittmann, LLC

BY: PHILLIP A. WITTMANN, ESQ.
546 Carondelet Street
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3660
1
2
3
Appearances:
For Cameron International
Corporation:
Beck Redden & Secrest, LLP

BY: DAVID J. BECK, ESQ.
DAVID W. JONES, ESQ.
GEOFFREY GANNAWAY, ESQ.
ALEX B. ROBERTS, ESQ.
1221 McKinney Street, Suite 4500
For Halliburton Energy

Services, Inc.:
Godwin Lewis, PC
BY: DONALD E. GODWIN, ESQ.
BRUCE W. BOWMAN JR., ESQ.
FLOYD R. HARTLEY JR., ESQ.
GAVIN HILL, ESQ.
1201 Elm Street, Suite 1700
Dallas, Texas 75270
For Halliburton Energy:

Services, Inc.:
Godwin Lewis, PC
BY: JERRY C. VON STERNBERG, ESQ.
1331 Lamar, Suite 1665
For M-I, LLC:
Morgan Lewis & Bockius

BY: HUGH E. TANNER, ESQ.
DENISE SCOFIELD, ESQ.
JOHN C. FUNDERBURK, ESQ.
1000 Louisiana Street, Suite 4000
Official Court Reporter:
Toni Doyle Tusa, CCR, FCRR

500 Poydras Street, Room HB-406
(504) 589-7778
Toni_Tusa@laed.uscourts.gov
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
Proceedings recorded by mechanical stenography using

computer-aided transcription software.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3661
I N D E X
2
3
PAGE
Joseph Keith
Cross-Examination By Mr. Brock
3662
Cross-Examination By Mr. Tanner
3705
Recross-Examination By Mr. Degravelles
3710
Redirect Examination By Mr. Hartley
3721
8
9
10
11
Geoffrey Webster
Voir Dire By Mr. Williams
3727
Direct Examination By Mr. Williams
3736
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3662
AFTERNOON SESSION
13:06
(March 13, 2013)
13:18
THE COURT:
13:18
MR. ROBERTS:
13:18
Cameron.
13:18
examination of Gregg Perkin yesterday.
13:18
exhibits this morning, and I heard no objection.
13:18
them at this time.
13:18
13:18
10
13:18
11
MR. ROBERTS:
13:18
12
THE COURT:
13:18
13
13:18
14
13:18
15
13:18
16
13:18
17
13:18
18
BY MR. BROCK:
13:18
19
Q.
Good afternoon, Mr. Keith.
13:18
20
A.
Yes, sir.
13:18
21
Q.
I want to pick up with a couple questions about your
13:18
22
access to the information in the mud logger shack.
13:18
23
A.
Okay.
13:18
24
Q.
I believe you said that there was a monitor there that
13:18
25
transmitted to the rig TV system?
Please be seated, everyone.

Your Honor, Alex Roberts on behalf of
I have two exhibits that Cameron used in its
THE COURT:
I circulated those
Move to admit
Anyone object to these exhibits?
Those are admitted.

Thank you.
Thank you.
All right, Mr. Brock.

MR. BROCK:
Thank you, Your Honor.

JOSEPH KEITH,
having been duly sworn, testified as follows:

CROSS-EXAMINATION
Are you ready to resume?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
Okay?
3663
JOSEPH KEITH - CROSS
13:18
A.
Yes, sir.
13:19
Q.
The display that would be put up during the time that you
13:19
would be in there would depend on the rig activity?
13:19
A.
Correct, or whatever the driller wanted me to put up.
13:19
Q.
Right.
13:19
or a curved line of pressure readings, correct?
13:19
A.
Correct.
13:19
Q.
As you described this morning, if you were to see an
13:19
indication of a kick or anomaly, you could expand the screen in
13:19
10
such a way as to be able to more clearly view what was going
13:19
11
on?
13:19
12
A.
Correct.
13:19
13
Q.
You also had a time log that would show the active pits,
13:19
14
the reserve pits, rotary torque, and that type of thing?
13:19
15
A.
Sure.
13:19
16
Q.
Now, your job as the mud logger was to monitor all
13:19
17
parameters, correct?
13:20
18
A.
Correct.
13:20
19
Q.
One of the tools that was available to you was the trend
13:20
20
lines that you could see as the data came through to you,
13:20
21
correct?
13:20
22
A.
Correct.
13:20
23
Q.
For some parameters, like drill pipe pressure, you could
13:20
24
also watch numerical values to see if it was changing?
13:20
25
A.
But for you, it could show either a digital output
Yes, sir.
Yes, sir.
Correct.
Yes, sir.
Yes, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3664
13:20
Q.
So when we say a numerical value, it would actually tell
13:20
you pressure over time, and you could see if it was moving up
13:20
or if it was moving down?
13:20
A.
Right.
13:20
Q.
Yes, a digital number.
13:20
13:20
13:21
13:21
13:21
10
A.
Correct.
13:21
11
Q.
You were relieving Cathleenia Willis, correct?
13:21
12
A.
Right.
13:21
13
Q.
I think I asked you about this before the break; but it
13:21
14
would be your practice to meet with her early, before the tour
13:21
15
would begin?
13:21
16
A.
Yes, sir.
13:21
17
Q.
On the afternoon of April 20, you reviewed the prior rig
13:21
18
activities -- that is, what had taken place that day -- plus
13:21
19
the planned activities for the rest of the day with Ms. Willis?
13:21
20
A.
Yes, sir.
13:21
21
Q.
I think you have described that that meeting took about
13:21
22
15 minutes?
13:21
23
A.
Approximately, yes, sir.
13:21
24
Q.
Now, you keep in the mud logger shack what you have
13:21
25
referred to today as a "ledger," correct?
The digital number, yes, sir.
Now, let's shift topics now to when you began your

service on the evening of April 20.
Okay?
You went on tour on the Deepwater Horizon between

5:00 and 5:30 that evening?
Yes, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3665
13:21
A.
Yes, sir.
13:21
Q.
That ledger is there so that you can keep a history of
13:21
what you have seen and what you have observed during your time
13:21
on tour?
13:21
A.
Yes, sir.
13:21
Q.
And it also is a good record for her to pass on to you
13:22
when you come on tour so you can see what's happened before?
13:22
A.
Yes, sir.
13:22
Q.
You would use that log or that ledger to track things like
13:22
10
pit transfers?
13:22
11
A.
Correct.
13:22
12
Q.
When you're monitoring pit volumes, you would write down
13:22
13
every time there would be a transfer and how many barrels were
13:22
14
being transferred?
13:22
15
A.
Yes, sir.
13:22
16
Q.
You were doing this to make sure that everything was going
13:22
17
to the right pits?
13:22
18
A.
As far as I know, yes, sir.
13:22
19
Q.
As part of your job?
13:22
20
A.
Correct.
13:22
21
Q.
Now, when you came on tour between 5:30 and 6:00, you
13:22
22
reviewed the notes that Ms. Willis had written down in her
13:22
23
ledger book to understand what had happened during her tour?
13:22
24
A.
Yes, sir.
13:22
25
Q.
You reviewed the time logs that were up?
Yes, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3666
13:22
A.
Yes, sir.
13:22
Q.
What are the time logs?
13:22
A.
The time log is the curved numeric curve lines, and it's
13:22
spaced out per time.
13:23
Q.
13:23
you look at that?
13:23
A.
Yes, sir.
13:23
Q.
And the other ones you have talked about?
13:23
A.
Yes, sir.
13:23
10
Q.
You asked Ms. Willis what steps she had completed and what
13:23
11
activities were coming up next?
13:23
12
A.
Yes, sir, correct.
13:23
13
Q.
You know that she had been at the operational meeting
13:23
14
earlier in the day at around 11:00?
13:23
15
A.
Yes, sir.
13:23
16
Q.
That's what you described before the lunch break?
13:23
17
A.
Yes, sir.
13:23
18
Q.
You discussed with her the displacement procedure for the
13:23
19
negative pressure test?
13:23
20
A.
13:23
21
where we were at at the time.
13:23
22
Q.
13:23
23
procedures?
13:23
24
A.
Correct.
13:23
25
Q.
You were shown this document earlier.
So you could see parameters like pressure over time when
We just went over the steps that had -- had been done and
Sure.
She showed you the M-I SWACO displacement
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
I want to just ask
3667
13:23
you a couple questions about it.
13:23
13:23
TREX-967.1.1.
13:23
BY MR. BROCK:
13:23
Q.
13:24
SWACO BP Deepwater Horizon displacement procedure, correct?
13:24
A.
Right.
13:24
Q.
You would have looked at it that night?
13:24
A.
Yes, sir.
13:24
10
Q.
Then if we look at 967.1.2, this is No. 3 on the list and
13:24
11
it says:
13:24
12
starboard with mud hose on her."
13:24
13
13:24
14
A.
Yes, sir.
13:24
15
Q.
That had already occurred by the time you arrived on tour,
13:24
16
correct?
13:24
17
A.
13:24
18
Q.
In other words, this activity had been completed, correct?
13:24
19
A.
Yes, sir.
13:24
20
at the time when I came on tour.
13:24
21
Q.
13:24
22
time you came on tour?
13:24
23
A.
13:24
24
Q.
Now, under Step 8 it says -- of the displacement it says:
13:25
25
"Switch to overboard discharge."
MR. BROCK:
If we could pull that up, it's
You can see here I've just called out that this is the
"Pump excess volume to Bankston and have boat on
Do you see that?
They had the spacer so much above the wellhead
So the mud had already been pumped to the Bankston by the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3668
13:25
Correct?
13:25
A.
Correct.
13:25
Q.
That activity had not occurred yet?
13:25
A.
Correct.
13:25
Q.
But you knew that it was upcoming during the period of
13:25
time you would be on the rig?
13:25
A.
Yes, sir.
13:25
Q.
Or on service in the mud logger's cabin?
13:25
A.
Yes, sir.
13:25
10
Q.
Then if we look at 1.4, we see that:
13:25
11
test is an apparent pass, discharge the remaining spacer and
13:25
12
seawater down the over board line.
13:25
13
13:25
14
A.
Yes, sir.
13:25
15
Q.
What this refers to is what we have talked about earlier
13:25
16
that took place after the sheen test, when the fluids were
13:25
17
pumped overboard and were no longer going past your flow meter?
13:25
18
A.
Correct.
13:25
19
Q.
After your discussion with Ms. Willis, you were aware of
13:25
20
the planned activities; that is, what was going to be occurring
13:26
21
the rest of the evening?
13:26
22
A.
Yes, sir.
13:26
23
Q.
You didn't have any questions about the M-I SWACO
13:26
24
displacement procedure?
13:26
25
A.
Yes, sir.
If the static sheen
Do you see that?
Yes, sir.
No, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3669
13:26
Q.
She mentioned to you the transferring of pits during the
13:26
displacement procedure?
13:26
A.
Yes, sir.
13:26
Q.
What we mean by that is the movement of drilling fluids
13:26
from one pit to another?
13:26
A.
Correct.
13:26
Q.
Ms. Willis did not express any concern about her ability
13:26
to accurately and continuously monitor the well from a mud
13:26
logging perspective because of the movement of mud during this
13:26
10
displacement, did she?
13:26
11
A.
I don't recall her mentioning it to me, no, sir.
13:26
12
Q.
In fact, she didn't express any concerns to you about the
13:26
13
activities that had taken place or that were planned to take
13:26
14
place for the rest of the day with regard to your mud logging
13:26
15
duties, correct?
13:26
16
A.
Correct.
13:26
17
Q.
At the end of the meeting, you had no concerns whatsoever
13:26
18
about your ability to accurately and continuously monitor the
13:27
19
well during your tour of duty?
13:27
20
A.
No concerns, no, sir.
13:27
21
Q.
Now, let's talk just for a minute about your
13:27
22
responsibilities during that period of time.
13:27
23
13:27
24
6:00 a.m. on the 21st?
13:27
25
A.
Yes, sir.
So your shift begins at 6:00 and is planned to go to
Yes, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3670
13:27
Q.
At that time, things had gone well.
Ms. Willis would have
13:27
come into the shack; you would have had a meeting at 5:30 or
13:27
so; you would have described to her what happened and she would
13:27
have the next shift?
13:27
A.
Yes, sir.
13:27
Q.
You have mentioned this.
13:27
crew had just circulated the spacer up above the wellhead to
13:27
prepare for the negative test?
13:27
A.
Correct.
13:27
10
Q.
Now, from the time you came on duty at 6:00 until the time
13:28
11
of the explosion, you would have been the only Sperry-Sun mud
13:28
12
logger who would have been working in that office?
13:28
13
A.
Yes, sir.
13:28
14
Q.
Did anyone come into the office the entire period of time
13:28
15
you were there?
13:28
16
A.
No, sir.
13:28
17
Q.
Did you leave the office -- other than the break that
13:28
18
we'll talk about in a little bit, did you ever leave the office
13:28
19
from 6:00 in the evening until the explosion?
13:28
20
A.
No, sir.
13:28
21
Q.
Your only responsibility when you were on tour on the
13:28
22
evening of April 20 was to monitor the data and the well
13:28
23
conditions?
13:28
24
A.
Correct.
13:28
25
Q.
You would have been monitoring all of the surface
When you went on tour, the rig
Yes, sir.
Yes, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3671
13:28
parameters during that period of time?
13:28
A.
Yes, sir.
13:28
Q.
You have described this, that you would be monitoring the
13:28
pits, the drill pipe pressure, flow-in and flow-out?
13:28
A.
And gas, yes, sir.
13:28
Q.
Gas and other things that you described?
13:28
A.
Yes, sir.
13:29
Q.
Now, there was some discussion earlier today about flow-in
13:29
rates.
13:29
10
A.
Yes, sir.
13:29
11
Q.
You could monitor flow-in, I think you said earlier today,
13:29
12
by calculating volume through the total pump strokes and the
13:29
13
volume pumped?
13:29
14
A.
Only by -- pumped by the stroke pumps, correct.
13:29
15
Q.
Right.
13:29
16
allow you to monitor flow-in?
13:29
17
A.
13:29
18
shows a digital number of how many barrels is being pumped.
13:29
19
Q.
13:29
20
say to us, "I was able to do that and perform my job
13:29
21
responsibilities adequately in that area"?
13:29
22
A.
Yes, sir.
13:30
23
Q.
Now, you were also able to continuously and accurately
13:30
24
monitor drill pipe pressure at all times while you were on tour
13:30
25
on April 20, 2010?
Do you remember that?
In other words, you had tools available to you to
Yes, sir.
In our pump output, where we change them, it
So in terms of being able to monitor flow-in, you would
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3672
13:30
A.
Correct.
Yes, sir.
13:30
Q.
Your testimony is you monitored the drill pipe pressure
13:30
from 5:00 to 5:30 all the way up through the time of the
13:30
explosion?
13:30
A.
Correct.
13:30
Q.
A couple questions about safety.
13:30
13:30
priority in your job when you were on board the
13:30
Deepwater Horizon?
13:30
10
A.
Yes, sir, very highly.
13:30
11
Q.
You felt safe on the Deepwater Horizon?
13:30
12
A.
Always, yes, sir.
13:30
13
Q.
You had been involved, as you have described today, in the
13:30
14
drilling of many wells where you were working with people with
13:30
15
SWACO and Transocean and BP and other contractors that were out
13:30
16
on the rig?
13:30
17
A.
Yes, sir.
13:31
18
Q.
You felt like that was a good team?
13:31
19
A.
Very good team.
13:31
20
Q.
If at any time on April 20 you had concluded or believed
13:31
21
that there was conduct or an event or activity that created an
13:31
22
unsafe condition, you understood that your responsibility would
13:31
23
be to report that to the company man, to the driller, or even
13:31
24
to the Transocean OIM, Jimmy Harrell?
13:31
25
A.
Yes, sir.
You viewed safety for yourself and rig personnel as a
Correct.
Yes, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3673
13:31
Q.
You made no such reports?
13:31
A.
Nothing seemed unsafe to me.
13:31
Q.
Thank you.
13:31
13:31
work if you believed that there was something unsafe.
13:31
A.
We always had the opportunity to stop the work.
13:31
Q.
If you believed that you were not able to monitor
13:31
important parameters related to safety, you could stop work.
13:31
A.
13:32
10
always felt safe that I could, yes, sir.
13:32
11
Q.
13:32
12
monitor your parameters.
13:32
13
you were able to monitor parameters that night?
13:32
14
A.
Yes, sir.
13:32
15
Q.
I think you have just said this, but let me just make sure
13:32
16
it's clear for the record:
13:32
17
duties until the explosion, you were able to accurately monitor
13:32
18
all the data you were supposed to in the mud logging shack?
13:32
19
A.
Yes, sir.
13:32
20
Q.
You never told anyone from BP at any time that you were
13:32
21
not able to monitor the parameters that you were required to
13:32
22
monitor?
13:32
23
A.
No, sir.
13:32
24
Q.
Never told anyone from Transocean that?
13:33
25
A.
No, sir.
You have said this:
You had the authority to stop
Yeah, but I was always able to perform my job, yeah.
Yes.
You felt safe that you could do that if you couldn't

And what you are telling us is that
From the time you assumed your job
I was able to do my job, perform my job.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3674
13:33
Q.
Now, there were some questions about activities that were
13:33
going on during the period of time that you were on tour.
13:33
13:33
A.
Yes, sir.
13:33
Q.
There was a slide put up about different things that were
13:33
going on that day.
13:33
A.
Yes, sir.
13:33
Q.
It's true, isn't it, that none of the activities that took
13:33
place on the rig between 5:00 p.m. on April 20, 2010 and the
13:33
10
moment of the explosion interfered with your ability to do your
13:33
11
job?
13:33
12
A.
Correct.
13:33
13
Q.
No activities on the rig distracted you or rendered you
13:33
14
unable to perform those mud logging duties at any time?
13:33
15
A.
I was still able to perform my job tasks.
13:33
16
Q.
Thank you.
13:33
17
13:33
18
and evening of April 20 were activities that you had seen
13:34
19
before when you were mud logging?
13:34
20
A.
Yes, sir, but not during displacements.
13:34
21
Q.
Do you recall saying that there was nothing unusual about
13:34
22
the rig activities on that afternoon and evening?
13:34
23
A.
I don't remember saying that, no, sir.
13:34
24
Q.
Let's look at your deposition briefly.
13:34
25
page 271, 7 through 12.
Do you remember those questions?
Now, the activities that took place on the afternoon
We are looking at
Do you recall being asked:
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3675
13:34
"QUESTION:
13:34
afternoon or evening of April 20, you had seen those
13:34
activities before when you were mud logging, right?"
13:34
13:34
A.
Certain things, yes, sir.
13:34
Q.
Let's look at the next question.
13:34
"QUESTION:
13:34
What was your answer?
13:34
A.
"No."
13:35
10
Q.
I apologize for asking you to do this.
13:35
11
us again how you had the drill pipe pressure set with regard to
13:35
12
the alarms?
13:35
13
A.
13:35
14
pumping --
13:35
15
Q.
Could you lean forward just a little bit?
13:35
16
A.
The alarm was set 150 to 200 psi above the normal pump
13:35
17
rate, and it was set 150 to 200 psi below the normal standpipe
13:35
18
rate.
13:35
19
up while they were pumping, if there was a pop-off valve going
13:35
20
off, and if there was a decrease, to let me know when they
13:35
21
turned the pumps off or just have an anomaly when they start
13:35
22
turning the pumps off or pressures off.
13:35
23
Q.
13:35
24
pressure" the same thing?
13:35
25
A.
"ANSWER:
The activities that took place on the
Yes, sir"?
"Nothing unusual about them?"
But could you tell
Once they went back to displacing while they were
I'm sorry.
That was to let us know if the standpipe pressure came
Are the terms "standpipe pressure" and "drill pipe
They're the same thing, yes, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3676
13:35
Q.
So if there is an increase of more than 150 psi on the
13:35
drill pipe, should the alarm go off?
13:36
A.
Yes, sir.
13:36
Q.
Is that how you had it set that night, according to your
13:36
normal?
13:36
A.
Yes, sir.
13:36
Q.
You're saying that prior to -- I think it was around 2120,
13:36
when the pop-off valve --
13:36
A.
The pop-off valve --
13:36
10
Q.
-- that's the first time the standpipe pressure went off,
13:36
11
alarm went off?
13:36
12
A.
Yes, because it exceeded the normal pressure.
13:36
13
Q.
If there was an increase of more than 150 psi on the drill
13:36
14
pipe prior to the issue with the pop-off valve, the alarm
13:36
15
should have sounded?
13:36
16
A.
13:36
17
see, if they were pumping at a different rate, I would have had
13:36
18
to go in and constantly change the alarm, you see.
13:36
19
Q.
13:37
20
pumping at a constant rate?
13:37
21
A.
Correct.
13:37
22
Q.
I want to talk to you about your break now.
13:37
23
A.
Okay.
13:37
24
Q.
There were some questions asked of you earlier today about
13:37
25
an interview that you had with representatives of BP about the
At my normal alarm setting, yes, sir.
That's while they were pumping at the normal rate.
You
So during the period of time 9:00 to 9:14, they were
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3677
13:37
evening of April 20.
13:37
13:37
A.
Yes, sir, I believe so.
13:37
Q.
You shared with the representatives of BP in that
13:37
interview that you did not take a break that evening.
13:38
A.
Correct.
13:38
Q.
Around that period of time, you had a -- you were given
13:38
some compensation and signed a release that was shown to you
13:38
earlier?
13:38
10
A.
Correct.
13:38
11
Q.
You never talked to anyone with BP about the compensation
13:38
12
that you received that relates to the release that we looked
13:38
13
at, did you?
13:38
14
A.
No, sir.
13:38
15
Q.
As far as you know, did anybody at BP even know about it
13:38
16
the day you met with them?
13:38
17
A.
No, sir.
13:38
18
Q.
That was a manager with Halliburton who came to you and
13:38
19
said, "Here's how we'll help you out," and they gave you some
13:38
20
sum of money for which you signed a release?
13:38
21
A.
13:38
22
was.
13:38
23
know when or if I would ever be able to come back to work
13:38
24
again.
13:38
25
Q.
Do you remember those questions?
Yeah.
He didn't know -- he asked me what my main concern
And I didn't want to lose everything I had, and I didn't
All right.
Do you remember, as you sit here today,
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3678
13:38
precisely the time that you took the break?
13:39
A.
13:39
out.
13:39
checked the flow, because I was definitely back in my unit when
13:39
they checked the flow.
13:39
Q.
13:39
been, would be around 9:08 because you know you were back by
13:39
the time they were doing the sheen test?
13:39
A.
I would say my break was roughly 8:30.
13:39
10
Q.
When you say you know you were back before the sheen test,
13:39
11
are you able to say how close in time you got back to the
13:39
12
driller's shack?
13:39
13
A.
13:39
14
checking of the flow.
13:39
15
Q.
13:39
16
sorry.
13:40
17
8:58 and 9:08, somewhere in that range?
13:40
18
A.
Roughly, yes, sir.
13:40
19
Q.
That's what I was coming to.
13:40
20
A.
Yeah.
13:40
21
Q.
So within 10 minutes of the conduct of the sheen test, you
13:40
22
would have returned to your mud logger shack?
13:40
23
A.
Yes, sir.
13:40
24
Q.
Now, before you left the mud logger shack, did you know
13:40
25
what time the sheen test would be conducted?
I know it was before they put the sandwiches and stuff

I know it was before that.
And I know it was before they
So one end of the scale, in terms of when it might have
I was in the unit probably about 10 minutes prior to the
So you would have returned to the drill shack -- I'm

You would have returned to the mud logger shack between
I don't exactly remember the time.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3679
13:40
A.
No, sir.
I had to go use the bathroom.
13:40
Q.
Now, do you believe that you left the mud logger shack for
13:40
your break around 8:30?
13:40
A.
13:40
around that time because the break stuff wasn't out yet, the
13:40
sandwiches and so forth.
13:40
Q.
13:41
logger shack at around 9:00, you would have looked at the trend
13:41
lines to see if there had been any developments during your
13:41
10
absence?
13:41
11
A.
13:41
12
13:41
13
it's page 22.
13:45
14
BY MR. BROCK:
13:45
15
Q.
13:41
16
by counsel for the PSC.
13:41
17
13:41
18
A.
Yes, sir.
13:41
19
Q.
You described for us how you could expand your view
13:41
20
monitor to depict the values in just this same way --
13:41
21
A.
Yes, sir.
13:41
22
Q.
-- if you chose to.
13:41
23
A.
Yeah.
13:41
24
Q.
Now, in this document that you were shown earlier by
13:42
25
counsel for the PSC, you see there that there is a box that
Roughly, yes, sir.
Like I said, I knew it was roughly
Now, your testimony is that when you returned to the mud
Correct.
Yes, sir.
MR. BROCK:
And if I could see TREX-91382.
I think
Now, this is the slide that was shown to you this morning
Do you remember this?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3680
13:42
says "Indication No. 1."
Do you see that?
13:42
A.
Yes, I see it.
13:42
Q.
Do you see that it says, "Drill pipe pressure increased by
13:42
100 psi"?
13:42
A.
Yes, sir.
13:42
Q.
Do you agree that there was a 100-psi increase in the
13:42
period of time 9:01 to 9:08?
13:42
A.
Yes, sir, I see that.
13:42
Q.
No.
13:42
10
A.
Yes, sir.
13:42
11
Q.
Sir, did you see that on the evening of April 20?
13:42
12
A.
Yes, sir.
13:42
13
Q.
You saw the 100-psi increase?
13:42
14
A.
Yes, sir.
13:42
15
Q.
But you made no call to the driller's shack to tell them
13:42
16
you had seen that?
13:42
17
A.
13:42
18
standpipe pressure decrease.
13:42
19
Q.
13:42
20
argumentative.
13:42
21
A.
All right.
13:42
22
Q.
You did not call the drill shack when you saw the 100-psi
13:43
23
increase, did you?
13:43
24
A.
Correct.
13:43
25
Q.
You told us earlier that your job is not to interpret what
Do you see that?
I'm saying, do you agree with that?

Yes, sir.
To me it's no indication of a kick.
I've always seen
Would you please focus on my question.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
I don't mean to be
3681
13:43
is going on but, rather, to call if there is a change, correct?
13:43
A.
Correct.
13:43
Q.
There is a change noted at 2101 to 2108?
13:43
A.
Correct.
13:43
Q.
Now, likewise, do you see the period of time that's noted
13:43
here, which is Indication No. 2?
13:43
A.
Yes, sir.
13:43
Q.
If you look over to the side, it says:
13:43
pressure increased by 246 psi with the pumps off."
13:43
10
13:43
11
A.
Yes, sir.
13:43
12
Q.
Now, has Halliburton trained you that if the pumps are
13:43
13
off, you should not be seeing an increase in drill pipe
13:43
14
pressure?
13:43
15
A.
13:44
16
that.
13:44
17
Q.
The answer is yes?
13:44
18
A.
Yes.
13:44
19
Q.
Halliburton has trained you that?
13:44
20
A.
Yes.
13:44
21
Q.
Now, I think you misspoke earlier, but I want to clarify
13:44
22
this.
13:44
23
13:44
24
whether or not you noted the 250-psi increase.
And my notes
13:44
25
reflect -- and I could have gotten this wrong.
I was trying to
Yes, sir.
"Drill pipe
Do you see that?
On the Horizon, yes, they trained me in certain ways like
You were asked a question by counsel for PSC about
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3682
13:44
listen closely.
My notes reflect that you said your screen
13:44
went blank or black?
13:44
A.
Yes, sir.
13:44
Q.
Were your screens black from 2101 to 2108?
13:44
A.
Not that I'm aware of, no, sir.
13:44
black not too long after they turned the pumps off.
13:44
Q.
13:44
indications of drill pipe pressure?
13:45
A.
13:45
10
my screens and the gas and all that came in my unit.
13:45
11
Q.
13:45
12
confusion, sir.
13:45
13
A.
Okay.
13:45
14
Q.
We are talking about the period of time now during the
13:45
15
sheen test.
13:45
16
A.
13:45
17
about.
13:45
18
Q.
13:45
19
13:45
20
time 2101 to 2108?
13:45
21
A.
During the sheen test, no, sir.
13:45
22
Q.
That's what I'm asking.
13:45
23
A.
I got confused.
13:45
24
Q.
Now, you were trained that a 250-psi increase, when the
13:45
25
pumps are shut down, is something that needs to be
My screens went black.
All I know is they went
So in other words, from 2101 to 2108, you were seeing no
It wasn't long after when they turned the pumps off that
So this is -- I think this is the reason for the
Okay.
Do you follow that?

Yes, sir.
Now I understand what you are talking
So let me ask the question again.

Did your screens go black or blank in the period of
I'm sorry.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3683
13:45
investigated.
13:45
13:45
representative of BP on the rig to report this change in drill
13:45
pipe pressure?
13:45
A.
13:45
I've never seen the standpipe pressure increase for a kick.
13:46
Q.
13:46
correct, sir?
13:46
A.
Correct.
13:46
10
Q.
There was a change here that you did not report?
13:46
11
A.
Correct.
13:46
12
Q.
Now, if we go over to Indication No. 3, do you see there
13:46
13
it says, "Drill pipe pressure increased by 556 psi with the
13:46
14
pumps off"?
13:46
15
13:46
16
A.
Yes, I see that.
13:46
17
Q.
Did you see that 556-psi increase with the pumps off?
13:46
18
A.
No, sir.
13:46
19
Q.
Do you see at that point in time that there had been a
13:46
20
300-barrel gain that had been missed by the crew of the
13:46
21
Deepwater Horizon by 2131?
13:47
22
A.
A gain in what?
13:47
23
Q.
Gains in flow, flow-out.
13:47
24
A.
No, sir, I wasn't aware of that.
13:47
25
Q.
Is allowing a 300-barrel gain acceptable to you as a
Did you call the driller's shack or the
No, sir, unless to me it was an indication of a kick.
Again, your job is to identify changes and report them,
Yes, sir.
Do you see that?
In pits or what?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3684
13:47
representative of Halliburton before detection?
13:47
A.
Repeat that again.
13:47
Q.
If you have a 300-barrel gain, does that meet the
13:47
standards of Halliburton?
13:47
and you don't detect it?
13:47
A.
I guess, yes, sir.
13:47
Q.
You think that does meet Halliburton's standards?
13:47
A.
Oh, no.
13:47
Q.
It does not meet Halliburton's standards, does it?
13:47
10
A.
I see what you're talking about.
13:47
11
Q.
It's below the standards that would be expected of you as
13:47
12
a mud logger, correct?
13:47
13
A.
But like I said, I've never seen that.
13:47
14
Q.
I'm asking you a different question.
13:47
15
A.
Right.
13:47
16
Q.
A 300-barrel gain is below the standard that is set for
13:47
17
you as a Halliburton mud logger?
13:47
18
A.
300-barrel gain in --
13:47
19
Q.
Flow.
13:47
20
A.
-- in flow?
13:47
21
Q.
Yes, sir.
13:47
22
A.
Flow-in or --
13:48
23
Q.
Flow-out.
13:48
24
A.
Yeah.
13:48
25
Q.
Just one second, Mr. Keith.
That is, you have a 300-barrel gain
No, no.
Flow-out, definitely.
I apologize.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3685
13:48
A.
That's okay.
13:48
Q.
I want to turn your attention now -- well, hang on just
13:48
one second.
13:49
13:49
100-psi increase from 9:01 to 9:08, correct, sir?
13:49
A.
Correct, yes, sir.
13:49
Q.
Do you remember being asked at your deposition, if you had
13:49
seen that drill pipe pressure increase 100 psi from 9:01 to
13:49
9:08 at a constant pump rate, you would have called the rig
13:49
10
floor?
13:49
11
A.
I really don't remember, sir.
13:49
12
Q.
Let's look at your deposition, page 104, line 4 to 105,
13:49
13
line 14.
13:49
14
13:49
15
it, Mr. Keith?
13:50
16
A.
Yes, sir.
13:50
17
Q.
Now, let me just -- I'm going to let you read it, but I
13:50
18
just want to ask you a couple questions here.
13:50
19
13:50
20
the parties were there to learn what you knew about the
13:50
21
accident on April 20?
13:50
22
A.
Yes, sir.
13:50
23
Q.
You knew that you needed to give honest and truthful
13:50
24
answers to the questions?
13:50
25
A.
I don't want to do that yet.
Now, you have just told the Court that you observed a
Let's look at the question at the top.
Do you see
When your deposition was taken, you understood that
Correct.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3686
13:50
Q.
People explained to you, if you have questions or you
13:50
misunderstand a question, let us know, we'll rephrase the
13:50
question?
13:50
A.
13:50
myself.
13:50
Q.
You didn't tell anybody that that day, though, did you?
13:50
A.
Not that I recall.
13:50
Q.
Now, you also had the opportunity, did you not, to review
13:50
your deposition and make any changes to it if there were
13:50
10
inaccuracies in the deposition, correct?
13:50
11
A.
Correct.
13:50
12
Q.
You didn't make any changes, did you?
13:50
13
A.
Not that I recall, no, sir.
13:50
14
Q.
All right.
13:50
15
answers.
13:50
16
13:51
17
pressure increased 100 psi from 9:01 to 9:08 at a constant
13:51
18
pump rate, would you have called the rig floor?"
13:51
19
13:51
20
A.
"Yes."
13:51
21
Q.
(Reading):
13:51
22
13:51
23
said, 'Look.
13:51
24
taking a kick,' right?
13:51
25
Correct.
You've got to keep in mind, too, I wasn't
Now, let's look at these questions and
"QUESTION:
Now, if you had seen that drill pipe
What is your answer, sir?
"QUESTION:
"ANSWER:
You would have called the rig floor and
I think we have some indications that we are
I would have just told them that I'm seeing
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3687
13:51
a slight change."
13:51
13:51
A.
Yes, sir, if it would have stood out as a kick to me.
13:51
Q.
Sir --
13:51
A.
If it was -- okay.
13:51
Q.
-- is that what you said?
13:51
A.
Yes, sir.
13:51
Q.
(Reading):
13:51
13:51
10
13:51
11
13:51
12
13:51
13
A.
Yes, sir.
13:51
14
Q.
(Reading):
13:51
15
"QUESTION:
13:51
16
"ANSWER:
13:51
17
"QUESTION:
13:51
18
"ANSWER:
13:51
19
'Look, we're seeing a slight change in a parameter,' and
13:51
20
then it's their decision."
13:52
21
Do you see that?
13:52
22
A.
Yes, sir.
13:52
23
Q.
Then you were asked:
13:52
24
13:52
25
Do you see that?
"QUESTION:
Sorry.
You would have said, 'I'm seeing
something that we need to check out'?

"ANSWER:
No, just seeing a slight change."
Do you see that?
You just said 'just slight change'?
Yes.
No commentary on it whatsoever?
No.
"QUESTION:
Basically call them and tell them,
Would you have also called the company
man?"
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3688
13:52
Do you see the answer?
13:52
A.
"Yes, sir."
13:52
Q.
Now, the same is true for the 250-psi increase in the
13:52
drill pipe pressure that took place while the pumps were off
13:52
from 2108 to 2114, correct, sir?
13:52
A.
Excuse me?
13:52
Q.
Yeah.
13:52
oath --
13:52
A.
Right.
13:52
10
Q.
-- that if you had seen a 250-psi increase on the drill
13:52
11
pipe in the period of time 2108 to 2114, you would have called
13:52
12
the drill floor.
13:52
13
A.
If it would have stood out as a kick to me, yes, sir.
13:52
14
Q.
Let's look at your testimony.
13:53
15
answer that you gave where you said -- the question was asked
13:53
16
of you:
13:53
17
13:53
18
said, 'Look, I think we are having some indications of a
13:53
19
kick'?
13:53
20
13:53
21
13:53
22
A.
13:53
23
sir.
13:53
24
Q.
13:53
25
turned off -- pressure should not be going up when the pumps
If you had seen -- you have testified, sir, under
"QUESTION:
"ANSWER:
Now, we just looked at the
You would have called the rig floor and
No, I would have just told them we were
having a slight change."

Correct, yes, sir.
At the time, that's what I said, yes,
For the indication at 2108 to 2114, when the pumps are
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3689
13:53
are off, right?
13:53
A.
13:53
pressure valve.
13:53
Q.
Goes up a little bit and then it levels off, right?
13:53
A.
It's supposed to, yes, sir.
13:53
Q.
It didn't go up a little bit and level off here.
13:53
all the way up, 250 psi increase, correct?
13:53
A.
That's correct, yes, sir.
13:53
Q.
Under oath, when your deposition was taken in March of
13:53
10
13:53
11
13:53
12
increase 250 psi from 9:08 to 9:14, with the pumps turned
13:54
13
off, would you have called the rig floor?"
13:54
14
13:54
15
A.
13:54
16
indicator, it would tell me and it did not.
13:54
17
Q.
13:54
18
have called the rig floor with a 250-psi increase because you
13:54
19
know that's an anomaly, correct, sir?
13:54
20
A.
13:54
21
to me.
13:54
22
Q.
You didn't call them, did you?
13:54
23
A.
No, sir.
13:54
24
Q.
That's a different point.
13:54
25
I've seen it before the way they isolate the standpipe
It went
2011:
"QUESTION:
If you had seen that drill pipe pressure
And was your answer, "Yes, I would have"?

On here, yes, it does; but if it had showed up in the kick
Your answer under oath over a year ago is that you would
It's an anomaly, but it didn't show up as a kick indicator
They didn't call me either.

We'll take that up later.
You didn't call them, correct?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3690
13:54
A.
Right.
13:54
Q.
As a full-service mud logger -- this is your
13:54
description -- whenever you see an anomaly or a change that
13:54
doesn't make sense, you call the rig floor, don't you?
13:54
A.
Correct.
13:55
Q.
All right.
13:55
13:55
13:55
13:55
10
wanted to hand the witness --
13:55
11
THE COURT:
Sure.
13:55
12
MR. BROCK:
You don't have to step down.
13:55
13
13:55
14
13:56
15
BY MR. BROCK:
13:56
16
Q.
13:56
17
you recognize it?
13:56
18
A.
Yes, sir.
13:56
19
Q.
It's a part of the strip chart.
13:56
20
A.
Yes, sir.
13:56
21
Q.
So if we look over in the right-hand column here, do you
13:56
22
see that the chart that we have here is showing that you're
13:56
23
dumping the trip tank to the flow line right here?
13:56
24
A.
Yes, sir.
13:57
25
Q.
This is looking at a period of time beginning about 2100.
Thank you.
MR. BROCK:
Now, if I could please -- let me see
Exhibit Demonstrative 4388.

Your Honor, is it okay if I approach?
for that.
I just
I apologize
Thank you.
I apologize, Your Honor, just one second.
Let me see if I can orient you to what we have there.
Do
Do you see that?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3691
13:57
Do you see that?
13:57
A.
Yes, sir.
13:57
Q.
Which is about 9:00?
13:57
A.
Roughly, yes, sir.
13:57
Q.
Now, this blue or purple line here is flow, right?
13:57
A.
Flow-out, yes, sir.
13:57
Q.
Just to be clear for the record, when we say "flow-out,"
13:57
we mean flow back to the rig?
13:57
A.
Flow is coming from the wellbore back up to the surface.
13:57
10
Q.
"Flow-in" is what we pump into the well?
13:57
11
A.
Up and down the hole, yes, sir.
13:57
12
Q.
So you have got a dumping of the trip tank, and here's
13:57
13
your flow rate right here.
13:57
14
A.
Yes, sir.
13:57
15
Q.
These are pump rates over here, if we go to the other side
13:57
16
of the column, aren't they?
13:57
17
A.
Yes, sir.
13:57
18
Q.
Do you see -- in looking at these trend lines, where the
13:57
19
flow rate is at around, let's just say, 2050, do you see
13:58
20
that --
13:58
21
A.
Yes, sir, I do.
13:58
22
Q.
This is the kind of data that you would be monitoring on
13:58
23
the evening of the 20th?
13:58
24
A.
Yes, sir.
13:58
25
Q.
Now, you understand that we are going through on the rig a
Do you see that?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3692
13:58
period of displacement and as the mud starts to come back,
13:58
because you are pumping lighter seawater, you would be
13:58
decreasing the pump rate over time?
13:58
A.
Yes, sir.
13:58
Q.
This reflects a decrease in the pump rate over time here,
13:58
doesn't it?
13:58
A.
Yes, sir.
13:58
Q.
Now, do you see right here when the pump rate is at this
13:58
level right here?
13:58
10
A.
Yes, sir.
13:58
11
Q.
Can you characterize that for the Court in terms of what
13:58
12
that pump rate is there?
13:58
13
A.
Which one?
13:58
14
Q.
Yeah.
This is 50 here, so it's up above --
13:58
15
A.
Yeah.
I'd say roughly 60, 65 maybe.
13:58
16
Q.
60, 65 is what you call --
13:58
17
A.
Strokes per minute.
13:59
18
Q.
Strokes per minute.
13:59
19
13:59
20
pumps that are being --
13:59
21
A.
Yes, sir.
13:59
22
Q.
-- utilized --
13:59
23
A.
Yes, sir.
13:59
24
Q.
All right.
13:59
25
pump rate goes from around 60 or 65 at 2050 to down
Yes, sir.
Do you see that?
The red line?
These different colors are representing different
Now, do you see when you look at this that the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3693
13:59
significantly below 50 at 2100?
13:59
A.
13:59
pump rate down.
13:59
Q.
13:59
displacing with seawater?
13:59
A.
Yes, sir.
13:59
Q.
Once they are decreased here, they stay pretty steady over
13:59
this period of time, don't they?
13:59
A.
Yes, sir.
13:59
10
Q.
Now, I'm going to hand you a red pen to go with your
13:59
11
document right there.
14:00
12
where the trip tank has finished dumping right here?
14:00
13
do that for me?
14:00
14
A.
Yes, sir.
14:00
15
Q.
Okay.
14:00
16
document --
14:00
17
A.
Yes, sir.
14:00
18
Q.
-- that occurs after the trip tank has dumped?
14:00
19
A.
Yes, sir.
14:00
20
Q.
How many minutes after the trip tank has dumped do you see
14:00
21
that flow spike?
14:00
22
A.
It wasn't long.
14:00
23
Q.
Well, it's more than a couple seconds, isn't it?
14:00
24
A.
About a minute maybe.
14:00
25
Q.
Let's look at that.
Yes, sir.
It looks like they slowed the pumps down, the
That's what you would expect to occur because they are
Would you draw a circle around the point

Will you
Then do you see a flow-out spike on this
It was just a couple of seconds maybe.
Is that right?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
Here's 2100, and this
3694
14:00
is 2110.
That's a 10-minute period of time, isn't it?
14:00
A.
Right.
14:00
Q.
So from there to there is a few minutes, isn't it?
14:00
A.
From where, now?
14:00
Q.
From right there --
14:00
A.
Now I see where you are pointing.
14:00
Q.
Right where you circled where the trip tank is dumped --
14:00
A.
Right.
14:01
Q.
-- down to this high point right here is a few minutes,
14:01
10
isn't it?
14:01
11
A.
Correct.
14:01
12
Q.
Now, did you draw a circle on the high point right there?
14:01
13
A.
I just did.
14:01
14
Q.
Now, if we look back up here, do you see that at a higher
14:01
15
pump rate you have about the same flow-out --
14:01
16
A.
Yes, sir.
14:01
17
Q.
-- as you do down here when you have a lower pump rate?
14:01
18
A.
Yes, sir.
14:01
19
Q.
Thank you.
14:01
20
14:01
21
20th?
14:01
22
A.
14:01
23
flow-out sensor.
14:01
24
Q.
14:01
25
were detectable by you on the evening of the blowout?
Was that detectable by you on the evening of the
Yes, sir.
They had rig movement, and that affects my
But these values that we have just described in D-4388
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3695
14:01
A.
Correct, yes, sir.
14:02
14:02
BY MR. BROCK:
14:02
Q.
14:02
examination.
14:02
A.
Yes, sir.
14:02
Q.
Now, over here is where your mud logger shack is, correct?
14:02
A.
Correct.
14:02
Q.
I think you have described that you're on the same floor
14:02
10
or the same level as the drill shack?
14:02
11
A.
Same level, yes, sir.
14:02
12
Q.
Now, do you see here we have "drill floor"?
14:02
13
A.
Yes, sir.
14:02
14
Q.
So this entire area here would be considered the drill
14:03
15
floor?
14:03
16
A.
Yes, sir.
14:03
17
Q.
And then within the drill floor, you have a drill shack
14:03
18
that looks right out over the rotary table?
14:03
19
A.
Yes, sir.
14:03
20
Q.
But if someone described that they were going to the drill
14:03
21
floor, they would be describing this entire area here, wouldn't
14:03
22
they?
14:03
23
A.
Yes, sir.
14:03
24
Q.
Where is the mud lab in relation to the mud logger's
14:03
25
station?
MR. BROCK:
Let me see D-2224, please.
This is a demonstrative that you were shown earlier in the

OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3696
14:03
A.
The mud lab would be towards this back side here, on this
14:03
side of the rig; the mud lab, on this side of the deck, on a
14:03
lower deck, the main deck.
14:03
Q.
Yes.
14:03
A.
Uh-huh.
14:03
Q.
-- is the sheen test conducted over here in the mud lab,
14:03
or is it conducted over here where your area is?
14:03
A.
14:04
gumbo with the flow line is and so forth, where it goes down to
14:04
10
the shakers.
14:04
11
Q.
Would it be a level below the drill floor?
14:04
12
A.
Yes, sir.
14:04
13
deck.
14:04
14
Q.
14:04
15
the drill floor but on the next level down?
14:04
16
A.
14:04
17
Q.
If someone said they were going to check the sheen test,
14:04
18
they would not be in the drill shack, would they?
14:04
19
A.
Correct.
14:04
20
Q.
Who mans the shale shaker area where the sheen test would
14:04
21
be conducted?
14:04
22
A.
14:04
23
or two shaker hands, depending on what's going on there.
14:04
24
Q.
14:04
25
conducted that you say you were not able to -- after which you
Now, when the sheen test is being conducted --
It would be performed in the shale shaker area, where the
It would be the next level down, on the main
So would it basically be under the rotary table or under
As far as I know, there's a shaker hand and -- maybe one
Now, there was a period of time when the sheen test was
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3697
14:05
were not able to observe flow, correct?
14:05
A.
Correct.
14:05
Q.
If you wanted to check flow, that is, to visually observe
14:05
whether or not there was flow coming from the well, where would
14:05
you go to do it?
14:05
A.
14:05
the flow lines to observe it.
14:05
system.
14:05
Q.
14:05
10
allows you to view what is coming out of the well until the
14:05
11
time that the diversion overboard takes place, correct?
14:05
12
A.
Correct, yes, sir.
14:05
13
Q.
Because at that point it does not go by your flow meter.
14:05
14
That's what you call --
14:05
15
A.
Correct.
14:05
16
Q.
But, in fact, that flow still goes by the Transocean flow
14:05
17
meter, which is a redundant flow meter that can also pick up
14:06
18
flow?
14:06
19
A.
I guess, yes, sir.
14:06
20
Q.
That's what you said earlier today?
14:06
21
A.
Yeah.
14:06
22
Q.
So was it ever one of your responsibilities, sir, to
14:06
23
actually go and visually look to see if there was flow coming
14:06
24
into the well?
14:06
25
A.
They shut the gate and blinded me off.
I would just look on Channel 14.
We never went down to
We could see it on the TV screen
So you have access to a TV screen, but that TV screen only
Yes, sir.
I guess -- yeah.
No, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3698
14:06
Q.
That was just not part of your job?
14:06
A.
Correct.
14:06
Q.
On the other hand, during the period of time after flow
14:06
was diverted overboard, the Transocean drill crew would have
14:06
the ability to observe their monitor as well as conduct or
14:06
order a flow check?
14:06
A.
Correct.
14:06
Q.
You didn't raise any safety concerns or ring any bells
14:06
when you were not able to observe flow after diversion
14:06
10
overboard, did you?
14:06
11
A.
14:07
12
that we have done before, the same way.
14:07
13
Q.
All right.
14:07
14
A.
You're welcome.
14:07
15
Q.
I'm just about through.
14:07
16
second.
14:07
17
14:07
18
14:08
19
14:08
20
14:08
21
BY MR. BROCK:
14:08
22
Q.
14:08
23
you about the period of time 8:30 to 9:00 when you were on your
14:08
24
break.
14:08
25
A.
No, sir.
Yes, sir.
They have always diverted it, every displacement
Thank you.
If you hang with me just a
I apologize.
MR. BROCK:
Could you put that -- actually, let me
see D-3185, please.

Your Honor, may I approach again?
THE COURT:
Yes.
I'm going to hand you 22983, Mr. Keith.
Okay.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
I want to talk to
3699
14:08
Q.
Do you see right here we have identified mud logger's
14:08
shack?
14:08
A.
Yes, sir.
14:08
Q.
I know we can't appreciate it just looking at this
14:08
picture; but this rig was enormous, wasn't it?
14:08
A.
Yes, sir.
14:08
Q.
There was only one designated area where you could go to
14:08
smoke, correct?
14:08
A.
Yes, sir.
14:08
10
Q.
Were there more than one?
14:08
11
A.
Yeah.
14:08
12
yeah.
14:08
13
Q.
So when you went on your smoke break --
14:08
14
A.
No, I went to use the bathroom, sir.
14:08
15
it wasn't just a smoke break.
14:09
16
Q.
14:09
17
14:09
18
smoked a cigarette?
14:09
19
A.
Half a cigarette.
14:09
20
Q.
All right.
14:09
21
about?
14:09
22
A.
Yes, sir.
14:09
23
Q.
This is where the mud logger shack is, here, correct?
14:09
24
A.
Correct.
14:09
25
Q.
Would you just take a pen and on that piece of paper I
Oh, no, sir.
There was a deck underneath the life capsules,
That's fair.
That was my main --
I went to use the bathroom.
I don't mean to mischaracterize it.
You went to the bathroom, you had coffee, and you
That's the period of time we are talking
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3700
14:09
have there just show me the path that you took to go on your
14:09
bathroom break.
14:09
A.
Okay.
14:09
Q.
I will get you to write it on there, and then I will maybe
14:09
let you show the Court after you do that.
14:09
A.
14:09
Okay.
14:09
Mud logging shack.
14:10
MR. BROCK:
14:10
10
14:10
11
14:10
12
is.
14:10
13
BY MR. BROCK:
14:10
14
Q.
14:10
15
helps you or not.
14:10
16
A.
To me it's the opposite.
14:10
17
Q.
That's fine.
14:10
18
Let's just don't.
14:10
19
A.
14:10
20
14:10
21
14:10
22
THE WITNESS:
14:10
23
THE COURT:
14:10
24
THE WITNESS:
14:10
25
I use my pointer or --
I'm trying to figure out which way the rig is facing.

Now I see.
Can I approach?
I don't mean to look
over his shoulder.

THE WITNESS:
I'm trying to figure out how the layout
I was told it was over here, but I don't know if that

Here's your shack here.
My unit was here.
Let's don't use that then.
That's fine.
Thank you for helping me.
I was trying to figure out the way it is on there.

THE COURT:
Where you were headed was on the same
main deck area?

Yes, sir.
Same level?
Yes, sir.
When I come down from the
rig floor deck, I walk -- there's a little flight of stairs.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3701
14:10
take like 20 steps down, and then I head underneath the rig
14:10
floor, out on the back side of the rig floor --
14:10
THE COURT:
14:10
THE WITNESS:
14:10
14:10
14:11
spool, the drawworks spool, and there's a door that goes right
14:11
there.
14:11
the break room is right there.
14:11
10
THE COURT:
14:11
11
THE WITNESS:
14:11
12
14:11
13
THE COURT:
14:11
14
there something between there?
14:11
15
14:11
16
they have the next deck, which was, I guess, the first deck for
14:11
17
the living quarters.
14:11
18
THE COURT:
14:11
19
14:11
20
14:11
21
BY MR. BROCK:
14:11
22
Q.
Just in terms of --
14:11
23
A.
It's the first deck that's underneath the main deck.
14:11
24
Q.
I thought we could do it with a pen.
14:11
25
help you.
So you're still on the main deck?

Main deck.
Actually, it's toward the
mud engineer's shack, the same way.

When I get to that end, we turn by the big
You walk down maybe 10 stairs, you walk in a door, and
What level is that on?

It's inside the living quarters.
It
would be the level beneath the main deck.

Is that considered the second deck, or is
THE WITNESS:
They have got the main deck and then
I guess that's what you would call it.

So basically you went to the living
quarters?
THE WITNESS:
Yes, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
Let me see if I can
3702
14:11
The mud logger's office is right behind the rig
14:11
floor, and it actually sits behind the firewall?
14:11
A.
Yes, sir.
14:11
Q.
You described for us on this break you went down a flight
14:11
of stairs, about 15 or 20 stairs, correct?
14:11
A.
And took a right.
14:11
Q.
You said in your deposition you took a left.
14:12
to reconsider?
14:12
A.
14:12
10
I take a left, it's going back towards the life capsules.
14:12
11
took a right to go back to the living quarters.
14:12
12
Q.
I'm not going to fuss with you about it.
14:12
13
A.
Yeah.
14:12
14
Q.
You went down a breezeway?
14:12
15
A.
Breezeway, yeah.
14:12
16
Q.
You described that as being about 50 yards?
14:12
17
A.
14:12
18
Q.
Then you turned by the drawworks school [verbatim]?
14:12
19
A.
Spool, yes, sir.
14:12
20
Q.
Spool?
14:12
21
A.
Yes, sir.
14:12
22
Q.
What is that?
14:12
23
A.
It's the main drill line for the block, the top drive.
14:12
24
It's just extra line they have when they slip and cut drill
14:12
25
line.
Well, it depends on how you are coming down.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
Do you want
You see, if
So I
That's fine.
3703
14:12
Q.
Gotcha.
You walked through the living quarters?
14:12
A.
Right.
14:12
Q.
Okay.
14:12
A.
About 10 steps, yes, sir.
14:12
Q.
Then you go through the living quarters which is another
14:12
15 yards?
14:12
A.
14:13
up a door, and you take another four or five steps, and there's
14:13
the break room.
14:13
10
Q.
14:13
11
through the breezeway, took that right through the living
14:13
12
quarters is, what, another 15 yards?"
14:13
13
14:13
14
A.
14:13
15
Q.
Then there's a flight of stairs after the living quarters
14:13
16
that's 10 or 15 steps?
14:13
17
A.
14:13
18
Q.
At the bottom of the steps, you walk straight, you open
14:13
19
the door, and you're at the bathroom?
14:13
20
A.
Yeah, the break room bathroom, yes, sir.
14:13
21
Q.
So you made that journey from the mud logger shack to the
14:13
22
bathroom, is the first thing you did, correct?
14:13
23
A.
Yes, sir.
14:13
24
Q.
Then you had a cup of coffee and smoked a cigarette?
14:13
25
A.
I grabbed my coffee and smoked a half a cigarette and then
There's one door you walk in.

Down another set of steps?
Not that far, no.
You take about five or six steps, open
So do you remember us asking you, "From the time you went
And you said, "Approximately"?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3704
14:13
I left.
14:14
Q.
14:14
changes in pressure -- 2101 to 2108 and 2108 to 2114 and you
14:14
did not report them?
14:14
A.
14:14
never seen a kick -- the standpipe pressures increase during a
14:14
kick ever.
14:14
Q.
14:14
correct?
14:14
10
14:14
11
14:14
12
14:15
13
the passage of the deposition I read in because I don't think I
14:15
14
noted it when I was asking him the question about it.
14:15
15
was -- this relates to the activity at 9:08.
14:15
16
105, line 20 to 106, line 20.
14:15
17
THE COURT:
Very well.
14:15
18
MR. BROCK:
I pass the witness.
14:15
19
THE COURT:
Cameron?
14:15
20
MR. BECK:
14:15
21
THE COURT:
14:15
22
MR. TANNER:
14:15
23
14:15
24
14:15
25
A.
On the evening of the 20th, you saw anomalies -- that is,
Correct.
They never stood out as a kick for me.
I have
That evening you saw anomalies and did not report them,
Correct.
It did not stand out as a kick.
MR. BROCK:
Just one second.
I think I'm done.
Your Honor, I just want to note for the record
It
The deposition at
Cameron has no questions of this witness.

M-I SWACO?
We have a couple of questions,
Your Honor.
THE COURT:
All right.
Mr. Tanner gets to make his
appearance.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3705
14:15
MR. TANNER:
14:15
14:16
14:16
14:16
14:16
14:16
THE COURT:
14:16
MR. TANNER:
14:16
14:16
10
BY MR. TANNER:
14:16
11
Q.
Just a minute, Mr. Keith.
14:16
12
A.
That's okay.
14:17
13
14:17
14
14:18
15
BY MR. TANNER:
14:18
16
Q.
14:18
17
and women of M-I SWACO, the mud company.
14:18
18
company that --
14:18
19
A.
Oh, yeah, M-I.
14:18
20
Q.
All right.
14:18
21
Mr. Leo Lindner, one of the mud engineers.
14:18
22
A.
Yes, sir.
14:18
23
Q.
Greg Meche, one of the compliance specialists out there
14:18
24
that day.
14:18
25
A.
with M-I.
In case you don't know, I'm Hugh Tanner
I'll just get set up here a minute.

THE COURT:
You were on the verge of getting the gold
medal for the entire trial.

MR. TANNER:
Surely that still works at this point, I
would think.
Maybe.
We'll see.
Well said.
CROSS-EXAMINATION
MR. TANNER:
Sorry, I'm setting up.
Robb, are you ready?
All right, Mr. Keith.
Mr. Keith, I'm Hugh Tanner; and I am representing the men

You know the mud
And you're friends with a guy out there,
Did you know Greg?
You know him?
Not as well?
I don't think I have ever met him.
His name doesn't sound
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3706
14:18
familiar.
14:18
Q.
But Leo is somebody who had been out there --
14:18
A.
Oh, yeah.
14:18
talking about.
14:18
Q.
He's a compliance engineer?
14:18
A.
Yes.
14:18
Q.
An M-I guy, you remember him?
14:18
A.
Yes, sir.
14:19
Q.
I really just have a few things.
14:19
10
14:19
11
You testified earlier today that on the evening of
14:19
12
April 20, you had made a call to the mud lab because you had
14:19
13
seen a small gain in the active pit?
14:19
14
A.
Correct.
14:19
15
Q.
You have testified that the response you got by whoever
14:19
16
answered the phone --
14:19
17
A.
Yeah.
14:19
18
Q.
-- was that the Transocean crew was cleaning out the sand
14:19
19
traps; is that correct?
14:19
20
A.
Correct.
14:19
21
Q.
Now, that answer satisfied you to the inquiry that you
14:19
22
had, you felt comfortable with that response, correct?
14:19
23
A.
Yes, sir.
14:19
24
Q.
Okay.
14:19
25
Yes, sir.
Greg Meche, now I know who you are
I just wanted to get up
here and clear up just a couple points.
Yes, sir.
All right.
Now, you mentioned that guy who answered the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3707
14:19
telephone, you said, sounded like it was Mr. Leo, Leo Lindner,
14:19
right?
14:19
A.
Sounded like Leo, yes, sir.
14:19
Q.
You said you made that call around 8:30, right before you
14:19
went on break?
14:19
A.
14:19
pit gain, yes, sir.
14:19
Q.
That was around 8:30 or so?
14:19
A.
Yes, sir.
14:19
10
Q.
That's what I want to talk about, too.
14:19
11
like Leo and --
14:19
12
A.
Right.
14:19
13
Q.
-- around the time.
14:20
14
correct?
14:20
15
A.
Correct.
14:20
16
Q.
Know him to be an honorable man, an honest man?
14:20
17
A.
Yes, sir.
14:20
18
Q.
That's what I want to go into just a little bit here.
14:20
19
14:20
20
this case, sir, I will represent to you that he went off-tour
14:20
21
at 7:30 on the evening of April 20.
14:20
22
A.
I didn't know that, sir.
14:20
23
Q.
If you will accept that for me, that he had testified to
14:20
24
that in a deposition?
14:20
25
A.
Approximately.
As soon as my alarm went off on the active
I know it sounded
As you said, you and Leo are friends,
If you could -- Mr. Lindner has provided testimony in
Are you aware of that?
Yeah.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3708
14:20
Q.
He has already testified in a deposition, I will represent
14:20
to you, that he was in bed at 8:10 this evening.
14:20
A.
I didn't know that.
14:20
Q.
Okay.
14:20
said it sounded like Leo, but if I'm telling you that there's
14:20
testimony there that Leo was off-tour by 7:30 and was in bed --
14:20
in fact, he had a funny story about how his gosh-darn alarm
14:20
clock and his TV that he used to wake him up, that's why he
14:20
knew he was in his room and what time.
14:20
10
A.
Yeah.
14:20
11
Q.
You are okay with that?
14:20
12
you?
14:20
13
A.
Right.
14:20
14
Q.
I guess in fairness to you, then, if -- perhaps if Leo
14:21
15
wasn't there to have the call, you had mentioned, I believe in
14:21
16
your deposition testimony -- and I'm happy to show this to you
14:21
17
if you would like me to.
14:21
18
A.
Yeah.
14:21
19
Q.
That in addition to -- and this is Mr. Lindner, the
14:21
20
compliance specialist who said, "Use that telephone in the mud
14:21
21
lab."
14:21
22
14:21
23
A.
14:21
24
of that lab.
14:21
25
Q.
So I guess the point I'm going to here is:
You
You wouldn't dispute that, would
Right?
Right.
There was a lot of people that would go in and out
And you had mentioned the compliance -- or the mud
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3709
14:21
engineer, Leo, the compliance specialist.
You mentioned the
14:21
Transocean guys --
14:21
A.
14:21
14:21
talk over each other.
14:21
intentionally.
14:21
you are agreeing or not agreeing in the middle of it.
14:21
can't talk over each other.
14:21
answer, then he gets to ask another question.
14:21
10
14:21
11
Mr. Keith.
14:21
12
BY MR. TANNER:
14:21
13
Q.
14:21
14
14:21
15
number of people used the mud lab phone?
14:21
16
A.
Correct.
14:21
17
Q.
You had mentioned, as I recall from reading that, that --
14:21
18
the mud engineer, correct?
14:22
19
A.
Correct.
14:22
20
Q.
The compliance specialist?
14:22
21
A.
Correct.
14:22
22
Q.
And I think you mentioned Transocean personnel and you
14:22
23
just said "and others," right?
14:22
24
A.
Yes, sir.
14:22
25
Q.
All right.
Yeah.
THE COURT:
Wait, wait, wait.
You-all are tending to
I know you are not doing it
But Mr. Tanner is still asking his question and
MR. TANNER:
So you
Let him finish, then you get to
We are just having too much fun,
We are going to slow it down.
Let's try that again.

You testified at your deposition, you recall, that a
I want to tell you as well that -- and if you
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3710
14:22
will accept this as a representation -- Mr. Greg Meche, the
14:22
compliance specialist, who you recall now --
14:22
A.
Right.
14:22
Q.
-- he has testified in this case that he didn't talk to
14:22
you on that day either.
14:22
A.
Correct.
14:22
Q.
So I guess the point I really want to make is:
14:22
you got the information that you wanted and the right
14:22
information, you aren't really sure who you really talked to,
14:22
10
are you?
14:22
11
A.
14:22
12
lab" when he answered the phone.
14:22
13
14:22
14
14:22
15
14:22
16
14:22
17
14:22
18
14:23
19
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:23
20
Q.
14:23
21
some point that evening, the gas sensor shut down your unit; is
14:23
22
that right?
14:23
23
A.
14:23
24
of our unit.
14:23
25
Q.
Okay?
He never said who he was or nothing.
MR. TANNER:
Although
He just said "M-I
That's really all I have.
Thank you.
appreciate it.
THE COURT:
Thank you.
Let's see.
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
I guess we are back to the PSC.

I have a few questions, Your Honor.
RECROSS-EXAMINATION
Mr. Keith, you indicated in earlier questioning that at
Yes, sir.
It's an automatic detector that we have inside
In fact, those gas detectors are all over the rig, are
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3711
JOSEPH KEITH - RECROSS
14:23
they not?
14:23
A.
14:23
company.
14:23
Q.
14:23
sensor; it is specifically Sperry-Sun's sensor?
14:23
A.
14:24
when gas comes in the lab.
14:24
Q.
It worked successfully, did it not?
14:24
A.
Yes, sir, it shut down instantly.
14:24
10
Q.
Were you aware there were sensors near the engine room
14:24
11
that did not work properly that night?
14:24
12
A.
No, sir.
14:24
13
Q.
Do you know of any reason, other than those sensors being
14:24
14
disarmed or simply not functioning because of being in the
14:24
15
state of disrepair, that they would not and should not have
14:24
16
worked that evening?
14:24
17
A.
14:24
18
14:24
19
14:24
20
14:24
21
14:24
22
THE COURT:
14:24
23
THE WITNESS:
14:24
24
That would be Transocean's.
Ours is provided for our
It's one of our sensors, M-I lab.
So the sensor you're talking about is not a Transocean
Yes, sir.
It's designed to shut my unit down in case --
I was -MR. MILLER:
Objection.
No foundation has been laid
for this question.

MR. DEGRAVELLES:
I'm just asking if he knows,
Your Honor.
I overrule the objection.
I was not aware of any of Transocean's
system being on bypass or anything like that at all.
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3712
14:24
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:24
Q.
14:24
had a long list of things that were your duties.
14:24
A.
Yes, sir.
14:24
Q.
You also mentioned that you were pretty stressed.
14:24
understand that correctly?
14:24
A.
What you mean by "stressed"?
14:25
Q.
I thought you said that it was a stressful job and that
14:25
you were stressed.
14:25
10
A.
14:25
11
to do for my tour for that night.
14:25
12
14:25
13
we could, first of all, pull up who it's from and to whom it
14:25
14
goes.
14:25
15
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:25
16
Q.
14:25
17
Mr. Kelly Gray from a Jonathon Bellow on April 11, 2010?
14:25
18
A.
14:25
19
time.
14:25
20
Q.
Who was on it?
14:25
21
A.
Yes, sir.
14:25
22
14:25
23
14:25
24
14:25
25
Now, you said in response to somebody's questions that you

Is that true?
Did I
Did I misunderstand that?
Not really stressed.
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
It was just they gave me more duties
If you could pull up TREX-4395.
If
Do you recognize this as an e-mail that went to you and
I have never seen that e-mail.
I wasn't on the rig at the
I was on my days off.
MR. BROCK:
Was Mr. Gray on the --
Objection, foundation.
He said he didn't
see it.
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
about it, Judge.
Well, he still may know something
I haven't had a chance to ask him.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3713
14:26
THE COURT:
Let's see where he goes.
14:26
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:26
Q.
14:26
even though you didn't get the e-mail, you knew about the
14:26
information conveyed in the e-mail.
14:26
14:26
14:26
14:26
14:26
10
14:26
11
14:26
12
to find a solution to this and quickly.
14:26
13
on this.
14:26
14
person per tour.
14:26
15
with the workload?
14:26
16
14:26
17
A.
Yes, sir.
14:26
18
Q.
In fact, were there, instead of two mug loggers -- on some
14:26
19
of the Transocean rigs where BP was the operator, did they have
14:26
20
three mug loggers?
14:26
21
A.
Not that I'm aware of.
14:27
22
Q.
Were you feeling that the two of you were overworked on
14:27
23
your wells?
14:27
24
A.
I was never overworked on the Horizon.
14:27
25
Q.
All right --
I'm going to read some of this to you and ask whether,
It says:
Kelly, Joseph:
Okay?
How are things?
I am
feeling that you two may be overwhelmed on our wells -MR. BROCK:
It says "overworked."
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
Q.
Sorry.
-- "overworked on our wells.
I believe that we need

I want your thoughts
One possibility is to increase your crew by one

Would one more junior mud logger help you
We have such a position on other rigs."
Did I read that correctly?
Maybe.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3714
14:27
A.
Never --
14:27
Q.
I'm sorry.
14:27
A.
I was never overworked.
14:27
never felt pressured or overworked at all.
14:27
Q.
14:27
Gray or through anybody at Sperry or anybody, period, that
14:27
Mr. Bellow -- did you know who Mr. Bellow is?
14:27
A.
14:27
head -- petrophysicist.
14:27
10
Q.
He works for BP, correct?
14:27
11
A.
Yes, sir.
14:27
12
Q.
Did you learn from any source that Mr. Bellow had the
14:27
13
feeling that you two might be overworked on the wells?
14:27
14
A.
No, sir.
14:27
15
Q.
Did you ever get the opportunity to respond to that
14:27
16
e-mail?
14:27
17
A.
14:28
18
14:28
19
TREX-611.006.
14:28
20
the whole page.
14:28
21
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:28
22
Q.
Do you remember being shown that document?
14:28
23
A.
Yes, sir.
14:28
24
Q.
It shows the equipment that's used in connection with the
14:28
25
work that you and other mug loggers do, correct?
All right.
Yes, sir.
No, sir.
Go ahead.
I was able to perform my job.
Did you get the message, either through Kelly
Jonathon Bellow is like a petroleum engineer or
I never seen the e-mail.
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
All right.
If we could go to
If you could highlight it some, try to capture
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3715
14:28
A.
Yes, sir.
14:28
Q.
It also has a long list of duties that you mug loggers do;
14:28
is that correct?
14:28
A.
Yes, sir.
14:28
Q.
Now, you are not suggesting to the Court today that you
14:28
were doing all these things that are listed on this piece of
14:28
paper, are you?
14:28
A.
Excuse me?
14:28
Q.
You are not suggesting to the Court, Mr. Keith, that all
14:28
10
of the things that are listed as your duties, that you were
14:28
11
doing them on the evening of April 20, 2010?
14:28
12
A.
14:28
13
certain activities.
14:29
14
Q.
14:29
15
in a number of other wells before the Macondo well, correct?
14:29
16
A.
Yes, sir.
14:29
17
Q.
Do you understand that few, if any, of those wells were
14:29
18
no-salt soft formation wells?
14:29
19
A.
Excuse me?
14:29
20
Q.
Yes, sir.
14:29
21
formation wells"?
14:29
22
A.
No, sir.
14:29
23
Q.
Do you know that this well was called the "Well from
14:29
24
Hell"?
14:29
25
No, sir.
There's certain things you have to do for
All right.
You also were asked about having participated
Have you ever heard the phrase "no-salt soft
I have never heard of them called like that, no.
MR. BROCK:
Your Honor, I object to this as being
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3716
14:29
beyond the scope of any of the examinations that have been
14:29
conducted.
14:29
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:29
MR. BROCK:
14:29
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:29
He was asked about these other -- participating
14:29
in these other wells, the suggestion being that he had all the
14:29
superlatives about how great it was to work on this rig and how
14:29
great the rig was.
14:29
10
whether he knows whether this particular well was different
14:29
11
from the other wells that he had worked on.
14:29
12
14:29
13
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:29
14
Q.
14:30
15
else that this was -- the Macondo well was the Well from Hell?
14:30
16
A.
14:30
17
about that.
14:30
18
Q.
14:30
19
Hell?
14:30
20
A.
14:30
21
MR. MILLER:
14:30
22
THE COURT:
14:30
23
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:30
24
It's for the -- I'm sorry.
14:30
25
He was asked, Judge, about --
Yeah, I -Excuse me.
May I respond?
What I'm trying to find out, Judge, is
THE COURT:
Let's see where it goes.
Go ahead.
Mr. Keith, have you ever heard the phrase from anybody
Yes, sir.
A lot of the rig hands were talking, mentioning
Did you know the reason they were calling it the Well from
Yes, sir.
Objection, hearsay.
I don't know how he would know.
THE WITNESS:
It's really not for the truth.
I can explain.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3717
14:30
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:30
MR. MILLER:
14:30
14:30
MR. BROCK:
14:30
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:30
THE COURT:
14:30
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:30
Well from Hell.
14:30
prove it from this witness.
14:30
10
14:30
11
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:30
12
Q.
14:30
13
calling this the Well from Hell?
14:30
14
MR. MILLER:
14:30
15
THE COURT:
14:30
16
THE WITNESS:
14:30
17
few sections had trouble when they had to set -- I think it was
14:31
18
the 20-inch casing.
14:31
19
because, I think, they took a shallow hazard kick or something
14:31
20
like that.
14:31
21
maybe, and they got the Horizon to take its place.
14:31
22
14:31
23
they accidentally pressured up the wrong way.
14:31
24
open or close that shouldn't have been opened or closed, and
14:31
25
instead some of pressuring up to test the BOP, they
truth, Your Honor.
Go ahead, Your Honor.
The reason is a circumvention of the
I think it's classic hearsay.

We join that objection.
May I respond, Judge?
You're not trying to -- go ahead.

I'm not trying to prove it was the
I think it's been proved, but I don't need to
THE COURT:
I wanted to know --
Overrule the objection.
What was your understanding, sir, as to why people were
Same objection.
Go ahead.
The original rig that drilled the first
They had to set it a little bit higher
I think the rig might have got damaged in a storm
As soon as we latched up to it with the BOPs,
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
They had a valve
3718
14:31
accidentally pressured up downhole; but they caught it.
Okay?
14:31
And then every wellbore section, we had problems, lost returns,
14:31
kicks, getting stuck, loss circulation materials, gas problems.
14:31
Just about every hole section, we had problems.
14:31
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:31
Q.
14:32
getting stuck is the March 8 kick that you and Mr. -- what's
14:32
his name?
14:32
A.
Nick Malczewskyj.
14:32
10
Q.
In any event, on the wells that preceded the Well from
14:32
11
Hell, did you know whether any of those wells were no-salt soft
14:32
12
formations?
14:32
13
A.
14:32
14
never heard subsoft or soft, anything like that, no.
14:32
15
Q.
14:32
16
control training manual, apparently, that you had used in your
14:32
17
training some 10 years ago; is that correct?
14:32
18
A.
Right.
14:32
19
Q.
Were you told in your training that at Transocean, if you
14:32
20
took a kick of over 20 barrels, that was a code red?
14:32
21
MR. MILLER:
14:32
22
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:32
23
of mind and what he knows about -- he claims to have had this
14:32
24
training manual and he knows about well control, and I want to
14:33
25
know if he knows this, Judge.
One of those hole sections that you talked about the pipe
I'm never heard that term before, just subsalt or -- I've
Now, you were asked about -- at some length about a well
Objection, hearsay, Your Honor.

Again, it has to do with his state
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3719
14:33
MR. MILLER:
He's not a Transocean employee,
14:33
14:33
14:33
14:33
14:33
14:33
14:33
Transocean, if you took a kick over 20 barrels -- you asked him
14:33
what Transocean told him or what Halliburton told him?
14:33
10
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:33
11
THE COURT:
14:33
12
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:33
13
Q.
14:33
14
part of your drills or whether it was part of the training that
14:33
15
you referred to when you looked at the training manual, in any
14:33
16
of your training were you ever told that at Transocean, if you
14:33
17
took a kick of over 20 barrels, that was a code red?
14:33
18
MR. MILLER:
14:33
19
THE WITNESS:
14:33
20
THE COURT:
14:33
21
THE WITNESS:
14:33
22
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:33
23
BY MR. DEGRAVELLES:
14:33
24
Q.
14:34
25
want to focus on -- if we could go to the right-hand section
Your Honor.
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
It doesn't mean he knows the answer
to the question, Judge.

THE COURT:
What's your question?
I don't understand
your question.
Were you told in your training that, at
I'll rephrase the question.
Okay.
In any of your training, whether it was on the rig as a
Same objection.
I've never heard of that, Your Honor.
Overruled.
Go ahead.
I've never heard of that term.

If we could pull up D-2105.
You have been shown this document several times, but I
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3720
14:34
where we're talking about 2130 to 2135.
14:34
14:34
A.
Yes, sir.
14:34
Q.
2135 hours would be 9:35, correct?
14:34
A.
Correct.
14:34
Q.
This is the time period in which there is an increase of
14:34
556 psi; is that true?
14:34
A.
According to what the graph shows, yes, sir.
14:34
Q.
Do you have any reason to dispute this graph?
14:34
10
A.
No, sir.
14:34
11
Q.
But you have no -- I understand.
14:34
12
representation of what was on the chart that you were looking
14:34
13
at, correct?
14:34
14
A.
Correct.
14:34
15
Q.
You have looked at that actual chart, correct?
14:34
16
A.
Yes, sir.
14:34
17
Q.
This is a true representation of what happened between
14:35
18
2130 and 2135 on April 20, 2010; is that true?
14:35
19
A.
14:35
20
little different.
14:35
21
Q.
14:35
22
this 556-psi gain because your gas sensor had shut your unit
14:35
23
down; is that true?
14:35
24
A.
Yes, sir.
14:35
25
Q.
Now, if the evidence in this case, Mr. Keith, shows that
Now, 2130 is 9:30, correct, 9:30 p.m.?
Yes.
I've never seen it.
So, you know . . .

But this is a
Yes, sir.
It's just the scales have been changed and are a
I understand.
Now, you have told us that you didn't see
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3721
14:35
the hydrocarbons did not reach the floor of this rig until
14:35
9:43, then your gas sensors could not have cut off or shut down
14:35
your unit at -- anywhere between 9:30 and 9:35.
14:35
true, sir?
14:35
A.
14:35
turned the pumps off.
14:35
Q.
But you don't know exactly when it was?
14:35
A.
It wasn't long after the pumps had turned off.
14:35
or two minutes, if that.
14:35
10
Q.
14:36
11
to the rig floor until 9:43, you would have no reason to
14:36
12
dispute that; isn't that true, sir?
14:36
13
A.
14:36
14
14:36
15
questions I have.
14:36
16
exhibits and demonstratives that we have used in connection
14:36
17
with this witness's testimony.
14:36
18
compliance with the Court's order.
14:36
19
14:36
20
14:36
21
14:36
22
14:36
23
BY MR. HARTLEY:
14:37
24
Q.
14:37
25
Isn't that
All I know is gas came in my unit not too long after they
That's all I know.
Maybe one
And if the evidence shows that the hydrocarbons didn't get
Correct.
MR. DEGRAVELLES:
Your Honor, that's all the
I would like to introduce all of the
THE COURT:
Okay.
And we will offer a list in
Very well.
Halliburton?
MR. HARTLEY:
Floyd Hartley.
REDIRECT EXAMINATION
You are almost there.

There are a few things I want to clear up to make
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3722
JOSEPH KEITH - REDIRECT
14:37
sure the record's straight.
14:37
14:37
14:37
14:37
A.
Yes, sir.
14:37
Q.
What time was it, as best you can recall, that you went to
14:37
take the break?
14:37
A.
14:37
break stuff wasn't out that the galley people bring, like the
14:37
10
sandwiches and so forth.
14:37
11
Q.
14:37
12
what time are those sandwiches typically set out in the break
14:37
13
room?
14:37
14
A.
Usually about 10, 15 minutes to 9:00.
14:37
15
Q.
Then how long were you back in your mud logging shack,
14:37
16
before you performed the flow check, when they shut down the
14:37
17
pumps for the sheen test?
14:37
18
A.
14:37
19
prior to them checking the flow.
14:37
20
Q.
14:37
21
checked the flow?
14:37
22
A.
14:38
23
one I had for all of my curves and stuff here.
14:38
24
14:38
25
Mike Brock, for BP, was asking some questions about

the break you took.
I would say it was around 8:30.
And like I said, the
That stuff wasn't out yet.
Based upon your experience on the Deepwater Horizon, at
I was roughly in my unit maybe eight minutes, 10 minutes
What did you do in that eight to 10 minutes before you
I went back and looked at the time log for the -- on the
I looked at the separate one that shows all my

separate pits.
There's separate displays for that.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3723
14:38
And I wrote down when I was back in the unit.
14:38
don't remember exactly what time it was that I wrote down in
14:38
the book.
14:38
Q.
14:38
when you came back from your break?
14:38
A.
Yes, sir.
14:38
Q.
Did you go back in time to see for the entire period you
14:38
were gone?
14:38
A.
Yes, sir.
14:38
10
Q.
When you reviewed that data, did you see any anomaly or
14:38
11
any indication that there was any problem while you were gone?
14:38
12
A.
I never seen no indications.
14:38
13
Q.
I want to pull up D-4388 that Mr. Brock showed you, and I
14:38
14
think you have a hard copy in front of you still.
14:39
15
14:39
16
with Mr. Brock?
14:39
17
A.
Yes, sir.
14:39
18
Q.
Do you recall him asking you some questions about the
14:39
19
pumps shutting down, the trip tank being dumped?
14:39
20
A.
Yes, sir.
14:39
21
Q.
Do you recall the questions he asked you about the 2108
14:39
22
time frame, where he mentioned this spike in flow-out?
14:39
23
A.
Correct.
14:39
24
Q.
On this chart, about what time was it that you visually
14:39
25
confirmed that the well was not flowing?
Did you view all of the screens in your mud logging shack
I scrolled back on my time log.
Do you recall looking at D-4388 a few minutes ago
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3724
14:39
A.
It was right after they first turned the pumps off at,
14:39
like, 2108.
14:39
flow line.
14:39
Q.
Right after that point where --
14:39
A.
Correct.
14:39
Q.
-- this chart shows a spike?
14:39
A.
Correct.
14:39
Q.
As you looked at the camera and you visually verified that
14:40
at 2108, 2109, the well was not flowing, what did that mean to
14:40
10
you?
14:40
11
A.
14:40
12
14:40
13
14:40
14
14:40
15
gone over this.
14:40
16
BY MR. HARTLEY:
14:40
17
Q.
14:40
18
respect to the phone calls you made.
14:40
19
14:40
20
on behalf of Transocean, he asked you about three phone calls
14:40
21
you made to Steve Curtis.
14:40
22
14:40
23
A.
Correct.
14:40
24
Q.
Were those the only three calls you made to the drill
14:40
25
floor that night?
I actually viewed that there was a no-flow at the
Yes, sir.
That the well was static.

MR. BROCK:
Objection, leading, and asked and
answered several times.

THE COURT:
Well, it is leading, and I think we have
One other point I wanted to clarify, Mr. Keith, with
When you responded to some of Mr. Miller's questions
Do you recall that?

Yes, sir.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3725
14:40
A.
I know there was a total of five phone calls.
14:40
Q.
With Mr. Kanner you talked about the mud lab.
14:40
A.
Right.
14:40
Q.
So there were four other phone calls is what you're
14:40
telling us?
14:40
A.
14:41
the trip tank to make standpipe pressure -- I mean, the
14:41
flow-out increase, and when he blew the pop-off valve and
14:41
staggered his pumps.
14:41
10
Q.
Did you call the rig floor before you took that break?
14:41
11
A.
Yes, sir.
14:41
12
Q.
Who did you talk to when you made that phone call?
14:41
13
A.
It sounded like Steve Curtis.
14:41
14
extension it was that I called.
14:41
15
rig floor.
14:41
16
Q.
14:41
17
14:36
18
BY MR. HARTLEY:
14:37
19
Q.
14:41
20
data.
14:41
21
A.
Okay.
14:41
22
Q.
In response to Mr. Brock's questions, you were asked a
14:41
23
series of questions about your duties in monitoring and
14:41
24
reporting.
14:41
25
Right.
The slow gain in the active pits, the dumping of
I can't remember what
There's two extensions to the
Last series of questions.

MR. HARTLEY:
If we can put up TREX-620.
This will be pretty familiar to you.
Do you generally recall that?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
It's the real-time
3726
14:41
A.
Yes, sir.
14:41
Q.
When you're on tour as the mud logger on the
14:42
Deepwater Horizon, do you place a call to the rig floor every
14:42
time there's a change in sensor data responses?
14:42
A.
14:42
they are transferring from one pit to another, I will make sure
14:42
that the curves are matching and so forth.
14:42
Q.
14:42
data, at what point do you make the decision where you are
14:42
10
seeing a change to make that call.
14:42
11
A.
If something doesn't look right to me.
14:42
12
me.
I mean, if, you know, I'm watching it and if I see
14:42
13
something stand out, first I look to see to what's going on.
14:42
14
And if I see that it's matching, like if they're transferring
14:42
15
from one pit to another pit, that means that they are
14:42
16
transferring.
14:42
17
14:42
18
14:42
19
14:42
20
14:43
21
14:43
22
14:43
23
14:43
24
14:43
25
Not all the time.
It depends if things match.
Like if
Well, explain to the Court, then, as you're monitoring the
MR. HARTLEY:
If nobody calls
Thank you, Joe.

THE COURT:
Mr. Keith, you're finished.
Thank you,
sir.
Plaintiffs?
MR. WILLIAMS:
The plaintiffs call Geoff Webster,
Your Honor.
THE COURT:
This is getting like an NFL game here.
Every time the ball changes hands, we have a whole platoon of
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3727
14:44
players who come up.
14:44
MR. BROCK:
14:44
14:44
THE COURT:
Was it identified with a number?
14:44
MR. BROCK:
Yes, sir.
14:44
MR. REGAN:
Let us scan it, and we will bring it
14:44
14:44
THE DEPUTY CLERK:
14:44
THE COURT:
14:44
10
14:44
11
14:44
12
14:44
13
spelling for the record, please.
14:45
14
THE WITNESS:
14:45
15
G-E-O-F-F-R-E-Y, W-E-B-S-T-E-R.
14:45
16
14:45
17
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
14:45
18
Q.
14:45
19
colleagues on the other side of the room here as Mr. Conrad.
14:45
20
14:45
21
been introduced as TREX-7672, along with his CV, reliance
14:46
22
materials, and reference documents attached.
14:46
23
to move for introduction of his report at this time
14:46
24
conditionally, subject to whatever objections there might be,
14:46
25
although I will note that there were no Daubert motions filed,
I'm going to offer this exhibit; but I
don't want to walk off with it, so I'll just leave it here.
tomorrow.
That's fine.
That's fine.
GEOFFREY WEBSTER,
having been duly sworn, testified as follows:

THE DEPUTY CLERK:
State your full name and correct
I'm sorry.
Edward Geoffrey Webster,
VOIR DIRE
Mr. Webster, I'm Conrad Williams, known to some of my
MR. WILLIAMS:
Your Honor, Mr. Webster's report has
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
And we would like
3728
GEOFFREY WEBSTER - VOIR DIRE
14:46
to my knowledge, at least with respect to Mr. Webster.
14:46
14:46
14:46
to strike Mr. Webster's report based upon substantial reliance
14:46
on the JIT report.
14:46
THE COURT:
14:46
MR. KINCHEN:
14:46
THE COURT:
14:46
MR. KINCHEN:
14:46
10
14:46
11
14:47
12
14:47
13
14:47
14
14:47
15
14:47
16
14:47
17
MR. KINCHEN:
14:47
18
THE COURT:
14:47
19
I see it.
14:47
20
that he can't rely on the JIT report.
14:47
21
MR. KINCHEN:
14:47
22
THE COURT:
14:47
23
MR. WILLIAMS:
14:47
24
MR. KINCHEN:
14:47
25
THE COURT:
MR. KINCHEN:
Your Honor, John Kinchen, Transocean.
In February of 2011, Transocean filed a motion
2012, huh?
I'm sorry.
February 20, 2012.
Right.
There was never a response filed by any
of the parties.
THE COURT:
Well, there was a ruling by
Judge Shushan, right?

MR. KINCHEN:
Not to my knowledge, Your Honor, there
was not.
THE COURT:
I'm looking at her order.
She issued an
order on Record Document 5902, on 2-27-12.

Right.
Which basically dealt with this issue, as
The only issue with his report and his testimony is
That's it.
That's the issue.
And that's what the --
I think everybody understands that.

Yes, Your Honor, we do.
I will take it up on cross.
Very well.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3729
14:47
MR. WILLIAMS:
Your Honor, I'd like to point out for
14:47
14:47
14:48
14:48
MR. WILLIAMS:
14:48
apparently it was double TREX'd.
14:48
been told we are to use is TREX-22700.
14:48
14:48
14:48
10
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
14:48
11
Q.
Good afternoon, Mr. Webster.
14:48
12
A.
Good afternoon.
14:48
13
Q.
I'm going to ask you a few questions about your
14:48
14
background.
14:48
15
could you tell us -- give us an idea of your educational
14:48
16
background, please.
14:48
17
A.
14:48
18
engineering and a Bachelor of Science degree in marine
14:48
19
engineering and naval architecture from Newcastle University in
14:48
20
England.
14:48
21
Q.
Do you have any memberships in any professional societies?
14:48
22
A.
Yes.
14:48
23
Architects.
14:48
24
Q.
Anything else?
14:48
25
A.
Yes.
the record, though -THE COURT:
So with that understanding, I will admit
the -- he's got a report and a CV?
THE COURT:
Yes, Your Honor.
It's actually --
The TREX number that I have
Okay.
Go ahead.
Yes.
We're not going to spend much time on it.
But
I have an Ordinary National Diploma in marine
I'm a fellow of the Royal Institution of Naval
A fellow of the Institute of Marine Engineers,
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3730
14:49
Science, and Technology, in the UK.
14:49
Q.
Are you a chartered professional engineer in the UK?
14:49
A.
Yes, I am.
14:49
Q.
But you are not a registered engineer in the
14:49
United States, are you?
14:49
A.
That is correct.
14:49
Q.
Could you just give the Court a brief overview of your
14:49
experience conducting audits, ISM audits, other regulatory
14:49
audits.
14:49
10
A.
14:49
11
marine superintendent for a large Dutch dredging company, an
14:49
12
offshore company, and worked around the world: India, Saudi,
14:49
13
South Africa, South America.
14:49
14
in '78 to build a $40 million vessel for a joint venture
14:49
15
between Bean Dredging and my company called Volker Stevin.
14:50
16
14:50
17
vessel and then setting up the vessel for operation, helping
14:50
18
train the crew and going through its safety situations and the
14:50
19
safety manual and all that with Bean Dredging and my company.
14:50
20
14:50
21
Circle.
14:50
22
wife didn't want to go and live in Canada, so I started my own
14:50
23
business in 1982 as a marine surveyor, naval architect, and
14:50
24
also as a consultant in the dredging business.
14:50
25
fair amount of that also.
Yes.
Well, I operated vessels until about 1982 as a
And I came to the United States
And I was involved in Avondale constructing the
In 1982, my company wanted me to go to the Arctic

We were dredging there with some big ships, and my
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
I still do a
3731
14:50
Then I also -- before I came to the United States, I
14:50
had been appointed a surveyor for Panama Bureau of Shipping,
14:50
which is an institution that works for the Panama flag state
14:51
issuing statutory certificates, and I then became the
14:51
New Orleans surveyor for Panama Bureau.
14:51
14:51
Bureau Veritas, which is a classification society based in
14:51
France, which is similar -- the same as ABS, ABS in the
14:51
United States.
14:51
10
and did a lot of safety surveys, safety equipment, safety
14:51
11
construction, for both Bureau Veritas and Panama Bureau of
14:51
12
Shipping.
14:51
13
14:51
14
Code, was coming into force throughout the world, including the
14:51
15
United States.
14:51
16
ISM and became what we know as a lead auditor.
14:52
17
14:52
18
on many different types of vessels and also on dredges and
14:52
19
drill ships and the various equipment.
14:52
20
Q.
14:52
21
just a little while.
14:52
22
14:52
23
marine superintendent.
14:52
24
duties of a marine superintendent involve.
14:52
25
A.
And then several years later, I got involved with
And I became a nonexclusive surveyor for them
In 1997, the ISM, International Safety Management
And I did a course here in New Orleans for the
And since '97/'98, I've been carrying out ISM audits
Okay.
We'll talk some more about ISM and ISM audits in
On your rsum you also have that you acted as a
Well, yeah.
Could you explain briefly what the
Shipping companies have, of course, crews on
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3732
14:52
board.
They have captains and chief engineers.
Then on the
14:52
shoreside, we have what's called a superintendent, or in the
14:52
United States it's termed "port captain" or "port engineer."
14:52
The job of a superintendent engineer is to maintain and dry
14:53
dock and supervise the repairs and the running and maintenance
14:53
of whatever vessels are in the fleet.
14:53
Q.
14:53
divisions of any companies that operate and/or own ships?
14:53
A.
14:53
10
running and operation of five VLCC tankers, a company called
14:53
11
Linea Peninsular here in Mississippi -- not to mention, of
14:53
12
course, Bean Dredging as well, and my own company.
14:53
13
Q.
14:53
14
shipping companies, were you involved in ISM safety issues for
14:53
15
those companies?
14:53
16
A.
Yes.
14:53
17
Q.
Have you ever stood any type of watch at sea?
14:54
18
A.
Yes.
14:54
19
17, I think, as the marine engineer for a company called the
14:54
20
Royal Fleet Auxiliary; and I stood watch as an engineer and
14:54
21
eventually sailed as a chief engineer.
14:54
22
Q.
How many years did you do that, sir?
14:54
23
A.
Approximately seven years.
14:54
24
Q.
Have you ever provided services as a marine architect,
14:54
25
obviously, in a non-litigation setting?
Have you managed the marine operations of any companies or
Yes.
I've been involved with Phibro Energy, with the
In the duties of the jobs you just described with those
I was an engineer at sea.
I went to sea when I was
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3733
14:54
A.
Yes.
Yes, many times.
14:54
Q.
Have you ever provided vessel design services to
14:54
contractors?
14:54
A.
I have, yes.
14:54
Q.
How about marine surveying services?
14:54
A.
Yes.
14:54
career.
14:54
Q.
14:54
or vessels under applicable international society codes, flag
14:54
10
state regulations, that type of thing?
14:54
11
A.
14:55
12
for a short while, the Polish Register of Shipping.
14:55
13
Q.
14:55
14
regulatory compliance; is that true?
14:55
15
A.
14:55
16
14:55
17
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
14:55
18
Q.
14:56
19
oceangoing vessels?
14:56
20
A.
Yes, I have.
14:56
21
Q.
Do you have any special knowledge or expertise in diesel
14:56
22
engine operation and maintenance, Mr. Webster?
14:56
23
A.
14:56
24
40 years, both repairing them, maintaining them, surveying
14:56
25
them, and purchasing them.
I've been a marine surveyor basically most of my
Have you ever been involved in the classification of ships
Yes.
For Panama Bureau of Shipping, Bureau Veritas and,
You have advised ship-owning and operating companies on
Yes, I have.
(Discussion off the record.)
Have you supervised shipyard repairs and refurbishment of
I do.
I have been working with diesel engines for
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3734
14:56
Q.
Have you in the past ever worked for Transocean or any of
14:56
its legacy companies?
14:56
A.
Yes, I have.
14:56
Q.
Could you briefly explain the details of your engagements
14:56
or engagements in that regard.
14:56
A.
14:56
but I do remember in -- I believe it may have been August 1992,
14:56
I was hired by a firm of lawyers in Houston, I believe, to
14:56
carry out a survey of the new DP MODU called the Cajun Express.
14:57
10
The vessel had been put under long-term charter to Marathon.
14:57
11
It had been built in -- I believe it was in Korea, had come
14:57
12
into the Gulf and started drilling.
14:57
13
14:57
14
the rig came off the wellhead.
14:57
15
happened, but they came into a big dispute with Marathon.
14:57
16
believe Marathon wanted to cancel the contract, which I
14:57
17
understand was a multimillion-dollar contract.
14:57
18
14:57
19
board with several of their senior personnel to carry out
14:57
20
basically an audit of the Cajun Express, to look at
14:57
21
particularly the problems that had occurred with the
14:57
22
dynamically positioned system.
14:57
23
that a German device called a "Hershman dioptric encoder,"
14:57
24
which is a device used to take electric signals and put them
14:58
25
into fiberoptic signals.
I'm not sure how many times I've actually worked for them,
And they had several uncontrolled drift-offs where

And I don't understand what
I
So I was hired by Transocean -- because I went on
They had actually found out
These had failed and caused a
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3735
14:58
complete shutdown of the rig.
They showed me all that.
They
14:58
showed me what they had done to correct the issues.
14:58
14:58
pipe-handling, pipe-racking systems, and other major issues
14:58
that they'd had, which really had occurred because the rig was
14:58
brand-new and they had teething problems.
14:58
Q.
14:58
marine safety?
14:58
district court.
14:58
10
A.
Yes, many times.
14:58
11
Q.
Have you ever been accepted as an expert in the
14:58
12
application of regulatory schemes to vessels and vessel owners
14:58
13
and operators?
14:58
14
A.
Yes, sir, I have.
14:58
15
Q.
Have you been accepted previously as an expert in ship
14:59
16
conditions and general matters of seaworthiness?
14:59
17
A.
Yes, I have.
14:59
18
Q.
Have you been accepted previously as an expert in marine
14:59
19
engineering matters?
14:59
20
A.
Yes, I have.
14:59
21
Q.
Have you ever been accepted before as an expert in matters
14:59
22
involving naval architecture?
14:59
23
A.
14:59
24
14:59
25
There were other issues that Marathon had with the
Have you ever been accepted as an expert in the field of

I'm talking about accepted in any federal
I have.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Your Honor, at this time we tender
Mr. Webster as an expert in the areas of marine engineering and
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3736
14:59
architecture, vessel condition and maintenance, marine safety,
14:59
and marine regulatory compliance.
14:59
14:59
14:59
MR. HAYCRAFT:
14:59
THE COURT:
14:59
MR. WILLIAMS:
14:59
14:59
14:59
10
Q.
14:59
11
Committee, of which I'm a member, to provide an expert report
14:59
12
and give expert testimony here in this matter, weren't you?
14:59
13
A.
That's correct.
14:59
14
Q.
You were deposed by all parties to this litigation,
15:00
15
weren't you?
15:00
16
A.
I was indeed, yes.
15:00
17
Q.
Let's get started on the meat of things, for lack of a
15:00
18
better word.
15:00
19
A.
15:00
20
and it's a code of safety -- basically safety regulations,
15:00
21
auditing.
15:00
22
international standard organization, which is a European-based
15:00
23
group.
15:00
24
15:00
25
THE COURT:
qualifications?
Anybody want to question his
Or we can do that on cross-examination?

No objection, Your Honor.
He is accepted.
Go ahead.
DIRECT EXAMINATION
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
Mr. Webster, you were engaged by the Plaintiffs' Steering
Could you tell us briefly what the ISM Code is.
ISM Code is called International Safety Management Code,
It's based on the ISO 9002, which was the
The ISM was enacted basically because there had been

a large number of major casualties of vessels, including the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3737
GEOFFREY WEBSTER - DIRECT
15:00
Herald of Free Enterprise, which was a ro/ro ship that flipped
15:00
over in Europe, killing many passengers.
15:01
bulk carriers, the Derby being one of them, which snapped in
15:01
half, killing all the crew.
15:01
15:01
that they should try to clean up the shipping companies, to
15:01
make them safe.
15:01
is 12 or 14 regulations which address the safety of life at
15:01
sea; they address the safety of the environment; they tell a
15:01
10
company what they have to do.
15:01
11
the qualifications and the certification of the crew, including
15:01
12
the captain, for example.
15:01
13
15:01
14
what's called a "designated person ashore," DPA.
15:01
15
purpose of that was to have the designated person be the
15:01
16
communication between the vessel, the operation of the vessel,
15:02
17
the captain, chief engineer, and the highest levels of
15:02
18
management.
15:02
19
happened with the ship and reported problems and deficiencies
15:02
20
and anything that was dangerous and, of course, tried to fix
15:02
21
them.
15:02
22
Q.
15:02
23
detail shortly.
15:02
24
15:02
25
There were some large
So the International Maritime Organization decided
So they enacted the ISM Code which, I believe,
They address the training and
And one of the major things they did was create
Okay.
And the
In other words, he basically controlled what
Thanks.
We are going to talk about that in some
Does the ISM -- did the ISM Code, on April 20, 2010,
apply to the Deepwater Horizon?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3738
15:02
A.
Yes, sir, it did.
15:02
Q.
Did the ISM Code apply to the Deepwater Horizon the
15:02
entirety of its life as a vessel?
15:02
A.
It did, yes, sir.
15:02
Q.
Of course, the ISM Code applies to the vessel's owner and
15:02
operator.
15:02
A.
15:02
have what's called a DOC, which is a Document of Compliance.
15:02
Q.
15:03
10
convenience?
15:03
11
A.
15:03
12
Panama-flagged, and then that was changed to the Republic of
15:03
13
the Marshall Islands.
15:03
14
Q.
15:03
15
the Marshall Islands, or you did before you rendered your
15:03
16
report, did you not?
15:03
17
A.
Yes, sir.
15:03
18
Q.
Does the Republic of the Marshall Islands, or the RMI,
15:03
19
mandate as a condition of granting the Deepwater Horizon or any
15:03
20
oceangoing vessel entering with its flag that the ISM Code
15:03
21
applies to that vessel -- those vessels?
15:03
22
A.
15:03
23
well, it could be ABS or DNV.
15:03
24
classification society to carry out the necessary audits and
15:03
25
surveys to put the vessel into ISM compliance.
Is that a true statement?
That is correct.
Okay.
Transocean would have to be audited and
Did the Deepwater Horizon fly a flag of
Yes, sir.
It flew -- well, originally it was
Now, you have reviewed the regulations of the Republic of
Yes.
They appoint a regulatory body, in this instance -And they appoint the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3739
15:03
Q.
In this case, it was DNV; is that correct?
15:04
A.
Yes, DNV were the ISM auditors for this vessel.
15:04
Q.
Did the Deepwater Horizon have what's referred to as a
15:04
"port state"?
15:04
A.
15:04
United States Coast Guard.
15:04
15:04
the -- by the IMO.
15:04
force," but they -- all ships have to be inspected on a regular
15:04
10
basis by a port state control.
15:04
11
certificates, make sure the insurance is correct, make sure the
15:04
12
vessel has the correct statutory documents, and also has to be
15:04
13
ISM compliant.
15:04
14
15:04
15
into port and does not have one of these requirements, the
15:04
16
vessel is actually arrested until such time as it's cleared up.
15:05
17
Q.
15:05
18
the United States, correct?
15:05
19
A.
15:05
20
15:05
21
please.
15:05
22
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:05
23
Q.
15:05
24
now, Mr. Webster.
15:05
25
point out some of the provisions of it.
Well, port state control in the United States is the
Again, this is something else which was enacted under

Basically it's like -- I won't say "police
The purpose, again, is to check
In most countries in the world, if a vessel comes
The port state with respect to the Deepwater Horizon was
Correct, the United States Coast Guard.

MR. WILLIAMS:
Carl, could you put up TREX-50361,
We are going to talk about the ISM codes in some detail

You have described what it is.
I'm going to
It should be on your
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3740
15:05
TV screen.
15:05
A.
15:05
was going for a hard copy.
15:05
Q.
15:06
Implementation, Part A.
15:06
A.
15:06
make it easier to see.
15:06
Q.
15:06
where objective evidence indicates the nonfulfillment of a
15:06
10
15:06
11
15:06
12
explain to us what that means and how it relates to the ISM.
15:06
13
A.
15:06
14
he found safety problems, let's say, with the fire system or
15:06
15
the fire main or the station bill was not correct or there were
15:06
16
many deficiencies in the logbooks, the logs weren't being kept
15:06
17
up, the oil record book, then that would be taken as an
15:06
18
nonconformity.
15:07
19
and normally given a certain amount of time in which to correct
15:07
20
the nonconformity, which the class will come back later on and
15:07
21
clear.
15:07
22
Q.
15:07
23
requisite amount of time, what typically happens or should
15:07
24
happen?
15:07
25
A.
I can read it now.
I couldn't read it to start with, so I
I want to direct your attention to Part 1.1.9 under
I do.
Do you see that?
Hold on one second.
Just let me get my glasses to
1.1.9.
It says that "Nonconformity means an observed situation
specified requirement."
Could you briefly put that in layman's terms or
Well, yes.
For example, if the auditor came on board and
And they actually are written up by the auditor
And if that nonconformity is not cleared up in the
Well, what should happen is that they write up a major
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3741
15:07
nonconformity, which is a pretty serious thing for a shipping
15:07
company to have because, if it's sent to the flag state and is
15:07
a major issue, then the flag state can withdraw the flag and
15:07
the vessel cannot sail.
15:07
Q.
15:07
1.1.10.
15:07
15:07
deviation that poses a serious threat to the safety of
15:07
personnel or the ship or a serious risk to the environment that
15:08
10
requires immediate corrective action and includes the lack of
15:08
11
effective and systematic implementation of a requirement of
15:08
12
this code."
15:08
13
15:08
14
A.
Correct.
15:08
15
Q.
Let's go down to Section 1.2, Objectives.
15:08
16
15:08
17
ensure safety at sea, prevention of human injury or loss of
15:08
18
life, and avoidance of damage to the environment, in particular
15:08
19
to the marine environment and to property."
15:08
20
15:08
21
outline all of the obligations of the ISM Code?
15:08
22
A.
Yes, they do.
15:08
23
Q.
Now, 1.2.2 says that "The safety management objectives of
15:09
24
the company should, inter alia:
15:09
25
ship operation and a safe working environment."
Okay.
Then let's look at major nonconformity, which is
It says:
"Major nonconformity means an identifiable
Is that correct?
Yes, sir.
Objective 1.2.1:
"The objectives of this code are to
Now, in this Objectives section, do they basically
Provide for safe practices of
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3742
15:09
Correct?
15:09
A.
Correct.
15:09
Q.
"Establish safeguards against all identified risks."
15:09
15:09
skills of personnel ashore and aboard ships, including
15:09
preparing for emergencies related both to safety and
15:09
environmental protection."
15:09
A.
That's correct.
15:09
Q.
During an ISM audit, this is one of the things an ISM
15:09
10
auditor would look at, correct?
15:09
11
A.
That is correct.
15:09
12
Q.
All owners of vessels that ply the high seas, that are
15:09
13
governed by the ISM, are or should be aware of all of these
15:09
14
objectives and rules, correct?
15:09
15
A.
15:10
16
what we call "third-party auditors," people who go in and make
15:10
17
sure that the company understands what's going on.
15:10
18
to produce what's called a "safety management system," and this
15:10
19
is a series of quite large manuals, which basically is a
15:10
20
guideline for what they have to do and how they have to do it.
15:10
21
It includes all the various forms for the audits, all the
15:10
22
various nonconformity reports and safety reports and all that.
15:10
23
It's all very, very well and carefully documented.
15:10
24
Q.
15:10
25
specifically required by the ISM.
And .3:
"Continuously improve safety management
Yes, because they are trained.
And they actually have
And you got ahead of me a little bit.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
They have
But that's
3743
15:10
If we look at Section 1.4, Functional Requirements
15:10
for Safety Management System, really this is set out fairly
15:10
simply:
15:10
a safety management system, which includes the following
15:10
functional requirements."
15:11
correct?
15:11
A.
Yes.
15:11
Q.
One is "a safety and environmental protection policy,"
15:11
correct?
15:11
10
A.
Correct.
15:11
11
Q.
One is "instructions and procedures to ensure safe
15:11
12
operation of ships and protection of the environment, in
15:11
13
compliance with relevant international and flag state
15:11
14
legislation"?
15:11
15
A.
Correct.
15:11
16
Q.
"Defined levels of authority and lines of communication
15:11
17
between and amongst shore and shipboard personnel"?
15:11
18
A.
Correct.
15:11
19
Q.
In your opinion, is that an important component of the
15:11
20
objectives of the safety management system?
15:11
21
A.
Yes, sir, very important.
15:11
22
Q.
Now, let's move to Section 4, Designated Persons.
15:12
23
15:12
24
and to provide a link between the company and those on board,
15:12
25
every company, as appropriate, should designate a person or
"Every company should develop, implement, and maintain
It says:
And then there's a list underneath,
"To ensure the safe operation of each ship
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3744
15:12
persons ashore having direct access to the highest level of
15:12
management.
15:12
person or persons should include monitoring the safety and
15:12
pollution prevention aspects of the operation of each ship and
15:12
ensuring that adequate resources and shore-based support are
15:12
applied as required."
15:12
15:12
A.
It does, yes, sir.
15:12
Q.
I just want to ask you a couple questions about this.
15:12
10
says that the person or persons ashore who should be designated
15:12
11
should have direct access to the highest level of management.
15:13
12
That's not plural levels of management.
15:13
13
level of management, does it not?
15:13
14
A.
It does.
15:13
15
Q.
In your opinion, what exactly is meant by that?
15:13
16
A.
Well, that should go to the board or the CEO or chief
15:13
17
operating officer.
15:13
18
Q.
Of the company?
15:13
19
A.
Of the company.
15:13
20
Q.
Do you recall the names of the designated persons ashore
15:13
21
or person ashore who were fulfilling that role on April 20,
15:13
22
2010?
15:13
23
A.
Yes, sir.
15:13
24
Q.
Who were they?
15:13
25
A.
Well, specifically for the Deepwater Horizon, a gentleman
The responsibility and authority of the designated
That's what it says, right?
It
It says the highest
I'm sorry.
Yes.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3745
15:13
called Gerald Canducci.
And there was another gentleman.
15:13
think his name was Moore, who was sort of a corporate
15:14
designated person.
15:14
Q.
15:14
opinions on this; but when you were reviewing the materials,
15:14
did you become aware that neither of those gentlemen had ever
15:14
been on the Deepwater Horizon?
15:14
A.
That is correct, I'm aware of it.
15:14
Q.
What's your opinion of having a designated person ashore
15:14
10
with access to the highest level of management in the company
15:14
11
who's never been on the vessel, he is acting as a go-between or
15:14
12
liaison for -- in safety matters?
15:14
13
A.
15:14
14
at least visit the vessel, meet the captain, meet the OIM, meet
15:14
15
the chief engineer, and meet the senior people on board so if
15:14
16
they have a problem, they can call him on the phone.
15:14
17
15:14
18
international way, we can call -- that a captain would call the
15:14
19
designated person and say, "Hey, we've got a problem, you know.
15:15
20
We are not getting the spares," or "We've got crew problems,"
15:15
21
and that type of thing.
15:15
22
Q.
15:15
23
those in authority on the vessel and the designated person
15:15
24
ashore?
15:15
25
A.
Later on I will ask you some more questions and get your
Well, it's bad practice, I think.
I mean, the OIM should
I mean, it's quite common nowadays, because of the
Is it important to develop ease of association between
Yes, that's his function.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3746
15:15
Q.
Okay.
Communication is obviously extremely important, is
15:15
it not?
15:15
A.
Yes.
15:15
Q.
Let's go to Category 5, please.
15:15
15:15
Section 5.1:
15:15
the master's responsibility with regard to:
15:15
safety and environmental protection of the company -- .3,
15:15
issuing appropriate orders and instructions in a clear and
15:15
10
simple manner; .4, verifying that specified requirements are
15:16
11
observed; and .5, reviewing the safety management system and
15:16
12
reporting its deficiencies to shore based management."
15:16
13
A.
That's correct.
15:16
14
Q.
Now, the master then should be -- is it your opinion that
15:16
15
the master should be intimately familiar with the company's
15:16
16
safety management system?
15:16
17
A.
Yes.
15:16
18
Q.
Is it your opinion that the master should be intimately
15:16
19
familiar with the vessel's safety management system?
15:16
20
A.
Correct.
15:16
21
Q.
Would that safety management system include all aspects of
15:16
22
the vessel's operation?
15:16
23
A.
Yes.
15:16
24
Q.
And that's not just the marine side, but the drilling side
15:16
25
as well, correct?
The master's responsibility and authority,

"The company should clearly define and document
Implementing the
Yes.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3747
15:16
A.
Correct, if it's on a MODU.
15:16
Q.
This section goes on to state that "The company should
15:17
ensure that the safety management system operating on board the
15:17
ship contains a clear statement emphasizing the master's
15:17
authority.
15:17
management system that the master has the overriding authority
15:17
and the responsibility to make decisions with respect to safety
15:17
and pollution prevention and to request the company's
15:17
assistance as may be necessary."
15:17
10
A.
That is correct.
15:17
11
Q.
Now, we are going to get into this at some length after we
15:17
12
finish the overview of the ISM; but I'm going to ask your
15:17
13
opinion right now.
15:17
14
15:17
15
Section 5, Master's Responsibility and Authority?
15:17
16
A.
They did not.
15:17
17
Q.
And I'm talking, of course, about the Deepwater Horizon.
15:17
18
A.
Correct.
15:17
19
Q.
And its crew on board on April 20, 2010.
15:18
20
A.
Yes, they did not comply.
15:18
21
Q.
Now, let's skip to Section 8, please, Emergency
15:18
22
Preparedness.
15:18
23
requires the company to establish procedures to identify,
15:18
24
describe, and respond to potential emergency shipboard
15:18
25
situations, does it not?
The company should establish in the safety
Did Transocean comply in your opinion with ISM
This is a relatively short section.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
But it
3748
15:18
A.
It does, yes.
15:18
Q.
Now, this ship, in addition to being a ship, has a
15:18
drilling function when it's engaged in drilling exploration
15:18
wells or whatever, correct?
15:18
A.
15:19
say.
15:19
Q.
15:19
underway while it's drilling?
15:19
A.
Yes.
15:19
10
Q.
Why do you say that?
15:19
11
A.
Well, the DP designation means "dynamically positioned."
15:19
12
So what you have here, this vessel has two large pontoons and
15:19
13
columns that come above it; and then on top of the columns, you
15:19
14
have the drilling equipment and the bridge and the living
15:19
15
quarters.
15:19
16
15:19
17
15:19
18
15:19
19
Your Honor.
15:19
20
of them.
15:19
21
15:20
22
call transponders on the seabed and gyrocompasses, the vessel
15:20
23
is actually kept in position just using the propulsion, the
15:20
24
thrusters.
15:20
25
the current makes it drift off a little bit, more power is
It is, but it's still a ship.
You say it's underway.
It's still underway, as we
Are you saying that the ship is
Why is that your opinion?
Underneath these columns are these big pontoons.
You
have eight thrusters, Aquamaster thrusters.

THE WITNESS:
They are like big outboard motors,
But they are 5.5000 kilowatts, and there are eight
And utilizing GPS from space, utilizing what we
So as the waves come or as the wind blows it or as
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3749
15:20
applied in a certain way to bring it back into position because
15:20
it must be -- it must maintain that position because the riser
15:20
is connected, obviously, to the vessel itself and then to the
15:20
BOP on the seafloor.
15:20
15:20
are equations and there's a maximum angle that the actual riser
15:20
can come off the BOP; and I believe it's something around
15:20
8 degrees or something like that.
15:20
15:20
10
that's what the DP operators do, that's the dynamic position
15:20
11
operators.
15:21
12
day.
15:21
13
yellow and red alerts and they can watch what's happening on a
15:21
14
graph or a matrix.
15:21
15
15:21
16
The computer senses it, pulls it back.
15:21
17
if there's really bad weather or, let's say, very bad currents
15:21
18
or, let's say, you lose power or don't have enough thruster
15:21
19
power, it can actually what we call "move off station" and at
15:21
20
that point they have to disconnect from the wellhead to avoid
15:21
21
any catastrophic damage.
15:21
22
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:21
23
Q.
15:21
24
offshore to inshore to, say, go into port or whether or not
15:21
25
it's drilling, it's always moving, is it not?
So depending on the length of the pipe, there
So one of the things they have on board -- and
They have two of them who are on watch 24 hours a
They have to watch this and they have red alerts --
And most times everything is done automatically.

Sometimes, of course,
Whether the vessel is moving from point to point or from
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3750
15:21
A.
Correct, it's always underway.
15:21
Q.
And the bridge crew, regardless of -- as long as the
15:21
vessel is at sea, regardless of what the vessel is doing,
15:21
whether going from point to point or drilling, has a bridge
15:22
crew or a marine crew manning the bridge 24 hours a day, seven
15:22
days a week; is that correct?
15:22
A.
Yes, sir, the same as a ship.
15:22
Q.
Let me just ask you a couple questions about the blowout
15:22
preventer, the BOP.
15:22
10
15:22
11
you?
15:22
12
A.
15:22
13
certainly not an expert in them.
15:22
14
Q.
15:22
15
was involved in this incident was a piece of Transocean
15:22
16
equipment?
15:22
17
A.
Yes, it's a vital part or apparatus of the vessel.
15:22
18
Q.
The vessel couldn't perform its primary mission without
15:22
19
the blowout preventer, correct?
15:22
20
A.
That is correct.
15:22
21
Q.
When the vessel moved from place to place or job to job,
15:23
22
it took the blowout preventer with it, did it not?
15:23
23
A.
15:23
24
and a rack and they put it in the rack.
15:23
25
Q.
Now, you are not an expert in how a BOP operates, are
I'm not.
I understand how they work, but I'm not -- I'm
Is it your understanding that the blowout preventer that
Yes.
They lift it up and there's a special crane on board
Now, you talked briefly just a minute ago, in answer to
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3751
15:23
one of my questions, about the DP officers, the dynamic
15:23
position officers.
15:23
comprised of the captain; is that correct?
15:23
A.
Correct.
15:23
Q.
First mate?
15:23
A.
Correct, chief mate, first mate.
15:23
Q.
Would it be fair to characterize in your opinion the DPO
15:23
as watch officers?
15:23
A.
Yes.
15:23
10
Q.
Let's just finish our overview of the ISM real quick
15:23
11
before we move on.
15:23
12
15:23
13
Carl, which is "Reports and Analysis of Nonconformities,
15:24
14
Accidents, and Hazardous Occurrences.
15:24
15
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:24
16
Q.
15:24
17
of the company "should include procedures ensuring that
15:24
18
nonconformities, accidents, and hazardous situations are
15:24
19
reported to the company, investigated and analyzed with the
15:24
20
objective of improving safety and pollution prevention.
15:24
21
company should establish procedures for the implementation of
15:24
22
corrective action."
15:24
23
A.
Yes, that is correct.
15:24
24
Q.
Would it also be the obligation of Transocean to inform --
15:24
25
in the case of the Deepwater Horizon, to keep BP fully informed
The marine crew on duty normally is
MR. WILLIAMS:
I want to go to Section 9, please,
We see that the ISM says that the safety management system
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
The
3752
15:24
as well?
15:25
A.
In my opinion, yes.
15:25
Q.
If there is any incident of noncompliance, is Transocean
15:25
under any affirmative obligation to report that to anybody?
15:25
A.
15:25
would report it to the company.
15:25
be reported to the classification society and the flag state.
15:25
Q.
15:25
have a time period in which it should be corrected?
15:25
10
A.
Yes.
15:26
11
Q.
It is the absolute obligation of the company to correct it
15:26
12
within that time period, correct?
15:26
13
A.
Yes, sir, that is correct.
15:26
14
Q.
A DNV auditor is not out there 24 hours a day every day
15:26
15
this rig is at sea, is it?
15:26
16
A.
No.
15:26
17
Q.
Is there an element of trust here?
15:26
18
A.
Yes, there has to be.
15:26
19
cannot look into every nook and cranny on the vessel and has to
15:26
20
rely on the information they are given.
15:26
21
Q.
15:26
22
there, in order to do his audit in accordance with ISM
15:26
23
regulations and the regulations of the flag state, two or three
15:26
24
months later, a nonconformity or a major nonconformity arises,
15:26
25
what is Transocean or any other vessel-owning company supposed
Well, yes.
I mean, again, a normal nonconformity they

A major nonconformity should
So once a nonconformity -- does a nonconformity always
A surveyor, when they go on board,
Well, two to three months after a DNV auditor has been out
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3753
15:26
to do?
15:26
A.
Well, as I said, a nonconformity, they are supposed to fix
15:27
it.
If they have been given a nonconformity from the
15:27
inspection before, they are supposed to solve that
15:27
nonconformity.
15:27
react immediately before they run into trouble with the flag
15:27
state.
15:27
Q.
15:27
and the equipment.
15:27
10
15:27
11
establish procedures to ensure that the ship is maintained in
15:27
12
conformity with the provisions of the relevant rules and
15:27
13
regulations and with any additional requirements which may be
15:27
14
established by the company."
15:27
15
15:27
16
A.
You did.
15:27
17
Q.
In layman's terms, what is the obligation of Transocean
15:27
18
with respect to maintenance of ship and equipment and reporting
15:28
19
and that type of thing?
15:28
20
A.
15:28
21
in operation.
15:28
22
all the deficiencies and repairs and outstanding items.
15:28
23
should be set up in a manner that the shoreside people can
15:28
24
react to their requests or the reports of nonconformities.
15:28
25
also, of course, maintenance items, the overdue maintenance
If it's a major nonconformity, they should
Let's move to Section 10, please, maintenance of the ship
Section 10.1 provides that, "The company should
Well, they should have a proper planned maintenance system

They should have a proper system of reporting
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
It
And
3754
15:28
items.
15:28
Q.
15:28
that maintenance records or records of nonconformities are
15:28
precisely and well maintained and transmitted to shore?
15:28
A.
Yes.
15:28
Q.
Section 10.3:
15:29
its safety management system to identify equipment and
15:29
technical systems the sudden operational failure of which may
15:29
result in hazardous situations.
15:29
10
should provide for specific measures aimed at promoting the
15:29
11
reliability of such equipment or systems.
15:29
12
should include the regular testing of stand-by arrangements and
15:29
13
equipment or technical systems that are not in continuous use."
15:29
14
Well, it's self-explanatory and we are going to spend
15:29
15
a lot of time on specific issues of maintenance; but let me
15:29
16
just ask you now:
15:29
17
shape, or form in compliance with Section 10 of the ISM Code?
15:29
18
A.
In no way.
15:30
19
Q.
Now, let's move on.
15:30
20
little while.
15:30
21
15:30
22
extremely complex piece of marine equipment?
15:30
23
A.
Very complex, yes.
15:30
24
Q.
Is it more complex than a very large crude carrier?
15:30
25
A.
Yes.
One of the most important components of that, is it not,
"The company should establish procedures in
The safety management system
These measures
Was Transocean, in your opinion, in any way,
We are going to leave ISM alone for a
Would you characterize the Deepwater Horizon as an
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3755
15:30
Q.
Supertanker?
15:30
A.
Yes, it is.
15:30
Q.
Is it true that this complex piece of marine equipment is
15:30
composed of or comprised of many components which, in and of
15:30
themselves, are extremely complex?
15:30
A.
Yes, it is.
15:30
Q.
Sir, is it true that these complex systems and subsystems
15:31
all have to be managed in a way that the vessel can operate
15:31
safely and that safe operation can be properly monitored?
15:31
10
A.
That is correct.
15:31
11
Q.
Did the Deepwater Horizon have any type of automated
15:31
12
system that manage all of these complex subsystems that
15:31
13
comprised this vessel?
15:31
14
A.
15:31
15
which is an integrated alarm and control system, extremely
15:31
16
complex system built with computers and many, many sensors.
15:31
17
takes in thousands of signals, inputs from all over the rig and
15:31
18
it basically takes these signals in and then sends signals back
15:32
19
to control various pieces of equipment, such as it could start
15:32
20
a generator up or it could shut a generator down.
15:32
21
start fans.
15:32
22
15:32
23
emergency systems.
15:32
24
alarms.
15:32
25
shows -- there's an alarm on it to show whether watertight
Yes, it had what's called an IACS system by Kongsberg,
It
It could
And it's also the brain, if you like, for the

So for the firefighting alarms, for the gas
Even as much as watertight doors, for example, it
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3756
15:32
15:32
15:32
15:32
doors are open or closed.

MR. WILLIAMS:
please.
So it's a very complex system.
Carl, could you bring up TREX-1109,
The diagram is on page 4 of 16.

There you go.
Thanks.
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:33
Q.
Okay, Mr. Webster.
15:33
A.
I do, yes.
15:33
Q.
Just explain to us briefly what it depicts.
15:33
A.
Well, it's a chart, or a line chart, to show how the
15:33
10
various signals, alarm signals, and also signals out to control
15:33
11
various pieces of equipment are arranged.
15:33
12
Q.
15:33
13
15:33
14
bubbles out there represent inputs to what is indicated as the
15:33
15
fire and gas system, do they not?
15:33
16
A.
That is correct.
15:33
17
Q.
Those inputs come from where?
15:34
18
A.
They come from alarm devices, smoke alarms, gas alarms.
15:34
19
These are sensors that are located throughout the vessel.
15:34
20
example, the smoke detectors, just like you have in your house,
15:34
21
if it senses smoke, it will ring the alarm and that will send a
15:34
22
signal to the F&G system.
15:34
23
Q.
15:34
24
send signals to the fire and gas system, does it?
15:34
25
A.
Do you recognize this drawing?
Now, out here -- it actually worked for me this time.

Out here in the left-hand column, those little
For
This drawing here doesn't reflect all of the sensors that
No.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3757
15:34
Q.
It's just a representative sampling of it, correct?
15:34
A.
That is correct.
15:34
Q.
For instance, in the engine rooms there are mist -- engine
15:34
oil mist detectors that send signals to the fire and gas
15:34
system, don't they?
15:34
A.
Yes.
15:34
Q.
Just tell us -- tell the Court briefly what a mist engine
15:34
room -- mist --
15:34
A.
Oil mist detector.
15:34
10
Q.
I'm sorry.
15:35
11
A.
An oil mist detector is on the inside of a crankcase of a
15:35
12
diesel engine.
15:35
13
malfunction, let's say a bearing gets hot or -- you know, a
15:35
14
bearing rubs because of lack of lubrication or something like
15:35
15
that, the temperature increases in the crankcase itself to a
15:35
16
point it could get to what we call spontaneous ignition.
15:35
17
could blow the engine up.
15:35
18
15:35
19
overheated bearing or something, it rings an alarm and has the
15:35
20
ability to shut the engine down.
15:35
21
Q.
15:35
22
depicted on this flow chart from Kongsberg -- by the way, is
15:35
23
Kongsberg Simrad the manufacturer of this system?
15:35
24
A.
Yes.
15:35
25
Q.
Out to the right we see fire pumps, fire dampers,
What an oil mist detector is.
And the purpose is that if the engine has a
It
So once the temperature rises due to a malfunction,
Okay.
Now, going back to the fire and gas system, as it's
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3758
15:35
firefighting systems, do we not?
15:35
A.
We do.
15:35
Q.
That's not representative, is it?
15:35
vessel schematics and that information.
15:36
representative of everything this fire and gas system controls
15:36
automatically, is it?
15:36
A.
15:36
to show that it controls those functions.
15:36
Q.
15:36
10
We'll get into them again and again and again I think, as the
15:36
11
day goes on.
15:36
12
15:36
13
bubble there?
15:36
14
A.
15:36
15
in a building or a hotel.
15:36
16
going into the space, because air and fuel obviously are causes
15:36
17
of combustion.
15:36
18
the airflow; therefore, you try to control the fire.
15:36
19
Q.
It's a safety-critical system on the rig?
15:36
20
A.
Yes.
15:36
21
Q.
Life depends on the fire dampers, doesn't it?
15:37
22
A.
Absolutely, yes.
15:37
23
Q.
And in the event of a fire?
15:37
24
A.
Yes.
15:37
25
Q.
We see firefighting systems described briefly.
No, that's correct.
You have reviewed the

That's not
It's just sort of a simplistic chart
Let's talk a little bit about fire dampers initially.
But what are fire dampers?
What is that little
What does that mean?
Well, a fire damper basically is just like a fire damper

The fire damper closes to stop air
If you shut down the fire damper, you shut down
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
What do
3759
15:37
fire and gas system controls with respect to the firefighting
15:37
systems?
15:37
A.
15:37
accommodation, just like a building.
15:37
You have CO2 smothering in the engine room.
15:37
there's a fire there, you can try and kill any fire with carbon
15:37
dioxide.
15:37
Q.
15:37
looking at right now, we go from the fire and gas system to the
15:37
10
ESD and F&G matrixes.
15:37
11
understand that means.
15:37
12
A.
15:38
13
IACS receives signals which tells it that something is really
15:38
14
serious, it could shut down that specific system automatically.
15:38
15
Q.
Automatically, correct?
15:38
16
A.
Yes.
15:38
17
Q.
That's how the system is designed?
15:38
18
A.
Yes.
15:38
19
is designed to shut down.
15:38
20
Q.
15:38
21
system.
15:38
22
process equipment.
15:38
23
depicts.
15:38
24
A.
15:38
25
alarms.
Well, we have normally sprinklers throughout the
In case
As we go vertically downward in this matrix that we are
Could you just explain briefly what you
The ESD is an emergency shutdown system, so that when the
Not for all areas, but for very critical areas, it
The last box at the bottom of this flow chart is the ESD
And out to the side we have fans and ventilation and
Could you just explain briefly what that
Well, for example, in the engine rooms you have gas

And if gas enters the engine room and there are two
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3760
15:38
high-high alarms, what we call high-high alarms, the system is
15:39
designed to automatically shut down the ventilation and shut
15:39
the fans, stop the fans, stop the gas and the air going into
15:39
the engine room.
15:39
room, I believe, and all those areas on board the vessel that
15:39
are subject to an explosive atmosphere.
15:39
Q.
15:39
closure or stopping of ventilation in the engine room, are
15:39
these louvers or dampers that allow air to enter the engine
15:39
10
room so the engine can aspirate or breathe while it's running?
15:39
11
A.
15:39
12
mechanically remotely.
15:39
13
Q.
15:39
14
should be?
15:39
15
A.
Yes, they are.
15:39
16
Q.
Why is that?
15:39
17
A.
Well, because you want to -- in an emergency situation for
15:40
18
a fire, for example, or if you get gas, you want to shut it
15:40
19
down as fast as possible to save the rig and save the lives of
15:40
20
the crew.
15:40
21
Q.
15:40
22
the IACS, the Kongsberg system, part of which we're talking
15:40
23
about right now, would it be fair to call it the electronic
15:40
24
brain of this vessel, particularly with regard to safety?
15:40
25
A.
And you have the same in the shale shaker
With respect to what you just described, the automatic
Yes.
They are louvers which are controlled electrically,
They are part of the ESD system, are they not, or they
Mr. Webster, would it be fair, in your opinion, to call
Yes.
No doubt about it.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3761
15:40
Q.
It's designed to detect potential emergency situations and
15:40
automatically take emergency actions with either no or very
15:40
little human intervention; is that right?
15:40
A.
Yes, sir.
15:40
Q.
Is it true, in your experience and expertise, that
15:40
critical emergency situations on a vessel as large and as
15:40
complicated as the Deepwater Horizon require the rapid
15:40
assessment of the source and the nature of the emergency?
15:41
A.
15:41
10
hydrogen sulfide or hydrocarbon gas.
15:41
11
Q.
15:41
12
emergency requires a very focused and rapid response to address
15:41
13
and deal with that emergency and take the appropriate
15:41
14
ameliorative action?
15:41
15
A.
Yes.
15:41
16
Q.
That's what the Kongsberg system is designed to do, isn't
15:41
17
it?
15:41
18
A.
Yes, sir.
15:41
19
Q.
Isn't the Kongsberg system and the ESD system designed to
15:41
20
perform multiple automated emergency response functions
15:41
21
simultaneously if necessary?
15:41
22
MR. KINCHEN:
15:41
23
THE COURT:
15:42
24
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:42
25
Q.
That's correct.
Very, very much so, especially on a vessel that has
Okay.
Is it also true, in your opinion, that such an
Objection, leading, Your Honor.
Restate the question.
Is the fire and gas system and the ESD system, that part
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3762
15:42
of the IACS, in your opinion, is it designed to perform
15:42
multiple automated emergency response functions simultaneously?
15:42
A.
Yes.
15:42
Q.
Do those functions include activation -- I'm sorry --
15:42
isolation of electrical equipment?
15:42
A.
It does, yes.
15:42
Q.
Would those functions include, in your opinion, the
15:42
closure -- automatic closure of watertight and fire doors?
15:42
A.
Yes.
15:42
10
Q.
What are fire doors?
15:42
11
A.
Well, we talked about that real quick.
15:42
12
15:42
13
fire and also to shut off air going into that space.
15:42
14
Q.
15:43
15
emergency response functions I asked you two or three questions
15:43
16
ago, its ability to perform these functions simultaneously in
15:43
17
the event of an emergency, would those functions also include,
15:43
18
in your opinion, the closure of ventilation dampers?
15:43
19
A.
Yes.
15:43
20
Q.
Would those include ventilation dampers in the engine
15:43
21
rooms?
15:43
22
A.
Yes.
15:43
23
Q.
That would include the engine air intake dampers, correct?
15:43
24
A.
Yes.
15:43
25
Q.
If it's working properly and fully able to work
Fire doors are doors that will prevent the spread of
Would those functions we were talking about, the automated
It should also shut the engine down.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3763
15:43
automatically, would it also shut off fuel to the engines?
15:43
A.
Yes.
15:43
Q.
Are there other engine shutdown features that the ESD
15:43
system can activate automatically?
15:44
A.
15:44
device.
15:44
the governor.
15:44
and that can actuate the governor as well.
15:44
15:44
10
or they call them -- in the oil business they call them rig
15:44
11
savers because they actually shut off -- mechanically stop air
15:44
12
from going into the turbochargers so that the methane gas can't
15:44
13
keep feeding the engine.
15:44
14
rack goes to zero and the engine is not getting any fuel, the
15:44
15
methane gas acts as the fuel.
15:44
16
and ultimately explode.
15:44
17
Q.
Why do they call them rig savers?
15:44
18
A.
Because it saves the rig from blowing up.
15:45
19
Q.
These rig savers -- even if the engine is ingesting
15:45
20
hydrocarbons or some flammable gas from some other source and
15:45
21
all else fails, the rig savers shut down the engine's ability
15:45
22
to ingest any type of air; is that correct?
15:45
23
A.
Yes, absolutely.
15:45
24
Q.
Mr. Webster, based on everything you have read, all the
15:45
25
documents you have reviewed, some of the testimony you have
Well, the engine itself has what we call an overspeed

There's a mechanical overspeed device which actuates
But there's also an electronic overspeed device,
But there's also what we call the air shutoff valves,
Because even if the rack -- the fuel
And those engines can take off
Do you have any idea?
It shuts everything off.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3764
15:45
heard here in court, and the depositions you have reviewed, in
15:45
your opinion, should the marine crew of the Deepwater Horizon
15:45
have been trained in all aspects of the operation and function
15:45
of the Kongsberg system, the IACS?
15:45
A.
Yes, they should have been.
15:45
Q.
Would that include all of its components, such as the fire
15:45
and gas system and the ESD system?
15:45
A.
That's correct, yes.
15:45
Q.
Would that include knowing exactly what those systems did
15:46
10
or were supposed to do or could do in the event of an
15:46
11
emergency?
15:46
12
A.
Yes, they should have been fully trained.
15:46
13
Q.
That would be expected -- in your opinion, would that be
15:46
14
expected of any competent marine bridge crew on any vessel?
15:46
15
A.
That is correct, yes.
15:46
16
Q.
Now, we've heard testimony and we've seen pictures of the
15:46
17
monitoring system of this fire and gas -- or I'm sorry -- the
15:46
18
ESD, the IACS.
15:46
19
is it not?
15:46
20
A.
That's correct, monitors.
15:46
21
Q.
Monitors in the bridge?
15:46
22
A.
Yes.
15:46
23
Q.
We heard testimony -- I think it was the first week of the
15:46
24
case -- that there was also a monitor in the drill shack
15:47
25
between the D-1 -- between the driller's chair and the
I would expect it.
It's monitored on television screens basically,
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3765
15:47
assistant driller's chair.
15:47
A.
That's correct.
15:47
Q.
Well, let me ask you the same question about the drill
15:47
crew.
15:47
Deepwater Horizon have been trained in all aspects of the
15:47
operation and function --
15:47
A.
Yes.
15:47
Q.
-- of the IACS?
15:47
A.
Absolutely, yes.
15:47
10
Q.
How about the subsea crew of the Transocean Horizon?
15:47
11
A.
I believe they should be as well.
15:47
12
Q.
Why is that?
15:47
13
A.
They should understand the functions of what's going on so
15:47
14
that they could shut the well down if necessary.
15:47
15
Q.
15:47
16
are intentionally disabled, what would be the obligations of
15:47
17
the crew -- what would the obligations of the crew and
15:47
18
Transocean be with respect to ISM Code requirements?
15:48
19
A.
15:48
20
to the management or to the flag state.
15:48
21
Q.
15:48
22
designated person ashore?
15:48
23
A.
Absolutely, yes.
15:48
24
Q.
Would it be your expectation that the designated person
15:48
25
ashore have intimate knowledge of the Kongsberg Simrad system,
In your opinion, should the drill crew of the
If the automatic safety features of the Kongsberg system
Well, truthfully, they should report it as a nonconformity
Would that be something that should be reported to the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3766
15:48
the IACS?
15:48
A.
15:48
have a general knowledge of what it does and what it's capable
15:48
of, the alarms and emergency systems that it's tied into.
15:48
Q.
15:48
about the audits.
15:49
15:49
think, requires periodic audits and inspections of the vessel,
15:49
correct?
15:49
10
A.
Correct.
15:49
11
Q.
If, during those audits, nonconformities are discovered,
15:49
12
whether they are regular or major nonconformities, what exactly
15:49
13
is the regulatory obligation of Transocean in that case?
15:49
14
A.
15:49
15
required under the code, as well, to do what we call internal
15:49
16
audits.
15:49
17
of the vessel, or rig, to try to discover defects and
15:49
18
nonconformities that the class may find.
15:49
19
15:49
20
on board and write up a whole bunch of nonconformities.
15:49
21
believe it's incumbent on them to report these nonconformities
15:49
22
to the DPA.
15:50
23
Q.
15:50
24
its own internal audits with respect to those measures covered
15:50
25
in the ISM?
I wouldn't say necessarily intimate knowledge, but should
We'll come back to this area again later on when we talk
Now, the ISM Code, you have already testified, I
Well, actually, we didn't talk about it.
But they are
And the idea of the internal audit is to do an audit
The whole idea is that you don't want class to come

I
Would the ISM also require the company itself to conduct
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3767
15:50
A.
Yes.
In fact, Transocean had internal auditors on their
15:50
staff.
15:50
Q.
15:50
process?
15:50
A.
15:50
audits.
15:50
the company auditors or third-party auditor.
15:50
company or third-party outside auditors.
15:50
look at that and make sure that the corrective actions were
15:50
10
taking place as soon as possible.
15:50
11
Q.
15:50
12
theoretically at least, at his -- I'm talking about the
15:51
13
designated person ashore -- at his behest, does he have an
15:51
14
obligation to report that or those nonconformities, if they are
15:51
15
not corrected, to the highest level of management at
15:51
16
Transocean?
15:51
17
A.
Yes.
15:51
18
Q.
He would certainly have a similar obligation if it were a
15:51
19
major nonconformity, whether it was corrected or not.
15:51
20
your opinion that that should be reported to the highest level
15:51
21
of management as soon as it becomes known?
15:51
22
A.
Absolutely, to avoid the flag state from pulling the flag.
15:51
23
Q.
Well, isn't there another reason for doing it as well, a
15:51
24
safety reason?
15:51
25
A.
How is the designated person ashore involved in that
Well, he should be the one that actually schedules the

And then, of course, he should get the feedback from
It can be either
He should obviously
If he finds nonconformities during the audit that is done,
Is it
Well, yes, to ensure safety is maintained on the rig.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3768
15:51
THE COURT:
Mr. Williams, is this a good time to take
15:51
15:52
15:52
get into a different section.
15:52
THE COURT:
15:52
THE DEPUTY CLERK:
15:52
(Recess.)
16:10
THE COURT:
16:10
MR. WILLIAMS:
16:10
10
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:10
11
Q.
16:10
12
What I'm --
16:10
13
16:10
14
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:10
15
Q.
16:10
16
assessment of the Deepwater Horizon blowout preventer control
16:10
17
system, April 2000 final report prepared by EQE International
16:10
18
for Cameron.
16:10
19
Deepwater Horizon, was it not?
16:11
20
A.
Yes, sir.
16:11
21
Q.
Have you reviewed this report previously?
16:11
22
A.
I have.
16:11
23
16:11
24
a break?
MR. WILLIAMS:
It would be, Your Honor.
I'm about to
Let's take about a 15-minute recess.

All rise.
Please be seated, everyone.

TREX-4275, please.
You might want to look at your TV screen, Mr. Webster.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Is this too loud?
Mr. Webster, I'm showing you Exhibit 4275.
It's a risk
This was early on in the life of the
MR. WILLIAMS:
Could you go to page 37 on the
document, please.
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3769
16:11
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:11
Q.
16:11
major contributor to the failure likelihood associated with the
16:11
BOP control system results from the selected stack
16:11
configuration.
16:11
well in, it is extremely difficult to remove all single failure
16:11
points from the control system."
16:11
16:11
A.
Yes.
16:11
10
Q.
Now, from a safety standpoint, what in your opinion does
16:11
11
that put Transocean on notice of?
16:12
12
16:12
13
16:12
14
THE COURT:
16:12
15
MR. KINCHEN:
16:12
16
testimony about the BOP.
16:12
17
be cumulative.
16:12
18
from a PSC witness would be cumulative.
16:12
19
16:12
20
that he has no expertise in the blowout preventer.
16:12
21
also object on those grounds, too.
16:12
22
16:12
23
everything Mr. Kinchen said.
16:12
24
BOP expert.
16:12
25
this rig, BOP is clearly an appurtenance.
Okay.
On that page down at the bottom, it says:
"The
With only one shear ram capable of sealing the
Is that what it says?
MR. KINCHEN:
Objection, Your Honor.
John Kinchen,
Transocean.
Get by a microphone, please.
This Court has already heard plenty of
So one objection would be this would
Any testimony by this witness about the BOP
Also, this witness has stated on the stand today
MR. WILLIAMS:
So we would
Well, Your Honor, I would agree with

We are not presenting him as a
These are risk issues.
Early on in the life of
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
I'm not going to ask
3770
16:12
him how the BOP worked or anything like that.
16:12
16:12
16:12
16:13
16:13
16:13
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:13
Q.
16:13
Let's go to the next page or so and read a couple of things.
16:13
10
16:13
11
page 38 of TREX-4275.
16:13
12
terms of probability of occurrence, associated with the failure
16:13
13
of the BOP to perform the emergency disconnect sequence when
16:13
14
required are," and one of the failure combinations is -- one of
16:13
15
the elements of the failure is "failure of the indication to
16:13
16
identify need to EDS or operator failure to initiate EDS."
16:14
17
16:14
18
A.
Correct.
16:14
19
Q.
In your opinion, given this information early on in the
16:14
20
life of this rig, would training on when and how to EDS be
16:14
21
important?
16:14
22
A.
Very much so.
16:14
23
Q.
I'm talking about training of the marine crew and the
16:14
24
drill crew when I ask that question.
16:14
25
same?
THE COURT:
Let's see where this goes, but I think we
all agree that we are not going to have a third BOP expert.
MR. WILLIAMS:
a BOP expert.
No, believe me, he is not going to be
J&B expert maybe, but he is not a BOP expert.

Now I have forgotten my --
Well, let's go to the next page.
We have read this.
"The dominant failure combinations" -- this is

"The dominant failure combinations, in
Correct?
Is your answer still the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3771
16:14
A.
It is, yes, sir.
16:14
Q.
Is your opinion still the same?
16:14
A.
It is.
16:14
16:14
next one and go to the -- it would be the next one, please.
16:14
Down at the bottom of the page, bottom of the last paragraph.
16:15
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:15
Q.
16:15
item for reducing the risk (i.e., increasing the reliability)
16:15
10
for both disconnect and well control operations is to ensure
16:15
11
that the indication, recognition, and willingness of the
16:15
12
operator to initiate the appropriate actions or to switch to
16:15
13
the standby pod following failure in the active pod.
16:15
14
16:15
15
operator to initiate the appropriate actions is also the next
16:15
16
largest factor which can potentially increase the risk for
16:15
17
failure to disconnect or failure of well control.
16:15
18
"Given the importance of the operator, it is
16:15
19
essential that the indication available to him provides a clear
16:15
20
picture of the status and that the guidelines for initiating a
16:16
21
disconnect or performing well control operations are clear and
16:16
22
concise."
16:16
23
Based on your review, do you have an opinion as to
16:16
24
whether the Transocean guidelines -- their SMS, their safety
16:16
25
management systems, their operations and procedures manuals --
MR. WILLIAMS:
It says here:
Let's go to page 40, please.
Skip the
Beyond these items, the largest potential
"The indication, recognition, and willingness of the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3772
16:16
all the things you reviewed, do you have an opinion as to
16:16
whether those guidelines were clear and concise, as suggested
16:16
in this initial BOP audit in 2000?
16:16
A.
16:16
16:16
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:16
Q.
Have you reviewed this document Mr. Webster?
16:16
A.
I have, yes.
16:16
Q.
It's a West Engineering document.
16:17
10
16:17
11
16:17
12
it says:
16:17
13
known equipment and system anomalies that have caused problems
16:17
14
on other rigs and to offer guidance for correction of these
16:17
15
issues on the Deepwater Horizon."
16:17
16
16:17
17
years before the Deepwater Horizon tragedy, correct?
16:17
18
A.
Correct.
16:17
19
Q.
The letter is addressed to a Mr. Doug Halkett of
16:17
20
Transocean Sedco Forex, correct?
16:17
21
A.
16:17
22
16:17
23
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:17
24
Q.
16:17
25
was in place.
No, I don't believe they were.

MR. WILLIAMS:
Let's go to TREX-7691, please.
We have seen during the
trial several West Engineering documents, not this one yet.

The first full sentence under the executive summary,
"The primary purpose of this assessment was to review
Now, this is dated April 26, 2001, approximately nine
Correct.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Page 3 of 6, please, Carl.
Paragraph 7, it says:
"No preventive maintenance program
Documentation on maintenance work performed
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3773
16:18
should be retained along with a rotational system for
16:18
rebuilding the valves."
16:18
16:18
here?
16:18
A.
That's correct.
16:18
Q.
Now, is it your opinion that that suggestion is in
16:18
conformance with the ISM code?
16:18
A.
16:18
place to upgrade it and to prevent failure.
16:18
10
Q.
16:18
11
correct?
16:18
12
A.
Yes.
16:18
13
Q.
Nine years before the incident?
16:18
14
A.
Correct.
16:18
15
16:18
16
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:18
17
Q.
16:19
18
Audit dated August/September 2001.
16:19
19
conducted by BP, apparently.
16:19
20
16:19
21
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:19
22
Q.
16:19
23
can see on the picture of the full document.
16:19
24
16:19
25
Again, we are talking about the blowout preventer
No.
There should be a preventive maintenance program in
That's correct.
They're pointing this out in this report,
MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-6164, please.
Here we have a Deepwater Horizon Integrated Acceptance
MR. WILLIAMS:
And it's an audit that was
I would like to go to Bates 43465.
They are talking about the fire and gas system, which you
It says:
"The audit team is concerned" -- it's your
understanding we are talking about the BP audit team, correct?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3774
16:19
A.
That's correct.
16:19
Q.
"The audit team is concerned about the availability and
16:19
reliability of the fire and gas system, including the
16:19
possibility that the long-term repeatability and robustness of
16:19
the system may be suspect."
16:20
It goes on to say that "The system should be fully
16:20
operational and function in accordance with the design cause
16:20
and effects philosophy prior to the engineer's departure.
16:20
Furthermore, all fire and gas detector heads should be
16:20
10
16:20
11
16:20
12
A.
You did, yes, sir.
16:20
13
Q.
Sir, is it your opinion that the system, which it says in
16:20
14
this audit should be fully operational and function in
16:20
15
accordance with the design cause and effects philosophy, in --
16:20
16
your opinion, does that mean the automatic function of the IACS
16:20
17
system?
16:20
18
A.
16:20
19
16:21
20
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:21
21
Q.
16:21
22
Assessment" prepared for Transocean Sedco Forex, correct?
16:21
23
A.
Correct.
16:21
24
Q.
It's a final report.
16:21
25
A.
That's correct.
operational, and no alarms or detectors should be overridden."

Yes, that's correct.

MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-3134, please.
This document is "Deepwater Horizon Design Risk
It's dated 2002 January.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3775
16:21
MR. WILLIAMS:
Go to page 4.8, please.
16:21
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:21
Q.
16:21
paragraph 10 says:
16:21
least one alternative operation panel that can be operated
16:21
independently from the one located at the driller's
16:21
workstation."
16:22
16:22
16:22
10
A.
Yes.
16:22
11
Q.
"Ensure that it is possible to operate the acoustic
16:22
12
control system from a portable unit which can be handled by one
16:22
13
person in the event of evacuation from the vessel."
16:22
14
16:22
15
A.
Correct.
16:22
16
Q.
Was there an acoustic control system installed on the
16:22
17
Deepwater Horizon?
16:22
18
A.
16:22
19
16:22
20
it, real quickly, please, if possible.
16:22
21
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:22
22
Q.
16:22
23
"Actual time to secure the well and disconnect the LMRP."
16:22
24
16:22
25
Under the section Disconnect and Move-off System,

"Ensure that the EH-MUX BOP control has at
Now, the MUX BOP control that they are talking about,
is that the BOP control panel, in your opinion?
That's what it says, right?
No, sir.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Could we go to paragraph 9 just above
It's the same section, Disconnect and Move-off System.
Are we talking about an EDS, an emergency disconnect,

here, Mr. Webster?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3776
16:22
A.
Yes, disconnecting the lower marine riser package.
16:23
Q.
Okay.
16:23
disconnect?
16:23
A.
That's correct.
16:23
Q.
"Actual time to secure the well and disconnect the LMRP
16:23
will be dependent on equipment/system configuration and water
16:23
depth, but is in any case expected to exceed the regulatory
16:23
requirement of 30 seconds for assumed deepwater drilling with
16:23
the Deepwater Horizon.
16:23
10
the regulatory requirement need to be addressed, and it is
16:23
11
recommended to assess the potential risk impact of increasing
16:23
12
the disconnection time between [verbatim] 30 seconds."
16:23
13
16:23
14
documents going forward, did you see any evidence that this was
16:23
15
ever done?
16:23
16
A.
16:24
17
16:24
18
System.
16:24
19
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:24
20
Q.
16:24
21
too, but this is the -- is this the emergency shutdown system
16:24
22
we talked about earlier?
16:24
23
A.
Yes.
16:24
24
Q.
Part of the Kongsberg Simrad?
16:24
25
A.
Yes, it is.
And is that what happens during an emergency
The top portion of the BOP comes off.
Necessary corrective actions towards
Now, in your review of all the audits and all of the
No, I have not.

MR. WILLIAMS:
Page 4.9, please, under the topic ESD
Now, we are not talking about the EDS.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
I get confused
3777
16:24
Q.
Paragraph 13:
"Consider changing the ESD system so that
16:24
human input is not critical for the success of the system."
16:24
16:24
A.
It does, yes.
16:24
Q.
Based on your review of all of the audits, surveys,
16:24
everything else that you have looked at, did you see that this
16:24
was ever done?
16:24
A.
16:24
16:24
10
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:25
11
Q.
16:25
12
Report, and it's dated May 18, 2002.
16:25
13
questions about these or about this document, based on your
16:25
14
experience as a lead ISM auditor.
16:25
15
16:25
16
Deepwater Horizon; is that correct?
16:25
17
A.
Yes.
16:25
18
Q.
It defines "major nonconformities" and "nonconformities"
16:25
19
in the Definition section of the document, correct?
16:25
20
A.
It does.
16:25
21
Q.
Now, if you go to the next page -- sorry, it's two pages
16:25
22
in -- we have a document that's titled "Nonconformity and
16:25
23
Finding Note."
16:25
24
A.
Got it.
16:26
25
Q.
They have a description of the deficiency that was found
No, it was not.

MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-5483, please.
What we have here is an ISM Code Certification, Ship Audit

Let me ask you a couple
This ISM Code Certification deals only with the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3778
16:26
in this audit.
It says that "the ISM Code requires that every
16:26
company shall define and document the responsibility,
16:26
authority, and interrelation of all personnel who manage,
16:26
perform, or verify work affecting safety," does it not?
16:26
A.
16:26
16:26
16:26
16:26
the prior paragraph.
16:26
10
THE COURT:
16:26
11
16:26
12
16:26
13
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:26
14
Q.
16:26
15
evidence"?
16:26
16
A.
16:26
17
obviously something that needs to be taken care of.
16:26
18
Q.
16:26
19
said that "Evidence found that certain responsibilities and
16:27
20
authorities were not fully defined and documented."
16:27
21
16:27
22
person in charge issued July 2001 designated OIMs as the
16:27
23
primary persons in charge with masters noted as alternate
16:27
24
persons in charge."
16:27
25
It does.
THE COURT:
Where are you reading from?
Are you
reading from this?

MR. WILLIAMS:
reading.
I'm sorry, Judge.
I was reading from
I'll go on to paragraph 3.
I was just trying to follow what you were
I didn't see it on the screen.

MR. WILLIAMS:
Sorry about that.
Paragraph 3 is Objective Evidence.
What is "objective
Well, it's what they found during their audit.
Okay.
It's
Part of this objective evidence or this finding
And one example of that is "Written designation of
"The above two items are contrary to the following
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3779
16:27
designations of the master as person in charge:
Approved
16:27
station bill states that the master shall be in command and
16:27
coordinate all emergency response activities, contrary to the
16:27
written and displayed designation of the OIM as person in
16:27
charge."
16:27
16:27
in your opinion?
16:27
A.
16:27
designated person at all times.
16:27
10
Q.
16:28
11
for here?
16:28
12
A.
16:28
13
structure and that the master should be the person in charge.
16:28
14
Q.
16:28
15
audit reports stay on the vessel?
16:28
16
A.
They stay on the vessel, and they also go to the office.
16:28
17
Q.
Who is responsible for dealing with them once they go to
16:28
18
the office, or who should be?
16:28
19
A.
16:28
20
to also the designated person ashore, who has the ultimate
16:28
21
authority --
16:28
22
Q.
Okay.
16:28
23
A.
-- to make sure the corrective action is taken.
16:28
24
Q.
The designated person is the person having direct access
16:28
25
to the highest level of management, correct?
Now, why is that an ISM Code violation, Mr. Webster,
Because on Section 5.2, the captain is to be the
What is DNV, the auditing authority, gigging Transocean

Can you sum it up for us?
Basically it's saying there is confusion in the command
Now, in your experience as an ISM auditor, do these ship
Well, it will go to the rig manager, and it will then go
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3780
16:28
A.
That's correct.
In this case, Mr. Canducci.
16:28
Q.
Well, this was --
16:28
A.
Oh, this was before him.
16:28
Q.
This was back in 2002.
16:28
A.
I'm sorry.
16:28
Q.
So 2002, at least, it appears to be one, if not the first
16:29
notice that there is an ISM nonconformity involving authority
16:29
of the master, is that correct, based on your review?
16:29
A.
16:29
10
16:29
11
16:29
12
THE COURT:
16:29
13
MR. WILLIAMS:
16:29
14
16:29
15
THE COURT:
16:29
16
MR. WILLIAMS:
16:29
17
THE COURT:
16:29
18
MR. WILLIAMS:
16:29
19
16:29
20
16:29
21
16:30
22
Your Honor.
16:30
23
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:30
24
Q.
16:30
25
you?
He didn't come until later, yes.
Yes.
MR. KINCHEN:
Transocean.
John Kinchen, Your Honor, for
Objection to leading.
It's sort of leading.
I tried to save it right at the end,
Your Honor.
You didn't quite get there.
It's a bad habit I have.
Try not to do that.

I'll try my best.
Could we go to the next exhibit.
Is there a
TREX?
44017 is the TREX number on this exhibit,
Mr. Webster, you have seen this document before, haven't
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3781
16:30
A.
I have, yes.
16:30
Q.
This is the Deepwater Technical Rig Audit of January 2005.
16:30
16:30
document, please.
16:30
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:30
Q.
16:30
second full paragraph, it says:
16:30
number of deficiencies within EMPAC that have a potential to
16:30
cause an incident or equipment downtime."
16:30
10
16:30
11
EMPAC was?
16:30
12
A.
16:31
13
effect at that time.
16:31
14
Q.
16:31
15
personnel to close out maintenance work orders even though not
16:31
16
all tasks are completed.
16:31
17
consequently being missed.
16:31
18
occasions during review of the maintenance history files.
16:31
19
Maintenance work orders assigned to the incorrect craft has
16:31
20
also resulted in critical maintenance tasks including NDT
16:31
21
inspection of the drilling load path being missed.
16:31
22
16:31
23
unsatisfactory, although a few were exemplary.
16:31
24
and measurements requested in the maintenance procedure were
16:31
25
frequently omitted from the history files.
MR. WILLIAMS:
If we could go to page 5 of that
Under the topic Maintenance Management, starting at the

"The audit has identified a
Mr. Webster, do you have an appreciation of what
I believe EMPAC was the planned maintenance system in
It goes on to say that "There is a practice by maintenance
Critical checks and inspections are

This was noted on numerous
"Maintenance history files were generally found to be
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
Work undertaken
An auditable trail
3782
16:31
of maintenance performed on equipment was often not possible
16:31
from interrogation of the maintenance history."
16:31
16:32
maintenance should be tracked on vessels at sea?
16:32
A.
Yes, and reported to the office.
16:32
Q.
In your opinion, Mr. Webster, as a marine safety expert,
16:32
what is the primary reason or reasons for that?
16:32
A.
16:32
done in a timely manner and the vessel remain safe for
16:32
10
operation.
16:32
11
are closing out maintenance tasks before they are completed,
16:32
12
that's a very serious breach of safety.
16:32
13
Q.
16:32
14
16:32
15
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:32
16
Q.
16:32
17
Equipment, Semisubmersible Deepwater Horizon."
16:33
18
16:33
19
was prepared by ModuSpec in March of 2005, correct?
16:33
20
A.
16:33
21
16:33
22
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:33
23
Q.
16:33
24
it says:
16:33
25
the full system PM . . ."
Now, under the ISM, is it your opinion that all
Well, the primary reason is to make sure that this work is
Failure to track it, or particularly this, if they
Thank you, sir.

MR. WILLIAMS:
Next we will go to Exhibit TREX-81.
This is a report of survey, "BHP Safety-Critical
Mr. Webster, it is prepared for BHP Billiton, and it
That's correct.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Page 11, please.
Under the topic Safety Equipment, 11.1 -- 11.1.1 Safety,

"Critical:
Repair the fire detection system, perform
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3783
16:33
In your opinion, what is PM?
16:33
A.
Plan of maintenance.
16:33
Q.
-- "earlier than the scheduled May 2005 annual PM."
16:33
16:33
expert, is the fire detection system a critical-safety
16:34
component of the Deepwater Horizon?
16:34
A.
16:34
the safety of the crew.
16:34
Q.
16:34
10
and this is a report of regular survey or just a report of
16:34
11
survey of the Deepwater Horizon, correct?
16:34
12
A.
Yes.
16:34
13
Q.
April 2005.
16:34
14
we go.
16:34
15
section on the BOP.
16:34
16
how it works.
16:34
17
16:34
18
original equipment manufacturer's recommended interval for
16:35
19
major service, requiring the changing of all seals in the
16:35
20
hydraulic systems.
16:35
21
with a five-year interval for disassembly, hardness, and
16:35
22
dimensional inspection.
16:35
23
compliance would soon be out of date."
16:35
24
16:35
25
Mr. Webster, in your opinion as a marine safety
Yes, one of the most paramount functions on the rig for
This is 2005.
We will go to the next TREX, which is 80,
Go to the next page, which would be -- there
It's under Topic 3.0, Executive Summary.
There's a
I'm not going to ask you any questions on
But it says:
"Overall, the BOP was beyond the
The recommended interval is three years
It was noted that the certificate of
Now, based on your review of all these documents

going forward from this date, is this -- was this the first
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3784
16:35
warning to Transocean regarding exceeding the original
16:35
equipment manufacturer's recommended interval for major
16:35
service?
16:35
A.
16:35
16:35
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:35
Q.
16:35
but this is a company audit report.
16:36
what a company audit report is as opposed to a vessel audit
16:36
10
report?
16:36
11
A.
16:36
12
the office -- and it might be more than one auditor, for
16:36
13
example -- and then visits with and interviews the various
16:36
14
members of the staff.
16:36
15
Q.
Okay.
16:36
16
A.
Yes.
16:36
17
Q.
Go to page 1 of the "Nonconformity and Finding Note,"
16:36
18
please.
16:36
19
16:37
20
this report, is there not?
16:37
21
A.
There is, correct.
16:37
22
Q.
That is that ISM Code Section 9.1, which we discussed
16:37
23
briefly at the outset, says that:
16:37
24
system should include procedures ensuring that nonconformities,
16:37
25
accidents, and hazardous situations are reported to the
Yes, it is the first, like, warning notice.

MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-1764, please.
Now, we have another ISM Code certification audit report,

Could you explain briefly
A company audit report means the auditor actually goes to
After the interview, is a report issued?
Now, there's a deficiency or nonconformity noted in
"The safety management
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3785
16:37
company, investigated and analyzed . . ."
16:37
16:37
implemented -- or effectively implemented; is that correct?
16:37
A.
Yes, sir.
16:37
Q.
Now, there are others -- other deficiencies noted below,
16:37
but those are vessel-specific; is that right?
16:37
A.
16:38
office, he will look for the files from various vessels to see
16:38
what's going on and make sure that the follow-up is happening.
16:38
10
16:38
11
16:38
12
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:38
13
Q.
16:38
14
Report," correct?
16:38
15
A.
Yes.
16:38
16
Q.
And its subtitle is "Intermediate ISM Audit"; is that
16:38
17
correct?
16:38
18
A.
Yes, it is.
16:38
19
Q.
Based on your experience as an ISM auditor, what is an
16:38
20
intermediate ISM audit?
16:38
21
A.
16:38
22
write up a nonconformity, they may go back -- or will go back
16:38
23
before the year is up and, most times, it's called an
16:39
24
intermediate survey -- intermediate audit, excuse me.
16:39
25
Q.
The deficiency is that the system/procedure is not
Yes, they are, but when the auditor does the audit in the
And that's probably why this is being written up like this.

MR. WILLIAMS:
Let's go to TREX-01 -- 1777, please.
This document is titled "Det Norske Veritas Survey
The audits are supposed to be every year, and if they
If you look down at the bottom, it indicates that the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3786
16:39
survey started and ended on June 29, 2005; is that correct?
16:39
A.
16:39
16:39
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:39
Q.
16:39
the significance of an observation under an ISM audit?
16:39
A.
16:39
nonconformity.
16:39
audit.
16:39
10
Q.
16:39
11
verify systematic follow-up of, and corrective action arising
16:40
12
from, findings from previous internal audits," and they
16:40
13
reference prior audits; is that correct?
16:40
14
A.
Yes.
16:40
15
Q.
Isn't systematic -- in your opinion, isn't systematic
16:40
16
follow-up of deficiencies or observations in prior ISM audits
16:40
17
required by the ISM?
16:40
18
A.
Yes, it is; and it's a major nonconformity.
16:40
19
Q.
Would that be something that the designated person should
16:40
20
know about?
16:40
21
A.
Absolutely, yes.
16:40
22
Q.
And should the designated person ashore for this vessel
16:40
23
know that it constitutes a major nonconformity?
16:40
24
A.
Should do, yes.
16:40
25
Q.
Would he be obligated in that case to go to the highest
Yes, uh-huh.
MR. WILLIAMS:
The next page, please.
The title of this page is an "Observation," and what is
Well, an observation is almost the same as a
Okay.
It's stating what a problem was during the
And that problem was:
"It was not possible to
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3787
16:41
level of management to inform him or her or them of the major
16:41
nonconformity and the reasons therefore?
16:41
A.
16:41
16:41
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:41
Q.
16:41
Winslow at Transocean, Inc.
16:41
16:41
A.
I do.
16:41
10
Q.
He is an officer in Transocean, correct?
16:41
11
A.
Correct.
16:41
12
like that.
16:41
13
Q.
16:41
14
the box where it says "Overall Audit Results," it says:
16:41
15
"Yellow.
16:41
16
business units.
16:42
17
of audit date or face being removed from the list of approved
16:42
18
contractors.
16:42
19
follow-up audit."
16:42
20
16:42
21
an ISM auditor, would it be Transocean's obligation to conduct
16:42
22
whatever follow-up audits are required to make sure that the
16:42
23
prior audit findings have been closed-out or rectified or
16:42
24
corrected?
16:42
25
A.
Absolutely.
MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-44015, please.
This is a letter dated August 30, 2005, sent to Mr. Daun
Do you recognize that name, Mr. Webster?
I think he is head of maintenance or something
I'm obviously not going to read the whole letter; but in
Conditionally approved to work for Gulf of Mexico

Must close all audit findings within 12 months
Closure of these findings will be verified by
Now, who -- in the first instance, in your opinion as
Yes, sir.
Absolutely.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3788
16:42
Q.
The ISM Code applies to Transocean, the vessel owner,
16:42
correct?
16:42
A.
It does.
16:42
Q.
Isn't it their obligation and not BP's obligation?
16:42
A.
It is their obligation.
16:43
Transocean on notice that they're on probation.
16:43
16:43
16:43
16:43
10
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:43
11
Q.
Do you recognize this document, Mr. Webster?
16:44
12
A.
I do, yes.
16:44
13
Q.
Just describe it briefly, please.
16:44
14
A.
This is an audit by Transocean Deepwater Drilling.
16:44
15
an audit protocol.
16:44
16
Q.
16:44
17
forward page on it.
16:44
18
prior audit findings?
16:44
19
A.
That could well be, yes.
16:44
20
Q.
Item 1.1:
16:44
21
determining which existing regulations apply to the
16:44
22
contractor's specific operations.
16:44
23
procedure for monitoring compliance.
16:44
24
demonstrate, in the auditor's opinion, the intent to comply
16:44
25
with the regulations."
MR. WILLIAMS:
What TREX is it?
This document also is putting
Next.
Is that part of the same TREX?
44038.
I'm sorry, Your Honor.
It's
Could this be -- I unfortunately didn't put the first or

Could this be the BP follow-up on the
"Contractor shall have a procedure for
Contractor shall have a

Contractor shall
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3789
16:45
The finding is:
"No procedure for determining which
16:45
existing regulation applies to Transocean's operations was
16:45
found."
16:45
16:45
A.
Correct.
16:45
Q.
Is that an ISM violation?
16:45
A.
Yes.
16:45
Q.
1.4:
16:45
regulations.
16:45
10
available for review, shall include a list of applicable
16:45
11
regulations and on-site inspection of compliance."
16:45
12
16:45
13
Security, or Coast Guard list of applicable regulations was not
16:45
14
available."
16:45
15
16:45
16
violation?
16:45
17
A.
16:45
18
16:45
19
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:45
20
Q.
16:46
21
immediate notification of the company occurs for those
16:46
22
incidents listed when those incidents occur on company sites or
16:46
23
company project sites or in support of either.
16:46
24
the contractor personnel -- that personnel are aware of the
16:46
25
requirement and the process and the notification is carried out
Correct?
"Contractor shall demonstrate compliance with

Records in support of this, which will be
The finding is:
"A specific safety MMS, Homeland
In your opinion as a lead ISM auditor, is that an ISM
Yes.
MR. WILLIAMS:
No. 15, please, page 7 of 15.
"Contractor shall have a procedure in place where
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
Records showing
3790
16:46
effectively shall be available for review."
16:46
16:46
procedure does not identify immediate verbal and written
16:46
notification to company supervisor."
16:46
Is that correct?
16:46
16:46
16:46
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:46
Q.
16:47
10
Deepwater Horizon prepared for Transocean.
16:47
11
survey; is that correct?
16:47
12
A.
Correct.
16:47
13
Q.
What is the date of that?
16:47
14
A.
17 to 31, October 2005.
16:47
15
MR. WILLIAMS:
16:47
16
MR. KINCHEN:
16:47
17
I'm going to object for relevance.
16:47
18
page 2 of a six-page chart that lists various audits.
16:47
19
these entities -- DNV, BP, ModuSpec -- audited, surveyed,
16:47
20
inspected this rig plenty of times in the period 2007, 2008,
16:47
21
2009, 2010, on up.
16:47
22
So I would object based upon relevance of, for
16:47
23
example, a ModuSpec 2005 audit when ModuSpec did an intrusive
16:47
24
survey in 2010 just essentially days before the incident.
16:48
25
The finding is:
A.
"The Transocean incident reporting
That is correct.
MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-75, please.
They have a Supplemental Report of Survey,
THE COURT:
This is a ModuSpec
Turn to page 13, please, Carl.

Your Honor, John Kinchen, Transocean.
It looks like we are on
All right.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
All of
3791
16:48
MR. WILLIAMS:
Your Honor, Mr. Kinchen is correct:
16:48
This vessel during its life was surveyed and audited to death.
16:48
The stack is that high.
16:48
show -- I'm not going through every one of them -- where time
16:48
after time, these deficiencies were pointed out to Transocean,
16:48
gross deficiencies with respect to maintenance and safety,
16:48
chain of command, all those types of things, all ISM
16:48
violations.
16:48
they knew about it, that there's a pattern here and, you know,
16:48
10
16:48
11
THE COURT:
16:48
12
MR. KINCHEN:
16:48
13
16:48
14
THE COURT REPORTER:
16:48
15
THE COURT:
16:48
16
16:48
17
16:49
18
16:49
19
16:49
20
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:49
21
Q.
16:49
22
364, the asset description -- we are talking about the
16:49
23
Deepwater Horizon, just to remind you.
16:49
24
A.
Yes, sir.
16:49
25
Q.
We are talking -- the asset description is the gas
There is a pattern that I'm going to
They were never corrected.
I'm establishing that
I think it goes to gross -All right.
I overrule the objection.
We agree there was a pattern,
Your Honor.
I'm sorry, who was that?
That was an uninvited comment by
Mr. Kinchen.
I ruled and there shouldn't be any comments
after I rule, Mr. Kinchen.
MR. KINCHEN:
Mr. Webster, as part of this audit, you'll see referenced
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3792
16:49
detection system?
16:49
A.
Correct.
16:49
Q.
We have talked about that already.
16:49
A.
Yes.
16:49
Q.
Part of the IACS, correct?
16:49
A.
Correct.
16:49
Q.
The severity level, over here on the right-hand column, is
16:49
"Major"; is that right?
16:49
A.
Yes.
16:49
10
Q.
At present, the combustible gas levels are set at
16:49
11
20 percent LEL (High), and 60 percent LEL (High-High), "but
16:49
12
with only 50 percent gas on the rig, these preset levels are
16:50
13
unobtainable; therefore, recommend the LEL values in the Simrad
16:50
14
system be set up to alarm at 20 percent (High) and 40 percent
16:50
15
LEL."
16:50
16
16:50
17
A.
You did.
16:50
18
Q.
Now, in your opinion as a marine safety expert, is that a
16:50
19
prudent recommendation?
16:50
20
A.
16:50
21
LEL means lower explosive limit.
16:50
22
done there is raise them so they don't alarm and they put the
16:50
23
rig in extreme danger.
16:50
24
Q.
16:50
25
level or trigger point high enough, that it effectively
Yes, that's a very dangerous thing they were doing there.

And basically what they have
Is it true and is it your opinion, if you raise the LEL
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3793
16:50
disables the utility of that particular alarm?
16:50
A.
16:50
16:50
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
16:51
Q.
Could you tell the Court what this is, Mr. Webster.
16:51
A.
It's a rig assessment by the maintenance department --
16:51
Transocean's maintenance department in October 17 to 31, 2005.
16:51
16:51
16:51
10
Q.
16:51
11
for almost five years.
16:51
12
it just well enough to get by; and some are very much lacking
16:51
13
in knowledge of how to use it.
16:51
14
inconsistent.
16:52
15
very poor in other situations where details and readings are
16:52
16
missing."
16:52
17
16:52
18
A.
You did, sir, yes.
16:52
19
Q.
Sir, in your opinion, is that very similar to a comment or
16:52
20
a finding made a year before regarding the EMPAC system?
16:52
21
A.
That is correct.
16:52
22
Q.
In your opinion as an ISM auditor, is that a violation of
16:52
23
the International Safety Management Code?
16:52
24
A.
It is, I believe, yes.
16:52
25
Q.
Going on, the second paragraph:
Yes, it does, yes.

MR. WILLIAMS:
MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-1192, please.
We can go to Section 2.2, please.
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
"Maintenance System Review:
The rig has been using EMPAC
A few people know EMPAC well; most know
Record keeping in EMPAC is
History notes are quite good in some cases and
"Due to the extent of the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3794
16:52
corrections needed, it will not be practical for the rig to
16:52
accomplish this project on their own.
16:52
spare time, available expertise, or user profiles to be able to
16:52
complete this work in a reasonable amount of time.
16:52
experienced EMPAC optimizer should be assigned to work with the
16:52
rig for one hitch to get this done."
16:52
16:53
A.
Yes, sir, correct.
16:53
Q.
In your review of all these documents, all the audits and
16:53
10
everything else you reviewed, did you see any evidence that one
16:53
11
or more experienced EMPAC optimizers were assigned by
16:53
12
Transocean to the rig for a hitch or more than a hitch to help
16:53
13
get this mess straightened out?
16:53
14
A.
16:53
15
out.
16:53
16
Q.
16:53
17
going to talk about thrusters.
16:53
18
16:53
19
the thrusters that has been manageable up to this point by
16:53
20
cleaning the oil with two portable filtering units.
16:53
21
3, 4, and 6 have been at or above the manufacturer's maximum
16:53
22
allowable moisture content in the past."
16:53
23
16:54
24
A.
Eight.
16:54
25
Q.
Now, could you share your opinion with the Court as to the
No, it wasn't.
They have neither the
An
In fact, the mess was never straightened
It got worse.
Let's just jump down on that same page, 2.32.
It says:
We are
"There has been salt water intrusion into
Thrusters
How many thrusters are on this vessel?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3795
16:54
significance of the detection of salt water intrusion into
16:54
thruster units on this vessel.
16:54
A.
16:54
running so much, is that the bearing in the seal where the
16:54
propeller shaft comes out of the gearbox, the seal gets worn
16:54
away and the bearings can be worn away; and water can get into
16:54
the gearbox, and the oil can leak out in a very dangerous
16:54
situation.
16:54
Q.
Why is that a very dangerous situation?
16:54
10
A.
Because you could lose a gearbox and lose a thruster.
16:54
11
Q.
In your opinion as a marine safety expert, is it
16:54
12
acceptable to simply filter the oil that is in -- I'm sorry --
16:55
13
the salt water that has intruded into the thruster with
16:55
14
portable filtering units?
16:55
15
A.
16:55
16
leaking out into the ocean is a violation of the Clean Water
16:55
17
Act and MPA.
16:55
18
Yes.
No.
What happens with these thrusters, because they are
It's a stopgap.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Not to mention the oil that's
TREX-3288, please.
19
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:33
20
Q.
16:55
21
Mr. Webster.
16:55
22
A.
This is a West Engineering Services condition audit.
16:55
23
Q.
Dated?
16:55
24
A.
30 November 2005.
16:55
25
Q.
It's regarding a subsea condition equipment condition
Could you identify this for the Court, please,
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3796
16:55
audit, correct?
16:55
A.
Yes, sir.
16:55
Q.
Now, we have seen a prior West audit that we talked about
16:55
earlier, correct?
16:55
A.
16:56
16:56
Section JD-930 paragraph.
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:33
Q.
16:56
10
sentence:
16:56
11
replaced with rebuilt ones in the past year.
16:56
12
being replaced, three sets of valves were listed as changed,
16:56
13
but there was no reference as to which ones.
16:56
14
ongoing problem with the PM, or preventive maintenance, work
16:56
15
orders.
16:56
16
A couple questions about this sentence, Mr. Webster.
16:56
17
First of all, in your opinion, based solely on your knowledge,
16:56
18
is the BOP a safety-critical piece of equipment on the vessel?
16:57
19
A.
Yes, it's one of the most critical items.
16:57
20
Q.
Is it acceptable practice, in your opinion, to change
16:57
21
valves -- or to have in the records that three sets of valves
16:57
22
were listed as changed, but there being no reference as to
16:57
23
which ones were changed?
16:57
24
A.
16:57
25
which ones have been recently repaired and which aren't.
We have.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Could you turn, Carl, to
"Gate valves, failsafe/subsea BOP."
It's the third full
"The upper chokes and bleed valves have been

Prior to these
This has been an
Not enough detailed information entered."
No, that's very bad, because they don't know in the future
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3797
16:57
Q.
Aren't there more than three valves on a BOP?
16:57
A.
Yes.
16:57
Q.
This would be -- would this be a violation of the ISM
16:57
Code, in your opinion?
16:57
A.
16:57
Yes, sir, it would.

MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-01765, please.
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:33
Q.
Could you identify this document for us.
16:58
A.
Yes.
16:58
10
the company, Transocean Offshore Deepwater Drilling.
16:58
11
Q.
What was the date of the audit?
16:58
12
A.
21 -- 20/21 April 2006.
16:58
13
Q.
Four years, almost to the date -- four years to the date,
16:58
14
actually, of this tragedy?
16:58
15
A.
Correct.
16:58
16
Q.
Now, down in the middle section, or starting at the middle
16:58
17
of the page, actually, they have a list of people who
16:58
18
attended -- apparently attended this audit.
16:58
19
A.
Yes, that is correct.
16:58
20
Q.
Is that what that normally indicates?
16:59
21
A.
Well, as I explained to Your Honor earlier, these would be
16:59
22
the people that were interviewed by the auditor in the office.
16:59
23
Q.
16:59
24
suppose, indicate the duration of the interview.
16:59
25
fair assumption?
This is another Det Norske Veritas audit program for
There's a start time and an end time.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
Is that right?
And that would, I

Is that a
3798
16:59
A.
Yes, sir, that is correct.
16:59
Q.
One of the folks who was there was the vice president of
16:59
QHSE.
16:59
A.
Adrian Rose.
16:59
Q.
Again, this is in April of 2006, correct?
16:59
A.
That is correct.
16:59
16:59
please.
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
And what is his name?
MR. WILLIAMS:
If we could go to the next page,
15:33
10
Q.
As in the prior audit we looked at, there is -- next
17:00
11
page -- contains observations, correct?
17:00
12
A.
That is correct.
17:00
13
Q.
Sir, those would be observations made by the ISM auditor?
17:00
14
A.
Yes.
17:00
15
Q.
"Item 1, a review of open items in the FOCUS GRS database
17:00
16
revealed over" -- well, I can't read it because there's --
17:00
17
somebody has written over it in the document that was produced.
17:00
18
But it looks -- what does that number look like to you?
17:00
19
A.
580 or 550, I don't know.
17:00
20
Q.
Or 500?
17:00
21
A.
Or 500 it could be, yes.
17:00
22
Q.
Let's call it 500 and give them the benefit of the doubt.
17:00
23
". . . over 500 overdue items dating as far back as 2003."
17:01
24
17:01
25
And this one would be Mr. David McKay.
In your opinion as a marine safety expert and an ISM

lead auditor, how would you characterize that finding?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3799
17:01
A.
I would call that a major nonconformity of Section 10.2,
17:01
which is the maintenance requirement.
17:01
Q.
17:01
you to read it.
17:01
17:01
A.
I have, yes.
17:01
Q.
Item 2 addresses training, correct?
17:01
A.
Yes, it does.
17:01
Q.
The ISM auditor takes issue with the quality of their
17:01
10
training program; is that correct?
17:01
11
A.
17:02
12
which requires the crew to be trained in accordance with the
17:02
13
requirements.
17:02
14
17:02
15
TREX-44032.
16
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:33
17
Q.
And could you identify this document for us, Mr. Webster?
17:02
18
A.
Yes.
17:02
19
and environmental management system internal EMS audit carried
17:02
20
out by, I think, Transocean.
17:02
21
Q.
Well, let's look carefully at that.
17:03
22
A.
And a consultant, E&S Group.
17:03
23
Q.
Thanks.
17:03
24
of the page.
17:03
25
Item 2 -- I'm not going to read the whole thing.
I'd ask
Have you reviewed this document before?
That is true, yes.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Sees it as a violation of Section 6.5,
Next document, please.
This is
This is a health, safety, environmental compliance
Let's go to the Section 3, please, page 6, bottom
"System evaluation, location."
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
What location are
3800
17:03
they talking about here?
17:03
A.
I think they're talking about the Deepwater Horizon.
17:03
Q.
"Location does not recognize the benefit of audits and
17:03
assessments.
17:03
17:03
17:03
"Managers and supervisors place no priority on action

plans and the results are inconsistent."
MR. WILLIAMS:
Next page, please.
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:33
Q.
17:03
10
17:03
11
17:04
12
expert and an ISM auditor, do these findings constitute
17:04
13
violations of the International Safety Management Code?
17:04
14
A.
They do, yes, sir.
17:04
15
Q.
Would these findings be something that the designated
17:04
16
person would know about?
17:04
17
A.
Should know about, yes.
17:04
18
Q.
Under the ISM Code, would that designated person be
17:04
19
obligated to inform the highest level of management of these
17:04
20
deficiencies?
17:04
21
A.
17:04
22
On the next page it says:
"No systemic approach to
dealing with the closure of action plans."

That's correct, yes, sir, should do.

MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-01766.
23
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:33
24
Q.
Would you identify this document for us.
17:04
25
A.
This is another DNV audit of the Deepwater Horizon -- I'm
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3801
17:04
sorry.
Hold on.
No, it's of the company.
I'm sorry.
17:05
Q.
Transocean Offshore Deepwater Drilling, Inc., correct?
17:05
A.
Yes.
17:05
Q.
The audit date?
17:05
A.
Audit date is January 22, 2007.
17:05
Q.
That's approximately nine months after the last Transocean
17:05
offshore deepwater drilling audit that we looked at just a few
17:05
minutes ago, TREX-1765; is that right?
17:05
A.
Same auditor, David McKay.
17:05
10
Q.
It's the same type of audit, correct?
17:05
11
A.
Yes.
17:05
12
Q.
Let's look down, starting at the middle of the page, and
17:05
13
some of the attendees.
17:05
14
present -- correct --
17:05
15
A.
Correct.
17:05
16
Q.
-- apparently was interviewed for an hour and 15-minutes
17:05
17
on January 22.
17:05
18
A.
17:06
19
well, for corporate.
17:06
20
Q.
17:06
21
the Deepwater Horizon?
17:06
22
A.
17:06
23
confusing in the file, but he was definitely, I think, the top
17:06
24
guy as far as the designated persons go in the company.
17:06
25
Q.
We've got QHSE director, Jimmy Moore,
I believe he was actually a designated person ashore, as
Okay.
The designated person ashore we talked about for
Well, I think for the whole fleet.
It's a little
He also had the QHSE manager, Mr. Steve Carlisle,
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3802
17:06
attending apparently?
17:06
A.
Yes.
17:06
Q.
You have the CEO, Mr. Bob Long, apparently was interviewed
17:06
or met with for approximately 35 minutes; is that correct?
17:06
A.
Yes.
17:06
Q.
Is it unusual for the chief executive officer of a
17:06
maritime company to participate in these ISM audits?
17:06
A.
17:06
the idea of it.
17:06
10
Q.
17:07
11
president and chief operating officer, Steven Newman.
17:07
12
A.
That's correct.
17:07
13
Q.
17:07
14
A.
Yes.
17:07
15
Q.
Apparently he spent approximately 45 minutes on the next
17:07
16
day with the auditor, being interviewed, correct?
17:07
17
A.
That is correct.
17:07
18
Q.
Now, is it normal in these types of audits, company
17:07
19
audits, for the auditor to discuss his concerns and findings
17:07
20
and possible deficiencies with the people he interviews?
17:07
21
A.
17:07
22
nonconformities.
17:07
23
15:33
Not at all.
That's the most senior management.
That's
Then also present, among others, was the executive vice
Yes.
He'll make observations and, if necessary,
MR. WILLIAMS:
24
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
25
Q.
Next page, please.
Again, attached to this we have an observation on this
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3803
17:07
audit, correct?
17:07
A.
Correct.
17:07
Q.
"Observation 1:
17:07
issue in the current economic climate for the drilling industry
17:08
and that there is a potential knowledge gap between senior
17:08
personnel nearing retirement age and new personnel coming into
17:08
the industry.
17:08
17:08
plan to maintain sufficient numbers of trained, qualified, and
17:08
10
suitably experienced personnel in the organization both onshore
17:08
11
and offshore to ensure safe operations."
17:08
12
17:08
13
A.
Yes.
17:08
14
Q.
And that is part of the company's -- is it part of the
17:08
15
company's obligation under the International Safety Management
17:08
16
Code to do that?
17:08
17
A.
17:08
18
It was stated that manning has become an
"It is recommended the owner prepare and execute a
Yes.
It goes to ISM Code Regulation 6.

MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-3403, please.
19
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:33
20
Q.
Would you identify this for the Court.
17:08
21
A.
Yes, sir.
17:08
22
which is used within the industry.
17:08
23
which is the International Association of Drilling Contractors.
17:09
24
Q.
When is it dated, please.
17:09
25
A.
May 11 to May 15, 2007.
This is a common marine inspection document

It's an IADC document,
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3804
17:09
Q.
It relates to the vessel Deepwater Horizon, does it not?
17:09
A.
Yes, sir.
17:09
Correct.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Page 5, please, Carl.
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
15:33
Q.
17:09
normally, don't they?
17:09
A.
Yes.
17:09
Q.
In this one the surveyor who conducted -- or the
17:09
inspector -- the inspectors who conducted this inspection
17:09
10
survey made the following observation.
17:09
11
in your experience, does that mean?
17:09
12
A.
That's a high priority.
17:09
13
Q.
"A significant number of fire dampers in engine rooms and
17:10
14
other machinery spaces found nonoperational.
17:10
15
fire dampers has been a long-term concern."
17:10
16
17:10
17
A.
Yes, sir.
17:10
18
Q.
Now, what -- as a marine safety expert, would you share
17:10
19
that concern?
17:10
20
A.
I would, indeed.
17:10
21
Q.
Why is that, sir?
17:10
22
A.
Well, it's putting the vessel at risk for a fire, or
17:10
23
should a fire occur.
17:10
24
Q.
17:10
25
expressed --
Now, the surveyor makes various comments in the survey
It says "High."
What,
It means it's a serious problem.
Reliability of
This is not the first time that we have seen this concern
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3805
17:10
A.
That's correct.
17:10
Q.
-- about fire dampers, correct?
17:10
A.
It is not.
17:10
17:10
fire hazard.
17:10
Q.
The quick-closing supply, the fuel supply?
17:10
A.
Yes.
17:10
any space, those valves are supposed to be turned off so that
17:10
they can't feed the fire with fuel.
17:11
10
Q.
17:11
11
nonoperational, and this system was not included in the
17:11
12
maintenance system."
17:11
13
17:11
14
of this vessel?
17:11
15
A.
The safety for the stability of the vessel, yes.
17:11
16
Q.
"A number of bilge valves in the port/aft pump room failed
17:11
17
to operate when tested."
17:11
18
17:11
19
A.
Yes.
17:11
20
Q.
And why is that?
17:11
21
A.
Well, if you can't pump the bilges out, you will flood the
17:11
22
space.
17:11
23
Q.
17:11
24
can they be controlled by the emergency shutdown system part of
17:11
25
the Kongsberg system?
Indeed, it is not.
In fact, No. 2 is not highlighted, but that's also a
In other words, when there's a problem or a fire in
It looks like at No. 3:
"Three watertight dampers found
Are watertight dampers safety-critical appurtenances
Is that safety-critical issue?

If you can't --
With respect to Observations 1, 2, and 3, should they or
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3806
17:11
A.
Yes.
17:11
Q.
If we go down under the Medium category, Item 5:
17:12
"Thruster drives 5-yearly replacement of critical components
17:12
not yet undertaken, and no plan in place to complete the work."
17:12
17:12
safety-critical defect with the Deepwater Horizon existing at
17:12
the time of this --
17:12
A.
17:12
into the lower gearbox.
17:12
10
Q.
17:12
11
or in passive mode due to defects.
17:12
12
available, and this system not included in the maintenance
17:12
13
system."
17:12
14
17:12
15
an expert in marine safety?
17:12
16
A.
Yes, sir, it is.
17:12
17
Q.
Now, in fairness, there are hundreds of smoke detectors
17:12
18
all over this rig, aren't there?
17:12
19
A.
Yes.
17:12
20
Q.
Do you have an estimate as to how many there are?
17:13
21
A.
I recall 50 to 100, maybe more.
17:13
22
Q.
In any event, there are a lot of them, correct?
17:13
23
A.
Many of them.
17:13
24
Q.
The monitoring of those smoke detectors, in addition to
17:13
25
other things, is done by the fire and gas detection system,
In your opinion as a marine safety expert, is that a
Yes.
Very much so, especially as they were getting water
Item 6:
"Approximately 11 smoke detectors either disabled

Onboard spares not
Is that a safety-critical defect, in your opinion as
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3807
17:13
correct?
17:13
A.
It is, with IACS.
17:13
Q.
That's part of IACS.
17:13
A.
Yes, sir.
17:13
17:13
same document.
17:13
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:13
Q.
17:13
routinely or formally reported to the BP well site leader.
17:13
10
EMPAC maintenance management system has a facility for
17:13
11
producing a monthly maintenance report indicating all overdue
17:13
12
maintenance work orders, but this feature is not routinely
17:14
13
used."
17:14
14
17:14
15
expert, should that system be routinely used to generate
17:14
16
monthly maintenance reports?
17:14
17
A.
Absolutely, yes.
17:14
18
Q.
Why is that?
17:14
19
A.
Well, so the follow-up could be -- so repair items could
17:14
20
be tracked and the follow-up can be made to make sure the items
17:14
21
were being taken care of in a timely manner and/or taken care
17:14
22
of, period.
17:14
23
Q.
17:14
24
don't know what's broke, correct?
17:14
25
A.
MR. WILLIAMS:
It's an automated system, correct?
Let's go to paragraph 3.9, please,
"Other than rig floor equipment issues, defects are not

The
In your opinion, should that -- as a marine safety
Correct.
Basically you can't fix what's broke if you
That's very well said.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3808
17:14
MR. WILLIAMS:
Next page, please, Section 12.1.
17:14
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:14
Q.
17:15
included" -- here we see it again -- "numerous fire dampers,
17:15
engine supply and exhaust and machinery spaces."
17:15
17:15
A.
Yes, sir.
17:15
Q.
Do they -- is it your opinion that they endanger the crew
17:15
of that vessel?
17:15
10
A.
Yes, they do.
17:15
11
Q.
"Main Engine No. 2 rig savers did not close on ESD."
17:15
12
17:15
13
that is a safety-critical issue that imperils the safety of the
17:15
14
men and women who work on board that rig?
17:15
15
A.
17:15
16
the rig in the event of gas getting on board.
17:15
17
Q.
17:15
18
defense to stop a diesel engine from overspeeding upon
17:15
19
ingestion of hydrocarbons or flammable gases are the rig
17:16
20
savers?
17:16
21
A.
17:16
22
17:16
23
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:16
24
Q.
Would you identify this quickly for us, Mr. Webster.
17:16
25
A.
This is another DNV survey report on the
"Other equipment defective during the audit period
Are those safety-critical issues?
Is it your opinion as a marine safety expert that
Exactly.
That's why they are called "rig savers," to save
Isn't it true that if all else fails, the last line of
That is correct.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Go to TREX-01778, please.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3809
17:16
Deepwater Horizon.
17:16
scope ISPS audit.
17:16
Q.
Did you tell me what day it was done?
17:17
A.
May 2007, May 15, 2007.
17:17
17:17
sections of that audit, please, Carl.
17:17
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:17
Q.
17:17
maintenance tasks were noted in the unit's planned maintenance
17:17
10
system database, including six overdue items for equipment
17:17
11
deemed safety critical dating back up to six months.
17:17
12
stated by the crew that spare parts are slow to arrive due to
17:17
13
supplier backlogs.
17:17
14
considered to prevent maintenance backlog becoming a problem."
17:17
15
17:17
16
Mr. Webster?
17:17
17
A.
That's a violation of Regulation 10.2.1.
17:18
18
Q.
Why is it important to have constant and reliable supply
17:18
19
of spares going to a vessel in operation at sea?
17:18
20
A.
17:18
21
broken down.
17:18
22
manner.
17:18
23
have a rig that's been out as long as this has, without going
17:18
24
in dry dock.
17:18
25
Q.
It's the renewal ISM audit and renewal
MR. WILLIAMS:
Observation No. 1:
Could we go to the Observation
"A small number of overdue planned
It was
It is recommended that actions be
Is that, in your opinion, an ISM Code violation,
Well, you end up with a rig that half the equipment is

I mean, you have got to maintain it in a good
You have got to supply spares, especially when you
What kind of an impact, in your opinion, does it have on
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3810
17:18
the maintenance crew?
17:18
A.
17:18
because they are having to patch up things, trying to keep them
17:18
working without having the proper spares.
17:18
put a bandaid on it to keep it going.
17:18
17:19
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:19
Q.
17:19
DP Proving Trials of May 2007 conducted by BP; is that correct?
17:19
10
A.
Yes.
17:19
11
Q.
Is that a survey and audit much like the others we have
17:19
12
talked about, regardless of who does them?
17:19
13
A.
17:19
14
dynamic positioning system as well.
17:19
15
17:19
16
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:19
17
Q.
17:19
18
executed and improvements need implementing.
17:19
19
maintenance activities which could impact stationkeeping
17:19
20
reliability and availability currently scheduled for the period
17:19
21
when the rig is scheduled to drill while alongside
17:19
22
Horn Mountain should be identified and an assessment performed
17:19
23
to determine which activities can be rescheduled either ahead
17:20
24
of the well or delayed after the well.
17:20
25
number of overdue maintenance activities, main engine
It puts a tremendous burden on the maintenance crew
MR. WILLIAMS:
They have to try to
TREX-3404, please.
This is the Deepwater Horizon Marine Assurance Audit and
Yes, it is.
Only this time they are looking at the
MR. WILLIAMS:
It says:
Go to page 3, please.
"Currently maintenance planning is not well

Therefore,
There are currently a
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3811
17:20
turbocharger renewal, thruster drive overhauls, main
17:20
switchboard 5-yearly inspection, that are overdue with no
17:20
demonstrable execution in place."
17:20
17:20
opinion as a marine safety expert, is the fact that the main
17:20
switchboard is overdue, the thruster drive needs overhauls, and
17:20
that there's no demonstrable execution plan in place to conduct
17:20
that maintenance and repair -- is that, in your opinion, a
17:20
violation of the International Safety Management Code?
17:20
10
A.
It is indeed.
17:20
11
Q.
The International Safety Management Code adopts or allows
17:21
12
the Code of Federal Regulations to apply as well, correct?
17:21
13
A.
17:21
14
17:21
15
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:21
16
Q.
17:21
17
rig integrity concern both watertight and fire integrity issues
17:21
18
such as availability and reliability of fire dampers and fuel
17:21
19
quick closing valves."
17:21
20
17:21
21
A.
17:21
22
last time.
17:21
23
Q.
17:21
24
expert?
17:21
25
A.
If this audit is correct, Mr. Webster, in your
33 C.F.R. 96.5.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Page 4, please, Carl.
Down near the bottom of the page:
"Findings that affect
Those show up again, do they not, Mr. Webster?

Yes, sir.
That item had not been taken care of since the
What does that fact indicate to you as a marine safety
Complete lack of maintenance, ongoing maintenance, planned
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3812
17:21
maintenance; in fact, a disregard for the safe operation of the
17:21
vessel.
17:21
Q.
17:21
findings which, when taken in isolation, do not present a
17:22
significant risk but when combined with other deficiencies may
17:22
exacerbate an ongoing emergency situation such as emergency
17:22
ballast or bilge operations."
17:22
17:22
17:22
10
present a danger to a vessel on the high seas but a combination
17:22
11
of those deficiencies could constitute a violation of the
17:22
12
ISM Code?
17:22
13
A.
17:22
14
comment that this was not a significant risk.
17:22
15
the emergency ballast system or pump the bilges, then the
17:22
16
vessel is at risk of possibly sinking.
17:23
17
17:23
18
please, Carl.
17:23
19
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:23
20
Q.
17:23
21
starting at the third paragraph:
17:23
22
during testing of main engine shutdowns.
17:23
23
devices (rig savers) on main engine 2 failed to close, and the
17:23
24
high jacket water temperature and high alternator bearing oil
17:23
25
temperature shutdowns failed to give the correct alarm/shutdown
It goes on to say that "There are also a number of other
As a marine safety expert, do you agree that

individual maintenance issues in and of themselves may not
Absolutely.
In fact, I disagree with the surveyor's
MR. WILLIAMS:
If you can't use
Let's go to page 5, same report,
Under the Power Generation and Distribution paragraph, I'm

"Problems were encountered
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
The air shut-off
3813
17:23
indication and shut down the engines."
17:23
17:23
expert, do the findings explained, set forth in this paragraph,
17:24
constitute an extreme danger to the crew of that vessel?
17:24
A.
17:24
water and a high alternator and bearing oil temperature is to
17:24
shut the engine down before it blows itself up or catches fire.
17:24
17:24
17:24
10
have someone in the control room, but there's not somebody
17:24
11
walking around the engine room all the time to check these, the
17:24
12
operation of these engines.
17:24
13
alternation.
17:24
14
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:24
15
Q.
17:24
16
well as your qualifications as a marine safety expert, a crew
17:25
17
on an oceangoing vessel can only do so much if they are not
17:25
18
getting support from the beach.
17:25
19
A.
17:25
20
stressed.
17:25
21
Q.
They are not magicians, are they?
17:25
22
A.
No.
17:25
23
Q.
They can only do what they -- they can only use the tools
17:25
24
that they are given by the managers, the operators, and the
17:25
25
ship?
Oh, absolutely, because the whole purpose of a high jacket
THE WITNESS:
I mean, these engine rooms are not
monitored, Your Honor, with people.
They are isolated.
You do
So you have to rely on
Mr. Webster, based on your experience going to sea, as
That's true.
Is that a fair statement?
Most of the times they become overworked and
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3814
17:25
A.
That is correct, whatever parts they can scrounge.
17:25
Q.
It goes on to say:
17:25
that's emergency shutdowns, right?
17:25
A.
Correct.
17:25
Q.
-- "a number of anomalies regarding closure of fuel oil
17:25
quick closing valves and operation of engine room ventilation
17:25
dampers were observed.
17:25
spill and No. 4 supply and spill failed to close."
17:26
17:26
10
emergency, the possible consequences, in your opinion?
17:26
11
A.
You can have an oil spill or oil pollution.
17:26
12
Q.
"Numerous problems have been experienced with HVAC dampers
17:26
13
around the rig due to poor robustness of the damper actuators
17:26
14
and dampers."
17:26
15
17:26
16
that -- in the event of fire at sea, does that present a
17:26
17
danger --
17:26
18
A.
It could.
17:26
19
Q.
-- to the lives of the crew?
17:26
20
A.
Heating and ventilation dampers.
17:26
21
would, for the accommodation.
17:26
22
17:27
23
17:27
24
"When testing engine room ESDs" --
Fuel oil quick closing valves No. 1
What are the consequences of that in the event of an
In your opinion as a marine safety expert, does
MR. WILLIAMS:
So yes, I think it
Next page, please.
Is there a
separate TREX number for this, or is it on the same TREX?

Thank you.
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3815
17:27
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:27
Q.
17:27
saw a little bit earlier, where after the BP audit is done or
17:27
survey is done, these sheets are used to keep track of
17:27
progress, correct?
17:27
A.
That is correct.
17:27
Q.
1.4.1, it's the Marine section, we see again mention of
17:27
the significant number of fire dampers in the engine rooms and
17:27
other machinery spaces found nonoperational during testing.
17:27
10
17:27
11
policies or standards and that "all fire dampers to be made
17:27
12
operational and maintenance frequency increased to ensure
17:28
13
availability and improve reliability."
17:28
14
17:28
15
that correct?
17:28
16
A.
That is correct.
17:28
17
Q.
1.4.5 on page 20 of the same document:
17:28
18
formal process to inform the BP well site leader of overdue
17:28
19
critical maintenance or defective equipment.
17:28
20
well site leader was unaware of the marine-related equipment
17:28
21
defects."
17:28
22
17:28
23
A.
Yes.
17:28
24
Q.
The recommendation is that Transocean monthly maintenance
17:28
25
reports be used as a method for formally reporting to the BP
This is an audit report action sheet, much like the one we
It says that these items do not comply with BP
The advised completion date is within two weeks; is
"There was no
Consequently, the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3816
17:28
well site leader the maintenance and defective equipment
17:29
issues, correct?
17:29
A.
17:29
previously, also.
17:29
Q.
17:29
we talked about them in the survey that this is a follow-up to,
17:29
correct?
17:29
A.
Yes.
17:29
Q.
-- "failed to close when an engine room ESD was
17:29
10
17:29
11
17:29
12
Is that your opinion?
17:29
13
A.
Yes.
17:29
14
Q.
"Investigate and rectify."
17:29
15
week, correct?
17:29
16
A.
Correct.
17:29
17
Q.
2.3.5:
17:29
18
EMPAC maintenance system for periodic testing."
17:29
19
17:29
20
in EMPAC, there is no way that you can keep track of whether
17:30
21
they are working or not or need maintenance or not; is that
17:30
22
correct?
17:30
23
A.
That is correct.
17:30
24
Q.
That's a violation -- is that a violation of the ISM Code,
17:30
25
in your opinion?
Correct.
And this is an item that was addressed
Page 23, Item 2.32, "Rig savers on main engine No. 2" --
initiated."
ESD is an automatic function, correct, or should be?
Advised completion within one
"Fire detectors have not been included in the
If the maintenance of fire detectors is not included
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3817
17:30
A.
Yes, sir, it is.
17:30
Q.
Is that a safety-critical issue?
17:30
A.
Very much so.
17:30
Q.
Is that an issue, in your opinion, that if not resolved
17:30
puts the crew at risk of personal injury or death?
17:30
A.
Yes.
17:30
Q.
3.3.11 on page 31:
17:30
restricted to 7 days and occasionally 30 days.
17:30
allow a proactive approach to maintenance planning with respect
17:30
10
17:30
11
17:30
12
constitute a violation of the International Safety Management
17:30
13
Code?
17:30
14
A.
Yes.
17:30
15
Q.
Why is that?
17:31
16
A.
Well, first of all, you have to get the spare parts on
17:31
17
order.
17:31
18
seals or bearings or something, then you need all that.
17:31
19
have to look way ahead and then get the parts and then get it
17:31
20
scheduled.
17:31
21
17:31
22
17:31
23
THE WITNESS:
17:31
24
No.
17:31
25
"Maintenance planning look ahead is

This does not
to the drilling program."

In your expert opinion, Mr. Webster, does that
It should be much longer than that.
You have to have the right tools.
THE COURT:
You know, if it's
Something is causing a humming.
You
I don't
know -I wonder if it's my phone, Your Honor.
My phone is switched off.
THE COURT:
Maybe you are just too close to the
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3818
17:31
microphone.
17:31
THE WITNESS:
17:31
THE COURT:
17:31
17:31
inch or two.
17:31
Thank you.
17:31
17:31
17:31
17:31
10
Q.
17:31
11
system is not being tested in accordance with the maintenance
17:32
12
procedures.
17:32
13
effects outputs to be tested and verified; however, outputs are
17:32
14
inhibited during periodic calibration and testing of the gas
17:32
15
detector heads."
17:32
16
17:32
17
safety-critical issue?
17:32
18
A.
17:32
19
17:32
20
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:32
21
Q.
Could you identify this for us quickly, Mr. Webster?
17:32
22
A.
Yes, sir.
17:32
23
BP, I think.
17:33
24
Q.
17:33
25
at, correct?
It's switched off.
It might be sending out secret signals.
Let's try that.

Just like that.
Push the microphone up just an

Try that and see if it works.
Go ahead.
MR. WILLIAMS:
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
Last item on this exhibit would be 3.3.14.
"Gas detection
The maintenance procedure states that cause and
Is that, in your opinion as a marine safety expert, a
Gas detection, yes, one of the most important.

MR. WILLIAMS:
TREX-4680, please.
It's a Deepwater Horizon technical rig audit by
Mr. Norman Wong's name is at the bottom.
Same thing, just -- very similar to what we just looked
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3819
17:33
A.
Yes.
17:33
Q.
If we go to the next page in the audit report, "Action
17:33
Sheet" --
17:33
17:33
Let's see if I can't move a little more quickly.
17:33
Reference 2.2.10 on the audit action sheet.
17:33
Thanks, Carl.
17:33
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:33
Q.
17:33
10
deadline anchor consisted of cut and paste of the maintenance
17:33
11
procedure.
17:34
12
therefore not possible to determine what work was actually
17:34
13
performed or indeed if the intent of the maintenance procedure
17:34
14
was met."
17:34
15
17:34
16
Mr. Webster, is that a violation of the International Safety
17:34
17
Management Code?
17:34
18
A.
It is, yes.
17:34
19
Q.
Why is that?
17:34
20
A.
Well, again, not carrying out planned maintenance, not
17:34
21
carrying out the maintenance in a timely fashion.
17:34
22
17:34
23
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:34
24
Q.
17:34
25
of the specified maintenance tasks listed in the procedure had
MR. WILLIAMS:
Skip that one and go to the next.

This would be
"Maintenance notes for the five-year overhaul of the
No additional comments were added.
It was
Is that a violation -- in your expert opinion,
MR. WILLIAMS:
Go to 2.3.1, please.
"Maintenance work orders were closed out even though all
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3820
17:34
not been completed."
17:34
17:34
incomplete maintenance work orders must cease immediately.
17:34
Transocean is to issue an instruction to maintenance
17:34
personnel."
17:34
"Advised completion:
17:35
Is that a violation of the ISM Code, Mr. Webster?
17:35
A.
Yes, sir, it is.
17:35
Q.
You can't fix something which you don't know is broken; is
17:35
10
that correct?
17:35
11
A.
That is correct.
17:35
12
Q.
Isn't it a fact that on vessels that are this complicated
17:35
13
with so much going on, so many complicated systems, that from a
17:35
14
safety standpoint, it is essential that every maintenance
17:35
15
task -- all maintenance performed and all maintenance required
17:35
16
should be kept track of meticulously?
17:35
17
A.
17:35
18
17:35
19
17:35
20
MR. WILLIAMS:
17:35
21
THE COURT:
17:35
22
17:35
23
THE WITNESS:
17:35
24
THE COURT:
17:35
25
MR. WILLIAMS:
The recommendation is that "The practice of closing
Immediately."
Absolutely.
MR. KINCHEN:
Your Honor.
Brian Kinchen for Transocean,
Objection, leading.
I thought I said in his opinion.
Overruled.
Did you answer that, sir?

I did, sir.
I'm sorry.
I just missed your answer.

I want to make sure your answer is on
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3821
17:35
the record.
17:35
17:35
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:35
Q.
17:36
performing any tasks."
17:36
17:36
read something like that?
17:36
A.
It's shocking.
17:36
Q.
Why is it shocking?
17:36
10
A.
Well, because they are not doing the maintenance and they
17:36
11
are trying to hide the fact.
17:36
12
and more problems, more and more breakdowns, putting the rig at
17:36
13
risk.
17:36
14
Q.
17:36
15
expert that if an item needs maintenance and it is entered into
17:36
16
the EMPAC or the RMS system showing that it requires
17:36
17
maintenance and that maintenance isn't done but the maintenance
17:36
18
work order is closed out anyway, what -- how would you
17:36
19
characterize that practice, that behavior?
17:36
20
A.
17:37
21
going to do is cause the piece of equipment to fail
17:37
22
prematurely, I would think.
17:37
23
top drive, which is one of the most critical items on the rig.
17:37
24
17:37
25
THE WITNESS:
2.3.2.
Yes.
"Maintenance work orders were closed out without
What does that mean to you, Mr. Webster, when you
It's just going to lead to more
Isn't it true -- or is it your opinion as a marine safety
Shocking.
Very, very bad practice.
THE WITNESS:
Your Honor, to drill.
I mean, what it's
I mean, this is talking about the
The top drive is actually used,

It takes the drill string.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3822
17:37
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:37
Q.
17:37
quickly, does that set forth a similar issue?
17:37
A.
17:37
17:37
3.3.1.
17:37
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:37
Q.
17:37
shack; is that right?
17:37
10
A.
Yes.
17:37
11
Q.
"The driller's cabin fire and gas panel had numerous alarm
17:37
12
conditions displayed.
17:37
13
ESD active, fault fire and gas active, and fire and gas
17:38
14
override active.
17:38
15
were unaware of the fault conditions."
17:38
16
17:38
17
you characterize that finding?
17:38
18
A.
I would say that's shocking.
17:38
19
Q.
Does it indicate to you that there is a lack of training
17:38
20
of the drill crew in the function of the ESD system?
17:38
21
A.
17:38
22
unaware of the fault conditions, that's unbelievable.
17:38
23
Q.
17:38
24
trained on the system or if they don't know what they are
17:38
25
looking at, it's not their fault, is it?
I won't read it; but 2.3.3, if you'll look at it real
Yes.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Now, let's go to the next page, Carl,
This says that "The driller's cabin" -- that's the drill
These included fire alarm active, fault
The driller and assistant driller on tour
In your opinion as a marine safety expert, how would
Absolutely.
If the driller and assistant driller were
You can't necessarily blame them if they have never been
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3823
17:38
A.
Well, it's not their fault, but they should know.
17:38
Q.
Sir, is it your opinion that it's the company's
17:39
responsibility to make sure that they know?
17:39
A.
17:39
17:39
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:39
Q.
17:39
rooms and other machinery spaces found nonoperational during
17:39
testing.
17:39
10
17:39
11
17:39
12
A.
I don't recall.
17:39
13
Q.
"Fire Damper 109 in way of Engine Room No. 1, Engine No. 1
17:39
14
exhaust damper . . . A list containing numerous other defective
17:39
15
dampers was also cited."
17:40
16
17:40
17
made operational and maintenance frequency increased to ensure
17:40
18
availability and improve reliability."
17:40
19
17:40
20
damper issue, is it?
17:40
21
A.
No, we have seen it several times now.
17:40
22
Q.
Over a period of several years now, correct?
17:40
23
A.
That is correct.
17:40
24
17:40
25
Well, it is.
Yes, they should be trained, fully trained.
MR. WILLIAMS:
Again:
Next page, Carl, 1.4.1.
"Significant number of fire dampers in the engine
Examples include Engine Room No. 2, supply damper,
Fire Damper 41 in HPU room."

What is the HPU room?
Do you have any idea?
The recommendation is that "All fire dampers to be
This isn't the first time we have seen the fire
MR. WILLIAMS:
Now, let's go to Reference 1.4.5,
Carl, please.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3824
17:40
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:40
Q.
17:40
process to inform the BP well site leader of overdue critical
17:40
maintenance or defective equipment.
17:40
site leader was unaware of marine-related equipment defects."
17:41
The recommendation is that Transocean -- again, and
17:41
this isn't the first time we have seen this issue, is it?
17:41
A.
No, it is not.
17:41
Q.
The recommendation is that the monthly maintenance report
17:41
10
be used as a method for formally reporting overdue critical
17:41
11
maintenance and defective equipment to the BP well site leader.
17:41
12
17:41
13
and Well Operations Policy?
17:41
14
A.
It does, yes.
17:41
15
Q.
Known as the DWOP?
17:41
16
A.
Yes.
17:41
17
Q.
The audit team advised completion within one month.
17:41
18
17:41
19
they would accept that recommendation or change?
17:41
20
A.
17:41
21
17:41
22
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:41
23
Q.
17:42
24
accordance with the maintenance procedures.
17:42
25
procedure states that cause and effect outputs to be tested and
In this observation, it's stated that "There was no formal
Consequently, the well
And BP, in its recommendation, cites the BP Drilling
What was the response of Transocean as to whether
They rejected it.

MR. WILLIAMS:
3.3.14, please.
"The gas detection system is not being tested in
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
The maintenance
3825
17:42
verified."
17:42
17:42
A.
No, sir, it's not.
17:42
Q.
The cause and effect outputs are a function of the
17:42
automatic operation of the emergency shutdown system, are they
17:42
not?
17:42
A.
They are.
17:42
Q.
This observation -- if it's true -- does it constitute a
17:42
violation of the International Safety Management Code?
17:42
10
A.
17:42
11
you that the alarms on the bridge not be inhibited.
17:42
12
Q.
I was going to get to that.
17:43
13
A.
I'm sorry.
I went ahead of you.
17:43
14
Q.
It's okay.
Let's go ahead and talk about it.
17:43
15
A.
I thought you had missed it.
17:43
16
Q.
It's gone on a long time, I know.
17:43
17
17:43
18
we see that the asset -- i.e, that would be Transocean,
17:43
19
correct?
17:43
20
A.
Correct.
17:43
21
Q.
The Deepwater Horizon --
17:43
22
A.
Yes.
17:43
23
Q.
-- management?
17:43
24
A.
Yes.
17:43
25
Q.
"Rejected alarms on bridge, but inhibited to prevent
Is this the first time we have seen this issue?
Yes, it definitely is.
It also -- they also suggest to
Where the asset accepts the recommendation or change,
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3826
17:43
general alarm."
17:43
17:43
make -- from a safety standpoint, does that make any sense at
17:43
all?
17:43
A.
17:43
a timeout period, and I believe it's about two minutes.
17:43
Q.
17:43
timeout period before the general alarm sounds, correct?
17:44
A.
17:44
10
bridge or in the engine room and the lights can flash, and then
17:44
11
it can take two minutes -- or it could be just set on the IACS
17:44
12
to whatever period that the company or the crew want, that it
17:44
13
will ring the general alarm.
17:44
14
Q.
17:44
15
the bridge crew, the DPOs, or whoever is manning the IACS or
17:44
16
monitoring it, time to investigate and determine, through the
17:44
17
system and perhaps the telephone, whether or not the emergency
17:44
18
is of a nature that the general alarm should be sounded?
17:44
19
A.
Right.
17:44
20
Q.
If it's determined that a false alarm -- it is a false
17:44
21
alarm, can they just override the general alarm or neutralize
17:44
22
it at that point?
17:44
23
A.
Yes.
17:45
24
Q.
TREX-01768, please.
17:45
25
quickly?
In your opinion as a marine safety expert, does that
No.
I believe the general alarm should be automatic after
You say a "timeout period."
That's correct.
The IACS has a built-in
Well, the general alarm can sound on the
Is the purpose for that delay to give the crew on watch,
And to see if it's a false alarm.
Would you identify this for us
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3827
17:45
A.
This is a DNV survey report for the company, again, and
17:45
it's in September 16, 2009.
17:45
extension on the DOC compliance.
17:45
Q.
What is the DOC compliance?
17:45
A.
Document of compliance.
17:45
operate and to ensure they are following the ISM Code.
17:45
17:45
17:46
17:46
10
page, Carl.
17:46
11
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:46
12
Q.
17:46
13
Given," correct?
17:46
14
A.
Yes.
17:46
15
Q.
It says:
17:46
16
April 2008 on the Transocean driller operating offshore Brazil,
17:46
17
and eight nonconformities and two observations were issued
17:46
18
based on deficiencies with the safety management system
17:46
19
operating onboard and local coastal state requirements.
17:46
20
nonconformities were deleted based on the corrective action
17:46
21
plan proposed with the proviso that the effectiveness of the
17:46
22
corrective action implemented would be verified during the next
17:47
23
audit.
17:47
24
deficiency tracking system within Transocean, indicating that
17:47
25
it had been successfully implemented.
MR. WILLIAMS:
It's actually a short-term
That's allowing the company to
Can we go to the page -- next page,
page 2 of 3.
Before we do that, could you just show the whole
There we go.
These are "Nonconformities, Condition, and Memoranda
"An external ISM audit was carried out on
The
The corrective action was closed in the Focus
The flag state requested
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3828
17:47
that a follow-up audit be carried out by DNV, and during this
17:47
audit, carried out in March 2009, it was discovered that the
17:47
corrective action had not been implemented as reported.
17:47
major nonconformity was then issued and a further corrective
17:47
action plan was proposed.
17:47
downgraded to a nonconformity.
17:47
"Within Transocean, a procedure exists for
17:47
implementation of corrective action and a deficiency tracking
17:47
system exists.
17:47
10
17:47
11
17:47
12
A.
You did.
17:47
13
Q.
Now, we have seen that -- we have the same issue going on
17:48
14
and has been going on in the Deepwater Horizon during the past
17:48
15
several years, correct?
17:48
16
A.
Correct.
17:48
17
Q.
But this is an audit of Transocean Offshore Deepwater
17:48
18
Drilling Company, correct?
17:48
19
A.
It is.
17:48
20
Q.
In your opinion, is the same or similar practice with
17:48
21
respect to tracking issues, correcting them or not correcting
17:48
22
them, and then deleting them from the system going on in
17:48
23
Transocean corporate as it is or has been on the
17:48
24
Deepwater Horizon?
17:48
25
A.
The major nonconformity was then
However, currently, there is no means to verify
that corrective action has been implemented as reported."

Yes.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3829
17:48
Q.
That's a violation of the International Safety Management
17:48
Code?
17:48
A.
17:48
Chapter 1.2.3.1, which is "Compliance With Mandatory
17:48
Requirements, Laws and Regulations."
17:48
Q.
17:49
is to protect lives and the environment.
17:49
statement?
17:49
A.
Yes, absolutely.
17:49
10
Q.
TREX-013272.
17:49
11
to various folks at Transocean; is that correct?
17:49
12
A.
Yes, the OIM, Paul Johnson.
17:49
13
Q.
The Deepwater Horizon maintenance supervisor, apparently?
17:49
14
A.
Yes.
17:49
15
Q.
Various people in Houston, James Kent?
17:49
16
A.
Yes.
17:49
17
Q.
Mr. Cocales is writing them about audit inspection
17:50
18
findings from a 2009 audit done on the Deepwater Horizon that
17:50
19
we'll talk about shortly, isn't he?
17:50
20
A.
Yes.
17:50
21
Q.
In this e-mail, he summarizes the marine inspection
17:50
22
findings, does he not?
17:50
23
A.
He does, yes.
17:50
24
Q.
Let's just start --
17:50
25
This is a very serious one because it goes to
Mr. Webster, the ISM -- the whole purpose of the ISM Code
Is that a fair
This is an e-mail from Brett Cocales at BP
THE COURT:
Excuse me one second.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3830
17:50
MR. WILLIAMS:
Sure.
17:50
THE COURT:
17:50
17:50
MR. WILLIAMS:
17:50
THE COURT:
17:50
17:50
MR. WILLIAMS:
17:50
THE WITNESS:
17:50
MR. WILLIAMS:
17:51
10
it, instead of naming the OIMs -- since they rotate on and
17:51
11
off -- by name, the address to the OIM on the Deepwater Horizon
17:51
12
is "OIM (Deepwater Horizon)," and the next addressee is
17:51
13
"Johnson, Paul" in Houston.
17:51
14
17:51
15
17:51
16
MR. WILLIAMS:
17:51
17
THE COURT:
17:51
18
MR. WILLIAMS:
17:51
19
THE COURT:
17:51
20
designated -- DPA, designated person ashore, is that the same
17:51
21
as the rig manager, or is that someone else you are talking
17:51
22
about?
17:51
23
17:51
24
Your Honor, was Gerald Canducci -- I'm sorry, not at this time.
17:51
25
It was Mr. Moore.
I'm looking at -- the witness referred to
Paul Johnson as the OIM.
Is he the OIM?
No, he's not, Your Honor.
I'm getting confused with the names now
because I thought he was the rig manager on shore.
THE COURT:
He is.
Yes, I'm sorry.
Instead of naming -- as I understand
I remember from previous testimony
Mr. Johnson was the rig manager on shore.

Correct.
Not a person who worked on the rig?

No, he's not.
When you referred earlier to
THE WITNESS:
No, totally different.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
The DPA ashore
3831
17:51
THE COURT:
He would be above Mr. Johnson --
17:51
THE WITNESS:
17:51
THE COURT:
17:51
THE WITNESS:
17:51
BY MR. WILLIAMS:
17:51
Q.
17:52
some of them.
17:52
The first one:
17:52
accordance with SOLAS requirements?
17:52
10
SOLAS is what again, sir?
17:52
11
A.
"Safety of Life at Sea."
17:52
12
Q.
Is that part of ISM, or is ISM part of it?
17:52
13
A.
ISM is part of SOLAS.
17:52
14
Maritime Organization, and SOLAS requires the ISM to be carried
17:52
15
out.
17:52
16
Q.
17:52
17
for that is "No," correct?
17:52
18
A.
Yes.
17:52
19
Q.
Is failure to have emergency drills in accordance with
17:52
20
SOLAS a violation of the law?
17:52
21
A.
Yes.
17:52
22
Q.
In your opinion as a marine safety expert, does it put the
17:52
23
crew at risk of death or personal injury?
17:52
24
A.
Yes, sir, it does.
17:52
25
Q.
"Are measures in place to effectively isolate ventilation
Yes.
-- in your understanding?
Absolutely.
"Summary of Marine Inspection Findings."
Let's touch on
Are emergency drills held in
It's enacted by the International
There's a column there that says "Pass," and the response
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3832
17:53
to enclosed spaces, i.e., machinery spaces,
17:53
accommodation/quarters, galley, storerooms, etc.?
17:53
"Pass?
17:53
Is that a violation of the ISM Code?
17:53
A.
Yes.
17:53
Q.
The next one, 11.8:
17:53
decks satisfactory?"
17:53
The answer is "No."
17:53
Is that a violation of the law, the ISM Code?
17:53
10
A.
Yes.
17:53
11
Q.
Does it put the crew at increased risk of personal injury
17:53
12
or death?
17:53
13
A.
Yes, it does.
17:53
14
Q.
As a mariner, ex-mariner, Mr. Webster, what is the most
17:53
15
frightening problem a mariner has to deal with at sea?
17:53
16
A.
Fire.
17:53
17
Q.
The next one, 13.3:
17:53
18
watertight doors and portholes, in good condition and capable
17:53
19
of being properly secured?"
17:54
20
17:54
21
A.
No, it didn't.
17:54
22
Q.
Is that a violation of the ISM Code?
17:54
23
A.
Not only that, a violation of the class requirements,
17:54
24
violation of the watertight integrity of the vessel.
17:54
25
Q.
No."
That's a violation of SOLAS.

"Is fire integrity of bulkheads and
"Are all deck openings, including
Did it pass?
15.7, the next one:
"Is the bilge system operational?"
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3833
17:54
Did it pass?
17:54
A.
No.
17:54
Q.
5.4:
17:54
nonconformances to the operator?"
17:54
Did it pass?
17:54
A.
No.
17:54
Q.
"Is there evidence of full compliance with the company's
17:54
HSE management system?"
17:54
17:54
10
A.
17:54
11
under the ISM Code.
17:54
12
Q.
17:54
13
17:55
14
17:55
15
17:55
16
A.
No.
17:55
17
Q.
"Is all firefighting equipment available for use and
17:55
18
defect free?"
17:55
19
A.
No.
17:55
20
Q.
"Are fixed fire and gas detection systems fully
17:55
21
operational and tested regularly?"
17:55
22
A.
No.
17:55
23
Q.
Is this a violation of the ISM Code?
17:55
24
A.
Yes, and SOLAS.
17:55
25
Q.
Does the fact of that violation put the crew of that
"Is there a system in place for reporting
Did it pass?
No.
And both of those items are major nonconformities
The next page, please.

"Does the vessel operator have a competency
assessment process?"
Did it pass?
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3834
17:55
vessel at an increased risk of personal injury or death, in
17:55
your opinion as a marine safety expert?
17:55
A.
Yes, sir, it does.
17:55
Q.
14.8:
17:55
communications, and navigation equipment as listed in SOLAS
17:55
available for use and free from defects?"
17:55
17:55
A.
No, it didn't.
17:55
Q.
What are the implications, in your opinion as an expert,
17:55
10
of that failure?
17:56
11
A.
17:56
12
there's a problem on board, especially the communications, they
17:56
13
may have trouble calling for a mayday or communicating with
17:56
14
other vessels or the Coast Guard, a serious problem.
17:56
15
MR. WILLIAMS:
17:56
16
This next section is --
17:56
17
17:56
18
going to shut down in a couple minutes.
17:56
19
point?
17:56
20
17:56
21
17:56
22
17:56
23
17:56
24
MR. WILLIAMS:
17:56
25
THE COURT:
"Is the standard equipment, including bridge,
Did it pass?
Well, that goes to the safety of the vessel.
THE COURT:
And if
Judge, do you want me to continue?
Are you moving to something else?
MR. WILLIAMS:
We are
Are you at a stopping
I'm almost at a stopping point, but
it's going to -- I've still got a -THE COURT:
It's going to take more than five
minutes?
Yes, sir.
All right.
We would just as soon stop
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
3835
17:56
now.
It's just about 6:00.
17:56
We will recess until 8:00 a.m. tomorrow morning.
17:56
Before we do that, let's talk about -- wait.
17:56
Before everybody gets up and moves, I want to talk about
17:56
witnesses following Mr. Webster.
17:56
17:57
any additional live witnesses other than Mr. Quirk, who will be
17:57
next Tuesday.
17:57
17:57
10
17:57
11
17:57
12
17:57
13
17:57
14
17:57
15
MR. UNDERHILL:
17:57
16
THE COURT:
17:57
17
MR. MAZE:
No, Your Honor.
17:57
18
THE COURT:
Or Louisiana?
17:57
19
MR. KANNER:
17:57
20
THE COURT:
17:57
21
17:57
22
MR. BRIAN:
That's correct, Your Honor.
17:57
23
THE COURT:
I think you-all sent a list around of
17:57
24
17:57
25
My understanding is that the PSC does not have
Is that correct?
MR. ROY:
That's correct, Your Honor.
We do have
some housekeeping matters that we -THE COURT:
Yes, I understand that.
I understand
that.
Then will the United States have any additional
live witnesses, Mr. Underhill?
Negative.
Alabama?
No, Your Honor.

So then we'll move to Transocean after
Mr. Webster, correct?
your proposed lineup?

MR. BRIAN:
We did, Your Honor.
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
And I anticipate --
3836
17:57
and we will start with Calvin Barnhill.
17:57
based on how long I project that Mr. Webster will go, that that
17:57
will probably take up tomorrow.
17:57
17:57
17:58
(Proceedings adjourned.)
17:58
* * *
CERTIFICATE
THE COURT:
And I anticipate,
Everyone have a good night, and we'll see
you at 8:00 a.m. in the morning.
I, Toni Doyle Tusa, CCR, FCRR, Official Court
10
Reporter for the United States District Court, Eastern District
11
of Louisiana, do hereby certify that the foregoing is a true
12
and correct transcript, to the best of my ability and
13
understanding, from the record of the proceedings in the
14
above-entitled matter.
15
16
17
18
s/ Toni Doyle Tusa

Toni Doyle Tusa, CCR, FCRR
Official Court Reporter
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
OFFICIAL TRANSCRIPT
$
$40 [1] 3730/14
$40 million [1] 3730/14
'
'78 [1] 3730/14
'97 [1] 3731/17
'97/'98 [1] 3731/17
'98 [1] 3731/17
'I'm [1] 3687/9
'just [1] 3687/15
'Look [3] 3686/23 3687/19 3688/18
.
.3 [2] 3742/4 3746/8
.4 [1] 3746/10
.5 [1] 3746/11
0
01 [1] 3785/11
013272 [1] 3829/10
01765 [1] 3797/6
01766 [1] 3800/22
01768 [1] 3826/24
01778 [1] 3808/22
02771 [1] 3655/7
1
1.1 [1] 3788/20
1.1.10 [1] 3741/6
1.1.9 [2] 3740/4 3740/7
1.2 [1] 3741/15
1.2.1 [1] 3741/16
1.2.2 [1] 3741/23
1.2.3.1 [1] 3829/4
1.4 [3] 3668/10 3743/1 3789/8
1.4.1 [2] 3815/7 3823/5
1.4.5 [2] 3815/17 3823/24
10 [7] 3701/8 3703/4 3703/16 3722/14
3753/8 3754/17 3775/4
10 minutes [4] 3678/13 3678/21 3722/18
3722/20
10 years [1] 3718/17
10-CV-02771 [1] 3655/7
10-CV-4536 [1] 3655/9
10-MD-2179 [1] 3655/4
10-minute [1] 3694/1
10.1 [1] 3753/10
10.2 [1] 3799/1
10.2.1 [1] 3809/17
10.3 [1] 3754/6
100 [2] 3656/16 3806/21
100 psi [3] 3680/4 3685/8 3686/17
100-psi [4] 3680/6 3680/13 3680/22
3685/5
1000 [2] 3659/17 3660/16
1001 [1] 3659/10
101 [1] 3656/19
104 [1] 3685/12
105 [2] 3685/12 3704/16
106 [1] 3704/16
109 [1] 3823/13
11 [5] 3655/14 3712/17 3782/21 3803/25
3806/10
11.1 [1] 3782/23
11.1.1 [1] 3782/23
11.8 [1] 3832/6
1100 [1] 3659/6
1109 [1] 3756/2
1110 [1] 3659/20
1192 [1] 3793/3
11:00 [1] 3666/14
12 [4] 3674/25 3728/16 3737/8 3787/16

12.1 [1] 3808/1
1201 [2] 3659/3 3660/9
1221 [1] 3660/5
13 [4] 3655/7 3662/2 3777/1 3790/15
13.3 [1] 3832/17
1308 [1] 3656/22
1331 [1] 3660/12
14 [3] 3685/13 3697/6 3737/8
14.8 [1] 3834/4
14271 [1] 3657/25
15 [7] 3702/5 3703/16 3722/14 3789/18
3789/18 3803/25 3809/4
15 minutes [1] 3664/22
15 yards [2] 3703/6 3703/12
15-minute [1] 3768/5
15-minutes [1] 3801/16
15.7 [1] 3832/25
150 [4] 3675/16 3675/17 3676/1 3676/13
16 [2] 3756/3 3827/2
1601 [1] 3656/3
1665 [1] 3660/12
17 [3] 3732/19 3790/14 3793/7
1700 [1] 3660/9
1764 [1] 3784/5
1765 [1] 3801/8
1777 [1] 3785/11
18 [1] 3777/12
1885 [1] 3658/12
1982 [3] 3730/10 3730/20 3730/23
1992 [1] 3734/7
1997 [1] 3731/13
2
2-27-12 [1] 3728/16
2.2 [1] 3793/8
2.2.10 [1] 3819/6
2.3.1 [1] 3819/22
2.3.2 [1] 3821/4
2.3.3 [1] 3822/2
2.3.5 [1] 3816/17
2.32 [2] 3794/16 3816/5
20 [25] 3655/5 3664/7 3664/17 3670/22
3671/25 3672/20 3674/9 3674/18 3675/2
3677/1 3680/11 3685/21 3701/1 3702/5
3704/16 3704/16 3706/12 3707/21
3715/11 3720/18 3728/7 3737/24
3744/21 3747/19 3815/17
20 barrels [3] 3718/20 3719/8 3719/17
20 percent [2] 3792/11 3792/14
20-inch [1] 3717/18
20/21 [1] 3797/12
200 [2] 3675/16 3675/17
2000 [2] 3768/17 3772/3
20004 [2] 3657/25 3659/4
2001 [3] 3772/16 3773/18 3778/22
2002 [4] 3774/24 3777/12 3780/4 3780/6
2003 [1] 3798/23
20044 [2] 3657/20 3658/6
2005 [11] 3781/2 3782/19 3783/3 3783/9
3783/13 3786/1 3787/6 3790/14 3790/23
3793/7 3795/24
2006 [2] 3797/12 3798/5
2007 [6] 3790/20 3801/5 3803/25 3809/4
3809/4 3810/9
2008 [2] 3790/20 3827/16
2009 [4] 3790/21 3827/2 3828/2 3829/18
2010 [11] 3655/5 3671/25 3674/9
3712/17 3715/11 3720/18 3737/24
3744/22 3747/19 3790/21 3790/24
2011 [2] 3689/10 3728/3
2012 [2] 3728/6 3728/7
2013 [2] 3655/7 3662/2
2050 [2] 3691/19 3692/25

20th [3] 3691/23 3694/21 3704/2
21 [2] 3797/12 3797/12
2100 [3] 3690/25 3693/1 3693/25
2101 [5] 3681/3 3682/4 3682/7 3682/20
3704/3
2105 [1] 3719/22
2108 [12] 3681/3 3682/4 3682/7 3682/20
3688/5 3688/11 3688/24 3704/3 3704/3
3723/21 3724/2 3724/9
2109 [1] 3724/9
2110 [1] 3694/1
2114 [4] 3688/5 3688/11 3688/24 3704/3
2120 [1] 3676/7
2130 [3] 3720/1 3720/2 3720/18
2131 [1] 3683/21
2135 [3] 3720/1 3720/4 3720/18
2179 [1] 3655/4
21st [1] 3669/24
22 [3] 3679/13 3801/5 3801/17
2211 [1] 3659/20
2216 [1] 3657/9
2224 [1] 3695/2
22700 [1] 3729/7
22983 [1] 3698/22
22nd [1] 3656/10
23 [1] 3816/5
23451 [1] 3656/10
24 hours [3] 3749/11 3750/5 3752/14
246 psi [1] 3681/9
250 psi [2] 3689/7 3689/12
250-psi [5] 3681/24 3682/24 3688/3
3688/10 3689/18
26 [1] 3772/16
2615 [1] 3656/6
271 [1] 3674/25
29 [1] 3786/1
3
3.0 [1] 3783/14
3.3.1 [1] 3822/6
3.3.11 [1] 3817/7
3.3.14 [2] 3818/10 3824/21
3.9 [1] 3807/5
30 [2] 3787/6 3795/24
30 days [1] 3817/8
30 seconds [2] 3776/8 3776/12
300 [1] 3658/23
300-barrel [6] 3683/20 3683/25 3684/3
3684/4 3684/16 3684/18
3089 [1] 3659/17
31 [3] 3790/14 3793/7 3817/7
3134 [1] 3774/19
3185 [1] 3698/18
3288 [1] 3795/18
33 [1] 3811/13
3403 [1] 3803/18
3404 [1] 3810/6
35 [1] 3802/4
355 [1] 3659/14
35th [1] 3659/14
36028 [1] 3657/13
36130 [1] 3658/10
364 [1] 3791/22
36604 [1] 3656/4
3668 [1] 3655/20
37 [1] 3768/23
3700 [2] 3659/6 3659/10
38 [1] 3770/11
4
4.8 [1] 3775/1
4.9 [1] 3776/17
3762/25 3794/3
aboard [1] 3742/5
40 [1] 3771/4
7-5395 [1] 3657/13
about [129] 3662/21 3664/13 3664/21
40 percent [1] 3792/14
701 [2] 3658/16 3658/19
3666/8 3667/1 3668/15 3668/23 3669/7
40 years [1] 3733/24
70113 [1] 3655/24
3669/12 3669/18 3669/21 3670/18
4000 [1] 3660/16
70130 [6] 3656/7 3656/13 3657/10
3671/8 3672/6 3674/1 3674/5 3674/21
402 [1] 3656/10
3658/17 3659/24 3660/19
3675/7 3676/22 3676/24 3676/25
406 [1] 3660/19
70139 [1] 3658/20
3677/11 3677/15 3678/13 3681/23
41 [1] 3823/10
70163 [1] 3659/7
3682/14 3682/17 3684/10 3685/20
4275 [3] 3768/9 3768/15 3770/11
70360 [1] 3656/20
3690/25 3691/3 3693/24 3694/15
4310 [1] 3657/6
70458 [1] 3656/23
3698/15 3698/23 3699/21 3702/5
43465 [1] 3773/20
70501 [1] 3659/18
3702/12 3702/16 3703/4 3703/7 3704/14
435 [1] 3656/19
70502 [1] 3655/21
3706/4 3707/10 3708/7 3711/4 3712/25
4388 [4] 3690/8 3694/24 3723/13
70801 [1] 3657/4
3713/4 3715/14 3716/3 3716/6 3716/8
3723/15
70804 [1] 3658/13
3716/17 3718/4 3718/6 3718/15 3718/15
4395 [1] 3712/12
75 [1] 3790/7
3718/23 3718/24 3720/1 3722/2 3722/14
44015 [1] 3787/4
75270 [1] 3660/10
3723/18 3723/21 3723/24 3724/20
44017 [1] 3780/21
7611 [1] 3657/19
3725/2 3725/23 3729/13 3730/10
44032 [1] 3799/15
7672 [1] 3727/21
3731/20 3733/5 3735/8 3737/22 3739/23
44038 [1] 3788/8
7691 [1] 3772/5
3744/9 3747/17 3750/8 3751/1 3758/9
45 [1] 3802/15
77002 [2] 3659/10 3660/17
3760/23 3760/25 3762/11 3762/14
450 [1] 3657/13
77006 [1] 3657/7
3765/3 3765/10 3766/6 3766/14 3767/12
4500 [1] 3660/5
77010 [2] 3660/5 3660/13
3768/3 3768/5 3769/16 3769/17 3770/23
4536 [1] 3655/9
77098 [1] 3659/21
3773/3 3773/22 3773/25 3774/2 3775/8
4680 [1] 3818/19
7778 [1] 3660/20
3775/24 3776/20 3776/22 3777/13
78257 [1] 3656/17
3777/13 3778/12 3786/20 3791/9
5
7:30 [2] 3707/21 3708/6
3791/22 3792/3 3794/17 3796/3 3796/16
5-yearly [2] 3806/3 3811/2
3800/1 3800/2 3800/16 3800/17 3801/20
8
5.1 [1] 3746/6
3805/2 3810/12 3816/6 3821/22 3825/14
5.2 [1] 3779/8
8 degrees [1] 3749/8
3826/6 3829/17 3829/19 3830/22 3835/1
5.4 [1] 3833/3
80 [1] 3783/9
3835/3 3835/4
5.5000 kilowatts [1] 3748/19
81 [1] 3782/14
above [10] 3667/19 3670/7 3675/16
50 [3] 3692/14 3693/1 3806/21
820 [1] 3655/23
3692/14 3748/13 3775/19 3778/25
50 percent [1] 3792/12
8:00 [1] 3835/2
3794/21 3831/1 3836/14
50 yards [1] 3702/16
8:00 a.m [1] 3836/5
above-entitled [1] 3836/14
500 [7] 3655/20 3658/9 3660/19 3798/20 8:10 [1] 3708/2
Abramson [1] 3656/5
3798/21 3798/22 3798/23
8:30 [6] 3678/9 3679/3 3698/23 3707/4 ABS [3] 3731/8 3731/8 3738/23
5000 [1] 3658/19
3707/8 3722/8
absence [1] 3679/10
50361 [1] 3739/20
8:58 [1] 3678/17
absolute [1] 3752/11
504 [1] 3660/20
absolutely [15] 3758/22 3763/23 3765/9
9
5395 [1] 3657/13
3765/23 3767/22 3786/21 3787/3
9.1 [1] 3784/22
546 [1] 3659/23
3787/25 3807/17 3812/13 3813/5
9002 [1] 3736/21
5483 [1] 3777/9
3820/17 3822/21 3829/9 3831/4
90071 [1] 3659/14
550 [1] 3798/19
accept [3] 3707/23 3710/1 3824/19
91382 [1] 3679/12
556 [1] 3655/20
acceptable [3] 3683/25 3795/12 3796/20
930 [1] 3796/7
556 psi [2] 3683/13 3720/7
Acceptance [1] 3773/17
94005 [1] 3658/13
556-psi [2] 3683/17 3720/22
accepted [7] 3735/7 3735/8 3735/11
94102 [1] 3657/14
580 [1] 3798/19
3735/15 3735/18 3735/21 3736/6
96.5 [1] 3811/13
589-7778 [1] 3660/20
accepts [1] 3825/17
967.1.1 [1] 3667/3
5902 [1] 3728/16
access [6] 3662/22 3697/9 3744/1
967.1.2 [1] 3667/10
5:00 and [1] 3664/9
3744/11 3745/10 3779/24
9:00 [3] 3679/8 3691/3 3722/14
5:00 p.m [1] 3674/9
accident [1] 3685/21
9:00 to [1] 3676/19
5:00 to [1] 3672/3
accidentally [2] 3717/23 3718/1
5:30 [4] 3664/9 3665/21 3670/2 3672/3 9:00 when [1] 3698/23
accidents [3] 3751/14 3751/18 3784/25
9:01 [4] 3680/7 3685/5 3685/8 3686/17 accommodation [3] 3759/4 3814/21
6
9:08 [8] 3678/7 3678/17 3680/7 3685/5
3832/2
3685/9 3686/17 3689/12 3704/15
6.5 [1] 3799/11
accommodation/quarters [1] 3832/2
9:14 [2] 3676/19 3689/12
60 [3] 3692/15 3692/16 3692/25
accomplish [1] 3794/2
9:30 [2] 3720/2 3721/3
60 percent [1] 3792/11
accordance [8] 3752/22 3774/7 3774/15
9:30 p.m [1] 3720/2
600 [3] 3656/10 3656/13 3659/17
3799/12 3818/11 3824/24 3831/9
9:35 [2] 3720/4 3721/3
601 [1] 3656/6
3831/19
9:43 [2] 3721/2 3721/11
60654 [1] 3658/24
according [2] 3676/4 3720/8
9th [1] 3656/13
611.006 [1] 3714/19
accurately [4] 3669/8 3669/18 3671/23
6164 [1] 3773/15
3673/17
A
618 [1] 3657/3
acoustic [2] 3775/11 3775/16
a.m [3] 3669/24 3835/2 3836/5
620 [1] 3725/17
Act [1] 3795/17
ability [8] 3669/7 3669/18 3674/10
65 [3] 3692/15 3692/16 3692/25
acted [1] 3731/22
3698/5 3757/20 3762/16 3763/21
6:00 [2] 3665/21 3835/1
acting [1] 3745/11
3836/12
6:00 a.m [1] 3669/24
action [17] 3741/10 3751/22 3761/14
able [19] 3663/10 3671/19 3671/20
6:00 and [1] 3669/23
3779/23 3786/11 3800/5 3800/10 3815/2
3671/23 3673/7 3673/9 3673/13 3673/17 3819/2 3819/6 3827/20 3827/22 3827/23
6:00 in [1] 3670/19
3673/21 3673/23 3674/15 3677/23
6:00 until [1] 3670/10
3828/3 3828/5 3828/8 3828/10
3678/11 3696/25 3697/1 3698/9 3714/3 actions [6] 3761/2 3767/9 3771/12
A
actions... [3] 3771/15 3776/9 3809/13
activate [1] 3763/4
activation [1] 3762/4
active [9] 3663/13 3706/13 3707/6
3725/6 3771/13 3822/12 3822/13
3822/13 3822/14
activities [18] 3664/18 3664/19 3666/11
3668/20 3669/13 3674/1 3674/8 3674/13
3674/17 3674/18 3674/22 3675/1 3675/3
3715/13 3779/3 3810/19 3810/23
3810/25
activity [5] 3663/3 3667/18 3668/3
3672/21 3704/15
acts [1] 3763/15
actual [4] 3720/15 3749/6 3775/23
3776/5
actually [25] 3664/1 3697/23 3698/17
3701/4 3702/2 3724/2 3729/5 3734/6
3734/22 3739/16 3740/18 3742/15
3748/23 3749/19 3756/12 3763/11
3766/14 3767/5 3784/11 3797/14
3797/17 3801/18 3819/12 3821/24
3827/2
actuate [1] 3763/8
actuates [1] 3763/6
actuators [1] 3814/13
added [1] 3819/11
addition [3] 3708/19 3748/2 3806/24
additional [4] 3753/13 3819/11 3835/7
3835/13
address [5] 3737/8 3737/9 3737/10
3761/12 3830/11
addressed [3] 3772/19 3776/10 3816/3
addressee [1] 3830/12
addresses [1] 3799/7
adequate [1] 3744/5
adequately [1] 3671/21
adjourned [1] 3836/6
admit [2] 3662/7 3729/3
admitted [1] 3662/10
adopts [1] 3811/11
Adrian [1] 3798/4
advised [5] 3733/13 3815/14 3816/14
3820/6 3824/17
affect [1] 3811/16
affecting [1] 3778/4
affects [1] 3694/22
affirmative [1] 3752/4
Africa [1] 3730/13
aft [1] 3805/16
after [25] 3668/16 3668/19 3682/6
3682/9 3693/18 3693/20 3696/25 3698/3
3698/9 3700/5 3703/15 3721/5 3721/8
3724/1 3724/4 3747/11 3752/21 3784/15
3791/5 3791/18 3801/6 3810/24 3815/3
3826/5 3835/20
afternoon [9] 3655/14 3662/1 3662/19
3664/17 3674/17 3674/22 3675/2
3729/11 3729/12
again [26] 3675/11 3677/24 3682/18
3683/7 3684/2 3698/19 3709/13 3718/22
3739/7 3739/10 3752/5 3758/10 3758/10
3758/10 3766/5 3773/3 3798/5 3802/25
3808/4 3811/20 3815/7 3819/20 3823/7
3824/6 3827/1 3831/10
against [1] 3742/3
age [1] 3803/6
ago [6] 3689/17 3718/17 3723/15
3750/25 3762/16 3801/8
agree [6] 3680/6 3680/9 3769/22 3770/3
3791/12 3812/8
agreeing [2] 3709/7 3709/7

ahead [15] 3714/2 3716/12 3717/1
3717/6 3717/15 3719/20 3729/9 3736/6
3742/24 3810/23 3817/7 3817/19 3818/7
3825/13 3825/14
aided [1] 3660/25
aimed [1] 3754/10
air [10] 3758/15 3758/16 3760/3 3760/9
3762/13 3762/23 3763/9 3763/11
3763/22 3812/22
airflow [1] 3758/18
al [2] 3655/8 3655/11
Alabama [5] 3656/4 3658/7 3658/8
3658/10 3835/16
alarm [30] 3675/16 3676/2 3676/3
3676/11 3676/14 3676/18 3707/6 3708/7
3755/15 3755/25 3756/10 3756/18
3756/21 3757/19 3792/14 3792/22
3793/1 3812/25 3822/11 3822/12 3826/1
3826/5 3826/8 3826/9 3826/13 3826/18
3826/19 3826/20 3826/21 3826/21
alarm/shutdown [1] 3812/25
alarms [12] 3675/12 3755/23 3755/24
3756/18 3756/18 3759/25 3760/1 3760/1
3766/4 3774/10 3825/11 3825/25
alerts [2] 3749/12 3749/13
ALEX [2] 3660/4 3662/4
alia [1] 3741/24
all [109] 3662/13 3663/16 3670/25
3671/24 3672/3 3673/18 3677/25
3680/21 3682/5 3682/10 3686/14 3689/7
3690/6 3692/24 3698/13 3699/20
3704/24 3705/14 3705/20 3706/24
3709/4 3709/25 3710/13 3710/25
3711/24 3712/13 3713/25 3714/4 3714/5
3714/18 3715/6 3715/9 3715/14 3716/7
3721/5 3721/6 3721/14 3721/15 3722/23
3722/24 3723/4 3726/5 3730/19 3735/1
3736/14 3737/4 3739/9 3741/21 3742/3
3742/12 3742/13 3742/21 3742/21
3742/22 3742/23 3746/21 3753/22
3755/8 3755/12 3755/17 3756/23
3759/18 3760/5 3763/21 3763/24 3764/3
3764/6 3765/5 3768/6 3769/6 3770/3
3772/1 3774/9 3776/13 3776/13 3777/5
3778/3 3779/3 3779/9 3781/16 3782/3
3783/19 3783/24 3787/16 3790/18
3790/25 3791/7 3791/7 3791/11 3794/9
3794/9 3796/17 3802/8 3806/18 3807/11
3808/17 3813/11 3815/11 3817/16
3817/18 3819/24 3820/15 3820/15
3823/16 3826/4 3832/17 3833/17
3834/25 3835/23
ALLAN [1] 3658/15
allow [3] 3671/16 3760/9 3817/9
allowable [1] 3794/22
allowing [2] 3683/25 3827/5
allows [2] 3697/10 3811/11
almost [5] 3721/24 3786/7 3793/11
3797/13 3834/20
alone [1] 3754/19
along [2] 3727/21 3773/1
alongside [1] 3810/21
already [6] 3667/15 3667/21 3708/1
3766/7 3769/15 3792/3
also [44] 3663/13 3663/24 3665/6
3671/23 3686/8 3687/24 3697/17 3712/5
3715/2 3715/14 3730/24 3730/25 3731/1
3731/18 3731/22 3739/12 3751/24
3753/25 3755/22 3756/10 3761/11
3762/13 3762/17 3762/22 3763/1 3763/7
3763/9 3764/24 3766/23 3769/19
3769/21 3771/15 3779/16 3779/20
3781/20 3788/5 3801/25 3802/10 3805/4

3812/3 3816/4 3823/15 3825/10 3825/10
alternate [1] 3778/23
alternation [1] 3813/13
alternative [1] 3775/5
alternator [2] 3812/24 3813/6
although [3] 3710/7 3727/25 3781/23
always [9] 3672/12 3673/6 3673/9
3673/10 3680/17 3698/11 3749/25
3750/1 3752/8
am [3] 3705/16 3713/6 3730/3
ameliorative [1] 3761/14
AMERICA [9] 3655/10 3657/12 3657/16
3657/22 3658/3 3658/19 3658/22 3659/3
3730/13
among [1] 3802/10
amongst [1] 3743/17
amount [4] 3730/25 3740/19 3740/23
3794/4
Analysis [1] 3751/13
analyzed [2] 3751/19 3785/1
anchor [1] 3819/10
and/or [2] 3732/8 3807/21
ANDREW [1] 3658/22
Angeles [1] 3659/14
angle [1] 3749/6
annual [1] 3783/3
anomalies [4] 3704/2 3704/8 3772/13
3814/5
anomaly [6] 3663/9 3675/21 3689/19
3689/20 3690/3 3723/10
another [14] 3669/5 3703/3 3703/5
3703/8 3703/12 3709/9 3726/6 3726/15
3745/1 3767/23 3784/7 3797/9 3800/25
3808/25
answer [16] 3675/8 3681/17 3686/19
3688/1 3688/15 3689/14 3689/17
3706/21 3709/9 3719/3 3750/25 3770/24
3820/22 3820/24 3820/25 3832/8
answered [4] 3706/16 3706/25 3710/12
3724/13
answers [2] 3685/24 3686/15
ANTHONY [1] 3657/9
anticipate [2] 3835/25 3836/1
Antonio [1] 3656/17
any [60] 3668/23 3669/7 3669/12
3672/20 3673/20 3674/14 3679/9 3686/9
3686/12 3698/8 3698/8 3711/13 3711/23
3714/12 3715/17 3716/1 3718/10
3718/11 3719/13 3719/15 3720/9
3723/10 3723/11 3723/11 3728/9
3729/21 3729/21 3732/7 3732/8 3732/17
3733/21 3734/1 3735/8 3738/19 3749/21
3752/3 3752/4 3752/25 3753/13 3754/16
3755/11 3759/6 3763/14 3763/17
3763/22 3764/14 3764/14 3769/17
3776/7 3776/14 3783/15 3791/17
3794/10 3805/8 3806/22 3821/5 3823/11
3826/3 3835/7 3835/13
anybody [7] 3677/15 3686/6 3714/6
3714/6 3716/14 3736/3 3752/4
anyone [5] 3662/9 3670/14 3673/20
3673/24 3677/11
anything [5] 3711/24 3718/14 3729/24
3737/20 3770/1
anyway [1] 3821/18
anywhere [1] 3721/3
APLC [1] 3658/18
apologize [5] 3675/10 3684/25 3690/12
3690/14 3698/16
apparatus [1] 3750/17
apparent [1] 3668/11
apparently [9] 3718/16 3729/6 3773/19
A
apparently... [6] 3797/18 3801/16 3802/1
3802/3 3802/15 3829/13
appearance [1] 3704/25
Appearances [6] 3655/17 3656/1 3657/1
3658/1 3659/1 3660/1
appears [1] 3780/6
applicable [3] 3733/9 3789/10 3789/13
application [1] 3735/12
applied [2] 3744/6 3749/1
applies [5] 3655/6 3738/5 3738/21
3788/1 3789/2
apply [4] 3737/25 3738/2 3788/21
3811/12
appoint [2] 3738/22 3738/23
appointed [1] 3731/2
appreciate [2] 3699/4 3710/14
appreciation [1] 3781/10
approach [5] 3690/9 3698/19 3700/9
3800/9 3817/9
appropriate [5] 3743/25 3746/9 3761/13
3771/12 3771/15
approved [3] 3779/1 3787/15 3787/17
approximately [13] 3664/23 3696/16
3702/17 3703/13 3703/14 3703/17
3707/6 3732/23 3772/16 3801/6 3802/4
3802/15 3806/10
appurtenance [1] 3769/25
appurtenances [1] 3805/13
APRIL [26] 3655/5 3664/7 3664/17
3670/22 3671/25 3672/20 3674/9
3674/18 3675/2 3677/1 3680/11 3685/21
3706/12 3707/21 3712/17 3715/11
3720/18 3737/24 3744/21 3747/19
3768/17 3772/16 3783/13 3797/12
3798/5 3827/16
April 11 [1] 3712/17
April 20 [18] 3664/7 3664/17 3670/22
3671/25 3672/20 3674/9 3674/18 3675/2
3677/1 3680/11 3685/21 3706/12
3707/21 3715/11 3720/18 3737/24
3744/21 3747/19
April 2000 [1] 3768/17
April 2005 [1] 3783/13
April 2006 [1] 3797/12
April 2008 [1] 3827/16
April 26 [1] 3772/16
Aquamaster [1] 3748/17
architect [2] 3730/23 3732/24
Architects [1] 3729/23
architecture [3] 3729/19 3735/22 3736/1
Arctic [1] 3730/20
are [194]
area [9] 3671/21 3695/14 3695/21
3696/7 3696/8 3696/20 3699/7 3700/21
3766/5
areas [4] 3735/25 3759/18 3759/18
3760/5
aren't [5] 3691/16 3710/9 3796/25
3797/1 3806/18
argumentative [1] 3680/20
arises [1] 3752/24
arising [1] 3786/11
around [19] 3666/14 3676/7 3677/7
3678/7 3679/3 3679/5 3679/8 3691/19
3692/25 3693/11 3707/4 3707/8 3707/13
3722/8 3730/12 3749/7 3813/11 3814/13
3835/23
arranged [1] 3756/11
arrangements [1] 3754/12
Arrell [1] 3659/19
arrested [1] 3739/16
arrive [1] 3809/12

arrived [1] 3667/15
as [195]
Asbill [1] 3659/8
ashore [18] 3737/14 3742/5 3744/1
3744/10 3744/20 3744/21 3745/9
3745/24 3765/22 3765/25 3767/3
3767/13 3779/20 3786/22 3801/18
3801/20 3830/20 3830/23
ask [18] 3666/25 3682/18 3685/18
3709/9 3712/25 3713/3 3729/13 3744/9
3745/4 3747/12 3750/8 3754/16 3765/3
3769/25 3770/24 3777/12 3783/15
3799/3
asked [19] 3664/13 3666/10 3674/25
3676/24 3677/21 3681/23 3685/7
3687/23 3688/15 3715/14 3716/3 3716/6
3718/15 3719/8 3723/21 3724/12
3724/20 3725/22 3762/15
asking [9] 3675/10 3682/22 3684/14
3703/10 3704/14 3709/6 3711/20 3722/2
3723/18
aspects [4] 3744/4 3746/21 3764/3
3765/5
aspirate [1] 3760/10
assess [1] 3776/11
assessment [7] 3761/8 3768/16 3772/12
3774/22 3793/6 3810/22 3833/14
assessments [1] 3800/4
asset [5] 3655/8 3791/22 3791/25
3825/17 3825/18
assigned [3] 3781/19 3794/5 3794/11
assistance [1] 3747/9
assistant [3] 3765/1 3822/14 3822/21
associated [2] 3769/3 3770/12
association [2] 3745/22 3803/23
assumed [2] 3673/16 3776/8
assumption [1] 3797/25
Assurance [1] 3810/8
at [162] 3662/8 3666/6 3666/13 3666/14
3666/21 3666/21 3667/8 3667/10
3667/20 3668/10 3669/17 3669/23
3670/1 3670/2 3670/10 3671/24 3672/20
3673/20 3674/14 3674/24 3674/24
3675/6 3676/3 3676/16 3676/17 3676/20
3677/13 3677/15 3679/8 3679/8 3681/3
3683/19 3685/7 3685/9 3685/12 3685/14
3685/14 3686/14 3686/17 3688/14
3688/14 3688/22 3688/24 3690/25
3691/18 3691/19 3692/8 3692/24
3692/25 3693/1 3693/25 3694/14
3697/13 3699/4 3703/18 3703/19
3704/15 3704/15 3705/5 3707/21 3708/2
3709/14 3710/20 3711/24 3712/18
3714/4 3714/6 3718/15 3718/19 3719/7
3719/15 3719/16 3720/13 3720/15
3721/3 3722/11 3722/22 3722/24
3723/15 3724/1 3724/2 3724/8 3724/9
3726/9 3727/23 3728/1 3728/15 3732/17
3732/18 3734/20 3735/24 3737/8 3741/5
3741/17 3742/10 3743/1 3745/14
3747/11 3749/19 3750/3 3752/15
3754/10 3759/9 3759/20 3767/9 3767/12
3767/12 3767/13 3767/15 3768/11
3769/2 3771/6 3775/4 3775/6 3777/6
3779/9 3780/6 3780/13 3781/6 3781/13
3782/4 3784/23 3785/25 3787/7 3792/10
3792/10 3792/14 3794/21 3797/16
3798/10 3799/21 3801/7 3801/12 3802/8
3804/22 3805/10 3806/6 3809/19
3810/13 3812/16 3812/21 3814/16
3817/5 3818/23 3818/25 3821/12 3822/2
3822/25 3826/3 3826/22 3829/10
3829/11 3830/2 3830/24 3831/11

3831/23 3832/11 3832/15 3834/1
3834/18 3834/20 3836/5
atmosphere [1] 3760/6
attached [2] 3727/22 3802/25
attended [2] 3797/18 3797/18
attendees [1] 3801/13
attending [1] 3802/1
attention [2] 3685/2 3740/4
Attorney [2] 3658/7 3658/11
audit [74] 3734/20 3742/9 3752/22
3766/16 3766/16 3767/11 3772/3
3773/18 3773/18 3773/24 3773/25
3774/2 3774/14 3777/11 3778/1 3778/16
3779/15 3781/2 3781/7 3784/7 3784/8
3784/9 3784/9 3784/11 3785/7 3785/16
3785/20 3785/24 3786/6 3786/9 3787/14
3787/16 3787/17 3787/19 3787/23
3788/14 3788/15 3788/18 3790/23
3791/21 3795/22 3796/1 3796/3 3797/9
3797/11 3797/18 3798/10 3799/19
3800/25 3801/4 3801/5 3801/7 3801/10
3803/1 3808/3 3809/1 3809/2 3809/6
3810/8 3810/11 3811/4 3815/2 3815/3
3818/22 3819/2 3819/6 3824/17 3827/15
3827/23 3828/1 3828/2 3828/17 3829/17
3829/18
auditable [1] 3781/25
audited [3] 3738/7 3790/19 3791/2
auditing [2] 3736/21 3779/10
auditor [24] 3731/16 3740/13 3740/18
3742/10 3752/14 3752/21 3767/7
3777/14 3779/14 3784/11 3784/12
3785/7 3785/19 3787/21 3789/15
3793/22 3797/22 3798/13 3798/25
3799/9 3800/12 3801/9 3802/16 3802/19
auditor's [1] 3788/24
auditors [5] 3739/2 3742/16 3767/1
3767/7 3767/8
audits [26] 3730/8 3730/8 3730/9
3731/17 3731/20 3738/24 3742/21
3766/6 3766/8 3766/11 3766/16 3766/24
3767/6 3776/13 3777/5 3785/21 3786/12
3786/13 3786/16 3787/22 3790/18
3794/9 3800/3 3802/7 3802/18 3802/19
August [3] 3734/7 3773/18 3787/6
August 1992 [1] 3734/7
August 30 [1] 3787/6
August/September 2001 [1] 3773/18
authorities [1] 3778/20
authority [12] 3673/4 3743/16 3744/2
3745/23 3746/5 3747/5 3747/6 3747/15
3778/3 3779/10 3779/21 3780/7
automated [5] 3755/11 3761/20 3762/2
3762/14 3807/3
automatic [8] 3710/23 3760/7 3762/8
3765/15 3774/16 3816/11 3825/5 3826/5
automatically [8] 3749/15 3758/6
3759/14 3759/15 3760/2 3761/2 3763/1
3763/4
Auxiliary [1] 3732/20
availability [5] 3774/2 3810/20 3811/18
3815/13 3823/18
available [10] 3663/19 3671/15 3771/19
3789/10 3789/14 3790/1 3794/3 3806/12
3833/17 3834/6
Avenue [5] 3655/23 3657/13 3658/9
3659/3 3659/14
avoid [2] 3749/20 3767/22
avoidance [1] 3741/18
Avondale [1] 3730/16
aware [11] 3668/19 3682/5 3683/24
3707/21 3711/10 3711/23 3713/21
A
aware... [4] 3742/13 3745/6 3745/8
3789/24
away [2] 3795/6 3795/6
B
Bachelor [1] 3729/18
back [32] 3675/13 3677/23 3678/4
3678/7 3678/10 3678/11 3691/8 3691/9
3692/1 3694/14 3696/1 3701/2 3702/10
3702/11 3710/16 3722/15 3722/22
3723/1 3723/5 3723/7 3723/9 3740/20
3749/1 3749/16 3755/18 3757/21 3766/5
3780/4 3785/22 3785/22 3798/23
3809/11
background [2] 3729/14 3729/16
backlog [1] 3809/14
backlogs [1] 3809/13
bad [6] 3745/13 3749/17 3749/17
3780/16 3796/24 3821/20
ball [1] 3726/25
ballast [2] 3812/7 3812/15
bandaid [1] 3810/5
Bankston [2] 3667/11 3667/21
BARBIER [1] 3655/15
Barnhill [1] 3836/1
barrel [6] 3683/20 3683/25 3684/3
3684/4 3684/16 3684/18
barrels [5] 3665/13 3671/18 3718/20
3719/8 3719/17
based [20] 3722/11 3728/4 3731/7
3736/21 3736/22 3744/5 3746/12
3763/24 3771/23 3777/5 3777/13 3780/8
3783/24 3785/19 3790/22 3796/17
3813/15 3827/18 3827/20 3836/2
basically [18] 3687/18 3696/14 3701/18
3728/18 3733/6 3734/20 3736/20
3736/24 3737/18 3739/8 3741/20
3742/19 3755/18 3758/14 3764/18
3779/12 3792/21 3807/23
basis [1] 3739/10
Bates [1] 3773/20
Bates 43465 [1] 3773/20
bathroom [8] 3679/1 3699/14 3699/15
3699/17 3700/2 3703/19 3703/20
3703/22
Baton [2] 3657/4 3658/13
be [162] 3662/3 3663/2 3663/3 3663/10
3664/14 3665/13 3668/6 3668/20 3671/3
3672/23 3677/23 3678/7 3678/25
3680/19 3681/13 3682/25 3684/11
3688/25 3691/7 3691/22 3692/2 3695/14
3695/21 3696/1 3696/8 3696/11 3696/12
3696/14 3696/18 3696/21 3701/12
3707/16 3711/2 3713/7 3714/13 3720/4
3725/19 3727/24 3737/15 3738/7
3738/23 3739/9 3739/12 3739/25
3740/17 3742/13 3744/10 3746/14
3746/15 3746/18 3747/9 3749/2 3751/7
3751/24 3752/7 3752/9 3752/18 3753/13
3753/23 3755/8 3755/9 3760/14 3760/21
3760/23 3764/13 3764/13 3765/11
3765/16 3765/18 3765/21 3765/21
3765/24 3767/5 3767/7 3767/20 3768/3
3768/8 3769/16 3769/17 3769/18 3770/4
3770/20 3771/5 3773/1 3773/8 3774/5
3774/6 3774/9 3774/10 3774/14 3775/5
3775/12 3776/6 3776/10 3778/17 3779/2
3779/8 3779/13 3779/18 3780/6 3781/22
3782/4 3783/13 3783/23 3784/12
3785/21 3786/19 3786/25 3787/18
3787/21 3788/16 3788/17 3788/19
3789/9 3790/1 3791/17 3792/14 3794/1

3794/3 3794/5 3795/6 3797/3 3797/3
3797/21 3798/13 3798/14 3798/21
3799/12 3800/15 3800/18 3805/8
3805/24 3807/15 3807/19 3807/20
3807/20 3809/13 3810/22 3810/23
3815/11 3815/25 3816/11 3817/14
3818/3 3818/10 3818/13 3819/5 3820/16
3823/4 3823/16 3824/10 3824/25
3825/11 3825/18 3826/5 3826/11
3826/18 3827/22 3828/1 3831/1 3831/14
3835/7
beach [2] 3656/10 3813/18
Bean [3] 3730/15 3730/19 3732/12
bearing [6] 3757/13 3757/14 3757/19
3795/4 3812/24 3813/6
bearings [2] 3795/6 3817/18
became [3] 3731/4 3731/9 3731/16
because [38] 3669/9 3676/12 3678/4
3678/7 3679/5 3689/18 3692/2 3693/4
3697/13 3704/13 3706/12 3711/14
3717/19 3720/22 3734/18 3735/5
3736/24 3741/2 3742/15 3745/17 3749/1
3749/2 3757/14 3758/16 3760/17
3763/11 3763/13 3763/18 3779/8 3795/3
3795/10 3796/24 3798/16 3810/3 3813/5
3821/10 3829/3 3830/6
Beck [2] 3660/2 3660/3
become [3] 3745/6 3803/3 3813/19
becomes [1] 3767/21
becoming [1] 3809/14
bed [2] 3708/2 3708/6
been [66] 3662/16 3666/13 3666/20
3667/18 3667/21 3670/11 3670/12
3670/25 3672/13 3678/7 3679/9 3683/19
3683/20 3706/2 3711/18 3716/1 3717/8
3717/24 3719/24 3720/19 3727/11
3727/21 3729/7 3731/2 3731/17 3732/9
3733/6 3733/8 3733/23 3734/7 3734/10
3734/11 3735/7 3735/11 3735/15
3735/18 3735/21 3736/24 3745/7
3745/11 3752/21 3753/3 3764/3 3764/5
3764/12 3765/5 3787/23 3793/10
3794/18 3794/19 3794/21 3796/10
3796/13 3796/25 3804/15 3809/23
3811/21 3814/12 3816/17 3820/1
3822/23 3827/25 3828/3 3828/10
3828/14 3828/23
before [41] 3655/15 3664/13 3664/14
3665/7 3666/16 3674/19 3675/3 3678/2
3678/3 3678/3 3678/10 3678/24 3684/1
3689/2 3698/12 3707/4 3715/15 3718/13
3722/16 3722/20 3725/10 3731/1
3735/21 3738/15 3751/11 3753/4 3753/6
3772/17 3773/13 3780/3 3780/24
3782/11 3785/23 3790/24 3793/20
3799/5 3813/7 3826/8 3827/9 3835/3
3835/4
began [1] 3664/6
begin [1] 3664/15
beginning [1] 3690/25
begins [1] 3669/23
behalf [2] 3662/4 3724/20
behavior [1] 3821/19
behest [1] 3767/13
behind [2] 3702/1 3702/2
being [29] 3665/14 3671/18 3671/19
3674/25 3685/7 3692/20 3696/4 3702/16
3711/13 3711/14 3711/24 3714/22
3715/25 3716/7 3723/19 3737/3 3740/16
3748/2 3781/17 3781/21 3785/10
3787/17 3796/12 3796/22 3802/16
3807/21 3818/11 3824/23 3832/19
believe [21] 3662/24 3677/3 3679/2

3708/15 3713/11 3734/7 3734/8 3734/11
3734/16 3737/7 3749/7 3760/5 3765/11
3766/21 3770/4 3772/4 3781/12 3793/24
3801/18 3826/5 3826/6
believed [3] 3672/20 3673/5 3673/7
Bellow [5] 3712/17 3714/7 3714/7
3714/8 3714/12
bells [1] 3698/8
below [6] 3675/17 3684/11 3684/16
3693/1 3696/11 3785/5
Ben [1] 3658/5
beneath [1] 3701/12
benefit [2] 3798/22 3800/3
best [3] 3722/6 3780/18 3836/12
better [1] 3736/18
between [17] 3664/8 3665/21 3674/9
3678/16 3701/14 3720/17 3721/3
3730/15 3737/16 3743/17 3743/24
3745/11 3745/22 3764/25 3764/25
3776/12 3803/5
beyond [3] 3716/1 3771/8 3783/17
BHP [2] 3782/16 3782/18
big [5] 3701/6 3730/21 3734/15 3748/16
3748/18
bilge [3] 3805/16 3812/7 3832/25
bilges [2] 3805/21 3812/15
bill [2] 3740/15 3779/2
Billiton [1] 3782/18
bit [10] 3670/18 3675/15 3689/4 3689/6
3707/18 3717/18 3742/24 3748/25
3758/9 3815/3
black [5] 3682/2 3682/3 3682/4 3682/6
3682/19
blame [1] 3822/23
blank [2] 3682/2 3682/19
Bldg [1] 3657/13
bleed [1] 3796/10
blew [1] 3725/8
blinded [1] 3697/2
block [1] 3702/23
blow [1] 3757/17
blowing [1] 3763/18
blowout [8] 3694/25 3750/8 3750/14
3750/19 3750/22 3768/16 3769/20
3773/3
blows [2] 3748/24 3813/7
blue [1] 3691/5
board [18] 3668/12 3672/8 3732/1
3734/19 3740/13 3743/24 3744/16
3745/15 3747/3 3747/19 3749/9 3750/23
3752/18 3760/5 3766/20 3808/14
3808/16 3834/12
boat [1] 3667/11
Bob [1] 3802/3
Bockius [1] 3660/14
body [1] 3738/22
book [3] 3665/23 3723/3 3740/17
BOP [25] 3717/25 3749/4 3749/7 3750/9
3750/10 3769/4 3769/16 3769/17
3769/24 3769/25 3770/1 3770/3 3770/5
3770/5 3770/13 3772/3 3775/4 3775/8
3775/9 3776/4 3783/15 3783/17 3796/9
3796/18 3797/1
BOPs [1] 3717/22
both [7] 3731/11 3733/24 3742/6
3771/10 3803/10 3811/17 3833/10
bottom [9] 3703/18 3759/20 3769/2
3771/6 3771/6 3785/25 3799/23 3811/16
3818/23
Boulevard [1] 3657/6
Bounds [1] 3656/2
BOWMAN [1] 3660/8
3742/24 3745/5 3746/24 3747/12

3747/22 3748/5 3748/19 3750/12
box [9] 3655/20 3657/13 3657/19
3754/15 3758/12 3759/18 3763/7 3763/9
3657/25 3658/13 3659/17 3679/25
3766/2 3766/14 3770/2 3770/5 3776/7
3759/20 3787/14
3776/21 3783/17 3784/8 3785/6 3785/7
BP [38] 3655/10 3658/18 3658/19
3787/13 3792/11 3796/13 3796/22
3658/20 3658/21 3658/22 3658/23
3798/18 3801/23 3805/4 3807/12 3812/5
3659/2 3659/3 3659/4 3667/6 3672/15
3812/10 3813/10 3821/17 3822/2 3823/1
3673/20 3676/25 3677/4 3677/11
3825/25 3828/17 3834/20
3677/15 3683/3 3713/19 3714/10 3722/2 bypass [1] 3711/24
3751/25 3773/19 3773/25 3788/17
3790/19 3807/9 3810/9 3815/3 3815/10 C
3815/18 3815/25 3818/23 3824/3
C.F.R [1] 3811/13
3824/11 3824/12 3824/12 3829/10
cabin [3] 3668/8 3822/8 3822/11
BP's [1] 3788/4
Cajun [2] 3734/9 3734/20
BRAD [1] 3659/13
Cajun Express [2] 3734/9 3734/20
brain [2] 3755/22 3760/24
calculating [1] 3671/12
Branch [3] 3657/12 3657/22 3658/3
CALDWELL [1] 3658/12
brand [1] 3735/6
calibration [1] 3818/14
brand-new [1] 3735/6
California [2] 3657/14 3659/14
Brazil [1] 3827/16
call [38] 3680/15 3680/22 3681/1 3683/2
breach [1] 3782/12
3687/18 3689/22 3689/23 3689/25
break [25] 3664/13 3666/16 3670/17
3690/4 3692/16 3697/14 3701/17
3676/22 3677/5 3678/1 3678/9 3679/3
3706/12 3707/4 3708/15 3725/10
3679/5 3698/24 3699/13 3699/15 3700/2 3725/12 3726/3 3726/10 3726/22
3701/9 3702/4 3703/9 3703/20 3707/5
3742/16 3745/16 3745/18 3745/18
3722/3 3722/7 3722/9 3722/12 3723/5
3748/22 3749/19 3757/16 3760/1
3725/10 3768/2
3760/21 3760/23 3763/5 3763/9 3763/10
breakdowns [1] 3821/12
3763/10 3763/17 3766/15 3798/22
breathe [1] 3760/10
3799/1
breezeway [3] 3702/14 3702/15 3703/11 called [26] 3667/5 3685/9 3686/18
Breit [2] 3656/8 3656/9
3686/22 3687/24 3688/11 3688/17
Brennan [1] 3659/8
3689/13 3689/18 3715/22 3715/23
Brett [1] 3829/10
3725/14 3730/15 3732/2 3732/10
BRIAN [2] 3659/13 3820/18
3732/19 3734/9 3734/23 3736/19
bridge [11] 3748/14 3750/2 3750/4
3737/14 3738/8 3742/18 3745/1 3755/14
3750/5 3764/14 3764/21 3825/11
3785/23 3808/15
3825/25 3826/10 3826/15 3834/4
calling [3] 3716/18 3717/13 3834/13
brief [1] 3730/7
calls [6] 3724/18 3724/20 3724/24
briefly [14] 3674/24 3731/23 3734/4
3725/1 3725/4 3726/11
3736/18 3740/11 3750/25 3756/8 3757/7 Calvin [1] 3836/1
3758/25 3759/10 3759/22 3784/8
came [15] 3663/20 3665/21 3667/20
3784/23 3788/13
3667/22 3670/10 3675/18 3677/18
bring [4] 3722/9 3727/6 3749/1 3756/2
3682/10 3721/5 3723/5 3730/13 3731/1
BROCK [5] 3659/3 3662/13 3722/2
3734/14 3734/15 3740/13
3723/13 3723/16
camera [1] 3724/8
Brock's [1] 3725/22
Cameron [7] 3659/22 3660/2 3662/5
broke [2] 3807/23 3807/24
3662/5 3704/19 3704/20 3768/18
broken [2] 3809/21 3820/9
Camp [1] 3658/16
BRUCE [1] 3660/8
can [51] 3665/2 3665/7 3667/5 3690/16
bubble [1] 3758/13
3692/11 3697/17 3700/9 3701/24
bubbles [1] 3756/14
3716/25 3722/6 3725/17 3736/4 3740/2
build [1] 3730/14
3741/3 3745/16 3745/18 3749/7 3749/13
building [3] 3656/16 3758/15 3759/4
3749/19 3753/23 3755/8 3755/9 3759/6
built [3] 3734/11 3755/16 3826/7
3760/10 3763/4 3763/8 3763/15 3767/7
built-in [1] 3826/7
3771/16 3773/23 3775/5 3775/12
bulk [1] 3737/3
3779/11 3793/8 3795/6 3795/6 3795/7
bulkheads [1] 3832/6
3805/24 3807/20 3810/23 3813/17
bunch [1] 3766/20
3813/23 3813/23 3814/1 3814/11
burden [1] 3810/2
3816/20 3826/9 3826/10 3826/11
Bureau [7] 3731/2 3731/5 3731/7
3826/21 3827/7
3731/11 3731/11 3733/11 3733/11
can't [14] 3699/4 3709/8 3725/13
Burling [1] 3659/2
3728/20 3763/12 3798/16 3805/9
business [4] 3730/23 3730/24 3763/10
3805/19 3805/21 3807/23 3812/14
3787/16
3819/5 3820/9 3822/23
but [76] 3663/5 3664/13 3668/5 3673/9 Canada [1] 3730/22
3673/15 3674/20 3675/10 3680/15
cancel [1] 3734/16
3681/1 3681/21 3684/13 3685/17
Canducci [3] 3745/1 3780/1 3830/24
3689/15 3689/20 3694/24 3695/20
cannot [2] 3741/4 3752/19
3696/15 3697/9 3697/16 3699/5 3700/14 capable [3] 3766/3 3769/5 3832/18
3706/2 3708/5 3709/6 3717/8 3718/1
capsules [2] 3699/11 3702/10
3719/24 3720/11 3720/11 3721/7 3727/2 captain [7] 3732/3 3737/12 3737/17
3729/14 3730/4 3734/7 3734/15 3739/9 3745/14 3745/18 3751/3 3779/8
captains [1] 3732/1

capture [1] 3714/19
carbon [1] 3759/6
care [4] 3778/17 3807/21 3807/21
3811/21
career [1] 3733/7
carefully [2] 3742/23 3799/21
CARL [16] 3655/15 3739/20 3751/13
3756/2 3772/22 3790/15 3796/6 3804/3
3809/6 3811/14 3812/18 3819/7 3822/5
3823/5 3823/25 3827/10
Carlisle [1] 3801/25
Carondelet [2] 3656/13 3659/23
CARRIE [1] 3658/22
carried [6] 3789/25 3799/19 3827/15
3828/1 3828/2 3831/14
carrier [1] 3754/24
carriers [1] 3737/3
carry [3] 3734/9 3734/19 3738/24
carrying [3] 3731/17 3819/20 3819/21
case [13] 3705/1 3707/20 3710/4 3711/6
3720/25 3739/1 3751/25 3759/5 3764/24
3766/13 3776/7 3780/1 3786/25
cases [1] 3793/14
casing [1] 3717/18
casualties [1] 3736/25
catastrophic [1] 3749/21
catches [1] 3813/7
category [2] 3746/4 3806/2
Cathleenia [1] 3664/11
caught [1] 3718/1
cause [7] 3774/7 3774/15 3781/9
3818/12 3821/21 3824/25 3825/4
caused [2] 3734/25 3772/13
causes [1] 3758/16
causing [1] 3817/21
CCR [3] 3660/18 3836/9 3836/17
cease [1] 3820/3
CEO [2] 3744/16 3802/3
CERNICH [1] 3657/17
certain [7] 3675/5 3681/15 3715/12
3715/13 3740/19 3749/1 3778/19
certainly [2] 3750/13 3767/18
certificate [2] 3783/22 3836/8
certificates [2] 3731/4 3739/11
certification [4] 3737/11 3777/11 3777/15
3784/7
certify [1] 3836/11
chain [1] 3791/7
chair [2] 3764/25 3765/1
CHAKERES [1] 3657/19
chance [1] 3712/25
CHANG [1] 3657/18
change [16] 3671/17 3676/18 3681/1
3681/3 3683/3 3683/10 3687/1 3687/11
3687/19 3688/21 3690/3 3726/4 3726/10
3796/20 3824/19 3825/17
change' [1] 3687/15
changed [5] 3720/19 3738/12 3796/12
3796/22 3796/23
changes [5] 3683/7 3686/9 3686/12
3704/3 3726/25
changing [3] 3663/24 3777/1 3783/19
Channel [1] 3697/6
Channel 14 [1] 3697/6
Chapter [1] 3829/4
Chapter 1.2.3.1 [1] 3829/4
characterize [6] 3692/11 3751/7 3754/21
3798/25 3821/19 3822/17
charge [6] 3778/22 3778/23 3778/24
3779/1 3779/5 3779/13
chart [12] 3690/19 3690/22 3720/12
3720/15 3723/24 3724/6 3756/9 3756/9
C
chart... [4] 3757/22 3758/7 3759/20
3790/18
charter [1] 3734/10
chartered [1] 3730/2
check [7] 3687/10 3696/17 3697/3
3698/6 3722/16 3739/10 3813/11
checked [3] 3678/4 3678/5 3722/21
checking [2] 3678/14 3722/19
checks [1] 3781/16
Chicago [1] 3658/24
chief [8] 3732/1 3732/21 3737/17
3744/16 3745/15 3751/6 3802/6 3802/11
chokes [1] 3796/10
chose [1] 3679/22
cigarette [4] 3699/18 3699/19 3703/24
3703/25
circle [3] 3693/11 3694/12 3730/21
circled [1] 3694/7
circulated [2] 3662/6 3670/7
circulation [1] 3718/3
circumvention [1] 3717/2
cited [1] 3823/15
cites [1] 3824/12
Civil [2] 3657/12 3657/22
claims [1] 3718/23
clarify [2] 3681/21 3724/17
class [4] 3740/20 3766/18 3766/19
3832/23
classic [1] 3717/3
classification [4] 3731/7 3733/8 3738/24
3752/7
clean [2] 3737/6 3795/16
cleaning [2] 3706/18 3794/20
clear [10] 3673/16 3691/7 3706/10
3721/25 3740/21 3746/9 3747/4 3771/19
3771/21 3772/2
cleared [2] 3739/16 3740/22
clearly [3] 3663/10 3746/6 3769/25
climate [1] 3803/4
CLINGMAN [1] 3659/9
clock [1] 3708/8
close [9] 3678/11 3717/24 3781/15
3787/16 3808/11 3812/23 3814/8 3816/9
3817/25
closed [7] 3717/24 3756/1 3787/23
3819/24 3821/4 3821/18 3827/23
closed-out [1] 3787/23
closely [1] 3682/1
closes [1] 3758/15
closing [6] 3782/11 3805/6 3811/19
3814/6 3814/7 3820/2
closure [7] 3760/8 3762/8 3762/8
3762/18 3787/18 3800/10 3814/5
CO2 [1] 3759/5
Coast [4] 3739/6 3739/19 3789/13
3834/14
Coast Guard [4] 3739/6 3739/19 3789/13
3834/14
coastal [1] 3827/19
Cocales [2] 3829/10 3829/17
code [51] 3718/20 3719/17 3731/14
3736/18 3736/19 3736/19 3736/20
3737/7 3737/24 3738/2 3738/5 3738/20
3741/12 3741/16 3741/21 3754/17
3765/18 3766/7 3766/15 3773/7 3777/11
3777/15 3778/1 3779/6 3784/7 3784/22
3788/1 3793/23 3797/4 3800/13 3800/18
3803/16 3803/17 3809/15 3811/9
3811/11 3811/12 3812/12 3816/24
3817/13 3819/17 3820/7 3825/9 3827/6
3829/2 3829/6 3832/4 3832/9 3832/22
3833/11 3833/23
codes [2] 3733/9 3739/23
coffee [3] 3699/17 3703/24 3703/25
colleagues [1] 3727/19
colors [1] 3692/19
column [5] 3690/21 3691/16 3756/13
3792/7 3831/16
columns [3] 3748/13 3748/13 3748/16
combination [1] 3812/10
combinations [3] 3770/10 3770/11
3770/14
combined [1] 3812/5
combustible [1] 3792/10
combustion [1] 3758/17
come [17] 3665/7 3670/2 3670/14
3677/23 3692/1 3700/24 3727/1 3734/11
3740/20 3748/13 3748/24 3749/7
3756/17 3756/18 3766/5 3766/19 3780/5
comes [4] 3711/7 3739/14 3776/4
3795/5
comfortable [1] 3706/22
coming [9] 3666/11 3678/19 3691/9
3697/4 3697/10 3697/23 3702/9 3731/14
3803/6
command [3] 3779/2 3779/12 3791/7
comment [3] 3791/15 3793/19 3812/14
commentary [1] 3687/17
comments [3] 3791/17 3804/5 3819/11
Commercial [1] 3658/3
Committee [1] 3736/11
common [2] 3745/17 3803/21
communicating [1] 3834/13
communication [3] 3737/16 3743/16
3746/1
communications [2] 3834/5 3834/12
companies [8] 3731/25 3732/7 3732/8
3732/14 3732/15 3733/13 3734/2 3737/6
company [61] 3658/20 3658/23 3659/4
3672/23 3687/24 3705/17 3705/18
3711/3 3730/11 3730/12 3730/15
3730/19 3730/20 3732/10 3732/12
3732/19 3737/10 3741/2 3741/24
3742/17 3743/3 3743/24 3743/25
3744/18 3744/19 3745/10 3746/6 3746/8
3747/2 3747/5 3747/23 3751/17 3751/19
3751/21 3752/6 3752/11 3752/25
3753/10 3753/14 3754/6 3766/23 3767/7
3767/8 3778/2 3784/8 3784/9 3784/11
3785/1 3789/21 3789/22 3789/23 3790/4
3797/10 3801/1 3801/24 3802/7 3802/18
3826/12 3827/1 3827/5 3828/18
company's [6] 3746/15 3747/8 3803/14
3803/15 3823/2 3833/7
compensation [2] 3677/8 3677/11
competency [1] 3833/13
competent [1] 3764/14
COMPLAINT [1] 3655/7
complete [4] 3735/1 3794/4 3806/4
3811/25
completed [5] 3666/10 3667/18 3781/16
3782/11 3820/1
completion [4] 3815/14 3816/14 3820/6
3824/17
complex [9] 3754/22 3754/23 3754/24
3755/3 3755/5 3755/7 3755/12 3755/16
3756/1
compliance [24] 3705/23 3706/5 3708/20
3708/25 3709/1 3709/20 3710/2 3721/18
3733/14 3736/2 3738/8 3738/25 3743/13
3754/17 3783/23 3788/23 3789/8
3789/11 3799/18 3827/3 3827/4 3827/5
3829/4 3833/7
compliant [1] 3739/13
complicated [3] 3761/7 3820/12 3820/13

comply [4] 3747/14 3747/20 3788/24
3815/10
component [2] 3743/19 3783/6
components [4] 3754/2 3755/4 3764/6
3806/3
composed [1] 3755/4
comprised [3] 3751/3 3755/4 3755/13
computer [2] 3660/25 3749/16
computer-aided [1] 3660/25
computers [1] 3755/16
concern [6] 3669/7 3677/21 3804/15
3804/19 3804/24 3811/17
concerned [2] 3773/24 3774/2
concerns [5] 3669/12 3669/17 3669/20
3698/8 3802/19
concise [2] 3771/22 3772/2
concluded [1] 3672/20
condition [8] 3672/22 3736/1 3738/19
3795/22 3795/25 3795/25 3827/12
3832/18
conditionally [2] 3727/24 3787/15
conditions [5] 3670/23 3735/16 3822/12
3822/15 3822/22
conduct [6] 3672/21 3678/21 3698/5
3766/23 3787/21 3811/7
conducted [11] 3678/25 3696/4 3696/6
3696/7 3696/21 3696/25 3716/2 3773/19
3804/8 3804/9 3810/9
conducting [1] 3730/8
configuration [2] 3769/5 3776/6
confirmed [1] 3723/25
conformance [1] 3773/7
conformity [1] 3753/12
confused [3] 3682/23 3776/20 3830/5
confusing [1] 3801/23
confusion [2] 3682/12 3779/12
connected [1] 3749/3
connection [2] 3714/24 3721/16
CONRAD [3] 3656/19 3727/18 3727/19
consequences [2] 3814/9 3814/10
consequently [3] 3781/17 3815/19
3824/4
Consider [1] 3777/1
considered [3] 3695/14 3701/13 3809/14
consisted [1] 3819/10
constant [4] 3676/20 3685/9 3686/17
3809/18
constantly [1] 3676/18
constitute [5] 3800/12 3812/11 3813/4
3817/12 3825/8
constitutes [1] 3786/23
constructing [1] 3730/16
construction [1] 3731/11
consultant [2] 3730/24 3799/22
containing [1] 3823/14
contains [2] 3747/4 3798/11
content [1] 3794/22
continue [1] 3834/15
continuous [1] 3754/13
continuously [4] 3669/8 3669/18 3671/23
3742/4
contract [2] 3734/16 3734/17
contractor [6] 3788/20 3788/22 3788/23
3789/8 3789/20 3789/24
contractor's [1] 3788/22
contractors [4] 3672/15 3733/3 3787/18
3803/23
contrary [2] 3778/25 3779/3
contributor [1] 3769/3
control [20] 3718/16 3718/24 3739/5
3739/10 3755/15 3755/19 3756/10
3758/18 3768/16 3769/4 3769/7 3771/10
3765/4 3765/4 3765/10 3765/17 3765/17

3770/23 3770/24 3783/8 3799/12 3808/8
control... [8] 3771/17 3771/21 3775/4
3809/12 3810/1 3810/2 3813/4 3813/16
3775/8 3775/9 3775/12 3775/16 3813/10 3814/19 3817/5 3822/20 3826/12
controlled [3] 3737/18 3760/11 3805/24 3826/14 3826/15 3831/23 3832/11
controls [3] 3758/5 3758/8 3759/1
3833/25
convenience [1] 3738/10
crews [1] 3731/25
conveyed [1] 3713/5
critical [25] 3758/19 3759/18 3761/6
coordinate [1] 3779/3
3777/2 3781/16 3781/20 3782/16
copy [2] 3723/14 3740/3
3782/24 3783/5 3796/18 3796/19
COREY [1] 3658/8
3805/13 3805/18 3806/3 3806/6 3806/14
corporate [4] 3656/19 3745/2 3801/19
3808/6 3808/13 3809/11 3815/19 3817/2
3828/23
3818/17 3821/23 3824/3 3824/10
Corporation [2] 3659/23 3660/3
critical-safety [1] 3783/5
correct [281]
cross [4] 3662/17 3705/9 3728/24
corrected [5] 3752/9 3767/15 3767/19
3736/4
3787/24 3791/8
cross-examination [3] 3662/17 3705/9
correcting [2] 3828/21 3828/21
3736/4
correction [1] 3772/14
crude [1] 3754/24
corrections [1] 3794/1
cumulative [2] 3769/17 3769/18
corrective [13] 3741/10 3751/22 3767/9 Cunningham [2] 3656/2 3656/3
3776/9 3779/23 3786/11 3827/20
cup [1] 3703/24
3827/22 3827/23 3828/3 3828/4 3828/8 current [2] 3748/25 3803/4
3828/10
currently [4] 3810/17 3810/20 3810/24
correctly [8] 3712/6 3713/16 3753/15
3828/9
3774/11 3792/16 3793/17 3794/7
currents [1] 3749/17
3828/11
Curtis [2] 3724/21 3725/13
could [74] 3663/5 3663/9 3663/20
curve [1] 3666/3
3663/23 3664/2 3666/5 3667/2 3671/11 curved [2] 3663/6 3666/3
3673/8 3673/10 3673/11 3675/10
curves [2] 3722/23 3726/7
3675/15 3679/12 3679/19 3681/25
cut [3] 3702/24 3721/2 3819/10
3690/7 3697/7 3698/17 3699/7 3701/24 CV [4] 3655/7 3655/9 3727/21 3729/4
3707/19 3712/12 3712/13 3714/18
D
3714/19 3719/22 3719/25 3721/2
3729/15 3730/7 3731/23 3734/4 3736/18 D-1 [1] 3764/25
3738/23 3739/20 3740/11 3755/19
D-2105 [1] 3719/22
3755/20 3755/20 3756/2 3757/16
D-2224 [1] 3695/2
3757/17 3759/10 3759/14 3759/22
D-3185 [1] 3698/18
3764/10 3765/14 3768/23 3775/19
D-4388 [3] 3694/24 3723/13 3723/15
3780/19 3781/3 3784/8 3788/16 3788/17 D.C [4] 3657/20 3657/25 3658/6 3659/4
3788/19 3793/5 3794/25 3795/10
Dallas [1] 3660/10
3795/20 3796/6 3797/8 3798/7 3798/21 damage [2] 3741/18 3749/21
3799/17 3807/19 3807/19 3809/5
damaged [1] 3717/20
3810/19 3812/11 3814/18 3818/21
damper [10] 3758/14 3758/14 3758/15
3826/11 3827/9
3758/17 3814/13 3823/9 3823/10
couldn't [3] 3673/11 3740/2 3750/18
3823/13 3823/14 3823/20
counsel [3] 3679/16 3679/25 3681/23
dampers [24] 3757/25 3758/9 3758/12
countries [1] 3739/14
3758/21 3760/9 3762/18 3762/20
couple [14] 3662/21 3667/1 3672/6
3762/23 3804/13 3804/15 3805/2
3685/18 3693/22 3693/23 3704/22
3805/10 3805/13 3808/4 3811/18 3814/7
3706/10 3744/9 3750/8 3770/9 3777/12 3814/12 3814/14 3814/20 3815/8
3796/16 3834/18
3815/11 3823/7 3823/15 3823/16
course [9] 3731/15 3731/25 3732/12
danger [4] 3792/23 3812/10 3813/4
3737/20 3738/5 3747/17 3749/16
3814/17
3753/25 3767/6
dangerous [4] 3737/20 3792/20 3795/7
court [20] 3655/1 3660/18 3685/4
3795/9
3692/11 3700/5 3715/5 3715/9 3726/8
DANIEL [1] 3658/4
3730/7 3735/9 3757/7 3764/1 3769/15
darn [1] 3708/7
3793/5 3794/25 3795/20 3803/20 3836/9 data [8] 3663/20 3670/22 3673/18
3836/10 3836/18
3691/22 3723/10 3725/20 3726/4 3726/9
Court's [1] 3721/18
database [2] 3798/15 3809/10
covered [1] 3766/24
date [10] 3783/23 3783/25 3787/17
Covington [1] 3659/2
3790/13 3797/11 3797/13 3797/13
craft [2] 3656/15 3781/19
3801/4 3801/5 3815/14
crane [1] 3750/23
dated [7] 3772/16 3773/18 3774/24
crankcase [2] 3757/11 3757/15
3777/12 3787/6 3795/23 3803/24
cranny [1] 3752/19
dating [2] 3798/23 3809/11
create [1] 3737/13
Daubert [1] 3727/25
created [1] 3672/21
Daun [1] 3787/6
crew [41] 3670/7 3683/20 3698/4
Dauphin [1] 3656/3
3706/18 3713/13 3730/18 3737/4
DAVID [4] 3660/3 3660/3 3798/14
3737/11 3745/20 3747/19 3750/2 3750/5 3801/9
3750/5 3751/2 3760/20 3764/2 3764/14 day [17] 3655/14 3664/18 3664/19
3666/14 3669/14 3674/6 3677/16 3686/6

3705/24 3710/5 3749/12 3750/5 3752/14
3752/14 3758/11 3802/16 3809/3
days [5] 3712/19 3750/6 3790/24 3817/8
3817/8
deadline [1] 3819/10
deal [2] 3761/13 3832/15
dealing [2] 3779/17 3800/10
deals [1] 3777/15
dealt [1] 3728/18
DEANNA [1] 3657/18
death [5] 3791/2 3817/5 3831/23
3832/12 3834/1
decided [1] 3737/5
decision [2] 3687/20 3726/9
decisions [1] 3747/7
deck [17] 3696/2 3696/3 3696/3 3696/13
3699/11 3700/21 3700/25 3701/3 3701/4
3701/12 3701/13 3701/15 3701/16
3701/16 3701/23 3701/23 3832/17
decks [1] 3832/7
decrease [3] 3675/20 3680/18 3692/5
decreased [1] 3693/7
decreasing [1] 3692/3
deemed [1] 3809/11
deepwater [69] 3655/4 3659/6 3659/7
3659/9 3659/10 3659/13 3659/13
3659/17 3659/17 3659/20 3659/21
3664/8 3667/6 3672/9 3672/11 3683/21
3722/11 3726/3 3737/25 3738/2 3738/9
3738/19 3739/3 3739/17 3744/25 3745/7
3747/17 3751/25 3754/21 3755/11
3761/7 3764/2 3765/5 3768/16 3768/19
3772/15 3772/17 3773/17 3774/21
3775/17 3776/8 3776/9 3777/16 3781/2
3782/17 3783/6 3783/11 3788/14
3790/10 3791/23 3797/10 3800/2
3800/25 3801/2 3801/7 3801/21 3804/1
3806/6 3809/1 3810/8 3818/22 3825/21
3828/14 3828/17 3828/24 3829/13
3829/18 3830/11 3830/12
Deepwater Horizon [51] 3664/8 3667/6
3672/9 3672/11 3683/21 3722/11 3726/3
3737/25 3738/2 3738/9 3738/19 3739/3
3739/17 3744/25 3745/7 3747/17
3751/25 3754/21 3755/11 3761/7 3764/2
3765/5 3768/16 3768/19 3772/15
3772/17 3773/17 3774/21 3775/17
3776/9 3777/16 3782/17 3783/6 3783/11
3790/10 3791/23 3800/2 3800/25
3801/21 3804/1 3806/6 3809/1 3810/8
3818/22 3825/21 3828/14 3828/24
3829/13 3829/18 3830/11 3830/12
defect [3] 3806/6 3806/14 3833/18
defective [6] 3808/3 3815/19 3816/1
3823/14 3824/4 3824/11
defects [6] 3766/17 3806/11 3807/8
3815/21 3824/5 3834/6
defense [1] 3808/18
deficiencies [14] 3737/19 3740/16
3746/12 3753/22 3781/8 3785/5 3786/16
3791/5 3791/6 3800/20 3802/20 3812/5
3812/11 3827/18
deficiency [5] 3777/25 3784/19 3785/2
3827/24 3828/8
define [2] 3746/6 3778/2
defined [2] 3743/16 3778/20
defines [1] 3777/18
definitely [4] 3678/4 3684/24 3801/23
3825/10
Definition [1] 3777/19
deGravelles [2] 3657/2 3657/3
degree [1] 3729/18
D
degrees [1] 3749/8
delay [1] 3826/14
delayed [1] 3810/24
DELEMARRE [1] 3657/23
deleted [1] 3827/20
deleting [1] 3828/22
demonstrable [2] 3811/3 3811/7
demonstrate [2] 3788/24 3789/8
demonstrative [2] 3690/8 3695/4
demonstratives [1] 3721/16
DENISE [1] 3660/15
department [6] 3657/11 3657/15 3657/21
3658/2 3793/6 3793/7
departure [1] 3774/8
depend [1] 3663/3
dependent [1] 3776/6
depending [2] 3696/23 3749/5
depends [3] 3702/9 3726/5 3758/21
depict [1] 3679/20
depicted [1] 3757/22
depicts [2] 3756/8 3759/23
deposed [1] 3736/14
deposition [14] 3674/24 3685/7 3685/12
3685/19 3686/9 3686/10 3689/9 3702/7
3704/13 3704/15 3707/24 3708/1
3708/16 3709/14
depositions [1] 3764/1
depth [1] 3776/7
Derby [1] 3737/3
describe [2] 3747/24 3788/13
described [17] 3663/8 3664/21 3666/16
3670/3 3671/3 3671/6 3672/13 3679/19
3694/24 3695/9 3695/20 3702/4 3702/16
3732/13 3739/24 3758/25 3760/7
describing [1] 3695/21
description [4] 3690/3 3777/25 3791/22
3791/25
design [4] 3733/2 3774/7 3774/15
3774/21
designate [1] 3743/25
designated [28] 3699/7 3737/14 3737/15
3743/22 3744/2 3744/10 3744/20 3745/3
3745/9 3745/19 3745/23 3765/22
3765/24 3767/3 3767/13 3778/22 3779/9
3779/20 3779/24 3786/19 3786/22
3800/15 3800/18 3801/18 3801/20
3801/24 3830/20 3830/20
designation [3] 3748/11 3778/21 3779/4
designations [1] 3779/1
designed [8] 3711/6 3759/17 3759/19
3760/2 3761/1 3761/16 3761/19 3762/1
Det [2] 3785/13 3797/9
detail [2] 3737/23 3739/23
detailed [1] 3796/15
details [2] 3734/4 3793/15
detect [2] 3684/5 3761/1
detectable [2] 3694/20 3694/25
detection [10] 3684/1 3782/24 3783/5
3792/1 3795/1 3806/25 3818/10 3818/18
3824/23 3833/20
detector [6] 3710/23 3757/9 3757/10
3757/11 3774/9 3818/15
detectors [9] 3710/25 3756/20 3757/4
3774/10 3806/10 3806/17 3806/24
3816/17 3816/19
determine [3] 3810/23 3819/12 3826/16
determined [1] 3826/20
determining [2] 3788/21 3789/1
develop [2] 3743/3 3745/22
developments [1] 3679/9
deviation [1] 3741/8
device [5] 3734/23 3734/24 3763/6

3763/6 3763/7
devices [2] 3756/18 3812/23
Dexter [1] 3658/9
diagram [1] 3756/3
did [94] 3669/7 3669/10 3670/14
3670/17 3670/18 3677/5 3677/13
3677/15 3678/24 3680/11 3680/22
3680/23 3682/19 3683/2 3683/10
3683/17 3686/6 3686/8 3686/12 3689/16
3689/22 3694/12 3694/13 3698/10
3703/22 3704/4 3704/8 3704/10 3705/24
3711/8 3711/11 3712/5 3712/9 3713/16
3713/19 3714/5 3714/7 3714/12 3714/15
3716/18 3718/11 3721/1 3722/20 3723/4
3723/7 3723/10 3724/9 3725/10 3725/12
3731/10 3731/15 3732/22 3737/13
3737/24 3738/1 3738/2 3738/4 3738/9
3738/15 3738/16 3739/3 3745/6 3747/14
3747/16 3747/20 3750/22 3753/15
3753/16 3755/11 3764/9 3774/11
3774/12 3776/14 3777/6 3790/23
3792/16 3792/17 3793/17 3793/18
3794/7 3794/10 3808/11 3809/3 3820/22
3820/23 3828/11 3828/12 3832/20
3833/1 3833/5 3833/9 3833/15 3834/7
3835/25
didn't [28] 3668/23 3669/12 3677/21
3677/22 3677/22 3686/6 3686/12 3689/6
3689/20 3689/22 3689/23 3689/25
3698/8 3707/22 3708/3 3710/4 3712/22
3713/4 3720/21 3721/10 3730/22
3766/14 3778/11 3780/5 3780/15
3788/16 3832/21 3834/8
diesel [4] 3733/21 3733/23 3757/12
3808/18
different [11] 3674/5 3676/17 3684/14
3689/24 3692/19 3692/19 3716/10
3720/20 3731/18 3768/4 3830/23
difficult [1] 3769/6
digital [4] 3663/5 3664/4 3664/5 3671/18
dimensional [1] 3783/22
dioptric [1] 3734/23
dioxide [1] 3759/7
Diploma [1] 3729/17
DIRE [1] 3727/16
direct [5] 3736/8 3740/4 3744/1 3744/11
3779/24
director [1] 3801/13
disabled [2] 3765/16 3806/10
disables [1] 3793/1
disagree [1] 3812/13
disarmed [1] 3711/14
disassembly [1] 3783/21
discharge [2] 3667/25 3668/11
disconnect [11] 3749/20 3770/13
3771/10 3771/17 3771/21 3775/3
3775/22 3775/23 3775/24 3776/3 3776/5
disconnecting [1] 3776/1
disconnection [1] 3776/12
discover [1] 3766/17
discovered [2] 3766/11 3828/2
discuss [1] 3802/19
discussed [2] 3666/18 3784/22
discussion [3] 3668/19 3671/8 3733/16
displacement [9] 3666/18 3666/22
3667/6 3667/24 3668/24 3669/2 3669/10
3692/1 3698/11
displacements [1] 3674/20
displacing [2] 3675/13 3693/5
display [1] 3663/2
displayed [2] 3779/4 3822/12
displays [1] 3722/25
dispute [4] 3708/11 3720/9 3721/12

3734/15
disregard [1] 3812/1
disrepair [1] 3711/15
distracted [1] 3674/13
Distribution [1] 3812/20
district [6] 3655/1 3655/2 3655/15 3735/9
3836/10 3836/10
diversion [2] 3697/11 3698/9
diverted [2] 3698/4 3698/11
Division [2] 3657/12 3657/22
divisions [1] 3732/8
DNV [11] 3738/23 3739/1 3739/2
3752/14 3752/21 3779/10 3790/19
3800/25 3808/25 3827/1 3828/1
do [144] 3667/13 3668/13 3671/9
3671/20 3673/11 3673/23 3674/3 3674/6
3674/10 3674/21 3674/25 3675/10
3677/2 3677/25 3679/2 3679/17 3680/1
3680/3 3680/4 3680/6 3680/9 3681/5
3681/10 3682/15 3683/12 3683/15
3683/19 3685/3 3685/7 3685/14 3687/2
3687/12 3687/21 3688/1 3690/16
3690/19 3690/21 3691/1 3691/13
3691/18 3691/19 3691/21 3692/8 3692/9
3692/24 3693/13 3693/15 3693/20
3694/14 3694/17 3695/5 3695/12 3697/5
3699/1 3700/5 3701/24 3702/7 3703/10
3711/13 3712/11 3712/16 3714/22
3714/25 3715/2 3715/12 3715/17
3715/23 3718/22 3720/9 3722/4 3722/20
3723/15 3723/18 3723/21 3724/22
3725/25 3726/3 3726/9 3728/23 3729/21
3730/24 3732/22 3733/21 3733/23
3734/7 3736/4 3737/10 3740/5 3740/6
3741/20 3741/22 3742/20 3742/20
3744/20 3748/10 3749/10 3752/22
3753/1 3756/6 3756/7 3756/15 3758/1
3758/2 3758/25 3761/16 3762/4 3763/17
3763/17 3764/10 3764/10 3766/15
3766/16 3771/23 3772/1 3779/14
3780/17 3781/10 3786/24 3787/8 3787/9
3788/11 3788/12 3800/12 3800/14
3800/21 3803/16 3806/20 3808/8
3808/10 3811/20 3812/4 3812/8 3813/3
3813/9 3813/17 3813/23 3815/10
3821/21 3823/11 3827/9 3834/15 3835/3
3835/9 3836/11
DOC [3] 3738/8 3827/3 3827/4
dock [2] 3732/5 3809/24
Docket [3] 3655/4 3655/7 3655/9
document [34] 3666/25 3679/24 3693/11
3693/16 3714/22 3719/24 3728/16
3738/8 3746/6 3768/24 3772/7 3772/9
3773/23 3774/21 3777/13 3777/19
3777/22 3778/2 3780/24 3781/4 3785/13
3788/5 3788/11 3797/8 3798/17 3799/5
3799/14 3799/17 3800/24 3803/21
3803/22 3807/6 3815/17 3827/5
Documentation [1] 3772/25
documented [2] 3742/23 3778/20
documents [7] 3727/22 3739/12 3763/25
3772/10 3776/14 3783/24 3794/9
does [59] 3684/3 3684/7 3684/9 3684/9
3689/15 3697/13 3737/24 3738/18
3739/15 3744/8 3744/13 3744/14
3747/25 3748/1 3752/8 3756/24 3758/13
3762/6 3766/3 3767/13 3769/10 3774/16
3777/4 3777/20 3778/4 3778/5 3785/7
3788/3 3790/3 3793/2 3798/18 3799/8
3800/3 3804/1 3804/11 3809/25 3810/12
3811/23 3814/15 3814/16 3817/8
3817/11 3821/6 3822/3 3822/19 3824/14
D
does... [13] 3825/8 3826/2 3826/3
3829/22 3829/23 3831/22 3831/24
3832/11 3832/13 3833/13 3833/25
3834/3 3835/6
doesn't [7] 3690/4 3692/6 3705/25
3719/3 3726/11 3756/23 3758/21
doing [9] 3665/16 3678/8 3709/5 3715/6
3715/11 3750/3 3767/23 3792/20
3821/10
dollar [1] 3734/17
Domengeaux [1] 3655/18
dominant [2] 3770/10 3770/11
Dominion [1] 3656/16
DON [1] 3658/19
don't [38] 3669/11 3674/23 3678/18
3680/19 3684/5 3685/3 3685/11 3690/4
3690/12 3693/8 3699/16 3700/9 3700/14
3700/17 3700/18 3704/13 3705/1
3705/25 3716/22 3717/8 3719/5 3721/7
3723/2 3727/3 3734/14 3749/18 3757/5
3766/19 3772/4 3792/22 3796/24
3798/19 3804/6 3807/24 3817/21 3820/9
3822/24 3823/12
DONALD [1] 3660/7
done [17] 3666/20 3698/12 3704/11
3735/2 3749/15 3767/11 3776/15 3777/7
3782/9 3792/22 3794/6 3806/25 3809/3
3815/3 3815/4 3821/17 3829/18
door [5] 3701/7 3701/8 3703/2 3703/8
3703/19
doors [7] 3755/24 3756/1 3762/8
3762/10 3762/12 3762/12 3832/18
double [1] 3729/6
doubt [2] 3760/25 3798/22
Doug [1] 3772/19
DOUGLAS [1] 3658/16
down [57] 3664/3 3665/12 3665/22
3668/12 3682/25 3690/12 3691/11
3692/25 3693/2 3693/3 3694/9 3694/17
3696/9 3696/12 3696/15 3697/6 3700/24
3701/1 3701/8 3702/4 3702/9 3702/14
3703/3 3709/11 3710/21 3711/6 3711/9
3720/23 3721/2 3722/16 3723/1 3723/2
3723/19 3741/15 3755/20 3757/20
3758/17 3758/17 3759/14 3759/19
3760/2 3760/19 3762/22 3763/21
3765/14 3769/2 3771/6 3785/25 3794/16
3797/16 3801/12 3806/2 3809/21
3811/16 3813/1 3813/7 3834/18
downgraded [1] 3828/6
downhole [1] 3718/1
downtime [1] 3781/9
downward [1] 3759/8
DOYEN [1] 3659/12
Doyle [4] 3660/18 3836/9 3836/17
3836/17
DP [5] 3734/9 3748/11 3749/10 3751/1
3810/9
DPA [4] 3737/14 3766/22 3830/20
3830/23
DPO [1] 3751/7
DPOs [1] 3826/15
draw [2] 3693/11 3694/12
drawing [2] 3756/6 3756/23
drawworks [2] 3701/7 3702/18
dredges [1] 3731/18
dredging [6] 3730/11 3730/15 3730/19
3730/21 3730/24 3732/12
Drescher [1] 3656/8
drift [2] 3734/13 3748/25
drift-offs [1] 3734/13
drill [45] 3663/23 3671/4 3671/24 3672/2

3675/11 3675/23 3676/2 3676/13
3678/15 3680/3 3680/22 3681/8 3681/13
3682/8 3683/3 3683/13 3685/8 3686/16
3688/4 3688/10 3688/12 3689/11
3695/10 3695/12 3695/14 3695/17
3695/17 3695/20 3696/11 3696/15
3696/18 3698/4 3702/23 3702/24
3724/24 3731/19 3764/24 3765/3 3765/4
3770/24 3810/21 3821/25 3821/25
3822/8 3822/20
drilled [1] 3717/16
driller [7] 3663/4 3672/23 3822/14
3822/14 3822/21 3822/21 3827/16
driller's [8] 3678/12 3680/15 3683/2
3764/25 3765/1 3775/6 3822/8 3822/11
drilling [26] 3659/6 3659/9 3659/13
3659/17 3659/20 3669/4 3672/14
3734/12 3746/24 3748/3 3748/3 3748/8
3748/14 3749/25 3750/4 3776/8 3781/21
3788/14 3797/10 3801/2 3801/7 3803/4
3803/23 3817/10 3824/12 3828/18
drills [3] 3719/14 3831/8 3831/19
drive [7] 3656/16 3656/19 3702/23
3811/1 3811/6 3821/23 3821/24
drives [1] 3806/3
dry [2] 3732/4 3809/24
due [5] 3757/18 3793/25 3806/11
3809/12 3814/13
DUKE [1] 3656/19
duly [2] 3662/16 3727/11
dumped [4] 3693/18 3693/20 3694/7
3723/19
dumping [4] 3690/23 3691/12 3693/12
3725/6
duration [1] 3797/24
during [34] 3663/2 3665/3 3665/23
3668/5 3669/1 3669/9 3669/19 3669/22
3671/1 3674/2 3674/20 3676/19 3679/9
3682/14 3682/21 3698/3 3704/6 3742/9
3766/11 3767/11 3772/9 3776/2 3778/16
3781/18 3786/8 3791/2 3808/3 3812/22
3815/9 3818/14 3823/8 3827/22 3828/1
3828/14
Dutch [1] 3730/11
duties [10] 3669/15 3673/17 3674/14
3712/3 3712/10 3715/2 3715/10 3725/23
3731/24 3732/13
duty [3] 3669/19 3670/10 3751/2
DWOP [1] 3824/15
dynamic [3] 3749/10 3751/1 3810/14
dynamically [2] 3734/22 3748/11
Edwards [1] 3655/19

effect [3] 3781/13 3824/25 3825/4
effective [1] 3741/11
effectively [4] 3785/3 3790/1 3792/25
3831/25
effectiveness [1] 3827/21
effects [3] 3774/8 3774/15 3818/13
EH [1] 3775/4
EH-MUX [1] 3775/4
eight [6] 3722/18 3722/20 3748/17
3748/19 3794/24 3827/17
either [9] 3663/5 3689/23 3710/5 3714/5
3761/2 3767/7 3789/23 3806/10 3810/23
electric [1] 3734/24
electrical [1] 3762/5
electrically [1] 3760/11
electronic [2] 3760/23 3763/7
element [1] 3752/17
elements [1] 3770/15
ELIZABETH [1] 3658/5
Ellis [1] 3658/21
Elm [1] 3660/9
else [9] 3716/15 3729/24 3739/7
3763/21 3777/6 3794/10 3808/17
3830/21 3834/17
emergencies [1] 3742/6
emergency [32] 3747/21 3747/24
3755/23 3759/12 3760/17 3761/1 3761/2
3761/6 3761/8 3761/12 3761/13 3761/20
3762/2 3762/15 3762/17 3764/11 3766/4
3770/13 3775/24 3776/2 3776/21 3779/3
3805/24 3812/6 3812/6 3812/15 3814/3
3814/10 3825/5 3826/17 3831/8 3831/19
EMPAC [13] 3781/8 3781/11 3781/12
3793/10 3793/11 3793/13 3793/20
3794/5 3794/11 3807/10 3816/18
3816/20 3821/16
emphasizing [1] 3747/4
employee [1] 3719/1
EMS [1] 3799/19
enacted [4] 3736/24 3737/7 3739/7
3831/13
enclosed [1] 3832/1
encoder [1] 3734/23
encountered [1] 3812/21
end [6] 3669/17 3678/6 3701/6 3780/13
3797/23 3809/20
endanger [1] 3808/8
ended [1] 3786/1
Energy [3] 3660/7 3660/11 3732/9
Enforcement [1] 3657/16
engaged [2] 3736/10 3748/3
engagements [2] 3734/4 3734/5
E
engine [44] 3711/10 3733/22 3757/3
e-mail [8] 3712/16 3712/18 3713/4
3757/3 3757/7 3757/12 3757/12 3757/17
3713/5 3714/16 3714/17 3829/10
3757/20 3759/5 3759/24 3759/25 3760/4
3829/21
3760/8 3760/9 3760/10 3762/20 3762/22
each [4] 3709/5 3709/8 3743/23 3744/4 3762/23 3763/3 3763/5 3763/13 3763/14
earlier [20] 3666/14 3666/25 3668/15
3763/19 3804/13 3808/5 3808/11
3671/8 3671/11 3676/24 3677/9 3679/24 3808/18 3810/25 3812/22 3812/23
3680/25 3681/21 3695/4 3697/20
3813/7 3813/8 3813/11 3814/2 3814/6
3706/11 3710/20 3776/22 3783/3 3796/4 3815/8 3816/5 3816/9 3823/7 3823/9
3797/21 3815/3 3830/19
3823/13 3823/13 3826/10
early [4] 3664/14 3768/18 3769/24
engine's [1] 3763/21
3770/19
engineer [14] 3706/5 3709/1 3709/18
ease [1] 3745/22
3714/8 3730/2 3730/4 3732/3 3732/4
easier [1] 3740/7
3732/18 3732/19 3732/20 3732/21
EASTERN [2] 3655/2 3836/10
3737/17 3745/15
economic [1] 3803/4
engineer's [2] 3701/5 3774/8
EDS [5] 3770/16 3770/16 3770/20
engineering [7] 3729/18 3729/19
3775/24 3776/20
3735/19 3735/25 3772/9 3772/10
educational [1] 3729/15
3795/22
Edward [1] 3727/14
engineers [3] 3705/21 3729/25 3732/1
E
engines [5] 3733/23 3763/1 3763/15
3813/1 3813/12
England [1] 3729/20
enormous [1] 3699/5
enough [4] 3749/18 3792/25 3793/12
3796/15
ensure [13] 3741/17 3743/11 3743/23
3747/3 3753/11 3767/25 3771/10 3775/4
3775/11 3803/11 3815/12 3823/17
3827/6
ensuring [3] 3744/5 3751/17 3784/24
enter [1] 3760/9
entered [2] 3796/15 3821/15
entering [1] 3738/20
Enterprise [1] 3737/1
enters [1] 3759/25
entire [5] 3670/14 3695/14 3695/21
3705/4 3723/7
entirety [1] 3738/3
entities [1] 3790/19
entitled [1] 3836/14
environment [8] 3657/16 3737/9 3741/9
3741/18 3741/19 3741/25 3743/12
3829/7
environmental [6] 3657/16 3742/7
3743/8 3746/8 3799/18 3799/19
EQE [1] 3768/17
EQE International [1] 3768/17
equations [1] 3749/6
equipment [40] 3714/24 3731/10
3731/19 3748/14 3750/16 3753/9
3753/18 3754/7 3754/11 3754/13
3754/22 3755/3 3755/19 3756/11
3759/22 3762/5 3772/13 3776/6 3781/9
3782/1 3782/17 3782/23 3783/18 3784/2
3795/25 3796/18 3807/8 3808/3 3809/10
3809/20 3815/19 3815/20 3816/1
3821/21 3824/4 3824/5 3824/11 3833/17
3834/4 3834/5
equipment/system [1] 3776/6
ESD [16] 3759/10 3759/12 3759/20
3760/13 3761/19 3761/25 3763/3 3764/7
3764/18 3776/17 3777/1 3808/11 3816/9
3816/11 3822/13 3822/20
ESDs [1] 3814/2
especially [4] 3761/9 3806/8 3809/22
3834/12
ESQ [58] 3655/19 3655/23 3656/3
3656/6 3656/9 3656/12 3656/15 3656/19
3656/22 3657/3 3657/6 3657/9 3657/12
3657/17 3657/17 3657/18 3657/18
3657/19 3657/22 3657/23 3657/23
3657/24 3657/24 3658/4 3658/4 3658/5
3658/8 3658/8 3658/9 3658/12 3658/15
3658/16 3658/19 3658/22 3658/22
3658/23 3659/3 3659/6 3659/9 3659/9
3659/12 3659/13 3659/13 3659/16
3659/20 3659/23 3660/3 3660/3 3660/4
3660/4 3660/7 3660/8 3660/8 3660/9
3660/12 3660/15 3660/15 3660/16
essential [2] 3771/19 3820/14
essentially [1] 3790/24
establish [6] 3742/3 3747/5 3747/23
3751/21 3753/11 3754/6
established [1] 3753/14
establishing [1] 3791/8
estimate [1] 3806/20
et [2] 3655/8 3655/11
etc [1] 3832/2
Europe [1] 3737/2
European [1] 3736/22
European-based [1] 3736/22

evacuation [1] 3775/13
evaluation [1] 3799/25
even [8] 3672/23 3677/15 3713/4
3755/24 3763/13 3763/19 3781/15
3819/24
evening [22] 3664/7 3664/9 3668/21
3670/19 3670/22 3674/18 3674/22
3675/2 3677/1 3677/5 3680/11 3691/23
3694/20 3694/25 3704/2 3704/8 3706/11
3707/21 3708/2 3710/21 3711/16
3715/11
event [10] 3672/21 3718/10 3758/23
3762/17 3764/10 3775/13 3806/22
3808/16 3814/9 3814/16
eventually [1] 3732/21
ever [20] 3670/18 3677/23 3697/22
3704/7 3705/25 3714/15 3715/20
3716/14 3719/16 3732/17 3732/24
3733/2 3733/8 3734/1 3735/7 3735/11
3735/21 3745/6 3776/15 3777/7
every [14] 3665/13 3698/11 3718/2
3718/4 3726/3 3726/25 3743/3 3743/25
3752/14 3752/19 3778/1 3785/21 3791/4
3820/14
everybody [2] 3728/22 3835/4
everyone [3] 3662/3 3768/8 3836/4
everything [9] 3665/16 3677/22 3749/15
3758/5 3763/23 3763/24 3769/23 3777/6
3794/10
evidence [10] 3720/25 3721/10 3740/9
3776/14 3778/14 3778/15 3778/18
3778/19 3794/10 3833/7
ex [1] 3832/14
ex-mariner [1] 3832/14
exacerbate [1] 3812/6
exactly [7] 3678/18 3721/7 3723/2
3744/15 3764/9 3766/12 3808/15
examination [8] 3662/6 3662/17 3695/5
3705/9 3710/18 3721/22 3736/4 3736/8
examinations [1] 3716/1
example [9] 3737/12 3740/13 3755/24
3756/20 3759/24 3760/18 3778/21
3784/13 3790/23
Examples [1] 3823/9
exceed [1] 3776/7
exceeded [1] 3676/12
exceeding [1] 3784/1
excess [1] 3667/11
excuse [6] 3688/6 3715/8 3715/19
3716/5 3785/24 3829/25
execute [1] 3803/8
executed [1] 3810/18
execution [2] 3811/3 3811/7
executive [4] 3772/11 3783/14 3802/6
3802/10
exemplary [1] 3781/23
exhaust [2] 3808/5 3823/14
exhibit [7] 3690/8 3727/2 3768/15
3780/19 3780/21 3782/14 3818/10
Exhibit 4275 [1] 3768/15
Exhibit TREX-81 [1] 3782/14
exhibits [4] 3662/5 3662/7 3662/9
3721/16
existing [3] 3788/21 3789/2 3806/6
exists [2] 3828/7 3828/9
expand [2] 3663/9 3679/19
expect [2] 3693/4 3764/15
expectation [1] 3765/24
expected [4] 3684/11 3764/13 3764/14
3776/7
experience [8] 3722/11 3730/8 3761/5
3777/14 3779/14 3785/19 3804/11
3813/15
experienced [4] 3794/5 3794/11 3803/10
3814/12
expert [41] 3735/7 3735/11 3735/15
3735/18 3735/21 3735/25 3736/11
3736/12 3750/10 3750/13 3769/24
3770/3 3770/5 3770/5 3770/5 3782/6
3783/5 3792/18 3795/11 3798/24
3800/12 3804/18 3806/5 3806/15
3807/15 3808/12 3811/5 3811/24 3812/8
3813/3 3813/16 3814/15 3817/11
3818/16 3819/15 3821/15 3822/16
3826/2 3831/22 3834/2 3834/9
expertise [4] 3733/21 3761/5 3769/20
3794/3
explain [9] 3716/25 3726/8 3731/23
3734/4 3740/12 3756/8 3759/10 3759/22
3784/8
explained [3] 3686/1 3797/21 3813/3
explanatory [1] 3754/14
explode [1] 3763/16
exploration [5] 3655/10 3658/18 3658/21
3659/2 3748/3
explosion [5] 3670/11 3670/19 3672/4
3673/17 3674/10
explosive [2] 3760/6 3792/21
express [4] 3669/7 3669/12 3734/9
3734/20
expressed [1] 3804/25
extension [2] 3725/14 3827/3
extensions [1] 3725/14
extent [1] 3793/25
external [1] 3827/15
extra [1] 3702/24
extreme [2] 3792/23 3813/4
extremely [5] 3746/1 3754/22 3755/5
3755/15 3769/6
F
face [1] 3787/17
facility [1] 3807/10
facing [1] 3700/6
fact [15] 3669/12 3697/16 3708/7
3710/25 3713/18 3767/1 3794/14 3805/4
3811/5 3811/23 3812/1 3812/13 3820/12
3821/11 3833/25
factor [1] 3771/16
fail [1] 3821/21
failed [6] 3734/25 3805/16 3812/23
3812/25 3814/8 3816/9
fails [2] 3763/21 3808/17
failsafe [1] 3796/9
failsafe/subsea [1] 3796/9
failure [17] 3754/8 3769/3 3769/6
3770/10 3770/11 3770/12 3770/14
3770/15 3770/15 3770/16 3771/13
3771/17 3771/17 3773/9 3782/10
3831/19 3834/10
fair [8] 3699/16 3730/25 3751/7 3760/21
3760/23 3797/25 3813/18 3829/7
fairly [1] 3743/2
fairness [2] 3708/14 3806/17
false [3] 3826/19 3826/20 3826/20
familiar [4] 3706/1 3725/19 3746/15
3746/19
Fannin [1] 3659/10
fans [4] 3755/21 3759/21 3760/3 3760/3
far [8] 3665/18 3667/17 3667/23 3677/15
3696/22 3703/7 3798/23 3801/24
fashion [1] 3819/21
fast [1] 3760/19
fault [6] 3822/12 3822/13 3822/15
3822/22 3822/25 3823/1
F
FCRR [3] 3660/18 3836/9 3836/17
feature [1] 3807/12
features [2] 3763/3 3765/15
February [2] 3728/3 3728/7
February 20 [1] 3728/7
federal [3] 3657/13 3735/8 3811/12
feed [1] 3805/9
feedback [1] 3767/6
feeding [1] 3763/13
feeling [3] 3713/7 3713/22 3714/13
fellow [2] 3729/22 3729/25
felt [6] 3672/11 3672/18 3673/10
3673/11 3706/22 3714/4
few [12] 3694/3 3694/9 3706/9 3710/17
3715/17 3717/17 3721/25 3723/15
3729/13 3781/23 3793/11 3801/7
fiberoptic [1] 3734/25
field [1] 3735/7
figure [3] 3700/6 3700/11 3700/19
file [1] 3801/23
filed [3] 3727/25 3728/3 3728/9
files [4] 3781/18 3781/22 3781/25 3785/8
filter [1] 3795/12
filtering [2] 3794/20 3795/14
final [2] 3768/17 3774/24
find [3] 3713/12 3716/9 3766/18
finding [9] 3777/23 3778/18 3784/17
3789/1 3789/12 3790/2 3793/20 3798/25
3822/17
findings [14] 3786/12 3787/16 3787/18
3787/23 3788/18 3800/12 3800/15
3802/19 3811/16 3812/4 3813/3 3829/18
3829/22 3831/6
finds [1] 3767/11
fine [5] 3700/17 3700/17 3702/12 3727/8
3727/9
finish [3] 3709/8 3747/12 3751/10
finished [2] 3693/12 3726/19
fire [65] 3740/14 3740/15 3756/15
3756/24 3757/4 3757/21 3757/25
3757/25 3758/5 3758/9 3758/12 3758/14
3758/14 3758/15 3758/17 3758/18
3758/21 3758/23 3759/1 3759/6 3759/6
3759/9 3760/18 3761/25 3762/8 3762/10
3762/12 3762/13 3764/6 3764/17
3773/22 3774/3 3774/9 3782/24 3783/5
3804/13 3804/15 3804/22 3804/23
3805/2 3805/5 3805/7 3805/9 3806/25
3808/4 3811/17 3811/18 3813/7 3814/16
3815/8 3815/11 3816/17 3816/19
3822/11 3822/12 3822/13 3822/13
3823/7 3823/10 3823/13 3823/16
3823/19 3832/6 3832/16 3833/20
firefighting [5] 3755/23 3758/1 3758/25
3759/1 3833/17
firewall [1] 3702/2
firm [3] 3656/21 3657/8 3734/8
first [24] 3676/10 3701/16 3701/23
3703/22 3712/13 3717/16 3724/1
3726/13 3751/5 3751/6 3764/23 3772/11
3780/6 3783/25 3784/4 3787/20 3788/16
3796/17 3804/24 3817/16 3823/19
3824/7 3825/2 3831/8
five [8] 3703/7 3703/8 3725/1 3732/10
3783/21 3793/11 3819/9 3834/22
five-year [2] 3783/21 3819/9
fix [4] 3737/20 3753/2 3807/23 3820/9
fixed [1] 3833/20
flag [15] 3731/3 3733/9 3738/9 3738/20
3741/2 3741/3 3741/3 3743/13 3752/7
3752/23 3753/6 3765/20 3767/22
3767/22 3827/25
flagged [1] 3738/12
flammable [2] 3763/20 3808/19
flash [1] 3826/10
fleet [3] 3732/6 3732/20 3801/22
flew [1] 3738/11
flight [3] 3700/25 3702/4 3703/15
flipped [1] 3737/1
flood [1] 3805/21
floor [28] 3656/13 3659/14 3685/10
3686/18 3686/22 3688/12 3688/17
3689/13 3689/18 3690/4 3695/9 3695/12
3695/15 3695/17 3695/21 3696/11
3696/15 3700/25 3701/2 3701/2 3702/2
3721/1 3721/11 3724/25 3725/10
3725/15 3726/3 3807/8
flow [53] 3668/17 3671/4 3671/4 3671/8
3671/11 3671/16 3671/19 3678/4 3678/5
3678/14 3683/23 3683/23 3684/19
3684/20 3684/22 3684/23 3684/24
3690/23 3691/5 3691/6 3691/7 3691/8
3691/9 3691/10 3691/13 3691/19
3693/15 3693/21 3694/15 3694/23
3696/9 3697/1 3697/3 3697/4 3697/7
3697/13 3697/16 3697/16 3697/17
3697/18 3697/23 3698/3 3698/6 3698/9
3722/16 3722/19 3722/21 3723/22
3724/2 3724/3 3725/8 3757/22 3759/20
flow-in [7] 3671/4 3671/8 3671/11
3671/16 3671/19 3684/22 3691/10
flow-out [11] 3671/4 3683/23 3684/23
3684/24 3691/6 3691/7 3693/15 3694/15
3694/23 3723/22 3725/8
flowing [2] 3723/25 3724/9
FLOYD [2] 3660/8 3721/21
fluids [2] 3668/16 3669/4
fly [1] 3738/9
focus [4] 3680/19 3719/25 3798/15
3827/23
focused [1] 3761/12
folks [2] 3798/2 3829/11
follow [12] 3682/15 3778/10 3785/9
3786/11 3786/16 3787/19 3787/22
3788/17 3807/19 3807/20 3816/6 3828/1
follow-up [10] 3785/9 3786/11 3786/16
3787/19 3787/22 3788/17 3807/19
3807/20 3816/6 3828/1
following [6] 3743/4 3771/13 3778/25
3804/10 3827/6 3835/5
follows [2] 3662/16 3727/11
force [2] 3731/14 3739/9
foregoing [1] 3836/11
Forex [2] 3772/20 3774/22
forgotten [1] 3770/6
form [1] 3754/17
formal [2] 3815/18 3824/2
formally [3] 3807/9 3815/25 3824/10
formation [2] 3715/18 3715/21
formations [1] 3718/12
forms [1] 3742/21
forth [6] 3679/6 3696/9 3722/10 3726/7
3813/3 3822/3
forward [4] 3675/15 3776/14 3783/25
3788/17
found [11] 3734/22 3740/14 3777/25
3778/16 3778/19 3781/22 3789/3
3804/14 3805/10 3815/9 3823/8
foundation [2] 3711/18 3712/22
four [4] 3703/8 3725/4 3797/13 3797/13
frame [1] 3723/22
France [1] 3731/8
Francisco [1] 3657/14
Franklin [1] 3658/5
Fraud [1] 3658/3

free [3] 3737/1 3833/18 3834/6
frequency [2] 3815/12 3823/17
frequently [1] 3781/25
friends [2] 3705/20 3707/13
frightening [1] 3832/15
Frilot [1] 3659/5
front [1] 3723/14
Frug [1] 3657/2
fuel [10] 3758/16 3763/1 3763/13
3763/14 3763/15 3805/6 3805/9 3811/18
3814/5 3814/7
fulfilling [1] 3744/21
full [8] 3690/2 3727/12 3772/11 3773/23
3781/7 3782/25 3796/9 3833/7
full-service [1] 3690/2
fully [8] 3751/25 3762/25 3764/12 3774/6
3774/14 3778/20 3823/4 3833/20
fun [1] 3709/10
function [10] 3745/25 3748/3 3764/3
3765/6 3774/7 3774/14 3774/16 3816/11
3822/20 3825/4
functional [2] 3743/1 3743/5
functioning [1] 3711/14
functions [11] 3758/8 3761/20 3762/2
3762/4 3762/7 3762/14 3762/15 3762/16
3762/17 3765/13 3783/7
FUNDERBURK [1] 3660/16
funny [1] 3708/7
further [1] 3828/4
Furthermore [1] 3774/9
fuss [1] 3702/12
future [1] 3796/24
G
G-E-O-F-F-R-E-Y [1] 3727/15
gain [11] 3683/20 3683/22 3683/25
3684/3 3684/4 3684/16 3684/18 3706/13
3707/7 3720/22 3725/6
Gains [1] 3683/23
galley [2] 3722/9 3832/2
game [1] 3726/24
GANNAWAY [1] 3660/4
gap [1] 3803/5
gas [46] 3671/5 3671/6 3682/10 3710/21
3710/25 3711/7 3718/3 3720/22 3721/2
3721/5 3755/23 3756/15 3756/18
3756/24 3757/4 3757/21 3758/5 3759/1
3759/9 3759/24 3759/25 3760/3 3760/18
3761/10 3761/25 3763/12 3763/15
3763/20 3764/7 3764/17 3773/22 3774/3
3774/9 3791/25 3792/10 3792/12
3806/25 3808/16 3818/10 3818/14
3818/18 3822/11 3822/13 3822/13
3824/23 3833/20
gases [1] 3808/19
gate [3] 3657/13 3697/2 3796/9
gave [3] 3677/19 3688/15 3712/10
GAVIN [1] 3660/9
gearbox [4] 3795/5 3795/7 3795/10
3806/9
general [11] 3658/7 3658/11 3735/16
3766/3 3826/1 3826/5 3826/8 3826/9
3826/13 3826/18 3826/21
generally [2] 3725/25 3781/22
generate [1] 3807/15
Generation [1] 3812/20
generator [2] 3755/20 3755/20
gentleman [2] 3744/25 3745/1
gentlemen [1] 3745/6
Geoff [1] 3726/22
GEOFFREY [3] 3660/4 3727/10 3727/14
Gerald [2] 3745/1 3830/24
G
German [1] 3734/23
get [29] 3700/4 3701/6 3705/2 3706/9
3709/8 3713/4 3714/5 3714/15 3721/10
3736/17 3740/6 3745/4 3747/11 3757/16
3758/10 3760/18 3767/6 3768/4 3769/14
3776/20 3780/15 3793/12 3794/6
3794/13 3795/6 3817/16 3817/19
3817/19 3825/12
gets [5] 3704/24 3709/9 3757/13 3795/5
3835/4
getting [10] 3705/3 3718/3 3718/7
3726/24 3745/20 3763/14 3806/8
3808/16 3813/18 3830/5
gigging [1] 3779/10
give [7] 3685/23 3729/15 3730/7
3736/12 3798/22 3812/25 3826/14
given [8] 3677/7 3740/19 3752/20
3753/3 3770/19 3771/18 3813/24
3827/13
glasses [1] 3740/6
GmbH [1] 3655/8
go [88] 3669/23 3676/2 3676/18 3679/1
3682/19 3683/12 3689/6 3691/15
3693/10 3697/5 3697/13 3697/23 3699/7
3700/1 3702/11 3703/5 3707/18 3708/23
3714/2 3714/18 3716/12 3717/1 3717/6
3717/15 3719/20 3719/25 3723/7 3729/9
3730/20 3730/22 3736/6 3741/15
3742/16 3744/16 3745/11 3746/4
3749/24 3751/12 3752/18 3756/4 3759/8
3759/9 3768/23 3770/8 3770/9 3771/4
3771/5 3772/5 3773/20 3775/1 3775/19
3777/21 3778/9 3779/16 3779/17
3779/19 3779/19 3780/19 3781/3
3782/14 3783/9 3783/13 3783/14
3784/17 3785/11 3785/22 3785/22
3786/25 3793/8 3798/7 3799/23 3801/24
3806/2 3807/5 3808/22 3809/5 3810/15
3812/17 3818/7 3819/2 3819/4 3819/22
3822/5 3823/24 3825/14 3827/7 3827/10
3836/2
go-between [1] 3745/11
Godwin [3] 3660/7 3660/7 3660/11
goes [21] 3689/4 3692/25 3696/9
3697/16 3701/7 3712/14 3713/1 3716/12
3747/2 3758/11 3763/14 3770/2 3774/6
3781/14 3784/11 3791/10 3803/17
3812/3 3814/2 3829/3 3834/11
going [70] 3663/10 3665/16 3668/17
3668/20 3674/2 3674/6 3675/19 3681/1
3685/17 3688/25 3691/25 3693/10
3695/20 3696/17 3696/23 3698/22
3702/10 3702/12 3708/4 3709/11 3713/3
3726/13 3727/2 3729/13 3729/14
3730/18 3737/22 3739/23 3739/24
3740/3 3742/17 3747/11 3747/12 3750/4
3754/14 3754/19 3757/21 3758/16
3760/3 3762/13 3763/12 3765/13
3769/25 3770/3 3770/4 3776/14 3783/15
3783/25 3785/9 3787/13 3790/17 3791/3
3791/4 3793/25 3794/17 3799/3 3809/19
3809/23 3810/5 3813/15 3820/13
3821/11 3821/21 3825/12 3828/13
3828/14 3828/22 3834/18 3834/21
3834/22
gold [1] 3705/3
Golden [1] 3657/13
gone [5] 3670/1 3723/8 3723/11 3724/15
3825/16
good [11] 3662/19 3665/6 3672/18
3672/19 3729/11 3729/12 3768/1
3793/14 3809/21 3832/18 3836/4

gosh [1] 3708/7
gosh-darn [1] 3708/7
got [20] 3678/11 3682/23 3686/4
3691/12 3701/15 3706/15 3710/8
3717/20 3717/21 3729/4 3731/6 3742/24
3745/19 3745/20 3777/24 3794/15
3801/13 3809/21 3809/22 3834/21
Gotcha [1] 3703/1
gotten [1] 3681/25
governed [1] 3742/13
governor [2] 3763/7 3763/8
GPS [1] 3748/21
grabbed [1] 3703/25
Grand [1] 3659/14
granting [1] 3738/19
graph [3] 3720/8 3720/9 3749/14
Gray [3] 3712/17 3712/20 3714/6
great [2] 3716/8 3716/9
Greg [4] 3705/23 3705/24 3706/3 3710/1
Gregg [1] 3662/6
gross [2] 3791/6 3791/10
grounds [1] 3769/21
group [3] 3656/18 3736/23 3799/22
GRS [1] 3798/15
Guard [4] 3739/6 3739/19 3789/13
3834/14
Guerra [1] 3656/15
guess [9] 3684/6 3697/19 3697/21
3701/16 3701/17 3708/4 3708/14 3710/7
3710/16
guidance [1] 3772/14
guideline [1] 3742/20
guidelines [3] 3771/20 3771/24 3772/2
GULF [3] 3655/5 3734/12 3787/15
gumbo [1] 3696/9
guy [4] 3705/20 3706/7 3706/25 3801/24
guys [1] 3709/2
gyrocompasses [1] 3748/22
H
habit [1] 3780/16
had [95] 3663/13 3664/18 3665/22
3665/23 3666/10 3666/13 3666/20
3666/20 3667/15 3667/18 3667/19
3667/21 3668/3 3669/13 3669/17 3670/1
3670/2 3670/7 3671/15 3672/13 3672/20
3673/4 3673/6 3674/18 3675/2 3675/11
3676/4 3676/17 3676/25 3677/7 3677/22
3679/1 3679/9 3680/16 3683/19 3683/20
3685/7 3686/8 3686/16 3688/7 3688/10
3689/11 3689/15 3694/22 3699/17
3703/24 3706/2 3706/12 3706/12
3706/22 3707/23 3708/7 3708/15
3708/25 3709/17 3712/3 3712/25
3714/12 3716/7 3716/11 3717/17
3717/17 3717/18 3717/23 3718/2 3718/4
3718/16 3718/23 3720/22 3721/8
3722/23 3731/2 3734/10 3734/11
3734/11 3734/13 3734/21 3734/22
3734/25 3735/2 3735/3 3735/5 3735/5
3735/6 3736/24 3745/6 3755/14 3767/1
3801/25 3811/21 3819/25 3822/11
3825/15 3827/25 3828/3
half [4] 3699/19 3703/25 3737/4 3809/20
Halkett [1] 3772/19
Halliburton [10] 3660/7 3660/11 3677/18
3681/12 3681/19 3684/1 3684/4 3684/17
3719/9 3721/20
Halliburton's [2] 3684/7 3684/9
hand [9] 3690/10 3690/21 3693/10
3696/22 3698/3 3698/22 3719/25
3756/13 3792/7
handled [1] 3775/12

handling [1] 3735/4
hands [3] 3696/23 3716/16 3726/25
hang [2] 3685/2 3698/15
HANKEY [1] 3657/18
happen [2] 3740/24 3740/25
happened [6] 3665/7 3665/23 3670/3
3720/17 3734/15 3737/19
happening [2] 3749/13 3785/9
happens [3] 3740/23 3776/2 3795/3
happy [1] 3708/16
hard [2] 3723/14 3740/3
hardness [1] 3783/21
HARIKLIA [1] 3658/22
Harrell [1] 3672/24
HARTLEY [2] 3660/8 3721/21
has [48] 3681/12 3681/19 3693/12
3693/18 3693/20 3704/20 3707/19
3708/1 3710/4 3711/18 3715/2 3718/22
3727/20 3739/12 3739/12 3747/6 3748/2
3748/12 3750/4 3752/18 3752/19
3752/21 3757/12 3757/19 3761/9 3763/5
3769/15 3769/19 3769/20 3775/4
3779/20 3781/7 3781/19 3793/10
3794/18 3794/19 3795/13 3796/13
3798/17 3803/3 3804/15 3807/10
3809/23 3826/7 3828/10 3828/14
3828/23 3832/15
HAUSER [1] 3658/4
have [262]
haven't [2] 3712/25 3780/24
having [11] 3662/16 3688/18 3688/21
3709/10 3715/14 3727/11 3744/1 3745/9
3779/24 3810/3 3810/4
HAYCRAFT [1] 3658/19
hazard [2] 3717/19 3805/5
hazardous [4] 3751/14 3751/18 3754/9
3784/25
HB [1] 3660/19
HB-406 [1] 3660/19
he [70] 3677/21 3677/21 3707/20
3707/23 3708/1 3708/2 3708/7 3708/8
3708/8 3708/9 3709/9 3710/4 3710/4
3710/11 3710/11 3710/11 3710/12
3711/20 3712/22 3712/22 3712/24
3713/1 3714/10 3716/3 3716/6 3716/7
3716/10 3716/11 3716/22 3718/23
3718/23 3718/24 3718/25 3719/3
3723/21 3723/22 3724/20 3725/8
3728/20 3736/6 3737/18 3740/14
3745/11 3767/5 3767/6 3767/8 3767/11
3767/13 3767/18 3769/20 3770/4 3770/5
3780/5 3785/8 3786/25 3787/10 3787/11
3801/18 3801/23 3801/25 3802/15
3802/20 3829/19 3829/21 3829/22
3829/23 3830/3 3830/6 3830/7 3831/1
He'll [1] 3802/21
he's [5] 3706/5 3719/1 3729/4 3830/4
3830/18
head [3] 3701/1 3714/9 3787/11
headed [1] 3700/20
heads [2] 3774/9 3818/15
health [1] 3799/18
heard [12] 3662/7 3715/20 3715/22
3716/14 3718/13 3718/14 3719/19
3719/21 3764/1 3764/16 3764/23
3769/15
hearsay [3] 3716/21 3717/3 3718/21
Heating [1] 3814/20
held [1] 3831/8
Hell [6] 3715/24 3716/15 3716/19 3717/8
3717/13 3718/11
help [4] 3677/19 3701/25 3713/14
H
help... [1] 3794/12
helping [2] 3700/18 3730/17
helps [1] 3700/15
her [11] 3664/14 3665/6 3665/22
3665/23 3666/18 3667/12 3669/7
3669/11 3670/3 3728/15 3787/1
Herald [1] 3737/1
here [61] 3667/5 3677/25 3681/6
3683/10 3685/18 3689/6 3689/15
3690/21 3690/22 3690/23 3691/5
3691/13 3691/15 3692/5 3692/8 3692/9
3692/14 3693/7 3693/12 3694/9 3694/14
3694/17 3695/7 3695/12 3695/14
3695/21 3696/1 3696/6 3696/7 3699/1
3699/23 3700/14 3700/15 3700/16
3705/2 3706/10 3707/18 3708/4 3722/23
3726/24 3727/3 3727/19 3731/15
3732/11 3736/12 3748/12 3752/17
3756/12 3756/13 3756/23 3764/1 3771/8
3773/4 3773/17 3775/25 3777/11
3779/11 3791/9 3792/7 3800/1 3808/4
here's [4] 3677/19 3691/12 3693/25
3700/15
hereby [1] 3836/11
Herman [3] 3655/22 3655/22 3655/23
Hershman [1] 3734/23
Hey [1] 3745/19
hide [1] 3821/11
high [20] 3694/9 3694/12 3742/12
3760/1 3760/1 3760/1 3760/1 3791/3
3792/11 3792/11 3792/11 3792/14
3792/25 3804/10 3804/12 3812/10
3812/24 3812/24 3813/5 3813/6
high-high [3] 3760/1 3760/1 3792/11
higher [2] 3694/14 3717/18
highest [10] 3737/17 3744/1 3744/11
3744/12 3745/10 3767/15 3767/20
3779/25 3786/25 3800/19
highlight [1] 3714/19
highlighted [1] 3805/4
highly [1] 3672/10
HILL [1] 3660/9
him [18] 3704/14 3705/21 3705/25
3706/7 3707/16 3708/8 3709/8 3712/25
3719/8 3719/9 3719/9 3723/18 3745/16
3769/23 3770/1 3771/19 3780/3 3787/1
hired [2] 3734/8 3734/18
his [23] 3700/10 3704/24 3705/25
3708/7 3708/8 3708/9 3709/6 3718/8
3718/22 3725/9 3727/21 3727/23
3728/19 3728/19 3736/3 3745/2 3745/25
3752/22 3767/12 3767/13 3798/3
3802/19 3820/20
history [6] 3665/2 3781/18 3781/22
3781/25 3782/2 3793/14
hitch [3] 3794/6 3794/12 3794/12
Hold [2] 3740/6 3801/1
Holdings [5] 3659/5 3659/8 3659/12
3659/16 3659/19
hole [3] 3691/11 3718/4 3718/6
Holthaus [1] 3657/2
Homeland [1] 3789/12
honest [2] 3685/23 3707/16
Honor [53] 3662/4 3662/14 3690/9
3690/14 3698/19 3704/12 3704/23
3710/17 3711/21 3715/25 3717/1 3717/3
3718/21 3719/2 3719/19 3721/14
3726/18 3726/23 3727/20 3728/2
3728/13 3728/23 3729/1 3729/5 3735/24
3736/5 3736/7 3748/19 3761/22 3768/3
3769/12 3769/22 3780/10 3780/14
3780/22 3788/9 3790/16 3791/1 3791/13

3791/19 3797/21 3813/9 3817/23 3818/8
3820/19 3821/25 3830/4 3830/24 3835/9
3835/17 3835/19 3835/22 3835/25
honorable [2] 3655/15 3707/16
HORIZON [56] 3655/4 3664/8 3667/6
3672/9 3672/11 3681/15 3683/21
3713/24 3717/21 3722/11 3726/3
3737/25 3738/2 3738/9 3738/19 3739/3
3739/17 3744/25 3745/7 3747/17
3751/25 3754/21 3755/11 3761/7 3764/2
3765/5 3765/10 3768/16 3768/19
3772/15 3772/17 3773/17 3774/21
3775/17 3776/9 3777/16 3782/17 3783/6
3783/11 3790/10 3791/23 3800/2
3800/25 3801/21 3804/1 3806/6 3809/1
3810/8 3818/22 3825/21 3828/14
3828/24 3829/13 3829/18 3830/11
3830/12
Horn [1] 3810/22
Horn Mountain [1] 3810/22
hose [1] 3667/12
hot [1] 3757/13
hotel [1] 3758/15
Houma [1] 3656/20
hour [1] 3801/16
hours [4] 3720/4 3749/11 3750/5
3752/14
house [1] 3756/20
housekeeping [1] 3835/10
Houston [9] 3657/7 3659/10 3659/21
3660/5 3660/13 3660/17 3734/8 3829/15
3830/13
how [37] 3665/13 3671/18 3675/11
3676/4 3677/19 3678/11 3679/19
3693/20 3700/11 3702/9 3708/7 3713/6
3716/8 3716/8 3716/22 3722/15 3732/22
3733/5 3734/6 3740/12 3742/20 3750/10
3750/12 3756/9 3759/17 3765/10 3767/3
3770/1 3770/20 3783/16 3793/13
3794/23 3798/25 3806/20 3821/18
3822/16 3836/2
however [2] 3818/13 3828/9
HPU [2] 3823/10 3823/11
HSE [1] 3833/8
HUGH [3] 3660/15 3705/1 3705/16
Hughes [1] 3659/19
huh [3] 3696/5 3728/6 3786/2
human [3] 3741/17 3761/3 3777/2
humming [1] 3817/21
hundreds [1] 3806/17
HVAC [1] 3814/12
hydraulic [1] 3783/20
hydrocarbon [1] 3761/10
hydrocarbons [4] 3721/1 3721/10
3763/20 3808/19
hydrogen [1] 3761/10
HYMEL [1] 3659/16
I
I'd [3] 3692/15 3729/1 3799/3
I'll [5] 3705/2 3719/10 3727/3 3778/9
3780/18
I'm [80] 3675/15 3678/15 3680/9 3682/5
3682/22 3682/23 3684/14 3685/17
3686/25 3693/10 3698/15 3698/22
3700/6 3700/11 3702/12 3704/11 3705/1
3705/11 3705/16 3708/4 3708/5 3708/16
3711/20 3713/3 3713/21 3714/2 3716/9
3716/24 3717/7 3718/13 3726/12 3727/2
3727/14 3727/18 3728/7 3728/15
3729/13 3729/22 3734/6 3735/8 3736/11
3739/24 3744/19 3745/8 3747/12
3747/17 3750/12 3750/12 3750/12

3757/10 3762/4 3764/17 3767/12 3768/3
3768/12 3768/15 3769/25 3770/23
3778/8 3780/5 3783/15 3787/13 3788/9
3790/17 3791/3 3791/4 3791/8 3791/14
3795/12 3799/3 3800/25 3801/1 3812/20
3820/23 3825/13 3830/2 3830/5 3830/8
3830/24 3834/20
I've [14] 3667/5 3680/17 3683/6 3684/13
3689/2 3718/13 3719/19 3719/21
3720/10 3731/17 3732/9 3733/6 3734/6
3834/21
i.e [3] 3771/9 3825/18 3832/1
IACS [15] 3755/14 3759/13 3760/22
3762/1 3764/4 3764/18 3765/8 3766/1
3774/16 3792/5 3807/2 3807/3 3826/7
3826/11 3826/15
IADC [1] 3803/22
idea [6] 3729/15 3763/17 3766/16
3766/19 3802/9 3823/11
identifiable [1] 3741/7
identified [5] 3699/1 3727/4 3742/3
3781/7 3810/22
identify [13] 3683/7 3747/23 3754/7
3770/16 3790/3 3795/20 3797/8 3799/17
3800/24 3803/20 3808/24 3818/21
3826/24
if [145] 3663/8 3663/24 3664/2 3664/3
3667/2 3667/10 3668/10 3668/10
3672/20 3673/5 3673/7 3673/11 3675/18
3675/19 3675/20 3676/1 3676/13
3676/17 3677/23 3679/9 3679/12
3679/22 3681/1 3681/8 3681/12 3683/12
3684/3 3685/7 3686/1 3686/9 3686/16
3687/3 3687/5 3688/7 3688/10 3688/13
3689/11 3689/15 3690/7 3690/9 3690/16
3690/21 3691/15 3694/14 3695/20
3696/17 3697/3 3697/23 3698/15
3700/14 3701/24 3702/9 3707/19
3707/23 3708/5 3708/14 3708/14
3708/17 3709/25 3711/20 3712/12
3712/12 3714/18 3714/19 3715/17
3718/19 3718/25 3719/8 3719/16
3719/22 3719/25 3720/25 3721/9
3721/10 3725/17 3726/5 3726/5 3726/11
3726/11 3726/12 3726/12 3726/14
3726/14 3739/14 3740/13 3740/22
3741/2 3743/1 3745/15 3747/1 3749/17
3752/3 3753/3 3753/5 3755/22 3756/21
3757/12 3758/17 3759/25 3760/18
3761/21 3762/25 3763/13 3763/19
3765/14 3765/15 3766/11 3767/11
3767/14 3767/18 3775/20 3777/21
3780/6 3781/3 3782/10 3785/21 3785/25
3792/24 3798/7 3802/21 3805/19
3805/21 3806/2 3807/23 3808/17 3811/4
3812/14 3813/17 3816/19 3817/4
3817/17 3817/23 3818/5 3819/2 3819/5
3819/13 3821/15 3822/2 3822/21
3822/23 3822/24 3825/8 3826/19
3826/20 3834/11
ignition [1] 3757/16
Illinois [1] 3658/24
immediate [3] 3741/10 3789/21 3790/3
immediately [3] 3753/6 3820/3 3820/6
IMO [1] 3739/8
impact [3] 3776/11 3809/25 3810/19
imperils [1] 3808/13
implement [1] 3743/3
implementation [4] 3740/5 3741/11
3751/21 3828/8
implemented [6] 3785/3 3785/3 3827/22
3827/25 3828/3 3828/10
I
implementing [2] 3746/7 3810/18
implications [1] 3834/9
importance [1] 3771/18
important [9] 3673/8 3743/19 3743/21
3745/22 3746/1 3754/2 3770/21 3809/18
3818/18
Imprevento [1] 3656/8
improve [3] 3742/4 3815/13 3823/18
improvements [1] 3810/18
improving [1] 3751/20
in [452]
inaccuracies [1] 3686/10
INC [18] 3655/11 3658/19 3658/22
3659/3 3659/6 3659/7 3659/9 3659/10
3659/13 3659/13 3659/17 3659/17
3659/20 3659/21 3660/7 3660/12 3787/7
3801/2
inch [2] 3717/18 3818/5
incident [6] 3750/15 3752/3 3773/13
3781/9 3790/2 3790/24
incidents [2] 3789/22 3789/22
include [14] 3744/3 3746/21 3751/17
3754/12 3762/4 3762/7 3762/17 3762/20
3762/23 3764/6 3764/9 3784/24 3789/10
3823/9
included [6] 3805/11 3806/12 3808/4
3816/17 3816/19 3822/12
includes [3] 3741/10 3742/21 3743/4
including [9] 3731/14 3736/25 3737/11
3742/5 3774/3 3781/20 3809/10 3832/17
3834/4
incomplete [1] 3820/3
inconsistent [2] 3793/14 3800/6
incorrect [1] 3781/19
increase [22] 3676/1 3676/13 3680/6
3680/13 3680/23 3681/13 3681/24
3682/24 3683/6 3683/17 3685/5 3685/8
3688/3 3688/10 3689/7 3689/12 3689/18
3704/6 3713/13 3720/6 3725/8 3771/16
increased [8] 3680/3 3681/9 3683/13
3686/17 3815/12 3823/17 3832/11
3834/1
increases [1] 3757/15
increasing [2] 3771/9 3776/11
incumbent [1] 3766/21
indeed [5] 3736/16 3804/20 3805/3
3811/10 3819/13
independently [1] 3775/6
India [1] 3730/12
indicate [3] 3797/24 3811/23 3822/19
indicated [2] 3710/20 3756/14
indicates [3] 3740/9 3785/25 3797/20
indicating [2] 3807/11 3827/24
indication [13] 3663/9 3680/1 3680/17
3681/6 3683/5 3683/12 3688/24 3723/11
3770/15 3771/11 3771/14 3771/19
3813/1
indications [4] 3682/8 3686/23 3688/18
3723/12
indicator [2] 3689/16 3689/20
individual [1] 3812/9
industry [3] 3803/4 3803/7 3803/22
inform [5] 3751/24 3787/1 3800/19
3815/18 3824/3
information [8] 3662/22 3710/8 3710/9
3713/5 3752/20 3758/4 3770/19 3796/15
informed [1] 3751/25
ingest [1] 3763/22
ingesting [1] 3763/19
ingestion [1] 3808/19
inhibited [3] 3818/14 3825/11 3825/25
initial [1] 3772/3

initially [1] 3758/9
initiate [3] 3770/16 3771/12 3771/15
initiated [1] 3816/10
initiating [1] 3771/20
injury [5] 3741/17 3817/5 3831/23
3832/11 3834/1
input [1] 3777/2
inputs [3] 3755/17 3756/14 3756/17
inquiry [1] 3706/21
inshore [1] 3749/24
inside [3] 3701/11 3710/23 3757/11
inspected [2] 3739/9 3790/20
inspection [10] 3753/4 3781/21 3783/22
3789/11 3803/21 3804/9 3811/2 3829/17
3829/21 3831/6
inspections [2] 3766/8 3781/16
inspector [1] 3804/9
inspectors [1] 3804/9
installed [1] 3775/16
instance [3] 3738/22 3757/3 3787/20
instantly [1] 3711/9
instead [4] 3713/18 3717/25 3830/9
3830/10
Institute [1] 3729/25
institution [2] 3729/22 3731/3
instruction [1] 3820/4
instructions [2] 3743/11 3746/9
insurance [1] 3739/11
intake [1] 3762/23
integrated [2] 3755/15 3773/17
integrity [4] 3811/17 3811/17 3832/6
3832/24
intent [2] 3788/24 3819/13
intentionally [2] 3709/6 3765/16
inter [1] 3741/24
inter alia [1] 3741/24
interfered [1] 3674/10
intermediate [4] 3785/16 3785/20
3785/24 3785/24
internal [6] 3766/15 3766/16 3766/24
3767/1 3786/12 3799/19
international [21] 3659/22 3660/2
3731/13 3733/9 3736/19 3736/22 3737/5
3743/13 3745/18 3768/17 3793/23
3800/13 3803/15 3803/23 3811/9
3811/11 3817/12 3819/16 3825/9 3829/1
3831/13
interpret [1] 3680/25
interrelation [1] 3778/3
interrogation [1] 3782/2
interval [4] 3783/18 3783/20 3783/21
3784/2
intervention [1] 3761/3
interview [4] 3676/25 3677/5 3784/15
3797/24
interviewed [4] 3797/22 3801/16 3802/3
3802/16
interviews [2] 3784/13 3802/20
intimate [2] 3765/25 3766/2
intimately [2] 3746/15 3746/18
into [31] 3670/2 3670/14 3691/10
3697/24 3707/18 3731/14 3734/12
3734/15 3734/25 3738/25 3739/15
3747/11 3749/1 3749/24 3752/19 3753/6
3758/10 3758/16 3760/3 3762/13
3763/12 3766/4 3768/4 3794/18 3795/1
3795/6 3795/13 3795/16 3803/6 3806/9
3821/15
introduce [1] 3721/15
introduced [1] 3727/21
introduction [1] 3727/23
intruded [1] 3795/13
intrusion [2] 3794/18 3795/1

intrusive [1] 3790/23
investigate [2] 3816/14 3826/16
investigated [3] 3683/1 3751/19 3785/1
involve [1] 3731/24
involved [8] 3672/13 3730/16 3731/6
3732/9 3732/14 3733/8 3750/15 3767/3
involving [2] 3735/22 3780/7
Irpino [2] 3657/8 3657/9
is [558]
Islands [3] 3738/13 3738/15 3738/18
ISM [87] 3730/8 3731/13 3731/16
3731/17 3731/20 3731/20 3732/14
3736/18 3736/19 3736/24 3737/7
3737/24 3737/24 3738/2 3738/5 3738/20
3738/25 3739/2 3739/13 3739/23
3740/12 3741/21 3742/9 3742/9 3742/13
3742/25 3747/12 3747/14 3751/10
3751/16 3752/22 3754/17 3754/19
3765/18 3766/7 3766/23 3766/25 3773/7
3777/11 3777/14 3777/15 3778/1 3779/6
3779/14 3780/7 3782/3 3784/7 3784/22
3785/16 3785/19 3785/20 3786/6
3786/16 3786/17 3787/21 3788/1 3789/6
3789/15 3789/15 3791/7 3793/22 3797/3
3798/13 3798/24 3799/9 3800/12
3800/18 3802/7 3803/17 3809/1 3809/15
3812/12 3816/24 3820/7 3827/6 3827/15
3829/6 3829/6 3831/12 3831/12 3831/13
3831/14 3832/4 3832/9 3832/22 3833/11
3833/23
ISM Code [8] 3736/18 3736/19 3737/7
3737/24 3738/2 3738/5 3738/20 3812/12
isn't [20] 3674/8 3693/23 3694/1 3694/3
3694/10 3721/3 3721/12 3761/16
3761/19 3767/23 3786/15 3786/15
3788/4 3808/17 3820/12 3821/14
3821/17 3823/19 3824/7 3829/19
ISO [1] 3736/21
ISO 9002 [1] 3736/21
isolate [2] 3689/2 3831/25
isolated [1] 3813/9
isolation [2] 3762/5 3812/4
ISPS [1] 3809/2
issue [18] 3676/14 3728/18 3728/19
3728/20 3741/3 3799/9 3803/4 3805/18
3808/13 3817/2 3817/4 3818/17 3820/4
3822/3 3823/20 3824/7 3825/2 3828/13
issued [5] 3728/15 3778/22 3784/15
3827/17 3828/4
issues [13] 3732/14 3735/2 3735/3
3735/4 3754/15 3769/24 3772/15 3807/8
3808/6 3811/17 3812/9 3816/2 3828/21
issuing [2] 3731/4 3746/9
it [461]
it's [125] 3666/3 3667/2 3673/16 3674/8
3679/13 3680/17 3684/11 3687/20
3689/5 3689/20 3690/19 3692/14
3693/23 3700/16 3701/4 3701/11
3701/23 3702/10 3702/23 3702/24
3710/23 3711/3 3711/6 3712/13 3716/23
3716/24 3717/3 3717/8 3720/19 3725/19
3726/14 3729/5 3732/3 3736/20 3736/21
3739/8 3739/16 3741/2 3742/23 3745/13
3745/17 3747/1 3748/3 3748/5 3748/5
3748/7 3748/8 3749/7 3749/25 3749/25
3750/1 3750/17 3753/5 3754/14 3755/22
3756/1 3756/9 3757/1 3757/21 3758/7
3758/19 3760/10 3761/1 3762/25
3764/18 3766/3 3766/4 3766/21 3768/15
3772/9 3773/18 3773/24 3774/24
3774/24 3775/22 3777/12 3777/21
3778/16 3778/16 3779/12 3780/12
I
it's... [44] 3780/16 3783/14 3785/23
3786/8 3786/18 3788/14 3793/6 3795/15
3795/25 3796/9 3796/19 3801/1 3801/10
3801/22 3803/22 3804/12 3804/22
3807/3 3809/1 3815/7 3817/17 3817/23
3818/2 3818/22 3821/8 3821/11 3821/20
3822/25 3823/1 3823/2 3824/2 3825/3
3825/8 3825/14 3825/16 3826/6 3826/19
3826/20 3827/2 3827/2 3831/13 3834/21
3834/22 3835/1
item [12] 3771/9 3788/20 3798/15
3799/3 3799/7 3806/2 3806/10 3811/21
3816/3 3816/5 3818/10 3821/15
items [14] 3753/22 3753/25 3754/1
3771/8 3778/25 3796/19 3798/15
3798/23 3807/19 3807/20 3809/10
3815/10 3821/23 3833/10
its [16] 3662/5 3717/21 3730/18 3734/2
3738/3 3738/20 3746/12 3747/19
3750/18 3754/7 3762/16 3764/6 3766/24
3785/16 3791/2 3824/12
itself [5] 3749/3 3757/15 3763/5 3766/23
3813/7
J
jacket [2] 3812/24 3813/5
JAMES [3] 3655/19 3658/12 3829/15
January [4] 3774/24 3781/2 3801/5
3801/17
January 2005 [1] 3781/2
January 22 [2] 3801/5 3801/17
JD [1] 3796/7
Jefferson [2] 3655/20 3659/17
JEFFREY [1] 3656/9
JERRY [1] 3660/12
JESSICA [2] 3657/22 3657/23
JIMMY [3] 3657/6 3672/24 3801/13
JIT [2] 3728/5 3728/20
job [18] 3663/16 3665/19 3671/20
3672/8 3673/9 3673/16 3673/23 3673/23
3674/11 3674/15 3680/25 3683/7 3698/1
3712/8 3714/3 3732/4 3750/21 3750/21
jobs [1] 3732/13
Joe [1] 3726/17
JOHN [7] 3657/3 3659/20 3660/16
3728/2 3769/12 3780/10 3790/16
Johnson [5] 3829/12 3830/3 3830/13
3830/15 3831/1
join [1] 3717/4
joint [1] 3730/14
Jonathon [2] 3712/17 3714/8
JONES [1] 3660/3
JOSEPH [2] 3662/15 3713/6
journey [1] 3703/21
JR [3] 3656/12 3660/8 3660/8
JUDGE [10] 3655/15 3712/25 3716/3
3716/9 3717/5 3718/25 3719/4 3728/12
3778/8 3834/15
Judge Shushan [1] 3728/12
July [1] 3778/22
July 2001 [1] 3778/22
jump [1] 3794/16
June [1] 3786/1
June 29 [1] 3786/1
junior [1] 3713/14
just [98] 3666/20 3666/25 3667/5
3669/21 3670/7 3673/15 3673/15
3675/15 3675/21 3679/20 3684/25
3685/2 3685/4 3685/17 3685/18 3686/25
3687/11 3687/15 3688/14 3688/20
3690/9 3690/14 3691/7 3691/19 3693/22
3694/13 3694/24 3697/6 3698/1 3698/15

3698/15 3699/4 3699/15 3699/25 3700/1
3700/18 3701/22 3702/24 3704/11
3704/12 3705/2 3705/11 3706/9 3706/9
3706/10 3707/18 3709/10 3709/23
3710/11 3711/20 3712/10 3718/4
3718/13 3720/19 3727/3 3730/7 3731/21
3732/13 3740/6 3744/9 3746/24 3748/23
3750/8 3750/25 3751/10 3754/16 3756/8
3756/20 3757/1 3757/7 3758/7 3758/14
3759/4 3759/10 3759/22 3760/7 3775/19
3778/10 3783/10 3788/13 3790/24
3791/23 3793/12 3794/16 3801/7
3817/25 3818/4 3818/5 3818/24 3818/24
3820/24 3821/11 3826/11 3826/21
3827/9 3829/24 3834/25 3835/1
Justice [4] 3657/11 3657/15 3657/21
3658/2
K
Kanner [3] 3658/15 3658/15 3725/2
KARIS [1] 3658/22
Katz [1] 3655/22
keep [9] 3664/24 3665/2 3686/4 3751/25
3763/13 3810/3 3810/5 3815/4 3816/20
keeping [1] 3793/13
KEITH [15] 3662/15 3662/19 3684/25
3685/15 3698/22 3705/11 3705/14
3705/16 3709/11 3710/20 3715/9
3716/14 3720/25 3724/17 3726/19
KELLEY [1] 3658/4
Kelly [3] 3712/17 3713/6 3714/5
Kent [1] 3829/15
kept [3] 3740/16 3748/23 3820/16
KERRY [1] 3659/6
kick [17] 3663/9 3680/17 3683/5 3683/6
3687/3 3688/13 3689/15 3689/20 3704/5
3704/6 3704/7 3704/10 3717/19 3718/7
3718/20 3719/8 3719/17
kick' [1] 3688/19
kick,' [1] 3686/24
kicks [1] 3718/3
kill [1] 3759/6
killing [2] 3737/2 3737/4
kilowatts [1] 3748/19
Kinchen [11] 3659/19 3659/20 3728/2
3769/12 3769/23 3780/10 3790/16
3791/1 3791/16 3791/18 3820/18
kind [2] 3691/22 3809/25
Kirkland [1] 3658/21
knew [7] 3668/5 3679/4 3685/20 3685/23
3708/9 3713/4 3791/9
know [68] 3665/18 3666/13 3667/17
3667/23 3675/18 3675/20 3677/15
3677/15 3677/21 3677/23 3678/2 3678/3
3678/3 3678/7 3678/10 3678/24 3682/5
3686/2 3689/19 3696/22 3699/4 3700/14
3705/1 3705/17 3705/21 3705/24 3706/3
3707/10 3707/16 3707/22 3708/3 3709/5
3711/13 3712/24 3714/7 3715/23
3716/18 3716/22 3716/22 3717/9
3718/11 3718/25 3720/10 3721/5 3721/6
3721/7 3725/1 3726/12 3731/16 3745/19
3757/13 3786/20 3786/23 3791/9
3793/11 3793/11 3796/24 3798/19
3800/16 3800/17 3807/24 3817/17
3817/22 3820/9 3822/24 3823/1 3823/3
3825/16
knowing [1] 3764/9
knowledge [9] 3728/1 3728/13 3733/21
3765/25 3766/2 3766/3 3793/13 3796/17
3803/5
known [4] 3727/18 3767/21 3772/13
3824/15
knows [6] 3711/20 3716/10 3718/23
3718/24 3718/25 3719/3
Kongsberg [11] 3755/14 3757/22
3757/23 3760/22 3761/16 3761/19
3764/4 3765/15 3765/25 3776/24
3805/25
Korea [1] 3734/11
KRAUS [1] 3658/16
Kullman [1] 3656/5
L
lab [12] 3695/24 3696/1 3696/2 3696/6
3706/12 3708/21 3708/24 3709/15
3710/12 3711/3 3711/7 3725/2
lack [5] 3736/17 3741/10 3757/14
3811/25 3822/19
lacking [1] 3793/12
laed.uscourts.gov [1] 3660/20
Lafayette [2] 3655/21 3659/18
Lafleur [1] 3659/16
laid [1] 3711/18
Lamar [1] 3660/12
LANGAN [1] 3658/22
large [7] 3730/11 3736/25 3737/2
3742/19 3748/12 3754/24 3761/6
largest [2] 3771/8 3771/16
Lasalle [1] 3658/23
last [7] 3725/16 3759/20 3771/6 3801/6
3808/17 3811/22 3818/10
latched [1] 3717/22
later [7] 3689/24 3731/6 3740/20 3745/4
3752/24 3766/5 3780/5
law [5] 3656/18 3656/21 3657/8 3831/20
3832/9
LAWRENCE [1] 3657/24
Laws [1] 3829/5
lawyers [1] 3734/8
layman's [2] 3740/11 3753/17
layout [1] 3700/11
lead [5] 3731/16 3777/14 3789/15
3798/25 3821/11
leader [7] 3807/9 3815/18 3815/20
3816/1 3824/3 3824/5 3824/11
leading [6] 3724/12 3724/14 3761/22
3780/11 3780/12 3820/19
leak [1] 3795/7
leaking [1] 3795/16
lean [1] 3675/15
learn [2] 3685/20 3714/12
LEASING [1] 3655/8
least [5] 3728/1 3745/14 3767/12 3775/5
3780/6
leave [4] 3670/17 3670/18 3727/3
3754/19
ledger [4] 3664/25 3665/2 3665/9
3665/23
left [6] 3678/24 3679/2 3702/7 3702/10
3704/1 3756/13
left-hand [1] 3756/13
legacy [1] 3734/2
Leger [2] 3656/12 3656/12
legislation [1] 3743/14
LEL [6] 3792/11 3792/11 3792/13
3792/15 3792/21 3792/24
length [3] 3718/15 3747/11 3749/5
Leo [11] 3705/21 3706/2 3707/1 3707/1
3707/3 3707/11 3707/13 3708/5 3708/6
3708/14 3709/1
let [20] 3673/15 3675/18 3675/20
3682/18 3685/17 3685/17 3686/2 3690/7
3690/16 3695/2 3698/17 3700/5 3701/24
3709/8 3727/6 3740/6 3750/8 3754/15
L
let... [2] 3765/3 3777/12
let's [52] 3664/6 3669/21 3674/24 3675/6
3685/12 3685/14 3686/14 3688/14
3691/19 3693/25 3700/17 3700/18
3709/13 3710/16 3713/1 3716/12
3736/17 3740/14 3741/5 3741/15
3743/22 3746/4 3747/21 3749/17
3749/18 3751/10 3753/8 3754/19
3757/13 3758/9 3768/5 3770/2 3770/8
3770/9 3771/4 3772/5 3785/11 3794/16
3798/22 3799/21 3799/23 3801/12
3807/5 3812/17 3818/4 3819/5 3822/5
3823/24 3825/14 3829/24 3831/6 3835/3
letter [3] 3772/19 3787/6 3787/13
level [21] 3689/6 3692/9 3695/10
3695/11 3696/11 3696/12 3696/15
3700/23 3701/10 3701/12 3744/1
3744/11 3744/13 3745/10 3767/15
3767/20 3779/25 3787/1 3792/7 3792/25
3800/19
levels [6] 3689/4 3737/17 3743/16
3744/12 3792/10 3792/12
Lewis [5] 3656/5 3658/18 3660/7
3660/11 3660/14
LI [1] 3659/13
liaison [1] 3745/12
life [11] 3699/11 3702/10 3737/8 3738/3
3741/18 3758/21 3768/18 3769/24
3770/20 3791/2 3831/11
lift [1] 3750/23
lighter [1] 3692/2
lights [1] 3826/10
like [49] 3663/23 3665/9 3666/5 3672/18
3679/4 3681/15 3684/13 3693/2 3701/1
3707/1 3707/3 3707/11 3708/5 3708/17
3711/24 3714/8 3715/22 3717/20
3718/14 3721/15 3722/8 3722/9 3724/2
3725/13 3726/5 3726/14 3726/24
3727/22 3729/1 3739/8 3748/18 3749/8
3755/22 3756/20 3757/14 3758/14
3759/4 3770/1 3773/20 3784/4 3785/10
3787/12 3790/17 3798/18 3805/10
3810/11 3815/2 3818/5 3821/7
likelihood [1] 3769/3
likewise [1] 3681/5
limit [1] 3792/21
Lindner [4] 3705/21 3707/1 3707/19
3708/19
line [16] 3663/6 3668/12 3685/12
3685/13 3690/23 3691/5 3692/13 3696/9
3702/23 3702/24 3702/25 3704/16
3704/16 3724/3 3756/9 3808/17
Linea [1] 3732/11
lines [6] 3663/20 3666/3 3679/9 3691/18
3697/7 3743/16
lineup [1] 3835/24
link [1] 3743/24
Liskow [1] 3658/18
list [11] 3667/10 3712/3 3715/2 3721/17
3743/5 3787/17 3789/10 3789/13
3797/17 3823/14 3835/23
listed [7] 3715/6 3715/10 3789/22
3796/12 3796/22 3819/25 3834/5
listen [1] 3682/1
lists [1] 3790/18
litigation [3] 3658/3 3732/25 3736/14
little [19] 3670/18 3675/15 3689/4 3689/6
3700/25 3707/18 3717/18 3720/20
3731/21 3742/24 3748/25 3754/20
3756/13 3758/9 3758/12 3761/3 3801/22
3815/3 3819/5
live [3] 3730/22 3835/7 3835/14

lives [3] 3760/19 3814/19 3829/7
living [9] 3701/11 3701/17 3701/18
3702/11 3703/1 3703/5 3703/11 3703/15
3748/14
LLC [13] 3655/19 3655/22 3656/2
3656/18 3658/15 3659/5 3659/6 3659/9
3659/12 3659/16 3659/20 3659/22
3660/14
LLP [8] 3656/15 3657/2 3658/21 3659/2
3659/8 3659/12 3659/19 3660/2
LMRP [2] 3775/23 3776/5
load [1] 3781/21
local [1] 3827/19
located [2] 3756/19 3775/6
location [3] 3799/25 3799/25 3800/3
log [5] 3663/13 3665/9 3666/3 3722/22
3723/9
logbooks [1] 3740/16
logger [17] 3662/22 3663/16 3664/24
3670/12 3678/16 3678/22 3678/24
3679/2 3679/8 3684/12 3684/17 3690/2
3695/7 3699/23 3703/21 3713/14 3726/2
logger's [4] 3668/8 3695/24 3699/1
3702/1
loggers [4] 3713/18 3713/20 3714/25
3715/2
logging [9] 3669/9 3669/14 3673/18
3674/14 3674/19 3675/3 3700/8 3722/15
3723/4
logs [3] 3665/25 3666/2 3740/16
long [16] 3682/6 3682/9 3693/22 3712/3
3715/2 3721/5 3721/8 3722/15 3734/10
3750/2 3774/4 3802/3 3804/15 3809/23
3825/16 3836/2
long-term [3] 3734/10 3774/4 3804/15
longer [2] 3668/17 3817/14
look [34] 3666/6 3667/10 3668/10
3674/24 3675/6 3681/8 3685/12 3685/14
3686/14 3688/14 3690/21 3692/24
3693/25 3694/14 3697/6 3697/23 3700/9
3726/11 3726/13 3734/20 3741/5
3742/10 3743/1 3752/19 3767/9 3768/11
3785/8 3785/25 3798/18 3799/21
3801/12 3817/7 3817/19 3822/2
looked [13] 3667/8 3677/12 3679/8
3688/14 3719/15 3720/15 3722/22
3722/24 3724/8 3777/6 3798/10 3801/7
3818/24
looking [11] 3674/24 3690/25 3691/18
3699/4 3720/12 3723/15 3728/15 3759/9
3810/13 3822/25 3830/2
looks [5] 3693/2 3695/18 3790/17
3798/18 3805/10
Los [1] 3659/14
lose [4] 3677/22 3749/18 3795/10
3795/10
loss [2] 3718/3 3741/17
lost [1] 3718/2
lot [5] 3708/23 3716/16 3731/10 3754/15
3806/22
loud [1] 3768/13
LOUISIANA [23] 3655/2 3655/6 3655/21
3655/24 3656/7 3656/13 3656/20
3656/23 3657/4 3657/10 3658/11
3658/12 3658/13 3658/15 3658/17
3658/20 3659/7 3659/18 3659/24
3660/16 3660/19 3835/18 3836/11
louvers [2] 3760/9 3760/11
lower [5] 3694/17 3696/3 3776/1
3792/21 3806/9
lubrication [1] 3757/14
LUIS [1] 3659/13
lunch [1] 3666/16

LUTHER [1] 3658/8
M
M-I [7] 3660/14 3666/22 3705/2 3705/19
3706/7 3710/11 3711/3
M-I SWACO [3] 3668/23 3704/21
3705/17
machinery [5] 3804/14 3808/5 3815/9
3823/8 3832/1
Macondo [2] 3715/15 3716/15
made [15] 3673/1 3680/15 3703/21
3706/12 3707/4 3724/18 3724/21
3724/24 3725/12 3793/20 3798/13
3804/10 3807/20 3815/11 3823/17
Magazine [1] 3657/9
magicians [1] 3813/21
Mahtook [1] 3659/16
mail [8] 3712/16 3712/18 3713/4 3713/5
3714/16 3714/17 3829/10 3829/21
main [20] 3657/3 3677/21 3696/3
3696/12 3699/14 3700/21 3701/3 3701/4
3701/12 3701/15 3701/23 3702/23
3740/15 3808/11 3810/25 3811/1 3811/5
3812/22 3812/23 3816/5
maintain [5] 3732/4 3743/3 3749/2
3803/9 3809/21
maintained [3] 3753/11 3754/4 3767/25
maintaining [1] 3733/24
maintenance [89] 3732/5 3733/22
3736/1 3753/8 3753/18 3753/20 3753/25
3753/25 3754/3 3754/15 3772/24
3772/25 3773/8 3781/6 3781/12 3781/14
3781/15 3781/18 3781/19 3781/20
3781/22 3781/24 3782/1 3782/2 3782/4
3782/11 3783/2 3787/11 3791/6 3793/6
3793/7 3793/10 3796/14 3799/2 3805/12
3806/12 3807/10 3807/11 3807/12
3807/16 3809/9 3809/9 3809/14 3810/1
3810/2 3810/17 3810/19 3810/25 3811/8
3811/25 3811/25 3812/1 3812/9 3815/12
3815/19 3815/24 3816/1 3816/18
3816/19 3816/21 3817/7 3817/9 3818/11
3818/12 3819/9 3819/10 3819/13
3819/20 3819/21 3819/24 3819/25
3820/3 3820/4 3820/14 3820/15 3820/15
3821/4 3821/10 3821/15 3821/17
3821/17 3821/17 3823/17 3824/4 3824/9
3824/11 3824/24 3824/24 3829/13
major [24] 3735/4 3736/25 3737/13
3740/25 3741/3 3741/5 3741/7 3752/6
3752/24 3753/5 3766/12 3767/19 3769/3
3777/18 3783/19 3784/2 3786/18
3786/23 3787/1 3792/8 3799/1 3828/4
3828/5 3833/10
make [29] 3665/16 3673/15 3686/9
3686/12 3690/4 3704/24 3710/7 3721/25
3725/7 3726/6 3726/9 3726/10 3737/7
3739/11 3739/11 3740/7 3742/16 3747/7
3767/9 3779/23 3782/8 3785/9 3787/22
3802/21 3807/20 3820/25 3823/3 3826/3
3826/3
makes [2] 3748/25 3804/5
Malczewskyj [1] 3718/9
malfunction [2] 3757/13 3757/18
MALINDA [1] 3657/24
man [4] 3672/23 3687/25 3707/16
3707/16
manage [2] 3755/12 3778/3
manageable [1] 3794/19
managed [2] 3732/7 3755/8
management [48] 3731/13 3736/19
3737/18 3741/23 3742/4 3742/18 3743/2
M
management... [41] 3743/4 3743/20
3744/2 3744/11 3744/12 3744/13
3745/10 3746/11 3746/12 3746/16
3746/19 3746/21 3747/3 3747/6 3751/16
3754/7 3754/9 3765/20 3767/15 3767/21
3771/25 3779/25 3781/6 3784/23 3787/1
3793/23 3799/19 3800/13 3800/19
3802/8 3803/15 3807/10 3811/9 3811/11
3817/12 3819/17 3825/9 3825/23
3827/18 3829/1 3833/8
manager [6] 3677/18 3779/19 3801/25
3830/6 3830/15 3830/21
managers [2] 3800/5 3813/24
mandate [1] 3738/19
Mandatory [1] 3829/4
manner [5] 3746/10 3753/23 3782/9
3807/21 3809/22
manning [3] 3750/5 3803/3 3826/15
mans [1] 3696/20
manual [4] 3718/16 3718/24 3719/15
3730/19
manuals [2] 3742/19 3771/25
manufacturer [1] 3757/23
manufacturer's [3] 3783/18 3784/2
3794/21
many [18] 3665/13 3671/18 3672/14
3693/20 3731/18 3732/22 3733/1 3734/6
3735/10 3737/2 3740/16 3755/4 3755/16
3755/16 3794/23 3806/20 3806/23
3820/13
Marathon [4] 3734/10 3734/15 3734/16
3735/3
March [6] 3655/7 3662/2 3689/9 3718/7
3782/19 3828/2
March 2009 [1] 3828/2
March 8 [1] 3718/7
marine [57] 3729/17 3729/18 3729/25
3730/11 3730/23 3731/23 3731/24
3732/7 3732/19 3732/24 3733/5 3733/6
3735/8 3735/18 3735/25 3736/1 3736/2
3741/19 3746/24 3750/5 3751/2 3754/22
3755/3 3764/2 3764/14 3770/23 3776/1
3782/6 3783/4 3792/18 3795/11 3798/24
3800/11 3803/21 3804/18 3806/5
3806/15 3807/14 3808/12 3810/8 3811/5
3811/23 3812/8 3813/2 3813/16 3814/15
3815/7 3815/20 3818/16 3821/14
3822/16 3824/5 3826/2 3829/21 3831/6
3831/22 3834/2
marine-related [2] 3815/20 3824/5
mariner [3] 3832/14 3832/14 3832/15
maritime [3] 3737/5 3802/7 3831/14
Marshall [3] 3738/13 3738/15 3738/18
master [8] 3746/14 3746/15 3746/18
3747/6 3779/1 3779/2 3779/13 3780/8
master's [4] 3746/5 3746/7 3747/4
3747/15
masters [1] 3778/23
match [1] 3726/5
matching [2] 3726/7 3726/14
mate [3] 3751/5 3751/6 3751/6
materials [3] 3718/3 3727/22 3745/5
matrix [2] 3749/14 3759/8
matrixes [1] 3759/10
matter [2] 3736/12 3836/14
matters [5] 3735/16 3735/19 3735/21
3745/12 3835/10
MATTHEW [1] 3658/23
maximum [2] 3749/6 3794/21
may [22] 3698/19 3712/24 3713/7
3716/5 3717/5 3734/7 3747/9 3753/13
3754/8 3766/18 3774/5 3777/12 3783/3

3785/22 3803/25 3803/25 3809/4 3809/4
3810/9 3812/5 3812/9 3834/13
May 11 [1] 3803/25
May 15 [2] 3803/25 3809/4
May 18 [1] 3777/12
May 2005 [1] 3783/3
May 2007 [2] 3809/4 3810/9
maybe [14] 3692/15 3693/22 3693/24
3696/22 3700/4 3701/8 3705/7 3713/21
3717/21 3721/8 3722/18 3770/5 3806/21
3817/25
mayday [1] 3834/13
MAZE [1] 3658/8
McCLELLAN [1] 3657/22
McKay [2] 3798/14 3801/9
McKinney [1] 3660/5
MD [1] 3655/4
me [52] 3663/4 3669/11 3673/2 3673/15
3675/20 3677/21 3680/17 3681/15
3682/18 3683/5 3685/17 3687/3 3688/6
3688/13 3689/16 3689/21 3689/23
3690/7 3690/16 3693/13 3695/2 3697/2
3698/15 3698/17 3700/1 3700/16
3700/18 3701/24 3704/5 3707/23
3708/17 3712/10 3715/8 3715/19 3716/5
3726/11 3726/12 3730/20 3735/1 3735/2
3740/6 3742/24 3750/8 3754/15 3756/12
3765/3 3770/4 3777/12 3785/24 3809/3
3829/25 3834/15
mean [21] 3669/4 3680/19 3691/8
3699/16 3700/9 3712/7 3719/3 3724/9
3725/7 3726/12 3745/13 3745/17 3752/5
3758/13 3774/16 3804/11 3809/21
3813/8 3821/6 3821/20 3821/22
means [10] 3726/15 3740/8 3740/12
3741/7 3748/11 3759/11 3784/11
3792/21 3804/12 3828/9
meant [1] 3744/15
measurements [1] 3781/24
measures [4] 3754/10 3754/11 3766/24
3831/25
meat [1] 3736/17
mechanical [2] 3660/24 3763/6
mechanically [2] 3760/12 3763/11
Meche [3] 3705/23 3706/3 3710/1
medal [1] 3705/4
Medium [1] 3806/2
meet [8] 3664/14 3684/3 3684/7 3684/9
3745/14 3745/14 3745/14 3745/15
meeting [4] 3664/21 3666/13 3669/17
3670/2
member [1] 3736/11
members [1] 3784/14
memberships [1] 3729/21
Memoranda [1] 3827/12
men [2] 3705/16 3808/14
mention [3] 3732/11 3795/15 3815/7
mentioned [10] 3669/1 3670/6 3706/25
3708/15 3708/25 3709/1 3709/17
3709/22 3712/5 3723/22
mentioning [2] 3669/11 3716/16
mess [2] 3794/13 3794/14
message [1] 3714/5
met [4] 3677/16 3705/25 3802/4 3819/14
meter [4] 3668/17 3697/13 3697/17
3697/17
methane [2] 3763/12 3763/15
method [2] 3815/25 3824/10
meticulously [1] 3820/16
MEXICO [2] 3655/5 3787/15
MICHAEL [2] 3657/12 3659/12
MICHELLE [1] 3657/23
microphone [3] 3769/14 3818/1 3818/4

middle [4] 3709/7 3797/16 3797/16
3801/12
might [7] 3678/6 3714/13 3717/20
3727/24 3768/11 3784/12 3818/3
MIKAL [1] 3656/15
MIKE [2] 3659/3 3722/2
MILLER [1] 3659/6
Miller's [1] 3724/19
million [1] 3730/14
mind [2] 3686/4 3718/23
minute [9] 3669/21 3692/17 3692/18
3693/24 3694/1 3705/2 3705/11 3750/25
3768/5
minutes [20] 3664/22 3678/13 3678/21
3693/20 3694/3 3694/9 3721/9 3722/14
3722/18 3722/18 3722/20 3723/15
3801/8 3801/16 3802/4 3802/15 3826/6
3826/11 3834/18 3834/23
mischaracterize [1] 3699/16
missed [5] 3683/20 3781/17 3781/21
3820/24 3825/15
missing [1] 3793/16
mission [1] 3750/18
Mississippi [1] 3732/11
misspoke [1] 3681/21
mist [7] 3757/3 3757/4 3757/7 3757/8
3757/9 3757/10 3757/11
misunderstand [2] 3686/2 3712/9
MMS [1] 3789/12
Mobile [1] 3656/4
mode [1] 3806/11
MODU [2] 3734/9 3747/1
ModuSpec [5] 3782/19 3790/10 3790/19
3790/23 3790/23
moisture [1] 3794/22
moment [1] 3674/10
money [1] 3677/20
monitor [18] 3662/24 3663/16 3669/8
3669/18 3670/22 3671/11 3671/16
3671/19 3671/24 3673/7 3673/12
3673/13 3673/17 3673/21 3673/22
3679/20 3698/5 3764/24
monitored [4] 3672/2 3755/9 3764/18
3813/9
monitoring [11] 3665/12 3670/25 3671/3
3691/22 3725/23 3726/8 3744/3 3764/17
3788/23 3806/24 3826/16
monitors [2] 3764/20 3764/21
Montgomery [1] 3658/10
month [1] 3824/17
monthly [4] 3807/11 3807/16 3815/24
3824/9
months [5] 3752/21 3752/24 3787/16
3801/6 3809/11
Moore [3] 3745/2 3801/13 3830/25
more [22] 3663/10 3676/1 3676/13
3693/23 3699/10 3712/10 3713/14
3731/20 3745/4 3748/25 3754/24
3784/12 3794/11 3794/12 3797/1
3806/21 3819/5 3821/11 3821/12
3821/12 3821/12 3834/22
Morgan [1] 3660/14
morning [5] 3662/7 3663/8 3679/15
3835/2 3836/5
most [13] 3733/6 3739/14 3749/15
3754/2 3783/7 3785/23 3793/11 3796/19
3802/8 3813/19 3818/18 3821/23
3832/14
motion [1] 3728/3
motions [1] 3727/25
motors [1] 3748/18
Mountain [1] 3810/22
M
move [11] 3662/7 3727/23 3743/22
3749/19 3751/11 3753/8 3754/19 3775/3
3775/22 3819/5 3835/20
Move-off [2] 3775/3 3775/22
moved [1] 3750/21
movement [3] 3669/4 3669/9 3694/22
moves [1] 3835/4
moving [5] 3664/2 3664/3 3749/23
3749/25 3834/17
MPA [1] 3795/17
Mr [4] 3705/14 3718/7 3768/1 3775/25
Mr. [94] 3662/13 3662/19 3684/25
3685/15 3698/22 3704/24 3705/11
3705/16 3705/21 3707/1 3707/19
3708/19 3709/6 3709/11 3710/1 3710/20
3712/17 3712/20 3714/7 3714/7 3714/12
3715/9 3716/14 3720/25 3723/13
3723/16 3724/17 3724/19 3725/2
3725/22 3726/19 3727/18 3727/19
3727/20 3728/1 3728/4 3729/11 3733/22
3735/25 3736/10 3739/24 3756/6
3760/21 3763/24 3768/11 3768/15
3769/23 3772/7 3772/19 3779/6 3780/1
3780/24 3781/10 3782/6 3782/18 3783/4
3787/6 3787/8 3788/11 3791/1 3791/16
3791/18 3791/21 3793/5 3795/21
3796/16 3798/14 3799/17 3800/11
3801/25 3802/3 3808/24 3809/16 3811/4
3811/20 3813/2 3813/15 3817/11
3818/21 3818/23 3819/16 3820/7 3821/6
3829/6 3829/17 3830/15 3830/25 3831/1
3832/14 3835/5 3835/7 3835/14 3835/21
3836/2
Mr. Bellow [3] 3714/7 3714/7 3714/12
Mr. Bob [1] 3802/3
Mr. Brock [3] 3662/13 3723/13 3723/16
Mr. Brock's [1] 3725/22
Mr. Canducci [1] 3780/1
Mr. Cocales [1] 3829/17
Mr. Conrad [1] 3727/19
Mr. Daun [1] 3787/6
Mr. David [1] 3798/14
Mr. Doug [1] 3772/19
Mr. Gray [1] 3712/20
Mr. Greg [1] 3710/1
Mr. Johnson [2] 3830/15 3831/1
Mr. Kanner [1] 3725/2
Mr. Keith [13] 3662/19 3684/25 3685/15
3698/22 3705/11 3705/16 3709/11
3710/20 3715/9 3716/14 3720/25
3724/17 3726/19
Mr. Kelly [1] 3712/17
Mr. Kinchen [4] 3769/23 3791/1 3791/16
3791/18
Mr. Leo [2] 3705/21 3707/1
Mr. Lindner [2] 3707/19 3708/19
Mr. Miller's [1] 3724/19
Mr. Moore [1] 3830/25
Mr. Norman [1] 3818/23
Mr. Quirk [1] 3835/7
Mr. Steve [1] 3801/25
Mr. Tanner [2] 3704/24 3709/6
Mr. Underhill [1] 3835/14
Mr. Webster [43] 3727/18 3728/1
3729/11 3733/22 3735/25 3736/10
3739/24 3756/6 3760/21 3763/24
3768/11 3768/15 3772/7 3779/6 3780/24
3781/10 3782/6 3782/18 3783/4 3787/8
3788/11 3791/21 3793/5 3795/21
3796/16 3799/17 3800/11 3808/24
3809/16 3811/4 3811/20 3813/2 3813/15
3817/11 3818/21 3819/16 3820/7 3821/6

3829/6 3832/14 3835/5 3835/21 3836/2
Mr. Webster's [2] 3727/20 3728/4
Ms. [6] 3664/19 3665/22 3666/10
3668/19 3669/7 3670/1
Ms. Willis [6] 3664/19 3665/22 3666/10
3668/19 3669/7 3670/1
much [15] 3667/19 3709/10 3729/14
3755/24 3761/9 3770/22 3793/12 3795/4
3806/8 3810/11 3813/17 3815/2 3817/3
3817/14 3820/13
mud [48] 3662/22 3663/16 3664/24
3667/12 3667/21 3668/8 3669/8 3669/9
3669/14 3670/11 3673/18 3674/14
3674/19 3675/3 3678/16 3678/22
3678/24 3679/2 3679/7 3684/12 3684/17
3690/2 3692/1 3695/7 3695/24 3695/24
3696/1 3696/2 3696/6 3699/1 3699/23
3700/8 3701/5 3702/1 3703/21 3705/17
3705/17 3705/21 3706/12 3708/20
3708/25 3709/15 3709/18 3713/14
3722/15 3723/4 3725/2 3726/2
mug [4] 3713/18 3713/20 3714/25
3715/2
multimillion [1] 3734/17
multimillion-dollar [1] 3734/17
multiple [2] 3761/20 3762/2
Munger [1] 3659/12
must [4] 3749/2 3749/2 3787/16 3820/3
MUX [2] 3775/4 3775/8
my [49] 3671/20 3673/9 3673/23
3673/23 3674/15 3676/3 3677/21 3678/4
3678/9 3680/19 3681/24 3682/1 3682/3
3682/10 3682/10 3694/22 3699/14
3700/3 3700/16 3703/25 3707/6 3711/6
3712/11 3712/19 3714/3 3721/5 3722/18
3722/23 3722/24 3723/9 3727/18 3728/1
3728/13 3730/15 3730/19 3730/20
3730/21 3730/22 3732/12 3733/6 3740/6
3751/1 3752/2 3770/6 3780/18 3817/23
3817/24 3835/6 3836/12
myself [1] 3686/5
3714/4 3714/17 3715/22 3718/13

3718/14 3719/19 3719/21 3720/10
3723/12 3728/9 3745/11 3791/8 3794/14
3822/23
new [15] 3655/6 3655/24 3656/7
3656/13 3657/10 3658/17 3658/20
3659/7 3659/24 3660/19 3731/5 3731/15
3734/9 3735/6 3803/6
New Orleans [2] 3731/5 3731/15
Newcastle [1] 3729/19
Newman [1] 3802/11
next [40] 3666/11 3670/4 3675/6
3696/12 3696/15 3701/16 3770/8 3770/9
3771/5 3771/5 3771/15 3777/21 3780/19
3782/14 3783/9 3783/13 3786/3 3788/7
3798/7 3798/10 3799/14 3800/7 3800/9
3802/15 3802/23 3808/1 3814/22 3819/2
3819/4 3822/5 3823/5 3827/7 3827/22
3830/12 3832/6 3832/17 3832/25
3833/12 3834/16 3835/8
NFL [1] 3726/24
Nick [1] 3718/9
night [7] 3667/8 3673/13 3676/4 3711/11
3712/11 3724/25 3836/4
nine [3] 3772/16 3773/13 3801/6
Ninth [1] 3656/22
no [119] 3662/7 3668/17 3668/25
3669/11 3669/17 3669/20 3669/20
3670/16 3670/20 3673/1 3673/23
3673/25 3674/13 3674/23 3675/9
3677/14 3677/17 3679/1 3680/9 3680/15
3680/17 3682/5 3682/7 3682/21 3683/5
3683/18 3683/24 3684/8 3684/8 3684/8
3686/13 3687/11 3687/17 3687/18
3688/20 3689/23 3697/25 3698/11
3699/9 3699/14 3703/7 3704/20 3711/12
3711/18 3714/14 3714/17 3715/12
3715/18 3715/20 3715/22 3715/22
3718/11 3718/14 3720/10 3720/11
3721/11 3723/12 3724/2 3727/25 3736/5
3752/16 3754/18 3756/25 3758/7
3760/25 3761/2 3769/20 3770/4 3772/4
3772/24 3773/8 3774/10 3775/18
N
3776/16 3777/8 3789/1 3789/18 3794/14
name [8] 3705/25 3718/8 3727/12
3795/15 3796/13 3796/22 3796/24
3745/2 3787/8 3798/3 3818/23 3830/11 3800/5 3800/9 3801/1 3806/4 3808/11
names [2] 3744/20 3830/5
3811/2 3811/7 3813/22 3815/17 3816/5
naming [2] 3830/9 3830/10
3816/20 3817/24 3819/11 3823/9
NATHANIEL [1] 3657/19
3823/13 3823/21 3824/2 3824/8 3825/3
National [1] 3729/17
3826/5 3828/9 3830/4 3830/18 3830/23
Natural [1] 3657/16
3831/17 3832/3 3832/8 3832/21 3833/2
nature [2] 3761/8 3826/18
3833/6 3833/10 3833/16 3833/19
naval [4] 3729/19 3729/22 3730/23
3833/22 3834/8 3835/17 3835/19
3735/22
no-flow [1] 3724/2
navigation [1] 3834/5
no-salt [3] 3715/18 3715/20 3718/11
NDT [1] 3781/20
No. [10] 3667/10 3680/1 3681/6 3683/12
near [2] 3711/10 3811/16
3805/4 3805/10 3809/8 3814/7 3814/8
nearing [1] 3803/6
3823/13
necessarily [2] 3766/2 3822/23
No. 1 [4] 3680/1 3809/8 3814/7 3823/13
necessary [6] 3738/24 3747/9 3761/21 No. 2 [2] 3681/6 3805/4
3765/14 3776/9 3802/21
No. 3 [3] 3667/10 3683/12 3805/10
need [8] 3687/10 3713/11 3717/8
No. 4 [1] 3814/8
3770/16 3776/10 3810/18 3816/21
nobody [1] 3726/11
3817/18
non [1] 3732/25
needed [2] 3685/23 3794/1
non-litigation [1] 3732/25
needs [4] 3682/25 3778/17 3811/6
noncompliance [1] 3752/3
3821/15
nonconformances [1] 3833/4
negative [3] 3666/19 3670/8 3835/15
nonconformities [19] 3751/13 3751/18
neither [2] 3745/6 3794/2
3753/24 3754/3 3766/11 3766/12
neutralize [1] 3826/21
3766/18 3766/20 3766/21 3767/11
never [27] 3673/20 3673/24 3677/11
3767/14 3777/18 3777/18 3784/24
3683/6 3684/13 3697/6 3704/5 3704/6
3802/22 3827/12 3827/17 3827/20
3710/11 3712/18 3713/24 3714/1 3714/3 3833/10
N
nonconformity [33] 3740/8 3740/18
3740/20 3740/22 3741/1 3741/5 3741/7
3742/22 3752/5 3752/6 3752/8 3752/8
3752/24 3752/24 3753/2 3753/3 3753/5
3753/5 3765/19 3767/19 3777/22 3780/7
3784/17 3784/19 3785/22 3786/8
3786/18 3786/23 3787/2 3799/1 3828/4
3828/5 3828/6
none [1] 3674/8
nonexclusive [1] 3731/9
nonfulfillment [1] 3740/9
NONJURY [1] 3655/14
nonoperational [4] 3804/14 3805/11
3815/9 3823/8
nook [1] 3752/19
Norfolk [1] 3659/20
normal [8] 3675/16 3675/17 3676/3
3676/5 3676/12 3676/16 3752/5 3802/18
normally [5] 3740/19 3751/2 3759/3
3797/20 3804/6
Norman [1] 3818/23
Norske [2] 3785/13 3797/9
North [1] 3658/12
not [179] 3668/3 3669/7 3673/7 3673/21
3674/20 3677/5 3680/22 3680/25
3681/13 3681/24 3682/5 3682/6 3683/10
3684/9 3686/7 3686/8 3686/13 3688/25
3689/16 3696/18 3696/25 3697/1 3697/4
3697/13 3698/1 3698/9 3700/15 3702/12
3703/7 3704/4 3704/8 3704/10 3705/24
3709/5 3709/7 3711/1 3711/4 3711/8
3711/11 3711/14 3711/15 3711/15
3711/23 3712/10 3713/21 3715/5 3715/9
3716/23 3717/6 3717/7 3719/1 3721/1
3721/2 3721/5 3723/25 3724/9 3726/5
3728/13 3728/14 3729/14 3730/4
3732/11 3734/6 3738/16 3739/15
3740/15 3740/22 3744/12 3744/13
3745/20 3746/2 3746/24 3747/16
3747/20 3747/25 3749/24 3749/25
3750/10 3750/12 3750/12 3750/13
3750/22 3752/14 3754/2 3754/13
3756/15 3758/1 3758/3 3758/4 3759/18
3760/13 3763/14 3764/19 3767/15
3767/19 3768/19 3769/23 3769/25
3770/3 3770/4 3770/5 3772/10 3776/16
3776/20 3777/2 3777/8 3778/4 3778/20
3780/6 3780/17 3781/15 3782/1 3783/15
3784/20 3785/2 3786/10 3787/13 3788/4
3789/13 3790/3 3791/4 3794/1 3795/15
3796/15 3799/3 3800/3 3802/8 3804/1
3804/24 3805/3 3805/3 3805/4 3805/11
3806/4 3806/11 3806/12 3807/8 3807/12
3808/11 3810/17 3811/20 3811/21
3812/4 3812/9 3812/14 3813/8 3813/10
3813/17 3813/21 3815/10 3816/17
3816/19 3816/21 3816/21 3817/4 3817/8
3818/11 3819/12 3819/20 3819/20
3820/1 3821/10 3822/25 3823/1 3824/8
3824/23 3825/3 3825/6 3825/11 3826/17
3828/3 3828/21 3829/22 3830/4 3830/17
3830/18 3830/24 3832/23 3835/6
note [4] 3704/12 3727/25 3777/23
3784/17
noted [10] 3681/3 3681/5 3681/24
3704/14 3778/23 3781/17 3783/22
3784/19 3785/5 3809/9
notes [5] 3665/22 3681/24 3682/1
3793/14 3819/9
nothing [4] 3673/2 3674/21 3675/7
3710/11
notice [4] 3769/11 3780/7 3784/4 3788/6

notification [3] 3789/21 3789/25 3790/4
November [1] 3795/24
November 2005 [1] 3795/24
now [110] 3663/16 3664/6 3664/6
3664/24 3665/21 3667/24 3669/21
3670/10 3671/8 3671/23 3674/1 3674/17
3676/22 3678/24 3679/2 3679/7 3679/15
3679/24 3681/5 3681/12 3681/21
3682/14 3682/16 3682/24 3683/12
3685/2 3685/4 3685/17 3686/8 3686/14
3686/16 3688/3 3688/14 3690/7 3691/5
3691/25 3692/8 3692/24 3693/10 3694/4
3694/6 3694/12 3694/14 3695/7 3695/12
3696/4 3696/24 3700/7 3706/3 3706/21
3706/25 3710/2 3712/2 3715/5 3718/15
3720/2 3720/21 3720/25 3738/14
3739/24 3740/2 3741/20 3741/23
3743/22 3746/14 3747/11 3747/13
3747/21 3748/2 3750/10 3750/25
3754/16 3754/19 3756/12 3757/21
3759/9 3760/23 3764/16 3766/7 3769/10
3770/6 3772/16 3773/6 3775/8 3776/13
3776/20 3777/21 3779/6 3779/14 3782/3
3783/24 3784/7 3784/19 3785/5 3787/20
3792/18 3794/25 3796/3 3797/16
3802/18 3804/5 3804/18 3806/17 3822/5
3823/21 3823/22 3823/24 3828/13
3830/5 3835/1
nowadays [1] 3745/17
number [20] 3664/4 3664/5 3671/18
3709/15 3715/15 3727/4 3729/6 3736/25
3780/21 3781/8 3798/18 3804/13
3805/16 3809/8 3810/25 3812/3 3814/5
3814/23 3815/8 3823/7
numbers [1] 3803/9
numeric [1] 3666/3
numerical [2] 3663/24 3664/1
numerous [5] 3781/17 3808/4 3814/12
3822/11 3823/14
NW [1] 3659/3
3758/16 3767/8 3778/17 3787/13

occasionally [1] 3817/8
occasions [1] 3781/18
occur [3] 3693/4 3789/22 3804/23
occurred [4] 3667/15 3668/3 3734/21
3735/5
occurrence [1] 3770/12
Occurrences [1] 3751/14
occurring [1] 3668/20
occurs [2] 3693/18 3789/21
ocean [1] 3795/16
oceangoing [3] 3733/19 3738/20
3813/17
October [2] 3790/14 3793/7
October 17 [1] 3793/7
October 2005 [1] 3790/14
off [52] 3675/19 3675/20 3675/21
3675/22 3675/22 3676/2 3676/8 3676/9
3676/10 3676/11 3676/14 3681/9
3681/13 3682/6 3682/9 3683/14 3683/17
3688/4 3688/25 3689/1 3689/4 3689/6
3689/13 3697/2 3707/6 3707/20 3708/6
3712/19 3721/2 3721/6 3721/8 3724/1
3725/8 3727/3 3733/16 3734/14 3748/25
3749/7 3749/19 3762/13 3763/1 3763/11
3763/15 3763/23 3775/3 3775/22 3776/4
3805/8 3812/22 3817/24 3818/2 3830/11
off-tour [2] 3707/20 3708/6
offer [3] 3721/17 3727/2 3772/14
office [16] 3655/20 3657/19 3657/25
3658/13 3659/17 3670/12 3670/14
3670/17 3670/18 3702/1 3779/16
3779/18 3782/5 3784/12 3785/8 3797/22
officer [4] 3744/17 3787/10 3802/6
3802/11
officers [3] 3751/1 3751/2 3751/8
Official [3] 3660/18 3836/9 3836/18
offs [1] 3734/13
offshore [13] 3659/6 3659/9 3659/12
3659/16 3659/20 3730/12 3749/24
3797/10 3801/2 3801/7 3803/11 3827/16
3828/17
O
often [1] 3782/1
O'Keefe [1] 3655/23
Oh [6] 3684/8 3699/9 3705/19 3706/3
O'ROURKE [1] 3657/17
3780/3 3813/5
oath [3] 3688/8 3689/9 3689/17
oil [18] 3655/4 3655/4 3740/17 3757/4
object [5] 3662/9 3715/25 3769/21
3757/9 3757/10 3757/11 3763/10
3790/17 3790/22
3794/20 3795/7 3795/12 3795/15
objection [18] 3662/7 3711/18 3711/22
3812/24 3813/6 3814/5 3814/7 3814/11
3712/22 3716/21 3717/4 3717/10
3814/11
3717/14 3718/21 3719/18 3724/12
OIM [9] 3672/24 3745/13 3745/14
3736/5 3761/22 3769/12 3769/16
3779/4 3829/12 3830/3 3830/3 3830/11
3780/11 3791/11 3820/19
3830/12
objections [1] 3727/24
OIMs [2] 3778/22 3830/10
objective [6] 3740/9 3741/16 3751/20
okay [41] 3662/22 3662/23 3664/7
3778/14 3778/14 3778/18
3676/23 3682/13 3682/16 3685/1 3687/5
objectives [6] 3741/15 3741/16 3741/20 3690/9 3693/15 3698/25 3700/3 3700/7
3741/23 3742/14 3743/20
3703/3 3705/12 3706/24 3708/4 3708/11
obligated [2] 3786/25 3800/19
3710/5 3713/5 3718/1 3719/11 3721/19
obligation [12] 3751/24 3752/4 3752/11 3725/21 3729/8 3731/20 3737/22 3738/9
3753/17 3766/13 3767/14 3767/18
3741/5 3746/1 3756/6 3757/21 3761/11
3787/21 3788/4 3788/4 3788/5 3803/15 3769/2 3776/2 3778/18 3779/22 3784/15
obligations [3] 3741/21 3765/16 3765/17 3786/10 3801/20 3825/14
observation [10] 3786/5 3786/6 3786/7 Olson [1] 3659/12
3802/25 3803/3 3804/10 3809/5 3809/8 omitted [1] 3781/25
3824/2 3825/8
on [303]
observations [6] 3786/16 3798/11
on-site [1] 3789/11
3798/13 3802/21 3805/23 3827/17
onboard [2] 3806/11 3827/19
observe [5] 3697/1 3697/3 3697/7
once [5] 3675/13 3693/7 3752/8 3757/18
3698/5 3698/9
3779/17
observed [5] 3665/3 3685/4 3740/8
one [70] 3663/19 3669/5 3678/6 3684/25
3746/11 3814/7
3685/3 3690/14 3692/13 3696/22
obviously [7] 3732/25 3746/1 3749/3
3697/22 3699/7 3699/10 3703/2 3704/11
O
one... [57] 3705/21 3705/23 3711/3
3713/13 3713/13 3713/14 3718/6 3721/8
3722/23 3722/24 3724/17 3726/6
3726/15 3737/3 3737/13 3739/15 3740/6
3742/9 3743/8 3743/11 3749/9 3751/1
3754/2 3767/5 3769/5 3769/16 3770/14
3770/14 3771/5 3771/5 3772/10 3775/5
3775/6 3775/12 3778/21 3780/6 3783/7
3784/12 3791/4 3794/6 3794/10 3796/19
3798/2 3798/14 3804/8 3815/2 3816/14
3818/18 3819/4 3821/23 3824/17 3829/3
3829/25 3831/8 3832/6 3832/17 3832/25
ones [5] 3666/8 3796/11 3796/13
3796/23 3796/25
ongoing [3] 3796/14 3811/25 3812/6
only [15] 3670/11 3670/21 3671/14
3697/9 3699/7 3724/24 3728/19 3769/5
3777/15 3792/12 3810/13 3813/17
3813/23 3813/23 3832/23
onshore [1] 3803/10
open [5] 3703/7 3703/18 3717/24 3756/1
3798/15
opened [1] 3717/24
openings [1] 3832/17
operate [5] 3732/8 3755/8 3775/11
3805/17 3827/6
operated [2] 3730/10 3775/5
operates [1] 3750/10
operating [6] 3733/13 3744/17 3747/3
3802/11 3827/16 3827/19
operation [20] 3730/17 3732/10 3733/22
3737/16 3741/25 3743/12 3743/23
3744/4 3746/22 3753/21 3755/9 3764/3
3765/6 3775/5 3782/10 3809/19 3812/1
3813/12 3814/6 3825/5
operational [9] 3666/13 3754/8 3774/7
3774/10 3774/14 3815/12 3823/17
3832/25 3833/21
operations [9] 3732/7 3771/10 3771/21
3771/25 3788/22 3789/2 3803/11 3812/7
3824/13
operator [8] 3713/19 3738/6 3770/16
3771/12 3771/15 3771/18 3833/4
3833/13
operators [4] 3735/13 3749/10 3749/11
3813/24
opinion [76] 3743/19 3744/15 3745/9
3746/14 3746/18 3747/13 3747/14
3748/10 3751/7 3752/2 3754/16 3760/21
3761/11 3762/1 3762/7 3762/18 3764/2
3764/13 3765/4 3767/20 3769/10
3770/19 3771/2 3771/23 3772/1 3773/6
3774/13 3774/16 3775/9 3779/7 3782/3
3782/6 3783/1 3783/4 3786/15 3787/20
3788/24 3789/15 3792/18 3792/24
3793/19 3793/22 3794/25 3795/11
3796/17 3796/20 3797/4 3798/24
3800/11 3806/5 3806/14 3807/14 3808/8
3808/12 3809/15 3809/25 3811/5 3811/8
3813/2 3814/10 3814/15 3816/12
3816/25 3817/4 3817/11 3818/16
3819/15 3820/20 3821/14 3822/16
3823/2 3826/2 3828/20 3831/22 3834/2
3834/9
opinions [1] 3745/5
opportunity [3] 3673/6 3686/8 3714/15
opposed [1] 3784/9
opposite [1] 3700/16
optimizer [1] 3794/5
optimizers [1] 3794/11
or [236]
order [7] 3698/6 3721/18 3728/15

3728/16 3752/22 3817/17 3821/18
orders [8] 3746/9 3781/15 3781/19
3796/15 3807/12 3819/24 3820/3 3821/4
Ordinary [1] 3729/17
organization [4] 3736/22 3737/5 3803/10
3831/14
orient [1] 3690/16
original [3] 3717/16 3783/18 3784/1
originally [1] 3738/11
Orleans [12] 3655/6 3655/24 3656/7
3656/13 3657/10 3658/17 3658/20
3659/7 3659/24 3660/19 3731/5 3731/15
other [43] 3666/8 3667/18 3670/17
3671/6 3671/15 3672/15 3682/7 3691/15
3698/3 3709/5 3709/8 3711/13 3713/15
3714/25 3715/15 3716/6 3716/7 3716/11
3724/17 3725/4 3727/19 3730/8 3735/3
3735/4 3737/18 3752/25 3763/3 3763/20
3772/14 3785/5 3793/15 3804/14 3805/7
3806/25 3807/8 3808/3 3812/3 3812/5
3815/9 3823/8 3823/14 3834/14 3835/7
others [4] 3709/23 3785/5 3802/10
3810/11
our [7] 3671/17 3710/24 3711/2 3711/3
3713/7 3713/11 3751/10
Ours [1] 3711/2
out [78] 3666/4 3667/5 3671/4 3672/15
3677/19 3678/3 3679/5 3683/23 3684/23
3684/24 3687/3 3688/13 3691/6 3691/7
3693/15 3694/15 3694/23 3695/18
3697/10 3700/6 3700/11 3700/19 3701/2
3704/5 3704/10 3705/20 3705/23 3706/2
3706/18 3708/23 3716/9 3722/9 3722/10
3722/12 3723/22 3725/8 3726/13 3729/1
3731/17 3734/9 3734/19 3734/22
3738/24 3739/25 3743/2 3752/14
3752/21 3756/10 3756/12 3756/13
3756/14 3757/25 3759/21 3773/10
3781/15 3782/11 3783/23 3787/23
3789/25 3791/5 3794/13 3794/15 3795/5
3795/7 3795/16 3799/20 3805/21
3809/23 3818/3 3819/20 3819/21
3819/24 3821/4 3821/18 3827/15 3828/1
3828/2 3831/15
out' [1] 3687/10
outboard [1] 3748/18
outline [1] 3741/21
output [2] 3663/5 3671/17
outputs [4] 3818/13 3818/13 3824/25
3825/4
outset [1] 3784/23
outside [1] 3767/8
outstanding [1] 3753/22
over [33] 3664/2 3666/5 3666/20
3668/12 3681/8 3683/12 3689/17
3690/21 3691/15 3692/3 3692/5 3693/7
3695/7 3695/18 3696/6 3696/7 3700/10
3700/14 3709/5 3709/8 3710/25 3718/20
3719/8 3719/17 3724/15 3737/2 3755/17
3792/7 3798/16 3798/17 3798/23
3806/18 3823/22
Overall [2] 3783/17 3787/14
overboard [5] 3667/25 3668/17 3697/11
3698/4 3698/10
overdue [11] 3753/25 3798/23 3807/11
3809/8 3809/10 3810/25 3811/2 3811/6
3815/18 3824/3 3824/10
overhaul [1] 3819/9
overhauls [2] 3811/1 3811/6
overheated [1] 3757/19
overridden [1] 3774/10
override [2] 3822/14 3826/21
overriding [1] 3747/6

overrule [3] 3711/22 3717/10 3791/11
Overruled [2] 3719/20 3820/21
overspeed [3] 3763/5 3763/6 3763/7
overspeeding [1] 3808/18
overview [3] 3730/7 3747/12 3751/10
overwhelmed [1] 3713/7
overworked [8] 3713/8 3713/11 3713/22
3713/24 3714/3 3714/4 3714/13 3813/19
own [5] 3730/22 3732/8 3732/12
3766/24 3794/2
owner [3] 3738/5 3788/1 3803/8
owners [2] 3735/12 3742/12
owning [2] 3733/13 3752/25
P
p.m [2] 3674/9 3720/2
package [1] 3776/1
page [56] 3661/2 3674/25 3679/13
3685/12 3714/20 3756/3 3768/23 3769/2
3770/8 3770/9 3770/11 3771/4 3771/6
3772/22 3775/1 3776/17 3777/21 3781/3
3782/21 3783/13 3784/17 3786/3 3786/5
3788/17 3789/18 3790/15 3790/18
3790/18 3794/16 3797/17 3798/7
3798/11 3799/23 3799/24 3800/7 3800/9
3801/12 3802/23 3804/3 3808/1 3810/15
3811/14 3811/16 3812/17 3814/22
3815/17 3816/5 3817/7 3819/2 3822/5
3823/5 3827/7 3827/7 3827/8 3827/10
3833/12
page 3 [2] 3772/22 3810/15
page 31 [1] 3817/7
page 38 [1] 3770/11
pages [1] 3777/21
Palmintier [1] 3657/2
Panama [6] 3731/2 3731/3 3731/5
3731/11 3733/11 3738/12
Panama-flagged [1] 3738/12
panel [3] 3775/5 3775/9 3822/11
paper [2] 3699/25 3715/7
paragraph [15] 3771/6 3772/24 3775/4
3775/19 3777/1 3778/9 3778/9 3778/14
3781/7 3793/25 3796/7 3807/5 3812/20
3812/21 3813/3
parameter,' [1] 3687/19
parameters [8] 3663/17 3663/23 3666/5
3671/1 3673/8 3673/12 3673/13 3673/21
paramount [1] 3783/7
part [23] 3665/19 3690/19 3698/1
3719/14 3719/14 3740/4 3740/5 3750/17
3760/13 3760/22 3761/25 3776/24
3778/18 3788/7 3791/21 3792/5 3803/14
3803/14 3805/24 3807/3 3831/12
3831/12 3831/13
Part A [1] 3740/5
participate [1] 3802/7
participated [1] 3715/14
participating [1] 3716/6
particular [3] 3716/10 3741/18 3793/1
particularly [3] 3734/21 3760/24 3782/10
parties [3] 3685/20 3728/10 3736/14
parts [4] 3809/12 3814/1 3817/16
3817/19
party [3] 3742/16 3767/7 3767/8
pass [11] 3665/6 3668/11 3704/18
3831/16 3832/3 3832/20 3833/1 3833/5
3833/9 3833/15 3834/7
passage [1] 3704/13
passengers [1] 3737/2
passive [1] 3806/11
past [5] 3668/17 3734/1 3794/22
3796/11 3828/14
P
paste [1] 3819/10
patch [1] 3810/3
path [2] 3700/1 3781/21
pattern [3] 3791/3 3791/9 3791/12
PAUL [4] 3656/6 3829/12 3830/3
3830/13
PC [3] 3656/9 3660/7 3660/11
pen [3] 3693/10 3699/25 3701/24
Peninsular [1] 3732/11
Pennsylvania [1] 3659/3
people [15] 3672/14 3686/1 3708/23
3709/15 3717/12 3722/9 3742/16
3745/15 3753/23 3793/11 3797/17
3797/22 3802/20 3813/9 3829/15
per [4] 3666/4 3692/17 3692/18 3713/14
percent [5] 3792/11 3792/11 3792/12
3792/14 3792/14
perform [13] 3671/20 3673/9 3673/23
3674/14 3674/15 3714/3 3750/18
3761/20 3762/1 3762/16 3770/13 3778/4
3782/24
performed [7] 3696/8 3722/16 3772/25
3782/1 3810/22 3819/13 3820/15
performing [2] 3771/21 3821/5
perhaps [2] 3708/14 3826/17
period [34] 3668/5 3669/22 3670/14
3671/1 3674/2 3676/19 3677/7 3680/7
3681/5 3682/14 3682/19 3688/11
3690/25 3692/1 3693/8 3694/1 3696/24
3698/3 3698/23 3699/20 3714/6 3720/6
3723/7 3752/9 3752/12 3790/20 3807/22
3808/3 3810/20 3823/22 3826/6 3826/7
3826/8 3826/12
periodic [3] 3766/8 3816/18 3818/14
Perkin [1] 3662/6
person [32] 3713/14 3737/14 3737/15
3743/25 3744/3 3744/10 3744/21 3745/3
3745/9 3745/19 3745/23 3765/22
3765/24 3767/3 3767/13 3775/13
3778/22 3779/1 3779/4 3779/9 3779/13
3779/20 3779/24 3779/24 3786/19
3786/22 3800/16 3800/18 3801/18
3801/20 3830/17 3830/20
personal [4] 3817/5 3831/23 3832/11
3834/1
personnel [14] 3672/7 3709/22 3734/19
3741/9 3742/5 3743/17 3778/3 3781/15
3789/24 3789/24 3803/6 3803/6 3803/10
3820/5
persons [8] 3743/22 3744/1 3744/3
3744/10 3744/20 3778/23 3778/24
3801/24
perspective [1] 3669/9
PETITION [1] 3655/8
petroleum [1] 3714/8
petrophysicist [1] 3714/9
Phibro [1] 3732/9
Phibro Energy [1] 3732/9
PHILLIP [1] 3659/23
philosophy [2] 3774/8 3774/15
phone [11] 3706/16 3709/15 3710/12
3724/18 3724/20 3725/1 3725/4 3725/12
3745/16 3817/23 3817/24
phrase [2] 3715/20 3716/14
pick [2] 3662/21 3697/17
picture [3] 3699/5 3771/20 3773/23
pictures [1] 3764/16
piece [7] 3699/25 3715/6 3750/15
3754/22 3755/3 3796/18 3821/21
pieces [2] 3755/19 3756/11
Pigman [1] 3659/22
pipe [23] 3663/23 3671/4 3671/24

3672/2 3675/11 3675/23 3676/2 3676/14
3680/3 3681/8 3681/13 3682/8 3683/4
3683/13 3685/8 3686/16 3688/4 3688/11
3689/11 3718/6 3735/4 3735/4 3749/5
pipe-handling [1] 3735/4
pipe-racking [1] 3735/4
pit [8] 3665/10 3665/12 3669/5 3706/13
3707/7 3726/6 3726/15 3726/15
pits [8] 3663/13 3663/14 3665/17 3669/1
3671/4 3683/22 3722/25 3725/6
place [23] 3664/18 3668/16 3669/13
3669/14 3674/9 3674/17 3675/1 3688/4
3697/11 3717/21 3726/3 3750/21
3750/21 3767/10 3772/25 3773/9
3789/20 3800/5 3806/4 3811/3 3811/7
3831/25 3833/3
plaintiffs [14] 3655/18 3655/22 3656/2
3656/5 3656/8 3656/12 3656/15 3656/18
3656/21 3657/2 3657/5 3657/8 3726/21
3726/22
Plaintiffs' [1] 3736/10
plan [6] 3783/2 3803/9 3806/4 3811/7
3827/21 3828/5
planned [10] 3664/19 3668/20 3669/13
3669/23 3753/20 3781/12 3809/8 3809/9
3811/25 3819/20
planning [3] 3810/17 3817/7 3817/9
plans [2] 3800/6 3800/10
platoon [1] 3726/25
players [1] 3727/1
PLC [3] 3658/20 3658/23 3659/4
please [66] 3662/3 3680/19 3690/7
3695/2 3698/18 3727/13 3729/16
3739/21 3746/4 3747/21 3751/12 3753/8
3756/3 3768/8 3768/9 3768/24 3769/14
3771/4 3771/5 3772/5 3772/22 3773/15
3774/19 3775/1 3775/20 3776/17 3777/9
3781/4 3782/21 3784/5 3784/18 3785/11
3786/3 3787/4 3788/13 3789/18 3790/7
3790/15 3793/3 3793/8 3795/18 3795/20
3797/6 3798/8 3799/14 3799/23 3800/7
3802/23 3803/18 3803/24 3804/3 3807/5
3808/1 3808/22 3809/6 3810/6 3810/15
3811/14 3812/18 3814/22 3818/19
3819/22 3823/25 3824/21 3826/24
3833/12
plenty [2] 3769/15 3790/20
plural [1] 3744/12
plus [1] 3664/18
ply [1] 3742/12
PM [4] 3782/25 3783/1 3783/3 3796/14
pod [2] 3771/13 3771/13
point [26] 3683/19 3689/24 3693/11
3694/9 3694/12 3697/13 3705/5 3708/4
3710/7 3710/21 3724/4 3724/17 3726/9
3729/1 3739/25 3749/20 3749/23
3749/23 3750/4 3750/4 3757/16 3792/25
3794/19 3826/22 3834/19 3834/20
pointed [1] 3791/5
pointer [1] 3700/3
pointing [2] 3694/6 3773/10
points [2] 3706/10 3769/7
police [1] 3739/8
policies [1] 3815/11
policy [2] 3743/8 3824/13
Polish [1] 3733/12
pollution [4] 3744/4 3747/8 3751/20
3814/11
pontoons [2] 3748/12 3748/16
poor [2] 3793/15 3814/13
pop [5] 3675/19 3676/8 3676/9 3676/14
3725/8
pop-off [5] 3675/19 3676/8 3676/9

3676/14 3725/8
port [9] 3732/3 3732/3 3739/4 3739/5
3739/10 3739/15 3739/17 3749/24
3805/16
port/aft [1] 3805/16
portable [3] 3775/12 3794/20 3795/14
portholes [1] 3832/18
portion [1] 3776/4
poses [1] 3741/8
position [6] 3713/15 3748/23 3749/1
3749/2 3749/10 3751/2
positioned [2] 3734/22 3748/11
positioning [1] 3810/14
possibility [2] 3713/13 3774/4
possible [9] 3760/19 3767/10 3775/11
3775/20 3782/1 3786/10 3802/20
3814/10 3819/12
possibly [1] 3812/16
Post [5] 3655/20 3657/19 3657/25
3658/13 3659/17
potential [6] 3747/24 3761/1 3771/8
3776/11 3781/8 3803/5
potentially [1] 3771/16
power [4] 3748/25 3749/18 3749/19
3812/20
Poydras [4] 3656/6 3658/19 3659/6
3660/19
practical [1] 3794/1
practice [8] 3664/14 3745/13 3781/14
3796/20 3820/2 3821/19 3821/20
3828/20
practices [1] 3741/24
preceded [1] 3718/10
precisely [2] 3678/1 3754/4
prematurely [1] 3821/22
prepare [2] 3670/8 3803/8
prepared [5] 3768/17 3774/22 3782/18
3782/19 3790/10
Preparedness [1] 3747/22
preparing [1] 3742/6
present [6] 3792/10 3801/14 3802/10
3812/4 3812/10 3814/16
presenting [1] 3769/23
preset [1] 3792/12
president [2] 3798/2 3802/11
pressure [30] 3663/6 3663/23 3664/2
3666/5 3666/19 3671/4 3671/24 3672/2
3675/11 3675/18 3675/23 3675/24
3676/10 3676/12 3680/3 3680/18 3681/9
3681/14 3682/8 3683/4 3683/6 3683/13
3685/8 3686/17 3688/4 3688/25 3689/3
3689/11 3704/3 3725/7
pressured [3] 3714/4 3717/23 3718/1
pressures [2] 3675/22 3704/6
pressuring [1] 3717/25
pretty [4] 3693/7 3712/5 3725/19 3741/1
prevent [4] 3762/12 3773/9 3809/14
3825/25
preventer [7] 3750/9 3750/14 3750/19
3750/22 3768/16 3769/20 3773/3
prevention [4] 3741/17 3744/4 3747/8
3751/20
preventive [3] 3772/24 3773/8 3796/14
previous [2] 3786/12 3830/14
previously [4] 3735/15 3735/18 3768/21
3816/4
primary [5] 3750/18 3772/12 3778/23
3782/7 3782/8
prior [14] 3664/17 3676/7 3676/14
3678/13 3722/19 3774/8 3778/9 3786/13
3786/16 3787/23 3788/18 3796/3
3796/11 3798/10
3691/15 3692/3 3692/5 3692/8 3692/12

3692/25 3693/3 3694/15 3694/17
3805/16 3805/21 3812/15
pumped [5] 3667/21 3668/17 3671/13
3671/14 3671/18
pumping [6] 3675/14 3675/19 3676/16
3676/17 3676/20 3692/2
pumps [23] 3671/14 3675/21 3675/22
3681/9 3681/12 3682/6 3682/9 3682/25
3683/14 3683/17 3688/4 3688/24
3688/25 3689/12 3692/20 3693/2 3721/6
3721/8 3722/17 3723/19 3724/1 3725/9
3757/25
purchasing [1] 3733/25
purple [1] 3691/5
purpose [7] 3737/15 3739/10 3757/12
3772/12 3813/5 3826/14 3829/6
Push [1] 3818/4
put [19] 3663/2 3663/4 3674/5 3678/2
3698/17 3725/17 3734/10 3734/24
3738/25 3739/20 3740/11 3750/24
3769/11 3788/16 3792/22 3810/5
3831/22 3832/11 3833/25
puts [2] 3810/2 3817/5
putting [3] 3788/5 3804/22 3821/12
rather [1] 3681/1

RE [2] 3655/4 3655/7
priority [3] 3672/8 3800/5 3804/12
reach [1] 3721/1
proactive [1] 3817/9
react [2] 3753/6 3753/24
probability [1] 3770/12
read [21] 3685/17 3704/13 3713/3
probably [3] 3678/13 3785/10 3836/3
3713/16 3740/2 3740/2 3753/15 3763/24
probation [1] 3788/6
3770/8 3770/9 3774/11 3787/13 3792/16
problem [12] 3723/11 3745/16 3745/19
3793/17 3794/7 3798/16 3799/3 3799/4
3786/8 3786/10 3796/14 3804/12 3805/7
3821/7 3822/2 3828/11
3809/14 3832/15 3834/12 3834/14
reading [8] 3686/21 3687/8 3687/14
problems [12] 3718/2 3718/3 3718/4
3709/17 3778/6 3778/7 3778/8 3778/11
3734/21 3735/6 3737/19 3740/14
readings [2] 3663/6 3793/15
3745/20 3772/13 3812/21 3814/12
ready [2] 3662/19 3705/13
3821/12
real [5] 3725/19 3751/10 3762/11
procedure [17] 3666/18 3667/6 3668/24
3775/20 3822/2
3669/2 3781/24 3785/2 3788/20 3788/23
real-time [1] 3725/19
3789/1 3789/20 3790/3 3818/12 3819/11
really [12] 3685/11 3706/9 3710/7
3819/13 3819/25 3824/25 3828/7
3710/9 3710/9 3710/13 3712/10 3716/23
procedures [11] 3666/23 3743/11
3735/5 3743/2 3749/17 3759/13
3747/23 3751/17 3751/21 3753/11
reason [10] 3682/11 3711/13 3716/18
3754/6 3771/25 3784/24 3818/12
3717/2 3720/9 3721/11 3767/23 3767/24
3824/24
3782/7 3782/8
proceedings [3] 3660/24 3836/6 3836/13
reasonable [1] 3794/4
process [6] 3759/22 3767/4 3789/25
reasons [2] 3782/7 3787/2
3815/18 3824/3 3833/14
rebuilding [1] 3773/2
produce [1] 3742/18
rebuilt [1] 3796/11
Q
produced [1] 3798/17
recall [17] 3669/11 3674/21 3674/25
producing [1] 3807/11
QHSE [3] 3798/3 3801/13 3801/25
3686/7 3686/13 3709/14 3709/17 3710/2
PRODUCTION [7] 3655/10 3658/19
qualifications [3] 3736/4 3737/11
3722/6 3723/15 3723/18 3723/21
3658/19 3658/22 3658/22 3659/3 3659/3 3813/16
3724/22 3725/25 3744/20 3806/21
professional [2] 3729/21 3730/2
qualified [1] 3803/9
3823/12
profiles [1] 3794/3
quality [1] 3799/9
received [1] 3677/12
program [5] 3772/24 3773/8 3797/9
quarters [10] 3701/11 3701/17 3701/19 receives [1] 3759/13
3799/10 3817/10
3702/11 3703/1 3703/5 3703/12 3703/15 recently [1] 3796/25
progress [1] 3815/5
3748/15 3832/2
recess [3] 3768/5 3768/7 3835/2
project [3] 3789/23 3794/2 3836/2
question [21] 3675/6 3680/19 3681/23
recognition [2] 3771/11 3771/14
promoting [1] 3754/10
3682/18 3684/14 3685/14 3686/2 3686/3 recognize [6] 3690/17 3712/16 3756/6
propeller [1] 3795/5
3688/15 3704/14 3709/6 3709/9 3711/19 3787/8 3788/11 3800/3
proper [3] 3753/20 3753/21 3810/4
3719/4 3719/5 3719/6 3719/10 3736/3
recommend [1] 3792/13
properly [4] 3711/11 3755/9 3762/25
3761/23 3765/3 3770/24
recommendation [9] 3792/19 3815/24
3832/19
questioning [1] 3710/20
3820/2 3823/16 3824/6 3824/9 3824/12
property [1] 3741/19
questions [33] 3662/21 3667/1 3668/23 3824/19 3825/17
proposed [3] 3827/21 3828/5 3835/24
3672/6 3674/1 3674/3 3676/24 3677/2
recommended [6] 3776/11 3783/18
propulsion [1] 3748/23
3685/18 3685/24 3686/1 3686/14
3783/20 3784/2 3803/8 3809/13
protect [1] 3829/7
3704/20 3704/22 3710/17 3712/2
reconsider [1] 3702/8
protection [4] 3742/7 3743/8 3743/12
3721/15 3722/2 3723/18 3723/21
record [12] 3665/6 3673/16 3691/7
3746/8
3724/19 3725/16 3725/22 3725/23
3704/12 3727/13 3728/16 3729/2
protocol [1] 3788/15
3729/13 3744/9 3745/4 3750/8 3751/1
3733/16 3740/17 3793/13 3821/1
prove [2] 3717/7 3717/9
3762/15 3777/13 3783/15 3796/16
3836/13
proved [1] 3717/8
quick [6] 3751/10 3762/11 3805/6
record's [1] 3722/1
provide [4] 3736/11 3741/24 3743/24
3811/19 3814/6 3814/7
recorded [1] 3660/24
3754/10
quick-closing [1] 3805/6
records [5] 3754/3 3754/3 3789/9
provided [4] 3707/19 3711/2 3732/24
quickly [7] 3713/12 3775/20 3808/24
3789/23 3796/21
3733/2
3818/21 3819/5 3822/3 3826/25
RECROSS [1] 3710/18
provides [2] 3753/10 3771/19
Quirk [1] 3835/7
RECROSS-EXAMINATION [1] 3710/18
Proving [1] 3810/9
quite [4] 3742/19 3745/17 3780/15
rectified [1] 3787/23
provisions [2] 3739/25 3753/12
3793/14
rectify [1] 3816/14
proviso [1] 3827/21
red [6] 3692/13 3693/10 3718/20
R
prudent [1] 3792/19
3719/17 3749/12 3749/13
RACHEL [2] 3657/18 3659/9
PSC [6] 3679/16 3679/25 3681/23
Redden [1] 3660/2
rack [4] 3750/24 3750/24 3763/13
3710/16 3769/18 3835/6
REDIRECT [1] 3721/22
3763/14
psi [23] 3675/16 3675/17 3676/1
reducing [1] 3771/9
3676/13 3680/4 3680/6 3680/13 3680/22 racking [1] 3735/4
redundant [1] 3697/17
raise [3] 3698/8 3792/22 3792/24
3681/9 3681/24 3682/24 3683/13
reference [6] 3727/22 3786/13 3796/13
3683/17 3685/5 3685/8 3686/17 3688/3 ram [1] 3769/5
3796/22 3819/6 3823/24
3688/10 3689/7 3689/12 3689/18 3720/7 range [1] 3678/17
referenced [1] 3791/21
rapid [2] 3761/7 3761/12
3720/22
referred [5] 3664/25 3719/15 3739/3
pull [5] 3667/2 3712/12 3712/13 3719/22 rate [17] 3675/17 3675/18 3676/16
3830/2 3830/19
3676/17 3676/20 3685/9 3686/18
3723/13
refers [1] 3668/15
3691/13 3691/19 3692/3 3692/5 3692/8 reflect [3] 3681/25 3682/1 3756/23
pulling [1] 3767/22
3692/12 3692/25 3693/3 3694/15
pulls [1] 3749/16
reflects [1] 3692/5
3694/17
pump [19] 3667/11 3671/12 3671/17
refurbishment [1] 3733/18
rates [2] 3671/9 3691/15
3675/16 3685/9 3686/18 3691/10
REGAN [1] 3658/23
R
regard [5] 3669/14 3675/11 3734/5
3746/7 3760/24
regarding [4] 3784/1 3793/20 3795/25
3814/5
regardless [3] 3750/2 3750/3 3810/12
Register [1] 3733/12
registered [1] 3730/4
regular [4] 3739/9 3754/12 3766/12
3783/10
regularly [1] 3833/21
regulation [3] 3789/2 3803/17 3809/17
Regulation 10.2.1 [1] 3809/17
regulations [14] 3733/10 3736/20 3737/8
3738/14 3752/23 3752/23 3753/13
3788/21 3788/25 3789/9 3789/11
3789/13 3811/12 3829/5
regulatory [8] 3730/8 3733/14 3735/12
3736/2 3738/22 3766/13 3776/7 3776/10
rejected [2] 3824/20 3825/25
related [4] 3673/8 3742/6 3815/20
3824/5
relates [4] 3677/12 3704/15 3740/12
3804/1
relation [1] 3695/24
relatively [1] 3747/22
release [3] 3677/8 3677/12 3677/20
relevance [2] 3790/17 3790/22
relevant [2] 3743/13 3753/12
reliability [8] 3754/11 3771/9 3774/3
3804/14 3810/20 3811/18 3815/13
3823/18
reliable [1] 3809/18
reliance [2] 3727/21 3728/4
relieving [1] 3664/11
rely [3] 3728/20 3752/20 3813/12
remain [1] 3782/9
remaining [1] 3668/11
remember [19] 3671/9 3674/3 3674/6
3674/23 3677/2 3677/25 3678/18
3679/17 3685/7 3685/11 3695/5 3703/10
3706/7 3714/22 3722/4 3723/2 3725/13
3734/7 3830/14
remind [1] 3791/23
remotely [1] 3760/12
remove [1] 3769/6
removed [1] 3787/17
rendered [2] 3674/13 3738/15
renewal [3] 3809/1 3809/1 3811/1
repair [3] 3782/24 3807/19 3811/8
repaired [1] 3796/25
repairing [1] 3733/24
repairs [3] 3732/5 3733/18 3753/22
Repeat [1] 3684/2
repeatability [1] 3774/4
rephrase [2] 3686/2 3719/10
replaced [2] 3796/11 3796/12
replacement [1] 3806/3
report [44] 3672/23 3683/3 3683/7
3683/10 3704/4 3704/8 3727/20 3727/23
3728/4 3728/5 3728/19 3728/20 3729/4
3736/11 3738/16 3752/4 3752/6 3765/19
3766/21 3767/14 3768/17 3768/21
3773/10 3774/24 3777/12 3782/16
3783/10 3783/10 3784/7 3784/8 3784/9
3784/10 3784/11 3784/15 3784/20
3785/14 3790/9 3807/11 3808/25
3812/17 3815/2 3819/2 3824/9 3827/1
reported [10] 3737/19 3751/19 3752/7
3765/21 3767/20 3782/5 3784/25 3807/9
3828/3 3828/10
Reporter [3] 3660/18 3836/10 3836/18
reporting [8] 3725/24 3746/12 3753/18

3753/21 3790/2 3815/25 3824/10 3833/3
reports [8] 3673/1 3742/22 3742/22
3751/13 3753/24 3779/15 3807/16
3815/25
represent [3] 3707/20 3708/1 3756/14
representation [3] 3710/1 3720/12
3720/17
representative [5] 3683/3 3684/1 3757/1
3758/3 3758/5
representatives [2] 3676/25 3677/4
representing [2] 3692/19 3705/16
Republic [3] 3738/12 3738/14 3738/18
request [1] 3747/8
requested [2] 3781/24 3827/25
requests [1] 3753/24
require [2] 3761/7 3766/23
required [8] 3673/21 3742/25 3744/6
3766/15 3770/14 3786/17 3787/22
3820/15
requirement [6] 3740/10 3741/11 3776/8
3776/10 3789/25 3799/2
requirements [11] 3739/15 3743/1
3743/5 3746/10 3753/13 3765/18
3799/13 3827/19 3829/5 3831/9 3832/23
requires [8] 3741/10 3747/23 3761/12
3766/8 3778/1 3799/12 3821/16 3831/14
requiring [1] 3783/19
requisite [1] 3740/23
rescheduled [1] 3810/23
reserve [1] 3663/14
resolved [1] 3817/4
resources [2] 3657/16 3744/5
respect [13] 3724/18 3728/1 3739/17
3747/7 3753/18 3759/1 3760/7 3765/18
3766/24 3791/6 3805/23 3817/9 3828/21
respond [4] 3714/15 3716/5 3717/5
3747/24
responded [1] 3724/19
response [12] 3706/15 3706/22 3712/2
3725/22 3728/9 3761/12 3761/20 3762/2
3762/15 3779/3 3824/18 3831/16
responses [1] 3726/4
responsibilities [4] 3669/22 3671/21
3697/22 3778/19
responsibility [9] 3670/21 3672/22
3744/2 3746/5 3746/7 3747/7 3747/15
3778/2 3823/3
responsible [1] 3779/17
rest [3] 3664/19 3668/21 3669/14
Restate [1] 3761/23
restricted [1] 3817/8
result [1] 3754/9
resulted [1] 3781/20
results [3] 3769/4 3787/14 3800/6
resume [1] 3662/19
retained [1] 3773/1
retirement [1] 3803/6
returned [4] 3678/15 3678/16 3678/22
3679/7
returns [1] 3718/2
revealed [1] 3798/16
review [13] 3686/8 3771/23 3772/12
3776/13 3777/5 3780/8 3781/18 3783/24
3789/10 3790/1 3793/10 3794/9 3798/15
reviewed [13] 3664/17 3665/22 3665/25
3723/10 3738/14 3758/3 3763/25 3764/1
3768/21 3772/1 3772/7 3794/10 3799/5
reviewing [2] 3745/5 3746/11
RICHARD [1] 3659/16
rig [90] 3655/4 3662/25 3663/3 3664/17
3668/6 3670/6 3672/7 3672/16 3674/9
3674/13 3674/22 3683/3 3685/9 3686/18
3686/22 3688/17 3689/13 3689/18

3690/4 3691/8 3691/25 3694/22 3696/2
3699/5 3700/6 3700/25 3701/1 3701/2
3702/1 3710/25 3712/18 3716/8 3716/9
3716/16 3717/16 3717/20 3719/13
3721/1 3721/11 3725/10 3725/15 3726/3
3734/14 3735/1 3735/5 3752/15 3755/17
3758/19 3760/19 3763/10 3763/17
3763/18 3763/19 3763/21 3766/17
3767/25 3769/25 3770/20 3779/19
3781/2 3783/7 3790/20 3792/12 3792/23
3793/6 3793/10 3794/1 3794/6 3794/12
3806/18 3807/8 3808/11 3808/14
3808/15 3808/16 3808/19 3809/20
3809/23 3810/21 3811/17 3812/23
3814/13 3816/5 3818/22 3821/12
3821/23 3830/6 3830/15 3830/17
3830/21
right [94] 3662/13 3663/5 3664/4
3664/12 3665/17 3667/7 3671/15 3675/3
3677/25 3680/21 3684/15 3686/14
3686/24 3688/9 3689/1 3689/4 3690/1
3690/6 3690/21 3690/23 3691/5 3691/13
3692/8 3692/9 3692/24 3693/11 3693/12
3693/25 3694/2 3694/5 3694/7 3694/8
3694/9 3694/12 3695/18 3698/13 3699/1
3699/20 3701/7 3701/9 3702/1 3702/6
3702/11 3703/2 3703/11 3704/24
3705/14 3705/20 3706/24 3707/2 3707/4
3707/12 3708/13 3708/22 3708/23
3709/23 3709/25 3710/3 3710/8 3710/22
3713/25 3714/5 3714/18 3715/14
3718/18 3719/25 3724/1 3724/4 3725/3
3725/6 3726/11 3728/8 3728/12 3728/17
3744/7 3747/13 3757/25 3759/9 3760/23
3761/3 3775/14 3780/13 3785/6 3790/25
3791/11 3792/7 3792/8 3797/18 3801/8
3814/3 3817/17 3822/9 3826/19 3834/25
right-hand [3] 3690/21 3719/25 3792/7
rigs [3] 3713/15 3713/19 3772/14
ring [3] 3698/8 3756/21 3826/13
rings [1] 3757/19
rise [1] 3768/6
riser [3] 3749/2 3749/6 3776/1
rises [1] 3757/18
risk [16] 3741/9 3768/15 3769/24 3771/9
3771/16 3774/21 3776/11 3804/22
3812/5 3812/14 3812/16 3817/5 3821/13
3831/23 3832/11 3834/1
risks [1] 3742/3
RMI [1] 3738/18
RMS [1] 3821/16
ro [2] 3737/1 3737/1
ro/ro [1] 3737/1
Robb [1] 3705/13
ROBERT [2] 3656/3 3659/3
ROBERTS [3] 3659/9 3660/4 3662/4
robustness [2] 3774/4 3814/13
role [1] 3744/21
room [26] 3660/19 3701/9 3703/9
3703/20 3708/9 3711/10 3722/13
3727/19 3757/8 3759/5 3759/25 3760/4
3760/5 3760/8 3760/10 3805/16 3813/10
3813/11 3814/2 3814/6 3816/9 3823/9
3823/10 3823/11 3823/13 3826/10
rooms [7] 3757/3 3759/24 3762/21
3804/13 3813/8 3815/8 3823/8
Rose [1] 3798/4
rotary [3] 3663/14 3695/18 3696/14
rotate [1] 3830/10
rotational [1] 3773/1
Rouge [2] 3657/4 3658/13
roughly [7] 3678/9 3678/18 3679/4
R
roughly... [4] 3679/4 3691/4 3692/15
3722/18
routinely [3] 3807/9 3807/12 3807/15
Roy [2] 3655/18 3655/19
Royal [2] 3729/22 3732/20
rubs [1] 3757/14
rule [1] 3791/18
ruled [1] 3791/17
rules [2] 3742/14 3753/12
ruling [1] 3728/11
run [1] 3753/6
running [4] 3732/5 3732/10 3760/10
3795/4
Rusnak [1] 3657/5
rsum [1] 3731/22
S
safe [12] 3672/11 3673/10 3673/11
3737/7 3741/24 3741/25 3743/11
3743/23 3755/9 3782/9 3803/11 3812/1
safeguards [1] 3742/3
safely [1] 3755/9
safety [111] 3672/6 3672/7 3673/8
3698/8 3730/18 3730/19 3731/10
3731/10 3731/10 3731/13 3732/14
3735/8 3736/1 3736/19 3736/20 3736/20
3737/8 3737/9 3740/14 3741/8 3741/17
3741/23 3742/4 3742/6 3742/18 3742/22
3743/2 3743/4 3743/8 3743/20 3744/3
3745/12 3746/8 3746/11 3746/16
3746/19 3746/21 3747/3 3747/5 3747/7
3751/16 3751/20 3754/7 3754/9 3758/19
3760/24 3765/15 3767/24 3767/25
3769/10 3771/24 3778/4 3782/6 3782/12
3782/16 3782/23 3782/23 3783/4 3783/5
3783/8 3784/23 3789/12 3791/6 3792/18
3793/23 3795/11 3796/18 3798/24
3799/18 3800/11 3800/13 3803/15
3804/18 3805/13 3805/15 3805/18
3806/5 3806/6 3806/14 3806/15 3807/14
3808/6 3808/12 3808/13 3808/13
3809/11 3811/5 3811/9 3811/11 3811/23
3812/8 3813/2 3813/16 3814/15 3817/2
3817/12 3818/16 3818/17 3819/16
3820/14 3821/14 3822/16 3825/9 3826/2
3826/3 3827/18 3829/1 3831/11 3831/22
3834/2 3834/11
safety-critical [11] 3758/19 3782/16
3796/18 3805/13 3805/18 3806/6
3806/14 3808/6 3808/13 3817/2 3818/17
said [37] 3662/24 3671/11 3673/4
3673/15 3677/19 3679/4 3682/1 3684/13
3686/23 3687/6 3687/9 3687/15 3688/15
3688/18 3688/22 3696/17 3697/20
3702/7 3703/13 3705/8 3707/1 3707/4
3707/13 3708/5 3708/20 3709/23
3710/11 3710/11 3712/2 3712/8 3712/22
3722/8 3753/2 3769/23 3778/19 3807/25
3820/20
sail [1] 3741/4
sailed [1] 3732/21
salt [6] 3715/18 3715/20 3718/11
3794/18 3795/1 3795/13
same [34] 3675/24 3675/25 3679/20
3688/3 3694/15 3695/9 3695/10 3695/11
3698/12 3700/20 3700/23 3701/5
3717/14 3719/18 3731/8 3750/7 3760/4
3765/3 3770/25 3771/2 3775/22 3786/7
3788/7 3794/16 3801/9 3801/10 3807/6
3812/17 3814/23 3815/17 3818/24
3828/13 3828/20 3830/20
sampling [1] 3757/1

San [2] 3656/17 3657/14
sand [1] 3706/18
sandwiches [4] 3678/2 3679/6 3722/10
3722/12
satisfactory [1] 3832/7
satisfied [1] 3706/21
Saudi [1] 3730/12
save [4] 3760/19 3760/19 3780/13
3808/15
savers [9] 3763/11 3763/17 3763/19
3763/21 3808/11 3808/15 3808/20
3812/23 3816/5
saves [1] 3763/18
saw [5] 3680/13 3680/22 3704/2 3704/8
3815/3
say [27] 3664/1 3671/20 3678/9 3678/10
3678/11 3691/7 3691/19 3692/15
3696/25 3722/8 3739/8 3740/14 3745/19
3748/6 3748/7 3748/10 3749/17 3749/18
3749/24 3757/13 3766/2 3774/6 3781/14
3812/3 3814/2 3822/18 3826/7
saying [6] 3674/21 3674/23 3676/7
3680/9 3748/7 3779/12
says [46] 3667/11 3667/24 3667/24
3680/1 3680/3 3681/8 3683/13 3713/6
3713/8 3740/8 3741/7 3741/23 3743/23
3744/7 3744/10 3744/12 3751/16 3769/2
3769/8 3771/8 3772/12 3772/24 3773/24
3774/13 3775/4 3775/14 3777/3 3778/1
3781/7 3782/24 3783/17 3784/23
3787/14 3787/14 3794/18 3800/9
3802/13 3803/12 3804/10 3804/16
3810/17 3815/10 3815/22 3822/8
3827/15 3831/16
scale [1] 3678/6
scales [1] 3720/19
scan [1] 3727/6
scheduled [4] 3783/3 3810/20 3810/21
3817/20
schedules [1] 3767/5
schematics [1] 3758/4
schemes [1] 3735/12
school [1] 3702/18
Science [2] 3729/18 3730/1
SCOFIELD [1] 3660/15
scope [2] 3716/1 3809/2
SCOTT [1] 3657/17
screen [8] 3663/9 3682/1 3697/7 3697/9
3697/9 3740/1 3768/11 3778/11
screens [6] 3682/3 3682/4 3682/10
3682/19 3723/4 3764/18
scrolled [1] 3723/9
scrounge [1] 3814/1
sea [13] 3732/17 3732/18 3732/18
3737/9 3741/17 3750/3 3752/15 3782/4
3809/19 3813/15 3814/16 3831/11
3832/15
seabed [1] 3748/22
seafloor [1] 3749/4
seal [2] 3795/4 3795/5
sealing [1] 3769/5
seals [2] 3783/19 3817/18
seas [2] 3742/12 3812/10
seated [2] 3662/3 3768/8
seawater [3] 3668/12 3692/2 3693/5
seaworthiness [1] 3735/16
second [10] 3684/25 3685/3 3690/14
3698/16 3701/13 3704/11 3740/6 3781/7
3793/25 3829/25
seconds [4] 3693/22 3693/23 3776/8
3776/12
Secrest [1] 3660/2
secret [1] 3818/3

section [36] 3655/5 3657/16 3658/3
3718/2 3718/4 3719/25 3741/15 3741/20
3743/1 3743/22 3746/6 3747/2 3747/15
3747/21 3747/22 3751/12 3753/8
3753/10 3754/6 3754/17 3768/4 3775/3
3775/22 3777/19 3779/8 3783/15
3784/22 3793/8 3796/7 3797/16 3799/1
3799/11 3799/23 3808/1 3815/7 3834/16
Section 1.2 [1] 3741/15
Section 1.4 [1] 3743/1
Section 3 [1] 3799/23
Section 5 [1] 3747/15
Section 5.1 [1] 3746/6
Section 5.2 [1] 3779/8
Section JD-930 [1] 3796/7
sections [3] 3717/17 3718/6 3809/6
secure [2] 3775/23 3776/5
secured [1] 3832/19
Security [1] 3789/13
Sedco [2] 3772/20 3774/22
see [91] 3663/8 3663/20 3663/24 3664/2
3665/7 3666/5 3667/5 3667/13 3668/10
3668/13 3676/17 3676/18 3679/9
3679/12 3679/25 3680/1 3680/2 3680/3
3680/4 3680/8 3680/11 3681/5 3681/10
3683/12 3683/15 3683/16 3683/17
3683/19 3684/10 3685/14 3687/2
3687/12 3687/21 3688/1 3690/3 3690/7
3690/16 3690/19 3690/22 3691/1
3691/13 3691/18 3691/19 3692/8 3692/9
3692/24 3693/15 3693/20 3694/6
3694/14 3695/2 3695/12 3697/7 3697/23
3698/18 3699/1 3700/7 3701/24 3702/9
3705/7 3710/16 3712/23 3713/1 3716/12
3720/21 3723/7 3723/10 3726/12
3726/13 3726/14 3728/19 3740/5 3740/7
3751/16 3757/25 3758/25 3770/2
3773/23 3776/14 3777/6 3778/11 3785/8
3791/21 3794/10 3808/4 3815/7 3818/5
3819/5 3825/18 3826/19 3836/4
seeing [7] 3681/13 3682/7 3686/25
3687/9 3687/11 3687/19 3726/10
seemed [1] 3673/2
seen [29] 3665/3 3674/18 3675/2
3680/16 3680/17 3683/6 3684/13 3685/8
3686/16 3688/7 3688/10 3689/2 3689/11
3704/6 3706/13 3712/18 3714/17
3720/10 3723/12 3764/16 3772/9
3780/24 3796/3 3804/24 3823/19
3823/21 3824/7 3825/2 3828/13
Sees [1] 3799/11
selected [1] 3769/4
self [1] 3754/14
self-explanatory [1] 3754/14
Semisubmersible [1] 3782/17
send [3] 3756/21 3756/24 3757/4
sending [1] 3818/3
sends [1] 3755/18
senior [4] 3734/19 3745/15 3802/8
3803/5
sense [2] 3690/4 3826/3
senses [2] 3749/16 3756/21
sensor [7] 3694/23 3710/21 3711/4
3711/5 3711/5 3720/22 3726/4
sensors [7] 3711/3 3711/10 3711/13
3721/2 3755/16 3756/19 3756/23
sent [3] 3741/2 3787/6 3835/23
sentence [3] 3772/11 3796/10 3796/16
separate [4] 3722/24 3722/25 3722/25
3814/23
September [2] 3773/18 3827/2
September 16 [1] 3827/2
S
sequence [1] 3770/13
series [3] 3725/16 3725/23 3742/19
serious [8] 3741/1 3741/8 3741/9
3759/14 3782/12 3804/12 3829/3
3834/14
service [5] 3664/7 3668/8 3690/2
3783/19 3784/3
services [6] 3660/7 3660/12 3732/24
3733/2 3733/5 3795/22
SESSION [2] 3655/14 3662/1
set [17] 3675/11 3675/16 3675/17
3676/4 3684/16 3703/3 3705/2 3717/17
3717/18 3722/12 3743/2 3753/23
3792/10 3792/14 3813/3 3822/3 3826/11
sets [2] 3796/12 3796/21
setting [4] 3676/3 3705/11 3730/17
3732/25
seven [2] 3732/23 3750/5
several [9] 3719/24 3724/13 3731/6
3734/13 3734/19 3772/10 3823/21
3823/22 3828/15
severity [1] 3792/7
shack [28] 3662/22 3664/24 3670/2
3673/18 3678/12 3678/15 3678/16
3678/22 3678/24 3679/2 3679/8 3680/15
3680/22 3683/2 3695/7 3695/10 3695/17
3696/18 3699/2 3699/23 3700/8 3700/15
3701/5 3703/21 3722/15 3723/4 3764/24
3822/9
shaft [1] 3795/5
shaker [5] 3696/8 3696/20 3696/22
3696/23 3760/4
shakers [1] 3696/10
shale [3] 3696/8 3696/20 3760/4
shall [9] 3778/2 3779/2 3788/20 3788/22
3788/23 3789/8 3789/10 3789/20 3790/1
shallow [1] 3717/19
shape [1] 3754/17
share [2] 3794/25 3804/18
shared [1] 3677/4
SHARON [1] 3657/24
Shaw [1] 3656/12
she [8] 3666/10 3666/13 3666/22 3669/1
3669/10 3669/12 3670/3 3728/15
shear [1] 3769/5
sheen [14] 3668/10 3668/16 3678/8
3678/10 3678/21 3678/25 3682/15
3682/21 3696/4 3696/6 3696/17 3696/20
3696/24 3722/17
sheet [3] 3815/2 3819/3 3819/6
sheets [1] 3815/4
shift [3] 3664/6 3669/23 3670/4
ship [20] 3733/13 3735/15 3737/1
3737/19 3741/9 3741/25 3743/23 3744/4
3747/4 3748/2 3748/2 3748/5 3748/7
3750/7 3753/8 3753/11 3753/18 3777/11
3779/14 3813/25
ship-owning [1] 3733/13
shipboard [2] 3743/17 3747/24
shipping [8] 3731/2 3731/12 3731/25
3732/14 3733/11 3733/12 3737/6 3741/1
ships [7] 3730/21 3731/19 3732/8 3733/8
3739/9 3742/5 3743/12
shipyard [1] 3733/18
shocking [4] 3821/8 3821/9 3821/20
3822/18
shore [6] 3743/17 3744/5 3746/12
3754/4 3830/6 3830/15
shore-based [1] 3744/5
shoreside [2] 3732/2 3753/23
short [3] 3733/12 3747/22 3827/2
short-term [1] 3827/2

shortly [2] 3737/23 3829/19
should [79] 3676/2 3676/15 3681/13
3688/25 3711/15 3737/6 3739/25
3740/23 3740/25 3741/24 3742/13
3743/3 3743/25 3744/3 3744/10 3744/11
3744/16 3745/13 3746/6 3746/14
3746/15 3746/18 3747/2 3747/5 3751/17
3751/21 3752/6 3752/9 3753/5 3753/10
3753/20 3753/21 3753/23 3754/6
3754/10 3754/12 3760/14 3762/22
3764/2 3764/5 3764/12 3765/4 3765/11
3765/13 3765/19 3765/21 3766/2 3767/5
3767/6 3767/8 3767/20 3773/1 3773/8
3774/6 3774/9 3774/10 3774/14 3779/13
3779/18 3782/4 3784/24 3786/19
3786/22 3786/24 3794/5 3800/17
3800/21 3804/23 3805/23 3807/14
3807/15 3810/22 3816/11 3817/14
3820/16 3823/1 3823/4 3826/5 3826/18
shoulder [1] 3700/10
shouldn't [2] 3717/24 3791/17
show [12] 3663/5 3663/13 3689/20
3700/1 3700/5 3708/16 3755/25 3756/9
3758/8 3791/4 3811/20 3827/9
showed [5] 3666/22 3689/15 3723/13
3735/1 3735/2
showing [4] 3690/22 3768/15 3789/23
3821/16
shown [7] 3666/25 3677/8 3679/15
3679/24 3695/4 3714/22 3719/24
shows [8] 3671/18 3714/24 3720/8
3720/25 3721/10 3722/24 3724/6
3755/25
Shushan [1] 3728/12
shut [27] 3682/25 3697/2 3710/21
3711/6 3711/9 3720/22 3721/2 3722/16
3755/20 3757/20 3758/17 3758/17
3759/14 3759/19 3760/2 3760/2 3760/18
3762/13 3762/22 3763/1 3763/11
3763/21 3765/14 3812/22 3813/1 3813/7
3834/18
shut-off [1] 3812/22
shutdown [7] 3735/1 3759/12 3763/3
3776/21 3805/24 3812/25 3825/5
shutdowns [3] 3812/22 3812/25 3814/3
SHUTLER [1] 3657/24
shutoff [1] 3763/9
shuts [1] 3763/23
shutting [1] 3723/19
side [10] 3681/8 3691/15 3696/1 3696/2
3696/2 3701/2 3727/19 3746/24 3746/24
3759/21
signal [1] 3756/22
signals [12] 3734/24 3734/25 3755/17
3755/18 3755/18 3756/10 3756/10
3756/10 3756/24 3757/4 3759/13 3818/3
signed [2] 3677/8 3677/20
significance [2] 3786/6 3795/1
significant [5] 3804/13 3812/5 3812/14
3815/8 3823/7
significantly [1] 3693/1
similar [6] 3731/8 3767/18 3793/19
3818/24 3822/3 3828/20
simple [1] 3746/10
simplistic [1] 3758/7
simply [3] 3711/14 3743/3 3795/12
Simrad [4] 3757/23 3765/25 3776/24
3792/13
simultaneously [3] 3761/21 3762/2
3762/16
since [3] 3731/17 3811/21 3830/10
SINCLAIR [1] 3658/9
single [1] 3769/6

sinking [1] 3812/16
sir [292]
sit [1] 3677/25
site [8] 3789/11 3807/9 3815/18 3815/20
3816/1 3824/3 3824/5 3824/11
sites [2] 3789/22 3789/23
sits [1] 3702/2
situation [5] 3740/8 3760/17 3795/8
3795/9 3812/6
situations [8] 3730/18 3747/25 3751/18
3754/9 3761/1 3761/6 3784/25 3793/15
six [4] 3703/7 3790/18 3809/10 3809/11
six-page [1] 3790/18
skills [1] 3742/5
skip [3] 3747/21 3771/4 3819/4
slide [2] 3674/5 3679/15
Slidell [1] 3656/23
slight [5] 3687/1 3687/11 3687/15
3687/19 3688/21
slip [1] 3702/24
slow [3] 3709/11 3725/6 3809/12
slowed [1] 3693/2
small [2] 3706/13 3809/8
smoke [9] 3699/8 3699/13 3699/15
3756/18 3756/20 3756/21 3806/10
3806/17 3806/24
smoked [3] 3699/18 3703/24 3703/25
smothering [1] 3759/5
SMS [1] 3771/24
snapped [1] 3737/3
so [84] 3664/1 3665/2 3665/7 3666/5
3667/19 3667/21 3669/23 3670/3
3671/19 3676/1 3676/19 3677/3 3678/6
3678/15 3678/21 3679/6 3682/7 3682/11
3682/18 3690/21 3691/12 3692/14
3694/3 3695/14 3696/9 3696/14 3697/9
3697/22 3699/13 3701/3 3701/18
3702/10 3703/10 3703/21 3707/8 3708/4
3709/7 3710/7 3711/4 3720/10 3722/10
3725/4 3726/7 3727/3 3729/3 3730/22
3734/18 3737/5 3737/7 3740/2 3745/15
3748/12 3748/24 3749/5 3749/9 3752/8
3755/23 3756/1 3757/18 3759/12
3760/10 3761/9 3763/12 3765/13
3769/16 3769/20 3770/9 3770/22 3777/1
3780/6 3790/22 3792/22 3795/4 3805/8
3806/8 3807/19 3807/19 3813/12
3813/17 3814/20 3817/3 3820/13
3820/13 3835/20
societies [1] 3729/21
society [4] 3731/7 3733/9 3738/24
3752/7
soft [4] 3715/18 3715/20 3718/11
3718/14
software [1] 3660/25
SOLAS [8] 3831/9 3831/10 3831/13
3831/14 3831/20 3832/5 3833/24 3834/5
solely [1] 3796/17
solution [1] 3713/12
solve [1] 3753/4
some [35] 3663/23 3671/8 3674/1
3676/24 3677/8 3677/19 3686/23
3688/18 3710/21 3713/3 3713/18
3714/19 3717/25 3718/15 3718/17
3722/2 3723/18 3724/19 3727/18
3730/21 3731/20 3737/2 3737/22
3739/23 3739/25 3745/4 3747/11
3763/20 3763/20 3763/25 3793/12
3793/14 3801/13 3831/7 3835/10
somebody [3] 3706/2 3798/17 3813/10
somebody's [1] 3712/2
someone [4] 3695/20 3696/17 3813/10
S
someone... [1] 3830/21
something [24] 3673/5 3682/25 3687/10
3701/14 3712/24 3717/19 3726/11
3726/13 3739/7 3749/7 3749/8 3757/14
3757/19 3759/13 3765/21 3778/17
3786/19 3787/11 3800/15 3817/18
3817/21 3820/9 3821/7 3834/17
Sometimes [1] 3749/16
somewhere [1] 3678/17
soon [6] 3707/6 3717/22 3767/10
3767/21 3783/23 3834/25
sorry [27] 3675/15 3678/16 3682/23
3687/5 3705/11 3713/10 3714/2 3716/24
3727/14 3728/7 3744/19 3757/10 3762/4
3764/17 3777/21 3778/8 3778/12 3780/5
3788/9 3791/14 3795/12 3801/1 3801/1
3820/23 3825/13 3830/8 3830/24
sort [3] 3745/2 3758/7 3780/12
sound [2] 3705/25 3826/9
sounded [7] 3676/15 3707/1 3707/3
3707/10 3708/5 3725/13 3826/18
sounds [1] 3826/8
source [3] 3714/12 3761/8 3763/20
South [2] 3730/13 3730/13
South America [1] 3730/13
space [5] 3748/21 3758/16 3762/13
3805/8 3805/22
spaced [1] 3666/4
spacer [3] 3667/19 3668/11 3670/7
spaces [6] 3804/14 3808/5 3815/9
3823/8 3832/1 3832/1
spare [3] 3794/3 3809/12 3817/16
spares [5] 3745/20 3806/11 3809/19
3809/22 3810/4
special [2] 3733/21 3750/23
specialist [4] 3708/20 3709/1 3709/20
3710/2
specialists [1] 3705/23
specific [6] 3754/10 3754/15 3759/14
3785/6 3788/22 3789/12
specifically [3] 3711/5 3742/25 3744/25
specified [3] 3740/10 3746/10 3819/25
spelling [1] 3727/13
spend [2] 3729/14 3754/14
spent [1] 3802/15
Sperry [3] 3670/11 3711/5 3714/6
Sperry-Sun [1] 3670/11
Sperry-Sun's [1] 3711/5
spike [4] 3693/15 3693/21 3723/22
3724/6
spill [4] 3655/4 3814/8 3814/8 3814/11
SPIRO [1] 3658/4
spontaneous [1] 3757/16
spool [4] 3701/7 3701/7 3702/19
3702/20
spread [1] 3762/12
sprinklers [1] 3759/3
stability [1] 3805/15
stack [2] 3769/4 3791/3
staff [2] 3767/2 3784/14
staggered [1] 3725/9
stairs [5] 3700/25 3701/8 3702/5 3702/5
3703/15
stand [4] 3704/10 3726/13 3754/12
3769/19
stand-by [1] 3754/12
standard [3] 3684/16 3736/22 3834/4
standards [5] 3684/4 3684/7 3684/9
3684/11 3815/11
standby [1] 3771/13
standpipe [9] 3675/17 3675/18 3675/23
3676/10 3680/18 3683/6 3689/2 3704/6

3725/7
standpoint [3] 3769/10 3820/14 3826/3
starboard [1] 3667/12
start [7] 3675/21 3740/2 3755/19
3755/21 3797/23 3829/24 3836/1
started [4] 3730/22 3734/12 3736/17
3786/1
starting [4] 3781/6 3797/16 3801/12
3812/21
starts [1] 3692/1
state [23] 3658/7 3658/11 3658/15
3711/15 3718/22 3727/12 3731/3
3733/10 3739/4 3739/5 3739/10 3739/17
3741/2 3741/3 3743/13 3747/2 3752/7
3752/23 3753/7 3765/20 3767/22
3827/19 3827/25
stated [4] 3769/19 3803/3 3809/12
3824/2
statement [4] 3738/6 3747/4 3813/18
3829/8
states [22] 3655/1 3655/10 3655/15
3657/11 3657/15 3657/21 3658/2 3730/5
3730/13 3731/1 3731/9 3731/15 3732/3
3739/5 3739/6 3739/18 3739/19 3779/2
3818/12 3824/25 3835/13 3836/10
static [2] 3668/10 3724/11
stating [1] 3786/8
station [5] 3658/5 3695/25 3740/15
3749/19 3779/2
stationkeeping [1] 3810/19
status [1] 3771/20
statutory [2] 3731/4 3739/12
stay [3] 3693/7 3779/15 3779/16
steady [1] 3693/7
Steering [1] 3736/10
stenography [1] 3660/24
step [2] 3667/24 3690/12
STEPHEN [1] 3655/23
steps [9] 3666/10 3666/20 3701/1
3703/3 3703/4 3703/7 3703/8 3703/16
3703/18
Sterbcow [2] 3656/5 3656/6
STERNBERG [1] 3660/12
Steve [3] 3724/21 3725/13 3801/25
STEVEN [3] 3657/17 3659/9 3802/11
Stevin [1] 3730/15
still [13] 3674/15 3697/16 3701/3 3705/5
3709/6 3712/24 3723/14 3730/24 3748/5
3748/5 3770/24 3771/2 3834/21
Stone [1] 3659/22
stood [5] 3687/3 3688/13 3704/5
3732/17 3732/20
stop [9] 3673/4 3673/6 3673/8 3758/15
3760/3 3760/3 3763/11 3808/18 3834/25
stopgap [1] 3795/15
stopping [3] 3760/8 3834/18 3834/20
storerooms [1] 3832/2
storm [1] 3717/20
story [1] 3708/7
straight [2] 3703/18 3722/1
straightened [2] 3794/13 3794/14
STRANGE [1] 3658/8
Street [19] 3655/20 3656/3 3656/6
3656/10 3656/13 3656/22 3657/3 3657/9
3658/12 3658/16 3658/19 3659/6
3659/10 3659/17 3659/23 3660/5 3660/9
3660/16 3660/19
stressed [5] 3712/5 3712/7 3712/9
3712/10 3813/20
stressful [1] 3712/8
strike [1] 3728/4
string [1] 3821/25
strip [1] 3690/19

stroke [1] 3671/14
strokes [3] 3671/12 3692/17 3692/18
structure [1] 3779/13
stuck [2] 3718/3 3718/7
stuff [5] 3678/2 3679/5 3722/9 3722/10
3722/23
subject [2] 3727/24 3760/6
subsalt [1] 3718/13
subsea [3] 3765/10 3795/25 3796/9
subsoft [1] 3718/14
substantial [1] 3728/4
subsystems [2] 3755/7 3755/12
subtitle [1] 3785/16
success [1] 3777/2
successfully [2] 3711/8 3827/25
such [10] 3663/10 3673/1 3713/15
3739/16 3754/11 3755/19 3761/11
3764/6 3811/18 3812/6
sudden [1] 3754/8
sufficient [1] 3803/9
suggest [1] 3825/10
suggested [1] 3772/2
suggesting [2] 3715/5 3715/9
suggestion [2] 3716/7 3773/6
suitably [1] 3803/10
Suite [14] 3655/20 3656/6 3656/10
3656/16 3656/19 3658/19 3659/6
3659/10 3659/17 3659/20 3660/5 3660/9
3660/12 3660/16
sulfide [1] 3761/10
SULLIVAN [1] 3657/23
sum [2] 3677/20 3779/11
summarizes [1] 3829/21
summary [3] 3772/11 3783/14 3831/6
Sun [1] 3670/11
Sun's [1] 3711/5
superintendent [5] 3730/11 3731/23
3731/24 3732/2 3732/4
superlatives [1] 3716/8
Supertanker [1] 3755/1
supervise [1] 3732/5
supervised [1] 3733/18
supervisor [2] 3790/4 3829/13
supervisors [1] 3800/5
Supplemental [1] 3790/9
supplier [1] 3809/13
supply [7] 3805/6 3805/6 3808/5 3809/18
3809/22 3814/8 3823/9
support [4] 3744/5 3789/9 3789/23
3813/18
suppose [1] 3797/24
supposed [8] 3673/18 3689/5 3752/25
3753/2 3753/4 3764/10 3785/21 3805/8
sure [21] 3663/15 3665/16 3666/22
3673/15 3690/11 3710/9 3722/1 3726/6
3734/6 3739/11 3739/11 3742/17 3767/9
3779/23 3782/8 3785/9 3787/22 3807/20
3820/25 3823/3 3830/1
Surely [1] 3705/5
surface [2] 3670/25 3691/9
survey [17] 3734/9 3782/16 3783/10
3783/11 3785/13 3785/24 3786/1 3790/9
3790/11 3790/24 3804/5 3804/10
3808/25 3810/11 3815/4 3816/6 3827/1
surveyed [2] 3790/19 3791/2
surveying [2] 3733/5 3733/24
surveyor [8] 3730/23 3731/2 3731/5
3731/9 3733/6 3752/18 3804/5 3804/8
surveyor's [1] 3812/13
surveys [3] 3731/10 3738/25 3777/5
suspect [1] 3774/5
Sutherland [1] 3659/8
S
SWACO [6] 3666/22 3667/6 3668/23
3672/15 3704/21 3705/17
switch [2] 3667/25 3771/12
switchboard [2] 3811/2 3811/6
switched [2] 3817/24 3818/2
sworn [2] 3662/16 3727/11
system [114] 3662/25 3697/8 3711/24
3734/22 3740/14 3742/18 3743/2 3743/4
3743/20 3746/11 3746/16 3746/19
3746/21 3747/3 3747/6 3751/16 3753/20
3753/21 3754/7 3754/9 3755/12 3755/14
3755/15 3755/16 3756/1 3756/15
3756/22 3756/24 3757/5 3757/21
3757/23 3758/5 3758/19 3759/1 3759/9
3759/12 3759/14 3759/17 3759/21
3760/1 3760/13 3760/22 3761/16
3761/19 3761/19 3761/25 3761/25
3763/4 3764/4 3764/7 3764/7 3764/17
3765/15 3765/25 3768/17 3769/4 3769/7
3772/13 3773/1 3773/22 3774/3 3774/5
3774/6 3774/13 3774/17 3775/3 3775/12
3775/16 3775/22 3776/6 3776/18
3776/21 3777/1 3777/2 3781/12 3782/24
3782/25 3783/5 3784/24 3785/2 3792/1
3792/14 3793/10 3793/20 3799/19
3799/25 3805/11 3805/12 3805/24
3805/25 3806/12 3806/13 3806/25
3807/3 3807/10 3807/15 3809/10
3810/14 3812/15 3816/18 3818/11
3821/16 3822/20 3822/24 3824/23
3825/5 3826/17 3827/18 3827/24 3828/9
3828/22 3832/25 3833/3 3833/8
system/procedure [1] 3785/2
systematic [4] 3741/11 3786/11 3786/15
3786/15
systemic [1] 3800/9
systems [15] 3735/4 3754/8 3754/11
3754/13 3755/7 3755/23 3758/1 3758/25
3759/2 3764/9 3766/4 3771/25 3783/20
3820/13 3833/20
T
table [2] 3695/18 3696/14
take [20] 3669/13 3677/5 3689/24
3699/25 3701/1 3702/10 3703/7 3703/8
3717/21 3722/7 3728/24 3734/24 3761/2
3761/13 3763/15 3768/1 3768/5 3826/11
3834/22 3836/3
taken [11] 3664/18 3669/13 3685/19
3689/9 3740/17 3778/17 3779/23
3807/21 3807/21 3811/21 3812/4
takes [5] 3697/11 3755/17 3755/18
3799/9 3821/25
taking [2] 3686/24 3767/10
talk [20] 3669/21 3670/18 3676/22
3698/22 3707/10 3709/5 3709/8 3710/4
3725/12 3731/20 3737/22 3739/23
3758/9 3766/5 3766/14 3794/17 3825/14
3829/19 3835/3 3835/4
talked [14] 3666/8 3668/15 3677/11
3710/9 3718/6 3725/2 3750/25 3762/11
3776/22 3792/3 3796/3 3801/20 3810/12
3816/6
talking [26] 3682/14 3682/16 3684/10
3699/20 3706/4 3711/4 3716/16 3720/1
3735/8 3747/17 3760/22 3762/14
3767/12 3770/23 3773/3 3773/22
3773/25 3775/8 3775/24 3776/20
3791/22 3791/25 3800/1 3800/2 3821/22
3830/21
tank [8] 3690/23 3691/12 3693/12
3693/18 3693/20 3694/7 3723/19 3725/7

tankers [1] 3732/10
TANNER [5] 3660/15 3704/24 3705/1
3705/16 3709/6
task [1] 3820/15
tasks [7] 3674/15 3781/16 3781/20
3782/11 3809/9 3819/25 3821/5
team [6] 3672/18 3672/19 3773/24
3773/25 3774/2 3824/17
technical [4] 3754/8 3754/13 3781/2
3818/22
Technology [1] 3730/1
teething [1] 3735/6
telephone [3] 3707/1 3708/20 3826/17
television [1] 3764/18
tell [14] 3664/1 3675/10 3680/15 3686/6
3687/18 3689/16 3709/25 3729/15
3736/18 3737/9 3757/7 3757/7 3793/5
3809/3
telling [3] 3673/12 3708/5 3725/5
tells [1] 3759/13
temperature [5] 3757/15 3757/18
3812/24 3812/25 3813/6
tender [1] 3735/24
tending [1] 3709/4
term [6] 3718/13 3719/21 3734/10
3774/4 3804/15 3827/2
termed [1] 3732/3
terms [8] 3671/19 3675/23 3678/6
3692/11 3701/22 3740/11 3753/17
3770/12
test [17] 3666/19 3668/11 3668/16
3670/8 3678/8 3678/10 3678/21 3678/25
3682/15 3682/21 3696/4 3696/6 3696/17
3696/20 3696/24 3717/25 3722/17
tested [6] 3805/17 3818/11 3818/13
3824/23 3824/25 3833/21
testified [10] 3662/16 3688/7 3706/11
3706/15 3707/23 3708/1 3709/14 3710/4
3727/11 3766/7
testimony [15] 3672/2 3679/7 3688/14
3707/19 3708/6 3708/16 3721/17
3728/19 3736/12 3763/25 3764/16
3764/23 3769/16 3769/17 3830/14
testing [7] 3754/12 3812/22 3814/2
3815/9 3816/18 3818/14 3823/9
Texas [8] 3656/17 3657/7 3659/10
3659/21 3660/5 3660/10 3660/13
3660/17
than [15] 3670/17 3676/1 3676/13
3693/23 3699/10 3711/13 3754/24
3783/3 3784/12 3794/12 3797/1 3807/8
3817/14 3834/22 3835/7
Thank [21] 3662/11 3662/12 3662/14
3673/3 3674/16 3690/6 3690/13 3694/19
3698/13 3700/18 3710/13 3710/15
3726/17 3726/18 3726/19 3736/7
3782/13 3791/19 3814/24 3818/6 3818/8
Thanks [4] 3737/22 3756/4 3799/23
3819/7
that [813]
that's [95] 3666/16 3676/10 3676/16
3678/19 3681/5 3682/22 3685/1 3688/22
3689/8 3689/19 3689/24 3693/4 3694/1
3697/14 3697/20 3699/16 3699/20
3700/17 3700/17 3701/17 3701/23
3702/12 3703/16 3705/12 3707/10
3707/18 3708/8 3710/13 3714/24 3721/6
3721/14 3727/8 3727/9 3728/20 3728/21
3728/21 3736/13 3742/8 3742/24 3744/7
3744/12 3745/25 3746/13 3746/24
3749/10 3749/10 3758/3 3758/4 3758/7
3759/17 3761/4 3761/16 3764/8 3764/20
3765/2 3773/5 3773/10 3774/1 3774/18

3774/25 3775/14 3776/4 3777/22 3780/1
3782/12 3782/20 3785/10 3792/20
3795/15 3796/24 3800/21 3801/6 3802/8
3802/8 3802/12 3804/12 3805/1 3805/4
3807/3 3807/25 3808/15 3809/17
3809/23 3813/19 3814/3 3816/24 3822/8
3822/18 3822/22 3826/9 3827/5 3829/1
3832/5 3835/9 3835/22
their [15] 3687/20 3698/5 3734/19
3753/24 3767/1 3771/24 3771/24
3771/25 3778/16 3788/4 3788/5 3794/2
3799/9 3822/25 3823/1
them [51] 3662/8 3671/17 3675/7
3677/16 3680/15 3683/7 3686/25
3687/18 3687/18 3688/20 3689/22
3689/25 3704/4 3704/8 3715/11 3715/22
3722/19 3731/9 3733/24 3733/24
3733/25 3733/25 3734/6 3734/24 3737/3
3737/7 3737/21 3748/20 3749/11
3750/13 3758/10 3763/10 3763/10
3763/17 3766/21 3779/17 3787/1 3791/4
3792/22 3798/22 3806/22 3806/23
3810/3 3810/12 3816/6 3822/23 3828/21
3828/22 3828/22 3829/17 3831/7
themselves [2] 3755/5 3812/9
then [51] 3667/10 3668/10 3687/20
3687/23 3689/4 3693/15 3695/17 3700/4
3700/17 3701/1 3701/15 3702/18 3703/5
3703/15 3703/24 3703/25 3708/14
3709/8 3709/9 3718/2 3721/2 3722/15
3726/8 3730/17 3731/1 3731/4 3731/6
3732/1 3738/12 3740/17 3741/3 3741/5
3743/5 3746/14 3748/13 3749/3 3755/18
3767/6 3779/19 3784/13 3802/10
3812/15 3817/18 3817/19 3817/19
3826/10 3828/4 3828/5 3828/22 3835/13
3835/20
theoretically [1] 3767/12
there [130] 3662/24 3662/24 3663/3
3665/2 3665/13 3670/15 3671/8 3672/21
3673/5 3674/1 3674/5 3674/21 3675/19
3675/20 3676/1 3676/13 3676/24 3679/9
3679/25 3679/25 3680/6 3681/1 3681/3
3683/10 3683/12 3683/19 3685/20
3686/9 3690/16 3692/12 3693/11 3694/3
3694/3 3694/5 3694/12 3696/23 3696/24
3697/4 3697/23 3699/7 3699/10 3699/11
3700/1 3700/4 3700/19 3701/8 3701/9
3701/14 3701/14 3705/20 3705/23
3706/2 3708/6 3708/15 3708/23 3711/10
3713/18 3720/6 3721/24 3721/25
3723/11 3724/2 3725/1 3725/4 3727/24
3727/25 3728/9 3728/11 3728/13
3730/21 3735/3 3736/24 3737/2 3740/15
3745/1 3748/19 3749/5 3752/3 3752/14
3752/17 3752/18 3752/22 3756/4
3756/14 3757/3 3758/13 3759/6 3759/25
3763/3 3764/24 3767/23 3773/8 3775/16
3779/12 3780/7 3780/15 3780/19
3781/14 3783/13 3784/20 3784/21
3785/5 3791/3 3791/12 3791/17 3792/20
3792/22 3794/18 3796/13 3796/22
3797/1 3798/2 3798/10 3803/5 3806/17
3806/18 3806/20 3806/22 3810/24
3812/3 3814/22 3815/17 3816/20
3822/19 3824/2 3827/10 3828/9 3831/16
3833/3 3833/7
there's [30] 3696/22 3700/25 3701/7
3703/2 3703/8 3703/15 3708/5 3715/12
3722/25 3725/14 3726/4 3743/5 3749/6
3749/17 3750/23 3755/25 3759/6 3763/6
3763/7 3763/9 3783/14 3784/19 3791/9
T
there's... [7] 3797/23 3798/16 3805/7
3811/7 3813/10 3831/16 3834/12
therefore [5] 3758/18 3787/2 3792/13
3810/18 3819/12
these [49] 3662/9 3686/14 3691/15
3691/18 3692/19 3694/24 3715/6 3716/6
3716/7 3734/25 3739/15 3742/13
3748/16 3748/16 3754/11 3755/7
3755/12 3755/18 3756/19 3760/9
3762/16 3763/19 3766/21 3769/24
3771/8 3772/14 3777/13 3779/14
3783/24 3787/18 3790/19 3791/5
3792/12 3794/9 3795/3 3796/11 3797/21
3800/12 3800/15 3800/19 3802/7
3802/18 3813/8 3813/11 3813/12 3815/4
3815/10 3822/12 3827/12
they [200]
they'd [1] 3735/5
they're [5] 3675/25 3726/14 3773/10
3788/6 3800/2
thing [11] 3663/14 3675/24 3675/25
3703/22 3733/10 3741/1 3745/21
3753/19 3792/20 3799/3 3818/24
things [22] 3665/9 3670/1 3671/6 3674/5
3675/5 3706/9 3712/3 3713/6 3715/6
3715/10 3715/12 3721/25 3726/5
3736/17 3737/13 3742/9 3749/9 3770/9
3772/1 3791/7 3806/25 3810/3
think [42] 3664/13 3664/21 3671/11
3673/15 3676/7 3679/12 3681/21
3682/11 3684/7 3686/23 3688/18 3695/9
3704/11 3704/13 3705/6 3705/25
3709/22 3717/3 3717/8 3717/17 3717/19
3717/20 3723/14 3724/14 3728/22
3732/19 3745/2 3745/13 3758/10
3764/23 3766/8 3770/2 3787/11 3791/10
3799/20 3800/2 3801/22 3801/23
3814/20 3818/23 3821/22 3835/23
third [7] 3658/12 3742/16 3767/7 3767/8
3770/3 3796/9 3812/21
third-party [3] 3742/16 3767/7 3767/8
this [269]
Thornhill [2] 3656/21 3656/22
those [46] 3662/6 3662/10 3674/3
3674/14 3675/2 3677/2 3710/25 3711/13
3715/17 3718/6 3718/11 3722/12
3724/24 3732/13 3732/15 3738/21
3743/24 3745/6 3745/23 3756/13
3756/17 3758/8 3760/5 3762/4 3762/7
3762/14 3762/17 3762/20 3763/15
3764/9 3766/11 3766/24 3767/14
3769/21 3772/2 3785/6 3789/21 3789/22
3791/7 3798/13 3805/8 3806/24 3808/6
3811/20 3812/11 3833/10
though [5] 3686/6 3713/4 3729/2
3781/15 3819/24
thought [5] 3701/24 3712/8 3820/20
3825/15 3830/6
thoughts [1] 3713/12
thousands [1] 3755/17
threat [1] 3741/8
three [11] 3713/20 3724/20 3724/24
3752/21 3752/23 3762/15 3783/20
3796/12 3796/21 3797/1 3805/10
through [15] 3663/20 3671/12 3672/3
3674/25 3691/25 3698/15 3703/1 3703/5
3703/11 3703/11 3714/5 3714/6 3730/18
3791/4 3826/16
throughout [3] 3731/14 3756/19 3759/3
thruster [7] 3749/18 3795/2 3795/10
3795/13 3806/3 3811/1 3811/6
thrusters [8] 3748/17 3748/17 3748/24

3794/17 3794/19 3794/20 3794/23
3795/3
tied [1] 3766/4
time [103] 3662/8 3663/2 3663/13
3664/2 3665/3 3665/13 3665/25 3666/2
3666/3 3666/4 3666/5 3666/21 3667/15
3667/20 3667/22 3668/6 3669/22 3670/1
3670/10 3670/10 3670/14 3671/1 3672/3
3672/20 3673/16 3673/20 3674/2
3674/14 3676/10 3676/19 3677/7 3678/1
3678/8 3678/11 3678/18 3678/25 3679/5
3680/7 3681/5 3682/14 3682/20 3683/19
3688/11 3688/22 3690/25 3692/3 3692/5
3693/8 3694/1 3696/24 3697/11 3698/3
3698/23 3699/20 3703/10 3707/13
3708/9 3712/19 3720/6 3722/6 3722/12
3722/22 3723/2 3723/7 3723/9 3723/22
3723/24 3725/19 3726/4 3726/5 3726/25
3727/23 3729/14 3735/24 3739/16
3740/19 3740/23 3752/9 3752/12
3754/15 3756/12 3768/1 3775/23 3776/5
3776/12 3781/13 3791/4 3791/5 3794/3
3794/4 3797/23 3797/23 3804/24 3806/7
3810/13 3811/22 3813/11 3823/19
3824/7 3825/2 3825/16 3826/16 3830/24
timely [3] 3782/9 3807/21 3819/21
timeout [3] 3826/6 3826/7 3826/8
times [12] 3671/24 3719/24 3724/13
3733/1 3734/6 3735/10 3749/15 3779/9
3785/23 3790/20 3813/19 3823/21
title [1] 3786/5
titled [2] 3777/22 3785/13
today [10] 3664/25 3671/8 3671/11
3672/13 3676/24 3677/25 3697/20
3706/11 3715/5 3769/19
told [14] 3673/20 3673/24 3680/25
3685/4 3686/25 3688/20 3700/14
3718/19 3719/7 3719/9 3719/9 3719/16
3720/21 3729/7
Tolles [1] 3659/12
TOM [1] 3656/22
tomorrow [3] 3727/7 3835/2 3836/3
Toni [5] 3660/18 3660/20 3836/9
3836/17 3836/17
too [9] 3682/6 3686/4 3707/10 3709/10
3721/5 3768/13 3769/21 3776/21
3817/25
took [19] 3664/21 3668/16 3674/8
3674/17 3675/1 3678/1 3688/4 3700/1
3702/6 3702/7 3702/11 3703/11 3717/19
3718/20 3719/8 3719/17 3722/3 3725/10
3750/22
tools [4] 3663/19 3671/15 3813/23
3817/17
top [7] 3685/14 3702/23 3748/13 3776/4
3801/23 3821/23 3821/24
topic [4] 3776/17 3781/6 3782/23
3783/14
topics [1] 3664/6
torque [1] 3663/14
Torts [2] 3657/12 3657/22
total [2] 3671/12 3725/1
totally [1] 3830/23
touch [1] 3831/6
tour [20] 3664/8 3664/14 3665/4 3665/7
3665/21 3665/23 3667/15 3667/20
3667/22 3669/19 3670/6 3670/21
3671/24 3674/2 3707/20 3708/6 3712/11
3713/14 3726/2 3822/14
toward [1] 3701/4
towards [3] 3696/1 3702/10 3776/9
track [5] 3665/9 3782/10 3815/4 3816/20
3820/16
tracked [2] 3782/4 3807/20
tracking [3] 3827/24 3828/8 3828/21
tragedy [2] 3772/17 3797/14
trail [1] 3781/25
train [1] 3730/18
trained [13] 3681/12 3681/15 3681/19
3682/24 3742/15 3764/3 3764/12 3765/5
3799/12 3803/9 3822/24 3823/4 3823/4
training [15] 3718/16 3718/17 3718/19
3718/24 3719/7 3719/13 3719/14
3719/15 3719/16 3737/10 3770/20
3770/23 3799/7 3799/10 3822/19
transcript [2] 3655/14 3836/12
transcription [1] 3660/25
transfer [1] 3665/13
transferred [1] 3665/14
transferring [4] 3669/1 3726/6 3726/14
3726/16
transfers [1] 3665/10
transmitted [2] 3662/25 3754/4
Transocean [83] 3659/5 3659/6 3659/7
3659/8 3659/9 3659/10 3659/12 3659/12
3659/13 3659/16 3659/16 3659/17
3659/19 3659/20 3659/21 3672/15
3672/24 3673/24 3697/16 3698/4
3706/18 3709/2 3709/22 3711/4 3713/19
3718/19 3719/1 3719/8 3719/9 3719/16
3724/20 3728/2 3728/3 3734/1 3734/18
3738/7 3747/14 3750/15 3751/24 3752/3
3752/25 3753/17 3754/16 3765/10
3765/18 3766/13 3767/1 3767/16
3769/11 3769/13 3771/24 3772/20
3774/22 3779/10 3780/11 3784/1 3787/7
3787/10 3788/1 3788/6 3788/14 3790/2
3790/10 3790/16 3791/5 3794/12
3797/10 3799/20 3801/2 3801/6 3815/24
3820/4 3820/18 3824/6 3824/18 3825/18
3827/16 3827/24 3828/7 3828/17
3828/23 3829/11 3835/20
Transocean's [5] 3711/2 3711/23
3787/21 3789/2 3793/7
transponders [1] 3748/22
traps [1] 3706/19
tremendous [1] 3810/2
trend [3] 3663/19 3679/8 3691/18
TREX [40] 3667/3 3679/12 3712/12
3714/19 3725/17 3727/21 3729/6 3729/7
3739/20 3756/2 3768/9 3770/11 3772/5
3773/15 3774/19 3777/9 3780/20
3780/21 3782/14 3783/9 3784/5 3785/11
3787/4 3788/7 3788/8 3790/7 3793/3
3795/18 3797/6 3799/15 3800/22 3801/8
3803/18 3808/22 3810/6 3814/23
3814/23 3818/19 3826/24 3829/10
TREX'd [1] 3729/6
TREX-01 [1] 3785/11
TREX-013272 [1] 3829/10
TREX-01765 [1] 3797/6
TREX-01766 [1] 3800/22
TREX-01768 [1] 3826/24
TREX-01778 [1] 3808/22
TREX-1109 [1] 3756/2
TREX-1192 [1] 3793/3
TREX-1764 [1] 3784/5
TREX-1765 [1] 3801/8
TREX-22700 [1] 3729/7
TREX-3134 [1] 3774/19
TREX-3288 [1] 3795/18
TREX-3403 [1] 3803/18
TREX-3404 [1] 3810/6
TREX-4275 [2] 3768/9 3770/11
TREX-4395 [1] 3712/12
T
TREX-44015 [1] 3787/4
TREX-44032 [1] 3799/15
TREX-4680 [1] 3818/19
TREX-50361 [1] 3739/20
TREX-5483 [1] 3777/9
TREX-611.006 [1] 3714/19
TREX-6164 [1] 3773/15
TREX-620 [1] 3725/17
TREX-75 [1] 3790/7
TREX-7672 [1] 3727/21
TREX-7691 [1] 3772/5
TREX-91382 [1] 3679/12
TREX-967.1.1 [1] 3667/3
trial [3] 3655/14 3705/4 3772/10
Trials [1] 3810/9
tried [2] 3737/20 3780/13
trigger [1] 3792/25
trip [8] 3690/23 3691/12 3693/12
3693/18 3693/20 3694/7 3723/19 3725/7
TRITON [1] 3655/8
trouble [3] 3717/17 3753/6 3834/13
true [22] 3674/8 3688/3 3712/3 3720/7
3720/17 3720/18 3720/23 3721/4
3721/12 3733/14 3738/6 3755/3 3755/7
3761/5 3761/11 3792/24 3799/11
3808/17 3813/19 3821/14 3825/8
3836/11
trust [1] 3752/17
truth [2] 3716/23 3717/3
truthful [1] 3685/23
truthfully [1] 3765/19
try [11] 3709/13 3714/19 3737/6 3758/18
3759/6 3766/17 3780/17 3780/18 3810/4
3818/4 3818/5
trying [10] 3681/25 3700/6 3700/11
3700/19 3716/9 3717/6 3717/7 3778/10
3810/3 3821/11
Tuesday [1] 3835/8
turbocharger [1] 3811/1
turbochargers [1] 3763/12
turn [4] 3685/2 3701/6 3790/15 3796/6
turned [10] 3675/21 3682/6 3682/9
3688/25 3689/12 3702/18 3721/6 3721/8
3724/1 3805/8
turning [1] 3675/22
Tusa [5] 3660/18 3660/20 3836/9
3836/17 3836/17
TV [7] 3662/25 3697/7 3697/9 3697/9
3708/8 3740/1 3768/11
two [22] 3662/5 3696/23 3713/7 3713/18
3713/22 3714/13 3721/9 3725/14
3748/12 3749/11 3752/21 3752/23
3759/25 3762/15 3777/21 3778/25
3794/20 3815/14 3818/5 3826/6 3826/11
3827/17
type [8] 3663/14 3732/17 3733/10
3745/21 3753/19 3755/11 3763/22
3801/10
types [3] 3731/18 3791/7 3802/18
typically [2] 3722/12 3740/23
U
U.S [4] 3657/11 3657/15 3657/21 3658/2
uh [2] 3696/5 3786/2
uh-huh [2] 3696/5 3786/2
UK [2] 3730/1 3730/2
ultimate [1] 3779/20
ultimately [1] 3763/16
unable [1] 3674/14
unaware [4] 3815/20 3822/15 3822/22
3824/5
unbelievable [1] 3822/22

uncontrolled [1] 3734/13
under [25] 3667/24 3688/7 3689/9
3689/17 3696/14 3696/14 3733/9
3734/10 3739/7 3740/4 3752/4 3766/15
3772/11 3775/3 3776/17 3781/6 3782/3
3782/23 3783/14 3786/6 3800/18
3803/15 3806/2 3812/20 3833/11
UNDERHILL [2] 3657/12 3835/14
underneath [5] 3699/11 3701/1 3701/23
3743/5 3748/16
understand [16] 3665/23 3682/16
3691/25 3712/6 3715/17 3719/5 3720/11
3720/21 3734/14 3734/17 3750/12
3759/11 3765/13 3830/9 3835/11
3835/11
understanding [7] 3717/12 3729/3
3750/14 3773/25 3831/3 3835/6 3836/13
understands [2] 3728/22 3742/17
understood [2] 3672/22 3685/19
undertaken [2] 3781/23 3806/4
underway [4] 3748/5 3748/7 3748/8
3750/1
unfortunately [1] 3788/16
uninvited [1] 3791/15
unit [13] 3678/4 3678/13 3682/10
3700/16 3710/21 3710/24 3711/6
3720/22 3721/3 3721/5 3722/18 3723/1
3775/12
unit's [1] 3809/9
UNITED [19] 3655/1 3655/10 3655/15
3657/11 3657/15 3657/21 3658/2 3730/5
3730/13 3731/1 3731/9 3731/15 3732/3
3739/5 3739/6 3739/18 3739/19 3835/13
3836/10
United States [11] 3730/5 3730/13
3731/1 3731/9 3731/15 3732/3 3739/5
3739/6 3739/18 3739/19 3835/13
units [4] 3787/16 3794/20 3795/2
3795/14
University [1] 3729/19
unless [1] 3683/5
unobtainable [1] 3792/13
unsafe [3] 3672/22 3673/2 3673/5
unsatisfactory [1] 3781/23
until [10] 3670/10 3670/19 3673/17
3697/10 3721/1 3721/11 3730/10
3739/16 3780/5 3835/2
unusual [3] 3674/21 3675/7 3802/6
up [81] 3662/21 3663/2 3663/4 3664/2
3665/25 3666/11 3667/2 3670/7 3672/3
3674/5 3675/19 3688/25 3689/4 3689/6
3689/7 3689/15 3689/20 3689/24 3691/9
3691/11 3692/14 3694/14 3697/17
3703/8 3705/2 3705/11 3706/9 3706/10
3708/8 3712/12 3712/13 3717/22
3717/23 3717/25 3718/1 3719/22
3721/25 3723/13 3725/17 3727/1
3728/24 3730/17 3737/6 3739/16
3739/20 3740/17 3740/18 3740/22
3740/25 3750/23 3753/23 3755/20
3756/2 3757/17 3763/18 3766/20
3779/11 3785/9 3785/10 3785/22
3785/23 3786/11 3786/16 3787/19
3787/22 3788/17 3790/21 3792/14
3794/19 3807/19 3807/20 3809/11
3809/20 3810/3 3811/20 3813/7 3816/6
3818/4 3828/1 3835/4 3836/3
upcoming [1] 3668/5
upgrade [1] 3773/9
upon [4] 3722/11 3728/4 3790/22
3808/18
upper [1] 3796/10
us [25] 3671/20 3673/12 3675/11

3675/18 3679/19 3680/25 3686/2 3702/4
3703/10 3720/21 3725/5 3727/6 3729/15
3729/15 3736/18 3740/12 3756/8 3757/7
3779/11 3797/8 3799/17 3800/24
3808/24 3818/21 3826/24
use [14] 3665/9 3679/1 3699/14 3699/15
3700/3 3700/17 3708/20 3729/7 3754/13
3793/13 3812/14 3813/23 3833/17
3834/6
used [14] 3662/5 3708/8 3709/15
3714/24 3718/16 3721/16 3734/24
3803/22 3807/13 3807/15 3815/4
3815/25 3821/24 3824/10
user [1] 3794/3
using [3] 3660/24 3748/23 3793/10
Usually [1] 3722/14
utility [1] 3793/1
utilized [1] 3692/22
utilizing [2] 3748/21 3748/21
V
value [1] 3664/1
values [4] 3663/24 3679/20 3694/24
3792/13
valve [7] 3675/19 3676/8 3676/9 3676/14
3689/3 3717/23 3725/8
valves [13] 3763/9 3773/2 3796/9
3796/10 3796/12 3796/21 3796/21
3797/1 3805/8 3805/16 3811/19 3814/6
3814/7
various [12] 3731/19 3742/21 3742/22
3755/19 3756/10 3756/11 3784/13
3785/8 3790/18 3804/5 3829/11 3829/15
ventilation [8] 3759/21 3760/2 3760/8
3762/18 3762/20 3814/6 3814/20
3831/25
venture [1] 3730/14
verbal [1] 3790/3
verbatim [2] 3702/18 3776/12
verge [1] 3705/3
verified [5] 3724/8 3787/18 3818/13
3825/1 3827/22
verify [3] 3778/4 3786/11 3828/9
verifying [1] 3746/10
Veritas [5] 3731/7 3731/11 3733/11
3785/13 3797/9
vertically [1] 3759/8
very [33] 3672/10 3672/19 3704/17
3721/19 3728/25 3742/23 3742/23
3743/21 3749/17 3754/23 3754/24
3756/1 3759/18 3761/2 3761/9 3761/9
3761/12 3770/22 3782/12 3792/20
3793/12 3793/15 3793/19 3795/7 3795/9
3796/24 3806/8 3807/25 3817/3 3818/24
3821/20 3821/20 3829/3
vessel [70] 3730/14 3730/17 3730/17
3733/2 3734/10 3735/12 3736/1 3737/16
3737/16 3738/3 3738/20 3738/21
3738/25 3739/2 3739/12 3739/14
3739/16 3741/4 3745/11 3745/14
3745/23 3748/12 3748/22 3749/3
3749/23 3750/3 3750/3 3750/17 3750/18
3750/21 3752/19 3752/25 3755/8
3755/13 3756/19 3758/4 3760/5 3760/24
3761/6 3761/9 3764/14 3766/8 3766/17
3775/13 3779/15 3779/16 3782/9 3784/9
3785/6 3786/22 3788/1 3791/2 3794/23
3795/2 3796/18 3804/1 3804/22 3805/14
3805/15 3808/9 3809/19 3812/2 3812/10
3812/16 3813/4 3813/17 3832/24
3833/13 3834/1 3834/11
vessel's [3] 3738/5 3746/19 3746/22
V
vessel-owning [1] 3752/25
vessel-specific [1] 3785/6
vessels [13] 3730/10 3731/18 3732/6
3733/9 3733/19 3735/12 3736/25
3738/21 3742/12 3782/4 3785/8 3820/12
3834/14
vice [2] 3798/2 3802/10
view [4] 3663/10 3679/19 3697/10
3723/4
viewed [2] 3672/7 3724/2
violation [28] 3779/6 3789/6 3789/16
3793/22 3795/16 3797/3 3799/11
3809/15 3809/17 3811/9 3812/11
3816/24 3816/24 3817/12 3819/15
3819/16 3820/7 3825/9 3829/1 3831/20
3832/4 3832/5 3832/9 3832/22 3832/23
3832/24 3833/23 3833/25
violations [2] 3791/8 3800/13
Virginia [2] 3656/10 3656/10
visit [1] 3745/14
visits [1] 3784/13
visually [4] 3697/3 3697/23 3723/24
3724/8
vital [1] 3750/17
VLCC [1] 3732/10
VOIR [1] 3727/16
Volker [1] 3730/15
volume [3] 3667/11 3671/12 3671/13
volumes [1] 3665/12
VON [1] 3660/12
W
W-E-B-S-T-E-R [1] 3727/15
wait [4] 3709/4 3709/4 3709/4 3835/3
wake [1] 3708/8
walk [6] 3700/25 3701/8 3701/8 3703/2
3703/18 3727/3
walked [1] 3703/1
Walker [1] 3656/9
walking [1] 3813/11
WALTER [1] 3656/12
Walther [1] 3659/22
want [34] 3662/21 3666/25 3676/22
3677/22 3681/21 3685/2 3685/3 3685/18
3698/22 3702/7 3704/12 3707/10
3707/18 3709/25 3710/7 3713/12
3718/24 3719/25 3721/25 3723/13
3727/3 3730/22 3736/3 3740/4 3744/9
3751/12 3760/17 3760/18 3766/19
3768/11 3820/25 3826/12 3834/15
3835/4
wanted [9] 3663/4 3690/10 3697/3
3706/9 3710/8 3717/9 3724/17 3730/20
3734/16
warning [2] 3784/1 3784/4
was [232]
Washington [4] 3657/20 3657/25 3658/6
3659/4
wasn't [13] 3679/5 3682/9 3683/24
3686/4 3693/22 3699/5 3699/15 3708/15
3712/18 3721/8 3722/9 3722/10 3794/14
watch [8] 3663/24 3732/17 3732/20
3749/11 3749/12 3749/13 3751/8
3826/14
watching [1] 3726/12
water [9] 3776/6 3794/18 3795/1 3795/6
3795/13 3795/16 3806/8 3812/24 3813/6
watertight [8] 3755/24 3755/25 3762/8
3805/10 3805/13 3811/17 3832/18
3832/24
Watts [2] 3656/15 3656/15
waves [1] 3748/24

way [19] 3663/10 3672/3 3679/20 3689/2
3689/7 3698/12 3700/6 3700/19 3701/5
3717/23 3745/18 3749/1 3754/16
3754/18 3755/8 3757/22 3816/20
3817/19 3823/13
ways [1] 3681/15
we [168] 3664/1 3666/20 3666/21
3667/2 3667/10 3668/10 3668/10
3668/15 3669/4 3671/17 3673/6 3674/24
3677/12 3682/14 3683/12 3686/23
3686/23 3687/10 3688/14 3688/18
3688/20 3690/16 3690/21 3690/22
3691/7 3691/8 3691/10 3691/15 3691/25
3694/14 3694/24 3695/12 3697/6 3697/7
3698/12 3699/1 3699/4 3699/20 3701/6
3701/24 3704/22 3709/10 3709/11
3710/16 3710/23 3712/13 3713/11
3713/15 3714/18 3717/4 3717/22 3718/2
3718/4 3719/22 3719/25 3721/16
3721/17 3724/14 3725/17 3726/25
3727/6 3727/22 3728/23 3729/7 3730/21
3731/16 3732/2 3735/24 3736/4 3737/22
3739/23 3742/16 3743/1 3745/18
3745/20 3747/11 3747/11 3748/5
3748/21 3749/19 3751/11 3751/16
3754/14 3754/19 3757/16 3757/25
3758/1 3758/2 3758/25 3759/3 3759/8
3759/8 3759/9 3759/21 3760/1 3762/11
3762/14 3763/5 3763/9 3764/23 3766/5
3766/14 3766/15 3769/20 3769/23
3770/2 3770/3 3770/8 3772/9 3773/3
3773/17 3773/25 3775/19 3775/24
3776/20 3776/22 3777/11 3777/22
3780/19 3781/3 3782/14 3783/9 3783/14
3784/7 3784/22 3790/17 3791/12
3791/22 3791/25 3792/3 3793/8 3794/16
3796/3 3796/3 3796/5 3798/7 3798/10
3801/7 3801/20 3802/25 3804/24 3806/2
3808/4 3809/5 3810/11 3815/2 3815/7
3816/6 3818/24 3819/2 3823/19 3823/21
3824/7 3825/2 3825/18 3827/7 3827/9
3827/10 3828/13 3828/13 3834/17
3834/25 3835/2 3835/3 3835/9 3835/10
3835/25 3836/1
we'll [11] 3670/18 3677/19 3686/2
3689/24 3705/7 3731/20 3758/10 3766/5
3829/19 3835/20 3836/4
we're [4] 3687/19 3720/1 3729/14
3760/22
we've [5] 3745/19 3745/20 3764/16
3764/16 3801/13
weather [1] 3749/17
Webster [47] 3726/22 3727/10 3727/14
3727/18 3728/1 3729/11 3733/22
3735/25 3736/10 3739/24 3756/6
3760/21 3763/24 3768/11 3768/15
3772/7 3775/25 3779/6 3780/24 3781/10
3782/6 3782/18 3783/4 3787/8 3788/11
3791/21 3793/5 3795/21 3796/16
3799/17 3800/11 3808/24 3809/16
3811/4 3811/20 3813/2 3813/15 3817/11
3818/21 3819/16 3820/7 3821/6 3829/6
3832/14 3835/5 3835/21 3836/2
Webster's [2] 3727/20 3728/4
week [3] 3750/6 3764/23 3816/15
weeks [1] 3815/14
welcome [1] 3698/14
well [123] 3669/8 3669/19 3670/1
3670/22 3685/2 3691/10 3693/23 3697/4
3697/10 3697/24 3698/5 3702/9 3704/17
3705/8 3705/24 3709/25 3712/24
3715/15 3715/23 3715/23 3716/10
3716/15 3716/15 3716/18 3717/8

3717/13 3718/10 3718/15 3718/24
3721/19 3723/25 3724/9 3724/11
3724/14 3726/8 3728/11 3728/25
3730/10 3731/25 3732/12 3738/11
3738/23 3739/5 3740/13 3740/25
3742/23 3744/16 3744/25 3745/13
3746/25 3748/11 3752/1 3752/5 3752/21
3753/2 3753/20 3754/4 3754/14 3756/9
3758/14 3759/3 3759/24 3760/17
3762/11 3763/5 3763/8 3765/3 3765/11
3765/14 3765/19 3766/14 3766/15
3767/5 3767/23 3767/23 3767/25 3769/6
3769/22 3770/8 3771/10 3771/17
3771/21 3775/23 3776/5 3778/16
3779/19 3780/2 3782/8 3786/7 3788/19
3793/11 3793/12 3797/21 3798/16
3799/21 3801/19 3801/22 3804/22
3805/21 3807/9 3807/19 3807/25
3809/20 3810/14 3810/17 3810/24
3810/24 3811/12 3813/16 3815/18
3815/20 3816/1 3817/16 3819/20
3821/10 3823/1 3823/4 3824/3 3824/4
3824/11 3824/13 3826/9 3834/11
wellbore [2] 3691/9 3718/2
wellhead [4] 3667/19 3670/7 3734/14
3749/20
wells [14] 3672/14 3713/7 3713/11
3713/23 3714/13 3715/15 3715/17
3715/18 3715/21 3716/7 3716/11
3718/10 3718/11 3748/4
went [28] 3664/8 3666/20 3670/6
3675/13 3676/10 3676/11 3682/2 3682/3
3682/5 3689/6 3697/6 3699/13 3699/14
3699/15 3699/17 3701/18 3702/4
3702/14 3703/10 3707/5 3707/6 3707/20
3712/16 3722/6 3722/22 3732/18
3734/18 3825/13
were [133] 3663/8 3664/11 3665/13
3665/16 3665/25 3666/11 3666/21
3666/25 3668/16 3668/17 3668/19
3669/13 3670/15 3670/21 3671/23
3671/24 3672/8 3672/14 3672/15 3673/7
3673/13 3673/17 3673/18 3673/20
3673/21 3674/1 3674/1 3674/2 3674/5
3674/18 3674/19 3675/3 3675/13
3675/19 3676/16 3676/17 3676/19
3676/24 3677/7 3678/7 3678/8 3678/10
3679/24 3681/23 3682/4 3682/7 3682/24
3685/20 3686/9 3687/23 3688/4 3688/20
3694/25 3695/4 3695/20 3696/17
3696/25 3697/1 3698/9 3698/23 3699/10
3700/20 3705/3 3711/10 3711/10 3712/3
3712/5 3712/9 3713/18 3713/22 3713/22
3715/6 3715/10 3715/14 3715/17
3716/16 3716/18 3717/12 3718/11
3718/15 3718/19 3719/7 3719/16
3720/12 3722/15 3723/8 3723/11
3724/24 3725/4 3725/22 3727/25
3730/21 3732/14 3735/3 3736/10
3736/14 3737/2 3739/2 3740/15 3744/21
3744/24 3745/5 3762/14 3764/10 3767/9
3767/18 3772/2 3772/4 3778/10 3778/20
3781/22 3781/23 3781/24 3791/5 3791/8
3792/20 3794/11 3796/12 3796/22
3796/23 3797/22 3806/8 3807/21 3809/9
3812/21 3814/7 3819/11 3819/24 3821/4
3822/15 3822/21 3827/17 3827/20
weren't [3] 3736/12 3736/15 3740/16
West [4] 3772/9 3772/10 3795/22 3796/3
West Engineering [1] 3795/22
what [161] 3663/10 3664/18 3664/24
3665/3 3665/3 3665/23 3666/2 3666/10
W
what... [153] 3666/10 3666/16 3668/15
3668/15 3668/20 3669/4 3670/3 3673/12
3675/8 3677/21 3678/19 3678/25
3680/25 3682/16 3682/22 3683/22
3683/22 3684/10 3685/20 3686/19
3687/6 3688/22 3690/16 3691/10
3692/11 3692/16 3693/4 3697/10
3697/14 3697/20 3701/10 3701/17
3702/22 3703/12 3707/10 3707/18
3708/9 3712/7 3716/9 3717/12 3718/23
3719/9 3719/9 3720/8 3720/12 3720/17
3722/6 3722/12 3722/20 3723/2 3723/24
3724/9 3725/4 3725/13 3726/9 3728/21
3731/16 3731/23 3734/14 3735/2
3736/18 3737/10 3737/18 3739/24
3740/12 3740/23 3740/25 3742/16
3742/20 3744/7 3744/15 3748/12
3748/21 3749/10 3749/19 3750/3
3752/25 3753/17 3756/8 3756/14 3757/7
3757/10 3757/16 3758/12 3758/12
3758/13 3758/25 3759/10 3759/22
3760/1 3760/7 3761/16 3762/10 3763/5
3763/9 3764/9 3765/16 3765/17 3766/3
3766/3 3766/12 3766/15 3768/12 3769/8
3769/10 3775/14 3776/2 3777/3 3777/11
3778/10 3778/14 3778/16 3779/10
3781/10 3782/7 3783/1 3784/9 3785/19
3786/5 3786/8 3788/8 3790/13 3792/21
3793/5 3795/3 3797/11 3797/20 3798/3
3798/18 3799/25 3802/13 3803/12
3804/10 3804/16 3804/18 3809/3
3809/25 3811/23 3813/23 3814/9
3815/22 3818/24 3819/12 3821/6
3821/18 3821/20 3822/24 3823/11
3824/18 3827/4 3831/10 3832/14 3834/9
what's [18] 3665/7 3696/23 3718/7
3719/5 3726/13 3732/2 3737/14 3738/8
3739/3 3742/17 3742/18 3745/9 3749/13
3755/14 3765/13 3785/9 3807/23
3807/24
whatever [7] 3663/4 3727/24 3732/6
3748/4 3787/22 3814/1 3826/12
whatsoever [2] 3669/17 3687/17
when [78] 3664/1 3664/6 3665/7
3665/12 3665/21 3666/5 3667/20
3668/16 3670/6 3670/21 3672/8 3674/19
3675/3 3675/20 3675/21 3676/8 3677/23
3678/4 3678/6 3678/10 3679/7 3680/22
3682/9 3682/24 3685/19 3688/24
3688/25 3689/9 3691/7 3692/8 3692/24
3694/17 3696/4 3696/24 3698/9 3698/23
3699/13 3700/24 3701/6 3702/24
3704/14 3710/12 3711/7 3717/17
3719/15 3721/7 3722/16 3723/1 3723/5
3723/10 3724/19 3725/8 3725/12 3726/2
3732/18 3745/5 3748/3 3750/21 3752/18
3759/12 3766/5 3770/13 3770/20
3770/24 3785/7 3789/22 3790/23
3803/24 3805/7 3805/17 3809/22
3810/21 3812/4 3812/5 3814/2 3816/9
3821/6 3830/19
whenever [1] 3690/3
where [39] 3666/21 3671/17 3672/14
3688/15 3691/18 3693/12 3694/4 3694/6
3694/7 3694/7 3695/7 3695/24 3696/7
3696/8 3696/9 3696/20 3697/4 3699/7
3699/23 3700/20 3713/1 3713/19
3716/12 3720/1 3723/22 3724/4 3726/9
3734/13 3740/9 3756/17 3770/2 3778/6
3787/14 3789/20 3791/4 3793/15 3795/4
3815/3 3825/17
whether [19] 3681/24 3697/4 3713/3

3716/10 3716/10 3718/11 3719/13
3719/14 3749/23 3749/24 3750/4
3755/25 3766/12 3767/19 3771/24
3772/2 3816/20 3824/18 3826/17
which [66] 3677/20 3681/6 3691/3
3692/13 3696/25 3697/17 3700/6
3701/16 3703/5 3720/6 3728/18 3731/3
3731/7 3731/8 3734/16 3734/24 3735/5
3736/11 3736/21 3736/22 3737/1 3737/3
3737/7 3737/8 3738/8 3739/7 3740/19
3740/20 3741/1 3741/5 3742/19 3743/4
3751/13 3752/9 3753/13 3754/8 3755/4
3755/15 3759/13 3760/11 3760/22
3763/6 3771/16 3773/22 3774/13
3775/12 3783/9 3783/13 3784/22
3788/21 3789/1 3789/9 3796/13 3796/23
3796/25 3796/25 3799/2 3799/12
3803/22 3803/23 3810/19 3810/23
3812/4 3820/9 3821/23 3829/4
while [12] 3671/24 3675/13 3675/19
3676/16 3688/4 3723/11 3731/21
3733/12 3748/8 3754/20 3760/10
3810/21
Whiteley [1] 3658/15
who [35] 3670/12 3677/18 3696/20
3706/2 3706/3 3706/25 3708/20 3710/2
3710/9 3710/11 3712/13 3712/20 3714/7
3725/12 3727/1 3742/16 3744/10
3744/21 3744/24 3745/2 3749/11 3778/3
3779/17 3779/18 3779/20 3787/20
3791/14 3797/17 3798/2 3804/8 3804/9
3808/14 3810/12 3830/17 3835/7
who's [1] 3745/11
whoever [2] 3706/15 3826/15
whole [10] 3714/20 3726/25 3766/19
3766/20 3787/13 3799/3 3801/22 3813/5
3827/9 3829/6
whom [1] 3712/13
why [18] 3708/8 3717/12 3748/10
3748/10 3760/16 3763/17 3765/12
3779/6 3785/10 3795/9 3804/21 3805/20
3807/18 3808/15 3809/18 3817/15
3819/19 3821/9
wife [1] 3730/22
will [37] 3693/12 3700/4 3700/4 3707/20
3707/23 3708/1 3710/1 3721/17 3725/19
3726/6 3727/6 3727/25 3728/24 3729/3
3740/20 3745/4 3756/21 3756/21
3762/12 3776/6 3779/19 3779/19
3782/14 3783/9 3785/8 3785/22 3787/18
3789/9 3794/1 3805/21 3826/13 3835/2
3835/7 3835/13 3836/1 3836/2 3836/3
Williams [4] 3656/18 3656/19 3727/18
3768/1
Williamson [2] 3657/5 3657/6
willingness [2] 3771/11 3771/14
Willis [7] 3664/11 3664/19 3665/22
3666/10 3668/19 3669/7 3670/1
wind [1] 3748/24
WINFIELD [1] 3658/9
Winslow [1] 3787/7
withdraw [1] 3741/3
within [11] 3678/21 3695/17 3752/12
3781/8 3787/16 3803/22 3815/14
3816/14 3824/17 3827/24 3828/7
without [4] 3750/18 3809/23 3810/4
3821/4
witness [8] 3690/10 3704/18 3704/20
3717/9 3769/17 3769/18 3769/19 3830/2
witness's [1] 3721/17
witnesses [3] 3835/5 3835/7 3835/14
Wittmann [2] 3659/22 3659/23
women [2] 3705/17 3808/14

won't [2] 3739/8 3822/2
wonder [1] 3817/23
Wong's [1] 3818/23
word [1] 3736/18
words [5] 3667/18 3671/15 3682/7
3737/18 3805/7
work [27] 3673/5 3673/6 3673/8 3677/23
3711/11 3714/25 3716/8 3750/12
3762/25 3772/25 3778/4 3781/15
3781/19 3781/23 3782/8 3787/15 3794/4
3794/5 3796/14 3806/4 3807/12 3808/14
3819/12 3819/24 3820/3 3821/4 3821/18
worked [9] 3711/8 3711/16 3716/11
3730/12 3734/1 3734/6 3756/12 3770/1
3830/17
working [7] 3670/12 3672/14 3733/23
3741/25 3762/25 3810/4 3816/21
workload [1] 3713/15
works [5] 3705/5 3714/10 3731/3
3783/16 3818/5
workstation [1] 3775/7
world [2] 3731/14 3739/14
world: [1] 3730/12
world: India [1] 3730/12
worn [2] 3795/5 3795/6
worse [1] 3794/15
would [154] 3663/2 3663/3 3663/3
3663/13 3664/1 3664/14 3664/15 3665/9
3665/12 3665/13 3667/8 3668/6 3670/1
3670/2 3670/3 3670/3 3670/11 3670/12
3670/25 3671/3 3671/19 3672/22
3676/17 3677/23 3678/7 3678/9 3678/15
3678/16 3678/22 3678/25 3679/8
3680/19 3684/11 3685/9 3686/18
3686/22 3686/25 3687/3 3687/9 3687/24
3688/11 3688/13 3688/17 3688/20
3689/13 3689/14 3689/16 3689/17
3691/22 3692/2 3693/4 3693/11 3695/14
3695/21 3696/1 3696/8 3696/11 3696/12
3696/14 3696/18 3696/18 3696/20
3697/4 3697/6 3698/4 3699/25 3701/12
3701/17 3705/6 3708/11 3708/17
3708/23 3711/2 3711/15 3713/14
3716/22 3720/4 3721/11 3721/15 3722/8
3727/22 3738/7 3740/17 3742/10
3745/18 3746/21 3751/7 3751/24 3752/6
3754/21 3760/21 3760/23 3762/7
3762/14 3762/17 3762/20 3762/23
3763/1 3764/6 3764/9 3764/13 3764/13
3764/15 3765/16 3765/17 3765/21
3765/24 3766/23 3767/18 3768/3
3769/16 3769/16 3769/18 3769/20
3769/22 3770/20 3771/5 3773/20
3783/13 3783/23 3786/19 3786/25
3787/21 3790/22 3797/3 3797/3 3797/5
3797/21 3797/23 3798/13 3798/14
3798/25 3799/1 3800/15 3800/16
3800/18 3800/24 3803/20 3804/18
3804/20 3808/24 3814/21 3818/10
3819/5 3821/18 3821/22 3822/16
3822/18 3824/19 3825/18 3826/24
3827/22 3831/1 3834/25
wouldn't [3] 3695/21 3708/11 3766/2
Wright [1] 3655/18
write [5] 3665/12 3700/4 3740/25
3766/20 3785/22
writing [1] 3829/17
written [7] 3665/22 3740/18 3778/21
3779/4 3785/10 3790/3 3798/17
wrong [2] 3681/25 3717/23
wrote [2] 3723/1 3723/2
Y
yeah [25] 3673/9 3673/9 3677/21
3678/20 3679/23 3684/24 3688/7
3692/14 3692/15 3697/21 3697/21
3699/11 3699/12 3702/13 3702/15
3703/20 3705/19 3706/3 3706/17
3707/25 3708/10 3708/18 3709/3 3716/4
3731/25
year [7] 3689/17 3783/21 3785/21
3785/23 3793/20 3796/11 3819/9
yearly [2] 3806/3 3811/2
years [13] 3718/17 3731/6 3732/22
3732/23 3733/24 3772/17 3773/13
3783/20 3793/11 3797/13 3797/13
3823/22 3828/15
yellow [2] 3749/13 3787/15
yes [436]
yesterday [1] 3662/6
yet [6] 3668/3 3679/5 3685/3 3722/10
3772/10 3806/4
Yoakum [1] 3657/6
you [749]
you'll [2] 3791/21 3822/2
you're [15] 3665/12 3676/7 3684/10
3690/22 3695/9 3698/14 3701/3 3703/19
3705/20 3711/4 3717/6 3725/4 3726/2
3726/8 3726/19
You've [1] 3686/4
you-all [2] 3709/4 3835/23
YOUNG [1] 3658/5
your [242]
Your Honor [40] 3662/14 3690/9 3690/14
3698/19 3704/12 3704/23 3710/17
3711/21 3718/21 3719/2 3721/14
3726/18 3726/23 3727/20 3728/13
3728/23 3729/1 3729/5 3736/5 3748/19
3769/12 3769/22 3780/10 3780/14
3780/22 3790/16 3791/1 3791/13
3791/19 3797/21 3813/9 3817/23 3818/8
3820/19 3821/25 3835/9 3835/17
3835/19 3835/22 3835/25
yourself [1] 3672/7
Z
zero [1] 3763/14

March 13, 2013 PM

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

March 13, 2013 PM

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Description:

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

March 13, 2013 PM

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

3655

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA

IN RE: OIL SPILL BY THE OIL RIG

DAY 11, AFTERNOON SESSION

Domengeaux Wright Roy

For the Plaintiffs:

Herman Herman & Katz, LLC

Cunningham Bounds, LLC

For the Plaintiffs:

Lewis Kullman Sterbcow & Abramson

For the Plaintiffs:

Breit Drescher Imprevento

For the Plaintiffs:

Leger & Shaw

For the Plaintiffs:

Watts Guerra Craft, LLP

For the Plaintiffs:

Williams Law Group, LLC

For the Plaintiffs:

Thornhill Law Firm

For the Plaintiffs:

deGravelles Palmintier Holthaus

For the Plaintiffs:

Williamson & Rusnak

For the Plaintiffs:

Irpino Law Firm

For the United States

U.S. Department of Justice

For the United States

U.S. Department of Justice

For the United States

U.S. Department of Justice

U.S. Department of Justice

For the State of

Attorney General of Alabama

For the State of

Attorney General of Louisiana

For the State of

Kanner & Whiteley, LLC

For BP Exploration &

Liskow & Lewis, APLC

For BP Exploration &

Kirkland & Ellis, LLP

Covington & Burling, LLP

For Transocean Holdings

For Transocean Holdings

Sutherland Asbill & Brennan, LLP

For Transocean Holdings

Munger Tolles & Olson, LLP

For Transocean Holdings

Mahtook & Lafleur

For Transocean Holdings

Hughes Arrell Kinchen, LLP

For Cameron International

Stone Pigman Walther Wittmann, LLC

Beck Redden & Secrest, LLP

For Halliburton Energy

For Halliburton Energy: