Post Neoliberalism Free Market and Disil
Post Neoliberalism Free Market and Disil
Post Neoliberalism Free Market and Disil
com/howtoshare)
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
Contents
Introduction ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������� 7
Gül Kurtuluş
Memory, Gender and Innovation in Caryl Churchill’s Cloud Nine: The
Brechtian Legacy in the Postmodern Theatre ����������������������������������������������������� 31
Mesut Günenç
Deciphering Postdramatic Tragedy in Sarah Kane’s Phaedra’s Love ����������������� 49
Mustafa Bal
Apocalypse In-Yer-Face: Mark Ravenhill’s Faust Is Dead ���������������������������������� 77
Özlem Karadağ
Becoming Human/oid: A Posthumanist Critique of Thomas Eccleshare’s
Instructions for Correct Assembly ��������������������������������������������������������������������������� 95
Hakan Gültekin
Post-Neoliberalism, Free Market and Disillusionment: Anders Lustgarten’s
If You Don’t Let Us Dream, We Won’t Let You Sleep ������������������������������������������������� 115
Pelin Doğan
“An International Crossroads of Female Pain�” Intersectional
Feminism: Jackie Kay’s Chiaroscuro �������������������������������������������������������������������� 129
Hakan Gültekin
Introduction
This chapter sets out to explore the significance of post-neoliberalism in
Anders Lustgarten’s If You Don’t Let Us Dream, We Won’t Let You Sleep (2013)�
Acknowledging that any literary production cannot be examined without con-
sidering a bigger and more complex social structure, the study attempts to find
out about the dialectical relationship between Lustgarten’s play and the society
in which the characters live� Anders Lustgarten is regarded in Britain as the most
exciting political playwright of recent years� He won both The inaugural Harold
Pinter Playwright’s Award and The Catherine Johnson Award with the play this
chapter examines� Lustgarten depicts society from the standpoint of corrup-
tion, decadence and hopelessness� His play Lampedusa, staged in 2015, mainly
revolves around the migrant crisis� A Day at the Racists tells the story of betrayal
to the working class in Britain�
Post-neoliberalism is a relational perspective on governance that emerged
after the 2008 global financial crisis� Post-neoliberalism is also a concept given
to a period on which a global climate crisis affected the whole world and vital
resources were crudely consumed� Most importantly, the post-neoliberal era has
been built on serious political disappointments fuelled by neoliberal policies� In
the play set in a dystopian UK, the business representatives decide that the finan-
cially burdensome culture of addiction must be eliminated� For this purpose,
the state invents “Unity Bonds,” a tool that will generate returns if the number
of people committing crimes to the investor or taking drug treatment drops to a
certain level� Thus, the state wants to shift the cost of social repair to the private
sector� The play takes place in a dystopian universe in which free market princi-
ples dominate every area of society, and the basic rights of citizens such as health,
education and housing are commodified, the basic principle of neoliberalism,
dominates every area of society, and the basic rights of citizens such as health,
education and housing are commodified� Using close reading method, this study
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
deals with the analysis of the interactive arrangements between the play and its
socio-political context�
The impetus behind this study is to investigate the ways in which Anders
Lustgarten critiques the post-neoliberal era which destroys the foundational
values of the western society and the social consensus lying in its base by deep-
ening the economic and social injustices�
criticism of neoliberalism’s argument that free markets would bring peace and
tranquillity� On the other hand, the biggest and most important crisis of the new
millennium is the 2008 global financial crisis� In the end of the first decade of the
2000s, a market crisis originating in the USA emerged and after the crisis that
sharpened in 2008, the stability of finance-centred accumulation was tried to be
restored with state interventions� After the 2008 crisis, the state’s interventions in
the market, which is claimed to be managed by an “invisible hand” in the neolib-
eral order, herald the end of neoliberalism and the beginning of a new era� This
marks the beginning of the post-neoliberal era in economic and political circles�
Post-neoliberalism presents a relational perspective on governmentality in the
context of a post-global present of climate change, resource exhaustion, and dis-
illusionment with neoliberal reforms�7 After the 2008 Global Economic crisis, it
became clear that neoliberalism fell short of preventing the contradictions posed
by its own practices�
With the limits of crisis management in neoliberalism, different proposals
and strategies have come to the fore� Different rules and strategies developed to
overcome the crisis of neoliberal financial market capitalism have been discussed
under the concept of post-neoliberalism� From this point of view, post-neolib-
eralism is both a set of rules, an ideological attitude, and the name given to an
era� Post-neoliberalism always develops in an incomplete “hybrid” manner�8
According to Yates and Bakker, post-neoliberalism is not a policy of abandoning
neoliberalism altogether� It is a tendency to move away from certain aspects
of neoliberal policy prescriptions� In particular, it aims to restructure the state
power against free market regulation and to prevent the social concerns created
by the market economy� It aims to revitalize citizenship through people’s active
participation to the governmental procedures�9
One of the most distinctive features of the post-neoliberal period is the criti-
cism of the destruction brought by neoliberalism, which has been the dominant
ideological formula of the world economy for nearly 40 years� In order to better
understand post-neoliberalism, a clear definition of neoliberalism must first be
made� As Steger and Roy defines, Neoliberalism is a doctrine that advocates the
utopian project of a society organized around self-regulating markets and free
7 Patti Lather, “Updata: Post-Neoliberalism,” Qualitative Inquiry 26, no� 7 (2020): 768�
8 Pierre Gautreau and Perrier Bruslé Laetitia, “Forest Management in Bolivia under Evo
Morales: The Challenges of Post-neoliberalism,” Political Geography 68 (2019): 121�
9 Julian S Yates and Karen Bakker� “Debating the ‘Post-neoliberal Turn’ in Latin America,”
Progress in Human Geography 38, no� 1 (2014): 62–90�
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
13 Anders Lustgarten� If You Don’t Let Us Dream, We Won’t Let You Sleep (London: A&C
Black, 2013), 2�
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
Thacker clearly states in this scene that he sees no barriers to the marketing of
social behaviour� Thacker utters this expression, which can be found to be blood-
chilling under normal conditions, with extraordinary ease on stage� Thacker
merely delivers his view, because in the fictional post-neoliberal universe cre-
ated by Lustgarten, everything is reduced to economic profit and a free market
economy� In Keynesian economies, the social security practices that the state will
provide equally to every citizen without expecting any gain have undergone a
neoliberal transformation and are no longer seen as a social right�
In the same scene, the audience learns from Thacker that prisons have
also been privatized� Privatization is the most basic tool of neoliberalism,
which advocates the idea of putting everything under the control of the free
market� However, the idea of privatizing the country’s judicial system through
mechanisms called Unity bonds did not even occur to Margaret Thatcher, one of
the most famous practitioners of neoliberalism� Maclean explains how the Unity
Bonds system works in the judicial mechanism with the following words: If the
number of people who commit crimes or receive treatment for drug addiction
goes down to a certain level, investors get a return�15 As Maclean clearly states,
if there is any reduction in crime, investors profit� However, if the crime rate
does not fall, investors cannot profit either� The aim of lowering the social crime
rate, which is normally considered a social issue and should be done without
expecting any benefit, has turned into an investment tool in Lustgarten’s post-
neoliberal universe�
In another scene, a teenager named Ryan and a man with “Competitive
Confinement Ltd” written on his jacket are seen in a prison cell� The man has
some documents and the man questions Ryan based on them� It soon becomes
clear that Ryan had participated in a peaceful demonstration and was holding
placards with political slogans:
Man If you plead guilty, bearing in mind the relatively minor nature of the crime, I’d see
you getting a very short custodial sentence� Three months maybe�
14 Ibid�, 5
15 Ibid�, 6�
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
16 Ibid�, 30�
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
level by private companies, created the 2008 crisis�17 As in every crisis period,
this crisis period also brought nationalist politicians with authoritarian tenden-
cies to the fore�
Donald Trump’s election as president in the USA and UKIP’s becoming
the third party in the UK’s general elections may be counted as examples of
authoritarianism's sudden rise in politics�
Another area that gets its share of Lustgarten’s critical approach in the play
is the national health system of the United Kingdom� Scene 4 opens with Joan’s
dialogue with a nurse at a hospital� Joan desperately asks the nurse for help, but
the nurse brings her some documents to fill out and sign� Although her health
condition is urgent, no one takes care of her� Then a hospital manager arrives
with documents and tells Joan “I’m afraid we can’t make provision for you at
this hospital, Joan�”18 Joan insists her condition is urgent and even mentions the
name of her illness�
Administrator We can’t make provision for you�
Joan Why not?
Beat�
Administrator Unity rejected your application�
Joan I didn’t make an application� I didn't make an “application�”
Administrator I’m very sorry, Joan� Please accept my sincere –
Joan Why’d they turn me down?
Administrator I couldn’t say, it’s a matter of commercial – 19
Neoliberalism regards education, health and social security areas, which are seen
as a citizenship right in the Keynesian understanding of capitalism, as a burden
to the state and aims to bring these areas under the control of the free market
economy through privatizations� To this end, neoliberal governments have over
the years privatized all the mechanisms of the health sector, turning human
health from being a universal social right into a property that can be bought and
sold� Such capital-centred practices originating from neoliberalism have created
serious social inequalities in access to health services� The period when these
inequalities are most visible is the post-neoliberal period that emerged after the
2008 global economic crisis�
17 Mitchell William, and Thomas Fazi� Reclaiming the State (Chicago: University of
Chicago Press Economics Books, 2017)�
18 Lustgarten, If You Don’t Let Us Dream, 35�
19 Ibid�,36�
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
20 Michael Billington, “If You Don’t Let Us Dream, We Won’t Let You Sleep” – Review�
The Guardian (2013)�
21 Chris Megson, “Can I Tell You About It?”: England, Austerity and “Radical Optimism”
in the Theatre of Anders Lustgarten,” Journal of Contemporary Drama in English, 6,
no� 1 (2018): 41–42�
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
the rise of populism in British mainstream politics, the fact that UKIP is one of
the components of the winning side of the Brexit referendum strengthens this
thesis�
While these were happening in Britain in the post-neoliberal period, inter-
esting developments were also taking place on the opposite shore of the Atlantic�
Businessman Donald Trump, generally known as a contractor, TV star and a
tabloid figure in American history, was elected president of the United States in
2016, the same year as the Brexit referendum�
As if he had no share in the crisis due to his great wealth and the capitalist class
he represents, Trump has built his entire election campaign on the consequences
of the crisis� With all the post-neoliberal era brought, Trump appeared before
the voters, made an accounting of neoliberalism and made countless promises
to the American people� Trump came to power with populist rhetoric that
scratched the public’s sensitive points, such as building a wall on the Mexican
border, deporting fugitives, or recalling American firms abroad� In the play,
Jason’s harassment of a Black employee in a bar because of his skin colour can
be interpreted as Lustgarten’s drawing attention to the increasing racism in the
post-neoliberal era�
The Conservative Cameron government, which could not respond to the
needs of the British people, especially the lower and middle classes, who were
deeply affected by the 2008 financial crisis, failed in this sense� Indicators such
as economic recession, foreign trade deficit, impoverishment of the middle class,
unemployment and injustice in income distribution are among the economic
realities of the Cameron period� Cameron’s economic administration has cre-
ated a serious disappointment in the British public� This growing disillusion-
ment underlies the successful Brexit campaign� Under the Brexit campaign led
by UKIP, this crisis, which has serious economic reasons and has almost become
a social trauma, has distorted and created unrealistic economic discourses� For
example, he claimed that the United Kingdom was taken over by foreign powers
and conducted political campaigns with the theme of “take back our country�”
Making a social trauma political material instead of saying something new is an
example of populism�
Post-neoliberalism is a set of ideals that somehow transforms neoliber-
alism, but is simultaneously characterized by economic policies embodied by
the Washington Consensus� While there is scholarly debate about the defining
features of post-neoliberalism, it is often associated with economic policies of
nationalization and wealth redistribution, opposition to deregulation, financiali-
zation, free trade and the weakening of labour relations, and more generally with
eco-finance� After the 2008 global financial crisis, there have been indications that
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
there will be a major paradigm shift in the ideas and policies that guide national
economies and global capitalism� While both left and right movements chal-
lenge the dominance of unelected technocrats and global markets, the populist
policies of the following years appear as another outcome of post-neoliberalism�
Anders Lustgarten uses in his play not only the landscapes of economic
depression that have had an impact in the post-neoliberal era but also situations
that document post-neoliberal governance principles such as the rise of author-
itarianism and financial centralization�
The death of social security and retirement comes at the beginning of the
most obvious economic depressions of the post-neoliberal era and has taken its
place in Lustgarten’s narrative� The failure of the national health system in con-
nection with the destruction of the social insurance system is another topic of
Lustgarten’s narrative of post-neoliberal devastation� In addition to these two
major issues that hurt people in the real world, Lustgarten creates a fictional
official judicial system and creates a fictional universe where people are judged
based on their performance in the economic system called unity bonds� In If
You Don’t Let Us Dream, We Won’t Let You Sleep, in which Lustgarten combines
real world data and fictional systems, he leaves a warning for the future in this
way: Neoliberalism is not dead; it is still living in its own hell�
Bibliography
Billington, Michael� “If You Don’t Let Us Dream, We Won’t Let You Sleep –
Review�” The Guardian, 2013� https://www�theguardian�com/stage/2013/feb/
21/if-you-dont-let-us-dream-review�
Cahill, Damien, et al�, eds� The SAGE Handbook of Neoliberalism� London:
Sage, 2018�
Gautreau, Pierre, and Laetitia Perrier Bruslé� “Forest Management in Bolivia
under Evo Morales: The Challenges of Post-neoliberalism�” Political
Geography, 68 (2019): 110–121�
Giddens, Anthony� The Third Way: The Renewal of Social Democracy�
Hoboken, NJ: Wiley, 1999�
Gültekin, Hakan� The Critique of Neoliberalism in David Hare’s Plays� Çizgi
Publishing, 2018�
Harvey, David� The New Imperialism� Oxford: Oxford University Press , 2005�
Harvey, David� A Brief History of Neoliberalism� Oxford: Oxford University Press,
2007�
Lather, Patti� “Updata: Post-Neoliberalism�” Qualitative Inquiry 26, no� 7 (2020):
768–770�
personal reading copy | copyright restrictions (www.peterlang.com/howtoshare)
Lustgarten, Anders� If You Don’t Let Us Dream, We Won’t Let You Sleep�
London: A&C Black, 2013�
Lustgarten, Anders� Lampedusa� London: Bloomsbury Publishing, 2015�
Lustgarten, Anders� A Day at the Racists� London: A&C Black, 2010�
Maier, Charles S� “The Politics of Productivity: Foundations of American
International Economic Policy after World War II�” International Organization
31, no� 4 (1977): 607–633�
Mitchell, William, and Thomas Fazi� “Reclaiming the state�” Chicago: University
of Chicago Press Economics Books, 2017�
Megson, Chris� “Can I Tell You About It?”: England, Austerity and “Radical
Optimism” in the Theatre of Anders Lustgarten� Journal of Contemporary
Drama in English, 6, no� 1 (2018): 40–54�
Sekler, Nicola� “Postneoliberalism from and as a Counter-hegemonic Perspective�”
Development Dialogue 51 (2009): 59–71�
Steger, Manfred B�, and Ravi K� Roy� Neoliberalism: A Very Short Introduction�
Vol� 222� Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2010�
Wang, Chaohua, ed� One China, Many Paths� London: Verso, 2003�
Yates, Julian S�, and Karen Bakker� “Debating the ‘Post-neoliberal turn’ in Latin
America�” Progress in Human Geography 38, no: 1 (2014): 62–90�