EUBOF - May Trends Report
EUBOF - May Trends Report
EUBOF - May Trends Report
Germany: Starting on July 1st, new legislation in Germany will enable a special kind of investment fund known
as "Spezialfonds" to invest as much as 20% of their portfolios in Cryptocurrencies. The new legislation could
introduce as much as €350 Billion in institutional investment in the cryptocurrency market, according to
Boersen Zeitung. Spezialfonds are similar to Luxembourg's Special Investment Funds (SIFs), and Ireland's
Qualifying Investor Funds (QIFs). Such funds are generally less restrictive, more flexible, and diversified than
others.
Speaking to popular cryptocurrency news website Decrypt, Frank Schäffler, Member of the Bundestag
mentioned that:
"The addition of crypto assets in Spezialfonds is an important step for their acceptance" and continued, “The
law is going in the right direction and we expressly welcome it”
This development falls in line with other signs pointing to cryptocurrencies gaining increased momentum
amongst Germany's regulators. Indicatively, in December of 2020, Deutsche Bank, Germany's largest,
revealed plans for Crypto Custody.
Ireland: On April 23rd, Irish regulators implemented The European Union's Fifth Anti-Money Laundering
Directive (5AMLD). As a result, businesses dealing primarily in the cryptocurrency space now have 3-month-
period to register with the Central Bank. Additionally, virtual asset providers now must comply with the same
know-your-customer (KYC), anti-money laundering (AML), and counter-terrorism financing (CTF)
requirements as banks and other financial institutions. The implementation of this directive effectively puts a
stop to anonymous cryptocurrency purchases and trading in the country.
Spain: Following the recent surge in the popularity of Bitcoin's in the country, Spain's Ministry of Finance
issued a reminder/warning on the taxable state of cryptocurrencies and highlighted the harsh penalties for
Page 1 | 9
cryptocurrency holders that fail to disclose their holdings. Telemadrit estimates that as many as 15,000
Spanish citizens will have to disclose their holdings in their tax statements.
"[...] As of now this rule looks technology neutral. Crypto same as cash. That seems good. (This) also only
applies to intermediaries (and businesses). Not p2p transactions"
ContrariwiseContrariwise, the price of the privacy focused coin Monero, that obscures the origins of transaction
to ensure anonymity, increased by more than 30% following the Treasury's announcement.
Consumer protection: In terms of consumer protection, the newly appointed SEC chair, Gary Gensler,
advocated on two separate occasions for additional measures. Appearing before the House Financial Services
Committee on May 6th, Mr Gensler said that while the SEC is restricted to securities and products that might
invest in cryptocurrencies, the Congress on the other hand could facilitate for regulatory clarity especially when
it comes to cryptocurrency exchanges.
“[...] Right now these exchanges do not have a regulatory framework at the SEC or at our sister agency, the
Commodity Futures Trading Commission. There’s not a market regulator around these crypto exchanges and
thus there’s really no protection around fraud or manipulation”
On May 21st, while speaking at the 2021 Financial Industry Regulatory Authority’s (FINTRA) annual
conference, the Chairman mentioned that "(The SEC) should be ready to bring cases involving issues such
as crypto" and further noted that "rules of the road" and constant monitoring are necessary to protect
consumers”, before admitting that the necessary framework has yet to be established.
The above statements followed important changes in the Safe Harbor proposal, introduced in February of this
year. The Safe Harbor proposal aims to update US security legislation to provide more leeway for
cryptocurrency tokens. Following feedback from the industry, Safe Harbor 2.0 may now facilitate for a "magic
frog" solution, by allowing up to three years before determining whether a cryptocurrency token is a security,
and thus subject to relevant regulation, or not. If the proposal materialises, a token could theoretically begin
its life as a security (i.e., a magic frog) but through building a functional, decentralized network and growing
participation in it to the point that the network is not reliant on the efforts of the founding team, the token could
be transformed into a utility (i.e., the magic frog becomes a prince) and any securities law restrictions would
no longer apply. Notably, this approach is one that the SEC opposed in the past.
Finally, following growing concerns regarding the sustainability of Proof of Work (PoW), New York State
Senator Kevin Parker proposed a bill that -if approved- will only allow Bitcoin mining facilities to operate, after
review of their environmental impact.
Page 2 | 9
Regulatory developments in the Middle East & Asia:
On the opposite side of the spectrum, an increasingly inhospitable approach against cryptocurrencies is
adopted by some countries from Asia and the Middle East.
Turkey: As the Turkish Lira slips to its weakest point against the dollar since November of 2020, in what was
characterised by Commerzbank's analyst Tatha Ghose as “self-reinforcing spirals”, the Country's Central Bank
announced the ban of Cryptocurrencies for payments for goods and services. The notice cited "irreparable"
possible damages and risk as reasons for the prohibition and noted that cryptocurrencies are "neither subject
to any regulation and supervision mechanisms nor a central regulatory authority".
A short week after the announcement of the ban, 2 large cryptocurrency exchanges went offline.
Cryptocurrency exchange Thodex abruptly halted trading and customer withdrawals. Shortly after, Vebitcoin
also blocked trading and prevented users from accessing its platform. Thodex's CEO claimed that the
operations were a result of Cyberattack, whereas Vebitcoin cited "intense transactions" that put the exchange
in a “financially difficult position”.
In response, the Turkish watchdog MASAK froze bank accounts, detained staff, and seized computers, with
the Turkish government revealing plans to offer cryptocurrency custody with the central bank, likely to prevent
the outflow of funds. Additionally, Turkey's ministry of Finance announced that cryptocurrency exchanges will
soon have to comply with new additional rules. As a first in a sequence of measures, they will have to report
information on trades or investments that exceed 10,000 Turkish Lira (~€960) to the government’s financial
crime agency. Bloomberg reports that Cryptocurrencies are especially popular amongst Turks seeking to
protect savings threatened by the volatility of the Turkish Lira.
China: Despite the 4-year crackdown on local cryptocurrency exchanges and ban of ICOs announced in 2017,
cryptocurrency trading remains popular in China. In a new round of prohibitions, Beijing banned banks and
payment providers from providing services related to cryptocurrencies and issued new warnings for potential
investors. While cryptocurrency mining has been tolerated in the country up until now, in what appears to be
the beginning of new cycle of restrictions, China’s Inner Mongolia region, Guangzhou, proposed new
punishments, such as license revocations, for companies that participate in cryptocurrency mining.
Japan: Following the extreme price fluctuations in the cryptocurrency market, Haruhiko Kuroda, Governor of
the Bank of Japan stated that “Most of the (cryptocurrency) trading is speculative, and (that) volatility is
extraordinarily high”. Mr Kuroda joins the many central bankers and top policy makers from countries such as
the EU, US, and the UK warning against cryptocurrencies as investment vehicles. As the discussion around
the environmental impact of Bitcoin and other PoW-based blockchains escalates on a global level, Mr Kuroda
also highlighted the BoJ’s inventions to further incorporate environmental sustainability in their upcoming
monetary policies.
Singapore: companies Singapore-based DBS, one of the largest banks in Southeast Asia has successfully
issed a tokenized bond on-chain bond as part of a Security Token Offering (STO) with a total value of over
€12 Million. The bond is traded on DBS’ own cryptocurrency exchange called DDex.
Eng-Kwok Seat Moey, DBS’ head of capital stated the following: “We expect asset tokenisation to increasingly
become more mainstream as more of our clients start to embrace security token issuance as part of their
capital fund raising exercise”
Page 3 | 9
S. Korea, Indonesia, and India are too considering additional regulations. According to The Economic
Times, the Indian government is considering the formation of a panel of experts responsible for examining
additional cryptocurrency regulations and the operationalisation the country’s CBDC, the Digital Rupee.
Reuters reports that S. Koreas minister of finance is considering cryptocurrency taxation as soon as next
year. The same source, reported on Indonesia’s plans to tax cryptocurrency trading as an additional revenue
stream amid the coronavirus pandemic.
Market
Following a period of exuberance during the first half of April, which saw Bitcoin (BTC) prices around USD 63
000 (approximately EUR 54 000), May was characterised by a more bearish environment. Ethereum and the
broader cryptocurrency market falling up to 60 % from all-time-highs on 12 May. Nevertheless, the surging
market has clearly been impacting adoption and investments. Several of the most notable changes are
described below:
• The worldwide payment provider MoneyGram announced a cooperation with Coinme Inc., a crypto exchange
and Bitcoin ATM operator, to allow clients in the United States to swap their cryptocurrency holdings for cash
at its point-of-sale locations around the country. MoneyGram also disclosed that consumers would be able to
acquire BTC and cryptocurrencies as part of the announcement, expanding on the existing crypto-to-cash
model pioneered by the almost 20 000 cryptocurrency ATMs around the world. MoneyGram's ability to acquire
Bitcoin at its physical locations might be a big step for would-be first-time crypto users who are intimidated by
dealing with internet crypto exchanges.
• Non-fungible tokens (NFTs) are bound to change how digital property and ownership rights are appreciated.
An iconic video with millions of views on YouTube titled “Charlie bit my finger” was sold as an NFT for the
price of USD 760 000. As NFTs are a type of certificate of authenticity, the original video will be unavailable
to YouTube.
• Auctions for non-fungible tokens, or NFTs, have been added to eBay's platform. According to a Reuters report,
eBay customers who match specific conditions would be able to offer NFTs on the market. In the future, the
firm plans to enhance its regulations and tools regarding digital collectibles, according to the firm.
• Ernst & Young, one of the Big Four accounting firms, is continuing to engage extensively in blockchain,
investing USD 100 million in engineering and creating distributed ledger technology for a variety of corporate
applications. Through its own EY Blockchain Analyzer software package, Ernst & Young announced its
second-generation Smart Contract & Token Review capabilities. This includes a testing studio that allows
simulated smart contract execution for sophisticated decentralised finance applications.
• IOHK revealed that it has been collaborating with the Ethiopian government to develop a blockchain-based
method to monitor academic performance at local schools. According to the official government statement,
Ethiopian schools will use the Cardano blockchain to track student achievement.
• In April, the Cardano Foundation also announced a partnership with Ethiopia to provide aid in solving real-
world problems with the use of blockchain. One of the initial actions will take place in the educational sector
with the objective of improving the quality of education for students. Cardano has established offices in Addis
Abbaba and the launch of the project is slated for 2022.
• Another event that attracted public attention in April was the Coinbase IPO that was estimated at around USD
100 billion. Coinbase is a centralised cryptocurrency exchange platform with no official physical headquarters.
This suggests the growing interest in the digital transformation that is happening with the blockchain
technology. Researchers have shared their opinions on the matter and such an opinion was shared by Phillip
Sander and Jong-Chan Chung in a blog post.
• In May 2021, a coal mine in China's Xinjiang province flooded and was forced to shut down. The consequent
impact on China's Bitcoin mining sector emphasised the practice's continued reliance on coal. The mine's
Page 4 | 9
closure coincided with a large decrease in Bitcoin's hash rate, the unit of measurement for the Bitcoin
network's processing power. According to Coin Metrics, the Bitcoin hash rate dipped to its lowest level since
November 2020 during the mine shutdown.
On the subject of blockchain technologies in terms of CBDC, it is easy to note with confidence that more and
more countries are beginning to show interest in innovations of this kind and are beginning to study their
potential introduction into their economies.
Several of the most noteworthy examples (from April and May 2021) are described below:
• The Bank of Israel issued a statement announcing it was creating an action plan to investigate the
economic benefits of a Digital Shekel. Even though the bank confirmed it had yet to decide whether to
create a central bank digital currency, it noted its willingness to go ahead with the plan as long as the
advantages outweighed the costs and possible risks.
• The European Investment Bank's EUR 100 million digital bond was a test of a digital currency issued by
a European central bank. The digital bond was resolved using a CBDC on a blockchain, according to an
announcement issued by France's central bank, Banque de France. The two-year bond, having a maturity
date of 28 April 2023, was issued on the Ethereum public blockchain on April 26, 2021 and settled the
following day. Goldman Sachs, Santander, and Société Generale led the deal.
• The Central Bank of Bahrain formally declared it is currently working with JP Morgan and the Arab Banking
Corporation BSC (Bank ABC) on a pilot plan to deliver an immediate cross-border payment solution based
on digital currency technology.
• The Kazakhstan National Bank (NBRK) published a report on a digital tenge pilot project and launched a
public consultation on the prospective digital currency of the Central Bank. The Digital Tenge publication
reports is a new kind of money being produced by NBRK to enable the "future growth of the national
payment system and the use of unique technical characteristics to lessen reliance on cash settlement."
The bank emphasised that CBDC is not meant to replace cash or cashless payments but is used
alongside existing payment methods.
• The National Bank of Georgia said it is contemplating introducing a CBDC. It announced this possibility
in a statement, saying it wants to "improve the efficiency of the domestic payment system and financial
inclusion." The NBG said fintech companies and other financial institutions will be invited to join in the
initiative, known as "Digital Gel", following the country's fiat currency, the lari.
• Following years of research, the Norwegian central bank, Norges Bank, is preparing to test several
technical options for a central bank digital currency. Following the suggestions of an internal working
group, the bank said that CBDC tests would be conducted over the next two years. “The working
committee believes that the incentive for CBDC research has been reinforced. Many central banks are
conducting comparable studies, and others are already doing technical testing,” read the bank statement.
• The initial findings of Sweden's central bank digital currency pilot on a network based on R3's Corda
blockchain were reported in a recent study. The bank modelled key components of a prospective CBDC
system, such as liquidity supply via RIX, the bank's settlement system, and network members acting as
e-kronor distributors. Participants, end-users, and payment devices such as mobile applications were also
simulated by the central bank.
• The Bank of England and Her Majesty's Treasury have started early CBDC research that might lead to
the formation of a national digital currency. The exchequer announced the formation of a CBDC task
group in partnership with the UK central bank in a document issued by HM Treasury. According to the
document, the task force will coordinate the work of all relevant statutory organisations in the UK in the
establishment of CBDCs. The responsibilities of the task force include investigating preliminary concerns
related to the design, implementation, and operation of a CBDC in the UK. The task group will also meet
with academics, fintech companies, and other relevant businesses to examine the technological
challenges that come with developing a sovereign digital currency.
Page 5 | 9
• The European Central Bank (ECB) received more than 8 200 replies to its public digital euro survey, a
new high for the bank in terms of public consultation participation. The majority of respondents, 43 % of
all individuals and professionals who took part in the study, agreed that privacy was the most desired
attribute for a hypothetical future digital euro. The ECB underlined in its research that “privacy is regarded
the most crucial aspect of a digital euro by both individuals and professionals participating in the
consultation, notably retailers and other businesses.” Security and the capacity to pay throughout the
eurozone were cited as top considerations by 18 % and 11 % of respondents, respectively, in the survey.
A total 9 % of respondents underlined the significance of reducing extra charges, while 8 % highlighted
the requirement for a digital euro to be used offline.
The further development of the digital yuan in China should also be noted. According to Bloomberg, the
Hong Kong Monetary Authority personnel certified last week that the currency's cross-border usage had
passed the first level of testing. Multiple parties participated in the early testing, including chosen
merchants and a bank recognised by mainland Chinese authorities.
Traditional businesses are also showing interest in the development of the national digital currency. As an
example, Alipay, Ant Group's mobile payment network, will soon allow some of its customers to engage in
the digital yuan commerce ecosystem. This new functionality is the result of MYbank's involvement in the
country's extended digital currency electronic payment testing processes, according to a report by China
Securities Journal.
• Block Time Distribution: PoS will introduce a regular schedule of one block per 12 seconds. This, in
combination with EIP 1559, will massively improve Ethereum's User Experience.
• Faster pre-finality confirmation: It takes two epochs for a block to be confirmed and confirm the
feasibility to be reverted. The PoS version, even after 12 seconds, will mark hundreds of attestation
supporting it, which will render it very difficult to revert.
• Better Light client protocols: While there are many PoW light clients, they are resource-demanding to
turn on and maintain. A PoS light client protocol is well-designed, and requires only a few kilobytes per
day to remain in sync.
• Faster ability to detect network issues: In a PoW, if half of the nodes go offline or are affected by a bug
or attack, it will take time to become known. In a PoS, if participation drop from 99 % to lower within a
slot, it will be immediately noticed.
Page 6 | 9
Bitcoin's Taproot Upgrade
Taproot is expected to be the most significant Bitcoin upgrade since 2017. It has led to a hard-fork of the
network. Taproot has achieved the required minimum of miners signalling support to proceed with the
upgrade. As defined by the Speedy Trial rules, at least 90 % of blocks mined within one of Bitcoin's difficult
periods need to signal support for the upgrade to be locked in for activation in November 2021. The long
process, which started on 1 May 2021, requires six possible signalling periods to initiate the Taproot Speedy
Trial activation process. While the upgrade will only affect two lines of code, the Taproot will introduce a new
signature scheme known as the Schnorr signatures. Schnorr signatures are similar to the Elliptic Curve
Digital Signature Algorithmic, which is currently being used. Schnorr signatures were invented much earlier
than ECDSA, and many researchers wonder why they haven't been integrated from the start. The most
logical explanation is that the patent expired in early 2008.
For this reason, might likely Satoshi Nakamoto decided to proceed with the open-source ECDSA. Schnorr
signatures are simpler compared to other alternatives. This is why they are considered more secure. Schnorr
signatures also have another competitive advantage: linearity. Linearity supports certain activities. Multi-
signature transactions are the most noteworthy of activities. In contrast, the Bitcoin network already supports
multi-sig (requiring more than one key to authorise a transaction), which is resulting in both economic viability
and reduced privacy. Schnorr signatures will introduce features such as signature aggregation, which
merges signatures from multiple parties into a single "master signature".
Understanding Flashbots
Miner Extractable Value (MEV) is consensus security that models miners' profit for their activity to include,
exclude or re-order transactions for the blocks they produce. Users of Ethereum express their interest to pay
for inclusion in a block through the number of gas costs they are willing to pay to the miners. Miners select the
transactions with the highest gas fee and prioritise them. Decentralised finance has introduced arbitrage
opportunities, with the concepts of frontrunning and backrunning. Backrunning further incentivised bad actors.
These have caused inefficiencies such as network and chain congestion. Particularly in cases of transactions
that change the pricing significantly, this may cause traders to earn or lose considerable monetary resources.
Miners who are usually knowledgeable about such opportunities may profit from such activities at the loss of
users. A 2019 study already explored the phenomenon, suggesting that sophisticated bots operators profited
from MEV in Ethereum. Bots were searching the Ethereum mempool to identify new MEV opportunities by
copying and frontrunning users' transactions. Flashbots is a research and development organisation aiming to
Page 7 | 9
mitigate the negative externalities of current MEV to avoid existential risks that MEV could cause to state-rich
blockchains like Ethereum. April and May 2021 has been a period of tremendous growth and experimentation
for Flashbots. Released in January 2021, Flashbots Alpha v0.1 introduced a communication channel between
miners and users that enables transparent and efficient MEV extraction. Users who send transactions on
Flashbots, called searchers, can send transactions directly to miners and bid for inclusion in a block. The v0.2
upgrade was released on 17 May 2021 and introduced new and upgraded features, as outlined here.
• Bundle merging: More revenue for miners, the higher chance of inclusion for searchers.
• Revamped auction pricing: Solve for bundle stuffing and maintain compatibility with gas price payments.
• Discard bundles with reverting transactions: avoid unintended transactions from landing on the chain
leading to less chain bloating
• Replace HTTP endpoints with WebSockets: Reduce latency, improved node security for miners.
Mining pools that account for more than 80 % of the Ethereum network have adopted Flashbots, while the
searchers' community has grown significantly.
Page 8 | 9
Chrysalis Network launched by IoTA
The IoTA foundation launched the Chrysalis Network following the migration period(Error! Reference source not found..
The updates are affecting an extensive number of the network aspects like protocols, libraries and wallets.
Another update by the IoTA foundation was announced in May 2021. This was a beta release for IOTA Identity.
The solution is a Self Sovereign Identity (SSI) that will allow people and machines to create and manage their
identity. The continuous updates aim to achieve the objective of the foundation to be the backbone in the IoT
sector in a more efficient way.
Oracles by Chainlink
Chainlink is actively committed to further developing Oracles, as well as refining and expanding their functions
and roles on the blockchain. Its latest effort resulted in a whitepaper issued in April 2021. Presenting the
collaborative work of researchers in various fields, the whitepaper elaborates on a framework for multiple
interoperating Decentralised Oracle Networks (DONs).
Page 9 | 9