Kelli's Reviews > Where They Found Her
Where They Found Her
by
by
Here is another book that others seemed to really enjoy but that fell flat for me. As another reviewer said, perhaps I, too, have read too many of these non-linear mysteries with multiple POVs and jostled storylines. Here I found the characters (and there were so many!!) very one-dimensional and interconnected past the point of believability. How all these seemingly cursory characters proved important in the end was a little weak and the relationship that was the most important piece of the puzzle was left unexplained...as was any legal follow-up to that branch of the story. A confusing road to an unconvincing ending made this journey somewhat forgettable. Giving this 3 stars feels generous, yet 2 might be a little low. 2.5
Sign into Goodreads to see if any of your friends have read
Where They Found Her.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-16 of 16 (16 new)
date
newest »
message 1:
by
Canadian Jen
(new)
Jun 03, 2015 12:26PM
Thanks for the honest review...will avoid.
reply
|
flag
I read Reconstructing Amelia and found bits and pieces too unbelievable. This is getting so much good buzz, I thought I might give her another chance. I don't mind a non-linear story line, but it's got to be believable. Not gonna rush out and read this one....
Words out of my mouth, couldn't agree more. I like her style of writing, but seriously, too many characters, too much going on, all wrapped up with one big bow at the end.
Yes, Niki..I agree way too many characters. I thought it was me getting confused with all the people and missing the point of the storyline. Good to know.
Such a controversial book, Kelli. Your review is excellent, spelling out specifically what you didn't care for. Very helpful.
Yeah, it's such a downer when you've really looked forward to reading a specific book and it let's you down.
What a bummer. I've had the opposite luck--I've had the good fortune to read a lot of winners, Kelli. I hope 2016 is a better book year for you.
I enjoyed the book but I do see your point. Too many characters and for me I knew it was Justin in the beginning. I have read so many mysteries in the last year (Gone Girl turned me on) that I feel almost as an expert in them.
Courtney wrote: "Loni thanks for spoiling the ending."
Anyone that reads all the comments has to expect the ending will be revealed. It's a message board for discussing the book as well as reviewing it.
Anyone that reads all the comments has to expect the ending will be revealed. It's a message board for discussing the book as well as reviewing it.