FILED: DUTCHESS COUNTY CLERK 05/23/2023 02:22 PM INDEX NO.

2023-51697
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/23/2023

At a 'ferm of the Supreme COUlt, in

and for the County ofDutehess held,
in and for the Dutchess County Supreme
tourt, in Poughkeepsie, New York, this
~day of May, 2023, .

PRE SEN 1': 'lIon, MARtA G. ROSA, J.S.C.

SUPltEM.E COIJRI' : S'IArE OF NEW YORK

COUNTY OF DUrCHESS

In the Matter the Application of TFIE COIJN'l'Y Index No. 2023~516<)7

OF DUTCI1ESS, WILLIAM. F'x. O'NEil" in' his
capacity as County Executive of the County of
Dutchess, DIrT'CHESS COUNTY DEPARTMENT
OF COMJVIUNTrVAND FAMILY SERVICES, ORDER '1'0 SHO'" CAUSE
and SABRINA JAAR MARZOUKA, in her capacity WITH TEMPORARY
as Commissioner of the Dutchess County RESTRAINTS
DepartInent of Community and Famil~ Services,

Petitioners-Plainti tIs,
~against-

TIIECITY OF NEW YORK, ERICADAMS, in

his capacity a~ Mayor of the C~ityof New York,
and MOLI,Y WASOW PARK in her capacity'
as Commissioner of the New York City Ikpartll1ent
of Social Services, ROUTE 9 110TEL LLC, a/k/a
.ROUrr.: <) LLC, d/b/a REI) ROO.F INN 394
and SAl RAM MANAGEMEN'I'LI,C d/b/a
IIOLIDA Y INN,
Respondents-Defendants, ,
-and-

NEW YORK STATE OFFICE OF TEMPORARY

])ISABIL,rry AND ASSIS'r.ANCE

Nominal Respondent-Defendant

For a Judgment Pursuant to Article 78 and for a

Declaratory Judgment Under Article 30 of the C\vil
Practice Law and Rules
OUTCHESS COUNTY

ATTORNEY

County Office Building

n M~ll'ktt Strt'Cf

Poughkc{'p!'ic~ NY

,l26UI

(845) 486,21]0 1

1 of 5
FILED: DUTCHESS COUNTY CLERK 05/23/2023 02:22 PM INDEX NO. 2023-51697
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/23/2023

Upon the Affirmation of CAROLINE E. BLACKBURN, County Attorney, dated the

19th day of May, 2023, and the combined Petition and Cornplaint verified the 19th day of May,
I
2023, together with the exhibits attached to this Order to Show Cause and notice pursuant to •!

~I Rule 202.7(1) ()fthe New York Rules of Court; u~ c>~o:;th~ t?e.~ h-)ed\~
he~ o,,~0.~Cl,,~IJ~~W\+'IA,a.\~ raAtl~<;;~/e~er\'~-\. . ,.
~cN.t'5

LE,l I he CIty of Nevi York, blc Adams III 1m capacity as Mayor of the CIty of New

York, and Molly Wasow Park in her capacity as the Acting Commissioner of the New York

City Department of Home1ess Services for the City of New York, and ROUTE 9 HOTEL LtC,

ROUTE 9 LLC, d/b/a the RED ROOF INN, located at 2349 South Itoad, Poughkeepsie, New

York 12601 and SAl RAM MANAGEMENT LLC, d/b/a Holiday Inn, located at 2170 South

Road,Pougbkeepsic, NY 12601, the Respondents-Defendants herein, or their attorncy( s) show

cause bcfore this Court at the Courthouse located at the Dutchelis County Courthouse, 10

Market Street, Poughkeepsie, New York on the a,S\- day of -:;$'ore. , 2023, at.
30 '. .. .
9 . o'clock in the~.-re..._noon of said day, or as soon thereafter as counsel can be

heard~$19 a~~l~~ made and entered: . . .

1. Pursuant to CPLR 6301 et seq., granting a preliminary injunction during the

pendency of this action, restraining and enjoining Responclents-Defendants, The City of New

York, Eric Adams in his capacity as Mayor of the City of New York, and Molly Wasow Park

in her capacity as the Acting Commissioner of th~ New York City Department of Homeless

Services for the City of New York, ROUTE 9 HOTEL LLC, A/KIA ROUTE 9 1,LC, d/b/a the

RED ROOF INN, located at 2349 South Road, Poughkeepsie, New York 12601 and SAl RAM

MANAGEMENT L.LC d/b/a HOLIDAY INN, located at 2170 South Road, Poughkeepsie, NY

1260 I,. through its agents, servants, representatives and employee's, from transpolting any
DUTCHESS COUNTY

I\TTOHN.£Y
County Oflkc Building homeless adult or minor individuals residing in a temporary sh~lter(s) in New York City to any
22 Mnrkcf Stn'ct

Poughkeepsie. NY
n601
(845) 486.211 0 2

2 of 5
FILED: DUTCHESS COUNTY CLERK 05/23/2023 02:22 PM INDEX NO. 2023-51697
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/23/2023

hotels within Dutchess County, including but not limited to the RED ROOF INN 394, and/or

the HOLIDAY INN; and

2. Granting such other and further relief as to this Court may deem jusumd proper,

including but not fimited to an award of C()sts and disbursements to the Petitioners-Plaintiffs

herein.

SUFFICIENT REASON THERE.FORE APPEARING, pending a hearing and fJnal

determination of the within application, it is hereby

I~M6dla~
OHJlERED, with appellate rights reserved, effective May. _._' ~ upon the
. IJ1 ofr&rt .
of the County of Dtitchess and the Dutchess COUlity Depat-tment of Community and
eOI1!.I€mt

1\.per0-i'r- '() ~ €-- c\c.e:\e-\ M M();\.,~ ~ % ts. m o-h- dY"\ \

Farnily Services, that Respondents-Defendants, The City of New York, Eric Adams in his

capacity as Mayor of the City of New York, and Molly Wasow Park in her capacity as the

Acting Commissioner of the New York City Departlnentof Hpmeless Services for the City of.

New York, ROUTE 9 HOTEL LLC, a/k/a ROUTE 9 LLC, d/b/a the RED ROOF INN, located

at 2349 South Road, Poughkeepsie, New York 12601 and SAl R.t\M MANAGEMENT LLC

d/b/a HOJ-JDAY INN, located at 2170 South Road, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601, through their

agents, servants, representatives and employees, are hereby temporarily enjoined and restrained
I ~~~~\. ~ln~~o~
from transporting any "homeless adult or minor individuals residing inAtemporary shelter(s) in

New York City iohotels within the County of Dutchess, including but not limited to, RED

ROOF INN 394, and/or HOLIDA Y INN; and it is further

I.
ORDIi;RKD, that the City of New York, including its agents or assIgns, shall not

transport any so-called migrants and/or asylum seekers and/or asylum refugees to the County

nUTCHESS COliNTY
of Dutchess; and it is further
,HTORNEY
CO\lnty Ollie£', Blinding

:n M:wktt Sfr~ct

1260.1

(845) 48(,.2110 3

3 of 5
FILED: DUTCHESS COUNTY CLERK 05/23/2023 02:22 PM INDEX NO. 2023-51697
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/23/2023
.;

".,.. ..,'{~:'\"ijm,;',,, 'L'0 __

~;;/'> .•.......•.....
'~., .;")1~?,. ..'$1f~
ORPlt1UDD, that PlaiIltiff-Peiitioliersshali beentitledtorn<lke.stl1tutory inspections at
-. ~ '.. ' -".: -{,\S ~l.( ~flo,.,.():~;()"" '.' . .
?,ubJect premises, ~pon reasonab~tice to defenq<lIlts-respondents', and such'
'., ~';.,;/~/ ,.<',~,.';.'. .- -.. <'1 "'it' .c:;,. ;", i.'.:,.' ....:;"•. "'>

..inspections;slla}l'.not jnterfer~with servic~sbeingprovided 16

fii,unti;i,fD~cl\~~~ and it is furtli6b' .."

•• fthr~,~~a.er;
prio, to'1ii~~OI

~~:~~l;ik~:~,
,_:,l> .. ~cJ,.Ql:
that t~'ec:ty ,ofNe~~";:~rk shall continue't(:'~rovide and shall continue tol
_" ' 'Y ,,' I
incur all ,el~~edAe~penses fo~~~tviccs ProV:dedto any oe<;ulia~!sa<lm,U~ to the COUnty,of I
Dutchess prior totl"e Elatet')f this Order; includingbtit not liniitedt()nH~dical, meals, laundry,/'~'/.'
" • , •.. ". • 0".". "".,

. .~ -
security andti'imsportation; and it,is further . . .... '. ..; ...,..........'. .. ' . <{;o' ....
. .....
".,' .....
~/ ....
~ ~.~\~~~~~'"'tF6 <;,e. ,G.A~ ~
ORDER~:Q;,that to ;Hlee'xtentilpermitt~4'bYJaw,.defenda!li}>.,.r~sp(}ndents
shall provide
"~/" ~~)"
.., ,~:~.~~;\:; . :". «*;'.~.~. '.' ,
_Pl;lintiffs-Petit;()"h\::rswitliideniifi<5ationforaQyanc1~li'J~ch(}Ccul?ritits adn1'm~dto the County
.. / ..~",;";,",,-,,,.~,>~,., . . , ', : :..: ",~:;;..... '.'

'.'"." .. ,'>: ..' •.. ..?,(i',:;'t:;o'0::'i'Y~:"';',h~",-" "_ '. '.

ofDutehess pri<:ij'}ot.l1s'date ef i,this;Ordcl~witRillfiye'(S):aft)",~(trtheclate Elf this erdcr, ....1 ..'
b';fen<lllflts,R~~pklldents,hatl' pri,lOptliiJi';tif;';I~intiffslpetiti-::,~'t.~~~&~J~
'. "" . .. ..' i.'" .. -.,.;,:;!' ..•/\ './A j~Cc.t.... '
• , .• ,:, '.; ,:_."'::-.: ":':~~~,:_;":"'.":' .J," :'6""'~~.'.. _,". .";.' I v~t:. U
vacatethes\lHjc~t"premises; and itisfurther vJfvluM' Go;'!.
.'y', ',' ..i.'/,,;": '. . . .' 'i- ...,'.
"Oni~EREl),that seryiceofa copy6fthis.Otdert()gether'~~ith '. .' ~.- "'. . .' . " ' , -j'"'-''''
the papcrson.yvhichit
.:
is.
;
',:"
~""" ",'

granted sh~lllbetnadc by NYSCEFServicc, orby hancldelivery orby{)vernight Mail delivery

r~

upOi1Respqndehi-;Defendant, The~Citx'ofNewYork,f.:hc
• , •• '. C',,_
Adarns .'>,' .

. as Mayorofe';/qity OfNe:York, arid Motly W•• ()wl;~k l~,h" caj>J6,ty as (he Actmg
c;om~;SSi9~<;i)ftlte~~",;Y~:k~itYD;;~tmen'()f 1l0mC'eS~~<{~ipesi~r
the City of New
York; uponf,th~&,':Attomeysrto'wit:N~~'York City. Law .Dep~i;flllent;I-Attn.: Corporation
'\:' ~ . :' ..-{'''" .~_.:'.., ' . ' ..::'::/.,.).:,:.f>": .\'... ' ',."'.~.:.\:-i<",," . " ..._-....>:,../,~::.:~:~~~:
...-:"'
....~ '...' . ~

Counsel, atth""flke address •• 'l bO~hurchStreet,~?w Y~rk,N o\V~o,~ 10007, nn 0' hefore

I
the '?Lf~ .ofM~Y, :20.2:3,.
':i:;?:1.:>;~,>:'::;'-
Sh:I;'~.e. i~emedg~od:~~~"~llfh~i~nt seiVii:; and:it'.i~;fbrthcr

. DUTCHESS COUNTy'l ' .

'I.
OR,DmliEn;that service (if a c.opy()ftllis Ordei;'togethcl'.\vith thc papers on which it is
. .
ATTOll.."'EY I
County.Otll« nuihliug I grahted sl~alJhe .made by hand'~eliv6ry~;rby bvernight~1~fJdelivcry upon Respondent-
22 t-'i;ukl't Street
.
" II
"Poughkeepsie, N'\t.

J2t>l1l

(845) 4il6,11lO

4 of 5
FILED: DUTCHESS COUNTY CLERK 05/23/2023 02:22 PM INDEX NO. 2023-51697
NYSCEF DOC. NO. 30 RECEIVED NYSCEF: 05/23/2023

Defendants, ROUTE 9 HOTEL LLC,a/k/a ROUTE 9LLC, d/b/a the RED ROOF INN,

upon their registered agent(s) for service, to wit: BHAV ANA PATEL, Address: 2349 SOlJ1'1'1

'ROAD, POUGIIKEEPSIE, NY 12601; and SAl RAM MANAGE.MENT 1.,LC dlbia

HOLIDAY INN, upon their registered agent(s) for service, t(> wit: SAl RAM MANAGEMENT
, ..... . ' ..or c.:>PM~<€-t'I'~~e( O~f.eCo('cl- .~ ..
LLC, Address: 2170 SOUTII RD, POUGHKEEPSIE, NY 12601, on or before the 24- day of

May, 2023, shall be deemed g?od and suffic;;ient service; and it is further

ORDERED, that service of a copy of this Order together with the papers on which it is

granted shall be made by hand delivery or by Overnight Mail delivery upon the Nominal

Respondent-Defendant, New York State Office of 'Femporary and Disability Assistance upon.

their GeneraIC:ounsel, Tifline)' Rudnik, at the offices at 'ren Eyck State Office Building, 40
~
2=':L day of May, 2023,
,

North Pearl Str~et, Albany, New York 12207 on orbeJore the shall be

deemed good and sufficient service; and it is further

ORDERED, that pursuant to Section 7804(c) of the Civil Practice Law and Rules, a
. '. c?ppos;"\-n:N' eAr-.~ Jc:9C""' /IItOhtf'VtS '

verified answer and supporting affidavits, if any~sball be served upon the Office of the Dutchess
~h\e-d.cUt!
County Attorney, counsel for the Plaintiffs-Petitioners, at their oflice'located at 22 Market
C;;ldOa~

~:;::Ob;~:~~~tp,,~~~
. (9f) oC' ~f'e ~(">e

~~:' 5'" F1~l~Ul~;;:~~; o...~ ~.rv-&!:- ern

.•4-tlm~ettfton. ~-\~ c)-(' ~
.
~('(2..20,
.
20'2...:~
.
Dated: Poughkeepsie, New York
Maya,3_, 2023,
ENTER:

HON~\~-'-S-A-'-.--'-----
JustiCe of the Supreme Court

nvrCHESS COUNTY
ATTORNEY

Count)' Office Building

.12 Markt!'! Stact

/

12601
(845) 4S6.211Q 5

5 of 5