Solitary Confinement Essay
Solitary Confinement Essay
Solitary Confinement Essay
Ms.Bruce/SocialStudies
SolitaryConfinement
Doyoueverwonderwhypeoplecommitseriouscrimesthatputtheminprison?Scientists
saythatbeinginsolitaryconfinementcancausebraindamage.Itmakestheprisonergo
crazyandtheytrytophysicallyhurtthemselves.Solitaryconfinementisaviolationofthe8th
amendmentbanagainstcruelandunusualpunishmentbecausealthoughinmatesdidthat
seriouscrimethatdoesntmeanthattheinmatesshouldbeinaboxcellfortwentythree
hours.Eventhoughinmatesshouldnthavecommittedthatcrimetheyshouldberequiredto
servethetimeinregularprisonnotsolitaryconfinement.
Prisonersshouldhaveprisontime
butunlessyouretryingtokillsomeoneintheprisonitselfthenthatpersonshouldbein
there.
First,Solitaryconfinementisaviolationofthe8thamendmentbanagainstcrueland
unusualpunishmentbecausealthoughinmatesdidthatseriouscrimethatdoesntmean
thattheinmatesshouldbeinaboxcellfortwentythreehours.AccordingtoWikipedia:It
statesthatSolitaryconfinement
issometimesemployedasaformofpunishmentbeyond
incarcerationforaprisonerandhasbeencitedasanadditionalmeasureofprotectionfor
theinmate.Thisformofpunishmentisalsogivenforviolationsofprisonregulations.Itis
alsousedasaformofprotectivecustodyandtopreventinthecaseofsuicide,restriction
fromitemsthatcoulddisrupttheprisonershealth.ThisevidenceshowsthatSolitary
Confinementcanreallycauseinmatestogothroughsomeseriousmentalchallenges.
Next,Eventhoughinmatesshouldnthavecommittedthatcrimetheyshouldberequiredto
servethetimeinregularprisonnotsolitaryconfinement.AccordingtoWikipedia:Itstates
that
Researchsurroundingpossiblepsychologicalandphysiologicaleffectsofsolitary
confinementdatebacktothe1860s.PrisonrecordsfromtheDenmarkinstituteduring
18701920indicatethatstaffnoticedinmateswereexhibitingsignsofmentalillnesses
whileinisolation,revealingthatthispersistentproblemhasbeenaroundfordecades.This
isreallyacruelwaytohandlethesesituations.Thisshowsthattheownersofprisons
shouldredesigntheirprisonstomakesafer,butwithoutSolitaryconfinement.
Then,Prisonersshouldhaveprisontimebutunlessyouretryingtokillsomeoneinthe
prisonitselfthenthatpersonshouldbeinthere.Accordingtowikipedia:Itstatesthat
The
firstcommentbythe
SupremeCourtoftheUnitedStates
aboutsolitaryconfinementcan
affectprisonersmentalstatuswasmadein1890.Initthecourtfoundthattheuseofsolitary
confinementproducedreducedmentalandphysicalcapabilities.Theuseofsolitary
confinementinprisonswasfirstintroducedinordertoregulateunrulyprisoners,andkeep
themawayfromtherestoftheprisonsociety.
Last,SolitaryConfinementtomeisaviolationofthe8thAmendment.Igoesagainstour
nationsprideandrespect.AlotofprisonersinSolitaryConfinementgothroughmany
mentaltrials.Whilebeinginthatninefootcellfortwentythreehourseveryday.Solitary
confinementshouldbeshutdownandshouldbegonefortherestofthisEarthstime.