THEORETICAL PRELIMINARIES - Text - P.1
THEORETICAL PRELIMINARIES - Text - P.1
THEORETICAL PRELIMINARIES - Text - P.1
Part 1
implication is also suggested by the antithesis in the title “Arrangement in Black and
White”.
Analogy (parallelism) may also be deeply suggestive. For example, in “The Roads We
Take” by O'Henry there is deep implication in the parallel actions of the dream and reality
(in the dream Shark Dodson murders his companion with cold ferocity to get the booty; in
the event that presents reality Dodson, the businessman, ruins his friend with cold ferocity
again in order to increase his profits). Parallelism here invites the reader to compare these
actions. It is suggestive not only of the ugly nature of the protagonist, but also of the
immoral means he uses to make money.
Events which begin and end a story are sometimes parallel (similar). This circling of
the action back to its beginning implies that nothing has changed and this may be the whole
point. The story of the firm Twigg and Dersingham in Priestley's “Angel Pavement” begins
with Dersingham's talk with Smeeth about the sad affairs of the firm and the necessity to
dismiss one of the clerks. At the end of the novel Dersingham has a similar talk, with
Smeeth again, about the bankruptcy of the firm. It returns the reader to the opening scene.
This circling of actions suggests and emphasizes that nothing has improved, none of the
characters have managed to avoid ruin and poverty.
Analogy and contrast underlie quite a number of such elements of poetic structure as
tropes and figures of speech (simile, metaphor, personification, antithesis, pun, etc).
Principle of Recurrence
Poetic structure of the literary text is so modelled that certain of its elements which
have already occurred in the text recur again at definite intervals.
Recurrence (or repetition) is one of the means conveying implication. Recurrent may
be a poetic detail, an image, a phrase, a word (both emotionally coloured and neutral), a
stylistic device. There often occurs semantic repetition, when one and the same idea is
repeated, though every time it is formulated differently. When repeated all of them are felt
to be especially significant for the understanding of the literary work and acquire special
relevance in its context.
The recurrent element may have several functions, i.e. be meaningful in a variety of
ways. One of these functions is that of the key-words organizing the subject matter,
giving it a dynamic flow. Consider, for instance, the following expository passage from
E. Hemingway's "Old Man at the Bridge" and see how the recurrent phrase old man
organizes and frames it up. "An old man with steel-rimmed spectacles and very dusty clothes
sat by the side of the road. There was a pontoon bridge across the river and carts, trucks, and
men, women and children were crossing it. The mule-drawn carts staggered up the steep
bank from the bridge with soldiers helping push against the spokes of the wheels. The trucks
ground up and away heading out of it all and the peasants plodded along in the ankle deep
dust. But the old man sat there without moving. He was too tired to go any farther".
Recurrence may be traced in the plot of any story. Though the events in the plot
generally vary among themselves, they have a similarity in function – each of them recalls
the reader to the central problem. For instance, no matter how different the events in the
story “The Lady's Maid” by K. Mansfield may seem to be, each of them returns the reader to
the main problem – the inequality between the rich and those who serve them. In this
sense writers fulfil contradictory demands: the demand for variation and the demand for
6
recurrence. If a writer fails to fulfil the former, his story will be monotonous and
uninteresting. If he fails to fulfil the latter, it will seem aimless and not directed at any
definite message.
The repeated words (or phrases), even if they are neutral ones, may acquire
emotional charge and become key-words important for understanding of the message
of the story. Such units create a certain leitmotif of the literary work expressing the
author's message. For instance, "The Basement Room" by G. Greene tells about a seven-
year-old boy whose parents have gone on a fortnight's vacation leaving him in charge of the
butler, Baines, and his wife, Mrs. Baines. The boy descends into the basement room, the
dwelling-place of the Baines' and ... finds himself involved in their life, with its conflicts, its
secrets and its bitterness. Each of them, in turn, entrusts his/her secret to the boy and
expects him to keep it. The boy is entirely on the side of the butler, he hates and abhors the
butler's wife. But when it happens that the butler unintentionally causes the death of his
wife, the boy betrays him to the police, for he feels it unbearable to keep the secret, to have
the responsibility Baines has laid upon him.
The following two sets of phrases run parallel to each other at certain intervals
through the whole of the story. The first set is: Philip began to live; this is life, this was life; it
was life he was in the middle of; Philip extracted himself from life; a retreat from life. And the
second set: And suddenly he felt responsible for Baines; Again Philip felt responsibility; He
would have nothing to do with their secrets, the responsibilities they were determined to lay
on him; he surrendered responsibility once and for all. These two recurrent sets of phrases
run as the leitmotif of the story: living means having responsibilities, asserts the author;
when one surrenders responsibilities one retreats from life.
When an artistic detail is repeated several times and is associated with a broader
concept than the original, it develops into a symbol.
A symbol is a word (or an object the word stands for), which represents a concept
broader than the literal sense of the word. It is therefore something concrete and material
standing for something else that is immaterial and has a more significant sense. A symbol is
a metaphoric expression of the concept it stands for. Like the metaphor, it is based on the
use of a word in its transferred meaning and suggests some likeness between two different
objects or concepts.
Symbols may be traditional or personal. An example of a traditional symbol is a rose.
The rose is a traditional symbol of beauty.
A writer establishes personal symbols by means of repetition and repeated
association with a broader concept. For example, in “Rain” by S. Maugham the rain is a
symbol of the primitive powers of nature before which man is powerless and all his efforts
are useless and hopeless. The association of rain with this broad concept is established in
the following passage: "...it (rain) was unmerciless and somehow terrible; you felt in it the
malignancy of the primitive powers of nature. It did not pour, it flowed. ...it seemed to have a
fury of its own. And sometimes you felt that you must scream if it did not stop, and then
suddenly you felt powerless, as though your bones had suddenly become soft: and you were
miserable and hopeless". Rain, therefore, symbolizes the powers of nature which proved
irresistible for Mr. Davidson.
7
keep in mind. He should discover the role the events of the story play in characterization
and in conveying the message.
Any plot is comprised of a variety of events, each of which recalls the reader, directly
or indirectly, to the central problem. No matter how casual each event might seem to be at
first glance, it generally returns the reader to the main problem of the story.
The plot of any story always involves character and conflict. They imply each other.
Conflict in fiction is the opposition (or struggle) between forces or characters. Conflicts are
classified into external and internal conflicts.
Different types of external conflicts are usually termed in the following way:
1. Man against man, when the plot is based on the opposition between two or more
people, as in “The Outstation” by S. Maugham or “The Roads We Take” by 0'Henry.
2. Man against nature (the sea, the desert, the frozen North or wild beasts). The
conflict in “The Old Man and the Sea” by E. Hemingway, “The Hunter” by J. Aldridge, or the
scientist's effort to discover the secrets of nature involve a conflict between man and
nature.
3. Man against society or man against the established order in the society, when the
individual fights his social environment openly, or when there is a conflict between the
individual and the established order: a conflict with poverty, racial hostility, injustice,
exploitation, inequality.
4. The conflict between one set of values against another set of values. These sets of
values may be supported by two groups or two worlds in opposition. For example, the
conflict in “The Moon and Sixpence” by S. Maugham is between the values of material world
where everything is thought of in terms of money, on the one hand, and the values of art
craving for beauty, on the other.
Internal conflicts, often termed as "man against himself', take place within one
character. The internal conflict is localized, as it were, in the inner world of the character
and is rendered through his thoughts, feelings, intellectual processes. The character is torn
between opposing features of his personality. For example, the tragedy of Soames Forsyte
in “The Man of Property” is his conflict with himself: the sense of property, on the one hand,
and a keen sense of beauty, on the other. The internal conflict within an individual often
involves a struggle of his sense of duty against self-interest.
The plot of a story may be based on several conflicts of different types, it may involve
both an internal and an external conflict.
The events of the plot are generally localized, i. e. they are set in a particular place and
time. The place and time of the actions of a story or novel form the setting. For the setting
the writer selects the relevant details which would suggest the whole scene. Such details as
the time of the year, certain parts of the landscape, the weather, colours, sounds or other
seemingly uninteresting details may be of great importance. The functions of the setting
may vary.
1. The setting, especially description of nature, helps to evoke the necessary
atmosphere (or mood), appropriate to the general intention of the story. It may be an
atmosphere of gloom and foreboding as in “Rain” by S. Maugham, or a mysterious
atmosphere as in “The Oval portrait” by E. A. Poe.
10
Climax is the highest point of the action, the key event, the crucial moment of the
story. In "Cora Unashamed" it is the death and burial of Cora's baby.
Denouement is the unwinding of the actions; it includes the event, or events, in the
story immediately following the climax and bringing the actions to an end. It is the point at
which the fate of the main character is clarified. The denouement suggests to the reader
certain crucial conclusions. The story referred to (Part I) ends with Cora returning after the
burial of her baby to work for the family of white folks: to nurse their baby.
A story may have no denouement. By leaving it out the author achieves a certain
effect – he invites the reader to reflect on all the circumstances that accompanied the
character of the story and to imagine the outcome of all the events himself. Such is the case
in “The Cop and the Anthem” by O'Henry.
Novels may have two more components of plot structure: the prologue and the
epilogue (see, for example, “Angel Pavement” by J. Priestley). The prologue contains facts
from beyond the past of the story, the epilogue contains additional facts about the future of
the characters if it is not made clear enough in the denouement.
A work of narrative prose that has all the elements mentioned above: exposition,
story, climax, denouement as clearly discernable parts, is said to have a closed plot
structure. This type of writing was most consistently cultivated by such American short
story writers as W. Irving, E. Poe, N. Hawthorn, Bret Hart, H. James, O'Henry and others.
A literary work in which the action is represented without an obvious culmination,
which does not contain all the above mentioned elements understood in their conventional
sense, is said to have an open plot structure.
The usual order in which the components of plot structure occur is as follows:
exposition, story, climax and denouement. Sometimes the author rearranges the
components of plot structure. There is a variety of plot structure techniques. A story may
have:
a straight line narrative presentation, when the events are arranged as they occur,
in chronological order;
a complex narrative structure, when the events are not arranged in chronological
order and when there are flashbacks to past events;
a circular pattern, when the closing event in the story returns the reader to the
introductory part;
a frame structure, when there is a story within a story. The two stories contrast or
parallel.
It should also be added that the plot structure is interlinked with the order in which
the writer presents the information included into the story. Sometimes plots follow a
chronological order of events, sometimes the author resorts to the following techniques.
Suspense (retardation) is the withholding of information until the appropriate time,
denying the reader immediate access to information which is essential to the full
understanding of the story. The clearest example of this can be found in detective stories
where the author does not reveal the identity of the murderer until the very last moment.
Suspense is often created through the careful ordering of events in the story.
12