Nothing Special   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

Fea n6 14 in Fea

Download as pdf or txt
Download as pdf or txt
You are on page 1of 31

NozzlePRO v2023.05.

1192 Output Report


Title:

Client:

Contract:

Engineer:

Date: Tuesday, 12 September 2023 1:16 PM

Description:

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 1 of 31
Table of Contents

1. Job: N6 14IN.nozzlepro ........................................ 1


Table of Contents ................................................... 2

(a) Elastic Analysis

- Stress Summary ....................................................... 4

- Load Case Report ..................................................... 5

- Text Reports ......................................................... 6

* Model Notes ............................................................. 6

* Job Title ............................................................... 8

* Solution Data ........................................................... 9

* Region Data ............................................................. 10

* Stress Results - Notes .................................................. 15

* Compressive Stress Summary .............................................. 16

- Stress Results [Max. 93%] ............................................ 17

* All Stress Results [Max. 93%] ........................................... 17

* Primary Stresses [Max. 93%] ............................................. 19

* Secondary Stresses [Max. 93%] ........................................... 20

* Peak Stresses [Max. 63%] ................................................ 21

- Fatigue Results ...................................................... 22

- Allowable Loads ...................................................... 23

- Stress Intensification Factors ....................................... 24

- Sustained Stress Indices ............................................. 24

- Stiffness and Flexibility Factors .................................... 24

- 3D Geometry Plots

* Thickness Profile ....................................................... 25

* Primary Stresses [Max. 93%]

1. Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] Case 2 [Max. 93%] ............................... 26

2. Qb < SPS Case 2 [Max. 66%] ......................................... 26

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 2 of 31
3. S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) Case 2 [Max. 47%] ................................ 27

* Secondary Stresses [Max. 93%]

1. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [In] Case 2 [Max.79%] ................................ 28

2. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [Out] Case 2 [Max.93%] ............................... 28

3. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [In] Case 3 [Max.74%] ................................ 29

4. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [Out] Case 3 [Max.92%] ............................... 29

* Range Stresses [Max. 92%]

1. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [In] Case 4 [Max.74%] ................................ 30

2. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [Out] Case 4 [Max.92%] ............................... 30

* Peak Stresses [Max. 63%]

1. Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa Case 4 [Max. 37%] .................................. 31

2. Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa Case 4 [Max. 63%] .................................. 31

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 3 of 31
Stress Summary
STRESS SUMMARY - PASSED
-----------------------

Date: 12/09/2023 1:15 PM


Filename: N6 14IN.nozzlepro
Stress Units: [MPa]

ASME STRESS CHECK - PASSED


--------------------------

Highest Primary Stress - PASSED


-------------------------------
Load Case : 2
Load Case Description : SUSTAINED [W+P]
ASME/EN Category : Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0]
Stress Ratio [%] : 93.263
Stress : 192.9
Allowable Stress : 206.8

Highest Secondary Stress - PASSED


---------------------------------
Load Case : 2
Load Case Description : SUSTAINED [W+P]
ASME/EN Category : Pl+Pb+Q < SPS
Stress Ratio [%] : 92.732
Stress : 383.6
Allowable Stress : 413.7

Highest Range Stress - PASSED


-----------------------------
Load Case : 4
Load Case Description : RANGE [Case 3 - Case 1] (Fatigue Performed)
ASME/EN Category : Pl+Pb+Q < SPS
Stress Ratio [%] : 91.552
Stress : 378.7
Allowable Stress : 413.7

Highest Peak Stress - PASSED


----------------------------
Load Case : 4
Load Case Description : RANGE [Case 3 - Case 1] (Fatigue Performed)
ASME/EN Category : Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa
Stress Ratio [%] : 62.648
Stress : 511.3
Allowable Stress : 816.2

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 4 of 31
Load Case Report
1. SUSTAINED [W]
2. SUSTAINED [W+P]
3. OPERATING [P+Fope]
4. RANGE [Case 3 - Case 1] (Fatigue Performed)
5. PROGRAM GENERATED -- FORCE ONLY [F] (Fatigue Performed)
6. PROGRAM GENERATED -- FORCE ONLY [F] (Fatigue Performed)
7. PROGRAM GENERATED -- FORCE ONLY [F] (Fatigue Performed)
8. PROGRAM GENERATED -- FORCE ONLY [F] (Fatigue Performed)
9. PROGRAM GENERATED -- FORCE ONLY [P] (Fatigue Performed)

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 5 of 31
Text Reports
Model Notes
Model Notes

Input Echo:

Model Type : Dished Head

Parent Geometry
Parent Outside Diam. : 3206.800 mm.
Thickness : 13.400 mm.
Inside Crown Radius : 2862.000 mm.
Inside Knuckle Radius : 540.600 mm.
Straight Flange Length : 50.000 mm.
Attached Shell Length : 8200.000 mm.
Attached Shell Thick : 18.000 mm.
Shell Weld Length : 10.000 mm.
Shell SCF/FSRF : 1.350

Parent Properties:
Cold Allowable : 137.9 MPa
Hot Allowable : 137.9 MPa
Material DB # 1097822.
Ultimate Tensile (Amb) : 517.1 MPa
Yield Strength (Amb) : 206.8 MPa
Yield Strength (Hot) : 184.8 MPa
Elastic Modulus (Amb) : 195135.0 MPa
Poissons Ratio : 0.300
Expansion Coefficient : 0.1583E-04 mm./mm./deg.
Weight Density : 0.0000E+00 N /cu.mm.(NOT USED)

Nozzle Geometry
Nozzle Reinforced OD : 455.600 mm.
Reinforced Thickness : 60.000 mm.
Reinforced Length : 50.000 mm.
Transition Length : 50.500 mm.
Neck OD : 355.600 mm.
Neck Thickness : 10.000 mm.
Neck Length : 546.500 mm.
Nozzle Weld Length : 10.000 mm.
Nozzle SCF/FSRF : 1.350
Location perpendicular
to the head centerline : 892.000 mm.

Nozzle Tilt Angle : 0.000 deg.

Nozzle Properties
Cold Allowable : 137.9 MPa
Hot Allowable : 134.5 MPa
Material DB # 1089222.
Ultimate Tensile (Amb) : 482.6 MPa
Yield Strength (Amb) : 206.8 MPa
Yield Strength (Hot) : 184.8 MPa
Elastic Modulus (Amb) : 195135.0 MPa
Poissons Ratio : 0.300
Expansion Coefficient : 0.1583E-04 mm./mm./deg.
Weight Density : 0.0000E+00 N /cu.mm. (NOT USED)

Design Operating Cycles : 7000.


Ambient Temperature (Deg.) : 21.10

Uniform thermal expansion produces no stress in this geometry.


Any thermal loads will come through operating forces and
moments applied through the nozzle.

Nozzle Inside Temperature : 65.00 deg.


Nozzle Outside Temperature : 65.00 deg.
Vessel Inside Temperature : 65.00 deg.

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 6 of 31
Vessel Outside Temperature : 65.00 deg.

Nozzle Pressure : 1.140 MPa


Vessel Pressure : 1.140 MPa

User Defined Load Input Echo for the ATTACHMENT:


Loads are given at the Nozzle/Header Junction
Loads are defined in Local Coordinatesc

Forces( N ) Moments (N-m)

Load Case FX FY FZ MX MY MZ
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
OPER: 19600.0 19600.0 14700.0 20600.0 13700.0 17800.0

FEA Model Loads:


These are the actual Attachment loads applied to
the FEA model.
These are the User Defined Loads translated to the
end of the nozzle and reported in global coordinates.

Forces( N ) Moments (N-m)

Load Case FX FY FZ MX MY MZ
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
OPER: 19600.0 -24253.8 3464.8 20600.0 -20032.1 12793.0

Stresses ARE nodally AVERAGED.

Vessel Centerline Vector: 1.000 0.000 0.000


Nozzle Centerline Vector: 1.000 0.000 0.000
Zero Degree Orientation Vector: 0.000 1.000 0.000

Nozzle Orientation Angle :135.000

Adjusted the reinforced nozzle section because it wasn't


long enough to let a normal section clear upper surface of
the parent and the weld. The old length was 50.000 mm.,
and the new length is 123.643 mm. .

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 7 of 31
Job Title
Paulin Research Group
FE/Pipe Version 15.0
Released Jan. 2021

Jobname:

Date/Time of Analysis: SEP 12,2023 1:13pm


Template Name: Nozzles/Plates/Shells

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 8 of 31
Solution Data
FEPipe Version 2023.5.0.1192 Jobname: NOZZLE
Released May. 2023 1:14pm SEP 12,2023

Solution Data

Maximum Solution Row Size = 1128


Number of Nodes = 4909
Number of Elements = 1644
Number of Solution Cases = 8

Summation of Loads per Case

Case # FX FY FZ

1 0. 0. 0.
2 9130627. 1. -1.
3 9150227. -24299. 3464.
4 1497184. 0. 0.
5 0. 0. 0.
6 0. 0. 0.
7 0. 0. 0.
8 9130627. 1. -1.

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 9 of 31
Region Data
FEPipe Version 2023.5.0.1192 Jobname: NOZZLE
Released May. 2023 1:15pm SEP 12,2023

Region Data 35:15:13 12 Sep 2023

Shell Next to Nozzle 1

Material Name = SA-240304LN 18Cr-8Ni-N Plate


Material ID ............. 1097822
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 138. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.
Stress Concentration ..... 1.350

Nozzle 1 Next to Shell

Material Name = SA-182F304 18Cr-8Ni Forgings


Material ID ............. 1089222
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 134. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.
Stress Concentration ..... 1.350

Shell Next to Nozzle 1 Pad

Material Name = SA-240304LN 18Cr-8Ni-N Plate


Material ID ............. 1097822

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 10 of 31
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 138. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.
Stress Concentration ..... 1.350

NOT USED

Material Name = SA-182F304 18Cr-8Ni Forgings


Material ID ............. 1089222
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 134. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.
Stress Concentration ..... 1.350

Nozzle 1 Pad Weld Area

Material Name = SA-240304LN 18Cr-8Ni-N Plate


Material ID ............. 1097822
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 138. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 11 of 31
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.
Stress Concentration ..... 1.350

Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity

Material Name = SA-240304LN 18Cr-8Ni-N Plate


Material ID ............. 1097822
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 138. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.
Stress Concentration ..... 1.000

Nozzle 1 Transition Area

Material Name = SA-182F304 18Cr-8Ni Forgings


Material ID ............. 1089222
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 134. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.
Stress Concentration ..... 1.000

Nozzle 1 Barrel Section

Material Name = SA-182F304 18Cr-8Ni Forgings


Material ID ............. 1089222
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 134. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 12 of 31
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.
Stress Concentration ..... 1.000

Nozzle 1

Material Name = SA-182F304 18Cr-8Ni Forgings


Material ID ............. 1089222
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 134. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.
Stress Concentration ..... 1.000

Pad at Nozzle 1

Material Name = SA-240304LN 18Cr-8Ni-N Plate


Material ID ............. 1097822
Cold Allowable ........... 138. MPa
Cold Elasic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Cold Yield Stress ........ 207. MPa
Hot Allowable @ 21 deg .. 138. MPa
Hot Yield Stress ......... 185. MPa
Hot Elastic Modulus ...... 195000. MPa
Case 2
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 3
Pressure Stress (Pd/2t) .. 136. MPa
Case 5
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 6
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 7
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 8
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 138. MPa
Case 9
Nominal Stress (M/Z) ... 136. MPa
Smallest Thickness ....... 10.000 mm.

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 13 of 31
Stress Concentration ..... 1.350

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 14 of 31
Stress Results - Notes
FEPipe Version 2023.5.0.1192 Jobname: NOZZLE
Released May. 2023 1:15pm SEP 12,2023

Stress Results - Notes

- Results in this analysis were generated using the finite


element solution method.

- Using 2019-2021 ASME Section VIII Division 2

- Use Polished Bar fatigue curve.

- Ratio between Operating and Design Pressure = 1.000000


Range cases use operating pressure. Primary cases
use design pressure.

- Assume free end displacements of attached pipe


(e.g. thermal loads) are secondary loads.

- Primary bending stresses at discontinuities


are treated like secondary stresses. (Pb=0)

- Use Equivalent Stress (Von Mises).

- TRIAXIAL Stress Guidelines:


S1+S2+S3 evaluation omitted from operating stress.
Include S1+S2+S3 evaluation in primary case evaluation.
Bending stress NOT included for all S1+S2+S3 calculations.

- Use local tensor values for averaged and not averaged stresses.

- Pressure axial force on nozzles computed using nozzle mean diameter.

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 15 of 31
Compressive Stress Summary
FEPipe Version 2023.5.0.1192 Jobname: NOZZLE
Released May. 2023 1:15pm SEP 12,2023

Compressive Stress Summary (MPa) 35:15:13 12 Sep 2023

Nomenclature:
-------------
Min Stress - Compressive Membrane and Bending Stress
Pts in Region - No. of nodes in the model region
>5% Compression - 5% of pts above Compressive Limit
>50% Compression - 50% of pts above Compressive Limit

Compressive Stress Limit = -0.55 Min(Sy, kEt/R), Section


slenderness ratio (elastic buckling) not considered.
>5% >50%
Min Pts Compression
# Load Type Case Stress in Region and Bending Region
-- --------- ---- ------ ---------- ------------ ----------------
1 SUSTAINED 2 -11. 558 94% 54% Nozzle 1 Next to Shel
2 OPERATING 3 -11. 558 93% 52% Nozzle 1 Next to Shel
3 EXPANSION 4 -11. 558 93% 52% Nozzle 1 Next to Shel
4 SUSTAINED 2 -5. 300 12% 0% Shell Next to Nozzle
5 OPERATING 3 -3. 300 28% 0% Shell Next to Nozzle

6 EXPANSION 4 -3. 300 28% 0% Shell Next to Nozzle


7 SUSTAINED 2 -119. 660 14% 2% Shell In Nozzle 1 Vic
8 OPERATING 3 -115. 660 11% 2% Shell In Nozzle 1 Vic
9 EXPANSION 4 -115. 660 11% 2% Shell In Nozzle 1 Vic
10 SUSTAINED 2 -38. 666 97% 87% Nozzle 1 Transition A

11 OPERATING 3 -41. 666 97% 87% Nozzle 1 Transition A


12 EXPANSION 4 -41. 666 97% 87% Nozzle 1 Transition A
13 SUSTAINED 2 -1. 1272 63% 60% Nozzle 1
14 OPERATING 3 -23. 1272 79% 69% Nozzle 1
15 EXPANSION 4 -23. 1272 79% 69% Nozzle 1

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 16 of 31
Stress Results [Max. 93%]
All Stress Results [Max. 93%]
Location ASME/EN Stress Allowable %
Category [MPa] [MPa] Allowable

Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 80.2 201.7 39.752
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 40.7 408.6 9.970
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 88.2 408.6 21.575
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 78.3 408.6 19.166
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 77.4 538.0 14.379
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 98.5 408.6 24.106
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 90.7 408.6 22.209
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 98.5 408.6 24.106
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 90.7 408.6 22.209
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 133.0 816.2 16.292
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 122.5 816.2 15.010
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 130.9 206.8 63.271
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 272.1 413.7 65.765
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 176.3 413.7 42.612
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 383.6 413.7 92.732
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 261.3 551.6 47.377
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 189.2 413.7 45.735
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 378.7 413.7 91.552
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 189.2 413.7 45.735
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 378.7 413.7 91.552
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 255.4 816.2 31.296
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 511.3 816.2 62.648
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 192.9 206.8 93.263
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 216.0 413.7 52.209
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 325.6 413.7 78.694
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 330.9 413.7 79.974
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 261.2 551.6 47.346
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 305.2 413.7 73.781
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 251.5 413.7 60.795
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 305.2 413.7 73.781
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 251.5 413.7 60.795
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 305.2 816.2 37.398
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 251.5 816.2 30.816
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 33.1 201.7 16.391
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 52.8 408.6 12.927
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 74.4 408.6 18.206
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 47.3 408.6 11.565
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 21.9 538.0 4.072
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 77.6 408.6 18.999
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 55.7 408.6 13.622
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 77.6 408.6 18.999
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 55.7 408.6 13.622
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 77.6 816.2 9.512
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 55.7 816.2 6.820
Nozzle 1 [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 19.4 201.7 9.620
Nozzle 1 [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 15.0 408.6 3.681
Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 21.2 408.6 5.190
Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 26.6 408.6 6.510
Nozzle 1 [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 34.5 538.0 6.420
Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 42.0 408.6 10.283
Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 41.9 408.6 10.259

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 17 of 31
Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 42.0 408.6 10.283
Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 41.9 408.6 10.259
Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 42.0 816.2 5.148
Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 41.9 816.2 5.136

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 18 of 31
Primary Stresses [Max. 93%]
Location ASME/EN Stress Allowable %
Category [MPa] [MPa] Allowable

Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 80.2 201.7 39.752
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 40.7 408.6 9.970
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 77.4 538.0 14.379
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 130.9 206.8 63.271
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 272.1 413.7 65.765
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 261.3 551.6 47.377
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 192.9 206.8 93.263
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 216.0 413.7 52.209
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 261.2 551.6 47.346
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 33.1 201.7 16.391
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 52.8 408.6 12.927
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 21.9 538.0 4.072
Nozzle 1 [Mean] (Case 2) Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] 19.4 201.7 9.620
Nozzle 1 [Bending] (Case 2) Qb < SPS 15.0 408.6 3.681
Nozzle 1 [Min. Principal] (Case 2) S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) 34.5 538.0 6.420

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 19 of 31
Secondary Stresses [Max. 93%]
Location ASME/EN Stress Allowable %
Category [MPa] [MPa] Allowable

Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 88.2 408.6 21.575
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 78.3 408.6 19.166
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 98.5 408.6 24.106
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 90.7 408.6 22.209
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 176.3 413.7 42.612
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 383.6 413.7 92.732
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 189.2 413.7 45.735
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 378.7 413.7 91.552
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 325.6 413.7 78.694
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 330.9 413.7 79.974
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 305.2 413.7 73.781
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 251.5 413.7 60.795
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 74.4 408.6 18.206
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 47.3 408.6 11.565
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 77.6 408.6 18.999
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 55.7 408.6 13.622
Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 21.2 408.6 5.190
Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 2) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 26.6 408.6 6.510
Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 42.0 408.6 10.283
Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 3) Pl+Pb+Q < SPS 41.9 408.6 10.259

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 20 of 31
Peak Stresses [Max. 63%]
Location ASME/EN Stress Allowable %
Category [MPa] [MPa] Allowable

Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 133.0 816.2 16.292
Nozzle 1 Next to Shell [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 122.5 816.2 15.010
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 255.4 816.2 31.296
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 511.3 816.2 62.648
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 305.2 816.2 37.398
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 251.5 816.2 30.816
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 77.6 816.2 9.512
Nozzle 1 Transition Area [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 55.7 816.2 6.820
Nozzle 1 [In] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 42.0 816.2 5.148
Nozzle 1 [Out] (Case 4) Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa 41.9 816.2 5.136

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 21 of 31
Fatigue Results
Stress ASME BS WRC WRC WRC
Location 5500 474 474 474
Avg 99% 95%
Failure Cycles Cycles

Nozzle 1 Next to Shell (Case 4) 1.000E+011 384,294 1.560E+006 362,349 503,076


Nozzle 1 Next to Shell (Case 4) 1.000E+011 491,426 2.015E+006 468,150 649,967
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 (Case 4) 925,097 115,064 603,155 140,118 194,537
Shell Next to Nozzle 1 (Case 4) 36,393 14,344 71,505 16,611 23,063
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity (Case 4) 332,806 27,406 134,221 31,181 43,291
Shell In Nozzle 1 Vicinity (Case 4) 1.017E+006 48,987 243,834 56,645 78,644
Nozzle 1 Transition Area (Case 4) 1.000E+011 1.176E+006 5.120E+006 1.189E+006 1.651E+006
Nozzle 1 Transition Area (Case 4) 1.000E+011 3.191E+006 1.563E+007 3.632E+006 5.042E+006
Nozzle 1 (Case 4) 1.000E+011 1.102E+007 7.774E+007 1.806E+007 2.507E+007
Nozzle 1 (Case 4) 1.000E+011 1.115E+007 7.932E+007 1.843E+007 2.558E+007

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 22 of 31
Allowable Loads
Direction Max. Conservative Realistic
Individual Simultaneous Simultaneous
Occurring

Primary Axial [N] 353928 8575 12862


Primary Inplane [N-mm] 45050402 771769 1637170
Primary Outplane [N-mm] 51106118 875511 1857240
Primary Torsion [N-mm] 152909653 3704578 5556866
Primary Pressure [MPa] 1 1 1

Secondary Axial [N] 353928 8575 12862


Secondary Inplane [N-mm] 45050402 771769 1637170
Secondary Outplane [N-mm] 51106118 875511 1857240
Secondary Torsion [N-mm] 152909653 3704578 5556866
Secondary Pressure [MPa] 1 1 1

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 23 of 31
Stress Intensification Factors
Direction FEA FEA FEA
Peak Primary Secondary

Inplane (ii) 5.656 4.190 8.379


Outplane (io) 4.986 3.693 7.386
Torsion (it) 1.666 1.234 2.469
Axial (ia) 8.566 6.345 12.691
Pressure (ip) 1.898 1.414 2.812

Sustained Stress Indices


Direction PRG ASME
Recommended B31J-2017

Inplane (Ii) 1.781 2.378


Outplane (Io) 1.447 2.233
Torsion (It) 1.291 1.291
Axial (Ia) 1.639 1.000
Pressure (Ip) 1.159 -

Stiffness and Flexibility Factors


Direction Stiffness k-factor
[Unitless]

Axial [N/mm] 147659.4 2.497


Inplane [mm.N/deg.] 130644944.1 12.229
Outplane [mm.N/deg.] 133967574.0 11.926
Torsion [mm.N/deg.] 1815620318.3 0.880

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 24 of 31
3D Geometry Plots

Thickness Profile

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 25 of 31
Primary Stresses

1. Pl+Pb < SPL [Pb=0] Case 2 [Max. 93%]

2. Qb < SPS Case 2 [Max. 66%]

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 26 of 31
3. S1+S2+S3<4S (SUS) Case 2 [Max. 47%]

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 27 of 31
Secondary Stresses

1. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [In] Case 2 [Max.79%]

2. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [Out] Case 2 [Max.93%]

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 28 of 31
3. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [In] Case 3 [Max.74%]

4. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [Out] Case 3 [Max.92%]

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 29 of 31
Range Stresses

1. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [In] Case 4 [Max.74%]

2. Pl+Pb+Q < SPS [Out] Case 4 [Max.92%]

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 30 of 31
Peak Stresses

1. Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa Case 4 [Max. 37%]

2. Pl+Pb+Q+F < 2Sa Case 4 [Max. 63%]

MiMOut v2023.5.0.1192 31 of 31

You might also like