Fahad Bin Sultan University, Saudi Arabia Al-Balqa Applied University, Jordan
Fahad Bin Sultan University, Saudi Arabia Al-Balqa Applied University, Jordan
Fahad Bin Sultan University, Saudi Arabia Al-Balqa Applied University, Jordan
2, 2024
Abstract: Considering the critical role of writing in EFL contexts, this study sets out to
examine the writing skills of Jordanian EFL students, addressing both the challenges they
encounter and the potential strategies for enhancing their capabilities. To achieve this, the
researchers implemented two distinct methods of data collection: a survey and semi-
structured interviews. The survey data were analysed utilizing basic descriptive statistics,
while the interview data were examined based on Braun and Clarke’s (2006) thematic
analysis framework. The participants in this study included 150 Jordanian EFL students
majoring in English language across three public universities, alongside eight experienced
EFL writing instructors. The results revealed a set of writing challenges confronted by the
students, such as the struggle to compose grammatically accurate and coherent text. These
difficulties originated from a variety of factors, notably a deficiency in linguistic knowledge
and a lack of motivation. Moreover, the study emphasized the crucial influence of the
teaching process, which holds the potential to impact the students' writing proficiency either
positively or adversely. To address the challenges in EFL writing, this study has outlined
potential strategies, encompassing effective instruction, the enrichment of students'
linguistic knowledge, the integration of advanced technologies such as Artificial
Intelligence (AI), and the encouragement of student motivation. Notably, the integration of
AI tools emerges as a novel strategy with the potential to revolutionize teaching practices
by offering personalized feedback and enhancing the learning experience. This research
substantially contributes to the existing body of literature on EFL writing, revealing the
specific challenges among Jordanian EFL students, and providing a comprehensive set of
practical and innovative solutions for EFL writing instructors.
Keywords: AI in EFL writing, EFL writing difficulties, EFL writing instruction, EFL
writing proficiency, grammatical competence, lexical knowledge, textual Coherence
1. Introduction
Writing is a pivotal communication skill for English learners, essential for
communicating messages with clarity and coherence. It stands as a core competence
in academia, where creating well-structured text is integral to success. This skill
goes beyond mere composition; it cultivates linguistic precision, reinforces
grammatical and lexical proficiency, and stimulates critical thinking. Thus, its
mastery is importance for students in EFL settings, aiding in the development of a
broad range of academic and cognitive abilities which can be done through
consistent practice and structured learning (Rao 2007; Godwin-Jones 2018; Anh
267
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
2019). It requires regular engagement with varied writing tasks and feedback on
performance.
Mastering English writing is essential for Jordanian EFL students,
significantly contributing to their academic language proficiency. In detail, English
is a core subject in Jordan, taught from kindergarten through higher education,
highlighting its importance across all educational levels. As students progress, they
are expected to handle more complex writing tasks, demonstrating a clear
understanding and application of English writing conventions. This skill is not just
vital for academic success; it also opens doors to international opportunities and
enhances employability, as English is a global language.
EFL learners at Jordanian universities often face significant difficulties in
mastering writing skills, with even simple paragraph construction proving arduous.
Studies have consistently identified a range of writing issues among these students,
including limited vocabulary and weak coherence, which affects their ability to
produce well-structured texts (Ibnian 2017; AL-Widyan and Abu Darwish 2019).
Moreover, an apparent disregard for the importance of writing further hampers their
quest for mastery.
Nevertheless, despite these insights, previous studies have not provided an
in-depth understanding of this phenomenon nor practical strategies to enhance
students' skills. Consequently, the current study endeavours to systematically fill
this gap, aiming to acquire a profound understanding of the existing issue by
exploring the types of writing challenges faced by the students, identifying the
causes, and proposing practical solutions to address these challenges, all while
considering the role of technological advancements in enhancing the students’
writing skills, in particular AI-driven tools in EFL writing settings. To this end, the
study aims at answering the following questions:
RQ.1: What are the most common writing difficulties encountered by EFL
Jordanian students?
RQ.2: Which factors contribute to the emergence of writing difficulties
encountered by EFL Jordanian students?
RQ.3: What strategies can be effectively implemented to address the writing
challenges encountered by EFL Jordanian students?
2. General background
2.1 Writing
Writing is a complex skill involving both physical and intellectual activities, such
as word composition and idea organization, which are crucial for English Language
learners and recognized as challenging, particularly in an EFL context (Anh 2019).
Additionally, much research indicates that writing is complex, and students often
struggle to learn and write effectively. For instance, cognitive process models,
specifically, highlight the writer's role in managing cognitive challenges throughout
the writing process, including stages such as planning, translating, and reviewing
(Olive Alves and Castro 2009). Subsequently, the writing process involves pre-
writing for idea organization, drafting focused on the flow of ideas, editing for
coherence and lexical choice, and ultimately, publishing the completed text.
268
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
269
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
Besides the previously mentioned difficulties, EFL learners also grapple with
the correct application of punctuation, capitalization, and spelling when writing in
English. In this regard, studies suggest that first language (L1) interference is a
significant cause (Olimat and Al-jamal 2022). Furthermore, research indicates EFL
students' lack of necessary linguistic knowledge and skills, including the use of
commas, periods, capital letters, semicolons, and adherence to spelling conventions
(Bani Younes and Albalawi 2015; Hussain 2019; Abdulrahman 2022).
Additionally, these studies reveal that insufficient instruction significantly
contributes to these issues. Indeed, the deficiency in linguistic knowledge and skills
in the areas of punctuation, capitalization, and spelling intensifies these issues. EFL
learners may find it challenging to determine when to use a comma to denote a
pause or separate items in a list, when a period is required to end a sentence, or
when a capital letter must be used at the beginning of a sentence or for proper nouns.
Additionally, the complexities of English spelling present further difficulties,
leading to frequent errors that detract from the professionalism and overall quality
of their writing.
Vocabulary mastery is a crucial difficulty, often emphasized by researchers.
It involves both understanding and using words, a key facet of language acquisition
(Williams 2003). Despite recognition of its importance, EFL/ESL students
frequently struggle to apply the right lexical items in writing (Karima, Hellalet, and
Breeze 2022; Nhung 2023). Studies show these learners often memorize words in
isolation, hampering effective communication. Furthermore, research by Bani
Younes and Albalawi (2015), Alharthi (2018), and Khatter (2019) identifies the
lack of suitable vocabulary learning strategies as a major obstacle affecting the
range and utility of students' vocabulary. However, learners are encouraged to
enhance their lexical knowledge and learn how to use the appropriate lexical items
in context. By doing so, they not only reinforce their vocabulary reservoir but also
develop a better understanding of when and how to employ these lexical items
effectively.
Writing coherently represents another challenging aspect of EFL/ESL
writing. In this regard, many researchers and linguists, including Halliday and
Hasan (1976) and Hoey (1991), have revealed the pivotal role that grammatical and
lexical cohesion play in organizing written text and ensuring its unity. Nevertheless,
a range of recent studies have revealed that many EFL learners consistently struggle
to produce coherent and connected written texts (Naser and Almoisheer 2018;
Alsariera and Yunus 2021, 2023). Nevertheless, the learners' inability to write
coherently and effectively organize texts is attributed to their limited knowledge of
various grammatical and lexical items. More importantly, the roots of these
difficulties are complex, stemming from inadequate educational practices, a lack of
awareness among EFL/ESL instructors regarding the importance of grammatical
and lexical devices in academic writing, and the learners' own unawareness of these
critical elements.
Beyond structural and lexical issues, research indicates that the learning
methods and strategies in writing profoundly affect EFL students' success in
handling writing challenges (Bakry and Alsamadani 2015). Such strategies guide
270
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
writers in text creation (Witte and Faigley 1981). Studies have also explored writing
operations like pre-writing, drafting, and reviewing before publishing the final text.
Specifically, writing involves prewriting, drafting, editing, and publishing stages
(Hyland and Hyland 2006). Annab (2016) found that writing includes various sub-
processes such as planning, translating, and reviewing. Accordingly, the impact of
learning processes and the strategies utilized by students plays a vital role in
improving EFL writing skills. Therefore, EFL instructors need to provide strategies
that are practical, and grounded in theory to address the various stages and detailed
sub-processes involved in writing.
Finally, writing engages complex cognitive processes involving the
communication of intentions, the synthesis and structuring of ideas, the discovery
of solutions, and the deployment of critical thinking (Fareed, Ashraf, and Bilal
2016; Ginting 2018). Moreover, writing is a purpose-driven exercise where the
writer employs a systematic method to extract and refine their thoughts into a
coherent and articulate presentation aimed at the reader. In this regard, Cumming
(1989) argues that writing extends well beyond the mere conversion of language
into written symbols; it also involves the mental processes of idea generation,
textual composition, and the conversion of these ideas into tangible text.
Consequently, it is essential for writers to master a diverse range of skills as they
engage in the written composition.
In conclusion, EFL learners encounter critical obstacles in writing accurately
and meaningfully, mainly due to limited grammar and vocabulary proficiency.
Clearly, without solid grammatical knowledge and lexical variety, EFL students
often struggle to articulate their thoughts, leading to ineffective writing. Hence, it
is apparent that they need effective support to enhance their writing skills. This
study aims to carefully outline the range of challenges Jordanian students face,
uncover the root causes of these issues, and offer potential strategies for
improvement.
3. Methodology
A mixed method framework was followed to attain the objectives of the research.
Accordingly, this design was implemented to achieve a holistic understanding of
the current issue through complementary qualitative and quantitative data.
3.1 Sample
The target population of the study was the English language and literature students
at three public universities in Jordan due to their strategic locations across different
regions of Jordan, and their significant role in delivering quality programs and
standing as influential pillars in the academic community. More importantly, one
of the selected universities has notably secured a high international rank,
showcasing excellence in delivering higher education and training, further creating
the credibility and validity of the research findings.
Regarding the participants of the current study, they were all selected using
the purposive sampling approach due to its appropriateness for the study objectives.
The sample included fourth-year undergraduates from English Language programs
271
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
at three universities. Additionally, they had completed at least one writing course.
They were also enrolled in an advanced writing course. Finally, they were all EFL
Jordanian students, sharing common cultural backgrounds. Accordingly, 150
students were recruited to participate in the study. On the other side, 8 writing
instructors from the same universities were chosen to participate in the interview.
These instructors were specifically selected based on their extensive experience in
teaching EFL writing, ranging from 5 to 10 years within higher education
institutions. Significantly, this selection criterion was vital to guarantee obtaining
of a profound and informed set of qualitative data.
272
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
273
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
area. Similarly, punctuation was deemed the least challenging, with only 21.7% of
students finding it difficult, suggesting a relative comfort with applying punctuation
rules. Figure 1 presents the types of writing difficulties among the students.
274
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
Regarding the students' lexical knowledge, the findings revealed that only
26.9% of EFL students were able to utilize complex types of lexical items, such as
antonyms and hyponyms, in their writing. Conversely, 73.1 percent of the
respondents tended to apply lexical repetition in their writing. In this regard, it is
worth mentioning that many studies have revealed that EFL Arab learners commit
lexical errors in their writing (Akki and Larouz 2021; Mukhlif and Challob 2021;
Abu Rumman and Rabab’ah 2023). The obtained results thus highlighted that EFL
learners often resort to using simple lexical items, avoiding more complex options
due to their limited knowledge in this area. As for difficulties in coherence and
organization, 68.13% of the respondents disclosed to facing such challenges in their
writing. Table 2 reveals the main issues students encounter in creating organized
paragraphs. The results display significant deficits in areas such as coherence and
unity (72.9%), paragraph organization (68.13%), forming authentic topic sentences
(60.4%), providing relevant supporting sentences (81.9%), concluding sentences
(67.82%), and utilizing appropriate cohesive devices (59%). Evidently, these
findings suggest that maintaining coherence and organization in writing is a
significant difficulty for many students (Elkhayma 2020; Alsariera and Yunus
2023). More importantly, these insights not only validate the presence of lexical
challenges highlighted in previous research but also specify the nature of these
challenges, emphasizing the learners' reliance on simpler lexical items and their
avoidance of more complex ones.
Additionally, the results showed that 63.2 percent of the participants acknowledged
their inability to paraphrase complex sentences effectively. Moreover, 52.9 percent
of the respondents were reported to be incompetent in summarizing complex
sentences efficiently. In the same vein, these findings align with those of several
recent studies conducted by Naser and Almoisheer (2018), and Mustafa, Arbab and
El Sayed, (2022). Thus, it can be inferred that the students face difficulties in
producing coherent texts, primarily due to insufficient command over cohesive
devices and inadequate exposure to authentic texts. These devices, crucial for
linking sentences and structuring ideas, are often ignored, resulting in disjointed
writing. Moreover, the lack of interaction with authentic texts denies students the
275
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
model examples they need to adopt the flow of the language. Indeed, these
deficiencies are evident in writings that lack clear and logical progression, pointing
to an urgent requirement for educational measures that concentrate on these
essential elements of language learning.
276
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
277
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
2. Insufficient feedback
The issue of inadequate and inefficient feedback in EFL writing classes, affecting
58.4% of students, represents a critical challenge in the educational process, with
profound implications on students' language skill development. In fact, when
feedback is limited or lacks depth, it can severely affect EFL learners' motivation,
engagement, and overall progress. Additionally, students may find themselves
unable to elevate their writing proficiency (Hawari, Al-Shboul, and Huwari 2022).
Moreover, the lack of feedback directly obstructs learners' ability to identify and
rectify grammatical, syntactical, and stylistic errors in their writing (Al-Sawalha
2016). In the absence of instructor-led correction and direction, these errors risk
becoming impressed in students' writing habits, creating a negative set of repeated
mistakes and missed learning opportunities (Yu, Jiang and Zhou 2020).
Accordingly, the insufficiency of insightful and transformative feedback within
EFL writing classes has negative consequences. It can demotivate students in their
pursuit of writing excellence. Thus, addressing this issue is paramount, as it stands
as a difficulty to students' gaining of adequate writing skills and their overall
academic and linguistic advancement.
278
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
students. Notably, these results are consistent with the results of previous studies
such as Rababah (2020), and Jaradat and Ajlouni (2021).
Certainly, the limited access to up-to-date blended learning materials,
competitive learning platforms, writing software, and other indispensable tools is a
critical component for cultivating comprehensive writing skills, as highlighted by
Rababah (2020). This lack of resources not only reduces students' motivation and
engagement but also impacts educational outcomes negatively. For instance,
instructors with limited technological access find it challenging to integrate
multimedia resources and interactive teaching methods. Meanwhile, students may
struggle to find relevant materials for practice, impeding their progression in
language proficiency. Additionally, the lack of resources can limit the development
of critical thinking skills and lead to inadequate evaluation mechanisms, preventing
students from receiving the necessary constructive feedback. Hence, these factors
collectively constrain EFL writing students' abilities to fully realize their potential
in written English, necessitating a systematic approach to overcome these
challenges in EFL writing classes.
4. Lack of encouragement
The lack of encouragement was identified as another significant barrier, with
47.22of respondents feeling overlooked by their instructors in class. Specifically,
this situation poses a considerable challenge for both students and teachers; learners
frequently hesitate to engage in writing activities, stemming from a lack of
confidence, or understanding (Hawari, Al-Shboul and Huwari 2022). However, this
problem arises due to certain factors. Primarily, the lack of peer support can leave
students feeling isolated, disheartened, and anxious when writing in English.
Additionally, the supportive role of writing instructors is critical. Yet, without
adequate guidance, EFL students might find themselves struggling to meet the
academic writing standards, impeding their chances of success in higher education
and professional settings. Moreover, the lack of encouragement and support not
only hinders their ability to improve their writing skills but also negatively impacts
their overall academic achievements.
5. Lack of self-motivation
Finally, lack of self-motivation (38.53%) could be the least hindrance to EFL
writing proficiency. However, unmotivated EFL students may not put forth genuine
effort in their writing, lacking the perseverance needed to overcome writing
difficulties (Gatcho and Ramos 2020). Writing efficiently is a skill, and like all
other skills, it requires effort and perseverance, such as devoting enough time to
learning and reading (Gatcho and Ramos 2020; Alharbi 2022). Notably, writing,
characterized as a skill that necessitates continual effort and dedication, is not
something that can be mastered through random or half-hearted attempts. Rather, it
requires a sustained commitment, which is operated by motivation. Thus, this
suggests that the key to writing mastery lies not only in the act of writing itself but
also in the motivational forces that drive consistent and hardworking practice.
279
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
280
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
familiar with using newly acquired lexical items in different contexts efficiently.
Thirdly, instructors should provide practical guidance by showing students how to
select the right vocabulary and utilize the appropriate cohesive devices, such as
transitional words and phrases, effectively to maintain a coherent and consistent
flow in their writing.
In conclusion, to elevate students' linguistic knowledge, a focused strategy
on grammar and vocabulary is vital. A well-organized curriculum with dynamic
activities boosts grammar, while digital tools further enhance learning. Vocabulary
development, essential for language mastery, is cultivated through various activities
and contextual learning. These strategies effectively bridge linguistic gaps in EFL
students.
281
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
5. Limitations
Notably, the data predominantly relies on self-reporting, which may not accurately
reflect actual linguistic behavior. Additionally, the findings cannot be generalized
to other populations unless a similar approach is used.
6. Conclusion
The study shed light on the difficulties students face, including fundamental issues
such as grammar, vocabulary, coherence, punctuation, and the ability to express
themselves clearly and cohesively in writing. Significantly, these challenges are
influenced by various factors, including students' limited linguistic proficiency,
insufficient motivation, and inadequate teaching practices.
In addressing these challenges, a comprehensive approach is paramount.
Writing instructors need to recognize the necessity of improving their students'
writing skills. Encouraging extensive reading and writing, providing constructive
guidance on various types of written assignments, and exposing students to well-
crafted written samples are vital steps. Furthermore, instructors should retain the
power of Artificial Intelligence (AI) like Grammarly and ETS Criterion to address
282
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
283
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
References
284
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
285
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
286
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
Derbas, Mohammad N. (2021). The study of the English article system errors
made by high school students in the United Arab Emirates MA thesis, the .
. British University in Dubai, UAE
Elkhayma, Rachid. (2020). ‘Moroccan students’ writing difficulties: Problems of
cohesion and coherence Kenitra as a case study’. International Journal for
Innovation Education and Research, 8(1): 0-17.
https://doi.org/10.31686/ijier.Vol8.Iss01.1537
Fareed, Muhammad, Almas Ashraf and Muhammad Bilal. (2016). ‘ESL
learners’ writing skills: Problems, factors and suggestions’. Journal of
Education and Social Sciences, 4(2): 83–94.
https://doi.org/10.20547/jess0421604201
Ginting, Siti A. (2018). ‘Lexical complexity on descriptive writing of Indonesian
male and female EFL learners’. International Journal of English Linguistics,
8(3): 297-302. https://doi.org/10.5539/ijel.v8n3p297
Godwin-Jones, Robert. (2018). ‘Second language writing online: An update’.
Language Learning and Technology, 22(1): 1–15.
https://dx.doi.org/10125/44574
Halliday, Michael. A. K. (1985). An Introduction to Functional Grammar. New
York: Hodder Arnold.
Hawari, Omar M., Yasser Al-Shboul, and Ibrahim F.Huwari. (2022).
‘Supervisors’ perspectives on graduate students’ problems in academic
writing’. European Journal of Educational Research, 11(1): 545–556.
https://doi.org/10.12973/EU-JER.11.1.545
Huneety, Anas, Bassil Mashaqba, Sabri Al-Shboul, and Abdallah T.
Alshdaifat. (2017). ‘A contrastive study of cohesion in Arabic and English
religious discourse’. International Journal of Applied Linguistics and English
Literature, 6(3): 116–122. https://doi.org/10.7575/aiac.ijalel.v.6n.3p.116.
Hussain, Roaa. A. M. (2019). ‘An analysis of undergraduate Saudi EFL female
students’ errors in written English essays’. Arab World English Journal, 1:
241–258. https://doi.org/10.24093/awej/efl1.17
Hyland, Ken and Fiona Hyland. (2006). ‘State of the art article: Feedback on
second language students’ writing’. Language Teaching, 39: 81–101.
Karima, Tayaa, Souhila Hellalet and Pr Ruth Breeze. (2022). The use of
language learning strategies to develop learners’ vocabulary knowledge and
writing proficiency: The case of third year students of English in written
expression. Ph.D. thesis, Batna University, Algeria.
Kerman, Nafiseh T, Seyyed K. Banihashem, Omid Noroozi and Harm J. A.
Biemans. (2022). ‘The effects of students perceived usefulness and
trustworthiness of peer feedback on learning satisfaction in online learning
environments.’ HEAd 2022-8th International Conference on Higher
Education Advances, 2022: 263-271.
Mukhlif, Majida and Alla I. Challob, (2021). ‘Enhancing vocabulary knowledge
among secondary school EFL students by using Facebook’. Turkish Online
Journal of Distance Learning, 22(3):293-309. 10.17718/tojde.961852
287
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
288
International Journal of Arabic-English Studies (IJAES) Vol. 22, No.2, 2024
289
Alsariera and Alsaraireh Advancing EFL Writing Proficiency …
Yu, Shulin, Lianiang Jiang and Nana Zhou. (2020). ‘Investigating what feedback
practices contribute to students’ writing motivation and engagement in
Chinese EFL context: A large scale study’. Assessing Writing, (44-): 100451.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.asw.2020.100451
Zhao, Xin. (2022). ‘Leveraging artificial intelligence (AI) technology for English
writing: Introducing Wordtune as a digital writing assistant for EFL
writers’. RELC Journal, 54(3): 890-894.
https://doi.org/10.1177/00336882221094089
290