F5 Synergy Kit
F5 Synergy Kit
F5 Synergy Kit
SYNERGY
PROFESSIONALS
ACCA Paper PM
Performance Management
Lecture Notes
Merits of ABC
1. It is simple to use.
2. It facilitates a good understanding of what drives cost.
3. It helps organisations control costs by identifying the activities that that
generate them.
4. It leads to more accurate product costs which help managers enhance the
quality of their decision making.
5. It recognizes the complexity of manufacturing a wider range of products with
its multiple cost drivers.
Criticisms of ABC
1. Some arbitrary allocations may still be required for some cost items.
2. Some cost drivers might not be easily identified – e.g. Training costs, cost of
external audit.
3. The cost of implementing ABC may be high
4. Implementing ABC needs the required information which may not be readily
available so existing Management Information System (MIS) may need to be
modified.
TARGET COSTING
Target costing is a costing system that involves setting a target cost by subtracting a
desired profit margin from a market competitive selling price.
LIFE-CYCLE COSTING
Life-cycle costing is a costing system that identifies and accumulates costs and
revenues incurred and earned by a product over the product life cycle. In other
words, life cycle costing can easily help a company determine the viability of a
product over its whole life.
Traditional costing systems are based on the financial accounting year but lifecycle
costing is based on the overall cost and revenue over the entire product life cycle.
THROUGHPUT ACCOUNTING
Throughput Accounting:
TA is a product management system whose major objective is to maximise
throughput (defined as the rate of production of a process over a stated period of
time). Throughput is also calculated as Sales revenue – Material cost. It focuses on
factors such as bottlenecks which are constraints to the maximizing of sales revenue.
It is a system that operates in a Just-In-Time (JIT) environment.
Total conversion cost includes ALL factory cost with the exception of material cost.
Non factory overheads to not form part of conversion cost.
Interpretation of TPAR
A TPAR > 1 means that the firm is earning money more than it is spending so the
product should make a profit.
A TPAR < 1 means that the firm is spending money more than it is earning,
resulting in a loss.
Improving the TPAR:
1. Increase the sales price for each unit sold, to increase the throughput per unit
2. Reduce materials cost per unit
3. Reduce total operating expenses
4. Improve the productivity of the work force and reduce the time required to
make each unit of the product.
Limitations of Throughput Accounting
1. It concentrates on the short term
2. It pays little attention to overhead costs
3. There can be other factors that limit throughput apart from bottlenecks e.g.
uncompetitive selling price, poor product quality, etc.
Physical information on the use, flows and destinies of energy, water and
materials (including wastes) and
Monetary information on environment-related costs, earnings and savings.
Simply speaking,
Environmental Management Accounting (EMA) is the generation and analysis of both
financial and non-financial information in order to support internal environmental
management processes.
This includes:
Identifying and estimating the costs of environment related activities
Identifying and monitoring the usage and cost of resources such as water, fuel,
electricity to enable such to be reduced
Assessing the likelihood and impact of environmental risks
Including environment related indicators as part of routine performance
monitoring
Benchmarking activities against environmental best practices
To control environmental costs, organizations need to
Define environmental costs
Identify the costs and
Allocate the costs
Defining Environmental costs
There are four types of environmental cost
1. Conventional costs – e.g. raw materials and energy costs that impact the
environment
2. Potentially hidden costs – costs that are captured in the accounting system but
are hidden within general overheads
3. Contingent cost – cost to be incurred at a future date e.g. clean up cost
4. Image and relationship cost – cost incurred to preserve the reputation of the
business. E.g. cost of compliance with regulatory requirements.
Identifying and Allocating Environmental costs
Much of the information that is needed can actually be found in the general ledger.
A close review should reveal the cost of materials, utilities and waste disposal. The
problem is that most of the cost will be found within the general overheads category
and it might be problematic allocating them appropriately. Examples of
environmental costs are:
Waste – unused raw materials and disposals
Water – cost of buying and then disposing
Energy – electricity, fuel, etc
Transport and Travel – transportation of goods and materials, etc
Consumables and raw materials
Multi-limiting factor
The assumption here is that there are more than one limiting factors or scarce
resources within the organization. The objective is to seek the best ways to utilize
these scarce resources. To solve the problem of multiple scarce resources, Linear
Programming is used.
Linear programming
This is a technique for solving problems of profit maximisation or cost minimization and
resource allocation. It is used when there are more than one resource constraints.
Slack
Slack occurs when maximum availability of resources is not used.
Shadow prices
The shadow price is the value assigned to an extra unit of a scarce resource normally
calculated as the increase in contribution created by the availability of an extra unit
of the scarce resource at its original cost. It is the extra contribution that may be
earned by making available one unit of a binding resource constraint.
Note the following:
1. The shadow price represents the maximum premium above the basic rate that
an organization should be willing to pay for one extra unit of resource.
2. The shadow price of a constraint that is not binding at the optimal solution is
zero
3. Shadow prices are only valid for a small range before the constraint becomes
non-binding or different resources become critical.
3. Graphical Method
Three possible graphs can be plotted to determine BEP
a) Break Even Chart
b) Contribution Chart
Margin of Safety
Margin safety indicates by how much sales can decrease before a loss occurs. It is
the excess of the budgeted level of activity over the break-even level of activity. It
can be calculated in terms of units or value ($).
Using the company above: Assuming budgeted sales is 20,000 Units
Margin of safety = 20,000 - 10,000 = 10,000 units
Shown as %: 10,000 ÷ 20,000 × 100 = 50%
In terms of $ sales revenue: 10,000 × $50 = $500,000
Break Even Point (BEP) in terms of sales revenue can be calculated with the C/S ratio.
BEP (in terms of value - $) =Fixed Cost ÷ C/S Ratio
Illustration: A company products 2 products A & B. The company expects to sell one
units of A for every two units of B. It has monthly sales revenue of $150,000. Product A
has a C/S Ratio of 20% and product B has a C/S ratio of 40%. Budgeted monthly Fixed
Costs are $30,000. What is the Budgeted BEP in terms of sales revenue?
Solution
Weighted Average C/S Ratio = ((20 × 1) + (40 × 2)) ÷ 3
=33.33%
BEP (Sales) = Fixed cost ÷ C/S Ratio
BEP (Sales) = $30,000 ÷ 0.333 = $90,000
The organization wishes to earn a profit of $52,000 next month. Calculate the
required sales value of each product in order to achieve the target profit.
Step 1: Calculate the contribution per unit
F G H
SP 22 15 19
VC 16 12 13
Contribution 6 3 6
Illustration:
Assume that budgeted sales are 2,000 units of product X, 4,000 units of Product Y and
3,000 units of Product Z. Also assume that the output and sales of X, Y and Z are in
constant proportions. Fixed cost is $10,000.
The following information also applies.
X Y Z
SP/unit 8 6 6
VC/unit 3 4 5
Draw the Profit Volume Chart and determine the break-even point.
*****
Read up
1. Limitations of CVP Analysis
2. Advantages of CVP Analysis
PRICING DECISIONS
Factors that affect or influence the prices of goods and services
1. Cost
2. Customers
3. Competitors
Demand:
Economic theory argues that the higher the price of a good, the lower the quantity
demanded.
Price
Demand
A normal demand curve
Price
Demand
Q
Price
Demand
Demand might be limitless at any price but there would be no demand above price
P & there is no point dropping price below P. Demand is said to be COMPLETELY
ELASTIC.
P= a – bQ
Where,
P = Price, Q = quantity, a = price when Q = 0, b = Change in price
Change in qty
Y = a + bx
Where,
TC = FC + VC/unit * no of units
TC
No of units
Pricing Strategies
Advantages
Disadvantages
i. It does not recognize that demand may be determined by price and that
there will be a profit maximizing combination of price and demand.
ii. It does not consider market and demand conditions
iii. Budgeted output volume will have to be determined so as to get a
reasonable overhead absorption rate.
iv. A suitable basis for overhead absorption must be selected.
b. Marginal cost plus pricing – This involves adding a profit margin to the
marginal cost of production or sales.
Advantages
i. It is simple and easy to use
ii. Profit mark up can be varied to reflect demand conditions
iii. It draws management attention to contribution
Disadvantages
4. Volume Discounting
A volume discount is a reduction in price given for larger than average
purchases. The aim is to increase sales
5. Price discrimination
The use of price discrimination means that the same product can be sold at
different prices to different customers.
Price discrimination can only be effective if
i. The market is segment able in price terms and the different segments
respond differently to price.
ii. There is little chance of a black market
iii. Competitors cannot undercut the firms prices in higher priced market
segments
iv. The cost of creating and administering segments does not exceed the extra
revenue to be derived.
This part of the syllabus extends the concept of price elasticity of demand and the linear relationship
that exists between Price and Quantity demanded.
The idea here is based on the micro economic theory that profit maximization is the process by which a
firm determines the price and output level that returns the greatest profit.
The approach to this problem that is relevant here is this: Marginal revenue (MR)-Marginal Cost
(MC), this is based on the fact that total profit in a perfect market reaches its maximum point
where marginal revenue is equal to marginal cost
In summary the theory states that as output increases the marginal cost rises because of the law
of diminishing returns and in a normal price-demand relationship this means that MR reduces. A
point is then reached when MC is greater than MR and it will not make sense to produce an
extra unit of the product.
This implies that profit will only continue to maximized at an output level where marginal cost
has risen to be exactly equal to Marginal revenue.
Simply put profit is maximized when MR=MC.
The following steps should be followed when determining the profit maximizing price:
The make option should give management more direct control over the work but the
buy option has the benefit that the external organization has a specialist skill and
expertise in the work.
The relevant cost of making and the relevant cost of buying should be considered. If
it is cheaper to make, the company should manufacture internally and if it cheaper
to buy then the company should buy from the outsiders. In a Make or Buy situation,
there are other factors to consider:
3. Customer loyalty might be affected if sales are forgone due to cases of full
capacity
Outsourcing Decision
1. The decision is made on the ground that specialist contractors can offer
superior quality and efficiency.
2. Contracting out manufacturing frees the capital that can be invested in core
activities such as market research, product definition, marketing and sales, etc.
3. Contractors have the capacity and flexibility to start production very quickly to
meet sudden variations in demand.
1. Control:
The in-house option should give management more direct control over the
work
2. Skill and expertise:
The outsourcing option often has the benefit that external organization has a
specialist skill and expertise in the work that may not be available in – house.
3. Capacity:
Will the outsourcing create spare capacity?
4. Are there hidden benefits to be obtained from outsourcing?
5. Would the company’s work force resent the loss of work to outside contractors
and can it possibly cause an industrial dispute?
6. Would the subcontractor be reliable with delivery times?
7. Would the subcontractor be reliable with quality?
1. What will the impact of the shut down have on employee morale?
2. What signal will the decision give to competitors?
3. How will customers react?
4. How will suppliers be affected?
Risk Preference
1. Risk seeker – interested in the best outcomes no matter how small the chance
2. Risk neutral – concerned with the most likely outcome
3. Risk averse – acts on the assumption that the worst possible outcome might
occur
Where probabilities are assigned to different outcomes, we can evaluate the worth
of the decision as the expected value (weighted average) of these outcomes.
Decision Rules
The maximin decision rule suggests that he should select the ‘smallest worst result’
that could happen.
This suggests that the decision maker looks at the best possible result. i.e. maximize
the maximum profits.
Criticism of Maximin
It is defensive and conservative
It ignores the probability of each different outcome taking place.
Criticisms of Maximax
It ignores probabilities
It is overoptimistic
****Note****
Regret for any = Profit for best action in those - Profit for
combination of actions circumstance action actually chosen
and circumstance in those circumstance
The decision rule is the action that minimizes the maximum potential regret.
Sensitivity Analysis
Sensitivity analysis is a term used to describe any technique whereby decision options
are tested for their vulnerability to changes in any variable such as expected sales,
sales price per unit, material costs or labor costs.
Sensitivity analysis can be used in any situation so long as a relationship between the
key variables can be established. This involves changing the value of a variable and
seeing how the results are affected.
Simulation Models
Decision Trees
A further method for analyzing risk and uncertainty is the decision tree. These are diagrams
that show the options and possible outcomes of a decision. For a decision tree analysis to be
complete a roll back analysis must be carried out.
Rollback Analysis simply evaluates the EV of each decision option. A decision tree is done
from left to right and rollback analysis is done for right to left after the decision tree is
completed.
All possible choices that can be made are shown as branches of a tree
All possible outcomes of each choice are shown as subsidiary branches on the tree
Every decision tree starts form a decision point from which the decision options are
being considered
A square is used to represent a decision point and a circle is used to represent an
outcome point
(A decision point indicates choice and outcome point highlights outcomes)
Outcome points are usually represented indicated by probabilities.
A decision can only be reached by the use of rollback analysis
At each decision point a decision is taken between 2 or more options and at each
outcome point the EV i.e.( weighted average) is determined and rolled back to the
next point.
It is typical for the examiner to test questions here with the assumptions that you are able to
identify and differentiate between options and outcomes and apply your understanding
accurately. Example is thoroughly demonstrated in class
BUDGETING: PART C
Budgetary planning and control
A budgetary planning and control system is a system for ensuring communication,
co-ordination and control within an organization.
Objectives of a budgetary system:
1. Ensure the achievement of the organizations objectives
2. Compel planning
3. Communicate ideas and plans
4. Co-ordinate activities
5. Provide a framework for responsibility accounting
6. Establish a system of control
7. Motivate employees to improve performance
Approaches to Budgeting (ways in which budgets can be set)
There are three approaches to budgeting
1. Imposed style (Top Down)
In this approach to budgeting, top management prepares a budget with little or
no input from operations personnel which is then imposed on the employee who
have to work to the budget figures.
This method is effective in the following cases:
i. The organization is a newly formed organization
ii. The organization is a small business
iii. During periods of economic hardship
iv. When operational managers lack budgeting skills
v. When the organizations different units require precise co-ordination.
Advantages
i. Strategic plans are likely to be incorporated into planned activities
ii. They enhance the coordination between plans and objectives
iii. They use senior managements awareness of total resource availability
iv. They decrease input from inexperienced or uninformed lower level
employees
v. They decrease the time taken to draw up budgets.
Disadvantages
i. Dissatisfaction, defensiveness and low morale amongst employees
ii. The feeling of team spirit may disappear
iii. Acceptance of organizational goals and objectives could be limited
iv. Feeling that the budget is a punitive device would arise
v. Lower level management initiative could be stifled.
vi. Unachievable budgets could be set for some divisions if consideration
is not given to local conditions.
Budgetary Systems
A budget is a quantified plan of action for a forth coming accounting period. It can
be set from “top down’ or ‘bottom up’.
Key points to consider when setting and preparing for budgets:
1. Long term plan
2. Limiting factor
3. Budget manual
4. Sales budget
5. Production capacity
6. Functional budgets
7. Discretionary costs
8. Consolidation and coordination
9. Cash budget
10. Master budget
Types of budgetary systems
1. Incremental budgeting
This is so called because it is concerned mainly with the increments in costs and
revenue which will occur in the coming period.
The traditional approach to budgeting, known as incremental budgeting, bases
the budget on the current years result plus an extra amount for estimated growth
or inflation next year.
Incremental budgeting is a reasonable procedure if current operations are as
effective, efficient and economical as they can be. It is appropriate for costs such
as salaries.
In general, it is an inefficient form of budgeting as it encourages slack and
wasteful spending to creep into budgets.
Advantages
i. It is a quick and relatively simple method
ii. The information is readily available so very limited quantitative analysis
is needed
iii. Assuming historic figures are acceptable, only the increment needs to
be justified.
Disadvantages
i. It builds on wasteful spending if the actual figures for this year includes
overspends caused by some form of error.
ii. It encourages organizations to spend up to the maximum allowed so
that they can get a larger budget the next period.
iii. It is not appropriate in a rapidly changing environment.
iv. Uneconomic activities may be continued. It does not let organizations
consider cheaper options.
Benefits of ABB
i. Different activity levels will produce a foundation for the base package and
incremental packages for ZBB
ii. It will ensure that the organizations overall strategy and any likely change
will be taken into account
iii. Concentration is focused on the activities and there is the likelihood that
the activities would be carried out efficiently.
5. Rolling Budgets
A rolling budget is a budget which is continuously updated by adding a further
accounting period when the earlier accounting period has expired.
Rolling budget is an attempt to prepare targets and plans which are more
realistic and certain.
Advantages
i. It reduces the element of uncertainty
ii. It forces managers to reassess the budget regularly and to produce
budgets that are up to date
iii. Planning and control will be based on a recent plan which is likely to be
more realistic than a fixed annual budget made months ago
iv. Realistic budgets have a better motivational influence on managers
v. There is always a budget which extends for several months ahead.
Disadvantages
i. Involves more time, effort and money
ii. Frequent budgeting is usually not desired by managers as it shifts their focus
from important operational issues.
Beyond budgeting
This is a model that proposes that traditional budgets should be abandoned.
Adaptive management processes should be used rather than a fixed annual budget.
Criticisms of budgeting
1. Budgets are time consuming and expensive
2. Budgets produce poor value to users
3. Budgets focus on the short term
4. Budgets are too rigid and prevent fast response
5. Budget protects rather than reduce costs
6. Budgets focus on sales targets rather than customer satisfaction
7. Budgets leads to unethical behavior
STANDARD COSTING:
A standard cost is an estimate unit cost.
Main uses
1. To value inventories and cost production for cost accounting purposes. (an
alternative to FIFO & LIFO)
2. To act as a control device by establishing standards and comparing actual
costs with expected costs.
Other uses
Types of standards:
VARIANCE ANALYSIS
Variance analysis is the process by which total difference between standard and
actual results are analyzed.
Types of Variances
Cost variances:
1. Direct Material
2. Direct Labor
Sales Variances:
There are two main differences between the variances calculated in an absorption
costing system and in a marginal costing system.
Investigating Variances
1. Materiality
2. Controllability
3. Variance trend
4. Type of standard
5. Interdependence between variances
Material price and usage
Labor rate and efficiency
Selling price and sales volume
6. Cost of investigation
Just as we have mix and yield variances for materials issued into production when there are
more than one materials that make up a product, Sales volume variances can also be
analyzed into Mix and Quantity variances, if a company produces and sells more than one
product.
Other conditions that need to be fulfilled to calculate mix and quantity variances are as
follows
This variance occurs when the proportion of the various products sold are different from
those in the budget.
This shows the difference in contribution that arises as a result of a change in sales volume
from the budgeted volume of sales.
The same approach used in mix and yield variances can be used. We will be comparing as
follows;
Sales Mix variance is calculated as the difference in Actual Quantity in Standard Mix and
Actual quantity in Actual mix (AQSM compared with AQAM), valued at standard margin per
unit
Sales Quantity Variance is calculated as the difference between the Actual Quantity in
Budgeted mix and Budgeted Quantity in Budgeted Mix
Management Control:
This is the process by which managers ensure that resources are obtained and used
effectively and efficiently in accomplishing organizations objectives. It is also called tactical
planning.
Accounting information required: Usually generated internally.
1. Productivity measurements
2. Budgetary control and variance analysis reports
3. Cashflow forecasts
4. Staffing levels
5. Profits within departments
6. Short term purchase requirements
Operational Control:
This is the process of ensuring that specific tasks are carried out effectively and efficiently. It is
more narrow focused and have shorter time frame than the tactical level.
Accounting information required: the information is more detailed than the others.
1. Operational information needed for the day to day implementation of plans
2. Transaction data e.g. customer orders, purchase orders, cash receipts, payments.
MANAGEMENT INFORMATION SYSTEMS
Transaction Processing Systems:
A transaction is an event that generates or modifies data that is eventually stored in an
information system.
A transaction processing system (TPS) collects, stores, modifies and retrieves the transactions
of an organization.
Types:
1. Batch transaction processing
2. Real time transaction processing.
Characteristics:
1. Controlled processing: The processing must support the organization’s operations.
2. Inflexibility: Transactions are processed the same way.
3. Rapid response: Inputs must become outputs in seconds
4. Reliability: The system must be reliable. Backup and recovery should be quick and
accurate.
Management Information Systems:
The MIS converts data from mainly internal sources into information. This information enables
managers make timely and effective decisions for planning, control and decision making. It
generates information for monitoring performance and maintaining coordination.
Characteristics:
1. Supports structural decisions at operational and management control levels.
2. Designed to report on existing operations.
3. Have little analytical capability
4. Relatively inflexible
5. Have internal focus
Characteristics:
1. Integrated to all key processes of the organization
2. Share the same database
3. Standardized information
4. Online, real-time.
OPEN AND CLOSED SYSTEMS
Closed Systems:
A closed system is a system that is isolated and shut off from the environment. Information is
not received from or provided to the environment.
Open Systems:
An open system is a system that is connected to and interacts with the environment. It is
influenced by the environment.
Advantages of an open system:
1. It encourages communication
2. It adapts to the changing environment
3. It helps leaders become aware of external factors
4. Highlights interdependence of different operations
Limitations:
1. Non-linear relationships could exist. A small change in one variable can lead to a
large change in another variable
2. It may be difficult to measure the success of the system.
PERFROMANCE MEASUREMENT:
Performance measurement aims to establish how well an organization or an individual is
doing in relation to a plan. Performance measurement is a vital part of the control process.
A performance measure is the basis against which the action of an individual can be
compared.
Reasons for performance measures:
1. To Evaluate
2. To Control
3. To Budget
4. To Motivate
5. To Improve performance
Factors to consider in determining performance measures
1. The performance measure should be relevant
2. It should be realistic
3. It should be fair
4. It should reflect both short and long term objectives
5. Performance must be measured in relation to something
Profitability ratios
1. Gross Profit Margin: This ratio indicates average gross profit on turnover. It indicates
how much of total revenue is used in the purchase of materials (and other direct
expenses) for production.
Gross Profit Margin = Gross Profit * 100
Sales
2. Operating Profit Margin: This ratio measures how well a company is able to control its
expenses.
Operating Profit Margin = Profit Before Interest and Tax (PBIT) * 100
Sales
3. Asset Turnover: Asset turnover is a measure of how well the assets of a business are
being used to generate sales.
Asset Turnover = Sales
Capital Employed
4. Return On Capital Employed: This ratio measures how efficiently and effectively
management has deployed the resources available to it, irrespective of how those
resources have been financed. Capital Employed in this case is Total Assets less
Current Liabilities or Long term Liabilities plus Shareholders funds. It is a combination of
the Operating Profit margin and Asset Turnover.
ROCE = PBIT
Capital Employed
Long Term Solvency
1. Financial Gearing: Gearing measures the relationship between Shareholders Capital
plus reserves and debt. Debt is any loan which pays interest, medium to long term and
are usually secured. Overdrafts do not form part of debt in a gearing ratio.
Gearing = Debt
Debt + Equity
A gearing ratio of over 50% indicates a high gearing.
A highly geared company must earn enough profits to cover its interest charges
before anything is available for equity. On the other hand, if borrowed funds are
invested in projects which provide returns in excess of the cost of debt capital, the
shareholders will enjoy returns on their equity.
2. Operating Gearing: This measures the business risk the company is exposed to. Business
risk refers to the risk of making low profits or even losses due to the nature of the
business that the organization is involved in.
Operating gearing = Contribution
Profit Before Interest and Tax
Short Term Liquidity
Liquidity is the amount of cash a company can obtain quickly to settle its debt (and possible
meet other unforeseen demands for cash flow).
1. Current ratio = Current asset
Current Liabilities
Ideally a ratio of excess of 1 is desirable but what is ideal varies between the different
types of business.
2. Quick ratio = Current asset less inventory
Current liabilities
Ideally the ratio should be at least 1. For companies with fast inventory turnover, a
ratio of less than 1 might be acceptable.
Efficiency ratios
1. Inventory Turnover period: this shows how long inventory is held by a company
Inventory turnover period = Inventory *365
Cost of Sales
2. Accounts receivable collection period: This measures the number of days it takes a
company to recover its debt from customers.
= Trade debtors * 365
Credit sales (or turnover if credit sales figure is not
available)
3. Accounts payables payment period: This measures the number of days it takes a
company to pay its creditors.
= Trade Creditors * 365
Credit purchases (or cost of sales)
Investors’ ratios
1. Earnings per share: ‘Earnings per share’ (EPS) is defined as the profit attributable to
each equity (ordinary share).
EPS = Profit after tax less preference dividend interest
Number of ordinary shares
2. Dividend per share: This is defined as the dividend payable on each ordinary share.
DPS = Total dividend payable (paid)
Number of ordinary share
3. Based on areas of responsibility and control – managers should have certain level of
control over their areas of responsibility.
Dimensions:
These are the dimensions with which the performance measures would take
1. Competitive performance – focuses on factors such as sales growth, market share
2. Financial performance – profitability, cost, capital structure
3. Quality of service - matters like reliability, courtesy and competence
4. Flexibility – ability to deliver at the right time, respond to customer needs, cope with
demand
5. Resource utilization – efficiency in the usage of resources like labor, materials, time,
space, etc
6. Innovation – innovative processes, new products
The first two (1 and 2) are known as results while the remainder (3 to 6) are known as
determinants. This means that items 3 - 4 determine the results 1 & 2.
Advantages of ROI
1. ROI is related to the standard accounting process and widely understood
2. ROI appeal to investors who are interested in assessing % return on their investment
3. ROI allows comparisons between projects that differ in absolute size
4. It is a convenient method of measuring performance.
Disadvantages of ROI
1. It can give a false impression of improving performance over time.
2. It is not easy to compare fairly the performance of investment centre.
3. It focuses on the short term.
4. It is subject to manipulation by management.
Residual Income
The alternative way of measuring the performance of an investment centre instead of using
ROI is Residual Income (RI).
Residual Income is a measure of the centre’s profit after deducting a notional or imputed
interest cost.
Note that:
The centre’s profit is after deducting depreciation on capital equipment.
The imputed cost of capital is the organization’s cost of borrowing or weighted
average cost of capital.
Advantages of RI
1. Residual income will increase when investments earnings above the cost of capital
are undertaken and investments below cost of capital are eliminated.
2. Residual income is more flexible since a different cost of capital can be applied to
investments with different risk characteristics.
3. Disadvantages
1. It does not facilitate comparison between investment centres.
2. It does not relate the size of a centre’s income to the size of the investment.
3. It is not easily understood by managers with little accounting knowledge.
Transfer Pricing
Transfer pricing is used when divisions of an organization need to charge other divisions of the
same organization for goods and services they provide to them. For example, subsidiary A
might make a component that is used as part of a product made by subsidiary B of the
same company, but can also be sold to the external market. i.e there are 2 sources of
revenue for A
A transfer price is a price at which goods or services are transferred from one department or
subsidiary to another or from one member of a group to another.
Disadvantages
1. The market price might be a temporary.
2. Many products might not have an equivalent market price
3. There external market might be imperfect.
Cost based transfer pricing: Cost based approach to transfer pricing is often used in
practice, because the following conditions are common:
1. There is no external market
2. The external market is imperfect.
The cost based approach can either be based on full cost or variable cost.
Full Cost: Under this approach, the full cost, including fixed overhead absorbed incurred by
the supplying division is changed to the receiving division and only its profit mark up/margin is
included to make up the transfer price.
Variable Cost: The marginal cost is used and it does not include the fixed cost.