Ijgo 154 220
Ijgo 154 220
Ijgo 154 220
DOI: 10.1002/ijgo.13771
CLINICAL ARTICLE
Gynecology
1
Nottingham Trent University,
Nottingham, UK Abstract
Objective: To explore the challenges of women taking antiretroviral treatment (ART)
2
Department of Nursing and Public
Health, Kwazulu Natal University, Durban,
South Africa
during the COVID-19 pandemic lockdown in a peri-urban area.
3
Manchester Metropolitan University Methods: An exploratory qualitative study approach was used. Semi-structured ques-
Faculty of Health, Manchester, UK tions were devised and used to elicit data on the impact of the COVID-19 lockdown
Correspondence on women accessing treatment for HIV. Twenty women were interviewed through
Mathew Nyashanu, Nottingham Trent contacts from community and faith organizations in peri-urban Harare. All interviews
University, 50 Shakespeare Street,
Nottingham NG1 4FQ, UK. were audio-recorded, transcribed verbatim and entered into NVivo to make analysis
Email: mathew.nyashanu@ntu.ac.uk easy. The data were thematically analyzed, underpinned by the four phases of data
analysis in the Silences Framework.
Results: The study discovered that transport problems, confusing COVID-
19 re-
strictions, abuse by police and soldiers at roadblocks, a shortage of medication,
lack of health check-up routines, involuntary default of ART, and a shortage of per-
sonal protective equipment affected HIV-positive women accessing ART during the
COVID-19 lockdown.
Conclusion: People living with HIV need a robust supporting environment and a func-
tioning health system. In response to COVID-19 all services were halted to prevent
the spread of COVID-19. Pandemic preparedness is important in keeping an adequate
supply of ART and responding to the needs of individuals on HIV treatment.
KEYWORDS
antiretroviral treatment, COVID-19, HIV, pandemic, women
This is an open access article under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial License, which permits use, distribution and reproduction
in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited and is not used for commercial purposes.
© 2021 The Authors. International Journal of Gynecology & Obstetrics published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of International Federation of Gynecology
and Obstetrics
220 |
wileyonlinelibrary.com/journal/ijgo Int J Gynecol Obstet. 2021;154:220–226.
NYASHANU et al. | 221
After the organization of the data by NVivo, the analysis of the public transport was not allowed to move or take people from one
data started with the coding of the data into broad categories by the place to another.
two researchers using the four phases of data analysis in the Silences
Framework.17 During phase 2 of data analysis, the researchers took the I live 60 kilometers from the health facility I get my
categorized broad themes to the research participants for verification ARVs supply and right now I do not know how I am
and confirmation as a true reflection of what they had said during the going to go for my next appointment because of
interviews. The research participants at this point had the opportunity this pandemic… no transport is servicing our area. (a
to refute or confirm the constructed broad themes in line with their 46-year-old woman)
contribution at interview. At phase 3 of data analysis, the data from
phase 2 were taken to a collective voice group for validation and veri- Even though I live 20 km away from the clinic, I am not
fication. The collective voice group is a group of people who mirrored sure I am still fit to walk that long to get to the clinic…
the research participants but did not participate in the research study. especially with this chronic condition that I have had
For example, this group was made up of HIV-positive women receiving for the past 10 years. (a 50-year-old woman)
treatment and living in peri-urban Harare but who did not take part in
the research study. At this point, the user voice group validated and
verified the data coined in phase 2. This was meant to critique the data
using an associative eye. Finally, in phase 4 the researchers analyzed 3.2 | Confusing COVID-19 information
the data in line with the contributions made in each phase to form the
final output of the research study. Figure 1 shows the four phases of Research participants expressed that they all had a general idea of
the analysis described above. what COVID-19 was, although there was a lot of wrong information
The research participants were given an information sheet to that was going around with no-one to rectify it. They felt that there
read and ask question before participating in the research study. was no clear or strategic policy dealing with the dissemination of
information about the pandemic to the people.
All the research participants agreed that the travelling restrictions 3.3 | Abuse by police and soldiers at roadblocks
made them miss appointments and/or sometimes made it difficult
to travel to healthy facilities to collect their supply of ARVs because Encounters with the authorities, in most cases, in Zimbabwe is not a
pleasant experience, especially the police and soldiers at roadblocks.
With the introduction of these travelling restrictions, roadblocks
were established to help enforce these restrictions.
By the time that I made it to my local clinic where I I had visited my brother in Bocha when the lockdown
normally collect my ARVs, the nurse told me that I happened. I could not make my way back to Gweru
was late, and I could only get supply for 1 month and I until after 3 weeks… The local clinic could not give
am now wondering where I will get my next supply. (a me any supplies, so I had to default for 1 week until I
42-year-old woman) returned to my Gweru. (a 37-year-old woman)
about COVID-19, leaving them in fear. It is important that during empathetic way to maintain a therapeutic relationship with them
a pandemic the government establishes effective channels of and avoid despondence.
communication that are available to and understood by all the Default of medication, whether voluntary or involuntary, has a
population. 22 It is also important that information is managed and direct impact on the health and well-being of the patient.30 Most of
disseminated by qualified health practitioners. More importantly, the research participants reported an involuntary default of medica-
information needs to be simplified to make sure that it is free of tion due to their medication running out while being locked down in
technical jargon and easily understood by the lay members of the a different location far from their homes. The research participants
communities. 23,24 This is more important when dealing with peo- reported difficulties in getting supplies at health facilities where
ple accessing ART to ensure that their uptake of medication is not they were not registered, and this led to an involuntary default of
interrupted. their ART. With the advent of the COVID-19 pandemic, they were
Meanwhile, although it is important that a lockdown should be now at risk of interrupting their HIV treatment.31 There is a need for
enforced by law enforcement agents such as police and soldiers, it is the central government to make it easy for individuals accessing ART
essential that the enforcement does not infringe on the rights of cit- to access their medication from any health facility in the country
izens, especially those who are vulnerable and accessing medication rather than referring them to where they are registered. This will
for chronic conditions such as HIV.25 Most of the research participants circumvent the problem of defaulting on treatment and enhance
reported abuse by police and soldiers at roadblocks while on their way positive outcomes for individuals on HIV treatment.
to collect their ART. They also reported breaches of their right to confi- Personal protective equipment is one of the most important re-
dentiality when the police and soldiers demanded to see their hospital quirements when fighting an infectious pandemic such as COVID-19.32
cards. It is important that during pandemic periods police and soldiers The shortage of PPE posed a threat of COVID-19 infection to individ-
are educated about their role during the pandemic, clearly articulating uals receiving HIV care or on ART. Nearly all the research participants
their roles and boundaries to avoid misuses of power, which can impact in the present study reported a severe shortage of PPE. The research
negatively on vulnerable people accessing ART. There is the need for all participants reported difficulties in acquiring PPE for themselves as it
law enforcement agents to have a clear knowledge and understanding was expensive and sometimes out of stock. They reported improvis-
on the laws governing confidentiality and sharing of information to pro- ing PPE to protect themselves as they travelled to get their supply of
tect vulnerable individuals accessing ART from being abused.26 This is HIV medication. The shortage of PPE also affected the health work-
crucial in protecting the rights of patients while upholding their dignity ers in many healthcare settings, exposing them to possible infection
when accessing medication for chronic conditions. of COVID-19. The shortage of PPE undoubtedly created fear and
Shortage of medication in LMICs is one of the long-standing health anxiety among the participants. This was also compounded by the
problems affecting many countries in this economic group.27 This is fact that COVID-19 is untreatable.33 There is a need for the central
normally caused by weak health systems and infrastructure. Most of government to have a clear policy on the procurement of PPE. This
the research participants reported a shortage of ART during the lock- will ensure an adequate stock of PPE and access by vulnerable groups
down period owing to some patients being given treatment supplies such as people on ART. More importantly, a subsidy on the price of
for 3–6 months. There is a need for the government to have reserve PPE is needed to make it affordable, especially to women accessing
ART in case of any future pandemics. This will prevent individual pa- ART who are usually unemployed.34 This will ensure affordability of
tients from taking medication errands during the lockdown period and PPE in times of pandemics such as COVID-19.
possibly exposing themselves to infections. There is a need to measure
an affordable amount of medication that each patient can get before
exhausting the supply in reserve.28 For example, instead of giving a 4.1 | Implication for professionals working
supply of medication for up to 5 months, all patients can be given med- with PLWH
ication equivalent to 3 months to avoid a shortage. This would ensure
that every patient receives medication for the first 3 months and gives There is a need for professionals working with PLWHs to raise
health facilities time to prepare the supply for the next 3 months. awareness among government departments to enlighten other pro-
Regular check-ups for people taking HIV treatment are import- fessionals such as the police and soldiers to understand the impor-
ant to prevent co-morbidities and other complications. 29 The par- tance of treating HIV-positive individuals with dignity. Furthermore,
ticipants also reported that it was challenging to communicate with professionals working in sexual health and HIV need to carry out a
the nurse through a window just to drop off their medical cards and more robust situational analysis to improve pandemic preparedness
sit as far as possible waiting to collect their medication. There is a when delivering services.
need to maintain the regular care of individuals on HIV treatment.
Health professionals need to be provided with PPE to make sure
that they carry out regular checks for vulnerable patients such as 4.2 | Limitations of the study
those on HIV treatment. This would enable medication to be regu-
larly monitored and replenished. There is also a need for health facil- The present study was carried out in a peri-urban area in Harare.
ities to explain the changes in patient care to the patients in a more Research encompassing more regions may be necessary to
NYASHANU et al. | 225
in low-and middle-income countries? A systematic review. Health 33. Albzeirat MK, Al-Tarawneh MS, Khalid N, Zulkepli NN, Islam DMZ.
Policy Plan. 2015;30(9):1207-1227. COVID- 19 story: the unknown killer and future studies. Int J
28. Banteyerga H. Ethiopia’s health extension program: improv- Multidiscip Sci Adv Technol Special Issue Covid-19. 2020;1(1):1-18.
ing health through community involvement. MEDICC Rev. 34. Gilbert M, Dewatripont M, Muraille E, Platteau JP, Goldman M.
2011;13(3):46-49. Preparing for a responsible lockdown exit strategy. Nat Med.
29. Mauser-Bunschoten EP, Fransen Van De Putte DE, Schutgens REG. 2020;26(5):643-6 44.
Co-morbidity in the ageing haemophilia patient: the down side of
increased life expectancy. Haemophilia. 2009;15(4):853-863.
30. Zhang NJ, Terry A, McHorney CA. Impact of health literacy on
How to cite this article: Nyashanu M, Chireshe R, Mushawa F,
medication adherence: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Ann
Ekpenyong MS. Exploring the challenges of women taking
Pharmacother. 2014;48(6):741-751.
31. American Society of Health-System Pharmacists. Drug shortages antiretroviral treatment during the COVID-19 pandemic
roundtable: Minimizing the impact on patient care. Am J Health-Syst lockdown in peri-urban Harare, Zimbabwe. Int J Gynecol Obstet.
Pharm 2018;75(11):816-820. 2021;154:220–226. https://doi.org/10.1002/ijgo.13771
32. Pallister-Wilkins P. Personal protective equipment in the human-
itarian governance of Ebola: between individual patient care and
global biosecurity. Third World Q. 2016;37(3):507-523.