2017reportvingles PDF
2017reportvingles PDF
2017reportvingles PDF
INCLUSION
REPORT
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
2
FINANCIAL
INCLUSION
REPORT
BANCA DE LAS SUPERINTENDENCIA
OPORTUNIDADES FINANCIERA DE COLOMBIA
Carmen Cecilia León, Deputy Director Juliana Lagos, Director of Research and Development
Paola Arias, Chief of Business Intelligence Ernesto Murillo, Deputy Director of Analysis and Information
Produced by:
www.superfinanciera.gov.co
The content of the information in this Financial Inclusion Report may be reproduced or distributed without
modifications for institutional use, exclusively. Any other use made of its content, including its distribution,
reproduction, modification, dissemination or transmission without the prior written consent of Banca de
las Oportunidades or Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia is prohibited. The modifications that are
introduced to the information shall be the responsibility of the user, always citing the authors as the source of
the information.
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
TABLE OF CONTENT
1 2
6 10
5 6
112 154
7
186
FINANCIAL
CONSUMER
PROTECTION
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
1
FINANCIAL
INCLUSION REPORT 2017
6
CHAPTER 1 | INTRODUCTION
1.
INTRODUCTION
B
anca de las Oportunidades and Su- nancial products comes from TransUnion, the
perintendencia Financiera de Colom- credit bureau, while data on dataphones co-
bia are pleased to present the seventh mes from the two low value payment networ-
report on Financial Inclusion with data up to ks, Credibanco and Redeban. The analysis
2017. This report is the result of collective was complemented with information on mu-
efforts made by the National Government to nicipal demographics, provided by the Natio-
analyze the current state of financial inclusion nal Planning Department (DNP by its Spanish
in the country. It constitutes a complete and ti- acronym), and the National Department on
mely tool to continue to implement public po- Statistics (DANE by its Spanish acronym).
licies, which will make help advance towards This report comprises six chapters:
a greater access and usage of financial servi- Advances and Challenges of Financial
ces in the country. Inclusion; Financial Infrastructure; Access
Our analysis consolidates data from credit and Usage of Deposits; Access and Usage of
institutions overseen by the Superintendencia Credit; Access and Usage of Insurance; and
Financiera, from financial credit unions over- Financial Consumer Protection. In particular,
seen by the Superintendencia de la Economía for this seventh iteration of the report, the last
Solidaria (SES), and from NGOs specialized one to be presented during the Government
on microcredit, which is reported directly to of President Juan Manuel Santos, we would
Banca de Oportunidades. Likewise, data on like to highlight some key achievements and
the number of adults and businesses with fi- remaining challenges in promoting access
7
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
and usage of financial services, as well as mittee and technical subcommittees to impro-
strengthening consumer financial protection ve articulation. According to The Economist,
in Colombia. the creation of the CIIF was a key milestone of
First, we strengthened the national policy 2016, as well as a crucial step in articulating
on financial inclusion by linking them to na- governmental policies on the subject.
tional development plans. We moved from in- Third, we launched the National Strategy
cluding a single goal in 2010-2014, to setting on Economic and Financial Education, which
a series of goals in 2014-2018, which were is aimed at articulating educational projects
aimed at increasing access and usage of fi- carried out by public and private sector actors,
nancial products. Currently, the National Go- following quality and objective standards. Its
vernment’s goal is to financially include 84% construction was based on international stan-
of the adult population. dards and was adjusted in accordance to the
Second, we set out to create the National challenges presented by the implementation
Strategy on Financial Inclusion, coordinating of these types of initiatives in the country. This
efforts between public entities and the priva- strategy is set to create an environment under
te sector. Within this strategy, five priorities which financial inclusion initiatives redound
on financial inclusion were established, and in adults and businesses making better deci-
the Interinstitutional Commission on Finan- sions about their finances.
cial Inclusion was created (CIIF, by its Spanish Overall, the balance is positive, and
acronym). The CIIF has oriented the regula- the Government had notable milestones
tion targeting financial inclusion, established towards the achievement of its inclusion
guidelines for developing financial inclusion goals. Not only do the availability of at least
initiatives, and created a Consultative Com- one access point in all Colombian municipa-
8
CHAPTER 1 | INTRODUCTION
lities is a reality, but also the significant re- inactive. These efforts must be aligned with
duction in the number of municipalities with the recently launched economic and financial
fragile financial coverage, which went from education strategy, which aims at boosting
34 to 3 last year. On the other hand, the pro- efforts to overcome this challenge.
portion of the population with access to at Finally, there are the challenges regarding
least one financial product stood at 80.1% innovation. The rapid technological develo-
by the end of 2017. Finally, the number of pment incorporated into financial services
adults with active savings accounts grew is becoming increasingly important and Co-
from 15.3 million in 2015 to 18.4 million in lombia has not been unaware of such pheno-
2017. These results are largely due to the menon. From the National Government, we
follow-up of the financial inclusion strategy, began to face the difficult task of balancing
which has helped prioritize projects aimed the risks associated with the entry of new pla-
at reducing barriers in the adoption of finan- yers. Such players, supported by new techno-
cial services. logies, offer innovative products and services
Some challenges persist. First, we must in- with the potential to contribute to financial in-
tensify efforts to include the 6.7 million adults clusion through the optimization of proces-
who are out of the financial system, especia- ses, reduction of costs and the improvement
lly those who live in rural areas. Second, the of customers’ experiences.
significant access gap between cities and ru- For their efforts and dedication to this re-
ral areas must be addressed. While in urban port, we would like to thank the teams at the
areas access to financial services stands at Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia: Er-
87.2%, in rural and scattered rural areas it is nesto Murillo, Maria Fernanda Tenjo, Mariana
65.1% and 54.7%, respectively. Escobar, Kelly Granados, Sara Diaz and Ya-
Likewise, initiatives to promote the usage mile Castro; and at Banca de Oportunidades:
of financial products must continue, as there Paola Arias, Daniela Londoño, Michael Bryan,
are still 3.9 million adults whose accounts are Sara Gómez and Marcela Jiménez.
9
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
2
FINANCIAL
INCLUSION REPORT 2017
10
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
2.
PROGRESS AND
CHALLENGES
F
inancial inclusion is a relevant issue helped drive financial inclusion in recent years.
worldwide due to its potential benefits This chapter highlights the progress made in
to the economic development of the dimensions of access and use, and seeks
countries. Several studies have shown a to identify barriers and existing challenges.
positive correlation between final inclusion This analysis uses information on individuals
and economic growth, poverty reduction and businesses with financial products,
and equality. In Colombia, the National reported to Banca de las Oportunidades by the
Government has promoted public policies Colombian-based credit bureau TransUnion.
aimed at facilitating access to and usage of
financial services1. These actions, together
with efforts made by the private sector, have 1. National Financial Inclusion Strategy.
11
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
1 2
3 4
Savings
13.7 million
women and 13.3
75.6% accounts
The distribution of of adults had the largest
adults with access to million men had
held deposit penetration
financial products was at least one
products. (25.2 million
homogeneous between product. adults)
women and men.
5 6
Credit cards
44% of were the
most utilized
adults had product,
access to credit followed by 935,880 businesses had
products. access to financial products. This represents
consumer
loans. a 24.5% increase relative to 2016.
7 8 About half of
Colombians with
access to the
23.2 million adults actively used their
products. This corresponds to 68.6% of financial system had
adults and 85.6% of adults with access to three or more
financial products.
products.
9 10
Access to financial
Adults aged 65 The urban-rural
products is greater
among adults aged or above had an FII FII gap is 32.5
of 73.9%, and those
26 to 40 (87.8%) percentage
who are 18 to 25
and those aged 41 to The FII drops as rurality
65 (88.3%).
years old of 53.9%.
increases. points.
12
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
Evolution of the
financial inclusion 80.1%
80.0%
indicator
79.2%
75.0%
% of adults with
products in all institutions 73.9%
61.8%
60.0%
55.5%
55.0%
Source: TransUnion,
50.0%
Banca de las
Oportunidades
Mar - 08
Agu - 08
Jan - 09
Jun - 09
Nov - 09
Apr - 10
Sep - 10
Feb - 11
Jul - 11
Dec - 11
May - 12
Oct - 12
Mar - 13
Agu - 13
Jan - 14
Jun - 14
Nov - 14
Apr - 15
Sep - 15
Feb - 16
Jul - 16
Dec - 16
May - 17
Oct - 17
Dec - 17
calculations
13
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Credit institutions were responsible for in- dispersed rural municipalities, the FII was
cluding most of the population in the formal 65.1% and 54.7%, respectively, equivalent
financial system. In 2017, their FII stood at to 2.2 million adults with financial products
79.2% (i.e. 26.8 million adults). On the other in rural municipalities and 1.2 million adults
hand, financial credit unions overseen by the in dispersed rural municipalities.
Superintendencia de la Economía Solidaria The difference in the FII between cities
recorded an FII of 4.1%, that is, 1.4 million and dispersed rural municipalities rose by
adults. NGOs specialized in microfinance re- 32.5 percentage points, a gap similar to
ported an FII of 3.7%, or 1.3 million. Compa- the one registered in 2016. Between 2016
red to the previous year, the number of adults and 2017, the FII increased at similar ra-
holding financial products with credit institu- tes across all rurality levels. In intermediate
tions increased by 5.5%, with NGOs by 2.5% municipalities, this indicator went up by 2.9
and with financial credit unions by 1.2%. percentage points, in cities and rural muni-
In 2017, at the regional level, the highest cipalities by 2.8 points, and by 2.5 points
FII were registered in the departments of in dispersed rural municipalities.
Casanare (96.1%), Bogotá, D.C. (96.0%),
Santander (89.1%) and Risaralda (88.8%). THERE ARE NO SIGNIFICANT
The departments of La Guajira, Vichada and DIFFERENCES BY GENDER IN
Vaupés ended the year with an FII of 45%. THE ACCESS TO FINANCIAL
PRODUCTS
THE FINANCIAL INCLUSION
INDICATOR DROPS AS An analysis of gender structure of adults
RURALITY INCREASES holding financial products reveals that
50.7% are women, equivalent to 13.74 mi-
By the closing of 2017, adults with financial llion, and 49.1% are men, that is, 13.3 million
products were concentrated in the cities. In- (Chart 2.3). The gender distribution of
deed, 87.2% of people who lived in cities adults with financial products and adults
and urban agglomerations, 19.8 million, held in Colombia in 2017 is the same. Between
financial products (Chart 2.2). In intermedia- 2016 and 2017, the gender FII gap decrea-
te municipalities, the FII stood at 70.0%, re- sed by two percentage points.
presenting 3.9 million adults. In rural and
4. 0.2% of adults with financial products could not be classified by gender. Banca de las Oportunidades and TransUnion have
worked to improve identification by gender of adults with financial products and, as a result, as of 2017 share of adults not
being identified dropped significantly compared to previous years.
14
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
100%
CHART 2.2 87.2%
Financial inclusion 84.4% 90%
indicator by rurality
80%
70.0%
67.1%
65.1% 70%
62.3%
2016
54.7% 60%
2017 52.2%
50%
40%
30%
20%
0.2% 0.2%
100%
CHART 2.3
Distribution of
adults with financial
products by gender 80%
52.3% 50.7%
60%
Men
Women
Undetermined
40%
47.6% 49.1%
20%
15
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
MORE FINANCIAL INCLUSION FOR In this period, the number of financially included
THE YOUTH adults of other age groups have also increased,
although slightly, at a rate near 2.4%5.
In 2017, most adults with financial products, 11.1 When comparing the number of adults hol-
million, were 41-65 years old. The second age ding at least one financial product, in 2017,
group with the highest participation level was that adults between the ages of 26 and 40, and
of adults between the ages of 26 and 40, or 9.5 between 41 and 65 showed the highest FII:
millon, followed by young adults aged 18-25, with 87.8% and 88.3%, respectively. Adults aged
a population of 3.7 million, and people over 65, 65 and over had an indicator of 73.9%, while
or 2.6 million (Chart 2.4). The number of adults youth between the ages of 18 and 25 showed
with financial products has increased in all age an indicator of 53.9%. Nevertheless, even if the
groups over the past years. Young adults aged number of included young adults between the
18-25 have shown the highest average percen- ages 18 and 25 have increased in recent years,
tage increase: 20.8% between 2014 and 2017. half of that group is yet to be included.
5 Between 2016 and 2017, the increase in adults between the ages of 26 and 40 was 3.3%; adults between the ages of 41
and 65, 4.3%; and 9.4% for people over 65.
12
10.6
11.1 CHART 2.4
10.6 Distribution of
10.4
10
adults with financial
9.5
9.1 9.2 products by age
8.8
groups
8
2014
2015
Million
6 2016
2017
4 3.4 3.7
2.8 2.6
2.5 2.5 2.4
2.1
2
16
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
products 20
Million
2014 15
2015
2016 10
2017
2.8 3.0 2.8 4.2
1.8 1.7 5
2.7 2.8 2.2 3.0 0.6 0.8 1.7 1.7
Source: TransUnion, Banca 0.5 0.8
de las Oportunidades 0
calculations Savings CAE* DE** Other Current
account savings accounts
products
17
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
The number of people with deposit products Credit products with the lowest penetration
have increased over the past years. Between level were mortgage loans and commercial
2014 and 2017, the number of people with sa- loans. As of December 2017, roughly 1.1 mi-
vings accounts increased by 3.4 million, for an llion adults had at least one mortgage loan
increase of 15.5%; with the number of electro- granted by credit institutions or financial credit
nic deposits standing at 2.0 million, for an increa- unions overseen by the Superintendencia de
se of nearly 90%. Adults with electronic savings la Economía Solidaria. This number decreased
accounts have showed a positive but slight by 21,101 adults, or 1.9%, compared to 2016.
increase compared to traditional savings accounts The number of adults with credit products in-
and electronic deposits. Between 2014 and 2017, creased has increased over the past years, par-
the number of adults with electronic savings ticularly in terms of credit cards and consumer
accounts went up by 268,919, or 9.9%. loans, which have had the highest penetration
in the country over the last four years. Between
44% OF ADULTS IN THE 2014 and 2017, the number of adults with cre-
COUNTRY HAVE AT LEAST ONE dit cards increased by 1.8 million, or 24.5%; with
CREDIT PRODUCT9 consumer loans by 1.4 million, or 20.9%; with mi-
crocredits by 280,082, or 9.3%; and with mort-
By the closing of 2017, almost 15 million people gage loans by 118,135, or 12.1%.
had a credit product. Out of these, 78.2% lived in
cities and urban agglomerations, 11.9% in inter- ADULTS ENTERING THE FINANCIAL
mediate municipalities, 6.4% in rural municipali- SYSTEM FOR THE FIRST TIME
ties, and 3.5% in dispersed rural municipalities.
Credit cards10 were the most used product, In 2017, 1.1 million adults entered the financial
followed by consumer loans and microcredits. As system for the first time. This is an increase of
of December 2017, 9.2 million adults had at least 11% compared to 2016, when 999,187 peo-
one active credit card, an increase of 372,048 or ple entered the financial system. The main ga-
4.2%, compared to 2016 (Chart 2.6). Credit cards teway products to the financial system in 2017
are only offered by credit institutions. were savings accounts (77.8% out of the total),
In addition, almost 8 million adults held followed by microcredits (7.2%), credit cards
a consumer loan. The number of adults (6.9%), consumer loans (4.1%) and term sa-
with consumer loans increased by 382,792 vings products (2.5%) (Chart 2.7). In recent
(5.0%) compared to 2016. On the other hand, years, savings accounts have been the main
approximately 3.3 million adults had a micro- financial product through which adults in the
credit, an increase of 253,564 (8.4%) compa- country have had access to the formal finan-
red to 2016. Adults held microcredits mostly cial system for the first time.
with credit institutions (2.6 million adults), fo-
llowed by NGOs specialized in microfinance
(801,311 people) and financial credit unions 9. Computed using the number of adults identified by their
overseen by the Superintendencia de la Eco- national identification numbers.
nomía Solidaria (154,713 adults). 10. This is a kind of consumer loan.
18
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
2016 6
Million
2017
5
3.1 3.3 4
3.0 3.0
1.1
1.1 1.1 2
1.0 1.1 0.8
0.7 0.8
Source: TransUnion, Banca 1
de las Oportunidades
0
calculations
Microcredits Consumer Credit cards Mortgage Commercial
loans loans loans
CHART 2.7
0.2%
0.4%
0.4%
Percent of adults
entering the financial 4.0%
0.06%
7.1%
0.2% 0.1% 100%
0.08%
6.9%
2.8%
0.7%
%
0.8%
0.8%
0.2%
6.7% 7.2%
09
0.9%
Savings account
0.
10.8% 0.1%
2.9% 2.5% 80%
CAE 0.07%
DE
70%
Other savings products
Microcredits
50%
Consumer loans
Credit cards
74.4% 77.6% 77.8% 40%
Mortgage loans
Commercial loans
30%
CATS*
20%
Source: TransUnion, Banca de las
Oportunidades calculations
10%
*Simplified-procedure savings account
(CATS, for its Spanish acronym) 0%
2015 2016 2017
19
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
20
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
700
CHART 2.8 641.2
Number of
600
businesses with
deposit products 501.4
476.0 483.8
500
421.0
439.4
420.5
2014 401.2
400
2015
Thousand
2016
2017 300
200
100
15.2
10.7 11.3 14.7
Source: TransUnion, Banca 0
de las Oportunidades
Savings Other savings Current
calculations
account products accounts
Number of 221.1
businesses with
199.7
credit products 200
186.4
2014
2015 150
Thousand
2016
2017
94.6
83.9 91.1 100
82.1 82.6
77.3
65.9
61.1
50
13.2
Source: TransUnion, Banca 10.5 14.6
de las Oportunidades 9.2
calculations
0
Microcredits Consumer Credit cards Commercial
loans loans
21
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
12. Active adults are adults with at least one active product in the financial system. A product is considered active when it has
been used at least once over the past 6 months.
13. Ratio of active adults to the total number of adults with products.
22
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
30
CHART 2.10 27.1
Number of total and 25.0
25.7
product 19.9
20
Million
15
Total
Active
10
100%
85.3%
CHART 2.11
85.1%
84.2%
83.2%
products to total
80%
products by type of
65.8%
65.4%
64.4%
64.2%
63.8%
63.5%
institution
59.7%
70%
60%
46.3%
50%
2014 40%
2015
2016 30%
2017
20%
de las Oportunidades
calculations 0%
Credit Institution Financial credit unions NGOs specialized in
overseen by the SES microfinance
23
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
90%
85.9%
85.6%
85.6%
CHART 2.12
85.5%
Distribution of adults
84.1%
80%
83.7%
83.0% with active financial
82.8%
60%
50%
40%
Men
30%
Women
20%
10%
100%
89.4%
88.8%
CHART 2.13
87.8%
85.5%
86.0%
85.9%
85.0%
85.0%
85.1%
84.1%
82.9%
number of adults by
70.1%
80%
age range
70%
60%
50%
40%
2014
30% 2015
2016
20% 2017
24
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
14. Computed using the adults identified by their national identification numbers.
15. Savings accounts of individuals.
25
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
30
CHART 2.14
Number of adults
with total and active
25.2
25 savings accounts
23.6
23.0
21.8
Total
20 Active
18.4
17.0
16.5
15.4
Million
15
10
26
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
CHART 2.15
96.6%
96.6%
96.5%
96.5%
95.2%
95.0%
Share of adults
94.2%
100%
with active deposit
89.5%
89.4%
87.3%
87.5%
86.4%
products as a
proportion of
adults wth financial
73.1%
72.2%
71.7%
80%
products
70.4%
2014 60%
2015
2016
2017
40%
20%
Although the number of businesses with some Of the 935 thousand businesses with at least
active financial products have increased in re- one financial product held with credit institu-
cent years, this growth has been slower than tions, 674 thousand used them actively, which
that of the number of businesses with financial yields an activity level of 72.1%. On the other
products. This has resulted in a drop in the hand, of the 4,265 businesses holding a finan-
activity level of businesses, which went from cial product with financial credit unions over-
74.7% in 2016 to 72.1% in 2017. The activity seen by the Superintendencia de la Economía
level for businesses is lower than the one ob- Solidaria, 2,568 had them active, for an acti-
served for adults. vity level of 60.2%.
27
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
8
CHART 2.16
7.0
6.7
Adults with
6.6
7 6.5 financial products
by portfolio type
6
5.1
5.0 5.0
4.9
5
4.7 2014
4.3
4.2 2015
Million
4 3.7 2016
3.4 3.3
3.2 2017
2.9
3
2.3 2.3 2.2
1.8
2
1
Source: TransUnion, Banca
de las Oportunidades
0 calculations
1 product 2 products 3 products 4 products Over 4
products
1000
935.9
CHART 2.17
900 Number of
businesses with
800
751.9 financial products by
727.5
680.9
activity level
700
675.1
600
547.0 561.7
506.1
Thousand
Total
500
Activity level
400
300
200
28
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
29
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
REASONS WHY
COLOMBIANS SAVE
AND GET INDEBTED
WHAT DO PEOPLE
SAVE FOR?
WHAT DO MICRO-
ENTREPRENEURS
SAVE FOR?
30
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
WHAT DO MICRO-
ENTREPRENEURS GET
INTO DEBT FOR?
WHAT DO
PEOPLE GET INTO According to the Gran Encuesta Mi-
DEBT FOR? croempresarial of Anif 2017, loans provi-
ded to micro-entrepreneurs were mostly
used to generate liquidity. Indeed, buying
raw materials, supplies, stock and other
operating or operation expense (77%
According to the 2017 Global Findex, industry, 87% commerce, and 56%
41% of the surveyed population had a services) were the most common use
loan during the past year (vs. 43% in specified by respondents. On the other
2014). 10% of respondents got indebted hand, less than 30% of respondents re-
for health and education purposes. On modeled or made improvements to ex-
the other hand, 7% of respondents said pand their productive capacity, and less
to have got indebted to run or expand than 13% of businessmen used their
their business or firm. The foregoing re- loans to buy or lease machinery.
asons to access to loans might certain- Loans used for investment have the
ly have a positive impact on welfare of potential to allow businesses to expand
people and their family members, as on their growth opportunities, and in-
they make it easier for them to respond crease their productivity through the use
to unexpected events related to health of new technologies, innovation, develo-
conditions, increase human capital levels pment of new products or services, mar-
and generate productive investment. ket expansion, among others.
31
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
2.3 MAIN CHALLENGES the country stood at 80.1% in 2017, the FII for
young adults between the ages of 18 and 25
INCLUDE THE UNDERBANKED IN reached 53.9%. In this regard, it is important
THE FINANCIAL SYSTEM to inquire into the reasons why the youth are
not accessing to financial products.
6.7 million Colombian adults need to be inclu-
ded in the financial system (that is, 19.8% of INCREASE THE USAGE OF
adults in the country). According to the 2017 FINANCIAL PRODUCTS
Global Findex, the main reasons given by res-
pondents for not having an account were re- As referred to above, it is relevant to conti-
lated to the lack of funds (67%), management nue to encourage the usage of financial pro-
costs (59%), lack of required documentation ducts by both individuals and businesses.
(28%) and physical distance to financial institu- This is due to the fact that the share of active
tion branches (20%). Only 3% of respondents adults in the total number of adults with finan-
said that they did not have an account because cial products was equal to 85.6%. At the le-
they did not need any financial services. This vel of businesses, such share reached 72.1%.
highlights the importance of reducing other ba- It is important to explore the new barriers16
rriers to financial inclusion (Chart 2.18). to the usage of products currently offered on
Particularly, there is a challenge to inclu- the market. In addition, it is important to con-
de individuals who live in rural areas, as well tinuing to develop strategies associated with
as the youths of the country. The FII is signifi- financial education and design of appropriate
cantly lower in rural municipalities compared products with the population’s and busines-
to cities. In rural and dispersed rural muni- ses’ needs.
cipalities, 2.2 and 1.2 million adults, respec-
tively, had access to financial products. The PROMOTE FINANCIAL LITERACY
FII stood at 65.1% in rural municipalities and
54.7% in dispersed rural municipalities. The The National Financial Inclusion Strategy re-
difference in the FII between cities and dis- cognizes the relevance of Financial Literacy,
persed rural municipalities went up to 32.5 reason why it has been prioritized as one of
percentage points. Consequently, it is key to the work fronts of the strategy, recommen-
reduce access barriers to the financial sys- ding the preparation and implementation of
tem in rural municipalities and dispersed rural the National Financial Inclusion Strategy. In
municipalities. Finally, this gap has remained this regard, one of the greatest achievements
constant in the past years. of 2017 was to prepare and release the strate-
Likewise and despite the increase recorded gy document, which results from the effort of
over the past years in the number of youths
between the ages of 18 and 25 holding some
financial product, the challenge is to include 16. The National Financial Inclusion strategy in Colombia
almost half of the population without access identifies the main suggested barriers and lines of action
to the formal financial system. While the FII of and instruments.
32
CHARTER 2 | PROGRESS AND CHALLENGES
100%
CHART 2.18
Barriers for 90%
accessing the
financial system 80%
67.0%
70%
59.0%
60%
50%
40%
28.0%
30%
Source: Global Findex, 20.0%
2017
20%
10%
0%
various entities composing the National Admi- challenge is still to increasingly expand arti-
nistrative System for Economic and Financial culation in entities and implement suggested
Education and the Cross-Sector Commission actions to expand Colombians’ knowledge,
on Economic and Financial Education17. abilities and skills so they can get to better
Even if having this roadmap for each life manage their personal finance, manage risks
stage (formal education, active stage, vulne- they may encounter, and make informed de-
rable population and micro-entrepreneurship, cisions –an aspect that has been developed
and provision for old age) is a first step, the ever since the strategy was launched.
17. Decree 457 of 2014, an opportunity to generate guidelines, work methodologies and management and coordination
mechanisms among the various public and private entities relating to public policy on economic and financial educa-
tion. It is composed of 8 sub-commissions, to wit: i) technical, ii) population in formal education, iii) population in active
productive stage, iv) vulnerable population, v) micro-entrepreneurs, vi) provision for retirement and protection for old
age, vii) measurement and assessment, and viii) consultative sub-commission. The latter as a space for articulation of
the Cross-Sector Commission on Economic and Financial Education with the private sector.
33
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
3
FINANCIAL
INCLUSION REPORT 2017
34
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
3.
FINANCIAL
INFRASTRUCTURE
T
his chapter analyses financial coverage at the national, department and municipal le-
in the country using information of finan- vels. The number and amount of transactions
cial institutions’ access points and their are analyzed by type of channel. In addition, the
transactionality. Access points include bank chapter deals with transactional services (e.g.,
branches, bank correspondents, POS termi- debit and credit cards) indicators, the number
nals, ATMs and mobile agents. This chap- of financial transactions per 100,000 adults, and
ter describes the evolution of access points access to Internet and mobile phones.
35
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
1
There is at least one In 2017, there
were 532,138
access point to
the financial system
access points in Municipal
the country.
across all Colombian
municipalities since
coverage
early 2015.
100% Since 2015
3
Fragile financial coverage Fragile coverage
municipalities (those with 1 or municipalities
34 3
2 correspondents and no bank
branches) went from 34 in 2016
to 3 by late 2017.
(2016) (2017)
7
Most
Banks Financing Financial creditunions
transactions $7.166 companies overseen by Superintendencia
were Trillions $32 Financiera de Colombia (SFC)
completed at (99.4%) trillion $11
(0.4%) trillion
banks. (0.2%)
9
ACH $10.1
The largest share on The amount million.
36
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
4
By the end of 2017, Colombia had
105,104 bank correspondents
distributed as follows: 99.8% 2017
(104,918 points) with credit institutions
and 0.2% (186) with financial credit 105,104
unions overseen by Superintendencia
de la Economía Solidaria (SES).
6
Mobile phone transactions had 2016 2017
8
Financial transfers
Payments
Out of all transactions made in the 34.8%
35.5%
financial system, in terms of transacted
amount, the most frequent were Internacional
Number
payments and transfers, representing transactions
10
On average, every 2016 2017
adult conducted 86 Virtual Virtual
transactions transactions
virtual transactions
annually. 75 86
37
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
1. According to DANE [National Administrative Department of Statistics, for its acronyms in Spanish], there are 1,102
municipalities and 20 departamental townships.
2. Access points exclude mobile financial agents, since such data is only collected on 23 NGOs specialized in microfinance.
3. Analysis by rurality levels exclude information on ATMs, collected at a national level.
4. Data by rurality level on POS terminals corresponds directly to data reported by Low Value Networks (CredibanCo
and Redeban).
38
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
Evolution of the
number of financial 15,709
500,000
access points by type 15,227
of access points 14,424
14,817
400,000
Branches
Correspondents
300,000
POS terminals 328,774 317,204 364,358 403,512
ATMs
200,000
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de 100,000
la Economía Solidaria, 95,730 92,627 94,263 105,104
and NGOs specialized in
microfinance, Banca de las
Oportunidades calculations. 7,593 7,704 7,743 7,813
0
2014 2015 2016 2017
0.6%
6.0%
6.7% 4.2% 3.9% 5.1%
access points by 100%
39
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
5. Information on bank branches comes from Form 322 of Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia. Historic series have
been homogenized based of this form. Previous versions of this Report used Form 398, replaced by Form 534. The lat-
ter discontinued the measure of the number of branches.
6. In 2017, the distribution of the number of credit institution branches were as follows: 5,722 banks, 453 financing com-
panies, 10 financial corporation, and 206 financial credit unions overseen by SFC and Superintendencia de la Economía
Solidaria (SES).
7. The total number of bank branches went down from 5,812 in 2016 to 5,722 in 2017.
40
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
6,000
Credit Institutions
Financial credit unions
5,000
overseen by SES
NGO
4,000
6,258 6,460 6,472 6,391
3,000
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de 2,000
la Economía Solidaria,
and NGOs specialized
1,000
in microfinance, Banca
de las Oportunidades
calculations. 0
Intermediate municipalities
Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia,
2,000
Superintendencia de
la Economía Solidaria,
and NGOs specialized
1,000
in microfinance, Banca
de las Oportunidades
calculations. 0
41
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
8. Bank correspondents are commercial establishments that provide financial services in the name of a financial service pro-
vider, thus becoming formal financial system access points. Data included in this section specifies the number of bank
correspondents reported by every institution overseen by the Financial Superintendence of Colombia and Superinten-
dencia de la Economía Solidaria.
9. The distribution of credit institution correspondents were as follows: 100,449 bank correspondents, 4,327 financing com-
panies’ correspondents, and 56 financial cooperative
10. Institutions with the largest presence in rural municipalities were Banco de Occidente (1,738), followed by Bancolombia
(1,516) and Banco Agrario (957).
42
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
Evolution of
186
58
the number of 4,327
53
103
11
100,050
correspondents by
57
69
23
type of institution 10,066 4,248 4,848
80,050
Banks
Financing Companies
Financial credit unions 60,050
overseen by SFC
Financial credit unions
overseen by SES
85,600 88,287 89,255 100,533
40,050
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de
la Economía Solidaria, 20,050
and NGOs specialized
in microfinance, Banca
de las Oportunidades
calculations. 50
Intermediate municipalities
60%
Rural municipalities
Dispersed rural municipalities 50%
43
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
100%
CHART 3.7
Ratio of self-operated
80%
correspondents vs. third
67.7% 69.0% party correspondents
60%
and active and inactive
99.0% 100.0%
correspondents by type
40%
of institution in the fourth
quarter of 2017
20%
1.0%
100%
4.1%
30.6% 29.5%
80%
60%
Number of self-operated
95.9% 100.0% correspondents
20%
Source: Superintendencia
0% Financiera de Colombia,
Banca de las Oportunidades
Bank institutions Financing Financial Total
calculations.
Companies credit unions
44
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
100%
CHART 3.8 90%
Ratio of self-operated 80%
correspondents vs. third 59.6% 62.2% 70%
63.8%
party correspondents 71.3% 69.0%
60%
and active and inactive 50%
correspondents by 40%
rurality level in the fourth 30%
quarter of 2017 40.4% 20%
37.8% 36.2%
28.7% 31.0%
10%
% of self-operated
correspondents
0%
% of third party correspondents Total
Cities and urban Intermediate Rural Dispersed rural
agglomerations municipalities municipalities municipalities
100%
70%
60%
30%
20%
11. Information on the number of active and third party correspondents is available only for the 104,918 credit insti-
tutions’ correspondents overseen by Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia.
12. Aggregators may provide services at the same physical point to several financial institutions. This may cause an
overestimation of the number of correspondents in the country in existing standardized reports, as institutions
currently report individual points managed by an aggregator, who provides services to several institutions.
13. The share of third party correspondents reached 71.3% in Cities and urban agglomerations, 59.5% in intermedia-
te municipalities, 62.3% in rural municipalities, and 63.8% in dispersed rural municipalities.
14. The activity level for intermediate and rural municipalities, 79.9%, is greater than the national one, which stands
at 77.7% respectively.
45
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
AUTOMATIC TELLER annual rate of 2.9%. In 2017, there were 892 ad-
MACHINES - ATM ditional ATMs compared to 2015, and 482 more
than in 2016. Due to the moderate increase in the
In 2017, there were 15,709 ATMs in the coun- number of ATMs, geographic and demographic
try: banks managed 84.7% (13,312), while the coverage indicators have remained almost un-
remainder 15.3% (2,397) were managed by Ser- changed, at around 46 ATMs per 100,000 adults
vibanca. The number of ATMs have increased and 16 per 1,000 km2. Data on ATMs is only avai-
consistently in the last three years at an average lable at a national level (Table 3.1).
46
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
Banks
10,000
Servibanca
8,000
2,000
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia,
Banca de las Oportunidades 0
calculations. 2014 2015 2016 2017
TABLE 3.1 Evolution of indicators for ATMs per 100,000 adults and 1,000 km2 by rurality level
Type of
institution Per Per Per Per
Per Per Per Per
100,000 100,000 100,000 100,000
1,000 km2 1,000 km2 1,000 km2 1,000 km2
adults adults adults adults
Source: Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia, DANE and DNP, Banca de las Oportunidades calculations.
47
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
667
551
1,000
500
48
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
TABLE 3.2 Evolution of indicators for mobile financial agents in NGOs per 100,000 adults
and 1,000 km2 by rurality level
POS TERMINALS16
As of December 2017, the number of POS Antioquia, Valle del Cauca, Atlántico, and
terminals was 403,512. This implies an Cundinamarca were the top five departments
increase of 10.7% (39,154) over the last year with the highest number of POS terminals,
and 27.2% (86,308) compared to 2015. By roughly 68.3% of POS terminals in the coun-
type of institution, CredibanCo and Redeban try. However, the top five departments in ter-
concentrated 96.4% (388,757 points) of the ms of the demographic coverage indicator
market, followed by banks with 2.1% (8,509), were: Archipelago of San Andres, Providen-
Asenda Red with 1.3% (5,287) and Red cia and Santa Catalina, Bogotá, D.C., Risaral-
Visionamos with 0.2% (959) (Chart 3.11). da, Quindío and Valle del Cauca, all of which
There were 1,149.8 POS terminals per had over 1,180 POS terminals per 100,000
100,000 adults and 405.1 per 1,000 km2 in adults (Annex 5). On the other hand, the lar-
2017 (Table 3.3). Additionally, 91.8% of POS gest 13 Cities and urban agglomerations had
terminals were available in Cities and urban 70.9% of Redeban’s and CredibanCo’s POS
agglomerations, 6.0% in intermediate munici- terminals (Annex 6).
palities, 1.6% in rural municipalities, and 0.6%
in dispersed rural municipalities (Chart 3.12).
In 2017, POS terminal had presence in all 16. Municipal data on POS terminals is only available for Cre-
of the country’s departments. Bogotá, D.C., dibanCo and Redeban.
49
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
219,756
206,034
204,163
250,000
terminals by type
179,900
of institution17
169,001
149,742
200,000
126,899
Other
107,913
150,000
Redeban Multicolor
Credibanco
100,000
14,755
14,827
10,405
50,000
10,405
Source: Superintendencia
0 Financiera de Colombia,
Banca de las Oportunidades
2014 2015 2016 2017
calculations.
CHART 3.12
Evolution of the
0.5%
0.6%
0.6%
1.5%
1.5%
1.6%
Rural municipalities
92.4% 92.1% 91.8%
60% Dispersed rural municipalities
50%
40%
Source: DNP, DANE, Low
30%
Value Networks (CredibanCo
y Redeban), Banca de las
2015 2016 2017
Oportunidades calculations.
17. Other category includes Banks, Red Visionamos and Asenda Red, the latter for 2017.
18. Low Value Networks (CredibanCo and Redeban) directly reported municipal data to Banca de las Oportunidades.
50
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
TABLE 3.3
Evolution of 2015 2016 2017
indicators for Type of
POS terminals per institution Per Per Per Per Per Per
100,000 adults 100,000 1,000 100,000 1,000 100,000 1,000
adults km2 adults km2 adults km2
and 1,000 km2 by
rurality level Cities and
urban agglo- 1,300.5 3873.4 1,464.9 4433.9 1,574.6 4882.0
merations
Intermediate
321.1 169.6 376.7 198.1 422.1 219.5
municipalities
Rural
139.2 19.9 163.1 23.8 180.6 26.6
municipalities
Dispersed
rural 72.8 2.9 88.8 3.5 111.0 4.5
municipalities
Source: DNP, DANE, Low
Value Networks (CredibanCo
y Redeban), Banca de las Total 941.1 320.9 1,064.5 369.2 1,149.8 405.1
Oportunidades calculations.
51
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
52
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
Transacted
$241 $11
amount $3,112 $2,556 $1,051
(trillion)
Mobile
Branches Internet ACH ATM
phones
21. It includes information of transactions made through distribution channels provided by overseen entities. It includes nine:
branches, bank correspondents (BC), automatic teller machines (ATM), POS terminals (POS), wire transfers (ACH), Internet,
mobile phones, audio-tellers and automatic payments.
53
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
ACH 10.0%
-7.1%
48.6%
Mobile telephone 67.6%
Intenet 20.5%
12.2%
5.5%
Audio-teller 14.2%
POS 12.2%
9.4%
3.8%
ATM
6.5%
-1.4%
Branches -6.2%
20% 10% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80%
Correspondents 40.3%
27.8%
Intenet -2.8%
6.1%
13.7% 2015 - 2016
Audio-teller -7.8%
2.8% 2016 - 2017
POS
2.0%
4.2%
ATM
7.8%
-1.3%
Branches -10.0% Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% 120% 140% 160%
54
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
Banks made 97.7% (5,330 million) of the total hand, withdrawals and deposits had a sha-
number of transactions, and channeled 99.4% re of 13.3%, or $965 trillion and $948 trillion,
($7,166 trillion) of the total amount of funds. Fi- respectively, while international transactions
nancing companies and financial credit unions 3.1%, or $223 trillion (Chart 3.16).
had a smaller share, 2.0% and 0.3% terms num-
ber of transactions, and 0.4% and 0.2% in terms AVERAGE TRANSACTION AMOUNT
of transacted amount, respectively (Chart 3.15). BY CHANNEL
Balance inquiries represented 48.3%
(2,635 million) of total transactions; payments The average transaction amount by chan-
had a share of 27.2% (1,482 million); and with- nel (i.e., the ratio between total transacted
drawals 15.0% (819 million). In terms of tran- amounts and the number of monetary tran-
sacted amounts, the share of transfers and sactions) shows that the highest average
payments stood out, representing, on avera- value corresponded to ACH (10.1 million), fo-
ge, 35.2% of total transfers, or $2,510 trillion llowed by the Internet (6.4 million), and bran-
and $2,560 trillion, respectively. On the other ches (5.6 million).
CHART 3.15
Share of the number
97.7%
of transactions and
transacted amount
2.0%
0.3%
by type of institution
Percentage of
the number of
transactions
Banks
Financing companies
0.4%
0.2%
Percentage of
the transacted
amount
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
55
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Number of transactions
CHART 3.16
Transfers (giros) 0.1% 0.1%
Share of the number
International
1.1% 1.0%
transactions of transactions and
Transfers 3.6% 3.8%
transacted amount
Deposits 5.0% 4.6%
Transfers (giros)
Transacted amount
2016
ATM 0.32 0.34
2017
Source: Superintendencia
ACH 8.91 10.11
Financiera de Colombia.
13.0 8.0 3.0 0.0 2.0 7.0 12.0
56
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
CHART 3.18
Share of the number 99.3%
of transactions and
0.4%
transacted amount by 0.3%
type of institution
Percentage of the
Banks transacted amount
Financing companies
Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC 96.0%
2.4%
1.6%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
57
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
2016
International 2017
transactions 1.0% 1.2%
50% 40% 30% 20% 10% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%
Transacted amount
43.2%
2016
Transfers 23.3% 26.3%
2017
58
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
CHART 3.20
92.7% 92.6%
Share of the number 7.2% 7.4%
of transactions and 0.09% 0.03%
transacted amount by
type of institution
Banks
Financing companies
Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC
59
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Transacted amount
1.1%
Transfers sent
(giros) 0.0% 0.1%
Transfers
received (giros) 1.3% 1.2%
Transfers
2.7% 2.6%
Withdrawals
24.5% 26.0%
2016
Deposits
27.0% 29.7%
2017
60
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
CHART 3.22
Share of the number Number of transactions
of transactions and
transacted amount by
rurality level 3.5% 3.4% Dispersed
rural
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Transacted amount
Dispersed
4.2% 4.0% rural
Rural
10.0% 9.5% municipalities
Intermediate
16.8% 16.5% municipalities
2016
2017
Cities and urban
69.0% 70.0%
agglomerations
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia. 90% 70% 50% 30% 10% 0% 10% 30% 50% 70% 90%
61
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHART 3.23
99.6%
Share of the number
0.2% of transactions and
0.1% transacted amount by
type of institution
Percentage of the
number of transactions
Banks
Financing companies
Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC
99,5%
0.4%
0.1%
Percentage of the
transacted amount
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
62
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
2016
0.5% 0.7% Payments
2017
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Transacted amount
3.3%
International
1.6% 1.7% transactions
2017
3.4% 3.4% Deposits
63
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
93.2%
CHART 3.25
6.7%
0.1%
Share of the number of
transactions and transacted
amount by type of institution
Percentage of the
number of transactions
Banks
Financing companies
Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC
88.2%
11.7%
0.1%
Percentage of the
transacted amount
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
64
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
2016
2017
4.1% 4.2% Balance check
International
7.5% 7.0% transactions
Payments and
88.4% 88.8% transfers
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Transacted amount
1.3%
International
6.1% 5.5% transactions
2016
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia. 120% 70% 20% 0% 30% 80% 130%
65
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
99.5%
CHART 3.27
0.48% Share of the number
0.05% of transactions and
transacted amount by
type of institution
Percentage of the
number of transactions
Banks
Financing companies
Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC
99.97%
0.01%
0.02%
Percentage of the
transacted amount
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
66
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
2016
Balance check
84.6% 84.6%
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Transacted amount
35.5%
2016
2017
66.6% 65.5% Transfers
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia. 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80%
67
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
100.0%
CHART 3.29
Share of the number
of transactions and
transacted amount
by type of institution
Percentage of the
number of transactions
Banks
100.0%
Percentage of the
transacted amount
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
68
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
2016
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Transacted amount
0.2%
2016
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia. 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80%
69
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
WIRE TRANSFERS (ACH) llion) of the total, and ranked ninth in terms
of number of transactions, with a share of
Banks held the highest share on total transac- 1.9% (104 million). The entirety of opera-
tions (99.2%, or 103 million), as well as on to- tions corresponded to payment of obliga-
tal atransacted amount (99.9%, representing tions or money transfers made within the
$1,049 trillion) (Chart 3.31). country. Compared to 2016, amounts tran-
Wire transfers (ACH) channeled the third sacted through this channel increased by
largest amount of funds, 14.6% ($1,051 tri- 5% (Chart 3.32).
99.2%
CHART 3.31
0.6% Share of the number of
0.1%
transactions and transacted
amountby type of institution
Percentage of the
number of transactions Banks
Financing companies
Financial credit unions overseen
by SFC
99.9%
0.04%
0.09%
Percentage of the
transacted amount
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
70
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
2016
2017
Payments and
100% 100% transfers
Transacted amount
14.6%
Payments and
100% 100% transfers
2016
2017
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia. 150% 100% 50% 0% 50% 100% 150%
71
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
TRANSACTIONAL PRODUCTS AND Between 2016 and 2017, this indicator in-
VIRTUAL TRANSACTIONS: creased by 6% (Chart 3.33).
In addition, the number of Internet and mo-
This section analyses indicators measuring bile phone transactions per 100,000 adults
access to transactional services (e.g., number reached 8,6 million 22 by the end of 2017,
of debit and credit cards per 100,000 adults), which, compared to 2016, represents a 15%
use of virtual transactions (e.g., number of increase (Chart 3.34).
Internet and mobile phone transactions per By the end of 2017, roughly 12.2 million
100,000 adults), as well as cashless transac- cashless transactions per 100.000 adults were
tions (e.g., number of online transactions, mo- made through Internet, mobile phones or cre-
bile phones, debit and credit card transactions dit or debit cards. Relative to 2016, this repre-
per 100,000 adults). sents an increase of 12% (Chart 3.35).
By the end of 2017, there were 81,404 de-
bit cards and 33,198 credit cards per 100,000 22. This means that on average every adult conducted 86
adults, for 114,602 cards per 100,000 adults. virtual transactions annually.
CHART 3.33
Number of cards per
Credit cards Debit cards
100,000 adults
2016
2017
33,198 81,404
32,681 75,682
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
and DANE.
72
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
CHART 3.34
Number of virtual Virtual transactions
per 100,000 adults
transactions per
100,000 adults 977,018
2017
8.597,384
7,620,367
Internet transactions
593,188
2016
7,492,472
6,899,284
1,000,000
2,000,000
3,000,000
4,000,000
5,000,000
6,000,000
7,000,000
8,000,000
0
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
and DANE.
CHART 3.35
Number of cashless
transactions per
Virtual transactions
100,000 adults per 100,000 adults
809,577
2017 977,018
12,157,102
Credit card transactions 2,750,141
6,899,284
Source: Superintendencia
0
1,000,000
2,000,000
3,000,000
4,000,000
5,000,000
6,000,000
7,000,000
8,000,000
Financiera de Colombia
and DANE.
73
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
This section presents the evolution of tech- 71.2% had a smartphone, a behavior similar
nology means by which people are approach to that found in municipal seats (76.1%). This
financial services, particularly through the proportion was 49.2% among populated areas
Internet and mobile phones. and dispersed rural municipalities. The number
In 2017, at the national level, 96.4% of hou- of adults with smartphones in populated areas
seholds had a mobile phone, with 97.5% held and dispersed rural municipalities, increased
at municipal seats23 and 92.2% in populated by 32%, relative to 2016 (Chart 3.37).
areas and dispersed rural municipalities24. Around 86.3% of people aged five and
As for the Internet, 50% of households above (38.8 million Colombians) used mo-
had Internet connection. Although Internet bile phones, which, again, is a behavior
connection is similar to the national average similar to that found in municipal seats
found at municipal seats (58.6%), it differs (88.3%); while populated areas and disper-
from populated areas and dispersed rural sed rural municipalities had a lower percen-
municipalities, where this proportion reaches tage: 79.5%.
17%. Between 2016 and 2017, the number Finally, 62.3% (27.9 million) of Colom-
of households with Internet access located in bian adults used the Internet, similarly to
populated areas and dispersed rural munici- those living in municipal areas (69.4%). On
palities went from 383 to 527, which consti- the other hand, with a very big difference,
tutes an increase of 37% (Chart 3.36). populated areas and dispersed rural muni-
In 2017, 73.2% of people aged five and cipalities had an average utilization rate of
above had a mobile phone. Out of these, 37% (Chart 3.38).
23. According to the National Quality of Life Survey [Encuesta Nacional de Calidad de Vida (ECV)] conducted by DANE, munici-
pal seats are defined as an urban perimeter which boundaries are set by “Agreements” of the Municipal Council. It is where
the Municipal Town Hall is found.
24. According to the National Quality of Life Survey, populated areas and dispersed rural municipalities represent small villa-
ges, police departments and townships in the rural area of a municipality, which are composed of 20 or more adjacent or
semi-detached houses.
74
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
CHART 3.36
Share of households Percentage of households
with mobile phones with mobile phones
and Internet
2017
Percentage of households
with access to internet
2016
2017
45.8% 50.0% Total
75
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHART 3.37
Percentage of people
aged 5 and above having
Share of people
a mobile phone aged 5 and
above having a
mobile phone
2016
2017
Municipality 75.5% 76.6%
proper
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
2016
2017
Total 63.5% 71.2%
76
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
CHART 3.38
Percentage of people using
Percentage of a mobile phone anywere
people aged 5 and
above using the
Internet and mobile
Rural settlement
78.1% 79.5%
2016
2017
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Rural settlement
32.2% 37.0%
2016
2017
58.1% 62.3% Total
77
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
ANNEXES
Annex 1. Number of branches and department indicator per 100,000 adults and
1,000 km2 (2017)
78
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
Source: DANE, DNP [National Planning Department, in Spanish], Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de la Economía Solidaria, and NGOs specialized in microfinance, Banca de las Oportunidades calculations.
79
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Annex 2. Number of branch offices and indicator per 100,000 adults and 1,000 km2 in the 13
largest cities (2017)
Source: DANE, DNP [National Planning Department, in Spanish], Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de la Economía Solidaria, and NGOs specialized in microfinance, Banca de las Oportunidades calculations.
Number
of corres- Number of co- Number of Number of Number of
Number of bank
Department pondents rrespondents active self-operated third party
correspondents
per 100,000 per 1,000 km2 correspondents correspondents correspondents
adults
80
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
Number
of corres- Number of co- Number of Number of Number of
Number of bank
Department pondents rrespondents active self-operated third party
correspondents
per 100,000 per 1,000 km2 correspondents correspondents correspondents
adults
1. These figures were computed using the information on bank correspondents of credit institutions overseen by Superinten-
dencia Financiera de Colombia, which corresponds to 104,918 points of access.
Source: DANE, DNP [National Planning Department, in Spanish], Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de la Economía Solidaria, and NGOs specialized in microfinance, Banca de las Oportunidades calculations.
81
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Annex 4. Demographic indicator for bank correspondents, number of third party, self-
operated and active correspondents for the 13 main cities (2017)
Number
Number Number of Number Number of Number of
of corres-
of bank correspon- of active self-opera- third party
Municipality pondents
correspon- dents per correspon- ted corres- correspon-
per 100,000
dents 1,000 km2 dents pondents dents
adults
Bogotá, D.C. 30,198 512.3 18,608.0 16,658 4,164 26,034
Source: DANE, DNP [National Planning Department, in Spanish], Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de la Economía Solidaria, and NGOs specialized in microfinance, Banca de las Oportunidades calculations.
Annex 5. Demographic indicators for the number of POS terminals by department (2017)
82
CHAPTER 3 | FINANCIAL INFRASTRUCTURE
83
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Annex 6. Demographic indicators for the number of POS terminals for the 13 main cities (2017)
84
CAPÍTULO 3 | INFRAESTRUCTURA FINANCIERA
85
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
4
FINANCIAL
INCLUSION REPORT 2017
86
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
4.
ACCESS AND
USAGE OF DEPOSIT
PRODUCTS
S
avings are crucial when it comes to buil- businesses with deposit products under the
ding financial resilience. They help set dimensions of access and use at the natio-
financial goals, face contingencies, and nal level. This analysis uses information re-
smooth maximum and minimum levels of in- ported by financial institutions to the credit
come and expenses. bureau TransUnion 1. In addition, this sec-
This chapter analyzes the recent evolution tion presents information on the number of
in the number of adults and businesses with adults who use their products by gender
access to deposits, the total number of pro- and age ranges.
ducts in the system, along with their activity
level, balances and transactions made throu-
gh them. This analysis emphasizes on tradi-
tional savings accounts, electronic savings
accounts, simplified-procedure savings ac- 1. A deposit product is considered to be active when it had
counts, and electronic deposits (CAE, CATS at least one movement in the last six months. Given the
and DE, respectively, for its Spanish acronym). above, figures refering to the total number of adults with
The first section of this chapter conducts deposit products, include both active and inactive pro-
a description of the number of adults and ducts.
87
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
The chapter presents the distribution by gen- in-force legal monthly minimum ranges (SML-
der using both the number of adults with pro- MV, by its Spanish acronym) (up to 1 SMLMV,
ducts and the total number of products in between 1 and 3 SMLMV, and between 3 to 5
circulation. The difference between these two SMLMV5).
distributions is that the former considers the Finally, complementing the analysis on ac-
total number of adults with financial products. tivity levels, recent trends on the following fi-
Therefore, if an individual has more than one nancial transactions were reviewed: deposits,
product, it is accounted only once. The se- payments and transfers. institution
cond measure accounts for the total number
of products held by adults. 2. Balances are only reported for savings accounts and
In addition, the evolution of the number of electronic savings accounts.
savings accounts, CAE, CATS and DE, as well 3. Institutions were classified as those supervised by the
as their activity levels, balances2 and transac- SFC: Banks, Financing Companies, Financial Corpora-
tionality, is reviewed. Regional data is presen- tions and Financial credit unions overseen by SFC, and
ted for traditional savings accounts and CAE3. credit unions overseen by Superintendencia de la Eco-
Analyses by level of rurality considers four nomía Solidaria (SES by its Spanish acronym).
types of municipalities: cities and urban ag- 4. This indicator is computed only for traditional savings
glomerations, intermediate municipalities, ru- account and CAE.
ral municipalities, and rural and scattered rural 5. In 2017, the legal monthly minimum wage (SMLMV by
areas4. Product balances are disaggregated by its Spanish acronym) was 737.717 COP pesos.
88
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
Out of the total number of adults with at least he distribution by age groups for
one simplified-procedure savings account, different products has remained similar
50.2% were men and 49.6% were women. over the past years. Access to deposit products
The majority of adults with electronic savings account
has been concentrated mainly in adults between
and electronic deposits are women. 26 to 40 and 41 to 65 years.
increased for all types of In the case of simplified-procedure savings account, 56.7%
deposit products. Simplified- of accounts belonged to women and 43.3% to men;
this distribution remained unchanged relative to 2016.
procedure savings account
had the largest growth rate In the case of electronic savings accounts, 85.5% of
(129.9%). the accounts belonged to women, while in the case of
electronic deposits 67.6% belonged to women; this
result has remained unaltered relative to 2016.
89
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
30 CHART 4.1
25.2 Adults with total
25 23.6 and active savings
accounts
20 18.4
17.0
Millon adults
15
Total
10 Active
5
Source: TransUnion, Banca de las
0 Oportunidades calculations.
2016 2017
90
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
700
CHART 4.2 641.2
Businesses with
total and active 600
savings accounts
501.4
500
Thousands of companies
Total 400
Active
310.1
300
246.2
200
100
Source: TransUnion, Banca
de las Oportunidades
calculations. 0
2016 2017
59.4
60
CHART 4.3 54.9
Total number of
savings accounts by 50
activity level
33.4
40
Active savings account 31.0
30 Million accounts
20
23.9 26.0
10
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
and Superintendencia de la
Economía Solidaria. 0
2016 2017
91
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
60
CHART 4.4
58 2.8 Total number of
savings accounts by
0.9
56
0.4 entity type
Savings accounts (in million)
Banks
54 2.5
Financing companies
50 Financial corporations
By the end of 2017, the majority of savings greater than one minimum wage (5.6% were ba-
accounts and active savings accounts were lances between 1 and 3 minimum wages, and
concentrated in banks: 93.2% and 90.4% of 2,5% had balances of more than 3 minimum
active accounts, respectively. These figures wages). Accounts with balances up to 1 mini-
have remained relatively stable over the last mum wage, despite representing the majority of
three years (Chart 4.4). The highest activity le- the accounts, only contributed 1.3% to total of
vels were experienced by credit unions: 66.7% balances in the system. Accounts with balances
of savings accounts were active. Savings ac- amounting 1 to 3 minimum wages had a share
counts with the lowest activity levels were tho- of 2.2% on total balances.
se of financing companies, with 42.5%. With Across all ranges, banks made the largest
the exception of financial corporations and contribution. Particularly, in the range of up to 1
banks, across all types of entities, there has minimum wage, banks contributed 97.4% of the
been a reduction in the activity levels of savings total number of accounts and 96.9% of balan-
accounts over the past three years. ces. In the range of 1 to 3 minimum wage banks
As of 2017, total balances on savings ac- contributed 98.3% and 98.0%, respectively. Sa-
counts accrued to $165 trillion, 3.8%6 higher vings accounts with more than 5 minimum wage
than in 2016 (Chart 4.5). Banks contributed represented 14.5% of the number of accounts
to most (97.8%) of total savings accounts’ and 94.7% of their balance.
balances. In the second place were credit
unions, with a share of 1.5%.
When analyzing the distribution of savings ac- 6. Growth rates of balances are expressed in real terms.
counts by ranges of minimum wages for 20177 7. This level of disaggregation is applied to the institutionssu-
(table 4.1), it was found that most accounts pervised by the SFC because the financial credit unions over-
(77.3%) had balances up to 1 minimum wage, seen by Superintendencia de la Economía Solidaria do not
while less than one tenth had balances that were yet report with this same level of disaggregation (by SMMLV).
92
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
$170,000,000
CHART 4.5
Balances of savings
accounts (million) $165,000,000
$2,429,062
$493,671
$251,991
$405.593
$145,000,000
Source: Superintendencia $149,737,594
Financiera de Colombia
y Superintendencia de la
Economía Solidaria $140,000,000
2016 2017
Financial
450 $16 18 $24 18 $53 96 $405,501
Corporations
Financing
355,069 $19,427 18,822 $24,742 6,084 $17,405 12,388 $190,417
Companies
Financial cre-
dit union over- 785,214 $43,514 35,433 $46,918 11,931 $34,662 22,927 $368,578
seen by SFC
93
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
The distribution of accounts by gender shows 3.5% and 1.7%, respectively. While cities con-
that 47.4% belonged to women (26.2 million tributed about 3.5 million additional accounts
accounts) and 52.5% to men (29.0 million (an increase of 7.5% compared to 2016) and
accounts). Between 2016 and 2017, men intermediate municipalities 660,740 (an in-
and women’s savings accounts increased by crease of 12.1%), it should be noted that rural
17.0% y 16.8%, respectively (Chart 4.6). In and scattered rural municipalities had growth
2016, no data on the number of accounts by rates of 11.9% and 11.3%, respectively.
gender was available for the credit unions. For The departments that registered the lar-
credit institutions alone, the growth rate in the gest number of accounts were: Bogotá D.C,
number of savings accounts belonging to men with a share of 28.8%); Antioquia, with a sha-
increased by 11.6%, while the growth rate re of 13.5%; and Valle del Cauca concentra-
among women was 10.5%, a difference of ted 10.4% of savings accounts. On the other
one percentage point. The remaining traditio- hand, Vaupés, Vichada and Amazonas had
nal savings accounts belonged to businesses. a share of less than 0.5% (Chart 4.7). This
With regards to the total balances by gen- distribution is consistent with the population
der8, women’s savings accounts represented distribution of such departments, where Bo-
46.4% of the total balance, while men ac- gotá concentrates 17.4% of Colombia’s po-
counted for 53.5%. This means that men’s pulation, Antioquia 13.9% and Valle del Cauca
savings accounts had an excess balance of 10.0%. At the same time, Vaupés, Vichada,
$3,7 trillion over women’s accounts. The ave- Amazonas and Guainía have less than 0.1%
rage balance of men’s accounts was above of the total population. Guainía has exhibited
than that of women: $969,434 and $931,081, the highest activity levels (above 58%) over
respectively. Compared to 2016, total balan- the last three years.
ces of women’s accounts had a real increase Additionally, Bolívar and Amazonas had the
of 2.9%, and of 1.8% in the case of balances largest growth rate in terms of the number of
of men’s accounts. accounts, while Bolívar and Vaupés had the
The average balance of women’s ac- largest growth rate with regards to balances.
counts in credit institutions was higher by Antioquia, one of the main departments of the
$152,038 than that of credit unions overseen country, was among those that grew at com-
by Superintendencia de la Economía Solida- paratively small rates (see Maps 4.1 and 4.2).
ria. In the case of men, that difference was
close to $149,250.
By the end of 2017, the distribution of sa- 8. The total of traditional savings accounts and their ba-
vings accounts by rurality barely changed lances take into account both natural persons and legal
compared to the last three years. Cities and persons. As a result, the number and balance of savings
urban agglomerations concentrated 84.4% of accounts by gender do not coincide with these totals.
the number of savings accounts, followed by The difference corresponds to legal persons.
intermediate municipalities with 10.3%, and
rural and scattered rural municipalities with
94
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
35
CHART 4.6
Savings accounts
distribution by gender 29.0 30
26.2
24.8
25
22.4
Women
Men 20
Million accounts
15
10
Source: Superintendencia 5
Financiera de Colombia
y Superintendencia de la
Economía Solidaria.
0
2016 2017
5,000,000
60%
accounts
Number of active savings 4,000,000 50%
accounts
% accumulated active 40%
savings accounts 3,000,000
30%
2,000,000
20%
1,000,000
10%
0 0%
Bogotá, D.C.
Antioquia
Valle del Cauca
Santander
Cundinamarca
Atlántico
Huila
Tolima
Bolívar
Norte de Santander
Risaralda
Boyacá
Caldas
Nariño
Meta
Córdoba
Cauca
Magdalena
Cesar
Quindío
Sucre
Casanare
La Guajira
Caquetá
Putumayo
Chocó
Arauca
San Andrés
Guaviare
Amazonas
Guainía
Vichada
Vaupés
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
y Superintendencia de la
Economía Solidaria.
95
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Arauca
-4.7%
Antioquia Casanare
-6.3% 20.4%
Vaupés
26.5%
96
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
MAP 4.2
Departments
with the largest
and smallest
growth rate in
the numbers of
savings accounts
Bolívar
17.1%
Antioquia
0.1%
Cundinamarca
15.4%
Amazonas
15.9%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia Bogotá D.C.
and Superintendencia de la 3.7%
Economía Solidaria.
97
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Finally, over the last quarter of 2017, $436 The share of young adults (between 18 and
million transactions were made through sa- 25 years) and adults over 65 years was 4.0%.
vings accounts for a total amount of $1,287 When analyzing the number of circulating
trillion9 (Chart 4.8). Compared to the same pe- electronic savings accounts, there were 4.0
riod of 2016, the number of monetary transac- million accounts by the end of 2017, 579,838
tions made through savings accounts in the additional accounts as compared to 2016.
last quarter of 2017 went down by 4.0% and Considering that people can only have one
the transacted amount by 5.3% in real terms. electronic savings account in the financial
Specifically, withdrawals had the largest sha- system, the number of adults with this pro-
re on the number of transactions (37.5%) (al- duct (2.9 million) should be equal to the num-
most twice as deposits’, which accounted for ber of existing accounts (4.0 million)10.
16.7% of the total). Withdrawals were followed With regards to the activity levels of elec-
by payments, which had a share of 30.3%. tronic savings accounts, 1.8 million accounts
The average number of transactions was 16.7 had been used over the last six months, which
per active savings account, a reduction of 2.2 are 88,434 accounts less than in 2016. The
with regards to the last quarterquarterquarter activity level of these accounts, measured as
of 2016. Transfers (sent and received) contri- the ratio between the number of active ac-
buted the most to the total amount traded, counts over the total number of accounts in
with shares of 40.2% and 19.3%, respectively. the system, was 46% (Table 4.2). Although the
activity level of electronic savings accounts
was higher than that of traditional savings ac-
4.2. ELECTRONIC counts, it went down by 10 percentage points
compared to 2016.
SAVINGS ACCOUNTS Relative to the size of the adult population,
By the end of 2017, 2.9 million adults had at for every 100,000 adults there were 11,898
least one electronic savings account. This fi- electronic savings accounts (14.9% more than
gure increased by 145 thousand adults, or in 2016) and 5,473 active accounts (6.0% less
5.1%, compared to 2016. The difference be- than in 2016). The number of active accounts
tween the number of men and women with per 100,000 adults had also fallen between
some CAE is wide. By the end of the year, 2015 and 2016 by (-9%).
76.8% of adults with at least one electronic
savings account were women. This is becau-
se electronic savings account are used to pay
monetary incentives in light of the largest con-
ditional cash transfer program, Más Familias
en Acción, which focuses on women. 9. It refers to the information of the last quarter of 2017
The distribution by age range shows that 10. There is a difference of approximately one million which
50.0% of adults with an active electronic sa- is explained because financial institutions are not repor-
vings account were between 41 and 65 years ting the total number of people with this product to the
old, and 46.0% between 26 and 40 years old. central information systems.
98
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
0
59
7,
CHART 4.8 180,000,000 $600,000,000
57
3,
7
38
16
Transactions made
4,
8
,3
18
160,000,000
with traditional
$5
2
49
$500,000,000
savings accounts
4.
29
2.
140,000,000
13
120,000,000 $400,000,000
Number of transactions
Number of transactions
$2
7
0
49
80,000,000
40
52
,1
7,
8.
2
4
1
9
2,
51
,7
.2
09
07
8,
73
3
7
$2
,4
60,000,000 70 $200,000,000
$1
9 6
,9
43
47
,4
,0
98
41
18
,3
$1
40,000,000
,0
74
39
,2
28
$100,000,000
20,000,000
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia. $0
Deposits Payments Withdrawals Sent transfers Received
transfers
2016 2017
99
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
By the end of 2017, electronic savings accounts were concentrated in cities and urban agglome-
had a balance of $222,095 million, while active rates (49.6%), followed by intermediate munici-
electronic savings accounts had a balance of palities (24.9%) (Chart 4.10). Rural and scattered
$154,623 million. The real growth of these balan- rural municipalities, which concentrated 16.3%
ces was 118% for the total accounts and 192% and 9.0% of electronic savings accounts, had
for active accounts, relative to 2016. the greatest growth rate over the last year
In 2017, the number of women’s accounts (34.6% in rural municipalities and 37.9% in sca-
was 3.4 million and that of men 581,798, a di- ttered rural areas).
fference of 2.8 million accounts (Chart 4.9). In When analyzing the distribution of electronic
addition, women’s accounts contributed 85.5% savings accounts by department, it was found
to the total balance, reaching $189,975 million. that Antioquia (11.4%), Córdoba (6.5%) and Va-
Men’s accounts contributed 14.5% of total ba- lle del Cauca (6.3%) were the regions that regis-
lance, or $32,120 million. tered the greatest number of electronic savings
Relative to previous years, the number of accounts by the end 2017 (Chart 4.11). Antioquia
men’s electronic savings accounts grew faster and Córdoba have remained within the top three
than that of women’s (21.2% and 16.1%, respec- positions in this regard for the past two years. In
tively). Overall, balances of women’s electronic turn, the largest balances of the last three years
savings accounts increased by 133.5%, while were recorded in Antioquia and Bolivar, which
balances of men’s electronic savings accounts contributed 18% of the total balance in 2017.
grew by 93.2%. The departments with the highest activity levels
As it was the case with traditional savings ac- of 2017 were Vaupés, Amazonas and Guainía
counts, circulating electronic savings accounts (above 75%)
CHART 4.9
Distribution of the
581,798
14.5% number of electronic
savings accounts
by gender
CAE women
CAE men
85.5% 3,441,176
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
100
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
3
CHART 4.10
Number of CAE by
level of rurality 2.0 2.0
1.9 2
2015
2016
2
2017
Million accounts
1.0
1
0.9
0.8
0.7
0.6
0.5
1
0.4
0.3 0.3
Source:Superintendencia 0
Financiera de Colombia. Cities and urban Intermediate Rural Dispersed rural
agglomerations municipalities municipalities municipalities
CHART 4.11
Accounts and 250,000 100%
% of accumulated 60%
active CAE 150,000
50%
100,000 40%
30%
50,000 20%
10%
0 0%
Antioquia
Córdoba
Bolívar
Magdalena
Nariño
Cauca
Valle del Cauca
Santander
Huila
Cesar
Cundinamarca
Tolima
Sucre
Norte de Santander
Boyacá
Atlántico
La Guajira
Meta
Bogotá, D.C.
Chocó
Putumayo
Caquetá
Casanare
Caldas
Risaralda
Arauca
Quindío
Guaviare
Amazonas
San Andrés
Vichada
Guainía
Vaupés
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
101
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Atlántico
47.9% Guainía
470%
Bogotá D.C.
11.8%
Vaupés
716%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
and Superintendencia de la Huila
Economía Solidaria. 406%
102
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
MAP 4.4
Departments with
the largest and
smallest growth
of the number of
electronic savings
accounts
Guainía
199.8%
Atlántico
1.6%
Vaupés
212%
Quindío
1.6%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
Amazonas
and Superintendencia de la
253%
Economía Solidaria.
103
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
3,500,000
$300,000 CHART 4.12
Transactions made
2
4.
80
with CAE
3,
26
3,000,000
$250,000
Number
2,500,000 Amount
$200,000
2,000,000
1,500,000
$150,000
1,000,000
$100,000
500,000
.1
08
,2
20
7
8.
29
88
2.
08
1,
4.
Finally, three million financial transactions minant transaction, accounting for 92.3% of
were made using electronic savings accounts the total number of monetary transactions in
over the four quarter of 2017. Such transac- 2017. This figure is like the one reported in
tions amounted to a total of $285,907 mi- 2016, which reached 95.1%.
llion. For both cases, there was a reduction
compared to 2016 (8.0% and 6.6%11, res-
pectively). Payments continued to be the do- 11. Measured in real terms.
104
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
105
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
1,400,000
800,000
583,411
600,000 547,985 Active CATS
Total CATS
400,000
279,342
200,000
Source: Superintendencia
0 Financiera de Colombia
2016 2017
106
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
CHART 4.14
Distribution of
CATS
554,371 43.2%
CATS men
CATS women
56.8% 725,922
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
Transactions made
3
27
4,
22
through CATS
7
54
1,
98
1,000,000
$200,000
800,000
Number $150,000
Amount
63
9
5,
600,000
57
$100,000
39
4
05
0,
,4
38
85
400,000
76
,9
12
70
,9
67
96 760
51
0,
,
44 275
28
$50,000
,3
200,000
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia 0 $0
Deposits Payments Withdrawals Sent transfers Received
transfers
107
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
4.4. ELECTRONIC
DEPOSITS
By the end of 2017, 4.1 million adults had at
least one electronic deposit and 3.9 million
were active. Regarding the gender distribu-
tion, 56.0% of adults with an active electro-
nic deposit were women. Likewise, 45.9% of
adults with active electronic deposits were be-
tween 26 and 40 years old (Chart 4.16). Adults
aged 40 and over had a share of 33.8% on
the total number of adults with active electro-
nic deposits, while youth between 18 and 25
years old had a share of 16.9%.
Alternatively, the number of electronic de-
posits by the end of 2017 was 4.1 million (Ta-
ble 4.3), while the number of active electronic
deposits was 1.8 million, or 45.0% of the to-
tal13. The activity levels of electronic deposits
went from 41.6% to 45.0%, a 3.4 percentage
points increase between 2016 and 2017.
Compared to 2016, the number of electro-
nic deposits grew by 30.1%. Such increase
may be partially influenced by the adjustments
in the distribution of participants in Más Fa-
milias en Acción and Jóvenes en Acción, as
well as participants in the humanitarian aid
programs of Unidad de Víctimas.
In relation to the size of the adult popula-
tion in the country (33.8 million), there were
12,172 electronic deposits per 100,000 adults
and 5,473 active electronic deposits per
100,000 adults. These figures increased by
28.0% and 38.4%, respectively.
108
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
Number of people
1,800,000
with DE by age
1,600,000
1,334,464
1,400,000
1,221,952
18 to 25 1,200,000
26 to 40
963,528
1,000,000
41 to 65
Over 65
800,000
668,323
600,000
384,799
400,000
2016 2017
DE Simplified Procedures DE
Number of
1,315,544 1,850,559 1,300,426 1,813,111
active DE
Amount
$820,698 $1,322,160 $820,851 $1,316,398
(millions)
109
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
3,000,000
CHART 4.17
2,783,060
Distribution of DE
by gender
2,500,000
2,000,000
DE women
1,593,151 1,570,441 DE men
1,500,000
1,332,709
1,000,000
500,000
Source: Superintendencia
0
Financiera de Colombia
2016 2017
3,000,000 700,000
CHART 4.18
63 69
Transactions made
3
0
15
11
2, 2,6
4,
8,
62
62
with DE
2,
600,000
4
53
2,500,000
6,
55
500,000
2,000,000
Transacted amount (in million)
Number of transactions
Number of transactions
400,000
Transacted amount (in million)
1,500,000
300,000
1,000,000
69
200,000
1,
18
6
9
04
97
5,
,
46
500,000
27
9
100,000
73
,4
4, 350
41
Source: Superintendencia
,
77
6
20
0 0 Financiera de Colombia
Deposits Payments Withdrawals Sent transfers Received
transfers
110
CHAPTER 4 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF DEPOSIT PRODUCTS
111
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
5
FINANCIAL
INCLUSION REPORT 2017
112
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
5.
ACCESS AND
USAGE OF CREDIT
PRODUCTS
A
ccess to credit products allows indi- of gross loan portfolios and number of ope-
viduals and households to get the ne- rations of credit institutions overseen by the
cessary means to meet their needs Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia1,
and respond to emergencies, as well as to financial credit unions overseen by the Su-
achieve their financial goals. This access also perintendencia de la Economía Solidaria, and
allows companies to adequately finance their NGOs specialized in microfinance.
activities at consumer loans stage of their bu-
siness life cycle.
This chapter conduct an analysis of ac- 1. Credit institutions are composed of banks, financing com-
cess and use, as well as the recent evolution panies, Financial corporations and financial credit unions.
113
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
1 The number of adults with consumer loans 2 The highest number of the various loans
product saw a positive evolution over the were mostly taken out by adults between the
past year for all types, except for mortgages. ages of 41 and 65, and there was an equal
share for both men and women.
Microcredits showed the highest increase.
3 The upward trend in the gross loan 4 The consumer loans portfolio showed a
portfolio and number of operations resulted positive evolution driven by payroll loans,
from the consumer loans, mortgages and all-purpose loans and credit cards, which
microcredit types. contribute most of the balance.
9% 6% 4%
All-purpose Payroll
423 2016 12 2016 loans
Credit
loans card
5
Consumer
Consumer loans number of operations continued loans number of
2016 2017
their upward trend driven by banks, financing operation (millons) 9.6 10.8
companies and overseens by SES.
114
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
6 7
The mortgages portfolio showed a favorable Even if banks made most mortgages number
behavior driven by mortgages and housing of operations at all rurality levels, financial
leasing - social interest housing (VIS, credit unions reached a significant share on
acronym in Spanish) in Real Value Unit (UVR, rural and dispersed rural municipalities.
acronym in Spanish), VIS in Colombian By gender, over half of the number of
Pesos, and no-VIS in Colombian Pesos. operations were made to men.
Número de desembolsos de
Mortagages 2�16 2�17
portafolio (trillion) vivienda (miles)
56 63
2�16 2�17 53%
183 186.3 Men
V I S 8% V I S 6% N O V I S 8% 91%
Banks
UVR $ $
92%
8 94% Cities Banks
The favorable behavior seen in the microcredit and urban
gross loan portfolio was based on the agglomerations 21%
dynamics of microcredits higher than 25 credit unions
0.9%
SMMLV (current legal minimum monthly wage, overseen by SES
Rural
in Spanish)2 and up to 120 SMMLV, although 12%
they held a third of the total balance. 0.2% Financial credit
Rurales dispersed unionsoverseen by SES
Cartera de 2�16 2�17
microcrédito (billones) 13,6 14,4
9
Just like other types, microcredit number of
11% operations increased in the number of transactions
compared to the preceding year. This evolution was
More than or equal
34% to 25 SMMLV
mostly driven by banks and NGOs specialized
in microfinance at all rurality levels in the
municipalities of the country.
10
Microcredit number of operations had a
greater share on several areas of the country At national level, women participated with over
than other types, being mostly made in half of the microcredit number of operations
rural and dispersed rural municipalities both in number and amount.
compared to other types.
Number of microcredit
Most departments had a greater number
disbursements (million) 2�16 2�17
of number of operations made in amounts 2.2
2.16
between 4 and 10 SMMLV.
58% 26%
Cities and urban intermediate
agglomerations municipalities 65% 56%
Banks Women
10% 6%
Rural Rural 28% 1%
dispersed NGO Companies
115
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
5.1 GENERAL On the other hand, by late 2017, the age dis-
tribution of adults with credit products had a
ANALYSIS similar trend to the preceding year. In parti-
cular, across all types of loans, it was found
Adults and companies with that adults between the ages of 41 and 65 had
credit products the largest share on the total number of adults
with credit products, followed by adults be-
In 2017, the number of adults with credit pro- tween the ages of 26 and 40 (Table 5.1).
ducts had a positive evolution in most types, Finally, in 2017, the number of companies
in particular with regards to the number of with credit products increased for all types
adults with microcredits, which increased by of loans. The positive trend in the number of
8% between 2016 and 2017. The gender dis- companies with consumer loans is particular-
tribution marginally favors marginally men, ex- ly high, which increased by 12.7% between
cept for microcredits (Chart 5.1). 2016 and 2017 (Chart 5.2).
7.592.245 7.595.037 1.116.997 1.095.896 3.028.242 3.281.806 8.842.532 9.214.480 CHART 5.1
Number of adults
with loans by type
and gender
Women
Men
116
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
TABLE 5.1. Distribution of the number of adults with products by age (2017)
range
2016 2017 2016 2017 2016 2017 2016 2017
117
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHART 5.2
100 Evolution of
94.6
the number of
91.1
companies with
90
82.1
83.9
82.6
credit products
(millions)
77.3
80
2014
2015
70 65.9
2016
61.1
2017
60
Thousand
50
40
30
20
13.2 14.6
10.5
9.2
10 Source: TransUnion
– Banca de las
Oportunidades
calculations.
0
Gross loan portfolio reached $458 trillion in 2017, The higher number of adults with credit pro-
and showed a real annual increase of 4.1%, dri- ducts is consistent with the increase in the
ven by consumer loans, mortgages and micro- number of operations. Including credit card
credits. In 2017, credit institutions contributed the operations, 13.2 trillion loans were disbursed,
most (91%) to the total gross portfolio. Consumer for a total amount of $105.7 trilllion; this be-
loans, mortgages and microcredits accounted for havior was mostly driven by consumer loans
48% of gross loan portfolio (Chart 5.3). and mortgages (Chart 5.4).
118
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
CHART 5.3
Gross loan portfolio 458
of credit institutions,
financial credit unions
overssen by SES, and
11.8%
NGOs specialized in Consumer
microfinance (trillion)
1%
8.0%
4.
Mortgage
423
2.1%
Microcredits
2016 2017
Banks
Financial credit unions 4%
overseen by SFC
Financial credit unions
overseen by SES 31%
Financing Companies
52%
Fondo Nacional del Ahorro
91%
NGOs specialized in microfinance 14%
3%
Commercial
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia, Consumer
Superintendencia de la Economía Mortgage
Solidaria, and NGOs specialized
Microcredits
in microfinance.
119
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Consumer loans, both in terms of the number of rations, and 71% of the total disbursed amount.
operations and disbursed amount, had the lar- Below is the individual characterization of con-
gest share, with 80% of the total number of ope- sumer loans, mortgages and microcredits.
13.2 105.7
CHART 5.4
Number of
operations and
disbursed amount
(consumer loans,
mortgages and
microcredit)
(Disbursed
amounts growth
rates in real terms)
12% 11%
Consumer Consumer
2% 9%
Mortgage Mortgage
12.0
92.5
2% 1%
Microcredits Microcredits
2016
2017
3. The total number of adults with credit cards have their cards with credit institutions.
120
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
8%
18%
2% 20%
80% 71%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de la
Economía Solidaria, and NGOs
specialized in microfinance.
5.2 ANALYSIS
consumer loans held them with credit insti-
BY TYPED tutions (7.6 million)3.
The share of men and women with credit
CONSUMER LOANS cards was the same. Out of the 9.2 million
adults with credit cards, 51% were men and
Adults and companies with 49% women. Similarly, out of the 8.0 million
consumer loans adults with consumer loans, 54% were men
and 46% women.
LCredit products with the highest penetra- In 2017, the age distribution of adults with
tion among Colombians are credit cards and credit cards or consumer loans showed that
consumer loans. By the end of 2017, 9.2 mi- most adults with credit cards and consumer
llion adults had at least one credit card, and loans were between the ages of 41 and 65, for
8.0 million adults had consumer loans. Be- a share of 45% and 44%, respectively, followed
tween 2016 and 2017, the number of adults by adults between the ages of 26 and 40, with
with credit cards and consumer loans in- a 38% share for credit cards, and a 40% share
creased by 372,000 or 4%, and by 383,000 for consumer loans. This distribution remained
adults or 5%, respectively. Most adults with the same between 2016 and 2017.
121
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
122
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
%
.8
11
Banks 121
Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC
Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC
Financing Companies 2016 2017
12%
5%
Share by type
of institution
82%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de la
Economía Solidaria, and NGOs
specialized in microfinance.
In addition, by the end of 2017, 95,000 com- with 82%, followed by financial credit unions
panies had consumer loans, and 91,000 overseen by SES with 12%, and financing
had at least one credit card. This repre- companies with 5% (Chart 5.5).
sents an increase of 10.6,000 companies The analysis by product shows that in 2017
(12%) for consumer loans, and an increase 36% of the total consumer loans gross port-
of 8,500 companies or 10%, between 2016 folio corresponded to payroll loans, followed
and 2017. by all-purpose loans and credit cards; this dis-
tribution has remained the same during the
Gross loan portfolio last two years (Chart 5.6). Nonetheless, these
products’ gross loan portfolio showed a lower
In 2017, total gross loan portfolio rea- real increase than others with a smaller sha-
ched $141 trillion (including financial credit re on the total balance (e.g., small consumer
unions overseen by SES), for a real increa- loans). Although this product contributed less
se of 11.8% relative to 2016. Out of this to- than 1% to the total consumer loans portfolio,
tal, banks contributed most of the balance, 2017 data shows a growing dynamic.
123
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHART 5.6
Share by financial product
Consumer loans
on the consumer loans
gross portfolio
gross portfolio
by product
1 2 3 4 5 6
36% 24% 22% 11% 5% 2%
Payroll Loan Unrestricted Credit Vehicle Revolving Other
Investment cards credit consumer
loans
Low-amount 391%
consumer loans
All-purpose 9%
investment
Payroll Loan 6%
Credit cards 4%
Employees 2%
Vehicle 1%
124
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
institution in the
consumer loans gross
portfolio by product
96.6% 95.2%
Banks
Financing Companies
11.7% 14.4%
88.2% 85.6%
2.8% 1.6%
96.7% 98.4%
2.9%
100%
96.8%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia. Employees Low-amount consumer loans
125
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
By type of institution, banks contributed most der, by the end of 2017, 51% of the total
to the gross loan portfolio across all credit consumer loan operations were made to
products. However, as to auto loans and cre- women (Chart 5.7).
dit card gross loan portfolios, financing com- By institution, banks contributed 66% of
panies also stood out, with shares of 14% and the total number of operations and 76% of the
12%, respectively. total disbursed amount, followed by financial
credit unions overseen by SES, with a share
Number of operations of 30% on the number of operations and 20%
on the disbursed amount. This structure chan-
In 2017, 10.8 million consumer loan ope- ged as compared to 2016, when banks had a
rations were made for an amount of $76.2 75% share on the total number of operations
trillion, which corresponded to 12% in the and 82% in the disbursed amount, mostly
number of operations and 11% in the dis- due to a 1% drop in the number of number of
bursed amount compared to 2016. By gen- operations made by these institutions and a
20%
30% 58% 55%
3% Banks
66% 1% 76% 3%
2% Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC
Financing Companies
2016 2017
Greater share
Number (million) 9.6 10.8 51% for women
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
Note: Information by gender is only available for the fourth quarter of 2017 and for credit and Superintendencia de la
institutions overseen by the Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia. Economía Solidaria.
126
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
58% increase among financial credit unions Furthermore, just like in 2016, most opera-
overseen by SES in terms of the number of tions were made in cities and urban agglome-
operations and a real increase of 55% in the rations, with a share of 97% on the number
disbursed amount. of operations, and 94.6% on the disbursed
In addition, 277 million purchases were made amount. Nonetheless, the increase in the sha-
with credit cards that amounted $69 trillion. This re on the number of operations of intermediate
represents a 9% increase in the number of ope- and rural municipalities and on the disbursed
rations, and a real increase of 6% in amounts amount of rural and dispersed rural municipa-
disbursed, as compared to 2016 (Chart 5.8). lities are to be highlighted (Chart 5.9).
CHART 5.8
Purchases with credit 2016 2017
cards (including
individual and
Number (million) 254 277
corporate cards)
Amount (trillion) 63 69
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
Number of
CHART 5.9 disbursements Amount disbursed
Distribution of 2016 2017 2016 2017
consumer loans
operations and Cities and urban
agglomerations 98.2% 97.0% 95.2% 94.6%
disbursements
by rurality
Intermediate 1.4% 2.4% 3.5% 4.0%
municipalities
Rural
municipalities 0.3% 0.4% 1.1% 1.1%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia Dispersed 0.1% 0.1% 0.2% 0.3%
and Superintendencia de la rural
Economía Solidaria.
127
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
During the last year, there was a widespread increased by 86%. Regarding the disbursed
increase in the number of operations across amount, there were increases of 7% and 11%
all rurality levels, particularly in the number of in intermediate and rural municipalities, res-
operations made in rural municipalities, which pectively (Chart 5.10).
Number of disbursements
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
CHART 5.10
Cities and urban
agglomerations
51% 44% 4% Distribution of
consumer loans
Intermediate 64% 12% 22%
municipalities operations and
Rural municipalities 59% 39% disbursements by
type of institution
Dispersed rural 75% 23%
and rurality
2016
Amount disbursed
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
2016
128
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
In 2017, across all rurality levels, banks con- bursed amount, men’s share was above
centrated the largest number of operations 55% (Chart 5.11).
and disbursed amounts. However, financial By region, in 2017, 67% of consumer loans
credit unions overseen by SES share on rural operations were made in three departments.
and dispersed rural municipalities continued Specifically, 38% loans were disbursed in Bo-
to stand out among others, which is seen in gotá, D.C.; 20% in Antioquia; and 9% in Valle
the increase in their share between 2016 and del Cauca.
2017 in terms of disbursed amount. By gender, by the end of 2017, in 22 of the
As to the gender distribution of clients 33 departments in the country (including Bo-
receiving consumer loans, by late 2017, gotá, D.C.), men had a higher share on the
women’s share was higher than men’s only number of operations (Map 5.1). It is worth
in terms of the number of operations in ci- highlighting that, by the end of 2017, the gen-
ties and urban agglomerations, with 51% der distribution of Bogotá, D.C., Cesar, Sucre,
of the total. Regarding the other rurality le- Valle del Cauca and Vaupés had reverted as
vels, both in terms of operations and dis- compared to 2016 (Map 5.1).
Number of
disbusements Amount disbursed
CHART 5.11
2016 2017 2016 2017
Distribution of
consumer loans
Cities and urban
operations and agglomerations
disbursements by 51% 51% 60% 58%
Dispersed
rural
54% 55% 60% 63%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
and Superintendencia de la Note: Information by gender is only available for the fourth quarter of 2017 for credit
Economía Solidaria. institutions overseen by the Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia.
129
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
>to 2% and up to 4%
>to 4% and up to 10%
Concentration
of the number of
consumer loans
operations by
department
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
and Superintendencia de la
Economía Solidaria.
130
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
Greater share
for women
Greater share
for men
Concentration
of the number of
operations
by department
and gender
131
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
By the end of 2017, nearly 1.09 million adults Gross loan portfolio
had mortgages. Between 2016 and 2017, Total gross loan portfolio by the end of
this number dropped by 21,000 adults, that 2017 amounted $63 trillion, for an increase
is, 1.9%. Additionally, 52% of adults with of 8.0% compared to 2016. Out of this total,
mortgages were men. By age range, 95% of banks’ share reached 87.5% (Chart 5.12).
adults with this credit product were between When analyzing the different mortgages
26 and 65 years old. On the other hand, products, during 2017, the highest share
Banks
56
8%
87.5%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de la
Economía Solidaria, and NGOs
specialized in microfinance.
132
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
was observed in the mortgages and so- employee’s social interest housing loans, and
cial interest housing leasing in Real Value of 8% in the gross loan portfolio of mortga-
Units (UVR, for its Spanish acronym), with ges and non-social interest housing leasing
65% of the balance, followed by mortga- in Real Value Units.
ges and Social Interest Housing (VIS, for As for almost all products in the mortgage
its Spanish acronym) leasing in Colombian category, banks contributed to most of the
Pesos, with a share of 15%, and mortga- gross loan portfolio. However, as to loans and
ges and non-social interest housing leasing social interest housing leasing in Real Value
in Real Value Units, with a share of 10% Units and non-social interest housing leasing
(Chart 5.13). in Real Value Units, the Fondo Nacional del
Between 2016 and 2017, there was a 20% Ahorro concentrated 35% and 38% of their
real increase in the gross loan portfolio of gross loan portfolio, respectively.
133
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
1 2 3 4 5
Mortgage and housing Mortgage and housing Mortgage and housing Mortgage and housing
Others
leasing non-VIS Colombian leasing VIS Colombian leasing VIS UVR leasing non-VIS UVR
Pesos Pesos
Note: The “Other” category in the top chart includes: employees’ non-social interest housing loans, employees’ social
interest housing loans, non-social interest housing payroll loans, and social interest housing payroll loans.
Employee loan
housing non-VIS 6%
134
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
Distribution of the mortgages gross loan portfolio by product and type of institution
9%
35%
Mortgage
Mortgage and and housing
housing leasing leasing VIS
VIS UVR Colombian
Pesos
61% 88%
3%
38%
62%
2%
98%
3% 4%
96%
97%
Financial credit
Banks Financing Companies union overseen by Fondo Nacional del Ahorro
SFC
135
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
3% 9% Banks
Financial credit unions
81% 91% overseen by SFC
Financial credit unions
overseen by SES
39% 29% Financing Companies
2016 2017
Numbers (thousands) 183 186.3 53%
Greater share
for men
Amount (millions) 18,9 21.4 58%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
Note: Information by gender is only available for the fourth quarter of 2017 for credit and Superintendencia de la
institutions overseen by the Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia. Economía Solidaria.
136
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
Nacional del Ahorro and 27% for financial and urban agglomerations, intermediate and
credit unions. dispersed rural municipalities (Chart 5.15).
With regards to the distribution of mortgages By type of institution, just like in the case of
operations by rurality, even if most operations consumer loans, banks reported a higher sha-
were made in cities and urban agglomerations, re compared to other types of institutions both
in 2017 the percent contribution of both the in the number of operations and in disbursed
number of operations and disbursed amount in amount. Nevertheless, in rural and dispersed
intermediate municipalities increased. rural municipalities, the share of other institu-
In 2017, the number of mortgages ope- tions such as financial credit unions have in-
rations increased across all rurality levels, creased by the end of 2017. The former had a
particularly those made in intermediate mu- 21% share on rural municipalities and 12% in
nicipalities, which experienced a growth rate dispersed rural municipalities in terms of the
of 81%. Disbursed amount increased in cities total of number of operations (Chart 5.16).
Intermediate
2.9% 5.0% 2.3% 3.0%
municipalities
137
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Number of disbursements
2016
Banks
Disbursed amount
0% 50% 100%
Intermediate 89% 6%
Rural 93% 4%
2016
Intermediate 93% 4%
50%
Source: Superintendencia
Rural 89% 8%
31% Financiera de Colombia
and Superintendencia de
Dispersed rural 93% 1% la Economía Solidaria.
18%
2017
Real growth rate of
the amount of
disbursements for
rurality
138
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
By late 2017, the distribution of mortgages made in three departments: 35% in Bogotá,
operations by gender shows that most of the- D.C.; 14% in Antioquia; and 11% in Valle del
se were made to men in cities and rural munici- Cauca. The distribution of mortgages favo-
palities, whereas in intermediate and dispersed red men in 24 of all 33 departments in Co-
rural municipalities loans made to women pre- lombia (including Bogotá, D.C.). By the end
vailed. Nonetheless, across all rurality levels, of 2017, the gender distribution of Bolivar,
amounts disbursed were higher among men Cauca, La Guajira, Norte de Santander, Su-
for both 2016 and 2017 (Chart 5.17). cre, Putumayo and Amazonas had reverted
The distribution of mortgages operations relative to 2016 (Map 5.2).
by department shows that most of them were
Intermediate
Rural
Dispersed
rural
52% 54% 56% 51%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
and Superintendencia de la Note: Information by gender is only available for the fourth quarter of 2017 for credit
Economía Solidaria. institutions overseen by the Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia.
139
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
>to 2% and up to 4%
Concentration
of the number
of mortgages
operations by
department
140
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
Without disbursements
Concentration
of the number
of operations
by department
and gender
141
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
By the end of 2017, almost 3.3 million adults Gross loan portfolio
had microcredits. This figure increased by
254,000 adults, or 8% compared to 2016. By Total gross loan portfolio reached $14.4 trillion by
type of institution, it was found that 2.6 mi- the end of 2017 (including financial credit unions
llion adults had microcredits with credit ins- overseen by SES and NGOs specialized in micro-
titutions, 801,000 with NGOs specialized in finance). Between 2016 and 2017, this amount
microfinance, and 155,000 with financial cre- increased by 2.1% in real terms (Chart 5.18).
dit unions overseen by Superintendencia de Credit institutions overseen by the Superin-
la Economía Solidaria4. tendencia Financiera de Colombia concentrated
The distribution of these 3.3 million adults 84% of the total microcredit gross loan portfo-
by gender is the same for men and women lio, NGOs specialized in microfinance 10% and
(50% each). Just like other types of credit pro- financial credit unions overseen by SES 6%.
ducts, most adults with microcredits were be-
tween 41 and 65 years old, a share of 60%,
followed by those between the ages of 26 and 4. It is to consider that this data did not include individuals
40, with a share of 33%. with business establishments.
13.6
2016 2017
142
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
Share by
institution in the
microcredit gross
loan portfolio
10%
Banks
6%
Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC
Financial credit unions
overseen by SES
Financing Companies
66%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de la Economía
Solidaria, and NGOs specialized
97% Banks
in microfinance.
143
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
11%
1%
19%
28%
8%
13%
3%
70% Banks
6% 65%
Financial credit unions
overseen by SFC
3%
2% Financial credit unions
overseen by SES
Financing
Companies
Distribution of microcredit operations and disbursed amount nationally and by gender
NGOs
2016 2017
Greater share
Numbers (thousands) 2.16 2.2 56% 1% for women
Source: Superintendencia
Amount (millions) 7.8 8 49% 6% Companies' share
Financiera de Colombia,
Superintendencia de
la Economía Solidaria,
Note: Information by gender is only available for the fourth quarter of 2017 for credit and NGOs specialized in
institutions overseen by the Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia. microfinance.
144
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
crocredits, and 24% were 31 to 365-days rural and dispersed rural municipalities com-
term microcredits. As to the size of number pared to other types because, even if 58% of
of operations, just like in 2016, 30% corres- the number of operations and of the disbursed
ponded to disbursements equal to or higher amount were found in cities and urban agglo-
than 4 minimum wages and lower than 10 merations, 16% of the number of operations
minimum wages (Chart 5.20). and 20% of the disbursed amount correspon-
The distribution by rurality level of micro- ded to rural and dispersed rural municipali-
credit operations showed a greater share on ties. It is found that, compared to 2016, there
CHART 5.20
Microcredit
operations by 5%
Share on the number of
term and size 24%
microcredit operations
by institutions overseen
by the Superintendencia
71%
From 31 to 365 days Financiera de Colombia by
From 366 to 1.095 days term (2017)
From 1.096 to 1.825 days
More than 1.825 days
4% 15%
Less than 1 SMMLV 15% Share on the number of
From 1 to < 2 SMMLV microcredit operations
From 2 to < 3 SMMLV 16% by institutions overseen
From 3 to < 4 SMMLV by the Superintendencia
30% Financiera de Colombia by
From 4 to < 10 SMMLV
16%
From 10 to < 25 SMMLV disbursement size (2017)
5%
> 25 SMMLV to < 120 SMMLV
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
145
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
was an increase in the share on the number channeled by banks and NGOs specialized
of operations in intermediate municipalities in microfinance across all rurality levels. Si-
and in the disbursed amount in dispersed ru- milarly to 2016, the share of NGOs spe-
ral municipalities (Chart 5.21). cialized in microfinance on the number of
Both the number of operations and the operations in rural and dispersed rural mu-
disbursed amount increased across all ru- nicipalities was 37%, and on the disbursed
rality levels. Just like in 2016, the number of amount in dispersed rural municipalities of
operations and the disbursed amount were 35% (Chart 5.22).
Number Amount
CHART 5.21
2016 2017 2016 2017
Share on
microcredit
operations by
59% 58% 58% 58% rurality
Cities and
agglomerations
Intermediate
Rural
Source: Superintendencia
6% 6% 7% 8%
Financiera de Colombia,
Dispersed rural
Superintendencia de
la Economía Solidaria,
and NGOs specialized in
microfinance.
146
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
Number of operations
CHART 5.22
Distribution of 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
Cities and
the number 66% 28% agglomerations
of microcredit
operations and 65% 29% Intermediate
disbursed amount
by type of institution 47% 41% Rural
and rurality
57% 36% Dispersed rural
Banks 2016
NGO
59% 37% Rural
1%
Disbursed amount
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100%
2016
147
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
148
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
Just like in 2016, in 2017 women had the hi- Additionally, in 29 of all 33 departments (inclu-
ghest share on the number operations (61%) ding Bogotá, D.C.) women’s share on the total
and disbursed amount (53%) in cities and ru- number of operations was greater than that of
ral agglomerations. Regarding the evolution of men. Comparatively, by the end of 2016, mi-
businesses, even though they concentrated crocredit operations to women were higher in
between 1% and 3% of total operations, they all departments but Norte de Santander.
contributed to 10% of the disbursed amount in In 2017, there was a higher concentration
rural and dispersed rural municipalities during of microcredits for disbursed amounts be-
the last two years (Chart 5.23). tween 4 minimum wages and 10 minimum
Department wise, the distribution of the wages among 24 of all 33 Colombian depart-
number of microcredit operations exhibited ments (including Bogotá, D.C.) (Map 5.4).
homogeneous trend compared to other cre- Finally, by the end of 2017, the five depart-
dit products. Particularly, the five departments ments accounting for the highest share on total
concentrated 39.3% of total operations: 9.8% microcredit operations geared toward busines-
in Antioquia; 8% in Valle del Cauca; 7.8% in ses were as follows: Antioquia (18.5%); Bogo-
Santander; 7.2 % in Nariño; and 6.5% in Bo- tá, D.C. (9.6%); Boyaca (9.6%); Cundinamarca
gotá, D.C. (Map 5.3). (8.2%); and Valle del Cauca (6%) (Map 5.4).
rurality level
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia, 54% 3% 53% 3% 53% 10% 53% 10%
Dispersed rural
Superintendencia de
la Economía Solidaria,
and NGOs specialized in Note: Information by gender and companies is only available for the fourth quarter of 2017
microfinance. for credit institutions overseen by the Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia.
149
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
150
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
Distribution of the
number of operations by
department and gender
151
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Highest share by
disbursement size
by department
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
152
CHAPTER 5 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF CREDIT PRODUCTS
From 0 to 0.5%
>to 2% and up to 4%
>to 4% and up to 6%
Concentration of the
number of microcredit
operations to companies
by department
153
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
6
FINANCIAL
INCLUSION REPORT 2017
154
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
6.
ACCESS AND
USAGE
OF INSURANCE
I
nsurance plays a significant role in fi- Vision 2025, a strategy developed at the Su-
nancial inclusion strategies as they ena- perintendencia Financiera de Colombia, esta-
ble families to mitigate external shocks, blishes inclusion, reliability, competitiveness
smoothen consumption, protect savings and and sustainability principles aimed at the con-
improve management of expenses related to solidation of a comprehensive insurance mar-
uncertain events such as medical emergen- ket. As an initial measure, it sought to diversify
cies, decease, theft or natural disasters. Gi- mass- and micro-insurance commercialization
ven its relevance, the insurance sector has channels, so they would contemplate sim-
fostered not only the creation of products plified and low-cost transactional channels,
accessible and affordable to low-income such as the use of insurance networks and
segments of the population, but it has also correspondents. Furthermore, it promoted
designed innovative products that respond the design of simple and expedite products in
to the specific needs of clients. terms of subscription and payment of claims,
155
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
by allowing products meeting the criteria of to the ninth part of 1 SMMLV1. The chapter
simplicity, universality and standardization, analyzes the performance of the Colombian
to be commercialized through correspon- insurance industry as a relevant component
dents. Lastly, it enabled the commercializa- for financial inclusion, by identifying advance-
tion of mass products by eliminating some ments, opportunities and challenges per type
client-characterization obligations to insuran- of insurance, policies and commercialization
ce companies, for insured amounts below 135 channels. It presents main sector figures, an
minimum monthly legal salaries (SMMLV - for overview of the Colombian insurance market
its Spanish acronym) and a maximum bi-mon- and relevant information on fostering insuran-
thly premium payment of less than or equal ce for inclusions.
The percent increase in the number of insurance policies related to financial in-
clusion (onwards, insurance for inclusion)3 is 14%:
Personal Insurance 17% and General Insurance 6%.
1 These dispositions are published in Decreto 034 of 2015 and the Circulares Externas 049, 034 and 050 of 2015 of the
Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia.
2 It relates to revenues on the sale of insurances carried, accounting for annulments and cancellations and including coinsurance.
3. Classification of policies for financial inclusion survey of the SFC - Circular letter 91 of 2017:
- Personal Insurance: Funeral expenses, Accidents, Group Voluntary Life, Group Debtors Life Insurance, Individual Life In-
surance, Periodic Financial Benefits and Unemployment.
- General Insurances: Fire, Earthquake, Theft, Home and Agroindustry.
156
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
Women represent 44% of the total number of insurance policies for financial
inclusion in the system: Personal Insurance 48% and General Insurance 17%.
4. Issued premiums as a proportion of total population as of December 2017 Source of Data: DANE
5. The claims ratio is the percentage of claims costs incurred in relation to the premiums earned.
6. The number of accrued cancellations as a proportion of the number of effective accrued policies enables knowing the
business index that complete coverage before their expiration date.
7. Objection refers to the no-payment of claims on the basis of absence of responsibility.
157
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
1 The accrued total value of issued premiums 2 Within the segment of insurance for
of insurance policies for financial inclusion inclusion, 29.7% of policyholders paid
reached $8 trillion, with a 31.3% share on a monthly premium of less than $20,000.
total production of the insured sector. This The most affordable insurance policies were
represents a 9.5% annually in real terms increase funeral expenses, personal accidents,
and 14% nominal annual increase, which is 2 Periodical Economic Benefits (BEPS, for
percentage points below the industry growth its Spanish acronym), unemployment, theft
levels of 2016.frente al 2016. and payment protection insurance.
9.5%
29.7%
2�17
28.0%
31%
2�16
2�16 2�17
3 The use of networks of credit institutions 4 In the market of insurance for inclusion,
overseen by the Superintendencia Financiera the number of policyholders acquiring
de Colombia, was the most representative insurance policies different from
distribution channel for the commercialization payment protection or mandatory
of insurances in Colombia, representing policies increased. These correspond
37.9% of total policyholders, followed by to voluntary insurances related to theft,
individual brokers (23.1%) and insurance personal accidents and unemployment.
intermediaries (17.3%). The channels
experienced the fastest growth rate of Percent share by
policyholders were public utility companies type of insurance
(194%) and electronic mediums, mobile 5.2%
devices and Internet (66%). 58.7%
20.8% 12.8%
66%
16.5% 5.9%
2 1 3 Electronic
channels,
mobile
Individual Commercialization Insurances devices and 2�16 2�17 2�16 2�17
brokers of insurances intermediaries Internet Personal accidents Unemployment
158
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
5 The share of women with access to insurance 6 The share of people using formal financial
policies for inclusion increased by 2.2 pp, insurance services increased by 2.3 pp.
vis-à-vis the previous year. Likewise, in the between 2016 and 2017. This trend is
case of policies covering fire damages, theft, also seen in rural areas.
home property damage and unemployment, as well
payment protection insurance policies, there was an
increase in women’s share in the microfinance Rural areas
institutions and networks channels. participation
44.2% 15.3%
42.0% 11.0%
51% 50%
13.5%
11.2%
25% 24%
159
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
160
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
3.0%
Individuals
1.0%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
and Fundación Mapfre 0.0%
$600,000
CHART 6.2
Historical insurance $530,386
$497,594
density11
$448,986
Total industry $400,242
$397,184
$400,000
Individuals
General
$200,000
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
$0
and Fundación Mapfre
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
161
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHART 6.3
Historical Result
9.2% 9.3%
Technical result /
6.8%
accrued premiums
5.6%
Result for the year /
accrued premiums 3.0%
-9.1%
-11.3% -11.6%
-11.9%
-14.0%
Source: Superintendencia
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
Financiera de Colombia
ROA
2.7%
2.5%
2.1%
6.0%
1.4%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
2013 2014 2015 2016 2017
162
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
163
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHART 6.5
69% Share of issued
premiums for
31% financial inclusion
27%
Other insurance
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
17%
16%
CHART 6.6
14% Growth rate of
premiums for
11% financial inclusion
9%
8%
7%
6% 2016
2017
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
Increase in insurance for General insurance for Total insurance for financial
Total insurance industry
financial inclusion financial inclusion inclusion
164
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
Personal insurance
CHART 6.7
6.5% 7.8% Unemployment
Distribution of
issued premiums for 0.2% 0.3%
Periodic economic
benefits
financial inclusion,
17.2% 15.9% Individual life
per policy type
33.7% 34.8% Group life - debtors
Group payment
22.2% 22.9% protection insurance
2017
0.6% 0.6% Funeral expenses
General insurances
2016
14.9% 16.6% Theft
2017
165
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
The value of insurance premiums is one of the previous year. The use of networks became
most important components to incentivize sec- the most representative distribution channel
tor's inclusion, as it may be an access barrier for for the commercialization of insurances in
financial services. During 2017, 29.7% of total is- Colombia having 37.9% of total policyhol-
sued premiums in products related to insurances ders, followed by individual brokers (23.1%)
for inclusion entailed a monthly average premium and insurance intermediaries (17.3%) Chan-
of less than $20,000 (28% in 2016). The most ac- nels experiencing greater growth of poli-
cessible policies were funeral expenses, personal cyholders were public utility companies
accidents, periodic BEPS, unemployment, theft (194%) and electronic media, mobile devi-
and group debtors life insurance (Chart 6.8). ces and Internet, with annually in real terms
increases of 193.6% and 66%, respectively
POLICYHOLDERS (Chart 6.9).
In 2017, the number of effective poli-
cyholders18 increased by 7.7% vis-à-vis the
CHART 6.8
6%
Agrarian 94%
Share of issued
premiums for financial
3%
8%
5%
Home 84%
Theft
inclusion, per policy
17% 28% 10% 45%
type and range of
2%
Earthquake 4% 92%
monthly premium19
2%
1% %
2
Fire 3% 94%
7%
> $50,000
Group life - voluntary 12% 13% 31% 44%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
18 The monthly premium refers to the value in pesos of issued premiums and paid on a monthly basis per policyholders.
19. The number of current insured refers to the number of insured with policies in force as of December of the year under study.
166
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
CHART 6.9
Evolution of insurance
Share by number total of risks
market share policyholders in per year
for financial inclusion, 6.7%
per sales channel 16.3%
3.2% 7.7%
14.6%
11.1%
Personal General
2015 2016 2017 insurance insurances
3.9% 18.6%
7.3%
37.9%
17.3%
25.2%
2,5%
7.9%
5.7%
23.1%
2.6%
0.2% 5.3%
7.2%
32.9% 74.8%
Source: Superintendencia
2015 2016 2017
Financiera de Colombia
Personal General
insurance insurances
167
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Although during 2017 the use of network conti- new insured risks through general insurance
nued as the most important channel in terms of coverage increased its share by 10.8pp over
insurance placement, its total share of new po- the total, from 6.4% to 17.2% (Chart 6.10).
licyholders for the year decreased by 15.9pp, New policyholders with insurances for
from 76.7% in 2015 to 60.8% in 2017. The fo- financial inclusion entered mainly through
regoing is mainly the result of the decrease in the group debtors life insurance business
the ratio of payment protection insure to the (40.4%), this share has decreased from 2015
total number of insured risks. (Chart 6.11). This situation may be interpre-
When reviewing data per type of insuran- ted as positive, as it is indicative that in-
ce, there is evidence that although 88% of surance growth for inclusion is driven by
effective policyholders of insurances for finan- different types of insurances placed throu-
cial inclusion in 2017 were personal insurance gh loans or other mandatory policies, as vo-
clients, their share was 3pp lower when com- luntary theft insurance, personal accidents
pared to the previous period. The number of and unemployment policies.
CHART 6.10
Evolution of
insurance market
95% 94% 83%
share of insurances
for financial
2015 2016 2017 inclusion, per type
of insurance
Personal insurance
2015 2016 2017 General insurance
Personal insurance
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
2015 2016 2017
168
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
Personal insurance
CHART 6.11
Evolution of the share
69.4%
of effective number
58.7%
of policyholders of
insurances for financial
inclusion, per policy type
40.4%
2015
2016
20.8%
2017 16.5%
16.5%
12.8%
11.4%
9.4%
7.6%
5.9%
4.7%
2.5%
0.01%
0.01%
0.01%
0.01%
1.4%
0.6%
0.7%
0.4%
Funeral Personal Group Group life - Individual life Periodic Unemployment
expenses accidents payment debtors economic
protection benefits
insurance
General Insurance
5.2%
4.1%
3.8%
1.4%
2015
1.3%
1.2%
2016
1.0%
0.9%
2017
0.7%
0.3%
0.3%
0.01%
0.01%
0.01%
0.00%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
Fire Earthquake Theft Home Agroindustry
169
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
170
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
Personal insurance
CHART 6.12
Evolution of the
share of effective
34.8%
policyholders of
33.0%
insurances for
30.1%
financial inclusion,
27.2%
per policy type
31.3%
31.2%
2015
16.1%
14.5%
2016
14.8%
2017
8.4%
6.8%
2.9%
4.8%
3.5%
3.1%
1.7%
0.00%
0.00%
0.01%
0.7%
1.6%
General Insurance
0.8%
6.5%
4.0%
3.6%
2.7%
2015
2016
1.3%
2017
1.0%
0.8%
1.2%
1.2%
1.2%
0.9%
0.01%
0.01%
0.1%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
Fire Earthquake Theft Home Agroindustry
171
172
Funeral 8% 6% 73% 9% Funeral
expenses expenses 16% 6% 44% 23%
Group life - 13% 7% 8% 8% 35% 23% Group life - 30% 6% 6% 27% 26%
voluntary voluntary
Fire 12% 11% 11% 30% 24% 9% Fire 14% 6% 7% 30% 29% 14%
Financiera de Colombia
Source: Superintendencia
and policy type
inclusion, per channel
insurances for financial
of policyholders of
Market share of number
CHART 6.13
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
Regarding distribution by gender, during 2017, products that are specific to women (acces-
56% of policyholders in the business of finan- sories, hand bags, among others) Chart 6.14.
cial inclusion insurances were men and 44% When reviewing data per policy and gen-
were women. Between 2016 and 2017, the der, there is evidence of an equal distribution
market share of women in insurances for fi- with the exception of the policies related to
nancial inclusion grew by 2pp, driven by an theft and agro-industry that had a larger sha-
increase in the number of women policyhol- re of men, 88% and 84% respectively (Chart
ders of personal and general insurance poli- 6.15). The businesses with greatest growth of
cies. These results may be attributed to the women policyholders relate to periodic BEPS
efforts carried out by the sector to design pro- (7pp), group voluntary life insurance (3pp) and
ducts differentiated by gender, such as poli- group debtors life insurance (3pp) and busines-
cies with coverage for illnesses related to men ses with greatest growth of number of men poli-
and women and/or those offering coverage for cyholders are theft (14pp) and home (9pp).
CHART 6.14
2015 2016 2017
Evolution of
the share of
total effective
policyholders
Total insurance
of insurances for for inclusion
financial inclusion,
54% 46% 58% 42% 56% 44%
per gender
Personal
insurance for
inclusion
General
insurance for
inclusion
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
173
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHART 6.15
Market share of effective
16.2%
48.7%
11.6%
40.2%
43.3%
47.2%
51.1%
50.3%
46.0%
43.6%
49.4%
51.2%
policyholders in 2017 of
insurances for financial
inclusion, per gender and
policy type
Women
Men
83.8%
51.3%
88.4%
59.8%
56.7%
52.8%
48.9%
49.7%
54.0%
56.4%
50.6%
48.8%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
Agrarian
Home
Theft
Earthquake
Fire
Unemployment
Periodic economic
benefits
Individual life
Group life -
debtors
Group life -
voluntary
Personal
accidents
Funeral
expenses
The sales channel with the greatest num- in microfinancial institutions21, and the use of
ber of effective men policyholders was the networks through the policies of fire, theft,
use of network (61.1%) while public utility home, unemployment and group life insuran-
companies was the channel having the lar- ces (Chart 6.16).
gest women representation in its products Among the purposes of financial inclusion is
(56.7%). When analyzing variation in femi- to provide affordable products that ensure cove-
nine market share per channel and policy, it rage to address needs of the population, irres-
was observed that the greatest growth were pective of their geographical location.
174
Men
2017
2016
Women
of effective
Market share
CHART 6.16
sales channel
per gender and
policyholders in
Financiera de Colombia
2017 of insurances
Source: Superintendencia
for financial inclusion,
29.9%
Use of network Other 55.8% 44.2%
38.9%
56.6%
Utility companies Own work 52.4% 47.6%
56.7%
47.6%
Own work Utility companies 43.3% 56.7%
47.6%
175
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
In the insurance sector, one may observe overcome financial crisis when faced with
a 3pp increase in the number of policyhol- unforeseen events (Chart 6.17).
ders living in rural municipalities and disper- The policy showing the greatest growth of
sed rural areas in the country during 2017 clients located in rural areas was fire, which
(13.5%). This growth means progress as re- had an increase of 13.3%, becoming the third
gards the objective of insurance for inclu- policy with greatest share of effective poli-
sions, which seek that Colombians from cyholders in this area (24.8%). Basic covera-
all areas of the country have mechanisms ges of the following insurance policies are more
in place that allow them to maintain their appealing to inhabitants from rural areas and
quality of life and ensure tranquility to their dispersed rural areas: fire, explosions, water
families to fulfill long term objectives and damage, flooding and avalanches (Chart 6.18).
CHART 6.17
90.0%
89.0%
84.7%
78.3%
87.2%
89.0%
87.5%
88.8%
86.5%
Evolution of
the share of
total effective
policyholders of
insurances for
financial inclusion,
per type of area
Rural municipalities
Urban
10.0%
11.0%
15.3%
21.7%
12.8%
11.0%
12.5%
11.2%
13.5%
176
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
Market share
95.3% 4.7% Home
of effective
policyholders 98.7% 1.3% Theft
who in 2017 of
insurances for 85.2% 14.8% Earthquake
Group payment
87.9% 12.1% protection insurance
99.9% Funeral
0.1% expenses
.0
Other
10
0.
Theft 4.0%
Other
Agroindustry 10.0% 5.2% Funeral expenses
Fire 11.3% Group payment
15.6%
protection insurance
Personal
20.4%
accidents
Personal
accidents 41.0% Group life -
30.3% debtors
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
Rural Urban
177
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
The commercialization channel with the grea- insured amounts, which value is discounted
test concentration of effective policyholders from the balance of products under deposit
in rural areas was that of insurance interme- that allow managing money from their mobile
diaries (32.4%), followed by electronic media, phones. These policies do not need insurabi-
mobile devices and Internet (21.3%). This last lity requirements nor are exclusions applicable
option is related to insurance policies with low thereto (Chart 6.19).
CHART 6.19
72.6%
67.6%
100%
99.3%
78.7%
93.2%
92.5%
98.8%
98.3%
Market share of
effective policyholders
in 2017 of insurances
for financial inclusion,
per type of area and
sales channel
Rural
Urban
27.4%
32.4%
1.2%
1.7%
21.3%
0.7%
6.8%
7.5%
Other
Insurance
brokers
Own work
Utility companies
Solidarity
sector
Microfinance
institutions
Use of network
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
178
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
CHART 6.20
Cancellation
index of
insurances22
for financial
inclusion, per 29.6%
type of insurance 28.3%
25.6% 26.4% 25.7%
2016
21.5%
2017
179
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Personal insurance
CHART 6.21
Cancellation index
Unemployment 73.3% 28.8% of insurances
for financial
Periodic economic
benefits 1.8% 2.4% inclusion, per type of
insurance and policy
Individual life
37.0% 34.1%
2016
Group life - voluntary
24.9% 26.8% 2017
Personal accidents
14.8% 12.2%
Funeral expenses
4.7% 6.9%
General insurances
11.2% 13.9%
Home
37.9% 19.2%
Theft
22.2% 34.7%
Earthquake
2016
100% 80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 100% Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
180
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
The policies with the greatest cancella- As per the foregoing, and given that the com-
tion index in 2017 were group debtors mercialization channel of insurances associa-
life insurance (49.6%), followed by earth- ted to loans is the use of networks, the highest
quake (34.7%) and individual life insurance cancellation index was found in this chan-
(34.1%). Those experiencing greater increa- nel (48.8%). In second place, electronic me-
ses in the indicator were fire, group deb- dia, mobile devices and Internet (43.5%) and
tors life and earthquake (Chart 6.21). It is in third place were stores and large retailers
worth noting that the cancellation of pro- (29.2%) (Chart 6.22). These results allow con-
ducts linked to these policies may be rela- cluding that channels with massive placement
ted, in part, to the payment of the loan by of policies show the largest number of comple-
policyholders to financial institutions ted transactions before their expiration.
CHART 6.22
Cancellation index
of insurances
for financial
24.7% 17.7% Other
inclusion, per
commercialization
Insurance
channel 10.9% 11.7%
brokers
2017
9.9% 18.2% Own work
Electronic means,
58.3% 43.5% mobile devices and
internet
Solidarity
2.1% 4.1% sector
Microfinance
44.7% 13,0% institutions
181
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHART 6.23
Share of losses
by insurances for
financial inclusion
85.1%
General insurance
Personal insurance
18.8%
81.2%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
182
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
CHART 6.24
Claims ratio by 51.0%
insurances for 50.0%
financial inclusion
2016
2017
30.0%
27.0%
25.0%
24.0%
16.0%
14.0%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia
voluntary group life insurance, unemployment responsibility of the insurance company, the
and group debtors life insurance drove the de- rate of objection of insurances for financial in-
crease in the accident rate for this type of insu- clusion in 2017 reached 24.4%, 6.6pp above
rance, showing a decrease of 8.7pp, 7.2pp and the previous year. Regarding personal insu-
3.7pp respectively. (Chart 6.23). rance, the policy with the greatest rate of ob-
Understanding by objection the non-pay- jection was unemployment (52.4%) and in
ment of claims in the case of the incident general insurances, the policy of theft showed
claim, due to circumstances that exclude the the greatest rate of objection (22.6%).
183
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Personal insurance
CHART 6.25
Claims ratio of
Unemployment 23.4% 16.1% insurances for
financial inclusion,
Periodic
economic 108.5% 110.4%
per policy type
benefits
Personal life
insurance 18.5% 18.9%
2016
Group life - 34.4% 30.7%
debtors 2017
General insurances
Fire and/or
2016
earthquake
13.7% 16.3% 2017
Source: Superintendencia
80% 60% 40% 20% 0% 20% 40% 60% 80%
Financiera de Colombia
184
CHAPTER 6 | ACCESS AND USAGE OF INSURANCE
CHART 6.26
Rate of objection of
Personal
insurances for insurance for
financial inclusion, per inclusion
type of insurance 27.2%
General
insurance
for financial
inclusion 14.8%
Total insurance
for financial
inclusion
Source: Superintendencia 24.4%
Financiera de Colombia
185
7
FINANCIAL
INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
7.
FINANCIAL
CONSUMER
PROTECTION1
F
inancial consumer protection drives the framework, which are addressed differently
development of long-term relations- in the regulation and supervision. These sce-
hips between consumers and financial narios cover aspects from ensuring the sui-
institutions, allowing consumers to achie- tability of advertising solutions of overseen
ve a favorable experience and have access institutions and the suitability of information
to mechanisms to exercise their rights at provided to consumers; limiting the use of
all stages of the interaction between par- practices and conducts that may not favor
ties, that is, when they search for the ideal consumers’ interests; to ensuring the availa-
product or service; when they establish a bility of effective disputes settlement mecha-
contractual relationship with a financial ins- nisms to be settled.
titution; and when they make use their ac-
quired financial products.
There are many aspects surrounding the 1. This chapter uses information on financial institutions over-
creation of a financial consumer protection seen by the Superintendencia Financiera de Colombia.
187
In this regard, in the Good Practices for Finan-
cial Consumer Protection (2017) report, the
World Bank highlights that jurisdictions must
ensure that overseen institutions have enou-
gh capacity and adequate internal processes
to receive and handle consumers’ complaints
and, in addition, ensure consumers have dis-
pute resolution mechanisms available other
than institutions and ordinary justice systems.
In addition, in 2017, within the internal pro-
cesses and requirements aimed at complaints
management, 124 jurisdictions reported in a
World Bank survey setting time limits; main-
taining databases with information on their
characteristics and management; having spe-
cialized management areas within financial
institutions; making channels available to con-
sumers; and informing about the various com-
plaint mechanisms available; and periodically
submitting information to the government re-
garding these (Chart 7.1).
In the case of Colombia, different advance-
ment have helped the country become aligned
with most regulatory good practices. Howe-
ver, there are no explicit provisions stating that
institutions must have a specific department
to receive and handle complaints made by
financial consumers. Also, regarding comp-
laint-management times, the regulation sta-
tes that requests, including complaints from
public and private institutions, are given a
maximum management timeframe of fifteen
business days upon receipt2.
Nonetheless, regulation from the Sistema
de Atención al Consumidor Financiero for ins-
titutions overseen by Superintendencia Finan-
ciera de Colombia states that institutions shall
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
74%
CHART 7.1 66%
64%
Percentage of 60%
58%
to have specific
requirements
for complaint
management
processes
Source: World
Bank (2017)
Compilation
of information about
complaints
Complaints
management
procedures
Timeframe
for answering
complaints
Presence of an
independent unit in charge
of complaints management
within overseen institutions
Variety of channels
to file complaints
Availability of
information
regarding the stages
of complaint filing
189
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
According to the World Bank’s survey on a financial consumer ombudsman for comp-
Good Practices for Financial Consumer Pro- laints5 and, in addition, since 2012, consumers
tection, 61% of Latin American and Carib- may settle conflicts with institutions before
bean countries said that there are alternative this institution by filing claims in full use of its
dispute resolution mechanisms other than or- jurisdictional powers granted by Law 1480 of
dinary justice, of which Colombia is a part 2011, which serves as an alternative to ordi-
of, as overseen institutions are required to nary justice.
have a financial consumer ombudsman. In This chapter provides significant informa-
contrast, 33% of surveyed Middle East and tion on receipt and management of complaints
North Africa countries responded positively. made to institutions overseen by the Superin-
Other regions of the world gave affirmative tendencia Financiera de Colombia and the fi-
answers as follows: 63% by countries in Eu- nancial ombudsman in 2016 and 2017, as well
rope and Central Asia, and 71% by countries as claims received by the Superintendencia Fi-
in South Africa (Chart 7.2). nanciera de Colombia over that same period.
It is worth mentioning that in Colombia,
most institutions overseen by the Superin-
tendencia Financiera de Colombia must have 5. Article 2.34.2.1.1 of Decree 2555 of 2010.
Latinamerica and
the Caribbean
Sub-Saharan
Africa
Europe and
Central Asia
South Africa
Source: World
Bank (2017)
190
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
1
In 2017, there was a decrease 1,283,057 1,261,593
Complaints Complaints
in the number of complaints
received in 2016 received in 2017
received by overseen
institutions and financial
consumer ombudsmen,
and progress was made on 94% 95.2%
the percentage of settled Settled Settled
complaints relative to 2016. in 2016 in 2017
3
Saving accounts
The upward trend of complaints 177,388 complaints 2%
received about deposit
products was due to savings Failures at ATMs 28%
accounts and certificates of
deposits. In the first case for ATM
failures, and in the second case Certificates of deposits
due to issues with review and/or
settlement of product conditions. 2,254 complaints 38%
Review and/or settlement
of product conditions 58%
5
Personal accidents
A higher share of group
life insurance was found in 16,015 complaints 72%
insurance product related Inappropriate supply of information
complaints. However, received by the time of filing 76%
complaints about personal
accidents and fire showed an
increase by over 70%, mostly Fire
due to inappropriate supply of
information by the time of filing.
13,020 complaints 230%
Inappropriate supply of information
by the time of filing 275%
7
Claims received by the Bogotá
49% 2016 2017
Superintendencia Financiera
de Colombia were mostly filed Córdoba 19 30
in Bogota (49%). However, the
Cundinamarca 73 91
scheme implemented by the
Superintendencia Financiera de Huila 57 75
Colombia enables complaint filing and management Nariño 23 46
in the regions. In particular, there was an increase in
Quindío 53 80
2017 in the number of complaints filed in Cordoba, Rest of
the country
Cundinamarca, Huila, Nariño and Quindio.
51%
192
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
2 Insurance
companies
15%
Banks
7%
Banks
Most received complaints 60%
were filed against banks.
However, insurance
companies showed the Insurance
highest increase in received companies
complaints.
Others
24%
24%
4 Mortgages
8
Complaints against credit institutions Credit institutions
decreased by 8%. Most complaints
were mainly filed about term, interest 1,774 complaints 8%
and contract obligation conflicts. On the
other hand, complaints against insurance
Insurance companies
companies increased by 18% due to
conflicts over indemnity payments under
insurance agreements.
773 complaints 18%
Indemnity payments under
insurance agreements 16%
193
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
49.7%
Favoring
1,338,679 financial consumers
Total complaints to be
settled in 2016
44.7%
Favoring
1,336,898 financial consumers
Total complains to be Source: Superintendencia
settled in 2017 Financiera de Colombia.
194
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
mers, 5pp less than the percent of settlement As to the completion of complaints to be se-
favoring consumers in 2016. At this point, it ttled, there is heterogeneity in the share of
is important to note that complaints that are settled complaints awarded to financial con-
not awarded to financial consumers do not sumers among the five types of institutions.
necessarily mean that the sense of the reply In 2016 and 2017, the institutions who admi-
was not appropriately provided. nistered the average premium regime had a
When analyzing complaint management highest settlement level in favor of financial
by the institutions that received most com- consumers, despite its drop over the last
plaints to be handled during the year (96% year, going from 96% to 75% of total sett-
of complaints to be settled), it is found that, led complaints.
with the exception of pensions and seve- On the other hand, financing companies
rance pays, while the other types of institu- showed a settlement level in favor of financial
tions reached a higher completion level of consumers that reached almost 20% in both
complaints to be settled in 2017 relative to years, being the institution with the lowest se-
2016 (Chart 7.4). ttlement level in favor of financial consumers.
Number of
compaints pending 850,764 186,226 160,167 51,916 38,970
to solve
% Favoring
55% 21% 49% 96% 24%
financial consumers
Number of
compaints pending 799,504 212,363 198,415 39,266 35,333
to solve
195
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
196
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
2017 2016
96% Insurance
companies
192,139 155,466
Pensions and
34,145 37,194
severance payment
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
Saving Saving
173,819 177,388
account account
Current Elderly
80,224 53,164
of the total number of account retirement
received complaints were
about these five products
Elderly Car
61,155 40,241
retirement insurance
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
197
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
SRegarding the reasons why financial consumers the trend in complaints related to contract infrin-
complain, issues with product costs, rates and gement and/or modification, a 28% increase
balances ranked first, for 17% of the total num- took them from ranking fourth to third in the top
ber of received complaints. Compared to 2016, five reasons for complaints in 2017 (Chart 7.7).
198
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
177,388
2% Vs. 2016
10% Wrongful charges for services or
commissions
34%
39,308
51% Vs. 2016
6% Contract infringement
and/or modification
22%
2,254
38% Vs. 2016
11% Wrongful charges for services
or commissions 459%
199
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
200
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
Commercial or
3,031 2,871
58%
consumer loan
Contract infringement
Commercial or 11% and/or modification
12%
consumer loan
135,689 11% Reports to credit bureaus 1%
2% Vs. 2016
Review and/or settlement
37% of product conditions
20%
Contract infringement
Mortgages loan
13% and/or modification
34%
Contract infringement
Microcredit 19% and/or modification
14%
10,352
17% Vs. 2016 15% Reports to credit bureaus 39%
201
Insurance products6
CHART 7.10
of the total number of
Received complaints 6% received complaints were
about insurance products about these six products
Group payment
protection
16% Contract infringement
and/or modification 25%
16,015
72% Vs 2016 4% Claim objection 78%
203
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
CHART 7.11
How many claims were received by gender and Received and
amount, and how many claims were settled? settled claims
2016 2017
2,733 2,709
By Gender By Gender
73% 78.3%
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
204
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
All of the 2,120 claims settled in 2017 had been because of lack of jurisdiction of the Superinten-
filed for several settlement reasons, particular- dencia Financiera de Colombia (Chart 7.12).
ly rejected claims, representing 55% of all recei- An analysis by department shows, just like
ved complaints in 2017, followed by claims that previous years, that most received claims were
were settled based on a ruling issued by the Su- filed in Bogota, 1,320 claims (49% of the to-
perintendencia Financiera de Colombia, or 17%, tal number of claims received during the year).
and dismissed claims by financial consumers, However, in 2017 there was an increase in the
and claims settled between the institution and number of claims received in other departments,
the consumer, or 13% each. Out of the 1,173 in particular: Cordoba, Cundinamarca, Huila,
claims rejected in 2017, 65% were rejected be- Nariño and Quindío (Map 7.1).
cause of lack of remediation (documentation and
supports) presented by the claimant, and 35% 7. The remaining 4% refers to legal entities.
2%
CHART 7.12
Claim settlement
13%
Reasons for
Others
13% claim settlement
Conciliated
Desisted
55% in 2017
Ruled
Rejected
17%
35%
Reasons for
claims rejection
in 2017
Absence of remedial actions 65%
Not a SFC competence
Source: Superintendencia
Financiera de Colombia.
205
FINANCIAL INCLUSION REPORT 2017
Córdoba 19 30
Cundinamarca 73 91
Huila 57 75
Nariño 23 46
Quindío 53 80
Over 1.000
Between 50 - 100
Between 20 - 50
Source: Superintendencia
Less than 20
Financiera de Colombia.
206
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION
CHART 7.14
Received claims by Which entities did financial consumers
type of institution and complaint about and why?
by complaint reason
6%
94% of the total number
of received claims by the
29%
Superintendencia Financiera
Others 65% de Colombia were filed against
Insurance companies and
brokers credit institutions and insurance
Financial institutions companies and insurance brokers.
Credit
institution 20% Unauthorized credit card charges 36%
1,774
19%
8% Vs. 2016
Fraud on electronic channels 27%
insurance brokers
773 11% Number of conflicts over terms,
interest and contract obligations
8%
18% Vs. 2016
207
CHAPTER 7 | FINANCIAL CONSUMER PROTECTION