Christ's Descent into Hell: John Paul II, Joseph Ratzinger, and Hans Urs von Balthasar on the Theology of Holy Saturday
()
About this ebook
Pitstick looks at what John Paul II, Ratzinger, and Balthasar have in fact said regarding the creedal affirmation that Christ “descended into hell,” and she shows that there are radical differences in their views. She then addresses a number of important questions that follow from these differences.
This careful, concise exploration of what three of the twentieth century’s most famous Catholic theologians had to say about Christ’s descent into hell provides an accessible take on a difficult point of theological debate.
Related to Christ's Descent into Hell
Related ebooks
Ressourcement after Vatican II: Essays in Honor of Joseph Fessio, S.J. Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsChrist's Descent into Hell: John Paul II, Joseph Ratzinger, and Hans Urs von Balthasar on the Theology of Holy Saturday Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Dynamics of the Liturgy: Joseph Ratzinger's Theology of Liturgy Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsCovenant and Communion: The Biblical Theology of Pope Benedict XVI Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Are Non-Christians Saved?: Joseph Ratzinger's Thoughts on Religious Pluralism Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsA Progressive Voice in the Catholic Church in the United States: Association of Pittsburgh Priests, 1966–2019 Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Authority of the Saints: Drawing on the Theology of Hans Urs von Balthasar Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsIn the Beginning…': A Catholic Understanding of the Story of Creation and the Fall Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Benedict XVI: Defender of the Faith Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5By Strange Ways: Theologians and Their Paths to the Catholic Church Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsThe Mystical Body of Christ Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Rekindle the Gift of God: A Handbook for Priestly Life Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsMind, Heart, and Soul: Intellectuals and the Path to Rome Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsPopes, Councils, and Theology: From Pope Pius IX to Pope Francis Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsExplorations in the Theology of Benedict XVI Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsPilgrim Fellowship of Faith: The Church as Communion Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Corpus Mysticum: The Eucharist and the Church in the Middle Ages Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Milestones: Memoirs: 1927 - 1977 Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Dogma And Preaching: Applying Christian Doctrine to Daily Life Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Credo for Today: What Christians Believe Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Bread That Is Broken Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsMary: God's Yes to Man Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5God and the World: Believing and Living in Our Time Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5There Is No Rose: The Mariology of the Catholic Church Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The God of Jesus Christ: Meditations on the Triune God Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsMary and the Fathers of the Church: The Blessed Virgin Mary in Patristic Thought Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Creation and Evolution: A Conference with Pope Benedict XVI Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Compassionate Blood: Catherine of Siena On the Passion Rating: 0 out of 5 stars0 ratingsHoliness is Always in Season Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5God Is Not Fair, and Other Reasons for Gratitude Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Christianity For You
Boundaries Updated and Expanded Edition: When to Say Yes, How to Say No To Take Control of Your Life Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Good Boundaries and Goodbyes: Loving Others Without Losing the Best of Who You Are Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Four Loves Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Decluttering at the Speed of Life: Winning Your Never-Ending Battle with Stuff Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Screwtape Letters Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Mere Christianity Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Anxious for Nothing: Finding Calm in a Chaotic World Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Law of Connection: Lesson 10 from The 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The 5 Love Languages: The Secret to Love that Lasts Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Book of Enoch Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Changes That Heal: Four Practical Steps to a Happier, Healthier You Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The 21 Irrefutable Laws of Leadership: Follow Them and People Will Follow You Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Girl, Wash Your Face: Stop Believing the Lies About Who You Are so You Can Become Who You Were Meant to Be Rating: 3 out of 5 stars3/5Winning the War in Your Mind: Change Your Thinking, Change Your Life Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Story: The Bible as One Continuing Story of God and His People Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Unoffendable: How Just One Change Can Make All of Life Better (updated with two new chapters) Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5The Purpose Driven Life: What on Earth Am I Here For? Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5How to Lead When You're Not in Charge: Leveraging Influence When You Lack Authority Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Present Over Perfect: Leaving Behind Frantic for a Simpler, More Soulful Way of Living Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Boundaries Workbook: When to Say Yes, How to Say No to Take Control of Your Life Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Uninvited: Living Loved When You Feel Less Than, Left Out, and Lonely Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5A Grief Observed Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5The Good Girl's Guide to Great Sex: Creating a Marriage That's Both Holy and Hot Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Wild at Heart Expanded Edition: Discovering the Secret of a Man's Soul Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5Becoming Free Indeed: My Story of Disentangling Faith from Fear Rating: 5 out of 5 stars5/5Less Fret, More Faith: An 11-Week Action Plan to Overcome Anxiety Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5NIV, Holy Bible Rating: 4 out of 5 stars4/5
Reviews for Christ's Descent into Hell
0 ratings0 reviews
Book preview
Christ's Descent into Hell - Lyra Pitstick
Christ’s Descent into Hell
John Paul II, Joseph Ratzinger, and Hans Urs von Balthasar
on the Theology of Holy Saturday
Lyra Pitstick
William B. Eerdmans Publishing Company
Grand Rapids, Michigan
© 2016 Lyra Pitstick
All rights reserved
Published 2016 by
Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co.
2140 Oak Industrial Drive N.E., Grand Rapids, Michigan 49505
www.eerdmans.com
Printed in the United States of America
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data
Names: Pitstick, Alyssa Lyra, author.
Title: Christ’s descent into hell: John Paul II, Joseph Ratzinger,
and Hans Urs von Balthasar on the theology of Holy Saturday / Lyra Pitstick.
Description: Grand Rapids, Michigan: Eerdmans Publishing Company, 2016. |
Includes bibliographical references and index.
Identifiers: LCCN 2015043019 | ISBN 9780802869050 (pbk. : alk. paper)
eISBN 9781467445399 (ePub)
eISBN 9781467444927 (Kindle)
Subjects: LCSH: Jesus Christ — Descent into hell. | Holy Saturday. |
Catholic Church — Doctrines. | John Paul II, Pope, 1920-2005. |
Benedict XVI, Pope, 1927- | Balthasar, Hans Urs von, 1905-1988.
Classification: LCC BT470.P58 2016 | DDC 232.96/7 — dc23
LC record available at http://lccn.loc.gov/2015043019
The inscription in the 14th-century image on the cover reads (in Old French),
"How the soul of Jesus has now, after death, descended into Hell and set free
Adam and Eve and all the good who were in the ultimate prison.
And He leaves all the bad, male and female, therein to abide in perpetual pain."
My thanks to Dr. Catherine Brown Tkacz for her help with this translation.
Dedicated to Mary, Queen of Heaven
and
St. Ignatius of Loyola and Company
For Fr. John Saward, Theologian
By this Constitution
which is to remain in force for ever,
we, with apostolic authority,
define the following: . . .
Since the passion and death
of the Lord Jesus Christ,
these souls [who "were not in need of any purification when they died . . .
or else, if they then needed . . .
some purification, after they have been purified after death,"
including "the souls of all the saints who departed from this world
before the passion of our Lord Jesus Christ"]
have seen and see the divine essence with an intuitive vision
and even face to face . . . ;
and in this vision they enjoy the divine essence.
Moreover, by this vision and enjoyment the souls of those who have already died
are truly blessed
and have eternal life and rest.
Pope Benedict XII,
Constitution Benedictus Deus (1336),
DS 1000
Contents
List of Tables
Acknowledgments
Note to Reader
Introduction
Balthasar on the Descent
Ratzinger on the Descent
Ratzinger on the Descent
after His Election as Benedict XVI
John Paul II on the Descent
A Significant Sidenote on Schönborn
The Crux of the Problem:
Who Is Right?
The Crux, Continued:
John Paul II’s and Ratzinger/Benedict XVI’s Praise of Balthasar
Conclusion
Benedictus Deus’ Definition
Roman Catechism (Catechism of the Council of Trent)
on Christ’s Descent
Catechism of the Catholic Church on Christ’s Descent
Pope John Paul II’s Catechesis on Christ’s Descent
The Passion and Triumph of Eternal Spring
Bibliography
List of Tables
Table 1. Ratzinger on Christ’s Descent
before His Election as Benedict
Table 2. Differences between Balthasar and Ratzinger
on Christ’s Descent
Table 3. Ratzinger on Christ’s Descent after His Election
as Benedict
Table 4. Benedict XVI on Christ’s Descent
Table 5. Differences between Balthasar and Ratzinger on Christ’s
Descent after Ratzinger’s Election as Benedict
Table 6. Differences between Balthasar and John Paul II
on Christ’s Descent
Table 7. Factors in Schönborn’s Introduction that Suggest
Balthasar’s Theology of Holy Saturday Will Not Be
Received by the Church
Acknowledgments
The core of this book reprises a lecture I gave at Heythrop College, London, May 9, 2011, funded by the Templeton Foundation as a result of my Templeton Award for Theological Promise (2009). I am deeply grateful to the Foundation for its avant garde willingness to recognize and so generously support junior theological researchers independently of institutional affiliation. May others do likewise! I extend very warm appreciation also to the Heythrop Jesuits for their gracious hospitality. Deserving of particular note in this regard is John Dade, S.J., Principal, for his invitation, enthusiastic participation, and comments, as well as Dominic Robinson, S.J., for his attentive management of the details of my visit and continuing collegiality. I am likewise warmly grateful to Gavin D’Costa of the University of Bristol for going above and beyond in laying the groundwork for my Templeton lectures in England and Scotland. Finally, I thank Hope College for a 2011 Nyenhuis Summer Research Grant, which partially funded the revision of the text, and I especially appreciate the generosity of the Betty S. Wheeler Trust, for a grant that enabled me to expand and finish it.
Feast of the Queenship of Mary
Lyra Pitstick
August 22, 2012
Note to Reader
A date in parentheses after a title is the date of the text’s publication or presentation in its original language, though the title of a non-English work may still be given in English.
Unless otherwise indicated, all quotations from papal documents are from the English versions on the Vatican website (www.vatican.va), and all translations from non-English publications are mine. Due to the dynamic nature of the Internet, readers may find pages have changed since the text here was completed.
Bible texts are from the Revised Standard Version, unless they are quoted from a cited source, in which case they are reproduced as quoted.
The author and publisher gratefully acknowledge permission to reprint material from the following sources:
Excerpts from the English translation of the Catechism of the Catholic Church for use in the United States of America. Copyright © 1994, United States Catholic Conference, Inc. — Libreria Editrice Vaticana. Used with permission.
Excerpts from The Catechism of the Council of Trent, transl. John A. McHugh, O.P., and Charles J. Callan, O.P. (Rockford, IL: Tan, 1982). Used with permission.
Text of Benedictus Deus reproduced from The Christian Faith in the Doctrinal Documents of the Catholic Church, 6th ed., ed. Jacques Dupuis (Staten Island: Alba, 1996).
Text of ‘He Descended into Hell’: General Audience Given on January 11, 1989,
by Pope John Paul II, transl. L’Osservatore Romano Weekly Edition in English. Copyright © 1989, LIBRERIA EDITRICE VATICANA. Reproduced with permission.
The Passion and Triumph of Eternal Spring
was first published in
Gonzaga Witness (April/May 2007): 16-17.
Introduction
Does the high regard of Pope (now St.) John Paul II and Joseph Cardinal Ratzinger (now Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI) for Hans Urs von Balthasar indicate approval of his controversial theology of Holy Saturday? Certainly Ratzinger uses some language similar to Balthasar’s when discussing Christ’s descent into hell, but does he mean the same thing by it? And what to do about the fact that both Ratzinger’s and Balthasar’s theologies contrast dramatically with John Paul II’s? The radical differences in the three men’s conclusions imply that not all of these influential theologians can be correct in what they say of Christ’s descent.
But if one or more is wrong, who is it?
And what should we then make of John Paul II’s and Benedict XVI’s praise of Balthasar? If the popes lauded someone with whom they disagreed, did they err in praising him or in disagreeing with him? Could there be implications for papal infallibility? Or does their praise simply concern something other than the theological matter on which they disagreed?
And how might we go about answering these questions?
Balthasar has a reputation as a conservative theologian who explicitly understood his work as service to the Church. His name is closely linked with the renewed emphasis on the Church Fathers during the mid-twentieth century in what is called the ressourcement (return to the sources) movement. His writings make frequent reference to Scripture and leave an impression of staggering erudition. Henri de Lubac, no mean theologian himself, said Balthasar was perhaps the most cultivated man of his time.
¹ Balthasar was a member, and then a priest, of the Society of Jesus (the Jesuits), remaining with them some twenty years, an experience that indelibly shaped his spirituality. Balthasar had a close friendship with Joseph Ratzinger, who eulogized him at his funeral in 1988 and, as Pope Benedict XVI, lauded him on the centennial of his birth. Earlier, John Paul II had conferred on Balthasar the first Paul VI Prize for his theological contributions and nominated him to be a cardinal. Especially for Catholic theologians, including myself, how could such a man’s works be regarded as anything but trustworthy, apparently founded on Scripture and Tradition as they are, praised as they are by not one, but two, popes? Isn’t papal judgment the standard of Catholic orthodoxy? Wouldn’t it be hubris to try to be more Catholic than the pope
?
After I raised questions about Balthasar’s theology of Holy Saturday in 2007 with the publication of Light in Darkness: Hans Urs von Balthasar and the Catholic Doctrine of Christ’s Descent into Hell, versions of this argument have consistently appeared in discussions of the book, most commonly in non-academic sources. The frequent, quick, and often vehement defenses of Balthasar on the web illustrated the degree of confidence people felt they could have in assuming Balthasar’s reliability as a voice of Christian orthodoxy — and, apparently, how shaken some were by any suggestion he may have erred. Moments of unintentional humor in some hasty postings aside — one person wrote that he hadn’t read Light in Darkness, but clearly I didn’t know what I was talking about! — the argument’s recurrence indicates it deserves an answer, especially as it would likely occur to any person, Catholic or non-Catholic, cursorily acquainted with Balthasar’s place in theological history. Indeed, it weighed on my mind for a good part of my studies — until I looked more closely into it.
Except for one partial exposition by Edward T. Oakes in an article for the International Journal of Systematic Theology,² it is notable that the argument is universally made, regardless of venue, without considering exactly what the popes themselves have said about either Christ’s descent into hell or about Balthasar. The authors simply characterize the case for his orthodoxy in fewer sentences than I did above, and then regard the matter as settled. Such brusqueness suggests the logic is self-evident and the conclusion necessary. The argument, however, turns on hasty assumptions about the approbation given Balthasar. Since a similarity in theologies might suggest a kind of approval, we will look at Balthasar’s theology of the descent, then Ratzinger’s (before and after his papal election), and finally that of Pope John Paul II. We will then see exactly what Benedict and John Paul II have said about Balthasar himself. I have attempted to consider here all the statements published to date (April, 2012) by Ratzinger/Benedict XVI and John Paul II on Christ’s descent, as well as all those of the two popes on Balthasar. With such prolific authors, it is certainly possible I may have missed something. If so, I would ask the reader two things: First, take into account that any other texts do not change those examined here nor any clear conclusions that emerge from them. Second, do let me know!
1. Henri de Lubac, A Witness to Christ in the Church: Hans Urs von Balthasar,
Communio 2, no. 3 (Fall, 1975): 230.
2. Edward T. Oakes, S.J., "Descensus and Development: A Response to Recent Rejoinders," International Journal of Systematic Theology, 13, no. 1 (January, 2011): 3-24. Oakes’s presentation is unfortunately undermined by his overly selective choice of texts and the fact that his arguments all turn on making inaccurate claims of proof or authority, misrepresenting authors (including myself), or ignoring historico-critical contributions, the context of quotations, or theological distinctions. The editors declined to publish my analysis demonstrating these flaws.
1
Balthasar on the Descent
According to Balthasar, Christ’s descent into hell is the pinnacle of the Trinity’s self-revelation in salvation history. In this event, God’s love remains unscathed by His descent into — and real union with — what is most not Himself, sin and the abandonment by God that is its punishment. The sovereign freedom necessary to punish sin and embrace this justice in love for the world’s redemption will manifest God’s trinitarian divinity.
Christ’s Descent, Not His Cross, Completes the Redemption
Four specific details can help fill out this summary of Balthasar’s theology of Christ’s descent into hell (or descensus, which is Latin for descent and still sometimes used as a technical term to refer to this event). First, in Balthasar’s view, the reconciliation of God with the world is not complete with Christ’s death on the cross, but only with the Son’s descent into hell. For, he says, it is possible to distinguish between sin and the sinner.
¹ He uses distinguish here in the sense of a real separation. Balthasar writes, because of the energy that man has invested in it, sin is a reality, it is not ‘nothing.’
² In other words, sin is not merely a defect in an action, or an action that lacks some good it ought to have; rather, sin has a kind of real being itself.³ As such a reality, sin may be taken from the sinner and loaded upon another,⁴ not just as a figure of speech or in idea, but in actuality. The transfer of sin to Christ begins in Gethsemane and is completed upon the cross.⁵ Mankind is thus freed from the guilt of sin even before Christ’s death. However, the separate reality of the sins themselves remains to be expiated. Balthasar insists that expiation occurs in the descent: Christ’s death on the cross provides Him entrance to the state of being dead, which constituted the term and aim of the Incarnation. . . . [For] only what has been endured is healed and saved.
⁶
Christ’s Suffering Increases in His Descent
Balthasar’s principle that only what has been endured is healed
resembles but significantly changes the patristic maxim, "What is not assumed is not healed. The Church Fathers were arguing that Christ was truly human, that the Son of God took upon Himself (
assumed) a whole human nature, both body and soul, and not a body only. In contrast, as we will shortly see confirmed, Balthasar’s version concerns not nature, but punishment: Christ expiates (
heals) sin by undergoing (
enduring) the punishment for sin. Balthasar’s principle is his premise for a second detail about his position: because Christ must bear all punishment for sin, His suffering intensifies after His death on the cross.
God has redeemed us, Balthasar reminds his reader, from
nothing less than hell, the eternal exclusion from the presence of God."⁷ Our Savior is conformed to his brethren even in this
;⁸ thus He descends into ultimate perdition
and the estrangement from God of hell
such that he experiences the complete godlessness of lost man.
⁹
Balthasar is explicit. "The interior death of sin . . . is the terminus a quo of the common Resurrection,"¹⁰ that is, the extreme from which both Christ and sinners rise. Because physical death entered the world through the spiritual death that is sin (par. Rom 5:12), Balthasar thinks both spiritual death and physical death should be understood in texts such as Rom 14:9: For to this end Christ died and lived again, that he might be Lord both of the dead and the living.
¹¹ Thus the scars in Christ’s risen body will reveal His unique experience of death that is both spiritual and bodily.
¹² "The reality of the poena damni [the pain of the loss of God in hell] is spiritual and can be experienced only spiritually."¹³ Balthasar calls the pre-redeemed afterlife where Christ experiences spiritual death Sheol. (In my text here, I will capitalize Sheol wherever it is used in Balthasar’s sense.) Parallel to St. Thomas Aquinas’s statement that God unites Himself to the human intellect in the