SIAL QPCR Technical Guide PDF
SIAL QPCR Technical Guide PDF
Detection Methods
Instrumentation
Applications Guide
Table of Contents
Introduction.............................................................................. 1 Optimizing qPCR.................................................................... 18
Guidelines for Optimizing Both qPCR and qRT-PCR................ 18
Quantitative PCR: How does it work?.................................... 2
Check Primer Design for Primer-Dimer Potential................ 18
qPCR Detection Methods......................................................... 3 Optimize Primer Concentrations........................................ 18
Dye-Based Detection............................................................... 3
qPCR Technical Guide
Introduction
The routine study of DNA became practical with the Numerous qPCR detection chemistries and instruments
invention of the polymerase chain reaction (PCR) by are now available to answer a wide range of questions.
Kary Mullis in 1983. With the advent of PCR, it was For instance, qPCR can be used to measure viral load or
possible to multiply a given DNA segment from com- bacterial pathogens in a clinical sample, to verify
only at the end point of amplification. of the data should show a classic exponential amplification as it
does in the standard X-Y plot. A logarithmic plot of a successful
The concept of qPCR is simple: amplification products are measured
geometric reaction will result in a straight line in the exponential
as they are produced using a fluorescent label. During amplification,
region of the graph. The slope of this portion of the semi-log plot
a fluorescent dye binds, either directly or indirectly via a labeled
can be used to calculate the efficiency of the PCR.
hybridizing probe, to the accumulating DNA molecules, and
fluorescence values are recorded during each cycle of the amplifi- Both plots can be broken into different regions showing the phases
cation process. The fluorescence signal is directly proportional to of PCR amplification. The different graphing techniques empha-
DNA concentration over a broad range, and the linear correlation size different reaction phases. During a typical qPCR experiment,
between PCR product and fluorescence intensity is used to calculate the initial concentration of template is extremely low; therefore
the amount of template present at the beginning of the reaction. the resulting product-related fluorescence is too low to be detected.
The point at which fluorescence is first detected as statistically The background signal is shown as baseline in Figure 1. After the
significant above the baseline or background, is called the threshold yield has reached the detection threshold, shown as the dotted
cycle or Ct Value. line, the reaction course can be followed reliably through the
exponential phase, which is best tracked in the semi-log plot.
The Ct Value is the most important parameter for quantitative PCR.
Once the reaction reaches significant product inhibition, or limiting
This threshold must be established to quantify the amount of
reagent, the reaction reaches a linear phase, which is best tracked
DNA in the samples. It is inversely correlated to the logarithm of
in the linear plot. After this point, the reaction is at the maximum
the initial copy number. The threshold should be set above the
yield, or the plateau phase.
amplification baseline and within the exponential increase phase
(which looks linear in the log phase). Most instruments automati- There are two main methods used to perform quantitative PCR:
cally calculate the threshold level of fluorescence signal by dye-based, or non-specific detection, and probe-based, or specific
determining the baseline (background) average signal and setting detection. Both methods rely on calculating the initial (zero cycle)
a threshold 10-fold higher than this average. DNA concentration by extrapolating back from a reliable
fluorescent signal.
In theory, an equal number of molecules are present in all of the
reactions at any given fluorescence level. Therefore, at the
threshold level, it is assumed that all reactions contain an equal
number of specific amplicons. The higher the initial amount of
sample DNA, the sooner the accumulated product is detected in
the fluorescence plot, and the lower the Ct value.
Plateau
Plateau 0 Linear
1
Log (Relative Fluorescence)
Relative Fluorescence
0.75 –1
Linear
Exponential
0.5
–2
0.25
–3 Baseline Cycle threshold
Baseline Exponential Ct ≅ 15.5
0
10 20 30 40 10 20 30 40
Cycle Number Cycle Number
700
600
500
400
300
200
100
0
100 390 410 430 450 470 490 510 530 550 570 590 610 630 650 670 690 710
Wavelength (nm)
■ Alexa dye (346) ■ FAM (420) ■ TET ■ JOE (500) ■ Cy3 (520) ■ Cy3 (528) ■ REX (520)
■ Tamra ■ RR (540) ■ ROX dye (550) ■ BTR (550) ■ TR (550) ■ Cy5
has no significant fluorescence in the products and begins to fluoresce. threshold cycle of Ct. The Ct value is
presence of single-stranded DNA. used to quantitate the starting
. amount of template.
Extension and Extension and ExtensionDenaturation
and Denaturation Denaturation
SYBR Green SYBR Green SYBR Green
JumpStart intercalation intercalation and reannealing
intercalation and reannealing and reannealing
JumpStart JumpStart
ReadyMix ReadyMix ReadyMix
primer
primer primer
template template
template
Annealing Annealing Annealing
Extension and Extension and Extension and
intercalation intercalation intercalation
structure, and the chemical formulation of the reaction chemistry. n Are an affordable and ideal method for optimizing qPCR reactions
To produce melt curves, the final PCR product is exposed to a n Uses conventional PCR primers
temperature gradient from about 50 °C to 95 °C while fluorescence
n Does not require an expensive probe to identify a specific target
readouts are continually collected. This causes denaturation of all
dsDNA. The point at which the dsDNA melts into ssDNA is observed n Are useful for generating melt curves, providing an economical
as a drop in fluorescence as the dye dissociates. The melt curves are solution for genotype analysis
converted to distinct melting peaks by plotting the first negative Disadvantages
derivative of the fluorescence as a function of temperature (-dF/dT). n Bind non-specifically to any double-stranded DNA
Products of different lengths and sequences will melt at different
temperatures and are observed as distinct peaks. It is important to n Cannot be used to compare levels of different targets
note that the populations are not necessarily homogeneous and Some of the DNA binding dyes will bind to single-stranded DNA
may contain multiple PCR product species. However, if the PCR (ssDNA). They also bind indiscriminately to any dsDNA, resulting
assay is fully optimized, it is possible to produce a melting profile in non-specific fluorescence and overestimation of the actual
that contains only a single peak representing the specific product product. Non-specific binding results in fluorescence readings in
expected from the primer pair. In this situation, SYBR Green I may the “no template controls” (NTC) due to dye molecules binding
be useful for mutation detection as amplicons that differ by a single to primer dimers and misprimed products. For RT-PCR assays,
nucleotide will melt at slightly different temperatures and can be separate reverse-transcription, PCR, and DNase treatment can
distinguished by their melting peaks. This makes it possible to dramatically reduce non-specific priming and provide more
distinguish homozygotes, a single peak, from heterozygotes, two accurate quantification when using SYBR Green I binding dye.
peaks.2 Please see www.corbettresearch.com for further
Another concern is that multiple dye molecules may bind to a
information about high resolution melt analysis for genotype
single amplified molecule. Signal intensity is dependent on the
analysis using dsDNA binding dyes.
mass of dsDNA in the reaction. Even in reactions with the same
Advantages and Disadvantages of amplification efficiencies, amplification of a longer product will
Dye-Based Detection generate more signal than a shorter one, leading to the implica-
Advantages tion that there are more copies of the longer template than the
shorter one. If amplification efficiencies are different, quantifica-
n Arethe most economical format for detection and quantifica-
tion of PCR products tion will be even more inaccurate.
Probe-Based Detection The DNA polymerase then displaces the Reporter molecule from the probe
resulting in fluorescence. The fluorescence accumulates as cycling of PCR contin-
Probe-based quantitation uses sequence specific DNA-based ues and is measured at the end of each PCR cycle. The intensity of fluorescence
generated by the Reporter molecule above background level (Ct value) is mea-
fluorescent reporter probes. Sequence specific probes result in
sured and used to quantitate the amount of newly generated double-stranded
quantification of the sequence of interest only and not all dsDNA.
Linear Probes Advantage: This is the most popular qPCR chemistry and relies
The major advantages of linear probes are that the absence of on the activity of Taq DNA polymerase.
secondary structure allows for optimum hybridization efficiency, Uses: Undoubtedly the chemistry of choice for most quantifica-
and they are extremely simple to design and use. The most tion applications and for those requiring multiplexing.
common linear probes are described below. All probes included in
this section are FRET based. Hybridization Probes
Developed by: Developed specifically for use with the Idaho
Hydrolysis Probes Technology/Roche capillary-based instrument, but can be used
Also known as Dual Labeled Fluorescent Probes (DLFP) or TaqMan® with many real-time instruments.
Developed by: Roche Molecular Systems How They Work: Two probes are designed to bind adjacent to
How They Work: The TaqMan method relies on the 5’-3’ one another on the amplicon. One has a donor dye at its 3’ end,
exonuclease activity of Thermus aquaticus (Taq) DNA polymerase FAM for example. The other has an acceptor dye on its 5’ end,
to cleave a labeled probe when it is hybridized to a complemen- such as LightCycler® Red 640 or 705, and is blocked at its 3’ end
tary target. A fluorophore is attached to the 5’ end of the probe to prevent extension during the annealing step. Both probes
and a quencher to the 3’ end. If no amplicon complementary to hybridize to the target sequence in a head-to-tail arrangement
the probe is present, the probe remains intact and low fluores- during the annealing step. The reporter is excited and passes its
cence is detected. If the PCR results in a complementary target, energy to the acceptor dye through FRET and the intensity of the
the probe binds to it during each annealing step of the PCR. The light emitted is measured by the second probe. Figure 6 illustrates
double-strand-specific 5’-3’ nuclease activity of the Taq enzyme how these probes work.
displaces the 5’ end of the probe and then degrades it. This process
releases the fluorophore and quencher into solution, spatially Figure 6. Function of Hybridization Probes
separating them, and leads to an irreversible increase in fluores-
bv
cence from the reporter. Reaction conditions must be controlled bv
Structured Probes Uses: Molecular Beacons7 probes have become popular for
standard analyses such as quantification of DNA and RNA.8 They
Thermodynamic analysis reveals that structurally constrained have also been used for monitoring intracellular mRNA hybridiza-
probes have higher hybridization specificity than linear probes.5,6 tion,9 RNA processing,10 and transcription11 in living cells in real-
Structurally constrained probes also have a much greater
Advantages
n Increased thermal duplex stability22
n Improved specificity of probe hybridization to target sequence23
n Enhanced allelic discrimination
n Added flexibility in probe design
Advantages: Scorpions probes combine the primer and probe in n Compatible with many systems
one molecule converting priming and probing into a unimolecular Increased Stability and Improved Specificity
event. A unimolecular event is kinetically favorable and highly
The LNA monomer chemical structure enhances the stability of
efficient due to covalent attachment of the probe to the target
the hybridization of the probe to its target. As a result, the duplex
amplicon ensuring that each probe has a target in the vicinity.19
melting temperature, Tm, may increase by up to 8 °C per LNA
Enzymatic cleavage is not required so the reaction is very rapid.
monomer substitution in medium salt conditions compared to a
This allows introduction of more rapid cycling conditions combined
DNA fluorescent probe for the same target sequence, depending
with a significantly stronger signal compared to both TaqMan
on the target nucleic acid.24 This increase in hybridization creates
probes and Molecular Beacons probes.20 Another advantage over
a significant broadening in the scope of assay conditions and
TaqMan assays is that the PCR reaction is carried out at the
allows for more successful single-tube multiplexing.25 Addition-
optimal temperature for the polymerase rather than at the
ally, this benefit also makes it possible to optimize the Tm level
reduced temperature required for the 5’-nuclease activity to
and thus the hybridization specificity via placement of the LNA
displace and cleave the probe. The most important benefit is that
base(s) in the probe design.26 By increasing the stability and the
there is a one-to-one relationship between the number of
specificity, background fluorescence from spurious binding is
amplicons generated and the amount of fluorescence produced.
reduced and the signal-to-noise ratio is increased.
Uses: Scorpions probes are ideally suited to SNP/mutation
detection and have been used to detect, type and quantitate Enhanced Allelic Discrimination
human papillomaviruses.21 SNP detection can be carried out LNAs can also be used for allelic discrimination. They provide an
either by allele specific hybridization or by allele specific exten- extremely reliable and effective means for SNP-calling in genotyp-
sion. If the probe sequence is allele-specific, allelic variants of a ing applications. The presence of a single base mismatch has a
SNP can be detected in a single reaction by labeling the two greater destabilizing effect on the duplex formation between a
versions of the probe with different fluorophores. Alternatively, LNA fluorescent probe and its target nucleic acid than with a
the PCR primer can be designed to selectively amplify only one conventional DNA fluorescent probe. Shorter probes incorporat-
allele of a SNP. Results with Scorpions probes compare favorably ing LNA bases can be used at the same temperatures as longer
with the high signal/high background ratio of the TaqMan probes conventional DNA probes.
and low signal/low background ratio of Molecular Beacons probes. Added Flexibility in Probe Design
Due to the enhanced hybridization characteristics and the Tm
Modifications contribution, LNA containing qPCR probes can be synthesized to
be shorter, allowing flexibility in design while still satisfying assay
A number of modifications can be incorporated when designing design guidelines. As such, certain design limitations that cannot
probes to provide enhanced performance. Locked Nucleic Acids be overcome with standard DNA chemistries can be reduced or
and Minor Grove Binders are two of the most commonly used eliminated. For instance, shorter probes can be designed to
modifications. address traditionally problematic target sequences, such as AT- or
GC-rich regions. LNAs also facilitate the querying of difficult or
inaccessible SNPs, such as the relatively stable G:T mismatch.
Locked Nucleic Acid
A Locked Nucleic Acid (LNA) is a novel type of nucleic acid analog
that contains a 2’-O, 4’-C methylene bridge. The bridge is locked
LNAs can also be used when AT-rich qPCR probes need to be over
30 bases long to satisfy amplicon design guidelines. With LNA
Template, Primer Design,
fluorescent probes, the selective placement of LNA base substitu- Probe Design and Dye Choice
tions facilitates optimal design of highly specific, shorter probes
It is very important to ensure that the primers and probes are
should also aim to design primers with a melting temperature, the thermal stability and hybridization stability, allowing for
Tm, higher than the Tm of any of the predicted template more accurate gene quantitation and allelic discrimination and
secondary structures. Again, the Mfold server is a very useful providing easier and more flexible probe designs for problem-
resource in this phase of the design process. atic target sequences.
4. Design primers longer than 17 bases. 3. Probe GC content may be anywhere from 30-80%
Shorter primers increase the chance of random, or non- preferably with a greater number of Cs than Gs.
specific, primer binding. Such random primer binding may be As in the case of primers, there should not be homopolymeric
more marked in targets of higher complexity, such as genomic runs of single bases, most definitely not of Gs, in probes.
DNA, and should be guarded against even when using more
4. For optimal efficiency of dual-labeled probes, the
predictable target sequences, such as plasmids. Even with a
5’-terminal of the probe (carrying the reporter dye)
plasmid, it is not always the case that the sequence is
should be as close as possible to the 3’-end of the
completely known.
forward primer.
5. Check the overall specificity of primers (and probes) by For Molecular Beacons probes, the probe should be designed
carrying out a BLAST search. to anneal in the middle of the amplicon.
BLAST, or Basic Local Alignment Search Tool, searches can be
5. A G placed at the extreme 5’ end of the probe adjacent
performed using the resources of the publicly available site at
to the reporter dye should be avoided.
NCBI at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/. A BLAST search
This may lead to spontaneous fluorophore quenching.
compares primer sequences against a library of genomic DNA
sequences. Another method is to use electronic PCR, or e-PCR. Dye Choice in Probe Design
e-PCR is used to identify sequence tagged sites (STS) within DNA It is also important to consider the dye choice when designing
sequences by searching for sub-sequences that closely match probes.
the PCR primers. STSs are short DNA segments occurring once
1. Make sure that the instrument being used can detect
in the human genome. Their exact location and sequence are
the dyes.
known and, as a result, they can serve as landmarks in the
human genome. e-PCR uses UniSTS, a database of STSs, to 2. When designing fluorescent probes, it is important to be
identify primers that have the proper order that could represent sure that the fluorophore and quencher are compatible.
PCR primers used to generate the known STSs. This tool is 3. When designing multiplexed reactions, spectral overlap
available at http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sutils/e-pcr/. should be minimized.
6. Forward and reverse PCR primers should be analyzed for Table 3 provides the excitation wavelength and the emission
self-complementarity in their sequences. wavelength for several popular dyes used in probe design.
In particular, 3’ self-complementarity primer-dimer formation
should be avoided. A number of commercial primer analysis Table 3. Dye Choice in Probe Design
resources are available to aid in this process. Filter Excitation Wv Emission Wv
7. Multiplexed primer pairs must all work efficiently at the Alexa 350 350 440
same annealing temperature.
FAM/SYBR Green 492 516
Probe Design Considerations TET 517 538
1. Probes may be anywhere from 9-40 bases in length.
HEX/JOE/VIC 535 555
In the case of the 5’-nuclease assay using dual-labeled probes,
probes with a reporter and a quencher, the overall probe Cy3 545 568
length tends to range up to 30 bases. Longer probes might TAMARA 556 580
compromise the efficiency of signal quenching. In the case of
ROX/Texas Red 585 610
Molecular Beacons probes, where quenching is a function of
the self-annealing hairpin design, probes may be a little longer, Cy5 635 665
perhaps up to 35 bases.
2. In most situations, the probe Tm should be approxi- Quenchers in Probe Design
mately 10 ºC higher than the Tm of the primers. FRET occurs when donor and acceptor molecules are separated
This allows for efficient probe-to-target annealing during the by about 100 Å. Since a helix occupies approximately 3.4 Å, the
reaction. During the reaction, the probe should anneal before maximum distance between a reporter and its quencher on a
the primers. When probes anneal before the primers, shorter linear probe should not exceed approximately 30 bases. The
probes can be used. The use of shorter probes is important acceptor can be another fluorophore, in which case the transfer
during mismatch detection. In such cases, the use of special releases the energy from the quencher as fluorescence at a longer
wavelength. For instance, the combination of FAM (a fluorescein Primer and Probe Design FAQs
derivative) and TAMRA (a rhodamine derivative) will absorb at What type of probe should I choose?
492 nm (excitation peak for FAM) and emit at 580 nm (emission It depends on the experiment being performed and the machine
peak for TAMRA). The inherent fluorescence and broad emission being used.
Dark quenchers absorb the energy emitted by the reporter Table 5. Probe Applications
fluorophore and emit heat rather than fluorescence. Early dark TaqMan/ Molecular
quenchers, such as 4-(49-dimethylaminophenylazo) benzoic acid Application Hydrolysis Hybridization Beacons Scorpions
(DABCYL), had limited spectral overlap between the fluorescent
dye and quencher molecule. Black Hole Quenchers (BHQ™-1 and Quantification X X
BHQ™-2) from Biosearch Technologies have lower background applications
fluorescence and a broad effective range of absorption. As a Multiplexing X X
result, Black Hole Quenchers provide greater sensitivity and SNP/mutation X X X
enable the simultaneous use of a wide range of reporter detection
fluorophores thus expanding the options available for multiplex
Generation of X
assays. It is important to ensure that the Black Hole Quencher is
melt curves
matched with the probe based on the excitation and emission
spectra of the probe. Monitoring X
intracellular
Table 4. Quencher Ranges mRNA
Quencher Quenching Range hybridization,
RNA processing,
BHQ-1 480-580 nm
and transcription
BHQ-2 550-650 nm in living cells
BHQ-3 620-730 nm Analysis of G/C- X
TAMARA 550-576 nm rich sequences
DABCYL 453 nm Detection of X
mRNA from
single cells
Primer and Probe Design Software and Web Sites
Several software programs can be used to design primers and Why do I need to have a good design?
probes, but software is only a tool to aid in the design process Well-designed primers and probes will provide ideal RT-qPCR
and cannot guarantee a perfect design. data: high PCR efficiency, specific PCR products and the most
sensitive results.
Designing Primers
What should I do if no primers and/or probes are found for
n Primer 3.0
my sequence?
Designing TaqMan Probes or Molecular Beacons Probes There are several parameters that can be adjusted to force the
n Beacon Designer from Premier Biosoft program to pick primers and/or probes without significantly
sacrificing primer and/or probe quality.
Designing Scorpions Probes
I have a very short target sequence. Is it possible to design
n DNA Software at dnasoftware.com
an optimal probe?
Designing FRET Probes (LightCycler Probes) It depends on the sequence. To design the probe, it may be
n LightCycler Probe Design Software 2.0 necessary to submit a longer target sequence (up to 160 bases).
Additionally, LNA bases can be included in the probe sequence to
Designing LNA Probes or Oligos reduce the probe length while retaining the optimal characteristic
n A combination of different types of software must be used of the probe.
On the following pages, qPCR instruments are categorized into more will be considered high throughput. All qPCR instruments
two groups: high throughput and low throughput. Any device require a computer for operation and data management/analysis.
that processes fewer than 96 samples in a run will be called Nearly all instruments are supplied with a computer and the
low throughput and anything that processes 96 samples or appropriate software.
Instrumentation
High-Throughput qPCR Instruments
Applied Biosystems Applied Biosystems Applied Biosystems Roche Applied Science
Manufacturer ABI 7300 Real-Time ABI 7500 Real-Time ABI 7900HT Fast LightCycler® 480
System PCR System PCR System Real-Time PCR System Real-Time PCR System
Advantages Affordable, 5 color multiplexing. Rapid 96- and 384-well plate Interchangeable 96- and
4 color multiplexing cycling upgrade available compatible. The system 384-well thermal blocks.
in the ABI 7500 Fast that can handle TaqMan Low The Therma-Base design
allows run times of <40 Density Arrays with fully provides added tempera-
min. TaqMan assays are automated robotic ture uniformity
available loading. Optional Fast
real-time PCR capability.
TaqMan assays are
available
Excitation Tungsten-halogen lamp, Tungsten-halogen lamp, Extended-life 488 nm Filtered (450, 483, 523,
single-excitation filter 5 excitation filters argon-ion laser is 558 and 615 nm) high-
distributed to all wells by intensity Xenon lamp
a dual-axis synchronous (430–630 nm)
scanning head
Detection 4 emission filters and a 5 emission filters and a CCD camera and a Filters (500, 533, 568,
CCD camera CCD camera spectrograph 610, 640, 670 nm) and a
CCD camera
Heat block Peltier Peltier Peltier Peltier plus Therma-Base
Rxn volume(s): 20-100 µL 25-100 µL 25-100 μL/10-30 μL (fast) 5-100 μL (96 well) or
for 96-well and 5-20 μL 5-20 μL (384 well)
for 384-wells
Multiplexing Up to 4 fluorophores Up to 5 fluorophores Multiplex number is The number is dependent
limited by spectral overlap on the excitation/emission
combination
Sensitivity 10 starting copies of the 10 starting copies of the 10 starting copies of the 10 copies (plasmid)
RNase P gene from human RNase P gene from human RNase P gene from human
genomic DNA genomic DNA genomic DNA
Dynamic Range– 9 9 9 10
Reaction –
Orders of
Magnitude
Software System Software and System Software and System Software and LightCycler Software
Primer Express software Primer Express software Primer Express software
included included included. Enterprise
Edition Software with SNP
Manager and RQ Manager
are available
Instrumentation
System Detection System Detection System Detection System Detector
Advantages Optical upgrade to the Optical upgrade to the Can perform plate reads Has a 96-well Alpha unit.
iCycler® thermal cycler. iCycler thermal cycler. This allows it to be used
Embedded tool for end- Limited to one color on any DNA Engine®
point fluorescence analysis chassis
Excitation Tungsten-halogen lamp Tungsten-halogen lamp 96 LEDs (470-505 nm) 4 LEDs in photonics
(475-645 nm) (475-645 nm) shuttle (450-650 nm)
Detection 5 color customizable 12-bit CCD camera Two photomultiplier 4 photodiodes
filter wheel and CCD (515-545 nm) tubes; one compatible (515-730 nm)
camera (515-700 nm) with SYBR Green I or
FAM; the other detects a
variety of fluorophores
Heat block Peltier and Joule Peltier and Joule Peltier Peltier
(gradient: 25 °C max) (gradient: 25 ºC max) (gradient: 24 ºC max) (gradient: 24 ºC max)
Rxn volume(s): 15-100 µL 15-100 µL 10-100 µL 10-100 µL
Multiplexing Up to 5 colors No Up to 2 colors Up to 4 colors
Sensitivity Linear to 10 copies of One copy of IL-1b in As little as one starting As little as one starting
b-actin DNA human genomic DNA template copy template copy
Dynamic Range– 9 8 10 10
Reaction – Orders
of Magnitude
Software iQ5 Optical System iCycler iQ Software DNA Engine Opticon 2 Chromo4 Software
Software Version 2.0 Version 3.1 Software Version 3.1 Version 3.1
Advantages Runs samples in blocks Centrifugal systems A centrifugal system The LightCycler series of
of 16, up to 96 samples designed to work with designed to work with instruments are rotor-
total, and allows each any real-time chemistry. any real-time chemistry. based and work with a
reaction to be separately Samples are rotated in Samples are rotated in variety of chemistries.
programmed for inde a changing thermal a changing thermal Rapid reactions take
pendent experimental environment to produce environment to produce place in passivated
protocols. Fast programs a uniform temperature a uniform temperature glass capillaries
complete in as little as between reactions. between reactions.
20 minutes. Fast runs Conventional or rapid Conventional or rapid
require proprietary cycling conditions possible cycling conditions possible
reaction tubes using conventional using conventional
reagents reagents. Dedicated
analysis software
Excitation LED 4 LEDs excite entire Separate color high- Blue LED (470 nm)
visible spectrum intensity LED per channel
Detection Silicon photo detector is A series of filters and a Separate emission filter Photodiodes (530, 560,
used to collect filtered photomultiplier tube per channel and a 610, 640, 670 and
light photomultiplier tube 710 nm)
Heat block Solid-state heater; Thermostated air Thermostated air Thermostated air
forced-air cooling
Rxn volume(s): 25 and 100 µL volumes 20-25 µl 5 µL to 100 µL, but 20 µL 20 µL and 100 µL
is typical
Multiplexing Up to 4 colors Two-channel (3000A) or 2, 5, or 6 color options Provides multiplexing and
four channel (3000) measures fluorescence
between 530-705 nm
Sensitivity 10 copies plasmid Unpublished Single-copy gene target Single-copy gene in 3 pg
amplification from a of human genomic DNA.
whole human genome 1-10 copies of plasmid
Dynamic Range– 8 Unpublished Unpublished 10
Reaction – Orders
of Magnitude
Maximum Number of samples can Up to 36 or 72 samples 72 individual tubes or 32
number of be increased in increments in specifically designed heat-sealed plates
samples of 16 – to a total number rotors
of 96 by linking additional
units to a single PC
Software SmartCycler Corbett system software Corbett system software LightCycler® Software 4.05
with analysis, graphing
and statistical license
For maximum sensitivity, optimum primer concentrations must be 3. Aliquot 26 µL master mix into all wells in the PCR plate that
determined empirically. Primer concentrations are most efficiently contain primers (A1-E5).
optimized by testing various combinations in qPCR, as shown in
4. Mix thoroughly and transfer 18 µL from each of wells A1
the example below. Regardless of the detection chemistry used in
through E5 to wells A8 through E12.
Optimizing qPCR
the final assay, the best assay sensitivity will be obtained if primer
concentrations are optimized in the presence of SYBR Green. This 5. Add 2 µL template-containing DNA (10-50 ng genomic DNA or
allows detection of primer-dimer and other non-specific products, 0.1-1 ng plasmid) or RNA (10-100 ng total RNA or 0.5-10 ng
and helps the user to screen out reactions with multiple products mRNA) to one set of reactions (columns 1-5) and 2 µL water to
(step 8, next section). Alternatively, if maximum sensitivity is not the other (columns 8-12).
a concern, the corresponding probe may be included in reactions 6. Perform thermal cycling:
at 250 nM.
Time Time
Primer Optimization Example Number
Temperature for for
1. Prepare and dispense diluted primers of Cycles
qPCR qRT-PCR
a. Prepare 60 μL of 8 μM working solutions of both forward
Reverse
(fwd) and reverse (rev) primers in the first tubes of 2 1 45 °C 0 min 15-30 min
transcription
separate 8-tube strips.
b. Dispense 30 μL of water into tubes 2-5. Denature 1 94 °C 3 min 3 min
c. Transfer 30 μL of the 8 μM primer solution from tube 1 into Denature 40 94 °C 15 sec 15 sec
tube 2. Mix thoroughly by pipetting up and down at least
Anneal, extend,
5 times.
and read 60 °C 1 min 1 min
d. Repeat transfer and mixing from tube 2 to 3, 3 to 4, and
fluorescence
4 to 5.
e. Using a multichannel pipettor, transfer 5 μL from the strip- Dissociation/
1 * * *
tubes containing diluted fwd primer into the first 5 wells melting curve
down columns 1-5 of a 96-well PCR plate. After adding *See manufacturer’s instructions for the real-time thermal cycler used.
reverse primer, PCR mix, and template (below), final
7. Evaluate fluorescence plots (DRn) for reactions containing
concentrations of forward primer will be 1000, 500, 250,
target nucleic acid (columns 1-5). Primer combinations with the
125, and 62.5 nM.
lowest Ct and the highest fluorescence will give the most
f. Similarly, transfer 5 μL from the strip-tubes containing diluted
sensitive and reproducible assays.
rev primer into the first 5 wells across rows A-E. After adding
PCR mix and template (below), final concentrations of 8. Evaluate dissociation/melting curves. Primer combinations
reverse primer will be 1000, 500, 250, 125, and 62.5 nM. with single, sharp peaks in the presence of target nucleic acid
(columns 1-5) and nothing detected in the corresponding
2. Prepare qPCR or qRT-PCR master mix (for 52 × 20 µL reactions):
no-template control (columns 8-12) will give the most sensitive
qPCR and reproducible assays. If all primer combinations give some
product in the absence of template, and this no-template
Reagent Catalog Number Volume
product melts at a lower temperature than that with template,
Water W1754 155 µL select the combination that gives the least amount of lower-
SYBR Green JumpStart™ Taq melting no-template product. The latter is likely primer-dimer.
S9939* 520 µL Detection can be avoided, or at least minimized, by adding a
ReadyMix™
15 second melting step approximately 3 °C below the melting
Reference dye** R4526* 1.0 µL
temperature of the desired PCR product during which fluores-
qRT-PCR cence is measured after the annealing/extension step in
each cycle.
Reagent Catalog Number Volume
Water W1754 123.8 µL Optimize Probe Concentration
For maximum sensitivity, 250 nM probe may be used in all assays.
SYBR Green JumpStart Taq ™
S9939* 520 µL However, if maximum sensitivity is not required, lower levels of
ReadyMix™
probe may suffice, thereby reducing the assay cost. To optimize
Reference dye** R4526* 1.0 µL probe concentration, test the probe at several levels from 50 to
40 U/µL RNase inhibitor R2520 26 µL 250 nM final concentrations in PCR with optimized levels of
200 U/µL MMLV reverse primers and the lowest level of target nucleic acid expected. The
M1427 5.2 µL lowest level of probe that allows acceptable detection (Ct ≤ 30
transcriptase
for best reproducibility) may be used.
* S9939 and R4526 are components of Catalog Number S4438.
** Use 10 × more for ABI 7700; replace with FITC for BioRad iCycler.
Ct
software for most real-time qPCR instruments can be set up
to prepare a standard curve and to calculate efficiency (see the 30
user guide for the instrument being used). If this feature is not
28
available, prepare a plot of Ct versus the log of nucleic acid input
level and perform a linear regression. Calculate the reaction 26
efficiency from the slope of the line using the equation:
24
Efficiency = 10(–1/slope)-1
-3 -2 -1 0
The correlation coefficient of the line, R2, is a measure of how Log of DNA dilution
well the data fits the model and how well the data fits on a straight B.
line, and is influenced by pipetting accuracy and by the range of
35
the assay. If R2 is ≤ 0.985, the assay may not give reliable results.
If one or more points at the lowest levels of input nucleic acid are
shifted away from the linear region of the plot, it is likely that the 30
level exceeds assay sensitivity (Fig. 11A). To improve sensitivity,
optimize primer concentrations or design different primers. 25
Similarly, if one or more points at the highest levels of input
nucleic acid are shifted away from the linear region of the plot, 20
Ct
Optimizing qPCR
PCR efficiencies are larger than 120%. Melt, or dissociation, curve higher than the background signal, (b) the samples must all be
analysis can also be used to determine the number and approxi- measured in the exponential phase of amplification and (c) the
mate size of products. An assay with high specificity will give efficiency of amplification must be identical for all samples.
a single peak at a high temperature (> 80 °C) in all reactions
The fluorescence value must be statistically higher than the
and nothing, or very little, detected in the no-template controls
background signal to ensure that real data are collected. Most
(Fig. 12A). If the melting curve has more than one major peak,
instruments automatically calculate a threshold level of fluores-
as in Figures 12B and 12C, the identities of the products should
cence signal by determining the baseline (background) average
be determined by fractionating them on an ethidum bromide-
signal and setting a threshold 10-fold higher than the baseline
stained agarose gel. As shown in Figures 12E and 12F, reactions B
average signal.
and C contain excessive amounts of primer-dimer or other non-
specific products. Lowering the primer concentrations will often Setting a manual threshold is best accomplished using a log
reduce the amount of non-specific products. If non-specific signal plot, as the exponential part of the curve shows clearly
products are still detected in significant amounts with low primer as a linear trace.
levels, redesign the primers.
D. E. F.
Melt, or dissociation, curves showing a sharp peak of specific product at > 80°C, very little non-specific product at lower temperatures (A), or significant amounts of
non-specific, lower melting product (B&C). D-F show PCR products from A-C, respectively, fractionated on ethidium bromide-stained 2% agarose gels.
n Confirm that primers span or flank long introns Figure 14. Evaluation of RNA Integrity by Agarose
n Conduct no-reverse transcriptase (no-RT) controls Gel Analysis
n Optimize reverse transcription 1 2 3 4
Figure 15. Illustration of Intron-Spanning (A) and Figure 17. Evaluation of No-RT Controls
Intron-Flanking (B) Primers for RT-PCR
A. B.
A. Primers Span Intron mw + – + – +/– RT
P2
Optimizing qPCR
P2
DNA:
P1 P1 2,000
P2
1,500
mRNA:
P1 1,000
300 294
Introns are in red, exons are in green. Primers P1 & 2 span an intron and primers
P3 & 4 flank an intron. Note that primers P1 & 2 are only partly complimentary 150 191
to the gDNA strand and will not generate a PCR product from DNA unless the 50
annealing temperature is extremely low. P3 & 4 may generate a longer PCR
product from DNA if the intron is short (~1 kb), but not if it is sufficiently long
(several kb). RT-PCR products produced in the presence (+) or absence (-) of RT enzyme
were fractionated on an ethidium bromide-stained 2% agarose gel in TBE.
Figure 16. BLAST Alignment of cDNA Sequence with Primers for the mRNA target in (A) flank a 1 kb intron. Note the 1.5 kb band
Genomic DNA Sequence in the no RT control. The mRNA target in (B) aligns with several genes, at least
one of which is a pseudogene that lacks the intron between the primers used
for RT-PCR. As such, the no RT control gives a larger yield than when reverse
transcriptase is added.
with and without RT should be performed at least once with each template, primer-dimer formation may start during the RT step.
new starting material and RNA preparation method. Increasing RT incubation temperature to the highest temperature
at which the enzyme is fully active or using a high-temperature
Figure 18. Comparison of On-Column DNase Digestion enzyme may reduce the amount of primer-dimer. For example,
(OC) with Post-Preparation DNase Digestion the primers used in Figure 18 gave significantly less non-specific
5 product in one-step qRT-PCR when RT was performed with MMLV-RT
(Moloney Murine Leukemia Virus-Reverse Transcriptase) at 45 °C
4
(Fig. 19B) than when the reaction was performed at 37 °C
(Fig. 19A). Similarly, performing two-step RT-PCR with a non-
Fluorescence (dRn)
specific primer for RT and hot-start Taq polymerase for qPCR may
3
+/– DNase give less primer-dimer (Fig. 19D) than one-step qRT-PCR with
+ RT gene specific primers that can form a 3’-duplex (Fig. 19B).
2
– DNase
– RT The amount of RT enzyme per reaction can also affect qRT-PCR
+ OC DNase
– RT results. As shown in Figure 18, one-step reactions with 2 units of
1 MMLV-RT (Fig. 19C) gave better specificity than reactions with
+ post-prep DNase 20 units (Fig. 19B). Superscript™ III, an RNaseH– deletion of
– RT
0 MMLV-RT, and Omniscript from Qiagen gave results similar to
2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26 28 30 32 34 36 38 40 42 44 those shown in Figure 18 (data not shown). Two-step RT-PCR
Cycles
with Oligo-dT or random primers for RT often gives greater
specificity than does one-step RT-PCR (Fig. 19D). This could be
Total RNA was prepared from 30 mg pieces of mouse liver with either the attributed to the fact that the gene-specific primers are not
Sigma GenElute™ Total RNA Kit or the Qiagen RNeasy Mini Kit according to the
present to form non-specific products during the low tempera-
manufacturers’ instructions. Two RNA samples were prepared with the respec-
tive manufacturer’s on-column DNase product and two were prepared without ture RT reaction. Higher levels of RT may give better results in
DNase digestion. After purification, aliquots of the four RNA samples prepared two-step reactions, but because the RT enzyme can interfere with
without on-column DNase were digested with Sigma’s Amplification Grade Taq activity, the amount of RT product transferred to qPCR should
DNase I according to the manufacturer’s instructions. Equal proportions of all be limited to no more than 10% of the final reaction volume.
were used in one-step qRT-PCR. Fluorescence plots for two of the RNA samples
are shown. Similar results were obtained with both manufacturers’ products.
Optimizing qPCR
C. D.
Melt curves of RT-PCR products produced with one-step (A-C) or two-step (D) qRT-PCR. Reactions (A-C) each contained 10 µL of SYBR Green JumpStart Taq
ReadyMix, 0.02 µL of Reference Dye, both gene-specific primers at 0.4 µM, and 10 ng human total RNA in a final volume of 20 µL. Gene-specific primers were
5’-CGGGCTTCAACGCAGACTA-3’ and 5’-CTGGTCGAGATGGCAGTGA-3’ for c-fos (Accession NM_005252). Reactions (A&B) also contained 20 units of MMLV- RT,
whereas reaction (C) contained 2 units. Reaction A was incubated at 37 °C for 30 min before qPCR, whereas (B&C) were incubated at 45 °C for 30 min before qPCR.
In (D), the RT reaction contained 1× MMLV buffer, 0.5 mM dNTPs, 1 µM Oligo-dT, 0.8 units/µL RNase inhibitor, 200 units MMLV-RT, and 10 ng human total RNA in a
final volume of 20 µL. The reaction was incubated at 25 °C for 10 min, 37 °C for 50 min, and 80 °C for 10 min. 2 µL of the RT reaction product was added to qPCR
containing 10 µL of SYBR Green JumpStart Taq ReadyMix, 0.02 µL of Reference Dye, and both gene-specific primers at 0.4 µM as for the one-step reactions (A-C).
All qPCR reactions were incubated at 94 °C for 3 min to denature, then for 40 cycles of 94 °C for 15 sec and 60 °C for 1 min.
quantitated in a single reaction, often require additional optimiza- and increasing magnesium raises the stability, or melting tempera-
tion. One simple consideration is to minimize the spectral separation ture, of a DNA duplex. It follows that high magnesium levels
of the multiple emissions. This facilitates signal isolation and data increase the affinity of primers toward hybridization, including mis-
analysis. As a result, fluorophores with narrow, well-resolved priming events and primer-primer interactions. The mis-primed
bandwidths are useful for multiplex applications. Appendix 1 DNA duplexes become substrates for the DNA polymerase, in
contains Traits of Common Fluorophores to aid in the selection of effect creating side products and sapping PCR efficiency. Salts,
fluorophores. For multiplex reactions, it is also recommended to such as KCl, will also change DNA duplex Tm, but the effect is
optimize the following: less drastic for these monovalent cations.
n Check primer design PCR requires a minimal amount of magnesium, and both efficiency
n Optimize primer concentartions and product Tm change as the cation concentration increases.
These effects are magnified when one attempts to perform
n Optimize Mg2+ concentration multiplex PCR. Running multiple reactions concurrently introduces
Check Primer Design competition for reagents and exacerbates any non-optimal conditions
As for single-target reactions, multiplex qPCR will give the best results creating major changes in PCR efficiency. Figure 20 demonstrates
if all primers in the reaction have similar melting temperatures this point. The efficiency curves for two primer/probe targets were
(Tm difference ≤ 2 °C) and none can form strong 3’-duplexes performed individually and then in multiplex. The graph shows
(DG ≥ –2.0 kcal). For more information, see the section Check that while the individual reactions (dark blue and green lines)
Primer Design for Primer Potential on page 18. Individual reaction give relatively similar efficiencies and sensitivities (y-axis values)
optimizations should be performed as well as optimization with running the reactions together dramatically changes the sensitivity
several or all primer combinations. It is very often the case that and efficiency of the later reaction.
individual primers work singly, but when combined in multiplex
the primers cross-react or otherwise alter reaction specificity
and efficiency.
Optimize Primer Concentrations
If one target in a multiplex reaction is significantly more abundant
than the other(s) or if one primer pair gives a much lower Ct or
higher DR (the amount of fluorescence in the no-template control)
than the other(s), amplification of that target may dominate the
reaction, using up reactants before other targets are detectable.
Adjusting the levels of primers may allow a more balanced
amplification of all targets. To determine if such adjustments
will be beneficial, prepare standard curves that cover the range
of targets expected for each primer pair alone (singleplex) and
with all primers combined (multiplex). There is no need to modify
primer levels if multiplex and singleplex reactions give similar results.
On the other hand, optimizing primer concentrations will likely
improve results if sensitivity is unacceptable in multiplex reactions.
Decrease primer concentrations for those primer pairs that give
low Ct values and/or increase concentrations for those that give
high Ct values, within the range of 50-500 nM.
Optimizing qPCR
&'&-2(VLQJOH
&'&-2(GXSOH[
/LQHDU&0<&IDPVLQJOH
/LQHDU&0<&IDPGXSOH[
/LQHDU&'&-2(VLQJOH
/LQHDU&'&-2(GXSOH[
&'&PXOWLSOH[
\ [
5
&'&VLQJOH
&7
\ [
5
FP\FGXSOH[
\ [
5
FP\FVLQJOH
\ [
5
ORJQJ'1$
S5193 SYBR Green JumpStart Taq 20 Reactions S5193 SYBR Green JumpStart Taq 20 Reactions
ReadyMix without MgCl2 100 Reactions ReadyMix without MgCl2 100 Reactions
(with separate tube of MgCl2) 400 Reactions (with separate tube of MgCl2) 400 Reactions
S9194 SYBR Green JumpStart Taq 20 Reactions
ReadyMix for High-Throughput 400 Reactions
Quantitative PCR (with internal 2000 Reactions
reference dye)
QR0100 SYBR Green Quantitative 1 Kit QR0100 SYBR Green Quantitative 1 Kit
RT-PCR Kit (100 Reactions) RT-PCR Kit (100 Reactions)
Catalog Catalog
Number Product Name Package Size Number Product Name Package Size
D7440 JumpStart Taq ReadyMix for 100 Reactions D9191 JumpStart Taq ReadyMix 20 Reactions
Quantitative PCR 400 Reactions with dUTP 100 Reactions
400 Reactions
Probe based qPCR
Troubleshooting
Fluorescence Issues
No, or low, fluorescence in both the test sample and in the positive control with the correct PCR
Number 1
product on the gel
Troubleshooting
SYBR Green Dye-Based Detection Probe Detection
Possible cause Bad SYBR Green binding dye High-background fluorescence Degraded probe
Compare fluorescence of the SYBR Check the raw fluorescence Digest 5 fmoles of probe with
Green binding dye mix ± 1 µg DNA. (multicomponent plot). Fluorescence DNase I. Fluorescence should be at
Diagnostic test Fluorescence should be at least should increase at least 10,000 units least 10,000 units greater than
10,000 units higher with DNA between cycles 1 & 40 without DNase digestion
added than without
Purchase new SYBR Green binding Purchase a new probe Purchase a new probe
Solution dye or a new qPCR mix with SYBR
Green binding dye
Number 2 Low fluorescence from test sample, but the positive control has good fluorescence
Possible cause Fluorescence quenching
Diagnostic test Positive control gives good fluorescence
Solution Purify the input nucleic acid
Number 3 Declining or hooked fluorescence plots
As PCR product accumulates, the complimentary strand competes with the primer and/or probe for annealing
Possible cause
to template
Diagnostic test See figure
Solution Ignore it if the Ct is not affected
Disable reference dye normalization or look at the results for DR (level of fluorescence in the no-template control)
Diagnostic test instead of DRn (the difference of the reporter fluorescence in the sample and that in the no template control). The
plots should become smooth if fluorescence is not normalized to an inactive reference dye
Solution Purchase a new reference dye. Always protect dye from light during storage
Number 5 No amplification results from a sample known to contain target and the positive control does amplify
Possible cause Inhibition in the test sample is likely
Test amplification with a diluted sample. Spike the reaction with a low level of exogenous target and test for
Diagnostic test
amplification of the exogenous target
Solution Try adding BSA to 0.3% in the PCR or purify the input nucleic acid
Dissociation/Melting Curves
Number 6 There are multiple peaks in the dissociation plot/melt curve
Possible cause The Mg2+ concentration in the reaction is too high or the annealing temperature is too low
Fractionate the PCR product on an ethidium bromide-stained agarose gel or use the Bioanalyzer to verify
Diagnostic test
multiple products
Titrate the Mg2+ to determine the optimum concentration. Perform annealing temperature gradient to select the
Solution
optimum annealing temperature
Number 7 There is a broad peak at a lower Tm than the desired product, especially in low or no-template reactions
Possible cause Primer-dimer, generated from primers that anneal at their 3’-ends, extend, and then amplify
Fractionate the PCR product on an ethidium bromide-stained agarose gel or use the Bioanalyzer. The primer-dimer
Diagnostic test
will appear as a diffuse band at ≤ 50 bp
Try lower primer concentrations. With RT-PCR, try using less RT enzyme and use a 2-step and/or a higher
Solution
incubation temperature for the RT step
Number 8 Multiple Tm peaks
Single product on gel Multiple products on gel
Localized AT or GC-rich regions or short repeats in Multiple targets in the source material
Possible cause
PCR product
Check sequence of amplicon for AT or GC-rich regions BLAST primer sequences against the sequence of the
Diagnostic test
or repeats source organism to verify single target
This is not a problem if the gel analysis shows that all Design unique primers
Solution
product is specific. Continue to use the primers
Standard Curve
Number 9 PCR efficiency < 80%
Suboptimal PCR conditions (See example. This illustrates Poorly designed primers
Possible cause
Troubleshooting
low Taq activity)
Prepare or purchase fresh PCR mix Check the primer design. Test the PCR mix with a set
Diagnostic test of primers known to work well and a positive
control template
Solution Prepare or purchase fresh PCR mix Design new primers
Number 10 PCR efficiency is greater than 120%
Possible cause Excessive primer-dimer Pipetting is inaccurate Inhibition
Evaluate dissociation plot as shown Test pipette calibration See Problem Number 4: The
Diagnostic test in the figure below fluorescence plots suddenly spike
upward
Try lower primer concentrations. If the pipettes are inaccurate, get See Problem #4: The fluorescence
With RT-PCR, try using less RT them re-calibrated. If the pipettes plots suddenly spike upward
enzyme, doing 2-step and/or using are properly calibrated, practice
Solution a higher incubation temperature for pipetting accurately
the RT step
Figure 22. Standard Curve that is not Linear with Low Levels of Sample Input
40
38
36
34
Ct
32
30
28
26
24
-3 -2 -1 0
Log of DNA dilution
Number 12 The standard curve is not linear with high levels of sample input
Possible cause Exceeded assay capacity
Diagnostic test Low Ct (< 12-15, depending on instrument)
Solution Use less input nucleic acid
Figure 23. Standard Curve that is not Linear with High Levels of Sample Input
35
30
25
Ct
20
15
10
5
-5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0
Log of DNA dilution
qRT-PCR Specific
Number 13 Product is detected in the no-RT reaction with primers that flank an intron
The intron is short enough that the primers amplify Pseudogenes are present that lack introns
Possible cause
Troubleshooting
(~1.4 kb in example)
Fractionate the PCR product on an ethidium bromide- Fractionate PCR product on ethidium bromide-stained
Diagnostic test stained agarose gel. No-RT product will migrate more agarose gel. No-RT product will migrate the same as
slowly than +RT product as in gel photograph shown +RT on gel
Solution Re-design the primers to flank or span a longer intron or multiple introns
Multiplex
Number 14 One, or more, primer/probe set does not work well in a multiplex reaction
Possible cause The target is less abundant or the primers are less efficient
Diagnostic test Conduct reactions with individual primer/probe sets to see if they work adequately in the absence of competition
Limit the level of primers that dominate the reaction and give higher signal. Determine the level that reduces DRn
Solution
without increasing Ct significantly
Appendix 2
How to Optimise Your Quantitative or in the first extraction buffer containing guanidine isocyanate,
provided in the extraction kits, and others freeze it in liquid
Real-Time RT-PCR (qRT-PCR) nitrogen. The extracted analyte (either total RNA or poly-
Michael W. Pfaffl, Physiology Weihenstephan, Technical University of Munich adenylated mRNA) as well as the RNA isolated using columns or a
Appendix 2
(TUM), Weihenstephaner Berg 3, 85354 Freising Weihenstephan, Germany liquid-liquid extraction, could result in varying RNA qualities and
http://optimisation.gene-quantification.info quantities. For example RNA extracted from collagen rich or
adipose tissues often has a lower total RNA yield, is of lesser qual-
Introduction ity, and contains partly degraded RNA sub-fractions. Particular
RNA extraction techniques can work more effectively in one
To get very reliable and quantitative real-time RT-PCR results, the specific tissue type compared with another one and result in up
applied mRNA quantification assay and working procedure to 10-fold variations in total RNA yield per extracted tissue mass
should be highly optimised. The efficacy of kinetic RT-PCR is and as a result, on the following real-time RT-PCR gene expres-
measured by its specificity, low background fluorescence, steep sion analysis as well. A lot of total RNA preparations are contami-
fluorescence increase and high amplification efficiency, and nated with genomic DNA fragments and protein at very low
constant high level plateau. Therefore the typical reaction history levels. The enormous amplification power of kinetic PCR may
can be divided in four characteristic phases, Figure 1. The 1st result in even the smallest amount of DNA contamination
phase is hidden under the background fluorescence, where an interfering with the desired specific RT-PCR product. To confirm
exponential amplification is expected; 2nd phase with exponential the absence of residual DNA, either a negative control (minus-RT
amplification that can be detected and above the background; 3rd or water) should be included in each experimental setup. It may
phase with linear amplification efficiency and a steep increase of be necessary to treat the RNA sample with commercially available
fluorescence; and finally 4th phase, or plateau phase, defined as RNase-free DNase, to get rid of any DNA. However, unspecific
the attenuation in the rate of exponential product accumulation, side reactions of the DNase often result in RNA degradation.
normally seen in later cycles. However, it is always recommended to remove the DNase prior to
any RT or PCR step. Furthermore, the design of the PCR product
Figure 1 should incorporate at least one exon-exon splice junction to allow
60 a product obtained from the cDNA to be distinguished on
electrophoresis from genomic DNA contamination.
50
4th phase RNA Quantity and Integrity
40
Accurate quantification and quality assessment of the starting RNA
3rd phase
sample is particularly important for an absolute quantification
30
strategy that normalises specific mRNA expression levels against a
given calibration curve measured in molecules or concentrations/
2nd phase grams RNA. The RNA quality assessment requires accurate quanti-
20
fication of the isolated total RNA or mRNA fraction by optical
background level density at 260 nm, (OD260), and determination of the RNA quality
10
1st phase
calculated by the OD260/OD280 ratio or by the RiboGreen RNA
Quantification Kit from Molecular Probes. Furthermore, the RNA
0
0 10 20 30 40
quality can be verified by capillary electrophoresis with the
Real-time PCR cycle Bioanalyzer 2100 on a microchip lab-on-chip system from Agilent
Technologies. The recently developed RNA integrity number (RIN)
The four characteristic phases of PCR. determines the level of intact total RNA on the basis of an
electropherogram, Figure 2. The RIN value can range between
The following information addresses optimisation strategies in 1-10: RIN 1 for totally degraded RNA, and RIN 10 for a perfect
quantitative real-time RT-PCR. Special focus is laid on the pre- and intact total RNA. RIN numbers under 5 are at least partly
analytical steps, sampling techniques, RNA extraction, and reverse degraded and result in low 18S rRNA and 28S rRNA peaks in the
transcription (RT), primer usage, and post-analytical steps, especially electropherogram. In a broader sense, poor RNA quality and low
on crossing point evaluation and crossing point measuring at RIN numbers influence the qRT-PCR performance significantly and
elevated temperatures. lead to an inhibition of the PCR performance in general and to a
Tissue Sampling and RNA Extraction later crossing point. Therefore, the extracted total RNA quality
and quantity must be verified prior to qRT-PCR experiments to
The sampling and preparation of intact cellular total RNA or
end in reliable mRNA quantification results.
mRNA is critical to all gene expression analysis techniques. A
successful and reliable experiment needs high quality, DNA free,
undegraded RNA. The source of tissue sampling techniques and
the subsequent storage of the tissue material often varies
significantly between processing laboratories (e.g. biopsy
material, single cell sampling, laser micro-dissection, slaughtering
samples). Some researchers store the tissue sample in RNAlater ®
An electropherogram of total RNA is shown (178 ng/µl total RNA; RIN = 7.9; : Elevated Fluorescence Acquisition
ratio 28s/18s = 1.4). The characteristic total RNA profile represent an internal
Real-time assays using SYBR Green I binding dye can easily reveal
reference peak (22 s), a small 5S RNA peak (27 s), a dominant 18S RNA peak
(41 s) and a dominant 28S RNA peak (43 s). the presence of primer dimers, which are the product of non-
specific annealing and primer elongation events. These events
Reverse Transcription take place as soon as PCR reagents are combined in the tube.
During PCR, formation of primer dimers competes with formation
An optimal reverse transcription (RT) is essential for a reliable and
of specific PCR product, leading to reduced amplification
successful qRT-PCR assay. The RT step is the source of high variability
efficiency and a less successful specific RT PCR product. To
in a kinetic RT-PCR experiment and for each enzyme specific reaction,
distinguish primer dimers from the specific amplicons, a melting
conditions have to be optimised. Buffer salt contamination, pH,
curve analysis can be performed in all available quantification
fatty acids, alcohol, phenol and other chemical or enzyme inhibitors
software. The pure and homogeneous RT-PCR product produces
carried over from the RNA isolation process can affect the apparent
a single, sharply defined melting curve with a narrow peak. In
RT efficiency. The extracted total RNA may contain chemical or
contrast, the primer dimers melt at lower temperatures (< 80 °C)
enzymatic tissue inhibitors that result in reduced RT and PCR
and have diffuse and broader peaks. To get rid of primer dimers,
reaction efficiencies and generate unreliable quantification results.
an intensive primer optimisation is needed by testing multiple
For many quantitative applications, MMLV H minus RT is the enzyme
primer pair by cross-wise combinations. Multiples of such primer
of choice, as the cDNA synthesis rate can be up to 10-fold greater
optimisation strategies have been developed.
than that of AMV. In numbers, the MMLV H minus RT has the ability
to reverse transcribe between 50 and 80% of the total RNA and The easiest and most effective way to get rid of any dimer
the AMV only around 5-20%. Newly available thermo-stable RNAse H structures, at least during the quantification procedure, is to add
minus RT maintains its activity up to 70 °C, thus permitting increased an additional 4th segment to the classical three segmented PCR
specificity and efficiency of first primer annealing. procedure, Figure 3: 1st segment with denaturation at 95 °C;
2nd segment with primer annealing at 60 °C; 3rd segment with
Another source of variability is the choice of priming method
elongation at 72 °C; 4th segment with fluorescence acquisition at
used to initiate cDNA synthesis, which can be either target gene-
elevated temperatures (herein 85 °C). The fluorescence acquisition
specific or non-specific. Target gene specific primers work well in
in the 4th segment eliminates the non-specific fluorescence signals
conjunction with elevated RT reaction temperatures to eliminate
derived by primer dimers or unspecific minor products and ensures
spurious transcripts. The same reverse primer is used for the
accurate quantification of the desired qRT-PCR product. High
subsequent PCR assay in conjunction with the corresponding
temperature quantification keeps the background fluorescence
gene-specific sense primer (forward primer); however, the use of
and the ‘no-template control’ fluorescence under 10% of maximal
gene-specific primers necessitates a separate RT reaction for each
fluorescence at plateau and ensures an optimal dynamic fluores-
gene of interest. It cannot be assumed that different reactions
cence range.
have the same cDNA synthesis efficiencies. The result can be high
variability during multiple RT reactions.
Appendix 2
is possible to fit sigmoidal and polynomial curve models, with
20
fluorescence (10log)
20
1
0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50
cycles
3. Selvin, P.R., Fluorescence resonance energy transfer. Meth. Enzymol., 246, 18. Solinas, A., et al., Duplex Scorpion primers in SNP analysis and FRET applica-
300-334 (1995). tions. Nucleic Acids Res., 29, E96 (2001).
4. Pals, G., et al., Detection of a single base substitution in a single cell using 19. Whitcombe, D., et al., Detection of PCR products using self-probing ampli-
the LightCycler. J. Biochem. Biophys. Methods, 47, 121-129 (2001). cons and fluorescence. Nat. Biotechnol., 17, 804-807 (1999).
5. Bonnet, G., et al., Thermodynamic basis of the enhanced specificity of 20. Thelwell, N., et al., Mode of action and application of Scorpion primers to
structured DNA probes. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 96, 6171-6176 (1999). mutation detection. Nucleic Acids Res., 28, 3752-3761 (2000).
6. Broude, N.E., Stem-loop oligonucleotides: A robust tool for molecular biol- 21. Hart, K.W., et al., Novel method for detection, typing, and quantification
ogy and biotechnology. Trends Biotechnol., 20, 249-256 (2002). of human papillomaviruses in clinical samples. J. Clin. Microbiol., 39,
7. Tyagi, S. and Kramer, F.R., Molecular Beacons: probes that fluoresce upon 3204-3212 (2001).
hybridization. Nat. Biotechnol., 14, 303-308 (1996). 22. Braasch, D., et al., RNA interference in mammalian cells by chemically-
8. Antony, T. and Subramaniam, V., Molecular Beacons: nucleic acid hybridiza- modified RNA. Biochem., 42, 7967-7975 (2003).
tion and emerging applications. J. Biomol. Struct. Dyn., 19, 497-504 (2001). 23. Latorra, D., et al., Design considerations and effects of LNA in PCR primers.
9. Perlette, J. and Tan, W., Real-time monitoring of intracellular mRNA hybrid- Molecular and Cellular Probes, 17, 253-259 (2003).
ization inside single living cells. Anal. Chem., 73, 5544-5550 (2001). 24. Christensen, U., et al., Stopped-flow kinetics of Locked Nucleic Acid oligo-
10. Dirks, R.W., et al., Methods for visualizing RNA processing and transport nucleotide duplex formation: studies of LNA-DNA and DNA-DNA interac-
pathways in living cells. Histochem. Cell Biol., 115, 3-11 (2001). tions. Biochem. J., 354, 481-484, (2001).
11. Liu, J., et al., Real-time monitoring in vitro transcription using Molecular 25. Latorra, D., et al., Multiplex allele-specific PCR with optimized locked
Beacons. Anal. Biochem., 300, 40-45 (2002). nucleic acid primers. Biotechniques, 34, 150-152, 1154, 1158 ( 2003).
12. Mhlanga, M.M. and Malmberg, L., Using Molecular Beacons to detect single- 26. Braasch, D. and Corey, D., Locked nucleic acid (LNA): fine-tuning the
nucleotide polymorphisms with real-time PCR. Methods, 25, 463-471 (2001). recognition of DNA and RNA. Chem. Biol., 8, 1-7 ( 2001).
13. Giesendorf, B.A., et al., Molecular Beacons: a new approach for semi 27. Bustin, S.A., Quantification of mRNA using real-time reverse transcription
automated mutation analysis. Clin. Chem., 44, 482-486 (1998). PCR (RT-PCR): trends and problems. J. Molecular Endocrinology, 29, 23-29
14. Marras, S.A., et al., Multiplex detection of single-nucleotide variations using (2002).
Molecular Beacons. Genet. Anal., 14, 151-156 (1999).
15. Tapp, I., et al., Scoring of single-nucleotide polymorphisms: comparison of
the 5’-nuclease TaqMan assay and Molecular Beacon probes. Biotechniques,
28, 732-738 (2000).
Trademarks
JumpStart, ReadyMix, and GenElute are trademarks of LNA is a registered trademark of Exiqon A/S.
Sigma-Aldrich Biotechnology, LP and Sigma-Aldrich Co.
MGB and Yakima Yellow are registered trademarks of Epoch
SYBR, YOYO, YO-PRO, BODIPY, Cascade Blue, Oregon Green, Biosciences, Inc.
and Texas Red are registered trademarks of Molecular Probes, Inc.
Quantica is a registered trademark of Techne Ltd. and Techne, Inc.
Trademarks
Rhodamine Green, Rhodamine Red, and Rhodol Green, are
RNAlater is a registered trademark of Ambion.
trademarks of Molecular Probes, Inc.
FAM, HEX, JOE, NED, ROX, TAMRA, and TET are trademarks of
Amplifluor is a trademark of Intergen Co.
Applera Corporation or its subsidiaries in the United States and
Scorpion is a trademark of DxS Limited. certain other countries.
TaqMan and LightCycler are registered trademarks of VIC is a registered trademark of Applera Corporation or its
Roche Molecular Systems, Inc. subsidiaries in the United States and certain other countries.
Rotor-Gene is a trademark of Corbett Research. Chromo4 and MyiQ are trademarks of Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc.
SmartCycler is registered trademark of Cepheid, Inc. DNA Engine and DNA Engine Opticon, iCycler are registered
trademarks of Bio-Rad Laboratories, Inc.
MX3000P and MX3005P are registered trademarks of
Stratagene, Inc. Cy is a registered trademark of GE Healthcare.
MxPro is a trademark of Stratagene, Inc.
LUX is a trademark of Invitrogen Corporation.
World Headquarters Order/Customer Service (800) 325-3010 • Fax (800) 325-5052 Accelerating Customers’
3050 Spruce St., St. Louis, MO 63103
Technical Service (800) 325-5832 • sigma-aldrich.com/techservice Success through Leadership
(314) 771-5765
sigma-aldrich.com Development/Bulk Manufacturing Inquiries (800) 244-1173 in Life Science, High
©2008 Sigma-Aldrich Co. All rights reserved. SIGMA, , SAFC, , SIGMA-ALDRICH, ALDRICH, , FLUKA, , and SUPELCO, are trademarks belonging to Sigma-Aldrich Co.
Technology and Service
and its affiliate Sigma-Aldrich Biotechnology, L.P. Sigma brand products are sold through Sigma-Aldrich, Inc. Sigma-Aldrich, Inc. warrants that its products conform to the information
contained in this and other Sigma-Aldrich publications. Purchaser must determine the suitability of the product(s) for their particular use. Additional terms and conditions may apply.
Please see reverse side of the invoice or packing slip.
02503-504204
0038