Nothing Special   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

WS 3.6 Decision Analysis

Download as docx, pdf, or txt
Download as docx, pdf, or txt
You are on page 1of 2

QUANTITATIVE METHODS IN MANAGEMENT

WORKSHEET 3.6: DECISION ANALYSIS

Members:

1. The personnel department at C&H has narrowed the search for a prospective employee to 3 candidates:
Steve, Jane and Maisa. The final selection is based on 3 criteria: personal interview, experience and
references. The department uses matrix A as given to establish the preferences among the 3 criteria. After
interviewing the 3 candidates and compiling the data regarding their experiences and references, the matrices
AI, AE and AR are constructed. Which of the 3 candidates should be hired? Assess the inconsistency of the
data.

I E R S J M S J M S J M
I 1 2 1
4
S 1 3 4 S 1 13 2 S 1 12 1
A AI  AE  AR 
E 12 1 1
5
J 1
3
1 15 J 3 1 12 J 2 1 12
R 4 5 1 M 1
4 5 1 M 1
2 2 1 M 1 2 1

2. Farmer McCoy can plant either corn or soybean. The probabilities that the next harvest prices of these
commodities will go up, stay the same or go down are 0.25, 0.30 and 0.45, respectively. If the prices go up,
the corn crop will net $30,000 and the soybean will net $10,000. If the prices remain unchanged, McCoy will
barely breakeven. But if the prices go down, the corn and soybean crop will sustain losses of $35,000 and
$5,000 respectively. Which crop should McCoy plant?

3. You are the author of what promises to be a successful novel. You have the option to either publish the novel
yourself or use a publisher. The publisher is offering you $20,000 for signing the contract. If the novel is
successful, it will sell 200,000 copies. If it isn’t, it will sell only 10,000 copies. The publisher pays $1 royalty
per copy. A market survey by the publisher indicates that there is a 70% chance that the novel will be
successful. If, conversely, you publish the novel yourself, you will incur an initial cost of $90,000 for printing
and marketing, but each copy sold will net you $2. Suppose that you contracted a literary agent to conduct a
survey concerning the potential success of the novel. From past experience, the agent advises you that when
a novel is successful, the survey will predict the wrong outcome 20% of the time. When the novel is not
successful, the survey will give the correct prediction 85% of the time. Based on these, would you accept the
publisher’s offer?

Page 1 of 2
QUANTITATIVE METHODS IN MANAGEMENT

4. Hank is an intelligent student and usually makes good grades, provided that he has the chance to review the
course material the night before the test. For tomorrow’s test, Hank is faced with a small problem. His
fraternity brothers are having an all-night party in which he would like to participate. Hank has three options:
a1) party all night; a2) divide the night equally between studying and partying; a3) study all night. The
professor giving tomorrow’s exam is unpredictable, in the sense that the test can be easy (s1), moderate (s2)
or tough (s3). Depending on the toughness of the test and the amount of review Hank does, the test score
combinations found on the table can be anticipated. Recommend a course of action for Hank.

5. Determine the saddle-point solution, the associated pure strategies and the value of the game for the
following game. The payoffs are for player A.

6. Two companies promote two competing products. Each product currently controls 50% of the market.
Because of recent improvements in the two products, each company is preparing to launch an advertisement
campaign. If neither company advertises equal market shares will continue. If either company launches a
stronger campaign, the other is certain to lose a proportional percentage of its customers. A survey of the
market shows that 50% of potential customers can be reached through television, 30% through newspapers
and 20% through radio. Formulate the problem as a two-person zero-sum game and select the appropriate
advertisement media for each of the companies.

Page 2 of 2

You might also like