Cotton B
Cotton B
Cotton B
SaaS BUSINESS
LESSONS LEARNED FROM A TRIO OF
BILLION DOLLAR COMPANIES
• •
BEN COTTON
How to Run a SaaS Business:
Lessons Learned from a Trio of
Billion Dollar Companies
About the Author
Ben is an experienced sales and marketing leader and has worked at category
Ben is a problem solver at heart and is fascinated by the art and science of
sales and marketing. He’s passionate about helping revenue teams grow by
unleashing the power of sales enablement. Over the past decade Ben has
helped many SaaS businesses tackle some of their biggest challenges. Today,
he has a proven track record within the industry of leading and scaling
Ben regularly writes and speaks on the topics of sales enablement, sales and
Amsterdam, Dublin, Helsinki, London and Oslo, as well as online events for
HubSpot, Selling Power, Sales Hacker, InsideSales.com, Sales for Life and
the Sales Management Association.
A global citizen, Ben currently lives in Seattle with his wife and daughter. He
enjoys sampling the occasional craft beer, watching his beloved QPR and
You can find out more about Ben and his thoughts on the SaaS industry, sales
Introduction
Introduction
for the majority of my working life. It's an exciting, innovative and rapidly-
During this time I’ve had the pleasure of working at HubSpot, Indeed.com
Idekoba, Mihir Shuklar and Ankur Kothari are true visionaries and it was a
pleasure to play a part in what they built. They saw the potential of SaaS and
Before I get to that, let’s back up a little. Over the past decade, the SaaS
“software is eating the world” has been proved well and truly right.
The SaaS business model has certain characteristics that makes it extremely
entry - thanks to Amazon Web Services (AWS), Google Cloud and Microsoft
Azure it's easier, quicker and cheaper than ever before to run a SaaS
business.
hastened the move to the cloud, which, in turn, has provided unprecedented
and low cost distribution to SaaS businesses. Software, unlike physical goods
has near infinite scale. For example, the labour and material costs required to
This trifecta of characteristics goes a long way to explaining the allure of the
SaaS industry, but what first drew me to SaaS, was that the customer is at the
I also believe that the SaaS business model is more equitable and offers a
genuine win-win situation. If companies truly put the customer first, they'll be
richly rewarded and can dramatically increase the lifetime value (LTV) of
clients.
businesses with different cultures, products and approaches, but what they
challenging and thrilling journey, and with each passing year I learnt more
share - that’s why I felt compelled to write How to Run a SaaS Business:
nine essays which show you how to approach perennial SaaS challenges,
such as churn, pricing, sales, marketing, unit economics, NPS, strategy and
more.
Lastly, thank you for taking the time to read the book - whether you’re new
to the industry or a SaaS veteran, my hope is that you find the lessons
insightful and that it helps your company grow, succeed and achieve
hypergrowth.
Thanks,
Ben
Essay 1
Rules to Run Your SaaS Business By
I've been working within the software as a service (SaaS) industry for more
than five years now. During this period, I've learnt more than I ever thought
possible about the SaaS business, and my personal growth has accelerated
with each passing year.
Before we dig into the rules, I want to say that in my mind, rules are made to
be broken, and should be thought of more as a guide, template, or guardrail.
My advice is to use them as a starting point of discussion at your business,
rather than follow them blindly.
ч Nf wn-
“The Rule of
40%“ line
S100MM
S2.000MM
S4.000MM
S6.000MM
Й.000ММ
S10.000MM
55x
Put simply, the rule of 3 and 10 means that when a company trebles in size,
everything breaks. The number of employees when things get particularly
troublesome are three, 10, 30, 100, 300 and 1,000 - before company
headcount hits these milestones, you'll need to rethink how you operate. Just
think, the skills and attributes which are required of a marketing leader at a
ten-person company are much different, and indeed could be a potential
weakness at a 1,000 person company.
It may not be immediately apparent, but there are some essential differences
between monthly and annual churn. Allow me to explain. A 5% annual churn
rate means that monthly churn is 0.42%, whereas a 5% monthly churn
equates into a hugely troubling 46% annual churn rate. Or put another way, a
5% monthly churn rate means that if you started January with 100 customers,
you'd only have 54 customers left at the end of December. In order to record
any kind of growth, you'd have to acquire another 47 new customers.
While each industry and company is different, a 5% monthly churn rate isn't
a solid foundation for a SaaS business, and in all honesty, a business in that
situation should seek to ramp up retention and dial down acquisition.
Otherwise, it's literally burning through money. To avoid this situation you
obviously want churn to be as low as possible, but SaaS businesses which
require a 12 month, upfront commitment should aim to keep annual churn
under 7%.
Remember that churn is the silent SaaS killer - often, sales and marketing
receive all the attention and glory, but services are where the predictable
recurring revenue is made and kept. Retention trumps acquisition.
While NPS may lack detail and qualitative data, it does provide an effective
indicator of the health of a client and was widely used at both HubSpot,
Indeed.com, and Automation Anywhere. For those unfamiliar with NPS, its
scoring system means that you're penalised heavily for a poor rating (0-6 are
classified as detractors), receive nothing for mediocre ratings (7-8 are
classified as passives) and are only rewarded for high ratings (9-10 are
classified as promoters).
01 23456789 10
Source: Wootric
What represents a "good" NPS changes between industry and product;
however, you should track your own NPS, as well as conduct research to
track and benchmark key competitors. To build upon my previous point -
churn is really important, and NPS is a metric SaaS business can and should
use to identify customers that are at risk of quitting.
6. Create a discounting process
Discounting tends to be a big challenge within the SaaS industry - it's literally
one of the quickest and easiest ways to maximise or damage revenue
potential. To manage discounting effectively, you need some guiding
principles and a process in place.
For starters, you should always sell on the basis of the value that your product
will create, rather than features or functionality. And if you do find yourself
in a negotiation, it is advisable to take a “give-to-get” approach and request a
greater commitment (more product, multi-year contract, payment upfront) in
return for a discount. You should also have predefined limits about who can
authorise what level of discount - for instance, a sales rep can sanction 5%, a
sales manager 10% and sales director 10%+.
While principles are valuable, you also need a process for sales reps to follow
when entering a negotiation - a clearly defined process ensures that sales reps
avoid discounting at every stage of a deal.
At HubSpot, we rolled out the following discount process. Sales reps explain
to prospects that the first four steps must be completed before a discount can
be discussed:
During my time at HubSpot, there were two frameworks which stood out as
strategic ways to make important decisions. The first is the idea of S Curves -
all products, markets, and business models follow a predictable cycle of
growth, maturity, and decline (the pattern often looks like an "S," hence its
name). After a period of growth, maturation strikes as price competition
emerges, the most attractive customers are acquired, and businesses see
diminishing returns.
Horizon 3
Create viable
options
Horizon 2
Build emerging
businesses
Horizon 1
Extend and defend
core businesses
time (years}
Source: McKinsey
The key point is, you need to have a framework for categorising and
investing in future growth opportunities for your SaaS business.
HubSpot applied its marketing product to the S Curve framework and saw it
was reaching maturation. The tool remains the company's greatest hit, and
what it's best known for, however, it is a high touch sale with a high CAC
and has an increasing number of competitors. In order to create another line
of business while reducing CAC, HubSpot launched sales, CRM, and more
recently, customer service tools.
Importantly, free, low touch versions are available for the marketing, sales
and CRM tools (see image below) - people can test a light version of the
product, see value and then graduate to the paid version.
HubSpot Software Pricing Resources ▼ Partners About
For growing companies of any size. Set the foundation for your business with a free system to build
deeper relationships with contacts, from first interaction to happy customer and beyond.
Source: HubSpot
The beauty of this freemium strategy is that HubSpot can use its free products
to acquire large numbers of users, a percentage of which will be converted
into paying customers at a later date. This approach means HubSpot has a
new source of highly qualified leads at a much lower CAC (in comparison to
other acquisition channels).
Adopting a freemium strategy lowers CAC for several reasons. First up,
while free products require development time and ongoing maintenance, the
potential reach is vast, and products are more scalable than other acquisition
channels, albeit less predictable. Secondly, free users often want to upgrade
"touchlessly" without speaking to a sales rep, and for those that do want to
speak with somebody, they often require fewer sales rep interaction than a
regular sale - both of which reduce CAC and time to sell.
9. Hire for stage fit, not experience
Let’s face it, when you boil it down, most problems are people problems.
Hiring matters. A lot. One of the biggest mistakes a fast-growing SaaS
company can make is hiring for experience over stage fit.
For example, it's not uncommon for a 100 person company fresh off a
funding round to go and hire a VP of Sales from a Fortune 500 company.
While this can work, you need to ensure that you're hiring somebody for their
ability to do the job today - as I said, it can work, but in all likelihood, it's
unlikely a VP at a Fortune 500 company will succeed at a 100 person
company. You need the right people for your company's growth stage.
Halligan adds, "The most important part of the document is probably the
"Omissions" part. These are the projects we are not going to fund this year.
This is how the organisation limits my appetite, so I don't overstuff us." The
key learning here is that's important to have a simple document which spells
out the strategy for the year ahead, plus the initiatives that very deliberately
won't happen. That's how you create alignment and focus.
There you have it. These are the rules I've learnt from my time within the
SaaS industry. HubSpot, Indeed.com, and Automation Anywhere have not
only survived, but thrived during this period and recorded record growth. I'd
love to hear what rules, principles, and truisms you use to lead your SaaS
business. The SaaS industry is still very much in its first act - by sharing this
information, we will uncover new best practices, dispel myths, and define
what good looks like. It's my belief that the best is yet to come from the SaaS
industry, and I'm excited about the second act and beyond.
Essay 2
Understanding the SaaS Business Model
There’s been lots of discussion about the recent downturn in the valuation of
technology businesses and while it’s more helpful to. focus on creating value,
rather than fixating on valuations, how do you understand the health of
software as a service (SaaS) company?
It all starts with understanding the SaaS business model. Unit economics and
specifically, LTV: CAC remains the best indicator. But what are these
acronyms, and why are they important?
LTV: CAC is the lifetime value (LTV) of a customer divided by the customer
acquisition cost (CAC). LTV, as its name suggests, is the total lifetime value
to the business of a customer. Many SaaS businesses are subscription-based
so often the figure is the value of the monthly subscription multiplied by the
average number of months that a company retains a customer.
The customer acquisition cost (CAC) is the costs associated with maintaining
the product, as well as marketing and sales costs. Looking at these numbers
as a ratio helps you understand how effective a business is at making money.
It also helps distinguish the donkeys from the unicorns.
For example, if a subscription for a product costs €1,500 per month and the
average customer remains for 18 months before churning, the LTV of a
customer is €27,000. If the cost of maintaining the product is €300 per month
and the combined sales and marketing costs are €200 per month, CAC will be
€9,000. This would give the company an LTV: CAC of 3:1.
In short, the company generates three euros for every euro spent - this is often
given as an acceptable ratio (a greater one is even better) for a SaaS business.
Once new businesses understand how to attract, retain, and grow customers,
they often look to scale the business by investing in sales, marketing, and
support. This is effectively when businesses go from being a startup to a
scale-up.
It's this accuracy and confidence, which explains why many SaaS businesses
focus on growth and sales, rather than immediate profitability. If a business
has a healthy LTV: CAC and operates in a largely untapped market, the right
play is to pour fuel on the fire and acquire customers quickly, rather than
building slow and posting steady profits.
In Marc Benioff’s book. Behind the Cloud: The Untold Story of How
Salesforce.com Went from Idea to Billion-Dollar Company - and
Revolutionized an Industry, he advises measuring a fast-growing company on
revenue, not profitability. "It's just not appropriate to stress profits over
revenue in the beginning when you are starting out and building a company,"
says Benioff. The fact is many SaaS businesses are selling new products and
creating new markets - getting to market first is important.
For all this talk of ratios and recurring revenue, the real strength of LTV:
CAC is its customer-centricity. It forces companies to focus on the long-term
success of its customers. The leading. SaaS businesses have figured out that
having a product which solves for the customer and provides compounding
value remains the best SaaS growth play.
Essay 3
SaaS Companies Must Invest in Building
Their Brand
Undoubtedly, brand building falls into the “hard to measure” category, but as
we see within the business to consumer (B2C) world, brand is hugely
important. By almost any measure, Coca-Cola, Apple, and Nike, three well-
known and loved companies have crafted successful brands. They’re
extremely valuable too, and research shows meaningful brands outperform
the stock market by 206%.
While the brand is rightly a key focus for B2C marketers, it's often a much
different story when looking at things through a business to business (B2B)
lense. Indeed, B2B marketers risk becoming fixated on what can be measured
at the expense of something that may be the better option. The lesson here is,
just because something is difficult to measure, it doesn't mean that we
shouldn't.
To be clear, I count myself as a data-driven marketer and use data each and
every day to make better decisions. However, I do believe there’s room for
activity that is easily trackable, as well as activity that is hard to quantify. It’s
easy to overlook the fact marketing is both an art and science, and humans,
the very people we’re targeting, are complex, messy and irrational - this is
seldom captured in an analytics dashboard.
That being said, the engineered approach to marketing is on the right path,
but it's too black and white - too binary. I recommend companies take a
blended approach to their marketing bets, so around 80% of marketing
activity and budget is completely trackable, and the other 20% less so. This
provides a spread of activity, and more accurately reflects the realities,
challenges, and nuances of marketing.
What is a brand?
This is a question I ask colleagues, clients, and partners all the time. And, in
truth, it's a philosophical question that reveals a lot when someone answers it.
Is a brand what organisations say, or is it made up of what people think, feel,
and experience? I firmly believe it's the latter.
Someone's view of your brand is the sum of their interactions with your
company at every step. This includes before and during their time as a client,
as well as afterward when this is no longer the case. A brand is a combination
of how you make people feel and what they think of your organisation - and
this all depends on whether or not you stay true to your brand promise.
To borrow a line from Warren Buffet, "A good business is like a castle, and
you've got to think every day, is the management growing the size of the
moat? Or is the moat shrinking?" Building a brand helps create a deeper moat
that can protect your business and capture mindshare.
Here's some free advice. If people have not heard of your brand, they're
unlikely to buy from you immediately. In fact,. 70% of consumers click on a
retailer they know. Instead, you need to create familiarity, credibility, and
trust. It takes time, focus, and money, but when executed well, it results in
people searching for your brand or product online. This is true of all brands,
regardless of industry.
Let’s look at how branding works:
5.
Brand Remarkable
Preference Experience
4.
2.
Delivering
Brand
on the
Recognition
Promise
3.
Moment of
Truth
1. Remarkable experience
Branding starts when a company provides a remarkable experience. It’s easy
to focus too heavily on channels and tactics, but to be successful, the
experience you provide, whether it be an event, social media post, online
advert or ebook, must be remarkable. Indeed, it must be so remarkable that it
creates an emotional connection. This stage is all about building familiarity,
credibility, and trust, but honestly, most brands never get past this stage.
They provide an unremarkable experience that generates unremarkable
results.
2. Brand recognition
If your marketing activity resonates and you manage to establish an
emotional connection, people will be receptive to learning more about your
products or services. This means they will either go directly to your website
having recalled your brand name, or they will use a search engine and search
for an answer to the challenge your product or service solves. The person is
thinking rationally when searching, but when they recognise your brand,
that's when the emotional sparks begin to fly.
3. Moment of truth
The real moment of truth for any marketer is when you persuade somebody
that your products or services are right for them. When somebody makes the
journey from prospect to the customer, it validates that your marketing efforts
are working. When the moment of truth occurs, it is both a left and right brain
decision - people are making a decision based on what they need, plus what
they feel about your brand. Many good businesses get to this stage, build a
repeatable model and are content, but to build a great company and brand,
you need to do more.
5. Brand preference
If a company successfully delivers on all previous steps, especially its brand
promise, it will then earn brand preference from clients. Brand preference is
hard-earned and easily lost, but it is what all marketers aspire to achieve.
Becoming the go-to brand and occupying top spot in a potential client's mind
is what matters. Not many companies reach this stage, but when they do their
brand truly becomes a competitive advantage.
Having a philosophy is easier said than done, but when you have a
philosophy, it becomes easier to articulate a clear point of view that people
can understand and organise themselves around. This is what piques people's
interest and gains attention.
Within the SaaS space, many of the industry’s most successful companies
have had notable and easily understood philosophies, such as
when Salesforce declared war on Siebel Systems and the antiquated world of
on-premise software, as well as HubSpot’s evangelism of inbound marketing
versus the old world of outbound marketing. More recently, Drift’s
#NoForms campaign, which aims at the marketing industry's reliance on
forms is worthy of note too. These disruptive, contrarian philosophies and
easily understood worldviews are how you become memorable and build
brand preference today. You need to stand for something, and it needs to be
remarkable. Being disruptive and contrarian gives people a reason to care and
has the potential to foster a community or movement (which is often bigger
than the company), leading to that all-important emotional connection
between customer and brand.
Many people obsess over being the first to market, but in terms of branding,
this is the wrong approach. While the. first-mover advantage is important, the
real battle is being first in the mind of the customer. It doesn't matter if you're
fifth, fifteenth or fiftieth to market if you're first in the mind of the customer.
That's the coveted, winning spot. But for SaaS companies to earn a place in
the mind of the customer, they need to provide a winning experience.
Over the last decade, we've seen the. consumerization of IT come to the fore,
with enterprise IT products becoming more like consumer ones. Following
the spread of this trend, I believe we're now entering a new period that will
see the consumerization of marketing - where people expect B2B marketing
experiences to be more like B2C ones. The growth of mobile, bots, and
messaging are just three examples of this trend in action.
Once these channels are cranking the next wave of activity will likely focus
on tactics, such as search engine optimization (SEO) and inbound marketing.
This is time-consuming and increasingly competitive work, and will likely
mean doubling down on authority building and content creation. These
activities can be tracked, measured and optimised; which is good, however, it
also means they're now highly efficient tactics, so the opportunity to benefit
from them is diminishing (which is bad, obviously).
When these initial activities are up and running, the regular playbook is for a
SaaS business to start building their brand. This is the third wave of
marketing activity, but it risks brand being merely an afterthought. It's never
too early to start building a brand as it acts as an insurance policy of sorts. To
share a brief example, Indeed.com, my former employer is heavily reliant on
website traffic from both Google AdWords and its search engine.
However, since the launch of Google Jobs, Google has become both a
competitor, as well as an important vendor of Indeed.com. If Google were to
stop accepting AdWords from Indeed.com or update its search algorithm in a
way that negatively impacted Indeed.com, the company would lose a
significant level of website traffic. Thankfully, Indeed.com has been
investing heavily in its brand since 2014 with several campaigns that
increased brand recognition and preference, resulting in more candidates and
employers going directly to its website. A strong brand doesn't just help you
win; it protects you too.
1. Podcasts
Today, podcasting is a genuine marketing arbitrage opportunity. There's
limited competition, and the barriers to entry remain high (you can't
outsource a podcast in the same way as a blog post). While this tactic is
becoming more common among SaaS companies, it remains a tremendous
opportunity for smart marketers to get ahead of their competitors, and
increase the reach of their brand. Podcasts may score high on emotional
connection, but low on tracking, however, they remain a highly effective
tactic to highlight your philosophy and share your point of view with the
world.
2. Books
Despite living in an era of seemingly endless content, we’re now seeing some
SaaS businesses take the unusual step of publishing (physical) books. The act
of reading a book is completely immersive and has the potential to provide a
remarkable experience that creates an emotional connection more easily than
other channels or tactics. From a branding perspective, books are once again
a great way to articulate your philosophy and point of view, although
understanding their impact and exact attribution is tough (however, you
should be comfortable with that reality).
3. Events
Many SaaS companies are turning their back on industry events in favour of
creating their own - this gives them full control over the experience attendees
have. There’s much research to. show just how important experiences are to
today’s consumers, and events, when executed flawlessly, are in my mind the
best way to let people truly experience a brand. Events help build a
community around a brand as they bring together like-minded people to share
an experience.
Every software as a service (SaaS) business that wants to make its mark on
the world must have a plan to hit $100M in annual revenue. Creating a
In reality, there are only three ways to hit this milestone. Businesses can
reach $100M in annual revenue by having:
The segment you target has many important implications. Each has a
different total addressable market (TAM), which subsequently impacts
everything from how much you charge to product functionality to levels of
support you can provide. A customer paying $1K per year will have vastly
different expectations to one that is paying $100K.
Businesses that sell into the mid-market segment include HubSpot, Zendesk,
and Yesware.
Companies selling into the enterprise segment include Eloqua, Marketo, and
Workday.
The outliers
There’s also businesses that have one million customers that are worth $100
each per year and some with 100 customers worth $1M each per year, but
these are the outliers. Creating a successful business aimed at these segments
is difficult. With one million customers you’re likely to be dealing with the
consumer segment, such as Netflix and Spotify and at the other end, creating,
launching and marketing a product that is worth $1M is likely to have high
entry costs and barriers to entry.
One more important point to clarify. While it’s important to have a clear
focus, you also want to make it easy for people to buy more from you and
upgrade. You can and should do this (most SaaS companies offer two or
three versions of their product), but it should not detract from your core
focus. Many of the smartest businesses offer free or freemium versions of
products with reduced functionality. This helps create a flow of future
customers, which upgrade once they have outgrown the free or freemium
solution.
Mapping out how you can see your business attracting $100M in annual
revenue is a simple, but valuable exercise that will impact how you think
about best-fit customers, sales process, product positioning, and customer
service. Completing it will help you understand which segment, whether it be
small, medium, or enterprise-sized businesses you need to target in order to
realise your growth ambitions.
Hitting $100M in annual revenue starts with having a clear focus on the right
segment to target.
Essay 5
Why Your SaaS Business Must Publish its
Pricing
Developing the right pricing strategy for your software as a service (SaaS)
business is absolutely crucial, as it’s the one lever businesses leaders can pull
Given the huge impact pricing strategy can have on a SaaS business, it is
perhaps surprising, alarming even, that 80% of leading SaaS businesses do
not publish their pricing. While that particular study looked at the Montclare
SaaS 250, a list of established SaaS businesses, the same trend appeared
among 386 companies on the AngelList SaaS startups list, which Dharmesh
Shah, HubSpot co-founder, analysed while an improvement and welcome
step in the right direction, just 39% of companies on the AngelList SaaS
startups list have publicly available pricing.
Secondly, and somewhat related to my first point is that SaaS businesses are
fearful of publishing their pricing information. They fear by publishing this
information they are giving up an important edge that a competitor may
leverage against them. But this fear is misplaced - business leaders are often
basing their decision on emotion and fear of the unknown, and defaulting to a
defensive position, rather than considering the advantages of taking the
proactive step to publish pricing.
In the interests of balance, I appreciate there are some legitimate reasons why
a small number of SaaS businesses would not want to make pricing
information available, such as if the product is genuinely bespoke or the types
of deals are long and convoluted and don't lend themselves to clear pricing.
But these are the exception, rather than the rule and not typical of the
majority.
I’m a firm believer that publishing your pricing information will help you sell
more. In the age of mass media and easily available information, there’s little
advantage to be gleaned from hoarding information like price. While that’s
noteworthy, the most pertinent point remains that if you don’t publish your
pricing, you’re leaving money on the table, and no sales organisation wants
that.
Essay 6
The Marketing Arbitrage Opportunity
Without doubt, one of the most exciting parts of being a marketer today is the
perpetual challenge of finding new channels and tactics to leverage. There’s
a whole host of marketing arbitrage opportunities out there - if you know
where to look and spend your time.
Identifying opportunities that we think will create business value is not only a
lot of fun; it's key to driving future growth. For that reason, organisations
need to invest in the discovery and cultivation of such opportunities.
Why is this important? As marketers, we're well acquainted with the standard
playbook of inbound marketing, search engine optimization (SEO), Google
AdWords, pay-per-click (PPC) advertising, email marketing, social media,
and online ads. While these channels and tactics remain effective and help
companies all over the globe to grow, they're in many cases becoming less
impactful. They're working for now, but eventually, they won't. It may not be
next month, year or decade, but eventually, decay will set in. When you
recognise this truth, it becomes clear that marketing leaders need to empower
their teams to explore new channels and tactics. Organisations can either
create a team with this responsibility or structure their business so everyone
feels ownership (something like Google's 20% time, albeit for marketers is an
example of what the latter could look like).
Figuring this out isn't easy - it takes speed, investment, and autonomy, but the
marketing landscape is scattered with examples of businesses moving quickly
when they spy an opportunity with much potential and little competition. We
call this situation, "marketing arbitrage." A marketing arbitrage opportunity is
when marketers identify a channel or tactic with low saturation that they
think will have an oversized impact if they leverage it quickly.
This isn't a new concept, and the world's leading companies are acutely aware
of what happens once a business stops growing. Amazon's Jeff Bezos best
sums it up when he talks about the concept of Day 2:
While Bezos is talking about halting decline at Amazon, the lesson and
warning are applicable to any channel or tactic. Eventually, they all decay.
A brief history of marketing arbitrage
There have been some notable waves of marketing arbitrage over the past 25
years. The very first online ads were served in 1994 by HotWired, and the
clickthrough-rate (CTR) was an incredible 78%. Today, the average CTR on
Facebook ads is 0.9%. Online ads have been through a huge transformation -
they were once a highly effective tactic, but after some initial traction, came
increased competition and in some cases, dubious practices. That started the
decline of online ads, and while the level of sophistication and targeting has
improved, their effectiveness is on the wane and the days of double-digit
CTRs are long gone.
With more competition and diminishing returns, the future of online ads is
uncertain - there's a big question mark over the accuracy of advertising
numbers due to. ad fraud, plus the emergence of ad blocking software.
However, it must be said there are some outstanding companies in this space
that are continually innovating. After all, a well-targeted online ad at exactly
the right moment is to be welcomed, but the reality is there's often a large
gulf between what the marketer and person being served the ad wants.
During this period, we also witnessed the golden era of email marketing.
While a highly tailored email that's based on a behavioural trigger will likely
deliver the best results, it too is becoming less effective as a tactic. Doing
more of something that is having less impact is never an effective strategy -
indeed, it should serve as a wake-up call to organisations to explore
marketing arbitrage opportunities. However, the death of email is overplayed
and is unlikely to be replaced any time soon. There's lots of progress being
made in terms of marketing automation which may herald a second golden
era of email marketing.
Around the same time as content and email marketing came to the fore, we
also saw the rise of AdWords, which enabled companies to buy highly
qualified search traffic. Others soon wised up to the benefits of this channel,
and the average cost of AdWords traffic increased. AdWords is still highly
effective, and many companies have built great businesses off the back of it.
However, it's an increasingly competitive channel - as more people start
buying AdWords, it pushes the price up for everyone. This is especially
worrying if the search volume for your product or service does not increase
accordingly.
It's a different story for Twitter, however. After years of anaemic growth and
an unclear monetisation strategy, it's becoming a less effective channel. Its
audience numbers are falling, and with it, the value it offers brands. The next
wave of social media platforms like Snapchat, plus messaging services, such
as WhatsApp and Facebook Messenger are the current marketing arbitrage
opportunities. Some businesses are making notable progress, but there's no
clear winner yet.
Channels
and Tactics
^—Online Ads
^—Content Marketing
Email Marketing
AdWords
^—MySpace
—Face book
^“Linkedln
—-Hots
^—Messaging
YEAR
Today’s marketing arbitrage opportunities
More recently, podcasting has been a big marketing arbitrage opportunity -
there was limited competition, and the barriers to entry remain high (you can't
outsource a podcast in the same way as a blog post). While this tactic is
becoming somewhat busy, it remains a tremendous opportunity for smart
marketers to steal a march on their competitors and increase the reach of their
brand.
There's also much discussion around messaging and bots, and the intersection
between these technologies. In my mind, they represent the greatest untapped
opportunity today. There's a number of companies investing in both
technologies, and they will likely achieve significant results before decay
starts to sets in. Conversion rate optimization (CRO) is also a big marketing
arbitrage opportunity. This tactic seeks to get more conversions from existing
website traffic or to increase website traffic to high converting parts of a
website.
2
Low Impact Low Impact
Low Saturation High Saturation
LOW HIGH
SATURATION
Marketers should focus primarily on channels and tactics, which have low
saturation and high impact. This is where marketing arbitrage opportunities
will be found. However, it's important to recognise that this matrix is
dynamic and fluid - the channels and tactics may be recategorised as they
grow or decay. This makes speed crucial to leveraging marketing arbitrage
opportunities.
Next up, you should also keep a close eye on channels and tactics which are
characterised as low saturation and low impact. You read that right. This may
seem counterintuitive at first, but allow me to explain. Firstly, if anything
changes and these channels or tactics become more impactful, you want to be
able to respond quickly to take advantage of the emerging opportunity.
Secondly, it’s highly likely you’ll already be well acquainted with the high
impact and high saturation opportunities. The majority of marketers follow
the same playbook and leverage the same channels and tactics. They work
and are highly effective, and that’s why it gets saturated, but you don’t want
to invest extra time here. Lastly, marketers should always avoid channels and
tactics with high saturation and low impact. These are time wasters and will
not provide significant returns.
While channels and tactics evolve, the continual challenge for marketing
teams is to strike a balance between investing in an activity that generates
great results today but also investing in the new and emerging activity, that
will drive future growth.
Essay 7
Never Build a SaaS Sales Team with Just
One Rep
If business leaders want to generate the growth that rockets their software as
a service (SaaS) business to the next level, then at some point, they will need
to build a SaaS sales team. This is true whether they're a new startup, have
recently closed a Series A round or are about to go public.
Hiring two sales reps to build out your sales organisation may seem
expensive, but it will more quickly help you understand your Product/Market
fit, positioning, and best-fit customers. With this information, you can double
down on what works and build repeatable processes to achieve
consistent sales at your startup.
In short, more sales reps help you more quickly understand what works for
your business. Gaining this insight truly is a wise investment that will pay
you back quickly and for a long time.
Essay 8
Building a SaaS Sales and Marketing
Engine
Thankfully, there are a number of marketing strategies available that are both
effective and scalable - meaning they will continue to require the same level
of resources regardless of whether you're delivering 100 or 100,000 leads
each month. Inbound marketing, content marketing, and search engine
optimization (SEO) are three proven approaches to lead generation that you
should consider. After some experimentation, analysis, and optimisation it's
possible to build programmes with these strategies that consistently generate
leads for your business.
However, each are long-term plays and can take time to see results. If
required, you should invest in Google AdWords to top up any shortfall in
leads as a short-term measure. I often see businesses take this blended
approach, to begin with, and then lessen their AdWords spend over time,
while their marketing engine starts to crank to full speed.
Software continues to eat the world
It is several years since Marc Andreessen announced in a seminal WSJ essay
that "software is eating the world," and his thesis has been comprehensively
proved right. Technology, specifically Amazon Web Services, Google Cloud,
Microsoft Azure, and the like have made all this possible. It is now easier and
cheaper to build software than ever before (which has helped create
an efficient market for SaaS products - in fact, too efficient for some
businesses), and with more than 3.5 billion internet users, the potential
market for SaaS products is vast.
Building and launching a product is one thing, but creating something that
people want to use is quite another. A distinct characteristic of SaaS
businesses is they continually provide value by frequently updating their
product and releasing new features, so we, the customers are in effect, always
paying to have the latest version of the software. This is in contrast to how
software used to be purchased and delivered. In the past, most software
products were paid for up-front, often at significant cost, and the customer
used the product until a new one was released. Given this rapidly changing
landscape, it is perhaps unsurprising we've seen software displace hardware
at many companies.
SLAs are critical, but so too are definitions, and you must get everyone in
sales and marketing using a common language quickly. Too many businesses
do not have a clear or well-understood definition of a lead. For example, is a
lead someone who visits your website, completes a form, or speaks with a
sales rep? Definitions matter and without them, confusion seeps in.
What stages should your sales and marketing funnel include? I've already
covered the danger of not defining a lead; however, I often speak with
marketers that have a half-baked process which looks like:
1. Prospect/Visitor
2. Lead
3. Customer
While this is clearly an improvement on having no process or definition, it is
basic and potentially means the marketing team will generate poor fit leads,
and sales will waste time following up with the wrong ones. The above
process fails to provide the detail or nuance sales teams require to be
successful.
To build an effective sales and marketing engine at your SaaS business, you
need a funnel consisting of the following stages:
1. Prospect/Visitor
2. Lead
3. MQL
4. SQL
5. Opportunity
6. Customer
Now let’s dig into what each stage means, who should own it at your
business and metrics to track.
1. Prospect/Visitor
A prospect is someone that visits your website but has not given you any of
their contact details. Despite them not handing over any information, it's easy
to begin tracking the actions a prospect takes on your website using a
marketing software. This information is stored and remains anonymous until
the person becomes a lead by giving you their contact details (often in return
for content or a product). Responsibility for driving prospects and website
visitors is owned by marketing, and they typically have a monthly website
traffic goal.
2. Lead
As mentioned, a person becomes a lead when they complete a form on your
website (at a bare minimum this means they have given you their email
address). Once this happens, a contact record will be created, which contains
contact details, actions they have taken on your website and company
information. Businesses often generate leads by creating offers, such as an
ebook, whitepaper, or webinar, that people must complete a form to access or
by releasing free products. Marketing owns all lead generation efforts and
will have a monthly lead goal.
BDRs are responsible for creating SQLs each month and will be measured on
a number of SQLs they create which are accepted by a sales rep; meetings set
up between a sales rep and lead, as well as total revenue generated.
5. Opportunity
If a sales rep chooses to accept a lead and begin working it, the lead will
become an opportunity (sales reps are often assigned leads based on the
territory, industry or segment they own and are then given a time to work the
lead before it is recycled for other sales reps to work). Sales are responsible
for working opportunities and will have to commit to working a set number
of leads within an agreed timeframe, such as working 100% of leads within
48 hours.
6. Customer
The sixth and final stage is when a lead closes, and they become a customer.
This is what sales teams aspire to do, and what marketing activity helps drive.
The sales organisation will be responsible for hitting a revenue goal each
month - most SaaS businesses focus on revenue, rather than several deals that
a rep closes. Some organisations also have a sales enablement function,
which can be part of sales or marketing that helps sales reps to close deals
through content, deal support, and training.
The first step to righting this wrong is for marketing to get more data-driven
and scientific. You can do this by having a firm grasp of the business metrics
and partnering with business leaders to define the new revenue goal for each
year. Once the new revenue goal is defined, marketing can calculate how
many leads they will need to generate for sales to close to hit (and exceed)
that revenue goal.
If your lead to customer close rate says, 10%, marketing will need to generate
1,000 leads in order to hit 100 customers. In short, understanding these
metrics and how they impact the business is how marketing will truly earn
trust, respect, and credibility of sales and the broader organisation.
The best SaaS businesses figure out their sales and marketing machine early
on. They realise that sales and marketing can be engineered, and the starting
point is clearly articulating each point within the process, who owns it and at
what moment it is handed over. Once you have this foundation in place, it's
time to set goals and optimise different parts of the process. That being said,
the tactics and levers which can impact each stage are in a perpetual state of
evolution, and the most successful SaaS companies continually innovate at
each stage. That's the most effective way for you to build a sales and
marketing engine that gets you ahead of the competition.
Essay 9
Churn is the Quiet SaaS Killer
Need 1 salesperson to grow Need 4 salespeople to grow Need 7 salespeople to grow Need 65 salespeople to grow
11X1111 11111*111tlllll
1111 11111*111111111
111111111111111
111111111*11111
11111X11111
TIME
can sell 5 new cuslomers/month Existing customers И Churned customers New customers
HubSp>6t Research
Source: HubSpot
Retention trumps acquisition
While new client acquisition often captures the attention of business leaders,
in my experience, many companies are taking the wrong approach. They
overestimate the importance of the initial sale and underestimate the
importance of a client’s lifetime value (LTV). Now don’t get me wrong - the
sales organisation plays a vital, absolutely vital role acquiring customers, but
when you have a services organisation that typically retains clients for several
years, you begin to realise that services are where the. recurring revenue and
big money is made.
PrteeintoaigaMly (aPncelntel
Source: ProfitWell
We've covered why high churn is undesirable, but let's turn our attention to
why low churn is important and what it means for a SaaS business.
Essentially, if you're acquiring customers, and the rate at which they buy
more is greater than the revenue lost from the churn, then you've built a
highly desirable business. A business that doesn't have to sell anything new,
but still grows is the holy grail of SaaS.
The key takeaway is to. make tackling churn a priority early on, rather than
reacting after the event.
Calculating churn
As I hope you'll agree by now, churn matters and understanding how it's
calculated is really important. It may not be immediately apparent, but there
are some important differences between monthly and annual churn. Allow me
to explain. A 5% annual churn rate means that monthly churn is 0.42%,
whereas a 5% monthly churn equates into a hugely troubling 46% annual
churn rate. Or put another way, a 5% monthly churn rate means that if you
started January with 100 customers, you'd only have 54 customers left at the
end of December. In order to record any kind of growth, you'd have to
acquire another 47 new customers. Just think back to the leaky bucket again.
While each industry and company is different, a 5% monthly churn rate isn't
a solid foundation for a SaaS business, and in all honesty, a business in that
situation should seek to ramp up retention and dial down acquisition.
Otherwise, it’s burning through money. High churn becomes even more
troublesome if you have a limited total addressable market (TAM) and you’re
capturing it quickly - when businesses acquire customers and then lose them,
it’s very difficult to re-win their trust and business at a later date.
SaaS businesses have unique characteristics, which means it makes sense for
them to be measured differently. They typically incur high up-front costs to
deliver products and acquire customers but follow the path to profitability by
retaining and adding customers over time, many of whom upgrade or buy
more. SaaS businesses often operate on a subscription basis, so monthly or
yearly subscription value is low, but lifetime value is high. This makes
retention and keeping a handle on churn absolutely vital.
Seemingly small improvements can have a dramatic impact on the health and
success of a SaaS company.
While NPS may lack detail and qualitative data, it does provide an effective
indicator of the health of a client and if they’re a churn risk. For those
unfamiliar with NPS, its scoring system means that you’re penalised heavily
for a poor rating (0-6 are classified as detractors), receive nothing for
mediocre ratings (7-8 are classified as passives) and are only rewarded for
high ratings (9-10 are classified as promoters).
01 23456789 10
Source: Wootric
What represents a "good" NPS changes between industry and product;
however, you should track your own NPS, as well as conduct research to
track and benchmark key competitors.
For SaaS businesses to turn a profit, they need clients to succeed and
continue paying for their products over a long period of time. This is what
increases LTV, retention, and recurring revenue. By investing in customer
success teams to provide strategic guidance, account management, and
support, businesses are well placed to reduce churn and increase spend per
client. Customer success is a vital cog in the SaaS sales engine - it has the
potential to generate considerably more recurring revenue than the original
sale.
Strategies to help SaaS companies reduce churn
Based on my experiences at HubSpot, Indeed.com, and Automation
Anywhere, I've identified five high impact strategies to lower churn:
The graph below shows that customer retention is closely tied to the number
of integrations they have - in fact, just one integration has a significant impact
on retention.
Source: ProfitWell
Integrations are an important weapon in your armour as they give your clients
more ways and reasons to use your product - this typically leads to higher
usage, which creates more value and often equates to greater retention.
You can get started with optimising your qualification process by looking at
the profile of successful customers and unsuccessful ones. Depending on
what you uncover it could lead you to take action such as, focussing on
targeted accounts like the Fortune 1000, or refining your value proposition.
This could mean moving away from being perceived as a money-saving
product to one that helps companies make money or increases productivity. It
could also lead you to target people in specific job roles or moving from mid
market to enterprise-sized companies.
The key learning here is to recognise that your qualification process needs to
be in a continual state of optimisation. There’s no guarantee what worked
yesterday will continue to work in the future. You need to understand who
wins (and loses) with your product.
Source: ProfitWell
SaaS businesses have two options when it comes to increasing ARPU - they
can either upsell, meaning to sell more of the same product, a higher value
plan or add-ons. The second way to increase ARPU is by cross-selling, which
is to sell a suite of different products to the customer.
Probability of selling
to an existing customer
It’s hard to prescribe exactly what the right red flag metrics will be, (although
ZOKRI lists 16 in this blog post) - instead, you should look at customers that
have churned and identify trends between them. Then it’s time to act. You
need to invest time in both the discovery and then running programmes to
defend against red flag metrics.
Companies with a higher percentage of annual contracts lends to see much lower churn than their • Q4 = 25TH PERCENTILE
monthly counterparts, because these customers have 1 purchasing decision per year, as opposed to 12. у = -0 0152X * 01JM
20%
18%
* 16*
=
и
£ 12%
| Ю% 6 10.40%
S
> 8* ( ) 8 .064 6 a.ts%
5 6% S£J%
О
5 4%
1S9%
2%
0%
0% .01%TOX)% 1001% TO 2S% 2 SO'% TO 50% 50.01% TO 7S% 7S 01% TO 100%
CLICK TO SHARE m
Brought li
Source: ProfitWell
While this is an effective approach, it obviously needs to be acceptable within
your market. The good news is that as SaaS companies grow, there's often a
move towards enterprise clients, which typically means larger ACV, as well
as switching from monthly billing to annual or multi-year. The chart below
shows that products with smaller ACV tend to be on monthly contracts, and
larger ACV products have multi-year deals.
Although, customer success teams speak with clients day in, day out,
increasing retention really is a team sport - each and every employee has an
important part to play. The best and indeed, the only way to retain clients for
the long term is to provide value continually. Like a lot of important lessons,
it's easier said than done, but the leading SaaS companies of today and
tomorrow understand that retention is the new frontier of growth. How is
your business tackling the twin challenges of reducing churn and increasing
the value it provides? The time to act was yesterday.
Final Thoughts
I hope that you found How to Run a SaaS Business: Lessons Learned from a
Trio of Billion Dollar Companies a valuable use of your time, and that it
book contains the key lessons I’ve learnt, the most important lesson is to
has its own dynamics and is heavily nuanced - there’s no silver bullet, “hack”
While tactics, strategies and approaches are in a constant state of flux, the
product which solves for the customer and provides compounding value
The SaaS industry is still very much in its first act and it’s my belief that the
best is yet to come - I’m truly excited about the second act and beyond.