Adomenas1993 (Epoxy Coatings)
Adomenas1993 (Epoxy Coatings)
Adomenas1993 (Epoxy Coatings)
AGENTS
A. Adomenas, K. Curran and M. Falconer-Flint
11.1 INTRODUCTION
In the plastics industry epoxy resins are classified as thermosetting resins, and they are used
in the paint industry as convertible coatings. Epoxy resins are converted to a thermoset state
by chemical reaction between the resin and a curing agent. Depending on the curing agent
this reaction can take place at elevated temperatures or at room temperature. The cured
resins are not soluble in solvents and cannot be melted by heating. This property is in direct
contrast to thermoplastic products such as polyvinyl chloride (PVC) or polystyrene, or
non-convertible coatings such as chlorinated rubber, acrylic or nitrocellulose lacquers, which
remain soluble in solvents and can be remelted by heating.
Epoxy resins became commercially available in Australia in the early 1950s, and since that
time have become firmly established in many industries. Most commonly used types are
based on epichlorhydrin and diphenylol propane (Bisphenol A) and are available in a range
of molecular weights. The low molecular weight resins are liquid; the high molecular weight
resins are solid.
What are the main properties of the epoxy resin-based systems that influence the choice
of epoxy resins from a wide range of plastics and resins available at present? The important
properties are listed below.
(a) The chemical structure of epoxy resins gives them high chemical resistance against a
wide range of severe corrosive conditions. These properties are derived from the
aromatic nature of the backbone and good chemical stability of the phenolic ether
linkage.
(b) Epoxy resins have good adhesion to a wide range of materials, including metals, wood,
concrete, glass, ceramic and many plastics. This is due to the presence of polar hydroxyl
and ether groups in the resin.
(c) Low shrinkage during curing results in good dimensional accuracy in construction of
structural items and enables manufacture of high-strength adhesives with a glue line of
low residual stress.
(d) Complicated shapes can be reproduced easily using liquid epoxy resins systems, which
can be cured at room temperatures.
(e) Good physical properties such as toughness, flexibility and abrasion resistance can be
obtained.
(f) Although there are temperature limitations, epoxy resins generally perform better than
most thermoplastics at elevated temperatures.
One of the main users of epoxy resins is the paint industry, which produces special types
of surface coatings (discussed in further detail later). The electrical industry was one of the
179
P. Parsons et al. (eds.), Surface Coatings
© Chapman & Hall 1993
180 SURFACE COATINGS
first industries in which epoxy resins became established during the early stages of
commercial production. Epoxy resins are convenient to use in solvent-free liquid form,
which sets into a hard infusible solid after the addition of curing agent. They are used
extensively-for example, for potting, embedding or encapsulation of electrical components,
for cable joining to make waterproof joints, and for manufacture of Telecom terminal
pillars.
Another industry to recognize the value of liquid epoxy resins was the engineering
industry. Low shrinkage and good dimensional stability in service are important properties
utilized for manufacture of foundry patterns, vacuum-forming moulds, press tools for
prototype or short runs, drilling jigs, and checking fixtures. Adhesives are used in many
applications in place of soldering, bolts or rivets, particularly in small-parts assembly and in
aircraft construction. Fibreglass-reinforced plastics are manufactured from epoxy resins for
applications where chemical resistance and good physical strength properties are the main
requirements-for example, piping and storage vessels in the chemical industry. In the civil
engineering industry the use of epoxy resins has also become established as a standard
practice. Epoxy adhesives cure more rapidly than cement, and good adhesion to new and
old concrete enables more rapid construction and repair of concrete structures.
o CH3
OH CH3 OR
Cl-CH,-Ci'i -CH,-o--©--{--@-o-CH,-bI-CH,Cl + 2NaOH~ (bl
CHa
(c)
The basic reaction is formation under alkaline conditions of a chlorhydrin ether of DPP (b)
followed by dehydrochlorination of the chlorhydrin group by alkali to form an epoxy group,
thus giving the diglycidyl ether of DPP (c). An excess of ECH will favour a high proportion
of the simple diglycidyl ether of DPP; higher DPP ratios will give higher molecular weight
polymers. Commercial grades of resin can be represented by the following formula:
EPOXY RESINS AND CURING AGENTS 181
The pure diglycidyl ether of DPP with n = 0 is a crystalline solid. The commercial
low-viscosity liquid resins are rich in this compound, and the average n is approximately 0.2.
Viscosity can be further reduced by addition of monoepoxide compounds such as aliphatic
glycidyl ethers. In low melting point solid resins, average n is approximately 2. The common
commercial high molecular weight resins have average n up to 13. There are also very high
molecular weight resins with molecular weights up to 200 000; these resins have mainly
hydroxy groups and practically no epoxy groups and are used as thermoplastic resins for
non-convertible coatings.
The commercial epoxy resins are characterized by specifying their main properties, as in
sections 11.2.1 to 11.2.3.
11.2.1 Epoxide group content (EGC), epoxy equivalent weight (EEW) or epoxy molar
mass (EMM)
EGC is express~d as millimoles of epoxide groups per 1 kilogram of resin (m mol/kg). It
can also be expressed as epoxy molar mass (EMM), in which case the unit is grams per mole
of epoxide (g/mol). Conversion to EGC from EMM can be done by the following formula:
1000 x 1000
EGC(m moVkg) = EMM(glmol)
EMM is numerically identical to EEW (epoxy equivalent weight).
11.2.2 Hydroxyl content
This is expressed as millimoles of hydroxyl groups per 1 kilogram of resin (m mol/kg). For
esterification purposes, one epoxy group is equal to two hydroxyl groups, and this must be
taken into account when calculating esterification equivalents.
11.2.3 Viscosity
The commonly used metric viscosity unit is the pascal second (Pa.s), which has replaced the
poise unit (1 poise = 0.1 Pa.s). Viscosity is normally measured at 25 C on liquid low-viscosity
0
resins without dilution. A 70 percent solution is used for high-viscosity liquid resins, and a
40 percent solution is commonly used for solid resins in solvents such as glycol ethers.
Properties of a typical range of epoxy resins are shown in table 11.1.
Selection of the resin grade depends on the application. Low molecular weight resins are
rich in epoxy groups and are used for applications where the crosslinking reaction is through
epoxy groups. These are usually two-component systems which cure at room temperature.
In high molecular weight resins, hydroxyl groups are predominant, and reactions involving
both hydroxyl and epoxy groups are selected for further polymerization and crosslinking.
These systems require elevated temperatures for crosslinking.
TABLE 11.1
Properties of a typical range of epoxy resins
Approx.
EEW Approx. Typical
Approx. or EMM EGC viscosity Solids*
Resin grade n g/mol m mOl/kg range Pa.s % mass
1. Low-viscosity liquid resins 0.2 200 5000 0.6-1.8 100
modified with monoepoxide
diluents
2. Low-viscosity basic resins 0.2 200 5000 8.0-16.0 100
3. High-viscosity resins 0.5 250 4000 0.4-1.0 70
4. Solid resins:
Durrans melting point approx. 70 C
0
2 500 2000 0.1-0.2 40
Durrans melting point approx. 100 C0
4 900 1100 0.5-1.0 40
Durrans melting point approx. 130 C0
9 1700 600 2.0-3.5 40
Durrans melting point approx. 150 C0
13 2700 370 4.0-12.0 40
* in diethylene glycol mono butyl ether
OH OR
I I
-CH-CHs ", /,CHI-CH-
I
CH -CH- '" II I
OH OH
polymer. Consequently the useful curing agents are polyamines, such as:
Functionality Molar mass
Ethylene diamine (EDA) 4 60
Diethylene triamine (DET) 5 103
Triethylene tetramine (TETA) 6 146
The reaction mechanism suggests that the curing agent should be used in stoichiometric
proportions. For example, with epoxy resin having an EMM of 190 the amount of DET
would be:
This is normally expressed as parts by mass of curing agent for 100 grams of resin (phr),
so for our example it would be 11 phr of DET. The use of incorrect proportions can lead
to water sensitivity, reduced chemical resistance and poor physical properties if an excessive
amount of amine is used. Even a small excess of amine will adversely affect the water
sensitivity, whilst low curing agent content will result in poor solvent resistance and poor
physical properties. When cured at ambient temperatures epoxy/polyamine coatings
develop maximum physical and chemical resistance in about seven days.
Disadvantages of aliphatic polyamine curing agents are their high volatility, toxicity,
tendency to blush, and inconvenient low mix ratios.
adducts formed by reaction with solid epoxy resins are used in conventional solvent-based
industrial coatings. For higher solids or solventless coatings, lower molecular weight liquid
epoxy resins are used.
11.3.2.2 Polyamides
Polyamides used in marine and maintenance coatings are amine terminated condensation
products of polyamines and dimer fatty acids. A typical polyamide structure would be:
By varying the dimer fatty acid and/or the polyamine functionality, the viscosity and
concentration of active amine on the polyamide may be tailored for specific application.
Polyamide manufacturers offer a wide range of products.
Disadvantages of polyamides include dark colour, high viscosity and reduced chemical
resistance relative to aliphatic polyamines and poor high-temperature properties.
Advantages of polyamide curing agents are non-critical mix ratios, low exotherm, low
toxicity and volatility, and excellent water resistance when cured. Polyamides are widely used
in zinc-rich primers, as their reactivity with zinc is negligible. Epoxy/polyamides are also
used as 'splash zone' coatings for ships, oil-drilling rigs, and other structures subjected to
wet/dry cycling and abrasion.
11.3.2.3 Amidoamines
The use of amidoamines is newer technology; they are the condensation products of
monobasic fatty acids and a polyamine. The structure of a typical amidoamine is given below.
When compared to aliphatic polyamines, amidoamines offer more convenient (higher) mix
ratios and improved flexibility and moisture resistance. They are lighter in colour than
polyamides. The properties of amidoamines are dependent upon the level of imidazoline
present. Their reactivity varies with composition but is generally slower than polyamines and
faster than polyamides.
11.3.2.4 Cycloaliphatic amines
When compared to aliphatic amines, cycloaliphatic amines display improved thermal
properties and toughness. However, they are less reactive and may require the use of an
accelerator or heat treatment to achieve reasonable cure times. Cycloaliphatic amines may
EPOXY RESINS AND CURING AGENTS 185
be adducted with epoxy resins. Structures for two popular cycloaliphatic amine curing agents
are given below:
This class of epoxy curing agent offers low temperature cure, freedom from blushing, and
good chemical and moisture resistance.
11.3.2.6 Aromatic amines
Aromatic amines are characterized by excellent thermal and chemical properties, which may
be attributed to the presence of the aromatic ring. When used with epoxy resins, heat is
normally required for complete cure. However, suitably accelerated solutions of aromatic
amines in non-volatile solvents are capable of curing epoxy systems at ambient temperatures.
Aromatic amines are often solid in form, making them less convenient to formulate when
compared to liquid aliphatic amines. The structure for methylene dianiline, a commonly
used aromatic amine, is given below:
11.3.3.2 Solvents
Solvents serve to solubilize the epoxy resin and curing agent during formulation and
application. Properly selected solvents enhance the flow and levelling, rheology, potlife,
tack-free time and recoatability. Conversely, poor solvent balance can result in film defects
such as pin holes and orange peel appearance.
Most ketones, esters, ethers and particularly glycol ethers are 'true' solvents for epoxy
resins and solvate them over a broad range of concentration. True solvents are those that
are volatile under normal drying conditions and in which the binder is completely soluble.
Aromatic solvents, alcohols, and other latent solvents may be used with ketones and glycol
ethers in amounts up to 50 percent of the total volatiles.
Toluene and xylene are widely used as diluents in marine and maintenance coatings.
Aliphatic hydrocarbons are poor solvents for epoxy resins and are not normally used in
epoxy coatings. .
Solvent selection is based upon the desired viscosity, curing agent type, and planned
method of application.
11.3.3.3 Additives
Flow-control agents, such as urea formaldehyde and silicone resins can be used to control
'crawling' and 'cratering' of two-pack marine and maintenance coatings.
Anti-foaming agents and defoamers are used to reduce air entrapment and increase
pigment-grinding efficiency.
11.3.4 Formulations
The following are typical two-pack marine and maintenance coating formulations.
11.3.4.1 General-purpose white gloss epoxy enamel
A general-purpose epoxy-polyamide gloss enamel with excellent water resistance, this
formulation is suitable for brush and roller application and may be thinned for spray
application.
EPOXY RESINS AND CURING AGENTS 187
Parts by weight
Part A
Dow Epoxy Resin D.E.R. 671 x 74 1 30
Methyl isobutyl ketone (MIBK) 9
Xylene 14.5
Part B
Versamid 115 x 70 2 12.5
Titanium dioxide, Ti-Pure R-960 3 20
Calcium carbonate 11.5
Chrome green oxide 2.5
Bentone 34 4 0.001
Cab-O-Sil TS 720 5 0.001
BYK P 1045 0.6
Total 100.00
Properties
Weight/litre: 1.26 kg/litre
% non-volatile (weight): 65.34%
% non-volatile (volume): 51.94%
1 Dow Chemical Company
2Henkel Corporation
3E.I. DuPont
4NL Industries
5Cabot Corporation
(a) oxidation at the film surface; and (b) polymerization throughout the depth of the film.
A metallic drier that will promote the oxidation mechanism is required. The driers most
used are cobalt naphthenate or octoate, and a manganese salt. The driers are used at
0.005-0.1 percent metal based on resin solids.
Ambient-temperature-cured films will reach maximum properties in approximately seven
days. Alternatively can be cured at 120· -150· C for 20-30 minutes.
The performance of epoxy resin esters may be improved by cross linking with a melamine
or a urea formaldehyde resin. Typical ratio is about 70:30 epoxy ester to amino resin. Cure
schedule for these systems is about 30 minutes at 150· C.
11.4.6 Formulations
The following formulations are for three epoxy esters of different oil length. There is a
comparison of physical properties of films cured at ambient temperature for three days and
those baked for 20 minutes at 150· C.
Esters of Dow Epoxy Resin D.E.R. 664 and DCO fatty acids
Formulation (% by weight) Short oil Medium oil Long oil
D.E.R. 664 resin 60 50 45
DCO fatty acids 40 50 55
Solution properties
Acid number (solids) 2.2 8.0 14.7
Solvent Xylene Xylene/MS, 1: 1 Mineral spirits
Non-volatiles % (wt) 50 50 50
Viscosity, Gardner-Holdt W V W
Colour, Gardner 5 5 5
Cooking time at 260· C 3.5 h 4h 4 h (250· C)
Film properties l
Dry to touch 15 min 18 min 23 min
Dry foil free 2 h 2.5 h 4h
Sward hardness (24 hours) 27 19 15
(7 days) 43 30 25
Air dry (3 days)
Knoop hardness 8.7 7.1 6.5
Flexibility, I/S" mandrel Passes Passes Passes
Adhesion Excellent Excellent Excellent
Reverse impact ~nch/pounds) >30 >30 >30
Water resistance vsh-cr sh-cr h-pr
Caustic resistance 3 Excellent Good Good
Solvent resistance 4 Excellent Excellent Excellent
Baked (20 min at 150· C)
Knoop hardness 13.1 12.1 10.1
Water resistance 2 Clear Clear Clear
Caustic resistance 3 Excellent Excellent Good
IDrier 0.04% cobalt, 25-38 J.lm films.
25 days water immersion at 25° C.
vsh-cr = very slight haze, complete recovery, 30 minutes.
Sh-cr = slight haze, complete recovery, 30 minutes
h-pr = haze, partial recovery, 30 minutes
3Immersion in NaOH at room temperature, two weeks.
4} hour immersion in mineral spirits.
190 SURFACE COATINGS
II.5.1 Crosslinkers
Crosslinkers that react with the secondary hydroxyl groups under heat are used for can and
coil coatings. The classes of curing agents mainly used are:
(a) phenol formaldehyde resins;
(b) melamine formaldehyde resins;
(c) urea formaldehyde resins and
(d) polyisocyanates (exterior coatings).
Coatings based on phenol formaldehyde crosslinked epoxy resins are characterized by
excellent chemical resistance, moisture and salt spray resistance, abrasion resistance, and
superior elevated temperature performance. This type of coating is used in three-piece food
cans where sterilization involves harsh conditions with temperatures up to 150· C. Other
applications include linings for drums, pails and lids, and appliance primers.
Epoxy resins thermally cured with amino formaldehyde (urea or melamine) resins are
characterized by clarity, absence of colour and taste, good flexibility, and solvent resistance.
Physical properties can be optimized by proper selection of type and amount of amino
formaldehyde crosslinker.
Melamine formaldehyde resins are used when maximum resistance to solvent, water,
detergent, or stain is required. They are used at a 5-35 percent level, based on resin solids.
Melamine formaldehyde resins are widely used in linings for beer and beverage cans,
closures and in appliance primers.
Urea formaldehyde resins are used to reduce costs and lower cure temperatures. These
crosslinkers impart excellent flexibility and adhesion to epoxy resin coatings.
11.5.2 Solvents
In can and container coatings, solvents are used to solubilize the epoxy resin and crosslinker
during formulation, application and storage. Solvents are necessary to impart good
application properties, flow, and final film appearance.
A blend of solvents is usually required. Ketones, esters, and glycol ethers are true solvents
for epoxy resins. Latent solvents such as alcohols and aromatic solvents, toluene and xylene,
are used to dilute the resin varnish and slow down the rate of evaporation of the drying
film. Solvent selection is based on the type and amount of epoxy and crosslinker used, the
application method and cure cycle. The higher the molecular weight of the epoxy resin, the
greater the proportion of ketone or glycol ether 'true solvents' required in the solvent blend.
11.5.3 Catalysts
Acid catalysts improve the reaction between epoxy reSInS and phenolic crosslinkers.
EPOXY RESINS AND CURING AGENTS 191
Common catalysts are phosphoric acid, alkyl phosphoric acid and para-toluene sulfonic acid.
In coatings for food and beverage contact, phosphoric acid is usually used.
Epoxy-aminoplast systems usually do not require a catalyst. The reactivity of aminoplast
resins can vary, and the use of catalyst can decrease cure temperature or the length of the
cure cycle.
11.5.4 Additives
Other additives used in epoxy resin-phenolic or epoxy resin-aminoplast can or coil coatings
are:
(a) flow additives;
(b) pigments;
(c) pigment wetting and dispersing agents;
(d) slip agents; and
(e) anti-settling agents.
11.5.5 General-purpose epoxy-phenolic clear coating for metal containers
The formulation shown below, a 70:30 ratio of Dow Epoxy Resin D.E.R. 667 to phenol
formaldehyde crosslinker, is suitable as a starting point for coating steel drums that contain
aqueous materials, concentrated bases, and other chemicals. It can also be used in interior
food can coatings, and is especially useful for protecting the can from oily foods.
Pigments can be incorporated by making a concentrated pigment grind using the pigment
and some of the formulation solvents and resin, and adding it to the remainder of the
formulation components. If roller coating is the application method, the formulation can be
increased in solids content to 35 percent or slightly higher. For spray applications, it may
be desirable to reduce the solids content, using a blend of glycol ether, n-butanol, and
xylene.
Formulation (parts by weight)
D.E.R. * 667 resin 210.0
Methylon t 75108 100.0
Dowanol* EB 183.0
Dowanol* DPM 9l.50
n-Butanol 137.25
Xylene 274.50
Silicone Resin SR-882* 0.75
Phosphoric acid, 85% 3.00
Total 1000.00
'Trademark of the Dow Chemical Company
tTrademark of BTL Speciality Resins Corporation
tTrademark of General Electric Company
The powders can be applied to articles by dipping the preheated object into a bath of the
powder which is fluidized (by blowing air through a specially designed porous bottom of the
bath) or by spraying the powder by flock gun. The most convenient method for application
of powders is electrostatic spraying onto cold or preheated objects. Epoxy powder coatings
have two main advantages compared with solvent-based systems:
(a) absence of solvents reducing health and safety hazards; and
(b) for special heavy duty applications, a high film thickness attainable in one application
without danger of solvent retention or film porosity.
Epoxy powder coatings are utilized where severe corrosion and/or abrasive conditions are
encountered. They have become established in interior decorative applications on articles
of complicated shapes, such as tubular steel furniture and expanded metal articles. Their
use in exterior applications such as agricultural equipment and heavy transport vehicles is
extensive. A major use is in the coating of pipelines for the transmission of natural gas and
water.