Representative and Experimental Basins.: Unesco
Representative and Experimental Basins.: Unesco
Representative and Experimental Basins.: Unesco
experimental basins.
An international guide fou research and practice I
Unesco
Studies and reports in hydrology 4
TITLES IN THIS SERIES
Co-edition Unesco/IASH
i. The use of analog and digital computers in hydrology. Proceedings of the Tucson Symposium,
vol. 2. I L’utilisation des calculatrices analogiques et des ordinateurs en hydrologie.Actes du
colloque de Tucson, vol. 2.
2. Water in the unsaturated zone. Proceedings of the Wageningen Symposium, vol. 1. / L’eau
dans la zone non saturée. Actes du symposium de Wageningen, vol. 1.
3. Floods and their computation.Proceedings of the Leningrad Symposiurn,August 1967,vol.2. J
Les crues et leur évaluation. Actes du symposiiim de Leningrad, aJût 1967, vol. 2.
Published by Unesco
4. Representative and experimental basins - A n international guide for research and practice
(Willalso appear in French, Russian and Spanish).
5. Discharge of selected rivers of the world, vol. 1. / Débit de certains cours d’eau du monde,
vol. 1.
Published in 1970 by the United Nations
Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
Place de Fontenoy, 75 Parìs-P
0 Unesco 1570
Prinled in îhe Neiherlands
SC NS.68/XX-l/A
Preface
contacts between research workers in this field. To this end Unesco has initiated two
collections of publications: Studies and Reports in Hydrology, and Technical Papers
in Hydrology.
The collection Studies and Reports in Hydrology is aimed at recording data collected
and the main results of hydrological studies undertaken within the framework of the
Decade as well as providing information on research techniques. Also included in the
collection will be proceedings of symposia. Thus, the collection will comprise the
compilatibn of data, discussions of hydrological research techniques and findings, and
guidance material for future scientific investigations.It is hoped that the volume will
furnishmaterial of both practical and theoretical interestto hydrologists and governments
participating in the IHD and respond to the needs of technicians and scientists concerned
with problems of water in all countries.
The responsibility for the choice and presentation of facts and for opinions and views expressed
lies with the organizations and authors cited in the foreword to each publication in the collection.
The designations employed and the presentation of the material do not imply the expression
of any opinion whatsoever on the part of Unesco concerning the legal status of any country
or territory,or of its authorities,or concerning the delimitations of the frontiers of any country
or territory.
Contents
Foreword 17
List of contributors 19
1 Introduction
1.1 Scope and purpose 21
1.2 Definition of representative and experimental basins 22
1.2.1 Representative basins 22
1.2.2 Experimental basins 23
1.3 Purposes of representative and experimental basins 23
1.3.1 Representative basins 23
1.3.2 Experimental basins 24
1.4 Survey of research needs 24
1.4.1 Staffing for basins 25
1.4.2 Basic recommendations on standardization of methods of observation,
instrumentation and data processing 25
1.4.3 Data-reporting methods 21
1.4.4 Research co-operation and research observation programmes 21
I .5 Terminology 30
1.6 Measurement units and symbols 36
References 41
Contents
Contents
Bibliography 341
Foreword
Since the inception of the IHD programme,it has been apparent that the development
of hydrological research should include the perfecting of research methodology on
specially chosen and equipped basins. Such basins, designated ‘representative’ or
‘experimental’basins, are of great value for hydrological research and for the training
of research workers when the standards of organization and functioning comply with
clearly defined research aims.
A Symposium on Representative and Experimental Basins was organized by Unesco
in collaboration with the Hungarian Government with the participation of the Inter-
national Association of Scientific Hydrology (IASH) in Budapest in September 1965
in order to study a wide range of experiments and the results obtained,so that general
guidelines could be formulated for these basins. These guidelines are intended mainly
for countries wishing to establish such research basins,but are useful also for improving
the effectiveness of research already in progress.
The Co-ordinatingCouncil ofthe I H D formed an ad hoc Working Group to draw up,
from the conclusions of the symposium,the principles for organizing representative
and experimental basins. This Working Group was asked to analyse the results of an
investigation undertaken on the current state of hydrological research being conducted
or contemplated in such basins in various countries. The growth of projects related
to the creation of representative and experimental basins in the countries participating
in the Decade, and the importance of independent experiments performed in several
countries,led theWorking Group to propose to the Co-ordinatingCouncilthe preparation
of a guide for international research and practice in representative and experimental
basins, based on existing documentation.
This technical guidance material outlines the methodological principles for the
organization and functioning of representative and experimental basins according to
the specific aim of the research undertaken.In order that it could be used for the setting up
of IHD national programmes,it was necessary to prepare the guide as soon as possible.
With this aim in view, the Co-ordinating Council, at its second session in April 1966,
established a permanent Working Group, which had as its main task the preparation
of this guide, and asked it to nominate from its members a Panel of Experts to
complete this task.
The Panel thus formed met for the first time in October 1966. T w o draft guides were
prepared, including contributions and material received from national committees for
the IHD. One was edited by Mr.Toebes,with Messrs. Hadley and Jacquet as sub-editors,
and the other was edited by Dr.Ouryvaev, and prepared in the U.S.S.R. The two guides
were combined at successive meetings of the chief editors, of the Panel and of the
17
Foreword
Working Group. The publication of the project was endorsed by the Co-ordinating
Council at its third session in May 1967.
The guide comprises six chapters:
The Introduction describes the aims of the publication and the purpose of representative
and experimental basins within the larger framework of hydrological research;
Chapter 2 gives the criteria for selecting sites and for organizing a network of basins;
Chapter 3 deals with the organization and planning of observations according to the
aims of the research being carried out on the basins;
Chapter 4 contains descriptions of methods of observation and types of instruments
to be used for the study of the various parameters of the hydrological cycle;
Chapter 5 gives a wide range of methods for data processing,synthesis,and preparation
for publication;
Chapter 6 deals with analysis techniques and interpretation of the results obtained.
The present publication,thus prepared in a very short period of time,obviously presents
imperfections and gaps. Nevertheless,it is hoped that it will serve as a valuable source
of guidance material, especially for countries in which this type of investigation is just
beginning, and will at the same time offer a framework for the international exchange
of experience in this field of hydrological research.
The Working Group which prepared this first version of the guide has also been
entrusted with the responsibility of collecting additional data and formulating various
improvements to the present text; particularly with reference to Chapters 3 and 6,
both of which are important prerequisites of successful research on representative and
experimental basins.
All IHD national committees are invited to send comments on the contents and to
forward complementary scientific material with a view to perfecting the guide. Such
contributions would be especially welcomed from countries where interesting new
results have been obtained from investigations.This information will be collected by
the Secretariat and passed on to the Working Group.
18
List of contributors
19
List of contributors
20
Introduction
21
Representative and experimental busins
The present work is aimed at serving those w h o are responsible for the organization
and conduct of hydrological research on representative and experimental basins. It is
based on the collective experience of various countries and contains general recommen-
dations on the selection of basins and the organization of observations on them, o n
the programme and types of observation, on instruments and observation methods,
on data-processing analysis and interpretation of observational results.
Taking into consideration the variability of natural conditions under which investi-
gations will be carried out on representative and experimental basins, only those
recommendations which are most suitable for definite conditions should be used.
The text which follows contains some detailed descriptions of observational methods
and data processing.These examples should not, however, pre-empt the use of methods
and existing procedures valid in many countries,
Numbers in brackets inserted in the text refer to references listed at the end of each
chapter. There is also a general bibliography at the end of the volume.
22
Iniroduction
23
Representative and experimental barins
24
Introduction
The objectives and research methods should be clearly stated for each basin or group
of basins. Fundamental scientific research for any problem demands that a hypothesis
be formulated and that methods be stated to test this hypothesis.
If changes in land use and/or land management are planned, approximate times
of change should be stated at the onset as a working plan. The approximate period
of investigations (normally indefinite for representative basins and for experimental
basins over a period typical of the local climate) should be stated.
To increase the usefulness of the data which is collected in experimental basins,
consideration should be given during the planning stage to the inclusion of companion
studies. Such studies, which could be carried out on sites within basins, plots or
sub-basins,would not only permit assessment of short-termmanipulative actions which
could guide the planning of larger modifications, but would also permit detailed
investigations of basin hydrological processes.
25
Representative and experimental basins
TABLE 1.1. Approximate number of staff employed on representative basins in the U.S.S.R.
according to the size of the basin and scope of observations
Scope of Small basins Medium basins Large basins
observations (up to 50 km2) (200-500 kma) (SOO-1,000 kmz)
TABLE 1.2. Approximate number of points for different kinds of observation on representative
basins of various sizes in the U.S.S.R.zone of temperate climate and plain relief
Size of basin
scope of Programme of
observations observations Small Medium Large
(up to 50 kmz) (200-500 kma) (SOO-1,000 km2)
;d Precipitation
,# (monthly) 5-8 8-10 10-15
Snow surveys up to 10 10-12 12-15
Streamflow 1-2 2-3 3-5
Evaporation from soil
and water surface1 1 1 1-2
Ground-water levels 5-10 10-15 15-20
Soil moisture 1 1-2 2-3
Erosion and suspended
sediment discharge 1 -2 2-3 3-5
Chemical composition
of water 1 1-2 2-3
Energy balance 1 1 1
Temperature of river
and ground water 2 2-3 3-5
Snow melt 1 1 1
Soil frost 1 1 1-2
1. Evaporation from the water surface is measured only on a specified number of basins.
regions, representative and experimental basins and run-off plots ; (b) selection of
instruments and methods of their installation;(c) methods of observation;(d) accuracy
of measuring and units of measurements;(e) methods of data processing;(f) publication
forms for observed data; (g) terminology.
Standardization of instrumentation and methods of observation,as specified in this
guide,may be carried out from country to country when compatiblewith physiographicai
conditions and the financial situation.These standardization methods can be used on
an internationalbasis to aid the fruitful interchange of data and results. O n a national
basis, the use of as few different types of instrument as possible will simplify servicing
and maintenance problems. Moreover, standards of installation, such as that for the
26
Introduction
height of precipitation gauges above the ground,are essential to obtain full value from
the national research.
It is inevitable and desirable that in future most observations and data-processing
methods be automated and it is important to simplify and standardize methods now
to ease the change-overto automated methods. It is also important to study the problem
of accuracy of data and indicate in publications, if possible,the standard of accuracy.
27
Representative and exper-imentalbasins
Country
JAPAN
Organisation in
Ministry of Agriculture and Forestry
charge of
Forest Experiment Station
activity
4-770 Shimo-megum , Meguuro-hi , Tokyo
Physloqraphic
description of
Bacin
~
Future -
To study the effect of change8 in forest
conditions, especially cutting, on flow.
ObjectIves
28
Intuodiiction
Co-operationis desirable not only on the national level, but also on a world-wide
regional level (i.e.,with countries that have similar problems or similar physiographical
areas) and on a general international level.Basin cards should be completed for each
basin showing research under way or planned in the various countries and these cards
transmitted to Unesco for international distribution. A n example of such a card is
shown in Figure 1.1.
A useful summary of present and proposed representative and experimental basin
studies by all Member States of Unesco is given in reference [13].
Analyses made : -
29
Representative and experimental basins
1.5 Terminology
The establishment of a uniform scientific terminology for use on research basins is
of great significance to aid international co-operation in such research. Some terms
which have been used in the text are given below [l-4,7-11, 15, 16, 19, 20, 22, 24-7,
31-3, 35, 37-42].
GENERAL TERMS
30
Introduction
CLIMATIC TERMS
Macro-climate. The general climate prevailing over a large area considered as a unit.
Meso-climate.The climate of a valley or system of valleys which differs from the macro-climate.
Micro-climate.The climate of a very small area with special reference to local variations from
the general climate of a region.
Precipitation.The discharge of water in liquid or solid statefrom the atmosphere onto the surface
of the earth. Precipitation includes rainfall,snow, hail, sleet and dew.
Rainfall. The quantity of precipitation that falls as rain only.
M a s s rainfall. The volume of rainfall.
Rainfall intensity. The rate of rainfall (depth or volume of rainfall per unit time).
Rainfall excess. The rainfall in excess of interception loss,depression storage,infiltration and
evaporation. It is the rainfall available for surface flow or direct flow.
Gross rainfall. The total amount of rainfall measured in the open or above the forest canopy.
Net rainfall. The water that enters the mineral soil after penetrating the forest canopy and litter.
Interception.The process by which rainfall is caught on forest vegetation and redistributed as
throughfall, stem flow, and evaporation.
ThroughfaZí. The rainfall which directly reaches the litter through spaces in the forest canopy
or as drip from leaves, twigs and stems.
Stem flow.The rainfall which,having been caught on the canopy,reaches the litter or mineral
soil by running down the stems.
Net interception loss. The portion of precipitation which is returned by the aerial parts of the
vegetation and which has no effect on the soil-waterconsumption of the plant.
Litter interception loss. The rainfall retained on the litter layer and evaporated without adding
to moisture in the underlying soil.
Gross interception loss. The rainfall evaporated from canopy and litter.
Snow. A form of precipitation composed of ice crystals-most are branched but some are star-
shaped.
Snow course. A line or series of connecting lines along which the depth of snow is measured
and snow samples are taken at regularly spaced points.
Snow depth. The snow accumulation on the ground (depth of snow-packcoverage).
Snow survey. Measurements of depth and density of snow pack along a fixed course to determine
water equivalent in snow pack over large areas.
Snow density. The ratio between the volume of melt water derived from a sample of snow and
the initial volume of the sample.This is numerically equal to the specific gravity (relative
density) of the snow.
Water equivalent (os snow). The amount of water that would be obtained if the snow were
completely melted.
D e w . Water drops deposited by condensationof water vapour from the air,mainly on horizontal
surfaces cooled by nocturnal radiation.
Vapour pressure. The pressure exerted by a vapour when it is in a confined space.When several
gases or vapours are mixed together in the same space each one exerts the same pressure
as it would if the others were not present.
Mixing ratio. (Humidity mixing ratio). The relative proportionsby weight of water vapour and
dry air in a given specimen of damp air.
Absolute humidity. The mass of water contained in a given volume of moist air.
SpeciJc humidity.The amount of water vapour (in grammes) containedin 1 grammeof moist air.
Relafive humidity. The ratio (expressed as a percentage) of the water vapour actually present
in unit volume, to that which the air would contain if saturated at the air temperature.
D e w point. The temperature to which air can be cooled without causing condensation.It is the
temperature at which the saturation vapour pressure is identical with the pressure of the
vapour in the air.
Radiation. Energy emitted in the form of electromagnetic waves.
Intensity of radiation. The rate at which energy crosses a given area.
Insolation. A term applied to the solar radiation received by terrestrial or planetary objects.
Long-wave radiation. Radiation received as heat.
Short-wave radiation. Radiation received with a smaller wavelength than that of heat, i.e.,
infra-red,ultra-violet,X-ray,gamma-ray,etc.
31
Representative and experimental basins
Perennial flow. Flow in streams containing water at all times except during extreme droughts.
Intermittentflow.Flow in streamsthat carry water most of the time but ceaseto flow occasionally
because evaporation and seepage into their bed and banks exceed the available stream flow.
Ephemeral flow. Flow in streams carrying water only after rains or periods of snowmelt.
Depression storage. The volume or depth of precipitation stored in natural depressions in the
land surface. Water in depression storage ultimately infiltrates,evaporates,or is drained
artificially.
Surface retention (Initialabstraction). That part of precipitation that does not infiltrate or appear
as a surface flow during,or immediately after the period of rainfall or snowmelt.Surface
retention includes interception storage and depression storage.
Detention storage. The volume or depth of precipitation on the ground surface or in channels
during or shortly after rainfall or snowmelt which is available for surface flow and/or
infiltration during or shortly after rainfall ends.Detention storage includes surface detention
and channel detention.Detention storage does not include depression storage.
Channel. An open,natural or artificial watercourse which periodically or continuously contains
moving water.
Surface detention. The volume or depth of detention storage on the ground surface,excluding
channels.Jt is available for overland flow and infiltration.
Channel detention. The volume or depth of detention storage in channels.Channel detention
is available for surface flow.
Infiltration.The movement of a fluid into a substance through pores or small openings; in
hydrology it is the movement of water into the soil.
Mass infiltration. The volume of infiltration.
Infiltration rate. The rate of infiltration (depth or volume of water infiltrating per unit time).
Infiltration capacity. The maximum rate at which water can flow into a soil in a given condition.
Initial infiltration rate. The initial rate of infiltration at the beginning of storm rainfall.
Ultimate infiltration rate. The final, approximate,constant rate of infiltration.
Flow. The movement of water or other mobile substance.As a term it may mean run-offor
discharge.
Run-08. Normally the flow of water derived from precipitation considered as a volume or as
depth of water.
Discharge. The flow of water considered as a rate.
Surface flow (Surface run-08). The flow of water over the land surface.Surface flow includes
overland flow and channel flow and is normally water derived from rainfall excess.
Overland flow. The flow of water over a land surface in transit towards a permanent stream
channel. Overland flow is derived from surface detention.
Channel precipitation flow (Channel precipitation).That part of the flow of water in permanent
stream channels that is derived from direct precipitation in channels.
Subsurface flow.Any flow below the surface of the ground which may contribute to interflow,
base flow or deep percolation.
Interflow (Prompt subsurface flow). The flow of water from ephemeral zones of saturation.It
moves through the upper strata of a formation at a rate much in excess of normal base-flow
seepage.
32
Introduction
Basefiow. The flow of ground water from beneath a permanent ground-water table.
Direct flow. The flow of water entering stream channels promptly. It includes surface flow and
interflow and is used where interflow cannot be separated in hydrological analyses.
Snowmelt spring fiood ('polovodie'). Considerable flood rise in rivers occurring every spring and
caused by melting of snow pack, accumulated during winter period. It is a typical feature
of rivers of plains in countries with a cold winter and heavy snowfalls.
Specific discharge.Water yield per unit drainage area,per unit time (l/sec/km2or ma/sec/km2).
Deep percolation. The loss of water from a basin by subsurface flow to other basins.
Basalflow. The volume of water appearing as base flow plus the volume of water lost by deep
percolation.
Zone of saturation. A zone in the lithosphere which is saturated with water.
Ephemeral zone of saturation. A zone in the lithosphere which is temporarily saturated with
water.
Ground-water table. The upper surface of a zone of saturation.
Water table (Phreatic surface). The upper surface of a continuous zone of saturation except
where that surfaceis formed by an impermeablebody.N o water table exists where the upper
surface of a continuous zone of saturation is formed by an impermeable body. Base flow
is supplied from water underneath the water table.
Perched ground-water table. The upper surface of a zone of saturation separated from other
bodies of ground water by impermeable strata.
Ephemeral ground-water table. The boundary of an ephemeral zone of saturation where this
cannot be termed a perched ground-watertable.
Zone of aeration (Unsaturated zone). A zone above the water table where unsaturatedconditions
occur.
Intermediate belt. That part of the zone of aeration that lies between the belt of soil moisture
and the capillary fringe overlying the water table.
Ground water. The water in the ground that is in a zone of saturation.
Intermediate wuter. The water in the intermediate belt.
Soil moisture (Soil water). The water in the soil if not all pores are filled with water (unsaturated
conditions). If all pores are filled with water (saturated conditions) soil moisture behaves
as ground water. (N.B. The base of the soil is regarded as reaching at least to the lower limit
of plant roots.)
Hygroscopic water (Hygroscopic moisture). The water adsorbed to the surface of soil particles
when in equilibrium with an atmosphere of 98 per cent relative humidity.It is unavailable
to plants.
Gravitational water. The water which moves into,through,or out of the soil under the influence
of gravity.
- WATER
GRAVITATIONA L CAPILLARY
I
I- WATER WATER l
a
+ I * - , =3
IQ
-
v>
-FIELD
CAPACITY
+
WILTING
POINT
Represetitative und experimeniul busitis
- LAND SURFACE
SOIL
MOISTURE EPHEMERAL GROUND-
. . _'WATER TABLE.
',
I LENS I
.-. .,,.+-:
i..:....:
i
:
:.::..:.....:,,-...:
.
.I
-10'
-10
O IO 20 30 40 50
Moisture content per ceni by weight
34
Introduction
Capillary water (Capillary moisture). The water held by surface tension in the capillary spaces
and as a continuous film around the particles, free to move under the influence of capillary
forces.
Field capacity. The amount of moisture held in the soil after excess gravitational water has
drained.
Wilting point. The soil moisture content at which permanent wilting of the plant occurs. This
may not apply to arid-land plants.
Available soil moisture. The water in the soil available to plants. It is normally taken as the
water in the soilbetween wilting point and field capacity.In this contextwater-holdingcapacity
of a soil is used and is identical to the available water.
Percolation. The movement, under hydrodynamic pressure, of water through the interstices
of a rock or soil, except the movement through large openings such as caves.
Capillary conductivity. (a) Qualitafive. The physical property relating to the readinesswith which
unsaturated soils or rocks transmit water; or:
(b) Quantitafive.The ratio of the water flow velocity to the driving force in unsaturated
soil or rock. The calculation is valid under conditions where flow velocity is proportional
to driving force,e.g.,in practical units when the driving force is expressed in terms of the
hydraulic gradient,capillary conductivity is the ratio of flow velocity to hydraulic gradient
and has the dimensions of velocity. As saturation is approached, capillary conductivity
approaches the hydraulic conductivity.
Hydraulic conductivity (Coeficient of permeability). (a) The ratio of the flow velocity to the
driving force for the viscous flow under saturated conditions of a specified liquid in a porous
medium. Physical dimensions will depend on the equation selected to express the flow.
(b) Practical unifs. The ratio V/grad 4 = K,where Vis a fictivemean velocity of a specified
liquid under saturated conditions,and grad 4 is the hydraulic gradient in the Darcy equation
V = K grad 4. In this case K = LT-l.
Potential level (of soil moisture). The level of soil moisture at which evapotranspiration depends
only on evaporative factors of the atmosphere and not on soil moisture conditions. Some
workers consider this level approximately equal to field capacity.
Water suction. ([Soil]water-moisture suction-tension). (a) A numerical measure of the energy
by which suspended water is held. When expressed as the common logarithm of the head
in centimetres of water necessary to produce the suction corresponding to the capillary
potential, it is called pF.
(b) The negative gauge pressure relative to the external gas pressure on the suspended
water, to which a solution of identical composition must be subjected in order to be in
equilibrium through a porous permeable wall with this water.This quantity may be identified
with the capillary potential defined below.
Capillary potential. The amount of work that must be done per unit quantity of pure water in
order to transportreversibly and isothermally,to the suspended water,an infinitesimalquantity
of water from a pool containing a solution identical in composition to the suspended water
at the elevation and the external gas pressure of the point under consideration.For a definition
of total and other potentials of suspended water, see reference [16].
EROSION A N D SEDIMENTATION T E R M S
Suspended sediment load. Sediment which remains in suspension in flowing water for a con-
siderable period of time without contact with the stream bed.
Sedinient concentration.The ratio of weight of dry solids to the weight of the sample of water-
sediment mixture.
Bed load. Sediment which moves in almost continuous contact with the stream bed,being rolled
or pushed along the bottom by the force of water.
Rill and sheet erosion. The removal of a fairly uniform layer of soil or material from the land
surfaceby the action ofraindropimpactand the product of the kineticenergy and the duration
of rainfall. When the overland flow concentrates in microchannels, sheet erosion becomes
rill erosion. Although rill and sheet erosion are difficult parameters to measure in the field,
it has been shown that, for the areas investigated, it is the dominant source of sediment,
accounting for over 90 per cent of the eroded material in many basins.
Mass movement (includes soil creep, landslip). The term applied to unit movement of a portion
35
Represen fative and experimental basins
ISOTOPIC TERMS
Fructionation factor. Ratio of the vapour pressures of the lighter isotopic species of water to
the heavier species.
SMO W . Standard Mean Ocean Water; an arbitrary standard from which relative deviations
of deuterium and oxygen-18 concentrations are determined.
Tritium Unit (T.U.). Unit used to express tritium concentrations.1 Tritium Unit is a concen-
tration of 1 tritium atom in 1018 hydrogen atoms.
Deviafion per thousandfrom SMO W . Unit of deuterium and oxygen-18concentration of water
relative to SMOW.
Isotopic species of water. Water molecules formed by the combination of different isotopes of
hydrogen and oxygen, i.e., H@O, HDO,HPO.
Environmental isotope technique.A method of studying the concentrationsof deuterium,oxygen-
18, tritium and carbon-I4in natural water.
Zsofopic composition of water. The concentrations of isotypes of hydrogen and oxygen in water.
Halfilife.The period of time in which a radioactive species loses half of its original activity.
Radioactive dating. A dating method based on the property of radioactivedecay of radioisotopes.
Pulse dating. A dating method based on the monitoring of a pulse introduced in a system.
36
Introduction
t-
3 W
w mmmnmNmmmm, b b
rnrn
m m m m m ~ m m m m r nm m
%8
c?t
rnmmrnrn~~rnrnrnrnm
0 0 0 0 0 “ 0 0 0 0 ~ õö
O 0 I I I 0 0 0 0 0 N 0 0 0 0 0 loo
N
37
Representative and experimental basins
.-o
I
-B
B
O
.--
.
I I I I I I I I I I
a
B
.-
aO
Fl-F
mwrnmrn
w - m m m
c mclrnrnrn
c \ 1 \ 0 0 0 0
.B
I I I I I I I I I I I I I I lhioooo
E
I I I
.
2.2.
I 'E.'E.i.i.c'
I I I I I I I I I I
I I
q"
I I sz" s I ks I i&
o
--aa
fi
.-
-a
3 T
,CI:
.-8
I
m
E
38
00
t ?g
I 21 I I40
rn
t.
QI
I % i I
I .i I I
3 3 3 3 3
L 4
444444
L L4 I4 I . .
. .
. .
I*
39
Representative and experimental basins
Ft-r-r-r-t-r-r-t-r-
3 m m m m m m m m m m
- m m m m m m m m m m
~ m m m m m m m m m m
9999999999
I~oooooooooo I I I
I I
40
Introduction
References
1. ACADEMYOF SCIENCES OF THE U.S.S.R. (ed.) 1952. Terwiinologia mekhaniki zhidkosti
(gidromekhaniki) [Terminology of fluid mechanics]. Moscow.
2. ALTOVSKY, M. E. (ed.) 1962. Spravochnik gidrogeologa [Manual for hydrogeologists].
Moscow, Gisgeoltehizdat.
3. BARKOV,A. S. 1958. Slovar-spravochnik po jìzichesko i geograjìi [Glossary of physical
geography]. 4th ed. Moscow, Uchpedgiz.
BAUR,A. J. 1952. Soil and water conservation glossary. J. Soil Water Cons., 49 :41-52.
~ 5: BEFANY, A. N.et al. 1959. Experimentalnye issledovania poverkhnostnogo stoka i metody
obobschenia opytnogo materiala [Experimentalinvestigationsof overland flow and methods
I
of interpreting observational data].Proc. Third All-Union Hydrological Congress,p. 44451.
I 6. BLIDARU, S. 1965. Emploi des bassins représentatifs et des stations expérimentales à l'étude
des phénomènes hydrologiques. IASH publ. no. 66, 1 : 107-15.
7. BRITISHHYDROGRAPHIC DEPARTMENT, ADMIRALTY. 1938. Admiralty weather manual.
London, HMSO.
8. BRITISHMETEOROLOGICAL OFFICE. 1939. The meteorological glossary. London, H M S O .
9. CAMPBELL, D.A. 1951.Types of soil erosion prevalent in New Zealand.IASH publ. no. 35,
p. 82-95, Brussels.
10. CHEBOTAREV, A. I. n.d. Gidrologichesky slovar [Glossary of hydrology].Leningrad, Gidro-
meteoizdat.
11. COLBY, B. R. 1964. Scour and 511 in sand-bed streams. (USGS Prof. paper 462-D.)
12. CORMARY, Y. 1965. Le bassin expérimental en tant qu' outil de recherche en matière de
conservation des eaux et du sol. IASH publ. no. 66, 1 :201-16. (Symposium of Budapest.)
13. COSTA, J. DA; JACQUET, J. 1965.Presentation of the results of the Unesco/IHD questionnaire
on the representative and experimental basins in the world. IASH Bull. Paris, no. 4.
14. DUB,O. 1965. Experimental and representative basins in Czechoslavakia. IASH publ.
no. 66, 1 : 131-5.
15. GLYMPH, L. M. 1957. Importance of sheet erosion as a source of sediment. Trans. Amer.
Geophys. Un.,38(6) :903-7.
16. INTERNATIONALSOCIETY OF SOIL SCIENCES. 1963.Soil physics terminology.ISSS Bull. no. 23.
(News of Commission I.)
17. JACQUET, J. 1962. Les études d'hydrologie analytique sur bassins versants expérimentaux.
Bull. du CREC Chatou, No. 2.
18. ; CORMARY, Y. 1965. L'étude du cycle de l'eau sur un bassin d'investigation.
L a houille blanche, no. 3.
19. KAYE,G.W.C.;LAHY,T. H.1953. Tables of physical and chemical constants. London,
Longmans, Green.
20. KHROMOV, S. P.;MANONTOVA, L. I. 1963. Meteorologichesky slovar [Glossary of meteo-
rology]. 2nd ed. Leningrad, Gidrometeoizdat.
21. KOVZEL, A. G. 1959. Sostoyanie experimentalnykh issledovaniy protsessov formirovania
vesennege polovodia i perspektivy ikh razvitiya [State of experimental investigations of
spring floods and probability of their prediction]. Proc. Third All-Union Hydrological
Congress, 2 : 566-72.
I
22. LANGBEIN, W . B.; ISERI, K. T. 1960. General introduction and hydrological definitions.
(USGS Water supply paper 1541-A.)
23. LASZLOFFY, W. 1965. Terrains d'études dans les recherches hydrologiques hongroises.
IASH publ. no. 66, 1: 185-9.
24. LEOPOLD, L.B. et al. 1966. Channel and hillslope processes in a semiarid area, p. 193-252
(USGS Prof. paper 352-G.)
25. LINSLEY,R. K. et al. 1949. Applied hydrology. New York, McGraw-Hill.
26. MAKKAVEEVE, A. A. 1961. Slovar po gidrogeologii i inzhenernoy geologii [Glossary of
hydrogeology and engineering geology]. Moscow, Gostoptehizdat.
27. MEINZER, O.E. 1923. Outline of ground-water hydrology. (USGS Water supply paper 494.)
28. OURYVAEV, V. A. 1953. Experimentalnye gidrologicheskie issledovania na Valdae [Experi-
mental hydrological investigations in Valdai]. Leningrad, Gidrometeorizdat.
~ 29. .1956.L'étude expérimentale des éléments du bilan d'eau et des procès de formation
de l'écoulement.Addit au Reczieil des articles pour le Congres Intern. Geogr. Leningrad,
Ed. Hydrometeorologiques.
41
Representative and experimental basins
42
2 Selection and organization
of basin networks
2.0 General
Selection of basins is the first and most importantstage of the organizationof observation
and research on representative and experimental basins. A n incorrect selection of basins
may reduce the value of long-term observations and expensive instrumentation and
throw doubts on the results of the scientific research. It must be realized also that
selection of basins is very difficult.
Difficultiesare caused by the specific requirementsfor representativeand experimental
basins and the lack of clear quantitative criteria for proper selection.
The principal requirement for representative basins is representativeness (the
correspondence of their physiographical characteristics to those of the hydrological
region). It is very difficult to select a basin which is representative of all hydrological
features and to satisfy simultaneously all other requirements. Aspects of selection of
representative basins are discussed in section 2.3.
The greatest problem in selecting experimental basins is the difficulty of finding a
completely homogeneous basin in all respects (e.g.,a basin completely covered by forest
or entirely composed of sandy or clay soils, etc.). Details of selection are given in
section 2.4.
In general, the selection of basins should follow a preparatory and a final stage.
The preparatory stage should be the selection and analysis of topographical,historical
and other reference information for the following purposes : survey of research needs
(see section 1.4);selection of hydrological regions (see section 2.2); selection of basins,
either representative or experimental according to the research objective (see
sections 2.3 and 2.4).
43
Representative and expeuinlental basins
data and on which specific hydrological research is of great scientific and/or economic
interest should be delineated. In these cases factors such as the needs of the country
forhydrologicaldata on given hydrologicalregionsinconnexion with present or proposed
development, access, density of population, etc., should be taken into account.
For the selection of hydrological region maps (if available) on hydrological,climatic,
pedological, vegetational and hydrogeological characteristics should be used (see
section 5.1).
Representative and experimental basins are finally chosen from a collection of possible
sites. This is, in part, achieved by using a small-scaletopographical map to consider
features such as aspect and topography.
Geological, pedological,climatic and land-inventory maps of comparable scale are
also required to check the general physiographical characteristics of the basins. Details
of maps are to be found in section 5.1.
Once a basin has been selected, a most detailed topographical map of the area is
required as a base map. It must be sufficiently accurate to minimize analysis errors.
The map may be simplified (e.g. to show only drainage patterns) but its main use is
in the location and storage of data in the field. Completed survey maps should never
be discarded.
Maps of basin geology, pedology, climate and observational sites, if not available,
must be obtained before the major flow and precipitation sampling positions can be
determined. Additional maps of vegetation, land use and historical record may also
assist in establishing patterns within the basin. Historical maps are extremely valuable
in building up the historical background to the basins.
As the studies develop, similar,but more detailed maps are required and new maps
of basin characteristics will become available.Master sites,for example,require detailed
hydrological soil surveys.
44
Selection aiid organization of besitz rietworks
45
Representative and experimental basins
Next the lithological conditions were studied from the geological map. Apart from
three limited sectors of sedimentary terrain covering a small area in the extreme south,
atthecentreand in theextremenorth-east,the whole of the basin was made up of normally
impermeable pre-Cambrian terrain. Three classes of ascending permeability were
adopted as follows:
KI Impermeable terrain with a pre-Cambrian base;
KZ Slightly permeable terrain with localized ground water;
K3 Permeable terrain.
Topography was subsequently considered, using a mean slope factor computed from
I=Lx/L, where Iis the mean slopefactor and a the variation in basin elevation(considering
only those altitudes which have approximately 5 per cent of the superficial area of
the basin above and below them) and L the length of the equivalent rectangle of the
basin. This slope factor was computed for basins from 300 to 500 k m 2 within the
Rio Jaguaribe from a 1 :500,000map, making no allowance for the larger rivers. This
resulted in four classes of relief for an area of 500 km2:
SI Very slight slopes, < 1.25m/km.;
SZ Slight slopes, between 1.25and 2.5 m/km.;
S3 Moderate slopes,between 2.5 and 5 m/km.;
S4 Reasonably steep slopes, between 5 and 12.5 m/km.
No other factor was introduced; the vegetation was uniform, partly savannah with
scattered scrub (caatinga) and partly cultivated vegetation which did not effectively
protect the soil during the rainy season.
The various boundaries of climate, geology and geomorphology were traced on a
1 :100,000map and the pairing of the factors PIand P3, KIand K3, and SI and S4
revealed eighteen hydrological regions as follows:
1. P~K~SI 7. P2KzSi 13. PzKiS4
2. P3KzSa 8. PzKzS3 14. PIKYSI
3. P3K2S4 9. PzKzS4 15. PIK&
4. P3KiS3 10. PzKiSi 16. PiKiSi
5. P~KIS~ 11. PzKiS2 17. PIK&
6. P2K3Si 12. P2KiS3 18. PiKiS4
For the above study it was considered that a representativebasin established in P3KzS4
would also represent all groupings of KZwith S3 or S4 irrespective of the value of P.
A basin within P~KISI could be used for the groupings of Ki with Si and SZirrespective
of the value of P.The K3Si combination stands on its own and the remainder (the
larger area of the basin) can be covered by KiS3 or KiS4 [I, 21.
46
Selection and organization of basin networks
47
Representative and experimental basins
areas of N e w Zealand [9],and for these regions the classificationand dominant land
use are:
Region Dominant land rise
FIG.2.1. Map showing hydrological regions of part of the South Island,New Zealand.
48
&ekctioi~ end organization of basin networks
combination with other physiographical factors (relief, geology, soils, vegetation) and
on the other hand by works carried out for economic reasons in dra'inageareas and
river channels. The division was based on hydrological observation data obtained at
base stations [4,li].
In dividing the territory, the following characteristicswere used :
1. Hydrological and climatic features, taking-into account the genetic type of hydro-
logical regimen and character of the stream recharge:
Type I-rivers with floods caused by snowmelt;
Type II-rivers with floods caused by snowmelt and rainfall;
Type III-rivers with floods caused by rainfall.
Periods of low water with ground-water recharge were also taken into account.
2. Orographical featurestaking account of the relief of basins and surroundingterritory.
3. Zonality features taking account of the hydrological regimen of rivers in plains
and in mountains of the main geographical zones.
In dividing into hydrological regions the following features were considered:(a) homo-
geneity of conditions of run-off(annual, seasonal), amplitude of flood peaks (snowmelt
and rainfall) and minimum (summer and winter) discharges; (b) variations of annual
discharge; (c) precipitation distribution in the region; (d) mean annual and annual
discharge variations; (e) duration of ice effects, dry and cold periods, periods of no
flow for intermittent and wholly frozen rivers.
Indices of drainage density, basin shape, river slope, lake and swamp type, karstic
features, etc., were also used.
The division was made by analysis, carried out in the following order, of annual flow
hydrographs:
1. The river regimen was studied by comparing flow hydrographs for the whole period
of observation, first those of individual rivers and then those of adjacent ones.
2. Rivers with homogeneous regimens were distinguished and were then classified into
separate types (groups) or subtypes (subgroups) of hydrological regimen.
3. Areas with riversof homogeneoushydrologicalregimenwere indicated on hypsometric
maps and their boundaries plotted. (Care was taken to ensure that regions were
neither too large nor too small so that regimen features could be relatively stable.)
4. Boundaries of regions were compared with distinct physiographical features (relief,
climate, geological structure, soils and vegetation).
5. Hydrological indices and their correlation with physiographical factors within the
region and between individual regions were indicated.
After the division was finished,a list of regions with brief, characteristic main features
of the hydrological regimen and river discharge was made.
To illustrate hydrological division,that of the Upper Volga territory (including the
Volga basin up to the town of Cheboksary) is given. In accordance with the present
hydrologicalmacro-division,the riversof the regionare referred to four largehydrological
regions (macro-regions), i.e.,to rivers of forest zone (Ly1 and Lyz) and to rivers of
steppe-temperatezone (Cy1 and Cy,).
Zonal differences between these regions are caused by the fact that, while rivers
of the first two (northern) regions (Ly1 and Lyz) are characterized by the presence of
spring snowmelt floods and summer and autumn rainfall floods, rivers of the second
two (southern) regions (Cy1 and Cyz) are characterized only by spring snowmelt floods
and summer rainfall floods.
Interzonal differences between the eastern and western regions (i.e., between Lyi
and Lyz and between Cy1 and Cy,) are caused by the fact that the boundary of winter
thawing weather lies between them (i.e.,January mean monthly isotherm -10" to -12").
This is why, in the more western regions (Lyz and Cyz), there are not only summer and
autumn floods due to rainfall but also winter floods due to thaw which are rarely if
ever found in the eastern regions (Lyl and Cy,).
49
Representative and experiniental basins
1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 Hydrological sub-regions
Hills
Index of the region Precipifalion (mm) Run-off (mm) Evaporalion (mm) Run-ofl coeficienf
51
Representative and experimental basins
52
Selection and organization of basin networks
purpose, a small basin will afford a better instrumentation provided that this does not
lead, at least in arid or semi-arid zones, to basins where subsurface flow cannot be
calculated.
In general, the representative basin should be so small that its sensitivity to high-
intensity rainfalls of short duration is not suppressed by channel characteristics.
53
Representative and experimental basins
characteristics. Unless the basin can be wholly owned or leased for the duration of
the experiment, it is not worth while to proceed with the research.
(b) Operation of basin. The topographical and access conditions must be such that
the required land-useand land-managementpractices to be used can be carried out.
Access must be good for detailed research observations and in some cases opportunity
must exist for buildings,either temporary or permanent,to be erected for management
and/or research staff. Since experimental basins are, by definition,small basins, roads
within the basin can have a very large effect on the hydrology and should be kept to
an absolute minimum and be installed before the experiment is started.
(c) Uniformity of soil, vegetation and geomorphology. Where possible a basin should
be a simple soil-vegetationcomplex based on broad soil-vegetation groupings (see
section 2.2.3). While a definite methodology for research on experimental basins is
not clear (see section 6.3), the selection of a basin on a soil-vegetationcomplex which
is typical of a large area will aid in the ultimate translation of the research results.
To facilitate research,a basin with simple geomorphologicalcharacteristics must be
selected if possible.Many depressions (small swamps) will,for instance,create storage
problems which are difficult to handle in analyses.Basins with many ‘cones’(sometimes
found in volcanic areas) are likewise difficult to handle analytically.
(d) Deep percolation and channel infiltration. This requirement is similar to that
for representativebasins.Deep percolation is,however,relatively large on small basins,
especially on the more permeable soils, and must be accepted as a variable factor.
The prevention of channel infiltration is relatively more important on small basins
and, if channel infiltration occurs, either an alternative basin must be selected or the
channel sealed.
(e) Aspect and climatic variability. In mountainous regions it is desirable that the
basin aspect is such that very shady and sunny faces do not exist simultaneously in
the basin, since moisture conditions may be entirely different on these different faces
and make analyses of data very complicated.Where replicationof basins is used,basins
should, if possible, have a similar aspect.
(f) Flow measurement. Where possible perennial or intermittent flow is preferred
to provide a measure of subsurface flow during periods of run-off.Where conditions
are such that only ephemeral streams are encountered, it is important that the basin
size be large enough to ensure that during and shortly after stormsthe totalflow measured
at the gauging station includes some interflow. A sharp distinction between surface
and subsurfaceflow is artificial and some interflow must be measured to carry out basic
research and to aid in the ultimate translation of the research results to other areas.
Basins should be provided with a self-rated measuring structure providing for
continuous, accurate measurement of flow (see section 4.3.4).
(g) Provisional observations. Before a basin is finally selected it is advisable to make
provisional topographical, geological and pedological investigations (see section 5.i).
It is also often useful,before the basin is finally selected,to carry out some provisional
flow and precipitation measurements to estimate possible floods and minimum flows
and to estimatewhether flow and precipitationcan be measured with sufficient accuracy.
54
Selection and organization of basin networks
the effect of a cultural change on the hydrological regimen to aid the translation of
results to natural basins, it is desirable to set up a number of plots of varying sizes
(these could even include natural basins). The establishment of run-off plots is not
recommended except when there are operating experimental basins available.
Plots should be organized on slopes within an experimental basin and should occupy
a whole slope or part of a slope. They may differ in area from tens of square metres
up to several hectares, depending on the experimental programme.
In arid zones where the water yield per unit area is very small, the dimensions of
run-off plots may be greater than those in humid zones. The increase in area of plots
provides an increase of accuracy of the results obtained, because of the increase of
measured volume of flowing water and, consequently, decrease of the relative error.
Very small run-off plots, especially those with artificial boundaries, should not be
used, because their necessary isolation from their surroundingsprevents their conforming
to a natural state.
In some cases the number of plots is considerable; this depends on the number of
factors studied, on the number of experiments and on the finance available.
From an economic point of view it is expedient to locate plots in pairs or groups
with mutual boundary walls, thus reducing the cost of their construction.
Principal requirements for the selection of sites for run-off plots are :
1. A natural slope surface not disturbed by soil work and roads and free of hillocks,
saucer-form depressions and other kinds of relief roughness causing a distortion
of natural flow formation.
2. The possibility of locating boundary side walls, perpendicular to contour lines.
3. Even slope, free of sudden breaks over the whole plot.
4. Equal bedding depth of a confining stratum.
5. The absence of ground-water outflow to the soil surface.
6. Homogeneity of vegetal cover, soils and subsoil over the whole plot.
7. The possibilities of collecting all the water flowing from the plot, of passing it to
the gauge and of draining the water flowing to the plot from adjacent slopes.
In solving individual problems the requirements need to be specified and extended.
While selecting sites for run-off plots, it is necessary to provide for the possibility of
performing observations on them under both natural and experimental conditions,
e.g.,using artificial sprinkling,varying soil moisture content, cultivating soil by modern
methods and performing other agrotechnicai and forest-improvement arrangements.
55
Representative and experimental basins
Maintenance of similarity of these characteristics between the basin and the region
it represents must guarantee the future satisfactory representativeness of the basin.
Wrong selection of representative basins is often due to insufficient knowledge of the
characteristics of both the entire region and the selected basin. For this reason reliable
estimation of basin representativeness must be based on more detailed data of these
characteristics or on special field investigations.
In selecting and operating basins to study the effect of individual catchment
characteristics on the hydrological regimen, estimation of representativeness is based
on the utilization of observations already made during definite time intervals. The
principal criteria determining basin representativenessare the degree of possible influence
of the given catchment characteristic on the unknown hydrological parameter (established
on the ground of Observationaldata) and a comparison of this influencewith the probable
error of this parameter.
References
1. DUBREUIL, P. 1964. The layout of basins representing homogeneous hydrological regions.
Trans. Inter-Regional Seminar, Bangkok. (UN Water resources series, no. 27.)
2. ___ . 1965. Contribution a I’étude d’implantation de bassins représentatifs de régions
hydrologiques homogènes. Paris. (Cahier Orstom d’hydrologie, no. 2.)
3. GIBBS, H.S. 1963. Soils of New Zealand and their limitations for pastoral use. Proc. N.Z.
Inst. Agric. Sci., 9.
4. Kuzm, P. S. 1960. Klassifikatsia rek i gidrologicheskoe raionirovanie SSSR [River classi-
fication and territorial division of the U.S.S.R.into hydrological regions]. Leningrad,
Gidrometeoizdat.
5. LANGBEIN, W . B.;HARDISON, C.H.1955. Extending streamflow data. Proc. ASCE, paper
826, vol. 81, 13 p.
6. LÁZLÓFFY,W.;SZESZTAY, K.1963. Organization of a hydrologic service. UN Conference
on the Application of Science and Technology for the Benefit of the Less Developed Areas.
Geneva.
7. SZESZTAY,K. 1965. O n principles of establishing hydrological representative and experi-
mental areas. IASH pubi. no. 66, 1 :64-75. (Symposium of Budapest.)
8. TOEBES, C.;NEEF, G.1962.Regional hydrology.Hydrology and land management, p. 76-80.
Wellington, S C and RCC.
9. TOEBES, C.1965. The planning of representative and experimental basin networks in N e w
Zealand. IASH publ. no. 66. (Symposium of Budapest.)
10. TOUCHEBEUF DE LUSSIGNY, P. 1965. Etude des bassins versants représentatifs de lo00 k m 2
en Afrique tropicale.ZASHpubl. no. 66,p. 320-4. (Symposium of Budapest.)Paris,Orstom.
56
‘ 3 Planning of observations
according to the research
obJectlves
3.1 General
The programme of observations o n representative and experimental basins depends
on the objectives of the research and on the natural conditions of the region.
It is naturally impossible to define a standard, uniform programme of observations
that would suit every hydrological region. Moreover, the observational programme
for representative basins generally differs from the programme for experimental basins.
Observational programmes for similar types of basin located in similar hydrological
regions may differ because of differences in research objectives, availability of finance
and personnel, etc.
A few general principles are given below which will aid in formulating a programme
for any one basin. It should be noted that the programme must be clearly defined
before any basin is established (see section 1.4).It may not be necessary,or even possible,
to study all the items listed in the examples given below. For instance, if snow does
not fall on the basin the need for snow measurement is obviated or if erosion is negligible
no erosion and sedimentation studies are required. In general, hydrological research
o n representative and experimental basins leads to two types of result: the estimation
of characteristic parameters, or comparisons by means of statistical tests. Consequently,
the value of the result and the degree of accuracy obtained depend in the first place
on the length of the observational period.
A reduction of the observational period may be made in many cases if correlations
can be established between hydrological variables from the research basin and other
basins in the same hydrological region (for instance, correlations of rainfall data from
research basins with rainfall data from the national network). If such correlations
are sufficiently high, the accuracy of the estimation of the relevant parameters (as
characterized, for instance, by a confidence band) may be considerably improved.
Representative and experimental basins normally have different observational periods.
O n representative basins observations are, as a rule, long term. They should include
at least several years (or periods) with high and low flows to establish the natural run-off
pattern typical of the area. O n experimental basins, the observational period m a y be
as short as a few years or seasons. This would apply, for instance, if the effect of soil
cultivation on the flow pattern were studied. In other cases, such as the study of the
effect of afforestation on the hydrological regimen, the observational period is perforce
of longer duration. In all cases, the need to obtain reliable results is of prime importance
and particular reference should be made to section 6.3 [7].
51
Representative and experimental basins
3.1.1.2 Observational programme for representative basins used for the study of
the effect, on the hydrological regimen, of natural changes (benchmark and
vigil basins)
The study of the effect, on the hydrological regimen, of a natural change (for instance,
climatic or geomorphological) is extremely difficult.The basin, and consequently the
hydrologicalcharacteristics,is in a continuous change and this ‘non-stationary’
condition
58
Planning of observations according to the research objectives
of the basin is difficult to analyse (see section 6.2.2). The observational programme
must therefore allow for rather precise observations of certain basic elements.
Climatic changes are usually long term and changes over a shorter period are within
the natural variability of observed phenomena. For this reason, a study of micro-climatic
changes may be more productive. As an example of the observational requirements
for an expected geomorphological change, the following programme should be regarded
as a minimum: flow, precipitation, climate, soil frost, erosion and sedimentation, and
geomorphology.
59
Representative and experimental basins
The study of the effect of various soil cultivationmethods on the hydrological regimen,
for instance,has as main parameters firstly the principal elements of the water balance
(irrespective of whether the basin is in a natural forest area, etc.), specific parameters
which are dictated by the problem (in this case, e.g., soil physical, micro-climaticand
similar characteristics) and the local physiographical conditions which may be
characterized by variations in soils,vegetation, climate,etc. Cultural changes are many
and the importance of each may vary from country to country. Important ones
recommended by the Unesco Working Group on the Influence of M a n on the
Hydrological Cycle are:
1. Afforestation, deforestation and modifications to forest vegetation.
2. The drainage of swamps by the control of surface water and the substitution of
useful vegetation for relatively useless vegetation.
3. Changes in vegetational cover imposed by the deliberate production of rain-grown
or irrigated crops.
4. Changes in surface water distributionby controland diversion for power production,
irrigation and other purposes.
5. Vegetational changes causing soil erosion and soil conservation works.
6. Imposition of urban and industrial development on natural conditions.
7. Changes in water quality due to a deterioration in vegetative cover.
8. Exploitationof ground-waterreservesleading to changesin surface-waterdistribution.
Section 6.3 describes general analysis techniques from which observationalprogrammes
may be derived (see also section 2.4, ‘Selection of experimental basins’). Particular
methods used in the U.S.S.R. to establish observational programmes on experimental
basins are given in section 3.3.
3.2.1 Precipitation
Precipitationis one of the most importanthydrologicalelements.The exact determination
of the amount of precipitation, its type (hail, snow, rainfall, dew, etc.), its origin
(convectional, cyclonic,orographical) and the knowledge of its spatial and temporal
distribution,governs the reliability of water-balancecalculations and the various relations
with hydrological characteristics (e.g., surface and subsurface flow,evaporation, soil
erosion, etc.).
Types of precipitation gauge and numbers required in any one basin are discussed
in section 4.2.1. The following measurements should be made on representative and
experimental basins :
1. Precipitation measurement daily, or twice daily, by a manual gauge with a visual
determination of the precipitation type (rainfall,snow,hail,etc.). The characteristics
of falling precipitation (storm, drizzle, etc.) and an indication of the continuity
(in hours) of the precipitation should also be recorded.
60
Planning of observations according to the research objectives
The use of manual gauges only on a basin provides basic data for: (a) the
determination of the mean basin precipitation for periods of one day or more;
(b) the developmentofrelations between precipitationand hydrologicalcharacteristics
for relatively long periods (month,season,year); and (c) the study of the formation
of floods on relatively large basins where the time lag exceeds one day.
2. Continuous recording of precipitation by means of recording rain gauges. Recording
rain gauges are essential on small basins for the determination of the mean basin
precipitation for periods of less than one day; for studies of flood formation on
basins where the time lag is in the order of hours or less; and for the determination
of intensity-frequency-durationrelations for various hydrological regions (for
instance, for estimation of peak flows for various frequencies for the design of
hydraulic structures).
3. Long-term measurements by storage gauge. These are manual gauges used in
mountainousregions and observations are made at intervals of more than one day.
A mixture ofthe three types of gauge is often employed. Utilization of the data available
for any particular purpose is described in section 5.3.1.
3.2.2 Interception
Interceptionobservations are made on vegetated areas to determine the net precipitation
(see section 1.5) that partakes in the infiltration or overland flow processes.Interception
is particularly important on small basins and may also be a major factor on experimenta1
basins where changes in vegetation are planned.
The amount of interception depends on the type of vegetative cover,its density and
stagein evolution,and also on the type,rate and falling characteristicsofthe precipitation.
Interception storage has a definite limit. Low-intensity precipitation, the amount of
which does not exceed the interception storage, is generally intercepted completely.
With high precipitation intensities,a relatively smaller amount is intercepted.Stem-flow
observations may be important in certain types of vegetation.
Snow is intercepted mainly by crowns of trees, especially conifers. Shrubby and
herbaceous vegetation greatly influences the interception of snow.
Interception involves complex sampling problems, especially in forested areas. A
failure of past investigations has been the inadequate description of the phytomorpho-
logical characteristics of the plots sampled.Details are given in sections 4.2.3 and 4.6.
61
Representative and experimental basins
3.2.3.2 Snowmelt
To calculate and predict spring flood hydrographs it is essential to obtain data on
snowmelt intensity and on the rate of water yield from the snow cover.
A study of snowmelt can be made by any of the following methods: energy balance;
water balance (including simplified variants of this method) ; and empirical methods
using certain climatological factors, e.g., air temperature (see section 4.2.2.1).
Depending on the method used and the accuracy required,the programme planning
for snow investigations during snowmelt should include observations as follows.
(a) When the energy-balancemethod is used, actinometric observations are made to
determine the radiation balance of the snow cover and climatological observations
are necessary to determine the heat exchange in the atmosphere (turbulent heat and
moisture exchange). This requires observations on the following: downward all-wave
radiation (hemisphericalradiation of both short-and long-wavelengths),upward short-
wave radiation (albedo), net exchange of all-waveradiation (difference between upward
all-waveand downward all-wave)(see section 4.2.5.3), snow surface temperature,wind
velocity, air temperature and humidity at 200 c m above the snow cover. In regions
with a shallow depth of snow cover (lessthan 20 cm) and dominant solar type of snowmelt
(radiation snowmelt), additional observations of radiation penetrating into the snow
and absorbed by the soil surface are required.
(b) When the water-balance method is used the following observations should be
made: depth and density of snow cover,amount of liquid water content in snow pack,
precipitation, evaporation from snow surface, percentage of snow-cover area over
the basin.
62
Planning of observations according to the research objectives
3.2.4 Condensation
Condensation is important only in desert and semi-desert regions with a continental
climate and great daily variations in temperature and, frequently, with sandy soils.
Some workers consider that the condensation on the surface.of frozen land is a significant
part of the total amount of moisture input in basins located in the permafrost zone.
In some mountain regions,intense hoar-frostformation is observed on trees and rocks
which are exposed to the wind.
D e w gauges (see section 4.2.1.3.6)are used for observation of condensation but
quantities observed lie frequently within the natural variability of the observations
and problems of the representativeness of the observations have not yet been solved.
3.2.5 Evaporation
Evaporation from the water surface and from the soil and snow cover and evapo-
transpiration are not necessarily to be studied on every representative and experimental
basin. In the simplest case, with the minimum observational programme for a
representativebasin,evapotranspirationmay be determined by the water-balancemethod
as a difference between precipitationand run-offwithout taking into accountsoil-moisture
conditions. This method is suitable only for long periods.
The study of evaporation for shorter periods requires a more complex observational
programme and in some cases may need detailed measurements of evaporation from
the soil and/or evapotranspiration,taking into account the dynamics of soil moisture,
and, in some cases, the utilization of the energy-balance method.
If several vegetative covers occur on any one basin, special investigations can be
carried out (especially on experimental basins) to determine the transpiration of various
types of vegetative cover by means of weighing evaporimeters and by determining
the difference between evapotranspiration and evaporation from the soil.
Observations of evaporation from the water surface and the snow cover are not
necessarily required on all basins, but on only a selected network of representative
and experimental basins, where such observations are carried out according to specific
problems and specialprogrammes.Climatologicalobservations,which usually accompany
evaporation measurements, include observations of precipitation, evaporating surface
temperature, air temperature, humidity and wind velocity. For the sake of economy
such observations are made at the same climatological station, located on the given
basin,or close to it. Similar principles may be used to carry out observations of energy-
balance components.
63
Repuesenlaiive and experimental basins
the following relations should be held in mind when measuring evaporation from
water surfaces:
1. Climatic conditions determine the duration of the evaporation period, the long-term
evaporation value, the interseasonal distribution and long-term evaporation
fluctuation.
2. Evaporation intensity depends on a combination of climatological factors.
3. The surroundings of the reservoir (relief, vegetative cover, height of shores and
their wind protection, towns and villages in the neighbourhood, etc.) govern the
transformation of the air flux coming from the land. This factor influences greatly
the intensity of evaporation from smallreservoirswith a surfacearea ofless than 5 km2.
4. Geometricalcharacteristicssuch as the area,configurationand depth of the reservoir
influence the evaporation on various parts of the water area.
To elucidate the above relations it may be necessary to carry out the following:
1. Observations by 20 m2 tank (to be organized only on selected representative and
experimental basins,if there are lakes and reservoirs within the area of these basins
and if they appear particularly suitable).
2. Observations by GGI-3000 pan (used on the station network in the U.S.S.R.),
by Class A pan (used on the station network in the U.S.A.), or by any other standard
pan, installed on land or in the middle of a lake on a raft. Observations by any of
these pans should be made until the establishment of an international standard
evaporation pan.
3. Observations, with either 1 or 2 above, of: (a) preCipitation; (b) water-surfacz
temperature in the tank or pan, and in the reservoir;(c) air temperature,humidity
and wind velocity.
3.2.5.2 Evapotranspiration
Evapotranspiration is one of the most important elements of the water balance. The
process of evaporation from land surfaces is complex and depends on the interaction
ofa relatively largenumber of variables,theimportantonesbeing climaticand vegetational
characteristics and subsurface water conditions.
The important methods used in estimating evapotranspiration are discussed in
section4.2.4.All methods have their drawbacks and few have proved to be very accurate,
although a most extensive estimation by evaporimeters has proved successful in the
U.S.S.R. Where the measurements are carried out correctly,the estimation procedure
is simple and gives a direct value of the evaporation. Observations should include
climatological variables such as air temperature, humidity,cloudiness,wind velocity,
precipitation and soil temperature and, in addition, soil-moisturemeasurements and
observations on the state and growth of the vegetation.
In some cases the energy-balancemethod can be used as a check and in such cases
complete actinometric observations are required as well.
Evaporation values estimated by evaporimeter are useful for the comparison of
evapotranspiration from various types of vegetation under various moisture conditions.
In certain regions of the world (e.g.,in arid regions and in countries with a continental
climate), evaporation from snow may be relatively large,thus constituting a significant
part of the water balance.
In such regions it is necessary to obtain data on evaporation from the snow pack;
such data are useful not only for solvingwater-balanceproblems but also for investigating
spring snowmeltby means of the water-balancetechnique.
64
Planning of observations according to the research objectives
~
TABLE
3.1
65
Representative and experimental basins
66
Planning oj observations according to the research objectives
67
Representafive and experimental basins
(d) Observation wells are sited in such a way that they are representative of the
hydrological region if possible. This will aid in the translation of results.
(e) A network of observation wells on representativebasins is required for the study
of the regional ground-water regimen. This network is not generally as dense as one
required for experimental basins (where research is directed towards an understanding
of the ground-water regimen and the relation of hydrogeological characteristics to
other hydrological variables).
(f) Observation wells are usually established over a period of several years;the first
to be installedare the most importantones,which reflecttheregimenof the major aquifers.
Observations of ground-water levels are carried out once in 3-5 days in all wells;
during high-intensityrainfalls and during snowmelt every day, and during dry periods
once in 5-10 days.
Some observation wells are equipped with automatic recorders. Where measurement
of the ground-waterenergy potential is required,piezometers are installed.Observations
of ground-watertemperature are carried out simultaneouslywith water-levelobservations,
but only on a selected network of wells, this network being selected to be typical of
the major aquifers.
Observations of ground-waterdischarge are carried out on streams fed by ground-
water springs by means of regular discharge measurements.
Water sampling for water quality is carried out on a selected network of observation
wells at the end of every season and about 3-5 times during occurrences of a high
ground-watertable at the beginning of the rise, in the middle, at the crest and during
the recession.
For the calculation of ground-water storage and yield the following characteristics of
aquifers are determined :
1. The dimensions (geometry) of water-bearing geological formations, the thickness
of aquifers and hydrological formation constants such as: porosity,pore volume,
effective porosity, specific retention, and specific yield.
2. The followingaquifer constantsand the hydraulicpropertiesof aquifers:the coefficient
of permeability (hydraulic conductivity); the coefficientof transmissibility;the coeffi-
cientof storage;the piezometrichead;and the hydraulicgradient or piezometricslope.
The aquifer constants,by which hydraulic properties of the aquifer are characterized,
are determined by pumping tests. For evaluating the results of pumping tests in Europe
the equilibrium methods (Dupuit, Thiem) are used, while in the United States the
non-equilibrium ones (Theis, Jacob, etc.) are mostly used.
Ground-water storage is generally estimated by multiplying the thickness of the
aquifer by the specific yield. The hydraulic gradient is calculated by means of
ground-watercontour maps (hydroisohypsal maps) or by direct measurement of water
levels in wells. The thickness of aquifers is determined with the aid of hydrogeological
survey data and hydroisohypsal maps.If such data are not available,data from water-table
observations are used [4].
For details of an analysis of hydrogeological characteristics, see sections 6.1.1.4
and 6.1.4.4.
3.2.8 Infiltration
Infiltrationis one of the most important processes in hydrology and one of the least
satisfactory as regards accuracy of determination. It is recommended, nevertheless,
that on all experimental basins infiltration be included in the programme.
68
Plaiitiing of observations according to the research objectives
Infiltration measurements are made by laboratory methods such as those carried out
by the U.S.S.R. in large soil monoliths with undisturbed profiles at various rates of
moisture and frost, by infiltrometer in the field (see section 4.5) and by infiltration
analysis (see section 6.1.3.3).
The programme should be directed to obtain infiltration data or indices for basins.
This may require an approach by more than one method on any one basin.In addition,
theoretical studies of subsurface flow measurement (see section 6.1.4.3) will aid in
understanding the infiltration processes and will consequently aid the interpretation
of results.
3.2.9 Glaciers
Glaciers,as accumulators of abundant water resources in the solid phase, are important
for water-resources investigation and nations with glacial regions should include a
glacial basin in the representative basin network.
Observations should ultimately be directed towards determination of a water balance
and an energy balance, together with detailed photogrammetric surveys carried out
at regular intervals (e.g.,every five years).
In the past, glacier observations have frequently been restricted to only one or two
of the above objectives or only a part of one, and it has been found generally that
results have not been sufficiently informative.
Initial observations on glaciers should include items 1 to 6 below. Observations 7to 9
may be made later in the study.
1. Continuous flow measurement on the stream emerging from the glacier.
2. Regular measurement of the ablation of the glacier and surveys at the tongue of
the glacier.
3. Climatological observations at one or more points to indicate typical conditions
for the glacier (wind, temperature, humidity, solar radiation, etc.).
4. Precipitation measurements.
5. Snow surveys.
6. Photogrammetric surveys.
7. Glacier volume measurements by seismic methods.
8. Special observations for energy-balance calculations (albedo measurements, glacial
air circulation, etc.).
9. Temperaturesurvey of glaciers (ice temperature measurement at the depth of constant
temperature and deeper).
In some countries run-offplots are also installed in glacial basins for specific,detailed
studies.
Glacial studies are frequently made difficultby lack of access and require careful
consideration of the programme of observation required before they are classified as
representative basins.
Since representative basins with glaciers are likely to be few in number, no details
are given in the guide except for flow and climatological observationsand snow surveys
(see Chapter 4).
69
Representative and experimental basins
on the basin; (d) prediction of silting rate of ponds and reservoirs. In basins where
erosion is severe, the programme should provide, where possible, for micro-levelling
of run-off plots and volumetric measurements of eroded materials, as well as for
sediment-dischargemeasurements. In such cases it is useful to make surveys and
measurements of rills and gullies. The study of siltation of ponds and reservoirs is
carried out mainly by volumetric surveys.
The following data should be obtained :
1. On run-off plots: (a) total amount of slope erosion; (b) mechanical composition
of the eroded material.
2. On stream channels: (a) annual suspended-sedimentdischarge;(b) data on bed-load
discharge; (c) mechanical composition of bed load and bed materials; (d) rate of
reservoir silting (if applicable).
For details of observational methods, see section 5.6.For analysis techniques see
section 6.1.5.
70
Planning of observations according to the research objectives
bottom and, owing to the continual increase of the thickness of the ice cover, some
water m a y infiltrate into the channel bed so that, if the stream is in the permafrost
zone, there is no flow at all.
Where large ice formations or naleds1 occur, a considerable amount of water m a y
I be temporarily stored in the channel and observations of formation,melt, ice thickness,
ice conditions, ice dams and ice jams may be required. Such observations should be
taken not only at the gauging station, but along the entire stream length.
l 1. Caused by freezing of water discharging through cracks in the ice cover on the surface,
or by discharge of ground water on to the surface with subsequent freezing.
71
Representative and experimental basins
72
Plaririing of observations accorditig to the research objectives
73
Representative and experimental basins
Correct selection of the basins is important for the success of the experiment and for
the reliability of the results. Details are given in section 2.4.
References
1. KHARCHENKO, S. I. 1964. Zadachi i metodika issledovaniy i raschetov vodnogo balansa
oroshaemykh zemel [Tasks and methods of water balance research and computation for
irrigated lands]. Materialy mezhduvedomstvennogo soveschania po problerne izuchenia i
regulirovania isparenia s vodnoy povorkhnosti i pochvy (30 July-3 August 1963), p. 285-300.
Valdai, GGI.
2. ~ . 1966. Osnovnye polozhenia programmy kompiexnykh vodnobaiansovykh i
agrometeorologicheskikh nabludeniy, metodika rascheta vodnogo balansa i kharakteristik
74
Planning of observations according to the research objectives
75
4 Methods of observation
and instrurnentation
76
Methods OJ observation ancl Nistrtiaieiiiation
5. All the rules and directions given in the instruction should be followed.
Observers should be provided with a brief written instructionfor every type of observation
which is not included in the standard written procedures used by the hydrological
and meteorological services of the country.
Such an instruction should contain the following:detailed description of instruments
with diagrams;recommendationson routine care and action to be taken in the event of
breakage or malfunctioning; procedure for taking readings; times of observation;
guidance and direction on making non-routine observations (e.g., during floods,
rainstorms,etc.); procedure for checking charts and tapes;completion of field notebook;
procedure of primary processing of observational data.
The observer should not be limited to regular observations only. Visual observations
(without instruments) on atmospheric phenomena and weather changes which may
affect any element of the hydrological regimen should be taken when necessary. Such
visual observations are of great importance during rainstorms and floods; for example,
the water level during a flood should be marked at several points along the stream if
the gauging structures are submerged by flood waters.
Sampling techniques are discussed in section 4.1.1.These cannot always be followed
and simpler methods may be necessary in some circumstances. A description of the
minimum equipment required for research on representative and experimental basins
is given in section 4.12.A discussion of this equipment and any special equipment
that might be required is given below.
Methods used are correlation [65, 1411 and stochastic treatment [li, 701. In some
cases,testing the representativenessof the sample by testing the data from an equivalent
time period of another hydrological variable for which a longer record is available
may increase the reliability of the data for use.
78
Methods of observation and instrumentation
correct points in the vertical to obtain the velocity in the vertical); (d) location error
(reflecting difference in soil moisture content from place to place; number of stations
in a gauging cross-section).
In both cases it was found that the location error was the most significantand relations
were developed between the expected standard error and the number of sampling points.
Investigations of a similar nature are invaluable for studying the sampling problem
for most hydrological observations.For further detail on sampling methods reference
I
should be made to standard textbooks on statistics [47,2051.
4.2 Climate
Hydrological research cannot exist without a knowledge of the macro-climate of a
basin. The precipitation pattern, for instance, is associated with lower atmospheric
conditions. For this reason,the climatic demands for research on representative and
experimental basins must extend beyond the basin divide,although detailed observations
should be confined to the basin to measure aspects of the meso- and micro-climates.
Most countries possess a standard meteorological network of climate-recording
stations with varying lengths and intensities of observation. When representative and
experimental basins are selected, the national meteorological network should be
consulted since if,in particular,researchinto a climatic change is projected,such research
will be assisted if a long-establishedstation is within the basin divide. If a new station
is set up, this should become part of the national network. Note that the WMO [234]
has issued a guide which deals specifically with climatic observations.
4.2.1 Precipitation
4.2.1.1 Generai
4.2.1.2 Networks
For representative and experimental basins it is essential that attempts are made to
estimate the mean basin rainfall with a high degree of accuracy [7].This will involve
dense networks on any basin where the natural climatic variability is high. General
1 sampling principles are given in section 4.1.1 but, for access or economic reasons,such
methods are not always possible. In such cases sampling might be complemented by
79
Representative and experimental basins
80
Methods of observation and instrumentation
-iWinbrn
8
O v - N T
3
O 3 6 0 6 0
2: v --*
O
O
3-I-2
V
s w-
mow 3P-m
inIA
3 4 m
min w N
o 3
3
d v
N. -
IA .n
3 N i n m b -3minw ---Nu
8
4
V
m
V
3
vv
O -I-ITtPO
N --wmm
2: V vv
O
3
-wr-m
3 N
-imo=
v --
mo
N o riNin
2: W
V
36
3
V
m IA N
N
-000
-in08
-IA
th
d k
73 73
3
81
Representative and experimental ‘basins
4.2.1.2.1 N E T W O R K REAPPRAISAL
Frequent review of the basin network is essential to permit determination of: (a) the
adequacy and possible refinement of the network and observation programme; (b) the
time required to achieve experimental significance; (c) the possible need for restating
objectives; (d) the presence of faulty gauges and poor instrument locations and exposures.
For some projects,reappraisal may permit a reduction in the network. Reappraisal
methods may include the study of the areal representativeness of point rainfall data.
Aspects treated in the past have been related either to the representativeness of total
storm gauge catch data (or daily or monthly rainfalls), with respect to the mean basin
rainfall (using correlation methods), or to methods of total storm catch by the isohyetal
method (see section 5.5.1).
Representativeness has often been defined by a comparison between absolute point
values at a gauge and mean basin values,or between the statisticalfrequency distribution
of time series values obtained at individual gauges and the time series represented
by the average of data from an entire network. In some of these studies [24,461, an
attempt has been made to establish the general shape of total storm gauge catch patterns
in special cases. In other studies the pattern of instantaneous gauge level precipitation
intensities during storms (see section 5.3.I) has been determined [5].
Three types of recording raingauge are in general use, the weighing type,the float type
and the tipping bucket. The first type is the most satisfactory in cases where snow is
a significant proportion of the precipitation.Details of recording raingauges are given
in the literature [44,2311.
The movement of the float, bucket or weighing mechanism can be employed to
produce a digital record of rainfall.This can be done at the gauge,either mechanically
with the record being punched on paper tape,or electronically on magnetic tape where
a battery-operated tape deck is available. The alternative is to convert the movement
of the mechanism into an electric signal and transmit it by wire or radio to a distant
receiver, where a data logger collects records from a number of instruments.
4.2.1.3.2 N O N - R E C O R D I N G PRECIPITATION G A U G E S
82
l Methods of observation arid instrumentation
Accuracy of rainfall readings can be maintained by increasing the size of the orifice
~
relative to the diameter of the container. Inexpensive storage gauges are most suited
I to the dense network requirements of steep terrain (Fig. 4.2).
FIG.4.2. Storage
raingauge at 1,300m,
Kaweka Range, New
Zealand.
4.2.1.3.3 E R R O R S IN P R E C I P I T A T I O N G A U G E S
Wind affects the accuracy of precipitation measurement. Some errors may also occur
because of evaporation or wetting of the surface of the gauge [113].
Experimental evidence suggests that losses by wetting equal approximately 0.2 mm
per measurement, and losses by evaporation, depending on the design of collector,
may equal up to 6 per cent of the total fallen precipitation during the warm season
[19,58, 61, 133, 1641.
In some mountainous countries, in representative and experimental basin studies
the installation of one or more vecto-pluviometers[86]may be essential to study storm
direction and to correct vertical gauge catches.
Observational errors must also be taken into account, but these are generally of
a random nature. Regular maintenance can eradicate some sources of error, while
addition of antifreeze in cold countries and oil in hot ones can eliminate others. Splash
into the gauge can be minimized by employing gauge surrounds like short turf and
shingle, but if a specially constructed non-splash surface is employed, the gauge can
be installed with its rim at ground level. This gives the far greater benefit of lessening
wind effects on the gauge, thus increasing the catch compared with that of elevated
gauges [135,193, 2101. A well-tried variant of the gauge at ground level is one set in
a circular turf wall [lo31 built around the gauge at a diameter of 3 m. An alternative
way of modifying the surroundings of the gauge is to fit suitably-shapedwind shields
around the instrument.When properly designed,these enable much more representative
results to be obtained than do unshielded gauges fully exposed to the wind. An ideal
83
Representative and experimental basins
shield should: (a) ensure a parallel flow of air over the orifice of the gauge;(b) avoid
any local acceleration of the wind above the orifice; (c) reduce as far as possible the
speed of the wind striking the sides of the receiver; (d) not give rise to any splashing
towards the oriñce of the receiver.
Where shielding leads to complete icing-overin blizzard conditions [75], it should
be discontinued.
4.2.1.3.4 INSTALLATION M E T H O D S
Installation methods for precipitation gauges are described in the literature [231].In
representative and experimental basin research it is essential to use, at least nationally,
uniform standards and it is recommended that orifices are sited with a uniform height
above the air-vegetation interface. This might require elaborate structures in forested
basins [175].
It is recommended that where gauges are installed in any way that is different from
the usual practice, they should be tested alongside the national gauge to provide a
basis for comparison.
4.2.1.3.6 M E A S U R E M E N T O F D E W A N D FOG
For details of dew and fog measurement, see section 4.2.3.3 and the literature [231].
84
Methods of observation and instrumentation
-dea
O 0 0
888
-dea
O 0 0
888
c
o
a
b
85
Representative and experimental basins
This will ensure an approximate agreement between the lengths of the courses crossing
various slopes,and the total length of all courses with areas with similar slope conditions
and the area of the entire basin.
The number of courses depends on the configurationof the basin:two or three courses
are considered to be quite sufficient for wide basins of rounded form,and four or five for
narrow basins. Courses are located approximately parallel to each other in the direction
of the main stream, with equal distances between them. The mean value of the water
equivalent of the snow pack is calculated arithmetically averaging the areal snow-survey
data.
The second method-landscape snow survey-is a more economical one and is used
on larger basins, which have various types of vegetative cover and more complex topo-
graphical conditions.Non-homogeneityof vegetation and relief affects in particular the
distributionof snow storage over a basin.
For the use of this method the entire basin is grouped into principal landscape elements
(grasslands,forests,scrubland,valleys, slopes,river channels,etc.) and the total area of
each element is determined.
Surveys are made on several courses 0.5-2km long,each course being located within
a defined landscape. Such a complexity of courses may characterize the mean conditions
of snow accumulationon basins up to 100-200k m 2(mountainous regions excluded). O n
larger basins several landscape complexes should be selected and each course should
characterizethe mean conditionsof the snow accumulationin differentparts of the basin.
Therefore, the number of courses on a basin of up to 100-200 km2or on part of a
bigger basin is determined by the number of principal types of landscape. The mean
water equivalent of the snow pack is estimated as the mean weighted value of the snow
survey data on individuallandscape complexes,taking into accounttheir respectiveareas.
For a large basin,the mean water equivalent of the snow pack is estimated as a mean
weighted value on the basis of mean snow-storagedata of individual parts of the basin
(taking their areas into account).
The snow course in an open (woodless) area may be from 1 to 2 km long,depending
on the roughness of the landscape.The snow course should cross not only even areas,
but slopes of different exposure,valleys,hills and other areas characteristic of the given
landscape.The snow course in forests is normally 0.5-1.0km long and should cross all
parts which are characteristic of the given forest area. Snow surveys in ravines should
be made along 2-5 cross-sectionswith a total length of not less than 0.2 k m and not
more than 0.5 km.
With areal and landscape snow surveys,the measurement of snow depth is made at
equal distances every 10-20 m and measurements of snow density at each fifth point of
the snow-depthmeasurement.
Closer distances between the measurement points are not desirable,since snow depths
in adjacent points have a comparatively high correlation coefficient and snow density in
adjacent points varies less than the depth [250].
Itshould be noted that,in steepbasins at high altitudes,snow depths are highly irregular
over the basin and snow accumulations in sheltered areas are not significant unless these
areas contribute substantiallyto run-off.Experience indicates that most snow areas are
frequently bare before run-offstarts and only the gully accumulations contribute sub-
stantially to run-off.
In very steep basins, snow accumulates in gullies only and the objective of obtaining
snow depth and density information for the whole basin for water-balancestudies is, for
practical reasons,unobtainable.In such cases the only practical approach is to relate an
area of accumulationto run-off[159].
In many basins,because of topography and lack of access,only basin indices can be
obtained.To provide basin indices.snow surveys should be made at index courses estab-
lished in each of the hydrologically distinct accumulation areas which contribute
86
Methods of observation and instriimentation
substantially to run-off.Surveys should be carried out at least once during the accumu-
lation period,preferably on the date which corresponds to the average date of maximum
accumulation. More frequent surveys will be required in climatic areas where significant
winter melt occurs.
Areas prone to avalanches,steep icy slopes,corniced areas and other dangerous sites
should obviously be avoided.Particular care should be exercised in the selection of snow
coursesto avoid unintentional samplingbias. Carefulobservations,includingphotograph-
ic records of snow conditionsin the basin during at least one snow season should precede
the selection of snow courses.For dates of snow surveys see section 3.2.3.1.
Because of the time and effort generally required to make snow measurements and
associated observations,and with the object of lessening the inherent risk of sudden
adverse weather changes at high altitudes in certain latitudes, reasonable access is of
primary importance in the selection of index courses.
Precipitation observations are usually made simultaneously with snow surveys on a
basin. In regions with an unstable snow cover,where estimation of the maximum water
equivalent of the snow cover is often difficult because of thaws,the data on the amount
by precipitation gauges may be used for correction of snow-surveydata.
Noting that the correlation coefficient of the snow-coverdepth in adjacent measuring
points within a distance of about 20 m is small,the errors in estimation of the mean
snow depth or water equivalent of snow may be evaluated approximately by means of
the following equation:
Px = -CT
ZVN
CV
x 100 = -
VN
x 100
where:
Px = relativevalue of the error expressed in percentage(67 per cent level);
u = standard deviation;
5 = mean value of snow depth or water equivalentof snow cover;
N = number of measuring points;
Cv = coefficient of variation.
The number ofmeasuring points N,required for the estimation of the mean water equiv-
alent of the snow cover over the basin with a given accuracy Px,is calculated by the ratio
In the U.S.S.R. a movable snow stake and a weighing snow sampler (see Fig. 4.3)are
used for snow surveys [250].The Mount Rose sampler (Fig. 4.4)which is used in the
U.S.A. is described in the literature [231].
The complete set ofa weighing snow sampler consists of: (a) a metal cylinder,60 c m
high with a cross-sectionalarea of 50 cm2,open on one side;on the outside the cylinder
is graduated to determine the depth of the snow core;(b) a shovel for cutting the core;
(c) a steelyard,each graduation of the scale corresponding to a weight of 5 g.
The volume of the core equals 50 h (where h = the core height), and the weight of the
core equals 5 m (where m = the reading on the balance scale). These are used to estimate
the snow density by the ratio:
87
Representative and experimental basins
ia)
Legend
1. Snow sampling tube.
2. Cutter.
3. Cover.
4. Movable ring with a hook
(5) for suspension.
6. Balance beam.
7. Balance prisms.
8. Suspension ring.
9. Prism with a hook. 2
10. Movable balance weight.
11. Balance weight stopping
screw.
12. Slot for pointer. 13
13. Scoop.
FIG.4.3. Movable
snow stake (a) and
weighing snow sampler
(b), U.S.S.R.
G F
Legend
A. Snow-sampling tube. D. Driving wrench. G. Screw couplings.
B. Tubular spring balance. E. Spanner wrenches. H. Scale.
C. Cradle. F. Cutter.
FIG.4.4. The Mount Rose sampler, U.S.A.
88
Methods of’observation and instrumentation
Thus to obtain the snow density the number of graduations of the weight scale should
be divided by the reading of the cylinder scale multiplied by ten.
The instrumental error in measuring snow density by the weighing snow sampler is
obtained by summing the error in measuring the snow depth (which may be estimated
as 0.5 cm) and the error in taking readings by the balance scale (which may be assumed
to be half a graduation or approximately 2.5g). The greatest relative errors occur when
the depth and density of the snow cover are small,and the smallest errors when the snow
depth is equal to the height of the snow sampler and the snow density is above normal.
When the snow depth is 50 cm and the density 0.40,for example,the relative error in
measuring the density will not be more than f 2 per cent.
In mountainous basins snow surveys are very difficultand sometimes dangerous for
a snow surveyor. In areas with difficult access and considerable snow depth where long-
distance methods of measuring are possible one of the simplest methods used is the in-
stallation of permanent snow scales with readings taken by means of optical devices.
Measurement of the water equivalent of snow in separate points can be made by an
instrument based on the principle of counting gamma rays absorbed by snow.Cobalt-60
is used as a source of gamma radiation and a long-distanceGeiger-Müllercounter may
serve as a detector (see section 4.11.3).
A device to measure the water equivalent of the snow cover,based on registration of
the diminution of the natural radioactive radiation of the earth under the influence of
a snow cover,is being installed in the U.S.S.R.The impulses of a medium radioactive
background of the earth on a selected course before and after snowfall are measured by
terrestrial or aerial survey [235].
4.2.2.1 Snowmelt
Data characterizing the intensity of snowmelt may be required in studying processes of
spring floods caused by snowmelt in order to develop methods of calculation and fore-
casting of spring run-off.
The simplest methods are based on the relation between snowmelt and positive air
temperatures. One of these methods consists of determining the dependence between a
reduction of the water equivalent of the snow cover,obtained by snow surveys,and the
sum total of the daily mean positive air temperatures.
Where researchinto snowmelt processes is to be done all factorsaffecting the snowmelt
should be taken into account.
In the U.S.S.R.a special method, which is based on an inventory of all the energy-
balance components of the snow pack has been developed. All the components of the
radiation balance and of the turbulent heat and moisture exchange of the snow pack with
the atmosphere are considered.With these investigations the water-balance method is
usually applied using data from snow surveys,measurements of evaporation from the
snow cover, precipitation observations and calorimetric estimation of the water-liquid
phase in the snow pack.
Simplified versions of snowmelt-intensitycalculationshave also been used,Such meth-
ods are generally based on the use of climatological data such as wind velocity,total and
lower cloudiness,vapour pressure and air temperature.
89
Representative and experimental basins
where :
Is = interception loss;
Pu = gross precipitation;
Tf = throughfall;
Sf = stem flow;
Litter I, = litter interceptionloss;
P, = net precipitation (see section 1.5).
4.2.3.1.1.2 Vuriubles
A complete treatmentof allvariables affecting interceptionby forestvegetation is beyond
the scope of this guide. The objective here is to review the variables known to affect
interception and to discuss their relative importance in the interception process. For
convenience,interception variables are classed as climatic factors or as stand character-
istics.
Total rainfall and storm frequency are the two most important climatic variables.
Analysing gross rainfall and interception factors by covariance techniques usually re-
moves 95 per cent or more of the variation between individual measurements. Other cli-
matic variables (i.e.,rainfall intensity, wind speed and air temperature) are sometimes
statisticallyrelated to interceptionfactors,but their net effect is small [91].
With the exception of gross rainfall,stand characteristics such as type of stand (coni-
ferous or deciduous)are usually more importantsources of variation between stands than
climatic variables. Interceptionloss in deciduous species is greater in the growing than
in the dormant season,but the seasonal effect is less important in conifers [125,1581.
Canopy density (an expression of species,stand age,stocking,etc.) is directly related to
interceptionloss [125,158].Stem flow varies with bark roughness and branching charac-
teristics,averaging 10 per cent of gross rainfall in beech [144],but stem flow is insignificant
in mature Douglas fir 11961.
90
Methods of observation and instrunientation
4.2.3.1.1.3.2 Throirghfall. Water filtering through the forest canopy varies from point
to point by 100 per cent or more [98].This large spatial variation has encouraged many
investigatorsto use samplers with large receiving areas in attempts to reduce throughfall
variation. Small cylindrical gauges are favoured because they are easily obtained and
positioned in the field.Furthermore,because gross rainfall is sampled with round gauges,
the use of round throughfall gauges avoids the problem of comparing data from different
types.
Point throughfall amounts are directly related to distance from tree trunks [98,1881,
but the correlation in closed forests is too weak to justify a stratified sampling scheme.
If throughfall is measured in very open stands,stratification may be desirable.Sampling
plots can be divided into homogeneous zones [126].
4.2.3.1.1.3.3 Stem flow. Stem flowis usually less than 10 per cent of gross rainfall and
it is often omitted in interception studies. This omission leads to overestimatesof total
interception loss and stem flow must thereforebe measured in any complete interception
study.
Stem flow is sampled by sealing collars of copper or tin sheetingto trees to divert down-
flowing water into containers for measurement.The collar should project about 2.5 c m
from the tree bole. Wider collars are sometimes used on rough-barkedspecies,but these
probably catch some throughfall in addition to stem flow [144].
The best method is to locate smallplots randomly within the study area and to measure
stem flow from all trees within these plots. Measured water volume is readily expressed
in conventional depth units by dividing by plot area. Plots should be at least 1.5 times
the crown area of the largest plot tree or 20 m2for very small trees [92].Measured in this
manner, the coefficient of stem-flowvariation is a tenth to a twentieth of that of single-
tree samples,or only slightly greater than that for throughfall.
4.2.3.1.1.3.5 Sampling intensity. Below is given an equation which is useful for deter-
mining the number of gross rainfall,throughfall and stem-flowsamplesneeded to achieve
a predetermined sampleaccuracy [208].In the equation
n is the number of samplesneeded,t is the tabulated value for the desired confidencelevel
91
Representative and experimental basins
and thedegreesof freedom,02 is the population variance,and dis the maximum permissible
difference between sample and population mean. Experience of other investigatorsis the
best source of estimates on population variance ; study objectives dictate sample accuracy.
Figure 4.5 shows the average coefficient of variation data of interception factors for
some stand and climatic conditionsin the eastern parts of the U.S.A. [91]. It shows that:
(a) each factor in the interception process is a different sampling population; (b) the
coefficientof variation is inverselyrelated to the gauge catch until the latter reaches about
10mm,but is independentfor larger gauge catches;(c) throughfall variation is related to
timber type and,for deciduous trees,to the season of the year;(d) stem flow measured on
40 m2plots is slightly more variable than throughfall.Data in the figure can be used as
a first approximation of sampling needs for other studies.The standard deviation (u) for
a given storm size can be computed from Figure 4.5 by multiplying the coefficient of
variation by the average gross rainfall,throughfall, or stem-flowgauge catch. With an
estimate of oz from Figure 4.5 and the proper t and d values necessary to meet study
objectives,the number of samples needed can easily be calculated by solving equation (6).
A= STEM FLûWPINE,ANNUAL
E= THROUGHFALL.HARDWOODS,SUMMER
C: THROUGHFALL.PINE,ANNUAL
D=THROUGHFALL,HARDWOODS.WINTER
E: GROSS RAINFALL. ANNUAL
4.2.3.1.2.1 General
Whereas forest and shrub communities have been widely studied,little research has been
done into the measurement of interception loss in herbaceous communities [33]. Most
work dates from 1940,although pasture grasses were considered earlier [loo]. The lack
of activity is attributablemainly to the difficulty of obtaining reliable measurements.The
mechanical and spatial restrictions imposed by the reduced forms of herbs make the use
of macro-sampling methods impossible. Micro-variations require refined and indirect
measuring techniques.
92
Methods of observation and instrumentation
as they may provide quick results for checking against more complicated but less
mobile techniques.
A note of warning must be sounded here. The investigatormust not rely too heavily
on variance information from Figure 4.5or from other studies. Such data provide a first
approximation of sampling needs, but calculations of actual variance must be made as
soon as enough data are available. For example, studies have been reported [115]in
which throughfall variation was higher than expected and more gauges were required to
meet study objectives.Too often variance is calculated after the study is closed and when
it is too late to correct gauging intensity.
4.2.3.1.2.3 Gross interception loss. Some of the earliest attempts,where the height
and density of the sward permitted,used standard precipitationgauges,placed 3 c m above
ground level,amongst the growing vegetation.The throughfall thus collected was compar-
ed with precipitation catches on open ground [162,1811. Others used test tubes flush
with the ground to avoid disturbing the vegetation. [74]Results skewed by overland flow
are a possibility in this method.
Others placed troughs in rows amongst the vegetation [lo, 431. Troughs integrate
throughfall to a greater extent than gauges, although they do tend to overestimate the
amount. They record the less dense outer portions of the canopy and do not measure
stem flow.
Stem flow forms a significant proportion of the gross precipitation reaching the soil.
Failure to record this value gives overestimation of the interception loss. Stem collars
cannot be used and therefore the surface may be waxed under a sward in an effort to
catch throughfall and stem flow [89].This method has been refined by others [50],but
even so its success in dense swards is doubtful.
The best method appears to be the cutting of specimensat ground level.They are then
arranged on a screen,irrigated with a known quantity ofprecipitationand the throughfall
collected 143, 134, 1981.
These methods measure stem flow but introduce artificial arrangements in vegetative
form. A test using a modified Northfork infiltrometer (Fig. 4.6)has been tried in dense
rye dairy pasture. This method measures leaf-interceptionloss but does not accurately
record the large quantity of moisture retained at the base of the stem. This moisture
could be considered as surface detention. The method is satisfactory for low-growing
and clustered plants.
93
Represenlutive and experimental busins
FIG.4.6. Herbaceous
interception measure-
ment using a modified
Northfork infiltrometer,
Ministry of Works,
N e w Zealand.
94
Methods of observation and instrumentation
4.2.4 Evaporation
Water is transferred to the atmosphere from open water,bare soil and wet vegetation by
evaporation and through leaf stomata by transpiration. For these two processes acting
together the term evapotranspiration is used by some workers,while others employ the
term evaporation.
The concept of potential evapotranspiration(or potential transpiration)has been devel-
oped to overcome the problems that arise when the effects of soil-moisturestresses on
the water loss of a plant have to be taken into account,as it is still not completely clear
what happens to transpiration rates as soil moisture becomes limited. Potential evapo-
transpiration implies that the vegetation has a copious water supply with climate as the
only control of transpiration.
As for precipitation,evaporation and evapotranspiration are defined in terms of depth
of water. There is a great variety in the means employed for measuring these factors,
with certain methods requiring very complex instrumentation and otherslittle more than
a bucket [114].The cost of the installation does not,however,indicate the precision of
the estimate.
There are several methods of estimating evaporation:
1. Water-balance methods : these employ the basic water-balance equation or modifi-
cations of it, the amount of evaporation or evapotranspirationbeing deduced by dif-
ference (see section 5.3.4.1).
2.Energy-balancemethods:for details, see section 4.2.5.4and [231].
3. Aerodynamic approach [231].
4. Empirical formulas;these have usually a limited regional application [173,213,2171.
5. Lysimeters and evaporimeters (see section 5.3.5.5).
6. Evaporation pans (see section 4.2.4.1).
95
I
FIG.4.7. Plan of 20 m2
pan.
Legend
i. Cylindrical reservoir 2 m
deep.
2. Reservou with measuring
glass (3).
4. Tube.
5. Stilling chamber.
6. Connecting tube.
7. Benchmark tube.
8. Water level indicator.
9. Volumetric burette.
FIG.4.8. Volumetric
burette.
FIG.4.9. Measuring
tubes.
96
Methods of observation and Nutrumeritation
pans are used on the basic network of the U.S.S.R. for measuring evaporation from water
surfaces.In the U.S.A. and some other countries the Class A pan (with an area of 1.14m2)
is used [30].
The U.S.S.R. 20 m2 evaporation pan is of a cylindrical design with a flat bottom,made
of welded sheet steel 4.4mm thick.The pan is 5.04m in diameter and has a depth of 2 m .
(Fig.4.7).A measuring reservoir is used for adding water to the evaporation pan up to
the normal level.The water level in the pan is measured in a stilling chamber which has
a benchmark tube with a hole for a volumetric burette.The latter is of a cylindrical de-
sign with a height of 60 mm and a cross-sectionof 20 cm2 (Fig. 4.8). For measuring the
water volume taken by the burette from the evaporation pan,measuring tubes in the form
of graduated glass cylinders are used (Fig.4.9).
The GGI-3000evaporation pan (Fig.4.10)consists of a tank, a raingauge (Fig. 4.11)
a volumetricburette (Fig.4.8)and measuring tubes (Fig.4.9).The pan is a cylinder 60 c m
high with a cone-shapedbottom,made of metal and protected from corrosion or specially
painted.The pan is 618 mm in diameter. A metal benchmark tube is placed in the centre
of the pan. During observations a volumetric burette is placed on the tube. A special
needle fixed on the tube indicatesthe level at which the water in the pan should be kept.
The raingauge has an orifice with an area of 0.3m2.
FIG.4.10. GGI-3000
evaporation pan.
97
Representative and experimental basins
The American Class A pan is of cylindrical design.The pan is made of galvanized iron
or some other metal protected from corrosion.The diameter of the pan is 120.6c m and
its height is 25.4 c m (Fig. 4.12). T w o white lines at heights of 5 and 7.5c m below the rim
of the pan are painted on its inner side to facilitate maintenance of the water level. A
. stilling chamber with a water-levelmeasuring device is enclosed in the pan.
The 20m2evaporation tank and the GGI-3000pan are sunk into the ground or mount-
ed on anchored floating platforms on lakes or reservoirs.The United States Class A pan
is mounted above the ground on a framework made of 5 x 10 cmz timbers.
Measurements of precipitation, water-surface temperature and other climatological
factors such as wind velocity,temperature and humidity of the air are made simulta-
neously with evaporation observations.Evaporation and precipitation observations are
made once or twice a day,precipitation being measured in the morning and evening at
hours nearest to the fixed time of climatological observations.
4.2.4.2.1 EVAPORIMETERS
4.2.4.2.1.1 General
For measurement of evaporation from the soil (particularlyfrom agricultural fields) stan-
dard gravimetric or 500 cm2 weighing-type evaporimeters are used in some countries.
They are 100 or 50 c m deep,depending on the depth of the soil layer which has the most
intensivewater exchange between the soil and the atmosphere.These evaporimeters may
be used to measure evaporation from grassland,arable land,and waste land and to meas-
ure evapotranspiration from crops and evaporation from soil under the vegetative cover.
Gravimetric or weighing-typeevaporimeters with an area of 0.3m2and 1 .Om2are used
to measure evapotranspirationfrom crops.
Soil evaporimeters of the weighing type are considered by some to be reliablein meas-
uring evaporation values for a five- or ten-day period with an error not greater than
10-15per cent.
98
Methods of observation and instrumentation
Hydraulic soil evaporimeters with a surface area of 0.2m2and a depth of 1.5 m are
used to study daily variations of evapotranspiration.The big hydraulic evaporimeter
(BGI)with an area of 5 m2and a depth of 2 m is considered by Soviet scientists to be the
most reliable reference instrument for the study of daily variations of evapotranspiration
for any period.
Measurement of evaporation from swamps and marsh-riddenareas is made by means
of evaporimeters for swamps [lo,35, 44, 68, 183, 247, 2481.
99
Representative and experimental basins
Legend
1. Inner cylinder. 4. Base plate catch. 7. Outer cylinder 10. Spring.
2. Base plate. 5. Latch. 8. Hook.
3. Water collector. 6.Handles. 9. Bracket.
Legend
1. Tunnel shaft for weights.
2. Weights.
3. Electric micrometer screw
of the water-level gauge.
4. Float of the water-level
gauge.
5. Cup with mercury (on the
float).
6. Float weight.
7. Rubber rings.
8, 10. Reservoir.
9. Evaporimeter casing.
100
Methods oj. observation and instrumentatton
Fisa
Legend
1. Ventilation tube. 10. Emergency outflow pipe. 16. Water-collectingpipe.
2. Reinforced concrete. 11. Outflow pipe from the 17. Supporting beams for the
3. Roof-supportbeam. annular reservoir. console.
4. Beam support. 12. Weights. 18. Monolith.
5. Annular reinforced con- 13. Indicator. 19. Axle.
crete reservoir. 14. Reservoirs for collection of 20. Stilling chamber.
6. Annular float. surface and subsurface 21. Recorder.
7. Float necks. flow. 22. Flume.
8. Outflow pipe. 15. Socket of the electro-
9. Inflow pipe. thermometers.
FIG.4.15. Vertical cross-sectionof the big hydraulic evaporimeter installation.
This type is used in the U.S.S.R.and some other countries for the study of total soil
evaporation values, total transpiration of various kinds of tree and daily variations in
each.
The foresthydraulicevaporimeter consistsof an hydraulicbalance and an evaporimeter
weighed on this balance; the pan has a soil monolith with a tree growing in it. The area
of the pan is 3 m2 and its depth is 1.5 m.A complete set includesfive evaporation pans,
each pan being installed on a special car which can be transferred along rails by means
of an electric winch.
101
Representative and experimental basins
The major elements of the hydraulic balance are a platform supported on four floats
by a system of beams;four reservoirs connected with one another;four floats,placed in
the reservoirsto support the evaporimeter;and the platform.
The hydraulic evaporimeter is supplied with a special device for measuring and record-
ing the weight of the monolith [183).
This instrument has an area of 0.3m2 and consists of an evaporimeter,an outer cylinder
and a water-collectingwell. The evaporimeter (60 c m high) is made of sheet steel 3 mm
thick,with a movable perforated bottom, bolted in three points. In the upper part, the
evaporimeter has a shelter 7 c m wide which protects the clearance between the side of
the evaporimeter and the outer cylinder (Fig. 4.16).
FIG.4.16. Soil.
weighing evapoIimeter
with a surface iirea of
0.3 m2 installed in a
maize field.
The outer cylinder is made of sheet steel 3 mm thick and with the bottom inclined to
the observation well. Under the shelter the evaporimeter has a rectangular opening for
water flowing from the monolith surface after heavy precipitation.A trough is welded
under the opening to direct flowing water into the outlet tube.
The water leakingthrough the monolith is collected on the bottom of the outer cylinder
and flowsinto the special tube.Both tubes protrude out of the cylinder border and convey
the water falling from the monolith surface plus any leaking water into a special well,
situated 4 m from the evaporimeter.T w o collectors are placed in the well to accumulate
this water.
102
Methods of observation and instrumentation
This evaporimeter has an area of 1.0m2and a depth of 80 cm. The design is similar to
that of the 0.3m2evaporimeter,differing only in dimensions.
This equipment consists of two concentriccylinders and a movable shelter to protect the
clearance between the cylinders from precipitation.
The inner cylinder,with a diameter of 356.5 mm and a height of 520 or 720 mm has
a solid bottom,above which is placed a wire bottom.A glass measuring tube is fixed on
the outer side of the cylinder and has a cover with a hole for the air. In the lower part,
the measuring tube is connected by means of a branch pipe with the space between the
wire and solid bottoms and with a valve for discharge of any excess water. The outer
cylinder has a lug where the measuring tube of the evaporimeter is inserted.
4.2.4.2.1.10 Lysimeter-compensatingevaporimeter
This lysimeter,used by the Valdai Scientific Research Hydrological Laboratory of the
U.S.S.R. comprises a set of four evaporimeters with a cross-sectionof 0.3 m2and a depth
of 2.0 m each;they are placed on concrete cylinders sunk into the ground (Fig. 4.17).
In the underground chamber joining the outer cylinders there are four compensating
vessels fixed on supports. Each vessel may be displaced vertically and readings of its
position are taken on a scale graduated on the vertical support. Each vessel is linked to
the evaporimeter by a rubber hose which is connected with the centre of the evaporimeter
bottom by means of a tube through the side of the chamber. These evaporimeters are
weighed on a standard platform balance [35].
A soil raingauge consists of a bucket and an outer cylinder for installation of the bucket.
The cylindricalraingauge bucket has an orifice of 500cm2and its height is 40 cm.
103
Representative and experimental basins
The outer cylinder has a height of 28 c m and a diameter of 35 cm.Three spring supports
for the raingauge installationare welded to the inner side ofthe cylinder bottom.
Legend
I. Cylinder.
2. Bottom plate.
3. Cover. 1
4. Shovel.
5. Outer cylinder.
FIG.4.18. GGI-500-6
snow evaporimeter
104
I Methods of observation and instvrrrnentation
a solid waterproof bottom, and a shovel for digging up and cutting a snow monolith.
During observations the evaporimeter is placed in the outer cylinder.
Observations on evaporation from snow and on the temperature of the snow-cover
surfaceare made morning and evening.This applies only when the depth of the snow cover
on the plot is 6c m or more.
In dry weather at temperatures below O" C and in the absence of snow,monoliths are
changed once every five days. In addition they are changed when snow drift or precipita-
tion has occurred during the period between the given and previous time of observation
or when the level of the compacted snow in the evaporimeter is lower than the upper rim
of the cylinder and structure of the snowfall has been disturbed [248].
4.2.4.2.2 LYSIMETERS
1 4.2.4.2.2.1 Purpose
1 The purpose of the lysimeter in representative and experimental basin research is to
establish a number of subsurfacewater characteristicswhich are measures of the capacity
of the soilto storewater,to convey it up or down inthe unsaturated zone and to determine
the variations in moisture conditions from the potential level (see section 1.5) to the leve-
where soil-moisturetension restricts the availability of soil moisture for evapotranspiral
tion.The amount of water drained off or the amount of evaporated moisture as determin-
ed by the lysimeter normally serves only as an indication of the order of magnitude
of these quantities under field conditions and has no value where more accurate
indications are needed.
The three major uses of lysimeters are:
1. Determination of the variation in soil-moisturein a given soil, and velocity of infil-
trating water and recharge due to precipitation (this enables the correlation of plant
growth and moisture content in successive soil horizons).
2. Prediction of the rate of evapotranspiration for a given soil-moisturecondition and
potential evapotranspiration and potential of the moisture uptake of the plant roots
in successive zones of the soil profile.
3. Assessment of the capacity of moisture storage of the soil and evapotranspiration
(this enables correlationof precipitationwith storage data which might lead to a better
understanding of subsurface flow).
Lysimeters for more detailed scientific investigations require a good deal of auxiliary
instrumentation.Only a few lysimetersshould be used and they must be of a high accuracy
and,often, of a large size. A n undisturbed soil is only seldom needed. These lysimeters
are generally constructed for permanency. When research of short duration and with
' restricted instrumentationis done to obtain resultsfor practical application,a larger num-
I
ber of lysimeters with different soil profiles and ground-watertables is used. These will
generally require undisturbed soil,be of small size,be used for a short time only and will
1 have to be cheap.
The use of a large number of small lysimeters has often to be regarded as a transitional
solutionwhere an investigationin the field without use of a lysimeteris too time-consuming
or is,for other reasons,less desirable.It should be borne in mind that methods are availa-
ble to determine in the field without a lysimeter as much as or even more than a lysimeter
can give.
The lysimeter for scientific purposes will often be built to give an accuracy of 0.1 mm of
water. The lysimeter for practical problems can be considered sufficiently accurate with
an error of up to 5 mm of water.Because a lysimetercontainer of volume 1 m3and height
1 m weighs some two tons,the accuracies of 0.1 and 5 mm respectivelymean accuracies
I 105
Representative and experimental basins
of 1/20,000and 1/400of the total weight,or 1/2,500and 1/50of the weight of the soil-
moisture content.These accuracies ensure a good balance for the scientificlysimeter and
a good moisture determination for the practical lysimeter.Different methods of weighing
have been tried out for the accuratelysimeter,includingroman balances,platform scales,
the determination of the volume of replaced water of floating containersor of the hydrau-
lic pressure in bolsters (which was pioneered by the U.S.S.R.). The last-mentionedmethod
is recently drawing more and more attention,partly bacause of the low cost of the weigh-
ing instrument [72,205, 2061.
The instrumentationof practical lysimetersis less generally accepted.Gypsum or nylon
blocks often give erratic results.The use of ceramic plugs or other moisture-absorbing
substances such as filter paper (which are brought into close contact with the moist soil
and are then taken out,weighed and dried after attaining moisture equilibrium) appears
to be promising but is as yet insufficiently tested. The neutron probe and gamma-ray
moisture-determination apparatus use costly instruments and still suffer difficulties of
calibration.These nuclear devices, however, get more and more preference. Where low
costs are important,the filter-paperplug as a technique of determination merits closer
attention (see section 4.4.1.1.4).
Different types of lysimeter are used in various countries. A description of lysimeters
used in the Netherlands is given in sections 4.2.4.2.2.3and 4.2.4.2.2.4.A description of
a lysimeterused in the U.S.S.R. is given in section 4.2.4.2.2.5.
--i25 cm------,
F
Q Q
Legend
1 r
a Container,inner dimensions 120 x 140 x 180 cm. e Access tubes to soil, also suitable for drainage or
b Iron frames on either side of pressure cells. supply of ground water.
c Pressure cells. f Calibrated reservoir for drained water.
d Posts for support and high enough to give access g Suspended soil-filled roof of passageway between
under container. containers.
h Self-recordingevaporation pan.
106
Methods of observation mid imtriitt~eiitution
Lysimeter containers of a fair size,say 1.40 x 1.40 x 1.70 m are arranged at both sides
of a passageway in a pit of, say,4 x 3 x 3 m,deep enough below the bottom of the
containers to allow the inspection of the measuring implements for leakage and wide
enough to allow measurements in the passageway.Each container rests on three pressure
cells,placed on masonry supports (see Fig. 4.19).A pressure cell is a case of some 40 c m
diameter and 4 c m height,closed at the top with a membrane and filled with oil.O n the
membrane a tapered plate, serving as a piston, conveys the weight of the container to
the oil.By bringing the oil under sufficient pressure,the membrane lifts the piston until it
is just free from the tapered rim of the cell. This is shown by a light.In this position the
membrane is flat,so that no vertical forces are exerted by it. The container,weighing 6
to 8 tons,is lifted by the pressure of 1.75 to 2.15atmospheresof the oil in the three pressure
cells.
The pressure in each set of three pressure cells is measured in a manometer stand.Each
manometer consists of a leg of 2 c m diameter and 1.80 m long,concentrically placed in
a closed wide leg of 10c m diameter and 10c m height.A rise in pressure of 104 c m mercury
Il k
m
T= J
Mercury Legend
a Three pressure cells carrying one container. g Tapered ring.
b Manometers. h Tapered plate.
c Reading tube with scale. i Lid.
d Body of pressure cell. j Tubing to pressure chamber
e Rubber ring. k Container with soil.
Membrane.
107
Representafìve and experimental basins
results in a drop of the meniscus in the wide leg of 4 c m and a rise in the narrow leg of
100 cm. The desired accuracy of 0.1 mm water requires an accuracy of reading of each
manometer of 0.04m m . This can be done with screw gauges and delivery of data in print
on punch tape.Simpler and cheaper,however,are a hydraulicmagnifier and adding device
(see Fig.4.20).
The three manometer legs, belonging to the same container,are connected to a thin
glass tube in a slanting position,Oil is poured on the mercury. A change in height of
1 c m in the three mercury columns will produce a change in height of the meniscus of
3 x 1 x 22/0.42= 75 c m in the slanting glass tube which is assumed to have an inner
diameter of 4 m m . The magnification is therefore 75. If the moisture content increases
by 0.1mm then three readings of 0.04 mm increase are substituted by one reading of
3 c m increase of the length of the oil column.The size of the thin glass tube has to be
selected in such a way that the oil meniscus does not deform. Changing the size of
the manometer tube enables choice of desired magnification.
The hydraulic transmission is temperature-sensitive.It is therefore necessary to install
the manometer and magnifier in a thermostat which keeps the surrounding air at a con-
stant temperature. Because it needs a rather complicated construction to extend the
thermostatto the pressure boxes,part of the hydraulic installation is better left out.Then,
however,it is a good precaution to install under at least one of the containers an identical
dummy pressure box connected to a manometer and magnifier in the thermostat,where
the result of inadequate temperature corrections can be measured separately.For further
details refer to the literature [17].
The lysinieters for practical problems are used mainly with undisturbed soil cylinders.
The principal problem is obtaining these large,undisturbed soil cores.Plastic tubes of
0.50m diameter and 1.30m length are pressed into the soil with hydraulicrams and soil
anchors.At the same time the soiloutside the cylinderis dug away to facilitatepenetration.
When the upper side of the plastic cylinder is level with the soil surface,a hole is made
next to the cylinder,as access for a bottom plate to be pushed under the cylinder (see
Fig. 4.21).
The soil coresare placed on both sides of a pit and are dug into the soilat some distance
from the passageway if gamma-ray moisture determination is applied. Where nylon
blocks or devices with a short duration of uninterrupted use are applied,the soil cores
are better placed against the outside of the wail of the pit for better access to the measur-
ing units.
The soil cores are prepared for measuring the drain discharge by filling the lower 5 c m
of the plastic cylinder with coarsesand or gravel.A dischargetube for drainageis attached
and a bottom plate is fixed.Then the cylinder is placed in an oil barrel and the space
between the cylinder and the barrel is filled with bituminous material to ensure that it is
completely watertight. The cylinders are then lowered into the soil and the bottles to
catch the drain dischargeand to supply the water lost by evapotranspirationare connected.
These consist of cylinders with an area of 0.2 mzwith depths of 1.0,lS, 2.0,and 2.5 m,
and are common in some countries.Every cylinder,filled with a monolith,has an outer
cylinder and a water-controllingdevice. The outer cylinder and the cylinder with the
monolith play the same role as those in weighing soil evaporimeters (see section 4.2.4.2).
The water-controllingdevice creates and automatically keeps the ground-waterlevel
inthe lysimetermonolith at a required depth.Measurement of the amount of water added
to or removed from the lysimeter in the process of returning the water level to the fixed
108
I Methods of observation and instrumentation
FIG.4.21. Use of lysimeter for general survey (undisturbed soil cores for study of the relation
between past nuclear fall-outand the water balance,taken in differentcountries,are brought
to a central place for investigation in order to avoid the cost of scattered research).
The aim of applying,in the field,results obtained with the lysimeter installationis limited
by the influences of the distribution of the root density over soil layers and the uptake
of moisture by the root. The plant probably has a high adaptabiIity to adverse moisture
conditions and is able to increase its capacity to extract water. Root density and uptake
activity are not,however,measurable in a non-destructiveway. Moreover,it is uncertain
that the conditionsin the field resemble those in the lysimeter to such an extent that they
may be assumed to be identical. Therefore the techniques to determine the moisture
balance of the soil covered by vegetation and under field conditions have to be applied
simultaneously with the lysimeter technique to obtain fully reliable results [218].
109
Representative and experimenial basins
4.2.5.2.2 LOCATION
Certain criteria for the location of climate stations are essential to ensure representative-
ness of the site and for comparing data between basins.
110
Methods of observation and iiistrnmentation
(a) 'The base station should preferably be near the centre of the basin at approximately
mean basin altitude. This requirement is not extremely important, especially if auxiliary
stations are used and the base station is used only for correlation.
(b) The dimensions of the plot for the station will depend on the number and type of
instruments required.The instruments must be arranged in such a way that each instru-
ment has adequate exposure. The plot should have a level surface and be uniformly
vegetated and away from high trees and other obstructions,slopes and hollows.Adequate
security measures should be taken to protect the instruments.
(c) There should be room for expansion of the climate station and any agent which
may affect future site exposure should be eliminated.
(d) It is important that precipitationmeasured in the basin is representative of aclual
rainfall received by the air-vegetationinterface. For this purpose, instruments should
have their recording surface level with the air-vegetationinterfaceor be a uniformly small
distance above this face.The installation of other climatic equipment at main climatic
stations should be according to the national standards.
In forested basins it may be desirable,when possible,to cut an area of the forest so
that the precipitation gauges are installed relatively close to the ground.
In each case, the angle of the gauges relative to the height of the nearest obstruction
should not exceed 45".
111
Representative and experimental basins
has been only experimental and in types of forest that are described too poorly for the
measurements to be transferred easily to other forest types [I 32,2441.
112
I Methods of observation und instrumentution
Discharge measurements of the highest accuracy can best be carried out in channel
reaches and at cross-sectionswhich conform to certain specifications [231].Water-surface
slopes can best be measured on a straight reach,but ñood rating can be carried to higher
stages when velocities are not excessive. Depth measurements are facilitated by the ab-
sence of excessive depth, line drag and surface disturbance. In flood periods, shallow
depths are associated with excessive velocities and surface disturbance.
The general requirements indicate a straight reach where the velocity range is 0.33-5
m/sec and the depth range is 0.5-6m.
The measuring section should have gently sloping banks,preferably grassed,and the
stream bed should be free of obstructions (boulders,tree stumps,etc.).
l
A gauging stationmay,therefore,consistof a stream section controlled either naturally
or artificially so as to give gauge-heightstability and sensitivity,and a section,not neces-
sarily with a low flow control,at which discharge measurements by current meter may
1 be carried out. Stage and flow ahould be measured on the same cross-section where
possible.
113
Representative and experimental basins
The desirable features of structures are conflicting and the final installationis a compro-
mise in which the followingfeatures must be considered:
The shape of the structure should permit the passage of water Rithout the creation of
undue afflux in the vicinity;
The head loss must be sufficient to maintain free flow throughout the stage range;
The structure should have as large a capacity as possible to permit the measurement of
low-frequencyfloods;
The storage area above the measuring structureshould be as smallas possible to minimize
modification of the hydrograph;
The structure should be winter-proofand should be constructed in such a way that flow
measurements can be made under winter conditions;
The intake pipe(s) should be arranged in such a way that fluctuations in the well are
minimal, that well level corresponds to river level at the gauging station and that
flushing of the well can be carried out;
The structure should permit easy calibration with the accuracy required ;
The profile of the crest should be designed to give reasonable sensitivity at ail flows
(this is particularly difficult to achieve at low flows) and this may require an additional
special structure to measure the low flows;
The structure should be leak-proofwith cut-offwalls sufficientlydeep to bring to the
surface deep subsurfacechannel flow;
The velocity of approach should suit the calibrationof the weir and the approach-channel
geometry should remain sensibly constant for long periods ;
The structuremust be self-cleaningand capable of maintaining its rating when operating
in rivers carrying silt and bed load.
114
Methods of observation and instrumentation
V-notch and sharp-crested weirs.l 120", 90",3(90"), a(90'). See Figures 4.224.26.
Capacity. Approximately 700 l/secwith a head of 60 cm for the 120" V-notch,and 500 l/sec
with a head of 62 c m for the 90"V-notch.Others have a proportionately smaller capacity
with a lower limit of 0.6 l/sec.
Accuracy. Percentage error= 250 dH/Hwhere dH is the allowable error in the recording of
I
I
FIG.4.23. g(90') V-notch sharp-crestedweir,Ministry of Works, New Zealand.
115
Representative and experimental basins
116
Methods of observation and instrumentation
Cross-section A-A 6
10
'14
IO
117
Representative and experimental basins
Compound V-notches (i). $(90") + 90"where i(90") is 20 cm high. See Figure 4.27.
Capacity. As for the 90", but with a small increase for the á(90").
Accuracy. Needs to be model rated and then checked by field calibrations.Low-stagevolumetric
gaugings are facilitated if a collector vessel is attached to the weir plate.
Siting criteria or advantages. Combines the capacity of the 90" V-notch with the low-flow
sensitivity of the 2(90") V-notchand is used where the important flows are within the capacity
of the a(90") weir (6 lisec).
Limitations. Where flow is intermittent, pondage volumes must be limited to the minimum
necessary to conform with the pondage specifications of the k(90") V-notch.Figure 4.27
shows a proposed arrangement.At high flows the intake-pipeposition will not conform to
standard requirements.
Compound V-notches (ii). $(90")+ 90"as above, but with sloping concrete side walls.
Capacity. The slope and width of the side walls are planned to suit flow requirements.
Accuracy. As for compound V-notch.Requires field or model calibration.
Sifìng criteria or advantages.Enables the V-notchweir to operate at fullcapacitywithout overflow
and provides a rateable section for higher stages.
Limitations. As above.
Compound V-notches (iii). 90" V-notch with sloping concrete side walls 25 cm thick. See
Figure 4.28 and [166].
Capacity. Five types.Rated by models up to 22,500 l/sec.(i) 2 hor.,1 vert.;)¡i( 3 hor.,1 vert.;
(iii) 5 hor., 1 vert.;(iv) 10 hor.,1 vert.; (v) horizontal (14.6 m wide).
, ,
118
FIG.4.28. Compound V-notch sharp-crestedweir with sloping concrete side walls, Ministry
of Works,New Zealand.
~
1. The use ofsharp-crestedweirs is not recommendedfor streamscarryinga significantsediment
and debrisload,where submergedflow conditionsmay exist,or where ponding is impractical.
119
Representative and experimental basins
V-shaped broad-crested weir (V-Romijn type). See Figures 4.31 and 4.32.
Capacity. Maximum capacity 500 I/sec for a head of 60 cm.
Accuracy. High at high flows, low at low flows.
120
Methods of observation and instrumentation
Siting criteria or advantages. Used where H-flumesor V-notches are unacceptable because of
pondage or submergence.
Limitations. Difficult to construct.
Crump weir. For construction methods and photographs of installations,see bibliography 1391.
Capacity. Unlimited.
Accuracy. Dependent on accuracy of head measurement.
Siting criteria or advantages.For operation requires a minimum head loss.Operates satisfactorily
with submergence ratios of up to 0.96.Self-scouring.Construction cheap.
Limitations. General aggrading of the stream bed can easily bury this low weir.A two-pen
recorder employing two stilling wells is used. Head-measuring accuracy is difficult and
questionable because silt may block the pressure holes in the weir.
Flumes. HS, H,HL. See Figures 4.33 and 4.34.
Capacity. Range of discharges:
HS-flume:0.005-23.0 l/sec.
H-flume:0.01-2,390I/sec.
HL-flume:0.15-3,320l/sec.
Accuracy. As for 90" V-notchbut the heads corresponding to given flows are much lower with
the accompanying necessity for reduction of the allowable error in recording of head. With
submergence ratios > 0.35 the up- and downstream levels should be recorded [18].
Siting criteria or advantages. Ideal for ephemeral or intermittent flow because no pondage is
required.Self-clearingis aided by a side-slopedfloor in the larger flumes. Screening against
surface debris or bed load is recommended.
Limitations. Not recommended for perennial streams where there are sustained low flows in
the order of 0.6 I/sec because of head-measurementdifficulties.It is difficult to maintain
the level of the zero-flowsetting because of floor irregularities and blockage of intake by
silt, earthworms,algae, etc. [222].
121
Representative and experimental basins
Parshall flume. Throat widths range from 7.6 cm to 1,524 cm. See Figure 4.35.
Capacity. 3,960 l/sec for 244 cm throat and 16.2 cm head.
Accuracy. Good for near-capacity flows, but not good for low flows. Operates best under
uniform flow-regimen conditions,e.g.,irrigation.
Siting criteria or advantages. Does not require a pond and when used with two recorders can
operate when submerged. It is self-clearing and tolerant to variations in the velocity of
approach.
Limitations. Construction is costly because the dimensions must be maintained within fine
limits.Normally two recorders are required,except under free-flowconditions when a certain
loss of head is necessiry [223].
H-flume combined with V-notch. Preferably a i(90") or a f(90")V-notch.See Figure 4.36.
Capacity. As for H-flume.
I
Long section Cross-section.
0.1 < h/lr0.75
Meosure h upstream from the weir
at o distance of 4 h (max.)
Plan
122
I Methods of observation aid instviimeritatioiz
FIG.4.33. H-flume
(76.2 c m deep) with
Coshocton silt-samplin
wheel in foreground,
Department of
Agriculture, U.S.A.
123
Representative and experimental basins
1o2
5
IO’5
5
a-
Plan
b = I.OSd(HS)
b = 1.9d (H)
b = 3.20d (HL)
;IO’
-1 5
P
$
E l
2
m k T l
Long section Cross-section
2 5 IO’ 2 5 10’ 2
Head h (cm)
H-flumos
FIG.4.34.
124
Methods of observation and instrumentation
IO’
5
IO’
5
IO’
4
5
û IO‘
-2
\
- 5
m
D
P l
7
.
P I Long section Crosr.seciion
1 5 IO’ 1 5 10’ 2
Head h (cm)
FIG.4.35. Parshall
flume, the Netherlands.
125
Representative and experimental basins
FIG.4.36. 61 c m H-Rume (capacity 312 l/sec) combined with 20 c m S(90') V-notch weir
(capacity 12.5 ]/sec), Ministry of Works, N e w Zealand.
I26
Methods of observation and instriiineiztaiion
Orifices.
Capacity. Limited to small flows where the sensitivity of other measuring devices is inadequate.
Accuracy. Five times that of a V-notch weir.It is particularly useful for flows below 8 c m of
head where the V-notch calibration is unreliable.
Siting criteria or advantages.When used with a tank containing several orifices and where
unlimited head is available, this method is the most accurate for measuring low flows.
Limitations. Head requirements for this device limit its use to sites where considerable head
(approximately 120 cm) is available.
Controls. See Figure 4.41.
Acciiracy. Insensitive,but a steeply angled section maintainsthe low-flowchannel at the recorder
intake pipe.
Siting criteria or advantages. Actas a bed-level control, but the lack of an upstream apron
permits the deposition of coarse bed material around the intake pipe. This causes erratic
low-flowrecording.
Limitations. For optimum performance requires an upstream control to produce scouring
velocities and a pool at the recording section. The upstream control is sited initially on a
temporary basis to find the optimum position for maintaining the pool. Heavy material will
be deposited at the upstream control and periodic removal will be necessary.
127
Representative and experimental basins
25
20
Ul
L
01
L
al 15
E
I
U
O
al
r
FIG.4.39. Design,
5 f
photograph and head-
discharge relationship O
of a Borgne water- O IO 20 30 40 50 60
measuring flume,
Di schar g e mhc.
Luette, Switzerland.
128
Methods of observation and instrumentation
FIG.4.40. Water-
gauging station at
Rappengraben,
Emmental, Canton of
Berne, Switzerland.
129
Representative and experimental basins
4.3.5.2.1 SALT-VELOCITY M E T H O D
C o m m o n salt is used and the time of passage between two measured points taken. A n
electrical detection method is used.
4.3.5.2.2 SALT-DILUTION M E T H O D
A solution of tracer is added at a constant rate and its concentration measured at the
minimum distance downstream at which mixing is complete. A turbulent stream is best.
This method, unlike the salt-velocityprocess,does not require knowledge of the cross-
sectional area. Sodium dichromate and radioisotopes(see section 4.11) have been used.
This method is being developed and shows promise for use in turbulent streams. The
principle involved is similar to that of the radioisotopemethod but has no corresponding
dangers and tracer suppliescan be stocked ready for emergency use.Dyesused are sodium
fluorescein (found unsatisfactory because of adsorption) and rhodamine-B (used by the
United States Geological Survey over distances up to 200 km for discharges of over
600 m3/sec). Another dye,called Pontacyl,is at present in use by the United StatesAgri-
cultural Research Service in Arizona and appears to be the most satisfactory.
4.3.5.2.3 . I N T E G R A T I O NO R ‘GULP’ M E T H O D
In this method the tracer is added rapidly as a single dose of a known quantity. At the
sampling point its concentration is determined at frequent intervals,and the mean con-
centration over the time taken for the whole ofthe tracer to pass is obtained.The advan-
tage of this method, commonly used with radioactive isotopes and dyes,is in avoiding
the use of constant-rateinjection equipment.
130
Methods of observation and instrumentation
The accuracy is low and the method is used only where velocities are too high for
other methods.
4.3.5.3.2 SLOPE-AREA M E T H O D
4.3.5.3.3 VOLUMETRIC G A U G I N G
4.3.5.3.4 OPTICAL C U R R E N T - M E T E R G A U G I N G
4.3.5.3.6 M E A S U R E M E N T OF F L O W T H R O U G H C O N T R A C T E D OPENINGS
4.3.5.3.7 FLOAT M E A S U R E M E N T S
In the U.S.S.R. one commonly used flow-measuringmethod is the use of floats. This
requires measurement of time taken for a float to pass between successive cross-sections
to obtain a measure of the surface velocities.Coefficients are used to convert the surface
velocity to the mean velocity. Such coefficients are obtained from analysis of detailed
131
Representative and experimental basins
i 32
Methods of observation and iiutrumentalion
133
Representative and experimental basins
4.3.6.5 Pressure-bulbrecorders
These have the advantage that a small-diametercopper tube connects the pressure bulb
to the recording instrument,thus avoiding the expense of a stilling-wellinstallation.
A disadvantage is that scale limitationsmake the instrument essentially a utility instal-
lation to be used where highly accurate stage records are not required.A weekly-chart
unit is the standard equipment,but recent developments include a strip chart and range
adjusters.The CSIRO of Australia has developed a pressure-operatedrecorder which can
operate for a year or more without attention.The power supply is a 1.5volt battery [40].
4.3.6.6 Servo-manometer
This is specifically for use where the installation of standard stilling wells ia difficult or
impossible because of unstable terrain, swamp and/or slumping river banks. The main
componentsare a gas purge system,a servo-manometerassembly and a servo-controlunit.
134
Methods of observation and instrumentation
Polyethylene tubing leads the purging gas (nitrogen) to the operating position located
in the river. The pressure from the gas-purge system corresponds to the water pressure
and through a servo-metercan operate a standard water-levelrecorder.The power unit
is a dry battery and field calibration of the instrument is required.
The advantages are portability and hence easy removal to alternative sites. The dis-
advantages are the initialexpense and the possibility of temperamental behaviour.
I35
Representative and experimental basins
4.3.7.6 Float-recorderstructures
The recorder structureis made up of two parts :(a) the recorder housing of size and mate-
rial to suit individual requirements and local conditions of humidity and temperature;
(b) the recorder well which may range in diameter from 40 c m to 125 c m and may be
made of concrete,iron or even of wood.
The concretestructureis used for the permanent key stationswhere ancillary recording
attachments,electric plum bob, telemetering devices, and occasionally both a graphic
and digital recorder may be required.
In general,the structure has to be adapted to suit the gauging site (bridge piers,etc.)
and the flow conditions (sediment concentration,etc.).
4.3.7.8 Flushing
Standard flushing equipment for permanent recorders should include a flushing tank,
a hand pump and an intake pipe with valve. Local meteorological or water-supply
conditionsmay permit the replacement of the hand pump by a reservoir of size sufficient
136
Methods of observation and instrumentation
I to permit repeated flushings. Flushing of the small-structureintake pipe and well will,
because of access problems,require the use of a portable pump for desilting.The recorder
float must be removed.
I
4.3.8 Run-of plots
:1 A run-offplot is a part ofa slopeisolated from the surroundingarea and used for measure-
ments of overland flow.Run-offplot dimensions,depending on the programme,may be
from 30 to 40m2up to severalhectares (see section 2.4.1).
I A run-offplot is surrounded by a water dividing wall and on the lower part of the plot
137
Representative and experimental basins
a flume is constructed (Fig.4.44).Along the walls,on the outside of the plot,small ditches
are made to prevent water flowing from the adjacent slopes into the plot. The gauges
are normally placed in a shelter and from them the water is removed either by means of
an underground pipe or by a collecting channel.When pairs of plots are used, the gauges
can be placed in one shelter house. Water dividing walls may be removable or stable.
In the U.S.S.R. stablewalls are made oframmed clay or reinforced concrete.and remov-
able ones are made of timber or sheet iron.Removable walls are demounted for the period
of mechanized soil clutivation of the plot. The walls are dug in at a depth of 20 c m and
raised above the land surface by 15-20c m (earthen walls by 20-30cm).
2
\ Cross-section A -A
Collecting channels are made of concrete,or tarred wooden planks puttied at joints
and covered inside with roofing iron,or of metal welded strips,or of metal pipes with a
cut-off sector equal to one third of the pipe circumference.For ease of maintenance,
flumes with a rectangular cross-sectionof not less than 10 c m width are usually used.
The outer wall of a flume is made 20 c m higher than the inner one and is raised 10 c m
above the land surface (Fig. 4.45).The inner wall of a flume should be lower than the
land surface by at least 10 c n but not more than 20 cm. T o prevent water leakage
through the joint between the inner flume wall and the plot, a metal sheet is placed in
such a way as to cut nearly horizontally into the ground by 15-20c m (with a slight slope
in the direction of the flume) on one edge and to rest with the other edge upon the flume
wall [163, 1691.
To prevent precipitationfailing directly into the collecting channel the latter is covered
with a metal cap. The flume slope is made as high as possible.
A shelter housing the gauge is either dug into the ground or placed outside the plot at
a distance of 5-10m.The shelterroofis made to rise not more than 0.5m above the ground
surface in regions which have snow cover in winter.The inner shelter dimensions depend
on the size of the measuring tank and the means of water removal.
Inthe shelter,a metal measuring tank and a weir are installed(Fig.4.45).For water-level
measurements a hook gauge and a water-levelrecorder are placed above the tank.
The recommended dimensionsof the measuring tank are:length,1.6m;width,0.8m;
height,up to the weir. The dimensions of the weir (angle and maximum head) are deter-
mined by the value of the estimated peak discharge.
138
Methods of observation and instrumerztatioon
Legend
I. Hook-gauge. 4. Measuring tank, with weir 7. Sewer.
2. Netting. cut (6). 8. Metallic gauge for the
3. Inflow tube. 5. Outflow tap. hook-gauge.
139
Representative und experimental busins
FIG.4.46. General
view of the forest waiter-
balance plot, Valdai
Hydrological
Laboratory, U.S.S.R
140
Methods of observation and instrnmentaation
Legend
1. Perforated tube for inter-
flow.
2. Metallic netted filter.
3. Gravel filter.
4. Impervious wall (clay or
concrete.
5. Clay bed.
6. Polyethylene film.
7. Flume.
FIG.4.47. Water-
collecting devices for a
water-balance plot,
U.S.S.R.
4.4.1.1.1 NETWORKS
141
Representative and experimental basins
This equation may be applied for the approximateestimationof the number of measuring
points for soil moisture on a typical plot or on a whole basin.
The determination of the mean water content in the soil for the whole basin can be
carried out using data obtained from homogeneous sites;the averaging must be done
taking into account the percentage area of every plot.
It has been shown that, for the measurement of a change in soil moisture, a lower
sampling accuracy is required than for the determination of soil-moisturecontent at any
specific time, and also that soil-moisturedetermination at subsites does not need the
accuracy required at master sites [96].
Calibrationof individualunits in individual soils and soil horizons is essential for quanti-
tative measurement of soil-moisturecontent.A calibrationcurve may be prepared by the
use of a pressure-membrane apparatus. The resistance and soil-moisturecontent are
determined for several values of soil-moisturetension and the number of calibration
points required on each block is determined by the uniformity of the blocks. The bulk
density of field samples must be known in order to calculate the percentage volume of
soil moisture.A n unknown hysteresis error is included in the calibrationof the resistance
unii.
142
Meihods OJ observation und instrumenturion
Where marked wet and dry seasons occur,simple resistance units can be very effective
in supplying useful information on soil-moistureconditions.This is not to suggest that
they should be used to compute actual soil-moisturecontents from precise calibrations,
but simply to be used as ‘on-off’switches indicating whether water is available or not
at specific depths in the soil [174].This method is useful for checking leaks in basins.
If run-offis an important facet of the hydrological problem,resistance units can also
be used to study the depth of penetration of rainwater under different land treatments or
covers [51].
Resistance units are particularly useful when reliance must be placed on observers
with very little training,
The greatest advantage of the neutron method over the other methods outlined in section
4.4.1.1.2is achieved when the study requires knowledge of the change in average soil
moisture with time. Experiments conducted in the U.S.A.for example, showed that
thirty-eightsites were required to obtain the soil-moisturecontent to a standard error of
1 per cent, but only two or three sites to measure the change in moisture to the same
precision.It is fortunate that for most basin research programmes greater precision is
required for the change in moisture than the actual content at any one time [234].
4.4.1.1.2.2.1 Access tubing. Plastic, steel, stainless steel and aluminium tubing have
been used and all are satisfactory if thin walled, as long as the tubing has a close fit to
the depth probe and a calibrationhas been run with the tube in position.It may be possible
to installthe tube by driving it down at the same time as the soilis augered out from inside
the tube.A solid rod driven down inside the tubing may be needed to move small stones
aside in gravelly subsoils. A n alternative method is to drill the hole mechanically. It is
important that the tube should fit tightly with no air spaces around it and a small mound
of earth should be pressed around the top of the tube to stop water intake. If the soil
cracks badly around the tube,a new installation is required. The bottom and top of the
access tubing should be sealed with rubberstoppers.It is also desirable,when installingthe
access tubes, to locate the tops of the tubes a uniform height above the soil surface.
Thus a certain distance of lowering will then bring the depth probe to a common soil
depth for all tubes.
4.4.1.1.2.2.2 Menscirement site. It is essential that the site be representativeof its im-
mediate area and that the conditions be maintained constant.Care must be taken not to
trample the vegetation or to compactthe surface in the immediate area of the access tube.
To prevent a change in run-offand evapotranspiration occurring right at the tube, it is
advisable to use a small stand when taking measurements.A smooth,flat (not necessarily
level) area must be maintained for the surface-probemeasurements.
4.4.1.1.2.2.3 Calibration. The most accurate aid to calibration is a metal drum with
height and diameter of 1.25 m and filled with soil of known moisture content and bulk
density.Although the difference in calibration between soils is often small,it is advisable
to complete careful measurements on the full range of soils to be encountered in the
research.Fixed standardsshould be used for periodic checking of the probe.The applica-
tion of the neutron method to the determination of evapotranspiration is discussed in the
literature[23,711.
4.4.1.1.3 F R E Q U E N C Y OF M E A S U R E M E N T
143
Representatbe and experimental basins
144
Methods of observation and instruinentalion
4.4.2.2 Instrumentation
4.4.2.2.1 GEOLOGICAL S U B S U R F A C E T E C H N I Q U E S
Electrical resistivity and spontaneous potential of earth materials in the vicinity of a bore
hole are measured. A sonde,which is lowered into the hole and recorded as it is pulled
145
Representative and experimental basins
out, has four electrodes-two for emitting current and two for recording potential. The
precise definition of formation boundaries is best accomplished by close spacing of the
electrodes. A resistivity log may reveal the lithology and sequence of rock formation and
formation boundaries ; the presence, approximate ionic concentration, and location of
fresh and salt-waterbodies present; the amount of casing in an old well; and an estimate
of porosity. The spontaneous potential log indicates permeable zones (in terms of relative
but not absolute permeability) and may be used to compute ground-waterresistivity [i 501.
Legend
1. Brass tube with scale.
2. Driving insulators.
3. Contacts.
4. Voltmeter.
4
\s + - - i/ I
l
I
5. Electric battery.
6. Shelter.
'3
FIG.4.48. Electrical
contact gauge.
ïhe two most commonly used radiation methods are the neutron and the gamma-ray
techniques.Both methods are used for determination of the porosity of any one formation
(see section 4.11.5).
A sonic log records the velocity of sound waves travelling through a formation.The
speed of propagation is dependent on the elastic properties, porosity, fluid content and
pressure in the strata. Reliable indications of low porosities and denser lithologies
can be derived by this method. The literature discusses well-logging methods in ground-
water investigations [118].
In conjunction with electrical logging programmes, geochemical subsurface methods
could be used. Temperature logs are easiest to acquire and are useful in delineation of
water from separate aquifers.
146
I Methods of observation and instrumentation
The results of pump, slug or recovery tests carried out on wells or piezometers can be
used to evaluate aquifer constants and the hydrological parameters of the subsurface
water. The data collected may be in the form of a continuous analogue, with float or
small-holeadapter,or for long-termrecords,a paper or magnetic tape. Either form can
be easily processed by electronic means and the accuracy of these measurementscan be
made to 0.3 cm.
147
Representative and experimental basins
4.4.2.3.1 ACCURACY
4.4.2.3.2 ADDITIONAL R E Q U I R E M E N T S
4.5 Infiltration
Net precipitation (grossprecipitationminus interceptionloss) arriving at the land surface
becomes divided into two principal components-one involving surface storage and trans-
lation elements and the other subsurface storage and translation elements. These two
systems are separated by a clear physical boundary,but interactin complexways.Because
this interaction involves not only downward motion of water, but also the return of
subsurface water to the surface,infiltration cannot necessarily be considered the single
connecting process between the two major systems.In addition,the infiltration capacity
of a given soil is highly variable, being influencedby texture and structure,moisture
content,protection of the surface from rainfall impact, temperature and other factors
more difficult to evaluate.
Lack of reliable data on infiltration has hindered progress for applications in basin
hydrology. Methods of obtaining such data are analysis of rainfall and run-offdata (see
section 6.1.3.5)by infiltrometer (see below); laboratorymethods;and analysisof relations
between precipitationand ground-waterrise [219].Analysis methods,generally applicable
to small basins only because of heterogeneity of large basins,require costly installations
and long periods of maintenance between informativeevents.
Infiltrometerobservationsmay give a fairly good insight into differences in permeability
of the soil. They do not, however,give exact values of the hydraulic conductivity (see
section 6.1.4).Furthermore,they do not give an evaluation of the infiltration but only an
order of magnitude of the infiltration capacity of the soil.
4.5.1 InJiltrometers
148
Methods o/ Observation and insrriimentution
Legend
i. Feeding reservoirs.
2. Graduated glass tube.
3. Frame.
4. Tube with air inlet tap.
5. Water outlet tube.
6. Inner ring.
I. Outer ring.
Tubes 15.25 c m in diameter and 38 or 51 c m long are jacked into the ground to confine
a column of soil against lateralflow when subjected to a smallhead of water.The gradu-
ated burettes shown in Figure 4.51 have been used to maintain a headinsidethe tube [160].
149
Representative and experimental basins
These burettes are read at regular intervals, as with the rings,to determine the rate of
infiltration. A perforated disc is usually placed on the surface to hold turbidity of the
surface water at a minimum.
150
I Methods of observation and instrumentation
[G.4.52. Tower housing a nozzle and screen for drop formations approximately 6m above plot surface [185].
151
Representative and experimental basins
FIG.4.53. Demountable rainulator assembled for simultaneous operation on three plots [94].
The rotating boom shown in Figure 4.54is ready to apply water to a pair of mulched
plots in a study of highway-bankstabilizationmeasures.Collapsible booms and pneumat-
ic tyres make this a highly portable unit with a minimum of reassembly problems.
A smaller unit,the Purdue sprinklinginfìitroineter [14],uses an overhead nozzle direct-
ing a spray downwardsfrom 2 or 3 m to a plot 1.175 m square.Three nozzles are provided
to give rainfall intensities approximating to 6.35,8.25,or 11.43cm/hr as desired. Run-off
is measured cumulatively by means of a stage recorder in a collecting tank.
Sprinkler-typeinfiltrometers rely mainly upon preliminary and post-testcalibrations
of rainfall intensity. The plot surface is covered by some impervious sheet or pan and
the unit is operated for a given period at the recommended standard pressure to ensure
equilibrium in run-offbefore calibration is started.
In using sprinkling infiltrometers,conditions close to rainfall should be created. Both
the infiltration capacity and the surface detention depend on the rainfall intensity and
duration and on the initial soil-moisturestatus. Experimental plots should be bounded
by walls to prevent lateral surfaceflow and flumes with recording gauges should be used.
O n small sites (0.1-10 mz)sprinkling infiltrometers assure an even sprinkling of the
area with a given rainfall intensity and raindrop energy.In this case the rainfall intensity
may be changed during the experimentif required.
152
Meihods of observuriori and insirunierirurioti
O n larger plots (up to 500 ni3) industrial sprinkling installations,which however fail
to assure an even sprinkling of the area and a constant rainfall intensity and raindrop
energy,are used.
.
The use of sprinkling installations for sprinkling plots with areas of 1-5m2is assumed
to be most effective and economical.
Figure 4.55 gives,as an example,the design of a sprinkling installationfor field exper-
iments of the State Hydrological Institute of the U.S.S.R.The installation consists of
four demountablesections with sprinkling areas equal to 1.5 m2each.
Experiments on the estimation of the infiltration capacity of plots with an area of 1 m2
and over must include regular soil moisture sampling up to a depth of 1.5-2m in order
to establish the initialand final moisture content and the depth of the wetting front below
the surface [66,67, 1951.
153
Representative and experimental basins
154
Methods of observation and ìmtrumentation
Reservoir and
.
.
control unit
y111
RA I N U L A TOR
Scale 1:4
Alternate-base
(separate splash
Aand run-off’
155
Representative and experimental basins
of surface detention causing overland flow. must however be evaluated and deducted
from the rainfall run-offdifference in estimating the curve of infiltration.For this purpose
an analytical run followingthe wet run on the second day is made [161,202].The analytical
run is started at a timewhen the depression storage from the wet run becomes negligible,
but before any appreciable portion of the soil profile has drained,and is continued until
the rate of run-offagain becomes constant. Recession flows are observed in detail for
all three runs: initial,wet and analytical. Since no portion of the profile is allowed to
drain between runs, analyses (see section 6.1.3.5)are based upon the premise that the
rate of infiltration is a constant throughout the analytical run.
The bibliography [2,1711,gives a more complete resum;. Selection of the proper in-
filtrometershould be based upon the needs and resources of the researcher but,if results
are to be applied to natural rainfall,a rainfall simulatoris preferable.Although the larger
plot adds to the applicability of results,it also detracts from the portability of the unit
and poses greater problems of water supply for operations. The type-F infiltrometer
using a 1.85 x 3.69 m rectangular plot has been used [161]to evaluate the infiltration
capacities of various soil-vegetationcomplexes and to prepare isodiabrexal maps (maps
showing lines of equal infiltration capacity) on two basins in Illinois.These maps proved
very useful in designing networks of small plots for sampling the hydrological perform
ance of the two basins under study.
i 56
Methods of observation and instrumentation
Sample plots should be located at random within the identifiable plant communitiesby
the use of grids and a table of random numbers (see section 4.1.1).This will result in
stratified random sampling within basins. After field data have been tabulated and ana-
lysed,the number of samplesneeded for a desired level of accuracy can be determined by
the use of formulas contained in standard statisticstextbooks.If sampling is inadequate,
additional field-sampleplots should be established. Field plots should be permanently
marked for future sampling.
FIG.4.58. A point-quadrat frame used to measure herbaceous cover. Pins are here spaced
2.5 cm apart. Alternate pins can be removed to give 5 cm spacing.
I 157
Representative and experimental basins
FIG.4.59. A large point frame used to measure shrub vegetation.Pins are spaced 7.5c m apart.
158
M e t h o h of'observation and instrumentution
established adjacent to each 30 m transect for counts of woody plant numbers. For in-
tensive studies,heights of trees and shrubs and stem diameters of trees within each plot
should be measured.
30
= 3.2 cu.m per m
3.2 hectare-metres per h e c t a r e
Plot type and sire: Transect 15 m
0.096
15= 0.006 cu.m per rn
0.006 h e c t a r e - m e t r e s per hectare
159
Representative and experimental basins
density, damage by climatological phenomena (hail, storm, frost, etc.), by insects and
other pests, diseases, etc.
The followingprincipal aspects of the growth ofagricultural crops should be surveyed :
seedlings,formationof leaves,formationof lateral shoots,flowering,ripening of seed,and
harvesting.
160
Methods of observation und instrumentation
in the soil. Some definitions are given in section 1.5.Principles of subsurface flow and
unsaturated and saturated flow analysis are discussed in section 6.1.4and in the literature
Wl.
4.7.1 Texture and structure
The texture or size distributionof the primary solid particles may be assessed in the field
by the common method of moistening and manipulation [220]or by dispersion and frac-
tionation in the laboratory [54].There is sometimes a broad correlationbetween texture
and the hydrological behaviour of soils,but as a rule the arrangementof particles or soil
structure,must also be considered.
Soil structure has been defined [28]as ‘thephysical constitution of-asoil material as
expressed by the size,shape and arrangement of the solid particles and voids, including
both the primary particles to form compound particles and the compound particles
themselves’.The quantity,size and continuity of voids or pores are particularly important
in hydrology, since it is in them that water is stored or transmitted during the subsurface
phase of the hydrologicalcycle.The total porosity S t is the percentage of the bulk (macro-
scopic) volume not occupied by solids, and is given by:
t = 100 (i-D/d)
S (9)
where D,the dry bulk density,is defined as M /Vin which M is the mass of soil (oven dry)
in bulk moist volume V ;d,the particle density,is the ratio M /VP where VP is the collective
volume of soil particles excluding pore spaces between them.
Bulk density is a widely used value and is needed for converting water percentage by
weight to content by volume. Owing to swelling and shrinkage with changes of moisture
content,the moisture content at which the bulk volume Vis measured must be specified,
the volume at field-moisturecontent at the time of sampling commonly being used. Bulk
density is convenientlydetermined in stonelesssoils by carefulsampling of soilcores using
a thin-walled metal cylinder;in stony soils alternative methods, such as weighing the
soil removed from a hole of known volume,must be used [27].For sampling soils,special
drills and special cylinders with given volume are often used. In the U.S.S.R. the BP-50
with 100,250and 500 cm3cylindersis used.At depths exceeding 3 m soilsamplesare taken
from drill holes and are subsequently immersed in paraffin. Transmission or scattering
of gamma rays may be used as an in situ method. Details of these methods and their
limitations(see section 4.11) are given in the literature [15].
Particle density is commonly determined by liquid displacement using a pycnometer
[16].A value of 2.65g/cm3is commonly assumed for the particle density of mineral soils,
but lower values are obtained when the content of organic matter is significant.
While bulk density or total porosity may sometimes be adequate to characterize soil
conditions,it is often preferable to measure the pore-sizedistributionor the volume occu-
pied by the largerpores.The literaturegives methods that may be used for these measure-
ments,which are based on a capillary-tubemodel of the soil-porespace [227].In such a
model the suction,h, required to drain water from a capillary of radius r is given by the
capillary-riseequation:
h = 2y cos &/@gr (10)
where :
y =the surface tension of water;
a=the contact angle between water and the surface of the solid (often, but not
always, zero);
@=the density of water;
g =acceleration due to gravity.
161
3
Representative and experimental basins
162
Methods of observation and instrumentation
FIG.4.61. Relationship
between centrifuge-
moisture retention and
saturation-moisture
capacity of 96 soil
samples of similar
geological origin. Saturation-moisturecapacity
4.7.3 Watermovement
Direct measurement of the quantity of subsurface water in contrast to that of surface
water is not possible.Therefore,in studies of hydrologicalconditionsof subsurfacewater,
it is possible only to observe some collateral factors and it is the function of scientific
163
Representative und experimental basins
1 64
Methods of observation and iristrunientation
Freezing and thawing of soils may improve soil tilth in agricultural lands but may also
increase erosion on poorly protected,steep slopes.Alternate freezing and thawing causes
a granulating action on soil clods [9]and moisture content of the soil plays an important
role in their effect. If the soil is dry during winter months, the effect of freezing on soil
structure is minimized. If rain occurs during the thaw cycle, dispersion of aggregated
material may occur [9].
Frost action on soils may cause either aggregation or dispersion, depending on the
nature of crystallizationof ice [120].Slow cooling produces aggregatesunder the influence
of ice-crystalpressure and dehydration. Rapid cooling produces dispersion, as the large
number of small crystals formed causes a breaking-up of aggregates. The freeze thaw
effects on soil erosion are accentuated by hillslope exposure, presence of swelling clays
and density of vegetative cover.
Observations of soil and subsoil frost and thaw should be carried out on one or several
sites,which differ by their vegetation or relief,Where a long frost period occurs,observa-
tions should start on the first day of negative mean air temperature and continue until
after the soil has completely thawed.
The following are suitable methods for the estimation of soilfrost and thaw:
1. The thermometric method, based on measurements of soil temperature at various
depths.
2. The physical-mechanicalmethod,based on an estimate of the changes in soil-physical
and mechanical properties due to a transition of the soil from the thawed to the
frozen state and vice versa (degree of soil-ice concrete,presence of ice crystals in
soil, etc.).
3. The electrometrical method, based on soil electrical resistancemeasurements.
4. The calorimetric method, based on measurements of the heat absorbed by the soil
while thawing.
The thermometric method requires observations of soil temperature at different depths
(in the U.S.S.R. observations are carried out at depths of 0.0, 0.2,0.4,0.6,0.8,1.2,1.6,
2.4 and 3.2m with soil thermometersenclosed in vinyl tubes placed in the soil). By inter-
polation of the readings the depth at which the zero temperature is observed, i.e.,the
boundary of soilîrost,may be calculated.
A cryopedometer,a special instrument for the estimation of soil frost or thaw depth,
is based on physical-mechanicalprinciples.The receiving part of the instrument is a rub-
ber tube with a centimetre calibration and has a diameter of about 1 cm. It is filled with
distilled water,closed at both ends and placed within a protective casing (pipe). This is
then dug into the ground to the maximum possible depth of soil frost.The height of the
column of ice indicates soil-frostdepth in the tube and the length of the thawed part of
the tube indicates the thaw.A piece of thread is run within the rubber tube;this freezes
within the ice and preventsmovement of the ice columnwhen the thaw starts.A cryopedo-
meter is permanently installed on one or more sites which are most typical of the given
basin.
Physical-mechanicalmethods include also measurements of soil-frost depth in open
pits.
The electrometrical and calorimetricmethods have a limited application and are used
only in experimental work.
Observations of soil frost and thaw vary in frequency according to the particular con-
ditions in each country and may need to be frequent when the variations in temperature
are very high.
165
Representative and experimental basins
70
FIG.4.62. Graph of
soil temperature at a
depth of 25 mm below
surface on contrasting
slopes in mountains of hi
western United States. 18 December l'i63
I66
Methods of observation mid instrumentation
of these studies have not always been met and, in many instances,have neglected the
cause-and-effectrelations so important to an understanding of basic processes. The pur-
pose of this section is therefore to define some of the basic processes of basin erosion
and to describe briefly some practical techniques for measurement of erosion and sedi-
ment transport, together with some applications of results.For definitions of terms, see
section 1.5.
The determination of sediment discharge has been the subject of much experimenta-
tion in laboratory flumes and in natural rivers and of instrument development work on
sampling equipment. Nevertheless, the measurement of sheet erosion, soil creep, and
rilling on hillslopes presents problems that have not been satisfactorily solved. in order
to arrive at a sediment budget for a small basin it is essential to determine the sediment
transport on hillslopes as well as in the stream channels [201].
Sheet erosion is initiated primarily by raindrop impact and the detached particles of
soil are transported by overland flow.The kinetic energy of rainfall has been expressed
by the following equation [62]:
E = KV4.33d1.07 i0.65 (12)
where :
E = the soil intercepted in splash samplers during a 30-minuteperiod;
V = the velocity of drops in feet per second;
d = the diameter of drops in millimetres;
i = the intensity of rainfall in inches per hour;
K = a constant.
Raindrop impact can detach large quantities of soil during a storm of high intensity but
other factors,such as vegetation and land slope,influence the transport of the detached
material.In certain areas,diurnalfreeze and thaw cycles may be a greater agent in causing
erosion than raindrop impact (see section 4.8.3).
A universal equation for predicting soil loss from sheet erosion has been developed
by the Agricultural Research Service in the U.S.A.12211.The equation is as follows:
A = RKLSCP (1 3)
167
Representaiive arid experimental basins
where :
A = the average annual soil loss in tons per hectare;
R = the rainfall factor;
K = a soil-erodibilityfactor;
LS = a slope-lengthand steepness factor;
C = a cropping and management factor;
P = the conservationpractice,such as terracing or contouring.
Mass movement or gravity erosion is often not as obvious as sheet or rill erosion, but
where slope conditions such as declivity, density of vegetation and soil moisture are
favourable,large quantities of material are moved downslope. If the mass movement
deposits are transported to the toe of a slope where stream action can undercut them,
the sediment yield may be high. In the south-western United States,measurements of
mass movement show that they constituteless than 1 per cent of the amount contributed
by sheet erosion [63]. In New Zealand,however,mass movement in its many types is a
major erosional process,contributing vast quantitiesof detritus to river systems by direct
movement into the river [37]. This detritus fills the river channel,widens it and enhances
its meander capacity,thereby further increasing the opportunity to cause erosion of toes
of slopes (see Fig. 4.63) [38].
FIG.4.63. Typical toe erosion in an aggrading stream (Ministry of Works, New Zealand).
I68
Methods of observation and Nisrrunieiztaiioii
Run-offplots which are used for overland run-offstudies can also be used for the study
of erosion.
Data on sediment discharge should characterize the natural conditions of a slope.
Therefore the plots should cover either the whole slope from the divide up to the edge
of the drainage network (large plots,up to several hectares) or the upper part of a slope
(small plots up to 1 ha).
Sediment-dischargemeasurements on plots are normally made by sampling at the flume
site.The number of samples required for a determination of the concentration depends
on the daily variations in it. When sediment discharge from the plots is high and when
the sediment discharge and flow vary considerably within a period of 24 hours,the water
should be sampled more frequently,for example, every one or two hours but not less
than four times per 24 hours. During storms the quantity of samples may be considerably
increased.
To establish relations between the sediment discharge and yield and the erosion on the
plot, micro-levelling of the plots should be done (say two or three times a year). For
this purpose permanent benchmarks should be installed alongside the plots.
With the above measurements of sediment and erosion, the following factors should
also be taken into account:the type and mechanical composition of the soil on the plot ;
the character of the surface (ploughed land,fallow land,virgin soil, etc.); the type of
vegetation and its distribution along the slope; the slope and aspect; the amount and
intensity of precipitation and flow;soil frost and thawing,etc.
When the sediment-watermixture from hillslopes reaches the stream channels,they not
only provide the conveyance for erosional debris from the uplands but contribute addi-
tional sediment through erosional processes. Channel-bankand channel-bederosion and
flood-plainscour are examples of the erosion caused by the concentrated flow of water.
4.9.2.2.1 M E A S U R E M E N T TECHNIQUES
4.9.2.2.1.1 Hillslope erosion
A simple way to measure sheet and rill erosion on hillslopes, as it is used in several
countries and is here given as an example,is to take a 25 c m nail,slip it through a large
washer and drive it flush with the land surface.Subsequent erosion will undermine the
washer and let it slide down the nail a distance equal to the increment of erosion [63].
The nails and washers may be installed either in a specified grid pattern on a hillslope or
in transectson contour or downslope (see Fig.4.64).
Mass movement of soil down a hillslope can be measured in a variety of ways. It is
simplest to measure the downslope displacement of individual pins from a surveyed line
169
Representative and experinienfa1 basins
170
Mrthuds uf observation and insirumetirniion
amount of scour and subsequent fill that occurs as the flood wave recedes [63](see Fig.
4.65). A hole is dug in the channel bed and a length of chain is placed vertically in the
hole with a rock or some heavy object wired securely to the bottom of it. The hole is
then refilled.During high flow,when scour occurs,the chain is laid over in a horizontal
pojition to the depth of maximum scour.As the flow recedes,the horizontal portion of
the chain is measured from monumented survey lines and excavated after each flood.
Measurement of the increment of chain that has been laid over in a horizontal position
will give the mximuin scour.The depth of sediment on top of the horizontal chain rep-
resents the fill that has occurred.From these two measurements the net change in the
bed elevation may be determined.
FIG.4.65. Scour chain excavated in channel bed (depth of excavation represents the filling
occurring after scour).
171
Representative and experimental basins
N o reliable devices for sampling bed load exist. All existing devices,when lowered to
the river bottom, disturb to some extent the natural regimen of sediment moving near
the bottom and do not give accurate results.
Although the samplers such as D o n (U.S.S.R.), Sphinx (Denmark) and VUV (Czecho-
slovakia) used for this purpose in various countries are amongst the best available,much
172
Methods of observation ami inscrimientation
doubt is cast on the accuracy of the sampling results. For sampling coarse bed load,
basket samplers and,for sampling sandy and gravel sediments,so-calledribbed samplers
are used (Fig. 4.66).The latter are suitable for bed load with a wide range of particle
size. Apparatus designed to trap and accumulate bed-load sediment must be calibrated
to determine its efficiency for any given condition [102].Efficiencies average about 45 per
cent for basket and pan samplers and about 65 per cent for pressure-differencesamplers.
For a complete discussion of apparatus and techniques for measuring bed load,refer
to the literature [102,2241.
In some cases it may be possible to divert the stream into a natural or artificial pond
or reservoir, or even a tidal basin. This offers the opportunity of estimating bed load or
total load by repeated surveys of the reservoir.
Nuclear techniques for measuring bed-load transport have been most successful (for
details,see section 4.11.1).
I73
Representarive and experimental basins
and by the width of the receiver of the sampler,it is possible to obtain the bed-load dis-
charge per unit of river width at the gauging section.The bed-load discharge for the
entire cross-sectioncan be easily calculated from these data.
Observations of bed load may include the sampling of bed material at several velocity
verticals ofthegauging sectionfor a determinationof the sizecomposition.In the U.S.S.R.,
sampling is done twice yearly (prior to the maximum flood and at its terminal phase).
In countries with rivers of complex-flowregimen,sampling times may be different.
For shallow rivers,where the bottom is composed of gravel and boulders,the charac-
teristics of the bed material can be estimated visually and expressed in per cent per
square metre of the bed area. For this purpose a device such as a steel frame (size 1 x
1 m), divided into 25 squares with 20 c m side,is placed on the river bottom at various
points along the cross-section.Photographic methods are also useful.
Depending on the character of the bed material, the following types of sampler may
be used: (a) devices for sampling bed material with a disturbed structure;(b) devices for
sampling bed material with an undisturbed structure.The first type is useful for sampling
gravel and the second for samplingfine gravelled,sandy and silty material.
Particle-sizedata has many uses. The size of suspended and bed material is importam
in the computation of total sediment discharge.The frequency and kind of particle-size
analysis should be adequate to describe the pertinent characteristics of sediment particles
so that satisfactory comparisons can be made between sediments collected at different
places or from the same place at different times [82].The three most commonly used
methods are: the sieve-pipettemethod; the visual-accumulation-tubepipette method;
and the bottom-withdrawal-tubeand visual-accumulation-tubemethod.
Several different methods have beer? used for sedimentation surveys of small reservoirs.
A field determination of the emergency spillway contour and a selected lower contour,
174
Methods of observation and instrumentation
together with data from several cross-sections or ranges, preferably parallel, provide
adequateinformation.A stage-areacurve is the most direct way to determine the capacity
of a reservoir and the volume of sediment deposits can best be obtained from capacity
differences.A detailed description of this survey method and computationalprocedures
may be found in the literature [224].
175
Representative ami experimental basins
of tributaries and major controls. The minimum programme for representative basins
should include a quality station near the main gauging station.Experimental basins are
likely to require supplemental stations for help in isolating the effects of cultural change
on subsidiary streams and run-offplots.
Water-qualityprogrammes are aimed at the development of procedures for predicting
future changes in the chemical and physical properties of water so that these proven
methods may then be applied to other basins and regions and this should be borne in
mind during the planning stage of all basin studies.
176
Merhods of' observation and ìnstrurne~itariorz
4.11.1.2 Time-integrationmethod
This method consists of monitoring the radioactivityin a section of the river downstream
of the injection section.The time at which the centroid of the activity curve is observed
gives the average time of travel from the injection cross-sectionto the sampling cross-
section.Detection is accomplished either by direct measurement of the radioactivity in
the stream bed or by collection of samples of bed material during the experiment for
subsequent measurement.It can be seen that,in both methods,only the velocity of the bed
material is obtained.To estimate the bed-materialdischarge,an estimate of the depth of
the moving layer must be made. If undisturbed samples are collected from the river bed
it is possible to estimate the depth of the moving layer.If the activities are measured by
lowering a detector to the stream bed,estimationof the depth of the moving layer becomes
difficult.
The measuring system consists of a collimated radioactive source at the surface of the soil
and a detector abovethe snow surface (see Fig.4.67).The radiation received by the detec-
tor is a function of the water content of the snow cover.This design can be reversed by
177
Representative and experimental basins
having the radioactive source above the snow surface and the detector at the soil surface.
Jt is possible to make a continuous record of the water equivalent of the snow cover and
to transmit the information by a telecommunicationsystem.
Geiger-Müllercounters can be used for the detectionof the radioactivity and the source
most commonly used is cobalt-60.This method is particularly suitable for basins with
poor access where an index of the snow pack is to be obtained.
A device which measures the water equivalent of the snow cover and which records
the diminution of natural radiation of the earth under it is being installed in the U.S.S.R.
O n a selected course before and after snowfall,impulses of a medium radioactive back-
ground of the earth activate a telemetering device. The measurements may be made by
terrestrial or aerial survey [235].
I
l I
I
' PROTECTIVE CASING
'IVE
FIG.4.61. Radioactive
snow gauge installed in
Kvilde in 1967 [149].
I78
Methods of' observation and instrumentation
radioactive tracers over conventional ones is the high sensitivity of detection and hence
measurement in both field and in the laboratory. The amount of tracer required is
thus considerably reduced though the cost remains high. A tritium concentration as
low as 1 TU1 can be measured with suitable counting equipment. Tritium has also the
advantage that it is not subject to adsorption, as the tritium atom is incorporated in
the water molicule.
4.11.4.2 Determination of the effective porosity and dilution techniques for the
determination of the direction and velocity of ground water
In addition to the point-to-pointtracing tests,radioisotopescan also be used in combi-
nation with conventional aquifer tests to increase the information obtained concerning
the flow and aquifer characteristics such as effective porosity [109].A n example of the
dilution technique is the so-called single-wellmethod. The tracer is introduced into a
perforated section of a borehole and its vertical movement is prevented by pneumatic
seals. The decrease of the activity in the section is monitored by a collimated or non-
collimated probe. It can be shown that the rate of decrease of activity in the perforated
borehole section through which ground water is allowed to flow is proportional to the
ground-watervelocity.By using a collimated detector to measure adsorption of the tracer
on the walls of the borehole,it is possible to determine the direction of the ground-water
flow,as the adsorption occurs mostly in the direction of the flow. This method of tracer
dilution may also be applied to larger water bodies such as small lakes and ponds which
are in hydraulic connexion with an aquifer.
The single-welltechnique is, however, in a development stage and serious difficulties
exist in the interpretation of the data obtained,owing to the existence of vertical flows
in boreholes [106,109,110,1121.
179
Representarive and experiniental basins
artificial means, but are invariably distributed by natural phenomena and follow closely
the hydrologicalcycle.Time and space variations of the so-called‘isotopiccomposition’
of water are governed only by physical phenomena (i.e.,spontaneous radioactivedisinte-
gration,atmospheric circulation,temperature and evaporation,etc.) except for those of
carbon-14which are also influenced by chemical reactions. For tritium,deuterium and
oxygen-18,however, this problem is negligible and constitutes the definite advantage of
these natural tracers over non-isotopictracers and over carbon-14[106,108, 1121.
The deuterium and oxygen-18contents ô of natural waters are best analysed by mass
spectrometry and are generally expressed in deviations per thousand from an arbitrary
standard,Standard Mean Ocean Water (SMOW). For definitions, see section 1.5 [48].
Csample-CSMOW
ô= x 1,000. (14)
CSMOW
The concentrationsof these stable isotopes in natural waters have a range which is about
200 times greater than the accuracy of measurement; there is ample room therefore to
look for variations and differences and for their interpretation.
The particular interest of deuterium and oxygen-18to the hydrologist lies in the fact
that,although they follow closely the hydrologicalcycle and are not subjectto preferential
adsorption and biological uptake, a change of isotopic composition occurs whenever
there is a change of state such as evaporation or condensation.The liquid phase is thereby
enriched in the heavy isotopic species owing to the lower vapour pressure of water mole-
cules containing deuterium or oxygen-18.This process is called the isotopicfractionation
of water and the ratio of the vapour pressure of the isotopically lighter component
(HPO)to the vapour pressure ofthe heavier component(HD160 or HPO)is the so-called
fractionation factor of the isotopic species concerned.Under normal temperature and
equilibrium conditions,the values of the fractionation factor are 1.OSO and 1.O09 for
deuterium and oxygen-18respectively.In other words, the ratios of the deuterium and
oxygen-18 concentrations of the liquid and gas phases are 1.080 and 1.009,provided
that equilibrium conditions exist (i.e.,that the liquid phase is overlain or surrounded by
saturated water vapour) and that enough time is availablefor molecular exchange [49,521.
Although these phenomena are complex and not yet fully understood,their consequen-
ces in natural waters may be labelled quite simply :the precipitationbecomes isotopically
lighter (i.e.,depleted in heavy isotopic species) with increasing latitude and altitude and
during the colder seasons (Fig.4.68)and there is a significantpositive correlationbetween
the isotopic concentrationsand atmospheric temperatures (Fig.4.69). Evaporating water
bodies such as lakes and reservoirs are,on the other hand,isotopically heavier than the
precipitation,run-offand ground water in the same region (Fig.4.70).
The cyclic seasonalvariations of stable isotopeconcentrationsin precipitationare con-
siderably smoothed during the accumulation and melting of water in the form of snow
and during its movement in the unsaturated zone, so that ground-water samples are
found to exhibit no large time variations with respect to deuterium and oxygen-18 con-
tent. This makes the comparison of different samples more significant and facilitates
identification of the sources of surface and ground waters,estimation of the altitude of
180
Methods of observation and instrrunzentation
recharge areas and determination of connexions between different water bodies such as
lakes,rivers and ground water [172].
O O
Gough Is.-+
6 ‘O = 0.695 ta - 13.6%.
-5 Marion Is. -+ -5
Valentia
(S D = 5.6 to -loo%=) Thorshavn -+
-1 o
Isfiord Svalbard + h CoDenhaqen
. - -10
Tvärminne
Gronnedal 610 N UI tuna
Angrnmgssolik 660N
Scoresbysund 70°NA -1 5
-15
-25 -25
South Greenland
-3c -30
North Greenland
-31 -35
-4( .40
-
x
-4l -45
O
2L4 -5( -50
-50 -40 -30 -20 -1 o o IO 20 oc
181
Representative and expcvirnental basins
the tritium pulse introduced to the river and ground-watersystems and to surface reser-
voirs [53, 112,167).
The half-lifeof tritium is 12.26years. With the precision of available analytical tech-
niques it will be possible to trace recent tritium pulses in ground water for severaldecades.
Tritium concentrations in precipitation are now being measured in some countries and
in a number of stations included in the I A E A / W M O world-widenetwork and it is possi-
ble to estimatethe inputfunction,provided that enough data is avaliableon climatological
and hydrologicalfactorssuch as precipitation,run-off,evapotranspiration,etc. (Fig.4.71).
Some of the major rivers of the world were recently included in this network.Data are
published in the literature-[l05].
FIG.4.69. Monthly 1
oxygen-18and deuterium
concentration in Genoa
precipitation.
8 '80(in %o)
-17 -16 -15 -14 -13 -12 -11 -10 -9 -E -7 -6 -5 -6 -3 -2 -1 b +I 4
-70-
-80-
-90.
Legend -100.
o Lake samples.
A Ground-water samples.
x Monthly precipitation.
FIG.4.70. 8D-81B0
relation, Beysehir-konya
region,Southern Turkey.
182
Methods of'observation and instrumentation
104
103
Legend
1. Vienna.
2. Genoa.
3. Midway Islands.
4.Gough Island.
102
FIG.4.71. Tritium
concentration at selected
stations [105]. IO
4.11.5.3 General
The isotopic methods described above are additional tools for the hydrologist.These
methods requireprecise laboratorywork,and samplescollected in the field must be shipped
to a laboratory.The size of the sample required is not,however,prohibitive;tritium and
carbon-14,for example,require samples of about 1 litre,although for carbon-I4prelimi-
nary field concentration of a larger sample is required. For deuterium and oxygen-18,
only about 20 ml of water are required.
Isotopicanalysis in many cases provides unambiguous answers to questions that can-
not be otherwise resolved.Its greatest value is, however,as a supplement to conventional
hydrologicalwork and its applicationrequires an adequate knowledge of the hydrological
and climatic conditionsin the region studied.
I83
Representative arid experimental basins
intensity for individual storms. The water equivalent of the snow pack needs to be esti-
mated only at the time of its maximum accumulation before the spring snowmelt.
The density of precipitation gauges depends on the drainage area and on the required
accuracy of the precipitation estimation (see section 4.2.1).
Flow should be measured on a gauging station that has adequate facilitiesfor obtain-
ing maximum and minimum flows. This means that it is necessary to install a complete
flow-measuringstation on each representative and experimental basin. Such a station
should include:(a) a water-levelrecorder; (b) a staff gauge and three benchmarks;(c)
a flow-measuringstructure (cableway,footbridge); (d) an artificial control on representa-
tive basins if no natural control is available;(e) a precalibrated measuring structure on
experimentaland small representative basins (see section 4.3.4).
Apart from observations of precipitation and flow,it is greatly desirable,if reservoirs
or lakes are a feature of a hydrological region,to measure evaporation from water sur-
faces by means of evaporation pans. O n all basins it is desirable to measure suspended-
sediment discharge; this does not require great expenditure.
The minimum equipment should also include a simple climatological station for air-
temperature and wind-velocityobservations.
TABLE
4.3. Minimum equipment necessary for basic observations
On a representative basin
Precipitation Precipitation gauges 3-5
Recording raingauges 1-2
184
Methods of observation arid iristrrinientation
@ Radio precipitation gauge. @ Observation well and measuring ;o0 0 ; Strip of forest.
.........
x-4 Snow course.
point of physical properties
of soil.
a I
Bushes.
a Stone talus.
fields.
185
Representative and experimental basins
References
1. ALTOVSKY, A. A. (ed.). 1957. Metodicheskoe rukovodsto
M. E.;KONOPLIANTSEV, PO
izucheniu rezhima podzemnykh vod [Methodologicalmanual on the study of subsurface
water regime]. Moscow, Gosgeolizdat.
2. AMERICAN SOCIETYOF CIVIL ENGINEERS. 1949.Hydrology handbook. New York.(Manual
of engineering practice, no. 28.)
3. AMERICAN SOCIETY OF RANGE MANAGEMENT. 1962.Basic problems and techniques in range
research. Washington, D.C.,with the Agricultural Board, Nat. Acad. Sci.,Nat. Res.
Council. (Publ. no. 890.)
4. AMERICAN SOCIETYFOR TESTING MATERIALS. 1967.Book of ASTM standards.Philadelphia,
Pa.
5. AMOROCHO, J. ; BRANDSTETTER, A. 1966. Characterization of gauge level precipitation
patterns. Amer. Geophys. Un.
6. ANGUS, D.E.1958.Measurements of dew.Climatology and microclimatology.Proceedings
of the Canberra symposium. Paris, Unesco. (Arid zone research, XI.)
7. BALEK, J.; HOLECEK, J. 1965.The influence of density ombrographic network on the accuracy
of hydrologic computation. Symp. Quebec. (IASH publ. no. 67.)
8. BARNES, O.K.;COSTEL, G.1957. A mobile infiltrometer. Agron. J., 49: 105-7.
9. BAVER, L. D.1956. Soil physics. New York, Wiley.
10. BEARD, J. S. 1956. Results of the Mountain Home rainfall interception and infiltration
project in black wattle. J. Sth African Forestry Assn, 27: 72-86.
11. BEARD,L. R. 1965.Use of interrelated records to simulate streamflow.Proc. ASCE,91
(HYS)Pt. 1 :13-23.
12. BEEKHUIS, J.; WILL, G.M.1965.Regional variation in exotic forest productivity in New
Zealand: influencing factors.Proc. 4th N.Z.Geog. Soc. ConJ Dunedin.
13. BENEDICT, P. C. 1957. Fluvial sediment transportation. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Un.,
36(6) :897-902.
14. BERTRAND, A.R.;PARR, J. 1961.Design and operation of the Purdue sprinkling infiltro-
meter. Purdue University Agric. Expt Stn Res. Eull., no. 723.
15. BLACK,O.A. (ed.). 1965. Methods of soil analysis. Pt. 1: Physical and mineralogical
properties. Wisconsin, Amer. Soc. Agron. (Agron. monograph 9.)
16. BLAKE, G. R. 1965. Particle density. In: BLACK(1965) q.v.,chapter 29.
17. BLOEMEN,G.W.1964. Hydraulic device for weighing large lysimeters. Trans. ASAE,
7(3) 297-9.
18. BLOK,T.; COLENBRANDER, H.J. 1966.Discharge measurements by measuring structures
in relatively flat areas.
19. BOCHKOV,A. P. 1965. O raschete osadkov na vodosborakh [On the computation of
precipitation in watersheds]. Materialy soveschania PO voprosam experimentalnogo izuchenia
sloka i vodnogo balansa rechnykh vodosborov,4-7 August 1964,p. 244-51. Valdai, GGI.
186
Methods of observation and instrumentation
I87
Representative and experimental basins
51. DAGG, M. 1962.Physical properties of the surface soils, infiltration and availability of
soil moisture. E. Afr. Agric. For. J., 27:68-70.
52. DANSGAARD, W. 1964. Stable isotopes in precipitation. Tellus, 16(4) :436-68.
53. DAVIS, G.H.et al. 1966.Seasonal variations in the tritium content of groundwaters of
the Vienna Basin, Austria. In: INTERNATIONALATOMIC ENERGYAGENCY(1966), 9.v.
54. DAY, P.R.1965.Particle fractionationand particle-sizeanalysis.In: BLACK(1965), q.v.,
chapter 43.
55. DENDY, F.E.;ASSMUSSEN, L. E.1963.Permeability measurements with small well points.
Presented to S.E.Section, ASAE. Tennessee.
56. DESI, F.et al. 1965.On determining the rational density of precipitation measuring networks,
p. 127-30. Symp. Quebec. (IASH publ. no. 67.)
57. DROST, H.1966. Pre-calibrated fibreglass flow-measurementstructures for experimental
basins. J. Hydrol. (N.Z.), 5(1): 20-4.
58. DROZDOV, O.A.,et al. 1965.Pogreshnost ucheta atmosfernykh osidkov [Errors in pre-
cipitation measurements]. Trudy GGO,vol. 175, p. 24-30.
59. DUBREUIL, P. 1966.Point de vue théorique sur le rôle du sol dans le cycle hydrologique.
Paris. (Cahier Orstom d’hydrologie,no. 6.)
60. DUVDEVONI, S. 1947.A n optical method of dew estimation.Roy. Meteorol. Soc. Quart.
J., 73 (317-8): 282-96.
61. DYGALO, V.S.1959.K voprosu o tochnostiizmereniaosadkov (PO materialam nabludeniy
stokovoistantsiiB.Sareevo) [On the problem ofthe accuracy of precipitation measurements
(by the data of observation on experimentalcatchment of B.Sareevo)]. Trudy GIP,vol.94,
p. 92-9.
62. ELLISON, W. D.1947. Soil erosion studies.Agric. Eng., 28:145444.
63. EMMETT, W.W.1965.The vigil network: methods of measurement and a sampling of data
collected, p. 89-106. (IASH publ. no. 66.)
64. ERDELYSZKY, Zs.; UBELL, K.1962.Experiments for determiningthe variations of ground-
water flow velocity with depth. Periodica Polytecnika, Budapest, 6(3) :205-17.
65. EZEKIEL, M. 1958. Methods of correlation and regression analysis. New York,
Wiley.
66. FEDOROV, S. F. 1950. Opyt primenenia dozhdevalnoy ustanovki dla izuchenia infiltra-
tsionnoy sposobnostipochvy [Someexperience of the sprinkler application for the study
of soil infiltration rate]. Trudy GGZ, vol. 24 (78), p. 109-21.
67. - . 1954. Experimentalnye izuchenie infiltratsii na slabopodzolistykh pochvakh
[Experimentalstudy of infiltrationrate for weakly podzolic soils]. Trudy GGZ,vol.46 (loo),
p. 48-72.
68. ~ . 1963,O vozmozhnosti ispolzovania lizimetricheskikh ustanovok dla izuchenia
elementov vodnogo balansa lesnykhvodosborov [Onthe possibility of lysimeter application
for the study of water balance components of afforested catchments].Materialy mezhduve-
domstvennogo soveschania PO Probleme izuchenia i regulirovania isparenia s vodnoy po-
verkhnosti i pochvy, 30 July-3 August 1963, p. 400-9. Valdai, GCI.
69. FEODOROFF, A.1965.Etude expérimentale de l’infiltrationde l’eaunon saturé.Ann. Agron.,
16 : 127-75.
70. FIERING, M.B. 1964.A multivariate technique for synthetic hydrology.Proc. ASCE, 90
(HY5) 43-61.
71. FILIPPOVA, A. K. 1964.Resultaty sjemok vlazhnosti pochvy na experimentalny vodos-
borakh stokovykh stantsiy [Resultsof soil-moisturesurvey on experimentalbasins]. Trudy
GGZ, vol. 92,p. 104-18.
72. FORSGATE, J. F.,et al. 1965.Design and installation of semi-enclosedhydraulic lysimeters.
Agric. Meteorol., 2 :43-52.
73. GEIGER, K.;HITCHON, B. 1965. Ground-watermeasurement.Proc. Hydrol. Symp. no. 4,
p. 245-65. Ottawa,Queen’s Printer.
74. GERTYSK, V.V.1957.Some data on the role of growing seasonprecipitation in replenishing
the moisture supply in the soil. Trans. V.V. Alekhin Central-Chernozen State Reserve,
Iss. 4.
75. GILLIES, A. J. 1964. Review of snow survey methods and snow surveys in the Fraser
Catchment, Central Otago. J. Hydrol. (N.Z.), 3(1).
76. GOLUBEV, V. S. 1960. O b uchete dozhdevykh osadkov razlichnymi priborami [On the
inventory of rainfall precipitation by various devices]. Trudy GGZ, vol. 81,p. 5-18.
188
Methods of observation and instrume~itarion
189
Representative and experimental basins
105. ~ . 1962-65. Tritium concentration in rain, rivers, oceans and other waters. Vienna.
(WP/17/1-5.)
106. ~ . 1963. Radioisotop& in hydrology.Proc. Symp. Tokyo. Vienna. (STI/Pub/71.)
107. ~ . 1964. The application of radioisotopes to the study of bed-load movement and
transport in rivers. Report on a meeting of experts. Vienna. (STI/Rep/lOl.)
108. ~ . 1964. Tritium and other environmental isotopes in hydrology, meteorology and
oceanography. Report of a panel meeting. Vienna.
109. ___ . 1965. Isotopes in hydrology. Report of a working group in Grenoble.
110. ___ . 1965. Radioisotope instrumentsin industry and geophysics.Proc.Symp. Warsaw.
Vienna. (STI/Pub/ll2.)
111. ~ . 1966. Safe handling of radioisotopes in hydrology. Vienna. (STI/Pub/l31.)
112. ____. 1966. Use of isotopes in hydrology. Proc. Symp. Vienna.
113. JACQUET, J. 1960. Répartition spatiale des précipitations ù l’échelle fine et précision des
mesures pluvioniétriques. Assemblée d’Helsinki.(IASH publ. no. 53.)
114. 1963. Comparaison des procédés de mesure directe de l’évaporationsur des bassins
versants expérimentaux. Assemblée de Berkeley. (IASH publ. no. 53.)
115. JEFFREY, W.W. 1964. Watershed research in the Saskatchewan River headwaters.Proc.
fourth synip. on research watersheds. Guelph,Ontario Agric. College.
116. JENNINGS, E.G.; MONTEITH, I. L.1954.A sensitiverecordingdew balance.J.Roy.Meteorol.
soc., 80 :344.
117. JOHNSTONE, D.;CROSS, W.P. 1949. Elements of applied hydrology. New York.
118. JONES, P. H.;SKIBITZKI,N. 1956. Subsurface geophysical methods in ground-water
hydrology. Advances in Geophys., 3 :241-300. (Amer. Geophys.Un.)
119. JONES, R.L. 1964. A simple dewfall integrator.N.Z.J. Sci.,7(1) :45-50.
120. JUNG, E. 1931. Untersuchungen über die Einwirkung des Frostes auf dem Erdboden.
Kolloidchem, Beihefte, 32 :320-73.
121. KAMIYAMA, K.;MORIGUCH, M.1953. Collectionof fog particles with fine fibre and infra-
red absorption of fog particles. Papers in Meteorology and Geophys.,3 :104-13.
122. KEMPER, W.D.1960. Water and ion movement in thin films as influenced by the electro-
static charge and diffusion of cations associated with clay mineral surfaces.Proc. Soil
Sci. Soc. Amer., 24(1) : 10-6.
123. KINDSVATER, E.; CARTER, R.W.1959. Discharge characteristics of rectangularthinplate
weirs. Trans. ASCE,124: 772-802, paper no. 3001.
124. KING, H. W.;BRATER,E. F. 1963. Handbook of hydraulics. New York, McGraw-
Hill.
125. KITTREDGE, J. 1948. Forest influences.New York, McGraw-Hill.
126. ___ , et al. 1941. Interception and stem-flowin a pine plantation. J. Forestry, 39 :
505-22.
127. KLUTE, A. 1965. Laboratory measurement of hydraulic conductivity in saturated soil.
In: BLACK(1965), q.v.,chapter 13.
128. ___ . 1965. Laboratory measurement of hydraulic conductivity in unsaturated soil.
In: BLACK (1965), q.v.,chapter 16.
129. ~ . 1965. Water diffusivity.In: BLACK (1965), q.v.,chapter 17.
130. ___ , et aí. 1965. Steady-statewater flow in a saturated inclined soil slab. Water
Resources Res., l(2) : 287-94. (Amer. Geophys. Un.)
131. KOLUPAILA, S. 1964. Discussion.Proc. ASCE, 90 (HYI):352.
132. KONSTANTINOV, A. R.;FEDOROV, S. F. 1960. Opyt primenenia gradientnykh macht dla
opredeleniaisparenia i teploobmena v lesu [Some experience of the application of gradient
masts to determine evaporation and heat exchange in the forest]. Trudy GGZ,vol. 81,
p. 91-114.
133. ___ ; KISILENKO, A. A. 1965. Experimentalnye issledovania tochnosti izmerenia
zhidkikh osadkov razlichnymi priborami [Experimental investigation on the accuracy
of liquid precipitation measurements by various devices]. Trudy GGO,vol. 175.
134. KONTORSCHIKOV, A. S.;EREMINA, K.A. 1963. Interception of precipitation by spring
wheat during growing season. Soviet Hydrol.,4 :400.
135. KOSCHMEIDER, H.1934. Methods and results of definite rain measurements:III. Danzig
report (i). Monthly Weather Review, 62 :5-7.
136. KOZLIK, V. 1965. Notions relatives aux recherches scientifiques du réseau nivométrique
représentatif, p. 168-78. Symp. Quebec. (IASH publ. no. 67.)
190
Meihods of observation and instrumentarion
I 137. KRESTOVSKY, O.I.,et al. 1966. Metody ucheta izmenenia zapasov vody na poverkhnosti
vodosborov v pochvo-gruntakh zony aeratsii i zapasov gruntovykh vod [Inventory
methods of water storage change on the surface of basins in soils and subsoils of the
unsaturated zone and underground water storage]. Materialy seniinara po raschetam
vodnogo balansa rechnykh basseinov i organizarsii komplexnykh vodno-balansovykh i
I
agrometeorologicheskikh nabludeniy, p. 67-102. Valdai, GGI.
138. KUZMIN, P. P. 1960. Formirovanie snezhnogo pokrova i metody opredelenia snegozapasov
[Snow-coverformation and methods of snow-storagedetermination]. Leningrad,Gidro-
meteoizdat.
139. . 1961. Protsessy tajania snezhnogo pokrova [Snow-pack melting processes].
Leningrad, Gidrometeoizdat.
140. LANGBEIN, W.B.; HARDISON, C.H.1955. Exíending stream-flowdata.ASCE. (Paper 826.)
141. LAZAREV, K.G.(ed.). 1962.Sovremennye metody analiza prirodnykh vod [Modern methods
of natural water resources analysis]. Moscow, Academy of Sciences of the U.S.S.R.
142. LEBEDEV, A. V. 1963. Metody izuchenia balansa gruntovykh vod [Methods of subsurface
water balance study]. Moscow, Gosgeolizdat.
143. ~- . 1964. Sravniteinaja otsenka dostovernosti nabludeniy za olementami balansa
gruntovykh vod PO lizimetrani [Comparativeassessment of reliability of observations of
underground water components by lysimeters]. Materialy mezhduvedornstvennogo soves-
chania po Probleme izuchenia i regulirovania isparenia s vodnoy poverkhnostin i pochvy,
30 July-3 August. Valdai, GGI.
144. LEONARD, R. E. 1961. Interception of precipitation by northern hardwood. U.S.Forest
Serv. North-easternForest Expt. Stn. (Paper 159.)
145. LEOPOLD, L. B. 1962. The vigil network. ZASH BuII.,7(2): 5-9.
146. LEVY, E.B.;MADDEN, E.A.1933.The point method of pasture analysis.N.Z. J. Agric.,46.
147. LEYTON, L.;CARLISLE, A. 1959. Measurement and interpretation of interception of pre-
cipitation by forest stands, p. 11 1-19 Symp. Hannoversch-Munden.(IASH publ. no.48.)
148. MARSHALL, T. J. 1959. Relations between water and soil. Harpenden, Commonwealth
Bureau of Soils. (Tech. comrn. no. 50.)
149. MARTINEC, J. 1961. Snowmelt-run-offforecasting on the Vltava River. Prague,Hydraul.
Res.Inst. Podbabska.
150. MAXEY, G.1964. Geology.Pt.I: Hydrogeology.In:VENTECHOW(ed.), 1964. Handbook
of applied hydrology. New York, McGraw-Hill.
151. MCMILLAN, W.D.;BURGY,R. H.1960. Interception loss from grass. J. geophy. Res.,
65 :2389-94.
152. MCQUEEN, 1. S. 1963. Coolev and humidifier for subsoil centrifuge. US. Patent Office,
patent no. 3,109,872.
153. . 1963. Development of a hand-portable rainfall simulator injìltrometer. USGS.
(Circ. 482.)
154. ; MILLER, R. F. 1966 (in press). Calibration and evaluation of a wide-range
method for measuring moisture stress in field soil samples.Proc. Unesco symp. on water
in the unsaturated zone, 19-25 June,Wageningen.
155. MILLER, R.F.,et al.1961. Soil moistnre under juniper andpinyon compared with moisture
under grassland in Arizona. p. 233-5. (USGS prof. paper 424-B.)
156. ; RATZLAFF, K.W.1961. Water movement and ion distribution in soils,p. 45-6.
(USGS prof. paper 424-B.)
157. ___ -- . 1965. Chemistry of soil profiles indicates recurring patterns and
modes of moisture migration.Proc. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer.,29 (23): 263-6.
158. MOLCHANOV, A.A. 1960. The hydrological role of forests. Translated and published for
U S D A and National Science Foundation,Washington, D.C. by Israel Programme for
Scientific Translations.
1 159. MORRISSEY, W.B. et al. 1966. Snow surveys. In: NEWZEALAND MINISTRY OF WORKS,
1961. Handbook of hydrologicalprocedures.
160. MUSGRAVE, G.W.; FREE, G.R.1937.Preliminaryreporton a determinationof comparative
I infiltration rates on some major soil types. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Un.,18 : 345-9.
l 161. ; HOLTAN, H.N. 1964. Infiltration.In: VEN TE CHOW(ed.), 1964. Handbook
of applied hydrology. New York, McGraw-Hill.
' 162. NEBOLSIN, S. I. 1929. Meteorological conditions in field vegetation: precipitation and
evaporation.Meteorol. Herald, l(2).
191
Represetitctive and experimental basins
163. ;- NADEEV, P.P. 1937. Elementary poverkhnostny stok (Surface run-off plots).
Leningrad,Gidrometeoizdat.
164. NECHAEV, I. N.1965. Poteri osadkov na smachivanie osadkomerov i metodika korrek-
tirovki summ osadkov [Precipitationlosses by gauge wetting and methods of total rainfall
correction]. Trudy GGO, vol. 175, p. 76-86.
165. NEWZEALAND. MINISTRY OF WORKS. 1965.Calibration of stream-gaugingweirs. Wellington.
(Central Lab. report no. 205.)
166. NIELSEN, D.R.,et al. 1964.Water movement through Panoche clay loam soil. Hilgardia,
35 :491-505.
167. NIR, A. 1964. On the interpretation of tritium 'age' measurements of groundwater.J.
geophys. Res., 69(12) :2589-95.
168. OSBORNE, B. 1953. Field measurements of soil splash to evaluate ground cover. J. Soil
Water Cons., 8 :255-60, 266.
169. OURYEV, V. A. 1953. Experitnentalnye gidrologicheskie issledovania na Valdae [Experi-
mental hydrological investigations in Valdai]. Leningrad,Gidrometeoizdat.
170. PACIFIC SOUTHWEST INTERAGENCYCoMMrr'rEE.1966.Limitarions in hydrologic data. Report
of Hydrological Subcommittee,USDI.
171. PARR, J.; BERTRAND,A.R. 1960.Water infiltrationinto soils.Advances in Agron.,12 :311-63.
172. PAYNE, B. R.;DINÇER, T. 1965. Isotope survey of the Karst region of southern Turkey.
Proc. sixth int. conj on radiocarbon and tritium dating. Pullman, Washington.
173. PENMAN, H. L. 1948. Natural evaporation from open water, bare soil and grass. Proc.
Roy. Soc., A193 :120-45,
174. PEREIRA, H.C.,ec al. 1958. Water conservation by fallowing in semi-arid,tropical East
Africa. Emp. J. expt. Agric., 25(103).
175. ~ . 1962. Assessment of the main components of the hydrological cycle. E.Afr.
Agric. For. J., 27 (special issue).
176. PEREZ, V. F. 1965.Design and operation of hydrometeorological networks in tropical regions.
WMO and IASH.
177. PETERS, D.B. 1965. Water availability.In: BLACK(1965), q.v.,chapter 19.
178. PHILIP, J. R.1966. Plant/waterrelations:some physical aspects.Ann. Rev. Plant Physiol.,
17 :245-68.
179. ___ ;DEVRIES, D.A.1957.Moisture movement in porous materials under temperature
gradients.Trans. Amer. Geophys. Un.,38(2) :222-32.
180. PHILLIPS, E. A. 1959. Methods of vegetation study. New York, Henry Holt.
181. PHILLIPS, J. F. V. 1926. Rainfall interception by plants. Nature, 118: 837-8.
182. POPOV, O.V. 1959. Lysimeters and hydraulic soil evaporimeters, p. 26-37. Symp. Hanno-
versch-Munden,8-13 Sept.(IASH publ. no. 49,)
183. ___ ; PUSHKAREV, V. F. 1964. Gidravlicheskie pochvennye ispariteli-pribory dla
izucheniavodnogo balansa pochvenno-gruntovoy tolschi [Hydraulicsoil evaporimeters-
devices for water balance study of soils and subsoils]. Sbornik rabot PO metodike issledo-
vaniy v oblasti Jiziki pochv. Leningrad,Agrophysical Res. Inst.
184. PRILL, R.C.; JOHNSON, A.I.1959.Effect oftemperatureon moisturecontentsas determined
by centrifuge and tension techniques. ASTM special publ. 254, p. 340-9.
185. RAUZI, F. 1963. Water intake and plant composition as affected by differential grazing
on rangeland. J. Soil Water Cons., 18(3): 114-6.
186. REE,W.O. 1965. Swiss channel-type gauging stations. USDA,Agric. Res. Serv.
187. --; CROW, F.R.1954.Culverts aswater run-offmeasuring services.Ag&. Eng..35(1).
188. REYNOLDS, E. R. C.;LEYTON, L. 1963. Measurement and significance of throughfall in
forest stands. The water relatiom of plants, p. 127-41. Dorking,Blackwell Sci.Publ.
189. RICHARDS, L.A. 1965.Physicalcondition of water in soil.In:BLACK(1965), q.v.,chapter8.
190. ___ et al. 1954. Saline and alkali soils. USDA. (Agric. handbook 60.)
191. RIJTEMA, P. E. 1965. An analysis of actual evapotranspiration. Netherlands, Rept. Inst.
Land Water Management. (Res.paper no. 659.)
192. ROCHE, M. 1963. Hydrologie de surface. Paris,Orstom.
193. RODDA, J. C. 1967. The systematic error in rainfall measurement. J. Inst. Water Eng.,
21 (March) : 173-7.
194. RODE, A.A.1960. Metody izuchenia vodnago rezhimapochv [Methods for studying hydro-
logical soil regimen]. Moscow,Acadexy of Sciences of the U.S.S.R.
195. Roo, S. S. 1965. Resultaty experimentalnykh issledovaniy infiltratsii na malykh vodos-
192
Methods of observation and instrumentation
193
Representative and experimental basins
226. VILLEMONTE, I. R.1943. New-type gauging station for small streams. Eng. News-Record,
131(21).
221. VOMOCIL, J. A. 1965. Porosity. In: BLACK(1965), q.v., chapter 21.
228. WHIPKEY, R. Z. 1965. Subsurface storm flow from forested slopes. IASH Bull.,lO(2):
14-85.
229. WILCOX, J. C. 1965.Time of sampling after an irrigation to determine field capacity of
soil. Can. J. Soil. Sci.,45: 171-7.
230. WORLD METEOROLOGICAL ORGANIZATION. 1962. Guide to meteorological instruments and
observing practices. ( W M O - N o . 8. TP3.)
231. . 1965. Guide to hydrometeorological practices. ( W M O - N o . 168, TP 82.)
232. YOUNG, A. 1960. Soil movement by denudational processes on slope. Nature, 188(4745) :
120-2.
233. ZHELEZNIAKOV, O.V.; DANILEVICH, B. B. 1966. Tochnost gidrologicheskikh izmereniy i
raschetov [The accuracy of hydrological computation and measurements]. Leningrad,
Gidrometeoizdat.
234. ZOTIMOV, N.V. 1964. Opyt izmerenia vlazhnosti pochvy na lizimetre gammametodom
[Experience of lysimeter soil moisture measurements by gamma-method]. Trudy GGI,
vol. 109, p. 140-50.
235. . 1965. O nazemnom metode izmerenia zapasov vody v snege s pomoschju
radioaktivnosti zemli [On terrestrial method of measurement of water equivalent in snow
pack by means of radioactivity of the earth]. Trudy GGI, vol. 130, p. 148-62.
236. ANON.1955. A million random digits with one hundred thousand normal deviates. Glencce,
Ill.,Rand Corp.,Free Press.
237. ___ . 1966. Metodicheskie ukazania Upravleniam gidrometsluzhby [Methodological
instructionsto the offices of the Hydrometeorological Service]. No. 71,Primenie materialov
aerofotocjemki dla izuchenia ruslovykh protsessov i deformatsii beregov vodokhranilisch.
Leningrad, Gidrometeoizdat.
238. , 1966. Metodicheskie ukazania Upravleniam gidrometsluzhby [Methodological
194
Methods of observation and instrumentation
5.0 General
Routine data processing for representative and experimental basins includes the collec-
tion of reliable cartographicalmaterial, used for a physiographical description of basins
and the processing of observationalresults of major hydrologicalvariables.
General recommendationson data-processingmethods are given below.
Some observationaldata should be published for international exchange. This can be
in the form of tables of standard observationaldata on representativeand experimental
basins together with summaries and reviews on research carried out. The major part of
the data should not be published for internationalexchange and is either kept by national
committees for the IHD or with the hydrological or hydrometeorological service of the
country.
196
Data processing and publication
Elevations of land surfaces,which are the basic data for establishing the basin divide,
basin area and other geomorphologicalcharacteristics(see section 6.1.1.2),are expressed
by contours.The following is a guide to a contour interval which may serve as an example
for mapping land of mild slope:
Size of busin M u p srak Coniour
(kni2) inirrval (m)
Special attention should be given to establishing the location of the basin divide. O n
large basins it may be located and established by inspection of the completed contour
map, but on small basins,on-the-groundinspection and surveys should be made to identi-
fy the natural divide. Moreover, on very small basins it may be necessary to construct
small embankmentsto make certain that the divide is permanently established.The arti-
ficial divide should then be surveyed and accurately plotted.
197
Representative and experimental basins
villages and other objects which may influence the hydrological characteristicsof the basin.
The basin divide and the location of ali the points where hydrological observations
are made are plotted on this map. T o indicate principal hydrological installations and
instruments (gauging stations, precipitation gauges, observation wells for ground-water
measurements,etc.), conventional signs are recommended. The size of these signs should
be sufficient to make them readable.
Consideration should be given to constructing the maps as a series of two or more bases.
The first m a p can, for example, include the basin divide, the stream system and the
benchmarks. On a copy of this map, man-made features such as roads, railways and
towns can be superimposed. O n another copy of the m a p the contours can be superim-
posed. Thus, three different base maps are available with only a small amount of additional
effort. This variety of base maps would provide a selection on which to superimpose the
maps of geology, soils and land use, and on which to plot the locations of the hydrolo-
gicd installations.
5.1.1.3.2 SIZE OF M A P S
Maps of different sizes (from a relatively large size, useful as a working map, down to
page size) are often useful for publication. Figure 5.1 is an illustration of a page-size
m a p showing the various features that m a y be shown on topographicalmaps. The m a p
is a reconstruction of a larger scale m a p on which 1.54 m contours were shown. Note
that a graphical scale is a necessity if maps are to be reduced or enlarged from the original
size.
198
Daia processing and publicaiion
Basin Characteristics
1. Size: 69.2 hectares 0.692 kmz.
2. Range in elevation (approx. mean sea level): from 349 to
380 m.
3. Prevailing land slope: 4 and I per cent.
4. Range in land slopes: from 1 per cent to 12 per cent.
5. Length of principal waterway: 746 m.
6. Average slope of principal waterway: 2.2 per cent.
N W 114 S W i14 Section 17 7. Total number of waterways: 4.
8. Number of hectares per waterway: 17.0.
T 6 N R 2 W of 4lh P M 9. Total length of waterways: 1,509 m.
onq 90" 39'W Lai 43'00'N 10. Drainage density (length of waterways per hectare): 21.8 m/h.
II. Form factor: (AiLa)0.76.
Note: Road ditches drain only the road and are not included
in the waterways.
WISCONSIN
I
LOCATION MAP
,/
199
Repvesenrative mid experimental basins
5.1.2.1.2 FEATURES
5.1.2.1.3 CARTOGRAPHY
200
Data processihg and publication
O.
ao
,
I
m
l GR Granite Strike and Dip of Bedding
'
- ...... .. Approximate Contact Boundary
l PO I
Represeniative and experimental basins
5.1.2.2.1 TECHNIQUES
5.1.2.2.1.1 Hydrogeological mapping
202
Dafa processing and publication
5.1.2.2.2 FEATURES
In addition to the features discussed in section 4.4.2.1, the depth to aquifers and their
confining aquicludes should be recorded. The permeability and porosity of each forma-
tion should be quantitatively described as it is obtained from logging techniques and core
samples. Surfaces of shallow ground-water tables and piezometric contours should be
mapped. The three-dimensionalextent of the ground-water flow system should be deli-
neated as controlled by the basin topography,lithology and structure.
Depth and extent of the alluvial fill in a valley are primary factors in site investigations.
Materials can be classified by conventional geological methods or by the unified soil
classification system [59].A proposed check of possible requirementsin site investigations
would include: cohesive or non-cohesive soil materials, consistency of the soil, density,
moisture content,permeability,coefficient of permeability, consolidation,shear strength,
gradation, texture, rock structure, strength of rock, colour, stratigraphy,type of deposit,
geological age, depth, thickness, continuity, structure and paleontology.
5.1.2.2.3 CARTOGRAPHY
203
Representarive aiid experimental basins
are not apparent on the conventionally oriented panel diagram is described in the liter-
ature [il]. Well logs can also be portrayed graphically.
Structure maps, isopach maps, facies maps, geophysical maps and geochemical maps
are useful in portraying subsurface features of interest to research on ground water.
Methods are described in the literature.
Statisticalmodels for use in trend surface analysisand various other aspects of statistical
sampling or analysis of subsurfacedata may be important [28].
Figure 5.4and Table 5.1show the methods which may be used to illustrate graphically
the hydrogeologicalconditionsin a typical basin study.
Standard hydrogeological mapping symbols have been prepared by Unesco [57] and
are suggested for use on representativeand experimental basins where applicable.
5.1.3.1 Techniques
The soil map should be prepared by a soil surveyor experienced in local soil mapping
and familiar with the current concepts of soil genesis and classification.Sufficient time
must be allotted to study the area and to take sufficient samples for field examination
and laboratory analysis.Mapping units are based upon observation of the landscape and
examination of the texture,structure,colour and consistency of samples obtained using
a hand auger or spade to a depth of approximately 1 m.
Soil-identificationsymbols,soil boundaries, streams and drainage-ways,roads,houses
and pertinent reference points may be plotted on the aerial photo or an overlay as shown
in Figure 5.5,a soil map on an aerial photograph of USDA-ARS experimental basin
No.1, Fennimore,Wisconsin.
The base for the finished soil map in Figure 5.6may be a standard topographicalmap of
appropriatescale.The boundaries of each significantsoiltaxonomic unit should be clearly
delineated on this base map. Within the boundary of each such mapping unit, a symbol
or symbols should be printed designating the type of soil,the surface texture,the degree
of erosion, and the mean land slope. Soil boundaries and soil symbols should be in
permanent black ink, complete and legible. Boundaries between soil units may be
solid lines;boundaries between slopeand erosion phases may be dashed and dotted lines
respectively.
204
Data processing and publicution
SINOSTONL.
"El" LITTLE
W E
4
- 0 4 8
kilometres
1 2
UPPER PART ..
~
205
Representative and experimental basins
I Data processing and publication
FIG.5.5. Aerial photograph used for mapping soils, Fennimore, Wisconsin [60].
207
Representative und expeviniental basins
I kilometre
Legend
Symbol Soil fype Sìopc percenfagc Erosion
ChB
JuB
Chaseburg silt loam
Judson silt loam
3-6
3-10
-
-
DsF2 Dubuque silt loam 20-30 moderate
DsE2 Dubuque silt loam 15-20 moderate
DtC2 Dubuque silt loam (deep) 6-10 moderate
DuD3 Dubuque soils 10-15 severe
DuE3 Dubuque soils 15-20 severe
DvC3 Dubuque soils (deep) 6-10 severe
DvD3 Dubuque soils (deep) 10-15 severe
DbD2 Dodgeville silt loam 10-15 moderate
DcC2 Dodgeville silt loam (deep) 6-10 moderate
DdC3 Dodgeville soils 6-10 severe
DdD3 Dodgeville soils 10-15 severe
DeC3 Dodgeville soils 6-10 severe
TaA
TaB2
T a m a silt loam
T a m a silt loam
0-2
2-6
-
moderate
TaB3 T a m a silt loam 2-6 severe
Tac2 T a m a silt loam 6-10 moderate
Tac3 T a m a silt loam 6-10 severe
FIG.5.6. Soil map of experimental basin, Fennimore, Wisconsin. Taken from an aerial
photograph (redrawn from Grant County Soil Survey, USDA, SCS, 1961,plate 46).
(b) Density and age should be determined by ground survey,in conjunction with aerial
photography.The information is most economically inventoried by aerial photography.
A variety of scales is available,including 70 mm photography, and these are in many
cases sufficient to show micro-arrangementon a sample basis.
(c) Association with environment: the mapping of the vegetative cover in relation to
the basin’s soils and physiography is often useful and illuminating.A clearer impression
of the effects of environment on cover development may be obtained by using overlays
of vegetative cover,aspect,elevation,physiography,surficial geology,etc.
In most research basins,periodic resurveys,at aboutfive-yearintervals,will be required
to evaluatechanges in conditionsand &rendclusters in range vegetation.As forestvegeta-
208
Data processing and publication
5.1.6.1 Techniques
Land use is usually mapped at the same time as the soils and to avoid confusion of
boundaries and symbols,the land-usemap is often drawn on an overlay to the soil map.
This is necessarysince soil and land use so often coincide and overlap.
5.1.6.2 Features
Classes of land use may be adapted from a publication such as the Soil Survey Manual
of the USDA (1951), and each class may be given a symbol (e.g.,L for cropland,O for
orchards), though these may prove to be insufficiently detailed.
5.1.6.3 Cartography
If drawn on soil maps, land-use boundaries and symbols are conventionally drawn
in red ink,often with broken lines.The land-useunits may be coloured and the colours
and symbols keyed to a legend which gives detailed descriptions of each land cover or
cultural practice.
The land-usemap should be revised periodically to record changes in land use,forest
209
Repuesentalive and experimental basins
FIG.5.7. Terrestrial stereogram of gravel deposit above weir, Switzer Creek, New York.
210
Data processing and publication
211
Representative and experimental basitu
For the most efficient use of any data collection,an inventory of natural and/or cultural
changes in a basin should be made. This inventory should be made for every representa-
tive and experimental basin in a special register and give the following(see sections 1.4.3
and 1.4.4):
Name of basin,basin area and geographicallocation;
Topic of research;
Date of start of observations;
Informationon the observationpoints and instrumentation; dates of beginning and end
of observations with these instruments;
Changes in the observational programme;
Natural and cultural changes on the basin; forest planting and cutting;ploughing of
waste lands;swamp reclamation;road building, etc.;
Information on significant and unusual hydrological phenomena (catastrophic floods,
mudflows,ice dams,etc.);
Summariesof the investigationscarried out for each year;
Date of completion of observations;
Final observationalresults.
212
Data processiiig and publicarion
21 3
Representative and experimental basins
shows each to be consistent within itself, the record for each location should be treated
separately.
(c) Wetting: the correction value for wetting may be estimated by means of frequent
comparison of a definite volume of water poured into a dry bucket and the amount of
water poured out of this bucket some minutes later. The mean correction is obtained by
taking the average for a large number of tests.
(d) Evaporation from the bucket: corrections for evaporation of precipitation from the
bucket are determined by special experimental data.
(e) Height of gauge: in some cases gauges are installed with their orifices some height
above the ground and the precipitation recorded may be incorrect because of wind effects.
The correct precipitation may be estimated by comparing the data with gauges with
their orifices level with the land surface.
For a thorough analysis of observed data, readings should be compared with those of
nearby gauges. Such comparisons m a y aid in filling in missing records or in detecting
bucket leakage and other malfunctioning of the gauge,irregularitiesin observational dates
and incorrect information concerning the precipitation type (solid, liquid). It is essential
to take into account the c o m m o n type of precipitation that may occur and weather con-
ditions.
For recording raingauges the data should be compared with those of the check gauge
and with the time of the start and end of any storms that may have been recorded by other
recording gauges.
214
Zrnins 5mins 10rnins i5rnins 2Omins 30mins 1 nr 2hr 6nr 12hr
DEPT H m m
5 7 8 9 12 16 27
I INTENSITY
mml nr 60 *L 32 27 24 i6 13.5
Representative and experimental basins
21 6
Data processing arid publication
measurementpoints into the total number of these points.The mean quantityof snowmelt
water under the snow pack should be estimated by multiplying the mean depth of water
by the porosity of the snow saturated by water (1 -ds), where ds is the mean density of
snow not saturated by water.
The total mean water depth on the surface of a basin (or any part of a basin) is estima-
ted by means of summing the corresponding mean amount of water in the form of snow
ice and free (snowmelt) water under the snow pack. When so-called ‘landscape’snow,
surveys are carried out the procedure is as follows.
For every landscape snow course,the mean depth and density of the snow cover,the
water equivalentof the snow pack,the mean depth,the water equivalentof the ice crust,
the water equivalentof the snow pack saturated with water and the total amount of water
on the soil surface should be estimated.
For a small basin (up to 100-200 kmz)the total mean amount of water on the soil
surface is estimated as the mean weighted value of the total water accumulationon indivi-
dual landscapes,taking into account their areas in the basin.
The percentage of landscape elements in the basin may be determined with the aid of
large-scalemaps and plans.
For a large basin, the total mean water content on the soil surface is estimated as the
mean weighted value from the total mean amount of water accumulated on individual
parts of the basin, taking into account their areas. If individual parts of a basin have
approximately equal areas,then the total mean amount of water for the basin is estimated
as the arithmetic average of the total mean amount of water, accumulated on the individ-
ual parts.
The coverage of snow, ice crust and free water for a basin on individual landscape
elements is determined by defining the ratio between the number of points with snow
(ice,water) and the total number of measuring points and is usually expressed as a per-
centage.
The distribution of the areal snow storage required for the analysis of spring floods
and for the calculationof snowmelt intensity may be given in the form of a snow storage
frequency curve. Such a curve is made by plotting areal snow survey data obtained late
in winter (before spring snowmelt) as a frequency curve. The frequency curve shows
which part of the basin has an excessive water equivalentofthe snow pack.
Current analysis of snow survey data is directed at plotting and comparing combined
chronological graphs of temporal variations of major snow-covercharacteristics and cli-
matological factors (precipitation,air temperature).
Snow-surveydata may be tabulated.Such tables could include snow-surveydates,data
on mean depth and density of the snow pack (for the whole basin and for individual
landscape elements), data on the water equivalent of the snow pack,depth of snowmelt
water on the soil surface,the percentage of snow coverage of the basin, the number of
observation points and frequency curves for water equivalent in the snow pack before
snowmelt occurs.
In rugged terrain average basin values are frequently meaningless and studies will have
to be carried out using index values only (see section 4.2.2).
217
Representative and experimental basins
consist mainly of increasesin tree canopy or growth of brush which changesthe intercep-
tion of snow and modifies the movement of wind.
Man-made changes include logging and construction.
Errors may be introduced by a failure to re-establishthe course on the same site on
successive surveys or to change the number of sampling points or by observationalin-
accuracy.
5.3.4 Evaporation
5.3.4.1 Water-balance method
The simplest method for estimating evaporation for a lake or reservoir is by the water
balance,which can be expressed by the water-balanceequation:
E=P+Z-OfAS (1)
where :
E = lake evaporation;
P = precipitation on lake surface;
Z = inflow,by streams of effluent ground water;
O = outflow,by streams or influent ground water;
AS = change in storage of lake.
The reliability of the method depends on the accuracy to which each item of the balance
can be measured or estimated and also on the magnitude of each item in relation to the
evaporation. For each of the water-balance items, the acceptable percentage error di-
minishes in approximately inverseproportion to the relative magnitude of that particular
item.Thus,unless evaporationis of aboutthe same magnitude on the largest ofthe water-
balance items,its determination,by the water-balancemethod, may not be reliable.
218
Data processing and publication
E = Ah+P (2)
where :
A h = hi -hz (the difference in level between the correctedprevious (hi) and the current
(hz) readings)
P = amount of precipitation.
If during a severe storm some water was poured out from the pan to prevent overflow,
the evaporation value for the period between observational dates is estimated by the
equation:
E=h+P-AH (3)
E = P f AH (4)
where AH is positive when water has been added and negative when water has been
poured out.
Current analysis of observational data consists of the determination of relations be-
tween temporal variations of evaporation and hydrological and climatological character-
istics that may cause variationsin evaporation.Simultaneousobservationsof evaporation
pans and evaporation tanks give opportunity for comparing results.
Normally,ten-dayand monthly values of evaporation from water surfaces are esti-
mated together with mean values of causative factors.
Methods for converting pan evaporation data to free water evaporation are given in
the literature [31,43, 68,731.
219
Represeii~ativeand experimental basins
where :
R, = themean extra-terrestrialradiationexpressed in equivalentmm/day of evaporation;
r = the reflection coefficient or albedo of water;
= the Iatitude of the station;
n/N=the ratio of actual to possible hours of sunshine;
u = the Stephan Boltzmann constant (also in equivalentmm/day of evaporation);
Ta= the mean air temperature (absolute);
e d = the actual vapour pressure of the air in millimetres of mercury.
E, = (a + bu)(ea -ed) (8)
220
Daia processing and publication
where u is wind speed and ea-ea is determined from daily mean temperature and
vapour pressure.Wind observations may be adjusted to the standard height of 2 m from:
Heighr (m)
3 4 5 10 15 20
Ratio of wind speed at 2 m to given height 0.94 0.92 0.89 0.78 0.72 0.68
The value of the potential evapotranspiration (Et)from short turf may be determined
from :
Et =fEo (9)
where fis a seasonal factor which, for south-eastEngland,varies between 0.6and 0.8.
There have been a number of amendments to the original Penman method, mainly
concerned with the radiation and wind speed terms and with the effect ofaltitude.
If for the reflection coefficient r a value which applies to the actual surface in question
is used,the value for Et can be calculated directly without the intermediate step of calcu-
lating EO. When measurements of either solar radiation or net radiation are available,
they facilitate determination of H.In the original equation Penman showed that in the
British system of units:
Ea = 0.35(~+ bu)(ea-ed) (10)
then the functions d/(d + y) and y/(d -t y) can be seen as weighting factorswhich are
functionsofmean air temperature and atmospheric pressure. Their variations with tem-
perature and altitude are shown in Table 5.2 [35].
TABLE5.2.
AIíAtv) YI@ 4-Y)
Ta PC)
Sea level 3000111 Sea level 3000111
221
Representative and experimental basins
For snow, evaporation data and the temperature of the snow surface are evaluated.
Soil evaporation is calculated by formulas given in section 4.2.4.2.The depth of the
snow evaporated is estimated from the weight of evaporated snow and the surface area
of the evaporation pan.
Current analyses of observational data on evaporation from soil and snow include
comparing evaporation data estimated by various devices for a similar time interval and
determining relations between temporalchronologicalvariations ofevaporation and tem-
poral variation of the major factors causing them.
In the U.S.S.R. evaporation from the soil,estimated by various methods,is tabulated
showing periods of observation,evaporation from under the vegetation,evapotranspi-
ration,transpiration,precipitation for individual time intervals and total values of these
items.
Tables of evaporation from snow may contain semi-diurnaland diurnal values of
evaporation and the results of regular observations of temperature,absolute and relative
air humidity,wind velocity and the temperature of the snow surface.
The estimation of mean depth of evaporation from representative or experimental
basins may be based on evaporation data from individual areas (forest,grass,etc.). Given
all these data the average areal depth of evaporation for different time intervals (month,
year) is estimated as a mean value, taking into account the size of the individual areas,
expressed as parts of the total basin area [29,301.
222
Data processing and publication
frequently based on a day from 00.00to 24.00 hrs. A standard day should be decided
upon-e.g.,00.00to 24.00 hrs-and all climaticvariables adjusted if possible.
5.3.5.1 Wind
Wind velocity may be recorded manually or automatically.In either case it is the practice
to express values in metres per second (daily,monthly and yearly).
5.3.5.2 Temperature
Temperature data is recorded manually or automatically. In either case data is to be
recorded in degrees Celsius to the nearest whole degree.The daily mean temperature can
be calculated approximately as the mean of the daily maximum and minimum tempera-
tures.
Other important characteristics are the monthly mean temperature,which is the mean
of all the daily mean values for one month, and the annual mean temperature,which is
the mean of all the daily mean values for one year.
For some types of climate the following definitions are useful;the monthly mean maxi-
m u m temperature is the mean of the daily maximum temperature for one month,and the
monthly mean minimum temperature is the mean ofthe daily minimum temperaturesfor
one month.
5.3.5.3 Humidity
Humidity is recorded with an hygrometer or wet- and dry-bulbthermometer.
Daily,monthly and annual values of relative humidity are recorded as for temperature
(see section 5.3.5.2).
The relative humidity can be read directly from the hygrograph chart.Where only
dry- and wet-bulb readings are available,the temperature of the dew point is obtained
from the dry-bulbreading and the temperature difference between wet-and dry-bulbread-
ings. The latter is termed depression of wet bulb. Standard psychrometric tables are
used to convert wet-and dry-bulbreadings to values of relative humidity,expressed as a
percentage.
Of the other methods for expressing humidity (see section 4.2.5) the vapour pressure
oneis probably the most useful.Vapour pressure can be obtained,togetherwith dew point,
from wet- and dry-bulbreadings using standard psychrometric tables.
5.3.5.4 Radiation
Solar radiation data is tabulated in langleys (1 small calorie per square centimetre of
surface per minute) for daily,monthly and annual values.
Sunshine duration records are tabulated as hours of sunshine.
i 223
Representative and experimental basins
where :
e = the air density;
C, = the air heat capacity at constant pressure;
dt/dz= the temperature gradient;
dpldz = the specific humidity gradient along the vertical;
LY = a coefficientof turbulent air flow,determined by the vertical wind profile (taking
intoaccountthe temperaturestratification oftheatmosphereinthefrictionlayer.)
However,the calculation of the value (x at high above-adiabatictemperature gradients
does not give reliable results.For this reason it is better to determine the values Wa and
LEby a simultaneous solution of equations (13) and (14).
The relation between the values L and t may be approximatedusing the Smithequation :
224
Data processing and publicution
Reliable results are not obtained by use of this equation where values of the difference
W p - Ws and of the value de are very small.
In this case the value W u should be calculated by equation (12), the value LE being
obtained as the residual term:
LE= W p - Ws- Wu.
Since the relationsof LEand Wu with temperature and humidity gradients are non-linear,
long-periodaverages should not be used (not even 24-hourvalues).
In the majority of cases, processes of evaporation and turbulent exchange may be
considered stationary or near stationary up to about one hour,and for this reason cal-
culations should be based on hourly averages.
In a number of cases,instantaneous values of the fluxes may be calculated and the
final results averaged. It is therefore necessary to make repeated measurements to obtain
reliable values of the energy fluxes for a given accuracy.The required repeatabilityof the
observations may be determined by means of a series of observations and subsequent
statistical analysis [45]. Further details on energy-balancecomputation are to be found in
the literature [36,431.
225
Representative and experimental basins
discharge.The principle should be that the hydrograph is defined in such a way that
peaks, valleys and points of inflection (instantaneousdischarges) can be reproduced and
mean dischargescan be calculated with a given accuracy.For research on representative
and experimental basins this accuracy may be set at 2 per cent, although this will be
impracticable in many cases.
This consideration may lead to a fixed time interval for observation which may aid
in the selection of the punch-outinterval for punched-taperecorders or selection of take-
off intervals for automatic or semi-automaticchart to digital conversion units.
Where manual processing is done (with or without desk calculator), take-offintervals
depend on chart scales.
For run-offplots,a greater accuracy may be required than for the larger representative
basin where less frequent intervals may be satisfactory (especially if weekly or monthly
charts are used).
The values of such coefficientsmay be interpolated, taking into account the dates of
discharge observations.The discharge at time t may be estimated as qt = C t qk.
In some cases the backwater may be variable and a family of curves will be obtained
for the discharge site,each curve relating to different backwater conditions.
In cases where it is impossible to obtain a uniform discharge curve (e.g.,the channel
is blocked by ice or snow) observations should not be neglected. Flow may,for instance,
be approximately estimated by interpolating from previously observed data, and rating
tables may be developed from the stage-dischargerating curves.Detailed procedures are
given in the literature [61,64, 681.
If a pond exists above the measuring structure,pondage corrections may have to be
applied to obtain discharges unaffected by ponding (the outflow hydrograph is corrected
to produce the inflow hydrograph).
If the pond area is less than 0.5per cent of the basin area,several storms must be
corrected on a trial basis and peak inflow plotted against peak outflow.If a straight line
resultsand no point varies by more than 5 per cent from a 45"line,no pondage correction
is necessary,but if the pond area is between 0.5 and 2.5 per cent of the basin area, a
correction is necessary.
226
Data processing and publication
If the pond area is over 2.5 per cent of the basin area,account should be taken of the
rain falling on the pond when calculatingrun-off[61].
5.4.5 M e a n discharges
The daily mean discharge is the mean flow over a period of one day from 00.00to 24.00
hrs.
The monthly mean discharge is the arithmetic mean of the daily mean discharges over
a period of one calendar month.
The annual mean discharge is the arithmetic mean of the daily mean discharges over
a period of one water year.
The monthly average discharge is the mean of a number (not necessarily consecutive)
of monthly mean dischargesfor a particular month.
The annual average discharge is the mean of a number (not necessarily consecutive)
ofannualmean discharges.
If stage intervals are taken off at irregular intervals,daily mean discharges are calcu-
lated by the method of balancing areas,as shown in Table 5.3.
TABLE5.3.
Instantaneous M e a n discharge Products
Hours (ma/sec) (cols. 3 x 4)
(hrs) discharge (m3/sec)
(1) (2) (3) (4) (5)
00.00
10.00 8 10 8 80
12.00 12 2 10 20
14.00 1O0 2 56 112
15.00 140 1 120 120
16.00 1O0 1 1 20 120
18.00 44 2 72 144
20.00 24 2 34 68
24.00 16 - 4
24
20 80
744
Daily mean discharge: 744/24 = 31 m3/sec.
227
Representative and experinienral basins
NNVTE3
MAQCH
1130
1245 75 40.6
1400 75 38.I
1515 75 35.6
1700 105 33.0
2100 240
._
30.5
2400 i80 2 7.9
MARCH
5 ~~
30 O0 27-9
3130 90 27-9
3200 30 30.5
--
1224 24 33.0
3230 6 35.6 1 I I .287 0059 0.055 0006 0403
3233 3
3236
3239
0242
3
3
3
l. 587
,765-
I 939
0. ;-I-
0073 0069 10003 0.109
__
081 0077 10,0040.113
-t
O089 O085 10.004~-0117
3245 3 -
. - !.323 0.106 0.0% 10.0050.122
3248 3 55.9 ,748 0426 0.116 0.0060.128
3251 3 63.5 3 433 O 157 O 142 0007 0135
1254 3 76.2 4 760 0218 O188 10009 0.144
3257 3- -
88.9 5.294 0.288 0.253 '0013 0.157
I_
3300
-_ 3 104.1
~.
-~
__ 8.468 0.388 0.338,0,0170174
i303 3 119.4 3.952 0.5020.445 10-0220.196
I396 3 132.1 3-30I 0.609 0.556 10.028 0.224
3309 3 144.8 5.885 10.72810.669 0033 O257
COMPUTED BY B. R. P.
CHECKED BY J . M . H.
FIG.5.9. Form for calculating flow records for representative and experimental basins,Ministry of Works,N e w Zea
228
Data pi-ocessirig arid publication
I
5.4.7 Approximate checks on validity of streamflow
Temporal variationsin the flow pattern as observed at a gauging station should be com-
pared with certain climatologicalfactorstocheckapproximatelytheirvalidity.Floodhydro-
graphs caused by rainfall only should be compared with precipitationand air temperature.
Flood hydrographs caused by snowmelt should be compared with water equivalent of
snow cover, precipitation and air temperature. Any variation in the normal low-flow
pattern should be checked with air temperature.
Where more than one gauging station is installed on a basin, it may be possible to
check approximately total seasonalor annual run-offvalues. The total run-offat a gaug-
ing station (QI) should equal the run-offfrom an upstream station (Qz) plus any inflow
between the stations (@). Where such inflow can be estimated with reasonable accuracy,
the difference between QIand 8 2 should not exceed 5 per cent. If greater discrepancies
occur,the flow measurements should be carefully checked.In some cases,great discrepan-
cies may be due to storage between the gauging stations (e.g.,karst phenomena) and/or
the occurrence of springs, etc. In such cases flow measurements between the gauging
stations may aid in clarifying any irregular differences.Unless a cultural or relatively
rapid natural change occurs in a basin,run-offrelations between successive gauging sta-
tions on the same stream should be relatively stable from year to year.
229
Representative and experimental basins
It is useful to tabulate certain soil physical characteristics such as wilting point, field
capacity,saturation,etc.,with these data (see section 4.7).
Soil moisture, expressed as a depth in millimetres of water in the soil,may be plotted
against time for each date on which soil moisture was sampled.Daily amounts of reten-
tion,computed as rainfall minus run-off,can be plotted on the same graph and these two
sets ofdata,retentionand soilmoisture,may be used to estimateaverage rates of moisture
depletion in deriving the moisture status between sampling dates.
Moisture-depletioncurves are useful for analysis purposes. Such curves are affected
by the soil-moisturetension which increases as soil moisture is depleted. Some workers
have described the construction of master depletion curves [5].
The advent of the neutron scatterer (see section 4.4.1.1)allows the depiction of soil
moisture throughout the soilhorizons.Patterns of moisture extraction are extremely use-
ful in analysis (see section 6.1.4)and provide important observations for water-balance
studies.
Data processing of soil physical characteristicsis carried out by standard methods [74].
230
Data processing and publication
160-
140-
120
._.
o
FIG.5.10. Fluctuation n
40 60 80 100 120 140 40 60 80 100 120 140
diagrams for ground- Depth in well A Depth in well A
water observations. a b
This method may be applied to a denser network of observation wells. After sufficient
data have been observed,correlationsmay be established and a limited number of wells
maintained forfurtherobservation.This Correlationis time-consumingbut may be reduced
by considering other factors,such as topography,soil characteristics,etc.
The method is very effective for the determination of the influence of drainage and
pumpage. For this purpose one reference well which is not influenced by such changes
is chosen.Figure 5.11 gives an example of the determination of the effect of temporary
231
~-
680
670
660
650
64C
L
630
3
o
1
+- 61C
FIG.5.11. Effect of .-Is)
a,
pumpage on depth of T I l I I l I I
water table (determined 600 610 620 630 640 650 660 670
from fluctuation
diagrams). River level
pumpage for building purposes on the piezometric head of the ground water. The latter
is plotted against river stage (the well was situated about 350 m from the river). The
original height of the ground water was determined by the river level.
The determination of mean fluctuations of ground water over a basin may be carried
out as follows.
According to the fluctuations of well levels and the specific yield of aquifers,the value
of ground-waterstorage fluctuation for a definite time interval may be determined for
individual points of a basin. After drawing isolines of the given variations on a map.
the areas between adjacent isolines are planimetered. The mean value of ground-water
storagefluctuationsfor each estimated area is taken as half the value of adjacent isolines.
For the entire basin, the mean ground-water storage fluctuations are estimated as a
weighted averagefrom the mean values of the variations for individualareas.If the water-
bearing strata in a basin are homogeneous,then the specific yield may be assumed to be
equal. Mean ground-waterfluctuations for the whole basin may then be estimated as
outlined above. Mean storage fluctuations are obtained by multiplying the estimated
mean fluctuations by the specific yield.
232
Data pr.ocessitig atid publication
a b C
233
Representative and experimental basins
are applied to instantaneous discharges similar to daily mean discharge calculations (see
section 5.4).
A simpler calculation is to apply sediment-dischargerelations to a flow-duration curve.
However, for the relatively small representative and experimental basins, especially those
of a flashy nature, final yields may be underestimated since a flow-duration curve is
calculated from daily mean discharges and not from instantaneous discharges [69,731.
Discharge (rn3/sec.)
234
Data processing and publication
I
5.6.3 Relation to deposits in reservoirs
I
The silting rate of ponds,lakes and reservoirs depends on the annual amount of sediment
transported into the reservoir. For very small reservoirs,a reasonable estimate of this
value may be made by calculating the trap efficiency of the reservoir.This trap efficiency
may be expressed as:
C
TE= -CL (1 8)
G,
where:
TE = percentage trap efficiency;
C = the original reservoir storage capacity in m3/km2;
G, = the annualnet sedimentinflow into the reservoirin m3/km2per year;
CL = the annual silting rate or capacity loss in per cent per year.
As an index to probable trap efficiency, the ratio of storage capacity over basin area
(C/.) is frequently used. T o determine this index,a survey is made of as many reservoirs
as possible in a given hydrological region. This index should not be used outside the
region since,with the same C/Aratio,the trap efficiency will increase as the run-offper
unit area decreases.
For a given period of operation of the reservoir,the annual amount of sedimentation
per square kilometre of its area may be estimated by multiplying the trap efficiency by
the annual sediment inflow.By multiplying this value by the basin area and the number
of years of operation of the reservoir,the total sedimentation may be calculated.Sub-
tracting the latter value from the initial reservoir-storagecapacity,a new trap-efficiency
index may by calculated and a prediction of future sedimentationmay be made by using
this revised trap-efficiencyindex and the expected sediment inflow.
Volume and weight of sediment in reservoirs may not represent total or long-term
average yield from the basin.Reasons include the facts that the period spanned by data
may not be a period of average climatic conditions;that,not uncommonly,data on sedi-
ment yield are from reservoirs of low trap efficiency; that, as a substitute for actual
measurements,no accuratemethod exists for computing amount of sedimentpassing over
spillways; that some data are from reservoirs with ungated outlets (and that sediment
passing through such outlets cannot be calculated satisfactorily); that available data
commonly fail to cover deposits above spillway level (upstream from the reservoir); and
that,in some streams,coarse sediment is a substantial part of the total yield and much
of this may be deposited outside of reservoirs.
235
Represrnraiive and ezrpeuimental basiiw
cations.The ionic run-offis determined by plotting discharge ir1 I/sec on the ordinate
against ionic concentration in mg/lon the abscissa. A curve is drawn through the mean
of the points. Applying this curve to the discharge hydrograph,the daily mean ionic
concentration may be derived.By multiplying the daily mean ionic concentration (mg/l)
by the mean daily run-off(in litres), the daily ionic run-off(in mg) can be calculated.
Adding these values for corresponding periods, the total values of ionic run-offfor a
month, season and year may be derived; these are usually expressed in tons/kni2of a
representativeor experimental basin area.With the accumulation of new data the graphs
should be brought up to date.
The results of chemical quality observations may be tabulated. Such a table would
contain water sampling and analysed data,individualionicconcentrationsof samples,etc.
236
Data processing and publication
Samples of soil are often collected during sampling operations for hydrological studies.
Thesesamples are chosen to be representativeof the depths and soils of particularinterest
to the soil-moisturestudy.The hydrological and physical properties of these samples are
obtained by suitable analyses in the laboratory.
The data are recorded on special summary forms by a suitable system of numerical and
alphabetical codes. These coded data are transferred directly from the summary forms
to punchcards by the key-punch operator. The punchcards are used for automated
231
Representative and experimental basins
333
444 4444444444 444444444444
555
666
777
888
999
Is Il JI
FIG.5.15. Punchcard for data on moisture properties of rock and soil samples.
238
Data processing and publication
5.8.1.4.2 E X A M P L E S OF P R O G R A M M E S A V A I L A B L E
(a) Computer programmes available from the United States Geological Survey, U.S.A.
B220 computer:
Multiple regression analysis. Backwater analysis.
General grain-size analysis. Run-offstatistics.
Flood-stage tables. Diffusion statistics.
Heat conductivity. Probability routing analysis.
Well pressure. Flood statistics.
Temperature effects. Flow through culverts.
Evaluation of aquifer constants. Flow variability.
Evaluation of aquifer constants card prepa- Hydrograph synthesis.
ration. Flow duration.
Drawdown tables. Current discharge.
p H curves. Stream cross-sectionanalysis.
Ionic activity. Random-walkanalysis.
Dissolved oxygen. Cross-sectionwalk analysis.
Ion-exchangechromotographical columns. 3-Drandom walk.
Static distribution coefficients. General least-square polynomials.
Static distribution coefficients II. Geochemical statistical analysis.
Static distribution Coefficients III. Curvilinear regression.
Cation-exchangecapacity. Multiple regression variable generator.
Chemical-wateranalysis. General regional gradients.
Multiaquifer flow. Trend contouring.
Irrigation networks. Orthogonal polynomial surfaces.
Tidal stream analysis. xy-symbol plot.
(b) Computer programmes available from the Water and Soil Division, Ministry of
Works, N e w Zealand, Elliott 503 computer (also available in metric units):
Flow programme for representative basins Current meter calibration (this includes a
(this calculates instantaneous discharge in curvilinear regression analysis of the cali-
cusecs,daily mean dischargein cusecs,daily bration points and the printing of a table
run-offin inches,monthly and annualmean of the velocities calculated from the
dischargesincusecsand maximum and min- equation obtained).
imum instantaneous discharges. Plotting Mean basin precipitation.
of stage and/or discharge is optional). Rainfall correlation.
Flow programme for experimental basins Thornthwaiteevapotranspirationcalculation.
(calculatesdischarge in in/hr,accumulated Penman evapotranspiration calculation.
discharge in inches,total run-offper day, Suspended-sedimentgauging calculation.
month and year in inches, daily mean Sediment-yieldcalculation.
discharge in cusecs, monthly and annual Iteration method of solution of unitgraph.
mean discharge in cusecs.Plotting of stage Matrix solution of unitgraph (least-squares
and/or discharge is optional). method).
Blackwater-curveanalysis. River stones analysis (sphericity).
Cross-section area calculation Multiple regression analysis.
239
Represeníutive and experimental busins
240
I Data processing and publicarion
I 243
Representative and experiniental basins
the data readily accessible and may prevent the loss of invaluable observations.Because
publication of data is more costly and difficult if postponed for a period of years until
the demand becomes very pressing,it should be started well before the demand for data
becomes critical.
If,on the other hand, data are readily available upon demand from computer storage,
little or no publication of basic or processed data may be necessary to meet demands.
Standard publication or demand print-out from the computer system can be evaluated
only on the basis of the needs of the greatest number of users and the relative efficiency
of the agency’s publication and computer systems.
One type of research on representativeand experimental basins requires hydrological
data on a daily, monthly, seasonal and annual basis. This requirement can usually be
satisfied by publications giving daily and monthly means and total of streamflow,precipi-
tation,evaporation and other climatic elements.
A second type of research requiresdetailed analyses of such items as individualstorms
and floods and short-durationdry periods. For such studies,hourly or more frequent
instantaneous data are essential.
The expense ofpublication to suit the second requirementis only occasionallywarranted
and the introductionof efficient data storage and retrieval systems makes detailed publi-
cation of this kind superfluous (see section 5.9). T o give an indicationof the kind of data
available,either a continuous annual hydrograph and/or one or more typical storms per
annum could be published.
Data from vegetation surveys,infiltration research,interception studies,etc., should
not be published in basic summaries,but in annual research reports (see section 1.4.3).
244
Data processing and publication
245
Representative and experimental basins
L
v
246
Data processing and publication
d)
d
O
N
241
Representative and experimental basins
248
Data processing atid publication
X
" f i
3 '9
z =
249
Representative and experimental b a s h
+
+
+,
+
Y
+
+
A I
8z
I
l
~
c
I
I
a
250
Data processing and publication
XI
I-
=I
Y
1-
- 1
I
.9
3
e
.zd
Li
251
Representative and experinierital basins
X
El
H
>
H
Y
U
252
Data processing and publication
Q
CI
~-
V
I
L
X
~ I-
1-F U
r(
I F
- I‘ L ,
I I
-I ü
Y
c
5
d
253
Representative and experimental basins
+
O
rci
O
254
Data processing and publication
255
Representative and experimental basins
8
h
3c
E
L1
c
o
-
T
L1
-
'6
C
c
L1
-
,E
c
L
h
E
h
5
c
,E
1
6
P
V
256
Data processing and publication
257
Representative and experimental basins
...................RIVER Mo. ............. IT ................. WLP REF. ........... REGION .........
IN OPERATION SINCE ................ FIELD AUTHORITY ..............
BASIN YAP: BASIN DEIAILS:
REFERENCES:
PAECIPI
GÏpT
ló
11
12
13
14
15
16
11
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
21
28
29
30
31
1
Canversion to di herge 1 tor.
19... to 19...
Highest
Doi1 Mean D i s c h a r g e Percentage
E g u a f l e d or Erceeded Of of Time of T ~ m r
m'/sec
Representative and experimental basins
References
I. ALTOVSKY, M.E.;KONOPLIANTSEV, A. A. (eds.). 1957. Metodicheskoe rukovodstvo PO
izuchenia rezhima podzemnykh vod [Methodological manual on the study of subsurface
water regime]. Moscow, Gosgeolizdat.
2. AMERICAN GEOLOGICAL INSTITUTE.1965. AGI data sheets, p. 147b. Washington, D.C.
3. AMERICAN Socmn OF PHOTOGRAMMETRY. 1960. Manual of photographic interpretation.
Washington,D.C.
4. ___. 1965. Manual of photogrammetry. Falls Church, Virginia.
5. AMERMAN, et al. 1966.North Appalachian experimental watershed Coshocton, Ohio. Annual
report 1965. USDA, Agric. Res.Serv.,Corn Belt Branch.
6. AMoRocno,J. ; BRANDSTETTER, A.1966. Characterization of gauge levelprecipitationpatterns.
Amer. Geophys.Un.
7. BADGLEY,
P.C. 1959. Structural methods for the exploration geologist. New York, Harper
and Row.
8. BENTAIZ, R.(comp.). 1963.Methods of determining permeability, transmissibility and draw-
down. Washington,D.C. (USGS water supply paper 1536-H.)
9. ___. 1963. Methods of collecting and interpreting groundwater data. Washington, D.C.
(USGS water supply paper 1544-H.)
260
I Data processing and publication
I 261
Representarive and experimental basins
36. MILLER, D.H.1965.The heat and water budget of the earth’s surface.Advances in Geophys.,
11. N e w York, Academic Press.
37. MILLER, R.L.;KAHN, J. S. 1962. Statistical analysis in the geological sciences. New York,
Wiley.
38. MILLER, V. C. 1961. Photogeology. New York, McGraw-Hill.
39. MORRISSEY, W.B. 1964. Interpretation and correction of water-levelrecorder charts. (Hand-
book of hydrological procedures, prov. proc. 32.) Wellington, S C and RCC.
40. NOZIN, V.;PETROV,B.1959.Methods and techniques of field soil mapping.In:I. V. Tjurin
et al. (ed.). Soil survey-a guide to field investigationsand mapping of soils, p. 45-60. Transl.
from Russian by Israel Programme for Scientific Translations.
41. ORLAND, H.P.(ed.). 1965. Standard methods for the examination of water and wastewater,
12th ed. N e w York, (Amer.Public Health Assn., Amer. Water Works Assn., Water
Pollution Control Fed.) Amer. Public Health Assn. Inc., 769 p.
42. ORLOVA, V. V. 1965. Gidrometria (Hydrometry). Leningrad, Gidrometeoizdat.
43. PACIFIC SOUTHWEST INTERAGENCY COMMITTEE. 1966.Limitations in hydrologic data. Chapter
IV: Report of Hydrology Subcommittee, USDI.
44. RETZER, J. 1963. Significance of stream systems and topography in managing mountain
lands. In: C. T. YOUNGBERG (ed.). Forest-soil relationships in North America, p. 399-411.
45. RIOU, CH. 1966. L e calcul de l’évaporation par la méthode du bilan énergétique en zone
sahélienne. Paris. (Cahier Orstom d‘hydrologie,no. 7.)
46. SEARCY, J. K. 1960. Graphical correlation of gauging station records. Washington, D.C.
(USGS water supply paper 1541-C.)
47. SILIN-BEKCHURIN,A. T. 1951. Spetsialnaya gidrogeologia [Special hydrogeology]. M .
Gosgeolizdat.
48. 1965. Dinamika podzemnykh vod (s osnowami gidravliki). [Dynamicsof under-
ground water (with elements of hydraulics)]. Izd. Mosk. Univ.
49. SMITH, H.T. U. 1943. Aerial photographs and their applications. N e w York, Appleton-
Century-Crofts.
50. SOIL CONSERVATION AND RIVERS CONTROL COUNCIL. 1966. Hydrology annual no. 14. Wei-
lington, Govt. Printer.
51. SOIL SURVEY OF GREAT BRITAIN. 1960. Field handbook. London.
52. SWAINSON, O. W . 1938. Topographic mapping. Washington, D.C.,Govt. Printing Office.
(U.S. Coast Geodetic Survey, special publ. 144.)
53. TAYLOR, N.H.;POHLEN, I. J. 1962.Soil survey method. N e w Zealand,DSIR. (Soil Bureau
bull. 25.)
54. THORNTHWAITE, C. W.;MATHER, T.R. 1957. Instructions and tables for computing po-
tential evapotranspiration and the water balance. Publ. in Climarol., lO(3). New Jersey,
Drexel Inst. of Technol.
55. TJURIN, I. V. et al. (ed.). 1965.Pochvennaja sjemka. Rurovodstvo po polevym issledovaniam i
Icaiiirovaniu pochv [Soil survey-a guide to field investigations and mapping of soils].
Moscow, Academy of Sciences of the U.S.S.R.Transl. from Russian by Israel Programme
for Scientific Translations.
56. TOEBES, C. 1964. Daza processing for experimental basins. (Handbook of hydrological
procedures, prov. proc. 33.) Wellington, S C and RCC.
57. UNITED NATIONS EDUCATIONAL, SCIENTIFIC AND CULTURAL ORGANIZATION. 1963. lnter-
national legend for hydrogeological maps. Paris, Unesco. (NS/NR/20.)
58. UNITED STATESDEPARTMENT OF AGRICULTURE. 1951. Soil survey manual. Washington,D.C.
(Agric. handbook no. 18.)
59. ___ . 1960. Soil classification-a comprehensive system, 7th approximation. SCS.
Washington, D.C., Govt. Printing Office.
60. ~ . 1961. A universal equation for predicting rainfall-erosion losses. Agric. Res. Serv.
(Special report 22-26.)
61. ___. 1962. Field manual for research in agricultural hydrology. (Agric. handbook
no. 224.)
62. ____ . 1968. Hydrologic data for experimental agricultural watersheds in the United
Sfates 1962. (Misc. publ. no. 1070.)
63. UNITED STATESDEPARTMENT OF THE INTERIOR. 1952. Water-loss ìnvestigations;Lake Hefner
studies. Tech. report. (USGS prof. paper 269.)
64. ____ . 1965. Discharge ratings at gauging stations. Surface wafer techniques, USGS.
262
Data processing and publication
263
6 Analysis techniques
and interpretation
of research results
6.1 General
The purposes of analysis on representative and experimental basins are:(a) development
of quantitativefactors of the water balance;(b) development of relations between basin
characteristicsand hydrologicalcharacteristics;(c) elucidationofthe hydrologicalcharac-
teristics themselves;and (d) the development of relations between the elements of the
hydrological cycle.
Ideal objectives of such analysis can be summarized as follows:
1. To define a basin by a set of quantitativeparameters,thus permitting translation of
research results to other basins.
2. To define as accuratelyas possible the relevantbasin and climatologicalcharacteristics.
3. To determine mathematical models representing some or all of the hydrological pro-
cesses on representativeand experimental basins.
4. To develop in some caseswater belances for basins.
Although these ideal objectives are worth aiming at, neither the development of satis-
factory practicalmodels,nor the derivation of a quantitativeindex for each physiograph-
ical element of the basin is easy.It is always necessary to consider the ultimate translation
of results to other basins and the hydrological effects of natural and cultural changes on
hydrological prediction and translation of results to other areas.
Research on representativeand experimental basins is more and more directed to a
description of the hydrological processes by complex model systems (see section 6.2).
This tendency should not discourage organizations which are utilizing representative
basins but have not yet the means to permit more complex research.Reasonableresults
may often be obtained by more simple means but,in such solutions,it is important that
the scientistcompareresults with those obtained by previous experience.Simplermethods
are useful but require a great deal of common sense,
264
I Analysis techniques a n d interpretation of research results
Legend
1. = total forest area.
2. = deciduous forest area.
3. = coniferous forest area.
N
E
Y
o
L
+
YI
'u
U
, FIG.6.1. Mass curves
of forest areas in a basin. Basin oreo ( k m * )
To obtain the maximum elevation, either the highest surveyed spot height is recorded
or an approximate value is obtained from the area-elevationcurve. Often, the 5 or 10
per cent value of the elevation-areacurve is better for correlation studies.
T o obtain the minimum elevation,the surveyed altitude of gauge-heightzero flow at
the lowest flow-measuringstructure is recorded. The 90 or 95 per cent elevation is fre-
quently a more significant parameter.
6.1.1.2.3 ASPECT
The maximum valley side-slopeis obtained by selecting the highest slope value normal
to the contours. Measurements should be made at intervals along the steepest valley
walls from the divide to adjacent channels,giving the equation:
where Zis the maximum valley side slope,h the vertical height and I the horizontal dis-
tance from the channel to the divide.
6.1.1.2.5 M E A N SLOPE C U R V E
This curve may be determined by planimetering the area (a)between two adjacnt con
tours and measuring the length (A) of each contour with an opisometer. The area (a)is
then divided by the mean contour length,+(A + A), to obtain the mean belt width. Be-
cause the length of a contour is rarely well defined,care is essential. Too simple or too
complex contour lines must be avoided.The contour heights are plotted on the ordinate
and the accumulated mean-beltwidth on the abscissa.The mean slope of the curve drawn
through the plotted points is the mean slope of the basin (see Table 6.1 and r ig.6.2)
266
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
TABLE6.1
Mean contour
Contour height Contour length L length +@+A) Area LX Mean-belt width
ím) ím) (m) (mz) (m)
268.5 45 - 263 -
270.0 128 86 821 9.45
271.5 223 176 1371 7.85
273.0 193 208 3095 14.89
274.5 153 173 1675 9.66
276.0 156 155 1533 9.86
277.5 142 149 1412 9.45
279.0 130 136 1331 9.66
280.5 60 95 1355 13.88
282.0 10 35 732 20.72
-
p 285
1
I-
- 1
I-Q
f 200
I
c
275
5?
W
I
2 70
œ
6.1.1.2.6 HYPSOMETRIC C U R V E
To determine the hypsometric curve,the continuous function relating the relative height
(y) to the relative area (x) is plotted,y being the ralio of height of a given contour (h)
to total basin height (H) and x is the ratio of horizontal cross-sectionalarea (a) to the
entire basin area (A) (see Table 6.2and Fig. 6.3).
TABLE6.2.
267
Representative and experimental basins
The slope index is derived from two concepts, those of the equivalent rectangle and the
hypsometric surve.
The equivalent rectangle is a rectangle having the same area, the same hypsometric
distribution and the same coefficient of Gravelius as the basin, and a similar drainage
density and vegetation distribution.
100 -
90
70
60
-
o
%SO-
If P is the perimeter of the catchment, A the basin area and K the coefficient of com-
pactness of Gravelius (K=0.28P/1/A), then the length and the width (I) of the equivalent
rectangle are given by :
L=- ""[1/
1.12
1+ 1 - l-z);1( -
and
It should be noted that, by transformation, the contours become straight lines parallel
to the smaller side of the rectangle. If ao, ...at, ...an are the elevations of the different
contours, then the average slope of the area between the lines marked a<-1 and a< is
-
(a< UZ-I)/X~, where xt is the distance between the lines on the rectangle. The so-called
slope index is given by:
If Bt is the fraction of the total basin area lying between the contours a* and ut-I,then:
268
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
The advantage of such an index is that the entire hypsometric distribution is taken into
account and no delicate or uncertain operation such as measuring lengths of contours
(which depends greatly on the accuracy of the contour lines on the map) is required.
6.1.1.2.8 D R A I N A G E CHARACTERISTICS
The maximum channel order may be derived by assigning order one to all unbranched
tributaries as determined from aerial photographs (maps frequently give insufficient de-
tails) and, where two first-orderchannels join, assigning order two to the composite
channel and so on (Fig. 6.4).The maximum order that occurs in the basin is recorded.
FIG.6.4.Channel order
and principal channel
length.
The bifurcation ratio may be calculated by taking the antilogarithm (base ten) of the
regression coefficient from a plot of the channel order against the number of streams
of each order (Fig. 6.5):
Channel order Number of sircams
1 20
2 6
3 1
The total length of channels of a given order is calculated by accumulating the lengths
(in metres or kilometres) of individual segments for that order.The first-ordersegments
are extended to the basin divide or to the internal divide as appropriate.
The length of the principal channel is defined by taking the distance (in metres or
kilometres) from the gauging station upstream of the main divide, selecting at each
junction the segment of the highest order. The principal channel normally begins at the
maximum elevation of the basin (see the unbroken line in Fig. 6.4).
269
Representative and experimental basins
FIG.6.5. Bifurcation
ratio.
CHANNEL ORDER
The drainage density is found by dividing the total length (L)of the channels in kilo-
metres by the basin area (A) in square kilometres.
The average junction angle is defined by measuring all angles between individual
channels and the principal channel at and immediately above the confluence. The stat-
istical average is recorded (see Table 6.3 and Fig. 6.6).
TABLE6.3
Below 60 m (degrees) Above 60 m (degrees)
1. 76 14. 45
2. 58 15. 25
3. 45 16. 25
4. 65 17. 27
5. 20 18. 25
h. 62 19. 32
7. 52
8. 12 Average: 29.83
9. 26
IO. 33
Average: 46.25 Average junction angle: 38.6"
270
Analysis techniques and interpretution of research results
FIG.6.6. Average
junction angle.
271
Representative and experimental basins
For water-balance studies, inflows, outflows and storage in aquifers are importan1
and, for a reasonable determination of such variables, characteristics of aquifers which
are connected to the relevant stream or reservoir should be determined.Such aquifers
should inchide ephemeral zones of saturation (see section 1.5).
Studies to determine which aquifer characteristics are most relevant in the supply of
base flow or interflow should be undertaken. Such characteristics should include the
location of aquifers the lithology of water-bearing strata, the depth of the ground-
water tables, the thickness of the aquifers, etc.
Simultaneous studies can be made of the ground-water balance in the regimen of
subsurface flow (including the temperature regimen and the chemical composition of
ground water).
Where confined aquifers occur, it may be important to study the contribution of
artesian water to flow and,in such a case,piezometric heights and their variations,and
the chemical composition of artesian water should be studied.
Generalhydrogeological characteristicsused in analysis are discussed in section 6.1.4.
In addition,data on discharge fluctuations of springs and on cultural changes affecting
aquifer performance(irrigation,water supply,construction of reservoirs,drainage,etc.),
may have to be studied.
In influent stream systems,channel losses in relation to subsurface flow may require
investigation.This should include the location of the aquifer and the depth of erosion
cut of the channel system.
212
I Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
sidered an important fact,for instance,it may not be certain whether maximum inten-
sity for the storm,average intensity for the storm,or average intensity for any period
of the storm is the most relevant and some or all these characteristics may have to be
considered.
6.1.2.2.1 PRECIPITATION
The parameter n varies between 0.5 and 1 for various basins.In this index Mi does not
converge,but for basins in countries with dry seasons the computation should be stop-
ped at the beginning of the rainy season,without considering the previous rainy season.
In certain cases simplified forms may be used. If, for instance,the storms are of a
similar type and the soil is relatively impermeable,the time t a elapsed between the flood-
producing storm and the first previous storm causing a hydrograph rise may be used.
273
Representative and experimental basiris
6.1.2.2.2 SNOWMELT
Snowmelt studies involve relations between snow characteristics (snow depth, water
equivalent,nature of snow) and relevant climatic characteristics (air temperature,solar
radiation,wind, etc.). Daily variations, e.g.,of temperature,should be considered as
well as averages in any analysis [58].
6.1.2.2.3 TEMPERATURE
For representativebasins, the observation of one climatic station may generally be re-
garded as typical for the basin, although problems may arise in mountainous regions
where the angle of incidence has to be taken into account in analyses (e.g.,in snowmelt
studies); for details,see section 4.2.5.3.
In experimental basins,'datafrom auxiliary stations should be used as discussed in
section 4.2.5.2.1.2.
Humidity data are important in evaporation studies where problems similar to those
discussed in section 6.1.2.2.3arise.
6.1.2.2.6 EVAPORATION
A problem in research involving evaporation data is often the utilization of data ob-
tained by various methods (see section 4.2.4). It is generally useful to compare with
formulas utilizing climatic elements, data from evaporation pans and evaporimeters.
If potential evapotranspiration data produces acceptable results, however, it does not
automatically mean that a workable relation exists between potential and actual evapo-
transpiration for all climatic conditions [59, 82, 1001.
6.1.2.3 Energy-balance
6.1.3 Surface-water
Surface-waterstudies encompass the entire field of surface-flowphenomena. Analytical
work has been restricted mainly to recession studies, hydrograph analyses,infiltration
analyses and unit hydrographs. Not considered are individual studies which relate
214
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
Surface-flowrecession
(surface detention)
Storage in channels
(channel detention 1
(7
Interfbw recession
of part of the hydrological cycle and indicates the various storages from which stream-
flow is supplied.All recessions represent withdrawal from storage modified by channel
storage;the shape of each recession therefore depends not only on the nature and ex-
tent of the storage reservoir,but also on the nature and extent of the channels through
which the flow is routed.
For small basins with an area of less than 10-20km2,channel storage phenomena
are frequently neglected; this applies particularly to arid regions when small storms
275
Represeritative and experimental basins
produce surface run-offwithout filling the channel and without influencing the record
of the gauging station.
Surface flow,if generated by itself, produces a surface-flow hydrograph, the reces-
sion of which represents depletion of surface detention. Interflow is the outflow from
ephemeralzones of ground-waterbut is sometimes indistinguishable from and combined
with the surface flow. The combined flow is called direct flow, and has an associated
direct-flowrecession.Bank storage is sometimes considered separately ; it is the storage
caused by flow into the banks of a stream during rising stages and will deplete during
falling stages, sometimes causing a recession similar to that of interflow.Bank storage
from effluent streams draining relatively small basins may be insignificant,but it may,
however,become important when the point at which the stream changes from effluent
to influent moves considerably downstream during or shortly after heavy rain.
Baseflow is the outflow from more permanent ground-waterzones and normally forms
the tail end of a hydrograph;this tail end is referred to as the baseflow recession (see
section i.5).
Recession studies are invaluable in representative and experimental basin research.
Much work has been done on baseflow recessions for low-flow prediction and basin
comparisons.Research into surfaceflow and interflow recessions is required to improve
techniques of hydrograph analysis (see section 6.1.3.3).Moreover, storage curves,which
may be obtained by integrating surface storage (surface detention), aquifer storage and
soil storage respectively.
Distinction between various recessions is frequently very difficult. Subsurface-flow
studies (see section 6.1.4)will aid research in interflow and baseflow characteristics.
6.1.3.2.1 M A S T E R RECESSION C U R V E S
Any storm hydrograph is a short-termevent and its recession varies from the next one
because of variations in storage.A number of hydrographs of varying magnitude (thus
covering a period of varying storage) can be combined to give a master recession curve,
e.g.,combining individual baseflow recessions gives a master baseflow recession curve.
Three construction methods are available.
(a) The correlation method. This involves the plotting of qt against qt+N (qt,I? days
later) on log-logpaper and drawing a straight line or curve through the points plotted.
If a straight line is drawn through the points at 45" to the axis, the slope of the line is
log k and therefore a simple exponentia1 equation is presupposed (see section 6.1.3.2.2).
(b) The strip method [i 351. This involves plotting individual recessions on tracing pa-
per; they are then superimposed and adjusted horizontally until the main parts overlap.
A mean line through the overlapping parts is the master recession curve. This method
is generally accurate because visual control allows omission of those parts of recessions
which are too high (surface flow) or too low (snowmelt). When the individual recessions
are very flat, it is difficult to decide where they fit together, and the resulting master
recession curve may be either elongated or telescoped.This can be overcome by the
use of a large magnification of the discharge ordinate.
(c) The tubulat'ng method [49].This is essentially the same as the strip method. It in-
volves the tabulation of daily mean discharges of individual recessions in columns (or
instantaneous discharges at a fixed time, e.g.,midnight). The columns are adjusted ver-
tically until the discharges agree approximately horizontally.Subsequently the dischar-
ges are averaged horizontally and these mean discharges constitute the master recession
curve. This method gives a good control of the data,making it less probable that the
final curve will be too long or too short.Its disadvantage is that irrelevant parts of the
recession cannot be omitted without a detailed inspection.
To obtain the overland-flowrecession,the surface-flowhydrograph must be corrected
for channel storage.
276
Ana(yJ'is techniques und interpretation of research resulfs
6.1.3.2.2 RECESSION E Q U A T I O N S
Recessions can be represented mathematically with relative ease. Little theoretical work
has, however, been done on them.
The diminishing discharge from a confined aquifer (i.e., baseflow recession) can be
expressed [127]by the following equation:
qb = q o eëat (8)
where:
qt = the discharge at time t;
q o = the initial discharge;
e = the base of the natural logarithm;
a = a constant.
Normally ëa is replaced by k,which is called the recession constant.
Various empirical equations which represent recessionsmore or less successfully have
been proposed and a number of these are given in the literature [121].
where S is the change in volume of water storage in the interval between the time of
occurrence of q o and qt, or the baseflow (or interflow or surface flow) discharged in the
interval between the times of occurrence q o and qt.
Equation (9) may be used to estimate the volume of baseflow (or interflow or sur-
face flow) which will be discharged in the time interval between any two discharges.
Taking qt as zero and 90 equal to the selected discharge,the volume of water remaining
in storage (and yet to be discharged) in an aquifer,or soil horizon or as surface deten-
tion,may be estimated.
In cases where empirical equations are fitted to recession curves or where no suitable
equation is available,graphical integration by planimetering the area under the recession
curve at suitable time intervals(starting from the end) and plotting these areas (storage
values) in millimetres depth over the basin against the discharge, can be resorted to.
I 277
Representarive and experimental basins
to baseflow. Assuming that a simple exponential equation (equation (8) )fits the reces-
sion,which can be represented by a straight line on semi-logarithmicpaper, detection
of any break is facilitated.
The actual separation consists of connecting the beginning of a rise with a break in
the recession by a straight line [88, 961 or by the alternative methods shown in Figure
6.8 /65,1361. Many other methods have been proposed, but suffer from their subjective
nature. When discharge variations are small, a curve may be suitably traced between
the beginning of the rise and the break in the recession as a function of time encompas-
sing both interflow and baseflow.The curve is drawn from data obtained by a study of
hydrographs which produced interflow only (i.e.,time elapsed between beginning of
Time-
FIG.6.8. Methods of
hydrograph analysis [65].
rise and maximum interflow,ordinates of this maximum, etc.). A close scrutiny of the
hydrographs,whether or not they are composed of interflow only, is essential and cor-
relation with the isohyetal pattern of the storm studied will indicate whether the hy-
drograph is in fact composed of interflow only or of surface flow from the upper pari
of the basin only.
A study of the hydrogeological conditions can be of great assistance and Figure 6.9
shows a number of methods of flow separation with respectto hydrogeologicalconditions
and subsurface ñow towards the stream channel.
278
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
a b at6 atbtc
II
III
IV
279
Representative and experimental basins
In studies involving the unit hydrograph (see section 6.2.5.3)or the isochrone method
11361,characteristicsother than the standard hydrological ones (see section 6.1.3.1)and
recession curves are frequently used.In such cases these characteristicsare derived from
surface-flowhydrographs; they could also be derived,however,from total-flowhydro-
graphs for use in correlationstudies,especially where relations with climatic and basin
characteristicsare considered.
In the case of the unit hydrograph,the storm is characterized by the depth of surface
run-offin millimetres and the hydrograph is expressed in terms of such characteristics
as time of rise, duration of flow, peak discharge, etc.,for subsequent correlation with
basin characteristics.
Such a characterizationis fairly simple for showmelt hydrographsand for cases where
the basin area is smaller than the area covered by the storm.In other cases complications
are likely to arise and,to avoid a number of trial and error attempts,it is useful to es-
timate in advance the order of magnitude of the characteristics.This can be done either
by estimating the minimum depth of precipitation at which surface flow occurs under
given antecedent moisture conditions,estimating the hydrograph characteristics by em-
pirical methods based on known relations with basin characteristics (synthetic hydro-
graphs) [136].The principal characteristics which can be defined are as follows.
(a) Time of rise. This is the interval between the beginning of a rise and the peak of
the hydrograph following this rise. In simple hydrographs caused by short,high-inten-
sity rainfalls the time of rise is usually less than the rainfall duration.
(b) Lug. This is the time interval between the centre of gravity of the effective rain-
fall hyetograph and the flood peak. On very small basins the lag may be shorter than
the time of rise.
(c) Duration offlow or base length. This is applicable in particular to surface-flow
hydrographs.In French terminology this duration corresponds to the time of concen-
tration of a unit flood.
(d) Peak percentage. This is the ratio of the volume of flow (run-off) occurring in a
given time smaller than the total storm period (but including the hydrograph peak) to
the total storm run-off.Any other dimensionless characteristicwhich expresses the peak
discharge in terms of a given run-off(for instance,the ratio of the peak discharge to the
mean discharge for the storm) can be used and will have a much greater magnitude
than the characteristic derived by the first method (except if a very short base length
for calculating the fractional run-offis used to derive the peak percentage).
According to the theory of the unit hydrograph, these four characteristics are in-
variant for a given basin for a storm of infinitely short duration.This may still be appli-
cable to a storm of a duration less than the time of rise and with a not-too-heterogeneous
spatial distribution.
The theory of the unit hydrograph is, however,an approximation which would only
apply if a number of conditions other than those of homogeneity were fulfilled. One
such important condition is constancy of the overland-flowvelocity irrespective of storm
rainfall depth and intensity and of the vegetation condition.
Since overland-flowvelocity is not independent of these factors, it may be useful in
some analyses to consider various types of hydrograph separately. Where distinctrainy
seasons occur and the vegetation cover is significantly different in the dry and rainy
seasons,hydrographs occurring in the beginning and at the end of the rainy season
can be used.A n alternative grouping is hydrographs with small flow volumes and hy-
drographs with large flow volumes.
If any one hydrograph characteristic appears to have rather large variations for a
given number of storms,it is useful to scrutinize the values in relation to the storm pre-
cipitation. This may aid in eliminating those derived from hydrographs which have
280
Analysis rechniqiies und interpueration of research results
abnormally long base lengths or which have been caused by too heterogeneous a
spatial distribution of the precipitation.
In any research where very large floods are of particular interest,hydrographs which
have been caused by homogeneous, high-intensity storms should be selected, even if
storm duration appears, at first sight,to be too long.
For any one basin either the lowest or the mean value of a characteristic is used in
analysis,depending on the purpose of the analysis.Alternatively the characteristics may
be expressed by curves for small or large flow volumes,etc.
In basins with a snow regimen, similar analyses may be made, but, for such basins
air-temperature and solar-radiationvalues are used rather than precipitation data pro-
vided that the snowmelt causing the hydrograph does not deplete the snowpackentirely.
Where the basin area is rather larger than the area covered by a storm,over-allbasin
analyses may be meaningless and more complex models may have to be used.
Procedures for the isochrone method [136], are not as well defined. The duration of
surface or direct run-offis normally studied for typical homogeneous or localized storms.
Such data are used to estimate the time corresponding to the intervals separating two
isochrones.
After flow separation has been carried out (see section 6.1.3.3.1)the surface or direct
run-off,expressed in cubic metres or in millimetres depth over the basin area,is deter-
mined (see section 5.4.6).Except in basins with very intense run-off,the surface or
direct run-offwill vary according to the method used for flow separation. A standard
method of flow separation allows a correlation of depth of run-offwith causal factors.
Some workers have expressed this relation in a coefficient of run-off,which is the
ratio of the storm surface run-offto the total storm precipitation [98]. An alternative
approach is to relate the run-offto the effective storm precipitation (see section 6.1.2.2.1),
or singly to the most intense rainfall. This may lead to more significant run-off coeffi-
cients.
Run-offcoefficients for periods longer than the storm are relatively meaningless un-
less the rainfall intensity pattern is similar for the periods for which they are calculated.
More complex relations involve infiltration studies (see section 6.1.3.5) and general
model studies (see section 6.2).
281
Representative and experimenral basins
depends on whether the rainfall is artificial or natural and on the size of the plot or
natural basin. Five methods are listed below.
(a) Sprinkling-plotanalysis. This method is restricted to data obtained by the use of
a sprinkling infiltrometer (or when a uniform rate of rainfall occurs).
(b) Run-offplotanalysis. This method, while being best suited to data obtained from
studies of plots, can be extended in many cases to data from natural basins of up to a
few square kilometres,provided that the rainfall intensity for the storm analysed can
be considered uniform over the entire basin area.
(c) Natural basin analysis. This is a more approximate but simpler method requiring
uniformity of rainfall over the whole basin area and separate hydrograph peaks from
separate storm peaks. The method is restricted to basins up to about 5 km2.
(d) Natural basin analysis using a flow-linlitcurve. This method, for rather permeable
soils,eliminates interception and surface storage and results from this analysis may be
compared with those obtained by infiltrometer [15].
(e) Natural besin analysis by time-condenscztion method (Holtan method). This method
is perhaps more subjective than the others.It is,moreover,restricted to basins of up to
a few square kilometres and requires uniform rainfall over the basin.It is furtherrestrict-
ed in that only certain types of storms can be analysed.
Detailed procedures for carrying out infiltration analyses are given in the literature
[i20]. Infiltration analysis cannot be used on data from large basins, firstly because
rainfall is generally non-uniformover large areas,and secondly because the errors asso-
ciated with correcting the total-flowhydrograph to obtain the overland-flowhydrograph
are,in the case of any basin but the smallest,too large to produce worth-whileresults.
The effective basin area may, moreover, be a variable quantity in larger basins (see
section 6.3.2).
6.1.3.5.1 GENERAL M E T H O D O L O G Y
The principle of the analysis is based on the comparison of net rainfall (rainfall minus
interception loss) with its associated overland-flowhydrograph.The difference between
the two,correcting for surface detention (Da) and depression storage (Vd),gives a meas-
ure of the average rate of infiltration in the basin.
In the case of sprinkling-plotanalysis,the hydrograph obtained is the overland-flow
hydrograph and a correction has to be made to the gross rainfall for interception loss
(see sections 4.2.3 and 5.3.3).
When infiltration analyses are applied to natural basins, the total-flowhydrograph
measured may have to be corrected for: baseflow (see section 6.1.3.3.1);interflow (see
section 6.1.3.3.1);channel-precipitationflow; channel detention; and gross rainfall for
interception loss.In addition,correctionsmay have to be made to the infiltration curves
derived if, during a storm,rain occurred at a rate less than infiltration capacity.In this
case an actual rate of infiltration,which may be less than the infiltration-capacitycurve,
is derived. Correction is by so-calledtime condensation.For details,refer to the litera-
ture [120].
A test run and an analytical run typical of those made with the Type-F infiltrometer
described in section 4.5.1.4 are plotted in Figure 6.10,together with their graphicalanal-
yses. Since infiltration is constant throughout the analytical run, accumulated rainfall
(e)
excess (Pe)is determinate.The difference between Pe and accumulated run-off is due
to depression storage (Vd) and surface detention (Da). Approximate separations of V d
and D a can be made by relating D a to the rate of flow (4).During hydrographrecessions,
D a is estimated for any given q as the integral of the subsequent recession curve and is
282
I Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
Time (min)
10 I I I I I I I I
1
.I
8-
7-
ó-
5-
4-
/p-F i
Time (min)
FIG.6.10. Test run, analytical run and graphical analyses of Type-F infiltrometer hydro-
graphs [74].
283
Representative and experirnenlal basins
and differences in the Da/q relationship for rising and falling rates of flow are not con-
sidered to be significant errors on small plots. As discussed in section 6.1.3.5.8,the
storage-flowrelationship derived from the recession curve can also be applied to the
rising limb of the hydrograph on larger areas if a hysteresis is induced.
10.0
T7
I
I
I
I
l
FIG.6.11. Detention-
flow relationships for
Type-F infiltrometer run
[106].
.-i,
.- 0.5
L
-
o
.c
0.1
0.01
d
0.05
Averoge depth of deiention,
0.1
Do ( c m )
6.1.3.5.3 R U N - O F F P L O T ANALYSIS
0.5
,
The curves of Figure 6.12,showing the influence of land use on infiltration capacity,
The principle of the natural basin analysis [46]is that for any storm burst resulting in
a hydrograph of surface flow, one average value of infiltration may be calculated for
284
Analysis techniques and interpretation of’research results
FIG.6.12. Mass infiltration curves based on Type-F infiltrometer tests on Cecil, Madison
and Durham soils [44].
the period of the storm burst. A series of storm bursts and associatedhydrographsmay
therefore be utilized to produce a series of average infiltration values which may be
combined in an infiltration curve [97].
285
06’04rm’hi
-P
4-
,
IineC
3- line D
u
C
.-
2-
L
C
3
O
J
il&
a
:1 -
Jz
\
E
C
.-
2 -0 4:OOp.m. -
A U I I
FIG.6.13. Analysis of storm and hydrograph,7 September 1941 ; Control Plot No.6,Lacrosse,
Wisconsin [22].
hours or days (ta) between the storm stuaied and the first antecedent storm that gene-
ated run-off.Any other index, e.g.,the Kohler index,also gives good results.
Neglecting the influence of the rainfall intensity,storm with antecedent index ta will
produce run-offif its storm rainfall depth (P)exceeds the value PO, corresponding to the
value ta or the flow-limitcurve.
The flow-limitcurve is related to a particular soil-vegetationcomplex.If rainfall in-
tensities are plotted for a given storm and a vertical line giving an area to the left of it
equal to the POvalue is drawn,then the area under the curve to the right of this verti-
cal line equals infiltration plus surface flow. O n the remaining part of the hyetograph
the mean infiltration capacities may be determined as described in section 6.1.3.5.4and
Figure 6.15[16].
A curve drawn with various values of F,corresponding to various storni durations,
has always the same origin, indicating similar antecedent moisture conditions.
286
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
R i6
R9
R II
TL
R 32
+
R I?
+ R 33
c R Flow
+ 278
0L Almost negligiblc flow
/
I N NO flow
/ L 14/6
R ?5
,
r)
R I4
20
''I7 N 19,'
/ a N 16
O 2 1 6 a
ia (Time from previous storm in days)
Infiltration capacities determined in this manner are more easily compared with those
obtained by infiltrometer.The method can also be used for small heterogeneous basins.
It gives good results for very small basins and permeable soils.
6.1.3.5.6 NATURAL BASIN ANALYSIS BY THE TIME-CONDENSATION M E T H O D
In this method [43], the time of the rainfall period is condensed to give a constant rate
of rainfall;by condensing the time of the flow at periods of low rates (where surface
detention is at a minimum) in sympathy with the rainfall time condensation, a curve
of P-Qis obtained. This equals infiltration plus surface retention.A correction for sur-
face retention leads to the infiltration curve.
287
Representative and experimental basins
advantage that, in the limit and as t approaches infinity,the infiltration rate does not
become zero. It does not fit well when infiltration rates decrease rapidly and three
parameters are needed to express any particular curve.
Another equation [53]is:
F = cta (12)
where Fis the mass infiltration and c and a are constant.The equation for the rate of
infiltration is obtained by differentiation:
Its scope is also limited,because the value of a, obtained when the equation is fitted.
depends on the range of t. A theoretical derivation is given in section 6.1.4.3.4.
n
40
20
O
17 ie 19 Time (hours)
288
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
FIG.6.16. Developing
q versus D u relation
[122]. Procedure: plot
points and when only a
few points are plotted
and no very definite
trend is apparent, as in
this example, draw upper
-5
and lower envelope lines 5
as shown, using a slope ;
,
of 5:3. Draw the line of
relation for q and D a , -
i
o
using a slope of 5:3 at
half the distance between li: c
the envelopes. Surface detention, D a (cm)
289
Representative and experimental basins
Differences between Pe and the integrated q 2 curve plotted versus q 2 give the type of
hysteresis observed in Figure 6.16.
The effect of natural or cultural changes in basins, may, logically,have great effect
on surface-detention-discharge relationships.The occurrence of hysteresis and the diffi-
culty of deriving such relationships accurately with infiltration analyses make the use of
these in predicting effects rather hazardous.
A n alternative method is to select a number of hydrographs which have uninterrupted
recession from the peak to the end of surface run-off.In such cases surface flow past the
peak is depletion from surface storage only. Correcting the hydrograph for subsurface
flow and channel detention (see section 6.1.3.5.1)allows the development of a relation
between the run-offoccurring after the peak (surface detention) and the peak discharge.
Such a relation is quite stable for relatively stationary conditions in a basin and expres-
ses the relation between the maximum surface detention occurring during storms and
the peak discharge (and not,as in infiltration analysis,a relation between surface deten-
tion and discharge occurring during a storm). This latter relation is subject to great va-
riation from storm to storm owing to rainfall intensity,vegetation and soil conditions.
A n example is given in Figure 6.17.
Equation (9)indicatesthat a simpleexponentialequation may be fitted to the overland-
flow recession (see section 6.1.3.2.2).Experimental evidence, however, indicates that
equation (9) should be written:
q = K Dam. (21)
It has been found that rn = 3.0 for laminar flow and approximately 1.67 for turbulent
flow [47].
o IO..
0.09-
0-08 -
0.07 -
0-06 - p :0-0126 Di
0.05 -
O04 -
.
003-
E
v
e
o 0.02-
P
2=
.VI
-
FIG.6.17. Relation U
between peak discharge 5
and maximum surface 2 0-01
.e .91.0 2 3
I
5
I
6
I I
7 B9Ii
I I
290
I
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
Subsurface water comprises all water below the surface of the ground,A useful way of
classifying subsurface water is to consider saturated and unsaturated conditions.When
soil horizons or strata are saturated,ground water is found;when they are unsaturated,
subsurfacewater is designed as soil water and intermediate water. The boundary between
ground-waterand soil-intermediatewater is a ground-watertable (see section 1 S).
In the unsaturated zone,infiltration and capillary rise are the most important phenom-
ena, apart from temporary storage of water. Ignoring the flow towards plant roots,
which is associated with water uptake by plants and evapotranspiration,the prevailing
flow is in a vertical direction.
The flow of ground-waterdepends on the readiness with which strata can transmit
water and hence on the sequence,thickness and permeabilities of the various strata or
soil horizons. Here horizontal flow will prevail.
For ground-waterflow a large number of analytical solutions for various boundary
conditions is known, while for unsaturated flow only some rather simple steady-state
analytical solutions and a limited number of numerical solutions are available,owing to
the inconstancy of the capillary conductivity.
Studies of subsurface water in the unsaturated zone consist mainly of an interpreta-
tion of rates and volumes of infiltration and computations of a possible rise of capillary
water. The latter is associatedwith water-uptakeby plants (see sections 4.4.1,4.7, 5.5..)i
Ground-water studies concern themselves with the determination of the subsurface
flow boundaries of a basin, an evaluation of the direction and intensity of flow and
evaluation of the hydrogeological characteristics.
For special investigations such as pumping test, well drilling,etc.,and for subsurface-
flow measurement,see sections 4.4.2,5.1.2,5.5.2.For detailed treatment of subsurface-
flow problems, refer to standard textbooks [41,75, 87,1191. Section 6.1.4.2deals with
the principles of subsurface flow,while sections 6.1.4.3and 6.1.4.4give some examples
of unsaturated and saturated-flowanalyses.
velocity to the driving force, the latter being the gradient of the velocity potential 4.
Since the potential gradient is dimensionless(L.L-l)K has the dimensions of velocity
I (L3.L-2.T-1).
K may be defined as the rate of flow per unit cross-sectionalarea perpendicular to
the flow direction under the influence of a unit driving force. Since flow takes place only
l
I in the water-filledinterstices and pores between the soil particles, and since in the case
l of saturated flow all these voids remain completely filled,K is a constant.
~ 291
Representative and experimental basins
In the case of unsaturated flow, part of the voids will be filled with air instead of
with water.Under these conditions the part of the cross-sectionalarea which is effective
in transmitting water will be smaller than that in the case of saturated flow.Moreover,
the effective part of the cross-sectionalarea,i.e.,the part of the pores filled with water
decreases with decreasing moisture content and hence, in the case of an unsaturated
zone,K is not a constant but a function of the moisture content.In this case K is called
the capillary conductivity.As saturation is approached,the capillary conductivity ap-
proaches the hydraulic conductivity (see section 1S).The velocity potential + consists
of two parts: one due to pressure (p) and the other to elevation (b). Therefore:
Ifp is expressed in length of water column, 4 also has the dimension of length and then
it represents the piezometric head, i.e.,the height of water in a piezometer placed with
its bottom at the point under consideration.The value of p then represents the height
of the water column in the pipe,
Soil water is held by forces of adsorption cohesion and solution and is therefore not
capable of doing as much work as pure, free water. For most flow problems it suffices
to deal with forces due to the attraction of the soil matrix. In order to cause the water
to move out of an unsaturated zone against the forces of the soil matrix,a certain suction
or tension must be applied.
In other words,soil water, in contrast to ground-water,has a negative pressure com-
ponent of the potential. Normally the matricial suction designated by y is taken as a
positive value and therefore equation (23) for unsaturated flow should be read as:
The flow of water in an unsaturated soil must obey the law of conservation of matter.
Hence the principle of continuity must be valid, and therefore:
av - --
_ a+
as at
which expresses the idea that the difference of the flowinto and out of an element equals
the rate of storage.In the latter equation 4 represents the volumetric moisture content
(i.e.,the volume of moisture per unit volume of soil); v stands for the flow velocity, s
for the flow path, and t for time.
Substitution of equation (25) into equation (22) yields:
a
!?al = -(K grad 4).
as (26)
Considering one-dimensionalflow only, we obtain for vertical flow into the z direction,
where M/az = 1,
at az
where z is taken to be positive in the upward direction. For horizontal flow, equation
(27)reduces to :
at ax
292
Analysis techniques and inierpretation of research results
Equations (26),(27) and (28) are the general equations for unsaturated flow. They can-
not be solved analytically,since K is a function of w. Moreover, hysteresis may occur
and then a distinction between sorption and desorption should be made.
The concept of diffusion in soil water movement is introduced by substituting [19]:
(30)
For horizontal flow,the last term of the right-handside of equation (30) vanishes again.
Nevertheless,the same problems as mentioned previously apply for the solution of this
equation.
Vertical downward flow or infiltration may be divided into three types: (a) infiltration
at a constant rate;(b) ponded rainfall infiltration;and (c) ponded infiltration.
Type (a) occurs when rain is falling on the soil surface at a constant rate, which is
smaller than the saturated hydraulic conductivity.In fact,this is the same problem as a
constant evaporation of water from the soil surface.
Type (b) is the most common one;at the beginning of rainfall the rate of infiltration
is rather high,but with continuing rainfall the rate of infiltration will decrease gradually
and become less than the rainfall intensity.When this occurs, temporary ponding (sur-
face detention) will occur on the soil surface.
In type (c) infiltration,it is assumed that surface detention occurs during the entire
period of infiltration. This happens,for instance,during field work with infiltrometers
(see sections 4.5 and 6.1.3.5).
If water is flowing at a constant rate down a sufficiently long column of soil to a water
table maintained at a constant level, and sufficient time has elapsed for the rate of flow
293
Representaiive and experimental basins
to be the same everywhere in the profile so that no further changes of the moisture con-
tent + take place, the differential equation for the flow is given by:
Oar
K(:+I)=O
where the suction y is taken as a positive value and z is positive upwards. Integration
of the latter equation between the boundaries z = O, y = O (water table) and z = z,
y = y then gives:
for the relation between z and y. Evaluation of this equation is possible only when
K(y),i.e., when K as a function of y, is known.
For capillary rise of water from a water table held at a constant level the same
solution holds,but then a constant rate of evaporation -EOmust be substituted instead
of an infiltration rate KO.Hence for capillary rise we obtain:
Values of the integral of equation (35) are given in the literature [37]by assuming for
R ($4:
a
K=-. (37)
Wn
The value a is determined mainly by the saturated hydraulic conductivity of the soil.
The value of n depends on the soil type and will be about 1.5 for heavy clays and up to
3.0 for coarse sand.Figure 6.18gives the relation between z and y for various values
of EOand KOfor the assumption that a = 200 and n = 2 and is compiled with the aid
of equations (34) and (35).
294
I Analysis techniques and interpretafion of research resuh
From the curves of Figure 6.18 the moisture profiles for each value of EOcan be re-
produced with the aid of the soil-moisturecharacteristiccurve.The line for EO= KO= O
represents the equilibrium moisture profile at which the height above the water table is
equal to the prevailing suction. For increasing infiltration rates, the suction decreases
gradually,causing a certain temporary storage of water in the unsaturated zone above
the water table. O n the other hand,increasing evaporation EOcauses an increasing suc-
tion, giving rise to a water shortage.
L o g suction = pF
FZG.6.18. The relation between height above water table (2) and suction (y) for various
values of KOand E.
Equation (32) can be used to determine the capillary conductivity by measuring suc-
tion gradient and flow rate,under either laboratory or field conditions.Curves such as
I those given in Figure 6.18 may serve as an estimate of the prevailing water supply from
l ground-waterto the root depth and depth of water table. Generally a suction of 1,ooO
c m (pF = 3) is assumed at the lower end of the rooting zone.The exact magnitude of
this suction y is not so important,since the y curves above a suction of 1,000c m show
a very large gradient owing to the small value of K.If now the intersectionof the various
curves for EOand the line y = 1,000(pF = 3) are plotted against each other,Figure 6.19
'
~
is obtained. From this figure it is seen that a flow rate of 5 mm/day is possibleover a
distance of 29 cm. If, however, the water level is 50 c m below the lower end of the
~
I 295
Representative and experimental basins
For soils showing an air-suctionvalue, i.e., a considerable range of suction near the sat-
urated end of the moisture-characteristic curve, with constant moisture content,
where y a represents the air-entry value. This is the minimum suction to be applied be-
fore a saturated soil releases its first amount of water.
107
9-
8-
7-
6-
5-
I
h
>.
O
4- .\ \
l -o
l \ 3-
l E
l v
E
l a>
v) 2-
l .-
l L
l ?
l
-
2
.-
Q
1-
FIG.6.19. The relation
between maximum
Co) o
I I l I l l I capillary rise and depth
10 20 30 40 50 60 70 of water table, for data
6.1.4.3.3 P O N D E D R A I N F A L L INFILTRATION
The term used [lo1J represents the appearance of surface detention, c o m m o n with heavy
rainfalls or imgation.
A method of analysis based on a solution of a difference equation instead of the differ-
ential equation has been developed [30, 1021.This method offers the possibility of com-
puting flow rates for different rainfall intensities. For the solution, a K (y) function or
D (4) function of the soil must be available.
Figure 6.20shows the result of the analyses for various rainfall intensities.Also given
is the flux for the case of ponded infiltration in the same soil. It shows that the flow rate
for rainfall ponding is larger over a greater time range than in the case of regular ponding.
The period of constant flow rates increases with a decreasing intensity of rainfall.
296
Analysis techniques and interpretaiion of research results
\
\
'
, 450
297
Representative and experimental basins
W h e n water is applied in excess to the top of a soil column initially having a homoge-
neous, constant moisture content, water will penetrate into the soil with a velocity de-
pendent on its physical properties. The entry of water is demonstrated by Figure 6.22
[71].The rate of infiltration is infinite at zero time and gradually decreases to a constant
value as time proceeds.
Time hours
O 50 100 150
I I I I l I I
FIG.6.22. into
infiltration Massfour
types of soil [71].
O , 1O 0
Time
200 300
min.
400 500
298
I Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
I S. The wetting front, a region of very steep mosture gradient which represents the vis-
1 ible limit of moisture penetration into the soil.
moisture content
I soturoted zone
I
II transition zone
I
l
l
I
I
l
l
1
I
I
I
l
XI
d
01
51
el
I
I
I
I
I
l
I l
L
c
c
a
r
I
l
I
wetting zone
/ I
l
I
1 I
wet front
FIG.6.23. Different
zones in the soil during
ponded infiltration [14].
A relatively simple analysis [123]can show the dependency of rate and volume of in-
filtration on the moisture suction of the soil. This analysis is based on the constant
moisture content in the transmission zone. Ignoring the ponding of water over the sur-
face and assuming that the flow is caused by capillary forces and gravity only, the ad-
vance of the wetting front can be represented by:
where Kt is the hydraulic conductivity of the transmission zone and p is the effective
porosity of the soil. This equation shows that the wetting front advances more quickly
in dry soils which have large suction.
Using the initial condition that the wetting front at t = O is located at z=O, inte-
gration of equation (40) gives:
Without introducing large errors, the moisture content in the whole profile may be con-
sidered to be constant and equal to that in the transmission zone. Consequently p is
299
Representarive and experitnental busitis
constant and the mass infiltration in the soil is given by F = p.z. By solvingp from equa-
tion (41)and substitutingp = FIZw e obtain:
F=K,t 1--In-
z ':T.
With an increasing moisture content the suction is decreasing and in wet soils y+O.
In this case equation (42)reduces to:
F = K1.t. (43)
Equation (43) means that Flt = K t and therefore the equation expresses Darcy's law
for unit potential gradient. This should be found after a sufficient time.
For the mass infiltration there is yet another analysis. Rearranging equation (41)we
obtain :
Y P
__
z-7~ In-Z + Y = K,.t= t . (44)
W h e n T is plotted against z on log-log paper for constant values of Y, straight lines are
obtained with a slope equal to 0.55:
where a represents the intercept on the z axis. From the above equation it follows that:
which, in general holds for O < z < O S y . Substitution of equation (46) into F =p.z
then yields:
where b is assumed to depend on the hydraulic conductivity of the soil and a = approx-
imately 0.5.The infiltration equation of Kostiakov is valid only for the first stage of
infiltration (zt0.5~). For-+t the value of a must approach unity. Therefore the value
of a cannot be a constant and the application of the equation is rather limited.
For rather large values of t it is advisable to follow a numerical solution of equation
(30) as given in the literature [83]. From the analysis based on this equation the infil-
tration equation :
F = Stil2 + At (49)
was derived [84]where the sorptivity S is a function of the initial and saturated moisture
content and A is a parameter that stems from the above-mentioned numerical solution.
For larger values of t the equation:
F =G + k.t
is proposed [U].
300
Analysis techniques and interpretatioti of research results
The construction of ground-water contour maps has been discussed in section 5.5.2.
From contour maps, a cross-section such as that shown in Figure 6.24may be construct-
ed. If the height difference between the isohypses is given by Ah (= O.l), the flow per
unit length of contour line is given by:
q = K D,+D,
- A h = KD- A-
.- h
2 Ax Ax
where KO represents the transmissibility of the aquifer. The Ax-value can be measured
from the m a p and is therefore known when KO is set beforehand. O n the other hand,
KD may be computed when q is known. The latter circumstance, however, will not
occur so often since normally KB is known from borings, pumping tests or measure-
ments on undisturbed cores (see section 4.4.2).
O8
i I i
l I I
I I l
I I I
I I 1
I I I
FIG.6.24. Schematic
diagram for computation
of flow intensity from a
contour map.
where q is equal to the effective rainfall (rain minus evaporation) on the area. The annual
run-off is often known and, with known Ah, the value of KB can be estimated at least
roughly.
For semi-confinedaquifers still another type of solution is worthy of mention. Sup-
posing that the confining layer consists of a layer of clay or peat with relatively low
301
Representative and experimental basins
-140 -120
302
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
6.1.4.4.2 F L O W A N A L Y S E S B A S E D ON P I E Z O M E T R I C H E A D S N E A R F R E E
W A T E R SURFACES
When observations of piezometric heads (see section 4.4.2)are made near free water
surfaces such as streams,lakes,etc.,such data can be used to compute the hydrological
constants of an aquifer. For this purpose the known boundary conditions along the free
water surface are used.
The first example pertains to a set of observations as given in Figure 6.27[129].Here
the aquifer is a semi-confinedone and consists of sandy material covered by a heavy
clay layer with a thickness of 2-6 m.Rows of observation wells were installed perpen-
dicularly to a stop-bankedriver. When the logarithms of the readings from given rows
are plotted against the distance from the stop-bank,Figure 6.28 is obtained.According
to a theory of Mazure, a straight line must be obtained from the relation:
where x is the distance and KD and c are the properties mentioned above. By taking
the natural logarithm of both sides of equation (54) one obtains:
or :
log h, = log ho --
0.43~
WDc) '
observoilon well
FIG.6.28. The relation between distance and piezometric head in two cross-sections of
Figure 6.27 [129].
I The lines need not necessarily pass through the zero point of the distance but will
I
I
generally give an intersect log ho. This is due to the fact that the river does not, as the
l
theory assumes,cut through the whole aquifer.In addition to this there will always be
I some foreland left between the river and the stop-bank.Apparently there is some type
l of radial flow,causing an additional resistance equal to a horizontal flow over some
I 220-250m.The same effect will be found in analysing data obtained from,for instance,
tidal movement.
When the hydrological constant I/(KDc)is known, it is simple to find the flow into
the aquifer. Applying Darcy’s law:
q = -KD-dh (57)
dx
With the latter equation,in which qo is the total flow per unit length of river, there is
immediately a distribution of the Row through the aquifer for each x.
304
l
Analysis techiques a d interpuetniion of research results
-
120
100- --\. {p,. Riverlevel
p,.
E 80-
S 60-
2 40-
{20- *
\.
'
.'
\. \-i. II* ' . '
.\a'
.-=-..s'
j i .'
i
z o-
.\*'
e
I I
I l
80 - i &Oc Well 1 at 163m
60-
40-
i
-
.
.
.\.'
. a '
. . s '
I
II
*/
/PL l
.'
\.
\. L.../-
i
/-\.
.\'
.'
/-
i
20-
0-
*i..
Pl
I
I Well 2 at 390m
.. .
K
.
'
--.*
60-
40-
20-
.-'-.-.
\.-.
.'.'
l
I
,
I
ICI-
/p.\,. .'.'
L. /-
.'
..-' .'. /*
*/,+\ '
J -.d.
0- 26-2-'59 I 27-2-I59
1 1 1 1 1 ' 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 ~ I ~
8 1
0 12 14 l
6 18 20 22 24 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 x) 22
where x is the distance from the free surface water and a and p are constants dependent
on the hydrological properties of the aquifer.
For a phreatic aquifer (i.e.,an aquifer consisting of one homogeneous layer), the re-
lation between a and ß on the one side and the hydrological constants on the other is
given by :
305
Representative and experimental basins
a2 -ß'
= pcn
2aß
where c represents the leakage factor or vertical resistance of the confining layer.
It has been proved [I281 that the compressibilityof the aquifer must often be taken
into account. In that case the above relations become:
Sn
2aß =-
KD
where S represents the storage coefficient (the capacity of releasing or taking up water
when the compressibility of the aquifer is taken into account).
The analysis of data is now reduced to determining the values of OL and B from obser-
vational data. In order to explain this, consider equations (60) and (61). From these
equations it is evident that the amplitude in the aquifer is e-"" times that in the free
surface water. Hence the ratio of the amplitude U, at a distance x and the amplitude
UOat x = O is given by:
or
and therefore a straight line must be obtained when the logarithm of the amplitude
ratio is plotted against the distance x. Results for three rows of observation wells are
shown in Figure 6.30.Here again the obtained lines do not pass through the origin:
this is due to the fact that the river does not penetrate fully into the aquifer.
From equations (60)and (61) it is also easily seen that the phase shift which is the
lag in time from the maxima and minima of the observations,is equal to Px. Therefore
the observed time lag (expressed in radians) plotted against the distancex gives a straight
line having an angle /3x (Fig. 6.30). The free-surface-waterdata need not necessarily be
involved in the analysis.For the zero movement,the well closest to the free surface wa-
ter may be used. Furthermore,the circumstance a = j3 points to a phreatic aquifer and
equation (62) must then be used to compute the hydrological data.The movement need
not show pure sinusoids at all and somewhat distorted ones will generally be dealt with.
The analyses may also be applied to the yearly fluctuation,but a Fourier analysis must
often be applied to resolve the movement into fundamental sinusoids [I IS].
It may happen that piezometer observations are available along free surface water
not showing the typical train of sinusoids in its level.This often occurs along ephemeral
streams. T w o conditions may occur: (a) a sudden rise or fall of the water level in the
channel,the level being constant during the rest of the time; (b) a slower rise or fall
306
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
'ioglornpliiude ro tio)
Ohose shift in rod.
disionce in rn
FIG.6.30. Relation between distance and logarithm of the amplitude ratio (left-handscales)
and the relation between distance and phase shift (right-handscales) for some wells given in
Figure 6.27.
of the water level in the channel,the lowering or rise being a linear function of the time.
Solutions for these cases are given in the literature [34].
6.1.4.4.3 F L O W A N A L Y S E S IN D R A I N E D A R E A S
or :
! 307
Representative and experimental basins
I I
I ' k2
H I
I d = fíH.L.ul
I '
I I
I '
I
i
~,/,/,/,,,,,//,,11,~/,,,,,,,,~,,/,,//////,,//,/,,,/////,,,//,/,,/~,/~~
This equation indicates that by plotting q/rn against rn, a straight line must be obtained.
N o w either a straight line parallel to the m-axis is obtained with an intersect 'u' or a
straight line with an intersect 'u' and a slope 'b'. In the former case the flow in the re-
gion above the drains may be neglected.
The analysis of the non-steadystate ground-watertable midway between two parallel
drains can be carried out in several ways,depending on the initial conditions set for the
problem.
Firstly, at t = O an instantaneous recharge R is applied, causing a rise of the water
table equal to R/p.For this case the height of the water level midway between the drains
is given by:
where z is taken as the ground-water level above the water level in the drains and
a = (nZKD)/(pLz) [31].For large values of t the terms with m > 1 may be neglected,and
equation (70)reduces to :
0.44
-1 e-Bat(- 1 e-at+e-sat(0.03 and t)-.
3 1O0 oc
Equation (71)is often used to determine the magnitude of the ground-waterflow to-
wards river systems [51].Applying Darcy's law,it is easily found that for the discharge
one obtains the general equation:
qt = qt-1 e-" (73)
308
Analysis techiiiqiies and inrerpretatìon of research results
where qt is the discharge expressed as a function of the discharge qt-i of the preceding
day. Pure base flow occurs as soon as a plot of qt against qt-1 shows a straight line.
Further, m is a constant depending on geological and hydrological properties of the re-
gion (see section 6.1.3.2.2).
Another initial condition to be applied to non-steadystate flow is the case of a steady
infiltration rate f starting at t = O. The flow rate towards the drains in this case is given
in the literature [55,681:
The height of the water table midway between the drains may be represented by:
The analysis based on these equations is similar to that described above. Solutions for
non-constant infiltration can be derived simply by means of superposition. Equation
(74)offers the possibility of dividing flow between surface flow and ground-waterflow.
This is done by computing the ground-waterhydrograph for the system under discus-
sion (with known a). The total ground-waterflow over a certain period is obtained by
integrating the flow rate. This amount is subtracted from the measured total flow,
leaving the surface run-offas the difference between them.
When data are gathered from measurements and field observations of a variety of hy-
drological and geomorphological variables in a representative or experimental basin,
it is only the first step to an understanding of the basin as a unit. In past years,the sedi-
ment yield as measured in a reservoir or at some other gauging point has been related to
a variety of basin variables by multiple regression analyses which may delineate the
effect of the characteristicsof basins on sediment yield [6],but there are often too many
interdependent and uncontrollablevariables at work in a natural basin to permit a sound
determination of many sedimentation phenomena [86].Moreover, extrapolation of sed-
iment-yieldrates in reservoirsto a largerarea downstream beyond the limitsof any record
is hazardous because of the land-formchanges which afford added opportunity for sed-
iment deposition [40].
In selectingresearch basins care must be taken that all variables important for accom-
plishing the stated objectives of the study can be measured accurately [86].If conditions
are carefully controlled and basic processes are understood, the relation of sediment
yields to basin characteristics will be more meaningful. Some of the relationships that
have been significantin basin studiesare described.For measurement and data processing,
see sections 4.9and 5.6.
The size of a basin has an important effect on the total sediment yield [38,401.Figure
6.32shows the relation of mean annual sediment yield to basin area for 99 small reser-
vojrs by size classes.The graph shows that the average unit sediment yield from basins
0.16km2 in area is about six times that of basins i .6km2in area. Similarly [40],records
309
Representative and experimental basins
FIG.6.32. Relation of
mean annual sediment
yield to drainage area
I 1 I I
for 99 basins in eastern 0.07 0.1 0.2 0.5 1.0 2.0 I
Wyoming 1401. BASIN AREA ( S Q U A R E KILOMETRES)
rom 1,100measurements in the United States show that basins less than 10 km2in area
have unit sedimentyieldsabout seven times those of unit sedimentyieldsfrom catchments
of 1,000km2.The significance of this relationship is that the larger basins have more
diversified topography and environments for redeposition of eroded material from head-
water areas.
3 10
Analysis techniques arid interpretation of research results
FRIABLE SANDSTONE
CONGLOMERATE R SANDSTONE
FIG.6.33. Regression
of sediment loss versus
relief ratio for basins in
the Colorado Plateau 0.1 I I I I
0.2 0.4 0.6
[104]. RELIEF RATIO
investigators have found that there is a good correlation between drainage density and
sediment yield on small catchments.
311
Representative and experimental basins
312
Analyssis techizigires und itzterpretution of research results
outputs of hydrological systems,and with respect to the states and properties of their
interior elements in time.
3. The inherent non-linearity of the processes of mass and energy transfer which con-
stitute the hydrological cycle.
These problems have a strong bearing on the accuracy of any quantitative description
of the hydrological behaviour of natural basins.
313
Representative and experimental basins
subsystems is used, or whether the basin is subdivided into partial areas and successive
routing operations are performed in order to compute the output. Consequently,the
problem consists of devising a model such that, when it operates on a lumped index,it
produces an output that agrees reasonably with the measurable output of a prototype
system which,in general operates non-linearlyon a distributed input. This concept is
illustrated in Figure 6.34.
With reference to the figure,a model W must be chosen such that the result of its
operation on the lumped index xi(t) is an output yl(t) which agrees as closely as possible
with the output y(t) of the prototype, which operates on a distributed input x(t,s)-a
function of time and space.
Distributed
basin input Y (f)
x (i, 5)
+ Minimized
4 H
x,(t) YI (tl
Various types of model have been proposed to perform this task. They fall generally
within the following categories:
1. Linear normal models (multivariate, correlation and regression analysis, factor and
discriminant function analysis).
2. Graphical analyses.
3. Models with a central linear element (unit hydrograph).
4. Non-linear functional models (general non-linear analysis).
5. Conceptual models (general synthesis).
It must be realized that the development of any relationship,however simple, may be
classified as a model. In normal hydrological problems, relatively simple models are
frequently satisfactory,but for research on representativeand experimental basins the
use of more complex model techniques is warranted. For practical application,models
should be verified with the results of field experiments.
Examples given in the description of the models have been restricted to rainfall-run-
off relationships, but such models are equally applicable to any other relations.Note
that some of these are to be classified as component models only. Some important ones
are:
Run-offfrom snowmelt with climatological factors;
Base flow with climatological characteristics;
Water level of the aquifer with climatologicalcharacteristics;
Natural recharge of the aquifer with climatological characteristics;
Evaporation with climatological characteristics;
Hillslope erosion with climatologicalcharacteristics;
314
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
where a’s and b’s are regression coefficients,xt, xt+~,etc., are values of the precipitation
during periods concurrent and antecedent with the run-offyz, the z’s are other variables
(such as evaporation) during concurrent and antecedent periods, and e is an error term.
Ithas been found,in practice,that in prediction equations like equation (76),the resid-
uals are not normally distributed,owing to non-randomeffects. This makes these linear
normal models imperfect in the general case.
A great deal of subjectivityunderlies the use of these models. Not only is it possible to
obtain almostequally good prediction equations on the basis of sets of different parame-
ters, but judgement must be exercised to avoid using physically irrelevant parameters.
The elimjnation of parameters which possess strong interdependence can be attempted
by some of the more recent methods of factor analysis. These procedures, together
with theuse of discriminantfunctions to test for differences,permit insight into the prob-
ability of successful utilization of these equations for prediction purposes [1261.
Other characteristicsof the procedure include: lack of assurance that among the mod-
els investigated the optimum has really been included; the impossibility of generaliz-
ing the prediction equation to other, similar systems; and inverse correlations with
some of the variables when such relationships are illogical from physical considerations.
O n the other hand, the methods of correlation analyses are powerful tools when ap-
plied to the test of well-definedhypotheses in many fields of physical hydrology. They
have also legitimate applicationswhen the purpose of the analysis is to evaluate physical
parameters in the experimental study of systems that are well defined by functional re-
lationshipsobtained independently [731.
315
Representative and experimental basins
generally break down under such circumstances as the often-observed case where a giv-
en storm produces virtually 100 per cent run-offin the middle of the winter and under
summer conditions a very similar storm produces virtually no run-off.Systematic pro-
cedures for taking this variation into account have been reported in the literature [65],
Notable successeswere obtained in relating,by graphical correlations,the observed storm
run-offvalues attributable to individual rainfall events, to the amounts and duration
of rainfall and to the Conditions in the basin at the times of occurrence of the storms.
In application to a given basin, the method may require,for instance,a record of rain-
fall and discharge (see section 6.2.5).
O n the discharge hydrograph,the base-flow separation is made (see section 6.1.3.3)
and the remainder of the hydrograph (i.e.,the direct surface run-off) is divided up be-
tween individualrainfall events.The volumes so determined are computed and graphical
relationships are established between the rainfall amounts and durations, the times of
year, the base-flow discharges at the time of occurrence of the storms and an index of
antecedent rainfall.It should be emphasized that the storms used in such analyses should
not be limited to those producing large amounts of storm run-off;if the selection is so
limited,insufficient notice will be taken of storms containing substantial rainfall but
producing little or no storm run-offbecause of antecedent conditions [so].
Once the relations have been established for a given basin, they are used to predict
the run-offto be expected from any given occurrence of rainfall in any given condition,
and hydrograph prediction becomes possible. See, for example,Figure 6.35 [16,171.
Il
O
20 LO 60 no 100 120
Moss ruinloll for euch storm mm
FIG.6.35. Simple
example of multiple
correlations for rainfall- (b)
run-off relations.
Representative basin of
Mayo Ligan (Chad):
(a) correlation between
ratio of surface ñow-
-
k
LO
20
O
rainfall and mass rainfall
for humidity index
Ih = 26; (b) correlation
between AKu and - 20 J I I I l 1 I
humidity index Ih
(Ih = 1:Pi [Piprevious I I l l
tl -LO
storm; regression for
correction]). Ih
316
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
As background for the discussion of this method and other methods to follow, it is
necessary to define the meanings of ‘systemanalysis’and ‘system synthesis’.Jn system
analysis, the relationship between input and output is established by a mathematical
process involving the use of measured input and output data only, without any attempt
to describe the internal mechanisms of the system in explicit form. This relationship
has the form of unique functions,which are made to operate on the input in order to
produce the output.In general these functions are not required to have a physical mean-
ing or to pcssess parameters fulfilling conditions of dimensional consistency.
In system synthesis,on the other hand,the investigator attempts to describe the oper-
ation of the system by a linkage or combinationof components,the presence of which
is presumed to exist in the system and of which functions are known and predictable.
The linkage of components must be made in such a manner that the correct output is
produced whenever a specific input is applied. In general,the process of synthesis does
not yield a unique model of the unknown system.
Pure synthesis or analysis can be performed on a system independently,or a combi-
nation of both can be employed. A method of partial synthesis with linear analysis is
the basis of the classical unit-hydrographprocedure. Since its formal presentation by
Sherman [lo71this procedure has had very extensiveuse throughout the world.Its present
mathematical basis was developed during the last decade [28,781.
6.2.5.3.2 C O N C E P T O F UNIT H Y D R O G R A P H
317
Representative and experimental basins
h(t) is a function of time, known as the kernel of the integral or the impulse response,
or system response function of the system it represents.It is the output which would
be observed in the limit if the system, while remaining linear, received a single input
of very high intensity and a duration approaching zero,such that the product of inten-
sity and duration remained unity. The lower limit of integration is -00, to take into
account the fact that systems of this type have memory. which means that,in general,
the inputs of the past, even if they are remote,may affect present and future outputs.
In hydrological literature the unit hydrograph u(t,T)is defined as a function of time
(t) giving the storm run-offdue to unit volume of effective rainfall generated uniformly
(or in some specified, perhaps typical, non-uniform manner) in space and time on a
basin in a period T.Thus we may speak of six-hour,three-hour,etc.,unit hydrographs,
the stated period indicating the duration of effective rainfall.In particular we may speak
318
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
of an instantaneous unit hydrograph u(t,O) which is the limit of the finite period unit
hydrograph as the duration of effective rainfall is reduced indefinitely.
Clearly the instantaneous unit hydrograph (IUH) is analogous with the impulse re-
sponse of the general linear system and the general convolution integral has its counter-
part in the definitive equation [54,63, 781.
If adequate data on input and output are available,the function h(t) of equation (77)
can be found by any one of a variety of techniques which have been used in hydrology,
such as those of harmonic analysis [81], Laguerre analysis [29]or other methods [27,
32, 701.The use of a matric solution involving least squares fitting has been developed
in the United States [114].
With the above procedures available, the difficulty remains not in the inversion of
the convolutionintegral but in defining the input and output data. When measurements
are available, an appropriate course of action to reduce error would be to find,in the
records of rainfall and discharge,single,isolated floods caused by storms of short du-
ration and to derive a set of unit hydrographsby reducing the ordinates proportionately
to the volume of direct or surface run-off.If T,the duration of effective rainfall,is small
relative to the period in which the flood rises, the variation of effective rainfall within
the period may be neglected,and the curve so obtained may be taken as the unit hydrv-
graph of duration T.This unit hydrograph may be quite close to the instantaneous unit
hydrograph.
The advantage of the short,intense storm lies in the fact that the shorter the duration
of rainfall the less the effect on the unit hydrograph of uncertainty in defining the losses
and therefore the effective rainfall. Similarly baseflow separation is somewhat less ar-
bitrary when the storm is isolated in time. It is important that the unit hydrographs
should be obtained,if at all possible, from fairly large floods;otherwise they might not
be representativeof the true conditions during high-flowperiods. If,however, the unit
hydrograph concept is used to study the relation between the full discharge hydrograph
and a rainfall record from which losses have been deleted in accordance with some
criterion,the more complex methods of inversion mentioned above would seem to be
advantageous [50,1031.
If significant inconsistencies in unit hydrographs derived from adequate records of a
single basin are observed, an attempt could be made to show the dependence of the
derived unit hydrographs on parameters of the storm and conditions in the basin at
the time of the occurrence of the storm. Such dependence might indicate the necessity
for a more sophisticated non-linearanalysis. It should be remarked,however,that any
conclusions reached with respect to the applicability of the unit hydrograph should be
restricted strictly to the relationships between indices of the prototype input and output
and not to the real input and outputs. The prototypes,in general,unquestionably repre-
sent fully non-linear systems.
It must be emphasized again that the unit-hydrograph hypothesis is nothing more
than a convenient assumption.Indeed,the cascade structure involved in it is quite arbi-
trary. Its merit lies in its simplicity and in the fact that it is the most general assumption
which can be made without recourse to non-linear methods.
319
Representative and experimental basins
m
= 2 J.. . J
n=l
-00 -M
n
t
hn(ti,. .., t n )
n
II
i= 1
.
~(t-tj)dti.. d t n
It can be seen that whereas in the representation of a linear system one employs only
the first term of the series,which is the ordinary convolution integral,the general non-
linear case involves other terms which are multidimensional generalizations of the con-
volution integral with generalized impulse responses hn(cl, . . .,tn). This resembles the
expansion of non-linearfunctions in a Taylor series.
The functional series representation of a system is illustrated in Figure 6.37 in which
each box corresponds to a subsystem of progressively higher order. Each one of these
subsystems,denoted by the symbols Ei, . ..E n ...is described by one of the elements of
the sum of equation (79).
Because hydrological systems are non-linear,recent work has been devoted to the
development of procedures for establishing the relationship between input and output
indices by a system with this structure.The problem,in its general form,is to determine
each system response function so that the sum:
Eixi + Ezxi + . . . + Enxi = yi(t) (80)
320
Analvsis techniques and interpretation of research results
matches the output of the prototype with reasonable approximation.Note that the input
component subsystem Ej is an index of the real prototype input.
X I of each
FIG.6.37. Functional
series representationof a
non-linearsystem.
321
Representative and experimental basins
Y Evaporation
Precipitation
Run-off from
impervious areas
-7
Interception and
depression storage
L o w e r zone
Interflow
_f_ storage
I 1r 11 i
-
4
Ground-water Translation and Translation and
storage routing storage routing storage
11 v
V L
t
S u b s urfoce
Hourly or daily
ground-water
stream flow
I J I I
322
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
istics by application of the model to many basins-either so that the model may be
used for prediction on basins without suitable records,or that it might be used for pre-
diction of the hydrological effect of changes proposed within a basin), then considerably
more than a mere ability to reproduce the observed output is required. These extra
requirements include a quantitative evaluation of the significance of the parametric
values determined for the model.
It is important to note with caution that far-reachingconclusions regarding the pro-
totype on the basis of analyses of the characteristics and the interaction of model com-
ponents are not always warranted and are often very risky.It must be recalled that the
modelling of a complex natural system involves simply recognizing the main functions
of the prototype and devising mathematical or analogue elements which, if properly
linked,can perform approximately these functions.The prototype and the model have,
as mentioned in section 6.2.1,only limited equivalence. This should always be taken
into account in the application of models to ungauged basins.
The significance of the model parameters is analogous to the significanceof regression
coefficients in linear regression analysis. Indeed,this analogy can be taken further so
that if the model has two parts which are very similar in their operation, it becomes
difficult to determine the parametric value of either of these parts reliably (for the same
reason that it is extremely difficult to find, by linear regression analysis, which of two
highly correlated independent variables has produced a given effect). It would therefore
seem justifiable that a conceptual model should be initially as simple as possible and
that additional modifications or components should be adopted only when these are
clearly seen to be necessary on physical grounds or have been shown to improve sig-
nificantly the reproduction of the observed hydrological system. One must also bear in
mind that the mere recognition of the existence of a physical phenomenon does not
necessarily indicate that this phenomenon should be reproduced in a conceptual model.
It'isnecessary that the effect of the phenomenon on the output be substantial.In some
cases the effect on the output may be variable,for instance with increasing precipitation
the effect may increase or decrease. This should be carefully checked and, to test it,
a method is required for the quantitativeevaluation of the efficiency of the model and
of the significance of each individual part. One such method might be the specification
of a measure of error expressing the disagreement between computed and observed
outputs and the comparison of the residual and initial values of this quantity. The
significance of a suspect part of a model of a single basin, or group of basins,might be
judged by the reduction obtained in the residual error on the introduction of this part
and subsequent optimization.
The neglect of this principle by the postulation of too complex a model in the first
instance may render difficult or impossible the extrapolation of results obtained from
one basin too another,or the recognitionof relationshipsbetween physical characteristics
and the parameters of the model-relationships which must be recognized if the pos-
tulation of a suitable conceptual model for ungauged basins is ever to be achieved.
It is as yet too early in the development of the technique to lay down any rules con-
cerning the elements to be incorporated in the actual model, but much can be learned
from the extensive work done by a few workers [21,951.
The successful operation of a digital computer in which the parametric values are ad-
justed by the operator has, until recently,relied to a considerable extent on the exper-
ience and personal judgement of the operator. However, optimization techniques have
been developed which determine the values of system parameters which maximize, or
minimize, some function dependent upon those parameters. These techniques are com-
pletely objective;many useless tests may be made of situations that would be dismissed
323
Representative and experimental basins
out of hand by an experienced hyman investigator, but the tremendous speed with
which a computer can make them compensates for such inefficiency.
In the basin-modelcontext, an obvious parameter-dependent function to be opti-
mized (minimized) isthe differencebetween an observed outflow and the outflow computed
by the model when supplied with the corresponding observed input.Other error criteria
could be used (e.g.,magnitude or timing of peak flows) or,in fact,any combinatioii of
such criteria.
One such technique has been developed [24]and applied to synthetic data of output
obtained by running the input data through a model with assigned parametric values.
It was demonstrated that the optimization techniques were capable of recovering the
specific parametric values efficiently and techniques were also developed for demonstra-
ting the sensitivity of the model to variation in each of the parametric values taken
separately.
324
Analysis iechtziqiies arid itztevpreiation of research results
observed before treatment, with one remaining untreated throughout the study period
as a control and the others being treated. Surface and subsurface-waterstudies and the
determination of hydrological characteristicsare important for single-basinor compara-
tive basin studies in quantifying the effect of natural or cultural changes,as described
in sections 6.1.3,6.1.4and 6.3.2.
It is important that the study period be one in which the climate is representativeof the
long-termclimatic pattern. If the study period is excessively wet or dry. hot or cold,
etc., the results may not be suitable for application in a normal period.
One test of representativenesscompares data from a nearby long-termrecord with the
short-termrecord from the study area as shown in Figure 6.39 [42]. The comparison
may be made for data on run-off,precipitation, air temperature,pan evaporation,or
any other climatic factors which are known to be important and for which a suitable
long-term record can be found.If the study period is found not to be representativeof
the long-term climatic pattern, great care must be exercised in the application of the
study results.
25 , , , , ,
Legend
O = Actual record
__ - Expected values based $ 20
on 1919-48period.
6 15
Y IO
FIG.6.39. Normalcy
test for annual
precipitation. ,949 ,911 ,953 1955 ,957 i913 1951 1963 1965 1967
In the single-basintechnique, basin flow is related to the factors which influence it,
usually through regression equations which relate monthly, annual or storm run-offto
climatic factors. These equations are then applied to climatic factors in the post-treat-
ment period and the estimated run-offcompared with the actual run-off.Differences are
a measure of the effect of the change in basin characteristics,but must be examined in
relation to the magnitude of differenceswhich could occur within the confidence interval.
Rainfall/run-offrelationships [i 151 (Figs. 6.40and 6.41-mass curve and double mass
curve), show how the data can be graphed for initial study. Comparisons are made of
run-offdata between the 28-monthcalibrationperiod and the 54-monthevaluation period.
In this case only a slight decrease in surface run-offis noted. There will be situations
where the difference in relationship between precipitation and run-offbetween the two
periods will be sizeable and more readily apparent.A regression analysis technique [i151
is also usable to evaluate the effect of changes. Its results are in agreement with the
double mass curve technique (Fig. 6.41). Studies of flow volumes and peak discharges
between the calibration and evaluation periods are not valid unless causative factors
such as rainfall intensities and antecedent moisture for both periods are normal. Ab-
normally wet or dry periods,either before or after the natural or cultural change,could
result in erroneous conclusions.
325
Representative and experimental basins
9
CALIBRATION ACTION
E
-
I
6
PRECIPITATION
= 5
O
O
0
- 4
z
0
$ 3
3
$ 2 / RUNOFF-/;)
o
u
I
O
1954 1955 1956 1957 1958 i959 1960 1961 196:
CALIBRATION 1 ACTION
O
O
0 I .2
I
IL
IL
z
æ
œ
w
O
O
M I
I
I I
2
I I
3
I I
4
I
5
1 I l
6
I I
7
I I
8
I 19
PRECIPITATION (i000M M I
326
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
Y = 18.99+O.95Xi- 1.69X2-0.80X~
in which:
Y = annual run-off(mm);
XI = annual precipitation (mm);
XZ = annual evapotranspiration (mm);
X3 = total measured soil and ground-waterstorage change plus 102.4m m .
Other parameters may improve the reliability of prediction, especially those involving
relations between climatological and hydrological characteristics. Standard errors of
estimate in the example given were below the expected minimum practical change in
run-off;namely, about 10per cent of the annual flow. Predicted values for the evalua-
tion period are compared with observed ones and the effect of a natural or cultural
change can thus be evaluated.
The adequacy of the single-basintechnique depends on the ability to predict run-off
from climatic data with a reasonable degree of accuracy and the normality of the data-
collection periods. The research scientist should determine if the streamgauge measures
all of the flow from the basin or if there are any leaks [22](see section 6.3.1.3).
Statistical control can be provided by establishing basins in a nesting arrangement,
as discussed in section 2.4.
6.3.1.3 Comparative-basin technique (for the study of the effect on the hydro-
logical regimen of a cultural change)
321
Representative and experimental basins
Fio. 6.42. Double mass curve of run-off from treated and control basins.
6 O0
J
e
- o
O
I l I I I l ~ I I I I I I I I ~ ~
(b) Treated basin. (Slope ~ 9.40 mm/yr i 4.32;r = -0.49).
600
m 1
:I
a o
1949 1951 19ä3 I955 1957
I 1959 1961 1963 1965 1967
I
(c) Control basin.-(Slope= 2.80mm/yri 4.57;r = -0.15).
FIG.6.43. Time trends of annual run-off from treated and control basins.
328
Analysìs teclmiqries atid iiiterpretatioii of research remlts
error was large for both basins. The effect of year-to-yearvariations in climate was
removed from the treated basin data by the equation:
= (QR+ 12.4873)-0.8573Qc
where:
QR,= adjusted annual flow (reafforested basin) ;
QR= annual flow (reafforested basin);
Q c= annual flow (control basin).
Constants in the equation were determined statistically €oreach set of basin comparisons.
The value of this technique in comparative basin studies is evident in the reduction of
scatter ofthe points(Fig. 6.43~) and the lowered standard deviation from f4.32to &1.27.
A mathematical curve or straight line is fitted to the data according to the best defi-
nition. The data on Figure 6.43 were fitted with a straight line,since there was no evi-
dence in the plotting that the trend was beginning to level off. A curve can be fitted
where the data points so indicate [76,771.
A technique for evaluating the effect of land-usechanges on peak-dischargerates
has been described in the literature [42].Flood-peak discharges (mm/ha/hr)from the
reafforested basin (17 ha) as a percentage of the causative-rainfallrate in the same units
were compared with those of a control basin (120 ha) for the calibration and evaluation
periods (Fig. 6.44). Although these two basins are about 1,400 m apart the difference
in their rainfall rates for the same storm was great enough to invalidate a comparison
of peak-dischargevalues alone. In small-basin comparative studies,precipitation rates
0 01967
i960
@1960-6701949
01956 0 i966
329
Representative and experimental basins
330
I Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
$ 0.05 - \ -
L \
FIG.6.45. Flow-
4
I
o
- \ -
\
duration curves for ?!a 0.01 I I
I 331
Representative and experimental basins
332
Analysis iechtziques and interpreiation of research results
I I I VIIAA AIA IIAAV
R 1 AV I
Representative and experimental basins
334
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
P = Q+EfAMs&AG+dV+e (84)
where, over a specified period:
P = totalprecipitation;
I
I
Q = totalstreamflow;
E = totalevapotranspiration;
A M , = change in soil-moisturestorage;
AG = change in ground-waterstorage;
A V = change in storage of liquid and solid precipitation in endoreic depressions;
e = an error term which includes not only deep percolation ( e d p ) but also errors
associated with other elements of the water balance.
All the water-balanceelements are calculated as mean values for a basin and expressed
in depths (mm).
In exceptional cases,representative or experimental basins have to be selected when
economic activities affect the water balance. In such cases additional terms should be
introduced,e.g. (Qcx), amount of water used for economic activity (irrigation,water
supply,etc.); (QB)amount of water returned from the economic activity (effluent dis-
charge,etc.).
In basins containing one or more natural or artificial reservoirs which affect the ñow
regimen significantly,additional parameters which characterizethe increase or decrease
of storage should be introduced.
Below are given some details of the main elements of the water balance. For further
details, refer to the relevant sections of chapters 4 and 5 [7,56, 57, 1391.
(a) Precipitation. Data obtained at precipitation stations within a basin are used for
the determination of the mean basin precipitation.Sometimes it is expedient to use data
obtained at precipitation stations outside the basin. If the analysis shows that data are
doubtful at any one station,they should be either excluded or corrected by correlation
with data from adjacent stations.In winter,when the error in solid precipitation measure-
ments is especially great, the amount of precipitation is estimated, in case of lack of
thaw, by the difference between the snow pack at the end and at the beginning of the
period, taking into account evaporation from the snow surface.In regions where thaw
takes place regularly the amount of precipitation for the winter period is determined
solely from readings from precipitation gauges, and corresponding corrections are
introduced.
(b) Streamflow.Flow data should,if possible,be separated into surface and subsurface
components.Flow-separationmethods are given in section 6.1.3.3.1.
(c) Evapotranspiration. This should be estimated by using any of the methods given
in section 5.3.4.If possible,evaporimeters (see section 4.2.4.2.1) or the energy-balance
method (see section 5.3.5)should be used. For the periods when the basin is covered
with snow,evaporation values may be determined from observed data of snow evapo-
ration.These values are usually small and vary slightly from year to year (e.g.25-30mm
per year in the greater part of the U.S.S.R). In spite of the relatively small variability
of the evaporation from snow,its role in the water balance of some arid and semi-arid
regions may be rather significant.
(d) Change in soil-moisture storage. Soil-moisture variations occur throughout the
year in most regions and may affect the water balance for any given period. Mean soil-
moisture values for a basin observed at the beginning and end of a water-balanceperiod
335
Representative and experimental basins
are used to determine the change in storage and whether this change is positive or neg-
ative.
(e) Ground-water storage (provided that the data is representative of the research
basin). Ground-water levels are obtained from wells located within the basin or from
similar,adjacent basins. The change in ground-waterstorage for any one period is cal-
culated by multiplying the difference in mean basin ground-waterlevels at the beginning
and end of the period by the specific yield.Values of specific yield are found in the lit-
erature or may be calculated approximately as follows:
su= p-Fe
where Suis the specific yield,p the effective porosity, and F, the field capacity of the
aquifer under consideration.
In some cases the change in ground-waterstorage may be calculated by relating base-
flow to the mean ground-waterlevel of a basin. This relation is similar to a storage/
discharge rating curve in that baseflows,observed during relatively stable low-flow per-
iods,are plotted against mean basin ground-waterlevels and a curve of relation drawn
through the points.
(f) Change in storage of liquid and solid precipitation. The solid precipitation accumu-
lated on the land surface during the winter period in the form of snow and water is par-
ticularly important.In some basins depression storage caused by rainfall may also be
important.
Data for the various components of the water balance may be tabulated as shown
in Figure 6.46.Graphical methods for water balance studiesare given in the literature [12].
336
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
x
YI
o
.-
Y
.e
Y
a
.e
c
u
337
Represeritative arid experimental basins
the case of very high floods.Because this is associated with imperfections of the models
as a whole, or of their individual components,it can certainly be hoped that the greater
number of more refined structures being perfected will result in a correspondingimprove
ment in the quality of the results. Some of the subjective factors which are currently
involved in building the models and in optimizing their parameters may be gradually
eliminated with further research [i i].
The non-linear functional models (see section 6.2.5.4)are likely to be the best pre-
dictors of high floods if the necessary equations can be developed from sufficiently long
records of rainfall and run-off.Because the mathematical operations involved are com-
pletely non-subjective,many of the sources of bias which are present in synthesis do not
exist in this process. However, it must be indicated that, at present, no experience is
available in the standardized use of non-linear analysis methods.
338
Analysis techniques and inferpre?u?ioii o,f research resuits
(a) The unit hydrograph inerhod, because it involves the determination of a specific
response function on the basis of records from a specific basin, does not furnish a direct
means of extrapolating in space. However, as indicated in section 6.2.5.3.4,several in-
vestigators have sometimesattempted to derive empirical relationships between the char-
acteristics of a basin and the unit hydrograph parameters,so that synthetic unit hydro-
graphs can be derived for the ungauged basins when only certain geomorphological or
other physical characteristics are known [log].
Various investigators [33,39,79,11 31 have used regression analysis in a process where-
by unit hydrographs have been derived for a number of streams in a region, and the
numerical measures of the basin’s characteristicshave been related to descriptive meas-
ures of the various unit hydrographs. The problem of the form of the relationships
which might be expected is one that has not been satisfactorily solved. In the absence
of guidance,most investigators have used characteristics such as area,basin and channel
slope,stream length, drainage density,etc. (see section 6.1.1.2) and have attempted to
select the relationships which are statistically more significant. It has been observed that
very different combinations of basin characteristics often serve almost equally well,
thus indicating high mutual dependence between these variables. Studies of basin char-
acteristics should be directed to the elucidation of some of these relationships with a
view to determining the number and combination of characteristics which are more
fundamental or to which the hydrological response might be more clearly related. An
example of such a study,using factor analysis,is given in the literature [117].
Graphical analyses have been used in West Africa for sixty basins using storm run-off
coefficients and elements of unit hydrographs for the prediction of ten-yearfloods [99].
The study was hampered by difficulties in standardizing the determination of the ele-
ments of the unit hydrograph and the basin characteristics (see Figs. 6.47 and 6.48).
A R E A (KU’)
FIG.6.47. Example of graphical analysis (run-off-rainfallagainst slope and area) for various
basins in West Africa. Sahelian and subdesertic areas (annual precipitation 150-800 mm);
permeability of soil: PI -P2 (impervious).
339
Representative and experimental basins
f
T
FIG.6.48. Example of graphical analysis (rise time-slope and area) for various basins in
West Africa.
340
Analysis techniques and interpretation of research results
The unit graph is limited to very small basins and for larger basins the isochrone
method may be more useful [136].
The results of the above methods have had varying degrees of success,but they do
not permit generalizations.Much additional work is required before standard procedures
can be recommended.
(b) The procedures of general non-linear analysis, when applied to the description of
the behaviour of a basin,have the same limitations as the unit hydrograph in the sense
that the impulse response functions of all orders apply strictly only to the basin for
which they were derived. Therefore,they cannot be used as a rule to predict directly
the behaviour of ungauged basins.
O n the other hand, if non-linear analysis is used in conjunction with a conceptual
model to describe the operation of one or more of its components,it may have the same
range of applicability as these models.
(c) Conceptualmodels appear promising for the prediction of the behaviour of ungauged
basins, provided structures of sufficient generality are developed. Their limitations
depend on how well each mechanism can be described in the representative or experi-
mental basins,as well as in the ungauged basins, and on how demanding they are with
respect to input data. The words of caution given in section 6.2regarding the physical
interpretation of model parameters vis-a-visthe characteristics of the prototype should
always be kept in mind.
References
O.A. J 953.Osnovy gidrokhiniii [Principles of hydrochemistry], 2nd ed.Leningrad,
1. ALEKIN,
Gidrometeoizdat.
2. AMOROCHO, J. 1961.Predicting storm run-offon small experimental watersheds.Discussion.
PP-OC.ASCE, 82 (HYZ): 185-91.
3. __- . 1963. Measures of the linearity of hydrologic systems. J. geophys. Res., 68(8) :
2237-49.
4. ____ . 1966. The non-linear prediction problem in the stud-v of the riin-off’ cycle.
5. __- ; ORLOB, G.T. 1961.Non-linearanalysis of hydrologic systems. Water Resources
Centre contrib., 40 : 1-47. Berkeley, University of California.
6. ANDERSON, H.W. 1957. Relating sediment yields to watershed variables. Trans. Amer.
Geop-s. Un.,38(6) :921-4.
7. ANDREJANOV, V. G.1960. Vnutrigodovoe raspredelenie rechnogo stoka [Annual distribution
of streamflow]. Leningrad, ci idrometeoizdat.
8. BALEK, J. 1965.The importance of beta-radioactivitymeasurements in representative and
research areas. ZASH publ. m. 66 (2). (Symposium of Budapest,)
9. BECKER, A. 1966. Ergebnisse einer Untersuchung über die Struktur der koaxralen gra-
phischen Storkregen-Abfluss-Beziehungen.Wasserwirtschaft-Wassertechiiik, 16(3) :90.
10. BERNIER, J. 1962. Théorie stochastique des réservoirs. L a houille blanche, 20(5) :434-44.
Il. ___ ; VERON,R. 1964. Sur quelques difficultés rencontrées dans l’estimation d’un
débit de crue de probabilité donnée. Revue de statisfique appliquée, Paris, 12(1).
12. BLOEMEN, 1967.Determination of deep recharge on discharge at a constant rate studying
fluctuations in ground-water level. J. Hydrol. (Netherlands).
13. BOCHKOV,A. P. 1965. O vlijanii agrotekhnicheskikh i lesomeliorativnykh meroprijativ
na stok rek lesostepnykh i stepnykh raionov [Onthe influence of agrotechnical and forest
reclamation measures on river run-off in forest/steppe and steppe zones]. T d y GGI,
vyp. 127, p. 10-81.
14. BODMAN, G.B.;COLMAN, E.A.1943. Moisture and energy conditions during downward
entry of water into soils. Proc. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer., 8 : 116-22.
15. BOUCHARDEAU, A. 1959. Méthode d‘extrapolation du coefficient de ruissellement sur les
bassins expérimentaux de la zone sahélienne du Tchad.Annuaire hydrologique de l’Orstom,
1957. Paris, Orstom.
341
Representative and experimental basins
16. BRUNET-MORET, Y.1965. Influencedu corps de l'averse sur le ruissellement d'un petit bassin.
Paris. (Cahier Orstom d'hydrologie no. 3.)
17. CAPPUS, P.1960. Bassin expérimental d'Alrance. Étude des lois d'écoulement. Application
au calcul et à la prévision des débits. Mémoires et travaux de la Société hydrotechnique de
France, no. 1. Paris.
18. CHAPMAN, C. A. 1952. A new quantitative method of topographical analysis. Amer. J.
Sci., 250 :428-52.
19. CHILDS, E. C.;COLLIS-GEORGE, N.C. 1950. The permeability of porous materials. Proc.
Roy. Soc., A201 :392-405.
20. COLMAN, E.A.;BODMAN, G . B. 1944. Moisture and energy conditions during downward
entry of water into moist and layered soils. Proc. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer., 9 :3-11.
21. CRAWFORD, N.H.;LINSLEY, R. K. 1963. A conceptual model of the hydrologic cycle.
IASH publ. no. 63 :573-87,
22. DAGG, M.; BLACKIE, J. R.1965. Studies of the effects of changes in land use on the hydro-
logical cycle in East Africa by means of experimental watersheds. IASH publ. no. 1q4):
63-75.
23. DARCY, H . 1856. Les fontaines publiques de la Ville de Dijon. Paris, Victor Daimont.
24. DAWDY, D . R.;O'DONNELL, T. 1965. Mathematical models of catchment behaviour.
P ~ O C .ASCE, 8(HY4) :123-37.
25. DERIDDER, N. A.;WIT, K.E. 1966. Evaluation of seepage and salt intrusion in the
south-western part of the Netherlands. J. Hydrol. (Neth.).
26. DILS, R. E. 1953. Influence of forest cutting and mountain farming on some vegetation,
surface soil and surface run-off characteristics. (US.Forest Serv. paper no. 24.)
27. DISKIN, M.H.1964.A basic study of the linearity of the rainfallIriIn-offprocessin watersheds.
Ph.D. thesis, University of Illinois.
28. DOOGE, J. C.I. 1959.A general theory of the unit hydrograph.J.geophys.Res.,62(2) :241-56.
29. ___ . 1965. Analysis of linear systems by means of Laguerre functions.J. Soc. indust.
und appl. Math. (control) series A. 2(3).
30. DIJEIRELJIL, P. 1966. Les caractères physiques er morphologiques des bassins versants. Leur
détermination avec une précision acceptable. Paris. (Cahier Orstom d'hydrologie no. 5.)
31. DUMM, L. D. 1954. A new drain spacing formula. Agric Eng., 35 :726-30.
32. EAGLESON, P. S. et al. 1965. The computation of the optimum realizable unit hydrographs
from raiirfall and run-off datu. MIT. Hydromechanics Laboratory. (Report no. 84.)
33. EDSON, C.G.1951. Parameters for relating unit hydrographs to watershed characteristics.
Trans. Amer. Geophys. Un.,32 :951-9.
34. EDELMAN, J. H.1947. On the computation of groundwater flow. Thesis, Tech. University,
Delft, The Netherlands.
35. EZEKEL, M.;Fox,K.A.1961. Methods of correlation and regression analyses. N e w York,
Wiley.
36. FEDOROV, S. F. 1962. Vlijanie lesa na vodny balans malykh vodosborov/po materialam
Valdaiskoy gidrologicheskoy laboratorii [The influence of forest on the water balance
of small basins/from data obtained at the Valdai Hydrological Research Laboratory].
Trudy GGZ,vyp. 95, p. 55-100.
37. GARDNER, W. R. 1958. Some steady state solutions of the unsaturated moisture flow
equations with application to evaporation from a water table. Soil Sci., 85 :228-33.
38. GOITSCHALK, L. C. 1964. Reservoir sedimentation. In: Ven Te Chow (ed.). Handbook
of applied hydrology, p. 17-1 to 17-33. N e w York, McGraw-Hill.
39. GRAY, D.M.1961. Synthetic hydrographs for small watersheds. Proc. ASCE, 87 (HY4):
33-54.
40. HADLEY, R. F.; SCHUMM, S. A. 1961. Hydrology of the upper Cheyenne River basin:
Sediment sources and drainage basin characteristics. USGS Water Supply Paper 1531-B:
137-97.
41. HARR, M. E. 1962. Groundwater and seepage. New York, McGraw-Hill.
42. HARROLD, L.L.et al. 1962. Influence of land use and treatment on the hydrology of small
watersheds in Coshocton, Ohio, 1938-57.( U S D A Tech. bull. 1256.)
43. HOLTAN, H.N. 1945.Time condensation in hydrograph analysis. Trans. Amer. Geophys.
Un.,407-13.
44. ____ ; KIRKPATRICK,M. H.,Jr. 1950. Rainfall, infiltration, and hydraulics of flow
in run-off computation. Trans. Amer. Geoph.ys. Un.,31 :771-9.
342
Analysis techniques and interpretation of resezirch results
45. -- ; OVERTON,
D. E. 1964. Storage flow hysteresis in hydrograph synthesis. J.
Hydrol. (Neth.),2 :309-23.
46. HORNER,
W.W.;LLOYD,
C. L.1940. Infiltration capacity values as determined from a
study of an eighteen month record at Edwardville,Illinois. Trans. Amer. Geophys. Un.,
pt. 2: 52241.
47. HORTON, R.E. 1938. The interpretation and application of run-offplot experiment with
reference to soil erosion problem.Proc. Soil Sci. Soc. Amer., 3: 340-9.
48. INTERAGENCYCOMMITTEE ON WATER RESOURCES.
1966.Methods of flow frequency analysis.
Notes on hydrological activities, Bull. 13.
49. JOHNSON, E.A.; DILS, R.E.1956. Oufliiie for compifing precipitation,riin-ofland ground-
water data bom srriall watersheds. US. Forest Serv. (Tech. note no. 34.)
50. KALININ, G. P.;MILYUKOV, P.I. 1958. Approximate calculations of the unsteady jlow
of water masses. (Trudy Ts. IP, iss. 66.)
51. KNISEL, W.G.1963. Base flow recession analysis for comparison of drainage basins and
geology. J. geophys. Res.,68 : 3649-53.
52. KORZOUN, V. I. 1968. Stok i poteri talykh vod na sklonakh polevykh vodoshorov [Run-off
and snowmeltlosses on the slopes of field catchments]. Leningrad,Gidrometeoizdat, 168 p.
53. KOSTIAKOV, A.N.1932. O dnamike koefficienta prosachivania vody v pochvogruntakh
i neobkhodimosti dinamicheskogo podkhoda k eye izucheniu v meliorativnykh tseliakh
[On the dynamics of the coefficient of water percolation in soils and the necessity for
studying it from a dynamic point of view for purposes of amelioration].Pochvovcdenie (3),
p. 293-7.
54. KOVZEL, A.G.1951.Opyt proektirovania gidrogafavesennego stoka dla malogo vodosbora
(Some experience of the computation of a spring run-offhydrograph for small basins).
Trudy GGZ, vyp. 31, p. 54-74.
55. KRAYENHOFF VAN DE LEUR, D.A. 1958. A study of non-steadyflow with special reference
to a reservoir coefficient. De Ingenieur, Delft,70B :70-84.
56. KUDELIN, B. I. (ed.). 1966. Podzenniy stok na territorii SSSR (Subsurface flow in the
territory of the U.S.S.R.). Moscow University.
57. KUZIN, P.S. 1960. Klassifikatsia rek i gidrologicheskoe raionirovanie SSSR [River classi-
fication and territorial division of the U.S.S.R.into hydrological regions]. Leningrad,
Gidrometeoizdat.
58. KUZMIN, P.P.1961. Protsess-v tajariia snezhiiogo pokrova [Snowpack melting processes].
Leningrad,Gidrometeoizdat.
59. KUZNETSOV, V. I. 1964. Isparenie so sezhnogo pokrova [Evaporation from snow cover].
Trudy GGI, vyp. 109, p. 3-56.
60. KUZNIK, I. A. 1962. Agrolesonieliorativnye nieropriatia, vessenniy siok i erozia pochv
[Forestreclamationmeasures,spring run-offand soil erosion]. Leningrad,Gidrometeoizdat.
61. LANGBEIN, W.B. 1940. Some channel storage and unit hydrograph studies. Trans. Amer.
Geophys. Un.,21 :620-7.
62. - - et al. 1947.Topographic characteristics of drainage basins. 157 p. (USGS Water
supply paper 968-C.)
63. LARRIEV, J. 1954. Contribution à l’étude des crues. L a honille blanche, 8:125.
64. LEOPOLD, L.B.; MADDOCK, T.1953. The hydraulic geometry of’stream channels and some
physiographic implications. (USGS Prof.paper 252.)
65. LINSLEY, R. K. et al. 1949. Applied hydrology. New York, McGraw-Hill.
66. LUTHIN, J. N.(ed.). 1957. Drainage of agricrrltural lands. Amer. Soc. Agron.
67. LVOVICH, M. 1. 1963. Chelovek i vody [Man and water]. Moscow, Geografgiz.
68. MAASLAND, M.1959.Water table fluctuationsinduced by intermittentrecharge.J.geophys.
Res., 64 :59.
69. MCCULLOCH, J. S. G. 1965.Tables for the rapid computation of the Penman estimate of
evaporation. J. E.Afr. Agric. and Forestr-v,30(3) :286-95.
70. MEHMETCIK, B. 1966. Instantaneous unit hydrograph derivation by spectral analysis and
its numerica! application. Cento Svmp. on Hydrol. arid Water Resources Development.
Ankara.
71. MILLER, R.D.;RICHARDS, F. 1952. Hydraulic gradients during infiltration in soils.Proc.
Soil Sci. Soc. Amer., 16 :33-8.
72. MOLCHANOV, A.A. 1960.Gidrologicheskaya rol lesa [Hydrologicalrole of forests], 2nd ed.
Moscow, Academy of Sciences of the U.S.S.R.
343
Representative and experimental busins
344
Analysis techniques and interpretarion of research results
345
Representairve and experimental basins
132. WICHT, C. L. 1965. The validity of conclusions from South African multiple watershed
experiments. Znt. symp. on forest hydrol. Pennsylvania State University.
133. WIENER, N. 1958. Nonlinear problems in random theory. New York, Wiley.
134. WILM, H.G.1949. H o w long should experimental watersheds be calibrated? Trans. Amer.
Geophys. Un.,30(2) :272-8.
135. WISLER, C. O.;BRATER,E. E. 1949. Hyduology. New York, Wiley.
136. WORLD METEOROLOGICAL ORGANIZATION. 1965. Guide to hydrometeorological practices.
(WMO no. 168, TP. 82.)
137. YOUNGS, E. G.1958. Redistribution of moisture in porous materials after infiltration, I.
Soil Sci., 86: 117-25.
138. ___ . 1958. Redistribution of moisture in porous materials after infiltration, II.
Soil Sci., 86 :202-7.
139. ANON. 1967. Vodnye resursy i vodny balans territorii Sovetskogo Sojuzu [Water resources
and water balance of the U.S.S.R.territory]. Leningrad, Gidrometeoizdat.
346
Bibliography
347
Representative and experimental basins
348