Measuring Performance of Microfinance Institutions A Framework For Reporting Analysis and Monitoring Toolkit
Measuring Performance of Microfinance Institutions A Framework For Reporting Analysis and Monitoring Toolkit
Measuring Performance of Microfinance Institutions A Framework For Reporting Analysis and Monitoring Toolkit
OF MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS:
A FRAMEWORK FOR REPORTING,
ANALYSIS, AND MONITORING
TRAINER’S GUIDE
AUGUST 2005
This publication was produced for review by the United States Agency for International Development.
It was prepared by Development Alternatives, Inc.
MEASURING PERFORMANCE OF
MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS:
A FRAMEWORK FOR REPORTING,
ANALYSIS, AND MONITORING
TRAINER’S GUIDE
The authors’ views expressed in this publication do not necessarily reflect the views of the United
States Agency for International Development or the United States Government.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
OVERVIEW 1
OVERVIEW 1
This guide contains a brief section on Introduction to the Spreadsheet Tool that describes how to
introduce the tool during the training and how to input the data into the tool using the case study
financial data and information. The trainer must decide how to integrate the case study financial data
and information and the use of the tool for analytical adjustments, ratios and indicators, and creating
and analyzing performance monitoring reports.. The training timeline identifies times during the
three days when to use the tool.
A powerpoint presentation accompanies the training. For this training the powerpoint slides are brief
notes to accompany the training. Depending on your situation you can also write this information on
flipcharts.
Pages 1 and 2 for each module is a description of the goals and objectives for the module and a
session plan that includes topics, technique, time, and materials needed.
The training agenda is very aggressive, with approximately 7 and a half hours of training for day 1
and 2. There are evening assignments that must be completed. Day 3 is not as defined so that the
trainer has some time at the end of the training if needed.
As the training is very intensive, the trainer might need to use some energizers during the day based
on participants’ ability to focus and concentrate. A list of energizers is presented in this guide at the
end of the Introduction Module.
PARTICIPANT GUIDE
For this training participants will be given a copy of the guide Measuring Performance Of
Microfinance Institutions: A Framework For Reporting, Analysis, And Monitoring. At times during
the training participants will be asked to refer to their guide or read a section of their guide for the
evening assignment. The small/large group exercises are all based on material that is in the guide.
To regularly assess the relevancy, flow, timing, etc of the training two quick training assessments are
included at the end of the Introduction module. These can be used at the end of the day for a quick
assessment of participant’s perceptions of the training.
Additionally a more detailed end of training is included at the end of the Introduction module.
The 3-day training timeline describes the flow of training topics and suggested timeframes. The
timeframes are for time budgeting only as they will vary depending on the audience and the trainer.
This training timeline does not include time for breaks or an evening assignment. The training
timeline does include time for lunch.
OVERVIEW 3
INTRODUCTION
Technique and
Session Materials
Time
Other
Daily Evaluation
Forms
End of Training
Evaluation
Energizer ideas
Step 1: Introduction
Lecturette
Welcome participants to the training.
5 minutes
Representative from the host or partner organization welcomes
participants and opens training. Introduction of and hand-over
to Facilitators.
Explain
OVERVIEW 5
Technique and
Session Materials
Time
that person to the rest of the group.
Ask
Explain the training agenda. Point out times for start and finish,
tea/coffee break, lunch.
Please be on time.
Leave the flip chart with rules posted on the wall throughout the
training.
Methodology
OVERVIEW 7
HANDOUT INTRO.1
PEOPLE HUNTER
Instructions: Find someone who has or did one of the following. When you have found a person,
write the person’s name in the box. A participant may appear only once on your sheet.
OVERVIEW 9
FIND SOMEONE
MY NAME
Interesting 1 2 3 4 5 Uninteresting
Relevant 1 2 3 4 5 Irrelevant
Organized 1 2 3 4 5 Disorganized
Relaxed 1 2 3 4 5 Tense
Interesting 1 2 3 4 5 Uninteresting
Relevant 1 2 3 4 5 Irrelevant
Organized 1 2 3 4 5 Disorganized
Relaxed 1 2 3 4 5 Tense
OVERVIEW 11
DAILY FEEDBACK/EVALUATION FORMS
Why:
Why:
Why:
Why:
COURSE EVALUATION
1. What are the most significant skills and/or knowledge you gained from the course Measuring
Performance of Microfinance Institutions?
2. What additional skills and knowledge do you need to learn more about to create financial statements
in the recommended format?
3. What additional skills and knowledge do you need to be able to use the spreadsheet tool at the MFI
you work at?
5. What will you have difficulty applying to your work that you learned this week? Why?
6. What did you not learn in this training that you were expecting to learn:
OVERVIEW 13
7. How did you feel about the length of the program?
Course Content 1 2 3 4 5
Comments:
Course Methods 1 2 3 4 5
Comments:
Course Materials 1 2 3 4 5
Comments:
Comments:
Overall Course 1 2 3 4 5
Comments:
Course Organization 1 2 3 4 5
Comments:
Pre-Course 1 2 3 4 5
Organization/communication/
Advertising
Comments:
Facilities 1 2 3 4 5
Comments:
Trainer name
Trainer name
Trainer name
Trainer name
OVERVIEW 15
ENERGIZERS
1. Simon Says: Tell all participants to stand up. The rules of the game are that the trainer will
tell the group to do something by saying “Simon says…” For example “Simon says touch
your head”. The trainer will then tell the group to do something without saying simon says.
Those people who did as they were told must sit down. Continue until there is one
participant left standing.
2. Ha Ha: Tell everyone to stand up. Explain that you will give the first person a word to say.
The next person must repeat the same word saying it twice, the next person three times, etc.
around the room. The word is ha. Try to go as fast as possible.
3. Scavenger Hunt: Put participants in teams of three or four people. Tell them this is a
scavenger hunt. All teams must bring to you the items that you tell them. Come up with
three or four items. Tell the teams that the items must be presented to you at one time.
4. Human Machines: Put participants into groups of 5 to 8 people. Each team has 5 minutes to
design a human machine where the members are the components of the machine. At the end
of 5 minutes the teams must demonstrate its human machine. The trainer can assign a
machine to each team. Ideas include a clock, a bicycle, a computer, a motorboat, a fan.
5. Tied in Knots: (This energizer may not be appropriate for all groups). Ask the participants to
stand and form a circle. Tell participants to raise their left hand in the air and place their right
hand into the center of the circle. All participants must take their left hand and grab someone
else’s right hand. Participants are to untangle themselves without breaking their grip on each
other. Some of the participants could be facing away from the center of the circle at the end
of this.
Goal Microfinance Practitioners will articulate how their microfinance institution will benefit
from using a performance monitoring framework.
Discuss how the framework provides standards for the microfinance industry and
how individual institutions can benefit from those standards.
Be familiar with the framework’s referencing system to better identify terms used
in the framework and help interpret formulas.
Duration 20 minutes
MODULE 1 SUMMARY
Time and
Session Materials
Technique
The Tool
STEP 1: INTRODUCTION
LECTURE AND
DISCUSSION Display
1 minute PPT 6 Goals and Objectives: Module 1 The Performance Monitoring Framework
PowerPoint Describe
Slide 6
The objectives and discuss the topics for this module. By the end of Module 1,
participants will:
Describe what a performance monitoring framework is and why a framework is
critical to monitoring their institutions performance.
Discuss how the framework provides standards for the microfinance industry and
how individual institutions can benefit from those standards.
Be familiar with the framework’s referencing system to identify terms used in the
framework and help interpret formulas.
Goal To construct and analyze financial statements and reports using terminology and formats that
promote global standards for microfinance institutions.
Describe the income statement, balance sheet, cash flow statement, portfolio report and non-
financial data report, and explain their significance and how they are related.
Duration 8 hours
MODULE 2 SUMMARY
Time and
Session Materials
Technique
Lecturette and Overview of Financial Statements and Reports Powerpoint slides 13-14
discussion
Facilitator provides an overview of the session goal and
10 minutes objectives.
Ask
What accounts are included under financial expense?
Responses include:
Financial expense on funding liabilities to include interest and fee expense on
deposits and interest and fee expense on borrowing
Other financial expense
Write the account names on the overhead/word document.
Participants might use different terminology for account names. The Facilitator must
understand the type of account that is being discussed and if necessary translate that
language to use the terminology that is described in the Framework. The terminology
in the Framework is the terminology that participants are encouraged to use.
Review the definition of each account
Ask
How do you calculate Financial Expense on Funding Liabilities?
Response
Interest and Fee Expense on Deposits + Interest and Fee Expense on Borrowings
I9 + I10.
Write the response on the overhead in the calculation column for Financial Expense
Payment of dividends
Explain that there are two ways a cash flow statement can be constructed
Direct method that shows all the cash transactions in and out of the Cash and
Due from Banks account.
The direct method for preparing a cash flow statement is the most intuitive of the
methods. It reconstructs the income statement by tracing the movement of cash
and adds other events not included on the income statement that have caused an
inflow or outflow of cash.
Indirect method deduces the movement of cash based on the changes in specific
income statement and balance sheet accounts.
It begins with the (I28) Net Income (After Taxes and Before Donations) and then
adds back all other sources of cash (such as loan payments) and subtracts all
other uses (such as loan disbursements) that can be deduced by changes in
balance sheet accounts.
Add that both methods can be used for this Framework.
Construct, Define and review a direct cash flow statement.
1. Pass out to all participants 1 or 2 cards from material 2.7 (Constructing a Cash
Flow Statement) and a copy of overhead/handout 2.8 Direct Cash Flow
Statement Template. Each card has one term written on it from either operating
activities, investing activities, or financing activities. Depending on how many
participants are in the training, each person should get at least one card. If some
20 minutes Ask
Handout: Whose institution produces a non-financial data report?
2.15 Non- Why does the institution collect this information?
Financial Data
How do you use this information?
45 minutes Review key points about financial statements and reports. Emphasize:
Overhead/ A lot of time was spent on reviewing financial statements, learning how to
Handout: categorize data into statements and reports, and becoming familiar with new
terminology.
2.16 Matrix to
Identify Linkages The financial statements and reports presented in this chapter include the
between minimum of information necessary to present accurately an MFI’s activities and
Financial results. All information presented in this framework is significant and
Statements noteworthy.
Every item is also necessary for managers to analyze the MFI’s performance and
condition and to create performance monitoring reports for themselves and
others.
Communicating less (but meaningful) information is sometimes better than
providing detailed information without explanation. Executive summaries,
narratives, and footnotes are vital to making financial statements transparent and
accessible to non-financial readers and financial analysts alike.
Say
The financial statements used in this Framework are linked. Managers should
learn the primary connections among the statements.
Ask
Why is it important to know and understand the linkages between the financial
statements? What does this tell us?
Describe activity
To understand and become more familiar with how the financial statements are
linked we will work on an activity.
The purpose of the activity is for participants to compile a list of main links between
financial statements that we have worked with. For this activity participants will
need their copy of handout 2.2 Sample Income Statement, handout 2.5 Sample
Balance Sheet, handout 2.10 Sample Direct Cash Flow Statement, handout 2.13
Sample Portfolio Report.
1. Describe the outcome of this activity: Each group is to identify as many linkages
I1
I2
I3
I4
I5
I6
I7
I8
I9
I10
I11
I12 Net Financial Income
I13
I14
I15
I16
I17
I18
I19
I20
I21 Net Operating Income
I22
I23
I24
From From
Ref. X-Ref. Account Name 1/1/2004 to 1/1/2003 to
12/31/2004 12/31/2003
I25 C27 Net Income (Before Taxes and Donations) 773,822 1,033,490
a a
I26 C8 , C30 Taxes 760,816 732,306
I27 B28 Net Income (After Taxes and Before 13,006 301,184
Donations)
Micro MFI, a microfinance institution that you work for as a manager, has made a decision to use the
SEEP Framework as part of their performance monitoring system. In order to use the framework Micro
MFI must create financial statements in the SEEP Framework format. As managers your job is to map
the income and expense information into the SEEP Framework income statement.
1. The task for your team is to create an income statement using the SEEP Framework Format.
2. The first step is to review the income and expense information and the trial balance of Micro MFI.
When reviewing this information you need to determine what accounts, if any, need to be relocated
into different accounts based on the SEEP Framework Income Statement.
3. Map the financial information into the SEEP Framework Income Statement format. To do this use
the worksheet Micro MFI Income and Expense Information. The last column in this worksheet is to
write the reference number for the SEEP Framework Income Statement. The last column is a guide
for you to use if you choose.
4. Complete Micro MFI’s SEEP Framework Income Statement for the current year and the past year.
in thousands From Income Statement From Trial Balance Current Year Last Year Framework Account
Interest and Fees on Loans 136,896.4 77,975.4 Interest on Loans 128,777.9 67,290.8
Registration Fees 6,097.2 3,704.0
Loan Application Fees 2,021.3 -
Risk Premium 6,980.6
Direct Expenses
Interest Expense 3,923.8 1,165.4 Interest on Loan 30.0 124.7
Interest on Savings 3,893.8 1,040.7
Provision for Loan Losses 10,034.8 5,138.1
Total Direct Expenses 13,958.6 6,303.5
2-32 MEASURING PERFORMANCE OF MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS: A FRAMEWORK FOR REPORTING, ANALYSIS, AND MONITORING
Operating Grants - 748.2
Loan Capital Grants 20,897.2 43,159.9
in thousands From Income Statement From Trial Balance Current Year Last Year Account
Interest and Fees on Loans 136,896.4 77,975.4 Interest on Loans 128,777.9 67,290.8 I3
Registration Fees 6,097.2 3,704.0 I4
Loan Application Fees 2,021.3 - I4
Risk Premium 6,980.6 I4
Direct Expenses
Interest Expense 3,923.8 1,165.4 Interest on Loan 30.0 124.7 I10
Interest on Savings 3,893.8 1,040.7 I9
Provision for Loan Losses 10,034.8 5,138.1 I14
Total Direct Expenses 13,958.6 6,303.5
Net Interest after Provision for Loan Loss 122,937.8 71,671.9
Other Operating Revenue 1,473.3 814.0 Bad Debt Recovered 503.5 I15
Bank Interest Received 13.5 9.5 I5
Income on Investments 260.5 254.2 I5
Pass book sales 184.5 228.7 I6
Sale of Fixed Assets 100.0 - I6
Other 411.3 321.6 I6
Net Operating Revenue 124,411.1 72,485.9
Non-Interest Expenses
Salaries and Benefits 45,252.4 28,575.3 I17
Administrative Expenses 42,283.6 22,676.7 Finance and Bank Charges 2,029.9
Services Charges 725.9 I19
Overdraft Interest 1,304.0 I10
Occupancy Expenses 2,226.0 1,840.0 I19
Travel 15,399.6 9,250.0 I19
2-36 MEASURING PERFORMANCE OF MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS: A FRAMEWORK FOR REPORTING, ANALYSIS, AND MONITORING
HANDOUT 2.3
I1 Financial Revenue
I2 Financial Revenue from Loan Portfolio
I7 Financial Expense
FACILITATOR NOTES
The result is the following income statement for the past two years.
Assets
B1
B2
B3
B4
B5
B6
B7
B8
B9
B10
B11
Liabilities
B13
B14
B15
B16
B17
B18
B19
B20
Equity
B22
B23
B24
B25
B26
B27
B28
B29
B30
B31
ASSETS
LIABILITIES
EQUITY
To continue your work in organizing Micro MFI’s financial statements into the SEEP Framework
formats, you have been given the balance sheet information. You must map the balance sheet data into
the SEEP Framework balance sheet
1. The task for your team is to create a balance sheet using the SEEP Framework Format.
2. The first step is to review the balance sheet and the trial balance from Micro MFI. When reviewing
this information you need to determine what accounts, if any, need to be relocated into different
accounts based on the SEEP Framework Balance Sheet.
3. Map the financial information into the SEEP Framework Balance Sheet format. To do this use the
worksheet Micro MFI Balance Sheet and Trial Balance Information. The last column in this
worksheet is to write the reference number for the SEEP Framework Balance Sheet. The last column
is a guide for you to use.
Complete Micro MFI’s SEEP Framework Balance Sheet for the current year and the past year.
in thousands Current Year Last Year From Trial Balance Current Year Last Year Account
Assets From Balance Sheet
Cash and Bank Balances 20,444 5,458
Deposits and Short-term
Investments 3,450 9,450
Loan Portfolio 248,875 179,816
Less Reserve (6,177) (4,058)
Loan Portfolio (net of
reserve) 242,698 175,758
Other Current Assets 27,414 14,050 Prepayments 1,712 1,421
Employee Advances 16,351 5,486
Accrued Interest 2,650 2,354
Capitalized MIS Expenses 1,913 2,476
Subsidiary Investments 4,788 2,313
Total Current Assets 294,005 204,716
Fixed Assets (Net) 49,402 40,897 Vehicles 9,067 8,717
Computer Equipment 5,987 1,508
Furniture 14,232 9,419
Machinery 3,992 2,727
Land and Building 35,505 33,597
Accumulated Depreciation on:
2-48 MEASURING PERFORMANCE OF MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS: A FRAMEWORK FOR REPORTING, ANALYSIS, AND MONITORING
Grant Balance
- -
Previous Year
Accumulated Operating
Accumulated Surplus 57,725 30,486 Surplus 15,788 (3,700)
Previous Year
Accumulated Operating
Grants 19,034 18,286
Net Operating Surplus 28,628 15,788
Operating Grants - 748
Total Equity 200,334 152,197 Difference (5,725) (637)
Total Liabilities and Equity 365,718 267,973
in thousands Current Year Last Year From Trial Balance Current Year Last Year Account
Assets From Balance Sheet
Cash and Bank Balances 20,444 5,458 B1
Deposits and Short-term
Investments 3,450 9,450 B2
Loan Portfolio 248,875 179,816 B5
Less Reserve (6,177) (4,058) B5
Loan Portfolio (net of
reserve) 242,698 175,758 B4
Other Current Assets 27,414 14,050 Prepayments 1,712 1,421 B7
Employee Advances 16,351 5,486 B7
Accrued Interest 2,650 2,354 B6
Capitalized MIS Expenses 1,913 2,476 B10
Subsidiary Investments 4,788 2,313 B8
Total Current Assets 294,005 204,716
Fixed Assets (Net) 49,402 40,897 Vehicles 9,067 8,717 B10
Computer Equipment 5,987 1,508 B10
Furniture 14,232 9,419 B10
Machinery 3,992 2,727 B10
Land and Building 35,505 33,597 B10
Accumulated Depreciation on:
Vehicles (6,820) (6,891) B11
Computer Equipment (2,519) (627) B11
Furniture (4,767) (3,697) B11
Machinery (840) (151) B11
Land and Building (4,434) (3,706) B11
Long-Term Investment 22,310 22,360 49,402 40,897
2-52 MEASURING PERFORMANCE OF MICROFINANCE INSTITUTIONS: A FRAMEWORK FOR REPORTING, ANALYSIS, AND MONITORING
HANDOUT 2.6
As of As of
Ref. X-Ref. Term
31/12/2004 31/12/2003
ASSETS
B2 Short-term Investments
B8 Other Investments
LIABILITIES
EQUITY
B29 Reserves
B32
FACILITATOR NOTES
As of As of
Ref. X-Ref. Term
31/12/2004 31/12/2003
ASSETS
LIABILITIES
EQUITY
B29 Reserves
Operating Activities
Investing Activities
Cash Received from Interest, Fees, and Commissions on Net (Purchase)/Sale of Other Investments
Loan Portfolio
Investing Activity
Operating Activity
Cash Received as Other Operating Revenue Net Cash from Investing Activities
Value of Loans Repaid Net Cash Received /(Repaid) for Short- and Long-term
Borrowings Financing Activity
Operating Activity
(Cash Paid for Financial Expenses on Funding Liabilities) Issuance/(Repurchase) of Paid-In Capital
Financing Activity
Net (Purchase)/Sale of Trade Investments Net Change in Cash and Due from Banks
Deposits/(Withdrawals) from Clients Cash and Due from Banks at the Beginning of the Period
Cash Received/(Paid) for Other Operating Assets and Exchange Rate Gains/(Losses) on Cash and Cash
Liabilities Equivalents
Net Cash from Operating Activities Cash and Due from Banks at the End of the Period
C1
C2
C3
C4
C5
C6
C7
C8
C9
C10
C11
C12
C13
C14
C15
C16
C17
C18
C19
C20
C21
C22
C23
C24
C25
C26
C1 I2a Cash Received from Interest, Fees, and Commissions 16,403,668 8,847,498
on Loan Portfolio
C12 Cash Received/(Paid) for Other Operating Assets and (1,100,000) (1,010,308)
Liabilities
C17 C41 Net Cash Received /(Repaid) for Short- and Long-term 1,365,241 6,533,518
Borrowings
C23 C47 Net Change in Cash and Due from Banks 1,801,521 (362,632)
C24 C48 Cash and Due from Banks at the Beginning of the 1,146,142 900,000
Period
C25 C49 Exchange Rate Gains/(Losses) on Cash and Cash 313,532 609,774
Equivalents
C26 C50 Cash and Due from Banks at the End of the Period 3,261,195 1,146,142
a
If an MFI uses cash accounting, these accounts will have the same value as the cross-referenced accounts. If the MFI uses
accrual accounting, these values will not be the same as the cross-referenced account. In the example above, the MFI uses
accrual-based accounting for financial revenue, financial expense, and operating expenses so that (C1), (C5), and (C7) are not the
same value as their income statement references.
C39 C15 (Increase)/Decrease in Book Value of Gross Fixed Assets (2,892,769) (747,282)
C46 I22a, C22 Net Cash Received/(Paid) for Non-Operating Activities (1,403,143) (1,838,992)
C47 C23 Net Change in Cash and Due from Banks 1,801,521 (362,632)
C48 C24 Cash and Due from Banks at the Beginning of the Period 1,146,142 900,000
C49 C25 Effect of Exchange Rate Changes on Cash and Cash 313,532 608,774
Equivalents
C50 C26, B1 Cash and Due from Banks at the End of the Period 3,261,195 1,146,142
You have now been told to create a cash flow for Micro MFI. You know from experience that Micro
MFI does not usually create this document on its own. In preparation for your task Micro MFI has
created a chart that you can use that compares how balance sheet accounts have increased or decreased.
Micro MFI does not have detailed information for 2002 and decides that you should construct a cash flow
for 2004, showing the movement in cash from the end of 2003 to the end of 2004. Using the financial
data presented create a cash flow using the indirect method.
1. The task for your team is to create a Micro MFI cash flow, using the indirect method, for the period
from the end of 2003 to the end of 2004.
2. The first step is to review the financial data. When reviewing this information determine what
accounts, if any, need to be relocated into different accounts based on the SEEP Framework Indirect
Cash Flow.
3. Map the financial information into the SEEP Framework Cash Flow format.
Difference
Current Year Previous Year Net Change
Loans to Clients
Beginning 179,816
Loans Disbursed 620,532
Loans Repaid (543,696)
Principal Before Write-Off 256,652
Write-off of Bad Debt (7,777)
Principal Balance At End 248,875
Demand Deposits - - -
C48 C24 Cash and Due from Banks at the Beginning of the Period
C50 C26, B1 Cash and Due from Banks at the End of the Period
FACILITATOR NOTE
C47 B1 Cash and Due from Banks at the End of 20,444 5,458
the Period
Portfolio Activity
Another Micro MFI manager has prepared the Portfolio Report and you are asked to review the report.
1. The task for your team is to review the prepared Portfolio Report to determine if Micro MFI has
appropriately represented the Portfolio Activity, Movement in Impairment Loss Allowance, and the
Portfolio Aging Schedule.
2. If your group determines that data in the report needs to be modified, identify that information and
determine what you would do to the data.
From 1/1/2004 to
From 1/1/2003 to 31/12/2003
31/12/2004
Ref. X-Ref.
Number of Value of Number Value of
Loans Portfolio Of Loans Portfolio
Portfolio Activity
P1, C9, Loans Disbursed during the 52,146 620,532 28,440 361,190
P2 C30 period
Operational Data
Macroeconomic Data
N11 Exchange Rate (Local Currency: U.S. Dollar, Euro, 48.0 45.0
or other)
Cash Flow
Income Balance Portfolio
Statement
Statement Sheet report Relationship
(Tables 2.6 and
(Table 2.1) (Table 2.3) (Table 2.10)
2.8
FACILITATOR NOTES
Cash Flow
Income Balance Portfolio
Statement
Statement Sheet report Relationship
(Tables 2.6 and
(Table 2.1) (Table 2.3) (Table 2.10)
2.8
(C25) Exchange
Rate Gains/
(Losses) on Cash
and Cash
Equivalents
(P2) Value of
Loans
Disbursed
SUMMARY OF ADJUSTMENTS
No. of Subsidy
Estimated Monthly Actual
Personnel Months (a – b) x
MarketCost (a) Monthly Cost (b)
(c) c
i Executive Director 2,000 0 12
ii Accountant 800 0 12
iii Part-time MIS Manager 400 100 12
iv Trainer 400 200 6
Adjustment for Personnel Expenses
Other Administrative Expenses
i Rent 1,500 400 12
ii Software Support 50 0 12
Adjustment for Other Administrative Expenses —
Fixed Assets Depreciation Rate Depreciation Rate
i Head Office Vehicle 12,000 0 20%
ii Branch Office Vehicle 18,000 0 20%
iii Four Computers, Branch Office 3,600 500 33.33%
Adjustment to Depreciation Expense
Total In-Kind Subsidy Adjustment
MICRO MFI operates in a country where inflation is fairly stable each year and is usually between 4 and 12 percent.
According to the Central Bank, the average annualized inflation rate for the year was 6.5 percent. MICRO MFI has a
grant agreement with a multilateral donor. The MFI draws down funds at the beginning of every month according to
its grant agreement and liquidates the advances at the end of each quarter. At the end of the year, MICRO MFI used
some of its cash from retained earning to purchase two new vehicles. The purchase nearly doubled the value of the
MFI’s net fixed assets.
To calculate the true performance inflation adjustment, MICRO MFI determined that it was best to use the value of its
Net Fixed Assets from the beginning of the year before the purchase of the two new vehicles shortly before the end of
the year. At the same time, management believes that using average equity is the best approach because its
Donated Equity and Retained Earnings were fairly steady throughout the year. Management uses a monthly average.
A3 = A3.1 – A3.2 =
The effect on MICRO MFI’s income statement is to increase the Net Inflation Expense by 107,250, resulting in the
same decrease in Net Income (After Taxes and Before Donations). On its balance sheet, management records an
increase of 9,750 in Net Fixed Assets. Because Assets have increased by 9,750, and Equity has decreased by
107,250, MICRO MFI must add 117,000 to the Adjustments to Equity account to bring the balance sheet back in
balance.
INFLATION ADJUSTMENT
Adjustment for
Number of Loss Allowance Impairment
Provision Expense Value of Portfolio
Loans Rate (%) Loss Allowance
Loan Impairment
Current Portfolio
PAR 1–30 days
PAR 31–90 days
PAR 91–180 days
PAR > – 180 days
Renegotiated
Portfolio
Total Gross Loan Adjusted Loan
B4
Portfolio Loss Allowance
B5adj Adjusted Impairment Loss Allowance
P8 Less Value of Recovered Loans (489,154)
B5 Less Actual Impairment Loss Allowance
A4 = B5adj – B5 Adjustment to Impairment Loss Allowance (if > 0)
1
If the MFI is adjusting for donated fixed asset, this item may also include (I17) Depreciation and Amortization Expense.
From 1/1/2004 to
X- From 1/1/2004 to
Ref. Term Adjustments 31/12/2004
Ref. 31/12/2004
Adjusted
I1 Financial Revenue 18,976,898 18,976,898
I2 Financial Revenue from Loan Portfolio 17,053,668 17,053,668
Adjusted
Ref. Adj. Account Name Current Year Adjustment
Current Year
Assets
B1 Cash and Due from Banks 3,261,195 3,261,195
B2 Trade Investments 10,611,928 10,611,928
B3 Net Loan Portfolio 54,338,636 54,338,638
B4 A5 Gross Loan Portfolio 55,609,309 (244,681) 55,364,628
A4
B5 Impairment Loss Allowance (1,270,673) 244,681 (1,025,992)
A5
B6 Interest Receivable on Loan Portfolio 1,604,993 1,604,993
B7 Accounts Receivable and Other Assets 1,610,308 1,610,308
B8 Other Investments 1,165,420 1,165,420
B9 A3.2 Net Fixed Assets 5,567,936 239,279 5,807,215
B10 Fixed Assets 10,640,051 10,640,051
B11 Accumulated Depreciation and Amortization (5,072,115) (5,072,115)
B12 Total Assets 78,160,416 239,279 78,399,695
Liabilities
B13 Demand Deposits — —
B14 Short-term Time Deposits 3,423,878 3,423,878
B15 Short-term Borrowings 2,737,009 2,737,009
B16 Interest Payable on Funding Liabilities 237,177 237,177
Accounts Payable and Other Short-term
B17 500,100 500,100
Liabilities
B18 Long-term Time Deposits 3,000,000 3,000,000
B19 Long-term Borrowings 16,661,750 16,661,750
B20 Other Long-term Liabilities 3,699,498 3,699,498
B21 Total Liabilities 30,259,412 30,259,412
Equity
B22 Paid-In Capital 12,000,000 12,000,000
B23 Donated Equity 37,175,822 37,175,822
B24 Prior Years 32,593,822 32,593,822
B25 Current Year 4,582,000 4,582,000
B26 Retained Earnings (1,401,678) (6,831,761)
B27 Prior Years (1,414,683) (1,414,683)
A1, A2,
B28 Current Year 13,006 (5,430,083) (5,417,078)
A3, A4
B29 Reserves 126,860 126,860
B30 Other Equity Accounts —
B31 Adjustments to Equity 5,669,362 5,669,362
B31-1 A1 Subsidized Cost of Funds Adjustment 738,314
B31-2 A2 In-Kind Subsidy Adjustment 2,569,600
B31-3 A3 Inflation Adjustment 2,361,448
B32 Total Equity 47,901,004 48,140,283
Using the information provided below, create a set of adjusted financial statements for the current year for
MICRO MFI.
1. To calculate the subsidized cost of funds adjustment for benchmarking MICRO MFI has told you to
use a market rate of 18%
2. MICRO MFI does not have all the information on in-kind subsidies, but provides information on
what they can estimate. This information is provided to you on the in-kind subsidy adjustment
worksheet.
3. For the adjustment for inflation MICRO MFI wants you to use 10%
4. Use the MicroBanking Bulletins minimum allowance rates to calculate the loan loss allowance.
ADJUSTMENT WORKSHEETS
ADJUSTMENT FOR SUBSIDIZED COST OF FUND
Formula Adjustment
Personnel Expenses
A2.2 Sub-total
Administrative Adjustment
Subsidies: A2.1 + A2.2
ADJUSTMENT WORKSHEETS
Formula Adjustment
Inflation Rate N9
Inflation Rate N9
ADJUSTMENT WORKSHEETS
PAR > 180 days past due A5.1 =P14 > 180 days
Number of Loans > 180 past due A5.2 =P13> 180 days
From 1/1/2004 to
From 1/1/2004
Ref. X-Ref. Term Adjustments 31/12/2004
to 31/12/2004
Adjusted
I1 Financial Revenue 137,866
Adjusted
Ref. Adj. Term Current Year Adjustment
Current Year
Assets
B1 Cash and Due from Banks 20,444
B2 Short-term Investments 3,450
B3 Net Loan Portfolio 242,698
B4 A5 Gross Loan Portfolio 248,875
B5 A4, A5 Loan Loss Allowance (6,177)
B6 Interest Receivable on loanportfolio 2,650
B7 Accounts Receivable and Other Assets 18,063
B8 Long-term Investments 27,097
B9 A3.2 Net Fixed Assets 51,316
B10 Fixed Assets 70,697
B11 Accumulated Depreciation (19,381)
B12 Total Assets 365,718
Liabilities
B13 Demand Deposits -
B14 Short-term Time Deposits 97,168
B15 Short-term Borrowings 3,196
B16 Interest Payable on fundingliabilities 3,894
Accounts Payable and OtherShort-term
B17 6,321
Liabilities
B18 Long-term Time Deposits -
B19 Long-term Borrowings 54,805
B20 Other Long-term Liabilities -
B21 Total Liabilities 165,384
Equity
B22 Paid-in Capital -
B23 Donated Equity 161,643
B24 Prior Years 140,745
B25 Current Year 20,897
B26 Retained Earnings 44,416
B27 Prior Years 15,788
A1, A2, A3,
B28 Current Year 28,628
A4
B29 Reserves -
B30 Other Equity Accounts (5,725)
B31 Adjustments to Equity
B31-1 A1 Subsidized Cost of Funds Adjustment
B31-2 A2 In-kind Subsidy Adjustent
B31-3 A3.1 Inflation Adjustment
B32 Total Equity 200,334
Formula Adjustment
Personnel Expenses
Technical Advisor
i 2,100 2,100
(Part-time)
ii On-Site MIS Advisor 3,240 - 3,240
A2.1 Sub-total
Personnel 5,340
Adjustment
Administrative
Expenses
On and Off-site
i Technical Support from 6,300 1,575 4,725
Network
A2.2 Sub-total
Administrative
Adjustment 4,725
Subsidies: A2.1 +
A2.2
Adjustment for In-
10,065
kind
PAR > 180 days past due A5.1 =P14 > 180 days 459
Number of Loans > 180 past due A5.2 =P13> 180 days 120
FACILITATOR NOTES
From
From 1/1/2004 1/1/2004 to
Ref. X-Ref. Term Adjustments
to 31/12/2004 31/12/2004
Adjusted
I1 Financial Revenue 137,866 137,866
Financial Revenue from Loan
I2 136,896 136,896
Portfolio
I3 Interest on Loan Portfolio 128,778 128,778
Fees and Commissions on Loan
I4 8,119 8,119
Portfolio
Financial Revenue from
I5 274 274
Investments
I6 Other Operating Revenue 696 696
I7 Financial Expense 5,228 21,148
Financial Expense on Funding
I8 A1 5,228 5,038 10,265
Liabilities
Interest and Fee Expense on
I9 3,894 3,894
Deposits
Interest and Fee Expense on
I10 1,334 1,334
Borrowings
I11 A3 Other Financial Expenses - 10,882 10,882
I12 Net Financial Income 132,638 116,718
FACILITATOR NOTES
Adjusted
Ref. Adj. Term Current Year Adjustment
Current Year
Assets
B1 Cash and Due from Banks 20,444 20,444
B2 Short-term Investments 3,450 3,450
B3 Net Loan Portfolio 242,698 240,168
B4 A5 Gross Loan Portfolio 248,875 (459) 248,416
B5 A4, A5 Loan Loss Allowance (6,177) (2,071) (8,248)
B6 Interest Receivable on loanportfolio 2,650 2,650
B7 Accounts Receivable and Other Assets 18,063 18,063
B8 Long-term Investments 27,097 27,097
B9 A3.2 Net Fixed Assets 51,316 4,337 55,653
B10 Fixed Assets 70,697 70,697
B11 Accumulated Depreciation (19,381) (19,381)
B12 Total Assets 365,718 1,808 367,525
Liabilities
B13 Demand Deposits - -
B14 Short-term Time Deposits 97,168 97,168
B15 Short-term Borrowings 3,196 3,196
B16 Interest Payable on fundingliabilities 3,894 3,894
Accounts Payable and OtherShort-term
B17 6,321 6,321
Liabilities
B18 Long-term Time Deposits - -
B19 Long-term Borrowings 54,805 54,805
B20 Other Long-term Liabilities - -
B21 Total Liabilities 165,384 165,384
Equity
B22 Paid-in Capital - -
B23 Donated Equity 161,643 161,643
B24 Prior Years 140,745 140,745
B25 Current Year 20,897 20,897
B26 Retained Earnings 44,416 15,901
B27 Prior Years 15,788 15,788
A1, A2, A3,
B28 Current Year 28,628 (28,515) 113
A4
B29 Reserves - -
B30 Other Equity Accounts (5,725) (5,725)
B31 Adjustments to Equity 30,322 30,322
B31-1 A1 Subsidized Cost of Funds Adjustment 5,038
B31-2 A2 In-kind Subsidy Adjustent 10,065
B31-3 A3.1 Inflation Adjustment 15,220
B32 Total Equity 200,334 202,141
Goal Understand and calculate “The SEEP 18” indicators and apply these to measure the
performance of an MFI.
Time and
Technique Session Materials
1 hour
1 hour 30 minutes Note to Facilitator: A more detailed description of Name that Ratio game is
included at the end of the facilitator notes for module 4.
Write
on small pieces of paper the name of each one of the four ratio groups:
• Profitability and sustainability,
• Asset/liability management,
1 hour During this session the participants will review the ratios calculated for an MFI
during two separate periods. The objective of the session is for the participants
to review ratios and to generate ideas on what might have caused the change in
ratio.
Explain the activity
1. Ask the participant to break into the same group that they were in during the
game.
2. Explain that each group must review the results for the ratio group they
have been assigned (this is the same group of ratios that they created the
questions for during the game). When reviewing the rations on handout 4.2
they must identify:
• The change between 2003 and 2004
The questions should generally end with the phase name that ratio….
For example:
This ratio measures how well an MFI covers its costs related to operating revenues, expenses also
taking into account adjustments….
(the answer is Financial Sustainability)
The bonus question should be more elaborate.
Tell me why this ratio is sometimes used as a proxy for commercial viability….
(the answer is “because the numerator does not include non-operating items or donations and is net of
taxes.”)
The questions created by each group will be asked to the other three groups during the competition.
THE COMPETITION
The competition will be completed in four rounds. During each round one group will pose the
questions they have created to the members of the other teams. Before starting with the question the
presenter will read a brief overview of the group of ratios. For example:
Profitability and sustainability ratios reflect the MFI’s ability to continue operating and grow in the
future. Most reputable MFIs are striving for sustainability, regardless of their nonprofit or for-profit
status; donors and investors alike look to fund sustainable institutions. Several factors can affect
profitability and sustainability. Although startup or rapidly growing institutions may have low
profitability, they are building the basis for a sustainable future. The ratios recommended in this
section are the most widely accepted in the industry.
The designated presenter from each group will pose the questions one at a time. The groups
responding must listen to the question and when they believe they know the answer, they must ring a
bell. The first team to ring the bell gets five seconds to answer the question. If they guess incorrectly,
then the question is read again (in its entirety) and the remaining two groups get the chance to ring the
bell to answer. If the second guess fails, the third team gets to answer.
The team posing the questions will ask all six questions.
As of As of
Ref. Account Name Formula
31/12/2004 31/12/2003
Adjusted
Return on 1,040
0.6%
Equity 178,237
(AROE)
R4 Yield on
136,896 77,975
Gross 63.9% 52.0%
214,345 149,783
Portfolio
R5 Portfolio to 248,875 179,816
68.1% 67.1%
Assets 365,718 267,973
R6
Cost of 5,228 1,713
3.9% 2.1%
Funds Ratio 135,014 82,929
Adjusted
10,265
Cost of 7.6%
135,014
Funds
Adjusted
165,384
Debt to 81.8%
202,141
Equity
R8
23,894 14,908
Liquid Ratio 21.6% 24.0%
110,579 62,096
R9
12,232 1,568,972
PAR Ratio 4.9% 872.5%
248,875 179,816
Adjusted
4.9%
PAR Ratio
Adjusted
8,542
Write-off 4.0%
214,116
Ratio
R11 Risk
6,177 4,058
Coverage 50.5% 0.3%
12,232 1,568,972
Ratio
Adjusted
Risk 8,248
70.1%
Coverage 11,773
Ratio
R12 Operating
93,553 56,151
Expense 43.6% 37.5%
214,345 149,783
Ratio
Adjusted
Operating 103,618
48.4%
Expense 214,116
Ratio
R13
Cost per 93,553 56,151
4 4
Active Client 24,819 13,828
Adjusted
103,618
Cost per 4
24,819
Active Client
R14 Borrowers
29,812 19,139
per Loan 262 195
114 98
Officer
R15 Active
Clients Per 32,983 16,655
190 127
Staff 174 131
Member
R16
Client 5,880
23.7%
Turnover 24,819
R17 Average
248,875 179,816
Outstanding 7,963 8,541
31,254 21,053
Loan Size
Adjusted
Average 248,416 179,816
7,979 8,948
Outstanding 31,134 20,095
Loan Size
R18
Average
620,532 361,190
Loan 11,900 12,700
52,146 28,440
Disbursed
Goal Understand common approaches to analyzing MFI performance and the types of
reports that to include in an MFI monitoring system.
MODULE 1 SUMMARY
Time and
Technique Session Materials
5 minutes Describe
Powerpoint slide 33 Objectives of the module
Emphasize:
Creating financial performance monitoring reports is only part of an overall
performance monitoring system. This system begins with drafting a business
plan, managing for results, monitoring progress, and holding management and
staff accountable for results. The reports must include not only data and details,
but they must also provide some meaningful analysis of an MFI’s performance
and condition. Managers of MFI should determine the content of these reports
by analyzing the following four issues:
timeliness
accuracy and integrity
relevance, and
requirements.
25 minutes Ask
Handout: What is trend analysis? Why do trend analysis?
5.1 Trend Analysis Responses should include
Calculations
Trend analysis is the examination of a company’s financial statements and
Powerpoint slides indicators over time to determine how actions affect results.
34-35
Ask
What is a method for performing trend analysis?
Responses should include
compare the current period to a previous period of the same length, such as the
previous quarter and the current quarter,
to annualize the indicators for the current period and compare the annualized
indicators to the previous year.
Exercise
On a flip chart write out the following number indicating growth in number of
loans issued each month and ask a participant to describe the trend:
120 150 190 220 240
Ptrend = P1 – P0
P0
Ask participants to use the data from the previous example, and the basic
formula, to define the percentage rate of change. Participants should do this
individually.
Answer
Ask
Participants to describe the percentage rate of change.
Point out
the number of loans issued per month has double over the last five months and
the trend related to the increase is declining. When analyzing the changes in
accounts or ratios, determining why the accounts or ratios are increasing or
decreasing is important. For example, management should be familiar with
seasonal trends, such as strong portfolio growth during a holiday season, to
distinguish seasonal fluctuations from general business trends.
Explain
For ratios, examining the absolute change between periods rather than the
relative change is customary. The calculation for the absolute change is more
common when comparing ratios from two different periods.
The following formula is used:
Show PPT 35 or write:
Rtrend = R1 – R0
In this case, the following result occurs:
FSStrend = 85% – 73% = 12%
Ask a participant to tell you in simple terms what the 93.75% indicates?
Answer:
The MFI met 93.75% of its goal for growth in its Loan Portfolio.
Demonstrate
that the same formula can be used with ratios
Show PPT 38 or write on a flipchart:
OSSvar = 109% = 87.2%
125%
Ask
What does this tell you?
This equation indicates that the MFI reached 87.2% of its OSS goal.
5 minutes Ask
Handout: Participants to define benchmarking and its usefulness to an MFI.
5.3 Peer Groups for Answer:
Benchmarking
Benchmarking is the process of comparing a single institution’s performance to
that of its peers.
The value of benchmarking depends on the availability and quality of
comparative data.
Comparisons across institutions or peer groups require caution.
Local conditions, institutional characteristics, and the management choices
affect institutional performance.
Unless the number of institutions in the peer group is sufficient, averages and
median calculations may be misleading.
Give
Participants handout 5.3.
A B C D E =(C – D)/C
A B C=(A x C) D E=(C – D)
RR12 Operating
19 35
Expense Ratio
FACILITATORS NOTES
MICRO MFI wants to determine if it has improved its performance over the previous year. To do
this, management wants to look at the MFI’s performance at the end of the first semester and compare
it to the previous year’s performance. It chooses to look at three accounts and three ratios.
A B C D E =(C – D)/C
A B C=(A x C) D E=(C – D)
RR12 Operating 2 38 –3
19 35
Expense Ratio
In calculating the trends, the MFI must annualize all flow data, such as (I19) Net Operating Income
and (P2) Value of Loans Disbursed, and ratios that contain a mixture of flow data and stock data,
such as (R2) Adjusted Return on Assets and (R12) Operating Expense Ratio. Because the (B4) Gross
Loan Portfolio is stock data and (R1) Operational Self-Sufficiency contains only flow data,
neither needs to be annualized.
The analysis reveals that the MFI is performing better overall than the previous year. This
improvement is led by the increase in Net Operating Income, up 8.3 percent on an annualized basis.
As noted above, Operational Self-Sufficiency is up only slightly (1 percent), but this is with a much
larger increase in the Value of Loans Disbursed (28 percent) and Gross Loan Portfolio (26 percent).
MICRO MFI management should investigate why strong growth has led to only modest increases in
profitability.
A B C = A/C D E =C/D
A B C=(A x C) D E=(C – D)
(12/9 = 1.33)
FACILITATOR NOTE
MICRO MFI wants to determine how well it is meeting its annual revenue targets. To do this,
management wants to look at the MFI’s performance at the end of the third quarter to determine its
progress. They choose to look at two accounts and two indicators.
A B C = A/C D E =C/D
A B C=(A x C) D E=(C – D)
(12/9 = 1.33)
In calculating the variance, the MFI must annualize all flow data, such as (I1) Financial Revenue and
(I19) Net Operating Income, and ratios that contain a mixture of flow data and stock data, such as
(R4) Yield on Gross Portfolio. Because (R1) Operational Self-Sufficiency contains only flow data, it
does not need to be annualized.
Variance analysis reveals that MICRO MFI has already achieved its year-end target for Financial
Revenue (126 percent) and is well on its way to achieving its Net Operating Income target by the end
of the year, having already reached 91 percent of that target. This might be explained by the next two
ratios, which show that MICRO MFI’s yield is 12 percent higher than projected, leading to higher
than expected Financial Revenue. At the same time, its Operational Self-Sufficiency is 13 percent
below the target. This analysis suggests that although MICRO MFI is exceeding its revenue targets
and is also exceeding its budgeted expenses. Expanding this analysis to other accounts and ratios will
help management pinpoint the cause and magnitude of the higher costs.
Africa
Portfolio Quality
Impairment
I13 Losses on 162,862 815,644 1,500,000 N/A
Loans
PAR Ratio 4.5% 5.1% 5.0% N/A
R9 Adjusted PAR
6.8% 5.1% 5.0% 3.4%
Ratio
Write-off Ratio 0.3% 1.8% 0.5% N/A
R10 Adjusted Write-
3.5% 2.1% 0.5% N/A
off Ratio
Risk Coverage
78% 82% 75.0% N/A
Ratio
R11
Adjusted Risk
26% 74% 75.0% 120%
Coverage Ratio
Asset/Liability Management
Gross Loan
B4 34,701,961 49,228,881 50,000,000 323,371,248
Portfolio
Portfolio to
R5 50% 67% 75% 78%
Assets
B13
+
B14 Total Deposits 4,030,868 5,054,327 5,000,000 12,047,040
+
B18
Yield on Gross
R4a 30% 38% 32% 38%
Portfolio
Cost of Funds
4.4% 4.2% 5% N/A
Ratio
R6a
Adjusted Cost
8.6% 7.2% 8% 7%
of Funds
Debt to Equity 64% 61% 65% 1.7
R7 Adjusted Debt
64% 61% 65% N/A
to Equity
Operating
I16 6,633,187 11,107,910 12,000,000 N/A
Expense
Operating
22% 35% 27% N/A
Expense Ratio
a
R12
Adjusted
Operating 34% 40% 32% 19.8%
Expense Ratio
Borrowers per
R14 226 187 22 552
Loan Officer
Active Clients
R15 per Staff 129 137 150 190
Member
Average
Outstanding 3,103 3,770 4,000 18,480
Loan Size
R17
Adjusted
Average
3,239 3,526 4,000 N/A
Outstanding
Loan Size
Average Loan
R18 4,500 4,835 5,000 N/A
Disbursed
a
Indicates annualized indicator.
FACILITATOR NOTES
Plan Target
Account As of As of Trend as of Variance
Ref. for Benchmark
Name 12/31/2003 9/30/2004 9/30/2004 (%) (%)
9/30/2004
Financial Self-
Sufficiency(FS 73% 80% 6 100% – 20 123%
S)
Return on
3.4% 1.1% -2.3% 5% -4% N/A
Assets (ROA)
a
R2 Adjusted
Return on -18% -3.0% 14.6% -5% 2% 4%
Assets(AROA)
Return on
R3a 5.4% 1.8% -3.6% 15% -13% N/A
Equity (ROE)
Adjusted
Return on -28.4% -9.7% 18.7% -10% 0% 9%
Equity(AROE)
Portfolio Quality
Impairment
I13 Losses on 162,862 815,644 401% 1,500,000 54% N/A
Loans
PAR Ratio 4.5% 5.1% 0.6% 5.0% 0% N/A
R9 Adjusted PAR
6.8% 5.1% – 1.7% 5.0% 0% 3.4%
Ratio
Write-off Ratio 0.3% 1.8% 1.5% 0.5% 1% N/A
R10 Adjusted
3.5% 2.1% – 1.4% 0.5% 2% N/A
Write-off Ratio
Risk Coverage
78% 82% 3.6% 75.0% 7% N/A
Ratio
R11 Adjusted Risk
Coverage 26% 74% 48.1% 75.0% – 1% 120%
Ratio
Asset/Liability Management
Gross Loan
B4 34,701,961 49,228,881 42% 50,000,000 98% 323,371,248
Portfolio
Portfolio to
R5 50% 67% 17% 75% – 8% 78%
Assets
B13 +
B14 + Total Deposits 4,030,868 5,054,327 25% 5,000,000 101% 12,047,040
B18
Yield on Gross
R4a 30% 38% 8% 32% 6% 38%
Portfolio
Cost of Funds
4.4% 4.2% – 0.2% 5% – 1% N/A
a
Ratio
R6
Adjusted Cost
8.6% 7.2% – 1.4% 8% – 1% 7%
of Funds
Debt to Equity 64% 61% – 3% 65% – 4% 1.7
R7 Adjusted Debt
64% 61% – 4% 65% – 4% N/A
to Equity
Liquidity
Cash and Due
B1 1,146,142 4,168,880 264% 4,600,000 91% N/A
from Banks
Cash Flows
C13,
from Operating (8,985,325) (1,070,260) – 88% (1,000,000) – 7% N/A
C37
Activities
R8 Liquid Ratio 9.1 4.06 – 56% 2.0 203% N/A
Due date:
Date
Report Frequency No. of days after Recipients
Completed
the end of period
branch managers
branch managers
senior management
branch managers
board,
senior management
senior management,
branch managers,
credit staff
senior management,
branch managers
OVERVIEW
The two-day Training of Trainers (TOT) course is designed to introduce participants to the training
course Measuring Performance of Microfinance Institutions: A Framework for Reporting, Analysis,
and Monitoring and to impart knowledge about, and skills to deliver, a participatory training model.
This training course provides a foundation of adult learning theory and integrates these ideas with
learning how to deliver the Measuring Performance of Microfinance Institutions training. As the
participants will be trainers themselves, all activities and discussions are intended to provide
examples of how active participation and learning by experience are used as effective learning tools.
The way the course is delivered is in itself an example of effective learning methodology, especially
in combination with the various activities and discussions.
OBJECTIVES
• Demonstrate skills associated with good training to enhance the learning environment for the
training course Measuring Performance of Microfinance Institutions: A Framework for Reporting,
Analysis, and Monitoring
• Interact effectively with participants to maximize the learning experience
• Use a variety of training techniques to enhance instructional material and in-class learning
• Know how to use the trainer’s guide for the training course Measuring Performance of
Microfinance Institutions: A Framework for Reporting, Analysis, and Monitoring and be familiar
with the flow of topics and session.
GENERAL OUTLINE
DAY 1
1.1 Course Introduction
1.2 Icebreaker – Join the Dots Game (5 minutes)
1.3 Participant Introductions and Course (20 minutes)
Overview
1.4 How Adults Learn Total: 45 minutes
-Activity – Dream Visualization (15 minutes)
-Child Learner vs. Adult Learner (15 minutes)
-Training vs. Education (15 minutes)
1.5 Experiential Learning Cycle Total: 40 minutes
-Activity – The Numbers Game (10 minutes)
-Description of the experiential learning (30 minutes)
cycle
1.6 Process Training (20 minutes)
DAY 2
3.2 Practice Training Continued (3 to 4 hours)
3.3 Process Practice Training (30 minutes)
4.0 Using the Case Study (1 hour)
5.0 Wrap-up
DAY 1
Welcome participants and introduce the trainers. Explain that before you jump into the training you
will first do a warm up activity.
This game is intended to relax the participants and begin the course by encouraging innovative ideas
and thoughts. It also encourages active participation right from the start.
a.) Hand out copies of the game so that each participant has one copy of the dots. (Handout 1).
Solutions to this exercise are included at the end with the handout material.
b.) Explain the rules of the game – each person will have two minutes to try and connect all the dots
using 4 straight lines and that they are not allowed to lift their pencil from the paper.
c.) After time has expired, inquire as to how many people came up with solutions. Have someone
demonstrate his/her solution on the flipchart or just by displaying his/her copy.
d.) Briefly discuss what the purpose of this activity is. Solicit answers from the participants as much
as possible. The main teaching points that should arise from this activity are
• solutions can be found outside the boundaries and normal ways of thinking
• one needs to consider all possibilities when solving a problem and not be closed in
e.) Hand out one copy to each participant of the 12-dot problem (Handout 2). Explain to participants
they must join the 12 dots with 5 consecutive straight lines. They are not allowed to lift their pen
off the paper or repeat a line.
The trainers and the participants should all introduce themselves and tell a little about themselves.
The trainer can start the introductions by saying that everyone needs to say their name, where they
work, what their job is, and something unique about him/herself.
The trainer should explain the objectives. Write the objectives on a flipchart.
Discuss the trainer expectations for the TOT. Describe that the TOT is for participants to become
familiar with adult learning theory and to integrate that knowledge and skill with the delivery of the
training course Measuring Performance of Microfinance Institutions. Further the training will impart
in detail how to deliver the course Measuring Performance through demonstration and actual delivery
by participants.
The trainer should then have participants describe what their expectations for the course are.
The objective of this section is to have participants analyze and understand the differences between
the way a child learns and the way an adult learns.
Activity – Dream Visualization
This activity is intended to provide the participants with the opportunity to compare the differences
between the way they learned as children compared to the way they learn as adults.
a.) The trainer should dim the lights and ask the participants to relax and close their eyes.
b.) Tell participants to visualize their childhood and what it was like to attend school. Example
questions are:
• Remember getting ready for school. What did you wear to school?
• You are going to school now. How did you get to school?
• You walk into your classroom. How was the classroom arranged?
• You sit down. What was this like?
• The teacher comes into the class. What was the teacher like? How did they talk? What did they
look like?
• You look around the room. You see all the students. How many students were in your class?
• The teacher starts the lesson. How does your teacher talk to the students?
c.) After these or similar questions, the trainer asks the participants to open their eyes and begins a
general discussion by letting the participants share what they visualized during the exercise. This
should lead into a guided discussion about how people learn as children compared to adults.
1.6 PROCESS
Ask participants to describe what they saw you do as a trainer that was effective?
Ask participants to describe what they saw you do as a trainer that was ineffective?
Write responses on a flipchart. Starting with the responses that they considered were ineffective go
down the list to determine what a more effective training technique/method would have been or what
you could have done differently as a trainer.
Go through the list of what the trainer did that was effective. Emphasize the skills that a good trainer
needs.
Note: It is assumed that all participants have read the trainer’s guide, the technical guide and are
familiar with the tool.
Trainer to begin by teaching Module 1: The SEEP Framework. Go through the material as if you
were conducting a training.
Continue training the first part of Module 2: Financial statements and reports and teach through the
income statement.
After the income statement introduce participants to the tool. Go through the introduction of the tool
and the demonstration of the tool.
Ask participants to describe the different training methods that were used during the
“demonstration” of the training.
Responses should include:
• Lecture/lecturette
• Guided discussion
• Small group work
• Question and answer
Ask participants
• how they felt as learners during the session.
Say to participants that a lot is going on in this training environment. We are learning about the
SEEP training course and we are also brushing up on our skills as trainers. Let’s reflect on what we
have learned about how adults learn, why adults learn and think about what our role is as a trainer.
Ask the participants to talk to their neighbor about what the role of a trainer is. They should write
this information down. Give participants a few minutes to do this.
Ask one group to describe one trainer role and write this on the flipchart. Go around the room to
generate other ideas. Do not comment on the list.
Go down the list and discuss each issue. When discussing each issue come up with a separate list of
skills/qualities that a trainer needs to have. Write this on a separate flipchart.
Go through each skill/quality and discuss. Ask questions such as what does this mean/how does a
trainer do this, etc.
Give participants handout 6,7,8,9
Ask participants, “what is a trainer’s guide?” Comment on responses and add that a trainer’s guide is
a format that has been developed for trainers to use. The learning has been sequenced into
steps/stages that allow the learner to build on knowledge and skill that has previously been learned.
The learning step/stages are broken into manageable parts so that the trainer can introduce a
topic/develop a skill etc, and then build on that knowledge. In the trainer’s guide for Measuring
Performance the topics have been sequenced so that the information is presented in an order that will
make sense to a learner, time has been allocated based on factors such as importance of the topic,
previous knowledge of learners, time required to teach topic, etc. Activities and exercises have been
developed to support/enhance and reinforce the theory that participants are learning.
Tell participants that they will get to practice their training skills and become more familiar with the
SEEP training by actually delivering a part of the training.
Assign each participant a manageable piece from the trainer’s guide. Depending on the size of the
class assign pieces of the training so that on day 2 of your training the morning will be devoted to
practice training. If the class is small give participants approximately 30 minutes for their
presentations.
Tell participants that they will need to prepare the material they need for the class. Give participants
time to review the section of the trainer’s guide that they are to deliver. Be available to answer
questions about how to deliver the training. Suggest to participants that they give serious
consideration as to how they will deliver their piece and to practice their session.
Inform the participants of the order they will be presenting on the following morning. The order of
the presentations should be in accordance with the training timeline.
Note to Trainer: Keep in mind that this training is two-fold; introduce trainers in training to the
SEEP training course and introduce them to how to use the material effectively in the classroom.
Tell participants that this practice training has two objectives; one for all participants to become
more familiar with the SEEP training, and two for participants to practice their training skills. At the
end of each participant practice time, the class will give constructive feedback to the “trainer”.
Ask participants to describe what constructive feedback is so that everyone understands it is an
opportunity to learn from the training experience.
Have the first participant present their training piece. Again the size of the class will dictate how
long each participant has for their presentation.
Note to facilitator: Be a timekeeper for the “trainer”.
At the end of the training time, start off the constructive feedback session with giving a few
comments to the “trainer”. Example I liked the way you controlled the person who was talking a lot
Go back to the flipchart on effective techniques developed during the practice training. Go through
the techniques/skills demonstrated and ask participants to describe in more detail the technique or
skill.
Ask participants to think about the three most important lessons they learned during this practice
training.
Go around the room and ask people to share one of their lessons. If there is time solicit additional
lessons.
Have participants get their copy of the case study for all topics. This session is to discuss how to use
the case study to reinforce the theory learned in the class and then use the data to learn about the tool.
Point out to participants that at the end of each topic the case study is introduced. Talk about why the
case study is introduced.
Point out that after the case study the class uses the tool. Discuss with participants ideas for using the
tool with the continued addition of new data.
Final discussion on how to integrate the information generated from the tool to reinforce the topics.
Specifically discuss what do you do with the information generated from the data that is inputted into
the tool. How do the trainers talk about analysis of the information.
Go through each module Financial Statements and Reports, Analytical Adjustments, Ratios and
Indicators, and Creating and Analyzing Performance Monitoring Reports and discuss how to integrate
the analysis of the information into the training.
5.0 WRAP-UP
Prior to lunch on the second day tell participants to think about any concerns or questions they have
related to technical areas of the training, the training, use of the tool, etc. If possible have participants
tell you these so that you can prepare for the wrap-up session beforehand.
Explore with participants any parts of the Performance Monitoring training they have questions or
concerns about. This could be technical or training related.
ADULT LEARNING
Andragogy Pedagogy
Adult Learning – Training Child Learning - Traditional Teaching
Self Concept
Autonomous – makes own decisions Dependent – guided by adults
Mutual exchange in teaching /learning transactions Dominant teacher – dependent learning
A helping relationship A directing relationship
Experience
Able to use/link to life Limited life experience
Multi - communication shared by all 1 way communication given by teacher to learner
Experience of teacher valued as the primary
Experience of all valued as resources for learning
resource
Readiness to Learn
Know what they want to learn Curriculum is set
Learners group themselves according to interests Learners are grouped by grade and class
Facilitator helps learners diagnose learning needs Teacher makes curriculum decisions
EXPERIENTIAL LEARNING
Experiential approach is learner-centered and allows the individual participants to manage and share
responsibility for their learning with their teachers. Effective training strategies which incorporate
experiential learning approaches provide opportunities for a person to engage in an activity, review
this activity critically, draw some useful insight from the analysis, and apply the result in a practical
situation.
A graphic representation of the experiential model is presented below and may be applied to training
in the following ways:
Experience
Activity, Doing
Application Process
Planning more effective Sharing, comparing
Post training behavior processing, reflecting
Generalization
Drawing conclusions,
Identifying general principles
The experience phase is the initial activity and data-producing part of the experiential learning cycle.
This phase is structured to enable participants to become actively involved in "doing" something.
Doing, in this instance, has a rather broad definition, and includes a range of activities like the
following:
1. CLIMATE SETTING
• Stimulates interest, curiosity, and enables the participants to begin thinking about the subject at
hand.
• Provides rationale for why the subject is important to the participants and how it will be useful to
them.
• Links this training session to previous ones and places it into the overall framework of the
workshop.
2. GOAL CLARIFICATION
• Presents statements to the participants which describe the intent, aim or purpose of the training
activity.
• Provides an opportunity for participants to get a clear understanding of the goals of the session, and
allows them to explore additional issues or raise concerns.
3. EXPERIENCE
• An activity in which the group engages that will provide an opportunity for them to "experience" a
situation relevant to the goals of the training session.
• This "experience" becomes the data producing event from which participants can extract and
analyze as they complete the 'learning cycle.
• Common "experiences" are role plays, case studies, self diagnostic instruments, games,
simulations, etc.
4. PROCESSING
• Participants share individual experiences and their reactions to the experience.
• The group analyzes and thoughtfully reflects on the experience.
• The trainer guides and manages the processing of information.
5. GENERALIZING
• Participants determine how the patterns that evolved during the experience phase of the learning
cycle relate to the experiences of everyday life.
• Participants seek to identify key generalizations that could be derived from the experience.
7. CLOSURE
• The events of the training session are briefly summarized.
• Provides a link to the original goals of the session and seeks to determine if the goals have been
met.
• Wraps up the training session and gives a sense of completion.
• Provides an opportunity to link the session to the rest of the program, especially the next training
activity.
TRY THESE:
• Ask for more information by requiring the responder to be more explicit and perhaps more sure of
his answer; "Can you give me an example?" Or "When you say xyz, what do you mean?"
• Restate what you have heard: "So, are you saying that people should … or did I misunderstand
you?" By stating what your understanding is to this point (rather than "Would you say that
again?")' you provide the other with a point from which to proceed. She may respond, "No that's
not what I meant. What I am trying to say is that...."
• Make critical observations to make learners look at their answer in a more probing and critical
way: "Why do you think this is so?" Or: "How would you explain your answer to someone who
feels quite the opposite?"
• Try to intensify the learner's statement if the response is important, requires no instructor comment,
and could be added to by others. You could say: "Very good, Colin. What implications would your
statement have for...?" (turning to the whole group). Or: "How can we use Colin's solution to solve
our dilemma?"
LISTENING METHODS
PARAPHRASING
Paraphrasing is simply restating what another person has said in your own words.
The best way to paraphrase is to listen carefully to what the other person is saying. If while the other
person is talking we worry about what we are going to say next or are making mental evaluations and
critical comments, we are not likely to hear enough of the message being sent to paraphrase it
accurately.
It is helpful to paraphrase often so that you develop a habit of doing so. You can throw back the other
person’s ideas by using such beginning phrases as
…So what you are saying is….
…In other words….
…I gather that….
…If I understand what you are saying….
You can at times even interrupt to paraphrase since people don’t generally mind interruptions that
communicate understanding.
…Pardon my interruption, but let me see if I understand what you are saying….
SUMMARIZING
The purpose of summarizing is to
• pull important ideas, facts or data together
• establish a basis for further discussion
• review progress
Summarizing can encourage people to be more reflective about their statements as they listen for
accuracy and emphasis. It is a skill which requires that the one who intends to summarize listen
carefully in order to organize the information systematically.
Summarizing is very useful for emphasizing key points; it is a deliberate effort to pull together the
main points made by the person who is talking.
…These seem to be the key ideas you have expressed…
…If I understand you, you feel this way about the situation….
QUESTIONING
Questioning is a critical facilitation skill. There are two basic types closed and open-ended.
DAY ONE
• Introduction
• Module 1: The Performance Monitoring Framework
• Module 2: Financial Statements and Reports
• Introduction to the Spreadsheet Tool
DAY TWO
• Module 2: Financial Statements and Reports continued
• The Tool and Financial Statements
• Module 3: Analytical Adjustments
• The Tool and Analytical Adjustments
• Module 4: Financial Ratios and Indicators
• The Tool and Financial Ratios
DAY THREE
• Module 5: Creating and Analyzing Financial Reports
• Using the Tool and Creating Reports
• I Income Statement
• B Balance Sheet
• C Cash Flow Statement
• P Portfolio Report and Activity Report
• R Ratios
• A Adjustments
• N Non-Financial Data Report
PAVG
or
• Mapping Accounts
• Adding Accounts
• Segregating Financial and Non-Financial Services
• Cash or Accrual
Reports
-Management
-Board User-sheets
-Donor
Input sheets
-Investor
Result sheets
Purpose of Adjustments
• True Performance
• Benchmarking
Types of Adjustments
• Subsidizes
• Inflation
• Portfolio at Risk
Key points:
• If an adjustment calculation produces a negative
number, the adjustment is not applied. Managers
should explain the adjustment calculation and which
variables they chose.
• Adjustments can be applied for any period of time.
The method used to calculate averages makes a
difference.
• Current Portfolio → 0%
• PAR 1–30 days → 10%
• PAR 31–90 days → 30%
• PAR 91–180 days → 60%
• PAR > 180 days → 100%
• Renegotiated Portfolio → 100%
Ptrend = P1 – P0
P0
Rtrend = R1 – R0
Pvar = Pactual
Pplan