The Effects of Technological Modernization To The Catholic Beliefs and To Ways of Living A Religious Life Thesis
The Effects of Technological Modernization To The Catholic Beliefs and To Ways of Living A Religious Life Thesis
The Effects of Technological Modernization To The Catholic Beliefs and To Ways of Living A Religious Life Thesis
In Partial Fulfilment
Presented By;
Table of Contents
Introduction…………………………………………………………………… [7-9]]
Thesis Statement…………………………………………………………..………[9]
Conceptual Framework……………………………...………………………[13-14]]
Introduction……………………………………………………………………[15]
Harrison, 2004.……...…………………………………………………………[15]
Carota,2016…………………………………………………………………….[15]
Brophy,2018.……………………………………………………………...……[15]
Hurkheim, 2014…..……………………………………………………………[15]
Bianchi, 2016…....……………………………………………………………...[17]
Bianchi, 2015…………………………………………….…………..………....[17]]
Horan, 2017.………………………………………….………………………...[18]]
Carota,2016…….…………………………….………………………………...[18]]
3
Gonzales
Carota,2015………………………………………………………………………..[19]
Jackson,2018………………………………………………………………………[19]
Zsupan-Jerome,2015…………………………...…………………………………[20]
Definition of terms…………………………………………………………..…[21-22]
Chapter 3: Methodology
Introduction……………………………………………………………………...[23]
Research setting……………………………………………………………....[24-25]
Sampling Criteria………………………………………………………………...[26]
Reliability………………………………………………………………………[28-29]
Validity……………………………………………………………………….……[29]
Ethical Consideration…………………………………………………………[30-31]
Introduction……………………………………………………………………...[32]
Figure1.1……………………………………………………………………,,,…[32]
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………………………..[33]
Figure 1.2………………………………………………………………………...[34]
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………………………..[35]
Analysis……………………………………………………………………….[35-36]
Figure 2.1………………………………………………………………………………...[37]
4
Gonzales
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………………….…………….[37]
Figure 2.2………………………………………………………………….….……….....[38]
Textual Interpretation……………………………………………………………..……[38]
Analysis………………………………………………………...…...………..…….…[38-39]
Figure 3.1……………………………………………………………………….….…….[40]
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………………………….…….[40]
Figure 3.2………………………………………………………………………….……..[41]
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………………………….…….[41]
Analysis………………………………………………………….………...…….……….[42]
Figure 4.1……………………………………………………………………......….……[43]
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………………….…,,,………..[43]
Figure 4.2………………………………………………………………,,…….…………[44]
Textual Interpretation……………………………………………………..……………[44]
Figure 4.3……………………………………………………………….……….……….[45]
Textual Interpretation……………………………………………………….………….[45]
Analysis…………………………………………………………………………….……..[46]
Figure 5.1……………………………….………………………………………………...[47]
Textual Interpretation……………………………………………………………...……[47]
Figure 5.2………………………………………………………………………………….[48]
Textual Interpretation……………………………………………………………………[48]
Figure 5.3……………………………………………………………………………...…..[49]
Textual Interpretation………………………………………………………,………...….[49]
Analysis……………………………………………………………………..……………...[50]
Figure 6.1………………………………………………………………………….……….[51]
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………………………………….[51]
5
Gonzales
Textual Interpretation…………………………...………………...….…….[52-53]
Figure 6.3…………………………………………………………..…………….[53]
Textual Interpretation…………………..………………...…………………[53-54]
Analysis…………………………………………………………………………..[54]
Figure 7.1……………………………………………………….………………..[55]
Textual Interpretation……………………………………..……………………[55]
Figure 7.2………………………………………………………………………...[56]
Textual Interpretation………………...……………………………………..[56-57]
Analysis……………………………………………………………….………….[57]
Figure 8.1………………………………………………………………………...[58]
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………………………..[58]
Fugure 8.2………………………………………………………………………..[59]
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………………………..[59]
Figure 8.3…………………………………………………………………………[60]
Textual Interpretation…………………………………………...………………[60]
Analysis…………………………………………………………………..……[60-61]
Figure 9.1…………………………………………………………………………[62]
Textual Interpretation…….……………………………………...…………..….[62]
Figure 9.2…………………………………………………………………………[63]
Textual Interpretation……………………………………………………………[63]
Figure 9.3………………………………………………………………………….[64]
Textual Interpretation……………………………………………...…………….[65]
Analysis…………………………………………………………………...……….[65]
Figure 10.1………………………………………………………..……………….[66]
6
Gonzales
Textual Interpretation……………………………………...…………..……..[66-67]
Analysis…………………………………………………………………….……..[67]]
Concluscion…………………………………………………………..[68-69]
Recommendation…………………………………………………….[69-70]
Bibliography………………………………………………………….[71]
Appendices……………………………………………………………..………[72-81]
Acknowledgement…………………………………………………………………[82]
Dedication………………………………………………………………………….[83]
7
Gonzales
Chapter 1
Introduction
According to Daniel Lerner, Modernization is the current term for an old process
which is the process of social change whereby, less developed societies acquire
a traditional, rural, and agrarian society to a secular, urban and industrial society. Moreover,
passing of traditional society and defines the policy planning of the social change.
Furthermore, the researcher gained the motivation to start this study because the
researcher herself is bothered of the technological and societal modernization that is now
happening not only in the community but also inside the Catholic church which serves as a
hindrance to the holiness and solemnity of the celebration of the Holy mass. Also, these
modernizations also affect the practice of the traditional catholic beliefs and the way the
people live their Christian life, in which instead of the original beliefs to be followed and to
be instructed. Consequently, it is being altered and changed in a way that is far from its
original ones which makes a big effect on the people’s beliefs and Christian way of life.
Based on the 20th Sunday Homily of Rev. Fr. Edwin Lusterio , the Parish priest of
Our Mother of Perpetual Help Parish about the Catholic beliefs, he quoted that “ Catholic
8
Gonzales
beliefs and ways of living a religious life are now being altered because not all people
are having the same beliefs and insights towards their religion and living such religious life.
It is because there are some who assume that their insight or idea about that certain belief is
right without even having an assurance if the one that they believe in is really a true belief, in
what everyone should believe in.” For example, the popular Catholic belief that there are
only two genders that exist in this world is based on the biblical scripture that can be found
in the book of Genesis 1:27 which says “ So God created a man in his image; in the image
of God He created him; male and female he created them.” This evidently proves that there
is no such thing as more than two gender complementary. For there are only two original
Nowadays, Gender Identity Crisis is the most complicated and extensive issue that we
Modernization. Because not all people believe in this said Catholic beliefs for there are
some people who do not only consider two genders and sexuality, instead they consider such
thing as they called the “LGBTQI” that stands for (Lesbian, Gay, Bisexuality,
Although it is already in the Biblical Scripture and is already been taught by the
Catholic church. Some people still insist that having more than one gender is not a wrong
thing and it is not violating God’s law. They wanted the acceptance and respect of the
society towards their gender identity expression even though that they are disobeying the
Christian morality and cause discrimination towards the natural gender law.
Also, the researcher already had a lot of encounters and experiences, these are
negative effects of technological and societal modernization. The posts in social media
9
Gonzales
(specially on Facebook) which contain threats to people may also posts who uses God as
their subject just to get likes shares and reactions from million of people. Chain
modernization. Because it does not only frighten the people in social media, but it also makes
Moreover, The researcher is really bothered on these particular issues and their
negative effects. The people should believe on something morally sound to their religious
life. Modernization gets severe that can surely and completely sweep the traditional and
original beliefs away and rather alter values. Popular trends and strong social media sites
Thesis Statement
The severe uprising of technological and societal modernity which includes different
popular societal trends and secularized mentality of the society have negative effects to the
The main problem that the researcher is bothered about is the negative effects of
technological and societal modernization to the Catholic beliefs and ways of living a religious
life. These may be hindrances to the holiness and solemnity of the celebration of the Holy
mass and the ways people should live their lives. Through this study, the researcher would
1.) What negative effects does technological and societal modernization bring to the
2.) How does the uprising of the popular trends and modernized technology influence
3.) What do you think are the possible ways that can solve these issues?
11
Gonzales
The goal of this study is to determine the negative effects of technological and
societal modernization to the Catholic beliefs and to ways of living a religious life. Also,
through this study, the researcher would be able to contribute different information, facts and
other knowledge that can be shared to the society, to the future researchers, to the dear alma
By conducting this study, the researcher can also give the readers and future
For the society, this can help them to be aware of the dangerous and negative effects
For the Catholic community, this study can give them a knowledge on how to live a
religious life that is based on the teachings of our Lord Jesus Christ. Christian morality
Furthermore, If they are able to read this particular study, this can also help them to
come up of an idea to be more of a traditional and religious minded people for their spiritual
growth.
For Catholic schools, this can help them on how to coincide the modern tehnology
and religionto be able to educate the young millenial Catholics that the practice of
Catholicism is very essential. Also, for them to know more about God and his words.
For my dear family and friends, this research will help them to lead good spiritual
lives. Proper studying and understanding of the true doctrine and beliefs can lessen the
12
Gonzales
uprising modernity in the society. They should focus on avoiding worldly and materialistic
things.
Lastly, For the future researchers, this study can be used as a reference and to speed
up the finishing of their study and for them to easily defend it.
This study was conducted in July 28,2019 and is finished on January 14, 2020. The
maximum number of respondents is 100 respondents. But due to lack of time and because
not all respondents being handed out of the survey questionnaires have returned and
answered the hard copy survey questionnaires. So, the researcher have changed the maximum
number of respondents from 100 respondents to 30 respondents. For it is the only number of
respondents that have greatly contributed to the completion of the data needed to complete
Conceptual Framework
13
Gonzales
INPUT
Independent variable
Dependent variable
PROCESS
OUTPUT
Many of the Catholics nowadays were really affected by the negative effects of
technological and societal modernization due to the strong influence of popular
trends, social media and modern technology
14
Gonzales
Secularism inclines due to the societal trends and advance modern technology
which leads many people specially young millennials to forget about the religious
practices
Due to the lack of Christian living education, many people either young and old
were still confuse on what to believe in due to many fake news in the social
media
It is needed that the Catholic church should make an approach to reach out those
Catholics who have lost their ways from the practice of Catholicism through
physical evangelization like Bible study, values formation conference to be able
to discuss the proper practice Catholic religion to be able for them to also
educate the others about the Catholic beliefs and on how to live a religious life.
The church should reach out to the Catholic people to attend the Sunday holy
mass regularly by having a special holy mass in malls and airports to be able for
the Catholics to still be updated on what the holy gospel wanted to teach.
In the homily or sermon of the priests during holy masses, they can mention the
importance of the practice of religious way of life and of the Catholic beliefs and
practices so that the church goers will be able to be educated of both the holy
gospel and its real life application.
CHAPTER 2
15
Gonzales
Introduction
This chapter presents a report of an investigation regarding this topic. Also, this
section provides a basis of answers on the questions that are indicated on the statement of the
problem.
Modernization has already influenced our lives including our common needs, our
mentality, our clothing, our lifestyle , our religion, our attitude and our morality. Because as
we can see in our society nowadays, most of the people have become modernists that resulted
into the ignorance of the importance of religion in your life. For, Catholics, although are
imperfect are trying our best to show true faith and extend such Christendom. 1 (Harrison,
2004) But because of the modernization dominating the whole world and even the world of
religion which causes the Sacramental and liturgical rites to be changed in which that instead
of it to be focused on God alone, they start to focus on the people’s satisfactions, wants, and
comfort Because of this majority of the churches and even members of the clergy would like
to celebrate the new order mass instead of the Tridentine Latin mass because they find the
new order mass a way to reach out and to be close to people who have a modernist
perspective when it comes to religion. Also, many traditional Catholics were being
persecuted because of the practice of the Traditional Roman Catholic rites in the modern era.
(Carota,2016).
Lastly, modernization is the main reason why the dogma of the faith changed which
resulted into the 2nd Vatican Council that lead to the rise of the New Order Holy Mass which
is now being celebrated on majority of the Catholic churches today (Brophy, 2018).
Related Literature
1
Christendom-Christianity as a territorial phenomenon.
16
Gonzales
On the book entitled ``The Catechetical Instructions of St. Thomas Aquinas’ ’Rev. Fr.
Rudolph G. Bandas stated that The forms of teachings and beliefs that are not thoroughly
assimilated2 nor understand can negatively affect the spiritual growth of a person. Which can
drastically lead into misconceptions and misinterpretation towards certain beliefs practices
(Bandas, Pg.6).
The researcher describes this statement as a claim that not all the teachings and
beliefs that are being taught and practice are being understood and applied. Because some
people commit misconceptions and misinterpretations towards a certain belief or teaching,
which can negatively affect a person’s spiritual growth. This can also cause such confusion
which can make a person’s certain belief more complex than it is. Because if people have
been being taught by a preacher who has a different conception or interpretation , there is also
a possibility that they will also have the same interpretation.
All of us has different interpretations on certain beliefs, practices and culture. It is
only up to us how we respect other people’s interpretations towards a certain thing.
Alessandro Bianchi on his article under THE GUARDIAN entitled “The Pope Just Took
Another Step to Modernize the Catholic Church stated that The Vatican was making changes
on how sacrament of marriage works. In such way that they allow the fast and free cost of
2
Assimilated- to cause something to be resembled
3
Protestantism- is a form of Christian faith and practice. It began in northern Europe in
the early 16th century. Also the religion established by Martin Luther in 1529 in
Germany.
17
Gonzales
annulment, which allows the local church to accept appeals regarding marriage. (Bianchi,
2016)
The researcher argues about the changes on the function of the sacrament of marriage.
Based on the covenant 4of this sacrament, it is said by Jesus Christ in Matthew Chapter 19
verse 4 that divorce should not be practiced. For it is written in the scripture that “a man will
leave his parents house to unite with his wife. Although they are in forms of two flesh, if they
unite they will become only one flesh because God is the one who united them and no one to
separate them.”
It has been stated in their covenant that they will love each other until death do
them apart. Thus, this issue is a big one because it violates the commitment that this
matrimonial sacrament has. Consequently, those who file annulment cases will somehow be
happy of having their marriage annulled. Because the Pope would like to make the process of
annulment a fast and free cost process, this will cause them no more to go through a long
process of annulment.5 Thus, this implies that those couples who want to take the sacrament
of marriage should be committed to each other. The sacrament of marriage is a covenant not
just between couples, but is between the couple and God. A few people nowadays never
know that the belief that having an annulment is a sin. It is said by Jesus Christ that divorce
should not be practiced (Bianchi, 2015).
4
Covenant-meaning a coming together.
5
Annulment-is a legal procedure within secular and religious legal systems for declaring
a marriage null and void.
18
Gonzales
which causes the change of cultures and beliefs about things in the surroundings either
tangible or intangible.
Daniel P. Horan on the article entitled “The Catholic Church Is Suffering from Holy
Spirit Atheism” under the column of Faith Seeking and Understanding explains that some of
the Catholic church leaders are starting to have such self-presumptous 6and proud attitude. In
such way that they sometimes rely their beliefs based on how they think, understood, and
interpret it.This now finds the accurate principle on how we should look at the church. -
(Horan, 2017)
Furthermore, they do not recognize Sensus Fidelium 7although that their mentors taught
them of the doctrine and the canon law, still some presume to their own reasoning. But, this
does not mean that these members of the clergy are not preaching properly. They are just
like us, ordinary people, who have their own opinions, perspectives and interpretations
towards a certain thing.
Rev. Fr. Peter Carota on his journal entitled “Who is a Traditional Catholic?” defines
that Traditional Catholics have discovered and identified what have made us into who we are
now. One of it is being discovered that the modernization of the church started when the
protestant advisers who are involved at the Second Vatican Council had successfully
converted the traditional mass into the Novus Ordo or also known as new order mass. In such
way that they drastically changed the Roman Catholic Missal in 1969 with the support of
Pope Paul VI. Furthermore, as we can observe at the New Order mass, instead of God to be
the center of the holy mass, the people are the focus of the gathering in the congregation.
(Carota, 2016)
People come to the holy mass just to feel comfortable. They only prefer the priest
that they like, to do the things they want to do and dress how they want, Most of the men
and women are wearing immodest clothing. They talk whenever they want, and when they
are hearing the homily, they tend to use their mobile phones to take texts, chats and calls
when they are bored. These are very distant from the Latin mass. We should enter and leave
the church quietly. People should dress modestly wherein women wear veils and long dress
or skirt. Men must wear formal attire. They should be respectful to Jesus in the tabernacle,
and do kneeling during the mass.
6
Presumptuous-failing to observe the limits of what is permitted or appropriate.
7
Sensus Fidelium- "the supernatural appreciation of faith on the part of the whole people,
when, from the bishops to the last of the faithful, they manifest a universal consent in matters
of faith and morals."
19
Gonzales
He also said in the article that there are changes in the catechism which had caused
some families to become atheists,8 agnostics9, protestants or non-denominationals.10
As result, some people no longer believe in sin and live their life immorally. Like,
they wanted to legalize the same-sex marriage, practice homosexuality, and even recognize
themselves as righteous.
In addition to that, traditional Catholics believe that the heresies of the modernization,
secularism, and progressivism have caused all the problems in the Catholic church. Tese
were being condemned by the former Pope Pius X in the Pascendi Domini Gregis 11
in September 8, 1907. These problems are also considered as the negative factors of
modernization technologically and socially, make the Catholic people have a negative
perspective towards Catholic beliefs and avoids them to live morally (Carota , 2015).
Wayne Jackson on the article “The Influence of the Modern Trends on the Church”
argees that The modern trends are one of the factors of the negative effect of societal
modernization towards Catholism. Nowadays, as we notice, our society has been being
conquered by modernity which also causes the church to be affected because even during the
ancient times, modernism had already evolved, which had also reflected the incline towards
the rejection of the propositional truth that is based on the divine authority. The idea of
Catholicism and Protestantism has become pervasive because of the heritage restoration that
is been being influenced by heresy12 (Jackson, 2018).
8
Atheist-a person who disbelieve or lacks belief in the existence of God
9
Agnostics-a person who claims neither faith nor disbelief in God.
10
Non-denominals-consists of churches which typically distance themselves from
the confessionalism or creedalism of other Christian communities.
Pascendi Domini Gregis-is a papal encyclical letter, subtitled "On the Doctrines of the
11
real knowledge and only consider subjective and at least objective perspective of a one
individual. The modern trends were also being generated caused by such different societal
and cultural diffusion which had caused the rise in the popularity of trends which affects the
Catholicism because the church thinks that they should be close and to get in touch with the
people to be able for them to go to church and attend the Holy mass which makes the Novus
Ordo to rise for sometimes it does not specifically focusing on God but rather getting in
touch with the people and the priests.
“We engage in verbal violence online because we can get away with it."
Social media may be the term used for websites that allow people to interact online, she added, but "it
doesn't seem social to someone on a screen in the privacy of their own room." ( Zsupan-Jerome, 2015)
Definition of terms:
.
Protestantism- is a form of Christian faith and practice. It began in northern Europe in
the early 16th century. Also the religion established by Martin Luther in 1529 in
Germany.
22
Gonzales
Chapter 3
23
Gonzales
Methodology
Introduction:
This chapter contains the methods being used to gather the needed data for this
particular research. It also contains the criteria and profile of the chosen respondents who
will answer the survey questionnaire. This also contains the scope and limitations that
includes the research setting where the sample datas are being gathered. The researcher also
discusses here on how she gathered and collected the data on the chosen specific research
setting where the respondents are residing at. The instruments being used in collection and
gathering are also contained here which helped the researcher to easily reach her
respondents.
This particular study had used of both qualitative and quantitative kind of approach.
The quantitative kind of approach was defined by Babbie, Earl R. as a method that
statistical data using computational techniques that focuses on gathering numerical data and
method being used on this particular research is a descriptive survey which is a kind of
research method that describes the characteristics of the population or phenomenon that is
being studied.
24
Gonzales
This methodology focuses more on the “what” of the research subject rather than the
“why” of the research subject. On the other hand, qualitative kind of approach was defined by
the Statistics solutions as the kind of approach that “seeks to tell the story of a particular
group’s experiences in their own words, and is therefore focused on narrative. This can be
challenging for researchers more accustomed to the traditional deductive approach.” The
researcher chose a descriptive type of survey because she found more accessible and
convenient for the research setting where she will held her distribution of survey
Research Setting
The research setting is referring to the specific area or place where the sample data
was gathered and collected. In which that the setting being chosen by the researcher herself
was accessible and hassle free for the researcher was also residing on the said research setting
that can help the researcher to easily collect and gather data from the said respondents and
respondees.. The research setting being chosen is within Laguna Belair, Brgy. Don Jose Sta.
Rosa Laguna, San Pablo, Laguna and Pila, Laguna. The said settings were known to have
many young millennials and adults who are highly connected to social media and were also
known to have religious people and members of the clergy who are known to have a
knowledge of the original Catholic beliefs and practice such a religious life and those who
are fond on social media but still practice the Catholic beliefs being thought by the church.
25
Gonzales
Also, the researcher have chosen specific places where she can conduct the survey
and the collection of data and these areas are: Catholic schools, seminaries, parish churches,
The Population and sample of the study consists of the young and adult Catholics and
religious people residing at Laguna, Cavite and Tagaytay area. All young and adult
Catholics who are under ages 13-60 years old were the scope of the population and
sample of the study. A sample of 30 respondents were being selected to be the source of
the gathered data. Also, the respondents being chosen have passed the criteria of the
researcher’s ideal respondees ; in which that all of the respondees being interviewed and
being given of the survey questionnaires are surely having a knowledge about Catholic
The total of the respondents who are willing to contribute to the research studies were
30 respondents and the scope and limitation is possible to increase if the researcher will
make her scope broader and if the researcher was able to distribute the survey
questionnaires exactly on the time proper. The word "sample" was defined as a finite part
of a statistical population whose properties are studied to gain information about the
whole.
26
Gonzales
Sampling Criteria
The researcher had set a criteria for the chosen respondents that will answer the
survey questionnaires to be able to have a reliable source of data and the respondents that will
*Must be a Catholic
*Must be a person/people who are though exposed to popular trends and social
medias are still into the morality based in the teachings of the Catholic church.
*Must be a person/ people who is serving at the church and has the knowledge of
The researcher have chosen instruments to be used for data collection and it is through
physical hardcopy survey questionnaires which will be handed out to the chosen respondents
and just in case that the hardcopy survey questionnaires will not be handed out personally, the
researcher have also decided to made use of online surveys through Google docs by sending
the link to those respondents through the use of private message to be able to gather more
data from those respondents who are residing farther from the researcher’s address. The
researcher had given all of her respondents of both online and physical survey. She had
*It makes the researcher to have an easy way of computing and compiling the data
being gathered
* It makes the researcher to know the opinions of different people from different ages
about the negative factors of technological and societal modernity to the Catholic
*It makes the respondents to define and cite their opinions about the problem that is
.
28
Gonzales
The data collection procedure that is being done by the researcher is that she
distributed the survey questionnaires to the chosen respondents on the research setting that
she have chosen which is within Laguna, Cavite and Tagaytay area in which that she asked
some help of some friends to distribute some of the survey questionnaires. Also, the
researcher have made an online survey for those respondents whom she cannot reach out due
to the long distance of the location of the respondents. Furthermore, The researcher have
also held an interview with some of the respondees because the researcher wants to gather
more informations that can exceed to the answer of the respondents on the survey
Consequently, some of the respondents were not able to give back the physical survey
questionnaires and some of the respondents that the researcher have sended an online survey
were not able to answer the online survey. So, the researcher just held an interview to some
of the respondents.
Reliability
consistently well. Furthermore, the proof of the reliability of the answers and questions is the
consistency of the answers of the respondents in each of the questions indicated in the survey
29
Gonzales
questionnaire. The proof of the reliability of the data that is indicated in the survey
questionnaires (which includes both online and physical) and of the interview can be shown;
In such way that the researcher herself was the only one who held the interview and the
distribution of the survey questionnaire that are in the form of hard copy with the proper
consent of the respondents. As for the interview/s, the researcher have organized the schedule
The researcher also made the questions understandable and explained briefly to be
able for the respondents to have a reliable answer that can also make the questions reliable
and valid. In addition to that, the researcher have no posted her online survey to any of the
social media sites (such as facebook, Instagram, and others) so that the researcher can
respondents.
Validity
Validity is defined as how well a scientific test or piece of research actually measures
what it sets out to, or how well it reflects the reality it claims to represent. The proof of
the validity of the data that is indicated in the survey questionnaires (which includes both
online and physical) and of the interview can be shown; the researcher have clearly
explained to her respondents of the things that should be done and on how the survey
30
Gonzales
should be answered accordingly. For them to understand of the concept of the survey
questionnaire and for them to put their shoes on the given scenario.
The way of answering the survey questionnaires is in the way of only giving brief
explanations and giving simple insights about the given situation; also for them to have a
convenient way of stating their responds on each situation/s being focused on. Lastly,
the researcher have asked her respondents to state their answers with honest answers. So
Ethical Consideration
Before the gathering of data through the distribution of the survey questionnaires and
held an interview with the respondents, the researcher have become considerate to some of
the respondents because of the late return of the hard copy survey questionnaire because
they have no answered it yet or they have not finished answering it yet. The researcher have
approached her respondents whom she had given the surveys with and asked them of the
surveys but some were not able to bring it back due to their personal schedules and agendas.
So the researcher have given them an extension of the deadline of the survey so that they will
not be forced and be pressured to answer the survey questionnaire and for them to have a
longer time of thinking of the answers and the researcher have also sent them of the online
form of the survey so that they will have more convenience of answering the survey
31
Gonzales
questionnaire. The researcher have not give any prizes or anything in exchange for answering
The respondents should take note of these parts being incuded on the informed
consent so that the collection of the data will be more fast and is easy to be computed. These
The information that they shoud give are the types of informations that are related
to the topic
The respondents should know whom to contact if ever that they have
Chapter 4
Introduction:
This Chapter shows the findings, analysis and interpretation of data being gathered
whose main objective is to know what makes modern technology and societal trends a
negative effect towards the Catholic beliefs and to ways of living a religious life. Also, this
consist of all the numbers of the data samples being collected by the researcher. More
1.) Do you think that the usage of modern technology affects a person’s beliefs towards
religion?
3%
97%
Yes No
Textual Interpretation
Twenty-nine (29) respondents (97%) out of 30 respondents answered Yes, which means that
they are being affected while One (1) respondent (3%) out of 100 respondents answered
How /why?
35
Gonzales
Series1
Atheism 2
3
shows advancement and progress of person as a Catholic 2
4
can use the social media to do evangelization 2
2
personal effect on the user 3
2
ng on modern technology (gadgets, socia media more often 3
3
at makes change to the views and opinions of the Catholics 5
0 1 2 3 4 5 6
36
Gonzales
Textual Interpretation
Five respondents (16%) out of 30 respondents answered that it is due to the influence of
opinions and value / principle formation of users that makes change to the views and opinions
media) more often, 2 respondents (7%) out of 30 respondents answered strong persuasion
impact to those do not deeply know their faith, 3 respondents (10%) answered personal effect
on the user, 2 respondents (6%) answered depends on the belief of the person on what he/ she
is believing at, 2 respondents (6%) can use social media to do evangelization, 4 respondents
(13%) answered adding knowledge and wisdom to the Catholic people, 2 respondents (6%)
Analysis
Majority of the Catholic people thinks that the usage of modern technology highly
affects their beliefs towards religion,.which implies that they are affected in a way that they
easily got brainwashed or rather by a person or group of people who posted such things
towards religion which influences them to have the same mentality and beliefs towards
religion.
The remaining 3% implies that the respondent’s belief towards religion was not being
itself. For there is something in religion, which has an ability to survive all particular symbols
eternally.” (Hurkheim, Pg. 22). The remaining 3% implies that the respondent’s belief
towards religion was not being affected due to his use of modern technology due to his
Also, It is evidently seen on the graph that the power of social media is very strong
upon influencing people in many ways that causes them to change their lifestyle, beliefs and
opinions about things which is for others are not that bad but due to the heresies of the
modernization, secularism, and progressivism had caused all the problems in the Catholic
church (Carota , 2015) that is being caused by the wrong usage of the social media.
38
Gonzales
2.) How often do you see some religion-based posts in social media which contain different
17% 3%
30%
13%
37%
Textual Interpretation
Nine (9) respondents (30%) out of 30 respondents answered Always, Eleven (11)
(17%) out of 100 respondents answered Occasionally, Four (4) respondents (13%) out of
30 respondents answered Seldomly and Lastly, One (1) respondent out of 30 respondents
answered Never.
39
Gonzales
33%
67%
Textual Interpretation
Analysis
Almost half of the sample population said that they only see religion based posts
SOMETIMES and also a few of them were not being affected about these particular posts
containing the opinions of other people because they said that they based will still based on
the original teachings, doctrines and beliefs being taught of the Catholic church and they
40
Gonzales
will just stick to it even though that the contemporary society was focused on technological
Modernization has already influenced our lives including our common needs, our
mentality, our clothing, our lifestyle , our religion, our attitude and our morality. Because as
we can see in our society nowadays, most of the people have become modernists that resulted
into the ignorance of the importance of religion in your life. For, Catholics, although are
imperfect are trying our best to show true faith and extend such Christendom.14 (Harrison,
2004)
While some others said that they are being affected for the reason that they said that the
religion-based posts and articles that they read were helpful towards their understanding of
their faith specially when they cannot understand some of Catholic beliefs .
3.) Is it recommended that all the Catholic people should be taught of the original Catholic
yes
100%
yes no
Textual Interpretation
Thirty (30) respondents (100%) out of 30 respondents answered Yes which means that the
computed data that were having the same opinions and ideas that can make the percentage of
Why?
42
Gonzales
20%
40%
17%
23%
ItEvery
itishelps
because
theCatholic
one
the
it isthat
Catholics
the
should
makes
foundation
have
toahave
person
the
ofmore
same
thea Catholic
knowledge
beliefs religion
about the doctrines and beliefs of the
Catholic church
Textual Interpretation
knowledge about the doctrines and beliefs of the Catholic church, 7 respondents (23%) out of
respondents answered that it is the the one that makes a person a Catholic, 6 respondents
(20%) out of 30 respondents answered that every Catholic should have the same beliefs.
Analysis
43
Gonzales
Catholics of the Catholic doctrines and beliefs because many had also said when the
Contemporary Catholics are being taught it can build up a strong foundation of our faith and
truth as Roman Catholics and it is also needed to learn of the Catholic doctrines for it is
Because according to an expert , Fr. Carl Pua “ It is not sufficient that people are just
sacramentalized but instead, it is also needed that the Catholic people should be taught of the
proper religious instructions that are imperative in order to know how to live the rule of
thumb. Lex orandi, lex credenda, lex vivendi (as we worship, so we believe and so we
live)”
10%
90%
yes no
Textual Interpretation
Twenty-seven (27) respondents (90%) out of 30 respondents answered No and Three (3)
If yes, why?
7%
37%
56%
Textual Interpretation
10 respondents (37%) out of 30 respondents answered that it violates the natural law, 2
100%
Textual Interpretation
3 respondents (100%) out of 30 respondents answered because love between two people is
Analysis
Most of the respondents had responded that they do not support the same sex marriage and
only a few said they do support the same-gender marriage. The most common reason why
most people said t hat they do not support same gender marriage is simply because of the
particular belief that can be found on the biblical scripture and can be found on Genesis 27:1
that states that “ So God created a man in his image; in the image of God He created him;
male and female he created them.” Contemporary based, it is also forbidden because it is
Those 3 respondents are supporting same sex marriage because they said that love
between two people are not measured or based in the gender of a person; which is contrary to
both natural law and the gender complementary. Further more, the problem of having two
genders can also somehow rooted from modernization. How? it is through the use of the
social media because according to Rev. Fr. Peter Carota, “Some people no longer believe in
sin and live their life immorally. Like, they wanted to legalize the same-sex marriage,
In addition to that, traditional Catholics believe that the heresies of the modernization,
secularism, and progressivism have caused all the problems in the Catholic church.
48
Gonzales
5.) Is the legalization of annulment and separation between married couples against the
no
47%
yes
53%
yes no
Textual Interpretation
Sixteen (16) respondents (53%) out of 30 respondents answered Yes and Fourteen (14)
If yes, why?
25%
31%
44%
marriage is a bind
Marriage covenant
promise
between
bybetween
a couple
man God
and
to serve
and
woman
man
and
and
and
love
they
woman
oneshould
another
not until
be separated
death anymore
Textual Interpretation
5 respondents (31%) answered that marriage is covenant between man and woman, 7
respondents (44%) answered that marriage is a bond between man in woman and they should
not be separated anymore, and 4 respondents (25%) out of 30 respondents answered that
If no, why?
21%
50%
29%
Textual Interpretation
7 respondents (50%) out of 30 respondents answered that annulment was being legalized by
the Catholic church, 4 respondents (29%)out of 30 respondents answered that only divorce is
against the Catholic church, and 3 respondents (21%) out of 30 respondents answered that it
Analysis
Most of the respondents said that the legalization of annulment and separation is
against the Catholic church because of these evidence “Based on the covenant of this
51
Gonzales
sacrament, it is said by Jesus Christ in Matthew Chapter 19 verse 4 that divorce should not
be practiced. For it is written in the scripture that “a man will leave his parents house to unite
with his wife. Although they are in forms of two flesh, if they unite they will become only
one flesh because God is the one who united them and no one to separate them.” (Christian
Thus, the legalization of annulment and separation is not against the Catholic beliefs
because it has been already being legalized by the Catholic church due to those who have
marriage problems and wanted to disregard the marriage. Either way it is still against the
Catholic beliefs because the couple that took the sacrament of matrimony although literally
6.) Do you agree that the uprising popular trends are the main cause of the decline of the
some it depends
how 10%
3%
yes
40%
no
47%
Textual Interpretation
Twelve (12) respondents (40%) out of 30 respondents answered Yes, Fourteen (14)
respondents (47%) out of 30 respondents answered No, Three (3) respondents (10%) out of
30 respondents answered It depends and Lastly, One (1) respondent (3%) out of 30
If yes, How?
14% 21%
29%
7% 29%
ItThecould
People
immoralpopular
attention
see
forget
acts
religious
trends
starts
ofabout
theappeal
topeople
life
worshipping
beaspracticed
mostly
something
are diverted
God
tobecause
sensual
medieval
andtofocus
materialism
itand
is and
starting
on
selfish
secularized
outdated
things
to be and
amentality
modern
focusestrend
on relativistic
ideas than absolute truth
Textual Interpretation
2 respondents (14%) out of 30 answered the popular trends appeal mostly to sensual and
selfish things and focuses on relativistic ideas than absolute truth, 4 respondents (29%)
answered it could forget God and focus on secularized mentality, 1 respondent (7%)
answered people see religious life as something medieval and outdated, 4 respondents (29%)
answered immoral acts starts to be practiced because it is starting to be a modern trend, and 2
respondents (14%) answered the attention of the people are diverted to materialism.
54
Gonzales
If no, How?
29% 14%
21%
36%
Some of the popular trends do not affect a person's way of living a religious life
It is just one of the reasons for the decline of practice of religious life
It depends on the person or a group of people who makes its cause
Not all people who are always in trend forgets God
Textual Interpretation
2 respondents (14%) out of 30 respondents answered some of the popular trends do not affect
a person’s way of living a religious life, 3 respondents (21%) answered it is just one of the
reasons for the decline of practice of religious life, 5 respondents (36%) answered it depends
on the person or group of people who makes it cause, and 4 respondents (29%) answered
Analysis
Wayne Jackson on the article “The Influence of the Modern Trends on the Church”agrees
’”The modern trends are one of the factors of the negative effect of societal
modernization towards Catholism. Nowadays, as we notice, our society has been being
conquered by modernity which also causes the church to be affected because even during
the ancient times, modernism had already evolved, which had also reflected the incline
towards the rejection of the propositional truth that is based on the divine authority. The
idea of Catholicism and Protestantism has become pervasive because of the heritage
Because not all in the internet are considered and proven to be true. If ever that there will
be a true and proven content in the social media maybe there will only be few that will be
found. For today, in the internet many are posting to spread fake news just to get
popularity: which is not good because it makes all its readers to believe on something
7.) Can modern technology (e.g social media) help the Catholic church to reach out the
some
how
14%
probably
10%
Yes
76%
Textual Interpretation
Twenty-two (22) respondents (76%) out of 30 answered Yes, Zero (0) respondents (0%)
answered No, Three (3) respondents (10%) out of 30 answered Probably and lastly, Four (4)
In what ways?
23%
41%
Textual Interpretation
practices and beliefs and teach Catechism to Catholics, 8 respondents (36%) out of 30
respondents answered to reach out those Catholics who do not attend mass through making
medias that contains Catechisms and teachings that is based on the Catholic doctrines and
beliefs, 5 respondents (23%) out of 30 respondents answered the Catholic church is not only
focus in spiritual in each approach holistic development but also focuses on temporal.
58
Gonzales
Analysis
Majority of the respondents said that modern technology can be helpful to reach out people
when it comes to their religious beliefs and ways of life. How? it is by using the modern
technology (specially the social media) to evangelize. Because most of the people nowadays
not only locally but on some parts of the world are on media.
Evangelizing on social media can help the Catholic church bring back those Catholics who
have ignored their religion and can somehow help the people in every parts of the world to
convert into the Catholic religion. Because most of the people nowadays not only locally but
on some parts of the world are on media. Evangelizing on social media can help the Catholic
church bring back those Catholics who have ignored their religion and can somehow help the
people in every parts of the world to convert into the Catholic religion. Although some will
just criticize nor disregard the post, then so he it. Because evangelization is not all about
forcing everyone to be converted, still it is their own choice.
We engage in verbal violence online because we can get away with it."
Social media may be the term used for websites that allow people to interact online, she
added, but "it doesn't seem social to someone on a screen in the privacy of their own room."
( Zsupan-Jerome, 2015)
59
Gonzales
8.) .) Do you consider gender identity crisis as a negative effects of technological and societal
modernization?
Somehow
30%
Yes
47%
No
23%
Yes No Somehow
Textual Interpretation
Fourteen (14) respondents (47%) out of 100 answered Yes, Seven (7) respondents (23%)
If yes, why?
8
6
4
2
0
ia
r
en
he
ed
tiz
ot
m
an
ne
in
e
by
n
on
ow
ce
te
sh
ita
en
g
in
flu
be
si
in
i
es
to
ich
go
ty
h
lo
sw
ci e
eo
so
ct
id
la
n
lse
er
ra
od
fa
o
m
m
e
th
e
si
ag
in
in
ur
ed
ta
co
ot
o n
en
ro
tc
Textual Interpretation
is
at
ha
th
is
t
r is
gy
i
ed
yc
lo
lm
no
tit
7 respondents (50%) answered Gender Identity Crisis is rooted in the false ideologies being
en
ch
ia
Id
te
oc
fs
er
n
er
shown in media, 3 respondents (21%) answered Influence of bad contents of social media
nd
od
ts
Ge
en
m
nt
that contains immoral acts which is imitated by netizens, 4 respondents (29%) answered
ug
co
ro
d
th
ba
le
influence of people through modern technology that encourage modern society to influence
of
op
ce
pe
en
of
flu
one another.
ce
in
en
flu
in
61
Gonzales
If no, why?
43%
57%
since in the past, before technologies evolved there are already people who are going
through gender identity crisis
It is a question of acceptance
Textual Interpretation
3 respondents (43%) answered since in the past and before technologies evolved, there aare
already people who are going through gender identity crisis and 4 respondents (57%)
Analysis
Majority of the respondents said that gender identity crisis is a form of the negative effects
of technological and societal modernization in such way that because of the influence of
media, some people were able to adapt the nature of homosexuality and making it as their life
style which specially prone to young millennials. Because they taught that expressing their
self being on a certain gender that is not man or woman is an act of being true to yourself.
62
Gonzales
Which is not. “Gender identity crisis is sometime the root of homosexuality. Some others call
it an “uncured illness” because it cannot be prevented by any medicine it is just coming to the
9.) .) Does the modernized technology influence a person's morality and how he/she lives her
religious life?
no
23%
yes
77%
yes no
Textual Interpretation
Twenty (20) respondents (67%) out of 30 respondents answered Yes and Ten (10)
Chart Title
100%
Influence of posts
Textual Interpretation
100%
Textual Interpretation
Analysis
integrably towards each of the actions moral meaning.” The practice of Catholicism
should be recognized in all ages. For basic Catholicism can be taught even to toodlers
for them to be familiar of the sect that they belong in. (Hurkheim, 2014).
Majority said that modern technology can influence a person’s morality simply
because many people who are into media are being influenced in such way that they were
able to adapt the culture of other people who have a different culture and traditions.
Thus, modern technology really affects the morality of a person because technology is very
vast and powerful when it comes on influencing people through different kinds of modern
technology.
67
Gonzales
10.) What do you think are the possible ways that can solve these issues?
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Series1
Textual Interpretation
Ten (10) respondents (33%) out of 100 answered that proper usage of modern
technology is a solution, Three (3) respondents (10%) answered that avoiding the
secularized mentality and practicing of religious life is a solution, Three (3) respondents
(10%) answered that studying the original Catholic beliefs is a solution , Five (5)
respondents (17%) out of 100 answered that the church should organize a way of reaching
out the young and adult Catholics which is through educating them of the negative
Analysis
These solutions indicated on the graph will surely help to solve the negative effects of
technological and societal modernization. Because these are the ones that lacks to lessen the
secularized mentality of contemporary people. Getting involved with modern technology and
societal trends is not that bad, it is just you have to not forgot about God because technology
Chapter 5
Introduction
This Chapter presents the concluscion and the recommendations being made by the
Concluscion
effect of modernization to the Catholic beliefs and to ways of life. Because based on the
results of the gathered data it shows the big percentage of answers related to the negative
effects of both technological and societal modernization towards the Catholic beliefs and
religious way of life. For it is already proven in the data results that the negative effects of
technological and societal modernity which also proves the researcher’s thesis statement that
“ The severe uprising of technological and societal modernity which includes different
popular societal trends and secularized mentality of the society have negative effects to
the Catholic beliefs and ways of living a religious life.” Thus, it is evident that
technological and societal modernization really affects a person’s belief towards religion and
social media many people either young or adult are being exposed to immoral acts that are
70
Gonzales
done by other people which influences their practice of morality which makes them to
neglect the practice of proper morality that is according to the Catholic beliefs and practices
being taught by the Catholic church. Lastly, modern technology and societal trends has a
great impact on the practice of religious life. For it is based on the data results which visibly
shows that societal and technological modernity hinders the practice of Catholicism if it is
being used improperly in which that you focus yourself on the modern technology and always
Recommendation
The researcher recommends that the Catholic church should use the modern
technology to do evangelization worldwide and they should teach the Catholics of the origin
of the Catholic doctrines, practices, and beliefs. Also, the researcher recommends that the
church should do physical evangelization through a bible study and values formation
conference for the contemporary people specially the Catholic ones to discuss to them the
proper usage of technology when it comes to religion and the negative effects of
technological and societal modernity to the Catholic beliefs and to religious way of life.
Furthermore, the resesrcher recommends that the church should be active not on
spiritual but also on technological aspect. In such way that they should make religious
organizations and post religion-based articles which can help the social media users to be
knowledgeable of the Catholic beliefs and on how to practice the religious way of life.
In addition to that, they can also make technological religious programs like making a
channel specialized for religious purposes which contains live coverage of holy masses and
Biblical foundation containing daily gospels and word of God to serve as a religious guide for
71
Gonzales
those elders and disabled people who are not capable of going to church to attend the holy
mass because of their illness and disability. Lastly, the researcher wants to recommend that
the church should make ways to reach out those who are lost and confused on their faith and
the Catholic people themselves as soon as possible should know on how to improve
themselves when it comes on their spiritual life through seeking God by doing self-study
about the word of God and through seeking spiritual guidance of the members of the clergy,
religious people, Christian Living educators and those who are expertise of the Catholicism.
72
Gonzales
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Banner, Michael. Christian Morality And Ethics. 1st ed., 2016, p. 170.
Business Insider. (2019). The pope just took another step to modernize the Catholic
Church. [online] Available at: https://www.businessinsider.com/the-pope-just-took-another-
step-to-modernize-the-catholic-church-2015-9 [Accessed 24 Oct. 2019].
The Catholic Primer, 2004, p. 6.Harrison, Brian. "The Society Of St. Pius X And Dissident
Traditionalism". Catholic Answers, 2014,
https://www.catholic.com/magazine/print-edition/the-society-of-st-pius-x-and-dissident-
traditionalism. Accessed 24 Oct 2019.
October 5, 2019
School Librarian
Biῆan Campus
Good Day!
Should you have any questions and for proper scheduling of my visit to your library,
Sincerely yours,
Noted by:
October 6, 2019
School Librarian
Good Day!
Should you have any questions and for proper scheduling of my visit to your library,
Sincerely yours,
Noted by:
October 4, 2019
Please excuse my daughter, Shaina Dyanne A. Gonzales for not being able to attend
on half of her Friday classes. She will be going to the library today in order to obtain needed
information in fulfillment of her thesis entitled “The Negative Effects of Technological and
Societal Modernization to the Catholic Beliefs and To Ways of Living a Religious Life.” On
their Chapter 2-Review of Related Literature.
Sincerely yours,
Sharon A. Gonzales
76
Gonzales
Hi! I am Shaina Dyanne A. Gonzales, a Grade 10 student from Seven Pillars Catholic School. I am
currently conducting my survey in completion of my thesis entitled “The Negative Effects of
Technological and Societal Modernization to the Catholic Beliefs and To Ways of Living a Religious
Life.” The goal of this thesis research is to spread awareness to parents and to young millennials of
the modern era of the negative effects of technological and societal modernization to the Catholic
beliefs and on ways of living a religious life. This survey questionnaire is STRICTLY FOR ACADEMIC
PURPOSES ONLY. Rest assured that any personal information (e.g name, age, gender, etc.) will be
STRICTLY CONFEDENTIAL and anonymous to anyone but me as I am the only one who is going to be
handling the information input into this survey questionnaire. Taking your time to answer these
questions truthfully and willingly would be very much appreciated. Thank you very much and have a
great day!
Name:
Age:
Address:
Religion:
1.) Do you think that the usage of modern technology affects a person’s beliefs towards
religion?
o YES
o NO
If yes, How/why?
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
____________
___________________________________________________________________________
___
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
2.) How often do you see some religion-based posts in social media which contain different
opinions of other people?
o Always
o Sometimes
o Seldomly
o Occasionally
o Never
Does it affect your insight and belief towards Catholic beliefs? How?/Why? Support your answer.
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
____________
3.) Is it recommended that all the Catholic people should be taught of the original Catholic
doctrines and beliefs?
o YES
o NO
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
____________
78
Gonzales
o YES
o NO
Do you think that it violates any of the traditional Catholic beliefs? Why/why not?
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
____________
5.) Is the legalization of Annulment and Separation between married couples against the
Catholic belief/s of the Catholic Church?
o YES
o NO
Why/Why not?
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
____________
79
Gonzales
How?
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
_______________
6.) Do you agree that the uprising popular trends are the main cause of the decline of the
practice of religious life?
o YES
o NO
o OTHERS:_______________(please specify)
How?
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
_______________
7.) Can modern technology (e.g social media) help the Catholic church to reach out the people
when it comes to their religious beliefs and ways of life?
o YES
o NO
o PROBABLY
o SOMEHOW
80
Gonzales
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
____________
8.) Do you consider gender identity crisis as a negative effect of technological and societal
modernization?
o YES
o NO
o SOMEHOW
Why?
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
____________
9.) Does the modernized technology influence a person’s morality and how a he/she lives
his/her religious life?
o YES
81
Gonzales
o NO
In what way/s?
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________
____________
10.) What do you think are the possible ways that can solve these issues?
o Study the original Catholic beliefs so that Catholic people will have a
knowledge about the origin of Catholic beliefs
o OTHERS:
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
________________________________________________________
____________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
82
Gonzales
___________________________________________________________________________
_________
Do you think it will be effective to solve the issues of the negative effects of technological
and societal modernization? Support your answer.
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
___________________________________________________________________________
_______________
Acknowledgement
84
Gonzales
Dedication
85
Gonzales
86
Gonzales