Nadia's Reviews > Someone Like You
Someone Like You (Oxford, #3)
by
by
Nadia's review
bookshelves: favorite-author, bad-bad-book, can-you-say-pathetic, cheesy-attacks, cheesy-book-name, could-ve-been-good-instead-it-s-meh, eyes-are-rolling-and-face-is-palmed, glad-it-s-over, gr-needs-negative-stars-for-this-sh, i-m-so-mad, i-wanna-punch-the-hero-in-the-face, nope, nothing-new, shallow, stupid, took-me-by-surprise
Dec 07, 2016
bookshelves: favorite-author, bad-bad-book, can-you-say-pathetic, cheesy-attacks, cheesy-book-name, could-ve-been-good-instead-it-s-meh, eyes-are-rolling-and-face-is-palmed, glad-it-s-over, gr-needs-negative-stars-for-this-sh, i-m-so-mad, i-wanna-punch-the-hero-in-the-face, nope, nothing-new, shallow, stupid, took-me-by-surprise
This review is spoilerish.
Well, that was disappointing. I don't want to go into a big rant, but if I do, don't hold it against me. It's only because I love the series and the author so much.
I've been a fan of the original series since forever. Seriously, it was pure luck when I stumbled upon Lauren Layne and After the Kiss, but I was hooked. I was sold on the banter and the writing style, the funny and cute characters, the dynamics between the supporting characters, it was just perfect for me. Every now and then I return to my favorites for a quick reread and a book high. Reading those books makes me happy, like genuinely puts a smile on my face. If I get to eat chocolate too, then my day is made.
And then comes this book. Now, let's be honest, I was not a fan of the prequel either (actually I still am not completely okay with it), but it's nowhere near as bad as this book. The author decided she wanted to take a more serious route with this book, but in my opinion, the issues this book tries to handle are too difficult and it's just a fail.
The beginning was actually strong, I felt it really had potential, but after 30% or so the story loses its momentum and never catches up.
Daisy's trust issues were glossed over, and in a span of a few weeks she went from a woman wary of touch and men, to pouring her heart out to the first man she meets.
Lincoln's ex, Katie, never goes away, so there is this weird love triangle between Lincoln, Daisy and Katie. Even on the day Daisy gives birth to their twins, Katie's ghost is there. And Daisy is the one who brought her up, which says quite a lot actually. Does that mean that Daisy realizes that she will never be number one in Lincoln's life, but that she's okay with it? Because that's the feeling I got from reading this book.
And the cheesy speech in the end!! Oh my god what the hell was that?! So painful to read. He told her something along the lines of I didn't want to call you love like I called every other woman because I thought if I called you love then it would be for real like gag seriously it's disgusting. My eyes are offended. Just that whole chapter was awful. And the epilogue was yuck.
I am not a happy reader right now. No cute banter. No cute story. No cute characters. No emotions (besides being disgusted). No fun bickering with supporting characters. This book ruined every other book Lincoln is mentioned in and I.am.not.happy.
Well, that was disappointing. I don't want to go into a big rant, but if I do, don't hold it against me. It's only because I love the series and the author so much.
I've been a fan of the original series since forever. Seriously, it was pure luck when I stumbled upon Lauren Layne and After the Kiss, but I was hooked. I was sold on the banter and the writing style, the funny and cute characters, the dynamics between the supporting characters, it was just perfect for me. Every now and then I return to my favorites for a quick reread and a book high. Reading those books makes me happy, like genuinely puts a smile on my face. If I get to eat chocolate too, then my day is made.
And then comes this book. Now, let's be honest, I was not a fan of the prequel either (actually I still am not completely okay with it), but it's nowhere near as bad as this book. The author decided she wanted to take a more serious route with this book, but in my opinion, the issues this book tries to handle are too difficult and it's just a fail.
The beginning was actually strong, I felt it really had potential, but after 30% or so the story loses its momentum and never catches up.
Daisy's trust issues were glossed over, and in a span of a few weeks she went from a woman wary of touch and men, to pouring her heart out to the first man she meets.
Lincoln's ex, Katie, never goes away, so there is this weird love triangle between Lincoln, Daisy and Katie. Even on the day Daisy gives birth to their twins, Katie's ghost is there. And Daisy is the one who brought her up, which says quite a lot actually. Does that mean that Daisy realizes that she will never be number one in Lincoln's life, but that she's okay with it? Because that's the feeling I got from reading this book.
And the cheesy speech in the end!! Oh my god what the hell was that?! So painful to read. He told her something along the lines of I didn't want to call you love like I called every other woman because I thought if I called you love then it would be for real like gag seriously it's disgusting. My eyes are offended. Just that whole chapter was awful. And the epilogue was yuck.
I am not a happy reader right now. No cute banter. No cute story. No cute characters. No emotions (besides being disgusted). No fun bickering with supporting characters. This book ruined every other book Lincoln is mentioned in and I.am.not.happy.
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Someone Like You.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
August 19, 2015
– Shelved
August 19, 2015
– Shelved as:
to-read
December 6, 2016
–
Started Reading
December 6, 2016
– Shelved as:
favorite-author
December 6, 2016
–
66.0%
"I haven't read Layne's Wedding Belles series, but I have a feeling this will somehow tie to these books."
December 7, 2016
–
83.0%
""Um, no. Nothing against the actor, but any guy holding a boom box outside my bedroom at dawn is going to get a swift kick to the balls."
Emma is my spirit animal."
Emma is my spirit animal."
December 7, 2016
–
85.0%
"Yeah Lincoln no amount of groveling and romantic gestures can undo the fuckery."
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
bad-bad-book
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
can-you-say-pathetic
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
cheesy-attacks
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
cheesy-book-name
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
could-ve-been-good-instead-it-s-meh
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
eyes-are-rolling-and-face-is-palmed
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
glad-it-s-over
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
gr-needs-negative-stars-for-this-sh
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
i-m-so-mad
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
i-wanna-punch-the-hero-in-the-face
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
nope
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
nothing-new
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
shallow
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
stupid
December 7, 2016
– Shelved as:
took-me-by-surprise
December 7, 2016
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Jenny
(new)
-
rated it 1 star
Dec 07, 2016 08:04AM
I agree. This was a dud.
reply
|
flag
I was skimming the epilogue, the cheesiness was killing me, but it's not out of the question that they named their daughter after Katie. She is basically a main character in this story -.-
I agree with Nadia. I expected them to name a daughter after Katie. She cast a very long shadow in the book. And I also agree, the epilogue was really cheesy. I think it was tacked on to reassure the reader that yes, everything works out and everyone is happy.
Jenny wrote: "I agree with Nadia. I expected them to name a daughter after Katie. She cast a very long shadow in the book. And I also agree, the epilogue was really cheesy. I think it was tacked on to reassure t..."
Aham, I think so too. But it was just too much. I didn't want to be reassured because I was not buying it, the whole romance thing. As Zuyu said, it was just so unsatisfying.
Aham, I think so too. But it was just too much. I didn't want to be reassured because I was not buying it, the whole romance thing. As Zuyu said, it was just so unsatisfying.
I agree, it was too much and felt forced. Almost as if the author knew the reader needed convincing. And I didn't buy it either so the epilogue didn't work for me. It was very unsatisfying. And that is such a shame.
Nadia wrote: "Not only second best, but also convenient. And she doesn't deserve it."
And I found out the girls middle name. What a pitiful character
And I found out the girls middle name. What a pitiful character
Rejane wrote: "Nadia wrote: "Not only second best, but also convenient. And she doesn't deserve it."
And I found out the girls middle name. What a pitiful character"
Yeah, really pathetic and I hate it because I wasn't expecting this from this author.
And I found out the girls middle name. What a pitiful character"
Yeah, really pathetic and I hate it because I wasn't expecting this from this author.