Lessons in Your Inbox 3 Inclusivity
Lessons in Your Inbox 3 Inclusivity
Lessons in Your Inbox 3 Inclusivity
Your Inbox
Inclusive classes online
Contents
3
Ten tips for teaching online 15
10 vocabulary practices that students
Teaching English: Best Practices with dyslexia hate
for Blended Learning ETpedia Vocabulary
Pete Sharma and Barney Barrett Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline
4
Learners with special needs: and Julie Moore
teaching those who need more help 18
Phonics chart
English Teaching professional (118) ETpedia Vocabulary
Damian Cunniffe Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline
6
Equal opportunities and Julie Moore
English Teaching professional (41) 20
10 tips for teaching vocabulary to
Ruth Shuter students who are hard of hearing
8
Five things you always wanted to ETpedia Vocabulary
know about using technology and Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline
special educational needs and Julie Moore
English Teaching professional (104) 23
10 tips for teaching students who are
Nicky Hockly colour-blind or who are partially sighted
9
10 things to know about SEN students ETpedia Vocabulary
and technology Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline
ETpedia Technology and Julie Moore
Nicky Hockly 26
Collaborative maps
12
10 thoughts on instructions ETpedia Vocabulary
ETpedia Young Learners Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline
Vanessa Reis Esteves and Julie Moore
14
Common classroom instructions 27
The dangers of differentiation
ETpedia Young Learners English Teaching Professional (112)
Vanessa Reis Esteves Adrian Tennant
This collection contains articles, chapters, and units from Pavilion ELT publications available to
purchase at www.pavpub.com/pavilion-elt
SEN recognition
Sometimes, learners with SEN can quickly be identified,
even if no prior information has been forwarded to the
schools. Ireland’s Education for Persons with Special
Educational Needs Act of 2004 (EPSEN) identifies four
main areas of disability:
■■ Physical
Learners
■■ Sensory
■■ Mental health
■■ Learning disability
with special
It could be argued that physical and sensory disabilities are
more easily identified by institutions, because of the often
observable nature of these disabilities. Mental health issues and
learning disabilities, on the other hand, may not become
needs
apparent until a learner has entered the classroom. As a
consequence, it is left to the teacher to make an assessment of
the learner’s needs, according to either their own experience or
instincts – neither of which is a very scientific approach, but
Damian Cunniffe offers a practical approach to both are called upon more often than institutions would like to
admit. So what should a teacher presented with a learner with
teaching those who need a little more help. no officially diagnosed or disclosed special need do?
A
large proportion of teachers in ELT will have had, First steps
or suspected they have had, learners with special
When teachers feel they have a learner with SEN in their
education needs (SEN) in their classrooms. In
classroom, they should first inform their institution of their
mainstream primary and post-primary schools in
concerns. A united front, even late in the day, is essential to
Ireland, tried and tested safeguards have long existed
enable the learner to have a fulfilling experience in the school.
for such learners. Processes for diagnosing their difficulties and
All queries related to a learner’s needs should be addressed to
meeting their needs are aided by external agencies, and support for
the parents, carers or leaders, as appropriate. Ideally, adult
teachers, involving direct institutional participation and assistance
learners should be spoken to directly, usually by a student
from trained SEN professionals, are the norm.
liaison officer or a suitably qualified individual. I have had
In private language schools in Ireland and elsewhere, experiences where learners with SEN have come to class and
however, this multi-layered approach is often unavailable for suffered adverse effects related to the stresses and strains of
reasons of practicality (learners are only present for short trying to fit in; they didn’t say anything in advance because they
periods, thus rendering the application of strong SEN policies felt that disclosure of their particular needs might not be
problematic) or for economic reasons (institutions do not see the viewed sympathetically. It is essential that learners are reassured
necessity of having expensive trained SEN professionals on site). that the school is there to help and support. Speaking to
Furthermore, information related to a learner’s SEN is not learners about their needs, in order to ascertain what would be
always supplied to a school prior to their arrival, and these best for them during their school day, often serves to relieve
learners are often not flagged as a concern until they are that stress and allows the student to enjoy their educational
already in the classroom. Moreover, a lack of substantive experience. Essentially, ignoring an apparent need in a learner
training in SEN in the ELT sector frequently leads to confusion places undue pressure on both teacher and learner alike. Using
as to what approach teachers should take when they discover a direct approach, tempered with sensitivity, understanding and
or suspect that a learner has SEN. the offer of support, reaps its own rewards for all concerned.
Is the lesson accessible for visual learners? Delaney, M Special Educational Needs OUP 2016
Is the teacher employing expression and gesture in order Skidmore, D Inclusion Open University Press 2004
to get a message or instruction across? Towle, P The Early Identification of Autism Spectrum Disorders
Jessica Kingsley Publishers 2013
Does the learner have clear sight of the board?
Is the classroom sufficiently well-lit?
Damian Cunniffe is a Cambridge Delta Tutor,
For learners with ADHD (attention deficit teacher, writer and researcher. He is a
passionate advocate of inclusive learning and
hyperactivity disorder) SEN teaching. He lives in Galway in the west
Does the teacher employ a set of guidelines or class rules of Ireland with his family.
in agreement with the parents or learners themselves? damian.cunniffe@teachers.atlantic.ac
Does the teacher employ a rewards system?
Is the lesson goal-driven, and are the goals achievable without
too many hurdles to clear?
L
anguage exams can represent an incentive for learning, Modifications
particularly where they are used as part of university Modifications to exam papers are designed to make it possible
admissions and job recruitment procedures. It is, for candidates with, for example, visual difficulties, to read exam
therefore, important that the assessment tools used in material; or for candidates with severe hearing difficulties to take
exams do not prevent candidates who have special listening tests. This may involve the production of papers in
requirements from showing their ability in an exam. There is Braille or enlarged print, plus some modifications to the format
also a growing legal obligation in many countries to protect and layout; or the production of lip-reading versions of the
people from discrimination on the grounds of disability. listening test.
In this article I shall refer specifically to arrangements for
candidates taking the Cambridge ESOL exams. However, I Combinations
recognise that ETp readers teach in a wide variety of contexts
Although the number of provisions is essentially fixed, the
and I hope that I will persuade you of the need to think about
combination of provisions required by the candidate is worked
integration of students with special requirements in all types of
out on a case by case basis. A blind candidate, for example,
assessment and in all aspects of education.
would typically need the following:
Setting goals ■■ Braille papers;
■■ extra time;
It should be possible to make special arrangements for such
candidates which, as far as possible, meet the following criteria: ■■ a special version of the listening test, where the tape is stopped
periodically to allow time for the questions to be read, and
■■ removal, as far as possible, of the effects of any given disability
answers written and checked;
on the candidate’s ability to demonstrate their true level of
attainment in relation to the assessment objectives; ■■ a special version of the speaking test, in which any visual
prompt material is presented as a written description;
■■ protection of the integrity of the assessment – a test must still
test what it claims to test – and protection of the validity of the ■■ some kind of arrangement to record the answers, such as an
certificate in certified assessments, so that the user of a certificate amanuensis, the use of a computer with appropriate software
will not be misled about the candidate’s level of attainment; or the use of a Braille typewriter.
■■ protection of the rights of other candidates by not allowing
candidates with special arrangements to gain an unfair Protecting exam integrity
advantage. As far as possible, a candidate taking the test with special
arrangements should take the same test as any other candidate.
Removing barriers Any modified test material should be based on the standard
material.
Based on the example of the provisions and procedures used
by University of Cambridge ESOL Examinations for its If possible, the only changes should be to the format, with
English language assessments, special arrangements the content being left unchanged. Examples of format changes
provisions can be thought of as falling into two main would be to split enlarged print or Braille versions of reading
groups: those which are administrative, and those which papers into a question booklet and a text booklet, so texts and
involve the modification of exam material. questions can be referred to side by side. Visually impaired and
blind candidates are likely to be unable to look at the whole page
Administrative arrangements at once, so it is also necessary to add extra ‘signposts’ to rubrics
and elsewhere in order to tell candidates where they will find the
Administrative special arrangements would include provisions
different parts of tasks.
such as:
With some material, a change to the test content may be
■■ extra time for candidates with dyslexia or with visual difficulties,
necessary (for example with a task based on a map or graph,
who would take longer than usual to read or write;
the information would need to be presented as text for a blind
■■ the use of a scribe, or amanuensis, by candidates with writing candidate), but such changes should be limited to what is
difficulties; absolutely essential. Also, some tasks would be totally
■■ supervised breaks for candidates with conditions which result inappropriate for some candidates. For example, a writing task
in difficulties with concentrating or writing for long periods, asking candidates to describe a favourite picture would need to
for example. be replaced for a blind candidate.
1What are special educational needs? can have audio content transcribed into text by activating closed captions
(subtitles not visible unless activated by the viewer) for video content on a
The term ‘special educational needs’ – SEN for short – is imprecise at best.
tablet. The font and size of these subtitles can be changed, so that
It is used to refer to learners with a wide range of needs, from students
learners with visual impairments can easily read them. For students who
with cognitive and learning challenges like mild dyslexia and mild
may have better hearing in one ear, many tablets include a mono option in
intellectual disability at one end of the spectrum, through to severe learning
the sound settings; and hearing aids can be connected to some tablets
difficulties and autism at the other. It includes learners with behavioural
via Bluetooth. For learners with motor-skill challenges, tactile screen
challenges such as ADHD (attention deficit hyperactivity disorder), or other
settings can be changed from swipe movements to tapping movements,
social or emotional difficulties. It also includes those with physical
which are easier to control; also, the screen display on mobile devices can
challenges like visual or hearing impairments and mobility issues, including
be locked into one position so that screen movement for these learners is
restricted movement and limited motor skills. Clearly, these very different
reduced. Finally, some tablets include an ‘assistive touch’ feature that
needs require differing levels and types of support with learning.
allows teachers to guide the students around the screen as they read.
2 Wclassroom?
hy might I have SEN learners in my language
Unsurprisingly, there is also a wide range of educational apps
available for SEN learners, including those learning a second or foreign
language. For example, for dyslexic learners, there are writing apps
There are two main approaches to dealing with SEN learners in that can help them learn to spell letters by tracing them on a touch
education. On the one hand, we have what we might call a ‘deficit’ screen. Learners who find writing challenging can use text-to-speech
model. In this model, SEN learners are perceived to have a ‘problem’ apps that deliver written texts in audio format. Learners with hearing
which education should try to put right through special learning disabilities can use speech-to-text apps that can provide written
programmes in separate schools. This corresponds to a medical or transcripts of audio texts. More sophisticated apps can enable
clinical approach to SEN. On the other hand, we have a social, or teachers to create video scenarios in order to help learners with autism
inclusive, approach, in which SEN learners are considered to be unique or behavioural challenges to develop empathy and social skills.
5 WSENherelearners?
individuals with their own strengths and weaknesses. In this model, SEN
learners are integrated into mainstream schools, with specialists like
can I find out more about supporting
educational psychologists helping teachers develop strategies and
materials to support these learners in the classroom. Depending on the
educational views and strategies for dealing with SEN that are prevalent Where can I find out more about supporting SEN learners?
in your context, you may well have learners with disabilities such as The OUP English Language Teaching Global Blog:
dyslexia, ADHD and mild-to-moderate intellectual disabilities, as well as Five myths about teaching learners with SEN: http://goo.gl/RKADjY
physical special needs, integrated into your language classes. eaching students with attention, concentration and hyperactivity
T
3 Wandhat’stechnology?
the connection between SEN learners
difficulties: http://goo.gl/w1Se3R
Dyslexia – a problem or a gift? http://goo.gl/F415dY
Help organisations:
Technologies have been used to support SEN learners in general Dyslexia Help: http://dyslexiahelp.umich.edu/tools/software-assistive-
education for decades. For example, tape recorders were originally technology
used to provide learners with audio prompts to help them understand Languages without Limits: www.languageswithoutlimits.co.uk
and/or produce language. Later, MP3 players and portable DVD
players could be used to deliver audio and video prompts, with the
added advantage that SEN learners could carry these smaller Nicky Hockly has been involved in EFL
teaching and teacher training since 1987.
technologies around with them, for support outside the classroom and She is Director of Pedagogy of The
in their daily lives. More recently, mobile devices such as tablet Consultants-E, an online teacher training and
computers have been enthusiastically taken up by SEN educators, development consultancy. She is the
because of their assistive features – more on which below. prize-winning author of several books about
language teaching and technology, most
Technology
Nicky Hockly
Technology
Nicky Hockly
5. Assistive technologies
Mobile devices, especially tablet computers, include a range of built-in assistive features that
can support SEN language students. These are features that can be turned on in the settings
for a mobile phone or tablet. Assistive features include text to speech (which turns a typed text
into audio), speech to text (which turns audio or video into written speech), as well as a range of
hearing, visual and tactile features to help students with these disabilities. These assistive features
are explored further in the points below.
6. Dyslexic students
Dyslexia is a neural condition that makes it difficult for those affected to process information, typically
resulting in issues with reading, writing and spelling. Dyslexic students frequently have problems
linking sounds to the corresponding written words, with the process of reading (letters seem to
change and move around the page for them as they read), and with short-term memory, which
means they find it difficult to remember something that has just been said. Additional challenges
for dyslexic students include sequencing and organisation, and numerical skills. Dyslexia is arguably
the most common type of SEN that you will come across in your English language classroom, so it
is encouraging to know that several of the assistive features of mobile devices can support these
learners. For example, activating text to speech in a mobile device’s settings is recommended
for dyslexic students. Because dyslexic students have challenges with reading, they can listen to
rather than read an English text; in this way a written text is, in effect, ‘read aloud’ by the device. In
addition, dyslexic students can audio-record what the teacher says on a mobile device, which can
help them overcome problems with taking notes or remembering what the teacher says in class. Using
graphic organisers such as mind maps (see Unit 10 and Unit 13) can also help dyslexic students with
sequencing and organisation by displaying information in a more visual format.
Technology
Nicky Hockly
9. Apps
There is a wide range of educational apps available for SEN learners, including those learning a
second or foreign language. For example, for dyslexic learners, there are writing apps that can help
them learn to write letters by tracing them on a touch screen. As we saw above, SEN learners who
find reading challenging can use text-to-speech apps that deliver written texts in audio format.
Similarly, learners with hearing disabilities can use speech-to-text apps that provide written transcripts
of audio texts. SEN learners with communication challenges can benefit from apps that support
communication, including those that predict sentence completion (eg Assistive Express) and those
that enable students to simply answer yes or no to questions.
Young Learners
Vanessa Reis Esteves
10 thoughts on instructions
Instructions can make or break a lesson. If children understand what you want them to do, they will
be able to meet your expectations and the lesson will run smoothly. However, if instructions are
confusing, chaos and confusion may ensue, requiring a lot of your time and effort to get things back
under control.
See Appendix (page 147) for some common and useful classroom instructions for use in
particular situations. To get some ideas on how to give effective instructions, have a look at the
10 tips below.
1. Plan instructions
Instructions are fundamental in the classroom, so spend time carefully planning the instructions
that you give. As you plan the activities for your lesson, think of and plan the corresponding
instructions that you will need for a particular activity. This may initially appear time-consuming, but it
will save you and the children a lot of stress in the classroom. See the Appendix for a list of useful
classroom instructions (pages 147–148).
4. Sequence instructions
Give instructions in a sequenced manner. Follow a 1-2-3 approach to giving instructions: First open
your books, then read the story, and finally do Exercise 1. Write this on the board in three steps,
numbered 1, 2 and 3, so that the children can go back to the instructions if they forget them as they
become immersed in the activity.
5. Repeat instructions
Make sure you give instructions more than once. Children have different learning rhythms and
language levels, which will mean that they don’t all understand you at the same time. Some children
may need to hear an instruction several times before they understand what you want them to do.
6. Demonstrate instructions
Remember that young learners still have a very basic command of English. To avoid misunderstandings,
give children instructions while demonstrating exactly what you want them to do. Think of yourself as a
mirror, constantly reflecting what you want the children to do.
Young Learners
Vanessa Reis Esteves
7. Check understanding
Once you have given an instruction, take the time to check whether the children have understood.
Don’t limit yourself to asking, ‘Do you understand?’ The natural answer to this question tends to be
‘Yes’. Try getting the children to repeat the instruction back to you like a parrot or in a parrot voice.
This will allow them to have fun and stay on track at the same time.
Young Learners
Vanessa Reis Esteves
How many months have 28 days? All the months (they all have at least 28 days).
What can you hear but not touch or see? Your voice.
Appendix
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
2. Ignoring phonics
Phonics training helps with both sides of word recognition – it allows learners to work out how
to pronounce a word they see, and it also allows them to work out how to write a word they
hear. Like all students, those with dyslexia will benefit from direct instruction of sound–letter
correspondence. This includes teaching students how letters and letter combinations sound (e.g. igh
sounds like /aɪ/, as in high; ou sounds like /əʊ/, as in though or /aʊ/, as in ouch), and how letter
sounds can change in combination with other letters (e.g. c sounds like /s/ before e or i, as in palace
and circus). Encourage students to keep charts in their vocabulary notebooks to record words
according to phonetic patterns. You can also display charts and word clouds around the walls for
reference. (See the phonic table on page 237 of the Appendix for an example.)
3. Being rushed
Students with dyslexia need extra time to process information, so avoid rushing them. Give students
time to complete written exercises and, when introducing new vocabulary, give them maximum mental
processing time. For vocabulary dictation exercises, allow extra time or provide scaffolding by giving
students part of the word with gaps to fill in for each letter. Give students plenty of time to write out or
type words to make use of muscle memory.
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
as they write or type them. Encourage students to use colours or larger fonts to highlight patterns
in words (e.g. words with ea that sound like /e/ (e.g. deaf) and those that sound like /i:/ (e.g. meat);
words with ough that sound like /ʌf/ (e.g. enough) and those that sound like /əʊ/ (e.g. although), etc).
In writing, focus on students’ ability to communicate ideas rather than on perfect spelling.
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
9. Ignoring technology
Technology gives students with dyslexia a range of useful tools, including accessibility tools on
computers and laptops, and assistive technology for web browsing. Here are some ways to use
technological tools:
XX Allow students to type (or dictate) their work and to use the spellchecker. Show them how to
right-click on a misspelled word to find a list of possible spellings. Another alternative is assistive
technology such as Ghotit, which is especially designed to help people with dyslexia with their
spelling.
XX Use an online dictionary with audio so that students can both see and hear the word.
XX Encourage students to use apps such as Mental Note for iPad to create a multi-sensory digital
notebook which can include text (including speech-to-text functionality), audio, pictures and
sketches.
XX Upload worksheets into an app such as SnapType Pro so that students can complete them without
having to write answers by hand.
For more information on useful apps, search for ‘dyslexia apps for adults’ in your web browser.
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
Sounds Words with these sounds Your words with these sounds
/ɪ/ this, symbol, dish
Appendix
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
Appendix
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
2. Use flashcards
Flashcards are key teaching aids for supporting learners who are hard of hearing. The problem with
referring to pictures in a coursebook is that it tends to be a heads-down activity, which detaches
the experience of seeing the visual from that of seeing the word being produced. Using flashcards
allows the teacher to have the image near their face when they say the word, thereby supporting
lip-reading; it can also be either held near a wordcard (a card with a single word or phrase written
on it) or stuck on the board next to the written form. In review lessons, you can use flashcards drawn
by the students. The act of producing cards is motivating for students; it also reinforces associations,
as the memory of drawing may trigger retrieval of the item.
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
4. Miming games
Charades builds associations with words either through watching classmates miming and relating
the actions to vocabulary items, or through the physicality of doing the mime itself. Write the day’s
vocabulary on slips of paper and invite a student to the front to take one and look without showing it.
The student then mimes the word silently for the class to guess. The student who guesses the word
correctly comes to the front and mimes the next word, or nominates someone to do it.
8. Use anagrams
Some hearing students, particularly adults, find solving anagrams tricky and don’t enjoy them (enger?
erd? loyewl?*). Students who were born deaf but have CIs or are hard of hearing are often much better
at these than hearing students are. This means that solving anagrams is a particularly useful, motivating
activity for reviewing, memorising or practising vocabulary, or to be used as a vocabulary warmer. The
activity constitutes an achievable challenge that plays to their strengths and offers a sense of reward.
(*green, red, yellow)
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
Working exclusively with blind students needs specific techniques on the part of the teacher at all times;
however, in more general classes, always incorporating activities that play to such students’ strengths, rather
than occasionally planning ‘special’ activities, really evens out everyone’s chances of learning vocabulary.
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
Vocabulary
Stacey H. Hughes, Fiona Mauchline and Julie Moore
Park R
ow
College Street
Main Street
Short Street
L ane
Old
B
efore explaining what I mean by the ‘dangers’ of Content
differentiation, I think it is important to define what ■■ Providing reading texts at varying levels.
is meant by the term differentiation. At its most basic
level, differentiation consists of the efforts of teachers
■■ Providing vocabulary lists with definitions for weaker learners.
to respond to differences among and between learners ■■ Having a variety of comprehension questions for a listening
in the classroom. This may be at the level of the individual or or reading task, eg from closed yes/no questions to more
small groups, and differentiation may be achieved by using a complex inference questions.
variety of activities and strategies throughout a lesson.
Process
Using activities that require reaching the same understanding
Theory ■■
and skills, but which have different levels of support,
Differentiation can be applied to four areas: the content – what challenge or complexity.
the learners are learning; the process – how they are learning; ■■ Grouping the learners according to level or ability.
the product – what they produce; and the learning environment
– the way the classroom works and feels. ■■ Varying the length of time a learner may be given to
complete a task, providing additional support for a
Teachers may well make decisions about differentiation
struggling learner or encouraging an advanced learner to
based on a number of factors connected to the learners. These
look at a topic in greater depth.
could include the readiness of the learners, their perceived
abilities and/or needs, their interests and their learning profiles. Product
Let’s take a closer look at each of these four areas, to gain a ■■ Asking the learners to produce different pieces of work. For
better idea of what this could mean. example, some learners could be asked to answer as many
The home of
modernenglishteacher ETpedia
TM
Te a c h i n g E n g l i s h