Final Revised LOI Report Corrected by E.E.dtd.16.2.2022 As Per DCPR 2034 Rohini
Final Revised LOI Report Corrected by E.E.dtd.16.2.2022 As Per DCPR 2034 Rohini
Final Revised LOI Report Corrected by E.E.dtd.16.2.2022 As Per DCPR 2034 Rohini
SRA/ENG/2937/GS/ML/LOI
Documentation: -
Society Annex. – I Draft Annex. – Annex. – III Draft
II forwarded by Slum Plan
Architect submitted
by
Architect
1)Ashtavinayak
SRA CHS Draft Ann-II
(Prop.), 2) forwarded by
Draft Slum
Arvind Nagar 2 Architect during
plan
SRA CHS acceptance of
alongwith
(Prop.), 3) scheme at pg. C-
Ann- II
Riddhi Siddhi 351 to
displayed on
Vyapari & C-367. Draft
Pg. C-1831 to C- Ann- II displayed site by the
Niwas SRA
1835 Pg. C- 1465 to Competent
CHS (Prop.) & on site by the
C-1466 Authority
4)Arvind Nagar Competent
forwarded
Worli SRA CHS Authority
by the
(Prop.) forwarded by the
Architect as
5)Gawankar Architect as at
at pg. C-111
Nagar SRA pg. C-1523 to
to C-113 &
CHS(Prop.) C-1631. Scrutiny
C-1661
6) Shree sheet at pg.C-
Mangalmurti 1815 to C-1817.
CHS Ltd.
Brief History :-
In this case, the S.R.Scheme is accepted on 14/06/2017 as per S.R.A.
circular 144 & office order dtd. 30.4.2015 for the amalgamated S.R.Scheme of
slum portion on plot bearing C.S. no. 286(pt) of Lower Parel division, under
Reg.33(10) of DCR 1991 amended upto date for Ashtavinayak SRA CHS Prop.,
Arvind Nagar 2 SRA CHS Prop., Riddhi Siddhi Vyapari & Niwas SRA CHS Prop.
& Arvind Nagar Worli SRA CHS Prop. & contiguous non-slum redevelopment
area on plot bearing C.S. no. 268(pt) & 286(pt) of Lower Parel division under
reg. 33(7) of DCR 1991 amended upto date for Shree Mangalmurti CHS Ltd. at
the junction of Ganpatrao Kadam Marg & S.S. Amrutwar Marg Worli Mumbai-
400 013 to be implemented under clause 7.7 of Appendix – IV of Reg. 33(10) of
DCR 1991 amended upto date. The Draft Annexure – II submitted by the slum
societies is forwarded to the Competent Authority i.e. Assistant Commissioner,
G/S ward for preparation of certified Annexure – II, the same is awaited. The
LOI ÛÎú.ÃÖ.†Ö/´ÖÖ»Ö´Ö¢ÖÖ/480/¯ÖÏ.†.(ÃÖÝÖéÃÖ)/ ÃÖÖêÃÖÖ-2 dtd.
6.4.2018 for redevelopment u/reg.33(7) of DCR 1991 amended upto date of plot
bearing C.S.no. 268(pt) & 286(pt) of Lower Parel division of G.K. Marg, &
S.S.Amrutwar Marg G/S ward for Municipal tenanted property popularly
known as Shri Mangalmurti Co-Op HSG Ltd. is issued by Asst. Commissioner
(Estate) MCGM vide at pg. C-1467 to C-1488.
Thereafter, the LOI report was submitted to then CEO(SRA) for joint
development under reg. 33(10) for slum portion and under reg.33(7) for non-
slum portion pending certified Annexure – II under clause 3.12 D of Appendix
– IV of reg. 33(10) of DCR 1991.
Accordingly, the amalgamated LOI of S.R. Scheme for total 14549.20
sq.mts. i.e. of slum portion adm. 7082.99 sq.mts. for 316 tenements & 197
Extra PAP on plot bearing C.S. No.286 (pt) of Lower Parel Division under
Regulation 33 (10) of DCR 1991 amended upto date for Astavinayak SRA CHS
(Proposed), Arvind Nagar 2 SRA CHS (Prop.), Riddhi Siddhi Vyapai & Niwas
SRA CHS (Prop.) and Arvind Nagar Worli SRA CHS (Prop.) for 3.87 FSI and for
contiguous non-slum redevelopment area adm. 7466.21 sq.mts. for 101
renewal tenants on plot bearing C.S. no. 268(pt) & 286(pt) of Lower Parel
division under reg. 33(7) of DCR 1991 amended upto date for Shree
Mangalmurti CHS Ltd. for 3.00 FSI at the junction of Ganpatrao Kadam Marg
& S.S. Amrutwar Marg Worli Mumbai- 400 013 implemented under clause 7.7
of Appendix – IV of reg. 33(10) of DCR 1991 amended upto date as per
Government of India initiative of Ease of Doing Business and as per
notification dated 1.10.2016 is approved/issued vide LOI u/no.
SRA/Eng/2937/GS/ML/LOI dtd.05/07/2018 at pg. C-1293 to C-1310.
The IOA of renewal tenants building no.02 is issued u/no. SRA/ENG/
GS/MCGM/0089/20170614/AP/B2 dtd.05/07/2018 in IOA file. Thereafter
no further approvals are issued. On site there is no construction or site
preparation activity.
Now, the Asst. Commissioner G/S. ward MCGM vide his letter
dtd.21.7.2018 have directed to consider / amalgamate the encroached area of
two roads i.e. Ganpatroa Kadam Marg & S.S. Amrutwar Marg under slum, vital
link between Ganpatrao Kadam Marg & Pandhurang Budhakar Marg, catering
to Worli Naka & Veer Sawarkar Marg with the approved S.R.Scheme by
treating the same as Vital Public Project in the interest of MCGM & public at
large for the amalgamated slum portion adm.11024.70 sq.mts. (7082.99 +
3941.71) & non-slum portion adm. 7466.21 sq.mts. i.e. total 18490.91 sq.mts.
by the treating the non-participating & non consenting occupancy as
nominated PAP without insisting consent while certifying Annexure – II or
implementing the scheme u/reg. 33(10) to be clubbed / amalgamated to be
adjoining non-slum portion under DCR 33(7) of Nehru Nagar subject to
conditions mentioned therein.
The conditions to that effect are incorporated in the Draft Revised LOI.
As stated above, the Architect has proposed the new R.L. of 12.20 mts.
passing through the approved S.R. Scheme plot at north side as an access to
the adjoining Municipal Plot bearing C.S. no. 437 of Lower Parel Division for
construction of PAP tenements u/reg.33(20) (A) of DCPR 2034. Thus, Architect
has proposed the new R.L. of 12.20 mts. subject to MCGM recommendation &
co-operation to allow exceptional concession in planning as a consequence.
Further, he has stated that the developer vide his letter to Dy. Che. Eng.
(Improvement.) dtd. 11.11.2021 as at pg.C-1795 to C-1799 has requested for
various concessions, out of which the salient planning concessions required
are listed as under :-
1. To allow basement/ podium in mandatory open space and allow below
12.00 wide proposed access to plot bearing C.S. no.437.
‘a’
2. To waive off amenity plot requirement u/reg. 14 of DCPR 2034.
3. To allow building/basement touching D.P. road/ existing road.
Further, the Architect vide his letter at pg.C-1421 to C-1429 has stated
that the buildable plot for the subject S.R. Scheme is 56% due to road setback
etc. and due to proposing this additional area under 12.20 mtr road at north
side of the scheme the buildable plot has approximately now reduced to 56%,
thereby putting additional planning constraints on the already difficult plot.
Also, as stated earlier the Asst. Commissioner G/S ward MCGM vide his letter
dtd. 21.7.2018 have directed to treat the S.R. Scheme as Vital Public Project in
the interest of MCGM and Public at large. Thus, the Architect has requested to
allow the above mentioned concessions in the planning of the layout
considering the subject S.R. scheme as Vital Public Project.
Wing ‘A’ & ‘B’ comprises of 03 level basements + Gr. (Retail & Restaurant)
+ 1st (Restaurant part & podiums part) + 2nd to 6th (Service utility room part &
part podium) + 7th (part home occupation offices & part podium) + 8 th Amenity
floor + 9th service floor + 10th to 47th residential upper floors having height is
167.90 mtr.
Accessible through 24.40 mtr. wide S.S. Amrutwar Marg at west side and
30.50 mtr. wide G.K. Marg at south side i.e. more than 13.00 mtrs. as per reg.
19(2) (subject to NOC from CFO MCGM & HRC) instead of earlier High rise
residential sale building no.05 comprising of Three Wings (i.e. Wing ‘A’, ‘B’ & ‘C’
with two level basements + Ground(pt) / stilt(pt)+ four level podiums + 5 th to
57th (pt) upper floor having height 163.15 mtrs.
As seen from above, the Architect has proposed mixed users in high rise
sale bldg. no. 05 at wing ‘A’ to ‘D’ as under: -
If Hon’ble CEO(SRA)’s approval/ orders to para side lined ‘A’ to ‘D’ above
are affirmative, then the further report in as under: -
5. Plot Area:-
The plot area details as per the various other documents submitted by
the Architect is as given below: -
Also, the separate PRC in the name of MCGM for the C.S. no. u/ref. shall
be submitted before C.C. to last 25% sale component in the scheme.
The conditions to that effect are incorporated in the Draft Revised LOI.
In view of above, CEO(SRA)’s orders are requested to consider the total plot
area for S.R. Scheme adm. 18490.91 sq.mts. (7082.99 sq.mts. (slum) +3941.71
sq.mts. (slum) + 7466.21sq.mts. non-slum) on 24.40 mts. wide Shivram
Amrutwar Marg and 30.50 mts. wide G.K.Marg. under 33(10)) for the
amalgamated S.R.Scheme under clause 3.15 of reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034 for 1)
Ashtavinayak SRA CHS Prop. 2) Arvind Nagar 2 SRA CHS Prop. 3) Riddhi Siddhi
Vyapari & Niwas SRA CHS Prop. 4) Arvind Nagar Worli SRA CHS Prop. And 5
‘E’
Gavankar Nagar SRA CHS under reg. 33(10) with Shree Mangalmurti CHS Ltd.
proposed u/reg. 33(7) of DCPR 2034 read with notification dtd. 8.7.2021, as
requested by Architect since it will result in better building design and planning
and holistic development of the area and also to clear access thus and to
establish a link between Pandurang Budhkar Marg and Ganpatrao Kadam Marg.
The in-situ development shall be restricted to 75% of the permissible BUA until
the plot area confirmation/Demarcation is obtained from the CTSO (City.)
6. Tenement Density :-
As per clause 3.12 (A) of Reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034 the existing tenement
density for rehab component on slum plot under reference is calculated as
below.
Sr. Particulars Area in sq.mt. including
No. slum pocket considered u/reg.
33(10) to be amalgamated
1. Area of slum plot considered for S.R. Scheme 11024.70 sq.mts.
(59.62% of 18490.91)
2. Deduction for proposed road 7885.05 sq.mts.
3. i) Plot for buildable Reservation for Homeless 8.00 sq.mts.(32.01/4)
Shelter
110.46 sq.mts.
ii) AOS 14(A) (59.62% of 185.27)
4. Net plot area for calculation of tenements 3021.19 sq.mts.
Density
6. Number of tenements required to achieve tenement 196.38 say 196 t/s.
density of 650 T/net hectare
7. Number of existing tenements
Residential 296
R/C. 09
Others 15
Equivalent Commercial t/s. of 243 t/s (copy at page 3595.73/27.88
C-1369 to C-1401 ) =129
Total 449
8. Number of exiting tenements 563 t/s. (R-296, R/C-09 Comm-
as per Scrutiny sheet from Tahsildar–1 (Special Cell) 243 and others-15 )
(SRA) has forwarded the Tahsildar–1 (Special Cell)
(SRA) vide u/no/no. Kra.tahasi-1vik/Nehru
nagar/21/63 dtd. 03/01/2022 as at pg.- C-1815 of
the subject S.R. Scheme.
9 Existing tenement density 1486.17 say 1486
10. Number of PAPs generated in the S.R.Scheme NIL
As per clause 3.12 (C) of DCPR 2034, the Architect has proposed the
S.R.Scheme for the entire slum dwellers for 4 nos. of societies including the
adjoining slum pocket known as Gawankar Nagar SRA CHS (Prop.) & affected
by appurtenant road of S.S. Amrutwar Marg & G.K.Kadam Marg & requested
to allow the same by considering the tenements remaining after allotment to
eligible slum dwellers as PAP’s / affordable housing etc.
In view of the above, 563 nos. of slum dwellers (i.e. 296 nos. of Resi., 09
nos. of R/C, 243 nos. of Commercial t/s., 05 nos. Temple & 10 nos. other
amenities) are considered for amalgamated S.R. Scheme u/reg. 33(10) for free
alternate accommodation & additional incentive sale FSI permissible as per
reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034 for sale in the open market to subsidize the rehab
component as per the Scrutiny sheet from Tahsildar–1 (Special Cell) (SRA) vide
u/no. /no. Kra.tahasi-1vik/Nehru nagar/21/63 dtd. 03/01/2022 as at pg.- C-
1815 for the draft Annexure-II of the subject S.R. Scheme as per clause 3.12
(C) of reg.33(10)of DCPR 2034.
As per clause 3.12 (C) of DCPR 2034, the existing tenement density
considering total nos. of slum dwellers listed in Annexure-II is 1486 t/s. per
net hectare as calculated above, which is more than 650 t/s. per net hectare.
The Architect has considered the scheme for grant of 4.00 FSI for entire 563
nos. of t/s. for amalgamated S.R.Scheme u/reg. 33(10) including adjoining
slum pocket known as Gawankar Nagar SRA CHS (Prop.) on adjoining
S.S.Amrutwar marg & G.K.Kadam Marg considered u/reg. 33(10) of DCPR
2034 pending the certified Annexure – II from competent Authority & in case of
tenements remaining after allotment to eligible slum dwellers this would be
converted into PAP’s/ affordable housing / rental housing / staff quarters etc.
at this stage & after finalization of appeal the balance t/s. shall be treated as
regular PAP t/s & requested to allow the same. As seen from the table at pg.C-
1357 the in-situ FSI consumed after provision of entire 563 nos. of t/s. is 3.29.
As per clause 3.8 of reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034 for plots having access road of
13.00 mts. & above permissible in-situ FSI is 4.00 or upto sanctioned FSI of
the scheme whichever is higher.
As such as per clause 3.12(B) the balance FSI available in slum scheme
(4.00 – 3.29 = 0.71) after in-situ development additional rehab tenements may
be allowed upto & extent such that this development & corresponding sale
component development remains within the limit of maximum permissible FSI
in the scheme. Thus, the Architect has proposed the balance FSI available
after in-situ rehab & sale development as additional 101 PAP t/s. for
amalgamated S.R.Scheme u/reg. 33(10) to the extent such that this
development & corresponding sale component development remains within the
limit of maximum permissible 4.00 FSI in the said scheme & requested to
allow the same.
As per the letter of Asst. Commissioner, G/S ward, MCGM under
21.07.2018 point number ‘E’ “ Regular proposal to obtain Estate’s NOC as
envisaged in the policy guidelines issued on 10.9.2015 by Estate Department
under No. AC/Estate/14401/AE-(I)-(II) shall be forwarded to A.C.(Estates) once
the proposal is approved”
‘G’ Pandurang Budhkar Marg as Vital Public Project and to treat the non-
participant & non-consenting eligible occupiers in this combined scheme as
Nominated PAP’s while certifying Annexure II/ implementing scheme as per the
letter of Asst. Commissioner, G/S ward MCGM dtd. 21/07/2018 subject to
submitting individual agreement as required before granting CC to any Rehab
building in the said scheme.
The Architect has now submitted the proposal for scrutiny & approval of
revised LOI for amalgamation of slum portion on plot bearing C.S.no. 286(pt),
268(pt) & 2/269 of Lower Parel Division knowns as Gawankar Nagar SRA CHS
(Prop.) and contiguous 24.40 mts. wide Shivram Amrutwar Marg and 30.50
mts. wide G.K.marg i.e.balance slum pockets under these roads not considered
earlier, under reg. 33(10) of DCPR2034 with approved amalgamated
S.R.Scheme for slum colony known as Nehur Nagar on slum portion on plot
bearing C.S.no. 286(pt) of Lower Parel Division for 1) Ashtavinayak SRA CHS
(Prop.), 2) Arvind Nagar 2 SRA CHS (Prop.), 3) Riddhi Siddhi Vyapari & Niwas
SRA CHS (Prop.) & 4) Arvind Nagar Worli SRA CHS (Prop.) with conversion
under reg. 33(10) of DCPR-2034 and for contiguous non-slum redevelopment
area on plot bearing C.S. no. 268(pt) & 286(pt) of Lower Parel division under
reg. 33(7) of DCPR 2034 read with notification 8.7.2021 for Shree Mangalmurti
CHS Ltd. at the junction of Ganpatrao Kadam Marg & S.S. Amrutwar Marg
G/S ward Worli Mumbai- 400 013 as per the letter of Asst. Commissioner,
G/S ward, MCGM dtd. 21.07.2018.
The Architect has opted to convert the proposal on non-slum plot as per
modified clause no.10 of reg. 33(7) of DCPR 2034 vide copy at pg. C-1819 to C-
1820.
As per modified clause no.10 of reg. 33(7) of DCPR 2034 of UDD
notification u/no. TPB-4320/107/CR-72/2020(Part-I)/UD-11 dtd. 8.7.2021
“In case of redevelopments scheme in progress and such schemes where LOI
has been issued, the Owner/ Developer/Co-op. Housing Society with the prior
approval of Vice president and Chief Executive Officer, Maharashtra Housing &
Area Development Authority, may convert the proposal in accordance with
modified regulations. However, such conversion is optional and shall not be
binding.”
As per the letter of Asst. Commissioner, G/S ward, MCGM dtd.
21/07/2018 point number ‘A’ “All the conditions of LOI issued for Nehru
Nagar Scheme under No. AC/Estates/480/AO(Soc.)/Soc.2 dtd. 6.4.2018
including condition of payment of Rs. 188.25 crore as capitalized value
generated in the scheme will be applicable.”
In view of above, the development of renewal tenement property under
Reg. 33(7) and to process the incentive BUA by considering FSI 3 as per the
provisions of clause 2 of Appendix -III of Reg. 33(7) of DCR 1991 as sanctioned
vide last LOI dtd. 6.4.2018 shall be continued as per UDD letter u/no.
TPB/4319259/Pra. Kra.150/2019/Navi-11 Dtd.13/09/2019 vide copy at pg.
C-1817 to C-1818 subject to incorporating a condition in LOI as mentioned as
per point A of letter of Asst. Commissioner, G/S ward, MCGM dtd.
21/07/2018.
In view of above, CEO(SRA)’s approval is requested to the development of
renewal tenement property under modified clause no.10 of reg. 33(7) of DCPR
2034 as per UDD notification u/no. TPB-4320/107/CR-72/2020(Part-I)/UD-
‘H’ 11dtd. 8.7.2021 and to process the incentive BUA by considering FSI 3 as per
1) To not to insist the NOC from Naval Authority in the vicinity of 500 mts.
of vital defense installation at Worli since there are many building
constructed between the scheme plot and the Defense establishment
and as per the superimposed plan the scheme plot is more than 500
mtrs from the defense establishment.
2) To not to insist the MMRDA / MMRC NOC for Metro line-3 as the subject
scheme is more than 50 mtrs buffer from the centre line of metro as
seen from the superimposed plan submitted by Architect.
3) Not to insist the NOC from A.C. Estates MCGM for implementing the
S.R. Scheme falling under WORLI HILL ESTATE SCHEME NO.52 as the
LOI dtd. 6.4.2018 is issued for redevelopment scheme under Reg. 33(7)
of DCR 1991 the same shall be insisted for the balance plot u/reg.
33(10) by way of certified Annexure – II before granting IOA to sale
building.
Further, stated that MMRDA Authorities have conveyed that to insist the
NOC from MMRDA / MMRC for developments of land situated within the
stipulated distance of 50.00 mts. on either side of the centre line of the
tentative proposed alignment of the metro line – 3 (Colaba -Bandra) & with in
vicinity of vital defense installation at Worli.
Also, as per the D.P. remarks SRDP 1991 since the land the under T.P.
scheme remarks from Town Planning of MCGM should be obtained before any
development in the scheme.
10.2 Development plan 2034 :-
As per.D.P.2034 remarks u/no. CHE/DP34201905111220035 Dated
6.5.2019 as at pg. C- 1491 to C-1497 and plan superimposed with DP-2034,
Architect has stated that the plot falls in R-zone and is reserved partly for
rehabilitation & resettlement + Homeless shelter (R.R. 2.1 + R.S.A. 2.9) and is
affected by 24.40 mts. wide Shivram Amritwar Marg. & 30.50 mtr. Ganpatrao
Kadam Marg.
Further, the land u/ref. is affected by the influence zone of the proposed
Metro Rail alignment, Natural water course and also by Coastal Road. As such,
remarks from MMRDA , concerned authority and Chief Engineer ( Coastal
Road Dept.), MCGM shall be obtained respectively before commencing any
development. Also it is stated the land u/ref. abuts nalla hence specific
remarks E.E. SWD of MCGM shall be obtained before any development of the
land.
As per the recent Govt. Notification of Ministry of Defense the NOC for
the building construction within 500.00 mts. within vicinity of vital defense
installation is required. The Architect has stated that there are a number of
S.R. Scheme which have been already approved by S.R.A. and have been
implemented at an advance stage after issue of certified Annexure –II by the
Competent Authority i.e. MCGM by following due procedure in the vicinity of
vital defense installation.
The Architect vide his letter at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that the
S.R.Scheme u/ref. is on part portion of the larger C.S.no.286 of Lower Parel
Division. It is further stated that as seen from the superimposed plan & Google
plan at pg. C-1499 the Metro line – 3 & the vital defense installation at Worli
are abutting & affecting the plots in the vicinity of Dr. Annie Besant Road.
However the S.R.Scheme u/ref. is at a distance greater than 50.00 mts. of the
stipulated distances on either side of the centre line of the tentative proposed
alignment of the metro line – 3 (Colaba-Bandra) and also is at a distance
greater than 500 mts. of the buffer zone in the vicinity of vital defense
installation of Worli.
Further, the Architect has stated that a few of the S.R.Scheme already
implemented falling under Worli Hill Estate Scheme no.52 are given certified
Annexure – II by MCGM as Competent Authority by recovery of their dues an
accordingly the S.R.Scheme have been implemented further.
The Architect has been submitted the LOI dtd. 6.4.2018 for Nehru Nagar
plot bearing 268(pt) & 286(pt) of Lower Parel Division to be implemented u/reg.
33(7) of DCR 1991 by the Asst. Commissioner (Estate) MCGM as at pg.C-1467
to C-1488. He has further stated that as per Governments recent policy of
Ease Of Doing Business and so as to implement the scheme & clear the D.P.
road of encroachment & develop the same they request to insist the remarks
from A.C. (Estates) MCGM for balance portion of plot bearing C.S. 268(pt),
2/269 & 286(pt) to be implemented u/reg. 33(10) before granting C.C. to sale
building in scheme.
He has further stated that his clients are ready to pay the necessary
fee/charges/premiums etc. if any to MCGM & indemnify CEO (SRA) & his staff
against any litigation in the matter & submit undertaking to that effect.
Also, the Architect has stated that though the S.R.Scheme is under
T.P.S. Mahim no. IV as per the D.P. remarks there is no mention of the same
in the PRC of property bearing C.S. 286(pt) & 268(pt) of Lower Parel Division.
Thus, he has requested to insist the T.P. remarks for the property u/ref.
before C.C. to the sale buildings. Also, the land is affected by nalla & Coastal
Road. Further as per the letter of Dy. Director (Town Planning) (SRA) at pg.C-
619 to C-623 wherein stated that the S.R. Scheme u/ref. is affected by
drainage channel under road & no development / construction shall be
permissible for the same. As such in order to implement the scheme at earliest
L.S. has requested to insist the NOC for drainage channel / nalla before
granting C.C. to the rehab buildings.
Further, Architect has stated that the proposed coastal road is far away
from the proposed S.R. scheme thus requested to not to insist the NOC from
Chief Engineer (Coastal Roads Department) MCGM.
Architect vide his representation has mentioned that as per clause 17
(D) of DCPR 2034 for buildable reservation on lands where guidelines approved
by Government under section 31 of the Maharashtra Regional and Town
planning Act 1966 are not available. However, built-up area equal 20% of the
area under reservation in that plot shall be made available free of cost for the
Municipal Corporation or for any other appropriate Authority.
As such, as per the superimpose plan vide at pg.C-1499, the reservation
area as per SRDP 1991 by triangulation area calculation for Housing for
Dishoused is adm. 265.00 sq.mts. and as per D.P.2034 for Homeless shelter is
also area adm. 265.00 sq.mts. Further, Architect has stated that out of total
265.00 sq.mt. reservation area, 104.94 sq.mt falls in non-slum plot 33(7) and
160.06 sq.mt. falls in slum plot 33(10).
i) The size of the plot is odd and narrow to rehabilitate total 562 nos. of
tenements of 27.88 sq. mtrs. carpet area each.
ii) The plot is majorly affected by set-back of 24.40 mts. wide S.S.
Amrutwar Marg.
iii) Large nos. of slum dwellers of rehab commercial have to be
accommodated.
However, the Architect has already been accorded the sanction of then
CEO(SRA) for condoning the deficiency in segregating distance by recovering
the premium charged for condoning deficiency in open spaces maximum upto
83.33% for Rehab buildings no.4 as per the Clause 6.24 of Appendix IV of DCR
33(10) read with reg. 57(3)(c)(iii) of DCR 1991 may please be seen vide pg. N-9
to N-171. Now, the architect has proposed the rehab bldg. no.4 at zero open
space at West side abutting the 24.40 mtrs wide S.S Amruthwar Marg due to
additional planning constraints due to provision of new road for MCGM plot
and thus requested to allow the same.
Further, as per Reg.14 (B)(c)(i) for plot areas under conversion of
industrial zone to residential /commercial zone less than 2000 sq.mts, 10%
amenity in the form of open land shall be handed over to MCGM free of cost. In
this case, the land area under slum encroachment in industrial zone is 993.04
sq.mts. The built-up amenity of homeless shelter admeasuring 101.80 sq.mts
is proposed to be handed over to MCGM in the SR scheme excluding areas
under DP road/set back area. Thus, Architect has stated that 10% amenities is
not proposed in the form of open land required as per Reg.14(B) (c)(i) read with
note b of reg. 14(B) of DCPR 2034.
As per regulation 23(1) Table 7 of DCPR 2034, for plot area more than
4000 sq.mtrs. upto 10000 sq.mtrs. for less than length of 75 mtrs., the width
of the access required is 9.0 mtrs. for residential and commercial zones. Also
as per clause 6.12 of reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034, the pathway shall act as an
access wherever necessary. The building shall be permitted to touch pathways.
Thus, from the above table it can be seen that 185.27 sqmt. amenities
plot is required to be carved out plot. Architect has to carve out Amenities
plot adm. 185.27 Sq.mts. Architect has accordingly made provision of plot
adm. 185.27 Sq.mts as against area adm 185.27 sqmt for plot towards
amenities under Reg. 14(A) of DCPR 2034.
The table showing the details of subdivided plots, its area on plan at page
C-1357 to C-1419 and same is tabulated below: -
7 Sub plot –G 55.00 Access Road to adjoining Gomata Nagar SRA CHS
Sub plot –H Amenity Open space as per reg. 14(A) of DCPR
8 185.27
2034.
9 Sub plot -I 516.14 12.20 mtr R.L.
10 Sub plot-D1 131.00 Rehab plot
11 Sub plot –J 220.97 9.00 mtr.pathway
TOTAL 18490.91 ---
Architect has requested to allow the notional subdivision as proposed by
insisting the layout approval before granting CC to sale building in the scheme.
The net plot area for non-slum plot excluding the area of D.P.Reservation
D.P Roads, works out to 7368.14 sq.mtrs. As such, the scheme falls in the
category of having net plot area from 2501 to 10,000 sqmt. Therefore, 20%
LOS is to be provided as per regulation 27 (1) of DCPR 2034. Provided further
the provision of LOS in case of the redevelopment scheme under the reg.33(7)
allows this LOS area to be reduced to 10%.
The same is tabulated below in the table as per clause no. 6.11 of regulation
33(10) of DCPR 2034.
Since scheme under reference is SRA scheme, the architect has proposed
physical RG of odd shapes and sizes at 5 different locations due to planning
constraints as per regulation 27(1) and clause no 6.11 of regulation 33(10) of
DCPR 2034. The total Physical/ Layout RG/Paved RG proposed in the layout is
1074.25 sq.mtrs against required 978.51 sq.mt. as seen from the above table.
As per reg. 27(2) note (2) minimum 60% of the required LOS shall be
provided exclusively on ground and atleast 50% of this shall be provided on
mother earth to facilitate the percolation of water & balance 40% may be
provided on podium area extending beyond building line. Thus, the Architect
has proposed 298.67 sq.mts. of R.G. at 2 locations i.e. R.G.3 & R.G. 4 of odd
shape & size on mother earth instead of required 293.56 sq.mts. ((978.51x
60%) x 50%). Thus, the balance R.G. adm. 775.58 sq.mts. (1074.25 – 298.67)
i.e. 69.84% is proposed at 3 locations i.e. R.G.1 & 2 at ground on Renewal
tenement bldg. no.2 & Rehab slum dwellers bldg. no.3 & R.G. 5 at 8 th floor of
sale bldg. no.5 i.e. amenity floor as paved R.G. free of FSI as shown on plan at
pg.C-1357 & requested to allow the same. Further, the width of R.G. 3 & 4 is
not less than minimum required 7.50 mts. as per reg. 27(1)(c) of DCPR 2034.
Also, the area of R.G.1 is not less than minimum required of 125.00 sq.mts. as
per reg. 27(1)(b) of DPCR 2034. All the R.G.’s 1 to 4 are accessible by
independent means of access.
The Architect has requested to allow the 5 nos. location of R.G. i.e. paved
R.G. no.1 to 2 & 5 and R.G. 3 & 4 of odd size & shape with minorly less size &
area accessible by independent means of access totally adm. 1074.25 sq.mts.
against required 978.51sq.mts. (8% for slum area & 10% non-slum area) due
to planning constraints as shown on plan at pg.C-1357 free of FSI & requested
to allow the same.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO(SRA)’s approval is requested to allow R.G.
adm. 1074.25 sq.mts. against required 978.51 sq.mts. (8% for slum area &
‘N’ 10% non-slum area) out of which R.G. adm. 298.67 sq.mts. is proposed on
mother earth instead of required 293.56 sq.mts. (978.51 x 60%) x 50%) & the
balance as paved R.G. adm. 775.58 sq.mts. (1074.25 – 298.67) i.e. 72.20 %
free of FSI due to planning constraints at 5 nos. of R.G. i.e. paved R.G. no. 1 &
2 & R.G. 3 & 4 of odd size & shape with minorly less size & area accessible by
independent means of access and R.G. 5 at 8 th floor of sale bldg. no.5 free of
FSI as requested by the Architect.
In this case, Architect has proposed single level part basement having
max. height of 4.20 mts. partly within building line and partly beyond building
line below wing ‘B’ of Rehab commercial building. no.1 & wing ‘C’ of Rehab
commercial building no.4 accessible by a 1.50 mts. wide staircase and lift each
for pedestrian access only. The depth of basement from the average ground
level is 3.45 mts & 3.80 mts for rehab commercial building no. 1 & 4
respectively.
The Architect has proposed basement for Rehab Commercial Building no.
4 with zero open space at front side, 1.30 mts. at rear east side instead of 3.00
mts. required as per Reg. 37(7)(i) of DCPR 2034 and more than 1.50 mts. at
north side plot boundaries.
The Architect has proposed basement in Rehab Commercial Building no.
1 with minimum front open space of 1.00 mtr. and at zero open space from
other plot boundaries of Renewal Tenants Building no. 2 at East Side and
Rehab Building no. 3 at North side instead of 3.00 mts. required as per Reg.
37(7)(i) of DCPR 2034.
The Architect has proposed 3 level part basement having max. height of
13.30 mts. partly within building line and partly beyond building line of Rehab
slum dwellers building no.3 accessible by 4 nos. 2.00 mts. wide staircase and 3
lifts each for rehab residential component & 3 nos. of 1.50 mts. wide staircase
& 4 lifts for rehab commercial component for pedestrian access only. The
Architect has provided min. 6.00 mts. wide 2-way ramp for vehicular access to
the basement as reg.37(16) ii. The depth of basement from the average ground
level is 12.43 mts.
The Architect has requested to allow the same free of FSI for provision of
essential building services and utilities like U.G. tank, firefighting tank, pump
room, RWH, STP & OWC for Rehab Commercial Building no.1, 4 and Rehab
Slum dwellers Building no. 3 as per Reg. 37(7) (iv) (c) & 16(ii) of DCPR 2034 as
shown on plan at pg.C-1357 to C-1419 and requested to allow the same.
The Architect has requested the basement at Rehab Slum Dwellers
Building no. 3, Rehab Commercial Building no.1 & 4 free of FSI as per reg.37(7)
& 16 read with reg.31(1) (v) of DCPR-2034.
The details of the basement proposed is tabulated as under: -
4.20 mts 4.20 mtrs. Maximum total Not more than 3.90
height of 13.03
mtr. below soffit of
Proposed
mts (6.93 mtr. +
slab & min. 2.40 mts.
Height of
3.00 mtr. + 3.00
below beam as per
Basement
mtr. reg. 37(7) (ii) of DCPR
2034.
3.45 mtrs. 3.80 mtrs. Max 12.43 mtrs. Min. 3.00 mts. from
the front open space
boundary / edge of
road & min. 1.50 mts.
at other sides for
basement having
depth upto 8.40 mts.
Depth of
if depth exceed 8.40
basement
mts. than the open
spaces shall be
increased by 1.50 mts.
for every 8.40 mts. or
fraction thereof as per
reg. 37(7)(i) of DCPR
2034.
Access to Accessible by a Accessible by a Accessible by As per Reg. 37(7)(v)(d)
basement 1.50 mts. wide 1.50 mts. wide 1.50 mts. wide 3 & (e) of DCPR 2034.
staircase and lift staircase and lift nos. of staircases
each for each for & 4 nos. of lifts
pedestrian pedestrian access of commercial /
access only only shop wings &
2.00 mts. wide 4
nos. of staircases
and 08 nos. of
lifts of rehab
residential wing
for pedestrian
access and a min
6.00 mts. wide
two-way ramp
for vehicular
access.
Ventilation Ventilation Shaft/ Ventilation Shaft As per Reg.37(7)(iii) of
Shaft/ cutouts cutouts at top at top slab of DCPR 2034.
Light &
at top slab of slab of basement basement
ventilation
basement provided provided
provided
Fire tank, Fire tank, Car parking, Fire Reg. 37(7) (iv) (c):
Domestic flush Domestic / flush tank, Domestic parking Spaces, (b):
tank, pump tank, pump room, flush tank, building utilities and
User room, space for space for STP, pump room, services, & (e): suction
STP, OWC & OWC & service space for STP, tank, pump room, STP
service utility utility room. OWC & service of DCPR 2034.
room. utility rooms.
From the above table, it is observed that the height of the plinth of
basement for rehab slum dwellers building no.3 varies from 0.60 mts. to 1.43
mts. as shown on plan at pg.C-1357 to C-1419 instead of maximum permissible
1.20 mts. as per reg. 37(7)(v)(a) of DCPR 2034.
Further, the height of basement at rehab commercial building no.1 & 4 is
4.20 mts. & the height of basement rehab slum dwellers building no.3 varies
from 4.20 mts. to 6.93 mts. instead of permissible 3.90 mts. as per reg. 37(7)(ii)
of DCPR 2034.
The Architect vide his letter at pg.C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that the
height of the plinth & the basement of rehab slum dwellers building no.3
proposed more than permissible is due to planning constraints since the
topography of the plot u/ref. is slopping in the east west directions in between
S.S. Amrutwar Marg & 6.00 mts. wide existing road. The existing 6.00 mts.
wide road is approximately 1.78 mts. above S.S. Amrutwar Marg, as such to
maintained the 3rd basement slab at uniform level they have proposed basement
height of maximum 6.93 mts.
Further, the Architect has stated that the 6.93 mts. basement is also
used for 2 level stack parking arrangement & building services & utilities
requiring additional height of approximately 6.93 mts. as per the MEP
consultant. The Architect has stated that the additional basement height of
4.20 mts. for rehab commercial building no.1 & 4 is proposed for building
services & utilities requiring additional height of approximately 4.20 mts. as per
the MEP consultant. Thus, he has requested to allow additional basement &
plinth height for rehab commercial building no.1 & 4 & rehab slum dweller no.
3.
Further, it is observed that the Architect has proposed Rehab Slum
dwellers building no. 3 with 3 level basements having max. height of 13.03 mts.
(1st basement = 6.93 mts. + 2 nd & 3rd basement 3.00 mts. each) partly within
building line on front side and partly beyond building line. The maximum depth
of basement is 12.43 mts. The minimum front open space of 3.00 mts. abutting
S.S. Amrutwar Marg. The open space at north side plot boundary is 3.00 mts.
with basement proposed below the 12.20 mts. wide proposed road. The
basement is proposed at zero open space from plot boundary of Renewal
Tenants Building No. 2 at South side & 6.00 mts. wide existing road at East
side instead of 3.00 mts. required as per Reg. 37(7)(i) of DCPR 2034 as shown
on plan at pg. C-1357 to C-1419. The Architect has requested to allow the
basement has proposed along with open space free of FSI.
Also, the Architect has stated that he has proposed the basement of
Rehab Slum Dwellers Building no 3, rehab commercial building 1 & 4 with sub-
standard & zero open spaces due to planning constraints like accommodating
large nos. of parking spaces, building services / utilities like U.G. tank, fire
fighting tank etc. with greater depth, odd & narrow shape of plot, large number
of slum dwellers to be accommodated, major plot affected by road set-back,
access road to adjoining municipal plot, provision of amenity plot etc.as shown
on plan at pg. C-1357 to C-1419 and has requested to allow the same.
Further, the Architect has proposed the basement of rehab slum dwellers
building no.3 at north side below the 12.20 mts. wide proposed road access to
adjoining municipal property at a distance of 3.00 mts. from plot boundary as
shown on plan at pg.C-1357 to C-1419 & has requested to allow the same. The
Architect has stated that he has proposed the same due to planning constraints
as explained above subject to obtaining M & E NOC from MCGM for allowing
the basement as proposed before plinth C.C. to the same. He has further stated
they shall amend the plans if required before plinth C.C.
The condition to that effect is incorporated in the Draft Revised LOI.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO (SRA)’s
1. Order are requested to single level part basement having max. height of 4.20
mts. partly within building line and partly beyond building line below wing
‘B’ of Rehab commercial building. no.1 & wing ‘C’ of Rehab commercial
building no.4 having depth of basement from the average ground level is
3.45 mts & 3.80 mts for rehab commercial building no. 1 & 4 respectively
accessible by a 1.50 mts. wide staircase and lift each for pedestrian access
only & has proposed 3 level part basement having max. height of 13.30 mts.
partly within building line and partly beyond building line below wing ‘A’ to
‘D’ of Rehab slum dwellers building no.3 accessible by 4 nos. 2.00 mts. wide
staircase and 3 lifts each for rehab residential component & 3 nos. of 1.50
mts. wide staircase & 4 lifts for rehab commercial component for pedestrian
access only & provided min. 6.00 mts. wide 2 way ramp for vehicular access
to the basement with depth 12.43 mts. for provision of essential building
services and utilities like U.G. tank, firefighting tank, pump room, RWH, STP
& OWC for Rehab Commercial Building no.1, 4 and Rehab Slum dwellers
‘P’ Building no. 3 free of FSI under clause 6.17 of reg.33(10) read with 37(7) (ii),
37(7)(iv) (b)(c) & (e), reg.37(7)(v)(d) & (e) & 31(1) (v) of DCPR 2034.
2. Orders are requested to allow basement for Rehab Commercial Building no.
4 with zero open space at front side, 1.30 mts. at rear east side instead of
3.00 mts. required as per Reg. 37(7)(i) of DCPR 2034 and more than 1.50
mts. at north side plot boundaries, basement in Rehab Commercial Building
no. 1 with minimum front open space of 1.00 mtr. and at zero open space
from other plot boundaries of Renewal Tenants Building no. 2 at East Side
and Rehab Building no. 3 at North side instead of 3.00 mts. required as per
Reg. 37(7)(i) of DCPR 2034 & basement of Rehab Slum dwellers building no.
3 with 3 level basements having max. height of 13.03 mts. (1 st basement =
6.93 mts. + 2nd & 3rd basement 3.00 mts. each) partly within building line on
front side and partly beyond building line with maximum depth of basement
is 12.43 mts. & minimum front open space of 3.00 mts. abutting S.S.
Amrutwar Marg with open space at north side plot boundary is 3.00 mts.
with basement proposed below the 12.20 mts. wide proposed road & at zero
open space from plot boundary of Renewal Tenants Building no. 2 at South
side & 6.00 mts. wide existing road at East side instead of 3.00 mts.
required as per Reg. 37(7)(i) of DCPR 2034 under clause 6.17 of reg.33(10)
read with 37(7)(i) of DCPR 2034 due to planning constraints as explained
above as requested by the Architect subject to obtaining NOC from MCGM
for allowing the basement as proposed below 12.20 mts. wide road to
adjoining municipal plot before plinth C.C. to the basement in the alignment
of road & that they shall amend the plans as per the requirement of MCGM
if required before plinth C.C.
3. Orders are requested to allow the height of the plinth of basement for rehab
slum dwellers building no.3 varying from 0.60 mts. to 1.43 mts. instead of
maximum permissible 1.20 mts. as per reg. 37(7)(v)(a) of DCPR 2034 &
height of basement at rehab commercial building no.1 & 4 is 4.20 mts. & the
height of basement rehab slum dwellers building no.3 varying from 4.20
mts. to 6.93 mts. instead of permissible 3.90 mts. as per reg. 37(7)(ii) of
DCPR 2034 due to planning constraints since the topography of the plot
u/ref. is slopping in the east west directions in between S.S. Amrutwar Marg
& 6.00 mts. wide existing road of approximately 1.78 mts. to maintain the
3rd basement slab at uniform level due to planning constraints as explained
above free of FSI under clause 6.17 of reg.33(10) read with 37(7)(ii), 37(7)(v)
(a) & 31(1)(v) of DCPR 2034 as requested by the Architect.
19. Parking requirement Rehab commercial bldg. no.1, 4 & Rehab slum
dweller bldg. no.3) :-
The parking spaces required for the Rehab commercial bldg. no.1,4 &
Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3 are tabulated as follows:
Rehab comm. bldg. no.1:-
Carpet area Number Parking required as Required Parking required
of Shops per Reg. 44 DCPR Parking/Flat
Table 21 under 33(10)
of DCPR -2034 Resi. Comm.
Carpet area is 35 1 parking for every 16.75 Nil 16.75
Rehab 670.18 sq.mts. 40.00 sq.mts. for floor
T/S (In rehab area upto 800.00
comm. bldg. sq.mts.
no.1)
Total 35 nos. -- 16.75 Nil 16.75 (a)
Hall (for 227.75 1 parking for every 15 15.18 15.18 (b)
temple) sq.mtr. sq.mtr.
10% parking for guest or min. 2 as per reg. 44 table 21. 3.19 (31.93 x 10%)
Say - 3 nos. (c)
Total (a + b + c) = 34.93 say
35 nos.
Total proposed parking 35 nos.
From the above table it is seen that the Architect has proposed total 152
nos. car parkings spaces at basement level 1,2 & 3 in Rehab slum dweller bldg.
no.03 as against required 152 nos car parking spaces with scooter parkings for
the total rehab component under Reg.33(10) i.e. for Rehab Commercial building
no.1, Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3 and Rehab Commercial Building no.4.
The Architect vide his letter as at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that
he has made provision of car parking spaces for the entire rehab component of
Rehab Commercial Building no.1, Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3 and
Rehab Commercial Building no.4 as there are planning constraints due to odd
& narrow shape of plot, rehab commercial Shops provision at ground floor etc.
therefore, it is not possible to provide car parking arrangement separately
within each individual buildings and thus, he has made provision for the
parking of entire rehab component at basement level 1, 2 & 3 in Rehab Slum
dwellers Building no.3 by way of two level stack parking arrangement at 1 st
basement level and single level parking spaces at 2 nd basement & at 2 level
stack parking arrangement by way of pit & single parkings at 3 rd level basement
of Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3 as free of FSI.
The commercial shops at Rehab Commercial Building no.1 wing A & B &
Rehab Commercial Building no.4 at ground floor are abutting 24.40 mts. wide
S.S. Amrutwar marg, the upper floor shops are accessible by 1.50 mts. passage
at zero open space abutting 24.40 mts. wide D.P.Road connected to 1.50 mts.
wide staircase and a lift deriving through 24.40 mts. wide S.S. Amrutwar marg.
The Architect has proposed 158 nos. of back to back rehab shops
proposed at Gr. to 4th floor in Rehab Slum dwellers Building no. 3 wing A to D.
The Architect has proposed floor to floor height at 1 st to 3rd floor of 4.20 mts.
each. However, the varying height from 3.95 mts. to 4.90 mts. is proposed at
ground floor, minorly more than the permissible height of 4.20 mts. as per Reg.
37(2)(ii) table 15 of DCPR 2034.
The back to back commercial shops at ground floor are abutting 24.40
mts. wide S.S. Amrutwar Marg and 6.00 mts. wide existing road. The back to
back commercial shops at 1st to 4th floor are accessible through 2.00 mts. &
1.50 mtr. wide passage at zero open space 24.40 mts. wide S.S. Amrutwar
marg connected to 4 staircases each of flight width 1.50 mts. and 6 lifts
deriving through 24.40 mts. wide S.S. Amrutwar marg and 6.00 mts. wide
existing road. The proportionate BUA of rehab commercial shops with existing
carpet area or upto carpet area adm. 20.90 sq.mts. is considered towards
rehab BUA/component & excess proportionate built up area beyond carpet
area 20.90 sq.mts. is counted towards sale FSI as per Scrutiny sheet from
Tahsildar–1 (Special Cell) (SRA) vide /no. Kra.tahasi-1vik/Nehru nagar/21/63
dtd. 03/01/2022 as at pg.- C-1815 and proposed by Architect due to planning
constraints as at pg. C–1421 to C-1429.
The depth of the shops is less than 12.00 mts. as per Reg. 34 (3.2) note 2
(a). The Architect has requested to allow the rehab commercial shop as
proposed for Rehab Commercial Building no.1 wing A & B, Rehab Commercial
Building no.4 and Rehab Slum dwellers Building no. 3 as per clause 5.3, 5.4 &
5.5 of Reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034.
The Architect vide his letter at pg. C–1421 to C-1429 has stated that due
to odd & narrow shape of plot, large nos. of slum dwellers / tenants/ shops to
be accommodated, major plot being affected by road setback, essential building
services to be provided at ground floor open spaces, ramps and driveways for
parking etc. there are server planning constraints to proposed all the rehab
commercial shops falling in the alignment or D.P. road at ground floor of the
Rehab component.
2) To order are requested for allowing Rehab commercial shopping with greater
height upto 4.90 mts. more than the permissible height of 4.20 mts. as per
Reg. 37(2)(ii) table 15 of DCPR 2034 due to planning constraints of sloping
topography of the plot from East side to West side with a level difference of
1.78 mts. under clause 6.17 of Reg. 33(10) read with Reg. 37(2)(ii) table 15 of
DCPR 2034.
Further, he has proposed carpet area of the convenience shops not more
than 30.00 sq.mts. maximum permissible as per reg. 2(IV) (32) of DCPR 2034.
In view of above, sale convenience shops having carpet area not more
than 30.00 sq.mtr. at 4th floor of Rehab Slum dwellers Building no. 3 abutting
24.40 mts. wide D.P.Road as per clause 5.6 of reg.33(10) read with reg.2(IV)
(32) of DCPR 2034.
22. Loft :-
The Architect has proposed loft atleast 2.00 mts. away from the entrance
of the rehab shops at Rehab Commercial Building no.1 & 4 & Rehab Slum
dwellers Building no.3 in shops having height not more than 1.50 mts. of sizes
as shown on plan as at pg. C-1357 to C-1419 free of FSI as per reg. 37(4) read
with 31(1) (viii) of DCPR 2034 & requested to allow the same.
The panel rooms are proposed as per the standard requirement of CFO
MCGM indicator panel of fire emergency in the electric room and has thus
requested to allow the same subject to NOC from concern electric supply
company shall be obtained before FCC of bldg. under ref.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO (SRA)’s Order are requested to allow the
proposed electric meter room at ground floor at Rehab Commercial Building
no. 1 & 4 & has proposed meter room/panel at ground floor of Rehab Slum
dwellers Building no.3 with additional height of the electric meter / panel
‘S’ rooms having maximum upto 4.90 mts. minorly more than 4.20 mts. due to
planning constraints of sloping topography of the plot from East side to West
side with a level difference of 1.78 mts. by counting it’s area in rehab fungible
compensatory FSI as tabulated above under Clause 6.17 of Reg. 33(10)read
with Reg. 31(xxxii) of DCPR 2034 as requested by Architect. Subject to NOC
from concern electric supply company shall be obtained before OCC of
buildings u/ref.
Total --- 39 53
92
From the above table it is seen that the Architect has proposed total 92
nos. toilets proposed for rehab commercial t/s. in Rehab Commercial Building.
no.1,4 & Rehab Slum dwellers Building no. 3 as tabulated above by counting
its area in sale FSI as per table no.13 of reg. 36 of DCPR 2034 as shown on
plan at pg. 1357 to C-1419 and has requested to allow the same.
‘T’ height at rehab commercial building no.4 free of FSI for vehicular &
pedestrian access to rehab residential slum dwellers & CFO point of view
under clause 6.17 of Reg. 33(10) read with Reg. 23(4) of DCPR 2034 as
requested by Architect. Subject to CFO NOC of MCGM before further C.C.to
building u/ref.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO (SRA)’s orders are requested to allow the
proposed fire, electrical & low voltage ducts for carrying pipes etc. for various
utilities /services like electric supply and L.V. supply at all floors having sizes
‘X’
and areas as tabulated above with depth of ducts more than 0.45 mts.
touching to habitable rooms by counting its area in rehab fungible
compensatory FSI for Rehab Commercial Building no. 1 & 4 and Rehab Slum
dwellers Building no. 3 under clause 6.17 of Reg. 33(10) read with reg. 31(1)
(xxxi) & 31(3) of DCPR 2034 as requested by Architect.
32. Temple :-
Architect has proposed 04 nos. of temple as per Scrutiny sheet from
Tahsildar–1 (Special Cell) (SRA) vide /no. Kra.tahasi-1vik/Nehru nagar/21/63
dtd. 03/01/2022 in Rehab Commercial Building no. 1 i.e. proposed 1 nos. of
ground + 1st upper floor temple having area adm. 109.74 sq.mtr. & has also
proposed 1 more ground + 1st upper floor temple combined for 03 nos. of
temples having total area adm. 180.00 i.e. 90.00 sq.mtr. each at ground + 1 st
floor on south side of building under ref. each with internal staircase having
flight width 1.20 mtr. by counting its area into Sale FSI as provision for non-
eligible temples as shown in the plan as at pg. C-1357 to C-1419. The height of
Temple portion at ground floor is 4.20 mtr. and at 1st floor is 4.20 mts.
The Architect has also proposed 1 no. of temple within the building line
of rehab commercial building no.4 having height 4.20 mts. directly accessible
from 24.40 mts. wide S.S.Amrutwar Marg as shown on plan at pg.C-1357 to C-
1419 by counting its area in sale FSI as provision for non-eligible temple &
requested to allow the same. The Architect vide his representation as at
pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that the 5 temples proposed are existing on
site. Further, he has stated that due to odd & narrow shape of plot, large no of
slum dwellers to be accommodated, major road set back provisions, of various
services for CFO, Environmental clearance etc. it is not possible to provided
separate temple structures with adequate open spaces. Thus, Architect has
stated that as requested by his clients to allow 4 nos. of temples at rehab
commercial building no.1 out of which 1 temple comprises ground + 1 st upper
floor temple & another ground + 1 st upper floor temple is for 3 combined
Temples proposed within bldg. line & he has proposed 1 no. of temple at
ground floor of rehab commercial building no.4 within the building line &
requested to allow the provision of these non-eligible temples by counting it
area in sale FSI at this stage to be handed over subject to eligibility of the
same. He has requested to allow the same by insisting NOC from the Police
Department & CFO of MCGM before granting C.C. to the temples building or
granting C.C. to temple structure.
The Architect has now proposed internal staircase each having flight
width 1.20 mt. for 02 nos. of rehab temple structure comprising of Ground + 1
upper floors at Rehab Commercial building no.1 i.e. Temple Survey no. 138,
277,278 & 125 of the bldg. Thus, he has counted the area of internal staircase
for these 2 rehab Temple Survey no. 138,277,278 & 125 free of FSI without
charging premium as per Reg. 31(1)(iii), (iv) & (xxv) read with clause 6.14 of
reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034 and requested to allow the same.
34. To allow 27.89 Sq. Mts. (300.00 Sq. Ft.) units on each floor with
inadequate size of rooms.:
Rehab Residential / H.S. T/s :-
Architect has proposed the Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3
comprising of 3 level basement +Ground + 1st to 22nd upper floor having height
75.03 mtr. for 409 t/s. (i.e. 296 rehab resi.,09 R/C, 101 Extra PAP & 03 H.S.
tenement) rehab residential tenements as shown on plan at pg. C-1357 to C-
1419 with rehab residential / H.S. units varying from 27.89 Sq.mt. to 27.91
Sq.mt. of adequate size of room as per Reg. 37 (2) table14,(sr.no. 1,2,10 & 11)
of DCPR 2034 and requested to allow the same.
35. Amenities for rehab slum dweller:-
1) Reference is requested to para sidelined ‘P’ point no. 18 of “Amenities for
rehab slum dweller bldg. no.3” as at pg.N-63 are requested 1) to allow 06
number of Balwadi each having carpet area adm. 25.29 sq.mtr. at 3rd
floor & 06 number of Welfare centers each having maximum carpet area
adm. 25.68 sq.mts. at 3rd floor by counting the corresponding BUA of
20.90 sq.mts. free of FSI & towards rehab component and consequently
counting its area towards sale component & 06 no. of society office each
having maxi. area adm.25.88 sq.mts. at 17 th floor of the rehab slum
dweller bldg. no.03 by counting the corresponding BUA of 20.90 sq.mts.
free of FSI due to planning constraints & towards rehab component and
consequently counting its area in Sale component as requested by
Architect under clause 6.24, 8.1 to 8.3 of Appendix – IV of DCR 33(10)
read with reg. 38(11) of DCR 1991 amended upto date
2) To allow 02 number of Balwadi each having maxi. carpet area adm.
25.88 sq.mtr. at 18th floor & 02 number of Welfare centers each having
maximum carpet area adm. 25.68 sq.mts. at 18 th floor by counting the
corresponding BUA of 20.90 sq.mts. free of FSI & towards rehab
component and rehab consequently counting its area towards Sale FSI &
02 no. of society office having area adm.25.68 sq.mts. at 18 th floor of the
rehab slum dweller bldg. no.03 by counting the corresponding BUA of
20.90 sq.mts. free of FSI & towards rehab component and rehab
consequently counting it’s area towards Sale component for adjoining
slum pocket due to planning constraints as per the request of L.
Surveyor under clause 6.24 read with 8.1, 8.2, 8.3 of Appendix-IV of
Reg.33(10) read with reg. 38(11) of DCR 1991 amended up to date
submitted to then Hon’ble CEO(SRA) at pg.N-09 to C-171 and then
Hon’ble CEO(SRA)’s approval thereon at pg.N-170 may please be seen.
The Architect has proposed total 667 nos. (296 nos. Resi., 243 nos.
Comm., 09 nos. R/C, 15 nos. of existing amenity, 101 nos. of Extra PAP & 03
nos. H.S. (Homeless Shelter) tenements for rehabilitation of slum dwellers in
the Rehab Commercial Building no.1 & 4 and Rehab Slum dwellers Building
no.3 in the subject S. R. Scheme.
The Architect vide his letter at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that the
ornamental projection / vertical fins proposed cannot be misused & thus he
requested to all the same by counting its area once in fungible compensatory
FSI. Further, Architect has stated that he has proposed the vertical fins at all
floors with adequate open space at all sides of rehab slum dwellers building
no.3.
‘Z1’ residential floors for the entire rehab slum dwellers building no.3 by counting
its area once in rehab fungible compensatory FSI as stated above by counting
its area once in FSI, with adequate open space at all sides of rehab slum
dwellers building no.3 as per reg. 31(1)(xii) of DCPR 2034 as requested by the
Architect.
37. Service and ventilation duct abutting to sanitary blocks (Toilet):
Reference is requested to para sidelined ‘Z3’ point no. 33 of “Service and
ventilation duct abutting to sanitary blocks (Toilet)” as at pg.N-91 are
requested to allow the service and ventilation ducts of varying sizes with
service slabs for carrying plumbing services having maximum width upto 2.00
mts. as tabulated above free of FSI for High rise renewal (tenement) bldg. no.2
& High rise rehab slum dwellers bldg. no.3 as per modified Reg. 35(2) (xxiii)
read with clause 6.3 of Appendix-IV of Reg. 33(10) of amended DCR 1991.
Submitted to then Hon’ble CEO(SRA) at pg.N-09 to N-171 and then Hon’ble
CEO(SRA)’s approval thereon at pg.N-170 may please be seen.
The Architect has proposed service and ventilation ducts with service
slabs at 1st floor to top most floor of various sizes with maximum width of 1.05
mtr. abutting the toilets in the high rise Rehab Slum dweller Building no. 3 &
has proposed service & ventilation ducts for the toilets blocks & Rehab
Commercial Building no.1 & 4 free of FSI as per the Reg. 31 (1) (xxiii) of DCPR
2034, as shown in the plans as at pg. C-1357 to C-1419 & requested to allow
the same.
In this case, Architect has proposed the service and ventilation ducts
with service slabs as shown on the plans vide at pg.
C-1357 to C-1419 in Rehab Slum dweller Building no. 3 & Rehab Commercial
Building no.1 & 4 with all internal / external ducts of varying sizes upto 2.00
mtr. with service slabs. Further, Architect vide his representation as at pg. C-
1421 to C-1429 has requested to allow proposed service ducts with service
slabs to sanitary blocks in front of toilet required for carrying plumbing services
and for ventilation free of FSI.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO (SRA)’s approval is requested to allow
service and ventilation ducts with service slabs at 1st floor to top most floor of
‘Z2’ various sizes upto maximum width of 2.00 mtr. abutting the toilets in the high
rise Rehab Slum dweller Building no. 3 & at Rehab Commercial Building no.1
& 4 upto maximum width of 1.20 mts. free of FSI as per the Reg. 31 (1) (xxiii)
of DCPR 2034 as requested by the Architect.
38. Chajja :-
The Architect has proposed chajja at lintel level projecting of maximum of
1.20 mtr. beyond the building line all around for weather protection and 0.60
mts. depth in front of passage of Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3 & Rehab
Commercial Building no. 1 & 4 by counting its area free of FSI as per reg. 42(ii)
(e)(i) read with reg.31(1)(xii) of DCPR 2034 as shown on plan at pg. C-1357 to
C-1419 by proposing on rear & side of more than 2.50 mts. open space.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO(SRA)’s approval is requested to allow
Chajja’s of maximum width 1.20 mts. beyond the building line all around for
‘Z3’
weather protection and 0.60 mts. depth in front of passage of Rehab Slum
dwellers Building no.3 & Rehab Commercial Building no. 1 & 4 by counting its
area free of FSI as per reg. 42(ii)(e)(i) read with reg.31(1)(xii) of DCPR 2034 as
requested by the Architect.
40. Chowk :-
In this case, Architect has proposed chowk for ventilation of habitable
rooms (living room/bed room & kitchen) at all floors of rehab slum dweller
bldg. no.3 wing ‘A’ to ‘D’ comprising of 3 level basement + ground + 1 st to 22nd
upper floors having 75.03 mtr. of sizes & area as tabulated below:-
Building Height of Building upto top of Chowk Area Min. width
parapet proposed proposed
Rehab slum dweller 76.23 313.56 11.03
bldg. no.3
‘Z5’ commercial shops, staircases and passages & toilet having minimum width
11.03 mts. i.e. more than 2.40 mts. by considering regular open space for
each wing of the building accessible through below both built over arch
portion for rehab slum dwellers building no.3 free of FSI as per reg. 41(8) (b)
of DCPR-2034 due to planning constraints as explained above as requested
by the Architect.
J.O.S. for rehab slum dwellers building no.3 = 12.00 mts. (3.00 + 9.00)
(Reg.41(5)(a)(i) & (iii))
J.O.S. of rehab tenants building no. 2 = 9.00 mts. (3.00 + 6.00)
(Reg.41(5)(a)(i) & (iii))
1. Rehab commercial building no. 1 varies from 66.66% to 100% for the
basement & varies from 22.22% to 100% for building above,
2. Rehab commercial building no.4 is upto 100% of basement & varies from
50% to 100% for building above &
3. Rehab slum dweller building no.3 varies from upto 100% for basement &
varies from 38.72% to 100% for building above.
Architect has represented the hardship justifying the deficiency in open
space which is as under:-
(i) Small & odd size of plot to rehabilitate the slum dwellers.
(ii) Large number of slum dwellers,
(iii) major plot affected by road set-back.
(iv) 12.20 mts. wide proposed road.
(v) Amenity plot u/reg.14 of DCPR 2034
(vi) Large number of rehab commercial shops etc.
(vii) Availability of only approximate 56% of buildable plot for rehab &
sale buildings.
i) Health Safety:
The open spaces around the building are proposed to be paved and
surface drainage arrangement is proposed to be provided as per the
requirement of SWD department of MCGM or SWD consultant.
Besides License plumber is appointed for design & supervision of
drainage work, the completion certificate from license plumber shall be insisted
revised drainage requirement will be incorporated in approval conditions.
The Architect vide his representation at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated
that the basement of rehab commercial building no.1 is at a distance of 1.00
mts. at west side abutting 24.40 mts. wide S.S.Amrutwar Marg instead of 3.00
mts. & north & east side to basement of rehab slum dwellers building no. 3 &
renewal tenant building no.2 at zero open space. The Architect has proposed
the building line above at west side abutting 24.40 mts. S.S.Amrutwar Marg at
zero open space instead of required 3.00 mts. & he has requested to allow the
same.
Further, the basement of rehab commercial building no.4 at west side
abutting 24.40 mts. wide S.S.Amrutwar Marg is at zero open space instead of
3.00 mts. required as per DCPR 2034. The Architect has proposed the building
line above at west side abutting 24.40 mts. S.S.Amrutwar Marg at zero open
space instead of required 3.00 mts. & he has requested to allow the same.
The basement of rehab slum dwellers building no.3 at east side abutting
6.00 mts. wide existing road is at zero open space. The basement at south side
is touching the basement of rehab renewal tenants building no.2 & rehab
commercial building no.1 at zero open space due to planning constraints. The
building above is at maximum zero open space adjoining to the 24.40 mts.
S.S.Amurtwar Marg at west side & existing 6.00 wide road at east side.
The Architect vide his letter at pg.C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that as
stated above there are various planning constraints like large area of plot is
affected by road setback, large number of slum dwellers to be accommodated
plot for AOS to be carved out to be handed over to MCGM, provision of layout
R.G. on mother earth etc. Additionally, now they have proposed 12.20 mts.
road passing through the plot at north side as an access to the municipal plot
bearing C.S.no.437(pt).
Since, to restrict earlier proposed maximum building height of rehab
buildings to approximately 70.00 mts. & to restrict the floors of large number
of rehab commercial shops to 4 floors they had to stretch footprint of buildings
to zero open space abutting the roads to make the scheme viable, as such the
deficiency for the basement is maximum 100%.
In view of above, the fire man lifts of size as stated above free of FSI at
mid-landing level of each staircase opening within the fire escape staircase
shall be allowed subject to submission of NOC from CFO of MCGM before
granting C.C of building under reference as proposed by Architect.
43. Refuge area and NOC from CFO:- Double Height refuge area:
Reference is requested to para sidelined ‘Z12’ point no. 43 of “Refuge
area and NOC from CFO” as at pg.N-109 are requested to allow the proposed
refuge area upto 4% free of FSI and by counting excess refuge area into rehab
fungible compensatory FSI at 8th,15th & 22nd floor level in Rehab slum
dwellers bldg. no.3 as tabulated above as per modified Reg. 35(2) (xix) & Reg.
44(7) (a) read with 35(4) of amended DCR 1991. & by insisting the NOC from
CFO MCGM before granting further C.C. to the respective building as
requested by the the L.S., submitted to then CEO(SRA) at pg.-09 to N-171 and
then CEO(SRA)’s approval thereon at pg.N-170 may please be seen.
Architect has proposed double height refuge area at 5th,12th & 19th floor
within & partly beyond the building line due to planning constraints with 4%
area free of FSI & the excess area exceeding 4% is counted in rehab fungible
compensatory FSI of building u/ref. as per reg. 48(8)(a)(ii) read with reg. 31(1)
(xix) of DCPR 2034. The refuge area at 5th floor is having double height i.e. 5.80
mts. height due to excess height of adjoining service area proposed for services
of commercial component below and also 12 th & 19th floor is having double
height i.e. 5.80 mts. height due to planning constraints. The Architect vide his
letter as at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has requested to allow the same.
The Architect has requested to allow the refuge areas as proposed with
additional height subject to submission of NOC from CFO, MCGM before
further CC to the building under reference.
The condition to that effect is incorporated in the Draft Revised LOI.
The details of refuge area required & provided for Rehab Slum dweller
Building no.3 are tabulated as below:
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO (SRA)’s orders are requested to allow the
double height refuge area at 5th, 12th & 19th floor partly within the building line &
partly beyond having maximum height i.e. 5.80 mts. due to excess height due to
The Architect vide his letter at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that they have
proposed the 15 amenities like MCGM office, Budha Mahasangh etc. out of which 10
nos. are counted free of FSI & counting its area in rehab component and 5 temples
are counted in sale FSI due to planning constraints like odd & narrow shape of plot,
major plot affected by setback of D.P. Road, large number of slum dwellers to be
accommodated etc. & has thus requested to allow the same.
‘Z11’ proposed space for 3 nos. watchman / Security booths at entry & exist point
access road S.S.Amrutwar Marg at west side & existing 6.00mtr. wide Road &
12.20 mtr. R.L. at north & east side for rehab slum dwellers building no.3 for
total plot area more than 4000 sq.mts. with carpet area of each booth not more
than 3.00 sq.mts. free of FSI as per reg. 31(1)(ii) read with 42(ii)(g) of DCPR
2034 subject to CFO NOC as requested by the Architect.
The Architect has also proposed hydraulic lifts (i.e. lift machine roomless
lifts) for Rehab Commercial building no.1 & 4 free of FSI as shown on plans at pg.
C-1357 to C-1419 & requested to allow the same.
The details of various staircases & lifts for the Rehab Residential
Component & Rehab Commercial Component of Rehab Slum dwellers Building
no.3, Rehab Commercial Building no.1 & 4 are as tabulated below :-
Sr. Bldg. no. / Floors Staircase (each Lift & Lobbies Remark
no. Wings wing) (each wing)
For For For resi. For Comm.
resi. Comm.
1 Rehab Basement (pt) +Gr. --- 01 nos. --- 01 nos.
Commercial to 2nd(pt)
bldg. no.1 (‘A’ &
‘B’ )
2 Rehab Basement(pt) +Gr. --- 01 nos. --- 01 nos.
Commercial to 3rd (pt) Free of FSI
bldg. no.4
3 Rehab Slum 3 level basement + 01 nos. 02 nos.& 01 01 nos.
Dwellers bldg. Gr.+ 1st to 22nd + 01 nos. no. of (upto 4th floor).
no.3 (‘A’ to ‘D’) Terrace (upto 5th Fireman lift 01 nos. goods
floors.) lifts for two
wings each
(A,B & C,D)
The Architect has requested to allow exemptions of following areas from
FSI computations for Rehab Commercial Building no.1, 4 & Rehab Slum
dwellers Building no.3 as per the provision of DCPR-2043 and MCGM circular
issued dtd.30/01/2020 copy as at pg. C-1633 to C-1635.
i. To allow staircase, lifts, lift lobbies areas & passages on all habitable floors
free of FSI without charging premium for Rehab Commercial Building no.1,
4 & Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3.
ii. To allow the staircase lift, lift lobbies areas at basement floor free of FSI
without charging premium of Rehab Commercial Building no.1, 4 & Rehab
Slum dwellers Building no.3.
iii. To allow the staircase from top most floor to terrace Rehab Commercial
Building no.1, 4 & Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3 free of FSI without
charging premium.
iv. To allow lift machine rooms top most floor to terrace floor free of FSI without
charging premium for Rehab Commercial Building no.1, 4 & Rehab Slum
dwellers Building no.3.
vi. To allow the area of passages free of FSI to the extent of two times of
staircase and lift lobby as per MCGM circular dtd. 30/01/2020.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO (SRA)’s approval is requested to allow the
exemptions of all the above mentioned areas in sr. no. i to vi for Rehab
Commercial Building no.1, 4 & Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3 free of
‘Z12’
FSI and to allow common passage in front of rehab units to be counted into
rehab component as per reg. 31(1)(iii), (iv) & (xxv) read with clause 6.14 of
reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034 and as per MCGM policy circular under
no.CHE/DP/110/GEN dt. 30/01/2020 as requested by Architect.
51. Basement: -
Reference is requested to para sidelined ‘S’ point no. 20 of “Basement for
renewal (tenement) bldg. no.2, rehab slum dwellers bldg. no. 3, rehab
commercial bldg.no.1 & 4 ” as at pg.71.
1) To allow 2 level basements with basement 1 with floor height of 3.00 mtr.
and basement 2 having 2 level car parking arrangement by provision of pit
parking having total max. height 5.50 mts. (inclusive of pit of depth 2.50
mts.) & 3.00 mts. for driveway for renewal (tenement) bldg. no.2 & has
provided 3 level basement for rehab bldg. no.3 with basement 1 with floor
height 4.20 mtr., basement 2 having height 2.90 mts. & basement 3 with
floor height 4.20 mtr for provision of 2 level stack parking & other building
utilities like U.G. tank. Pump room etc. along with the standard building
utilities as requested by SEAC and has provided single basement for rehab
bldg. no.1 & 4 with floor height 3.00 mtr. for other building utilities like
U.G. tank. Pump room etc. along with the standard building utilities as
required by S.E.A.C. for Environmental Clearance free of FSI. All the
basements for renewal (tenement) bldg. no.2 & rehab slum dwellers bldg.
no.3 are contiguous & is separated by single RCC wall in between them.
The L. Surveyor has proposed the basement within the building line having
minimum plinth height of 0.15 mts. & the basement beyond building line is
proposed flushed with the ground level for Rehab buildings no.3 and
Renewal building no.2 for vehicular movement with AA class RCC slab as
per the provisions of clause no. 6.24 of Appendix IV of Regulation no. 33
(10) read with 64 (b) of D.C Regulation 1991, amended up to date subject
to submission of registered undertaking against its misuse.
2) To allow maximum open space deficiency of 100% for basement of rehab
building no.3 touching the compound wall at north side and on south side
touching the basement of renewal (tenement) bldg. no.2 and for rehab slum
dweller rehab / commercial building no.1 & 100% for the basement of
Rehab renewal (tenants) bldg.no.2 & rehab commercial building no.1 i.e.
touching to basement of rehab building no.3 at north side & sale building
no.5 at south side. Also to allow the open space of 3.00 mtr. abutting
24.40mtr. road Shriram Amrutwar Marg & 6.00 mts. wide existing road at
east side for basement of rehab commercial bldg no.1 & 4 & renewal
tenants building no.2 due to planning constraint under reg. 6.24 of
Appendix-IV of DCR 33(10).
3) To allow minimum 0.15 mts. height plinth for rehab building no.1, 3 & 4
and renewal tenants building no.2 instead of min 0.30 mts. and 0.60 mts.
min. required as per DCR 1991 due to planning constraints under reg. 6.24
of Appendix – IV of DCR 33(10).
4) To allow maximum height of basement of 5.80 mts. for renewal (tenement)
bldg. no.2 & rehab slum dweller bldg. no. 3 & rehab commercial bldg. no.1
& 4 under clause 6.24 of Appendix – IV of DCR 33(10) read with reg.38(9)(ii)
of DCR 1991 amended upto date as requested by L. Surveyor.
5) To allow access to basement through 6.00 mts. wide two-way ramp for
rehab slum dweller bldg. no.3 and renewal (tenement) bldg. no.2 touching
to compound wall at zero open space and through staircase only for rehab
building no.1 &4 as requested by L. Surveyor.
6) To allow basement of the renewal no. 2 and rehab bldg. no. 3 extended
below the 9.00 mtr. wide internal pathway touching to the buildings.,
The Architect has now increase the maximum depth of basement to 8.23
mts. instead of earlier approved 5.85 mts. The area of basement is now reduced
to 2931.10 sq.mts. from earlier 3541.46 sq.mts. due to decrease in area
abutting 6.00 mts. wide existing road. The plinth height of the basement is now
varying from 0.60 mts. to 1.93 mts. due to variation in the road levels at west &
east side instead of earlier approved 0.40 mts. within building line & 0.15 mts.
beyond instead of permissible 1.20 mts. as per DCPR-2034. The Architect has
requested to allow the additional plinth height as ventilation is continued to
proposed through mechanically ventilated system.
The alignment of the 6.00 mts. wide 2 way ramp for vehicular access to
the basement within the approved basement line is changed. The services for
the building like STP, U.G.Tank etc. are continued with change location. There
are no other changes in the basement of the proposed renewal tenement bldg.
no.2.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO(SRA)’s orders are requested
1. To allow two level basement within building line & partly beyond building
line at east & west side, basement 1 & 2 each having floor height 3.00
mts. with basement to having 2 level car parking arrangement by
provision of pit parking having total height 10.73 mts. (inclusive of pit of
depth of 2.50 mts.) having depth of basement of maximum 8.23 mts.
having plinth height varying from 0.60 mts. to 1.93 mts. due to
topography of plot accessible through 6.00 mts. wide 2 way drive way
touching to compound wall at zero open space for provision of car
‘Z13’ parking arrangement & other building utilities like U.G.Tank pump room,
Fire fliting tank, OWC, STP, Rain water harvesting tank etc. with
maximum open space deficiency of 100% touching compound wall at
north (rehab building no.3), south (sale building no.5) & west (rehab
building no.1) & 3.00 mts. open space at east side under clause 6.17 of
reg. 33(10) read with 37(7)(i)&(ii), 37(7)(iv) (b)(c) & (e), reg.37(7)(v)(a)(d) &
(e) & 31(1) (v) of DCPR 2034.
Architect vide his letter at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that they
have proposed the additional height of max. 16.85 mts. for stilt free of FSI
which is proposed for rotary parking system as per the requirement of MEP
consultant & has requested to allow the same.
‘Z15’ the proposed area of 03 nos. watchman /security cabin for total plot area more
than 4000 sq.mts. as explain above 31(1)(ii) read with 42(ii)(g) of DCPR 2034
as proposed by Architect.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO (SRA)’s orders are requested to allow the
proposed electric meter /panel room having BUA 16.44 sq.mtr. each for wing
‘Z16’ ‘A’ & ‘B’ instead of earlier approved 15.13 sq.mtr. with maximum height 7.20
mtr. to maintain the entrance lobby level the by counting its area in sale FSI at
ground floor in renewal tenement bldg. no.2 under clause 6.17 read with reg.
37(11) of DCPR 2034 as requested by Architect.
57. Temple :-
In this case, Architect has continued to propose temple within building
line having reduces BUA 12.39 sq.mtr. with height of 7.20 mts. at changed
location instead of earlier approved having BUA 26.50 sq.mtr. having height
7.20 mts. in the Renewal tenements bldg. no. 2 by counting its area in sale FSI
as shown in the plan as at page C-1357 to C-1419 subject to NOC from Police
Department & CFO of MCGM before C.C. to temple structure to the respective
building.
The proposed temple within building line having reduced BUA 12.39
sq.mtr. with height of 7.20 mtr. at changed location by counting its area in sale
FSI instead of earlier approved temple having BUA 26.50 sq.mts. & height 7.20
mts. as shown by Architect shall be allowed subject to NOC from Police
Department & CFO of MCGM before C.C. to temple structure to the respective
building.
64. Service Duct /Service slab abutting to sanitary blocks (Bath & W.C.
for renewal t/s.):-
Architect has proposed the service duct with service slab abutting
sanitary blocks (Toilet) having maximum depth upto 2.00 mts. at all levels for
down take of plumbing services free of FSI as per as per the Reg. 31 (1) (xxiii) of
DCPR 2034 in renewal tenement bldg.no.2 as shown in plan at pg. C-1357 to
C-1419 and requested to allow the same.
The details of service duct/ service slab is as below table:-
Sr. Wing & floors Size & Area of service duct/slab Remarks
No. & nos. of duct at each floor.
1. High rise renewal tenement bldg. no. 2 i) 2.60 x 1.46 x 4 External
wing ‘A’ & ‘B’ comprising of 2 level ii) 1.47 x 2.13 x 4 duct
basement + ground (pt) + stilt (pt) + 1 st to
18th upper floors having height 69.05 iii)2.71 x 1.38 x 2 Internal
mtr. iv) 1.47 x 2.13 x 2 duct
Side D/W O.S. req.(m) O.S. prop. Defi. Defi. (%) Remarks
L/V (m)
Basement
North -- 4.50 0.00 4.50 100% J.O.S. between rehab
(3.00 + 1.50) slum dwellers building no.3
& renewal tenement
bldg.no.2.
East -- 1.50 More than Nil Nil From existing 6.00 mtr.
1.50 wide road.
South -- 4.50 More than Nil Nil J.O.S. between of renewal
(1.50 +3.00) 4.50 tenant bldg.no.2 & sale
bldg. no.5
West -- 3.00 0.00 3.00 100% J.O.S. between basement of
(1.50 +1.50) renewal tenant bldg.no.2 &
commercial bldg. no.1.
Building
North D/W 15.00 9.23 5.77 38.46% J.O.S. between renewal
(6.00 + 9.00) tenant bldg.no.2 & rehab
slum dwellers building
no.3.
South D/W 6.00 +9.00 9.00 6.00 40.00% J.O.S. between renewal
=15.00 tenant bldg.no.2. & sale
bldg. no.5.
East L/V 6.00 More than Nil Nil From existing 6.00 mtr.
6.00 wide road.
West L/V 3.00 + 6.00 = 7.00 2.00 22.22 J.O.S. between renewal
9.00 tenant bldg.no.2 &
commercial bldg. no.1.
It is seen from the above table that the open space deficiency generated
for the renewal tenements bldg. no.2 is maximum upto 100 % for the basement
& varying from 22.22 % to 40.00 % for building above.
Architect has represented the hardship justifying the deficiency in open
space which is as under:-
i) Small & odd size of plot to rehabilitate the slum dwellers.
ii) Large number of slum dwellers,
iii) major plot affected by road set-back.
iv) 12.20 mts. wide proposed road through the plot.
v) Amenity plot u/reg.14 of DCPR 2034
vi) Large number of rehab commercial shops etc.
vii) Availability of only approximate 52% of buildable plot for rehab & sale
buildings.
Therefore, Architect has requested to condone the deficiency in the open
spaces for the renewal tenant bldg. no.2 as stated above as per provisions
Reg.41(5)(a)(i) & (iii), 41(2)(i)(a) table ‘A’ sr.no.4 Reg.37(7)(i) & Reg.41(4) table 18
sr.no.2 read with 6.17 of 33(10) of DCPR 2034.
The requirement of open spaces vis-n-vis requested relaxation as per the
provisions of Reg. No. 6(b) of DCPR 2034, is verified as per given provisions in
respect of following aspects.
In this context Architect has submitted his certificate vide pg. C-1667
i) Health Safety:
The open spaces around the building are proposed to be paved and
surface drainage arrangement is proposed to be provided as per the
requirement of SWD department of MCGM or SWD consultant.
Besides License plumber is appointed for design & supervision of
drainage work, the completion certificate from license plumber shall be insisted
revised drainage requirement will be incorporated in approval conditions.
ii) Fire Safety:
The compliance of Fire safety measures is incorporated as a
condition of approval of amended plans being sought. The completion
certificates from CFO shall be insisted before grant of OCC.
iii) Structural Safety:
Architect has not submitted the revised structural design, drawing &
calculations as per amended plans. The same will be insisted before granting
plinth C.C. A condition to that effect will be incorporated in amended plans
approval letter. Further structural stability certificate from the appointed
License Structural Engineer shall be insisted after completion of the building.
Structural stability of the building is thus taken care.
iv) Public Safety:
Considering the above aspects of Health safety, Fire safety and
structural safety, public safety is taken care.
The Architect vide his representation at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 as stated
that the basement of renewal tenant building no.2 is touching at north side to
basement of rehab slum dwellers building no. 3 & at west side to basement of
rehab commercial bldg. no. 1 at zero open space due to planning constraints
like large area of plot is affected by road setback, large number of slum
dwellers to be accommodated plot for AOS to be carved out to be handed over
to MCGM, provision of layout R.G. on mother earth etc. as such the deficiency
for the basement is maximum 100% required as per DCPR 2034 & he has
requested to allow the same. The open space deficiency generated maximum
upto 100% for basement & maximum upto 65.38% for building above is
condone is earlier vide para sideline ‘Z10’ of earlier LOI report by then Hon’ble
CEO(SRA)’s as stated above.
Now, the Architect has proposed the parking spaces required for the
renewal tenements bldg. no.2 are tabulated as follows:
Renewal tenements bldg. no.2
Carpet Nos. of Parking required Required Parking required
area flat as per Reg. 44 Parking/
DCPR Table 21 Flat
under 33(10) of Resi. Comm.
DCPR -2034
Tenement 105 1 parking for 1 105 105 Nil
with tenements
carpet
area
exceeding
70sq.mt.
Renew
al T/S Total 105 nos. -- 105 105 – (a) Nil
10% parking for guest as per reg. 44 table 21 read with 10.50
notification u/no. TPB-4321/CR-12/2021/UD-11 dtd. Say - 11 nos. (b)
21/12/2021 (@10 %
Total (a + b) = 116 nos.
Total required parking 116 nos.
Total proposed parking 116 nos. (x)
Hall & (84.73) + 1 parking for 6.47 nos. 6.47 nos. say 6 nos.
temple (12.39) = every 15 sq.mtr.
97.12
sq.mtr.
10% parking for guest as per reg. 44 table 21 read with 02 nos.
notification u/no. TPB-4321/CR-12/2021/UD-11 dtd.
21/12/2021
Total 8 nos. (y)
(x + y) 124
From the above table it is seen that the Architect has proposed total 124
nos. car parking spaces required against 124 nos. at basement level 1 & 2 and
stilt in renewal tenements bldg. no.2 as shown on plan at pg.C-1357 to C-1419
free of FSI & requested to allow the same instead of earlier approved 79 nos. of
parking free of FSI. Further, the Architect has proposed total 124 nos. (instead
of earlier approved 79 nos. of parking) by way of 06 level of rotary parking
arrangement at stilt, 1st basement with 21 nos. of single parking & 2 level
basement with 2 level stack parking by way of pit in renewal (tenements) bldg.
no.2 due to planning constraints & requested to allow the same.
The Architect vide his letter at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that due
to planning constraints and odd shape of plot, large nos. of slum dwellers,
major portion of plot affected by D.P. road etc. of renewal tenements bldg. no.2
it is not possible to provide regular parking & thus they have proposed parking
partly stack & rotary parking and request to allow the same free of FSI as
shown on plan pg. C-1357 to C-1419. As there is no specific provision to allow
stack parking / rotary parking arrangement in DCPR 2034.
Wing ‘A’ & ‘B’ comprises of 03 level basements + Gr. (Retail & Restaurant)
+ 1st (Restaurant part & podiums part) + 2nd to 6th (Service utility room part &
part podium) + 7th (part home occupation offices & part podium) + 8 th Amenity
floor + 9th service floor + 10th to 47th residential upper floors having height is
167.90 mtr.
Accessible through 24.40 mtr. wide S.S. Amrutwar Marg at west side and
30.50 mtr. wide G.K. Marg at south side i.e. more than 13.00 mtrs. as per reg.
19(2) (subject to NOC from CFO & HRC, MCGM) instead of earlier High rise
residential sale building no.05 comprising of Three Wings (i.e. Wing ‘A’, ‘B’ & ‘C’
with two level basements + Ground(pt) / stilt(pt)+ four level podiums + 5 th to
57th (pt) upper floor having height 163.15 mtrs.
As seen from above the Architect has proposed mixed users at wing ‘A’ to
‘D’ as under: -
70. Retail :-
The Architect has proposed Gr. + 1st floor for shops / stores for
conducting retail business / trade at all wings in sale building no.5 accessible
from 24.40 mts. wide S.S. Amrutwar Marg at west side & 30.50 mts. wide
G.K.Kadam Marg at south side. The retail shops are limited to less than 50% of
floor space of principal residential user as per sr.no.27 table C of reg. 34(3.2) of
DCPR 2034.
71. Business office & services establishment :-
The Architect has proposed commercial business offices from 2 nd to 7th
upper floor of wing ‘C’ & ‘D’ accessible from 24.40 mts. wide S.S. Amrutwar
Marg at west side. The Business Offices are limited to less than 50% of floor
space of principal residential user as per sr.no.25 table C of reg.34 (3.2) of
DCPR 2034.
72. Home Occupation Offices :-
The Architect has proposed Home Occupation Offices at 7 th upper floor of
wing ‘A’ & ‘B’ of sale bldg. no.5 as shown on plan at pg.C-1357 to C-1419 by
counting its area in sale FSI accessible from 24.40 mts. wide S.S. Amrutwar
Marg at west side as directed by his clients as stated by him vide his letter at
pg.C-1421 to C-1429. The Architect has requested to allow the same as per
sr.no. 76 of reg.2 (IV) of DCPR 2034. The same is elaborated at point no.3.1
above Hon’ble CEO(SRA)’s orders are requested therein.
73. Service apartments:-
The Architect has proposed total 444 nos. i.e. 10 nos. of service
apartment per floor by counting its area in sale FSI as shown on plan at pg.C-
1357 to C-1419 as directed by his clients as stated by him vide his letter at pg.
C-1421 to C-1429 accessible by 2 nos. of 2.00 mts. wide separate staircases &
5 nos. of lifts above the commercial business office of wing ‘D’ from 10 th to 47th
upper floor & requested to allow the same. The same is elaborated at point
no.3.2 above Hon’ble CEO(SRA)’s orders are requested therein.
74. The t/s. statement for sale bldg. no. 05 as per proposed plans is as
under:-
Floor Residential Commercial
Wing-A Wing-B Wing-C Wing-D Wing-A to D
Basement- -- -- -- -- --
1, 2 & 3
Gr. -- -- -- -- 03
1st 01
2nd to 5th -- -- -- -- 04
podium (1 X 4 floor)
6th 01
7th 06
8th Amenity -- -- -- -- --
9th Service -- -- -- -- --
10th (Refuge) 03 03 03 10 --
11th 04 04 04 12
12th 04 04 04 12
13th 04 04 04 12
14th 04 04 04 12
15th 04 04 04 12
16th 04 04 04 12
17th (Refuge) 03 03 03 10
18th 04 04 04 12
19th 04 04 04 12
20th 04 04 04 12
21st 04 04 04 12
22nd 04 04 04 12
23rd 04 04 04 12
th
24 (Refuge) 03 03 03 10
25th 04 04 04 12
26th 04 04 04 12
27th 04 04 04 12
28th 04 04 04 12
29th 04 04 04 12
30th 04 04 04 12
31st(Refuge) 03 03 03 10
32nd 04 04 04 12
33rd 04 04 04 12
34th 04 04 04 12
35th 04 04 04 12
36th 04 04 04 12
37th 04 04 04 12
th
38 (Refuge) 03 03 03 10
39th 04 04 04 12
40th 04 04 04 12
41st 04 04 04 12
42nd 04 04 04 12
43rd 04 04 04 12
44th 04 04 04 12
45th (Refuge) 03 03 03 10
46th 04 04 04 12
47th 01 04 04 12
Total 143 146 146 444 15
The Architect vide his representation at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated
that due to planning constraints like odd & narrow shape of plot, major road
set-back affecting the plot & large no. of slum dweller etc. at ground floor so it
is not possible to make provision of basic services such as U.G. tank, Fire tank,
Domestic tank, pump room, OWC, & flush tank etc. in the marginal open
spaces. Thus, he has provided these services in the basement portion of the
Sale bldg. no.5 by claiming the area of the basement free of FSI and requested
to allow the same.
From the above table, it is observed the total height of the basement is
15.70 mts. for double stack parking & other utilities & services required for
sale bldg. no.5 as per reg. 37(7)(ii) of DCPR 2034. The Architect vide his letter
as at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that they have proposed building
services / utilities like U.G. tank, fire fighting tank, BMS etc. with greater
depth at the basement due to planning constrains like odd shape of plot, large
number of slum dwellers, major plot affected by road set-back etc.
Further, there is no specific provision to allow stack parking arrangement
as per DCPR 2034. The Architect has stated that due to planning constraints
as mentioned earlier they have proposed 3 level stack parking arrangement to
accommodate required car parking spaces in 3 level basement. Thus,
Architect has requested to allow the same subject to NOC from CFO, E.E. (T &
C) & E.E. (M & E) of MCGM.
From the above table it is seen that the Architect has proposed entrance
lobbies 1 each for wing ‘A’ to ‘C’ & 1 no. of entrance lobby each for mixed user
of services apartment & commercial business office at wing ‘D’ of sale building
no.5 of various sizes & areas as tabulated above having height 8.40 mts for
building u/ref. free of FSI as shown on plan at pg. C-1357 to C-1419 &
requested to allow the same.
As per reg. 31(1) (xxi) of DCPR-2034 “Entrance lobbies in stilted portion,
height not exceeding 7.20 mts. or height equivalent to two floor or height of stilt
whichever is more.”
In this case as seen from the section at pg. C-1419 of sale building u/ref.
the floor to floor height for sale business offices at wing ‘D’ & adjoining parking
podiums at wing ‘A’ to ‘C’ from Ground to 7 th upper floor is 4.20 mts. each. The
height of the services apartments at wing ‘D’ & sale residential units at wing ‘A’
to ‘C’ above is 3.20 mts. The height equivalent 2 floor i.e. 3.20 mts. x 2.00 mts.
= 6.40 mts., thus, the maximum height of entrance lobbies permissible as per
reg.31(1)(xxi) of DCPR 2034 is maximum 7.20 mts.
From the above table it is seen that the Architect has proposed Electric
meter /panel rooms 1 each for wing ‘A’ to ‘C’ & 1 no. of Electric meter /panel
room each for mixed user of services apartment & commercial business office at
wing ‘D’ of sale building no.5 of various sizes & areas as tabulated above having
height 4.20 mts. for building u/ref. free of FSI as shown on plan as at pg. C-
1357 to C-1419 as per reg. 31(1)(xxxii) of DCPR-2034. There is no specific
provision in DCPR 2034 to allow panel room, however the same are proposed as
per standard fire safety requirement of CFO MCGM. Further, Architect has
requested to allow the same subject to CFO MCGM NOC & Electric Supply
Company NOC before grating plinth C.C. to the buildings u/ref.
Architect has proposed total 609 nos. car parking spaces at 1, 2 & 3 level
basements by way of 2 level stack parking and from 1st part & 2nd (part) to 7th
(
part) podium level by way of 2 level stack parking as against required 609 car
parking spaces for the sale bldg. no.5 due to the planning constraints as odd &
narrow shape of plot etc. as shown on plan as at pg. C-1357 to C-1419. Thus,
he has requested to allow the same.
The parking are provided as per reg. 44 table 21 read with reg.
31(1)(vi) of DCPR 2034 and the Architect has requested to allow the same free of
FSI.
Also, the Architect has proposed by way of 2 level stack parking
arrangement at podium of sale bldg. no. 5 for provision of parking free of FSI as
shown on plan pg. C-1357 to C-1419 and requested to allow the same subject
to NOC from E.E.(T&C) MCGM and EE(M&E) MCGM before granting plinth CC
to the building u/ref.
‘Z32’ stack car parking as against required 609 car parking spaces for the sale bldg.
no.5 due to the planning constraints as odd & narrow shape of plot etc. as per
reg. 44 table 21 read with reg. 31(1)(v) of DCPR 2034 subject to NOC from E.E.
(T&C) MCGM and E.E.(M&E) MCGM before granting plinth CC to the building
u/r.
86. Podium:-
The Architect has proposed upto 7 th level podium (i.e. 1st part & 2nd (part)
to 7th (part)) within building line accessible through 6.00 mtr. wide two-way
ramp having last podium level of 30.30 mts. i.e. within 32.00 mts. with total
height of podium upto the roof slab of 34.50 mtr. for 2 level stack car parking
provision & scooter parking provision in sale bldg. no.05 along with driver
toilet of size 2.2 sq.mts at each podium level except 1 st & 7th and service utility
room each of 10.00 sq.mts (1 room per 50 tenements) at 2 nd floor to 6th floor
free of FSI as per reg. 31(1)(xxvi) & (xxxii) read with 37(31) of DCPR -2034 as
shown on plan at pg. C-1357 to C-1419 and requested to allow the same
subject to NOC from E.E. (T & C.) of MCGM before further C.C. to building
u/ref.
The open space proposed min. 3.00 mtr. between plot boundary / edge of
road of all side. The proposed car parking spaces are accessible through 6.00
mtr. wide two-way ramp with height of each podium of 4.20 mts. for the sale
bldg. no.5 as per reg. 31(1)(xxvi) read with 37(31) of DCPR -2034.
The condition to that effect is incorporated in the Draft Revised LOI.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO(SRA)’s approval is requested to allow 7th
level podium (i.e. 1st part & 2nd (part) to 7th (part)) within building line accessible
through 6.00 mtr. wide two-way ramp having last podium level of 30.30 mts.
‘Z33 i.e. within 32.00 mts. with total height of podium upto the roof slab of 34.50
’ mtr. for 2 level stack car parking provision and scooter parkings along with
driver toilet of size 2.2 sq.mts at each podium level except 1 st & 7th and service
utility room each of 10.00sq.mts (1 room per 50 tenements) at 2 nd floor to 6th
floor accessible through the 6.00 mtr. two way ramp with each podium having
height of 4.20 mts. with minimum 3.00 mts. open space on all around free of
FSI as per reg. 31(1)(xxvi) & (xxxii), 37(31) of DCPR-2034 subject to NOC from
E.E. (T & C.) of MCGM before further C.C. to building u/ref.
87. Society Office:
The Architect has proposed Society Office as tabulated below: -
Wing User Floor
Nos. of Size Area Height Remarks
Society Mts. Sq.mts. Mts.
Office
‘A’ to Residential Amenity 01 2.87 X 21.20 8.80 Purely
‘C’ floor 6.95, each Residential
(8th Flr.) 1.25X1.00 /
‘D’ Commercial 01 5.81 x 19.99 Commercial
3.44 wings /
Mixed
Users
The Architect vide his letter at pg.C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that as
directed by his clients he has proposed 2 nos. of society office, 1 society office
for residential wing ‘A’ to ‘C’ having carpet area upto adm.21.20 sq.mtr.& 1
society office for commercial wing ‘D’ each having carpet area upto adm.19.99
sq.mtr. as tabulated above with maximum height 8.80 mtr. due to floor height
maintain in sale bldg. no.05 and claiming its area free of FSI under clause 6.17
read with reg. 31(1) (vii) read with 37 (9) of DCPR 2034 as shown on plan at pg.
C-1357 to C-1419 & requested to allow the same.
The developer vide his letter at pg.C-1431 to C-1439 has stated that the
sale building no.5 is a large building with 4 wing with mixed user & thus, they
have proposed 2 society offices for residential & commercial wings for
convenience of the affairs of each society & requested to allow the same subject
to registered u/t. for not misusing the same or for not creating any third party
interest in what-so-ever manner before grating OCC to the buildings u/ref.
The condition to that effect is incorporated in the Draft Revised LOI.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO(SRA)’s orders are requested to allow 02
society offices for residential wing ‘A’ to ‘C’ having carpet area upto adm.21.20
sq.mtr.& commercial wing ‘D’ each having carpet area upto adm.19.99 sq.mtr.
‘Z34’ with maximum height 8.80 mtr. due to floor height maintain in sale bldg.
no.05 and claiming its area free of FSI under clause 6.17 read with reg. 31(1)
(vii) read with 37 (9) of DCPR 2034 subject to registered u/t. from developer for
not misusing the same or for not creating any third party interest in what-so-
ever manner before grating OCC to the buildings u/ref.
From the above table, it is seen that the Architect has proposed toilets as
tabulated above in sale bldg. no.5 by counting its area in sale FSI as shown on
plan at pg. C-1357 to C-1415 and has requested to allow the same as per reg.
36 of DCPR 2034.
89. Drivers Sanitary Blocks:-
The Architect has proposed Sanitary block having area not exceeding
2.20 sq.mts. at each parking floor level / podium for used of drivers free of FSI
at shown on plan at pg.C-1357 to C-1419 & requested to allow the same as per
reg. 31(1)(xxvi) of DCPR 2034.
90. Services utility rooms :-
The Architect has proposed service utility room at each podium level free
of FSI totally adm. 180 sq.mts. i.e at 2 nd to 6th podium levels as per reg. 31(1)
(xxxii) of DCPR 2034 as shown on plan at pg.C-1357 to C-1419 & requested to
allow the same.
91. Amenity floor
91.1 Fitness Centre/Gymnasium:-
The Architect has proposed fitness Centre adm.1122.49 sq.mts. i.e. 2%
equivalent to the total BUA of sale building no.5 by counting its area free of
FSI having 8.80 mts. height & partly with 13.00 mts. height for proposed
badminton court for the use of proposed co-operating housing society
including toilet facility at 8th amenity floor as against required 1123.39 sq.mts.
(56169.66 BUA x 2%) as shown on plan at pg.C-1357 to C-1419 & requested
to allow the same. The Architect has proposed fitness center for various sport
facility users like card room, Reading room, Gym, Badminton, Multipurpose
court, SPA, Yoga etc.
As per reg.37(28) fitness centre including toilets facilities shall be
allowed free of FSI equivalent 2% of total BUA of every building distributed as
desired for the use of co-operative housing society. The centre shall used for
fitness centre activities & reading room.
95. Chajja :-
The Architect has proposed chajja at lintel level projecting of maximum
upto 1.20 mtr. beyond the building line all around for weather protection for
sale building no.5 by counting its area free of FSI as per reg. 42(ii)(e)(i) read
with reg.31(1)(xii) of DCPR 2034 as shown on plan at pg. C-1357 to C-1419
without proposing more than 2.50 mts. open space as required.
Further, Architect has stated that he has proposed the chajja at zero
open space at all floors and open space deficiency is already elaborated in the
report and approvals / orders are also requested.
‘Z39’ for weather protection for sale building no.5 as stated above by counting its
area free of FSI under clause 6.17 of reg. 33(10) read with reg. 42(ii)(e)(i),
reg.31(1)(xii) of DCPR 2034 as requested by the Architect.
The details of refuge area required & provided for Sale Building 5 are
tabulated as below:
Refuge Floor & Refuge Area in. sq.mtr.
Sr. Bldg. Level in. mtr.
Wing Remarks
No. No. Reqd. Prop. Excess
36.40
82.87 46.47
Wing -C
6th flr.(level 26.10)
66.63 66.63 Nil
89.39 Nil (i.e.4.037%
90.21
Wing -A within 4.25%)
10th flr (level 46.30), 90.16 Nil (i.e.4.002%
90.21
17th flr. (level 68.70) Wing -B within 4.25%)
24th (level (91.10) 89.39 Nil (i.e.4.037%
90.21
31st (level 113.50), Wing -C within 4.25%)
38th (level 135.90),
95.20 Nil (i.e.4.003%
95.27
Wing -D within 4.25%)
D
26.53
82.87 56.34
Wing – A
36.74
82.87 46.13
45th flr. level Wing -B
158.30 36.40
82.87 46.47
Wing -C
39.15
71.83 32.68
Wing -D
The Architect vide his letter at pg.C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that are
generated due to planning constraints thus has requested to allow the same.
The necessary NOC from Ex.Engineer (M&E) MCGM will be insisted before
granting further C.C. to building u/ref.
Wing ‘A’ & ‘B’ comprises of 03 level basements + Gr. (Retail & Restaurant)
+ 1st (Restaurant part & podiums part) + 2nd to 6th (Service utility room part &
part podium) + 7th (part home occupation offices & part podium) + 8 th Amenity
floor + 9th service floor + 10th to 47th residential upper floors having height is
167.90 mtr.
As per provisions of Clause 6.15 & 6.17 of Reg. 33(10) & Reg. 41(2) (i) (a)
table A & (5)(a)(iii) of DCPR 2034 for building having height of more than
120.00 mtr. open space required for L/V= max.20.00 Mtr. and for D/W = 9.00
Mtr. and front open space required is 3.00 Mtr. as per table 18 of Reg. 41(4) A,
the requirements of open spaces are as under.
J.O.S. of rehab Comm. building no. 1 = 12.00 mts. (9.00 (D/W) + 3.00)
(Reg.41(5)(a)(iii))
‘Z45 swimming pool (Infinity pool) before asking C.C. for the same and that no
’ Municipal Water shall be used for filling up the swimming pool & shall
indemnify SRA & its officers against any form of litigation in this matter as
regards swimming pool. A registered under taking to that effect from the
developer shall be submitted before approval of swimming pool plans.
The Architect vide his letter at pg. C-1421 to C-1429 has stated that they
have proposed to use the open to sky terrace at top most storey of completely
commercial building /wing ‘D’ as restaurant as per the requirements of
direction of his client by counting free of FSI & counted the area of toilet block
in sale FSI as per reg. 37(22) as an additional amenity for the mixed
commercial users like business office & service apartments & thus, requested
to allow the same subject to allowing the user u/ref. only after obtaining CFO
MCGM, E.E.(T & C) MCGM NOC before approval of the plans & registered
undertaking & indemnity bond from the developer indemnifying CEO(SRA) &
his staff against any future accident / litigations thereof & they shall ensure
that they / the person running the premises shall take necessary precautions
for safety of the occupants.
Wing ‘A’ & ‘B’ comprises of 03 level basements + Gr. (Retail & Restaurant)
+ 1st (Restaurant part & podiums part) + 2nd to 6th (Service utility room part &
part podium) + 7th (part home occupation offices & part podium) + 8 th Amenity
floor + 9th service floor + 10th to 47th residential upper floors having height is
167.90 mtr.
As the height exceeds 120.00 mts., the NOC from Technical Committee
for High-Rise Building having height exceeding 120.00 mts. is necessary as per
Reg. 19(3) of DCPR 2034.
ii) The project proponent shall undertake that they will revised the
executed work as per the suggestion of HRC & indemnify MCGM /
Committee member & his its officers any part of work executed upto
plinth needs to be demolished & reconstructed.
108. Exemption of Staircase Room, Passage, Lift and Lift Lobby Area etc.
From FSI Computation For High rise Sale bldg. no.5:-
1. The Architect has proposed high rise sale bldg. no. 05 wing ‘A’ to ‘D’
having height 167.90 mtr. out of which wing ‘D’ is fully commercial wing
comprising of 03 level basements + Gr. to 1 st (Retail) + 2nd to 5th (business
offices) + 6th (business office & Refuge) + 7th (business office) + 8th amenity
floor + 9th service floor + 10th to 47th upper floor service apartments
having height is 167.90 mtr.
Wing ‘A’ & ‘B’ comprises of 03 level basements + Gr. (Retail &
Restaurant) + 1st (Restaurant part & podiums part) + 2 nd to 6th (Service
utility room part & part podium) + 7 th (part home occupation offices &
part podium) + 8th Amenity floor + 9th service floor + 10th to 47th
residential upper floors having height is 167.90 mtr.
The Architect has proposed 2 Nos. of open well staircases each having
flight width 2.00 mts. and appurtenant common passage along with 02 nos.
common lifts with 01 nos. of stretcher lift & 01 nos. of fire lift, lift lobbies for
each wing ‘A’ to ‘C’ & 2 Nos. of open well staircases each having flight width
2.00 mts. and appurtenant common passage along with 03 nos. common lifts
with 01 nos. of service lift & 01 nos. of fire lift, lift lobbies for purely commercial
building / wing ‘D’ free of FSI at all floors of Sale Building no.5 as shown on
plan as at pg.C-1357 to C-1419.
The Architect has also proposed exclusive 2.00 mts. wide doglegged
staircase along with lift for the restaurant / café / banquet hall at 8 th amenity
floor of sale building no.5.
‘Z49 no.5 free of FSI as per reg. 31(1)(iv) & (xxv), reg.48(5) A(e) read with clause
6.16 of reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034 and as per MCGM policy circular
dtd.30.1.2020 as requested by Architect.
Wing ‘A’ & ‘B’ comprises of 03 level basements + Gr. (Retail & Restaurant) +
1st (Restaurant part & podiums part) + 2 nd to 6th (Service utility room part &
part podium) + 7th (part home occupation offices & part podium) + 8 th Amenity
floor + 9th service floor + 10th to 47th residential upper floors having height is
167.90 mtr.
As per reg. 18(h)(i) of DCPR 2034 since the plot is outside 2438 m from
international civil airport. The NOC from Civil Aviation Department is not
submitted by Architect/developer. Further, the Architect has submitted the
colour coded maps of AAI at pg. C-1657 to C-1659. As seen from the map the
permissible top elevation 135 mtr AMSL or below for sale building no.5 and
115 mtr AMSL or below for rehab buildings. The Architect has proposed Sale
Building no.5 with building height of 177.90 mts. & for rehab commercial
building no.3 with height of 80.53 mts. upto to the top of OHT/LMR/lighting
arrester.
In this case, the Architect has proposed high-rise sale building no.5
having total height 177.90 mts and Architect has stated that as per recent
discussion of installation of radars for monitoring air traffic, it is found as per
data available at pg. C-1845 to C-1847 that MMRDA has carried out survey
through ICAO for permissible building height at BKC. As per ICAO report
published in 2017 based on Indian regulations governing building height
norms plots in BKC is getting height is only between is 50.00 to 75.00 mts.
In the S.R. Scheme under reference the total proposed built up area in-
situ exceeds 20000 sq.mt. and thus, the S.R. scheme attracts the Environment
Clearance. Further, as per this office circular No. 177, SRA/ENG/Desk 1/1775
dtd.6.2.2017 as at pg. C-867 to C-895 of point no.5 for is of doing business in
case of building proposal wherein construction area exceeds 20000 sq.mts. the
IOA shall be issued for the full permissible potential & the CC restricted upto
maximum 20000 sq.mts. construction area.
In view of above, Hon’ble CEO (SRA)’s orders are requested to allow 1 nos.
of electric substation having size of 12.00 mtr. x 3.50 mtr. Having area
adm.40.00 sq.mtr. with height 5.00 mtr. instead of required 2 Nos. as per Reg.
28 (A) table no.11 sr.no.4 of DCPR 2034 free of FSI in R.G. portion on north
‘Z52 side of the plot in the layout with 3.00 mts. from the building and at a distance
of 1.50 mts. from the compound wall under reg.28 (A) table no.11 sr.no.4 &
Reg. 31 (1) (xxx) read with Clause 6.17 of Reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034 subject to
submission of NOC from electric supply company concerned regarding its
location and size before granting C.C. to Sale building u/ref. as requested by
the Architect.
114. Annexure-III:
The Architect has now proposed total 687 nos. (296 nos. Resi., 243 nos.
Comm., 09 nos. R/C, 15 nos. of existing amenity, 101 nos. of Extra PAP, 20 nos. all
amenities, 01 Comm. Hall & 03 nos. H.S. (Homeless Shelter) in the SR Scheme
under Reg. 33(10) of DCPR 2034.
In this case, Architect has stated the certified Annexure-III for 531 nos. of
t/s. for the said scheme from F.C (SRA) has been obtained vide at pg. C-1465.
and Architect has requested to insist the revised annexure III for above said t/s
before further CC to any building in the layout.
1. Approvals is requested to Para’s sidelined ‘D’,‘H’, ‘K’, ‘L’, ‘M’, ‘N’, ‘O’, ‘Z1’,
‘Z2’, ‘Z3’, ‘Z5’, ‘Z11’, ‘Z12’, ‘Z15’, ‘Z19’, ‘Z20’, ‘Z23’, ‘Z24’, ‘Z28’ ‘Z30’, ‘Z32’,
‘Z33’, ‘Z36’, ‘Z37’, Z38’, ‘Z40’, Z42’, ‘Z45’, ‘Z46’,‘Z49’, ‘Z50’, ‘Z51’, ‘Z53’,
‘Z54’ & ‘Z55’.
‘XX’
2. Orders are requested to Para’s sidelined ‘A’ ‘B’,‘C’,‘E’, ‘F’, ‘G’, ‘I’, ‘J’, ‘P’ to
‘Z’, ‘Z4’ ‘Z6’ to ‘Z10’, ‘Z13’, ‘Z14’, ‘Z16’, ‘Z17’, ‘Z18’, ‘Z21’, ‘Z22’, ‘Z25’,
‘Z26’, ‘Z27’, ‘Z29’, ‘Z31’, ‘Z34’, ‘Z35’, ‘Z39’, ‘Z41’, ‘Z43’, ‘Z44’, ‘Z47’, ‘Z48’
& ‘Z52’.
3. To sanction 4.00 FSI for scheme under 33(10) & 3.00 FSI for scheme
under 33(7).
4. Approval is requested to Draft Revised Letter of Intent as at pg. C-1507 to
C-1513.
On Hon’ble CEO (SRA)’s approval on para sidelined ‘XX’ above in the affirmative
Ex. Eng. (SRA)’s approval is requested to :-
1. Draft amended IOA plans of Renewal tenements building no.2 & draft IOA
plans of Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3, 1 & 4 as at pg. C-1357 & C-
1359, C-1361 to C-1367 & 1369 to C-1401 and 1403 respectively.
2. Draft amended IOA letter of Renewal tenements building no.2 as at pg C-
‘YY’
1653
3. Draft IOA letter of Rehab Slum dwellers Building no.3, 1 & 4 as at pg C-
1639 to C-1651.
Submitted please,