1 s2.0 S2214317315000335 Main
1 s2.0 S2214317315000335 Main
1 s2.0 S2214317315000335 Main
com
Alfadhl Yahya Khaled a, Samsuzana Abd Aziz a,*, Fakhrul Zaman Rokhani b
a
Department of Biological and Agricultural Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Universiti Putra Malaysia, Serdang, Selangor,
Darul Ehsan 43400, Malaysia
b
Department of Computer and Communication Systems Engineering, Faculty of Engineering, Universiti Putra Malaysia, Serdang, Selangor,
Darul Ehsan 43400, Malaysia
A R T I C L E I N F O A B S T R A C T
Article history: The repeated usage of frying oil has been proven hazardous due to the degradation process
Received 19 November 2014 by chemical reactions that lead to changes in the quality of the oil. Currently, the degree of
Received in revised form frying oil degradation is indicated by the percentage of its total polar compounds (TPC). In
6 July 2015 this study, a capacitive sensor was designed to assess frying oil degradation at several heat-
Accepted 21 July 2015 ing time intervals by measuring changes on its electrical capacitance. The sensor was
Available online 7 August 2015 designed using interdigitated electrode structure. A total of 30 samples of 130 ml palm
oil were heated at 180 °C up to 30 h. For each one hour interval, one sample was moved
Keywords: out from the laboratory oven. The electrical capacitance, total polar compound (TPC) and
Capacitance sensor viscosity of the samples were measured for analysis. Preliminary results demonstrated
Frying oil quality significant correlation between oil electrical capacitance with TPC and viscosity with R2
Heating ranged from 0.83 to 0.90. The designed sensor has good potential for simple and inexpensive
way of determining frying oil quality.
Ó 2015 China Agricultural University. Production and hosting by Elsevier B.V. All rights
reserved.
used to observe frying oil at all stages of its used and deter-
Table 1 – Physical and chemical Indicators of frying oil
quality. mine its viscosity [11]. Other than that, instruments such as
Testo 270 (InstruMartlnc, Germany), and Ebro FOM 310
Physical indicators Chemical indicators (ebroÒElectronic GmbH, Germany) were developed by elec-
Smoke point Free fatty acids (FFA) tronic companies to measure the quality of frying oil by
Color Peroxide value (PV) testing the total polar materials (TPM) based on changes
Viscosity Iodine values (IV) in the dielectric constant of the oil. In addition, kits such
Taste Total polar compounds (TPC) as Fritest (E. Merck, Germany) and Oleh TestTM (Panreca,
Odor Polymeric triglycerides
Spain) were developed to measure the quality of frying oil
Foam persistence Anisidine value (AV)
by testing the FFA and TPC, respectively based on the color
Polymerized and oxidized material
reaction of the oil [9,37]. However, there are some limita-
tions with the current devices such as complex calibration
frying oil are important to determine the deterioration level of requirement, suitability for different type of oil as well as
the oil [6]. distinct temperature dependencies [27].
Several physical indicators (Table 1) are used to evaluate Numerous studies have attempted to explain the molecu-
the quality of frying oil: smoke point, color, viscosity, taste, lar polarizability and the orientational effects of polar media
odor, and foam persistence [24,31,35]. These tests are by observing changes in their electrical properties. Morgan
extensively used; however they are not decisive in them- et al. [25] reported that the dipole moment of the biological
selves. Color, for example, basically depends on the sort particles is induced when subjected to an AC field. Where
of food fried as well as the oil; taste and odor depend the polarized particles gain a force that can cause them to
on the food type used for frying. Smoking amount of fry- replace to electric field, relying on the particle polarizability
ing oil is related to the temperature as well as to the as comparing to the suspending medium. The molecular
amount of low molecular weight breakdown in the oil. polarizability is effecting the magnitude of the dipole
Viscosity measurements can be used as an indicator to moment, and this in turn is controlled by the dielectric prop-
detect the quality deterioration of frying oil, but it is not erties of the medium and molecular. Bagchi et al. [4] stated
conclusive in itself. that the values of the polarizability of the molecule can expe-
While the chemical indicators listed in Table 1, can be a rience substantial changes from their values when a molecule
more reliable way to assess the deterioration of frying oil is excited to higher electronic state. According to Hughes [15]
[22]. Innawong et al. [16] stated that the volatile compounds a molecule experience negative or positive dielectrophoresis
produced from chemical reactions through frying process is relying on its polarizability relative to its nearby medium.
contribute to raise the peroxide value (PV) in the oil. As Hughes noted that the variances in the quantity of induced
Tsuzuki et al. [34] argued that PV increases with time as the charge at the interface between medium and particle lead to
oil is heated at 180 °C. In addition, iodine value (IV) is used oriented dipole counter to applied field where the polarizabil-
for the assessment of the suitability of the oils [23]. Garba ity of medium is less than that of molecule, and in the same
et al. [12] reported that oil with high IV exhibited poor perfor- direction as the applied field where it is less. The relative
mance due to the oxidation reactions of lipids and the polarizability depends on applied field frequency, it has a
hydroperoxide formation between the unsaturated fatty acids strong frequency dependence, beside the conductivity and
and oxygen. Also, free fatty acid (FFA), polymeric triglycerides, permittivity, because it is a complex function. According to
anisidine value (AV), and polymerized and oxidized material Darma [8], the movement of dipole throughout polarization
(POM) are broadly used as the pointers of the frying oil quality, resulting in displacement current, and this contributes to
but are not conclusive in themselves [21]. At present, mea- total current and improves the conductivity.
surement of the total polar compounds (TPC) is considered Generally, studies on changes of electrical properties have
to be the most commonly used method to evaluate the qual- been introduced and some sorts of instruments were
ity of oil because it determines overall chemical degradation proposed to be used in the agricultural field [17]. The parallel
taking place in the oil [10]. planar electrodes are one of the generally used probes to
To date various methods have been developed and sense the moisture content in peanut oil [18], analysis of egg-
introduced to measure the different chemical and physical plant pulp and effects of drying and freezing–thawing treat-
parameters of frying oil. For example, chemosensory system ments on its capacitance characteristics [38]. Presently,
for controlling the quality of oil in food industries [36], interdigitated electrodes (IDEs) are applied in many sensing
Fourier transforms infrared (FTIR) to differentiate between devices including surface acoustic wave, chemical sensors,
good and inadmissible oils [17], chromatography to measure and MEMS biosensors [33]. Furthermore, IDEs have been
dielectric constant, smoke point and viscosity [28] and image studied in cancer cell detection as well as other biological
analysis to determine the TPC rate in frying oil [14]. However, associated applications [3,19]. Therefore, IDE could be used
these methods are complicated, time consuming, and expen- in solving complex calibration requirements and improving
sive. Thus, developing a simple sensing system to help in the accuracy of sensory sensitivity. Also, IDE shape has some
appraising the quality of frying oil is required. advantages such as no moving parts, ease of fabrication, flex-
More recently, there are many instruments and kits that ible in design, and cost effective [30]. In this study, a capacitive
can be used to determine oil degradation. For example, vis- sensor was designed using IDE platform to assess frying oil
cosity meters and electronic-based physical tests such as degradation due to heating at different frequencies. The aims
Vibro Viscometer (A&D Company Limited, Japan) can be of this study were to develop and evaluate a new sensor for
144 Information Processing in Agriculture 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 1 4 2 –1 4 8
Fig. 1 – (a) A top-view illustration of capacitance sensor probe; (b) A photograph of a prototype device next to a Malaysian coin.
Fig. 2 – Capacitance sensor connected to LCR meter. Fig. 3 – Measurement of TPC using Testo 270.
Information Processing in Agriculture 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 1 4 2 –1 4 8 145
Table 2 – The mean of capacitance, TPC and viscosity at different heating time.
Heating time (h) TPC (%) Viscosity (mPas) Capacitance
100 Hz 1000 Hz 10 kHz 20 kHz 100 kHz
Fig. 5 – The capacitance and TPC measurements at 100 kHz Fig. 7 – The capacitance and viscosity measurements at
at different heating time. 100 kHz at different heating time.
Table 3 – The correlation coefficient and the RMSE of the regression equation used to predict TPC using capacitance
measurements at different frequencies.
Table 4 – The correlation coefficient and the RMSE of the regression equation used to predict viscosity using capacitance
measurements at different frequencies.
3.2. Relationship between capacitance measurements and This study is funded by the Prototype Research Grant Scheme,
viscosity measurements Ministry of Higher Education; project number PGRS/1/12/
TK02/UPM/02/2.
The viscosity values of the frying oil samples generally went
up from 50.80 mPas to 90.60 mPas as the heating time
increased (Table 2). On the other hand, the capacitance mea- R E F E R E N C E S
surements were increased from 3.48 pF to 4.24 pF as the heat-
ing time increased. Fig. 7 is a representative plot of viscosity
and capacitance measurements across heating time at [1] Aditama S. Dielectric properties of palm oils as liquid
100 kHz where other frequencies generally had similar trend. insulating materials: effects of fat content. In Electrical
148 Information Processing in Agriculture 2 ( 2 0 1 5 ) 1 4 2 –1 4 8
Insulating Materials. Proceedings of International [20] Khaled AY, Aziz SA, Rokhani FZ. Development and Evaluation
Symposium on IEEE 2005(1): 91–94. of an Impedance Spectroscopy Sensor to Assess Cooking Oil
[2] Agilent Technologies. Agilent 4263B LCR Meter User’s Guide. Quality. Int J Environ Sci Dev 2014;5(3):299–302.
4th ed., Japan; 2000. [21] Kress-Rogers E, Gillatt PN, Rossell JB. Development and
[3] Alexander JF, Price dT, Bhansali S. Optimization of evaluation of a novel sensor for the in situ assessment of
interdigitated electrode (IDE) arrays for impedance based frying oil quality. Food Control 1990;1(3):163–78.
evaluation of Hs 578T cancer cells. In: Journal of Physics: [22] Lee KS, Lee K, Lau V, Shin K, Ju BK. SWNT sensors for
Conference Series, 2010. IOP Publishing, 012134. monitoring the oxidation of edible oils. World Acad Sci Eng
[4] Bagchi B, Oxtoby DW, Fleming GR. Theory of the time Technol 2011;74:385–8.
development of the stokes shift in polar media. Chem Phys [23] Matthäus B. Use of palm oil for frying in comparison with
1984;86(3):257–67. other high-stability oils. Eur J Lipid Sci Technol 2007;109
[5] Bansal G, Zhou W, Barlow PJ, Joshi PS, Lo HL, Chung YK. (4):400–9.
Review of rapid tests available for measuring the quality [24] Moreira RG, Castell-Perez ME, Barrufet MA. Deep Fat Frying:
changes in frying oils and comparison with standard Fundamentals and Applications. Gaithersburg, ML: Aspen
methods. Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr 2010;50(6):503–14. Publishers Inc; 1999. p. 33–74.
[6] Blumenthal MM. A new look at the chemistry and physics of [25] Morgan H, Hughes MP, Green NG. Separation of submicron
deep-fat frying. Food Technol 1991;45(2):68–71. bioparticles by dielectrophoresis. Biophys J 1999;77(1):516–25.
[7] Choe E, Min DB. Chemistry of deep-fat. J Food Sci 2007;72 [26] Peter A, Lieberzeit AA, Gerd G, Franz LD. Molecularly
(5):77–86. imprinted sol-gel nanoparticles for mass-sensitive engine oil
[8] Darma IS. Dielectric properties of mixtures between mineral degradation sensing. Anal Bioanal Chem 2007;389:441–6.
oil and natural ester. In Electrical Insulating Materials, 2008. [27] Saltmarsh M. Rapid analysis of fats and oils: thermal
(ISEIM 2008). International Symposium on (pp. 514–517). IEEE. degradation. Presented at Western Food Industries
[9] Dobarganes M, Márquez Ruiz G. Regulation of used frying fats Conference 1990; UC Davis, March.
and validity of quick tests for discarding the fats. Grasas y [28] Sanibal EAA, Mancini-Filho J. Frying oil and fat quality
Aceites 1998;49(3–4):331–5. measured by chemical, physical, and test kit analyses. J Am
[10] Farhoosh R, Tavassoli-Kafrani MH. Polar compounds Oil Chem Soc 2004;81(9):847–52.
distribution of sunflower oil as affected by unsaponifiable [29] Santos JCO, Santos IMG, Souza AG. Effect of heating and
matters of bene hull oil (BHO) and tertiary- cooling on rheological parameters of edible vegetable oils. J
butylhydroquinone (TBHQ) during deep-frying. Food Chem Food Eng 2005;67(4):401–5.
2010;122(1):381–5. [30] Staginus J, Aerts IM, Chang ZY, Meijer G, De-Smet LC,
[11] Fritsch CW, Egberg DC, Magnuson JS. Changes in dielectric Sudhölter EJ. Capacitive response of PDMS-coated IDE
constant as a measure of frying oil deterioration. J Am Oil platforms directly exposed to aqueous solutions containing
Chem Soc 1979;56(8):746–50. volatile organic compounds. Sensor Actuat B: Chem
[12] Garba ZN, Gimba CE, Emmanuel P. Production and 2013;184:130–42.
characterisation of biobased transformer oil from Jatropha [31] Susheelamma NS, Asha MR, Ravi R, Kumar AV. Comparative
Curcas Seed. J Phys Sci 2013;24(2):49–61. studies on physical properties of vegetable oils and their
[13] Gertz C. Chemical and physical parameters as quality blends after frying. J Food Lipids 2002;9(4):259–76.
indicators of used frying fats. Eur J Lipid Sci Technol 2000;102 [32] SV-A Series Sine-wave Vibro Viscometer. User Handbook; Ver.
(89):566–72. 1.13E. International Div., A&D Company, Limited, Japan, 2009.
[14] Gil B, Cho YJ, Yoon SH. Rapid determination of polar [33] Thong-un N, Sriratana W, Tanachaikhan L. Design of
compounds in frying fats and oils using image analysis. LWT- Capacitive Sensor for Concentration Measurement. In: SICE-
Food Sci Technol 2004;37(6):657–61. ICASE, 2006. International Joint Conference. IEEE, 2006: 1959–
[15] Hughes MP. Strategies for dielectrophoretic separation in 1962.
laboratory-on-a-chip systems. Electrophoresis 2002;23 [34] Tsuzuki W, Matsuoka A, Ushida K. Formation of trans fatty
(16):2569–82. acids in edible oils during the frying and heating process.
[16] Innawong B, Mallikarjunan P, Marcy JE. The determination of Food Chem 2010;123(4):976–82.
frying oil quality using a chemosensory system. LWT-Food [35] Tyagi VK, Vasishtha AK. Changes in the characteristics and
Sci Technol 2004;37(1):35–41. composition of oils during deep-fat frying. J Am Oil Chem Soc
[17] Innawong B, Mallikarjunan P, Irudayaraj J, Marcy JE. The Frying Oils 1996;73(4):499–506.
determination of frying oil quality using fourier transform [36] Vlachos N, Skopelitis Y, Psaroudaki M, Konstantinidous V,
infrared attenuated total reflectance. LWT-Food Sci Technol Chatzilazarou A, Tegou E. Applications of fourier transford-
2004;37(1):23–8. infrared spectroscopy to edable oils. Anal Chem Acta
[18] Irawadi TT, Fauzi AM. Potential of conductance measurement 2006;573:459–65.
for lard detection. Int J Basic Appl Sci IJBAS-IJENS 2011;11 [37] White PJ. Methods for measuring changes in deep-fat frying
(5):26–30. oils. Food Technol 1991;45(2):75–80.
[19] Kaushik A, Kumar R, Huey E, Bhansali S, Nair N, Nair M. Silica [38] Wu L, Ogawa Y, Tagawa A. Electrical impedance spectroscopy
nanowires: growth, integration, and sensing applications. analysis of eggplant pulp and effects of drying and freezing-
Microchim Acta 2014;181(15–16):1759–80. thawing treatments on its impedance characteristics. J Food
Eng 2008;87:274–80.