Nothing Special   »   [go: up one dir, main page]

Academia.eduAcademia.edu

Review of James D. G. Dunn, Unity and Diversity in the New Testament.

Unity and Diversity in the New Testament, James D. G. Dunn. Religious Studies Review 33.2 (2007): 144-145.

UNITY AND DIVERSITY IN THE NEW TESTAMENT. By James D. G. Dunn. London: SCM Press, 2006. Pp. lv + 520. ISBN 0-334-02998-8. Heralded for many years as a premier study of early Christian origins, Dunn’s Unity and Diversity in the NT is now available in a handy 3d ed. This edition showcases a detailed preface, an updated bibliography, additional reflections on the canon, and an appendix. Particularly valuable is the new preface, where Dunn reassesses his work in light of recent trends in NT scholarship. Readers should note, however, that the study has not been revised, updated, or expanded. Save for the final chapter, the bulk of the material appears as it did in the 2d ed. While the preface was clearly crafted to compensate for the lack of changes to the material, one of the unfortunate results is that the preface resembles a “wish list” of what Dunn would have liked to do. At one point Dunn even offers readers a sketch of what a chapter on NT ethics would have looked like (xix-xxii)! Moreover, some material, like the chapter on Hellenistic Christianity, is in dire need of an overhaul, not a supplement. But perhaps the most pressing issue pertains to Dunn’s transition from the descriptive task to what is normative. Throughout Unity and Diversity, the legacy of Wrede’s Task of NT Theology looms large, with its heavy emphasis on lines of historical development, continuities, discontinuities, and attention to prominent figures. When Dunn finally turns his attention to “The Authority of the New Testament,” however, the mode remains descriptive. No compelling reason is offered as to why rigorous historical research makes the NT normative. Indeed, there is none. Juan Hernández Jr. Bethel University