Sustainable Development Agenda 21 Booklet
Sustainable Development Agenda 21 Booklet
Sustainable Development Agenda 21 Booklet
Fr eedom A dvocates
Recognize Unalienable R ights
w w w.Freedom Advocates.org
Table of Contents:
What is Sustainable Development? ............................. 2
Historical Development and Origins The Antithetical Foundations of Liberty and Sustainable Development
Introduction
You may have heard people talking about Sustainable Development in public meetings, on television and on the radio. Consultants talk about it, university professors lecture on it, and at all levels of government, it is now being mandated. But what is Sustainable Development? That is precisely the question this guide is intended to address. In the following pages, you will read of the origins of Sustainable Development, its theoretical underpinnings, its major programs, and how it is implemented. When you have finished reading this document, you will have the knowledge necessary to begin identifying the vast array of Sustainable Development programs that exist and continue to arise. Please recognize this document for what it is: a unique opportunity to learn more about Sustainable Development. Then you can make a difference in your community by supporting present and future actions that restore and protect the rights and well-being of you, your family, and your fellow citizens. More information on the nature and consequences of Sustainable Development is available from Freedom Advocates. (http://www.FreedomAdvocates.org)
Freedom Advocates is a 501(c)(3) public benef it cor poration. Your tax deductible contribution is valuable for the continuation of our work.
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 known as the Rio Earth Summit, where more than 178 nations adopted Agenda 21, and pledged to evaluate progress made in implementing the plan every five years thereafter. President George H. W. Bush was the signatory for the United States. Although Congress never authorized the implementation of Agenda 21 2 (as a soft-law policy recommendation 3 not a treaty it needs no Image 1: The United Nations website clearly ratification), in 1993, displays Agenda 21 documents President Bill Clinton established, by Executive Order, the Presidents Council on Sustainable Development (PCSD) for the purpose of implementing Agenda 21 in the United States. The
2. Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) submitted a resolution (H.J. Res. 166) to the 103rd Congress on March 29, 1993 urging the President and Congress to assume a strong leadership role in implementing the decisions made at the Earth Summit by developing a national strategy to implement Agenda 21 and other Earth Summit agreements.... Though that bill stalled in the Subcommittee on Economic Policy, Trade and Environment, its recommendations have been implemented through various actions by the President, and Congress. 3. Soft law policy is not binding. This is a common procedure in the U.N.s policy development strategy. Soft law documents are quite often followed by treaties or covenants, which are binding international law; alternately, soft law can find immediate application through local legislation or policy without an internationally binding agreement. 3
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 PCSD operated through 1999, but its actions to promote Sustainable Development have taken root, and now exert an increasing influence in communities across America. International organizations such as the U.N., and its accredited Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs), generally consider Sustainable Development and Agenda 21 to be synonymous. Therefore, in order to avoid confusion and equivocation, Sustainable Development will be the term used throughout this document to refer to both. Agenda 21 will only be used to refer to the actual document from the Rio Earth Summit. At times, the political agenda embodied in Sustainable Development is implemented under other names for purposes of political expediency. J. Gary Lawrence, a planner for the city of Seattle, and advisor to the Presidents Council on Sustainable Development, said in 1998, that, Participating in a U.N. advocated planning process would very likely bring out many ... who would actively work to defeat any elected official ... undertaking Local Agenda 21. So we will call our process something else, such as comprehensive planning, growth management, or smart growth. 4
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 The institution of private property was understood by those who participated in the American Experiment 5 and its principles were consequently included in the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights. 6 The right to property as outlined in those documents is premised on an owners determination of its use, provided that such use does not disturb the equal rights of another. all Menare endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty, and the Pursuit of Happiness. The Declaration of Independence
Individual Rights
Community Rights
Protect the natural or unalienable rights of each individual That all Men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights...
Control the individual for the greater good of a global community Rights and freedoms may in no case be exercised contrary to the purposes and principles of the United Nations Government grants, restricts or withdraws your rights according to its needs. You and the product of your labor belong to the community.
2007 FREEDOMADVOCATES
In short
Youre born with rights, government exists to protect them. You and the product of your labor belong to you.
5. Soapes, Emily Williams. The American Experiment: Living with the Constitution. Prologue: Journal of the National Archives 19, no.3 (Fall 1987): 185-189. 6. See also Machan, Tibor, Private Rights & Public Illusions, Transaction Publishers, New Brunswick (1995). 5
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 In contrast to the unalienable rights found in Americas founding documents, the United Nations Charter and the Declaration of Human Rights are based on a very different idea: rights are granted and rescinded by men. The Sustainable Development political agenda originates in the founding documents of the United Nations. This isnt surprising, since the myriad of countries represented in the drafting of Agenda 21 have widely divergent forms of government, and must have a point of agreement (a least common denominator) to rally around and the U.N. Charter provides that point. However, for progress to be made in implementing Sustainable Development in the United States, unalienable rights such as the right to property must be eroded, attacked, and struck down altogether. 7, 8
Environment
Equity
Economy
SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT
Equity:
The authors of the Sustainable Development action plan recognized that their environmental and economic objectives, and the corresponding transformation of the American system of equal justice to a system of "social" justice, are radically divergent from the views and objectives of the average person. Therefore, in order to achieve their objectives, they call for a shift in attitudes that can be seen in the educational programs developed by its proponents. This is the premise of Sustainable Development: That individual human wants, needs and desires are to be conformed to the views and dictates of planners. Harvey Ruvin, Vice Chair of the International Council on Local Environmental Initiatives (ICLEI), and Clerk of the Circuit and County Court in Miami-Dade County, Florida, has said that individual rights will have to take a back seat to the collective in the process of implementing Sustainable Development. 9
9. Peros, Joan, unpublished report, UNCED Rio+10 Summit Johannesburg, South Africa (2002). 7
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 Public/private partnerships bring businesses desiring the protection offered by governments legalized force together with government agents that want the power that comes with economic control. The power of economics, and the force of government, must serve as a check and balance on each other; combining the two will ultimately result in tyranny. Free enterprise is lost amid subsidies, incentives, tax-breaks, and insider privilege, and with it goes the notion that the customer is the final determiner of how resources are allocated in production. The Sustainable Development partnerships involve some corporations domestic and multinational some tax-exempt family foundations, select individuals, and collectivist politicians and their administrations. Of these participants, only elected politicians are accountable to the public for their actions.
Economy:
According to its preamble, The developmental and environmental objectives of Agenda 21 will require a substantial flow of new and additional financial resources to developing countries. Language throughout Agenda 21 erroneously assumes that life is a zero-sum game (the wealth of the world was made at the expense of the poor, making them even poorer). This critique of economic ills denies the ingenuity of private action, individual determination, and truly freemarket innovation, and leads inevitably to the conclusion that if the conditions of the poor are to be improved, wealth must be taken from the rich. Sustainable Development embodies this unjust redistribution of wealth both in theory and in implementation, effectively lowering the standard of living in America to that of the rest of the world. The Draft Covenant on Environment and Development states in Article 8: equity will be achieved through implementation of the international economic order ... and through transfers of resources to developing countries.... When in fact such justification covers up the real transfer of power and resources which is to the elite cabal that drives world government. In addition to its appeal for the international redistribution of wealth, Sustainable Development is actually restructuring the economy, molding it not on private enterprise but on public/private partnerships.
8
Environment:
Americans support laws and regulations that are designated to effectively prevent pollution of the air, water, or the property of another. Yet, it is increasingly clear that Sustainable Development uses the environment simply as the means to promote a political agenda. For example, Al Gore says that Sustainable Development will bring about a wrenching transformation of American society. 10 Sustainable Development is ostensibly concerned with the environment; it is more concerned with restructuring the governmental system of the worlds nations so that all the people of the world will be the subjects of a global collective. Many of its proposed implementation strategies require the surrender of unalienable rights.
10. Minor shifts in policy, marginal adjustments in ongoing programs, moderate improvements in laws and regulations, rhetoric offered in lieu of genuine change these are all forms of appeasement, designed to satisfy the publics desire to believe that sacrifice, struggle, and a wrenching transformation of society will not be necessary. Gore, Al, Earth in the Balance. Plume (1993): 274. 9
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 This fact alone casts a serious shadow of doubt on the motives of Sustainable Development planners who would discard the unalienable rights to life, liberty, and property in order to pursue dubious programs. 11 When Sustainable Development is implemented, ordinary people will be left unprotected from de facto decrees placing nature above man, while relegating man to the status of a biological resource. 12
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 partner organizations. The list goes on and on. While taxpayers foot the bill for the increasing costs of government education, parents are increasingly shut out of decisions crucial to the molding of their childs mind. Controversial programs designed for values clarification are being performed in government schools that employ powerful behavior control techniques and peer pressure to make [a] developing child question his or her individual worth and values, and are designed to disrupt parental oversight in the upbringing of their children, according to Professor of Organizational Behavior, Brent Duncan.
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 Stakeholder council meetings are typically arranged under the auspices of soliciting input from community members on a project. This project may be initiated by local public officials, a local nonprofit organization, a national or regional non-profit organization, or an NGO. 13 It is very rare for community members to instigate the stakeholder visioning process. A typical stakeholder council meeting is run by a trained facilitator. 14 It is not the facilitators job to make sure that all views are entered into the record. His job, instead, is to guide the group to arrive at a consensus on the project. The consensus process has no mechanism for recording minority views. Since he is being paid by the organization responsible for the project, it is in his interest to arrive at a consensus sympathetic to the desired outcome of the project. Tactics vary between the facilitators, but consensus generally is reached by using subtle means to marginalize opposition, such as recording only the good ideas, and allowing criticism only for the bad ideas. A Sustainable Development stakeholder meeting in Greenville, South Carolina, was adjourned with a frank admission by the paid facilitator that they had not reached the consensus that he needed to support the predetermined plans. 15 Why all the effort to gain support for programs few citizens want? The answer to this question lies in the origin of each specific project. Sustainable Development projects are often initiated at the directive
13. Recall that many Non-Governmental Organizations are accredited by the U.N., making them international, or multinational in their political purpose. In this sense, they might be more appropriately called Global Governance Organizations. 14. Professional facilitators are frequently paid thousands of dollars for only a few hours of work. 15. Dill, Bob, Land Use Leaders Declare Defeat; Wrong Consensus Reached, Meetings Cancelled, Times-Examiner, Greenville, South Carolina. Steven Lipe, the meeting organizer, announced that the consensus is that we dont have enough people to make change. As far as I am concerned, our meeting is done. 12
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 of NGOs or non-profit organizations that have or create fear over problems that are portrayed as a crisis: development near a riparian corridor, poor water management infrastructure, or too many cars on the freeway are common examples. Once a problem has been identified, every NGO, non-profit, and local government body has a vast stock of Sustainable Development solutions at hand, provided by the International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives (ICLEI). Indeed, ICLEI has a veritable treasure trove of boilerplate solutions for change agents, enabling them to identify problems with the goal of implementing predetermined outcomes that advance Sustainable Development policies. 16
ICLEI: Local Governments for Sustainability is directing policies that cause: - stack em and pack em housing - traffic congestion - inaccessible open space - managed control over our lives - mismanagement of water supplies - prohibition on natural resource management leading to increased fire hazards and private property restrictions Image 2: ICLEI, aka The International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives
ICLEI, launched in 1990 at the World Congress of Local Governments for a Sustainable Future, is based in Toronto, Canada, but has offices around the globe, including Oakland, California. Its stated mission is to provide policy recommendations to assist local governments in the implementation of Sustainable Development.
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 ICLEI was instrumental in the development of Agenda 21, having drafted Chapter 28 in 1991 in preparation for the upcoming summit. In a recent document, ICLEI confirmed its dedication to the U.N. mandate: Local Action 21 strategies [i.e. those formulated at the 2002 Earth Summit in Johannesburg, South Africa] will ensure the unwavering, systematic implementation of local action plans over the next decade. 17 Essentially, Sustainable Development claims knowledge of all sustainability issues and has stock solutions that can be applied in Stockholm, Boulder, Santa Cruz indeed, anywhere. Around the world, ICLEI is responsible for communicating with local special interests to translate international policy objectives into local and regional legislation. 18 Every county in America now has Sustainable Development directives guided by federal agencies, NGOs, and/or ICLEI.
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 After government and non-profit funding schemes, the third leg of the Sustainable Development financial insiders is a group of tax-exempt family foundations. These include the Rockefeller Foundation, Pew Charitable Trusts, the Turner Foundation, the David and Lucille Packard Foundation, the James Irvine Foundation, the Carnegie Foundation, the McArthur Foundation, and local community foundations.
Political Support
When George H. W. Bush signed the Rio Accords at the Earth Summit in Rio de Janeiro in 1992, he pledged the United States support for Agenda 21. A year later, when Bill Clinton created the Presidents Council for Sustainable Development by Executive Order, he laid the foundation for a proliferation of intermediate and local stakeholder councils that would set out to reinvent the structure of United States government. As Sustainable Development policies permeate every county in America, it has become apparent that the conflict is not a dynamic of Republican vs. Democrat, liberal vs. conservative, or left vs. right. In fact, the implementation of Sustainable Development is occurring on a bi-partisan basis.
Funding Sources
The list of money sources for the implementation of Sustainable Development is impressive. American taxes fund the federal agencies present focus: implementing Sustainable Development. Over two thousand NGOs are accredited by the United Nations for the purpose of implementing Sustainable Development in America, and are given massive tax advantages. Some of these NGOs are the Nature Conservancy, the Sierra Club, the National Audubon Society, the American Planning Association, the National Teachers Association, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the U.S. Farm Bureau.
17. Otto-Zimmerman, Konrad, Local Action 21: Motto, Mandate, Movement, International Council for Local Environmental Initiatives, Toronto (2003): 2. See ICLEIs website for more information: http://www.iclei.org. 18. Note that ICLEIs objectives presuppose the notion that the goal of improving the conditions of the world can only be achieved through legislation, denigrating the intelligence and ingenuity of individuals in facing their particular circumstances, and placing them under the increasing oversight of government planners. 14
15
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 Since all things ultimately come from natural resources on rural lands, the transfer of the landscape from citizen control to government control will make it easy for government and its partners NGOs, certain foundations and certain corporations to control what we have, what we do, and where we go. The transformation of free societies into collectivized societies through Sustainable Development ensures the dominance of a ruling elite which, by definition, excludes all but a very select few.
Taken From: The United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity, Article 8a-e; United Nations Global Biodiversity Assessment, Section 13.4.2.2.3; US Man and the Biosphere Strategic Plan, UN/US Heritage Corridor Program, The Wildlands Project, WildEarth, 1992. Also see Science, The High Cost of Biodiversity, 25 June, 1993, pp 1968-1871 and the Border 21 Sidebar of NAFTA. The very high percentage of buffer zone in the West is due to the very high percentage of federal land. NOTE: Do not use this map for real estate purposes. Copyright 1997, Environmental Perspectives, Inc. (207) 945-9878
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 Endangered Species Act, the adoption of conservation easements and direct land acquisitions from battered willing sellers. The Wildlands Network seeks to collectivize all natural resources (e.g., water) and centralize all use decisions under government direction, often implemented through public/private partnerships.
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 Plans to herd citizens into tax-subsidized, government controlled, mixed-use developments, 21 called human settlements. These settlements are sometimes distinguished from one another by how productive or useful the citizens are for society.22 Heavy restrictions on development in most areas, and the promotion of extremely dense development, constructed and managed by government partners, in other selected areas. Rations on public services, such as health care, drinking water 23 and energy resources (and sources). A typical day in the Orwellian society created by Smart Growth would consist of an individual waking up in his governmentprovided housing unit, eating a ration of government-subsidized foods purchased at a government-sanctioned grocery store, walking his children (if he has any) to the government-run child care center, boarding government-subsidized public transit to go to his government job, then returning to his quarters later that evening.
Smart Growth
The rural land-use plan embodied in the Wildlands Network is inextricably tied to its urban counterpart, Smart Growth. As human beings are barred from rural land, there will be a concentration of human activity in urban areas. Through Smart Growth, the infrastructure is being created for a post-private property era in which human action is subject to centralized government control. With the combined implementation of Smart Growth and the Wildlands Network, humans will be caged and the animals will run free. Sometimes called comprehensive planning or growth management, 20 Smart Growth is the centralized control of every aspect of urban life: energy and water use, housing stock and allocation, population levels and control, public health and dietary regimens, resources and recycling, "social justice" and education, toxic technology and waste management, transportation modes and mobility restrictions, business and economic activity including capping and trading energy. Smart Growth policies include: Transportation plans that reduce the freedom of mobility, forcing people to live near where they work, and transforming communities into heavily-regulated but self-sufficient feudalistic transit villages.
20. ...we call our [U.N. advocated planning] processes something else, such as comprehensive planning, growth management, or smart growth. Lawrence, J. Gary, op cit. 18
21. The lure of paying as little as $150 per year in taxes on properties valued at $1.5 million has led to high occupancy in some developments in Portland, Oregon, for example. 22. The Smart Growth plan for Richland County, South Carolina, for example, distinguishes between employment-based villages, and non-employmentbased villages, with special gated communities set aside for the wealthy individuals responsible for the plan. Most of the non-employment-based villages are slated to be built in areas currently populated by the descendants of liberated slaves. 23. Reasonable access to water in urban areas is defined as the availability of 20 litres per capita per day at a distance no longer than 1,000 metres. Global Water Supply and Assessment Report 2000. 19
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 In order to meet the global equalization objectives of the economic E (see page 8), the Sustainable Development system requires global management of trade directed by the World Trade Organization (WTO) pursuant to policy created by the World Bank. This system of managed trade necessitates bringing down American production and middle class standards of living to a sustainable level. Similar to the European Union, the North American Union calls for an eventual merger of countries (Canada, Mexico, and the United States). By design, this leads to regional governance that sacrifices our unalienable rights and national sovereignty. 26
Image 4: The Trans-Texas Corridor as originally displayed on the North Americas SuperCorridor Coalition (NASCO) website, http://www.nascocorridor.com/
24. Corsi, Jerome R., The Late Great USA - The Coming Merger with Mexico and Canada (Chapter 6), World Ahead Media, Los Angeles, CA (2007). 25. Texans Uniting for Reform & Freedom: http://www.TexasTurf.org 20 26. Henry Lambs DVDs contain information on the North American Union and the Trans-Texas Corridor: https://secure.freedom.org/eco/nauboth.dyn 27. Kelo v. City of New London, 545 U.S. 469 (2005); 125 S. Ct. 2655. 28. Institute for Justice: http://www.ij.org/ 21
Understanding Sustainable Development Agenda 21 If Americans, with your help, come to a timely understanding of the threat and face the challenge squarely, the deceptive fraud of Sustainable Development will quickly come to light. Together, we will rise to restore Liberty through a renewal of reason and respect for the dignity of individual determination. The future of the freedom once taken for granted in America depends on us recognizing and countering the threats of Sustainable Development.
Fr e e dom A dvoc at e s
Recognize Unalienable R ights
w w w.f reedomadvocates.org
For more Freedom Advocates products, call: 831.684.2232, or visit our Store at: http://www.FreedomAdvocates.org
(Add $2.00 shipping for 1-10 copies of either pamphlet, call for shipping costs for orders over 10)
Audio:
8 Hours of Radio Interviews and Presentations from the Freedom 21 Santa Cruz Radio Show
America is being transformed from the land of the free to the land of the controlled via mechanisms that target the middle class. Knowing reality the threat and the potential is the foundation for restoring and preserving liberty. Hosted by Michael Shaw, Freedom Advocates, with the following guests and topics:
Abolishing Private Property - Dr. Michael Coffman (2 hours) Screening your Child for Mental Health Dismantling the Family - Dr. Karen Effrem Central Banking and Sustainable Tyranny - Dr. Edwin Viera Fabian Socialism, Regionalizing England, and the European Union - Robert Theobald The All Out War on Natural Law - William Roberts (2 hours)
Freedom Advocates
P.O. Box 3330 Freedom, CA 95019 831.684.2232 831.685.1472 (Fax)
SM
_ _ _ War on Reason Audio CD sets _ _ _ Americas Choice DVDs _ _ _ Total Items $_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Total Price with Shipping Name: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Address: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ City: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ State: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Zip: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Phone: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ Email: _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
www.FreedomAdvocates.org
24