Childe 1923
Childe 1923
Childe 1923
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at http://www.jstor.org/page/
info/about/policies/terms.jsp
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content
in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship.
For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.
Wiley and Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve
and extend access to The Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute of Great Britain and Ireland.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
263
BY V. GORDON CHILDE.
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
264 V. GORDONCHILDE.-Schipenitz: a Late NeolithicStation
VOLHYNIA '
RZHISHCHEvX
KOO NAAKA
FIG o
- --
C, y
~~V~WCE., 0MN
NORDO p.AI1
W PODOI A
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPainted Potteryin Bukowina. 265
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
266 V. GORDON CHILDE.-Schipenitt: a Late NeolithicStation
2. a0
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Bukowina. 267
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
268 V. GORDON CHILDE.-Schipenitz: a Late NeolithicStation
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Bukowina. 269
arms of the spiralsare in black,but two broad red radii are added, and broad red
stripesset offthe borderribbons.
A similarfreeuse ofredis frequentat Bilcze Ztota,Wasylkowce,and Koszytowce.
At the firsttwo sites the main designsare oftenactuallyexecutedin red, the black
merelyservingas a framework(e.g. the spirals on the well-knownurn fromBilcze
figuredin Zbior Wiad., xviii, p. (23) ).
Forms.-The Schipenitzpotter'srepertoireof shapes was considerablebut not
unlimited,and to each formcorrespondsa restrictednumberof designswhichrecur
again and again with minorvariations. The designsmay in most cases be traced
to the lyingS spiralofErosd, CucuteniI, and Horodnica. The accompanyingfigures
willsufficientlyillustratethe formsand ornaments,whilea glanceat the comparisons
cited will show how closely the Schipenitzpotteryresemblesthat of other sites
within the area.
Form 1.-Fig. 3 and P1. XIV, 3. Conical dishes; average ratio of rimto base
diameters,34I: 1; diameterof largest specimen,4292 cms.; ornamentonly on
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
270 V. GORDON Station
CHILDE.-Schipenitz: a Late Neolith>ic
near Trembowla(Mat. a.-a., Fig. IOA), Bileze (Zb. W., xvi, P1. I, 2 - designiv at
Schipenitz),Wasylktowce(similardesigns,but with lugs on the belly,Zb. W., xiv,
P1. II, 3), Koszytowce(modifications of design iv), Petreny (with handles on the
belly) (P.K.S.R., P1. X, 8, reproducesour designsii and iii), Er6sd (Arch. Ert.,
xxxii, P1. I, 1, withreliefornament). The finespiralson the moreroundedvases,
\
0 ~~~~~/1
FIG. 5.-FORM 3, DESIGN I, IN BLACK AND RED ON FIG. 6.-FORM 3, DESIGN II, IN BLACK
WHITISH SLIP. I4. ON RED CLAY. 5.
fromBilcze implythat these are the older (Zb. W., xviii, p. (23), Fig. 15). All
the above preservethe characteristicdepressionround the neck.
Form 3'.-Pl. XIV, 1. Unique example; neckornamentedwithzigzag ribbons.
Form 4.-Fig. 10. Biconical urns; height always less than greatestwidth.
One specimenattains the heightof 64 cms., with a diameterof 65 cms., but large
I /
sizes are rare in this shape. With the exceptionof one example painted in style
of class c, all the vases of this shape are decoratedas in the illustration,but the
ribbonroundthe neck may be replacedby an animalfrieze. Parallels-Rzhishchev
(Zapiski, I.c., Pl. III, 7), Popudnia, Bilcze, Koszytowce,CucuteniII (Z.f.E., I.c.,
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Bukowina. 271
Fig. 3B), Petreny(P.K.S.R., PI. IX, 1). The designrecursat Bilcze (Zb. W.,xvi,
PIs. II, 4 III, 8, and IV, 1) and more degeneratedat Koszytowce(J.H.S., xlii,
PI. XIIB, Album,xv, 130).
face motive "-Popudnia, Bileze (Zb. W., xvi. P1. III, 2), Petreny (P.K.S.R.,
P1. VI, 6), allied formsfromTripolye B (Trudy,I.c., P1. XXV, row 2), Petreny
(P.K.S.R., P1. II, 1), Koszylowce (Album,xvii, 146).
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
272 V. GORDONCHILDE.-Schipenitz: a Late NeolithicStation
.- wo
FIG. 11.-FORM 4', DESIGN (i), IN BLACK AND RED ON FIG. 12.-FoRm 4', " FAcR,
ORANGE SLIP. 1 . MOTIVE."1-i7Z
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPainted Potteryin Bukowina. 273
I"
X - - - -h
J~Z ~
footedcrater(Pl. XV, 6) and that with ridgehandles on the shoulder(Fig. 15) are
exceptional. Parallels-Popudnia (withcognateornament),TripolyeB, and Petreny
(Fig. 17). The formappears already in Cucuteni I. The four-footed variant is
known in coarse ware fromZhukovtsy(Trudy, l.c., Fig. 72), Petreny (P.K.S.R.,
Pi. I, 7), Cucuteni(Z. f. E., I.c., Fig. 4A), and Koszylowce (Album,
vi, 42).
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
274 V. GORDON CHILDE.-Schipenitz: a Late NeolithicStation
panelling,and Oltszem in Transylvania(Arch. Ert., l.c., P1. III, 14). The form
seemsto go back to a roundertypefoundin CucuteniI (Fiihrerdurchdie staatlichen
Museenin Berlin,Vorgeschichtliche Abteilung, 1922,P1. V, row2, No. 1) and Horodnica
(Hadaczek, Album,xiv, 115). Similarroundedshapes withgood spiralsin red occur
at Wasylkowee. The cups withhandlesillustratedby Hadaczek, fromKoszytowee
(Album,xiii, 118 Hf.)are all miniatures6*5 cms. or less high.
Form7.-Pls. XIV, 2, and XV, 1. Soup-platelids. BeingornamerLted onlyon
the outside,these vesselscannothave been intendedforuse as dishes; on theother
hand,theirdecorationcorrespondsto that typicalof urnsof form3, and theirrims
fitexactlyin width and profileinto the depressionround the necks of such urns.
P1. XV, 3 showssuch a lid in place on an urn of identical pattern and technique.
Parallels-Zielenicze(Mat. a.-a., l.c.,Fig. 9E), Bileze (Zb. W., PI. III, 4), Koszytowee
(Album,xii, 92); both the latterwithdesignscorresponding to those of form3, and
so also the " Swedishhelmets" of Petreny(P.K.S.R., P1. VI, 9). The handleson the
lattermustbe broughtintoconnectionwiththesimilarhandleson thebodies of these
N~~~~~N I,'
I
I,
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Bukowinsa. 275
(Z. f. E., i.e., Fig. 2) and in Transylvania,where open ring stands are also found
(Arch. Ert., xxxii, P1. IV).
Form 9.-Fig. 21. Baths; maximumlength,44 cms.; the inside plan is a
flattenedoval, but the broad rimis contractedtowardsthe middleof the long sides
to a figure-eight outline; ornamentedonlyon the inside; fouirspecimensat Vienna.
'e ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-~
A -
~ _7
Form9'.-Fig. 22. Onlyin small sizes; thereare two handleson one long side
and one in the middle of the other.
WARE B.
Most ofthe above shapes are also metwithin plain warewhich,froma technical
poinitof view, is identicalwiththe precedingcategory. We have in additionthe
followingnew formswhichare not met in painted ware.
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
276 V. GORDONCHILDE.-Schipenitz: a Late NeolithicStation
FIG. 23.-THERIOMORPICVASE. -.
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Bukowirta. 277
Form B7.-Sieves. Only one of these was found. It is made of very hard
burnt red clay with walls 0-65 cm. thick. The walls curve outwardsfromthe
base very slightlyand are 8 cms. high. The bottom,whichis flat and perforated
with 40 holes about 0 5 cm. wide,has a diameterof 15 '75 cms.
FormB8.-Averycurious shape is shownin P1.XV, 10. The interiorand exterior
are very carefullypolished. In some examples the base is enlargedto a bulb-like
flattenedunderneathto allow the vessel to stand. In
knob, but is still sufficiently
view of the carefulfinishing of the innersurface,I am inclinedto regardthesevases
as drinkingcups. They range in heightfrom6 75 to 8 5 cms. Von Stern, on
P1. VI, 12,publisheswhatappearsto be an identicalshape,5 cms.high,fromPetreny.
Popudnia and Buczacz furnishexact parallels. They are all to be connectedwith
such groovedvases as Trudy,P1. XXVII, top row, a miniatureexample of which
comes fromCucuteniI.
Ware 0.-With the typicalwell-burntreddishware was founda small number
of sherdsof a very rude fabric,never painted,but sometimesadorned with rough
incisionsor impressions. This material is at once distinguishablefromeven the
It2 --f
t tt,11
110
coarsest sherdsof ware B. The clay is verycoarse and badly purified,and generally
mud colouror ash-grey; only once was it reddish. The surfaceis unpolishedand
pitted all over with grit holes till the sherdslook porous. They feel remarkably
light in the hands. The primitivedecorationsare shown on Pls. XVI, 3, and
XVII, m to o. So rarewas thisware at Schipenitz(thereare only fourwholevases
and less than fortysherdsat Vienna) that only threeshapes can be made out.
Form 1.-Deep cylindricalbeakers (P1. XV, 7). At the widestpoint are two
small lugs.
Form 2.-Wider cups with a slightlycontractedneck and out-turnedrim (cf.
Fig. 24).
Form 3.-Wide bowls (P1. XVI, 3). No completespecimensurvives,but this
shape also had lugs on the shoulder.
Now it is clear that none of these shapes has anythingto do with the charac-
teristicformsofwaresA or B, just as thetechniqueis utterlydifferent.Nevertheless,
thereis no reasonto doubt that the coarse ware belongsto the same stratigraphical
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
278 V. GORDON CHILDE.-Schipenitz: a Late NeolithicStation
context. An identicalfabrichas been foundat CucuteniII (Z. f. E., l.c., Fig. 4),
(PetrenyP.K.S.R., P1. I, 9, 13, 17), Bileze Ziota, on the Dniepr,and at othersites,
which have yielded potteryin every way parallel to that of Schipenitz. Fron
CucuteniII, I saw a sherdin Berlinof whichour P1. XVI, 3, mightperfectly well be
a photograph,and ourforms1 and 2 can also be paralleledfromthe same site. At
Petrenymost of our designsrecur. The completecup fromBilcze Ztota shown in
Zb. W.,xv, P1. V, 3, reproducedhere as Fig. 24, is in shape an exact replica of
our form2 and showsan analogousdesign. Two fragments illustratedby Khanenko
(op. cit.,P1. VI, 18 and 27) as from" Kiev and the environsof Tripolye" are clearly
relatedto ourforms3 and 2 respectively, whilesomeoftheincisedwarefromcultureB
in the same region,shown in P1. XXV of Trudy xi (especiallyrow 2), may very
likelybelong here.
Sherds of the same fabricwere observed by me, always in close connection
with the painted wares, in the recentexcavationsat Koszytowce. Ailio connects
./ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~N
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Bukowina. 279
The techniqueof this potteryis not very different fromthat of the standard
ware. The surfaceis eitherorange,as in the bowl of P1. XV, 4, or a deep, rather
brownishred,as in the sherdsof Fig. 26. In both cases the paint is applied directly
to the surfaceand the whole burnished. The two fragmentslast mentionedare of
coarserworkmanship. The clay is grittyand not burntevenlythroughout. The
largersherdseemsto belongto a bowl ofthe same shape as P1.XV, 4, butit has been
leftroughon the inside. I have seen a numberof sherdsidenticalin designand
technique fromHorodnica. Furtherparallels come fromTransylvania. A sherd
fromOltszemlprovidesan almostexact analogyto the ornamentation of our sherds.
MoreoverKaindl illustratesa fragmentof the handle of a ladle fromthe trench
in whichthe whitepainted ware was found,whichrecalls the well-knownseriesof
ladles fromPriesterhiugel.But these analogies are mnot sufficient to allow us to
inferthat this materialhas been importedfromacrossthe Carpathians. It is more
1 Arch.Ertesitd,
xxxii,p. 57, P1. III, 8. The whitespiralson a reddishgroundofFig. 25
recallthoseon a fruit-stand
fromErosd,ib., P1. II, 6.
VOL. LIII. U
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
280 V. GORDON CHILDE.-Schipenitz: a Late NeolithicStation
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Bukowina. 281
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
282 V. GORDON CHILDE.-Schipenitz: a Late NeolithicStation
Bileze Z ota and Koszylowce.3 But the animals depicted are differentat each
site.
In the sphereof the Bandkeramikcto the west,we have strayexamplesoftherio-
morphicornament-in fragmentswith plastic animals from Hungary.4 To the
east we have, of course,the great provinceof theriomorphic ornamentrepresented
at Susa, and, thoughin a differentmedium,the famoussilvervase of Maikop. The
rich animalplasticof theso-called" Arctic" culture,whichcameverynear our area,
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Buk7owina. 283
CL~~~~~
0-rP
C fO R2
MiscellaneousObjectsof Clay.
Weightsor Net Sinkers.-These were very common. Though only of rough
workmanship,they may be divided into several groups
A. Verticallypierced.
(a) Flat, 28 specimens: the largestmeasured11 ems. in diameterand was
4*3 cms. thick.
(b) Roughlyhemispherical : 8 specimens,the largestbeing10 cms.in diameter.
(c) Conoid ornamentedwith deep slashes roundthe edge.
1 in " Iranians and Greeksin SouthRussia " (Oxford,1922).
Cf. Prof.Rostovtseff
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
284 V. GORDON Station
CHILDE.-Schipenitz: a LateNeolithic
B. Horizontallypierced.
(a) Thick triangularlumps withthe hole near the top.
(b) Conoidwiththe hole at the top.
d 'e
FIG. 29.-FINT CHISEL, MINIATURE VASES, CLAY HORNS AND WHORLS. 2
of his Albumis a parallel type. But a close examinationof the Galician material
in the Polish museumshas convincedme that the shoe-last celt was only very
rarelyassociated with the painted pottery. The concave section of No. 51100 is
to be noted. The bored axe (Fig. 30a) had been brokenat the haft in antiquity,
and a commencement has been made on a new hole nearerthe blade. This axe, like
one fromCucuteniIL, wouldseemto belongto a groupassociatedwithDanubian II
potteryin Moravia and Silesia, and at Grossgartachand elsewherein South-West
Germany.
Flints.-The povertyof stone is counterbalancedby an exceptionalwealth in
flintartefacts. These are of a deep grey colour,and some of the blades attain a
greatlength. Some show fineretouching. Similarflintformsin the same material
are very commonin Galicia, and recurat Petrenyand Cucuteni. The materialis
plentifulin the whole region. Parallels to our arrow-headsmay be cited from
1 Z.f.E., I.C., Fig. 8, p. 591.
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Bukowina. 285
-, ~~~~~~~~~
c ==D t<
eU
FIG. 30.-STONE IMPLEMENTS.
Elaborate carving such as is exemplifiedby the pins and pendantsof Denev i'
Bulgaria,2is generallylacking. On the otherhand, Bilcze Ztota has yielded.some
moreadvanced work,includinga daggerimitatinga metalprototype.3
I Ibid., Fig. 10; Mitt.derprdh.Comm.,I.c., p. 367,Fig. 3.
2 Izv. Buly. Arch. Druzh.,iv, Figs. 202 and 204.
3 Hadaczek, Album,P1. VI, 27B.
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
286 V. GORDONCH1LDE.-Schipenitz:a Late NeolithicStation
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
withPaintedPotteryin Bukowina. 287
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
288 V. GORDON CHILDE.-Schipenitz: NeolithicStation withPaintedPottery.
kurgansof the Kuban valley' and again in the Fatyanovo gravesof the Oka-Volga
area,2the carefulstudy of their distributionmade by Kossinna and Koztowski3
favoursa north-southratherthan an east-westmovement. That this movement
was an invasionfromEast or CentralGermanydoes not,however,follow; the tombs
and amphoram may rathermerelymarka veryold ambertrade route. That is the
natural conclusionfromthe fact that, while such tombs in Galicia contain Baltic
amber,in Saxony and the Baltic lands they containalso Galician banded flint.4
In conclusion,I would like to express my thanks to the directorsof the
PrehistoricSection of the Naturhistorisches
Museumin Vienna forthe opportunity
afforded me of publishingthesevaluable documentsfromtheircollectionand forthe
assistancerenderedme in theirpreparation,to Hofrat Szombathyforinformation
on several points,and to the staffof the museumfortheirgenerousco-operation.
I am also indebted to the directorof the TowarystwoNaukowe, Warsaw, Prof.
Demietrikiewicz of Krakow,and Prof.Koztowskiof Lwow, forfacilitiesto studythe
MajewskiCollection,Warsaw,the collectionof the AkademijaUmietnosci,Krakow,
and that ofDzieduszyckiMuseum,Lwow,respectively at a timewhenthesebuildings
were closed to the public.
Fuller reports on the potteryand architectureof Er6sd will be found in
Dr. Ferencz Laszlo's articles in the Dolgozatokaz Erdelyi NernzetiMuzeunm
(Koloszvar)1911 and 1914), copies of whichI have just received by the courtesy
of theirauthor.
N.B.-
P.Z. Zeitschrift
Prahistorische (Berlin).
S MY A Suomen Muinaismuistoyhdistyksen Aikakauskirja (Finska Fornniinnes-
f6reningensTidskrift)
(Helsingfors).
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Journalof theRoyal Anthropological
Institute,Vol. LllI, 1923, PMlate
XIV.
i. "M
/ d d
i:
ls~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ;..
| -~~~~~4
.
l - - -~~~~~~~~
FIG 3-FR I DEIN .
FIG. 2.-FoRm 7. j.
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Journalof theRoyal Anthropological Vol. LIII, 1923, Plate X 1'.
Institu.te,
'->
4 4
FIG. 2.-4.
FIG. 5. -- FIG. 6.
FIG. 7.FIG., FIG. 8. 1s, FIG. 9. -1-. FIG. 10. 1; *
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
NHz~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~j ..lt-
td
04
0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
04
o
Hh - |
_5:
o H~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~*.
t ~~~~~~~I. 3...ER ..
:...':.............. ........... C. xT IG
H~~~~~~~~~FG .SEDO AEC - a
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
m
a
t_4
1
M
V a
"
-.. . .. . ... ....... ... ...
-: Vi .. .i:
,::.1,::&
l"-1-'&-'b !iXw;....
.li._
.-k.. %...:-12::M
.... ....:s;_- ili:::,,,!
-.""I . ,.111-11.:.:
,
N .."..".1'...".
I I-s .. -, I ... .. .... I .. .. .. - - "I '... . . .::.. . -.
. . .
. %--:....:..---:...:M-.::..%%%--:.%---.%-
1j:%:
. -.. .. .. : ::--:::
.......
. :.: ...
..:..
.. .... .N. .. N-- :%. . -- - - --- . - , . .
: .. ..
,, . , -. ".. ..--M.
. . NX ::....::.:ii:;..,..,..4i::i:".i:!..s;sz.
, , . ...-,. , _,: ..::: .: :.: - .. :1: :.."j'N..N:
M= ,.M ;:: ::.i:: ..
- :: , , " :. .
........
x- ...---m;
:::.:.., NI
-: :...-".:.
I.::% iFiMlii.l:i:iP. .:!.:l1:i:!-:::il::%::-
, iI ...: -:
.
4-11,snx.M:MN
.-- "MIM
, . t:ill"Rois_
,-
,lA
. .
:M 'E "', iNl
,I I
.-.,
,IiI
....
.. ..
,--,
M. ..l...M
::
......1 :,-.. . .: X, . .i.:::.4 1:: .
-X:, ..... -
-
--iil-",.!:liiii
- - .-N
-
- ;
I", .:.:::7:.::.:::".:%,:::::,.:::: N . .2:: . .: :.I: I;: .. , -11 - IN . .
.. -X ..j:;isiiiS.",;i?i:ii:i:,. I.. "... .1 ... ... .... .. . .. . N N -1:::% .::::: - ..:: -- .::::: ::%::
,:,l:.::ii:,.,j,..-..ig-,iiI
... :Z. xv..v lksff-!:I .... .r.,IOri!
: -M....
4
::: : ..
! ,%24,f
: ! X . .. ... .." . 11 - :::: .%
%::::-,:::. iih.',!Q7,,ll llill;::- ,
NX.-Im %X.:::f
::: 'I .. ...I :: ::
.1 %:
: iM i: : : :m illIr. ... ... .
_ ... :11::::
;... .-1". ! !..- ...., ::-- :-
..` . . ....%
.I.-
:X -:::--.:::M .:
..::
:::.! ...h:.:% : :'.:4 : : .. .f . ..: : : : :.... .::::4 ......
::. :: s-, .. -:.- ...., .1.... ". :-:-- :- :::: -::: %:.: : .: : ..
::'-':.----xvv-x:: .1...... 11.1.1...... .11.... . n.::: '%:::X! -- : N! N-:- :i: ,1 ..,:: I
.- -4:.:1.:= .:.:::: - . ::::: N. .::.,.::::: !.. I I..... . 4: . ::: :.: :..%::.. -:- X, ...: :::
I . .. . ....iX:: .... ::::- :.: :- %:4.::--:-:::X .mm..... ..... ... :-,::::- , I:
t- ,%%:::-,:::. .:.:- . .... .. . . ... ..%.4.. .:,
-::::4 .::X-X:::-
........... :-::: - .: ... ... - ... -%-::I ,x: ..% .. ... .. e....
."... - : .%.:..:
%:-4-.::...::.::" N. -::X::: . : .. . .... :-- - --:- ...
:.::: : .- N - .::E- -, iv :, ,,,
-:1 -X: . 's.,%i1s::l ::. .. - :..
.::: I NX '..
- -:X, .: ...
::::...- .. ..."%;jjj;r'.j .
.: X
;_
-
,:-:-
--:: . . ...
. ::
..::. -.....
....... .I..
.-:1:
............ .......
"...
.
.%--
- .....
:-0 ..... :-:.. ... -:44 . ..:;...... ..... :,f::. ..:i%i,Hi::.-
.. ... .- -::.:::,:..
H :.:% ...:::: .:....::::: . .::.
1-i:-"--
.,:.':ii
..; I ::: : .
.:::: ....j!'---,.!!!
.:...:::::::::`
.... :- "'
...... .:::::%-.:V--:
... -:::::-:::V- .::., -::- .::::, .:.::. .N. ... . :-:
:::,..:...:
.... ... . .7:.::::
.....
N .: . :::.......
.:. . ... .:: ---::.
. .
.-NN:.:::
-..::..%.;..- ....
M :i:
. ..
.. .. NN ..: -::
...:.
:.:.N ..... :---
.:::- :::%.:.::
...::
..::.%
t-d .. :.::
V::%:-: :4 NX::
. . ..: N ::.
:::......
::1-
... ..
N.... : ... :. ..::
..::. -v%
--:::
: ::: ":.:.: ::: -:::::: ..::
..:. ..:.:. %X:.: ...
N :::.::.%.
.:: :-
............ .: ...... ::: %. N .,:::: ::::X N
NNN :.
: : ::: .
. ..
....
::::.
.
.. " ......: .:.::. :. .. - ..: . - -
..:...
::::- .:. :- : ... .. ..: :. :::: . - .:..:::!:::: ::; - .. N . .: - :. .:
. .. . ..... ..... ..:.
:::::-
. . . .. .. . . - :-::- ...: ..:::. .. ...
.. . . :::::i::
.,::::. .:. - ! II..:. ii j:::::j i: --1.::%-M
%-- ,::-4.:--4: ... .., .. . .. .: .:. -::: ..::- .:.. . .. . : .. Y .:. ..
: .... :-- ... -. - .: . .
.. .
..
....: .-N
. .: .:::. .:::::: --:::
:::
:... -: ... . .::::
:::
0 . . . :-4N::-::N.y: '.. : :::
-:1
IL :
, ,,
-::
.
. ..
- -..
.. . .. .:
. '.%.::- :... - - -...
.I ...... 11... :" ::,. .:::
::: ... :-:X--X::- :::
11-1
- ....
......
.
.M...:. --::::X%.-. - :
"..", .1 ...I.........
.:: .., . . . . .. ... .,.:...
. ..: . : .
r-4
.:.:.%--::
....
: ..::
.: :::.:: . ...%. -
.-M- : ::i ..... . ........-
N". .. XX4,X:: ." ...........
1"..11
......
.
1%,:I .:: iifil. -,mil:
-::%
.:
..: . .:.:-
... .
. ..
. ... I .:-I
-::::- N .:..::::
: ... .. .:. %.:.
N. :.::,-: -iiiiifnili4i
ilj
: -X::V-4X::,. .
. ::::
..... .... . . .:. . : m.::: - .,:.:.::: ...:. i
::-: . .: :-
: -::--- -::- ... . N - : "N:-1::::I
.4 ..:: .:::
:::::::: `LN:%xN: .:x1",
-::...: N:,;z N .":: ... . .. .. .': .:: li
.::. - .: . . .. -. . . -.:. .. - ..::. : :--:- ..: :,::::::
:4 . . .:-- i:-:
N......... ..::.. :.::::: .:: . ... .. --:::'%::-',:-.:::: ... : :::,, ... . -X .. .. . ... .. .... ... 11 .
. :::. : N .:..::.:::-:.:..
. ........:...:.l:: ... :. .:
.. N::: -::N:, : :
.::. ::4 %. .,: :... %--- !:: 1111- I . I :- % ..:..% .. .
:-::- :-:-- N... ::::: ... . .. N . . ..:. .: -::.:%
.. N... ::--
- - . - : .:. %X: :. ,::.::
.. .... -::.:%:::
... . ........-:4:.:--.::M %:l-.:
X:--.:W4--%::: ::::- : , :::: :4.; :::: . ....
.:::: :. .... .. I..... . ...NX-X:- .
,.
::v :::: .-:::-%:
::X:::- . :.
:X :: :::::: N :;:.: : : : . - ..
............. :::... ...1.11"111"..".1 ... : :
,-:` .......I...... :".
...... ... ....
IP . !.....,iil;ii:::::-::::i-,:::
I.." ... :::::
: N ::%: :::
m : :. :u x:,
. ......11
... n: N 1. 'n 1. ::::. .:.. :.:: :::---:::::,-:::.. .. ...1-M-
.N:.
_...:
-N:114 - :.-.::::--
..".. .." .....I...... -::- .: :: '. XX::m .: : : N %N.., ... I--
... ..."I..,
- f : -:::f!l:..".".!;f!:
-..."11
. .... . :::..-
4.: ..:-X:
M.%
--. :--
-1
.N-11::::- -%%N: . :: ..
.. .1
-1...mw
...
.... I---... 11-111.
1-11-11.i
m.- : .. Xi
11.
a
I t::,::4:. -: .:::% :::-::.::--.:- :. .
...%::::s
.., .- . : --
P4 11
I.
.. ....I
.... ...... .... ......
,i::: .,::::- -:::::- :-:. .::.
,::%:..::. 1-:.,!::::
::::::
....I.... I "I',"..
. . ...........Nr
:- ,: : m
_ ::::: m: -1...- ..... : : ,
::-- - - ., ::: . .::.,., N:: I.,: :4:4X444:N
" -:::
.:.."'..:::: ::::::
. ""I .... . .. ,:. .s fe
.:::. 3Q:L.,p::,::-:--::-: .--:: ::::::-- ::: .:
X44
i m mi
0 -
..N.,
....: .. - - .
. .1 ". . ...,- 1-;-X
.
....
::::-
.... - ,
.. ::
: N N : N ..I
.%;!%
:::::: ..
; :N :'-
.:: i :N
m% i,q P , ..:,: -.1M - 11 : XN .:::: ::::. :::.:::::: -:X: : i::::
-::::.
:::.. : : N
..". :3 "I",. :4t :
::: :..."M .. ::..: ....H : .:
. .....'.. .N. . .. - -,-:
: : iX: X:`:.: :N :- N -X:::- .11 ::% - ,:::u XXW
.:: %.- :". .:::.
NX .1 .... :. -:: ::::: !: ::: :%. cz: 1-11-11.
.....
04 i: , . .1 . Al".1 w -
Is:::N.-,:::
..... .. :-
N.
: :
1. :.ii:L ....... :4444.N
""I 1 :Ca
N .. ...11.1:-::Nmmx::
N.
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
N~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~"
N .~~...
o~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~b
-~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~-
0~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I.Alf" Vi~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
H~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~....... ...... :7
H~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~FITATFCS
This content downloaded from 144.122.201.150 on Tue, 15 Dec 2015 08:00:09 UTC
All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions