Rainfall Cannot Be Appropriated. Hence, It Is Not Property? NO
Rainfall Cannot Be Appropriated. Hence, It Is Not Property? NO
Rainfall Cannot Be Appropriated. Hence, It Is Not Property? NO
A: Rainfall cannot be appropriated. Hence, it is not property? NO. Rainfall gathered through pails and
buckets can be owned through occupation
Q: What are the other means of acquiring ownership aside from sale?
A: Yes
Q: What are the factors that should be considered in distinguishing things from property?
Personal property may be considered real property. If it is the owner who introduced the property and
the blackboard is necessary. In classrooms> yes. In canteen> even if it is the owner who introduced it,
regardless of the intention, cannot be considered real property
Statutory Construction (Art. 415) (4) Ejusdem Generis – “other ornamentation” > intention was to
decorate or beautify
A: Lights - real or personal property? What manner/degree of attachment is required for a personal
property to be considered real property?
Q: Is the intention important with reference to attachment to determine won a property is real or
personal.
A: Intention is immaterial in immovable property by incorporation .Art. 415 (3). Who introduced the
property is immaterial in Art. 415 (3)
A: Air conditioning unit remains to be a personal property because it is detachable property. Same with
the fluorescent lamp.
Pawnshops
o Principal Contract: Loan
o Accessory Contract: Pledge (only personal property)
Foreclosure of real property? Are the structure classified real or personal? A distinction must be
made to determine what will be included in the foreclosure?