PRAHAAR International Relations
PRAHAAR International Relations
PRAHAAR International Relations
com
p
RAHAAR
The final hit to UPSC Exam
Comprehensive, Integrated and Current Linked Notes for CSE Mains 2021
GS PAPER - II
INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS
ONE
STOP
SOLUTION
+91-7007-931-912
Google it:- https://upscpdf.com
https://upscpdf.com << Download From >> https://upscpdf.com
PREFACE
Dear aspirants, OnlyIAS team is ecstatic to present this book to you, which is certainly
going to be your best companion in your prepration.
This book has been designed by considering the issues and challenges students face
during mains preparation. While preparing this book, our team was aiming to solve as much
problems as possible. For example, students are many a times so confused about what to study
and what not, which news is relevant and which news is to be ignored, how much in depth we
should go for any topic, what kind of questions UPSC asks from particular topic, how to link
static with current etc.
This book is an honest attempt to solve these problems and to help students perform
better in exam, save time in preparation and get rid of various confusions which they basically
come across.
Right from the number of pages, to what topic to be covered, our team has done
research on every aspect to make it the finest version of itself. Covering everything comes with
a limitation of retention power, relevancy, possibility of revision, too many pages which makes
it beyond bulky and ultimately lot of time consumption of students for not so important things
adding to that a kind of distracted paths.
This book is an attempt to make your preparation to the point, relevant, based on UPSC
ongoing trend and pattern, revision friendly, and most updated.
OnlyIAS team wish you all the best for your preparation with all humility and
humbleness and we are hopeful that this book will do wonders for you. Keep reading.
Note: Although our team has tried best, yet if any important issue we found
which needs updating we will do the same and current issues of last few months
will be updated and a supplementary of few issues will be compiled and will be
released soon.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 1
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 2
INDIA-RUSSIA....................................................................................................................................................................... 59
AREAS OF COOPERATION ............................................................................................................................................................... 59
ISSUES IN RELATIONSHIP ................................................................................................................................................................. 60
RUSSIA-CHINA-PAKISTAN AXIS- ........................................................................................................................................... 60
US -RUSSIA TENSIONS-......................................................................................................................................................... 60
IMPLICATIONS FOR INDIA AND THE WORLD ....................................................................................................................... 61
INDIA-CHINA RELATIONS ..................................................................................................................................................... 63
INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................................................................................................ 63
AREAS OF RELATIONSHIP ......................................................................................................................................................... 63
Convergence: ....................................................................................................................................................................... 63
Divergence: .......................................................................................................................................................................... 63
India-China Cooperation ...................................................................................................................................................... 64
ISSUES IN NEWS ....................................................................................................................................................................... 64
India China Border Standoff................................................................................................................................................. 64
Why in News ........................................................................................................................................................................ 64
Reasons for Chinese Aggression .......................................................................................................................................................... 65
India’s Concerns .................................................................................................................................................................................. 65
Five Point Plan to De-escalate LAC Stand-off ...................................................................................................................................... 65
India’s Response to Chinese Aggression ............................................................................................................................................. 65
What is Line of Actual Control ? .......................................................................................................................................................... 66
China has Crossed its 1960’s LAC Claims ............................................................................................................................. 66
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 3
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 4
Indo-Pacific:......................................................................................................................................................................................... 83
Connectivity: ....................................................................................................................................................................................... 83
Partnership at Multilateral forums:..................................................................................................................................................... 84
Environment:....................................................................................................................................................................................... 84
Economic ............................................................................................................................................................................................. 84
Defence: .............................................................................................................................................................................................. 84
Space cooperation: ............................................................................................................................................................................. 85
Bilateral Partnership: .......................................................................................................................................................................... 85
Supply Chain Resilience Initiative(SCRI): ............................................................................................................................................. 85
Agreements: ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 85
Issues in relationship: .......................................................................................................................................................... 86
Osaka declaration:............................................................................................................................................................................... 86
Indo-Pacific:......................................................................................................................................................................................... 86
Significance of relationship for India: .................................................................................................................................. 86
Collaboration At UNSC: ........................................................................................................................................................ 86
CURRENT DIMENSIONS: ................................................................................................................................................................. 87
India-Japan ink mutual military logistics agreement ........................................................................................................... 87
Significance: ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 87
Japan-India Foreign Ministers’ Strategic Dialogue .............................................................................................................. 88
Japan Provides Loan to India ............................................................................................................................................... 88
Significance: ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 88
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 5
ISSUES- ...............................................................................................................................................................................101
ABRAHAM ACCORD .....................................................................................................................................................................102
WEST ASIA PEACE CONFERENCE ....................................................................................................................................................102
DJIBOUTI CODE OF CONDUCT ........................................................................................................................................................103
GULF COOPERATION COUNCIL AND INDIA .......................................................................................................................................103
IMPORTANCE OF GCC- .......................................................................................................................................................103
RECENT GOVERNMENT STEPS TO STRENGTHEN THE RELATIONSHIP- ..............................................................................104
CHALLENGES- .....................................................................................................................................................................104
INDIA AND CENTRAL ASIA .................................................................................................................................................. 105
Historical Ties : ...................................................................................................................................................................105
India and central Asia ties :................................................................................................................................................105
Importance of region : .......................................................................................................................................................105
Chabahar port :..................................................................................................................................................................107
IN NEWS....................................................................................................................................................................................107
Connect Central Asia Policy : .............................................................................................................................................107
INDIA AND UZBEKISTAN................................................................................................................................................................108
Key Points ..........................................................................................................................................................................108
Challenges..........................................................................................................................................................................109
CONFLICT BETWEEN NAGORNO-KARABAKH ...................................................................................................................................... 109
New Peace deal .................................................................................................................................................................110
INDIA AND AUSTRALIA....................................................................................................................................................... 111
Areas Of Cooperation : ......................................................................................................................................................111
Economic Ties :.................................................................................................................................................................................. 111
Covid-19 ............................................................................................................................................................................................ 112
Defence Relations : ........................................................................................................................................................................... 112
The QUAD : ........................................................................................................................................................................................ 112
Civil Nuclear Cooperation : ................................................................................................................................................................ 112
Co-operation at multilateral fora. ..................................................................................................................................................... 112
Indian Diaspora : ............................................................................................................................................................................... 113
Areas Of Convergence :......................................................................................................................................................113
Areas Of Concerns :............................................................................................................................................................113
ISSUE IN NEWS............................................................................................................................................................................114
India Australia First Virtual Meet :.....................................................................................................................................114
Australia to be included in Malabar Exercise: ...................................................................................................................114
Uranium Supply from Australia .........................................................................................................................................114
EFFECT OF POLICIES ON INDIA'S INTERESTS ....................................................................................................................... 116
Previous Year Questions on this topic ................................................................................................................................116
EFFECT OF POLICIES ON INDIA'S INTERESTS ....................................................................................................................... 117
E-DIPLOMACY.........................................................................................................................................................................117
Benefits of E-diploamcy .....................................................................................................................................................117
Concerns regarding e diplomacy .......................................................................................................................................117
RISE OF THE MINILATERALISM ...............................................................................................................................................118
Advantages of minilateralism ............................................................................................................................................118
Concerns over minilaterals ................................................................................................................................................118
INDIA’S VACCINE DIPLOMACY- VACCINE MAITRI PROGRAMME....................................................................................................118
POSITIVES...........................................................................................................................................................................119
CONCERNS .........................................................................................................................................................................119
SUPPLY CHAIN RESILIENCE INITIATIVE....................................................................................................................................119
GEOPOLITICS OF TECHNOLOGY .......................................................................................................................................... 120
HOW TECHNOLOGY CAN FOSTER GEOPOLITICAL COOPERATION? ...................................................................................120
CONCERNS- ........................................................................................................................................................................120
ISSUES IN INDIA W.R.T TECHNOLOGY ................................................................................................................................121
TECH COLD WAR BETWEEN USA AND CHINA ..................................................................................................................... 121
DATA FREE FLOW WITH TRUST...............................................................................................................................................121
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 6
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 7
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 8
PYQ
1. ‘China is using its economic relations and positive trade surplus as tools to develop potential military
power status in Asia’, In the light of this statement, discuss its impact on India as her neighbor. 2013
2. Project `Mausam’ is considered a unique foreign policy initiative of the Indian Government to improve
relationship with its neighbors. Does the project have a strategic dimension? Discuss. (2015)
3. What do you understand by ‘The String of Pearls’? How does it impact India? Briefly outline the steps
taken by India to counter this. (2013)
4. What is meant by Gujral doctrine? Does it have any relevance today? Discuss. (2013)
INTRODUCTION-
• The South Asian region, which is home to eight countries, and the Indian Ocean region (maritime Indian Ocean
region; mostly Western Indian Ocean) comes under the broad geographic expanse of India’s neighbourhood.
• India, being the largest country in terms of size, population and economy is the preponderant regional power.
However, India’s foreign policy engagements with its neighbourhood is an active topic of debate now, especially
in the context of “territorial disputes” with China and Nepal.
VIEWS-
• Muchkund Dubey- Multiple factors shape neighbours’ perception of India- huge asymmetry in size, land,
water and other disputes and India’s involvement in their domestic politics. India couldn’t establish itself as
a benevolent neighbour.
• M.K. Narayanan- If India is not seen to be actively involved in ensuring that the region is at peace and is
functioning in conformity with its worldview then any claim of global leadership will be nothing more than
treading water.
• Constiantino Xavier- Disconnectivity remains the default state of affairs between India and its neighbours.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 9
o The ‘family approach’ propagated the idea of ‘part of one’ theory. Because of British legacy the focus
during the Nehruvian era was primarily on security aspects and not much on economic dimensions
such as building developmental projects etc.
• GUJARAL DOCTRINE- In the post-Cold War period, which began in the 1990s, India set out to refashion its
foreign policy premises on non-alignment, its relations with Western bloc countries, regionalism and so on,
which in turn had a huge impact on India’s neighbourhood/regional policies.
o The Gujaral doctrine was based on the principle of Panchsheel and Non-Reciprocity. It called for
greater investment in the region without expecting reciprocity as it was felt that India being a larger
and more developed country in all the aspects should shoulder larger responsibilities.
o The present policy of Neighbourhood First is based on similar premises.
• MANMOHAN DOCTRINE- It was focused on creating Economic Interdependence through enhanced trade
relations and regional integration. However due to coalition politics, India’s relations with Bangladesh and
Sri Lanka deteriorated.
WAY FORWARD-
• BORDER SECURITY- Strengthening border security to control smuggling, illegal migration and terrorist infiltration.
• Dialogue- India should engage constructively and generously with its smaller neighbours like Nepal to deal with
the border issues.
• POLICY CONSENSUS- Broader policy consensus at domestic levels needs to be developed in order to maintain
continuity in border negotiations and consistency in India’s position.
• BUILDING REGIONAL ARCHITECTURE- Due to huge asymmetry in power equations, neighbours accuse India of
Big Brotherly Attitude. A regional architecture on the lines of SAARC can be established to device broader
principles for border negotiations.
• TRACK 2 DIPLOMACY- can be used to find innovative solutions on border disputes.
RIVER DISPUTES-
• In 2016, UNEP claimed that by 2030 almost ‘half of the world’s population will suffer from severe water
stress’. In this context river disputes will determine India’s riparian relations with its neighbours: Pakistan,
China, Bangladesh, Nepal and Bhutan.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 10
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 11
TRADE BARRIERS
• South Asia is one of the most poorly integrated region due to multiple factors. The intra-regional trade
among South Asian economies is lowest in the world at 5.6% (2017) of their total global trade.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 12
• Adopting Global Best Practices- Good practices from other regions must be tailored to the South Asian context
to facilitate the resolution of reported barriers to trade.
o For instance, Sub-Saharan Africa has addressed NTBs by way of an online mechanism that consists of
national monitoring committees in each country to facilitate the resolution of reported trade barriers.
o Stronger political will is required to combat barriers to trade in the region, especially after the COVID-19
crisis which may result in unleashing a new wave of protectionist measures.
CONCLUSION-
• Enhancing trade in the South Asian region is not only economically beneficial, it is also strategically important in
order to integrate India with the global economy.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 13
• CHINA CARD FOR NEIGHBOUR- Increased Chinese presence also provides neighbour countries to strike a hard
bargain with India.
• SECURITY CONCERNS- The recent clashes in Galwan Valley highlight China’s Salami Slicing Policy in work.
• CHINESE INTERFERENCE IN DOMESTIC POLITICS- Of countries like Nepal and Sri Lanka has resulted in strained
relationship with India.
• TRADE
o Over the past decade, China has replaced India as the major trading partner of several South Asian
countries.
o Only Afghanistan, Bhutan, and Nepal have a higher trade share with India compared to China.
o China’s exports to the region has increased from $8 billion in 2005 to $52 billion in 2018.
o China has committed around $100 billion investment in the economies of Afghanistan, Bangladesh, the
Maldives, Pakistan, Nepal and Sri Lanka.
• CHINA-PAKISTAN ALL WEATHER FRIENDSHIP- As seen in CPEC project, China is stalling India’s effort in UNSC to
list Masood Azhar as terrorist and Raising Kashmir issue.
• DEBT TRAP DIPLOMACY- As seen in Sri Lanka where China has acquired Hambantota port on lease for 99 years.
WAY FORWARD
• NEIGHBOURHOOD FIRST- Giving diplomatic and political priority to the neighbourhood. India can adopt principle
of Gujaral Doctrine i.e. Non-Reciprocity.
• LEVERAGING QUAD AND OTHER MINILATERALS- Joint implementation of projects with QUAD countries to
improve connectivity in the region.
• FAST COMPLETION OF PROJECTS- Like hydropower projects in Nepal, Bhutan, Kaladan Multimodal project etc.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 14
• SOLVING BOUNDARY AND RIVER WATER DISPUTES- to reduce the trust deficit among countries.
• REVIVING SAARC -to provide platform for cooperation and discussion and fastening regional integration
TERRORISM
THREAT
• STATE SPONSORED TERROSISM BY PAKISTAN
o ISIS has presence in Maldives, Sri Lanka as well as in India. The Easter bombings in Sri Lanka highlight
the threat posed by it.
o Poor border infrastructure along borders. For ex- Borders along Nepal, Bangladesh are used by
terrorists for infiltration.
IMPACT-
• POOR REGIONAL INTEGRATION
• TRUST DEFICIT between countries due to boundary disputes and other conflicts,
• LOW LEVELS OF TRADE AND ECONOMIC INTERDEPENDENCE
• FEAR OF NUCLEAR WAR between India and Pakistan.
• Impact on India’s global image and status as a rising power.
WAY FORWARD-
• SAARC - SAARC FORCE with contribution from all countries to conduct coordinated action against terrorists.
• STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP AND INTELLIGENCE SHARING with armed forces of other countries. It can be based
on the RATS mechanism of SCO.
• JOINT MILITARY EXERCISES to enhance interoperability between armed forces and protecting against
traditional and non-traditional threats in Indian ocean region.
REGIONAL ORGANISATIONS
IMPORTANCE
• PLATFORM FOR DISCUSSION to solve disputes between countries.
• REGIONAL COOPERATION on critical issues such as Blue economy, FTA in trade and investment etc
• REGIONAL INTEGRATION- Through enhanced trade and reduced trust deficit
• PEACE AND PROSPERITY
• COMMON POLICY ON GLOBAL PLATFORMS such as WTO, UN. Support from neighbouring countries is critical
for India’s ambition of a permanent seat of UNSC.
• DEVELOPING REGIONAL SECURITY ARCHITECTURE by building border infrastructure and joint patrolling in
Indian Ocean Region. India can help other countries in capacity building through SAARC.
• REASONS FOR INEFFECTIVENESS- (covered above in trade barriers)
WAY FORWARD-
• LEARNING FROM ASEAN -importance of continuing discussion and negotiations. For Ex- despite being under
Military rule, ASEAN countries still engaged with Myanmar.
• ALTERNATIVE ARRANGEMENT- BIMSTEC can be a new SAARC MINUS PAK.
• LEADERSHIP BY INDIA by putting more resources in Organisations like BIMSTEC and providing concessions
to neighbours and helping them in capacity building in sectors such as Health, Education, disaster
management etc.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 15
CONCLUSION-
As pointed out by former PM Vajpayee, we can change history but not geography, we can change our neighbours
but not our neighbours. So, India needs to give diplomatic priority to build peaceful and stable relations with
neighbours and work for creating a security community in South Asia based on mutual trust.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 16
INDIA – PAKISTAN
PYQ
1. Terrorist activities and mutual distrust have clouded India-Pakistan relations. To what extent the use of
soft power like sports and cultural exchanges could help generate goodwill between the two countries?
Discuss with suitable examples.2015
Introduction-
• Pakistan represents the biggest foreign policy challenge to India and is source of all sorts of threats, from nuclear
war to proxy wars.
VIEWS-
• Stephen P. Cohen- ‘Shooting for the century’: It is a paired minority conflict and has reached mutually hurting
stalemate where India can’t win and Pakistan can't lose. The other examples of such rivalries are Jews-Arab,
Shia-Sunni.
• Rajesh Basrur- The fundamental contradictions are India’s status quoist approach on Kashmir and Pakistan’s
determination to change it.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 17
Other issues
• ASYMMETRIC BALANCING- Pakistan uses terrorism as means to destabilise Kashmir. Many terrorist launch pads
have been established in PoK along Kashmir border to infiltrate terrorists into India.
• TRADE- Political tensions have also impacted trade relations between India and Pakistan.
▪ Intra-regional trade- accounts for a little more than 5 percent of South Asia’s total trade while it accounts
for 50 percent of total trade in East Asia and the Pacific and 22 percent in Sub-Saharan Africa. SAARC and
SAFTA are also ineffective due to the conflictual relations between two.
▪ After the Pulwama terror attack in February 2019, India withdrew the non-discriminatory market status it
had unilaterally granted Pakistan in 1996, popularly known as Most Favoured Nation, and imposed a
customs duty of 200% on all goods originating from Pakistan.
▪ India also suspended cross-LoC trade in April 2019 on receiving reports that these routes were being
misused by Pakistan-based elements for funnelling illegal weapons, narcotics and fake currency.
CHINA PAKISTAN ALL WEATHER FRIENDSHIP-
▪ Recent India-China border standoff in Ladakh Region have increased possibility of 2 front war on North-
western and North-Eastern borders.
▪ Strategic encirclement: China is also using Pakistan for strategic encirclement of India through CPEC and
Gwadar port.
▪ China-Pakistan-Iran-Russia axis: The emerging China-Pakistan-Iran-Russia axis can endanger India’s
security on Northern borders as well as in Indian ocean.
▪ China has raised J&K issue in UNSC for third time since 2019.
AFGHANISTAN-
▪ Pashtun Nationalism: Due to fear of 2 front war and Pashtun Nationalism, Pakistan seek strategic depth in
Afghanistan. Thus, it is opposed to any Indian involvement in Afghanistan.
▪ Links with Haqqani faction: ISI has deep links with Haqqani faction of Taliban which can be used to
endanger India’s investments in Afghanistan.
▪ US withdraw: Pakistan can also recruit Taliban fighters for destabilising Kashmir once US forces withdraw
from Afghanistan.
• OPPOSITION TO INDIA’S UNSC SEAT CLAIM- Pakistan has formed coffee club to oppose permanent seat for India
at UNSC.
• CEASEFIRE AGREEMENT- Pakistani forces have violated the ceasefire 5,100 times in 2020 with an average of 14
cases daily. In these ceasefire violations, 36 people including 24 security personnel were killed and 130 injured.
• Gilgit-Baltistan was part of the formerly princely state of Jammu and Kashmir illegally occupied by Pakistan
since it invaded the region after the partition of India.
• China Pakistan Economic Corridor passes through the region.
• It will bring the region directly under control of federal government of Pakistan
• India’s response- India considers it as an integral part of India by virtue of its fully legal and irrevocable
accession”.
RECENT NEWS-
Pakistan’s New Map-
• Pakistan has unveiled a new map that shows Kashmir as part of Pakistan. It includes the UT of J&K and Sir
Creek as part of Pakistan
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 18
• India’s objections- India has objected to new map of Pakistan and held that it has neither legal validity nor
international credibility.
• However, it also presents opportunity to India as whole Kashmir has been shown as a single entity including
Gilgit Baltistan. Thus, strengthening India’s position. This gives opportunity to India to include the Gilgit
Baltistan issue in Kashmir Talks.
Azad Pattan:
• PoK Hydel Project-Pakistan and China signed an agreement for
the 700 MW Azad Pattan hydel power project, worth $1.5
billion, on the Jhelum river in Pakistan Occupied Kashmir (PoK).
• It is the second power project under the China Pakistan
Economic Corridor (CPEC). The first agreement was for the
1,100 MW Kohala project on Jhelum river.
• India has protested the construction of dams and other
infrastructure in PoK and Gilgit Baltistan, which are territories
claimed by India as part of Jammu & Kashmir.
J&K Issue Raised at UNSC-
• China has raised J&K issue in UNSC for third time since 2019.
• It was raised under “any other business” in the meeting.
• China called India’s move in J&K “illegal and invalid”, India responded by saying that Beijing has “no locus
standi” on the matter.
• Internationalisation of Kashmir: This highlight Pakistan’s attempt to Internationalise the Kashmir issue.
However, as per Shimla Agreement of 1971, Kashmir issue is bilateral issue.
Ceasefire Along Line of Control
• After hotline contact between Director Generals of Military Operations (DGMOs) of India and Pakistan, both
countries have agreed to strictly observe ceasefire agreement along the Line of Control (LoC).
• Reduce infiltration: This can reduce infiltration attempts and terrorist incidents. It can help in reducing trust
deficit between 2 countries and can normalise the relations.
• Reduce radicalisation: This can further reduce radicalisation and recruitment of local youth.
• Narcotics still remains the concern: Indian Army chief has pointed out that though ceasefire agreement has
reduced violence along LoC yet Pakistan has yet not dismantled terror infrastructure along LoC and
smuggling of weapons and narcotics still remains the concern.
Basmati Rice Issue
• Net exporter: Both India and Pakistan are net exporters of Basmati Rice.
• Exclusive trademark : Recently, India has applied for an exclusive trademark that would grant it sole
ownership of the basmati title in the European Union.
• Pakistan opposed India's move to gain Protected Geographical Indication (PGI) from the European
Commission.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 19
• For the complete rights: India conceded its upper riparian position on the western rivers for the complete
rights on the eastern rivers as it was vital to get the waters of the ‘eastern rivers’ for the proposed Rajasthan
canal and the Bhakra Dam without which both Punjab and Rajasthan would be left dry, severely hampering
India’s food production.
ISSUES-
• Pakistan has objected to Indian projects on Western Rivers Jhelum and Chenab.
• Resentment in India: There is also resentment in India as it conceded 80% of water to Pakistan and there is
demand to revise the treaty.
• Article XII of the IWT says that it “may from time to time be modified” but it required ratification from both
countries.
WAY FORWARD-
• Permissible storage capacity: Utilise 3.6 million-acre feet (MAF) of “permissible storage capacity” granted by
the IWT on the western rivers.
• Tapping on hydroelectricity- out of the total estimated capacity of 11406 MW electricity that can be
harnessed from the three western rivers in Kashmir, only 3034 MW has been tapped so far.
India’s projects on western rivers-
WAY FORWARD-
• Continuing dialogue- While sticking to its redlines on terrorism and Kashmir, India should work towards building
on the ceasefire pact and resuming a more comprehensive dialogue.
• Enhancing Trade Relations- Recently, Pakistan allowed limited imports of sugar, cotton, and wheat from India.
Both countries can build on this to normalise trade along the border.
• Confidence Building Measures like prisoner exchanges, sporting visas etc can go long way to reduce trust deficit
between 2 countries.
• Backchannel Diplomacy through civil society and industry bodies and third-party counties like Saudi Arabia and
UAE can compensate for diplomatic standoff.
• Soft Power Diplomacy like PM Modi’s greetings letter on Pakistan day, hydro diplomacy on Indus water sharing
and cricket diplomacy can have spill over effect on creating comprehensive and sustainable conflict resolution
mechanism.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 20
INDIA – BANGLADESH-
PYQ
1. The protests in Shahbag Square in Dhaka in Bangladesh reveal a fundamental split in society between the
nationalists and Islamic forces. What is its significance for India? (2013)
Introduction
Bangladesh, given its strategic location, political stability and spectacular economic growth in the past few years, has
emerged as the ideal partner for India. New Delhi’s proactive engagement with Dhaka also reflects a broader shift in
India’s foreign policy, as it increasingly focuses its attention eastward, toward the Bay of Bengal and the Indo-Pacific
region.
Highlighting the importance of the relationship, Foreign Minister Subrahmanyam Jaishankar stated that India and
Bangladesh have the potential to change “the whole geo-economics of the region.”
Recent context
• The Prime Minister Narendra Modi visited Bangladesh to commemorate the 50th anniversary of the war of
liberation and establishment of bilateral diplomatic ties between India and Bangladesh and the centenary
year of Sheikh Mujibur Rahman.
• During the virtual summit both countries also signed 7 key agreements covering important areas like Rail
Connectivity, hydrocarbons etc.
MILITARY COOPERATION
• The armed forces from both sides regularly conduct joint drills like exercise sampriti and Milan. India has
extended $500 million line of credit to Bangladesh for defence imports from India.
TRADE RELATIONS
• Bangladesh is India’s largest trading partner in South Asia.
• India’s exports to Bangladesh in FY 2018-19 stood at $9.21 billion and imports during the same period was
at $1.04 billion.
• India has also granted the Duty-Free and Quota Free access to Bangladeshi exports to India under South
Asian Free Trade Area (SAFTA) since 2011.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 21
ENERGY COOPERATION
• India exports electricity to Bangladesh and India-Russia are jointly developing Rooppur Atomic Power Plant
in Bangladesh.
Connectivity
• Under the transit agreement between India
and Bangladesh signed in 2010, Bangladesh
provides transit facilities to India on three
modes of transport: inland water, rail, and
coastal shipping.
• Once finalized, the Bangladesh-Bhutan-Nepal-
India (BBIN) Motor Vehicle Agreement, which
has already been piloted, will add a fourth
mode to the existing facilities.
• India-Bangladesh inland waterway route: The
route connects Tripura with the National
Waterways of India through Bangladesh. A trial
run of an inland waterways protocol route was completed with a cargo vessel leaving for Sonamura port in
Tripura from Munshiganj in the neighbouring country.
• Protocol on Inland Water Transit and Trade (PIWTT)- Under the renewed Protocol on Inland Water Transit
and Trade (PIWTT) between Bangladesh and India, there are ten water routes, known as Indo Bangladesh
Protocol (IBP) routes.
● RAIL CONNECTIVITY- Currently, four railway routes are operational between Bangladesh and India AND three
railway routes are under construction.
● During the recent virtual summit, PM of both countries jointly inaugurated newly restored railway link
between Haldibari and Chilahati.
● COASTAL SHIPPING- Bangladesh and India signed a coastal shipping agreement back in 2018 which
allows India to use the Chattogram and Mongla ports for transporting goods to the states of Tripura, Assam,
and Meghalaya. There are no transit fees or customs duties for India under the agreement. Indian cargoes
just need to pay administrative fees to Bangladesh.
● India’s NE development and connectivity: Bangladesh has also recently granted permission to use its inland
route and ports of Chittagong and Mongla for trans-shipment of goods to northeast Indian states.
Blue Economy
● India and Bangladesh are cooperating in the exploration of hydrocarbons, marine resources, deep-sea
fishing, preservation of marine ecology and disaster management.
● During the virtual summit, both countries agreed to expeditiously conclude the Memorandum of
Understanding (MoU) in the area of disaster management cooperation.
Border Cooperation
● Both countries have signed Land Boundary Agreement in 2015 to demarcate the boundary.
● In recently concluded virtual summit, both countries stressed on the full implementation of the
ongoing Coordinated border management plan which included collaborated efforts against smuggling of
arms, narcotics and fake currency and to prevent trafficking of women and children.
Rohingya issue
● In 2018 India sent relief materials for 300,000 Rohingyas in under ‘Operation Insaniyat’ to support
Bangladesh in its humanitarian efforts. In recently concluded virtual summit, India appreciated the efforts of
Bangladesh in providing humanitarian assistance to the Rohingya refugee.
Partnership on Multilateral forums
● Both countries are important partners in regional forums like SAARC, BIMSTEC, BBIN.
● Bangladesh will also assume chairmanship of the Indian Ocean Rim Association in 2021.
● Both countries are also cooperating in reform of UNSC and attainment SDGs.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 22
ISSUES IN RELATIONSHIP
● CHINA FACTOR- In recent years that the Chinese investment into Bangladesh has grown exponentially. The
main concerns which is raised about these investments is that of Bangladesh falling into the same debt trap
like Sri Lanka. Further, Bangladesh is overwhelmingly dependent on China for military hardware.
● Rising radicalisation in Bangladesh can have a spill over effect in Eastern states of India.
● Boundary- Porous boundary has given rise to smuggling, human, drugs and arms trafficking.
● River Disputes- India and Bangladesh share 54 rivers. Both countries have major dispute over the Teesta
river. With the India-Bangladesh water-sharing deal stuck; it has begun to discuss a Chinese loan to manage
the river.
● Domestic Politics - Bangladesh has raised concerns over CAA-NRC. Foreign Minister of Bangladesh has gone
on to say that the new law would weaken India's “historic position” as a “tolerant and secular nation. There
were also reports of cancellation of high level visits by Bangladesh as a protest.
o However, officially Bangladesh has clarified that CAA is internal matter of India.
● Issues in connectivity-
o Inland Waterways- the utilization of the inland waterway transit by Indian vessels remains below
anticipated levels. A study by the Indian High Commissioner in Dhaka found the lack of navigability,
lack of container facilities in Ashuganj port, and the long-distance of custom offices from the ports
as some reasons for Indian carriers to not operate using Bangladesh’s inland water routes.
o Poor Infrastructure development- in both countries along the borders.
● Financing- India has provided four Lines of Credit (LoC) worth USD 7.8 billion to Bangladesh since 2010.
However, the disbursement of capital through the LoCs has been slow. Of the total USD 7.8 billion credit,
only around 9 percent or USD 686.08 million has been disbursed to Bangladesh till FY 2019-2020.
● Rohingya issue- India’s position on Rohingya migrants and remarks in 2017 have not gone down well with
Bangladesh which is facing challenge of providing shelter to more than a million refugees. Further, India has
also refused to exert any pressure on Myanmar for taking the Rohingyas back despite requests from
Bangladesh.
● Bureaucratic red Tapism- Out of total approved $7.4 billion , only $442 million was disbursed till 2019 due
to red Tapism and requirement of approval by Exim Bank.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 23
● India’s own compulsion: Bangladesh wants 50 percent of the Teesta's waters between December and May
every year, because that's when the water flow to the country drops drastically. However, India has its own
compulsions as India needs this water for irrigation in North Bengal.
Reasons for the crisis
● Reduction in Water- recent report of thirdpole.net shows that river has only one-sixteenth of the water
needed.
● Planning Failure- Barrages are built to hold back water for dry seasons. However, water has been released
by wrong time by authorities in both counties.
● Sikkim Effect- The water released from run of the river projects in Sikkim is not coordinated with peak time
need of farmers.
● Opposition of West Bengal government- (covered above)
● Federalism Issue- Different ruling parties at centre and the states makes the matter more complex.
Recent News-
● During virtual summit in December 2020, Bangladesh highlighted the need for early signing of an interim
agreement for sharing of the Teesta waters, as agreed upon by both the governments in 2011.
● Role of China - Bangladesh is discussing an almost $1 billion loan from China for a comprehensive
management and restoration project on the Teesta River.
Way Forward
● Regional Mechanism- To decide on mutually agreed principles on water sharing and enforcing of
agreements. SAARC could be used to enhance cooperation among riparian states.
● Water sharing deals from other rivers- India and Bangladesh shares 54 rivers. Sharing waters from other
rivers in equitable manner can help meeting water demands from both sides. Recently, WB CM has also
proposed sharing of water from Torsa river. Similarly, in 2019 both countries signed MoU on withdrawal of
1.82 cusecs water from Feni River by India a drinking water supply scheme in Tripura.
● Transparency in data sharing- sharing of data on river water flow in a transparent manner based on mutually
agreed scientific parameters.
● Cooperating on transboundary river management and water conservation by strengthening the institutional
mechanism of Joint River commission. Also, early conclusion of Framework of Interim Agreement on sharing
of waters of six joint rivers is needed.
Conclusion
● The hydrological linkages between India and Bangladesh are a product of geography and a matter of shared
history. Thus, to make the recent gains in overall relationship irreversible, both countries need to continue
working on the three Cs — cooperation, collaboration, and consolidation.
GOVERNMENT STEPS
BORDER SECURITY
● Land boundary agreement of 2015.
● establishment of Border Protection Grid (BPG) And creation of crime-free stretch
CONNECTIVITY
● Agreement on Standard Operating Procedure on use of Chattogram and Mongla Ports for movement of
goods to and from India;
● Recently Bharat Bangla Maitri Bridge was inaugurated in Tripura’s South district. It can serve as a new trade
corridor between the two countries.
VACCINE MAITRI
● India gifted 109 ambulances, and also donated 1.2 million doses of Covid-19 vaccines as a grant.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 24
Developmental support
● Since 2010 India has approved 3 lines of credit to Bangladesh amounting to $ 7.4 billion.
WAY FORWARD-
- Removing red tape to expedite infrastructure development: Bangladesh and India can expedite the process
by directly sending the bill from the line ministry to India’s EXIM Bank.
- Use new inland water ports for promoting regional connectivity: Water transport provides a sustainable
alternative to other models of transport.
- Allow third party goods to be transported under the coastal shipping agreement: This will save time and
costs: an estimate puts the savings at USD 37.5 million per year for Bangladesh. It will also reduce congestion
at the Chattogram seaport.
- Greater regional connectivity- The coastal shipping agreement between India and Bangladesh can also lead
to a greater BIMSTEC coastal shipping agreement which can increase trade between the member countries.
Further, the road and rail transit routes, both existing and proposed, can also be a part of the Trans-Asian
highway and railway projects.
CONCLUSION-
- PM Modi has termed the present state of relationship as ‘Sonami Adhyay’ and both sides can play a
significant role in global and regional value chains by further integrating their economies and boosting
connectivity.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 25
INDIA-NEPAL
introduction-
• As close neighbours, India and Nepal share a unique relationship of friendship and cooperation characterized by
open borders and deep-rooted people–to–people contacts of kinship and culture. The India–Nepal Treaty of
Peace and Friendship of 1950 forms the bedrock of the special relations that exist between India and Nepal.
WHY IN NEWS?
• Recently, Nepal published a new political map that claimed Kalapani, Limpiyadhura and Lipulekh of Uttarakhand
as part of its sovereign territory. India responded by saying that artificial enlargement of territorial claims will
not be acceptable to it and asked the neighbouring country to refrain from "unjustified cartographic assertion".
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 26
WHY IN NEWS?
▪ In May 2020 India’s defence minister virtually inaugurated a new 80 km-long road in the Himalayas,
connecting to the border with China, at the Lipulekh pass.
▪ The Nepal government protested this and introduced a constitutional amendment which made changes to
the Nepali map to include that Kalapani, Limpiyadhura and Lipulekh of Uttarakhand as part of its sovereign
territory
VIEWS-
▪ C. Raja Mohan identifies the territorial dispute as “merely a symptom of the structural changes unfolding in
the external and internal context of the bilateral relationship.
▪ As noted by Dinesh Bhattarai, a former Nepali diplomat, the border dispute “looks minor, but allowing it to
fester is likely to sow the seeds of immense competition and intense rivalry in the sensitive Himalayan
frontier with far-reaching geopolitical implications.”
▪ Similarly, Nepal expert S. D. Muni cautions that, sooner or later, the dispute “will be exploited by the third
parties to their advantage.”
HISTORY and PRESENT
● Open borders: The two countries share an approximately 1800-kilometre international open border, which
is managed under the bilateral Treaty of Peace and Friendship (1950).
o The border was formally demarcated for the first time with the Treaty of Sugauli (1816).
o Under section 5 the treaty Nepal renounced its claims on the region west of river kali. Thus, river
Kali became boundary between India and Nepal.
• Nepal’s stand- Nepal claims it conducted a census there in the
early 1950s and refers to the 1815 Sugauli Treaty as legitimising
its claims.
• India’s stance- Though the areas of Kalapani, Limpiyadhura and
Lipulekh lie west of river Kali, India has historically controlled the
region. And claims that the border begins at Kalapani where the
river begins.
• In 1981, both the governments had agreed to set up the India-
Nepal Border Joint Technical Committee to re-demarcate the
boundary pillars.
• They also established The Nepal-India Joint Border Inspection
Mechanism in 1981 and the Nepal-India Joint Border
Management Committee in 1997 to manage borders.
• No-man’s land: However, The Kalapani border has yet to be properly demarcated, especially the so-called
‘no-man’s land’ in the area.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 27
• DELAY IN PROJECT COMPLETION- The trust deficit between Nepal and India largely affected the
implementation of various Indian-aided projects in Nepal. At times, some of the Indian investment
projects had been attacked.
• Political instability in Nepal- Recently, Nepali president has dissolved the House of Representatives in
controversial manner. With this Nepal has entered into another phase of uncertainty.
• RISING CHINESE FOOTPRINT-
o INVESTMENT- In 2019 China accounted for approximately 40% of new FDIs and 90% of total FDI
against India’s 30%.
o CONNECTIVITY- In 2017, Nepal formally joined the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) of China.
▪ China is also developing US$ 2.5 billion trans-Himalayan railway connecting Tibet to Nepal’s
capital city Kathmandu.
▪ China and Nepal have also signed agreement for construction of all-weather road
connecting Tibet and Kathmandu under The Trans Himalayan Multidimensional connectivity
network.
o INTERFERENCE IN DOMESTIC POLITICS- During recent political crisis in Nepal, A Communist Party of
China delegation spent 4 days in Nepal, playing mediator between two factions of the ruling Nepal
Communist Party. The Chinese envoy too held meetings with both factions.
• NEW GEOPOLITICAL GREAT GAME-
o Elevated Partnership: During the visit of Xi Xinping, Nepal and China elevated their ties from
“Comprehensive Partnership of Cooperation Featuring Ever-lasting Friendship” to “Strategic
Partnership of Cooperation Featuring Ever-lasting Friendship for Development and Prosperity”.
o Treaty on Extradition: China also signed a Treaty on Mutual Legal Assistance in Criminal Matters
(MLACM) and expressed hope for an early conclusion of the Treaty on Extradition.
o Himalayan ‘Quadrilateral’: The recent Himalayan ‘Quadrilateral’ meeting between China, Pakistan,
Afghanistan and Nepal also highlight Chinese attempt to contain India in south Asia.
o DAFENCE COOPERATION- For the first time, the People’s Liberation Army (PLA) and the Nepali Army
held two joint-military exercises in 2017 and 2018. Since 2019, the PLA has also agreed to provide
financial assistance to the Nepali Army on a regular basis
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 28
• The issue also became prominent after the India-Nepal boundary dispute in Kalapani region.
WAY FORWARD-
• Demarcation of borders: Both countries have demarcated 97% of border. Both India and Nepal must invest
in negotiating new border management agreements to take into consideration recent events.
• Joint military deployment: Both countries can agree upon joint military deployment, special access rights for
Nepali citizens.
• Interdependence between Nepal and India is the secret to reset the relations between
the neighbours. Towards this end, the two countries could also build an international corridor along the
border region to enhance the trade between the two countries.
• Institutional mechanism: Both countries can also create institutional mechanism to play an active role in
several important multilateral forums such as BBIN, BIMSTEC, NAM, and SAARC to serve their common
interests.
• Full-fledged engagement: India should remain fully engaged with Nepal at all levels and across the political
spectrum. The safeguarding of India’s vital interests demands such sustained engagement.
• People-to-people links: India needs to appreciate that the people-to-people links between our two countries
have an unmatched density and no other country, including China, enjoys this asset. India needs to leverage
this precious asset to ensure a stable and mutually-productive state-to-state relationship.
INDIA – AFGHANISTAN
PYQ
1. The proposed withdrawal of International Security Assistance Force (ISAF) from Afghanistan in 2014 is
fraught with major security implications for the countries of the region. Examine in light of the fact that
India is faced with a plethora of challenges and needs to safeguard its own strategic interests. (2013)
INTRODUCTION-
• Afghanistan has been the centre of ‘Great Games’ and ‘Graveyard of Empires’. It derives its political
significance because of its Geo-strategic location.
• Due to its geographical positioning and influence on regional stability, the political future of Afghanistan will
be of considerable significance to several nations with competing sets of interests as well as to pan-Asian
relations as a whole.
• Peace and stability in Afghanistan is important for India for security in Kashmir, securing Indian investment
in Afghanistan as well as India’s power projection as a major global power.
SIGNIFICANCE OF AFGHANISTAN FOR INDIA
GEOSTRATEGIC
• Location- Connecting East, West, central and north east Asia.
o Proximity to major powers like Russia, China, India, Iran.
o Centre of Great game between the USA and Russia since the cold war.
• Regional balance power- Peace and stability in Afghanistan is linked to India’s vision of regional leader and
global power.
• Internal security- Afghanistan is centre of radical ideology, drug trafficking and smuggling. Thus peaceful
Afghanistan is necessary for regional security.
GEOECONOMIC
• Connectivity- Important transit hub for trade and commerce and access to landlocked Central Asia.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 29
• Mineral Wealth- According to US geological Survey, Afghanistan is home to resource deposits like iron,
copper etc worth $1 trillion.
• Energy Security- Afghanistan has huge untapped sources of hydrocarbons including oil and gas. Further it is
also an important component of TAPI pipeline.
RECENT EVENTS
TALIBAN TAKEOVER OF AFGHANISTAN
After two decades of active involvement in the affairs of Afghanistan, and spending over a trillion dollars in the
process to defeat terrorism and the al Qaeda, the U.S. has left Afghanistan in a worse situation than when it entered.
CHALLENGES
• For India, the virtual retreat of the U.S. from this part of Asia; the growing China-Russia-Pakistan nexus across
the region; and an Iran under a hardliner like Ebrahim Raisi, all work to its disadvantage.
• Post US withdrawal-
o The vacuum can be filled by China and Pakistan which can be detrimental to India’s security.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 30
o There is also risk of terrorism. While the U.S.-Taliban agreement states that the Taliban will prevent
terrorist outfits from operating on Afghan soil, there is little clarity on how the agreement will be
verified and enforced.
o It is not possible to discern any reduction in terrorism or the demise of any of the better known
terror groups, such as the al Qaeda and the Islamic State (IS), or for that matter, of lesser known
terror outfits.
o The other risk has to do with the growing influence of Pakistan’s Inter-Services Intelligence
Directorate, which shares an undeniable link with the Taliban, especially the Haqqani group.
• SECURITY- Afghanistan is hub for transnational terrorism and radicalisation. It can have a spill over effect on
Kashmir. It is also a hub for opium trade and organised crime.
• TRADE- trade through Afghanistan under a Taliban regime would be routed through Karachi and Gwadar,
and the Indian investment in the Chabahar port, meant to circumvent Pakistan, may become unviable.
• Connectivity- India lacks direct connectivity with Afghanistan. New route bypassing Pakistan through
Chabahar port is threatened by heightened US – Iran tensions and growing closeness between Iran and
China.
• Pakistan- Pakistan views its Afghanistan relations from prism of its relations with India. Thus it wants Strategic
Depth in Afghanistan. According to M. K. Narayanan, Pakistan is the ‘patron saint’ of the new regime.
o The Pakistan-Taliban close relationship was also seen when ISI Chief, Faiz Hameed flew into
Kandahar to greet Mullah Baradar.
▪ Pakistan can recruit Taliban fighters for destabilizing Kashmir post USA withdrawal.
▪ Pakistan also fears of Pashtun nationalism as no government in Afghanistan has ever accepted
Durand line. That’s why Pakistan wants to control afghan military and its foreign policy.
▪ Pakistan’s all-weather friendship with China and inclusion of Afghanistan in BRI can further
marginalise India in Afghanistan in new unfolding ‘Great Game’ in Afghanistan.
• Russia and CHINA- Rising Chinese footprint in Afghanistan through its proxy i.e. Pakistan. Emergence of
China-Pakistan-Iran-Russia axis. Afghanistan is important for China for its BRI project as well as stability in its
Xinjiang province.
o Russia, though no longer the power it once was, is currently seeking to enlarge its influence in
Eurasia, and the Afghan imbroglio gives it an opportunity.
o China, which envisages domination of Asia as the first step in its bid to become the world’s number
one power, sees Afghanistan as a prize both from a geo-economic and geo-political standpoint.
o For China, the mineral wealth of Afghanistan is only one aspect; a key objective is to make its Belt
and Road Initiative a truly viable entity, and further extend its reach to the Indian Ocean, without
being totally dependent on Pakistan.
• Institutional weakness in Foreign Policy making due to risk aversion approach and lack of capacity to meet
rising expectations of Afghanistan.
• New Great game- Between US-INDIA-Afghanistan on one hand and Pakistan-China-Russia on the other.
o Ethnic tensions in Afghanistan- a 33-member interim government overwhelmingly Pashtun in
character. Pakistan holds certain key cards given the prominent role assigned to its protégés,
Sirajuddin Haqqani and Mohammad Yaqoob, the son of Mullah Omar. In the new government quite
a few members are on various terror lists, including that of the United Nations and the United States.
o India’s relations with Taliban government- India’s relations with the new Taliban leadership may
remain strained due to its association, earlier with the Northern Alliance, and subsequently with the
Hamid Karzai and Ashraf Ghani administrations.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 31
o HUMAN RIGHTS- there is the worry for India of the impact on Afghanistan itself, given the Taliban’s
past record in power, of an erosion in women’s and minority rights, the overturning of a democratic
system and the imposition of the Taliban’s brutal form of justice.
India’s Position-Shift on Taliban
• Presently, India is taking ‘wait and watch’ approach as events are still unfolding in Afghanistan. However,
India’s recent engagements with Taliban and Taliban’s request to New Delhi to resume flights to Kabul
highlight position shift towards Taliban. India is unlikely to pursue past policy of not recognising Taliban and
supporting Northern Alliance.
WAY FORWARD-
• Engaging with Taliban- It would allow New Delhi to seek security guarantees from the insurgents in return for
continued development assistance or other pledges as well as explore the possibility of the Taliban’s
autonomy from Pakistan.
• According to M. K. Narayanan, India should take on a mediating role among the different nations anxious to
involve themselves in Afghanistan, and produce a formula that would help maintain Afghanistan’s neutrality
and ensure that it becomes a buffer zone to prevent further Chinese expansionism towards South Asia.
• India needs to work with countries like China and Iran who have similar stakes in peace and stability in the
region. The announcement of India-China joint development project in Afghanistan during Wuhan Talks is a
welcome step.
• India needs to closely collaborate with US’ local networks, which still carry considerable heft, when engaging
the Taliban. The US has also shown an appetite for India’s increased role by recently inviting it to the latest
rounds of Afghan peace talks.
• India should strive to ensure the continuance of the Kabul process so that counter-terrorism, women’s rights,
and democratic values (i.e. an Afghan-led, Afghan-controlled and Afghan-owned process) stay on the agenda.
This may entail bringing the Taliban into a “legal” process of governance and simultaneously supporting the
rise of civilian leaders who have legitimacy and clout beyond Kabul.
CONCLUSION-
• As suggested by C. Rajamohan, strategic rewards in Afghanistan are as large as risks. India is realistic enough
to know that it doesn't have power to unilaterally define Afghanistan’s future. But India needs to develop
some leverage and influence outcomes in Afghanistan through proactive diplomacy and some purposeful
action on the ground.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 32
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 33
INDIA – MYANMAR
Introduction
• India-Myanmar relations are rooted in shared historical, ethnic, cultural and religious ties. India and
Myanmar share a long land border of over 1600 km and a maritime boundary in the Bay of Bengal.
• It is the only ASEAN country adjoining India and, therefore, is a gateway to South East Asia. India is seeking
to enhance its cooperation with Myanmar in line with our ‘Act East’ and ‘Neighborhood First’ Policies.
Overview of relationship
Institutional Mechanisms
• The National Level Meeting (NLM) at Home Secretary is the main forum to discuss security cooperation,
consular issues, drug trafficking and liaison between agencies.
• Boundary matters are discussed by Joint Boundary Working Group (JBWG) led by Joint Secretary (BM), MEA.
• Commercial issues are discussed in the Joint Trade Committee (JTC) held at Commerce Minister-level.
Development Cooperation
• India’s development assistance portfolio in Myanmar is now over US $1.75 billion. The bulk of this assistance
is grant-funded.
Commercial Cooperation
• Trade agreement: Since the signing of the India-Myanmar trade agreement in 1970, bilateral trade has grown
steadily. The current trade figures stand at US $ 1.7 Billion. India is the fifth largest trading partner of
Myanmar.
• Energy: Myanmar is potentially an important partner in the energy sector as future offshore gas finds can be
piped to India. Currently has a Joint Working Group on Oil and Gas and on Power cooperation.
• In terms of investment, India stands at 11th position with an approved investment of US$ 771.488 million.
13 Indian Public Sector Undertakings have presence in Myanmar in different sectors
Enhancing Connectivity
• In August 2018, two international entry/ exit points were inaugurated at Tamu-Moreh and Rih-Zowkhawthar.
Measures to fully operationalize these two land border points are underway.
• Negotiations on a Motor Vehicle Agreement is also ongoing.
• Other important connectivity projects include
o Kaladan Multimodal Transit Transport Project
o The Trilateral Highway Project, which is an East-West corridor connecting our Northeast with
Myanmar and Thailand;
Disaster Relief
• India has responded promptly and effectively in rendering assistance following natural calamities in
Myanmar like Cyclone Mora (2017), Komen (2015), earthquake in Shan State (2010), Cyclone Nargis in 2008
etc.
Culture
• India and Myanmar share close cultural ties and a sense of deep kinship, given India's Buddhist heritage.
Building on this shared heritage, India is undertaking some key initiatives in the restoration of the Ananda
Temple in Bagan and the repair and conservation of a large number of damaged pagodas
Security cooperation
• In July 2019, India and Myanmar signed a Defence Cooperation Agreement aimed at boosting military
engagement
• Both countries also conduct Joint Naval Exercise ‘IMCOR’, Indian Navy-Myanmar Navy (MN) Bilateral Exercise
‘IN-MN BILAT’ and the India-Myanmar Joint Army Exercise (IMBAX)
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 34
• Armies of India and Myanmar have carried out Operation Sunrise along the Myanmar border targeting camps
of insurgent groups operating in North East. They also work together to destroy several militant camps of
Arakan Army on the Indo-Myanmar border.
Maritime cooperation and Blue Economy
• Blue economy is an important pillar of BIMSTEC where both countries are working together. Under India’s
SAGAR (Security and growth for all in the region) programme, India has built Sittwe Port.
Issues in relationship
• Insurgency- Many insurgent groups in North East have their base in Myanmar. The free movement regime
further facilitate their movement and links with organised crime.
• Rising Chinese footprint
• Domestic instability in Myanmar
• Rohingya crisis
• Porus borders and Organised Crime- Proximity to the ‘Golden Triangle’ together with a porous and poorly
guarded border provides the enabling environment for traffickers to smuggle heroin and psychotropic
substances into India through the India-Myanmar border.
ROHINGYA CRISIS
• Rohingya are described as the world’s most persecuted people. They live predominantly in Rakhine state.
• Systematic discrimination: The Rohingya are considered as illegal immigrants and they suffer from systematic
discrimination in Myanmar.
• Stateless people: The Myanmar government has made them stateless people by denying them citizenship.
• The recent crackdown on Rohingya by Myanmar army is described by the United Nations as a “textbook
example of ethnic cleansing” due to which around 800,000 Rohingyas fled Myanmar and took shelter in
Bangladesh.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 35
Timeline of crisis
India’s position on Rohingya
• Illegal migrants: Indian government
considers Rohingya as illegal migrants and
maintains that Rohingyas are a threat to
its national security and have links with
international terror groups.
• Recently, SC has also rejected an
application to stay the deportation of
Rohingya refugees to Myanmar.
• India has asked Myanmar to secure
position for the displaced people
within the country and to start the
repatriation process soon in
consultation with Bangladesh.
• Development of the Rakhine province :
India has also laid emphasis on the
socio-economic development of the
Rakhine province to create enough
economic incentive for the displaced
people who will return from the camps
at Bangladesh.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 36
• Security of North-East- India is also concerned about the links between Arakan Army and the Naga self-
administered zone operated by NSCN (K) group.
Way forward
• Diplomatic Solution- New Delhi should use creative diplomacy to persuade Myanmar to resolve the Rohingya
crisis as a stable and democratic Myanmar will naturally gravitate towards New Delhi.
• National security: India has the right to prioritize its national security. However, security concerns need to
be balanced by constitutional values and Human Rights of refugees.
• Domestic Refugee Policy- India needs to enact a domestic refugee policy legislation to bring clarity on India’s
stance as The Foreigners Act, 1946, fails to address the peculiar problems faced by refugees
• Economic- China is the largest trading partner of Myanmar. The bilateral trade stands at about USD 12
billion in 2019 that roughly
amounts to 1/3rd of the total
trade of Myanmar.
• Connectivity- Myanmar is part
of OBOR project. China has also
proposed China-Myanmar
Economic Corridor (CMEC) as
part of BRI project.
• Energy- China constructed a
natural gas and oil pipeline
running in parallel which starts
from Kyaukphyu City in
Myanmar’s Rakhine State to
China’s Yunan region
constructed at a combined cost
of USD 4.5 billion.
• Defence- China has been one of
the largest military suppliers of Myanmar since 1988. According to SIPRI database Myanmar spent USD 1.3
billion in arms from the Chinese between 2010- 2019.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 37
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 38
Multilateral Partnerships :
• Both countries share multilateral organizations like ;
o SAARC (South Asian Association For Regional Cooperation).
o BIMSTEC (The Bay of Bengal Initiative for Multi-Sectoral Technical and Economic Cooperation).
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 39
Roadblocks in cooperation :
• External debt: India is Bhutan’s largest trade partner having favourable balance of payment which has
created problems for Bhutan. Its external debt has become more than 100% of its GDP.
• Delays in hydropower projects : by Indian companies have led to Bhutan's rising national debt.
• Both countries have agreed to jointly develop 10000 MWs of hydropower generating capacity in Bhutan.
India is failing to develop projects in expected time.
• Electricity Tariff :Hydropower forms a major source for Bhutan hence they are asking to increase electricity
tariff. India's power surplus status and enhancing renewable energies like wind and solar power pose a
challenge for Bhutan to ensure its hydropower sector in profit.
• Indian Intervention : Government’s decision to cut cooking gas subsidy just before the 2013 elections in
Bhutan indicating India's interference. The Sovereignty issues raised because of episodes like Project Dantak
have raised local concerns regarding preserving their autonomy. It has created negative perception
regarding India’s intrusion in domestic affairs.
• BBIN :Bhutan did not join the BBIN Motor Vehicle Agreement considering its adverse impact on the
environment and climate.
• Internal Security : Insurgent groups situated in the south east forest of Bhutan have become an issue of
concern for them.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 40
• Chinese Concern :Chinese attempts to establish diplomatic ties with Bhutan and extending its BRI project to
Bhutan has become cause for concern for India.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 41
ISSUES IN NEWS :
• This MoU would enable ISRO/DOS to share its expertise and Bhutan would be benefited with a range of
applications from Broadcast services to disaster management.
• It will help Bhutan to venture into the Space industry with Indian help.
• On the background of Chinese aggression this step would further strengthen the relations between them.
• It can facilitate Indian investment in Bhutan and help to create new employment opportunities in Bhutan.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 42
o Environment protection and management of natural resources on the basis of equity, reciprocity
and mutual benefits.
o It takes into consideration applicable laws and legal provisions in each country.
• Areas Of Cooperation : Memorandum of Understanding covers the following areas of environment: Air ,
Waste , Chemical Management , Climate change .
• Public and private Stakeholders : The MoU intends to encourage organizations, private companies,
government institutions at all levels and research institutions on both sides aimed at fulfilling the objectives
of the Memorandum of Understanding.
• Formation of Joint Working Group :A Joint Working Group would be formed to review and analyze the
progress of activities and track the progress and achievements.
Implications:
• Best practices: The Memorandum of Understanding would facilitate exchange of experiences, best practices
and technical knowhow through both public and private sectors and shall contribute to sustainable
development.
• Lessons from Bhutan: India can take lessons from the Bhutanese value system based on environment
conservation and its importance in happy human life.
Doklam Issue :
What is the Issue :
• Chinese transgression : Indian troops along with Bhutanese army obstructed chinese attempts to build road
infrastructure in Doklam region which is disputed territory between China and Bhutan.
• Standoff : This escalated to a standoff between two armies for two month in summer 2017.
Geographical location and importance to India :
• Strategic Location: It is surrounded by Chumby Valley of
Tibet , Bhutan’s ha Valley and Sikkim. Being very close to
India's chicken neck corridor which connects mainland
India with its north eastern region hence it is strategically
important for India.
• Doklam being a plateau provides strategic advantage of
higher altitude compared to Chumby valley. Hence it is
very strategic and required to be protected from Chinese
transgression.
• The Doklam region has been neglected in the recent past
however it gained significance when China started
increasing its troops in Chumby Valley. Indian and
Bhutanese army situated at Doklam plateau are in a militarily advantageous position.
Immediate cause:
• Road Infrastructure: The issue surfaced when China (People's Liberation Army) started construction of roads
in this region and India Army along with Royal Bhutanese Army objected Chinese developments.
• Chinese Aggression: China considered India's presence at Doklam as a transgression. So, China responded
by destroying two Indian Bunkers and She closed the route to kailash-Mansarovar via NathuLa pass.
• Escalation: These developments escalated to a two-month standoff between China and India in summer
2017which eventually solved through high level negotiations.
Chinese interest in the region:
• Interest in Bhutan: China aims to establish formal diplomatic ties with Bhutan for that reason by pressurising
it through escalating boundary disputes.
• Logistics : The Road Construction project of China has many benefits for military logistics.
• Regional development : China wants to develop its Yudong region by increasing connectivity to Lhasa.
• Military Benefits : Control over Doklam will strengthen the position of China against India in military warfare.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 43
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 44
• India-Bhutan relationship is perhaps the only bilateral engagement in South Asia which has stood the test of
time.
• Global relations influenced by COVID 19 pandemic , Protectionism , Trade war directs our foreign policy to
remain adhere to our neighbourhood first policy and Bhutan is a crucial player in development of the north
east region.
• Bringing innovative approaches to solve issues related to hydropower is required.
• Bhutan is a crucial player in dealing with Chinese aggression near Chumbi valley.
• India should transform from its earlier big brother approach to mentor when required and widen its
engagement on multiple facets like sports , yoga , Bollywood etc.
INDIA-SRILANKA
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 45
PYQ
1. In respect of India —Sri Lanka relations, discuss how domestic factors influence foreign policy. (2013)
INTRODUCTION
• India and Sri Lanka have a legacy of intellectual, cultural, religious and linguistic interaction and the
relationship between two countries is more than 2500 years old.
OVERVIEW OF RELATIONS
ECONOMIC-
• Largest trading partner: Sri Lanka is India’s largest trading partner in SAARC. Both countries signed a Free
Trade Agreement in March 2000. According to Sri Lankan Customs, bilateral trade during January –
November 2019 amounted to USD 4.19 billion.
• Currency swap: Recently, The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) has signed an agreement for extending a $400-
million currency swap facility to Sri Lanka to boost the foreign reserves and ensure financial stability post
COVID-19.
POLITICAL-
• High-level exchanges: Political relations between the two countries have been marked by high-level
exchanges of visits at regular intervals.
• ‘India first’ policy: Sri Lankan President during his first foreign visit to India highlighted ‘India first’ policy of
Sri Lanka and held that, ‘while China is friend, India is Relative.’
GEOSTRATEGIC SIGNIFICANCE OF Sri Lanka
• It is located on important sea lines of communications in Indian ocean from where 90% of India’s trade is
carried out.
• Sri Lanka has also made it clear that its strategic security policy will have ‘India first’ approach though it will
also cooperate with other partners for economic development. PM of Sri Lanka called India as a relative and
China as a friend thus highlighting importance of India.
Defence and security cooperation
• Military exercise: India and Sri Lanka conduct annual joint Military exercise ‘Mitra Shakti’ and Naval exercise
SLINEX. India also provides defense training to Sri Lankan forces.
• Maritime security: India, Sri Lanka and the Maldives have signed a trilateral maritime security cooperation
agreement to improve surveillance, anti-piracy operations and reducing maritime pollution in Indian Ocean
Region.
• In 2019, India and Sri Lanka also concluded agreement on countering Drug and Human trafficking.
Developmental Assistance-
• Sri Lanka is an important pillar of Neighbourhood First Policy and vibrant democracy like India.
• India has provided rehabilitation and relief assistance for internally displaced Tamils. India has constructed
30000 houses and other medical facility infrastructure.
• The Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the Central Bank of Sri Lanka (CBSL) have concluded the USD 400 million
currency swap agreement under the SAARC currency swap framework.
• Exim Bank has so far extended nine LOC to Sri Lanka including the latest one taking the total value to $1.68
billion.
Cultural and Educational Cooperation
• India and Sri Lanka have a legacy of intellectual, cultural, religious and linguistic interaction and the
relationship between two countries is more than 2500 years old.
• India and Sri Lanka signed a cultural cooperation agreement back in 1977. India cultural centre in Colombo
promotes Indian culture by providing courses in Indian music, dance, yoga etc.,
• India provides scholarships to qualified Sri Lankan students in Undergraduate and research studies.
• Sri Lanka is also a partner in Nalanda university project of India
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 46
TAMIL QUESTION-
What is the issue?
• Religious and linguistic discrimination by Sinhala speaking Buddhist majority. Tamil has not given status of
official language and primacy is given to Buddhism in employment and education.
• Denial of Citizenship- The majority of the Tamils were denied citizenship. Thus, most of the Tamils continued
to live in poverty in the tea estates of Sri-lanka.
• Civil war and Human Rights abuses- The UN estimates that 40,000 civilians alone died in the five months
before the civil war between LTTE and Sri Lankan government ended in May 2009.
ROLE OF INDIA-
• Indi-Sri Lanka peace accord, 1987- Under the accord Sri Lanka government agreed to enact 13th Amendment
which provided for devolution of powers to provinces and recognition of Tamil as official language.
• Indian Peacekeeping Mission – As per
terms of the peace accord, the LTTE
initially agreed to surrender their arms to
IPKF but later refused to surrender. The
IPKF found itself in bloody police action
against the LTTE and the mission failed.
• UN resolution: In March 2012, the
United Nations passed a resolution
urging Sri Lanka to investigate alleged
abuses during the final phase of war with
Tamil rebels. India voted against Sri
Lanka, under pressure from parties from
south India.
• India in March 2021 abstained from voting in the United Nation Human Rights Council on a resolution sought
to fix responsibility for war crimes and human rights violations against Tamils by Sri Lankan authorities in the
final days of the Eelam War IV.
• 20th Amendment: The new government in Sri Lanka has brought the 20th Amendment which dilutes the
13th amendment. Other provisions of Indo-Sri Lanka Accord of 1987 such as provincial Autonomy and
recognition of Tamil language are also not met.
• However, in recent times, salience of Tamil Question is declining in India-Sri Lanka relations as well as in
Tamil Nadu politics.
CHINA FACTOR
• Sri Lanka scrapped its $500 million agreement with India and Japan to develop the East Container Terminal
(ECT) project at Colombo port due to protest by trade unions.
• It handed over a $12 million energy project to a Chinese firm for the joint development of three renewable
power plants in islands off the Jaffna peninsula, about 50 km away from the Tamil Nadu coast. India has
registered strong protest over this project.
FISHERMAN ISSUE
• The key conflict lies with respect to Katchatheevu island. The island was ceded to Sri Lanka in 1974. The
agreement allows Indian fishermen access to Katchatheevu for rest, for drying of nests but it did not ensure
the traditional fishing rights.
• After the end of civil war in 2009, arrests and attacks increased on Indian fishermen when they enter Lankan
waters because of depletion of marine resources on the Indian side.
• Sri Lanka also protests against use of big trawlers by Indian fishermen.
• Boundary demarcation: Though both countries have demarcated the International Maritime Boundary Line
(IMBL) yet fishermen from both sides cross the line unknowingly.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 47
o Recently, the recovery of bodies washed ashore in Sri Lanka has triggered protests in Tamil Nadu as
they are believed to be of the four fishermen reported missing from the state.
• Both countries have established the Joint Working Group mechanism to find the permanent solution to the
issue. Also, MoU was signed between India and Sri Lanka to provide nets and other necessary equipment to
fisherman.
NEW CONSTITUTION OF SRILANKA
• The Sri Lanka government has introduced the 20th Amendment to undo changes brought by the 19th
Amendment which reduced Powers of the president.
• The 20th Amendment seeks to establish the Executive Presidency and reduce powers of the PM and
Parliament.
• These changes can strengthen Sinhalese nationalist sentiments and can further dilute the 13th Amendment.
This is a cause of concern for India.
ECONOMY AND DEBT
● Debt to GDP ratio of Sri Lanka is 80% of which China and ADB own 14%.
● Leasing of port: Recently, Sri Lanka leased Hambantota Port to China for 99 years. India is apprehensive that
the port is part of ‘String of pearls’ policy of China aimed at containing India.
● It will also give China control of port just few hundred miles from India and possible military presence in the
future.
● Trade Balance in favour of India: Exports from India to Sri Lanka in 2018 were US$ 4.16billion, while exports
from Sri Lanka to India are US$ 767 million. Sri Lanka wants to reduce this imbalance and wants greater
access to Indian markets
WAY FORWARD
● CONNECTIVITY- Economic integration through development of connectivity via Palk strait bridge.
● Economic integration roadmap(EIRM)- It is based on Sub Regionalism and aims to connect 5 southern states
of India with Sri Lanka to tap a total of 300 million population and $500 billion GDP.
● India can also work with other countries like Japan, Australia for infrastructure and connectivity development
in Sri Lanka and leveraging Blue Economy.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 48
INDIA - VIETNAM
Introduction:
The traditionally close and cordial relations between India and Vietnam have their historical roots in the common
struggle for liberation from foreign rule and the national struggle for independence. In recent times, economic and
strategic complementaries and common threat of China have strengthened economic, defence as well as political
relations.
WHY IN NEWS?
● India, Vietnam signed seven agreements during the virtual summit in December 2020. Agreements signed
are in areas such as defence, scientific research, renewable energy, nuclear energy, Petro-chemicals, and
cancer treatment.
OUTCOME OF SUMMIT-
● STRATEGIC COOPERATION- Both countries welcomed the signing of a Plan of Action for period 2021-2023
for further implementation of Comprehensive Strategic Partnership in order to strengthen their bilateral
partnership with a clear agenda for the next two years.
● JOINT VISION DOCUMENT and a Plan of Action for our bilateral engagement from 2021 to 2023 to strengthen
strategic partnership.
● DEFENCE COOPERATION- India extended $100 million Defence Line of Credit. Both countries also agreed for
implementation of the High-Speed Guard Boat Manufacturing Project for Vietnam under the $100 million
Defence Line of Credit. VINBAX is the military exercise between armies of India and Vietnam.
● NUCLEAR ENERGY COOPERATION- MOU to promote mutual cooperation between the regulatory bodies of
the two countries in the fields of radiation protection and nuclear safety.
● GLOBAL COOPERATION- Vietnam reiterated its strong support for India’s permanent membership in an
expanded UNSC. Both countries also agreed to work closely to actively promote reformed multilateralism to
make international organisations, including the UNSC, more representative, contemporary and capable of
dealing with current challenges.
IMPORTANCE OF VIETNAM-
● ACT EAST POLICY- India sees Vietnam as a pivotal state in its "Act East" policy, the same way that China sees
Pakistan as a strategic counter-balance to India.
● RELATIONSHIP WITH ASEAN- India’s growing ties with ASEAN (Associations of South-East Asian Nations)
countries to counter Chinese aggression in the South China Sea is a strategic necessity.
● CHINESE AGGRESSION- India is locked in a military standoff with China in the Ladakh sector of the Line of
Actual Control (LAC) while Vietnam has major differences over Chinese claims within its exclusive economic
zone in the South China Sea.
● MARITIME SECURITY-India and Vietnam held their second maritime security dialogue in a virtual format in
April 2021.
● CO-OPERATION IN UN- India and Vietnam could work closely to actively promote reformed multilateralism
to make international organisations, including the UNSC, more representative.
● STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP- countries have elevated their partnership to ‘Comprehensive Strategic
Partnership’. The joint vision document highlighted how a strengthened defence and security collaboration
between India and Vietnam could be “an important factor of stability in the Indo-Pacific region.” Both
countries also agreed to augment military-to-military exchanges, training, and capacity building
engagements between the two militaries including the coast guard.
● ENERGY SECURITY: Vietnam has rich hydrocarbon reserves. ONGC videsh is involved in exploration in
Vietnam.
● INDIA’S DEVELOPMENTAL ASSISTANCE- During the summit, India handed over seven Development Projects
with Indian ‘Grant-in-Aid’ Assistance of US$ 1.5 million for the benefit of local community in Vietnam’s Ninh
Thuan province. Both countries also agreed to enhance the number of annual Quick Impact Projects (QIPs)
from currently five to ten commencing FY 2021-2022.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 49
● CULTURAL COOPERATION- India-Vietnam launched three new Development Partnership projects in heritage
conservation in Vietnam and bilateral project for preparing an Encyclopedia on India – Vietnam Civilizational
and Cultural Relations.
ISSUES
● GEOECONOMIC- Vietnam is competing with India in attracting manufacturing companies leaving China from
sectors such as textile, automobile etc.
● CONNECTIVITY- Various connectivity projects launched by India are languishing for a long.
● LACK OF SUSTAINABLE DIPLOMATIC OUTREACH- Projects such as Mekong Ganga Cooperation suffer from
apathy from the government.
● OPPOSITION TO QUAD- Vietnam has been non-committal in backing QUAD grouping saying that it is opposed
to formation of any kind of military alliance.
● DEFENCE TIES- India and Vietnam are negotiating transfer of Brahmos Missiles to Vietnam. However, the
deal could not be materialised due to various issues like funding, CAATSA and China.
WAY FORWARD-
● Converting geostrategic convergence into geo-economic cooperation by cooperating in sectors such as
Nuclear energy, defence manufacturing etc. Both Countries also need to leverage the economic
opportunities available because of anti-China sentiments and several manufacturing firms deciding to shift
from China.
● Improving connectivity by extending IMT highway upto Laos and Vietnam and completing it time.
● Focus on Sub-Regionalism- India and Vietnam can jointly explore the potential for enhancing capacit y
building and providing technical assistance and training within the new emerging sub -regional
grouping of Cambodia-Laos-Vietnam growth triangle.
Conclusion
Vietnam is an important pillar of ‘Act East Policy’ and the close relationship between the two countries is significant
for the maintenance of strategic balance in South East Asia which is witnessing aggressive Chinese activities.
INDIA – INDONESIA
WHY IN NEWS?
● Defence Ministers’ Dialogue between India and Republic of Indonesia was held in July 2020.It is in
consonance with the Comprehensive Strategic Partnership between the two sides.
AREAS OF COOPERATION-
● DEFENCE COOPERATION- Potential areas of cooperation in the field of defence industries and defence
technology were also identified by the two countries. The issue of possible export of BrahMos cruise missile
to Indonesia by India are also under discussion.
o JOINT EXERCISE- Exercise Samudra Shakti the bilateral maritime exercise. Garuda Shakti is the joint
military exercise.
● STRATEGIC CONVERGENCE in context of rising unilateralism by China in South Asia and in the South China
Sea. In 2018, during Modi’s visit to Indonesia, both countries agreed on ways to boost cooperation within
their comprehensive strategic partnership.
o They agreed mainly on six broad areas including trade; sustainable development of marine
resources; disaster risk management; tourism; maritime safety and security; and science and
technology cooperation.
● MARITIME SECURITY- Together, they control the entry point from the Bay of Bengal in the Indian Ocean to
the Strait of Malacca which are strategically important sea lines of communications.
o Indonesia’s Global Maritime Fulcrum and India’s strategic vision of SAGAR (Security and Growth for
all in the Region) are complementary in nature. Both countries have also signed naval logistical
agreements with various Indian Ocean countries.
o In May 2018, India and Indonesia announced “Shared Vision of India-Indonesia Maritime
Cooperation in the Indo-Pacific.” The Shared Vision articulated common goals to improve maritime
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 50
connectivity between the Andaman and Nicobar Islands and Sumatra, as well as developing the
marine resources of both countries.
● TRADE-Indonesia has emerged as the second largest trading partner of India in the ASEAN region. Bilateral
trade has increased from USD 4.3 billion in 2005-06 to USD 21 billion in 2018-19. India is the second largest
buyer of coal and crude palm oil from Indonesia and imports minerals, rubber, pulp and paper and
hydrocarbons reserves.
● Terrorism- India and Indonesia are stressing the importance of existing counter-terror mechanisms and
strengthening intelligence cooperation systems amid rising violence and spread of radical ideologies. New
Delhi and Jakarta have also put in place an arrangement of Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty and instrument
of extradition to deal with terror operatives who are a threat to both countries.
● CONNECTIVITY- The Sabang port is being developed in partnership with neighbour and strategic partner
Indonesia. It is close to Malacca strait.
● Global forums: Both countries are members of G20, the Non-Aligned Movement (NAM), East Asia
Summit and the United Nations.
Conclusion
● India and Indonesia’s regional ambitions, growing maritime orientations, and apprehensions over China’s
rise demonstrate that they are well positioned to develop a broad-based partnership.
INDIA – MAURITIUS
WHY IN NEWS?
● External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar’s visit to Mauritius on February 22-23, 2021 strengthens India’s
partnership with the key Indian Ocean island country across the economic, health and security spheres.
CECPA
● It is India’s first such agreement with an African country.
● It will cut or eliminate duties on majority of goods as well as liberalise norms to promote services trade. It
will cover trade in goods, rules of origin, trade in services, Technical Barriers to Trade like Sanitary and
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 51
Phytosanitary (SPS) measures, dispute settlement, movement of natural persons, telecom, financial services,
customs procedures and cooperation in other areas.
● It will provide preferential access to a number of items like surgical equipment, medicine, and textile products
that would cater to market requirements on both sides.
● India and Mauritius have also agreed to negotiate an Automatic Trigger Safeguard Mechanism (ATSM) for
some highly sensitive products within two years of the signing of the agreement. The mechanism is aimed to
provide protection in case of sudden import rise.
INDIA-THAILAND
WHY IN NEWS?
● The 30th edition of India-Thailand Coordinated Patrol (CORPAT) has been concluded in the Andaman Sea
close to the Strait of Malacca.
SIGNIFICANCE-
● As part of Government of India’s vision of SAGAR (Security And Growth for All in the Region), the Indian Navy
has been involved in assisting countries in the Indian Ocean Region with EEZ Surveillance, Humanitarian
Assistance and Disaster Relief (HADR), and other capacity building and capability-enhancement activities.
INDIA – MALDIVES
PYQ
1. Discuss the political developments in Maldives in the last two years. Should they be of any cause of
concern to India? (2013)
Introduction
● India was among the first to recognize Maldives after its independence in 1965 and to establish diplomatic
relations with the country. India’s prompt assistance during the 1988 coup attempt under ‘Operation
Cactus’, led to development of trust and long‐term and friendly bilateral relations with the Maldives.
Overview of the relationship
• Economic- India and Maldives signed a trade agreement in 1981. India is Maldives’ 4th largest trade partner.
India‐Maldives bilateral trade now stands at US$ 290.27 million with trade balance in favor of India.
• Defence: India provides the largest number of training opportunities for Maldivian National Defence Force
(MNDF), meeting around 70% of their defence training requirements. A comprehensive Action Plan for Defence
was also signed in April 2016 to consolidate defence partnership.
• Key projects in the defence sector include Composite Training Centre for MNDF, Coastal Radar Surveillance
System and construction of new Ministry of Defence Headquarters.
• Disaster management: GoI had provided large‐scale assistance to Maldives in the aftermath of the 2004 Indian
Ocean tsunami and during the 2014 Male water crisis. India has also offered customized training for MNDF Fire
and Rescue Service in India.
• Developmental cooperation: The major completed and ongoing development assistance projects executed by
India include Indira Gandhi Memorial Hospital, Maldives Institute of Technical Education, National College for
Policing and Law Enforcement (NCPLE) etc.
▪ Connectivity project: India has also provided US $500 million assistance for the Greater Male
Connectivity project (GMCP), the largest civilian infrastructure project in Maldives, to connect Male
to three neighboring islands.
▪ Currency Swap: A Bilateral US Dollar Currency Swap Agreement of $400 million was signed between
RBI and Maldives Monetary Authority (MMA) in 2019.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 52
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 53
INDIA – US
Introduction
▪ India-US relations have come a long way in the last 7decades. From being described as ‘estranged
democracies’ by Dennis Kux . to being described as ‘Natural Allies’ by Vajpayee.
▪ India-U.S. bilateral relations have developed into a "comprehensive global strategic partnership", based on
shared democratic values and increasing convergence of interests on bilateral, regional and global issues.
▪ Estranged democracies: US and India, though being the oldest democracy and largest democracy
respectively, remained detached during the cold war.
VIEWS-
▪ Harsh Pant- Reflexive anti-Americanism is no longer evident in Indian foreign policy.
▪ Amitabh Mattu- Indo-US relations are going through ‘wow phase’.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 54
o The Defence Technology and Trade initiative(DTTI) has transformed the traditional buyer seller relationship
to ‘co-production and co-development’.
o US has designated India as Major Defence Partner, a status unique to India. India has also received
clearance on purchasing licence free space and defence technology under Strategic Trade
Authorization-I.
o In National Security Strategy and National Defence Strategy, China has been identified as a key
adversary while India has assumed a key place to counterbalance China.
Trade Relations
o India’s trade relations with the USA is balanced. India enjoys a $19 billion trade surplus in 2020-21.
o Total trade between India-US was $88.9 billion in 2019-20. The US remained India's top trading partner for
the second consecutive fiscal in 2019-20
o Defence trade: Apart from Oil , India-US defence trade is also increasing in recent years.
o Indian service sector and especially the IT sector is hugely dependent on US markets.
o MORE ON INDO-US TRADE
o Total USD 46 billion US Investments in India; over 2,000 US companies are in India, including every
major Fortune 500 company and over 200 Indian companies created about 125,000 jobs in the
United States across all states.
o Trade deal: Both countries have set target of $500 billion trade and are also working on securing a
‘mini trade deal’ as talks on FTA are stalled.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 55
• Strategic importance of Blue dot network: Blue Dot network is part of the US’s Indo-Pacific strategy, which
is aimed at countering Chinese President Xi Jinping’s ambitious BRI.
• Counter terrorism, Maritime security , cyber security are other important pillars of strategic partnership.
• During recent 2+2 ministerial dialogue key agreements on
o Technical Cooperation on Earth Sciences.
o Extending the arrangement on nuclear cooperation.
o Agreement on postal services.
o Cooperation in Ayurveda and cancer research
India as counterbalance to China-
• Balancing: The US views India as a geopolitical counterbalance, economic alternative and a democratic
contrast to China. And for India, the US is crucial to its China policy not just in terms of internal balancing and
capacity building, but also external balancing
• The declassified document of the Trump administration said a strong India, in cooperation with like-minded
countries, would act as a counterbalance to China in the Indo-Pacific region.
• Accelerate India’s rise: The USA’s objective is to accelerate India's rise and capacity to serve as a net provider
of security in the IOR region and major defence partner of the USA.
• There is Bipartisan Support for India’s rise. It will ensure USA’s policy continuity with respect to India.
Civil Nuclear Cooperation
• The bilateral civil nuclear cooperation agreement was finalized in July 2007 and signed in October 2008.
• The two sides have started the preparatory work on site in India for six AP 1000 reactors to be built by
Westinghouse. Once completed, the project would be among the largest of its kind.
• In 2020, India and the USA have extended their Memorandum of Understanding for cooperation on the
Global Centre for Nuclear Energy Partnership (GCNEP) by 10 years.
• The GCNEP, near Bahadurgarh in Haryana state, houses five schools to conduct research into advanced
nuclear energy systems, nuclear security, radiological safety, as well as applications for radioisotopes and
radiation technologies.
Cooperation at multilateral forums
• The U.S. has expressed support for India’s permanent membership on a reformed U.N. Security Council
and for India’s early membership in the Nuclear Suppliers Group.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 56
• Reengage with Iran: Biden has indicated its willingness to reengage with Iran. If the US rejoins JCPOA, it
can be helpful for India to restart its connectivity and energy projects with Iran.
• On China, the US policy of strengthening QUAD is expected to continue.
Energy Cooperation-
• Paris Climate Accord: Biden has promised to re-join the Paris Climate Accord. It can help India as it may
get access to critical technologies and finances to deal with the massive adaption and mitigation
challenges.
• Renewable energy: Through the India-U.S. Climate and Clean Energy Agenda 2030 Partnership, the two
have set ambitious targets for 2030. Under it United States has set an economy-wide target of reducing
its net greenhouse gas emissions by 50-52 percent below 2005 levels in 2030 and India has set a target
of installing 450 GW of renewable energy by 2030.
• Multilateralism- Biden administration has re-joined WHO. USA’s reengagement in global institutions can
help India to revive multilateralism and globalization and counter Chinese dominance.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 57
GEOSTRATEGIC-
o Though aggressive behaviour by China has brought India-USA together yet geostrategic interests of both are
not completely aligned
o In Afghanistan- USA’s announcement to withdraw from Afghanistan can destabilize the country
which can have a spill over effect in Kashmir.
o Indo Pacific- While India’s primary focus is on Indian ocean ,the USA is more focused on pacific ocean.
o Middle East- Trump Administration’s Maximum Pressure strategy for Iran has impacted India-Iran
relations and Iran has moved closer to China.
ON CLIMATE CHANGE
- Climate first” policy: Biden administration is pursuing a “climate first” policy agenda. On the other
hand, India is already the third-largest greenhouse gas emitter and its demand for energy will grow
faster than any other country for the next two decades. It has accordingly ruled out a zero-emissions
goal.
ON DATA SOVEREIGNTY-
o Osaka Track: In recently concluded G-20 summit, India boycotted the Osaka Track on the digital economy. It
favoured creation of laws which allowed free flow of data between countries. However, India opposed free
flow of data as it is breach of sovereignty.
o The CLOUD act of USA allows security agencies to procure data stored in servers regardless of whether Data
originates in the US or foreign soil.
WAY FORWARD-
o Connectivity- USA can invest in India ,Japan proposed Asia Africa growth corridor. Both countries can also
undertake joint infrastructure development programmes in IOR littoral states to counter Chinese projects in
the region.
o Cooperating in Maritime Domain- in fields such as blue economy, maritime domain awareness.
o Both countries need to find common ground on Afghanistan and Pakistan.
o TRADE- Both countries need to finalise Bilateral Investment Treaty to achieve target of $500 billion trade by
2025.
o De-risking Supply Chains- US can work with India, Japan and Australia to diversify and de-risk supply chains
through Supply Chain Resilience Initiative.
Conclusion-
o As suggested by Barak Obama, the Indo-US relationship is the ‘most defining’ partnership of the 21st century.
Thus, countries need to iron out their differences and should work together to achieve the objective of rule
based, stable and peaceful Indo-pacific.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 58
INDIA-RUSSIA
Introduction
• In words of PM Modi,” India has given top priority to its relationship with Russia. In this rapidly changing
world, our relationship has become more relevant.”
• At Sochi Summit,2018, the relationship was elevated to ‘Special and Privileged Partnership.’ India and Russia
relationship is based on ‘deep mutual trust’ , common foreign policy goal of multipolar world order and long
term partnership in the military, security and nuclear energy fields.
Historical overview
• During the cold war, Treaty of Peace and Friendship of 1971 was the manifestation of shared goals of the
two nations as well as a blueprint for the strengthening of regional and global peace and security.
• After disintegration of USSR: After the dissolution of the Soviet Union, India and Russia entered into a new
Treaty of Friendship and Cooperation in January 1993 and established a Strategic Partnership in 2000.
AREAS OF COOPERATION
Defence
• Arms import: Russia accounts for 58% of total arms imports by India followed by Israel and USA.
• Share strategic technology: Russia is one of the few nations willing to share strategic technology with India.
S-400 defence system deal also highlight India’s desire to maintain strategic autonomy.
• Partner in Brahmos: Russia has leased Akula class submarine to India and also an important partner in
Brahmos missile system development.
• Both countries also conduct annual tri-service exercise INDRA.
Trade
• Trade between Russia and India amounted to US $10.11 billion in 2019–20 and both countries have
invested in each other’s oil and gas sectors. They have set a bilateral trade target at $30 billion by 2025.
• Strategic Economic Dialogue: India-Russia started Strategic Economic Dialogue in 2018. It has focus on six
core areas of cooperation, namely, Transport Infrastructure; Agriculture; Small and Medium Business
support; Digital Transformation and Frontier Technologies; Trade, Banking, Finance, and Industry; and
Tourism & Connectivity.
• India also participated in Eastern Economic Forum and extended $1billion line of credit for development
of far right region of Russia.
• Maritime route: Recently, maritime route from Chennai to Vladivostok has also been proposed. It would
reduce time to reach Russian far east by 16 days.
Energy
• Natural gas: Russia has one of the largest reserves of Natural Gas in the world. India’s ONGC videsh has
acquired 20% stakes in Sakhalin oil and gas plant.
• In the St. Petersburg Declaration, both countries agreed for joint exploration of hydrocarbons in the Arctic
region. Russia’s ‘Pivot to Asia’ strategy and India’s Draft Arctic Policy both highlight convergence between 2
countries. The Northern Sea Route will further facilitate development of resources in the region.
• Nuclear Energy production: Russia is the only foreign country involved in Nuclear Energy production in India.
Both are also working to jointly develop nuclear energy plant in Bangladesh (Rooppur power plant).
o Kudankulam Nuclear Power Plant (KKNPP) is being built in India with Russian cooperation.
Geopolitical convergence
• Goal of Multipolar World Order: Both India-Russia have shared goal of Multipolar World Order. Both
countries are cooperating through BIMSTEC, SCO to realize this objective.
• On China- Russia continues to see China as potential strategic adversary in the future. Hence it is deepening
cooperation with countries like India, Vietnam, Indonesia etc. Russia also pushed for India’s entry into SCO
to contain Chinese influence. Similarly, India has expanded the scope Act East Policy to include Russia.
• Support for UNSC seat to India: Russia has also support India’s claim for permanent seat in UNSC and stood
by India on J&K issue thereby blocking Pakistan’s attempt to internationalize the issue.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 59
Space technology
• The former Soviet Union launched India’s first two satellites, Aryabhata and Bhaskar.
• Russia has also provided India Cryogenic technology to build heavy rockets.
ISSUES IN RELATIONSHIP
• Limited areas of cooperation: Post-cold war, India-Russia relations have become more transactional. It is
centred on military cooperation and spares whereas there is little progress in other aspects of relationship.
• USA-Russia dilemma: The deteriorating Russia-USA relations has introduced new element of discomfort as
India seeks to maintain its traditional relationship with Russia without spoiling its growing closeness to USA.
• DEFENCE- Though Russia still commands 56% of total arms imports by India, this figure is step down from
2010-14 when Russia’s share was 70%. The reasons for the decline are- India’s desire to diversification of its
defence imports, Growing India-US relationship, Sanctions on Russia under CAATSA, dissatisfaction in India
with post sales delivery and maintenance being offered by Russia.
• TRADE- The various issues in Indo-Russia trade are –
o Lack of involvement of private sector
o Poor connectivity- stalling of International North-South Transport corridor
o Weak banking links
o Cumbersome regulatory procedures on Both sides.
• INDO-PACIFIC
o Russia’s apprehensions: In the emerging construct of Indo-Pacific, India is growing close to USA. It
has left Russia concerned. Russia is apprehensive that the US would exert pressure on India’s foreign
policy choices and it would lose a friendly country and biggest buyer of its military equipments.
o Russian Foreign Minister Sergei Lavrov called Indo-Pacific as “an artificially imposed construct” being
promoted by the US, Australia and Japan.
• TERRORISM- India and Russia are calling for early finalization of the Comprehensive Convention on
International Terrorism.
RUSSIA-CHINA-PAKISTAN AXIS-
▪ The sanctions on Russia post Ukrain crisis by the West has pushed Russia closer to the China. Both countries
are working against the US and the West in Asia, Middle East and in Indo Pacific. Even the UNSC is divided
into P-3 and P-2.
▪ Russia-China trade: Apart from geopolitical convergence both countries also share economic
complementarities. Russia-China trade stands at $110 billion in 2019.
▪ Russia overtook Saudi Arabia as leading supplier of Oil to China. Both countries have also signed $400
Billion gas deal and proposed to connect EEU to the BRI project. China and Russia have inaugurated
the first cross border pipeline ‘power of Siberia’ to transport natural gas.
▪ Defence and technology: Russia also shares cutting edge technologies in defence production with China.
China has also received S-400 missile defence system from Russia.
▪ Russia has also removed Arms embargo on Pakistan in 2014 and since then both countries have also
conducted joint military exercise. Pakistan has already granted permission to Russia to use its Gwadar port
under the CPEC. Both Pakistan and Russia plan to elevate their bilateral relationship to strategic level.
▪ Pakistan is also important for Russia in context of Afghanistan and wider stability in central Asia and Caucasus.
US -RUSSIA TENSIONS-
▪ The key objectives of Russia’s foreign policy are- Honorable accommodation with West and multipolar world
order with Russia as swing state in global balance of power. It has no desire to play second fiddle to China.
However, sanctions from the US and West has crippled Russian economy and pushed it towards China.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 60
WAY FORWARD
• NEW AREAS OF COOPERATION-India Russia need to transform a 20th century partnership and make it fit for the
21st century. Apart from Energy and defence , both countries need to find new areas of cooperation such as trade
, connectivity etc. Creation of FTA between India and Eurasian Economic Union can also facilitate trade between
India-Russia.
• Balancing China- Russia is also apprehensive of growing Chinese influence in its periphery of Central Asia , India
being rising global power can help contain Chinese influence. For this both countries need to work together
through SCO platform.
• ARCTIC POLITICS: India can work with countries like Japan and South Korea in Far East region of Russia and
contain Chinese influence in Arctic politics which Russia also desires.
• CONNECTIVITY- India can also explore possibility of Russian involvement in Chabahar project to ensure access to
Afghanistan and central Asia.
• Both countries have shared interest in Multipolar world order. Both can work in global platforms to avoid the
new cold war between the USA and China with the help of like-minded countries.
• REDUCING US-Russia tensions- India being a great power will certainly balance both Russia and US for promoting
a peaceful global order. India can leverage its warm relations with both US and Russia can help ensure “Cold
Peace” between 2 countries. India can also help in establishing detente on critical issues like Iran’s nuclear crisis,
Indo-Pacific geopolitics, Ukrainian fiasco or the Afghan impasse.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 61
• 2+2 Dialogue:
o On the lines of 2+2 dialogue with the United States, India and Russia have decided to establish
dialogue on the same pattern, to add further momentum to the strategic partnership between the
two countries
CONCLUSION
• Russia retains its position as one of the great powers and has rich natural resources and history of mastery
over science and technology. Thus Steps to improve the economic partnership and charting of a clear
future plan of action should be a priority for India to moderate Russia’s tilt towards China. Russia
would also benefit from keeping Indian concerns in mind so as to not damage a long -standing
partnership with an emerging power.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 62
INDIA-CHINA RELATIONS
PYQ
1. With respect to the South China sea, maritime territorial disputes and rising tension affirm the need for
safeguarding maritime security to ensure freedom of navigation and over flight throughout the region. In
this context, discuss the bilateral issues between India and China. (2014)
• “India Conquered and dominated China culturally for 20 centuries without ever having to send a single soldier
across her border.” - Hu Shih
• “China is India’s largest foreign policy challenge” - Shashi Tharoor
• India-China relations are a journey from ‘Inch towards Miles’. INCH is ‘India-China’, towards MILES is
‘Millennium of Exceptional Synergy’. - PM Modi
INTRODUCTION
China is India’s largest neighbour. It is among India’s largest trade partner, supplier for many critical ingredients in
strategic industries and a partner in many issues of global concern such as Climate Change. However, being the
world’s largest army, a nuclear power, 2nd largest economy and a totalitarian regime, it is also considered to be a
formidable competitor to India’s global aspirations. Relations with China have always been central to India’s Foreign
Policy in both crests (Panchsheel) and troughs (1962 war, Doklam stand-off, Galwan Valley clash). China is thus
considered one of India’s most formidable Foreign Policy Changes.
AREAS OF RELATIONSHIP
Convergence:
• International Cooperation Organizations: Both are members of Shanghai Cooperation Organization, East Asia
Summit, RIC (Russia India China grouping), BRICS and G-20
• Trade: China is among the top 2 trade partners of India and largest in Asia. Bilateral trade is worth over $80
billion.
• New Economic Order reform: Both support World Bank and IMF reforms.
• Support WTO Reform and strengthening rules based multilateral trading order
• Climate Change: both support principle of Common but Differentiated Responsibilities
• Financial Mechanisms: India and China are prominent stakeholders in AIIB and NDB
• Energy Security: Against Asian Premium
• Piracy and armed robbery
• Terror cooperation as both countries face threats from extremist outfits. SCO RATS is a prime example.
• Sustainable Development Goals
Divergence:
• Border issues – India-China border is unsettled in Aksai Chin, Ladakh, Arunachal and Doklam. Recent military
clash in Galwan Valley is widely attributed to this.
• Geopolitical struggle: Both are locked in Geopolitical struggle for domination in Asia and Globe
o India is widely seen as being in the Western Camp with its participation in Quad and growing
security cooperation with USA, Japan and Australia
o China-Pakistan alliance and China-Russia quasi-alliance puts China in the opposite camp as India.
• China is opposed to UNSC Reform – Permanent seat for India
• Chinese support to Pakistan - Kashmir, Terrorism, Hafiz Sayeed.
• Massive Trade Imbalance: India runs its largest trade imbalance with China.
• China opposes India’s NSG entry
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 63
• BRI and CPEC: India has concerns over the project running through Pakistan Occupied Kashmir which India
claims. Further China seeks to expand its hard and soft power in South Asia and Africa, putting it in conflict with
Indian interests (violation of India’s territorial integrity).
• Forays in South Asia: China has made heavy investments and engaged in strategic-military cooperation with
nearly all South Asian nations. It engages in debt trap diplomacy and neo-colonialism to ensure fulfilment of its
strategic interests.
• Water cooperation: China refuses to share hydrological data over flow in Brahmaputra River. Further Chinese
aggressive dam building operations in Brahmaputra can have serious repercussions for India’s North East.
• Dalai Lama: China protests against Indian asylum to Dalai Lama, religious head of Tibet.
• India opposes Chinese Aggression in Indian Ocean Region and East China Sea
• Kashmir: China has called India’s moves on Article 370 as altering the status quo ante while India calls it an
internal matter.
India-China Cooperation
• Wuhan Consensus: Recognized that both India are China are factors for stability in the world. They resolved to
not let disagreements become disputes.
• Signed Strategic Partnership in 2003
• Border agreements
o 1993 Border Peace and Tranquillity Agreement
o 1996 Agreement on Confidence-Building Measures in the Military Field Along the LAC
o 2005 Protocol on Modalities for the Implementation of Confidence-Building Measures in the Military
Field Along the LAC
o 2012 Agreement on the Establishment of a Working Mechanism for Consultation and Coordination on
India-China Border Affairs
o 2013 Border Defense Cooperation Agreement.
• Wuhan and Chennai informal summits
• China India Plus cooperation:
o BCIM Economic Corridor
o Rohingya
o Afghanistan
o Iran
o Nepal
• 2020 was designated as Year of India- China Cultural and People to People Exchanges.
Conclusion
Xi Jinping, the Chinese premier said at Mamallapuram Summit: “to achieve the ‘Dragon and Elephant Dance’ is the
only correct choice for China and India. In line with the same it is important that both India and China resolve their
differences and cooperate to usher in the Asian century as agreed in Wuhan Consensus.
ISSUES IN NEWS
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 64
India’s Concerns
• Threat of escalation of standoff into larger military conflict
• Loss of territory in Ladakh sector
• Loss of lives - 20 Indian soldiers killed
• Derailing of the India-China peace process eg. Wuhan and Chennai informal summits
• Diversion of resources to ensure peace along the border amidst a global pandemic - men, equipment and
money.
This was followed by the First Phase of Disengagement along the Line of Actual Control in February 2021. However
much of the standoff still persists as of April 2021 in Depsang Plains, Hot Springs-Gogra, and Demchok.
India’s Response to Chinese Aggression
• India held Chinese ‘directly responsible’ for the violence. Foreign Minister logded a strong diplomatic
protest as well.
• To boost its military muscle, it approved the purchase of 33 Russian fighter jets and upgrades to 59 war
planes. It also expedited the acquisition of Rafale fight jets from France.
• Plans to boost infrastructure along China border
• Economic measures
o India banned over 100 Chinese-origin apps including popular ones such as Cam Scanner and
Tik-Tok under Section 69A of Information Technology Act 2000.
o Government introduced changes in FDI rules which required ‘prior approval’ from the Central
government for foreign investments from countries bordering India. This was majorly
considered to be aimed at China
o Certain ministries (for eg. Ministry of Road Transport and Highways) and state governments
announced that Chinese companies will not be allowed to take part in projects.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 65
Way Forward
While keeping the Wuhan Consensus in mind, both sides must amicably try to resolve differences via dialogue and
reach a practical and sustainable solution to end the standoff. From a long-term perspective, resolving the
difference in perception of LAC and reaching permanent solution to solve the border issue is imperative for peaceful
relations between the two Asian Giants.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 66
Implication
The excess claims reflect Chinese willingness to maximize old claims for territorial gains and pressurize India
geopolitically.
Way Forward
India must constructively engage China in dialogue while maintaining .
Increased Chinese Transgressions Reasons for transgressions
• 2019 and 2020 witness a sharp upsurge in incursions along the • Un-demarcated nature of LAC
LAC. • Undulating terrain
• 2019 saw a more than 75% rise in transgressions as compared to • Different interpretations of LAC on
2018. both sides
• Most of them took place in Western Sector i.e Ladakh. • Aggressive Chinese nationalism
• Aerial transgressions also saw a marked rise in 2019. under Premier Xi.
• A similar spike was seen during the Doklam standoff after which
the Wuhan consensus was reached between PM Modi and
Premier Xi.
Response
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 67
• Both sides have denied the offer stating that given various high-level mechanisms between the two sovereign
nations, both of them were capable of resolving the issue.
Way Forward
• Despite the merits, Third Party Mediation must only be treated as a last resort in a crisis due to the above-
mentioned concerns. Until then, India must seek to resolve the standoff with its own mechanisms.
Why in News ?
• During a virtual meet of Global Environment Facility (GEF) to discuss aid to Bhutan’s Sakteng Wildlife
Sanctuary, China laid claim to
740 sq km area (including the
sanctuary) in Bhutan for the
first time.
• China then opposed the
proposal to grant aid to the
disputed area. But the GEF
Council passed the resolution
despite Chinese opposition.
• Bhutan rejected the
Chinese claim saying that area
was not disputed as China
never mentioned it in 24
rounds of boundary talks between China and Bhutan so far.
India’s Concerns
• Pressure tactic on India: Coming in the midst of the tense border standoff between India and China, the
Chinese move is largely seen as a pressure tactic on India as Sakteng Wildlife Sanctuary borders the disputed
province of Arunachal Pradesh. The same move (to target Bhutan) was used by Chinese during the Doklam
plateau.
• Endangers Indian interests: Further, any package deal that grants China territory in West Bhutan,
endangers Indian interests due to its proximity to Siliguri Corridor (India’s Chicken’s Neck).
• India’s diplomatic edge in Bhutan may be tapered due to Indian interests being the only roadblock to an
otherwise lucrative deal with China.
• Greater Chinese engagement with Bhutan: The deal may open doors for greater Chinese engagement with
Bhutan, which is the only South Asian neighbour to resolutely stand by India in the Doklam crisis and reject
the BRI.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 68
• In 1996, China had offered a package deal to Bhutan - “to exchange the valleys to the north, with an area
of 495 square kilometers, with the pasture land to the west, totaling 269 square kilometers” (Bhutanese
King in the Bhutan National Assembly).
• However due to Indian reservations over the deal, Bhutan did not accept it.
• In 2020, China has after raising claims in Eastern Sector again offered a package deal, similar to the 1996
deal. The details of the deal, however, are kept secret.
Indian Reponse
India has not officially responded to the new Chinese package deal as it doesn’t want to be seen as interfering in
Bhutan’s internal matters. However it is reportedly keeping a keen watch on the situation.
Way Forward
India must continue building on its special relationship with Bhutan by means of developmental aid and special
unilateral concessions. It must bilaterally convey its concerns regarding the deal but must desist from taking any
‘big brotherly’ steps regarding the same.
China’s Railway Near Arunachal Border
Why In News ?
China has begun work on the strategically important high-speed railway link between near Arunachal Pradesh
border).
• The project connects Chengdu in Sichuan Province and Nyingchi in Tibet.
• This would be its second major rail link with Tibet, first one being Qinghai-Tibet railway line.
Implications
• Consolidation of Chinese hold over Tibet It is considered a major step in consolidating the Chinese
government’s hold on the border region of Tibet and a major boost to socio-economic development of the
region.
• It will also aid in swift movement of troops and resources in case of crises such as Doklam stand off or
internal unrest in Tibet.
• Alongside the national goals, it is also seen as a major step in connecting China to South Asia, especially the
Trans-Himalayan Multi-Dimensional Connectivity Network project which is the Himalayan leg of BRI
involving Nepal.
India’s Concerns
• Chinese aggression : Heavy Infrastructure development close to an area claimed by China (Arunachal
Pradesh) is a sign of Chinese aggression and disregard for Indian sensitivities especially in the backdrop
of recent border standoff.
• Poor linkages from Indian side: Vastly improved connectivity and infrastructure on Chinese side is a
stark contrast to the poor linkages on Indian side of the border in Arunachal Pradesh where even
strategic and large towns like Tawang lack basic rail connectivity.
• Undermine India’s advantage: The project is also a part of larger Chinese plans to ramp up connectivity
and infrastructure linkage with Nepal which can seriously undermine India’s strategic advantage with
Nepal.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 69
• Work in progress: the construction of 57 roads, construction and refurbishing of 32 helipads, development
of 47 outposts, and 12 staging camps for Indo-Tibetan Border Police (ITBP) along with the construction of
18-foot tracks in Arunachal Pradesh.
Way Forward
• China’s actions despite being near the disputed border are well within its sovereign rights.
• India must seek to match the neighbour’s actions by continuing to develop strong connectivity linkages.
Basic railway connections to all major towns along the border and good road connectivity to all villages is a
must.
• Both sides must engage in a transparent consensual approach in developing border infrastructure to allay
mistrust.
Hydrological Status
• Five major rivers flowing through India find their origins in China. They can be divided into two major
groups:
o Brahmaputra River System: Siang
(Brahmaputra), Lohit and Subansiri
o Indus River System: Indus and Satluj
• China, courtesy of its sovereignty over
Tibetan plateau, is also the upper riparian
controller on 7 of South Asia’s largest rivers –
Indus, Ganga, Brahmaputra, Irrawaddy,
Salween, Yangtze and Mekong.
• Run off from Tibetan Plateau forms the
largest volume from a single point in the world.
• Both nations face significant water stress
- India has 16% of population but only 4% water
resources while China has 20% population but only 7% of water resources. The two nations are also
industrial and agricultural giants.
Water Cooperation
• There is no institutional agreement on water sharing between the two.
• There is only Expert Level Mechanism (ELM) in 2006 to discuss various issues related to trans-border
rivers
• India and China have a water data sharing agreement. But China has stopped sharing data after the
Doklam standoff of 2017.
• In 2018, an MOU was signed between the two nations on sharing hydrological information about
Brahmaputra River in flood season (May to October) by China to India. China is also obligated to share
data if waters exceed pre-agreed levels in non-flood season.
Concerns
• Weaponisation of water flow: China has the capability to weaponise the upper riparian status by
altering the flow using its mega-dams.
• Any major hydro-power project downstream (Indian territory) cannot be planned without an assured
water cooperation agreement between the countries.
• China’s status as upper-riparian limits India’s ability to deal with water cooperation issues with
Bangladesh and Pakistan where India is the upper riparian.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 70
o India’s plans to utilize the full allocation to it under Indus Water Treaty as means of keeping
Pakistan in check can be spoiled by Chinese actions upstream.
Way Forward
• Finalizing a water cooperation agreement: There is an urgent need for finalizing a water cooperation
agreement between the two nations which addresses water data sharing, cooperation on dam building
and agreements on minimum water flow downstream.
• IWT as a guide: The renowned Indus Water Treaty should serve as a valuable guide as to water
cooperation between two rival nations.
• Politicization of water must be avoided at any costs.
Once considered the strategic backyard of India, South Asia has recently been a theatre of rising Chinese influence.
• Pakistan:
▪ China-Pakistan relationship considered to be all-weather alliance
▪ China has heavily invested in Pakistan via the China Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC)
▪ China also has a substantial stake in the strategic Gwadar port.
▪ China provides diplomatic support to Pakistan in the UN and FATF.
• Bangladesh:
▪ China is the largest source of defense imports for Bangladesh
▪ China is also its largest trade partner. It also grants Bangladesh duty free access to over 97% of traded
goods.
▪ It is financing 25 energy projects along with Bangladesh’s second Nuclear Power plant.
▪ China has also extended technical support for Bangabandhu-1, Bangladesh’s 1st communication satellite.
• Sri Lanka:
▪ Sri Lanka forms a major leg of the maritime component of BRI. Hambantota Port is one of the biggest
projects under BRI.
▪ Due to debt-trap diplomacy, China has also gained control of strategic assets such as Hambantota Port.
China is one of the largest creditors of Sri Lanka.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 71
▪ China is one of its largest trade partners and source of defense equipment.
▪ China has provided crucial diplomatic support to Sri Lanka in the UN Human Rights Commission after the
Civil War between LTTE and the Sri Lankan Government.
• Nepal:
▪ Nepal is the host for Himalayan leg of the BRI in three corridors – Kosi, Gandak and Karnali.
▪ China has granted access to 7 land ports to Nepal for it to escape the excessive dependence on India for
connectivity to the outside world.
▪ Major investments in projects such as Pokhara airport, Kathmandu-Lumnini rail link, Lhasa Shigatse Rail Link.
▪ Second largest trade partner and largest source of FDI.
• Maldives
▪ China owns over 70% of Maldives debt and has heavily invested in infrastructure such as Male Airport and
Sinamale Bridge.
▪ A Chinese company has received a 50-year lease to the Feydhoo Finolhu Island
▪ With the return of the civilian democratic government to Maldives, many grand infrastructure projects have
been stalled or cancelled due to concerns over Debt-trap and unviability of the projects.
Way Forward
• India needs to ramp up its development assistance to its neighbourhood while improving on its delivery deficit.
Further, it should seek to cooperate jointly with China in the neighbourhood to alleviate poverty in the region.
INDIA –TAIWAN
Why in News ?
• Two Indian MPs attended (virtually) the swearing-in of the Taiwanese President for the first time. Coming in
the aftermath of the clashes in the Galwan Valley, it is seen as a change in approach towards Taiwan.
About Taiwan
• After the victory of the Communist Party of China (CPC) in the Chinese Civil War in 1949, the Kuomintang Party
escaped to Taiwan and CPC established a new nation, People’s Republic of China. The Kuomintang established
the Republic of China in Taiwan.
• Both the CPC and Kuomintang party claim to be legitimate rulers of the whole of China (including Taiwan).
• Initially Taiwan was recognized as a separate nation by many including the US. However, as China progressed,
many nations only accorded recognition to the People's Republic of China (as per One China Policy).
• One China Policy states that any nation wanting to establish diplomatic ties with the People’s Republic of China
must sever all ties with Taiwan and recognize that there is only one China.
• Today, 179 out of 193 members of the UN do not maintain diplomatic ties with Taiwan.
• Taiwan is not a member of the UN and WHO. It is a member of WTO as a member economy under the name
‘Chinese Taipei’.
• Taiwan is today's Asia’s 5th largest economy. It is also the most populous state and largest economy outside
the UN system.
• It is a global leader in chip manufacturing and IT hardware.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 72
• In the Cold War Era, ties were remote as Taiwan was seen as part of the Western bloc while India was Non-
Aligned.
• After the end of the Cold War, the policy was reoriented and unofficial relations were set up with the
establishment of India-Taipei Association in Taipei, Taiwan.
• Taipei Economic and Cultural Centre was also set up in 1995 as Taiwan Government’s office in India which
serves as its unofficial embassy.
• The relations are continuously improving with growing trade and cultural linkages.
Concerns
• India-Taiwan ties are limited by the constraints of One China Policy.
• Any rapid improvement in ties risks earning the displeasure of China with whom both the nations share
substantial economic ties.
• Trade relations with Taiwan are still under-exploited with India forming just around 1% of Taiwan’s total
trade.
Way Forward
• Taiwanese companies must be encouraged to set up manufacturing facilities in India. India’s massive industrial
base and cheap labor would complement Taiwan’s technical expertise.
• Taiwan’s response to COVID-19 has earned it global praise. India must seek cooperation with it in the domain
of healthcare.
• Tourism, particularly Buddhist heritage tourism, is a potential sector for further cooperation.
Conclusion
• India must seek to expand and diversify its relations with Taiwan – both in trade and strategically while being
mindful of the Chinese angle.
Tibet
Why in News ?
• The US Senate passed the Tibetan Policy and Support Act.
Tibet’s History
• Tibet is the world's highest and largest plateau located in the north of Himalayas.
• Throughout history, Tibet has either been independent or under loose sovereignty of China.
• China conventionally views Tibet as the palm, and Ladakh, Nepal, Sikkim, Bhutan and Arunachal Pradesh as the
five fingers.
• In British era, Tibet was considered as a buffer against Imperial Russia. British adopted a forward policy to mark
its hold on the region. It existed as a weak independent state in the early 20th century.
• Upon the rise of the People's Republic of China, the People’s Liberation Army occupied Tibet in 1950-51. This
led the 14th Dalai Lama (spiritual head of Tibet) to flee and seek asylum in India since then.
• A peaceful movement for autonomy has been going on since then from outside Tibet.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 73
India-Tibet Relations
• India recognizes Chinese claims over Tibet.
• On the other hand, it also provides asylum to lakhs of Tibetan refugees and also to the Dalai Lama.
• India also provides unofficial assistance to the Tibetan Government in Exile which operates out of India.
• India provides education & healthcare support for Tibetan refugees along with lifelong work visas.
• Seven Indian institutes also offer PG courses in Tibetology.
• India’s policy has drawn ire from Chinese government who view Tibetan movement as a separatist tendency
but has drawn worldwide praise for India’s humanitarian approach.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 74
INDIA-EU
Introduction
India-EU relations date to the early 1960s, with India being amongst the first countries to establish diplomatic
relations with the European Economic Community. India and EU share various complementaries such as pluralistic
society, market economy and political democracy.
Views
• S. Jaishankar-
Recognising that we live
in a rebalancing,
multipolar world, both
India and the EU should
aim to build a more
‘compact’ relationship to
engage with this new
reality.
• Stefania Benaglia- Post
Galwan Clash India is
waking up to the fact that
in today’s fragmented
world, the power of any
aspiring global player
depends on the number
and quality of its bi- and
multilateral
relationships. In this
context, the EU is a useful
partner India can rely on. At the same time, the EU needs a strong partnership with India to meet its leadership
objectives of becoming a global actor and tackling climate change.
Why in news- 15th annual summit in July 2020
• India and the European Union (EU) held their 15th annual summit in July 2020, after a gap of more than two
years.
• During the leaders meeting in May 2021, India and EU relaunched FTA talks, signed comprehensive
connectivity partnership.
Outcome of the leaders meet in May 2021
• Resuming BTIA talks- India and the European Union agreed on to relaunch free trade negotiations by
resuming talks that were suspended in 2013 for the Bilateral Trade and Investment Agreement (BTIA).
• Connectivity- India and EU adopted Connectivity Partnership document outlining plans to cooperate on
digital and infrastructure projects, and signed the contract for the second tranche of $150 million from the
EU for the Pune Metro rail project.
• Vaccine cooperation: The leaders meeting also discussed Covid recovery plans and vaccine cooperation.
Leaders also highlighted the need to ramp up the production and delivery of Sars-Cov2 vaccines through
greater investment.
• Investing in India-EU Strategic Partnership- The leaders discussed the need for a reformed, renewed and
effective multilateral system, which is fit for tackling current and future global challenges and reflects
contemporary realities. For this India and EU agreed to advance the implementation of the actions set out
in the India-EU Roadmap 2025.
Outcome of annual summit in July 2020-
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 75
- A Roadmap to 2025 has been endorsed between India and EU as a common roadmap to guide joint
action and further strengthen the Strategic Partnership over the next five years.
- safer, cleaner and more stable world-Both have a common interest in each other's security,
prosperity and sustainable development. They can contribute jointly to a safer, cleaner and more
stable world.
2. Trade Pact:
- Both sides have agreed to launch a high-level trade dialogue to foster progress on “balanced,
ambitious and mutually beneficial” trade and investment agreements, address trade irritants and
discuss supply chain linkages.
3. Defence and Security Cooperation:
- Both sides agreed to launch a new maritime security dialogue.
- The EU and India agreed to cooperate in counter-piracy military operation in the western Indian
Ocean.
- India’s Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) and Europol launched negotiations to combat
organised crime and terrorism.
4. Civil Nuclear Cooperation-A civil nuclear cooperation agreement was signed which will focus on research
and development cooperation for peaceful uses of nuclear energy and on new ways of using nuclear energy
5. Both side signed A joint declaration on circular economy and resource efficiency
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 76
Developmental partnership-
• India-EU development cooperation spans several decades and encompasses issues like health, education,
poverty reduction, water and sanitation.
o Since 1976, the European Commission has committed 2 billion euro (US$ 2.4 billion) in development
cooperation to India.
o Since 2014, the India–EU partnership has changed from the donor-recipient paradigm to that of
cooperation through several instruments such as loans from European Investment Bank.
• Sustainable Development: Another key area of development cooperation is the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable
Development. India and the EU are working closely on several fronts that cover the Sustainable Development
Goals (SDGs) — such as the smart cities initiative (SDG 11), clean water and sanitation (SDG 6) and climate
action (SDG 13).
o Climate change: The two have become key stakeholders in global efforts to combat climate change
through the framework of Clean Energy and Climate Change Partnership, 2017
Science and Technology cooperation
• Both sides have an Agreement on Scientific and Technological Cooperation to expand scientific and
technological cooperation aimed at strengthening their collaboration in this area in the next five years(2020-
2025).
• Horizon 2020: Both have initiated joint research projects-‘Horizon 2020’ related to climate change and polar
research.
Defence and security cooperation
• Shared objective: EU and India have agreed to strengthen cooperation and work towards tangibles outcomes
on shared objectives such as counterpiracy, counter terrorism - including counter radicalisation - and cyber
security.
• The new Information Fusion Centre – Indian Ocean Region in New Delhi (IFC – IOR) has recently linked up
with the Maritime Security Centre - Horn of Africa (MSC – HOA) established by the EU NAVFOR Atalanta
• Combating terrorism-India and the EU adopted a declaration to counter terrorism at the 14th India-EU
summit.
• Counter-piracy operations: Both sides conducted the maiden Indian Navy and European Union Naval Force
(EUNAVFOR) exercise in the Gulf of Aden in June 2021. It was aimed at enhancing cooperation in counter-
piracy operations and protection of vessels deployed under the charter of World Food Programme.
People to people
• Migration & Mobility- Both sides have signed Joint Declaration on Common Agenda on Migration and
Mobility (CAMM)
Parliaments, Civil Society
• A Delegation for Relations with India (D-IN) was formally constituted in the European Parliament (EP) in 2007
to follow relations with India
• India-EU Think Tank Twinning Initiative- the exchange of ideas on issues of core relevance for the India-EU
Education & Culture
• Over 50,000 Indian students are currently enrolled in various European universities, many of whom are
supported by the EU's Erasmus Mundus scholarship programme for higher education.
Multilateral forums
• India and the EU have emerged as important stakeholders in the multilateral global system. India and EU are
partners in climate change negotiations, G-20 etc. Support of EU is critical for India’s claim on permanent
seat of UNSC.
Issues in India EU relation
• Trade-currently India accounts for only 1.9% of EU total trade in goods in 2019, well behind China (13.8%)
• Broad-based Trade and Investment Agreement, (Covered below)
• While India’s bilateral relations with EU member states — like Germany, France and the UK —
developed substantially, it did not lead to the expected intensification of ties with the grouping.
• EU on CAA and article 370: The European Parliament was critical of both the Indian government’s decision
to scrap Jammu and Kashmir’s special status in 2019 and the Citizenship (Amendment) Act.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 77
• Protectionism: The EU is critical about India’s “protectionist” measures on tariffs and the termination of
bilateral investment treaties with EU member states
• Rise of anti-migration and ultra-nationalist sentiment in Europe after refugee crisis and rise in trade
protectionism and resentment against globalization has strengthened anti EU sentiments as manifested in
Brexit.
• Green pass: Recently EU has initiated “Green pass’ system and excluded Indian Covishield. EU’s drug
regulator, the European Medicines Agency (EMA), has approved Vaxzevria — as AstraZeneca’s shot is known
outside India but Covishield has not yet figured in its approval list as yet despite being approved by the World
Health Organisation.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 78
• Bilateral investment treaties: The EU is also uneasy about India’s termination in 2016 of existing bilateral
investment treaties (BIT), with countries like France and the UK to renegotiate older pacts on the basis of a new
model of the BIT approved in 2015.
• Lack of political will-The differences that arose during the trade and investment talks were too wide to be
overcome without a political push from the higher level.
• The arrest and trial of Italian marines in India led to a backlash in the EU. The ban on Indian Alphonso mangoes
and four other vegetables due to the finding of pests invited a strong reaction from India. Both these issues with
different levels of gravity led to the deterioration of bilateral relations in the last decade and indirectly impacted
the revival of trade talks.
Way forward
• Negotiators from both sides must look beyond the multiple differences to focus on the
complementarities.
• India and the EU should begin by negotiating less difficult sectors and aim for greater cooperation
in new areas like green technology and artificial intelligence, which could lead to a more balanced
outcome in the talks.
• India’s pharmaceutical manufacturing capabilities coupled with access to European healthcare
technologies can provide new avenues for enhancing partnerships and promoting innovation
between the partners
Conclusion
The conclusion of the BTIA will not only strengthen India and the EU’s global standing but can also provide
an opportunity to further integrate their partnership on various shared goals like green economy,
sustainable development and resource efficiency.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 79
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 80
• Sustainable development: It also contains sustainable development provisions including legally binding rules
on climate, labour and human rights.
• Removal of tariffs: At the core of the EUVFTA is a near complete removal of tariffs between the EU and
Vietnam, including the elimination of more than 99% of customs duties within 10 years. Immediately upon
entry into force, 65% of EU exports to Vietnam and 71% of Vietnamese exports to the EU will be duty free.
• In service sector, many of the concessions offered by each party exceed those provided under the WTO trade
in services agreement, including packaging services, building-cleaning services, interdisciplinary R&D
services, and nursing services.
Effects on India
• India’s exports of footwear, garments, marine products and furniture to the European Union stand to be the
worst-hit.
• In the apparel sector India will need to pay 9 percent duty (in the EU), while Vietnam will not pay any duty.
• EU may pressurize India to expediate conclusion of BTIA and inclusion of issues such as government
procurement, labour standards and sustainability which India finds difficult to accept.
• Advantageous location for investments: The EVFTA will also make Vietnam a more advantageous location
for investments moving out of China due to the China-US trade war, instead of India.
WAY FORWARD
Foreign Policy
• Intensified dialogue and deliberations, a realignment of trade policies and emerging prospects of
collaboration in the post-pandemic world provide India and the EU an opportunity to transform their
economic ties into a robust strategic partnership.
Security
• Focusing on exchange on strategic priorities, security issues, crisis management and peacekeeping.
• Strengthen cooperation in non-proliferation and disarmament, maritime security, counter-terrorism and
cyber security.
Trade and investment, Business & Economy
• Export potential: India has an untapped export potential of $39.9 billion in the EU and Western Europe. Both
sides need to optimally use the Investment Facilitation Mechanism (IFM) established in 2017 to promote
and facilitate EU investment flows into India
Climate change and clean energy
• Clean Energy: Strengthen the India-EU Clean Energy and Climate Partnership agreed at the 2016 Summit
and prepare and implement a new work program.
• Low greenhouse gas emission: Additional focus should be on safe and sustainable low greenhouse gas
emission energy security, integration of electric vehicle charging infrastructure in the energy grid, energy
research & innovation.
• Healthcare: The linking of research efforts can help India and the EU leverage their capacities to find
innovative solutions for healthcare. Overall, this will also present new opportunities for joint ventures and
enhanced trade between the two sides.
• Multilaterally, India and the EU can work to strengthen the World Health Organisation and bring together
various stakeholders, health experts and global economic institutions to prepare a coordinated approach to
handle the current and any future health crisis.
Conclusion
• A close bilateral relationship between India and the EU has far reaching economic, political, and strategic
implications for the world order in crisis. Both sides must recognise this potential and use strong political will
to expand bilateral ties. As outlined in the EU's India strategy, which was adopted in 2018, India and the EU
should expand their relationship beyond a "trade prism," acknowledging significant geopolitical and strategic
convergences.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 81
INDIA-JAPAN RELATION
UPSC Question:
The time has come for India and Japan to build a strong contemporary relationship, one involving global
and strategic partnerships that will have a great significance for Asia and the world as a whole.’
Comment. (CSE mains -2019)
Swami Vivekananda, Gurudev Rabindranath Tagore, Mahatma Gandhi, Neta ji Subhash Chandra Bose..... many
Indians have contributed in strengthening India's relationship with Japan. And that's why after World War-2, India
and Japan's relationship grew stronger.- PM Modi
Iit would not be a surprise if in another 10 years, Japan-India relations overtake Japan-U.S. and Japan-China
relations. --- Shinzo Abe, book Toward a Beautiful Country
Relations between Japan and India have the biggest potential in the world... A strong Japan benefits India and a
strong India benefits Japan.” “I believe until and unless India and Japan have strong relations Asia can never
develop.- PM Modi
In my opinion, if all our rich and educated men once go and see Japan, their eyes will be opened.
— Swami Vivekananda
Why In The News: Indo-Japanese partnership during COVID-19 relevant for global stability: PM Modi
Introduction:
● Traditionally strong: India–Japan relations have traditionally been strong. The people of India and Japan have
engaged in cultural exchanges, primarily as a result of Buddhism.
● The ideals of democracy like tolerance, pluralism and civil freedom are the same in both of these countries.
They are one of the oldest democracies in Asia, having a high degree of congruence of political, economic
and strategic interests, view each other as partners that have responsibility for, and are capable of,
responding to global and regional challenges.
● Aid: India is the largest recipient of Japanese aid. India is a big market for Japanese firms. Japanese firms
were some of the first firms to invest in India.
Background:
● Diplomatic ties between India and Japan were established in 1952 with the signing of the Peace Treaty post
World War II.
● The 1952 Peace Treaty between India and Japan was followed by a Cultural Agreement signed in 1956
between the two countries.
● A Comprehensive Economic Partnership was concluded in 2011 for economic and commercial relations.
● In 2016, Japan announced its Country Assistance Policy providing Official Development Assistance (ODA) to
build India’s infrastructure.
● Visa on arrival: In 20218, India announced a “visa on arrival” scheme for all Japanese travellers.
● Logistics agreement: In 2020, India and Japan signed a logistics agreement which will allow the Armed Forces
of India and Japan sides to coordinate in services and supplies issues.
o This agreement is known as the Acquisition and Cross-Servicing Agreement (ACSA).
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 82
● Collaboration in Initiatives: In April 2021, India, Japan and Australia formally launched the Supply Chain
Resilience Initiative (SCRI). It will help in a move to counter China’s dominance of the supply chain in the
Indo-Pacific region.
Areas of Cooperation:
Covid-19 Pandemic:
India and Japan had previously agreed to work together with other countries to deal with post COVID-19 related
challenges with the India-Japan special strategic and global partnership as the basis.
○ Emergency aid: Japan is extending its emergency aid of nearly $14.8 million, which includes
additional medical supplies to India to help its “friend” fight the Covid-19 pandemic
○ They are further calling for investigation into the origins of COVID-19 virus.
○ The India-US-Japan-Australia Quadrilateral initiative, or Quad, at its maiden summit decided to
build a first-of-its-kind joint vaccine supply chain to address the current and any future pandemic
situations in the Indo-Pacific region.
Indo-Pacific:
● Geopolitical interests in the Indo-Pacific region: Together, India and Japan act as a anchor of the two ends
of the Indo-Pacific.
o Given their growing concerns about China, it’s going to be a continued progress building on landmark
past agreements for Indo-Pacific region.
● Countering Rising China: Analysts feel the looming presence of China across the strategic landscapes of India
and Japan have guided the strategy to enhance collaboration in an accelerated manner.
o China due to the nine-dash line, has developed conflicts with Indonesia, Malaysia, Australia,
Philippines, Vietnam and Taiwan.
o The tensions along the Line of Actual Control (LAC) in 2020 had posed the biggest national security
challenge to India in at least 20 years.
o The clashes in Galwan Valley in eastern Ladakh have claimed 20 Indian lives, the first incident of
fatalities on the India-China border in 45 years.
● Maintaining Rule base order: The two countries' vision for the Indo-Pacific is based on a rules-based order
that respects sovereignty and territorial integrity of nations, ensures freedom of navigation and overflight as
well as unimpeded lawful commerce.
● Japan’s Free and Open Indo-Pacific: It is a concept given by Japanese PM’s during their India Visit.
o Which aim prepares Japan to deal with the fast changing global and regional order and threats from
China and North Korea.
o It includes creating a “free and open” Asia-Pacific region which connects parts of eastern Africa,
south Asia and southeast Asia with the western Pacific Ocean region and Japan.
Connectivity:
● The Asia-Africa Growth Corridor (AAGC): It is a joint collaboration of India-Japan, for Infrastructure
development in Asia-Africa region. The AAGC will give priority to development projects in health and
pharmaceuticals, agriculture and Agro-processing, disaster management and skill enhancement.
o The connectivity aspects of the AAGC will be supplemented with quality infrastructure.
o As per the vision document, the four key pillars of AAGC include:
▪ Enhancing Capacity and Skills
▪ Quality Infrastructure and Institutional Connectivity
▪ Development and Cooperation projects
▪ People-to-people partnership.
● Blue Dot Network: The BDN was formally announced on 4th November 2019 at the Indo-Pacific Business
Forum in Bangkok, Thailand. It is led by the USA along with Japan and Australia.
o Recently, The group of the US Senators, in a letter, has asked India to join the Blue Dot Network
(BDN) which will help India to make an impact on economic development through a various
international projects.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 83
o The Blue Dot Network (BDN) is a multi-stakeholder initiative formed by the United States, Japan,
and Australia to provide assessment and certification of infrastructure development projects
worldwide.
▪ On measures of financial transparency, environmental sustainability, and impact on
economic development, with the goal of mobilizing private capital to invest abroad.
● Developing infrastructure: All Across Asia and Africa in order to provide a counterweight to China both
countries are investing in infrastructure.
o They now have to find a more effective way of translating this convergence of goals into brick and
mortar projects that actually make a difference on the ground.
● Bilateral relationship for regional stability: Bilateral relationship between two countries have major value for
regional stability.
o Until and unless India and Japan have strong relations it is hard to give stability in Asia.
Defence:
● Security Cooperation: India and Japan signed a joint declaration on security cooperation signed in 2008. `It
proposed the establishment of meetings between defence ministers, military-to-military talks, navy-to-navy.
● Technical cooperation: Both sides worked to build military-technical cooperation (MTC) that increases
mutual dependence.
● Modernising Indian Arm force: Japan hopes to assist India in modernising military capabilities via its US-2
amphibian aircraft and Soryu submarines.
● Joint military drills: Exercise Dharma Guardian brought Indian Army and the Japanese Ground Self Defence
Forces (JGSDF) together in 2018.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 84
1. Air forces of both countries engage in Exercise Shinyuu Maitri, while coast guards through Exercise
Sahyog-Kaijin.
2. Japan also participated in Malabar naval exercises.
Space cooperation:
● In March 2019, India and Japan conducted their first Annual Bilateral Space Dialogue, for enhancing bilateral
cooperation in outer-space.
Bilateral Partnership:
● In Post-cold war time: In the Cold War time, both countries kept distance from each other. Reasons were
India’s distancing from the Japan–US alliance, Policy of non-alignment.
● After the collapse of the Soviet Union: Soviet union's collapse and a severe balance-of-payments crisis, Indian
leadership favoured closer ties with Japan.
● New Policy Initiative: In 1993 India announced the ‘Look East Policy’. India’s ‘special strategic and global
partnership’ with Japan is a grand strategy in the post-Cold War era.
o The ‘Act East Policy’ announced in November, 2014 is the upgrade of the “Look East Policy”.
o It is a diplomatic initiative to promote economic, strategic and cultural relations with the vast Asia-
Pacific region at different levels which further put impetus for better relationship build up with
Japan.
● Elevation of tie’s: In 2014 both elevated ties to ‘special strategic and global partnership,’
● 2+2 Arrangement: In 2016, India started ‘2 + 2’ arrangement for foreign and defence ministries. This was
elevated to the ministerial level three years later, signalling its special status.
● Covid19 pandemic: The partnership will help to tackle COVID-19 pandemic. For a pandemic situation the
Supply Chain Resilience Initiative between India, Japan, Australia has been started.
● The Indo-Pacific visions: It is based on rule of law and respect for sovereignty and territorial integrity, Japan
started Indo-Pacific Oceans’ Initiative (IPOI).
o It is to ensure a free, open and inclusive region in which countries both inside and outside (countries
who have stakes in this region) the Indo-Pacific region would participate.
Agreements:
● Treaty of Peace (1952): Being one of the first treaties between India and Japan, it restored the full diplomatic
relation between two countries after World War II.
● Agreement for Air Service (1956): An agreement for the purpose of establishing air services between and
beyond their respective territories. Accordingly appointed their respective representatives for this purpose.
● Convention for the Avoidance of Double Taxation (1960): To avoid double taxation between the two
countries for The income tax, the super tax and the surcharge, imposed under the Indian Income-tax Act,
1922.
● Agreement for Cooperation in the Peaceful Uses of Nuclear Energy (2017): This agreement provides a
necessary legal framework for the transfer of technology and material for non-military use.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 85
Issues in relationship:
● Indian foreign policy strategy: It is driven by an overarching preference for strategic autonomy and by three
broad priorities: security, economic development, and status That put significant restraints in further
improvement in relation with Japan because India want to maintain the strategic autonomy.
Economic:
● Economic Negotiation: Japan hopes to assist India in modernising its military capabilities through the sale of
its US-2 amphibian aircraft and Soryu submarines. Also has offered to transfer technology and proposed
setting up a plant in India but the two sides remain at a stalemate over pricing issues.
● Trade Dispute: The recent verdict delivered against India by the World Trade Organization (WTO) on a
dispute on Iron and steel imports from Japan has made policymakers concerned about safeguard duties
imposed by India on iron and steel imports from Japan
● The Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership(RCEP): After years of negotiations, India recently pulled
out of the proposed RCEP trade deal over unresolved core concerns. While Japanese establishment thinks
India should join it to counter China.
● Overdependence with China: With Beijing taking advantage of the vulnerability, or the dependence on
China in trade, resorting to economic coercion, Japan needs to strengthen its economic security as part of
its strategy to ensure national security for more participation in Indo-Japan collaboration.
Osaka declaration:
● Indian refusal: Recently India refused to sign the “Osaka Track”, a framework to promote cross-border data
flow with enhanced protections, launched at the G20 summit in Japan.
○ The initiative seeks to standardise rules of global movement of data with enhanced protection for
personal information, intellectual property and cybersecurity.
○ India’s primary concern on terrorism was not given due prominence at G-20 Osaka track and India
refuse to join it.
Indo-Pacific:
● Different priority: The Indian establishment has more focus on Indian Ocean region while the Japanese
establishment has more focus on the Pacific ocean region, which creates the problem of differential
priority which leads to a non-coherent strategy overall.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 86
● Expansion of the United Nations Security Council: Both countries have resolved to work towards early reform
of the United Nations, including both permanent and non-permanent categories.
● UNSC Current Membership: China, France, Russia, Britain and the US are the five veto-wielding permanent
members of the UNSC. There are also 10 non-permanent members, with five elected each year to serve two-
year terms.
● An open, rule-based Order: Together they will seek reforms in the United Nations Security Council, an open,
rule-based and balanced regional architecture with deeper regional economic integration and connectivity,
● Arc of freedom and prosperity: Japan has been cooperating with countries of South East Asia, Central Asia,
and Central and Eastern Europe, which are developing democracy and market economy, through dialogues
as well as Official Development Assistance (ODA).
CURRENT DIMENSIONS:
Significance:
• Access to Military bases: It will allow their militaries to access each other's bases for logistics support.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 87
• Increasing Arms Force Reach: besides allowing militaries of the two countries to use each other's bases and
facilities for repair and replenishment of supplies.
• Help in Current Geo-Political Situation: The signing of the agreement comes when there is a bitter border
row with China, and rising concerns in the region over increasing Chinese assertiveness.
• Similar Agreement: In June 2020, India and Australia sealed a Mutual Logistics Support Agreement (MLSA)to
scale up their overall defence cooperation.
• India signed similar agreements with the US, France and Singapore.
• Strengthening Quad: In Nov 2017, India, the US, Australia and Japan gave shape to the long-pending "Quad"
to develop a new strategy to keep sea routes free of any influence.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 88
need to increase their own influence as well as to offer these countries an alternative, non-exploitative
model of development.
● Transfer technology and military hardware: India and Japan hold joint military drills quite regularly and also
hold frequent high-level military dialogues but efforts to transfer technology and military hardware have not
yet borne fruit.
● Reducing the Ambivalence of Quad: India has been very ambivalent about the Quad, giving rise to the
impression that it has not yet made up its mind on whether to openly participate in what is widely regarded
as a grouping of democracies against a totalitarian China.
o To utilise the full potential of Quad India need to fully participate in this initiation without paying
unnecessary heed to strategic autonomy.
● India needs to speed up the project implementation: Due to regulatory forbearance and slow administrative
process compared to China, joint efforts are slowing down. Projects like The Bullet Train are likely to be
delayed over land acquisition, with some farmers objecting to the takeover of their land by the government.
● Need to Increase collaboration for Climate change: The two Governments need to strengthen their energy
and environmental cooperation including on sustainable development and environmentally sound
technologies. With ensuring increased focus on energy security, energy efficiency, conservation, and
pollution-free fuels.
● Expanding the cooperation: In the possible cooperation in areas like 5G, submarine cables, strengthening of
industrial competitiveness, diversification of supply chains and development projects in the northeastern
state.
Conclusion
• Overall, India-Japan has taken multiple important initiatives emphasizing the deep interest in both India and
Japan to further strengthen their security and strategic engagements. The two countries have built a strong
strategic partnership in the last decade.
• While China may have been a factor, but building this relationship was easier because of the absence of any
baggage, unlike, for instance, with the United States. But India and Japan also need to build a larger coalition
if they are to balance China effectively in the economic and defence sector.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 89
INTRODUCTION-
C. Rajamohan-
• After more than a half century of false starts and unrealized potential, India is now emerging as the swing
state in the global balance of power. In the coming years, it will have an opportunity to shape outcomes
on the most critical issues of the twenty-first century: the construction of Asian stability, the political
modernization of the greater Middle East, and the management of globalization.
BROAD OVERVIEW
• Indian foreign policy engagement in West Asia can be divided into two distinct phases, pre- and post-1991.
• PRE 1990- Prior to 1991 India’s engagement with the region was one of “political distance,” due to dynamics
of Cold War politics and the fact that India purchased the bulk of its hydrocarbons needs (15-25 percent)
from Russia.
• POST 1990- India’s engagement with the region began to increase and solidify in the early 1990s due to a
multitude of factors: the end of the Cold War, the disintegration of Soviet Union, and India’s growing demand
for oil and gas due to its accelerated economic development.
• India has balanced it’s relationship well with all pillars of West Asian geopolitics- United Arab Emirates
(U.A.E.), the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia, the Islamic Republic of Iran, and Israel.
SIGNIFICANCE
• ENERGY SECURITY- The Gulf Arab states provide 50 percent of Indian crude oil and 85 percent of its natural
gas requirements.
• DEFENCE COOPERATION- Israel is increasingly regarded not just as a “strategic defence partner” but as a
“model of counter-terrorism”. India has also strengthened strategic cooperation with Saudi Arabia and UAE.
India has signed Comprehensive Strategic Partnership with UAE and established Strategic Partnership
Council with Saudi Arabia to strengthen counter terrorism cooperation.
• CONNECTIVITY- projects such as INSTC, Chabahar port in Iran can provide connectivity to India to west Asia
as well as Eurasia.
• SECURITY- Ensuring the stability and security of the Persian Gulf region, including the protection of the large
Indian expatriate community.
• INVESTMENTS- The UAE government has committed USD 75 billion towards developing Indian
infrastructure. Recently, The NIIF entered into an agreement with a Dubai based firm for investment up to
USD 3 billion. The Saudi Arabia is planning to launch a $3 trillion sovereign wealth fund to invest in business
opportunities abroad. India offers both investment opportunities for the Saudi fund and remains a major
buyer of its oil which make the country an important economic destination for the Saudis.
• INDIAN DIASPORA- Gulf is one of the strategically important regions where more than 8 million Indian
diaspora community lives. One fourth of total Indian diaspora lives in this region. Security and wellbeing of
Indian diaspora is an important pillar of India’s West Asia policy.
• Maritime Security- Important sea lines of communications pass through the Persian Gulf. Thus, the region is
critical to counter traditional and non-traditional security threats in Indian Ocean Region.
• ECONOMIC COOPERATION- India has certain advantages here as India is prepared to “act west” at a time
when the Gulf countries are “looking east”. Both the Saudi camp and Iran want India as an economic partner
and a friend.
ISSUES
• DETERIORATING SECURITY ENVIRONMENT IN WEST ASIA- Intensification of sectarian conflict, terrorism, civil
wars in Yemen and Syria and the involvement of external actors can make India’s traditional Balancing Policy
difficult.
• SECURITY OF INDIAN DIASPORA- Reverse migration induced by COVID-19 and efforts of nationalisation of
workforce in GCC countries. Saudi Vision 2030 aim to skill and employ more nationals and limit the number
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 90
of expatriates. stringent labour laws, lack of human rights and absence of minimum wage provision and strict
visa and recruitment process results in exploitation of Indian workers.
• DELAY IN PROJECTS COMPLETION from Indian side dent investors’ confidence. Further, Indian companies
operating in the UAE also face problems due commercial regulations, labor laws and lack of transparency on
part of GCC businesses.
• TERRORIST FINANCING-Money from Saudi Arabia has been accused of funding Wahhabi Islamic groups
around the world. These groups are linked to radicalization and financing of terrorist activities in Kashmir.
• RISING CHINESE INFLUENCE- While a China-Iran-Pakistan-Russia-Turkey axis is not a reality yet, it could very
well take shape in the near future and pose a serious national security challenge for India. China is already
extending its activities in the Indian Ocean through “String of Pearls” network encircling India. The
emergence of a similar axis to India’s north – with a trans-Himalayan Quad and the proposed alliance of five
nations – would encircle India entirely and therefore, severely limit its outreach capabilities.
• Impact on Energy security- India imports more than 70% of the oil it needs. However, after the US strike
which killed General Soleimani the oil prices rose by 4%. An increase in the price of oil can lead to an increase
in the Current Account Deficit and erosion of forex reserves.
• Pakistan factor- Pakistan has close relations with many West Asian countries and especially with GCC
counties.
WAY FORWARD-
• LEVERAGING INDIA’S SOFT POWER- No major power has the kind of people-to-people socio-cultural
compatibility and socio-economic interdependence with countries of the Gulf region, in particular with
G.C.C. countries that India has.
• STRENGTHENING ECONOMIC RELATIONS- India’s West Asia engagement must focus on delivering on its
commitments and strengthening its presence as an economic and security partner. Timely completion of
projects and domestic business reforms to attract sovereign wealth funds from GCC countries should be on
top of government’s policy agenda.
o The success of Act East policy was mainly due to increased trade and commerce with South-East
Asian countries. On the same lines a FTA with GCC can increase trade with West Asia.
• CONTINUATION OF BALANCING POLICY- India should not step on intensifying fault lines in middle east
geopolitics. Traditional equidistance policy and maintaining cardinal relations with all powers has provided
rich dividend in the past and this needs to be continued.
• Independent Approach in the Region- India should adopt a flexible policy to maximize regional cooperation
with the great powers where our interest converges and minimize negative consequences when they
diverge.
• Leveraging Islamic Link- Shared historical, cultural and religious heritage can be leveraged for strengthening
economic and political relationships.
• Defence Diplomacy through active engagement with defence forces of West Asian countries and joint
defence production can improve India’s profile in the Region. The recent visit by Army Chief to UAE is a good
start.
• Increasing people to people contacts- Through liberalising visa norms, cultural exchange can boost tourism
as well as enhance India’s soft power in the region.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 91
picking and choosing between them, and on the basis of mutual benefit. This Balancing Policy enabled India
to have cardinal relations with all West Asian countries without having to step on any fault lines.
• Look West policy: India initiated Look West policy in 2005. The key focus areas were energy security,
investment opportunities and Indian diaspora. Collectively, the G.C.C. countries have become India’s
preeminent oil and gas supplier and leading trade partner whereas Indians are the largest expatriate group
in each of the six G.C.C. countries.
PRESENT POLICY-
• Continuation of look west: The present policy is continuation of old look west policy. However, it is marked
by High Octane Diplomacy market by intensified security cooperation in counter terrorism and maritime
domain, economic complementaries and policy based on enlightened self-interest.
• Think West policy: While announcing ‘Think West policy’ the then foreign secretary S. Jaishankar held that
“we are no longer content to be passive recipients of outcomes". India’s landmark “Act East" policy, he
added, “would be matched with ‘Think West’."
• Strategic agreements: India has signed strategic agreements with UAE and Saudi Arabia. Recently, Indian
army chief also visited UAE and Saudi Arabia for ‘strengthening strategic and defence cooperation’.
• Maritime security: Apart from cooperation in counter terrorism, maritime security has become important
pillar of India’s west Asia policy. Recently , Indian , French and UAE navies conducted three-day Varuna
trilateral exercise to jointly test combat skills and war game in the Persian Gulf.
• Leveraging Economic Complementaries- (covered earlier)
• Leveraging India’s moderate profile- India is not seen as a hostile power by either of the blocs. Even as the
trade ties between Saudi Arabia and China keep thriving, there’s a fair amount of strategic mistrust between
them.
o On the other side, India has kept its equidistance. The Saudis know that India does not have any
ambitions to control West Asia. Nor is India part of any global alliance that challenges the Saudi
influence in the region. This makes it easier for New Delhi to deepen its partnership with the Gulf
Arab countries.
o India has also maintained a distance from developments which Iran sees hostile to its interests. This
balancing offers a pattern in India’s engagement in the region. It is shaped not by hostility towards
anybody, but friendship with everybody moored in political realism
INDIA-IRAN
INTRODUCTION-
• India-Iran relations span centuries marked by meaningful interactions. The two countries shared a border till
1947 and share several common features in their language, culture and traditions. However, presently, the
growing closeness between Iran, China and Pakistan and growing rift between GCC and Iran has created new
challenges for India’s west Asia policy.
IMPORTANCE OF IRAN-
• ENERGY SECURITY- Iran is a significant source of crude oil, accounting for 6 percent of India’s oil imports. Iran
used to be India’s second largest oil supplier after Saudi Arabia till New Delhi slashed imports in the wake of
the international sanctions
• GEOSTRATEGIC- Iran borders the Strait of Hormuz through which a fifth of the world’s seaborne oil
passes. From a realpolitik perspective, Iran’s importance for India derives from its immense energy
resources, strategically important location linking West Asia with Central Asia, and the possibility of building
a friendship not disturbed by the “Pakistan factor.”
• CONNECTIVITY-
o India’s “gateway” to Central Asia: Iran is poised to become India’s “gateway” to Central Asia, Europe
and Russia as a result of the future construction of the ports at Chabahar and Bandar Abbas and the
International North-South Transport Corridor (INSTC).
o Chabahar port Not only connect India to Afghanistan and Central Asia, bypassing Pakistan, but
Chabahar also acts as a balance to CPEC and a symbol of India’s commitment to Iran and Afghanistan.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 92
WAY FORWARD-
• RETHINKING PRESENT POLICY- India should rethink its Iran policy and recalibrate the way forward to detract
from a possible China-Iran alliance and broaden the scope of its cooperation with Iran to make their
partnership a more strategic one.
• MEDIATING BETWEEN IRAN -US- India can emerge as a neutral third-party with cordial ties to both regimes
to bring Iran and the United States closer to direct talks to further the peace process and discuss a new,
broader nuclear deal.
• Improving implementation record of infrastructure projects as delays frustrates the partner countries and
give chance to China to increase its footprint.
RECENT NEWS-
CURRENCY CHANGE IN IRAN-
• Under the ‘Reforming Monetary and Banking Law’ passed in May "Iran’s currency unit will be toman and
each toman will be worth 10,000 rials and 100 qerans”.
• It was done to simplify transactions and to check inflation.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 93
What is INSTC?
• The International North South Transport Corridor is a 7,200-km-long multi-mode transport route, wherein
India is partnering with 12 nations to
establish an economic corridor.
• It will help in moving freight among
India, Iran, Afghanistan, Armenia,
Azerbaijan, Russia, Central Asia and
Europe.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 94
• To prevent nuclear proliferation: It intended to prevent Iran from developing nuclear weapons while granting
it an internationally monitored civilian nuclear power programme. Iran’s compliance with the nuclear-related
provisions of the JCPOA is verified by the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) according to certain
requirements set forth in the agreement.
• It limited the number of centrifuges Iran could run and also reconfigured a heavy-water reactor so it couldn’t
produce plutonium and agreed to convert its enrichment site at Fordo into a research centre.
• US withdrawal: In 2018, US unilaterally withdrew from JCPOA and in 2020 Iran withdrew from JCPOA after
the killing of General Soleimani.
INDIA - ISRAEL
HISTORY-
• Though India officially recognised Israel in 1950, the two countries established full diplomatic ties only on
January 29, 1992. Diplomatic ties between India and Israel completed 29 years in 2021.
• In recent years, relations have seen rapid growth across a broad spectrum of areas and the future vision of
the cooperation is of a strong hi-tech partnership as befits two knowledge economies.
• In 2017, Prime Minister Modi undertook an historic first ever visit by an Indian PM to Israel during which the
relationship was upgraded to a strategic level and seven Agreements/MoUs were signed in the fields of R&D
innovation, water, agriculture and space.
• In 2018, Prime Minister of Israel Benjamin Netanyahu, made a visit to India during which four G2G
agreements on cyber security, oil & gas cooperation, film co-production and air transport were signed, along
with five other semi-government agreements.
AREAS OF COOPERATION-
• Since the upgradation of relations in 1992, defence and agriculture formed the two main pillars of our
bilateral engagement.
Defence Cooperation
• Largest buyer: India is the largest buyer of Israeli military equipment
• Strategic partnership: The two countries have elevated their ties to a strategic partnership; an important
pillar of this relationship is defence.
• Increased ambit: The ambit of India-Israel defence cooperation has widened to include other domains like
space, counter-terrorism, and cyber security;
however, the cornerstone remains Israeli arms
sales to India.
• The major defence sells from Israel to India
include Heron UAV, Barak Missiles,SPYDER-MR
air defence system etc.
• Increased FDI: The government has increased
the limit for FDI in defence through the
automatic route from 49% to 74%.
What makes Israel a good arms supplier to India?
• Israel supplies ready-to-use critical
technologies, even on short notices. Israel has
created its niche in the market with its
innovation-backed technologies such as UAVs,
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 95
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 96
• Customisation- Israel has developed the expertise to customise its arms according to the requirements of its
customers.
• Israel has always been a ‘no-questions-asked supplier’, i.e., it transfers even its most advanced technology
without placing limits to its use.
• These factors make Israel a potential ‘all-weather’ defence partner for India.
Agriculture
• Agricultural cooperation between the two sides is formalized through 3-year Work plans wherein 3-year
Action plans are developed. Thus far, out of 29 Centres of Excellence in twelve Indian states have been
commissioned.
• Technology and expertise: India has benefited from Israeli expertise and technologies in horticulture
mechanization, protected cultivation, orchard and canopy management, nursery management, micro-
irrigation and post-harvest management particularly in Haryana and Maharashtra.
• Israeli drip irrigation technologies and products are now widely used in India.
• Dairy farming: Some Israeli companies and experts are providing expertise to manage and improve dairy
farming in India through their expertise in high milk yield.
Trade-
• The bilateral trade between India and Israel grew from $200 million in 1992 to $5.84 billion in 2018.
• India’s major exports to Israel and vice versa include precious stones and metals, organic chemicals,
electronic equipment etc.
• The two countries have also signed a ‘Double Taxation Avoidance Agreement’.
- Other areas of cooperation include water accessibility and oil and natural gas cooperation etc, where both
countries have common interest.
ISSUES-
• CHANGING GEOPOLITICS- as China-Iran-Russia vs Saudi-Israel-USA axis has emerged in west Asia, it can make
India’s balancing policy difficult.
• China- Israel china trade and defence cooperation is bigger than India-Israel. This may lead to Israel taking a
neutral position in case of Sino-India conflict.
• Israel Palestine conflict - the recent escalations in the conflict between Israel and Palestine after a series of
missile strikes from the Israel Defence Forces on civilian settlements in the Gaza Strip, violating a ceasefire
arrangement can further deteriorate the Arab-Israeli relations and destabilise the region further.
WAY FORWARD-
• Strengthening cooperation in sectors such as renewable energy, biotechnology and agricultural technologies
like precision agriculture.
• On Palestine issue- Though Palestine has become a non-issue, yet India should continue its moral stance on
the issue.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 97
• Utilizing India's soft power - The Indian model of democracy and secularism, which accommodates religious,
ethnic, linguistic and other diversities, could be a viable model for the peaceful coexistence of formerly
antagonistic groups.
• Maintaining balanced policy based on ‘enlightened self-interest’, in context of emergence of china-Iran-
Russia vs Saudi-Israel-USA axis.
RECENT NEWS-
Operation Breathing Space-
• Under it a team of top Israeli defence scientists and health experts will collaborate with Indian
counterparts to develop, test and deploy rapid diagnostic tests for Covid-19 that aims to provide results
in under a minute.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 98
• Budgetary support: So far, India has extended budgetary support of US$ 30 million to Palestine.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 99
• In 1997, an MoU between India and Palestine was signed, which provides for promoting scientific,
technical and industrial cooperation including provision of training facilities in specialized areas and
undertaking of mutually agreed projects.
Various Indian projects in Palestine are-
• Jawaharlal Nehru Library at the Al Azhar University in Gaza city and
• The Mahatma Gandhi Library-cum-Student Activity Centre at the Palestine Technical College at Deir Al
Balah in the Gaza Strip.
• India-Palestine Centre of Excellence in ICT and Innovation in Al Quds University
• Palestine India Techno Park in Ramallah
• During the Historic first ever visit of an Indian Prime Minister to Palestine, India provided one-time project
assistance worth USD 42.1 million for Palestinian Nation Building in Education, Health, Women
Empowerment and capacity building.
• India, Brazil, South Africa (IBSA) Fund has also funded five projects in Palestine,
• Welfare of Palestinian refugees: India has also given USD 2 million in aid to the United Nations Relief and
Works Agency working for the welfare of Palestinian refugees
INDIA-QATAR
WHY IN NEWS?
• India’s External Affairs Minister on his 2 day visit in December 2020 met the top leaders of Qatar and
discussed strengthening the economic and security cooperation.
INDIA- QATAR RELATIONS-
• ENERGY SECURITY- Qatar is the largest supplier of Liquefied Natural Gas (LNG) to India. Countries have
agreed to set up a task force to identify projects in India for investment.
• TRADE- India is considered to be the fourth largest export destination for the State of Qatar. India’s exports
to Qatar have nearly doubled in last decade.
• Diaspora welfare there are over 7 lakh Indians in Qatar and are source of big amounts of remittances back
to India.
• STABILITY IN AFGHANISTAN - Qatar is the host of the intra-Afghan talks and Taliban delegation with
Afghanistan.
• SECURITY COOPERATION- There is close cooperation between the two countries in the field of combating
terrorism, drug and human trafficking.
• Defence relations- Za’ir-Al-Bahr is the naval exercise between Indian and Qatar Navy.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 100
• GEOSTRATEGIC-Riyadh Declaration (2010) has raised the level of partnership to strategic partnership. During
PM Modi’s visit countries have agreed to establish a Strategic Partnership Council (SPC). India to become the
fourth country to sign such an agreement with Saudi Arabia.
• DIASPORA- 2.6 million Indian diaspora are in Saudi Arabia and are the largest recipient of foreign remittances,
up to $11 bn annually.
• DEFENCE- The navies of the two countries were also planning to hold their first-ever joint naval exercises in
March 2020 but it had to be postponed on account of the pandemic. The naval exercise has been
rescheduled for the first half of 2021.
• DEALING WITH PAKISTAN- Saudi Arabia is the only country apart from China that can put pressure on
Pakistan to
• SECURITY COOPERATION- during Modi’s 2016 visit, an MoU on cooperation in the exchange of intelligence
related to money laundering and terrorism financing was signed between the 2 countries.
• OTHER AREAS OF COOPERATION- In a recent meeting between NITI Aayog-led delegation and their Saudi
counterparts, areas such as information and communications technology, healthcare and pharmaceuticals,
electronic and manufacturing facilities, and housing were identified as potential areas of enhanced
cooperation.
ISSUES-
• ENERGY RELATIONS- Indian state refiners bought 36% less oil from Saudi Arabia in May 2021 than normal as
India blamed cuts by the Saudis and other oil producers for driving up crude prices.
• Secondly, Saudi Aramco has raised the price of oil shipments to Asia by between 20-50 cents per barrel.
However, it has not increased the price for Northern Europe and even cut the prices for the US. According
to experts, this move is the signal to India who is trying to diversify its oil imports away from Saudi Arabia.
• SAUDI-PAKISTAN RELATIONS- Saudi Arabia funded Sunni extremist groups through Pakistan to recruit jihadist
fighters for the first Afghan war. The groups fighting India in Kashmir have their origins in this.
• RADICALISATION- Saudi funding to Madrasas in Pakistan and other countries leading to radicalisation.
• IRAN-SAUDI RELATIONS- As tensions between Saudi and Iran grows, it will be difficult for India to maintain
its traditional Balanced policy in the Middle East.
• CONDITION OF INDIAN LABOURS IN SAUDI ARABIA- The working conditions for the Indian blue collared
labourers in Saudi Arabia have been a major bilateral concern. Saudi Vision 2030 further aim to skill and
employ more nationals and limit the number of expatriates.
WAY FORWARD-
• CONTINUING BALANCED POLICY- It allows India to have good relations with Saudi Arabia, Iran and Israel
alike, the three poles of power
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 101
• STRENGTHENING TRADE RELATIONS BEYOND OIL IMPORTS - It is in line with Saudi Vision 2030 and Make in
India. Saudi Arabia itself is undertaking large development projects including Smart City, Red Sea Tourism
Project, and Entertainment City, in which Indian companies can participate.
ABRAHAM ACCORD
WHAT IS IT?
• It is the agreement for full normalization of relations between Israel and the United Arab Emirates. After the
UAE, Bahrain, Morocco and Sudan have also normalised relations with Israel.
SIGNIFICANCE-
• Full Diplomatic Relations- through establishing embassies and exchanging ambassadors.
• Suspension of annexation plans by Israel in the west bank.
• Israeli-Palestinian solution- new push for normalization will aid the cause of Israeli-Palestinian compromise.
• It may lead to peace and stability in the region.
REASONS BEHIND THE AGREEMENT? -
• CHANGING GEOPOLITICS OF MIDDLE EAST-
o Emergence of Israel-Saudi Arabia - USA and China-Iran-Russia-Pakistan Axis.
o Reduced Importance of Palestinian issue.
• RISING INFLUENCE OF IRAN in the region and its growing closeness with China.
• DIVERSIFICATION OF OIL ECONOMIES - Saudi and UAE are looking to diversify their economies away from
dependency on Oil.
• USA ARMS SELL- After the deal USA can now sell sophisticated military equipment to UAE.
CHALLENGES-
• Opposition from Palestinian- Palestine has criticised the agreement and held that agreement encourages the
occupation (Israel) to continue its denial of the rights of our Palestinian people.
• Iran-Saudi rivalry will be intensified and can further destabilize the region.
• There is also fear of domestic opposition in GCC countries.
IMPLICATIONS FOR INDIA-
India has supported the agreement.
• INTENSIFICATION OF SHIA-SUNNI CONFLICT- It can have spill over effect in India.
• DIPLOMATIC CHALLENGE- To manage traditional policy of neutrality and balancing in the region.
• IRAN-CHINA- The agreement can strengthen Iran-China relations. (Comprehensive strategic partnership or
25-year deal and Iran's proposal to link Chabahar port to Gwadar in Pakistan)
• SAFEGUARDING CORE INTERESTS like energy security, diaspora, trade and investment.
• RELATIONS WITH GCC- Opportunity to strengthen defence and intelligence cooperation.
WAY FORWARD-
• PEACE AND STABILITY- Standing up for Arab sovereignty and opposing the forces of regional destabilisation
should be at the very heart of India’s new engagement with the Middle East.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 102
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 103
CHALLENGES-
• Managing GCC and Iran relations- As GCC and Iran relations are deteriorating , it will be difficult for India to
manage ties.
• China and GCC- China signed the highest category – the “Comprehensive Strategic Partnership” — with Saudi
Arabia (2016) and the UAE (2018). Even during India-china border standoff GCC countries-maintained
silence.
• Impact of pandemic- The pandemic has only worsened economic outlook, exacerbated India’s problem of
reverse migration and impacted Gulf sovereign wealth funds.
WAY FORWARD-
• Focus on the new possibilities for economic cooperation- As the Gulf states have embarked on massive
economic diversification and are investing in a variety of new projects including renewable energy, higher
education, technological innovation, smart cities, and space commerce.
• Cooperating with GCC for political modernization in the Middle east and stability in Afghanistan.
CONCLUSION-
• C. RAJAMOHAN- As it seeks to recalibrate India’s ties with the Gulf, the real challenge for South Block is to
get the rest of the Indian establishment to discard outdated perceptions of the Gulf and seize the new
strategic possibilities with the region.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 104
Importance of region :
Complex Geopolitics :
• The complex geopolitical situation is the result of interaction of both global and regional forces and their
subsequent impact on the region.
• The collapse of the USSR brought changes in geopolitics and compelled these countries to pursue a policy
of multi vector. The region denoted as Heartland by Helford Mackinder indicates its strategic importance.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 105
• Rise of china : China has made prominent presence in the region through BRI led infrastructure projects and
financial aid. However Central Asian countries have received little benefit out of it and suffering from Chinese
debt trap. It has created favourable conditions for India to intervene with better alternative proposals.
Connectivity :
• Connecting link: CAR(Central Asian Region) provides a connecting link between West Asia , Eurasia and Indian
Subcontinent.
• Vital player: CAR is a vital player in developing INSTC to establish connectivity to Eurasian region.
• The development of Chabahar port of Iran has established road rail connectivity to Afghanistan and CAR.
Economic imp :
• The Silk Route was the connecting link which flourished the economic engagements between the regions.
• CAR has potential to develop growth , trade and investment.
Mineral wealth :
• The region is rich in gold , iron ,copper , iron , aluminium hence cordial relations are important to secure
continued flow of commodities for growing Indian demand.
Digital Connectivity :
• In the Digital era having a strong foundation in the IT sector India is planning to establish a central Asian e-
network linking all five states and provide tele-education and tele-medicine connectivity.
Trade Relations :
• India has also acceded to the Customs Convention on International Transport of Goods under the cover of
TIR and joined the Ashgabat Agreement.
Energy Security :
• Resources : The region has large oil , natural gas and uranium reserves. It is important from the point of view
of India’s energy security.
• Energy Diplomacy : Slowly and steadily India also took steps to get a share in the energy sectors of
Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan. Even in Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan India got a stake over the years in the
hydroelectric projects.
• Ongoing Projects : India is developing the TAPI pipeline with the help of Tajikistan , Afghanistan , Pakistan
and India.
Common multilateral organisations :
• Eurasian Economic Union : It is an organisation for regional economic integration which provides free
movement of goods , services and labour.
• Heart Of Asia Conference : It aims at ensuring peace , stability , security and prosperity in Afghanistan and
nearby region.
• Shanghai Cooperation Organisation : It aims at promoting cooperation in politics , economy , technology and
to ensure peace , security in the region.
India’s soft power- Bollywood, Islam, Buddhism :
• Central Asian people have been great audience for Bollywood films which provides huge revenue and
strengthens the people to people ties.
• Cultural ties based on belief , pilgrimage are important to attract more tourist from these countries.
Security :
Peace and stability :
▪ Also region is important to have peace and stability for India because of increasing terrorism and its
vicinity to Golden Crescent.
▪ The region is important to establish stability in Afghanistan and control terrorism, fundamentalism
spreading out.
Defence Ties :
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 106
▪ India has also signed a number of defence and security pacts with the Central Asian countries like
Security Cooperation Agreement.
▪ India executes many defence exercises with central Asian countries like India Kyrgyzstan military
exercise – Khanjar.
Tackling terrorism :
▪ Both with Kazakhstan and Tajikistan India also signed agreements to fight against terrorism.
▪ SCO – RAT initiative helps member countries to fight extremism , terrorism and separatism.
Humanitarian Ties :
Social Capital :
1. To enhance people to people ties , India can provide assistance in augmenting the Social
Capital.
▪ E.g. India can share experience in managing the local-self-government (Panchayat
Raj system) to Central Asian countries where mahalla culture (local self-
government) is widely prevalent.
Healthcare services:
1. India can provide affordable health care services E,g. Ayurveda and Siddha.
Other Sectors :
• These countries can also engage in the agricultural sector, information technology and the
civilian nuclear cooperation to further strengthen their relations.
Chabahar port :
• It is an important link of connectivity between India and central Asia.
• In 2026 India, Iran and Afghanistan signed the trilateral agreement to establish a Transit and Transport
Corridor among them using Chabahar port in Iran.
• It is being considered a gateway to golden opportunities for trade by the three countries with other Central
Asian countries in the wake of Pakistan denying transit access to India.
• The port can also act as a counter to Pakistan’s Gwadar Port and Chinese OBOR projects in this region.
• In future, the Chabahar project and the International north south transport corridor (INSTC) will complement
each other enhancing Indian connectivity to the Eurasia region.
IN NEWS
· Engagement with the region in 2020 saw a clear focus on issues of regional economic development,
connectivity, and security — apart from the immediate need of dealing with the ongoing pandemic.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 107
Key Points
Covid Cooperation :
· Dialogue recognised the need to cooperate for Sanitary and Epidemiological Services between India and the
Central Asian countries in the fight against Covid-19 pandemic.
Financial Aid :
· Line of Credit: India extended the US$ 1 billion Line of Credit in fields such as connectivity, energy, IT,
healthcare, education, agriculture etc.
· Grant assistance: Also India offered grant assistance for implementation of High Impact Community
Development Projects (HICDP) for enhancing socio-economic development in the countries of the region.
Economic cooperation:
· Expand trade: To further expand trade and economic cooperation, an initiative to form working groups
under the India-Central Asia Business Council (ICABC) to promote business linkages, facilitate greater
understanding of taxation etc was started.
· ICABC – A B2B body established by the Government of India along with FICCI and key chambers of the other
nations.
Connectivity :
· Participants recognised the importance of connectivity for increasing trade and commerce as well as people-
to-people contacts between India and the Central Asian countries.
· They are planning to promote joint initiatives to create regional and international transport corridors.
Condemned terrorism :
· Participants condemned terrorism in all its forms and manifestations.
· They reaffirmed their efforts to combat this menace by destroying terrorist safe-havens, networks,
infrastructure and funding channels.
· They also underlined the need for every country to ensure that its territory is not used to launch terrorist
attacks against other countries.
The participation of Afghanistan in the India- Central Asia Dialogue.
· Participants want cooperation for economic reconstruction of Afghanistan, including implementation of
infrastructure, energy, transit and transport projects.
· They called for the settlement of the Afghan conflict on the principle of Afghan-led, Afghan-owned and
Afghan-controlled peace process.
Humanitarian, cultural, educational and tourism cooperation:
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 108
· Increasing tourism arrivals, creating tourism trails across the region, making the visa process simpler and
encouraging investment in tourism infrastructure was emphasized.
· Social welfare: Taking note of the large number of students from India and the Central Asian countries
studying in each other’s higher educational institutions, the Ministers stressed the importance of ensuring
their social welfare.
Challenges
Geoeconomics:
1. Interests of China and the US to a greater extent also altered the geopolitical narratives of Central Asia and
competing India’s interests. Chinese OBOR initiatives have led to increase its influence in the region.
2. India’s trade with the region amounts to US$ 2 billion, owing to limited connectivity and low economic
engagement.
Connectivity :
1. Hostility of Pakistan has closed the nearest land route to central Asia via Afghanistan.
2. Destabilised Afghanistan makes connectivity insecure via Chabahar port. Thus both land and sea routes are
not safe in transporting goods and cargo.
3. Sluggish development of INSTC projects have placed India on the backfoot in establishing commercial
projects in the region.
Security :
1. Growing radical Taliban in Afghanistan, role of Pakistan, Saudi Arabia , Turkey and Iran in spreading
radicalisation in Central Asia.
2. Both Pakistan and Afghanistan are not secure hence making connectivity and engagements difficult.
3. Chinses penetration: China through its BRI projects have penetrated well in central Asian countries and are
suffering from debt trapped economics of china.
4. Vicinity to Golden crescent and increasing terrorism is threat to peace and stability.
Geopolitics:
1. The Geopolitical region is fragile as interest of the USA is lessening , China-Russian convergence in this region
and adverse impact of Syrian crisis pushing India away and obstructing its efforts of developing relations.
2. Internal conflicts: CAR have failed to associate as a strong regional group due to various internal conflicts
over terrorism , ethnic issues and global geopolitical intervention preventing them to unite.
Chinese Role :
1. China has heavy investments in CAR. China launched its OBOR project in Central Asia and given massive aid
for infrastructure projects. China is also taking advantage of Russia’s economic weakness and trying to
replace Russia as a major force in Central Asia.
2. Expansionist policy: China with its expansionist policy and urge to control important water resources in the
region is a threat to sovereignty of central Asian countries.
3. However, the Central Asian countries are now more interested in getting rid of Chinese debt diplomacy in
this region in recent years. Thus opens the avenues for India to strengthen its ties and act as a strong pole in
the region.
• Ethno-territorial Conflict: It is ethno-territorial conflict between Armenia and Azerbaijan over Nagorno-
Karabakh region. The conflict is unresolved for the last three decades.
• Conflicting Principle: It is a struggle between – the principle of territorial integrity advocated by Azerbaijan
and the principle of right to self-determination advocated by Nagorno-Karabakh with the support of
Armenia.
Issue of Conflict :
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 109
• Nagorno-Karabakh region is centre of conflict which has been territorial part of Azerbaijan since Soviet Era
however resided mostly by Armenian Christian ethnic people who have been demanding independent status
from Muslim majority Azerbaijan.
• Both the countries claim that the disputed region was under their control in known history.
• After the disintegration of USSR Nagorno-Karabakh with the support of Armenia declared independence
which resulted in war between Azerbaijan and Nagorno-Karabakh with the support of Armenia.
Mediation :
• The clash was resolved with mediation of Russia and a ceasefire agreement was signed in 1994.
• The OSCE Minsk Group (Organization for Security and Co-operation in Europe) co-chaired by the USA, Russia
and France are striving to provide an amicable solution.
Current status of conflict :
• Armenian rebels have control over Nagorno-Karabakh region and have declared it as a republic named as
Nagorno-Karabakh Autonomous Oblast.
• Azerbaijan is striving to gain control over it.
Strategic Importance of region :
• INSTC route: Azerbaijan is situated on the INSTC route thus an important connecting link of India and
Eurasian region.
• Gas and oil pipelines: Azerbaijan has developed many gas and oil pipelines across the Caucasus to European
countries. Safety of these pipelines is important for ensuring energy security.
International Implication :
Global Concerns :
• Energy security of European countries: Though this territorial conflict is between two small countries , many
foreign players like Russia , USA , Turkey , Europe , Iran are involved to secure their interests. The region is
having high strategic value due to gas pipelines connecting European regions through this area. Thus stability
of the region is required for ensuring energy security of European countries.
Failure Of Mediators :
• No acceptable solution: The international interlocutors are striving with no luck to provide an acceptable
solution for both the parties. The full independence demand of Nagorno-Karabakh is not acceptable by
Azerbaijan.
Indian Relations :
• No specific policy : India does not have specific policy for the region like Neighbourhood First, Act East
or Central Asia Connect. The region has been neglected by Indian Foreign policy makers.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 110
• Relation with Armenia : Armenia is the only country in the region with which India has a friendship and
cooperation Treaty signed in 1995 which may prevent Indian assistance to Azerbaijan.
• Relation with Azerbaijan: However ,India has its investments in an oilfield project in Azerbaijan. ONGC and
GAIL are exploring new opportunities in Azerbaijan. Azerbaijan is integral to the International North South
Transport Corridor route , which connects India with Eurasian region and Europa region.
• Indian Stand : India has emphasised on peaceful resolution of the conflict through diplomatic negotiations.
India has also supported efforts of OSCE Minsk Group’s efforts to bring a peaceful solution.
Way Forward :
• Efforts must be put to realise the fruits of the steps like -India-Central Asia Business Council.
• Its success would create many avenues of engagement in future.
• Investment in the region: India should also plan to increase its direct investment in the region to reap the
economic benefits of the strategic location of Central Asia.
• Humanitarian aid: Sectors like the construction industry, sericulture, pharmaceuticals, IT, and tourism offer
potential for collaboration. Humanitarian aid would help to create ground level goodwill and enhance people
to people ties.
• The region is dominated by China and Russia hence India has a long way to go before it can be recognised as
a consequential actor in Central Asia. The proposals and ideas discussed in the 2020 virtual summits possess
the potential to form the bedrock of a sustained, balanced, long-term strategy.
• Thus there is a need to transcend India’s engagement in central Asia from symbols to substance.
Introduction :
• India and Australia are major maritime powers among the littoral states of the Indian Ocean and form the
geopolitical poles of the region.
• Mutual indifference has long characterized relations between them but interests of the two countries are
increasingly converging in the recent period.
• Australian PM Scott Morrison has described India and Australia relations in following words “The deep
friendship between Australia and India is about more than trade and diplomacy. Founded on bharosa(trust)
and samman(respect) it is a friendship with depth , and marked by democracy , defence cooperation ,
diaspora and dosti (mateship) “.
This shows the mutual understanding and strength of the relation between them.
Background :
• India and Australia were part of British empire and have their federal structures inspired by British polity.
• Indian constitution has borrowed elements like the concept of concurrent list , freedom of trade and
commerce. Presently both the countries are members of the British Commonwealth.
• 2009 a strategic partnership and 2014 Uranium supply deal marked the significant advancement in the
relations between the two countries.
• Increasing strategic importance of Indian Ocean Region and convergence of interest have raised
opportunities for both to cooperate and deal with increasing Chinese assertiveness in the region to
maintain rule of law and freedom of navigation in Indo-Pacific Region.
Areas Of Cooperation :
Economic Ties :
• Worth : Bilateral trade between two nations was worth US$ 30.3 billion in 2018-19.
o Two-way goods and services trade with India was $24.4 billion in 2020. Australia's stock of
investment in India was $15.4 billion in 2020.
o In the financial year 2021, India's exports to Australia were worth $4.04 billion, while imports were
$8.24 billion.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 111
• Trading Partner :India is Australia’s eighth largest trading partner and fifth largest export market.
• Import/Export Commodities :
Export : Motor vehicle & machinery , pharma products , pearls , jewellery.
Import : Coal , Gold , Uranium ,Copper , Education services.
• Joint Ministerial Commission(JMC) formed in 1989 encourages interaction between government and
business groups to find areas of collaborations and solving issues.
• CECA : Conclusion of Comprehensive Economic Cooperation Agreement (CECA) would grant FTA equivalent
status to each other, boosting trading opportunities and increasing the list of duty free tradable items.
• India-Australia Circular Economy Hackathon (I-ACE) was organised recently.
• The trade Ministers of India, Japan and Australia have formally launched the Supply Chain Resilience
Initiative (SCRI).
Covid-19
• Australia has sent oxygen, ventilators and Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) kits to India as part of an
immediate support package.
Defence Relations :
• Net security provider : To become a net security provider in Indian Ocean , it is imperative to engage with
key players in the region like Australia through defence cooperation.
• AUSINDEX : Bilateral naval exercise aimed to maintain open , free and rule based order in the Indo-Pacific
region.
• Malabar : Australia participated in the Malabar exercise in 2007 and recently in 2020.
• From 2016-18 , both countries conducted a joint military exercise named “AUSTRA HIND “.
The QUAD :
• Countries involved : India , USA , Japan , Australia. They are having common democratic ideology and
common interest of ensuring fair maritime trade and security.
• Aim : Quadrilateral Security Dialogue is an informal strategic dialogue aimed to ensure a fair , free and
prosperous Indo-Pacific region.
• Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe introduced the concept of QUAD in 2007 which failed to materialise.
• In 2017 QUAD revived because of the rising importance of Indo-Pacific region and increasing aggressiveness
of china.
Significance of Quad :
• To provide security and ensure peaceful navigation routes in Indo-Pacific region.
• Protection of economic interest in the region and anti-piracy actions.
• Promotion of economic interests and upholding rule based order in the region.
Consular Cooperation :
• Both the nations have signed and ratified The Mutual Legal Assistance Treaty(MLAT) and Extradition
Treaty.
Co-operation at multilateral fora.
• UNSC support: Australia supports India’s candidature in an expanded UN Security Council.
• At WTO: Both countries are members of the Five Interested Parties (FIP) in the World Trade
Organization context.
• India and Australia are members of the Quad, ASEAN Regional Forum, Commonwealth, Indian Ocean Rim
Association (IORA), , Asia Pacific Partnership on Climate and Clean Development, and have participated in
the East Asia Summits.
• Support for APEC’s membership: Australia is an important player in Asia Pacific Economic Cooperation
(APEC) and supports India's membership of the organisation.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 112
Indian Diaspora :
• India is the third largest source of immigrants to Australia and Second largest source of skilled professionals
like IT professionals , Doctors , Accountants etc. Thus both nations should evolve favourable public policies
to enhance people to people ties.
Areas Of Convergence :
• International Issues: To deal with issues like reforming the World Health Organisation , Evolving 5G
Technology , building resilience against climate change and disaster required political and institutional
engagement.
• CECA : The conclusion of CECA is important to encourage investment and remove non-tariff barriers.
Deeper economic engagements through CECA would further strengthen strategic alliances like QUAD.
• Energy Sector : Australia is a key exporter of Uranium and LNG to India and expected to overtake Qatar as
the largest exporter of LNG.
o Diversification of the energy basket by deepening relations with Australia is beneficial in the long
term.
• International Solar Alliance : Australis has recently joined ISA which opens new opportunities of
developing solar panels and knowledge sharing for cheaper production and decreasing dependency over
china.
• Education and skill development : BY 2027 India would have the largest working population in the world.
Australia is well equipped to assist knowledge sharing and skill development.
• Chinese Threat : Both countries perceive Chinese threats to maritime security and freedom of navigation
in the Indo-Pacific region. Both nations can increase their deterrence by initiating joint activities including
maritime domain awareness and development of strategically located islands.
• Economic Integration : Indo-Pacific region offers great scope for regional economic integration. RCEP
provides a good platform for regional economic development .
• The Make In India initiative can use Australian expertise in the health , education and tourism sector.
• Science and technology : Both nations have formed AISRF-Australia India Strategic Research Fund to
collaborate on space , 5G , IoT , AI , Blockchain related research and innovation.
• Pandemic Lessons : Australia has managed to suppress COVID-19 to low levels through ‘controlled
adaptation’. Both can formulate India specific methodology to combat pandemic.
Areas Of Concerns :
• Trade Deficit : Since 2001-02 India’s trade deficit has been rising. This largely due to Australia’s lower share
of services trade with India.
• RCEP : Stating adverse impact on Indian dairy and manufacturing sector India did not join RCEP however
Australia has been negotiating with India to join RCEP.
• CECA Negotiations : The differences over Australia’s demand to access Indian dairy sector and Indian
demand to have greater free movement and relaxed visa norms for its IT professionals have become the
issue of contention impeding the progress of CECA.
• Chinese Influence : The Chinese pressure has affected foreign policies of both nations which has prevented
full realisation of their engagement.
• Uranium Supply : There has not been significant growth in uranium supply since the 2014 bilateral
agreement. Recently DAE has turned down the offers given by Australian companies due to economic
viability
• Defence Cooperation : In Spite of common understanding with respect to Indo-Pacific region, the defence
cooperation remained undeveloped.
o AUSINDEX , AUSTRA HIND exercises can be used to share the expertise and formulate common
SOP to create deterrence in the region.
• Attacks on Indians : The racist attacks on Indians have become a major issue which is increasing the gulf
between people to people ties.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 113
ISSUE IN NEWS
India Australia First Virtual Meet :
• Summit held in June 2020 was a significant development in bilateral relations . It concluded nine
agreements including a joint declaration on ‘Shared Vision For Maritime Cooperation in the Indo-Pacific’.
Inclusion Of Australia :
• This would mark the first Malabar exercise where all the participants of Quad engage together militarily.
• This move will realise “Quadrilateral military alliance’ and further proceed towards formalisation of QUAD
alliance.
• It would strengthen the efforts towards maritime security , anti-piracy and securing communication
channels.
Uranium Supply from Australia
• Civil nuclear cooperation agreement 2014 enabled India to import Uranium from Australia.
• Despite these efforts, Uranium supply was not enough to meet India’s expectations.
• Declined Offer : Recently DAE- Department of Atomic Energy has turned down the offers submitted by BHP
Billiton and Heath gate Resources citing lack of viability of the proposals.
• The real progress is missing on the issue of uranium export to India hence concerned departments must
engage to find common viable grounds.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 114
WAY FORWARD :
• According to the experts future engagement between India and Australia will be driven by China's actions
, as it was in the past. After the clash in Ladakh India-China relations hit an all-time low. This marked the
fertile ground for India-Australia relation to reach its all-time high.
• Views of ORF(Observer research Foundation) : Harnessing comparative advantages of goods and services
, formation of trade blocs , strategic collaboration in Indo-Pacific and digitising value chains forms the new
parameters of economic and strategic diplomacy between India and Australia.
• Both nations should strive to develop digital infrastructure utilising blockchain technology to increase the
access in the maritime spaces which would augment the trade opportunities.
• It is also important to collaborate closely in undervalued sectors like agriculture , education , tourism and
services.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 115
2016
1. “The broader aims and objectives of WTO are to manage and promote international trade in the era of
globalization. But the Doha round of negotiations seem doomed due to differences between the developed
and the developing countries.” Discuss in the Indian perspective.
2. Evaluate the economic and strategic dimensions of India’s Look East Policy in the context of the post Cold
War international scenario.
3. “Increasing cross-border terrorist attacks in India and growing interference in the internal affairs of member-
states by Pakistan are not conducive for the future of SAARC (South Asian Association for Regional
Cooperation).” Explain with suitable examples.
4. What are the aims and objectives of the McBride Commission of the UNESCO? What is India’s position on
these?
2017
1. ‘China is using its economic relations and positive trade surplus as tools to develop potential military power
status in Asia’, In the light of this statement, discuss its impact on India as her neighbour. (150 words)
2. What are the main functions of the United Nations Economic and Social Council (ECOSOC)? Explain different
functional commissions attached to it. (150 words)
3. The question of India’s Energy Security constitutes the most important part of India’s economic progress.
Analyze India’s energy policy cooperation with West Asian Countries. (250 words)
4. Indian Diaspora has an important role to play in South-East Asian countries’ economy and society. Appraise
the role of Indian Diaspora in South- East Asia in this context (250 words)
2018
1. “India’s relations with Israel have, of late, acquired a depth and diversity, which cannot be rolled back.”
Discuss. (10 )
2. A number of outside powers have entrenched themselves in Central Asia, which is a zone of interest to India.
Discuss the implications, in this context, of India’s joining the Ashgabat Agreement, 2018. (10)
3. What are the key areas of reform if the WTO has to survive in the present context of ‘Trade War’, especially
keeping in mind the interest of India? (15)
4. In what ways would the ongoing US-Iran Nuclear Pact Controversy affect the national interest of India? How
should India respond to its situation? (15)
2019
1. ‘The time has come for India and Japan to build a strong contemporary relationship, one involving global and
strategic partnership that will have a great significance for Asia and the world as a whole.’ Comment.(10)
2. ‘Too little cash, too much politics, leaves UNESCO fighting for life.’ Discuss the statement in the light of US’
withdrawal and its accusation of the cultural body as being ‘anti-Israel bias’.(10)
3. “The long-sustained image of India as a leader of the oppressed and marginalised Nations has disappeared
on account of its new found role in the emerging global order” Elaborate(15)
4. “What introduces friction into the ties between India and the United States is that Washington is still unable
to find for India a position in its global strategy, which would satisfy India’s National self- esteem and
ambitions” Explain with suitable examples.(15)
2020
1. Critically examine the role of WHO in providing global health security during the COVID-19
pandemic. (Answer in 150 words)
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 116
2. ‘Indian diaspora has a decisive role to play in the politics and economy of America and European Countries’.
Comment with examples. (Answer in 150 words)
3. ‘Quadrilateral Security Dialogue (QUAD)’ is the transforming itself into a trade bloc from a military alliance,
in present times – Discuss. (Answer in 250 words)
4. What is the significance of Indo-US defence deals over Indo-Russian defence deals? Discuss with reference
to stability in the Indo-Pacific region. (Answer in 250 words)
Introduction-
To quote C. Rajamohan,’ after decades of false starts and unrealised potential , India is now emerging as an ideal
swing state. In maintaining Asian stability, political modernization of middle east , management of globalisation ,India
is going to be critical factor’
E-DIPLOMACY
Context: e-diplomacy is an adaptive mechanism to counter threats posed by covid pandemic and coordinate bilateral
, multilateral responses.
WHAT is it?-
• It's conducting official bilateral or multilateral summits, negotiations and agreements in virtual cyberspace
mode instead of physical meetings.
Benefits of E-diploamcy
• Physically safe: E-summits are physically safer for leaders and also time-saving. It also economises events
where costly physical journeys with entourages can be avoided.
• Fast track diplomacy and quick decision making. For ex- India and Australia upgraded their strategic
partnership into ‘COMPREHENSIVE STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIP’ in a recent virtual summit.
• More transparency in foreign policy. In virtual mode secret negotiations are difficult. Thus, it reduces role
of middleman, corruption in important arms deals negotiations etc.
• Better coordination: ensuring better coordination at bilateral and multilateral levels.
• Building public opinion- Digital platform are very useful to build public opinion on important global issues
like climate change, terrorism etc. Diplomacy is now emerging as a social institution and a medium of public
policy. The use of digital media in the world of diplomacy provides spaces for more intense interaction and
engagement between government and citizens. For ex- social media was instrumental in building public
opinion during the Arab Spring movement.
• Crisis Response Mechanism- Twitter as a crisis response mechanism has become a useful helpline for many
distressed Indians stranded abroad during COVID lockdowns. This enhances the reach of Indian embassies
and missions abroad.
Concerns regarding e diplomacy
• Cyber security- Digital diplomacy is not without risks like the possibility of information leak, hacking and
maintaining the anonymity of internet users. Diplomatic business involves sensitive data having national
security implications.
• Productivity- Less productive where crucial sticking points need ironing out.
• Propaganda- Digital media can be used for spreading propaganda and harming core national interests like
sovereignty. For ex- the recent tweets by celebrities like Greta Thunberg, Popstar Rihanna supporting the
farmers protest using Fake Toolkit.
• Jingoism- World leaders have even resorted to a war of words on twitter to fuel nationalistic sentiments and
score domestic brownie points. For ex- Twitter War between Trump and North Korean Leader Kim Jong-un
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 117
Way forward-
• Twiplomacy: Twitter diplomacy, also "Twiplomacy" or "hashtag diplomacy", is the use of social media
website, Twitter, by heads of state, leaders of intergovernmental organizations (IGOs), and their diplomats
to conduct diplomatic outreach and public diplomacy. Twiplomacy is direct, often unencumbered and
enables wider reach .
• Cybersecurity- strengthening cyber security infrastructure to prevent any breach of data.
Conclusion: Digital diplomacy is characterised by hybridity and breaks through the limitations of traditional
diplomacy. India would have to fast adopt and adapt to these irreversible changes.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 118
POSITIVES
• Countering Vaccine Nationalism whereby developed countries pre book major chunk of vaccines for their
populations thereby depriving developing and LDC’s of vaccines.
• Enhanced global status- recognition of India's role as 'pharmacy of the world'.
• Making India centre of global supply chain in health and pharmaceutical industry. This can prove
gamechanger in context of weaponization of supply chains by China.
• Economic- Promoting medical tourism and reviving economy post COVID-19
• Leadership - strengthening India's position as leader of the developing world.
• strategic dimension- It will strengthen India’s claim on permanent seat in UNSC and give greater say in other
forums like G-20 , WTO etc.
CONCERNS
• Vaccine nationalism- When a country manages to secure doses of vaccines for its own citizens or residents
and prioritises its own domestic markets before they are made available in other countries it is known as
‘vaccine nationalism’. This is done through pre-purchase agreements between a government and a vaccine
manufacturer.
o For ex- USA banning export of raw materials to India, developed countries hoarding excess vaccines
than their need.
• IPR laws- Major developed countries prefer strict IPR laws which may impact Indian pharma industry as they
may not be able to produce affordable vaccines.
o Recently, the European Union, UK, Switzerland and Korea reiterated their opposition to waiving
TRIPS provisions as a response to COVID-19.
• Impact on domestic vaccination programme- as India exported 66 million of vaccines produced, supply to
states has been disrupted thereby negatively impacting domestic vaccination programme.
WAY FORWARD
• Self-sufficiency in production of raw materials- Dependence on China ,USA for raw materials makes Indian
pharma sector vulnerable to supply side shocks.
• Strengthening domestic R&D capacity by increasing budgetary allocation , improving industry academia
linkages and promoting innovation based start-up ecosystem.
• Ease of doing reforms such as liberalisation of FDI rules, labour law reforms etc to attract global pharma
companies to set up their manufacturing units in India.
CONCLUSION-
• India needs to balance its domestic needs with diplomatic commitments. Though vaccine diplomacy may
help increase India's stature and strengthen its claim to gain its rightful place in the COMITY OF NATIONS yet
the domestic requirement under the world's largest vaccination programme can’t be ignored.
Why in news?
• Supply Chain Disruption; Amidst Covid-19 due to heavy dependence on China and weaponization of supply
chain by China.
• The US-China Trade Tensions: More than 20% of the world’s supplies are dependent on China and the USA.
Trade tensions between 2 countries can disrupt whole global supply chain endangering globalisation and
liberal international economic order based on free trade.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 119
• To Counter China’s Political Influence on the Indo-Pacific Region: China’s expansionist approach in the South
China Sea and weaponization of supply chains to gain EEZ in south china sea has highlighted need for de-
risking supply chains.
Objectives
• Restructuring supply chains away from China due to the increased security risks associated with production
networks significantly embedded in or connected to China.
• To build on the existing supply chain network; by setting up industrial parks and onboarding ASEAN countries
in the SCRI
• To attract FDI and to turn the Indo-Pacific zone into an economic powerhouse by improving sea and air
connectivity between the three countries.
• To build a mutually complementary transparent trade relationship between countries in Indo-pacific based
on free and fair terms.
Way forward-
• Operational Risks: It must check volatility in the supply chain with improved real-time transparency and
mitigation solutions.
• Reforming India’s Perceived Image: To take full advantage of the SCRI, India must take progressive steps
towards cleaning up its perceived image of a protectionist country.
• Streamlining India’s Manufacturing & Supply Bottlenecks: Need to push through long-pending legislation
that aims to address the structural bottlenecks w.r.t Land, Labour, Law, and Liquidity.
• Collaboration for Technology-Driven Supply Chain: The partner countries must collaborate and share
knowledge to adopt an automated supply chain driven by state-of-the-art technology.
GEOPOLITICS OF TECHNOLOGY
• Technology, especially in the digital domain, is now deeply affecting all human activities and, by extension,
international relations. Artificial intelligence, blockchain and 5G capabilities are fast becoming the frontlines
of either global competition or coordination.
HOW TECHNOLOGY CAN FOSTER GEOPOLITICAL COOPERATION?
• ECONOMIC-5G alone is projected to generate $13 trillion in global economic value and 22 million jobs by
2035. And artificial intelligence is projected to add over $15 trillion to the global economy by 2030.
• DATA BASED POLICIES- policies and international agreements based on technologies can enhance efficiency
in achieving SDG’s, Paris climate goals etc.
• STRENGTHENING GLOBALISATION- free flow of goods, peoples and ideas can build global society
• FOSTERING INNOVATIONS and start-ups and new business models.
CONCERNS-
• Nationalisation and weaponization: The single biggest challenge around technology is the way it is being
nationalized and weaponised. There is a new map of power in the modern world that is no longer defined
by geography, by control of territory or oceans but rather by control over flows of people, goods, money and
data and by exploiting the connections technology creates. In this way, every connection between nations –
from energy flows to IT standards – becomes a tool of geopolitics.
• GEOPOLITICAL RIVALRY- among major countries like USA,EU ,CHINA for leadership in technology domain like
5g,big data etc.
• RETREATING GLOBALISATION and rise in protectionism leading to intensified tensions between USA and
china
• North South Divide on important issues like climate change, trade protectionism, disagreement on OSAKA
TRACK etc.
• ISSUES OF NATIONAL SECURITY AND SOVEREIGNTY- free flow of data and threat of state sponsored cyber
attacks such as the stuxnet used by USA to derail Iran's nuclear programme.
• Surveillance capitalism- the battleground for geopolitical influence will be centred on who owns the tech
companies, who governs them and how their supply chains will be integrated. For example, India has banned
several Chinese apps as they were sharing the data of Indian citizens with Chinese government.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 120
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 121
5 PILLARS OF POLICY-
• Science and research activities,
• Economic and human development cooperation,
• Transportation and connectivity,
• Governance and international cooperation, and
• National capacity building.
OBJECTIVES-
1- GEOECONOMIC-
• RESEARCH- putting in place Arctic related programmes for mineral/oil and gas exploration
• Energy security- Exploration of resources, including minerals and hydrocarbons,
• CLIMATE RESEARCH, ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING- Arctic research will help to study melting rates of the
third pole — the Himalayan glaciers.it will also help understand the impact of climate change on monsoon.
2- GEOSTRATEGIC
• MARITIME COOPERATION WITH RUSSIA- Russia is developing its northern sea routes. Also both countries
are discussing Chennai to Vladivostok maritime corridor.
• STRENGTHENING INDIA-RUSSIA RELATIONSHIP- India offered 1 billion dollars line of credit for development
of the far east region of Russia.
• COUNTERING CHINA- China has launched ‘Polar silk road’ and aspire to be ‘Polar Power’.
ABOUT ARCTIC politics-
• The region is governed by the ARCTIC COUNCIL comprising Five Arctic littoral states — Canada, Denmark
(Greenland), Norway, Russia and the USA (Alaska) — and three other Arctic nations — Finland, Sweden and
Iceland.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 122
• India launched its first scientific expedition to the Arctic in 2007 and set up a research station ‘Himadri’ in
the international Arctic research base at Svalbard, Norway. It has two other observatories.
WAY FORWARD
• As suggested by Shyam Saran India’s institutions lag behind its ambitions thus India needs proactive
diplomacy along with timely completion of commitments and projects.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 123
other and their shared future. It forms the basis of UNESCO’s ongoing dialogue between cultures, religions
and civilisations.
• Achieving Political Goals- The present government has sought to embed India’s cultural values in a larger
geopolitical context and has put special emphasis on the idea that India can be the ‘viswaguru’ or world
teacher.
• Preventing conflict and promoting peace- Cultural diplomacy has emerged as the force to connect, to build
bilateral relations and to heal the raptures created by history and politics. Further, cultural diplomacy based
on Indian values like peace, brotherhood, coexistence and prosperity helps bridging trust gap between
countries not only in India’s neighbourhood but beyond.
• Religious tourism – It can help States to overcome years of mutual mistrust and push forward the process of
regional integration.
- For ex- India has revived the old Buddhism tourism circuit to link up with Nepal, Sri Lanka,
Bhutan and other States in our wider neighbourhood which had Buddha’s footprints.
• Religion as tool of soft power- Islam and Buddhism are important pillars of India’s soft power in Middle East
and South East Asia respectively.
• Diaspora- India’s cultural and religious soft power is built by diaspora living abroad and propagating Indian
civilizational values.
- For ex- Spread of Yoga, Ayurveda etc.
GOVERNMENT EFFORTS
• INSTITUTIONAL ARRANGEMENTS- INDIAN COUNCIL OF CULTURAL RELATIONS- ICCR is involved in India’s
external cultural relations or cultural diplomacy, through cultural exchange with other countries and their
peoples.
• PROJECT MAUSAM- it aims to re-connect and re-establish communications between countries of the Indian
Ocean world, which would lead to an enhanced understanding of cultural values and concerns.
• DIASPORA- Indian Diaspora namely NRIs and PIOs play a vital role in protecting its Soft Power. Both put
together add up to twenty million. The best example of this was during the negotiations of the Indo-US
Nuclear Deal in the early years of the first decade of this century.
• BUDDHIST CIRCUITS- It is an attempt to attract Buddhist tourists to India, alongside Sri Lanka and Nepal with
the Buddhist circuit spanning over all the three countries.
• MIDDLE EAST- Islam forms important link between India and middle eastern countries. For ex- India has 2nd
largest Shia Muslim population after Iran.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 124
SAARC
PYQ
1. “Increasing cross-border terrorist attacks in India and growing interference in the internal affairs of several
member-states by Pakistan are not conducive for the future of SAARC (South Asian Association for
Regional Cooperation).” Explain with suitable examples. 2016
• The South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation (SAARC) is the regional intergovernmental
organization and geopolitical union of states in South Asia. The SAARC was founded in Dhaka in December
1985. Its secretariat is based in Kathmandu, Nepal.
• Its member states are Afghanistan, Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, the Maldives, Nepal, Pakistan and Sri Lanka.
The SAARC comprises 3% of the world's area, 21% of the world's population and 4.21% of the global
economy.
• The objectives of the SAARC are
1- Cultural and social: To establish better cultural and social ties amongst the member states to promote
peace in the region
2- To promote trade amongst the members in order to improve the economic status of its members
3- Social wellbeing :To accelerate the pace of social and economic development of the countries and raise
it from a region of poverty to a region of economic and social wellbeing.
4- Further the cause of peace, progress and stability in the region.
ACHIEVEMENTS OF SAARC
• SAPTA and SAFTA- To boost regional trade among countries of the region.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 125
• South Asian Identity- The most important achievements of SAARC are to bring the members of the states
close and think about regional issues and identity. They share common heritage, culture, clothing, political
system etc.
• South Asian University- it is an international university established in 2010. At present, the University is
offering postgraduate and doctoral programs in several disciplines. The university aims to create a center of
excellence and produce leaders who identify themselves as citizens of the region with a common vision of
success for both their home country and the neighbors.
• SAARC Development Fund- It was established in 2010. The Fund serves as the umbrella financial institution
for SAARC projects and programs which aims to promote the welfare for the people of the South Asian
region; to improve their quality of life, economic growth, social progress and poverty alleviation in the region.
• SAARC Arbitration Council- is an inter-governmental body authorized to provide a legal framework or forum
within the region for fair and effective settlement of industrial, commercial, trade, investment banking, such
their other issues, and disputes, as may be referred to it by the member states and their people.
Failures of SAARC
However, SAARC has failed in its objective of regional integration due to various reasons like-
• Indo-Pak Relations: Escalated tension and conflict between India and Pakistan have severely hampered the
prospects of SAARC.
• No regular meetings- After terrorist attacks on Uri, SAARC meetings could not be held due to India-Pakistan
tensions. Year 2021 marked 7th year since last summit where SAARC leaders met.
• Weak Cultural Identities – National identities are not yet consolidated in countries of south Asia. This limits
the prospects of cooperation among the countries due to trust deficit among members.
• Unresolved issues: The region still faces many unresolved border and maritime issues. Further, Fear of India's
Big Brotherly attitude among small neighbors has reduced scope of cooperation at SAARC.
• India’s apprehension: Such an organization might be used by her smaller neighbors to extract undue
concessions by expressing their fear of being bullied by India.
• Limitation in SAFTA: The implementation of SAFTA has not been satisfactory. Due to this South Asia remains
the least integrated region in the world with trade among members being less that 5% of their overall trade.
• Decision Making- As per SAARC charter, all decisions are taken by consensus. This has enabled Pakistan to
oppose every initiatives of India on connectivity and trade.
• Bilateral issues like Bangladesh’s concerns over CAA-NRC, Madhesi issue and Kalapani Border issue between
India and Nepal etc.
• Rising Chinese footprint- According to a Brookings India study, most South Asian nations are now largely
dependent on China for imports despite geographical proximity to India. Apart from all-weather friendship
between Pakistan and China, Nepal is also moving closer to China for ideational and material reasons.
Further, China is wooing Bangladesh by offering tariff exemption to 97% of Bangladeshi products, and has
intensified its ties with Sri Lanka through massive investments.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 126
WAY FORWARD-
• Reviving SAARC to deal with China- Several foreign policy experts argue that India’s strategic dealing with
China has to begin with South Asia. In this regard, it is important to reinvigorate SAARC, which has been in
the doldrums since 2014.
• Increasing people to people contact- Solely relying on the governments to bring about an integration of the
region may not be enough. An active participation of the fifth estate (social media) and citizens can
strengthen people to people contact and hence bring about regional integration.
• Economic Integration- India should take the lead and work with its neighbours to slash the tariff and non-
tariff barriers. There’s a need to resuscitate the negotiations on a SAARC investment treaty, pending since
2007.
• Greater resources and focus on SAARC instead of BIMSTEC- BIMSTEC cannot replace SAARC for reasons such
as lack of a common identity and history among all BIMSTEC members. Moreover, BIMSTEC’s focus is on the
Bay of Bengal region, thus making it an inappropriate forum to engage all South Asian nations.
• Ease of doing business- for the freer transit trade throughout the region, development of supply and logistic
chains, single-window and digitised clearance systems, wider use of trade lines of credit, denser connectivity,
smoother cross-border inspections, and reduced transaction costs, using technology as a force multiplier.
• Developing Modus Vivendi to work with Pakistan. As India already attends summits of SCO, where Pakistan
is also a member, it should also consider reviving regular SAARC summits. Nepal and Sri Lanka have already
urged India to reconsider its decision of boycotting the meetings.
CONCLUSION-
• The biggest challenge to India’s leadership in South Asia comes from China. Seen through Beijing’s prism,
India’s SAARC neighbourhood may be a means to contain India. In this context, India needs to find its own
prism with which to view its South Asian neighbourhood as it should be: a unit that has a common future,
and as a force-multiplier for India’s ambitions on the global stage. For this, revival of SAARC is essential to
realise this goal.
RELEVANCE OF BRICS-
• As a counterweight to the G-7 and bridge between the developed and developing world.
• BRICS countries are rich in natural resources, have strong military industrial complexes and skilled
manpower.
o Rise of BRICS has been described by Fareed Zakaria as decline of the west and rise of rest.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 127
• Multipolar world order- BRICS members have the same objective of multipolar world order. They can also
play important role in preventing the ‘New Cold War’ between the USA and China as BRICS countries
together accounts for 42% of the world’s population, a third of the global GDP and around 17% share of
world trade.
ISSUES
• CHINESE UNILATERALISM- China no longer needs BRICS to further its agenda.so its interest in forum has
declined.
• CHANGING GEOPOLITICAL ENVIRONMENT- While Russia has sided with China against the USA, India is
working with the USA in QUAD.
• TRADE- intra BRICS trade amounts to only 6.5% of their total trade.
• BRICS failed to achieve any of its core goals like reform of the UN , Multipolar world order etc.
• Various regional organisations like ASEAN undermined BIMSTEC due to duplication of agenda.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 128
BAY OF BENGAL INITIATIVE FOR MULTI -SECTORAL TECHNICAL AND ECONOMIC COOPERATION
(BIMSTEC)
WHAT IS IT?
• BIMSTEC is a regional organization comprising seven Member States lying in the littoral and adjacent areas
of the Bay of Bengal constituting a contiguous regional unity. It came into being on 6 June 1997 through the
Bangkok Declaration. Its secretariat is in Dhaka.
PRINCIPLES OF BIMSTEC-
• Sovereign equality, Territorial integrity, Peaceful co- existence and mutual benefit, No-interference in
internal affairs, Political independence.
Evolution of BIMSTEC
OBJECTIVES
As stated in the Declaration of
BIMSTEC, its objectives are:
• RAPID ECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT
• TO PROVIDE ASSISTANCE to
each other in the form of
training and research
facilities in the educational,
professional and technical
spheres.
• CONNECTIVITY- To
cooperate more effectively
in joint efforts that result
in their living standards,
including generating
employment and improving
transportation and
communication
infrastructure.
• GLOBAL CO-OPERATION- To
maintain close and beneficial
cooperation with existing
international and regional
organizations with similar
aims and purposes.
• REGIONAL INTEGRATION-
through connectivity and
cooperation and leveraging
Blue Economy.
IMPORTANCE
• BRIDGE BETWEEN SOUTH AND SOUTH EAST ASIA- BIMSTEC has also established a platform for intra-regional
cooperation between SAARC and ASEAN members. The objectives of the BIMSTEC are in conjunction
with India’s policies of ‘Neighbourhood First’ and ‘Act East’
• GEOECONOMIC IMPORTANCE- The BIMSTEC region is home to around 1.5 billion people which constitute
around 22% of the global population with a combined GDP of 2.7 trillion economy.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 129
- Theatre of convergence: The coming years will most likely be characterised by a “theatre of
convergence and competition for China’s Belt and Road Initiative, India’s Act East policy, and the
Asia–Africa Growth Corridor.” In this context BIMSTEC becomes important to build on these
convergences.
• SECTOR-DRIVEN COOPERATIVE ORGANIZATION- It covers total 14 sectors of cooperation.
• CONNECTIVITY-
▪ Kaladan Multimodal Project – links India and Myanmar.
▪ Asian Trilateral Highway - connecting India and Thailand through Myanmar.
▪ Bangladesh-Bhutan-India-Nepal (BBIN) Motor Vehicles Agreement - for seamless flow of passenger and
cargo traffic.
▪ India has also circulated a draft text for the BIMSTEC Coastal Shipping Agreement.
▪ In the recent summit, the members conveyed their support for the Master Plan for Transport
Connectivity.
• It is important for the success of neighbourhood First Policy, Act East Policy.
• ALTERNATIVE TO SAARC- India has clubbed BIMSTEC division with SAARC division in MEA and also invited
BIMSTEC members instead of SAARC members during 8th BRICS summit for BRICS-BIMSTEC outreach summit.
• Counter terrorism and Transnational Crime-
- Against terrorism: BIMSTEC, through its various sub-groups under Counter Terrorism and Transnational
Crime has been working towards strengthening cooperation against terrorism.
- Common security space: Three Meetings of the BIMSTEC National Security Chiefs (NSCs) have so far
been held underscoring the importance of recognizing the Bay of Bengal as common security space and
agreed to work out collective strategies for common response.
• Regional Integration- In the recent virtual summit, the foreign ministers cleared the draft for the BIMSTEC
charter.
• Environment and Disaster Management-
- Capacity building: The BIMSTEC Summit in 2014 resolved to enhance cooperation in environmental
protection and sustainable development and promote capacity building in the area of disaster
management.
- Disaster response: Member countries also undertake BIMSTEC Disaster Management Exercise for
capacity building of countries for disaster response.
- Addressing regional susceptibilities: India has also taken the initiative for addressing regional
susceptibilities by setting up a BIMSTEC Centre for Weather and Climate (BCWC), a state-of-the-art
facility in NOIDA, in 2014.
- Sharing data: India has also set up a link between BIMSTEC countries through Tsunami Early Warning
Centre and has been sharing data from the Tsunami Early Warning Centre since 2006.
ISSUES-
• NEGLECT BY MEMBER STATES: India’s engagement has been episodic and ad hoc and other major members
like Thailand and Myanmar are focused more towards ASEAN than BIMSTEC
• BILATERAL ISSUES BETWEEN MEMBER NATIONS: Bangladesh is facing one of the worst refugee crisis of
Rohingyas. There is a border conflict between Myanmar and Thailand. Further, the military coup in
Myanmar, brutal crackdown of protesters and continuation of popular resistance resulting in a extended
impasse have produced a new set of challenges.
• No FTA: BIMSTEC FTA was being negotiated since 2004, but it has not been concluded yet. Even in the recent
conference, there was no reference of it in the trade and economic dossier.
• INCONSISTENCY IN MEETINGS: BIMSTEC planned to hold summits every two years, ministerial meetings
every year, but no summit was held after 2018. Also, while most of the regional organisation (SCO, ASEAN,
G20) were able to meet at a high political level even during the Pandemic, BIMSTEC leaders failed to meet.
• Uncertainties over SAARC impact the development of BIMSTEC.
o For instance, BIMSTEC members Nepal and Sri Lanka want a revival of the SAARC summit.
• Asymmetry among members: There exist significant asymmetries among the BIMSTEC countries which
cannot be overlooked when it comes to conducting negotiations as well as implementations.
o For example, while Thailand, India ,Sri Lanka have made considerable progress in socio-economic
indicators, countries like Nepal, Myanmar are still battling with political instability , poverty etc.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 130
• Poor Physical Infrastructure- The BIMSTEC region is beleaguered by poor road and rail connectivity,
insufficient last-mile links and cumbersome customs and clearance procedures which hamper trade.
WAY FORWARD
• Leadership by India- India needs to put more resources and adopt proactive diplomacy for the success of
BIMSTEC.
• Project Delivery- Connectivity projects like Kaladan Multi Modal Transport Corridor needs to be completed
at earliest.
• Improving connectivity- Physical infrastructure is essential for linking the region not only in terms of boosting
connectivity and trade but also for facilitating people-to-people interactions. Thus, for BIMSTEC to evolve
into a functional and vibrant platform, it is imperative that expanding and deepening connectivity among the
Bay littorals be treated with utmost importance.
• Early Finalization Of FTA- FTA can lead to a levelling of capacities, boost productivity and improve
quality. Further, it can also bring regional integration and have positive spill over effect in other areas such
as security cooperation, political stability etc.
• Members also needs to cooperate in Blue Economy for sustainable development of maritime resources and
socio-economic development of coastal communities.
• Regular Meetings- regular annual summits are needed to convince the region about strong commitment of
the members to the new vision they have for this unique platform linking South Asia and Southeast Asia.
Conclusion-
• Pivot to its ‘Act East Policy’: The BIMSTEC has a huge potential to emerge as a platform that accelerate the
process of the regional integration and inclusive growth. For India, BIMSTEC can act as pivot to its ‘Act East
Policy’.
• However, as per Shyam Saran,’ Our capacities and institutions lag behind our ambitions. Thus, It is time to
move from an event oriented to process driven approach to revitalise the platform.’
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 131
Recent news-
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 132
IMPORTANCE OF ASEAN-
• TRADE- It stands at 76 billion dollar. ASEAN is India’s 4th largest trading partner while India is ASEAN’s 7th
largest trading partner. India has FTA in goods as well as services with FTA.
• GEOSTRATEGIC-
o Shared interest in free, open and rules based Indo-Pacific.
o 30 annual level dialogue mechanisms including PM level annual summits highlights the importance
of the relationship.
o ASEAN centrality: As the centre of Gravity of global politics is shifted towards Indo Pacific, India has
supported ASEAN centrality in emerging regional security architecture. ASEAN also looks towards
India as a balancer to China.
• CONNECTIVITY-
o India has supported a master plan on ASEAN connectivity 2025 which aims to achieve a seamlessly
and comprehensively connected and integrated ASEAN that will promote competitiveness,
inclusiveness, and a greater sense of Community.
o Negotiations are going on for ASEAN India transit and transport agreement.
o Kaladan multimodal transport agreement is also aimed to promote connectivity between ASEAN and
India.
o India and ASEAN are holding consultations on extension of Trilateral Highway toLaos, Cambodia and
Vietnam.
• CULTURE
o 9 out of 10 ASEAN countries have Indian cultural base.
o Buddhism provides important cultural linkage. Countries are also working towards revival of Nalanda
University.
• MARITIME SECURITY –
o Shared interest of free, open and rules-based Indo-Pacific. India has launched Indo-pacific ocean
initiative(IPOI). It is based on 7 pillars of maritime security; maritime ecology; maritime resources;
capacity building and resource sharing; disaster risk reduction and management; science,
technology, and academic cooperation; and trade connectivity and maritime transport.
o Indo-ASEAN Plan of Action (2021-2025) adopted during India-ASEAN Ministerial Meeting held in
September aims to ensure maritime security, shared progress, territorial integrity, and international-
rules based system in the region.
PROBLEMS-
Political relations have outpaced economic, commercial and people to people relationships.
• TRADE- India’s profile has been modest as compared to china. While India-ASEAN trade is 71 billion, it is 450
billion between ASEAN and china. India and ASEAN also missed out target of $100 billion trade due to Red-
Tapism and delays in projects implementation.
• RCEP: India coming out of RCEP will also disappoint ASEAN while giving advantage to China. India has also
demanded review of existing FTA in goods and greater market access for its goods.
• Logistic challenges: Challenges in establishing a supply chain, poor infrastructure, bad maritime and air
connectivity, bureaucratic costs involved in complex tax and duty structures hamper FDI inflows and SMEs
collaboration between India and ASEAN countries.
• The relevance of ASEAN is itself in question due to differences among members.
o For Ex – Cambodia, and Laos almost supports China but at the same time Vietnam, the Philippines,
and Indonesia opposes China for their authoritarianism.
• LACK OF PHYSICAL CONNECTIVITY- Kaladan project, IMT highway projects are languishing for long which
increases the logistics costs for transport of goods.
• Relationships with selected countries like Singapore, Myanmar and Thailand have advanced.
o For ex- 98% of ASEAN investment into India comes from Singapore.
WAY FORWARD-
• STRENGTHENING DEFENCE PARTNERSHIP- through regular trilateral and multilateral exercises, greater
interoperability between navies.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 133
India already has FTA in goods and services with ASEAN and a comprehensive economic partnership
agreement(CEPA) with Japan and South Korea. India is also negotiating a Comprehensive Economic Cooperation
Agreement with Australia.
IMPLICATIONS-
GEOECONOMIC-
• Impact its bilateral trade ties with RCEP member nations, as they may be more inclined to focus on bolstering
economic ties within the bloc.
• Could impact the Australia-India-Japan network in the Indo-Pacific. It could potentially put a spanner in the
works on informal talks to promote a Supply Chain Resilience Initiative among the three.
• With this India will be out of 2 major regional FTA’s - COMPREHENSIVE AND PROGRESSIVE AGREEMENT FOR
TRANSPACIFIC PARTNERSHIP (CPTPP) and RCEP.
GEOSTRATEGIC-
• BALANCING CHINA- ASEAN countries look at India as balancer to China. India’s withdrawal can further
increase Chinese influence in the region and dent credibility of India.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 134
• PARTNERSHIP WITH JAPAN- India’s withdrawal was a blow to Japan. For Japan, RCEP is an important step
towards a free and open economic system, one that would pressure the United States to return to a trade
framework, with an Indian presence checking Chinese influence.
• IMPACT ON ACT EAST POLICY- India’s withdrawal can also negatively impact Act East Policy as economic ties
with ASEAN and broader Indo-pacific is an important pillar of policy.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 135
• The Prime Minister of India indirectly referred chinese infrastructure projects in Pakistan Occupied Kashmir
and India China standoff at line of actual control and urged members of the SCO to respect “territorial
integrity” and “sovereignty” of each other.
About SCO-
• The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation (SCO) is a permanent intergovernmental international
organisation. The Shanghai Cooperation Organisation Charter, formally establishing the organisation, was
signed in June 2002 and entered into force on 19 September 2003.
• SCO comprises eight member states, India, Kazakhstan, China, the Kyrgyz Republic, Pakistan, Russia,
Tajikistan, and Uzbekistan.
OBJECTIVES:
• To deal with extremism, radicalism, drug trafficking and counter terrorism.
• Promote economic security by trade, connectivity and financial inclusion.
• Its aim was to counter the USA and showcase eastern values of mutual respect and plurality.
PRINCIPLES-
• It is based on the SHANGHAI SPIRIT of good neighbourliness which include non-interference, consensus,
harmony, respect for culture and non-alignment.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 136
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 137
• However unlike other members whose primary focus is on Pacific ocean, India’s primary focus is on Indian
Ocean Region .
CHINESE APPREHENSION
• China considers QUAD as ASIAN NATO or MINI NATO intended to stop its rise. On the eve of the QUAD
summit, the Global Times—the ruling Chinese Communist Party’s paramount mouthpiece—had warned that
an attempt to replicate NATO in Asia will not succeed.
ASEAN
• As the Quad approaches the intended institutionalization, its members are working more closely with key
regional actors.
• ASEAN centrality: To reassure the ASEAN member countries amidst the geopolitical turbulence, the leaders
reaffirmed their strong support for ASEAN’s unity and centrality in the emerging security architecture.
• No open confrontation: However, many ASEAN countries do not want to openly take sides in the
confrontation between the U.S. and China. Most of them welcome the U.S. presence in the region.
Concurrently, they are aware of the benefits of cooperation with China, which will in any case remain the
main trading partner.
QUAD AS COUNTERBALANCE TO CHINA-
• PREVENTING CHINESE UNILATERALISM- the Galwan clashes, along with China’s assertiveness in the South
China Sea, are being touted as the “tipping point” towards the militarisation of the Quad.
• NEW SECURITY ARCHITECTURE IN INDO-PACIFIC- QUAD aims to promote a free and open rules-based order,
rooted in international law in Indo-Pacific region. It has also accepted ASEAN Centrality in new regional
architecture.
• MILITARY RESPONSE TO CHINA’S AGGRESSION- USA has increased freedom of navigation operations in south
china sea. Also inclusion of Australia in Malbar Exercise highlight willingness on part of QUAD members to
counter "China's unfolding hegemonic master-plan."
• REDUCING DEPENDENCE ON CHINA- QUAD members have launched initiatives like supply chain resilience
initiative, blue dot network to diversify supply chains and ensuring sustainable infrastructure development
respectively.
ISSUES-
• DEPENDENCY ON CHINA- All QUAD members have overwhelming economic dependence on China.
o For ex- 38% of Australian exports are to china. China is also the biggest trading partner of all QUAD
members.
• QUESTIONABLE CONSTRUCT- some scholars like Brahma Challney question Indo-pacific constructs.
According to him, it is a combination of 2 systems- Indian ocean system and East Asian system and not a
continuous construction. This makes it a artificial construct. Thus building coherent policy for the whole
region is difficult for countries.
• LACK OF INSTITUTIONALIZATION – Due to lack of synergy among members, asymmetry in terms of military
power and lack of consensus on burden sharing.
• DIFFERENT CAPABILITIES AND BURDEN SHARING- 4 members have different military and economic
resources. There is lack of consensus among members regarding role and responsibilities of members.
• DIFFERENCE IN PRIORITIES- while India’s focus is on Indian Ocean Region , other 3 members are focused on
pacific ocean.
• DEFINITIONAL DILEMMA- members are reluctant to name china as main strategic adversary due to huge
economic interdependence.
WAY FORWARD-
• CENTRALITY OF ASEAN- QUAD members should accept this principle as it will reject the centrality of china as
well as will enhance credibility and legitimacy of QUAD.
• COUNTERING WEAPONIZATION OF TRADE by China. QUAD should expand its scope to include quality
infrastructure, resilient supply chains , connectivity etc.
• Institutionalization- members need to put resources to provide robust institutional framework to grouping.
• QUAD PLUS-
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 138
o The membership can be increased to include countries like Vietnam, New Zealand, South Korea etc,
who share similar interests.
o European countries UK and France who have naval bases in the region can also be incorporated in
expanded QUAD.
CONCLUSION-
• Though prime motivation behind QUAD is rising unilateralism by China yet it is neither an exclusive bloc or
military arrangement. Thus India needs to continue its policy of STRATEGIC AUTONOMY and multiple circles
of engagements like QUAD, BRICS, SCO etc. It gives Indian foreign policy a degree of flexibility and room for
manoeuvre vis-a-vis major powers.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 139
may not be in the best Interests of India considering diplomacy makes the anti-colonialism agenda of
the close relationship between India and the USA. NAM relevant again.
• Duplication- Various organisations duplicating the • Multipolar world order- NAM can help in formation
agenda of NAM such as south-south cooperation of a multipolar world with India becoming a major
have come into existence. Due to their small size pole in Global Balance of Power.
and greater convergence of interests, they have
proved more useful than the NAM. For ex- G-33,
IDSA, BRICS etc.
WAY FORWARD-
• REINVENTING THE AGENDA as long-held assumption and alignments rooted in the legacies of colonialism
and the ideology of the Cold War are making way for new configurations and partnerships , NAM needs to
be reformed to deal with 21st century issues of developing countries such as Climate change, environmental
degradation, terrorism, radicalisation, poverty, public health emergencies, humanitarian and natural
calamities, cyber security
• BETTER INSTITUTIONALISATION AND REGULAR SUMMITS for coordinated policy making.
• Containing China- NAM platform can be used to garner support by South-East Asian countries against
Chinese assertion in South China Sea and related island and border disputes. Similar consensus can be build
among African countries.
Conclusion
• NAM has served the useful purpose of protecting the interest of the Third World countries well in the past
and can play the significant role in protecting the economic interest of the Third World countries as well as
promoting south-south cooperation at present.
RECENT NEWS-
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 140
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 141
ABOUT AIIB-
• AIIB is a multilateral development bank with headquarters in Beijing, China. It started its operations in
2016. Currently it has 103 members.
• Membership to the bank is open to all members of the Asian Development Bank or the World Bank. It
allows non-sovereign entities to apply for membership provided their home countries are members.
• The largest contributor to AIIB is China and the second-highest shareholder is India
ABOUT APEC-
• It is a voluntary forum of 21 pacific rim economies to promote free trade throughout Asia-Pacific region.
• The idea of APEC was first publicly broached by former Prime Minister of Australia Bob Hawke FOR
1. Coordinated policy making
2. Capitalising on complementarities of economies in the region.
SIGNIFICANCE-
• It adopts a bottom up approach and also involves the private sector so it can play an important role in
human resource development , regional integration etc.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 142
CONCLUSION
• The concept of Asia-Pacific has been broadened to Indo-Pacific. So inclusion of India can help it rediscover itself
and can help it revitalise.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 143
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 144
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 145
INDIA IN UNSC
Recent Developments
• T. S. Tirumurti has been appointed as the Permanent Representative of India to the United Nations.
• For the eighth time, India has become a non-permanent member of the United Nations Security Council
(UNSC) for two years i.e 2021-22.
REFORM OF UNSC
Need for Reform
• Veto power: The permanent members of the UNSC (P5) possess veto power. It provides them with the
ultimate weapon to stop the functioning of the UN against their National Interest.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 146
• Partial nature of P5: None of the UNSC decisions goes without criticism and allegations because of the
partial nature of P5 eg: During the Cold, War UNSC remained divided between P2 (China and Russia) and
P3 (US, France and Britain).
• Lack of transparency: There is a lack of transparency and accountability in the functioning of the UNSC.
• Lack of coordination between UNSC and UNGA (United Nations General Assembly) is always visible.
• Not reflect today’s reality: UNSC in its present configuration cannot be called representative in any
manner.
• The G4 countries (India, Brazil, Germany and Japan) which share a significant amount of economic
contribution in the world's GDP have been raising voices for much-needed reform in UNSC.
• Two-thirds majority: It also suggested that reforms-related decisions should be by a two-thirds majority
in the UN General Assembly, which was enshrined in the 1998 resolution of the UNGA.
Most urgent reforms needed
• VETO Reform: UNGA should be given the power to override the VETO by P5 members.
• Membership Reform: The present configuration of UNSC permanent seats is not aligned with today’s
reality. The permanent seats of UNSC have no representation from Africa where most of the UN actions
are taken. Latin America has no representation whereas Europe is over-represented.
Benefits to India
• It will help India to globally expand its geo-economic and geopolitical influence.
• It will also transform India’s status to a global rule-maker from being a stakeholder.
• It will help India to be more vocal about the rights of developing and under-developed nations and thus
increase the influence of its soft power.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 147
Way Forward
• Since the formation of the UNSC world order has changed a lot, it is time to re-think the permanent members
of the UNSC.
• The power of veto is frequently cited as a major problem as the P5 members often influence the resolutions
making those countries suffer, which rather need a platform to grow.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 148
Governance of WTO
• Ministerial Conference- The topmost decision-
making body of the WTO is the Ministerial
Conference, which usually meets every two
years.
• General Council- The General Council is the
WTO’s highest-level decision-making body
located in Geneva, meeting regularly to carry out
the functions of the WTO.
• The Trade Policy Review Body (TPRB)-The WTO
General Council meets as the TPRB to undertake trade policy reviews of Members under the TPRM and to
consider the Director-General's regular reports on trade policy development.
• Dispute Settlement Body (DSU)- The General Council convenes as the Dispute Settlement Body (DSB) to deal
with disputes between WTO members.
Achievement of WTO
• Codification of global trade- WTO has framed the binding rules for global trade in goods and services. It also
enhanced the value and quantity of trade by eradicating trade and non-trade barriers.
• Surge in Global Value Chains- The predictable market conditions and improved communications by WTO has
enabled the rise of global value chains, trade within these value chains today accounts for almost 70% of total
merchandise trade.
• Supporting under-developed countries- The various agreements and trade negotiations by WTO has
recognized that poor countries must benefit from the greatest possible flexibility by lowering import barriers
on least-developed countries’ exports.
Issues Related to WTO
• China’s mercantilism- The nature of China’s economic system, combined with the size and growth of its
economy, has created tensions in the global trading system. China’s state-owned enterprises present a major
challenge to the free-market global trading system.
• US-China trade war- The trade tussle between the US and China not only distorts the trade structure of the world
but also impacts the trade of other dependent countries.
• Institutional Issues- The Appellate Body’s operations have effectively been suspended since December 2019, as
the US’s blocking of appointments has left the body without a quorum of adjudicators needed to hear appeals.
• Lack of Transparency- There is a problem in WTO negotiations as there is no agreed definition of what constitutes
a developed or developing country at the WTO.
• Rising e-commerce and digital trade- The global trade structure of the world has changed over the last two
decades and WTO has not yet kept pace.
• Rising deadlock- WTO is facing challenges in terms of unilateral measures and countermeasures by some
members, deadlock in important areas of negotiations and ongoing impasse in the appointment of members of
the Appellate Body of WTO’s dispute settlement mechanism.
• Rise of regional trade agreement- It impacts the WTO’s multilateral trading system violate the WTO’s principle
of non-discrimination for all WTO members.
• Erosion of preferences- Concessions granted by developed countries on imports from certain developing
countries become less meaningful if the normal tariff rates are cut.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 149
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 150
Why in News?
• The USA has lifted sanctions and visa restrictions on officials of the International Criminal Court (ICC), who
were investigating American military and intelligence officials for potential war crimes in Afghanistan and
probed against alleged crimes by American ally Israel in Palestinian territories.
About ICC
• ICC is an intergovernmental organization and international tribunal headquarters in Hague. It was created
by the 1998 Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court and started functioning on 1st July 2002 when
the Statute came into force.
• Last resort: It is considered as the last resort to prosecute offences that would otherwise go unpunished and
has jurisdiction over four main crimes: genocide, crimes against humanity, war crimes, and the crime of
aggression.
Role and Functions
• Accountability: It enforces an integrated mechanism for bringing about Individual Accountability for
International Crimes.
• To prevent impunity: To enforce an International justice System to prevent impunity.
• To resolve the limitations of the Ad Hoc tribunals.
• It recognizes the role of the Security Council.
• It deals with 4 types of International Crimes including genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity, crimes
of aggression.
Limitations of ICC
• Weak legitimacy- The contribution of the ICC to furthering the cause of justice and peace is limited by the
fact that some states do not yet accept its legitimacy, by the tendency of certain states to seek to control
and use it as an instrument to reinforce their power, and by its ability to pursue its investigations successfully.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 151
• High influence of UNSC members- The role of the permanent five members of the UN Security Council is
crucial when crimes are committed in states which are not a party to the ICC in that case the UNSC decision
is necessary for triggering the ICC's jurisdiction. The big powers are likely to be the only states politically
capable of carrying out an ICC arrest warrant.
• Biasness- ICC has been accused of being a two of Western imperialism and biased in favour of powerful
countries against which states.
• Procedural challenges- Extensive deficiencies leading to delays and frustration have questioned the efficacy
of the court.
WORLD BANK
Introduction
• Provide financing: The World Bank is an international organization dedicated to providing financing, advice,
and research to developing nations to aid their economic advancement and bolster their economies.
• Bretton Woods Agreement: The World Bank and International Monetary Fund were founded simultaneously
under the Bretton Woods Agreement with the same focus to help serve international governments globally.
Structure of World Bank
The World Bank Group consists of five organizations
• The International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD) provides debt financing to governments
of middle-income and creditworthy low-income countries.
• The International Development Association (IDA) provides interest-free loans called credits and grants to
governments of the poorest countries.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 152
• The International Finance Corporation (IFC)- It is the largest global development institution focused
exclusively on the private sector.
• The Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA) promotes foreign direct investment into developing
countries to support economic growth, reduce poverty, and improve people’s lives.
The International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) provides international facilities for
conciliation and arbitration of investment disputes.
Main functions of World Bank
• Financing countries: It supplies qualifying nations with low-interest loans, zero-interest credits, and grants,
all to support the development of individual economies.
• Sharing of information with various entities through policy advice, research and analysis, and technical
assistance. It offers advice and training for both the public and private sectors.
Goals
• Ending extreme poverty by 2030 (understood as reducing the percentage of people living on less than $1.25
a day to 3%)
• Promoting shared prosperity (understood as fostering income growth of the bottom 40% of the population
in every developing country).
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 153
• It aims to reduce global poverty, encouraging international trade, and promoting financial stability and
economic growth.
Functions of IMF
• Overseeing the economies of member countries
• Lending to countries with balance of payments issues
• Modernizing economies: Helping member countries modernize their economies
The member countries of the IMF pay their capital subscription (quotas) when they become members. Each member
of the IMF is assigned a quota, based broadly on its relative position in the world economy. Countries can then
borrow from this pool when they fall into financial difficulty.
The existing quota formula of the IMF is a weighted average of GDP (weight of 50%), openness (30%), economic
variability (15%), and international reserves (5%). The formula also includes a “compression factor” that reduces
the dispersion of calculated quota shares across members.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 154
• Redistribution of quota: The traditional industrial countries should agree to a target of limiting their quota
shares to 60 per cent of their GDP shares to facilitate the further redistribution of quota shares toward the
non-industrial countries.
• A reasonable benchmark would be an increase in the size of the Fund (total quotas) by at least 50 per cent
to implement the redistribution of quota and voting shares under the new quota formula.
• Comprehensive implementation of 2010 reform which included an amendment to the Articles of Agreement
established an all-elected Executive Board, which facilitates a move to a more representative Executive
Board.
• Governance reforms: Implementation of The 15th General Quota Review (in the process) provides an
opportunity to assess the appropriate size and composition of the Fund’s resources and to continue the
process of governance reforms.
Conclusion
• In the present world order of economical competition, the IMF will have to do more than just superficially
tinker with its asymmetric power structure and outdated quota system. Else, it could be slowly but steadily
pushed into irrelevance.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 155
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 156
• India began the battle against the disease in response to the WHO’s 1988 Global Polio Eradication Initiative
as a result of these efforts, India was removed from the list of endemic countries in 2014.
India, WHO and COVID-19
• The World Health Organization is a leading organization involved in global coordination for mitigating the
COVID-19 pandemic.
• The WHO has spearheaded several initiatives like the COVID-19 Solidarity Response Fund, the UN COVID-
19 Supply Chain Task Force, and the solidarity trial for investigating potential treatment options for the
disease.
• Both India and WHO have come forward for vaccine development and organising immunization programs
in response to COVID-19.
Recent developments
• India has been elected to the Executive Board of the World Health Organisation (WHO). It will also be
holding a Chairmanship of the Executive Board for the next year (from May 2020- May 2021)
o The main functions of the Board are to give effect to the decisions and policies of the Health
Assembly, to advise it and generally to facilitate its work.
o The Board and the Assembly create a forum for debate on health issues and for addressing concerns
raised by the Member States.
• The Union Minister of Health and Family Welfare has been nominated by the Global Alliance for Vaccines
and Immunisation (GAVI) as a board member.
o GAVI is an international organisation, a global vaccine alliance created in 2000. WHO is one of its
partners. It is responsible for strategic direction and policy-making, oversees the operations of the
Vaccine Alliance and monitors programme implementation.
o It unites the public and private sectors on a common platform with a shared goal of creating equal
access to new and underused vaccines for children living in the world’s poorest countries.
Criticism
• Dependent on rich countries: WHO has been dependent on donor funds from rich countries rather than
through secured funding from countries.
• Efficacy under question: After its inadequate performance in containing West Africa’s Ebola epidemic of
2014, its efficacy has been questioned.
• Lack of rigidity on analysis of the spread of coronavirus due to which various countries are still not able to
overcome the pandemic completely.
Way Forward
• There should be proper support to the WHO financially and administratively for study and research.
• After electing India as a nation has an important say in fundamental reforms in the UN System, including
the WHO to make it more transparent, competent, and accountable.
Palestine refugees are defined as “persons whose normal place of residence was Palestine during the period 1
June 1946 to 15 May 1948, and who lost both home and means of livelihood as a result of the 1948 conflict.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 157
• Indian aid: India contributed 2 million USD to the UNRWA fulfilling its commitment of USD five million in
aid annually to support its programmes and services, including education, health care, relief and social
services for Palestinian refugees.
• India increased its annual financial contribution to UNRWA from USD 1.25 million in 2016 to USD 5 million
in 2018 and 2019.
• India has also assured to assist countries in need of critical, life-saving drugs amidst the COVID-19 pandemic
and will send a medical shipment to Palestine in the coming week.
Importance
• This contribution by India is more significant as it comes at a critical time when India is facing a difficult
situation at home due to the pandemic and it has still not forgotten the Palestinian refugees and stepped
in to help stabilise basic services, including education, health care, relief and social services for Palestinian
refugees.
• This financial assistance by India comes at a time when UNRWA has been facing a huge budgetary deficit
and with an overwhelming majority of the 5.6 million refugees living under the poverty line, the ongoing
pandemic has broken the backbone of the basic infrastructure in the area they live.
Way Forward
• Appeal to other countries: India has also made a strong appeal to other traditional donors of UNRWA to
consider enhancing their contributions as well as to non-donor member states to consider contributing to
the agency in solidarity with the Palestine refugees.
• UNRWA should extend its help to other parts of the region where other innocent people are suffering from
the consequences of war like Yemen, Syria and many other countries.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 158
Functions
• Designing and implementing policies that directly solve social and labour issues.
• Adopting the international labour standards in the form of conventions and recommendations and control
over their implementation.
• Assisting member-states in solving social and labour problems.
• Protecting the human rights of labour and ensuring their welfare.
• Recent Development
o After 35 years, India has assumed the role of chair of the International Labour Organisation’s
governing body for October 2020 till June 2021.
▪ It will provide a platform to apprise participants of the transformational initiative taken by
the government in removing the rigidities of the labour market, besides making intention
clear about the universalisation of social security to all workers in the organised or
unorganised sector.
Way Forward
• With the rising pandemic across the nation, the social security of labour is again in danger, there is a need
for collaboration of all states with ILO to come up with a policy formulation to ensure employment and
protect their rights amid pandemic.
INDIAN DIASPORA
WHY IN NEWS?
• Recently Prime Minister Narendra Modi called Diaspora as ‘RASHTRADOOT’ or ‘Informal Ambassadors’,
highlighting the important role played by them in India’s foreign policy.
Diaspora
• A diaspora is a large group of people with a similar heritage or homeland who have since moved out to
places all over the world.
• Historically, the word diaspora was used to refer to the mass dispersion of a population from its indigenous
territories, specifically the dispersion of Jews.
• Diaspora in Indian context includes Non-Resident Indians (NRIs), Persons of Indian Origin (PIOs) and
Overseas Citizens of India (OCI). PIO and OCI card holders were merged under one category OCI in 2015.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 159
• Switch of foreign policy priorities: When there was a switch of foreign policy priorities from realism to inter- third
world cooperation under the regime of Rajiv Gandhi, there was a slight shift in Diaspora policy as well.
• Having realized Indian Diaspora as a strategic asset, he invited Indian diasporic talents like Sam Pitroda to
realize his vision of 21st century India and took administrative measures like the establishment of Indian
Overseas Affairs department in 1984.
• Post LPG reforms: On the advent of new economic model post LPG reforms, the Indian Diaspora was able to
participate in the plethora of economic opportunities of the unregulated and open Indian economy.
• It resolved the foreign currency crisis due to substantial investment and remittance from the Indian Diaspora.
Subsequently, the Indian government changed its outlook towards Diaspora and reviewed its Diaspora
policy.
• Serious engagement: Atal Bihari Vajpayee is credited for having promoted serious engagement with the
Indian diaspora to develop mutually beneficial linkages.
• The various initiatives taken by him were separate Ministry of Overseas Indian Affairs, PIO Card, Overseas
Citizen of India Card, Pravasi Bharatiya Divas, Pravasi Bharatiya Samman Award, NRI funds and voting rights
for Indian citizens abroad.
• The present government has given special focus on diaspora. In 2015, the Ministry of External Affairs launched
the e-migrate system that requires all foreign employers to register in the database. Government has also
launched ‘Know India Program’ (KIP) in 2016 for diaspora engagement to familiarizes Indian-origin youth (18-30
years) with their Indian roots and contemporary India.
DATA
• As per International Migration Stock ,2019 of UNDESA, Indian diaspora comprises 6.4%(17 million) of total
migrant population. Top destinations are USA and west Asia.
• According to Global Migration Report 2020, India continues to be the largest country of origin of international
migrants with a 17.5 million-strong diaspora across the world, and it received the highest remittance of $78.6
billion (3.4% of India’s GDP) from Indians living abroad.
• They constitute 1.3% of the USA population and contribute 6% of the UK's GDP.
Significance of Diaspora-
• Remittances- India received the highest remittances ($78 billion), majority from the middle east. Further, the
migration of less-skilled labour (especially to West Asia) has also helped in bringing down disguised
unemployment in India.
• Reverse brain drain- in form of capital, technology and investments. Post LPG reforms, investments from Indian
diaspora was instrumental in solving BoP crisis.
• Strategic advantage- Indian diaspora is one of the richest minorities in many developed countries. They are
important for track 2 or backchannel diplomacy. Their advantage is evident in “diaspora diplomacy”, whereby
they act as “bridge-builders” between their home and adopted countries.
• For example, Indo-US Civil Nuclear Deal is a case in point, as ethnic Indians in the United States successfully
lobbied for the signing of the Nuclear Deal.
• Soft power- Diaspora are instrumental in spreading Indian culture, cuisine, tradition and civilizational values
abroad. This has positive impact on India’s soft power abroad as well as tourism.
• Political power: Many people of Indian origin hold top political positions in many countries, in the US itself they
are now a significant part of Republicans and Democrats, as well as the government. Similarly, many Indian origin
people hold important position in Pacific island nations like Fiji.
ISSUES
• Impact of Covid Pandemic- Due to reverse migration the remittances from diaspora will reduce. Further, the
economic problems due to pandemic can also cost their jobs and livelihood. This can further increase demand
on Indian job market and enhancing disguised unemployment.
• Economic slowdown- and rise of protectionism like America first policy and reduction in H1-B visas can reduce
job prospects for Indian diaspora abroad. Further, with the rising Anti-globalization wave, there has been an
increase in the incidents of suspected hate crimes against the Indian community
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 160
• Laws such as Kafala and Nitaqat in West Asia are against human rights and dignity and amount to exploitation of
Indian workers.
• Instability and civil wars in countries like Bahrain, Yemen etc. threatens the security of Indian workers.
• Separatist movements like Khalistan are backed by certain section of diaspora in Canada through funding support
• Heterogenous diaspora- The diaspora from the Gulf look to India for support on welfare issues those whereas
from wealthier nations such as the US look to India for investment opportunities. This create difficulty in devising
common diaspora policy.
GOVT STEPS
• Merging of ministry of OIA with MEA for more coherent diaspora policy and supporting Indian citizens abroad.
• MoU with countries for protection of workers and online database of emigrants.
• For example, India has been entering into bilateral Social Security Agreements (SSAs) with other countries in
order to protect the interests of Indian professionals / skilled workers working abroad for short durations
and enhance the competitiveness of Indian companies.
• ‘Madad’ portal for grievance redressal of diaspora. Consular grievances regarding compensation, court cases,
domestic helps, imprisonment abroad, transportation of mortal remains, repatriation, salary dues, tracing the
whereabouts can be lodged under this scheme.
• Operation Rahat, operation Sankat Mochan and Vande Bharat, Samudra Setu missions during Covid-19 Pandemic
to bring back stranded Indians from countries such as Yeman.
• Pravasi bhartiya divas and schemes such as Bharat Ko Janiye etc. to familiarize Indian origin people of their rich
cultural and civilizational heritage and strengthen their links with India.
WAY FORWARD
• Dual Citizenship- AS suggested by L.M Singhavi committee in 2000.
• Special Economic Zones for NRI investments and cutting red tapism. Diaspora should also be treated at par with
other Indian citizens both in the private and public sectors, to attract talented persons into the public sector.
• Diversification- Currently, India’s migration is concentrated in English-speaking countries for jobs and education.
The EU, Japan, Latin America and Russia should also be targeted over the next few decades. Also, there is greater
scope for jobs at all skill levels in global transportation, health and home care. This requires major investments
in specific educational services.
• Evacuation Policy: There is a need for a transparent diaspora evacuation policy from conflict zones in a world
where crises materialize in order to ensure safety and security of Indian diaspora.
CONCLUSION-
• As MEA lacks capacity and has resource crunch, diaspora as Informal Ambassadors can complement official
diplomatic efforts and expand India’s reach. Also, viewing the diaspora only through the looking glass of
remittances and financial flows represent very myopic view. A comprehensive diaspora policy is thus needed to
encourage and incorporate Indian diaspora in Indian growth story.
To Join 60 Days Rigorous Answer Writing Program click here: or visit: dpp.onlyias.in 161