Professional Skills - Chapter 7 (Trust and Collaboration)
Professional Skills - Chapter 7 (Trust and Collaboration)
Professional Skills - Chapter 7 (Trust and Collaboration)
Introduction
Trust and credibility are the building blocks of interpersornal relations, team and transtormed
ure. Trust means having a feeling of confidence and positive expectations among others. In our
daily life, we make decisions based on trust that our expectations shall be met and we shall be
Tespected. These feelings of confidence and positive expectations have positive impact upon our
working. Stephen Covey puts forward the proposition that trust always affects two outcomes-speed
7.2 Trust and CollaboratBo
and cost. If trust in organization or relationship is low, the speed of getting things done
and the costs will be high. Conversely, when trust is high, the speed of getting things
wil be slow
fast and cost will be low and consequently organizations with high trust done wil be
outperform their cOunterparts
cultures
with low-trust cultures in various performance indicatorssignificanty
organizations have to build the environment of trust and individuals have to earn credibility. Therefore
MEANING OF TRUST
Trust in context of organization has been defined as the willingness of a party to be vulnerable h
the actions of another party. It is defined as
"decision to rely on another party under condition of risk" -Currall &Epstein
" "one party's level of confidence in and willingness to open oneself to the other party" -Hon & Grune
" Employees' willingness to be vulnerable to their organizations' actions based on the belief that their
organizations have integrity, and are dependable, and competent, etc.
Thus trust in general involves willingness to become vulnerable upon the actions of the other
persons (especially persons in power) who will fulfill their promise and shall behave with honesty,
reliability and integrity. Trust also involves expectations that trustee's actions shall be beneficial not
detrimental to one's interest and trustor shall maximize trustee's interest.
TYPES OF TRUST
Trust also implies risk of becoming vulnerable as physical and emotional well-beings may be
threatened. When the risks in relationship are low, trust may exist in the background whereas when
the risk is high, trust becomes the crucial factor of success. How much level of trust is involved in
relationship, it depends upon personal trustworthiness being shared between each of the persans
involved. The process of building trust in relationship begins with each individual first becoming
trustworthy-how he or she is perceived by others as worthy of their trust. Aperson cannot demand
trust, but has to earn and command trust for making relationships long lasting and sustainable.
In actual real life situation, there may be four types of trusts:.
(a) Spontaneous trust
(b) Contractual trust
(c) Value based trust
(d) Safety trust
Spontaneous trust occurs when the people involved choose to further a relationship
with each other based on their own intentions, as well as their initial Perceptionsofthe
other person''s motivation capabilities and character. know well
how to behave in opening moments so that first Successful salesmenCreatedinthe
mind of other person. impression is positively
Contractual trust is aformalized approach of creating trust in a wherethe
parties involved develop a purpose for the relations. Here relationship
togetherfora
specitic
parties
definite purpose and demonstrate confidence in each other for meet
common purpose. pursuns
Trust and Collaboratlon 7.3
In value-based trust the parties make commitments to each other based on ther
knowledge of each others' personal motivations, values and capabilities to fulhll
expectations.
In safety trust, the parties build the trust through actual behavior and actions. This type
of trust builds loyalty between parties in a
relationship.
CREDIBILITY
The other term related with trust is credibility that stenms from the same
trust or believe". Communication researchers Berlo points out the root, credo, meaning"1
credibility" as trustworthiness,expertise and dynamism. characteristics of "source
Bank manager is lending because he has faith in the repayment of the
or accepts the message because s/he perceives the communicator credible.
borrower. A person listens
Followers are willing to
cooperate with their leaders because they perceive them more credible. People are willing to lend
their time, talent and toil when they perceive the other person as credible:
honest, competent and
inspiring.
The differences between persons having and lacking credibility are reflected from the
comparison: following
Expertise: competency. Lack of adequate skills and knowledge regarding their work. To
compensate it, they project themselves as whales in the sea despite
being frogs in the well through conning and manipulating
Dynamism: Inspiring, uplifting, Talks demoralizing, depleting and depriving others of their meaning
elevating in work and consequently vital energy.
People judge credibility of others from their:
Intentions as reflected in their actions or hidden agenda
Integrity as reflected in their action in a particular situation especially in the situation of
stress. Is there any dissonance between their walk and talk?
Initiatives- whether they initiate action or just talk
When the persons lacking credibility want to get the things done through others, they indulge in
one or other following ways:
Form alliances based on temporary relations or bargaining tactics,
Use manipulative and secretive ways,
Lead more by instructions than inspirations,
Become more suspicious about other people,
Treat others in unethical, inhuman and insensitive ways,
7.4 Trust and Collaborato
Deplete the morale and motivation of other persons,
Keep the things secret to such an extent that the whole task is sub-divided into such a wa
that one does not know the working of the other except the master-manipulat
themselves,
Form cliques,caucus and coterie on certain latent patterns to grab resOurces,
Eulogize their insignificant achievements and seek back patting from superiors,
Harass and humiliate others and derive sadistic pleasure out of it.
eredibility adversely
Lack of trust and more affect the dynamics of our relationships. When
elevated.
people around us
are cooperative and credible, we feel more energized and
Trust and Collaboration
7.5
.dneople manipulanve, Secreive and non-transparent, we feel scared. There may be time in our
life whern events are severe and time is compressed, we have to depend upon others. Here trust and
credibility play their role as we time people willingly contribute and cooperate.
a Positive effect on team efforts
Io the present world of interdependence, we have to work with various pefsons
and to interact
ah thenm in the group. Leaders have to build the team of dedicated and devoted
individuals to
bhieve comprehensIVe goals in the cómplex environment. Groups are different from teams. Team
ogether Everyone Attains More) implies unity of purpose, collaboration and commnitment to the
In situation of team individual members interact with each other and with the
team leader in
hieving their common goals. These team members depend on each other's input to perform their
wOrk. In team, comunication stemming out of transparency and trust is key
instrument for the
noss and survival of team. Without trust as suspicious and mistrust arise,
people will question
each others' intentions and the whole team efforts shall collapse. Thus trust leads to team efforts.
4. Leadership
In context of leadership, "Credibility is the foundation of leadership" Kouzes and Posner
remarks.
aptly
because it enables the leaders to earn the trust and confidence of their followers. Their
intensive and ongoing research since 1980s, with interviews and focus group opinions of more than
L00,000 people over more than three decades searching the qualities people most look for their
willing cooperation-credibility is the answer. Kouzes and Posner point out the characteristics of
admired leaders in the form of 225 values as provided by more than 1500
nationwide managers,
which are subsequently analyzed into 225 factors and then reduced to 15 categories with following
the most frequent categories :
Integrity (honesty, trustworthiness, character, convictions)
Competernce (capable,productive, efficient, professional)
Leadership (inspiring, decisive, providing direction)
Transformational leadership requires trust of followers which is earned when they perceive their
leader as honest and possessing integrity. Trust is built and maintained by transformational leader by
Walking the talk, through patterns of actions consistent with espoused values and behavioral
integrity .
5. Engagement of
Employees
eever changing and complex environment characterized as volatile, uncertain, complex and
ambi
speedguous (vUCA)-organizations have to engage their employees to survive and thrive. Given the
and scale of
innovation and market changes happening, employees engagement is considered
e of essential kev to organizational success and to remain competitive in regular
waves of
change.
Employees' engagement refers to:
iodvation and commitment of staff to contribute to the organization,
7.6 Trust and Collaboratioa
the degree of feeling valued and enjoying work,
the positive psychological state of feeling energized and absorbed in work
Transformational leaders effectively engage their employees throughtrust and transparency as it
helps to secure willing cooperation of different employees and accelerate the speed of working. They
departments that lead
to jealousy and
competition between different individuals and
discouragepractices like back-biting or sabotaging that adversely affect the harmony and
contribute
unecal
Conflicts among different individuals. Trust and openness play dominating role in engaging the
heads, hearts and spirit of emplovees. On the other hand-suspicion, fussiness, and defensive behavior
retard the engagement of employees.
6. Transformation of culture
Trust of the leader and colleagues help to transform the organizational culture. In present era of
Competition at global level and fast changing environment, an organization cannot afford low trust
culture of surveillance and high-control management that bread political posturing, promote internal
competition and cynicism, and deplete vital energy of the organizational members.
How
members
organization can compete in the era of speed, quality and innovation when trust among its
is difficult to
is low. It needs to be transformed as high culture of trust and empathy. Without trust, it
maintain teamn cohesion, initiate change programs in smooth way as it provokes resistance than
cooperation due to suspicion.
7. Employees' well-being
Trust and credibility of the leader and team mates help to contribute their well-being. As the
leaders and team mnates work in the environment of trust because of honesty, integrity and
transparency of different persons, they fel greater job satisfaction and become willing to cooperate
with others. This spirit contributes to ernployees' happiness and wellbeing. Therefore
ethical
leadership deeply grounded in honesty and integrity leads to wellbeing of employees because
employees feel to reciprocate by performing better, become more loyal and ethical at workplace and
feel higher level of job satisfaction. Authenticity of leader generating trust among others not ony
and
influences his or her well-being but also the wellbeing of the employees. Moreover honesty
integrity earn the respect of the employees and their positive perception about the organization that
increases the job satisfaction and consequently wellbeing.
8. Effective corporate governance
shareholders,
The corporate governance is the field of study that encompasses the interests of orderlyand
employees, customers and vendors, communities, financiers, and the government in the haveto
balanced management of business corporations. To attract funds from outsiders, companies
structuraland
governance. For corporate governance, so far reliance has been placed on
ensure good mentality, but
that has led to checks and balances system with "check box compliance"
legal aspect confidence of different stakeholders. But legal cannot work the
long
has failed to win the system reach
Compliance with law and regulation is an important first step, but those who wish toeleganceof
leadership in the field need to be inspired by the sheet ethical
commanding heights of
governance principles that build the trust among different stakeholders.
Trust and Collaboration 7.7
2.Appreciate constituents
Leading others is a dialogue, not monologue. These are relationships built on mutual
understanding. Constituents have to believe in that you are worthy of their trust. Leaders and
persons who are onlyinterested in their own agendas and their own advancements of goals will not
be followed willingly in the long run. Credible leaders and persons demonstrate empathy and
compassion for their constituents, and avoid behaving in selfish manner. They shift the focus from
self to others and understand others perspective, share information voluntarily, reciprocate and
make conversation as synergized dialogue. The persons acting in dictatorial manner fail to appreciate
others and consequently fail to earn respect.
3. Affirm shared values
Affirm shared values by honoring the diversity of many constituencies and finding a common
ground of agreement on which everyone can stand. Conflicts should be resolved on the basis of
principles, not on positions, on problems not personalities. Conflicts are inevitable in environment of
diversity, but shared yalues provide internal compass to act independently and interdependently,
and to resolve the conflicts in the light of those shared values.
TRUSTING APPROPRIATELY
Besides creating trust among others, one should learn to trust others appropriately. There are
negative effects of broken trust when a person faces situation of broken trust by others:
Emotional reaction of anger
Frustration at oneself for trusting someone
Frustration at offender for exploiting
Damage to interpersonal relations
Avoidance of transactions with offender in future
Withholding support and cooperation.
Negative effect on organizational citizenship behavior and job performance,
Relationship continues as a hollow "shell", a façade of superficial cooperation or pursuit or
specific transactions that are tightly controlled.
Experience of stronger negative cognitive and emotional reactions, including a sense of moral
outrage.
Therefore one should be selective in trusting others. But one should analyze why we trust
inappropriately, the reasons may be:
Lack of power to discriminate
Focus on particular image or feature of the person without taking the picture in holistic
manner due to lack of maturity
Emotions dominating intellect
Lborontpature to act altruistically without regard whether the person is
deserving or no
Weaknessof seeking power or praise, which is exploited through flattery
Lack of maturity to judge others' intentions.
Trust and Collaboration 7.13
One should work upon these reasons to avoid trusting inappropriately. As the one
enters into
relationship, one should grow in trust gradually.
REBUILDING TRUST
As a rule, one should build trust and credibility on continuous basis. But
sometimes without bad
intentions, we could not fulfill our promises because of pressures of time. In such situation, others
rust is broken. We have to rebuild trust in such situation. It is
repaired, but there is research that indicates that broken trust perceived
can bethat brokento trust
re-built cannor
certain te
extent.
However building trust is not as straight forward as building trust in the first place. There are certain
strategies that pay the way to re-build the trust.
There are two ways to rebuild trust: reconciliation and forgiveness. For reconciliation, the person
breaching trust should ask the victim whether s/he is ready to reconcile. If the person is not ready to
reconcile, rebuldin8 Process iS not possible. First one has to prepare the victim for reconciliation. For
this, one should first restore for damages that have already been done. Then apologize sincerely tor
what has been done and assure that this thing will not happen in future. One should take care of
words and deeds. It will take time to rebuild the trust. Forgiveness is the ultimate state of which
reconciliation is a behavioral manifestation. With forgiveness. the heart of the victim is cleared of
resentment.
COLLABORATION
Collaboration among individuals and organizations is all about their mutual trust. at present
business is not operating at local level, but at global level where they have to enter into different
types of collaborations where both the parties are dependent upon each other. Foreign business
partner provides the advantage of technology and capital whereas local business house provides the
network of relations. They trust each other for mutual advantages. In context of organization,
different individuals collaborate and network with each other to excel. People can collaborate
effectively if they build up trust. As successful transformation of the organization depends on its
ability to bring people with diverse competencies that can lead to high quality decisions, it has to
build up trust among different individuals. It is in collaboration that crucial information and
perspective is shared that depends upon trust among different people.
In organizational context and foreign collaborations, trust is crucial factor as both the parties
become vulnerable to actions of other person. Therefore professional competencies and integrity of
the person become dominating factor in that. Trust is channelized as different members have
intuitive and immediate feeling while interacting with others. These feelings are based upon past
experiences, person's looks, sounds and acts. If these feelings resonate with person's past experience
or intuition, trust will be enhanced. On the other hand, if there is difference then distrust shall
emerge. There will be unconscious bias in the memory of the person interacting. As a result
collaborations collapse when the person feels that he has been cheated. In case of organization,
people do not collaborate because of lack of trust as they feel alienation, provocative behavior,
cheating. Therefore trust is must for effective collaboration.
7.14 Trust and Collaboratiom
REVISION OF CHAPTER
Trust and Credibility are the building blocks of interpersonal relations, team and
culture. Trust means having afeeling of confidence and positive expectations among others. Trust i
transforned
context of organization has been defined as the willingness of aparty to be vuherable to the actions
of another party. The other term related with trust is credibility that stems from the same root, credo
meaning "I trust or believe". Communication researcher Berlo points out the characteristics o
"source credibility" as trustworthiness, expertise and dynamism. People judge credibility of others
from their:
Arguing uselessly
Manipulating others through fear and flattery
Falsehood even for no specific gains and calumny, and accusing others with raise a
fabricated charges
Building tragile, calculative, and temporary relationships; and formation of cliques, caucus
and coterie on certain underlying and latent paterns with intention to grab power and
resources
EXERCISE
FILL IN THE BLANKS
1. Trust in organizational context means the become
vulnerable to the actions of another party. willingness of the party to
2. Trust also implies becoming as
physical and emotional well-beings
are
threatened.