Court of Appeals: Republic of The Philippines Manila
Court of Appeals: Republic of The Philippines Manila
Court of Appeals: Republic of The Philippines Manila
Court of Appeals
Manila
GONZALES-SISON, M. B.,
Chairperson
-versus- PEREZ, P. A. and
LAUIGAN, R. R. R., JJ.
DECISION
Record shows that among the benefits that Nestle extends to its
employees is the so-called “Home Suite Loan Program” (HSLP) to help
the employees acquire a residential property, make improvements on
their existing residential property, purchase another property, pay off
mortgage loans due for foreclosure, installation of water systems,
and/or make investments or acquire proprietary club shares, among
others. In connection therewith, an employee who would like to avail
of the loan must submit a clear and competent proof of the need for
such loan, payment of which would be through monthly salary
deduction. Several employees availed of such loan.
6 Rollo, p. 670.
7 Rollo, p. 483.
8 Rollo, p. 484.
Nestle Cabuyao Workers Union (NCWU-PTGWO) vs. Nestle Phils., Inc. Decision
CA GR SP No. 164673 Page 5 of 22
9 Rollo, p. 485.
10 Rollo, pp. 685-686.
Nestle Cabuyao Workers Union (NCWU-PTGWO) vs. Nestle Phils., Inc. Decision
CA GR SP No. 164673 Page 6 of 22
2. JONJON M. YASAY
3. Erickson G. Hernandez
16 Rollo pp. 81-89 Decision dated March 29, 2019 penned by Voluntary Arbitrator Delia T. Uy
Nestle Cabuyao Workers Union (NCWU-PTGWO) vs. Nestle Phils., Inc. Decision
CA GR SP No. 164673 Page 13 of 22
Yasay claims he used the proceeds of the loan to pay off his
mother's housing loan with Pag-ibig but the Waiver of rights over the
property executed by his mother was only done in April 2018, a year
after the investigation and was only presented as evidence in their
Position Paper. The Pag-ibig loan documents were also doubtful as
there was no stamp of any receipt or approval by Pag-ibig Fund.
SO ORDERED.
MARLENE B. GONZALES-SISON
Associate Justice
Nestle Cabuyao Workers Union (NCWU-PTGWO) vs. Nestle Phils., Inc. Decision
CA GR SP No. 164673 Page 22 of 22
WE CONCUR:
PABLITO A. PEREZ
Associate Justice
CERTIFICATION
MARLENE B. GONZALES-SISON
Associate Justice
Chairperson, Eighth (8th) Division
Nestle Cabuyao Workers Union (NCWU-PTGWO) vs. Nestle Phils., Inc. Decision
CA GR SP No. 164673 Page 23 of 22