Unit 6
Unit 6
Unit 6
Objectives
The objectives of this unit are to:
• Highlight the need of investments in marketable securities.
• Explain different types of securities available for investments.
• Provide an overview of markets for securities.
• Explain models to optimize the cost and opportunity income.
• Provide a guideline to develop strategies in the management of
securities.
Structure
6.1 Introduction
6.2 Need for Investments in Securities
6.3 Types of Marketable Securities
6.4 Market for Short-term Securities
6.5 Optimisation Models
6.6 Strategies for Managing Securities
6.7 Summary
6.8 Key Words
6.9 Self-Assessment Questions
6.10 Further Reading
6.1 INTRODUCTION
Cash and marketable securities are normally treated as one item in any
analysis of current assets. Holding cash in excess of immediate requirement
means the firm is missing out an opportunity income. Excess cash thus is
normally invested in marketable securities, which serves two purposes
namely, provide liquidity and also earn a return. Marketable securities form a
major component of cash and marketable securities.
Investing surplus cash in marketable securities is normally a part of overall
cash management. It becomes a separate activity of the firm, if the
investments in marketable securities form a major part of the current assets.
Many firms in India today are very active in money and capital markets,
where marketable securities are traded. A cursory look at the investments by
some of the companies makes us believe that they are very active in the
securities market. For example, Reliance Industries has investment in
securities to the tune of Rs.3,47,285 crore, which is 58.33 per cent of the total
assets. As can be seen from the data incorporated in Table-6.1., companies
like ONGC, Vedanta, Tata Steel, Bharti Airtel, IOC, Larsen, Maruti Suzuki,
128 Grasim, etc., have significant amounts invested in securities.
Management of
Table 6.1: Investment in Securities by Select Companies by 2-04-2022
Cash
(Rs. in Crore)
Activity 6.1
i) What are the major reasons for deciding to invest “excess” cash balances
in marketable securities?
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
ii) What characteristics should an investment have to qualify as an
acceptable marketable security?
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………… 131
Management of iii) Give an account of the activity of marketable securities of a company
Current Assets
you are aware of.
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
A) Debt Securities
All debt securities represent a promise to pay a specific amount of money
(the principal amount) to the holder of the security on a specific date (the
maturity date). In exchange for investing in security, the investor or holder of
the security, receives interest. This interest may be paid upon maturity of the
security (as with most short term debt instruments) or in periodic instalments
(as with most long term debt instruments). Different types of debt securities
are discussed below.
i) Call money
The demand and time liabilities (DTL) of a bank are evaluated every
fortnight on a Friday called the ‘Reporting Friday’. During the first fortnight
following the Reporting Friday, the bank is expected to maintain daily 4% of
its DTLs (as on the Reporting Friday) in cash with RBI. This is known as
cash reserve ratio CRR. The banks are expected to maintain this balance in
such a way that the average daily balance is within the stipulated
requirement. The market that arises as a result of borrowing and lending by
banks in order to maintain their CRR is known as the call market.
Theoretically call money is money that is literally on call, i.e., it can be called
back at short notice. In the case of interbank market, the notice period can be
132 as short as one day.
Management of
ii) Certificates of Deposit
Cash
A certificate of deposit (CD) is an instrument issued by a bank or other
depository institution representing funds placed on deposit at the bank for a
certain period of time. They are called negotiable certificates of deposit.
Negotiable CDs are generally not redeemable before maturity, but an investor
who purchases, for example, a six-month CD may sell it to another investor
one month later rather than wait until the CD matures. The interest on CDs is
calculated on the face amount of the CD. It is a Non-discount instrument and
pays the face amount plus accrued interest at maturity. The rates available to
investors in CDs are typically somewhat higher (averaging about 1 percent
higher) than those on T-bills of equal maturity. This yield differential can be
attributed to several factors: a) the somewhat thinner market for CDs, b) the
tax differential, c) the risk factor of the issuing financial institution.
iii) Commercial paper
Commercial paper (CP) is the term, for the short-term promissory notes
issued by large corporations with high credit ratings. Commercial paper
usually carries no stated interest rate and sells at a discount from its face
value as T-bills. The objective of the RBI introducing CP as an instrument
to finance working capital needs was to reduce the dependence of corporates
on banks. Also, by pricing the CP at market rates, the financial efficiency of
corporates was coveted to increase. Also, this instrument securitises the
working capital limits. CPs can be issued to individuals, banking companies,
corporate bodies, whether located in India or outside India, including NRIs
and FIIs. The companies can now issue CP for a maturity period ranging
from 3 months to less than a year. Minimum net worth of issuer is also
reduced from Rs. 5 crores to Rs. 4 crores and the minimum working capital
(fund-based) limit is also being reduced from Rs. 5 crores to Rs. 4 crores.
And the borrowable account of the company is classified as the Standard
Asset by the Banks. CPs now can be issued in multiples of Rs. 5 lakhs.
(iv) Bankers Acceptances
Bankers’ Acceptances are time drafts drawn on a commercial bank for which
the bank guarantees payment of the face value upon maturity. They are
commonly used to finance international transactions for the short term. For
e.g., a jewellery retailer in India might purchase watches from a manufacturer
in Switzerland, paying for the goods by sending a time draft (a draft payable
at some future date) drawn upon the jeweller’s bank. When the bank accepts
the draft, it stamps “accepted” on the reverse side of the draft, meaning that
the bank guarantees payment of the draft upon maturity. In effect, the bank is
guaranteeing the credit of the jeweller. Since the credit behind the draft is
now on the bank, the draft can be traded in the money market along with
other short-term debt instruments. Although bankers’ acceptances are
available to individual investors, they are typically most popular with
commercial banks and foreign investors.
(v) Government Securities or Securities Guaranteed by the Government
Government securities are public debt instruments issued by the Government
of India, State Governments or Financial Institutions, Electricity boards,
Municipal Corporation, etc. guaranteed by the governments to finance their
133
Management of projects. The default risk of these securities is perceived to be lower than that
Current Assets
of corporate bonds or equity shares since they are issued on account of
Sovereign risk. These securities are therefore termed as Gilt-edged securities.
Government securities traded in the money markets fall within 5 distinct
categories.
a) Treasury Bills
b) Central Loans
c) State Loans
d) Central Guaranteed loans
e) State Guaranteed loans
The order of these securities ranges from most liquid to less liquid and also
safest to less safe. All these securities are of different maturities and coupon
rates. Currently, the coupon rates of government securities range from lowest
of 5 per cent to the highest of 11 per cent.
You may refer money market page of economic dailies such as The
Economic Times or The Hindu Business Line, Business Standard, Financial
Express. Where you get indicative rates for many of these securities for
different maturity periods. Exhibit-6.1 shows some of the inputs, which you
normally see in a money market page of economic dailies.
Treasury bills have of late started attracting good response, especially since
the introduction of 364 days T Bill in April 1992. Presently, there are 3
maturities - 91 days, 182 days and 364 days. Government securities are one
of the lowest yielding securities that one can invest in. Most investments in
these securities are made due to regulatory reasons. Generally, Banks and
Financial Institutions buy these T-Bills from out of the funds, they are
supposed to maintain as part of SLR.
c) Corporate Bonds
Debt securities of corporations with maturity of longer than one year are
corporate bonds. The usual par value of a corporate bond is Rs. 100 and
sometimes Rs. 10,000, and maturities range from about 2 years to as many as
30 years. In recent years, however, corporate bond issues have been of
shorter maturities as inflation and economic uncertainties have caused
investors to be less willing to commit their funds for longer periods of time.
B) Equity Investments
Equity securities represent the residual ownership of the firm. Residual
ownership means that the debt holders must first be paid off, before the
company belongs completely to the equity holders. The two types of equity
securities are common stock and preferred stock.
135
Management of a) Common Stock
Current Assets
The common stockholders are the risk takers; they own a portion of the firm
that is not guaranteed, and they are last in line with claims on the company’s
assets in the event of a bankruptcy. In return for taking this risk, they share in
the growth of the firm because the growth in the value of the company
accrues to the common shareholders. The company may make a periodic cash
payment called a cash dividend to the common stockholders. Cash dividends
are commonly paid to shareholders on a quarterly basis, but they may be paid
annually, irregularly, or even not at all. The common shareholder has no
guarantee of receiving a dividend payment. Common stockholders usually
have voting rights that allow them to vote on the corporation’s board of
directors. Since the board of directors hires the top management of the
company, the stockholders indirectly determine the company’s management.
b) Preferred Stock
Preferred stock is technically an equity interest in the company, but its
characteristics are more like those of bonds. Preferred means that this type of
stock has a stated par value that represents a claim against corporate assets
that supersedes the claims of the common stockholders, but is subordinate to
the claims of bondholders. Preferred stock also carries a fixed cash dividend
to the common shareholders. Like debt, preferred stock is often
systematically retired through a sinking fund. It also does not represent true
residual ownership because preferred shareholders usually do not participate
in earnings growth by receiving higher dividends, as common shareholders
do.
(a) Options
An option is a contract giving its holder the right to buy or sell an asset or
security at a fixed price. All options are valid only for a specified time period,
after which they expire. A call option gives its holder the right to buy the
underlying asset and thereby guarantees the purchase price of the asset for the
duration of the option. A put option carries the right to sell and guarantees the
selling price of the underlying security.
(b) Warrants
Warrants are like call options that are issued by the corporation. They give
their holders the right to purchase the common stock from the corporation
at a fixed price. Warrants usually have longer life than options (typically
five to seven years), although a few perpetual warrants do exist. Corporations
usually issue warrants in conjunction with another issue of securities and
offer a “package deal.” For example, the purchase of one share of preferred
136
stock might entitle the investor to receive one warrant to purchase common Management of
Cash
stock of the company. Companies offer such packages to sweeten the deal
and make the other security easier to sell.
There is still one more security in the list, called units of mutual funds,
which is not a separate security on its own but backed by an investment in the
above securities. Indian companies traditionally prefer mutual funds units,
particularly Unit-64 of Unit Trust of India, to invest their surplus money for
short period because of reasonable return, high liquidity and tax concession
(tax provisions governing mutual funds investments have seen significant
changes during the last few years). Since many private sector mutual funds
have also started offering a reasonable return in their debt-oriented schemes,
corporate attention is slowly moving towards the units of private sector
funds. Another instrument similar to mutual funds units that is likely to
emerge in the future is the unit arising out of securitisation process. These
are units backed by mortgages of housing loan or any other receivables. A
few securitisation deals have already taken place in the Indian market but
they were restricted to financial institutions. This market is the second largest
segment of the market, immediately next to government securities market,
and is also very active.
Activity 6.2
i) List out the different kinds of instruments in the money market.
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
………………………………………………………………………… 137
Management of ii) What is call money market?
Current Assets
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
iii) Trace out the trends in the Indian Debt Market?
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
Money market is a place where borrower meets the lender to trade in money
and other liquid assets that are close substitutes for money. A developed
money market will have large number of instruments, both in terms of variety
and volume, presence of large number of traders and existence of requisite
infrastructure to facilitate efficient settlement of transactions. Till 1991,
money market in India was in a dormant state. It was operating in a closely
regulated environment, where interest rates are fixed and regulated. The
operations were also restricted in a few securities involving commercial
banks. The conditions of the money market improved after the Reserve Bank
of India initiated many changes on the basis of the recommendation of the
Vaghul Committee, which recommended deregulation of interest rates,
introduction of new instruments and increase in the number of participants.
As a result, India now has fairly developed money market with a number of
138 instruments and active trading. The establishment of institutions like,
Discount and Finance House of India Ltd. (DFHL), SBI Guilt, etc., and Management of
Cash
arrival of several wholesale dealers has provided liquidity to the market.
Mutual funds have also started actively investing in short- term securities
along with banks and other institutional investors.
Market for long-term securities is a place where the borrowers raise capital
for longer term. Due to active secondary market for many of the long-term
securities, there is no need that only investors having long-term surplus alone
enter into the market. For instance, a significant percentage of volume of
trading (more than 75%) in stocks, which are long-term instruments, are
settled within a trading cycle of five days. Now ‘T + 1’ trading is going on in
the market. Long- term securities - debt, equity and other types of securities -
are actively traded in the stock exchanges like National Stock Exchange,
Mumbai Stock Exchange. These exchanges deal in corporate securities,
government securities PSU securities and units of mutual funds, etc. Stock
exchanges are more organised than the money market, due to volume of
operations and huge participation of players.
139
Management of (c) Market for Derivative Securities
Current Assets
Derivatives market in India is relatively new and started developing since
2000, when NSE and BSE commenced trading in equity derivatives. Since
then derivatives market in India has grown by leaps and bonds. Actually,
there are four types of derivatives that can be traded in the Indian Stock
Exchanges. They are: Equities, Bonds, Currencies and Commodities. While
the market for equities, bonds and commodities has evolved, the derivative
market for currencies growing now. The following are the usual types of
derivatives traded in India. (a) Forward contracts, (b) Future contracts, (c)
Option contracts, (d) Swap contracts. Though the market for derivatives is of
recent origin, it has recorded phenomenal growths over the years. During the
last 10 years (2011-2021) daily turnover of derivatives grew by 4.2 times
from Rs. 33,305 crore in 2011 to Rs.1,41,267 crore by 2021. Dealings in cash
derivatives also grew by 6.2 times from Rs.11,187 crore to Rs. 69,644 crore
in the same period. In this trade, NSE has emerged the top global Exchange
with about 17.3 billion turnover in 2021 alone.
Activity 6.3
i) What are the reasons for the corporate sector in accessing the capital
markets? List down the various instruments used in capital markets?
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
ii) Describe briefly the market for the Government Securities?
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
iii) Briefly explain the role played by Debt Instruments in the investment of
surplus funds?
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
iv) How far derivatives can serve as a market for surplus cash?
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
140 …………………………………………………………………………
Management of
6.5 OPTIMISATION MODELS Cash
At the beginning of this unit, we have observed that holding cash in excess of
immediate requirement means missing out an opportunity to earn an income.
However, it is necessary to find the cost associated with investing activity
before taking investment decision. For example, if Rs. 5,00,000 is surplus
available for one-week and it can earn an interest income of Rs. 750 for one
week, the interest income is to be compared with cost associated with buying
and selling of securities. Suppose, the security dealer charges 0.1%
commission. The firm will incur Rs. 500 when it buys the security and
another Rs.500 when it sells the security. The total cost of Rs. 1000 is greater
than Rs. 750 and thus, the net effect of the investment is loss. The investment
decision is feasible, if the surplus money is available for two weeks or more.
Thus, the decision on investing surplus money needs a careful analysis of
cost and benefit. A few models are available to balance the cost and benefit
and five of such models are discussed below:
4 0 0 560000 0 560000
141
Management of (B) Interest Outflow in Option 2 (Raising Rs. 20 lakhs Year 1 and Year 3)
Current Assets
0 2000000 50000 0 0 50000
4 0 0 560000 0 560000
0 50000 50000 0
2 330000 330000 0
4 560000 560000 0
The net interest outflow in Option 2 is lower than the interest outflow of
Option 1. Thus, the firm benefits by raising Rs. 20 lakhs at the beginning of
year 1 (Year 0 in the Table), spends Rs. 10 lakhs and invests the balance in
marketable securities at 11.5% for a year. The marketable securities are sold
at the end of year 1 and the value is used for capital expenditure of year 2.
There is no need to raise fresh funds in year 2 because the required amount is
already raised. The process is repeated again in year 3. This strategy leads to
reduction of overall cost of funds because the total amount spent on flotation
is only Rs.1,00,000 against Rs. 2,00,000 under Option 1. What about other
options like raising Rs. 30 lakhs in year 1 and Rs. 10 lakhs in Year 4 or Rs. 40
lakhs in year 1? None of these options give you a lower cost than raising
Rs.20 lakhs in year 1 and Rs. 20 lakhs in year 3. Bierman and McAdams
showed the way to get the optimal financing through the following equation.
Q= 2FD i Y
Where F = the fixed flotation cost of obtaining new financing
D = the firm’s total net outlay of cash for the next period
i = the percentage of interest rate on new financing
Y= the percentage yield on marketable securities
Substituting the value of funds required (Rs. 10 lakhs), flotation cost of Rs.
50000, interest rate of 14% on new financing and 11.5% interest income on
marketable securities in the above equation, we get the following:
142
The model basically optimise the flotation cost with the difference between Management of
Cash
interest outflow and interest income on marketable securities. This model
helps the financial managers to decide on how much to be raised from the
market given the requirement of funds and how much to be invested in
marketable securities. On the other hand, the remaining four models guide the
finance managers on how to switch funds from marketable securities to cash
and vice versa.
Baumol Model: This model assumes that the demand for cash is continuous
and frequent withdrawal of cash from investment will cost more. Thus, the
model gives an approach to find the optimal withdrawal of cash from
investments. An example will be useful to understand the concept. Colleges
or Universities like IGNOU collect fee from the students at the beginning of
the year or term. Assume the receipt for the year is Rs. 12 lakhs. There is no
major cash inflow during the year or term. However, the institution requires
cash continuously to meet various operational expenses during the year or
term. Assume the total demand for the cash during the year is Rs. 10 lakhs.
Suppose the initial receipt of Rs. 12,00,000 is invested in marketable
securities. The issue before us is how much worth of marketable securities is
to be sold and cash be realised. If there is no transaction cost of selling
securities, the amount could be as low as possible. If the cost of each
transaction is Rs. 575, how much money is to be withdrawn every time. The
cost affects our decision because if we withdraw too many times, it will cost
more. At the same time if we withdraw a large amount, then the cash is idle
and we lose an opportunity to earn a return. Baumol resolves the problem
using the following equation, which gives an optimal withdrawal quantity.
C= 2bD /Y
Where b = cost of each transaction
D = total amount required during the period
Y = the percentage of yield on marketable securities
Substituting the value of funds required (Rs.10 lakhs), transaction cost (Rs.
575) and interest on marketable securities (11.5%) in the above equation, we
get the following:
The institution has to sell securities worth of Rs. 1,00,000 every time to
optimise the transaction cost and interest income on marketable securities.
That means, the sale will be effected at the end of every fifth week.
Miller and Orr Model: The earlier two models assume that one of the two
cash flow variables namely cash inflow or cash outflow is constant and thus
come out with a solution on optimal withdrawal value or investment value. In
a situation where both inflow and outflow are not constant, Miller and Orr
model is useful. The model is based on control-limit approach. According to
the approach, the optimum level is first derived based on certain assumptions
and this optimum level needs to be disturbed only when the assumptions are
violated. Miller and Orr model using the interest rate on marketable
securities, transaction cost and minimum desired level of cash, derive the
optimal cash holding for the firm with the use of following equation
Using the minimum desirable cash limit called Lower Limit (L), Miller and
Orr model gives the Upper Limit of cash holding (H), which is equal to
H = 3 Z – 2L
As long as cash is within upper limit (H) and lower limit (L), no action is
required. The moment the cash balance breached one of these two limits, an
action is required. If the cash balance touched the upper limit (H), then all the
excess cash above the optimal holding (Z) is invested in marketable
securities. Similarly, if the cash balance touched the lower limit (L), the firm
sells marketable securities to an extent that brings the cash balance back to
optimal cash holding (Z). The following example shows how the three values
given in the Miller and Orr model are derived.
144
The Treasurer of Blue Diamond Hotel wants to develop a cash management Management of
Cash
model for investing surplus cash in marketable securities. Since the cash
flows show a volatile behaviour, the treasurer feels the Miller and Orr model
is the most suitable for the situation. An analysis of last three-year daily cash
flows shows a standard deviation of Rs. 12,200. Investment in marketable
securities currently offers a return of 12% per annum. The transaction cost
per transaction is Rs.300. The Treasurer believes the hotel should have
minimum cash balance of Rs. 20,000. What is the optimal cash holding?
When an investment or disinvestment action is to be taken?
Substituting the above values in the Miller and Orr model, we get the
following:
Thus, the cash management policy is when the cash balance goes below Rs.
20,000, marketable securities are sold and cash balance is brought back to Rs.
46,702. If the cash balance exceeds Rs. 1,00,107, the cash value above Rs.
46,702 is invested in marketable securities. The cash balance is allowed to
move between Rs. 20,000 and Rs.1,00,107 and occasionally brought down to
the optimum level.
Activity 6.4
i) What is the essential theme of Bierman-McAdams Model?
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
145
Management of ii) Do you believe that the Cash Management Models have any appeal to
Current Assets
the Cash Managers? Comment.
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
The second step in the process of designing the strategy is the extent to which
the firm should take risk while investing in securities. In other words, in stage
one, we have identified the amount available for investments but we haven’t
specified the nature of investments. A set of guidelines needs to be developed
that will direct the operational managers while taking investment decisions.
For instance, many banks have a clearly defined investment policy that lists
the kind of securities where the surplus cash can be invested. It is advisable to
prescribe the proportion of investments in different securities like
government securities 60%, corporate securities 20%, etc. The firm should
have a clear mechanism to get the risk of the portfolio and this information
should be made available to chief of treasury operations. If the level of
operation is very high, it is worth to implement the concepts like Value-at-
Risk (VAR) to avoid major losses on such transactions.
Activity 6.5
i) Imagine yourself as the finance manager of a leading firm. What are the
basic criteria you would follow in making optimum investment decisions
on a portfolio of securities with the surplus cash available with the firm?
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
…………………………………………………………………………
6.7 SUMMARY
Firms invest surplus cash in marketable securities because it enables firms to
earn a return or at least recover a part of the cost of funds. Since the risk,
return and liquidity of marketable securities are different, an understanding of
them is essential before the selection of securities. An understanding of the
markets in which such securities are traded is also useful. Since firms incur a
cost in buying and selling of securities, the opportunity return needs to be
compared with the cost before deciding the investment decision. There are
different models that enable the managers to optimise the cost and decide the
quantum of investments. What is more important in managing marketable
securities is developing a system that enables the managers not only to take
investment decisions but also monitoring the investments in securities. In the
process of earning an opportunity income, the firms should not incur a loss
by investing wrongly or giving an opportunity for operational managers to
make personal gains. Studying the behaviour of cash flows is important,
before devising a strategy. Each firm should develop its own strategy. The
companies in India have compiled a very rich experience in managing their
cash balances and investing them intelligently in Indian and global securities.
Indian companies are no longer at the receiving end now. They have turned
transnational and are able to dictate global stock markets.
5. What are the advantages and disadvantages of floating rate securities for
both issuer and the investor?
6. What are liquid assets? Why do firms hold cash and cash equivalents?
10. What are the options available to a firm for investing surplus cash?
Discuss strategies that a company employ to gain from the market?
11. Alpha Trading Corporation requires Rs 2.5 mn in cash for meeting its
transaction needs over the next 6 months. It currently has the amount in
the form of marketable securities. The cash payments will be made
evenly over the 6-month planning period. It earns 10% annual yield on
148 the marketable securities. The conversion of marketable securities into
Management of
cash entails a fixed cost of Rs 1200 per transaction. What is the optimal Cash
conversion size as per the Baumol Model?
150
Management of
Exhibit 6.1: Money Market Operations as on May 2, 2022
Cash
(Amount in Crore, Rate in Per cent)
RESERVE POSITION
Source: RBI Press Release on Money Market Operations as on May 02, 2022
153