Homosexuality - A Social Workers Imbroglio
Homosexuality - A Social Workers Imbroglio
Homosexuality - A Social Workers Imbroglio
Volume 6 Article 3
Issue 2 March
March 1979
Joyce C. Albro
Virginia Department of Welfare
Part of the Gender and Sexuality Commons, and the Social Work Commons
Recommended Citation
Tully, Carol and Albro, Joyce C. (1979) "Homosexuality: A Social Worker's Imbroglio," The Journal of
Sociology & Social Welfare: Vol. 6 : Iss. 2 , Article 3.
Available at: https://scholarworks.wmich.edu/jssw/vol6/iss2/3
ABSTRACT
Introduction
-154-
will be considered. Various suggestions will be offered to enable
social workers to more effectively work with their homosexual
clientele.
Historical Perspectives
Once the single-god religious system became the norm and the
Bible was written, the proscriptions of homosexuality became more
legitimized. The Old Testament clearly details laws that condemn
homosexuality. Leviticus 18:22 states, "Thou shalt not lie with man-
kind as with womankind: it is an abomination," and Leviticus 20:13
-155-
warns, "If a man also lie with mankind as he lieth with a woman,
both of them have committed an abomination: they shall surely be put
to death; their blood shall be upon them." 3 Quite obviously these
strict laws forbidding homosexuality had a profound impact on the
ancient culture. In the New Testament, St. Paul condemned homo-
sexuality, 4 and in the Thirteenth Century, Thomas Aquinas indicated
that homosexuality was inconsistent with God's design for humanity,
and it offended reason and nature. 5 The Christian ideal of the time
was complete celibacy, and even certain types of heterosexual activi-
ties were banned as being too pleasurable. 6 It is easy to see why the
homosexual was condemned for seeking sexual pleasure without attempting
to procreate.
-156-
that all homosexuals are mentally ill. According to the ancient
Judeo-Christian value base, engaging in homosexual acts was thought
to be ungodly or out of grace with God. To willfully be ungodly
obviously indicated that the offender was possessed by devils. People
who were mentally ill in older cultures were considered to be possessed
by devils so it is easy to see how homosexuality became equated with
mental illness. Even today, several prominent American psychiatrists
describe homosexualit as a character defect, a pathology or a severe
sexual maladjustment.1 0 These doctors tend to believe the homosexual
is in desperate need of treatment to insure that the deviant behavior
will cease so the once disturbed patient can function normally within
the society. Other contemporary psychiatrists believe that such
psychiatric attitudes toward homosexuality are actually based on moral
values and are reinstatements of the Judeo-Christian code with scienti-
fic rationalizations. 1 1 Such religiously based beliefs were easily
rationalized by clinical experience with small numbers of homosexual
patients who became the basis
12
for generalized psychiatric opinions
regarding all homosexuals.
-157-
often have such conflicting values. Generally, our society through
its religious and legal ethics, does not condone a lifestyle other
than the heterosexual, family oriented norm. Society fears anything
that seems to disrupt the familial constellation, and hence, a deeply
instilled fear of homosexuality exists in our culture. This fear has
been termed "homophobia". Homophobia is simply an excessive fear of
homosexuality that arises out of our society's ignorance and condem-
nation of a homosexual lifestyle. Societal stereotypes, myths and
prejudices about homosexuality exist because of widespread ignorance
and are an integral part of homophobia.
-158-
-One in three believe that a homosexual cannot be
a good Christian or Jew.
-159-
and through the reinforcement of ancient proscriptions about homo-
sexuality in media coverage and court cases, social workers may
encounter difficulty in being open minded about homosexuality and
may have deeply ingrained homophobic attitudes which are compounded
by ignorance. Such "gut" reactions and personal fears, based on
misconceptions and limited social interaction with openly homosexual
individuals must be confronted by every social worker. Social
workers' values mirror the values of society, and need thorough
evaluation to insure that human rights, individual self-determina-
tion and basic social work ethics are maintained.
-160-
Therefore, because of homophobia and unrealistic beliefs
about homosexuals, some social workers may be unable to develop
an atmosphere in which a trusting relationship with a homosexual
client can develop. Such a relationship is necessary so the
client feels safe to discuss important issues including sexual
orientation. Another hindrance to the emergence of a trusting
worker/client relationship is the general reluctance of some
social workers to discuss sexuality at all. For the homosexual
client who wishes to discuss sexual matters, this reluctance
may become an insurmountable barrier. In order for a trusting
relationship to develop between homosexual clients and workers,
workers must be willing to genuinely accept homosexuality as
19
a viable lifestyle. Only then can the necessary climate of
acceptance evolve.
-161-
The availability of supportive counseling services becomes
even more important for homosexuals who are just beginning to
admit or understand their sexual orientation. This process of
"coming out" to oneself, family, friends, society etc., is a
primary problem for many homosexuals. Social work services, if
needed, should be provided to assist the client with this process
by helping the client explore the anticipated and unanticipated
consequences of "coming out".
-162-
have specific and unique needs.
-163-
which will often provide bibliographies and other written in-
formation as well as homosexual speakers. 2 3 By reading realistic
information about homosexuals and by listening to homosexuals
discuss their lifestyles, the social worker can start to discount
stereotypes and myths and can view homosexuals as fully function-
ing, unique persons. Once so educated, the social worker can
then knowledgeably act as client advocate. Providing such an
advocacy support system for the homosexual client can do nothing
but enhance the worker/client relationship and improve societal
attitudes regarding homosexuals.
For every social worker, there are certain things that must
be remembered when working with any homosexual client. To
facilitate this special kind of worker/client relationship the
following suggestions are provided.
-164-
9) Become at ease when talking to the homosexual client
about sexual matters.
Conclusion
FOOTNOTES
i
Arno Karlen, Sexuality and Homosexuality (New York: W.W.
Norton, 1971), p. 3.
2
Ibid., pp. 9-10 and Delores Klaich, Woman Plus Woman
(New York: Simon and Schuster, 1974), pp. 232-233.
3
Holy Bible, King James Version.
4
Romans 1:26-27; I Corinthians 6:9; Timothy 1:10.
5
St. Thomas Aquinas, Summa Theologica, Question 154, Arts.
11-12, pt. 11-11 at 1825-26 (Fathers of the English Dominican
Province translation, 1947).
6
Genesis 19:1-38; Judges 19:22-30.
-165-
Betty Wysor, The Lesbian Myth (New York: Random House,
1974), p. 65.
8
John A. Symonds, "A Problem in Modern Ethics," in
Donald W. Cory, ed., Homosexuality: A Cross Cultural Approach
(New York: Julian Press, 1956) , pp. 7-8.
9
"The Homosexual's Legal Dilemma," Arkansas Law Review,
27(Winter 1973), pp. 689-690.
10
Specific psychiatrists that share one or more of these
values include: Edmund Bergler, Homosexuality: Disease or Way
of Life? (New York: Collier Books, 1956); Charles Hite, "Now
That It's Not Abnormal to be Gay, " Washington Star Newspaper,
4 April 1974, sec. 4, p. Dl; Richard Ryan, "A Catholic Psy-
chiatrist Dissents," The Tablet Magazine, 30 May 1974, p. IM;
and Charles Socarides in "Should Marriage Between Homosexuals
be Permitted?," Advocates (Transcript, WGBH-TV Boston, Pro-
ducers: 11 May 1974).
11
Judd Marmor, "Homosexuality and Cultural Value Systems,"
American Journal of Psychiatry, 130 (November 1973), p. 1208
and George Weinberg, Society and the Healthy Homosexual (New
York: Anchor Press, 1973), p. 22.
12
Advocates, p. 9.
13
American Psychiatric Association, Press Release (Wash-
ington, D.C., 15 December 1973), p. 1.
14
Advocates, pp. 9, 20-22.
15
"Gallup Poll: Social Role Sets View of Gays," Richmond
Times-Dispatch Newspaper, 19 July 1977, sec. 1, p. A2.
16
See Gifford G. Gibson, By Her Own Admission: A Lesbian
Mother's Fight to Keep Her Son (New York: Doubleday and Com-
pany, Inc., 1977); Bennett v. Clemens, 196 S.E. 2d 842 (S.C.
Ga. 1973), cited in E. Carrington Boggan; Marilyn G. Haft;
Charles Lister and John P. Rupp, The Rights of Gay People
(New York: Discus Books, 1975), p. 125; Chaffin v. Frye, 2 Civ.
No. 43862 (Cal. Ct. App. 2d App. Dist., 12 December 1973),
-166-
cited in R.A. Basile, "Lesbian Mothers I," Women's Rights
Law Reporter, 2(December 1974), p. 23 and In re Tammy F.,
1 Civ. No. 32648 (Cal. 1st App. Dist., Div. 2, 21 August
1973), cited in Basile, p. 21.
17
"Status as Homosexual Grounds for Teacher Dismissal,"
Sexual Law Reporter, 3 (March/April 1977), pp. 14-15.
18
Gordon Hamilton, Theory and Practice of Social Case-
work (New York: Columbia University Press, 1951), pp. 52-55
and Florence Hollis, Casework: A Psychosocial Therapy (New
York: Random House, 1972), p. 91.
19
It is our contention that any worker who views homo-
sexuality as anything other than a viable, alternative life-
style should not work with homosexual clients. Since homo-
sexuals receive little societal support anyway, the homosexual
client needs and deserves an accepting social worker.
20
"The Homosexual's Legil Dilemma," p. 693.
21
John P. DeCecco, "Studying Violations of Civil Liberties
of Homosexual Men and Women," Journal of Homosexuality, 2 (Summer
1977), pp. 315-322 and Mary Adelman, "Sexual Orientation and
Violations of Civil Liberties," Journal of Homosexuality 2 (Summer
1977), pp. 327-330.
22
"Tucson Enacts Gay Rights Ordinance," Sexual Law Reporter,
3 (March/April 1977), p. 2 1 .
23
Several good journals about homosexuality now exist as well
as more and more credible research on the topic. For information
about the gay community, the best resource now available is the
National Gay Task Force (NGTF), Room 506, 80 Fifth Avenue, New
York, New York 10011. NGTF is an excellent resource for educational
materials and information about the homophile community in your
area.
24
National Association of Social Workers, "Code of Ethics."
-167-